Aerial of Stillwater in Englewood, Florida, the homes and lakes of the Stillwater plats beside Medical Boulevard and the hospital campus, with the wooded land to the east before Shores at Stillwater was built, in Sarasota County

Stillwater in Englewood

Stillwater in Englewood, FL 34223: the Stillwater plats and Pulte's Shores at Stillwater in Sarasota County, with 35 recorded sales at a $485,000 median, costs, CDD, flood and schools. Call McGreevy and Comisar at (239) 898-6072.

Search Homes

Home › Englewood › Stillwater

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida, selling and buying homes in Stillwater. Top 1% Nationally since 2008. Over $900 million in personal sales and $2.5 billion+ sold as a team. The team Stillwater homeowners call first. For the wider town picture, read our Englewood guide. Stillwater in Englewood is two neighborhoods under one name: the established Stillwater plats, Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2 and Unit 3, with homes built from 2000 to 2016, and Shores at Stillwater, the gated Pulte Homes section beside them, with homes built in 2025 and 2026. Both sit in unincorporated Sarasota County with Englewood 34223 addresses and are reached through Medical Boulevard beside the HCA Florida Englewood Hospital campus. On the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026 the five recorded plats hold 394 parcels, and from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 they recorded 35 qualified home sales at a $485,000 median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Last Updated November 2026 · By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar at Domain Realty · More about Jesse McGreevy, Marc Comisar and our team on the about page.

Why McGreevy and Comisar Are the Best Realtor for Stillwater

Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and they bring over 45 years of combined direct experience between Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar to Stillwater sales. We price from county recorded sales, plat by plat and home by home, never from a blended Englewood average.

Why Stillwater Needs Plat-by-Plat and Home-by-Home Pricing

Stillwater, Englewood looks like one neighborhood on a map and trades like three. The county sales file shows the older Stillwater Unit 3 homes, the larger homes in Stillwater Units 1 and 2, and the new Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater each selling at their own level. From October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 the Sarasota County Property Appraiser recorded 10 qualified sales in Stillwater Unit 3 at a $282,500 median, 7 in Unit 1 at $550,000, 2 in Unit 2 at $585,000, and 16 first sales of new homes at Shores at Stillwater at $523,250 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026).

The all-sales median for the five plats, $485,000, is a number no single home in the set is likely to sell for by accident. It sits between a cluster of Unit 3 sales in the high $200,000s and low $300,000s and a cluster of Unit 1, Unit 2 and Shores sales above $500,000, and only 4 of the 35 sales fell in the $450,000 to $499,999 band (same source and window). A seller who prices a 1,349 square foot Unit 3 home from that median overshoots by a wide margin, and a buyer who reads it as the price of a 2,200 square foot Unit 1 home undershoots. Our first step is to place the home in its plat, its county use code and its size band before anyone names a number.

Shores at Stillwater adds a second layer. Every one of its 16 sales in the window was the first qualified sale of a home built in 2025 or 2026, and each of those homes sits inside the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District, which the older Stillwater plats are not part of (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). A resale in Unit 1 and a new Pulte home across Medical Boulevard can show similar prices on paper while carrying different annual costs, different warranties and different contract terms. We read both sides of that comparison for every client.

The Credentials We Bring to Stillwater

These are the credentials we bring to that work:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

In the 2026 RealTrends rankings, Domain Realty Group was the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026): 241 transactions, $157M+ volume, and the #1 real estate team in Bonita Springs by sales volume and by transaction sides. Domain Realty Group has closed 4,000+ transactions as a team.

How to Compare Agents for a Stillwater Sale or Purchase

Start with what is public. Our best real estate agents in Englewood page sets out a fair way to compare the agents and teams who work in Englewood, using reviews, licensing history and published production rather than slogans. For a home in Stillwater, Englewood, add two questions that the general comparison cannot answer.

First, ask each agent which plat the home is in and what that plat sold for. ZIP 34223 covers a large part of Englewood, from older homes near Dearborn Street to new construction on the River Road corridor, and a ZIP-wide figure says little about a Stillwater home. Inside Stillwater itself, the median Unit 3 home on the county roll has 1,349 heated square feet and the median Unit 1 home has 2,204 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). An agent who cannot tell you that, or who cannot separate a Shores at Stillwater first sale from an older Stillwater resale, has not opened the parcel file.

Second, ask what they would check before a price is set. At Shores at Stillwater that list includes the district's Phase One bond allocation of $18,580.37 on a 34-foot lot and $25,726.66 on a 52-foot lot, its maximum annual debt assessments of $1,382.68 and $1,914.48, and its $276 operations and maintenance rate (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; CDD Final Budget FY2026/2027, both read November 17, 2026). In the older Stillwater plats it includes the association documents, which we could not find in any public record online, and the flood zone of the specific lot. Those items move the cost of owning a home as much as square footage does, and they are where we start.

Talk to Jesse or Marc About Stillwater

Selling your Stillwater home? Start with a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 (text or call, same-day response).

Buying a home in Stillwater? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or read our buying guide.

Key Takeaways

Stillwater, Englewood is five recorded plats in unincorporated Sarasota County: the older Stillwater Units 1 to 3 and the new Pulte section, Shores at Stillwater. These twelve facts from the county parcel and sales file, the district's own records, Pulte's pages and county and school tools frame every decision below, each with its source and date or window.

Stillwater Market Takeaways

  • Stillwater recorded 35 qualified home sales at a $485,000 median. The window is October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; sales ran from $250,000 to $766,700, the middle half sold between $305,000 and $570,000, and the median price per heated square foot was $241 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026).
  • That median blends two markets. The 19 resales in the older Stillwater plats had a $315,000 median and a $203 median price per square foot, while the 16 first sales of new homes at Shores at Stillwater had a $523,250 median and $267 per square foot (same source and window).
  • Unit 3 and Units 1 and 2 trade far apart. Stillwater Unit 3 recorded 10 sales at a $282,500 median, Unit 1 recorded 7 at $550,000 and Unit 2 recorded 2 at $585,000 in the same 12 months (same source).
  • Older Stillwater resales sold above the same home's earlier sale. For the 15 of 19 resales that had an earlier qualified sale on the county file, the median change was 12.2 percent higher, over a median of 8 years between the two sales; that is a small sample to read as direction only (same source).

Stillwater Homes and Builder Takeaways

  • Stillwater is 394 parcels and 278 homes on the county roll. Stillwater Unit 1 has 77 parcels, Unit 2 has 36 and Unit 3 has 141; Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A has 54 and Phase 1B has 86, and 107 Shores lots were still coded vacant on the file dated October 21, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • Unit 3 is the small-home section. Its 140 homes have a 1,349 square foot median heated area and were built from 2007 to 2013, against medians of 2,204 square feet in Unit 1 and 2,181 in Unit 2, and the county roll gives Unit 3 and the finished Shores villas a separate single-family use code (0101) (same source).
  • Pulte was still selling Shores at Stillwater on November 17, 2026. Pulte listed seven plans from 1,321 to 2,870+ square feet with "Starting From" prices of $309,990 to $565,990, two attached villa plans and five single-family plans, and "255 future front doors" in all; these are Pulte's own list prices, not market values (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

Stillwater Location and Rules Takeaways

  • Stillwater is in Sarasota County, even though Pulte files Shores at Stillwater under "Sarasota." Pulte's address path uses its Sarasota sales market label; the district's own records place the Shores land "entirely within the unincorporated area of Sarasota County," and the Census Bureau's 2024 boundary files put the older Stillwater streets in Census Tract 27.33, Block Group 2, inside the Englewood Census Designated Place (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book; Census TIGER/Line 2024 block groups, both read November 17, 2026).
  • Only Shores at Stillwater is in a community development district. Sarasota County Ordinance No. 2025-032 created the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District on about 79.83 acres; the older Stillwater plats lie outside its legal description, and Phase One homes carry a maximum annual debt assessment of $1,382.68 on a 34-foot lot or $1,914.48 on a 52-foot lot (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026).
  • Both checked addresses returned the same three school zones. For one older Stillwater address and one Shores at Stillwater address, the Sarasota County School Zone Lookup returned Englewood Elementary Zone, L.A. Ainger Middle Zone and Wellen Park High Zone on November 17, 2026; confirm any exact address in the same tool (Sarasota County School Zone Lookup, read November 17, 2026).

Stillwater Cost, Hazard and Data Takeaways

  • Every Stillwater home carries the same county millage and fire assessment. The 2026 countywide rate for unincorporated parcels is 11.3068 mills, and the Englewood Area Fire Control District charges $290.78 per home and $63.95 per vacant lot for 2026 to 2027 (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Englewood Area Fire Control District, both read November 17, 2026).
  • Flood zone must be checked lot by lot, and MLS-only measures are not printed. An earlier check by our team on November 14, 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer) returned Zone X at one Lake Victoria Court address; every other lot must be checked on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center and its elevation certificate. Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active listings, months of supply and rents: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

Table of Contents

What Is Stillwater in Englewood, and Which County Is It In?

Stillwater in Englewood is five recorded plats in unincorporated Sarasota County, Florida: Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2 and Unit 3, with homes built from 2000 to 2016, and Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A and Phase 1B, a gated Pulte Homes section with homes built in 2025 and 2026. All 394 parcels carry Englewood 34223 addresses (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026).

What Is Stillwater, Englewood, Florida?

Stillwater, Englewood is a residential neighborhood east of Pine Street and south of the HCA Florida Englewood Hospital campus, laid out on streets named for lakes: Clear Lake Drive, Lake Tahoe Court, Lake Victoria Court, Ontario Court and Niagara Court, along with Abercrombie Drive, Abercrombie Avenue and Montigello Court. On the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026, the three older Stillwater plats hold 254 parcels, and 251 of them are homes with heated area on the roll, built from 2000 to 2016 with a median year built of 2008 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The remaining 3 parcels, one in each unit, carry use code 0900, which we read as common tracts.

Shores at Stillwater is newer and still being built. Pulte Homes, a PulteGroup brand, markets it as a gated community of "Twin villas and single-family home designs" with "255 future front doors," a heated community pool and a cabana (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). On the county file its two recorded phases hold 140 parcels, of which 27 were homes with heated area on the roll and 107 were lots still coded vacant (use code 0000); the other 6 carry tract or common-area codes by our reading.

The two sections are not one development under one set of rules: they were built about two decades apart, by different builders, and only Shores at Stillwater sits inside a community development district. On this page "Stillwater" alone means all five plats, "older Stillwater" means Units 1 to 3, and "Shores at Stillwater" means Pulte's section on Silver Shores Boulevard and Tavira Place.

The Five Plats: Stillwater Units 1, 2 and 3 and Shores at Stillwater Phases 1A and 1B

The Sarasota County Property Appraiser file holds five plats under the Stillwater name, and the table sets each one beside its home count, building years and, where we could read it, its recorded plat book and page. Parcel and home counts are from the county file dated October 21, 2026; plat references are from the Shores at Stillwater district's own legal descriptions.

Recorded plat

Parcels

Homes with heated area on the roll

Years built (median)

Median heated sq ft

Plat book and page (as read)

Stillwater Unit 1

77

76

2000 to 2016 (2004)

2,204

Not found online

Stillwater Unit 2

36

35

2005 to 2006 (2006)

2,181

Plat Book 45, Pages 12 through 12C

Stillwater Unit 3

141

140

2007 to 2013 (2011)

1,349

Not found online

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A

54

19

2025 to 2026 (2026)

1,977

Plat Book 59, Pages 140 to 147

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B

86

8

2026

1,574

Plat Book 59, Pages 122 to 127

All five plats

394

278

2000 to 2026 (2009)

1,616

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; plat references from the Shores at Stillwater CDD April 20, 2026 and June 15, 2026 meeting books, read November 17, 2026)

The Stillwater Unit 2 reference comes from the district's boundary description, which begins at "the Southeast corner of STILLWATER, UNIT TWO, according to the Plat thereof, recorded in Plat Book 45, Pages 12 through 12C" and runs along Unit Two's east line (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). That one sentence tells a reader two useful things: Shores at Stillwater's south parcel shares a boundary with older Stillwater, and the district line was drawn to start where Unit Two ends. The plat book and page for Units 1 and 3, and the recording dates of all five plats, were not in any document we could read; the Sarasota County Clerk's official records index or a title search holds them.

The Shores at Stillwater counts on the roll are slightly larger than the district's lot counts. The district assesses 52 lots in Phase 1A (lots 1 to 10, 40 to 64 and 84 to 100) and 84 in Phase 1B (lots 101 to 130, 171 to 212 and 244 to 255), 136 in all, while the county file shows 54 and 86 parcels (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The difference is consistent with common tracts carrying their own parcel numbers, but we did not confirm it parcel by parcel.

Who Builds Shores at Stillwater, and Who Built the Older Stillwater Plats?

Pulte Homes builds Shores at Stillwater. On November 17, 2026 Pulte's community page showed a "$309,990+" headline price, a size range of "1,321 - 2,870 sqft," two home types ("Single Family Home" and "Villa") and the tag "Quick Move-Ins Available," with a sales center at 2048 Silver Shores Blvd, Englewood, FL 34223, phone (941) 389-1010, open Monday to Saturday 9:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. and Sunday 12:00 to 5:30 p.m. (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). Those prices are Pulte's own list figures for that day, not market values and not county sale prices; recorded sales are in the market section below.

The district record names the developer behind the land in plain terms. The Phase One assessment methodology identifies "Pulte Home Company, LLC, or its successors or assigns" as the developer, and of the 136 Phase One lots on the roll it prepared, 125 listed Pulte Home Company LLC as owner and 11 listed individual buyers (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The district engineer's report says the development "will be developed in four (4) phases," that the PUD approval "allows for a maximum of 269 units," and that "The current approved site development plans include 255 units," split between 119 detached homes on 52-foot lots and 136 attached homes on 34-foot lots (same source). Only Phases 1A and 1B are platted on the county roll so far.

The builder or developer of the older Stillwater plats is a different matter. We searched for a primary source, such as a plat dedication, a news report from the 2000s, a builder release or a public filing, and did not find one. Some listing pages name builders for parts of older Stillwater, but those are not records we can verify, so we do not name a builder here. The recorded plats for Units 1, 2 and 3, which show who dedicated each plat, and the declaration of covenants, which names the declarant, are the documents that settle it. A title company or the Sarasota County Clerk's official records hold both.

Is Stillwater in Sarasota County or Charlotte County?

Stillwater is in Sarasota County. The confusion has two sources. Englewood itself is a Census Designated Place that straddles two counties: the 2020 Census geographic header lists an "Englewood CDP" with a Sarasota County part and a Charlotte County part (Census 2020 PL 94-171, Florida, read November 17, 2026). And Pulte's web address for Shores at Stillwater files it under Florida, then Sarasota, then Englewood, with a breadcrumb that reads Florida, Sarasota, Englewood (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). That "Sarasota" is Pulte's sales market label. It is not the City of Sarasota, which is a separate municipality well to the north.

Four records settle the county. First, all 394 parcels are on the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file, and every one carries an Englewood address in ZIP 34223 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Second, the Shores at Stillwater district's methodology describes the district as "a local unit of special-purpose government located entirely within the unincorporated area of Sarasota County, Florida" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). Third, the district itself was created by a Sarasota County ordinance, No. 2025-032, which the Florida Department of State acknowledged receiving on February 11, 2026 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, Ordinance 2025-032, read November 17, 2026). Fourth, the Census Bureau's 2024 street and block group files put every older Stillwater street we tested inside Sarasota County (FIPS 12115), in the Sarasota County part of the Englewood CDP (Census TIGER/Line 2024 block groups, read November 17, 2026).

The Charlotte County part of Englewood begins a short distance to the south and east, and some nearby places are on that side of the line, including Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park on Manasota Key. That does not change where a Stillwater home is taxed, permitted or zoned. A Stillwater home pays Sarasota County millage, files for homestead with the Sarasota County Property Appraiser and is zoned for Sarasota County public schools. Stillwater is also unincorporated: the Census Bureau's 2024 place file shows no incorporated city at any older Stillwater street point, only the Englewood CDP, a statistical area (Census TIGER/Line 2024 places, Florida, read November 17, 2026), so zoning, permits and code enforcement are Sarasota County functions.

Which Census Tract and Commission District Cover Stillwater?

By point-in-polygon against the Census Bureau's 2024 block group file, every older Stillwater street point we tested, including Lake Victoria Court, Clear Lake Drive, Lake Tahoe Court, Montigello Court, Abercrombie Drive, Niagara Court, Ontario Court and both blocks of Abercrombie Avenue, falls in Census Tract 27.33, Block Group 2, Sarasota County (GEOID 121150027332), and the 700 block of Medical Boulevard falls in the same block group (Census TIGER/Line 2024 block groups, read November 17, 2026). Shores at Stillwater's streets, Silver Shores Boulevard and Tavira Place, are too new to appear in the 2024 Census street file, so no Census point exists for them yet; a test point east of the hospital, in the area the land-sale reporting describes, also fell inside the Englewood CDP.

Block Group 2 is far larger than Stillwater, about 25.7 square miles of land reaching north-east toward the River Road corridor, so its figures describe the surrounding area and not Stillwater alone. With that caution, the 2020 Census counted 748 housing units in the block group, 84 of them vacant and 47 of those held for seasonal, recreational or occasional use (Census 2020 DHC, Florida, read November 17, 2026). Those counts predate every Shores at Stillwater home.

The American Community Survey adds a housing-age contrast. Its 2020 to 2024 five-year estimates give a median year built of 2008 (plus or minus 4 years) for both Tract 27.33 and Block Group 2, against 1982 for the Sarasota County part of the Englewood CDP (ACS 2024 five-year table B25035, read November 17, 2026). The tract's median value of owner-occupied homes is estimated at $561,000, with a margin of error of plus or minus $38,969 (Census Reporter, Census Tract 27.33, repackaging the Census Bureau's ACS 2020 to 2024 release, read November 17, 2026). That is an owner's estimate pooled over five years across a 33.6 square mile tract, not a sale price and not a Stillwater figure; the county's recorded sales below are the better measure for Stillwater itself.

On the Board of County Commissioners, Your Observer reported in December 2025 that Ron Cutsinger, who represents District 5, was chosen as the commission's 2026 chair, and that his district on the "southern end of Sarasota County" includes much of North Port and Englewood (Your Observer, "Sarasota County commissioners pick chair, vice chair," December 19, 2025, read November 17, 2026). We did not check the district line at a Stillwater parcel in the county's own district locator, so confirm a given address with Sarasota County before relying on it.

Which Other Places Share the Stillwater Name?

Stillwater is a common place name, and the overlap shows up in search results and even in public records. There are cities named Stillwater in Minnesota and Oklahoma, a "Shores at Stillwater" in Park City, Utah, a "Stillwater Cay" in Estero, Florida, and a "Stillwater on the Bay" in Sarasota. None of them has any connection to Stillwater in Englewood.

The last one matters most for data. The Sarasota County Property Appraiser file holds 7 parcels under "Stillwater on the Bay," on Bay Harbor Lane with Sarasota 34231 addresses (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Because they share the county and part of the name, a careless search of the county file could fold them into Englewood figures. We excluded them, and every count on this page is limited to the five plats named STILLWATER UNIT 1, STILLWATER UNIT 2, STILLWATER UNIT 3, SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1A and SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1B. When you read about "Stillwater" anywhere else, check for the Englewood 34223 address before you trust the number.

What Does New Construction Mean for a Stillwater Buyer or Seller?

In Stillwater, Englewood, new construction and resale are almost equal halves of the recent market. Of the 35 qualified sales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, 16 were first sales of new Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater and 19 were resales in the older plats, about 45.7 and 54.3 percent (our arithmetic; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). For a general explanation of how a builder's contract, deposit and closing process differ from a resale in Englewood, read our new construction in Englewood guide.

Three facts follow from the split. First, the two halves come with different paperwork. A Shores at Stillwater buyer signs Pulte's purchase agreement, receives Pulte's written limited warranty and, because the home is inside a community development district, must see the statutory district disclosure printed above the signature line on the initial sale contract (Florida Statutes 190.048, read November 17, 2026). An older Stillwater buyer signs a resale contract with a private seller and inherits a home that is 10 to 26 years old by its roll year built.

Second, the two halves have different annual costs. The older Stillwater plats lie outside the Shores at Stillwater district's legal description, so they carry no district debt or operations line, while a Shores at Stillwater Phase One home carries a district debt assessment until the Series 2026 bonds mature in May 2056 or the lot's share is prepaid (Shores at Stillwater CDD, Amended Final Budget 2025-2026, read November 17, 2026).

Third, the two halves are priced on different bases. A Shores at Stillwater first sale starts from Pulte's base price, lot and options, and Pulte changes prices and incentives through the year; on November 17, 2026 its two advertised move-in-ready homes each showed a "Was" price above the current one (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). An older Stillwater resale is priced against the few recent sales in its own plat, and it competes with Pulte's new inventory across the road.

Where Is Stillwater, and How Do You Get Around?

Stillwater, Englewood sits off Medical Boulevard, east of Pine Street, beside the HCA Florida Englewood Hospital campus in the Sarasota County part of Englewood. By routing estimate on November 17, 2026 from an Abercrombie Avenue point, the hospital is about 0.6 road miles away, Dearborn Street 2.3 miles and Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park 3.4 miles.

Which Roads Lead to Stillwater?

Medical Boulevard is the way in. In the Census Bureau's 2024 road file, Abercrombie Drive and Clear Lake Drive each share an end point with Medical Boulevard, Abercrombie Avenue links Clear Lake Drive, Abercrombie Drive and Ontario Court, and Medical Boulevard in turn connects to Pine Street, Power Line Road and Poincianna Avenue (the Census file's spelling) (Census TIGER/Line 2024 roads, Sarasota County, read November 17, 2026). By that file, the older Stillwater street network reaches the public road system through Medical Boulevard. Pine Street runs north to south along the west edge of older Stillwater (same source).

Shores at Stillwater uses the same road. The district engineer describes the development as "located in Sarasota County on the south side of Medical Blvd, approximately 0.8 miles east of Pine Street," in two parcels, one "on the south side of Medical Blvd across from the HCA Florida Englewood Hospital (South Parcel)" and the other "at the eastern terminus of Medical Blvd (North Parcel)" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's own directions agree: from U.S. 41, take West River Road 6.5 miles, turn left on Pine Street, then left on Medical Boulevard and "continue straight for .8 miles," with the community on the left (Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Pulte also gives a route from Interstate 75 at Exit 170 in Charlotte County by way of Kings Highway and Veterans Boulevard.

The larger arterials are a short distance away. Measured in a straight line from the center of older Stillwater, the nearest segment of State Road 776 (McCall Road and Indiana Avenue) is about 1.2 miles west and south, River Road is about 1.0 mile north and east, East Dearborn Street about 1.0 mile and Power Line Road about 0.5 mile (Census TIGER/Line 2024 roads, Sarasota County, read November 17, 2026). Those are straight-line distances, not drive distances. River Road carries two route labels in public sources: the Florida Department of Transportation's interstate exit list names it "CR 777 (River Rd)" at Exit 191, while the Census road file carries both county and state route names on nearby segments (FDOT, Interstate Exit Numbers for I-75, read November 17, 2026). We call it River Road.

Current traffic counts for the roads around Stillwater were not available to us; the only State Road 776 counts we could read date from 2013, so we do not print them. FDOT's Florida Traffic Online carries the current figures.

How Far Is Stillwater From the Beach, the Hospital and Nearby Towns?

All times below are routing estimates, not official distances. We placed each destination from the Census Bureau's 2024 address-range files (or, for Boca Grande and the airports, a published coordinate) and asked the OSRM public routing service for road distance and free-flow drive time from a point on the 150 block of Abercrombie Avenue in older Stillwater on November 17, 2026. Free-flow means no traffic, no bridge openings and no construction, so real trips run longer, especially in season and during the State Road 776 work (OSRM routing table service, computed November 17, 2026).

From Stillwater, Englewood to

Road distance (routing estimate)

Drive time (routing estimate, free-flow)

Straight-line distance

HCA Florida Englewood Hospital, 700 Medical Blvd

0.6 miles

2 minutes

0.5 miles

Dearborn Street, 100 W Dearborn St block

2.3 miles

5 minutes

1.5 miles

Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park, 2100 N Beach Rd (Charlotte County)

3.4 miles

8 minutes

2.1 miles

Venice City Hall, 401 W Venice Ave

13.8 miles

27 minutes

12.6 miles

I-75 Exit 193, Jacaranda Blvd interchange

14.1 miles

26 minutes

11.7 miles

North Port City Hall, 4970 City Hall Blvd

15.7 miles

28 minutes

11.8 miles

Boca Grande village (published coordinate)

16.1 miles

31 minutes

14.5 miles

Port Charlotte Town Center, 1441 Tamiami Trl

16.5 miles

25 minutes

12.6 miles

Data updated: November 2026 (OSRM routing estimates computed November 17, 2026; destination points from Census TIGER/Line 2024 address-range files for Sarasota County and Charlotte County)

Two published claims line up with the beach estimate. Pulte says the beaches are "less than 3.5 miles away" from Shores at Stillwater (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026), and Sarasota Magazine put the community "about 3.5 miles from Englewood's beaches" in November 2024 (Sarasota Magazine, November 8, 2024, read November 17, 2026). Our 3.4-mile routing estimate to Chadwick Park is close enough to treat them as the same trip. Pulte's 2.5-mile figures for the Englewood Sports Complex and the Lemon Bay Playhouse are builder-stated and were not routed.

We do not print a drive time to Interstate 75 Exit 191 at River Road, because the router's result for that interchange was not reliable; check that trip in a map app.

Which Airports Serve Stillwater?

Three commercial airports serve the region, and none is close. By routing estimate from the same older Stillwater point on November 17, 2026, Punta Gorda Airport (PGD) is 28.7 road miles and 49 minutes away, Sarasota Bradenton International Airport (SRQ) is 42.5 miles and 65 minutes away, and Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) is 65.8 miles and 86 minutes away (OSRM routing table service, computed November 17, 2026, using each airport's published coordinates).

From Stillwater, Englewood to

Road distance (routing estimate)

Drive time (routing estimate, free-flow)

Straight-line distance

Punta Gorda Airport (PGD), unincorporated Charlotte County

28.7 miles

49 minutes

21.4 miles

Sarasota Bradenton International Airport (SRQ)

42.5 miles

65 minutes

33.7 miles

Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW), unincorporated Lee County

65.8 miles

86 minutes

45.8 miles

Data updated: November 2026 (OSRM routing estimates computed November 17, 2026)

What Is Next Door to Stillwater on Medical Boulevard?

Two large public-facing facilities share Medical Boulevard with Stillwater, Englewood. HCA Florida Englewood Hospital is at 700 Medical Blvd, Englewood, FL 34223, phone 941-475-6571, and describes itself as "our 100-bed acute care hospital" with a 24/7 emergency room, cardiovascular care, general surgery, imaging, orthopedic care and a Primary Stroke Center (HCA Florida Healthcare, Englewood Hospital, read November 17, 2026). By routing estimate it is 0.6 road miles from the Abercrombie Avenue origin, and the district engineer places Shores at Stillwater's south parcel directly "across from" it.

The Englewood YMCA, part of SKY Family YMCA, is at 701 Medical Blvd, Englewood, FL 34223, phone 941-475-1234, with branch hours of 5:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. Monday to Thursday, 5:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. Friday, 7:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. Saturday and 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Sunday (SKY Family YMCA, Englewood YMCA, read November 17, 2026). Membership, programs and fees are set by the YMCA, so check its page. Sarasota Magazine described Pulte's purchase as "a 32-acre lot west of the YMCA, and across the street, a 45-acre lot east of HCA Florida Englewood Hospital," which places the two Shores parcels on either side of these two facilities (Sarasota Magazine, November 8, 2024, read November 17, 2026).

Water is close too. Measured in a straight line from older Stillwater streets, the nearest edge of Lemon Bay in the Census water file is about 1.1 miles from Abercrombie Avenue near Pine Street and about 1.2 miles from Lake Victoria Court, and the Gulf is about 2.3 to 2.8 miles away (Census TIGER/Line 2024 area water, Sarasota County, read November 17, 2026). A stream the Census file labels "Rocky Crk" runs about 0.5 mile east of Ontario Court (same source). The internal Stillwater lakes, suggested by the street names, are not mapped in that Census layer; the plats and the county's aerial maps show them.

Which Grocery Stores, Shops and Dining Areas Are Near Stillwater?

Two Publix stores in Englewood appear in Publix's own sources. Olde Village Publix, store 737, is at 55 N Indiana Ave, Englewood, FL 34223, with a pharmacy at (941) 473-3301, bakery, deli, produce, meat and seafood departments, and a Publix Liquor Store in the same center (Publix, Olde Village Publix, read November 17, 2026). Publix's newsroom reports a new 54,964 square foot store at Merchants Crossing, 1500 Placida Rd., Ste. C, Englewood, FL 34223, opened November 5, 2026, with a full-service pharmacy and Publix Liquors next door (Publix newsroom, "Publix opens new store in Englewood, Florida", read November 17, 2026). We did not route a drive time to either store.

For a walkable district of independent shops and restaurants, Visit Sarasota describes Dearborn Street in Old Englewood Village as "several blocks of independent shops & eateries," with boutiques, galleries, coffee shops, live music at several venues and a farmers market "every Thursday (Oct to May)" (Visit Sarasota, Dearborn Street Englewood, read November 17, 2026). By routing estimate the 100 block of West Dearborn Street is 2.3 road miles and 5 minutes from older Stillwater. Market dates and vendors vary by season, so check before you go.

What Road Projects Are Planned Near Stillwater?

Two Florida Department of Transportation projects on State Road 776 are under way, and a large county widening of River Road and Winchester Boulevard is scheduled to start in 2027. None of them changes the Medical Boulevard route into Stillwater, Englewood, but each affects trips out of it.

FDOT project 447882-1, "SR 776 From Charlotte County Line to Tangerine Woods Blvd.," is a 2.189-mile project that replaces the two-way center turn lane with raised medians and directional turn lanes and adds protected bike lanes on the south portion; its page lists the construction phase, a start in "Mid 2026" and completion in "Mid 2027," last updated October 20, 2026 (SWFLRoads, FDOT project 447882-1, read November 17, 2026). FDOT's companion fact sheet for project 451014-1, "S.R. 776 from Charlotte County Line to South of U.S. 41," lists resurfacing over 8 miles in Englewood, Sarasota County, a construction cost of "$15.4 Million" and the same mid-2026 to mid-2027 schedule, and says the combined contract with the median project is estimated at $15 million overall (SWFLRoads, FDOT fact sheet 451014-1, read November 17, 2026). Trips from Stillwater to Venice, Dearborn Street and the beaches use segments inside those limits, so expect lane closures through 2027.

Suncoast Searchlight, reporting through WGCU on November 13, 2026, said the South River Road and Winchester Boulevard widening covers a 7.3-mile corridor from Tamiami Trail to the Charlotte County border, at a cost of "$95 million," with a timeline of "Spring 2027 to Summer 2029"; it quoted the county saying "The South River Road corridor serves as an important evacuation route for Englewood and the barrier islands" (WGCU, "Sarasota County is playing catch-up on roads," November 13, 2026, read November 17, 2026). Final designs were still being drawn, so the schedule may move.

We found no county or FDOT project that names Medical Boulevard or Pine Street. The Sarasota County Capital Improvement Program and its Public Works project list are where to check for local work near Stillwater.

What Does the Stillwater Market Look Like Right Now?

Stillwater, Englewood recorded 35 qualified home sales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, at a $485,000 median and a $241 median price per heated square foot. Nineteen were resales in the older Stillwater plats at a $315,000 median, and 16 were first sales of new homes at Shores at Stillwater at $523,250 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

Every figure in this section comes from one county source, the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The newest qualified sale in our Stillwater parcel set is dated October 13, 2026. The county record lags the market by several weeks, which is why the 12-month window ends in mid-October rather than in November, and why the newest month in the file reads lower than it will once later deeds are recorded.

How we counted (method note). We tracked every qualified sale on the Sarasota County file for the five Stillwater plats, one file and one window at a time. In the last 12 months we tracked 35 qualified improved sales in Stillwater, from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026. Our Stillwater parcel set is every Sarasota County parcel in the five recorded plats STILLWATER UNIT 1, STILLWATER UNIT 2, STILLWATER UNIT 3, SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1A and SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1B: 394 parcels, all Englewood 34223. "Stillwater on the Bay" (7 parcels on Bay Harbor Lane, Sarasota 34231) is a different place and is excluded. A sale counts if the county file marks it as a qualified sale, the parcel is improved and the price is over $1,000. The 12-month window is October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; the 24-month window starts October 15, 2024, the 36-month window October 15, 2023 and the 60-month window October 15, 2021. A "first sale" is the first qualified improved sale of that home on the county file; at Shores at Stillwater every sale in the window was the first sale of a home built in 2025 or 2026. We do not call these builder-direct sales, because the county file does not name the seller; we call them first sales of new homes. A "resale" is a sale of a home in the older Stillwater plats. The county roll codes the Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes 0100, the roll's single-family detached code, and gives all 140 Unit 3 homes and the finished Shores villas a separate single-family use code, 0101. Price per heated square foot uses the heated area on the roll. Three qualified sales of vacant land in 2026 are left out of every home figure below.

What Did Stillwater Homes Sell For in the Last 12 Months?

The 35 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026 had a $485,000 median and ranged from $250,000 to $766,700, with the middle half between $305,000 and $570,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The homes that sold had a median heated area of 1,948 square feet and a median year built of 2013.

Measure, Stillwater (Stillwater Units 1 to 3 and Shores at Stillwater Phases 1A and 1B; ZIP 34223)

Value

Qualified improved sales, October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026

35

Median sale price

$485,000

Lowest and highest sale

$250,000 to $766,700

Middle half of sales (25th to 75th percentile)

$305,000 to $570,000

Median price per heated square foot

$241

Middle half, price per heated square foot

$200 to $268

Median heated area of homes sold

1,948 sq ft

Median year built of homes sold

2013

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

How Do Prices Differ Between Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3 and Shores at Stillwater?

In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A recorded 12 sales at a $564,750 median, Stillwater Unit 1 recorded 7 at $550,000, Unit 2 recorded 2 at $585,000, Shores Phase 1B recorded 4 at $390,300 and Unit 3 recorded 10 at $282,500 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The spread between the highest and lowest plat medians was $302,500 (our arithmetic: $585,000 minus $282,500).

Plat, 12 months to October 14, 2026

Sales

Median

Range

Median price per heated sq ft

Stillwater Unit 1

7

$550,000

$450,000 to $590,000

$214

Stillwater Unit 2

2

$585,000

$550,000 and $620,000

$257

Stillwater Unit 3

10

$282,500

$250,000 to $315,000

$198

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A

12

$564,750

$455,000 to $766,700

$290

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B

4

$390,300

$375,000 to $407,600

$248

All five plats

35

$485,000

$250,000 to $766,700

$241

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

Read the plat medians beside the home mix. Unit 3's ten sales all fell between $250,000 and $315,000, a tight band that matches a plat of 140 homes with a 1,349 square foot median. Unit 1's seven sales fell between $450,000 and $590,000, and its homes have a 2,204 square foot median. The Unit 2 median rests on only two sales, $550,000 and $620,000, so it is a pair of data points rather than a market level (same source).

The two Shores phases differ for the same reason. Phase 1B's 8 homes on the roll are all 1,574 square feet, and its 4 sales sat between $375,000 and $407,600; Phase 1A's homes have a 1,977 square foot median and its 12 sales ran from $455,000 to $766,700 (same source). A Shores at Stillwater price therefore depends first on whether the home is one of Pulte's attached villas or one of its single-family plans, and only then on lot and options.

Notice also where the plats overlap. The lowest Unit 1 sale, $450,000, sits just below the lowest Phase 1A sale, $455,000, and the Unit 1 median of $550,000 is within $14,750 of the Phase 1A median of $564,750 (our arithmetic). For a buyer choosing between an older detached home in Unit 1 and a new single-family Pulte home, the price levels are close; what separates them is size, age, the district assessment and the warranty.

How Do Older Stillwater Resales Compare With First Sales at Shores at Stillwater?

The 19 resales in Stillwater Units 1 to 3 in the 12 months to October 14, 2026 had a $315,000 median, while the 16 first sales of new homes at Shores at Stillwater had a $523,250 median, a gap of $208,250 at the median (our arithmetic; Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

12 months, October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026

Sales

Median

Range

Middle half

Median price per heated sq ft

All qualified improved sales

35

$485,000

$250,000 to $766,700

$305,000 to $570,000

$241

Older Stillwater (Units 1 to 3), resales

19

$315,000

$250,000 to $620,000

$280,000 to $550,000

$203

Shores at Stillwater, first sales of homes built 2025 or 2026

16

$523,250

$375,000 to $766,700

$419,450 to $662,575

$267

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

The older-Stillwater median is pulled down by the mix of what sold, not only by price. Ten of the 19 older resales were in Unit 3, the small-home plat, so the $315,000 median lands near the top of the Unit 3 range rather than in the middle of the older stock (same source). The older homes that sold had a median heated area of 1,536 square feet, against 1,948 for all 35 sales. Comparing the $315,000 resale median with the $523,250 Shores median without that context would overstate the premium for new construction.

The use-code split shows the same pattern from a different angle. The county roll's single-family detached code, 0100, covers the Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes and the finished single-family Shores homes; the separate 0101 code covers all of Unit 3 and the finished Shores villas.

Use code on the county roll, 12 months to October 14, 2026

Sales

Median

Range

0100 (single-family detached: Units 1 and 2, Shores single-family homes)

21

$550,000

$450,000 to $766,700

0101 (separate single-family code: Unit 3, Shores villas)

14

$301,000

$250,000 to $407,600

All qualified improved sales

35

$485,000

$250,000 to $766,700

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

By our arithmetic, the 21 sales coded 0100 are the 7 Unit 1 and 2 Unit 2 sales plus 12 Shores sales, and the 14 coded 0101 are the 10 Unit 3 sales plus 4 Shores sales. The $249,000 gap between the two use-code medians (our arithmetic: $550,000 minus $301,000) is the clearest single number on this page for how much home type matters in Stillwater, Englewood. Over 24 months the same split reads 30 sales at a $555,000 median for 0100 and 25 at $317,500 for 0101, and over 60 months 43 at $592,000 and 43 at $360,000 (same source).

The first Shores at Stillwater closing on the county file is dated February 27, 2026, so the Shores line stays at 16 sales and a $523,250 median in every longer window below.

What Does a Square Foot Cost in Stillwater?

The median price per heated square foot for Stillwater's 35 qualified sales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 was $241, with the middle half between $200 and $268 and a range from $183 to $385 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Older Stillwater resales had a $203 median and Shores at Stillwater first sales $267.

Price per heated square foot, 12 months to October 14, 2026

Sales

Median

Middle half

Lowest to highest

All qualified improved sales

35

$241

$200 to $268

$183 to $385

Older Stillwater (Units 1 to 3)

19

$203

$192 to $246

$183 to $268

Shores at Stillwater

16

$267

$241 to $329

$234 to $385

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

The gap is $64 per heated square foot at the median (our arithmetic: $267 minus $203). On a 2,000 square foot home that is $128,000 of price difference attributable to the square-foot rate alone, before size, lot or options (our arithmetic, an illustration and not an appraisal). That gap is the single most important number for an older Stillwater seller to understand: a buyer touring a Pulte model and then an older home a few hundred yards away is weighing a new home's warranty, impact glass and tile roof, which Pulte says it includes (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026), against a lower price per square foot and no district assessment.

By plat, the medians move with the window:

Plat

12 months, from October 15, 2025

24 months, from October 15, 2024

60 months, from October 15, 2021

Stillwater Unit 1

$214 (7 sales)

$261 (12 sales)

$264 (21 sales)

Stillwater Unit 2

$257 (2 sales)

$251 (6 sales)

$262 (10 sales)

Stillwater Unit 3

$198 (10 sales)

$215 (21 sales)

$237 (39 sales)

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A

$290 (12 sales)

$290 (12 sales)

$290 (12 sales)

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B

$248 (4 sales)

$248 (4 sales)

$248 (4 sales)

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

Within Unit 1 and Unit 3, the 12-month medians are lower than the 24 and 60-month medians (same source). With 7 and 10 sales in the latest year, that difference could reflect which homes sold, their condition and whether they had pools, as much as any change in the market, so we do not read a direction from it. Price per square foot also has limits of its own. The county measures heated area only, so a garage, a covered lanai, a pool and the lot are in the price but not in the square footage, and a smaller home often carries a higher rate than a larger one on the same street.

How Are Stillwater Sales Spread Across Price Bands?

Stillwater's 35 qualified sales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 spread across eleven $50,000 bands from $250,000 to $799,999, with the most sales, 6 each, in the $250,000 band and the $550,000 band (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Price band, Stillwater qualified sales, October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026

Sales

$250,000 to $299,999

6

$300,000 to $349,999

4

$350,000 to $399,999

2

$400,000 to $449,999

2

$450,000 to $499,999

4

$500,000 to $549,999

5

$550,000 to $599,999

6

$600,000 to $649,999

2

$650,000 to $699,999

1

$700,000 to $749,999

2

$750,000 to $799,999

1

Total

35

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

The shape has two humps, not one. Ten sales, about 28.6 percent, fell below $350,000; 8, about 22.9 percent, fell between $350,000 and $499,999; and 17, about 48.6 percent, sold at $500,000 or more (our arithmetic). The low hump is mostly Unit 3, whose ten sales all fell between $250,000 and $315,000; the high hump is Unit 1, Unit 2 and Phase 1A (same source).

The four sales at $650,000 or more were the top of the range, and all of them sat above the highest older Stillwater sale of the year, $620,000, so they were Shores at Stillwater first sales (our deduction from the two ranges). A valuation of any Stillwater home above $600,000 rests on very few comparable sales, and for an older home in that range the comparison set usually reaches back beyond 12 months.

How Many Stillwater Homes Sell Each Month?

Stillwater's monthly count of qualified sales ran from 0 to 7 between November 2025 and October 2026, with a peak of 7 in April 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Month

Qualified sales

October 2025 (from October 15)

0

November 2025

2

December 2025

0

January 2026

2

February 2026

6

March 2026

3

April 2026

7

May 2026

4

June 2026

4

July 2026

2

August 2026

3

September 2026

1

October 2026 (to October 14)

1

Total

35

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

The monthly average is about 2.9 sales (our arithmetic: 35 divided by 12). The four sales from October 15, 2025 through January 2026 all came before the first Shores at Stillwater closing on February 27, 2026, so they were all older Stillwater resales; from February on, the counts mix resales with Pulte's first closings, which follow Pulte's construction and delivery schedule as much as buyer demand (same source). The rise from February to June coincides with the start of Shores closings, and the file alone cannot say how much of it was seasonal demand for resales.

The last two months in the table, September and early October 2026, show one sale each. The county was still recording deeds when the October 21 file was pulled, so the newest months may read low. We do not read a trend from one or two months.

Do Older Stillwater Homes Resell Above Their Earlier Sale Price?

For the 15 older Stillwater resales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026 that had an earlier qualified sale of the same home on the county file, the median resale price was 12.2 percent higher than the earlier sale, with a range from 10.3 percent lower to 77.4 percent higher and a median of 8 years between the two sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

15 older Stillwater resales, October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, each compared with the same home's earlier qualified sale

Change

Median

12.2 percent higher

Lowest to highest

10.3 percent lower to 77.4 percent higher

Median time between the two sales

8 years

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

This is a small sample, so read it as direction only. Fifteen pairs is enough to say the typical older Stillwater resale in the last year sold above the owner's purchase price, and not enough to say by how much a particular home will. A median gain of 12.2 percent over a median 8 years is a modest figure, and the range shows that some owners sold below what they paid. We make no prediction about the next 12 months.

The comparison is also not a seller's net: the file does not record improvements made between the two sales, or concessions and selling costs. The other 4 of the 19 resales have no earlier qualified sale of the same home on the file, and the file does not say why. No Shores at Stillwater home had resold in the window; all 16 were first sales.

How Have Stillwater Prices Moved Over 24, 36 and 60 Months and by Calendar Year?

Over the 24 months from October 15, 2024 to October 14, 2026, Stillwater recorded 55 qualified sales at a $455,000 median; over 36 months, 63 sales at $454,000; and over 60 months, from October 15, 2021, 86 sales at $444,950 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Window

All sales

Median

Older Stillwater (Units 1 to 3)

Unit 1

Unit 2

Unit 3

Shores at Stillwater

12 months, from October 15, 2025

35

$485,000

19 at $315,000

7 at $550,000

2 at $585,000

10 at $282,500

16 at $523,250

24 months, from October 15, 2024

55

$455,000

39 at $362,500

12 at $562,500

6 at $546,000

21 at $305,000

16 at $523,250

36 months, from October 15, 2023

63

$454,000

47 at $390,000

not computed

not computed

not computed

16 at $523,250

60 months, from October 15, 2021

86

$444,950

70 at $402,750

21 at $590,000

10 at $593,500

39 at $350,000

16 at $523,250

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

The middle halves give a sense of spread in each window. Over 24 months the middle half of all sales ran from $320,000 to $565,000 and of older Stillwater sales from $302,000 to $550,000; over 36 months, $330,000 to $570,000 and $315,000 to $560,000; over 60 months, $359,000 to $592,550 and $341,250 to $590,000, with a top sale of $900,000 in Unit 1 (same source). The longer windows do not hold a larger share of Unit 1 and Unit 2 sales (9 of 19 older sales in 12 months, 18 of 39 in 24 months and 31 of 70 in 60 months, our count on the same file); the older-Stillwater median rises as the window lengthens because the unit medians themselves are higher over 60 months than over 12, Unit 3 most of all ($282,500 over 12 months, $305,000 over 24 and $350,000 over 60). That reflects which homes sold in each window, and we do not read a price trend from it.

Calendar year

Qualified sales

Median

Older Stillwater sales

Shores at Stillwater sales

2015

19

$295,000

19

0

2016

11

$235,000

11

0

2017

11

$335,000

11

0

2018

27

$269,900

27

0

2019

18

$322,000

18

0

2020

13

$271,000

13

0

2021

13

$377,600

13

0

2022

11

$400,900

11

0

2023

10

$539,950

10

0

2024

13

$390,000

13

0

2025

17

$500,000

17

0

2026, January 1 to October 14

33

$455,000

17

16

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

Calendar-year medians in Stillwater swing with which plat sold, and we do not claim a price trend from them. The 2023 median of $539,950 rests on 10 sales and the 2024 median of $390,000 on 13; a year with more Unit 1 sales reads high and a year with more Unit 3 sales reads low, whatever the market did. The 2026 figure is the first to include Shores at Stillwater, and its 33 sales are the most in any year in the table, almost double 2025's 17 (same source). What the calendar table does show reliably is volume: older Stillwater has recorded between 10 and 27 qualified sales a year since 2015, and in 2026 Pulte's first closings added 16 more.

The county file also holds 3 qualified sales of vacant land in the set in 2026, with a $400,000 median per deed. They are land and builder transfers, not public lot sales, and the price per deed is not a lot price, so we leave them out of every figure above and do not print them as lot values.

Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active listings, months of supply and rents: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Those measures come from the multiple listing service and are not in the county file. Pulte's list prices on November 17, 2026 are builder-stated, and the county sale prices above are recorded sales.

What Homes Are in Stillwater, and How Big Are They?

Stillwater, Englewood holds 278 homes on the county file dated October 21, 2026: 251 in the older plats, built from 2000 to 2016 with a 1,538 square foot median, and 27 at Shores at Stillwater, built in 2025 and 2026 with a 1,948 square foot median. Pulte lists seven plans from 1,321 to 2,870+ square feet (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Pulte).

What Does the County Roll Show for Each Stillwater Plat?

Each plat has its own size band and building years, and the five together hold four quite different products. The table is from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026.

Plat

Parcels

Homes with heated area

Use code of the homes

Parcels without heated area

Median heated sq ft (range)

Middle half

Years built (median)

Stillwater Unit 1

77

76

0100

1

2,204 (1,961 to 3,548)

2,068 to 2,466

2000 to 2016 (2004)

Stillwater Unit 2

36

35

0100

1

2,181 (1,976 to 2,525)

2,181 to 2,333

2005 to 2006 (2006)

Stillwater Unit 3

141

140

0101

1

1,349 (1,338 to 1,730)

1,349 to 1,525

2007 to 2013 (2011)

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A

54

19

0100 or 0101 (not split by phase)

35

1,977 (1,574 to 2,204)

1,948 to 2,088

2025 to 2026 (2026)

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B

86

8

0100 or 0101 (not split by phase)

78

1,574 (1,574 to 1,574)

1,574

2026

All five plats

394

278

128 coded 0100, 150 coded 0101

116

1,616 (1,338 to 3,548)

1,349 to 2,181

2000 to 2026 (2009)

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026)

The use-code counts by section are firmer than by phase. In the older plats, 111 homes are coded 0100 and 140 are coded 0101, which matches Units 1 and 2 (76 plus 35 homes) and Unit 3 (140 homes) exactly; 3 parcels carry code 0900 (same source). At Shores at Stillwater, 17 finished homes are coded 0100 and 10 are coded 0101, 107 lots are coded vacant (0000), 4 parcels carry 0900 and 2 carry 0001 (same source). Nine of the 10 Shores parcels coded 0101 are 1,574 square foot homes; the tenth, 2,204 square feet, is the parcel at Pulte's sales center address, so the 0101 code at Shores is not a pure villa count (same source). We read the 0900 and 0001 parcels as tracts and common areas from their codes, and we did not split the Shores use codes by phase.

The roll gives Unit 3 a different use code from Units 1 and 2, and its homes are much smaller. The roll does not say how the Unit 3 homes are built or joined, and we found no plat, declaration or county record that does, so we describe them only as smaller homes with their own single-family use code. Some brokerage pages give Unit 3 a separate name and describe its homes in more detail; we could not verify those descriptions from a primary source, and the recorded declaration and plat for Unit 3 are where to confirm them.

At Shores at Stillwater the product types are on the district's own record: 136 attached homes on 34-foot lots and 119 detached single-family homes on 52-foot lots, 255 in all, with 74 of the 34-foot and 62 of the 52-foot units in Phase One (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). Pulte calls the attached product its villas.

When Were Stillwater Homes Built?

Stillwater was built in two waves about a decade apart, then a third two decades later. The roll counts 144 homes built in the 2000s, 107 in the 2010s and 27 in the 2020s, and every 2020s home is at Shores at Stillwater: 8 built in 2025 and 19 in 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026).

Years built on the roll

Homes

Share of 278 homes (our arithmetic)

Where

2000 to 2009

144

51.8 percent

Unit 1 (half from 2003 to 2005), Unit 2 (2005 to 2006), early Unit 3

2010 to 2019

107

38.5 percent

Most of Unit 3 (to 2013) and the last Unit 1 homes (to 2016)

2025

8

2.9 percent

Shores at Stillwater

2026

19

6.8 percent

Shores at Stillwater

All homes

278

100 percent

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026)

Within the older plats the building years are tight. Half of Unit 1's 76 homes were built from 2003 to 2005, all 35 Unit 2 homes in 2005 or 2006, and half of Unit 3's 140 homes from 2010 to 2013 (same source). No older Stillwater home on the roll was built after 2016. The median year built for the 251 older homes is 2008.

Build years matter for three practical reasons. First, building codes: Florida's building code changes over time, and the edition in force when a home's permit was filed governs that home, so a 2004 Unit 1 home, a 2012 Unit 3 home and a 2026 Pulte home were not necessarily built to the same rules. We do not assert which edition applies to a given home, because the permit date decides it. Second, roofs and systems: on a home built from 2003 to 2006, ask for the permit dates of the current roof and air conditioner, because an insurer will ask for the roof's age and a wind mitigation report. Third, assessments: under Florida Statutes 192.042 a Shores at Stillwater home not substantially completed on the January 1 assessment date is taxed that year on the lot alone, and 107 Shores lots were still coded vacant on the October 2026 file.

How Big Are Stillwater Homes, and What Does the Roll Show for Bedrooms and Baths?

All 278 homes on the roll have a median of 1,616 heated square feet, a range from 1,338 to 3,548 and a middle half from 1,349 to 2,181 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). That overall median sits between two clusters: Unit 3's homes around 1,349 square feet and the Unit 1, Unit 2 and Shores homes around 1,950 to 2,200.

The older plats show the split most clearly. The 251 older Stillwater homes have a 1,538 square foot median and a range from 1,338 to 3,548; Unit 3's middle half is 1,349 to 1,525, while Unit 1's is 2,068 to 2,466 and Unit 2's 2,181 to 2,333 (same source). The largest home in the set, 3,548 square feet, is in Unit 1. The smallest Unit 1 home, 1,961 square feet, is larger than the largest Unit 3 home, 1,730, so the two plats do not overlap in size at all.

Unlike some county rolls, the Sarasota County file carries bedroom and bath counts. For the 251 older Stillwater homes:

Older Stillwater homes on the county roll (Units 1 to 3)

Homes

Share of 251 (our arithmetic)

2 bedrooms

83

33.1 percent

3 bedrooms

159

63.3 percent

4 bedrooms

9

3.6 percent

2 baths

231

92.0 percent

2.5 baths

6

2.4 percent

3 baths

14

5.6 percent

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026)

Roll counts are the county's record, not an inspection; the permit history and a walk-through settle a home's room count. We do not print roll bedroom counts for Shores at Stillwater, because only 27 of its homes were on the roll and Pulte's plan options change room counts; Pulte's own plan pages give the bedroom range for each plan.

Shores at Stillwater homes on the roll have a 1,948 square foot median, a range from 1,574 to 2,204 and a middle half from 1,574 to 1,992 (same source). Phase 1A's 19 homes have a 1,977 square foot median, and all 8 Phase 1B homes are 1,574 square feet. The roll's 1,574 sits close to Pulte's 1,579 square foot Ellenwood villa, but that is our comparison and not a county or Pulte statement, because roll areas and marketing areas are measured differently. None of the 27 homes on the roll is as large as Pulte's two-story Mystique Grande at 2,870+ square feet.

Which Streets Are in Stillwater?

Ten street names account for 390 of the 394 parcels on the roll; the other 4 are 2 parcels with no street address and 1 parcel each on Medical Boulevard in the older plats and at Shores at Stillwater. Every addressed parcel carries an Englewood 34223 address (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026).

Street on the roll

Parcels

Section

Abercrombie Dr

87

Older Stillwater

Tavira Pl

86

Shores at Stillwater

Silver Shores Blvd

53

Shores at Stillwater

Clear Lake Dr

51

Older Stillwater

Niagara Ct

32

Older Stillwater

Ontario Ct

21

Older Stillwater

Abercrombie Ave

19

Older Stillwater

Lake Tahoe Ct

18

Older Stillwater

Lake Victoria Ct

14

Older Stillwater

Montigello Ct

9

Older Stillwater

Medical Blvd

2

One in each section

No street address

2

Older Stillwater

All parcels

394

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026)

The older Stillwater streets sum to 251 parcels (our arithmetic: 87 plus 51 plus 32 plus 21 plus 19 plus 18 plus 14 plus 9), and with the 2 unaddressed parcels and 1 Medical Boulevard parcel they make the 254 older parcels. Tavira Place and Silver Shores Boulevard sum to 139, and with 1 Medical Boulevard parcel they make Shores at Stillwater's 140. The roll groups streets by section, not by unit, so a street name alone does not tell a buyer which of Units 1 to 3 a home is in or which price level applies. We check the plat before we check the street.

What Pulte Plans Are Sold at Shores at Stillwater?

Pulte lists seven plans at Shores at Stillwater, two attached villas and five single-family homes, every one with a two-car garage, and every size, room count and price below is builder-stated on Pulte's community page as read November 17, 2026 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Prices are Pulte's "Starting From" base prices on that day; they are not market values and change without notice.

Plan

Pulte series and type

Sq ft

Bedrooms

Baths

Stories

Starting from (Pulte)

Colton

Villa (attached)

1,321

2

2

1

$309,990

Ellenwood

Villa (attached)

1,579

2 to 3

2

1

$331,990

Prosperity

Distinctive, single-family

1,670+

2 to 3

2

1

$399,990

Mystique

Distinctive, single-family

1,889+

2 to 4

2 to 3

1

$419,990

Palmary

Distinctive, single-family

1,943+

2 to 3

2

1

$424,990

Prestige

Distinctive, single-family

2,080+

2 to 3

2.5

1

$452,990

Mystique Grande

Distinctive, single-family

2,870+

3 to 5

3 to 4

2

$565,990

Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte pages read November 17, 2026; builder-stated, not market values)

Pulte groups the plans into a Villa Collection, "$309,990+" and "1321+ sqft," which it describes as "The attached villa floor plan," and a Distinctive Collection, "$399,990+" and "1670+ sqft," described as "mid-range floor plan sizes" (same source). The plan descriptions follow a common pattern of an open gathering room, a café or dining area beside the kitchen, a private owner's suite with a walk-in closet and a covered lanai. The Mystique Grande is the only two-story plan: Pulte describes it as "everything the Mystique has plus a loft with an additional bed and bath," and its option captions include "Bedroom 4 in lieu of golf cart garage" (same source).

The range has widened since the project was announced. In November 2024 Sarasota Magazine reported plans of 1,579 to 2,080 square feet, "single-level living" and starting prices in the "mid-$300,000s" (Sarasota Magazine, November 8, 2024, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's 2026 list adds the smaller 1,321 square foot Colton and the two-story Mystique Grande, so the earlier article no longer describes what is for sale.

On November 17, 2026 Pulte also advertised two move-in-ready homes. A Prosperity at 1828 Silver Shores Blvd, 1,686 square feet with 3 bedrooms and 2 baths, showed "$444,990" with "Was $518,780," and an Ellenwood villa at 1596 Tavira Place, 1,579 square feet with 2 bedrooms and 2 baths, showed "$364,990" with "Was $405,880" (Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, both builder-stated). The differences, $73,790 and $40,890, are Pulte's own "Savings" figures (our arithmetic agrees). That is a snapshot, and one Pulte changes often; the price a buyer pays is in the purchase agreement, not on the web page.

What Does Pulte Include, and What Amenities Does It List at Shores at Stillwater?

Pulte's feature tags for Shores at Stillwater read "Natural Gas Community," "Gated, with Heated Pool & Cabana," "Impact Glass & Tile Roof Included" and "Quick Move-Ins Available," and its neighborhood list adds "Impact glass windows included with every home," "Natural gas appliances," "Water and preserve views" and "Personalized pool options for both the villas and single-family homes" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Impact glass and a tile roof bear directly on insurance and wind mitigation, and a buyer should get the window and roof specifications for the specific home in writing.

The move-in-ready Prosperity listing names an "oversized island," a "Gourmet built-in wall oven and microwave," an "Upgraded laundry room with sink," an "Extended lanai for outdoor living" and "Porcelain tile flooring" (Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Those are features of one home, not a standard list, and options vary by plan and homesite. Pulte also states that it was the "Florida Green Building Coalition (FGBC) 2020 Builder of the Year for the most certified single-family homes" and offers "an industry leading 10-year limited structural new home warranty" (same community page). Pulte's national warranty book sets the terms at one year for materials and workmanship, two years for heating, air conditioning, electrical and plumbing systems, five years for certain water infiltration and internal leaks, and ten years for structural elements (Pulte National Warranty Book, read November 17, 2026).

For shared amenities, Pulte lists a "Heated community pool," a "Pool cabana with covered seating," "BBQ grills" and "Mail kiosks" (same community page). The district engineer's report confirms that the development plan includes "an amenity center, and various open spaces for resident use," and states that "The roadways, irrigation, landscaping and amenity center will be private and are not included in the CIP" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). In other words, the pool, the cabana and the streets at Shores at Stillwater belong to the private side of the community, not to the district, while the district owns the stormwater ponds.

What we could not find for either section: the pool hours and guest rules at Shores at Stillwater, the name of its homeowners association and its dues, and, for the older Stillwater plats, whether there is a gate, a pool or a clubhouse and which association owns them. Pulte's pages say "Community Association fees required" and that payment estimates "do not include monthly homeowners' association dues," but give no dollar figure (same Pulte page). No public document we read says whether owners in older Stillwater may use the Shores at Stillwater amenities or the reverse. Information not available at time of publishing; the recorded declarations, the associations' management companies and Pulte's sales team hold it.

Buying New From Pulte at Shores at Stillwater vs Buying an Older Stillwater Home

Buying new at Shores at Stillwater means signing Pulte's contract for a 2025 or 2026 home inside a community development district, while buying an older Stillwater home means a seller's contract on a house built 2000 to 2016 with no CDD. In the 12 months to October 14, 2026 the county recorded 16 Shores first sales and 19 older resales.

What Counts as a First Sale and a Resale in Stillwater, Englewood?

We use two plain definitions on this page. A first sale is the first qualified improved sale of a home on the county file, which at Shores at Stillwater means the closing of a newly built home. A resale is a qualified sale of a home that already stood and, in most cases, already had an earlier qualified sale. The county file does not name the seller on a deed, so we never call a Shores closing "builder-direct". We say "first sales of new homes".

The numbers come from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, qualified improved sales over $1,000, across the five recorded plats of Stillwater Units 1 to 3 and Shores at Stillwater Phases 1A and 1B (394 parcels, all Englewood 34223). Stillwater on the Bay in Sarasota 34231 is a different place and is not counted.

In that window Stillwater in Englewood recorded 35 qualified home sales. Every one of the 16 Shores at Stillwater sales was a first sale of a home the roll dates to 2025 or 2026, and all 19 sales in the three older Stillwater plats were resales of homes built from 2000 to 2016 (same file). That split is clean because the newest older Stillwater home on the roll was built in 2016, nine years before the first Shores homes the roll dates to 2025, and Pulte builds only in Shores at Stillwater.

How Do Pulte's Published Prices Compare With Recorded Shores at Stillwater Sales?

They answer different questions, so we never blend them. Pulte's page shows what the builder is asking today for homes it still sells. The county file shows what closed. On November 17, 2026, Pulte's Shores at Stillwater page listed seven plans with "Starting From" prices of $309,990 for the Colton villa to $565,990 for the two-story Mystique Grande, and a headline range of 1,321 to 2,870 square feet (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). The page groups them as a Villa Collection from $309,990 and a Distinctive Collection of single-family homes from $399,990 (same page).

The 16 recorded first sales at Shores at Stillwater had a median of $523,250, a range of $375,000 to $766,700 and a middle half of $419,450 to $662,575 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026). Recorded prices sit above most base prices for three reasons a buyer can see on Pulte's own pages: the base price excludes options, the homesite affects price, and Pulte prices pools separately (its November offer valued a standard pool at $69,500). The county file does not itemize what each buyer bought, so we do not attribute any one sale to any one plan.

Pulte also advertised two finished homes on November 17, 2026, each marked "Available Now". These are builder-stated asking prices, not recorded sales:

Pulte quick move-in home (builder-stated)

Plan and series

Heated area per Pulte

Asking price

Pulte's "Was" price

Difference (Pulte's figure)

1828 Silver Shores Blvd

Prosperity, Distinctive

1,686 sq ft, 3 beds, 2 baths

$444,990

$518,780

$73,790

1596 Tavira Place

Ellenwood, Villa

1,579 sq ft, 2 beds, 2 baths

$364,990

$405,880

$40,890

Sources: Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in and Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026. Prices change without notice.

A gap between a "Was" price and an asking price is Pulte's own framing. It tells you that the builder is pricing finished inventory to move in November 2026. It does not tell you what an appraiser will value the home at, and it is not a recorded sale.

What Do Older Stillwater Resales and Shores at Stillwater First Sales Look Like Side by Side?

Here is the 12-month record for the two parts of Stillwater, Englewood. All figures are qualified improved sales over $1,000 in the window stated.

Stillwater, Englewood, 12 months (Oct 15, 2025 to Oct 14, 2026)

Older Stillwater (Units 1 to 3)

Shores at Stillwater (Phases 1A and 1B)

Sale type

Resales of homes built 2000 to 2016

First sales of homes built 2025 or 2026

Qualified sales

19

16

Median price

$315,000

$523,250

Range

$250,000 to $620,000

$375,000 to $766,700

Middle half

$280,000 to $550,000

$419,450 to $662,575

Median price per heated sq ft

$203

$267

Price per sq ft range

$183 to $268

$234 to $385

In the Shores at Stillwater CDD

No

Yes

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

Read the medians with care. The older Stillwater median of $315,000 blends two very different products: 10 Unit 3 resales at a $282,500 median and nine Unit 1 and Unit 2 resales, seven in Unit 1 at a $550,000 median and two in Unit 2 at $550,000 and $620,000 (same file). Unit 3 homes are the smaller homes on the roll, with a median of 1,349 heated square feet, while Units 1 and 2 have medians of 2,204 and 2,181 square feet. The median older Stillwater home that sold in the window had 1,536 heated square feet (same file).

The fairer comparison is price per square foot, because it strips out most of the size difference. Shores at Stillwater first sales came in at a median $267 per heated square foot against $203 for older Stillwater resales, a gap of $64, or about 31.5 percent (our arithmetic on the same file). By plat the gap holds: Shores Phase 1A sold at a median $290 per square foot across 12 sales and Phase 1B at $248 across 4, against $214 in Unit 1 (7 sales), $257 in Unit 2 (2 sales) and $198 in Unit 3 (10 sales) (same file).

What that premium buys, on the builder's description, is a 2025 or 2026 home with impact glass, a tile roof and natural gas, and a 10-year structural warranty that starts at closing (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). What it adds is the CDD debt and operating assessment, which the older plats do not carry. A buyer comparing a Unit 1 resale with a similar-size Shores home should set the price gap beside a CDD debt line of up to about $1,915 a year for a 52-foot lot, plus the $276 operations assessment, which the CDD section below explains.

The resale record adds one more signal. We matched each of the 19 older Stillwater resales to the same home's earlier qualified sale; 15 had one on the file. Their median resale price was 12.2 percent higher than the earlier sale, with a range of 10.3 percent lower to 77.4 percent higher and a median of 8 years between the two sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, sales through October 14, 2026).

Fifteen matched sales is a small sample, so read it as direction only: most older Stillwater sellers in the window sold above what they paid, and not all did. No Shores at Stillwater home has resold yet on the county file. Every Shores sale in our set is a first sale, and the first Shores closing on the file was recorded on February 27, 2026 (same file).

What Incentives and Pulte Mortgage Terms Did Pulte Publish in November 2026?

Pulte's Shores at Stillwater page carried two November offers on November 17, 2026, and a buyer could take one or the other, not both (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026):

  • The pool offer. For new purchase agreements on select homesites for select to-be-built homes accepted between November 2, 2026 and November 30, 2026, eligible buyers receive "a standard pool, valued at $69,500".
  • The savings offer. For select homes accepted in the same dates, the "builder will credit buyer $77,000 to be used toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins as a reduction to the total purchase price of the home". The page says the offer "cannot be combined with other offers or incentives".

Both offers end on November 30, 2026 as written. A buyer reading this page later should treat them as a record of what Pulte published, not as a current offer.

On financing, Pulte's pages say plainly: "You are not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage to purchase a home from seller; but use of Pulte Mortgage is necessary to receive BFC-related rate offers" (Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). BFC is a Builder Forward Commitment, which Pulte describes as a rate "offered through Pulte Mortgage LLC, seller's affiliated lender, to lock in an interest rate for a pool of funds", available to qualified borrowers on certain homes until the pool runs out or the lock period ends, and "limited to new home agreements only" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). The affiliated lender is Pulte Mortgage LLC, NMLS 1791.

Pulte's payment illustrations carry their own conditions. One plan page showed a Colton at $309,990 at $2,036.24 a month, including principal and interest of $1,567.48 and Pulte's "Estimated Taxes" of $368.01, on rates "locked with Pulte Mortgage LLC from 08/17/2026 to 08/30/2026" (Pulte, Mystique Grande plan, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Another page bases its rates on a FICO score of 780. Every calculator says "Estimated payments do not include monthly homeowners' association dues", and none shows a CDD line (same pages).

So treat a Pulte payment as a marketing example. Add the HOA dues, add the CDD lines for your lot width, replace Pulte's tax estimate with the county millage on your price, and get a second lender's quote on the same loan. Compare all-in cost, not the headline rate. Our buying guide lays out the steps.

How Do the Contract, Deposit, Inspections and Closing Timeline Differ?

Pulte's public pages do not print its purchase agreement, its deposit schedule or a closing timeline for Shores at Stillwater, and we do not print what third parties say about them. The deposit amount, the inspection rights in the contract, who pays title and closing charges, and the completion date are contract terms: Information not available at time of publishing. The executed contract governs.

What the public record does set out:

  • The CDD disclosure. Florida Statutes section 190.048 requires each contract for the initial sale of a parcel or home in a community development district to carry, in bold type immediately before the buyer's signature, a statement that begins "THE (Name of District) COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT MAY IMPOSE AND LEVY TAXES OR ASSESSMENTS, OR BOTH TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS, ON THIS PROPERTY" (Florida Statutes 190.048, read November 17, 2026). A Shores at Stillwater first-sale contract should carry it; an older Stillwater resale has no CDD to disclose.
  • The district's own disclosure. The Shores at Stillwater board approved a Master Disclosure of Public Financing and a First Supplemental Disclosure on June 15, 2026, which district counsel described as "a legal requirement notifying the homeowners of the debt" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, October 19, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). Ask for both before you sign.
  • Inspections during construction. Pulte says its construction manager holds four meetings with a buyer: an introduction, a "Pre-Drywall Orientation", a "Pre-Closing Orientation" and a "Celebration", and that several steps involve inspections of the foundation, frame and mechanical systems (Pulte, Build Quality Experience, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Whether a buyer's own inspector may attend at the pre-drywall stage is not stated: Information not available at time of publishing. Get the answer in writing.
  • Inspections on a resale. An older Stillwater home is a finished house you can inspect fully before your inspection period ends. On a home built 2000 to 2016 the roof and mechanical systems may be original, and the permit history shows what has been replaced.
  • Closing timeline. A Pulte home marked "Available Now" can close sooner than a to-be-built home, whose closing waits on completion and a certificate of occupancy. A resale closes on the date the parties agree.

If you are weighing a Shores at Stillwater purchase against other new homes in the area, our new construction guide for Englewood sets the communities side by side. Read the deposit, completion and inspection pages of any builder contract before the price page.

How Does the Pulte Warranty Work, and What Does Florida Law Add?

Pulte's national limited warranty book (August 2024 edition) states that "materials and workmanship are warranted for one year from the time of closing", that heating, air conditioning, electrical and plumbing systems "are warranted for two years from closing", that "Certain kinds of water infiltration and internal leaks are warranted for a period of five years", and that defects in structural elements "are warranted for ten years from closing" (Pulte National Warranty Book, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

Pulte limited warranty term (August 2024 book)

Years from closing

Materials and workmanship

1

Heating, air conditioning, electrical and plumbing systems

2

Certain water infiltration and internal leaks

5

Structural elements

10

Source: Pulte National Warranty Book, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026. The warranty document delivered with your contract controls.

Four details in the same book matter more than the headline years:

  • What "structural" means. Structural elements are "load-bearing walls, beams, girders, trusses, rafters, bearing columns, lintels, posts, structural fasteners, subfloors, footings and roof sheathing", and an element is not defective "unless there is actual physical damage that diminishes the ability of the Structural Element to perform its load-bearing function such that the home is unsafe". That is a narrow test.
  • What is excluded. "Elevators, Solar Systems, Emergency Power Systems, Smart Home Components and Consumer Products" fall under their makers' warranties.
  • Implied warranties. The book says "all warranties regarding your home ... including, but not limited to, statutory and implied warranties, are hereby disclaimed by us and waived by you".
  • Disputes. Disputes go to arbitration "which will be binding on the Homeowner and the Builder", under the Federal Arbitration Act before an American Arbitration Association arbitrator with at least ten years of construction arbitration experience.

Pulte's warranty page adds that "Warranties are transferable to subsequent owner who takes title within the applicable warranty period", and notes that separate warranty documents apply to purchase agreements signed before September 1, 2024 (Pulte, Warranty; Pulte, 10-Year Limited Warranty, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). So a buyer of a Shores at Stillwater resale in the years ahead inherits what remains of the first owner's terms, counted from the first closing. Pulte did not build the older Stillwater homes, so its warranty does not reach them, and any remaining warranty on a 2000 to 2016 home is Information not available at time of publishing.

Florida law adds its own timetable. Section 558.004 requires a written notice of claim at least 60 days before filing suit (120 days for an association representing more than 20 parcels); the builder may inspect within 30 days (50 for a large association) and must answer in writing within 45 days (75 for a large association) (Florida Statutes 558.004, read November 17, 2026). Section 95.11(3)(b) sets four years for a construction claim, from the certificate of occupancy or discovery of a latent defect, and an outer limit of 7 years from the certificate of occupancy or completion (Florida Statutes 95.11, read November 17, 2026).

Section 553.835 bars implied-warranty claims for damage to "offsite improvements" such as streets, drainage and utilities, but keeps the shared structure of attached homes out of that definition, which matters for the Colton and Ellenwood twin villas (Florida Statutes 553.835, read November 17, 2026). These are statute summaries, not legal advice; a Florida real estate attorney should read the Pulte contract and warranty with you.

What Should a Buyer Check Before Choosing New or Resale in Stillwater, Englewood?

A short list, in the order we use it:

  • Which plat. Units 1 and 2 hold the larger homes, Unit 3 the smaller ones, Shores Phases 1A and 1B the new Pulte homes. The 12-month medians ran from $282,500 in Unit 3 to $585,000 in Unit 2 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026).
  • Price per square foot. $267 at Shores against $203 for older resales in the same window. Set that gap beside the age of the resale's roof and systems.
  • The CDD line. Shores lots carry it, the older plats do not. Ask the district manager for the debt on your lot and whether it can be prepaid.
  • The HOA. Get the budget, the declaration and the dues in writing; we found none of them published for either association.
  • The warranty and the pre-drywall question. The full Pulte book, and in writing whether your inspector may attend.
  • Insurance quotes. Wind and flood, before you commit; Citizens requires flood coverage on all of its wind policies from January 1, 2027.
  • An agent on your side. A builder's sales consultant works for the builder. Our contact page reaches the team, and we will read a Pulte contract with you before you sign.

Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active listings, months of supply and rents: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

The Shores at Stillwater CDD, HOAs and the Rules

Shores at Stillwater sits inside the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District, created by Sarasota County Ordinance 2025-032, which financed its stormwater, water and sewer systems with $2,970,000 of bonds sold in 2026. The older Stillwater plats are outside the district. We found no published legal name or dues for either the Stillwater or the Shores association.

How Was the Shores at Stillwater CDD Created, and What Land Does It Cover?

A community development district is a local unit of special-purpose government under Chapter 190 of the Florida Statutes. It can borrow to build public infrastructure and repay the debt through assessments on the land that benefits. The Shores at Stillwater district describes itself as established under Chapter 190, governed by a five-member board elected by landowners, with the status "Independent, Sarasota County" and a fiscal year of October 1 to September 30 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, home page, read November 17, 2026).

The creating law is Sarasota County Ordinance No. 2025-032, petitioned by Pulte Home Company, LLC (Ordinance 2025-032, text copy, read November 17, 2026). The district's posted copy includes a Florida Department of State letter acknowledging the ordinance "was filed in this office on February 11, 2026" (Ordinance 2025-032, read November 17, 2026), and the district's methodology says it was enacted February 10 and effective February 11, 2026 (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The board organized on February 17, 2026 (April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026).

The district covers two surveyed parcels of 45.789 and 34.041 acres, about 79.83 acres in all (our arithmetic, matching the district's methodology), which the engineer describes as a South Parcel "on the south side of Medical Blvd across from the HCA Florida Englewood Hospital" and a North Parcel "at the eastern terminus of Medical Blvd" (June book).

The older Stillwater sections are not in it. The district's boundary starts at the corner of Stillwater Unit Two and follows its east line, so Unit Two is the neighbor, not part of the district, and the Phase One assessment roll lists only Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A and 1B lots (April 20, 2026 meeting book; June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). We found no other district for Stillwater Units 1 to 3. Any district elsewhere in Florida with "Stillwater" in its name has nothing to do with Stillwater in Englewood.

How many homes the district plans, and of what type, comes from the same record. The engineer's report says the development "will be developed in four (4) phases and will consist of single-family detached and attached residential units, an amenity center, and various open spaces", that "The PUD approval allows for a maximum of 269 units" and that "The current approved site development plans include 255 units" (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The product table settles the villa question:

Shores at Stillwater product (district record)

Lot width

Master plan units

Phase One units

Attached (Pulte's twin villas)

34 feet

136

74

Detached single-family

52 feet

119

62

Total

255

136

Source: Shores at Stillwater CDD engineer's report and Phase One First Supplemental Special Assessment Methodology dated May 28, 2026, in the June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026.

Pulte's page matches the total with "255 future front doors" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). The methodology states that "All 136 residential units planned for Phase One have been platted" (June book). Earlier press counts from 2024 differ and describe plans that have since changed, so we use the 2026 district record.

What Does the CDD Pay For, and What Stays Private?

The district's capital improvement plan prices the master project at $11,060,350 (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026):

Shores at Stillwater capital improvement plan item

Estimate

Stormwater management system

$4,509,741

Sanitary sewer collection system

$2,493,834

Potable water distribution system

$1,011,171

Professional services

$1,202,212

Contingency

$1,843,392

Total

$11,060,350

Source: Shores at Stillwater CDD engineer's report, Table A, read November 17, 2026.

Ownership is split three ways. The engineer's report says the stormwater ponds, designed for "100-year flood control", "will be owned and maintained by the District"; the sewer system and water mains, tied into existing lines on Medical Boulevard, "will be owned and maintained by the Englewood Water District"; and "The roadways, irrigation, landscaping and amenity center will be private and are not included in the CIP" (same book).

The June 15, 2026 minutes add that "the maintenance items, with the exception of engineering, would be included in an agreement with the HOA and are currently included in the HOA budget" (same book). So a Shores at Stillwater owner pays for pond upkeep through HOA dues, not the CDD line.

How Much Bond Debt Is There, and Who Validated It?

There are two numbers, and they are easy to confuse: the ceiling a court approved, and the amount actually borrowed so far.

  • The ceiling. In Case No. 2026-CA-001067 NC, the Twelfth Judicial Circuit Court in Sarasota County "entered a Final Judgment validating the District's ability to issue an aggregate principal amount not to exceed $14,000,000 in Special Assessment Bonds" on April 13, 2026 (Business Observer legal notice 26-00560S; June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026).
  • The bonds sold. On May 28, 2026 the district sold $2,970,000 of Special Assessment Bonds, Series 2026 (Phase One Project), dated June 17, 2026, due 2027 to 2056 and callable from November 1, 2036, through FMSbonds, Inc. (The Bond Buyer, May 29, 2026, read November 17, 2026), at 4.10 to 5.8 percent, maturing May 2056 (Amended Final Budget 2025-2026, read November 17, 2026).

The bond resolution states that the bonds are not a debt of Sarasota County or the State and are payable solely from special assessments (March 16, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The issue was sized at an average coupon of 5.666 percent, with a maximum annual debt service of $207,755 before collection costs (June book).

That leaves $11,030,000 of validated room (our arithmetic). The methodology says any part of the master project not paid for by the Series 2026 bonds "will be paid for by Pulte Home Company, LLC, or its successors or assigns ... or in the District's sole discretion a future series of bonds" (June book). A later series for later phases is possible but not decided.

What Does Each Shores at Stillwater Lot Owe the CDD?

The Phase One methodology dated May 28, 2026 allocates the $2,970,000 by lot width, with a 34-foot lot counted as 0.72 of a 52-foot lot (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026):

Shores at Stillwater Phase One lot

Bond principal allocated per lot

Maximum annual debt assessment

Operating (O&M) assessment, FY2026/27

Combined annual CDD line (our arithmetic)

34-foot lot (attached villa)

$18,580.37

$1,382.68

$276

$1,658.68

52-foot lot (detached)

$25,726.66

$1,914.48

$276

$2,190.48

Sources: Phase One First Supplemental Special Assessment Methodology, Tables D and F, May 28, 2026; O&M from the FY2026/27 assessment notice and Final Budget 2026-2027, read November 17, 2026. Annual amounts include the 1 percent Tax Collector fee, 1 percent Property Appraiser fee and 4 percent early-payment discount.

Four notes make the table usable:

  • The gross-up. Annual figures are divided "by a factor of 0.94" to cover collection fees and the 4 percent early-payment discount, so an owner who pays in November pays less than the maximum (April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026).
  • A rounding difference. The district's Disclosure of Public Financing prints $1,382.98 and $1,914.89, figures that "may fluctuate". Work with about $1,383 and $1,915 and get your lot's exact figure from the district manager.
  • The term. Up to 30 annual installments, through May 2056, unless prepaid (June book).
  • Prepayment. The amended 2025 to 2026 budget recorded bond prepayments of $25,727, equal to the $25,726.66 principal allocated to one 52-foot lot (Amended Final Budget 2025-2026, read November 17, 2026).

The master figures that appeared in the April 2026 assessment notice, $46,469 of debt and $4,185.71 a year for a 34-foot unit, and $64,540 and $5,813.48 for a 52-foot unit, are legal maximums if all $14,000,000 were ever issued at an assumed 7.50 percent. They are not the Phase One amounts (April book). If you see those larger numbers in a recorded notice, that is why.

One more rule protects a Shores buyer. If a replat lowers the number of assessable units, the methodology says "It is the responsibility of the landowner of record (other than homebuyers unaffiliated with the Developer) to make any required true-up payments" (June book). A true-up falls on the developer side, not on a home buyer.

How Is the CDD Collected: at Closing or on the Tax Bill?

Both, depending on the year. The district's FAQ says "The assessment will appear on the property tax bill sent in November of each year" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, FAQs, read November 17, 2026), and the board held an April 20, 2026 hearing on the uniform method that puts assessments on the county bill (Notice Registry, notice 11535830, read November 17, 2026).

For 2026 to 2027, though, the budget shows O&M assessments of $66,157 "To Be Collected At Closings" and developer funding of $62,968 "For Expenditures That Exceed $276 O&M Rate" (Final Budget 2026-2027, read November 17, 2026), and the district is not on the Tax Collector's 2026 list of levying authorities (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage, read November 17, 2026).

In practice, then: a Shores at Stillwater buyer closing in late 2026 or 2027 should expect a CDD line on the closing statement, and from a future year a CDD line in the non-ad valorem section of the November tax bill. Once on the bill, the district's disclosure says unpaid assessments lead to tax certificates just as unpaid taxes do (June book). Read your closing statement and your first tax bill side by side to make sure the same year is not billed twice.

The 2026 to 2027 budget totals $129,125, of which $109,125 is administration (management $30,000, legal $25,000 and legal advertising $25,000 are the largest lines) and $20,000 is engineering and inspections (same budget).

Who Runs the District, and When Does It Meet?

The district manager is Special District Services, Inc., 2501A Burns Road, Palm Beach Gardens, (561) 630-4922 (April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026); counsel is Kutak Rock LLP, the engineer Heidt Design, LLC and the trustee U.S. Bank Trust Company, National Association (March 16, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The October 19, 2026 minutes list Alexander Burseth as chairman (October 19, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026).

Meetings are held at 11:00 a.m. at the offices of Pulte, 501 N. Cattlemen Road, Suite 106, Sarasota. The 2026 to 2027 schedule lists October 19, 2026; November 16, 2026 (cancelled); January 25, 2027 (moved from January 18); and February 15, March 15, April 19, May 17, June 21, July 19, August 16 and September 20, 2027 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, Documents, read November 17, 2026). Any owner may attend.

Control stays with landowners for years. The disclosure says landowner elections give "one vote for each acre of land", and seats move to qualified electors only after both six years and "a minimum of two hundred and fifty (250) qualified electors" (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). On the Phase One roll prepared for that meeting, 125 of the 136 lots listed Pulte Home Company LLC as owner (same book).

Who Are the HOAs, and Where Do You Verify Them?

We did not obtain the legal name of any association in Stillwater, Englewood, and we are not going to guess. Here is what the primary record does say:

  • Shores at Stillwater. An HOA exists and has a budget: the CDD minutes say maintenance items "are currently included in the HOA budget" (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). Pulte says "Community Association fees required" but publishes no figure, and describes the community as gated with a heated pool, a covered-seating cabana, BBQ grills and mail kiosks (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).
  • Older Stillwater (Units 1 to 3). The association's legal name and structure, dues, management company and any gate: Information not available at time of publishing.
  • Shared or separate. No primary source says the two share an association or amenities.

To verify, search Sunbiz by "Stillwater" and "Shores at Stillwater"; read the recorded declaration at the Sarasota County Clerk; ask the Pulte sales center at 2048 Silver Shores Blvd, (941) 389-1010, open Monday to Saturday 9:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. and Sunday 12:00 to 5:30 p.m. (builder-stated, read November 17, 2026), for the Shores association's name, budget and dues; and on a resale, order an estoppel certificate from the management company.

What Are the Rules on Leasing and Short-Term Rental in Stillwater?

We found no source that states a lease minimum, rental cap or approval rule for any Stillwater association. Those rules, if they exist, sit in the recorded declarations and in the association's resale documents. Read them before you buy a home you plan to rent, for any term.

State law sets two frames. Under section 720.306(1)(h), a rental restriction adopted after July 1, 2021 "applies only to a parcel owner who acquires title to the parcel after the effective date of the governing document" or who consents, although an association may still limit rentals under six months and "may prohibit the rental of a parcel for more than three times in a calendar year" for all owners (Florida Statutes 720.306, read November 17, 2026). Section 509.032(7)(b) bars local laws that prohibit vacation rentals or regulate their duration, but not those "adopted on or before June 1, 2011" (Florida Statutes 509.032, read November 17, 2026).

We did not read Sarasota County's own rental code text, so we print no minimum term for Stillwater, Englewood. Before listing any Stillwater home for stays under a month, read the rental provisions of the county's Unified Development Code on Municode, ask Sarasota County Planning and Development Services at 941-861-5000, and read the declaration.

Who Governs Stillwater, and What Is the Zoning?

Stillwater sits in unincorporated Sarasota County, so the county, not a city, handles its zoning, permits and code enforcement, and news reports place Englewood in County Commission District 5. Shores at Stillwater is zoned RSF-1/PUD and RSF-4/PUD with a 269-unit cap; the older plats' zoning was not confirmed from a primary source.

Is Stillwater, Englewood in a City or in the County?

It is in the county. The Shores at Stillwater bond documents state that the district lands "are located entirely within the unincorporated area of the County", and the district's methodology calls it "a local unit of special-purpose government located entirely within the unincorporated area of Sarasota County, Florida" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). For the older plats, every Stillwater street point we tested against the Census Bureau's 2024 place boundaries fell in no incorporated city, only in the Englewood census-designated place, which is a statistical area and not a government (US Census Bureau, TIGER/Line 2024 places, read November 17, 2026).

The Englewood census-designated place spans Sarasota and Charlotte counties (2020 redistricting file, read November 17, 2026); Stillwater, Englewood is in the Sarasota part, and all 394 parcels in our set are on the Sarasota County roll. There is no city millage on a Stillwater bill (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage, read November 17, 2026).

In practice the county handles zoning, permits, code enforcement and public roads; the Englewood Area Fire Control District and the Englewood Water District are separate independent districts; and at Shores at Stillwater the CDD adds a third.

Which County Commission District Is Stillwater In?

Your Observer reported on December 19, 2025 that Ron Cutsinger, who represents District 5, was chosen as the Sarasota County Commission's 2026 chair, and that his district covers the "southern end of Sarasota County", including much of North Port, Englewood and the Casperson and Manasota Key beaches (Your Observer, Sarasota County commissioners pick chair, vice chair, read November 17, 2026). That places Stillwater in Englewood in District 5 by the news report's description.

We did not check the line at a Stillwater address against the county's own district locator, which refused our requests. For a specific lot, use the county's commission district locator or call 941-861-5000.

What Zoning Does Shores at Stillwater Carry?

The district engineer's report states: "The North Parcel is zoned RSF-1/PUD and is 45.79 acres in size. The South Parcel is zoned RSF-4/PUD and is 34.04 acres in size" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). RSF is the prefix of Sarasota County's residential single-family districts, and PUD means a Planned Unit Development overlay. The report adds that "The PUD approval allows for a maximum of 269 units" and that the approved site plans include 255 (same book).

The ordinance that created the CDD records the land's recent zoning history in its recitals: the land was "previously designated as Special Planning Area 2" and was "rezoned to a Planned Unit Development form with unified control per Ordinance No. 2023-060" (Ordinance 2025-032, text copy, read November 17, 2026). We read that reference in the CDD ordinance, not the text of Ordinance 2023-060 itself, so the rezoning's stipulations, hearing date and vote are Information not available at time of publishing. They sit in the Board of County Commissioners' minutes and the Clerk's ordinance index.

Shores at Stillwater zoning (district record)

North Parcel

South Parcel

Zoning

RSF-1/PUD

RSF-4/PUD

Acreage

45.79 acres

34.04 acres

Location per the engineer

At the eastern end of Medical Blvd

South side of Medical Blvd, across from HCA Florida Englewood Hospital

Combined unit cap under the PUD

269

Units on approved site plans

255

Source: Shores at Stillwater CDD engineer's report, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026.

What Does a PUD Allow in Sarasota County?

The text below comes from a third-party mirror of the Sarasota County Unified Development Code; confirm it against the county's official Municode text before you rely on it (Zoneomics copy of the Sarasota County UDC, chapter 7, Special Zoning Districts, read November 17, 2026). The PUD overlay "allows more flexibility in use and site design than is permitted in the base zoning district" and "will provide flexibility in placement and clustering of residential units", and, under section 124-101(b)(2), "Within the boundaries of the PUD, no minimum lot size, lot coverage or minimum yards shall be required" (same mirror).

Base district with a PUD (code mirror)

Maximum density

RSF-1

2.5 units per acre

RSF-2

3.5 units per acre

RSF-3

4.5 units per acre

RSF-4

5.5 units per acre

Source: Zoneomics copy of the Sarasota County UDC, chapter 7, read November 17, 2026. Third-party mirror; confirm on Municode.

On those densities, the North Parcel's 45.79 acres at 2.5 units per acre would allow about 114 units and the South Parcel's 34.04 acres at 5.5 would allow about 187, about 301 in all (our arithmetic). The PUD's 269-unit cap is lower, so the PUD approval, not the base district, is the binding limit at Shores at Stillwater.

Because a PUD sets no minimum lot size or yards of its own, setbacks on a Shores lot come from the approved site plan and the plat, and the HOA's covenants can be stricter still. Your survey, plat and declaration decide whether you can add a pool, screen enclosure or fence.

What Zoning Do the Older Stillwater Plats Carry?

We could not confirm it. The zoning district for the Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2 and Unit 3 plats is Information not available at time of publishing, because the county's zoning documents refused our requests and we do not read the Property Appraiser's parcel pages by script. We will not infer a district from the Shores parcels next door.

A person can settle it in minutes on the county's Map Viewer zoning layer, or by calling Sarasota County Planning and Development Services at 941-861-5000 with the parcel number. The Unit Two plat is recorded in Plat Book 45, Pages 12 through 12C, as the Shores at Stillwater legal description cites it (April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026); the Unit 1 and Unit 3 references were not found.

The zoning answer matters most for two questions a Stillwater owner asks: what can be added to the lot, and what the county allows on rentals. Both turn on the district, and both should be settled for the parcel, not the neighborhood.

Which Special Districts and Units Bill Stillwater Parcels?

A Sarasota County tax bill combines ad valorem taxes, which depend on taxable value, and non-ad valorem assessments, which are flat or formula charges that ignore value. The Tax Collector's 2026 sheet lists the levying authorities that reach Englewood (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage, read November 17, 2026):

Tax Collector code (2026)

Levy

What we know for Stillwater, Englewood

F092

Englewood Fire Control

Residential $290.78, vacant lot $63.95 for 2026 to 2027 (EAFCD)

G055, G056

Sarasota Solid Waste District

Amount for a Stillwater parcel not read

W056, W057

Stormwater, county base and impervious charges

Amount for a Stillwater parcel not read

W016 to W022

Englewood Water District sewer and capital areas

Whether any Stillwater parcel is inside one: not confirmed

L015

Lighting-Englewood, 0.0644 mills in 2026 (0.0438 in 2025)

Whether Stillwater is inside it: not confirmed

none listed

Shores at Stillwater CDD

Not on the 2026 list; collected at closing for 2026 to 2027

Sources: Sarasota County Tax Collector 2026 and 2025 millage sheets; Englewood Area Fire Control District, read November 17, 2026.

The Englewood Area Fire Control District, at 579 S. Indiana Avenue, (941) 474-3311, runs six firehouses numbered 71 to 76 (Englewood Area Fire Control District, read November 17, 2026). Its assessment is "not affected by the Homestead Exemption" (EAFCD, Assessments, Fees and Charges, read November 17, 2026). The hospital levy on the bill is the countywide Sarasota County Public Hospital District at 1.0420 mills, not an Englewood district (Tax Collector 2026 sheet).

The reliable way to see every line for one home is the parcel's TRIM notice or its tax bill. Look the parcel up at the Sarasota County Tax Collector's site by account number.

Who Maintains the Streets, and How Do Permits Work?

At Shores at Stillwater, "The roadways, irrigation, landscaping and amenity center will be private" (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026), so the gated streets are maintained outside the CDD and paid for through HOA dues. Whether the older Stillwater streets are county or private roads: Information not available at time of publishing; the plat dedications settle it. Every Stillwater street reaches the public network through Medical Boulevard (US Census Bureau, TIGER/Line 2024 roads, read November 17, 2026).

For a pool, fence, screen enclosure or addition, you need a county permit and, separately, HOA approval. On a resale, ask for the permit history: it shows which roofs, air conditioning systems and windows have been replaced, and it answers the code-year question a wind mitigation inspector asks.

Water, Sewer and Utilities in Stillwater

Englewood Water District owns and maintains the water and sewer lines at Shores at Stillwater, under the CDD engineer's report, and those lines tie into existing mains in Medical Boulevard beside the older Stillwater sections. From October 1, 2026 its base charges are $29.37 for water and $42.75 for sewer per month. Florida Power and Light supplies electricity.

Who Provides Water and Sewer in Stillwater, Englewood?

For Shores at Stillwater the record is direct. The CDD engineer's report says the water distribution mains connect to "existing water mains within Medical Blvd" and "will be owned and maintained by the Englewood Water District", and that the sewer system, with two lift stations and force mains to existing infrastructure on Medical Boulevard, "will be owned and maintained by the Englewood Water District (EWD)" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The site plans were approved by Sarasota County, the Englewood Water District and the Southwest Florida Water Management District, and water and sewer permits from the Florida Department of Environmental Protection "have been obtained" (same book).

For the older Stillwater sections, the evidence is indirect. The Shores lines tie into existing mains in Medical Boulevard, the road every older Stillwater street connects to, and the district describes itself as covering "approximately 44.5 square miles in Southern Sarasota County and Western Charlotte County" (Englewood Water District, read November 17, 2026). We did not query the district's interactive service map. So we say it this way: Englewood Water District serves this part of Englewood; confirm with the district for a given address. Its customer service line is (941) 474-3217, toll free 866-460-1080, and its office is at 201 Selma Ave., Englewood, FL 34223 (same site).

The district's rules add three points that run with every Stillwater parcel: "Florida law requires connection to central wastewater when available"; service, assessments, purchased capacity and liens "run with the parcel"; and a single-family home "by definition is one (1) ERC", an equivalent residential connection (EWD FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations, dated October 1, 2026, read November 17, 2026).

What Do Englewood Water District Rates Look Like From October 1, 2026?

The district's Customer Rules and Regulations dated October 1, 2026 set these single-family charges (EWD FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations, read November 17, 2026), shown beside the rates that took effect October 1, 2025 (EWD, Board-Approved Rate Adjustments Effective October 1, 2025, read November 17, 2026):

Englewood Water District charge

From Oct 1, 2025

From Oct 1, 2026

Water base facility charge, per ERC per month

$25.54

$29.37

Water usage, 0 to 6,000 gallons, per 1,000

$3.04

$3.50

6,001 to 8,000 gallons

$4.06

$4.67

8,001 to 12,000 gallons

$8.07

$9.28

12,001 to 18,000 gallons

$13.48

$15.50

Over 18,000 gallons

$21.05

$24.21

Wastewater base facility charge, per ERC per month

$37.17

$42.75

Wastewater usage, all gallons, per 1,000

$4.74

$5.45

Reuse water, isolated pond, per 1,000

$0.44

$0.51

Reuse water, pressurized, per 1,000

$0.58

$0.67

Sources as named above. ERC means equivalent residential connection; a single-family home is one ERC.

The tiers rise steeply after 8,000 gallons a month because the district uses an inverted rate schedule to encourage conservation (same FY27 rules). The district's board approved the 2025 changes at an August 14, 2025 public hearing (EWD, Rates, read November 17, 2026). A dedicated irrigation meter is billed from the $9.28 tier up, and a new service application costs $50.00 (FY27 rules).

What Does a Month of Water and Sewer Cost?

Here is one worked example at the October 1, 2026 rates for a Stillwater home using 5,000 gallons in a month (our arithmetic on the district's schedule):

Line, 5,000 gallons a month

From Oct 1, 2025

From Oct 1, 2026

Water base

$25.54

$29.37

Water usage, 5 x per-1,000 rate

$15.20

$17.50

Wastewater base

$37.17

$42.75

Wastewater usage, 5 x per-1,000 rate

$23.70

$27.25

Monthly total

$101.61

$116.87

Our arithmetic on the Englewood Water District schedules named above. Not a bill; taxes, fees and any irrigation meter are excluded.

The same 5,000 gallons cost about 15.0 percent more from October 1, 2026 than a year earlier (our arithmetic). A home that irrigates from the potable meter will cross into the higher tiers quickly, which is why the irrigation source on a lot matters as much as the house.

What Are Capacity Charges, and Who Pays Them on a New Shores at Stillwater Home?

A capacity charge is the one-time fee a utility charges for the plant and pipe capacity a new connection uses. The district's FY27 rules list these per ERC (EWD FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations, read November 17, 2026):

Englewood Water District one-time charge, per ERC (from Oct 1, 2026)

Amount

Water capital capacity, plant and transmission

$3,062.00

Water capital capacity, distribution

$1,200.00

Wastewater capital capacity, plant and transmission

$5,170.00

Wastewater capital capacity, collection

$5,817.00

AGRF, water

$229.50

AGRF, wastewater

$387.00

Total for one single-family connection (our arithmetic)

$15,865.50

Source as named above. Meter installation is a separate line: $2,000.00 for a district-installed 5/8-inch short tap, or $425.00 where a developer installs the service using a district meter (same rules).

Who paid those charges on each Shores at Stillwater home is not stated in any source we read: Information not available at time of publishing. At Shores the CDD financed the onsite water distribution and sewer collection systems ($1,011,171 and $2,493,834 in its capital plan), and Pulte connects each home before closing, so the charges are most likely inside the contract price rather than a separate buyer line. That is an inference, and the contract is where to confirm it. On an older Stillwater resale, the connection was paid when the home was built, between 2000 and 2016.

The Englewood Area Fire Control District also charges a one-time fire impact fee of $404.35 on a new single-family residence (EAFCD, Assessments, Fees and Charges, read November 17, 2026). On a new Shores home, ask whether it is already inside the contract price. Sarasota County's own impact and mobility fee schedules were not readable during our research, so we print no county figure.

What About Irrigation at Shores at Stillwater and Wells on Older Lots?

At Shores at Stillwater the irrigation is private, and it runs on permitted wells. The Southwest Florida Water Management District issued a new water use permit on July 2, 2025 "to withdrawal water from two approved wells at Shores at Stillwater" to Pulte Home Company, LLC, application number 20 021234.000, for residential lawn and landscape use, with an annual average of 26,100 gallons per day, a drought annual average of 30,400 gallons per day and a peak month of 82,900 gallons per day (Business Observer legal notice 25-01328S, read November 17, 2026). Whether the permit passes to the HOA or the CDD after turnover is not stated.

For an older Stillwater lot, the district's rules bar drilling an irrigation well "within one mile of an existing District water supply well head" unless its models show no harm (EWD FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations, read November 17, 2026). We did not check any lot's distance to a wellhead. Ask the district before you plan a well.

Electric, Natural Gas and Internet

Electric. Florida Power and Light's electric tariff, sheet 7.030 "COMMUNITIES SERVED", effective January 1, 2026, lists Englewood and the unincorporated part of Sarasota County under Sarasota County (FPL Electric Tariff, Section 7, read November 17, 2026). No co-op or municipal electric utility is named for this area. Confirm service for an address with FPL when you set up the account.

Natural gas. Pulte calls Shores at Stillwater a "Natural Gas Community" and lists "Natural gas appliances" among its features (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Pulte does not name the gas utility, and we found no source that says whether natural gas reaches the older Stillwater streets. Ask Pulte which appliances run on gas and which company bills it, and on a resale check the home itself.

Internet and telephone. No Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater association, CDD or Pulte page we read names an internet provider. The FCC National Broadband Map, searched by exact address, shows the providers that report service there (FCC National Broadband Map). We do not print third-party coverage percentages.

Trash, Recycling and Stormwater

Trash and recycling. Since March 31, 2025, residential garbage, recycling and yard waste in unincorporated Sarasota County have been collected by Waste Pro of Florida in the county's North Service Area and by FCC Environmental Services of Florida in the South Service Area, with the rule that "All garbage must fit inside the new cart for collection" (ABC7, Sarasota County changing to new waste removal company, March 12, 2025, read November 17, 2026). Which service area holds Stillwater, Englewood, and its pickup days: Information not available at time of publishing. The county's collection map gives both by address. The service is billed on the tax bill as a Sarasota Solid Waste District assessment (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage, read November 17, 2026), and the amount for a Stillwater parcel is on its TRIM notice.

Stormwater. The county's stormwater utility bills a base charge and an impervious-area charge on the tax bill. WUSF reported in September 2025 that the impervious fee is charged "per 500 square feet" and that a 2,700-square-foot home paid $112 a year, and that commissioners voted 5 to 0 on September 5, 2025 not to raise the rate (WUSF, September 4, 2025; WUSF, September 5, 2025, read November 17, 2026). A Shores at Stillwater home pays the county stormwater charge and, separately, funds its own CDD-owned ponds through the CDD and HOA lines. Whether the county gives Shores parcels any credit for those ponds was not found.

What Does It Cost to Own a Home in Stillwater?

Owning a Stillwater home means county property tax at 11.3068 mills in 2026 on a value that resets at purchase, the $290.78 Englewood fire assessment, county trash and stormwater lines, HOA dues, and at Shores at Stillwater a CDD line of about $1,659 or $2,190 a year. A $485,000 home pays $5,483.80 in 2026 ad valorem tax without homestead.

What Millage Applies in Stillwater, Englewood?

Stillwater, Englewood is unincorporated, so a Stillwater parcel pays the Tax Collector's countywide total with no city levy. Here are the components for tax years 2025 and 2026 from the Tax Collector's certified sheets (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2025 millage, roll certified October 3, 2025; 2026 millage, roll certified September 29, 2026, read November 17, 2026):

Levy

2025 mills

2026 mills

Sarasota County General Revenue

3.2273

3.2317

Mosquito Control

0.0520

0.0490

Sarasota County Hospital District

1.0420

1.0420

West Coast Inland Navigation

0.0394

0.0394

Southwest Florida Water Management

0.1831

0.1831

Bonds, Debt Service

0.0667

0.0653

Legacy Trail, Debt Service

0.0382

0.0373

Total county, not including school

4.6487

4.6478

School Board, State

2.8470

2.6810

School Board, Local (one line in 2025)

3.2480

School Board, Local Non-Voted (2026)

2.2480

School Board, Local Voted (2026)

1.0000

Total school

6.0950

5.9290

Emergency Medical Services

0.7300

0.7300

Total countywide (all but Longboat Key, North Port and City of Venice)

11.4737

11.3068

Source: Sarasota County Tax Collector millage sheets, 2025 and 2026, read November 17, 2026.

The total fell by 0.1669 mills from 2025 to 2026, almost all of it in the state school levy (our arithmetic). The non-school portion, which matters for the homestead calculation below, was 5.3787 mills in 2025 and 5.3778 in 2026 (our arithmetic). The Englewood Area Fire Control District levies no millage on this sheet; it bills a flat assessment instead. The optional L015 Lighting-Englewood levy, 0.0644 mills in 2026, is not in the table because we could not confirm that Stillwater lies inside it.

One mill is $1 of tax for each $1,000 of taxable value. So the formula is taxable value times millage, divided by 1,000.

What Would a $485,000 Stillwater Home Pay in Property Tax?

We use $485,000, the 12-month median of all 35 qualified Stillwater home sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026), as an example value. The example assumes the assessed value equals the purchase price, which is how a home is valued in the first year after a sale. A real bill depends on the parcel's own assessed value.

Without homestead (a second home, a rental, or the first year after buying before homestead applies): at 2026 rates, $485,000 x 11.3068 / 1,000 = $5,483.80; at 2025 rates, $485,000 x 11.4737 / 1,000 = $5,564.74 (our arithmetic on the Tax Collector's rates). By levy at 2026 rates:

Levy, 2026 rates, $485,000 taxable, no homestead

Tax (our arithmetic)

County general revenue, 3.2317

$1,567.37

Hospital district, 1.0420

$505.37

School, state, 2.6810

$1,300.29

School, local non-voted, 2.2480

$1,090.28

School, local voted, 1.0000

$485.00

Emergency medical services, 0.7300

$354.05

Southwest Florida Water Management, 0.1831

$88.80

County debt service, 0.0653

$31.67

Mosquito control, 0.0490

$23.77

West Coast Inland Navigation, 0.0394

$19.11

Legacy Trail debt service, 0.0373

$18.09

Total ad valorem

$5,483.80

Our arithmetic on the Sarasota County Tax Collector 2026 millage sheet. An illustration, not a bill; non-ad valorem lines are added below.

With homestead (an owner who held title and lived in the home as a permanent residence on January 1): Florida Statutes section 196.031 grants a $25,000 exemption against all levies, plus an additional exemption of up to $25,000 on the assessed value between $50,000 and $75,000 that applies to non-school levies only (Florida Statutes 196.031, read November 17, 2026). On a $485,000 home the arithmetic runs this way:

  • School taxable value: $485,000 minus $25,000 = $460,000. School tax: $460,000 x 5.9290 / 1,000 = $2,727.34.
  • Non-school taxable value: $485,000 minus $25,000 minus $25,000 = $435,000. Non-school tax: $435,000 x 5.3778 / 1,000 = $2,339.34.
  • Total ad valorem with homestead, 2026 rates: $5,066.68, about $417 less than without homestead (our arithmetic).

The statute indexes the second $25,000 for inflation each January 1, so the amount printed on a 2026 TRIM notice is somewhat higher than $25,000 and the real homestead bill slightly lower than our figure. Confirm the current indexed amount with the Sarasota County Property Appraiser at 941-861-8200.

How Do Homestead, Save Our Homes and Portability Work in Sarasota County?

Filing. The Sarasota County Property Appraiser says an applicant must own and occupy the home as a permanent residence "on January 1st", that "March 1 of each year is the last day to submit a timely filed homestead exemption application", that the office "will consider homestead exemption applications filed after the March 1 deadline", and that the application can be filed online with Social Security numbers for the applicant and spouse (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Homestead Overview, read November 17, 2026).

The cap. Once a home is homesteaded, its assessed value may rise each year by no more than "the lower of" three percent or the change in the Consumer Price Index (section 193.155(1)) (Florida Statutes 193.155, read November 17, 2026). The Property Appraiser publishes the cap for each year (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Save Our Homes and Portability, read November 17, 2026):

Tax year

Save Our Homes cap on homestead assessed value

2026

2.7 percent

2025

2.9 percent

2024

3.0 percent (CPI 3.4 percent)

2023

3.0 percent (CPI 6.5 percent)

2022

3.0 percent (CPI 7.0 percent)

2021

1.4 percent

2020

2.3 percent

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, read November 17, 2026.

The reset on purchase. Property "shall be assessed at just value as of January 1 of the year following a change of ownership" (section 193.155(3)(a), same statute). That matters for an older Stillwater resale. A seller who has owned a Unit 1 home for many years under the cap may pay tax on an assessed value far below the price you are paying. Their bill is not your bill. Budget from your price and the full millage.

Portability. An owner who had a Florida homestead on January 1 of any of the three preceding years can reduce the new homestead's assessed value by the lesser of $500,000 or the old home's Save Our Homes difference (section 193.155(8), same statute). The Property Appraiser notes that "each homestead has a unique portability scenario" (same Property Appraiser page). You must file for the exemption and for portability on the new home; neither follows automatically.

What Did Amendment 3 Change for Stillwater Owners?

Florida voters approved Amendment 3 on November 3, 2026. WGCU and Suncoast Searchlight reported 62 percent approval statewide with 95 percent counted and about 63 percent in Sarasota County; a non-school homestead exemption rising "from $50,000 to $150,000" in 2027 and to $250,000 in 2028; a halved assessment cap for non-homestead property; and projected county "shortfalls of $241 million over the first two years" (WGCU and Suncoast Searchlight, November 5, 2026; WUSF, November 7, 2026, read November 17, 2026).

Those are news reports, and the implementing law, including how the new exemption treats a first-year homestead, was not in any primary source we read. So we have not recomputed the $485,000 example under Amendment 3. Ask the Property Appraiser before relying on a 2027 figure.

Why Does the First Full Tax Bill Jump on a New Shores at Stillwater Home?

Because the first bill can be based on the lot alone. Florida values real property "on January 1 of each year", and "Improvements or portions not substantially completed on January 1 shall have no value placed thereon", where "substantially completed" means the improvement can be used for the purpose for which it was built (section 192.042(1)) (Florida Statutes 192.042, read November 17, 2026).

The roll shows how many Shores at Stillwater parcels sit in that gap. Of the 140 parcels in Phases 1A and 1B on the October 21, 2026 file, 27 carried a home with heated area and 107 were vacant lots coded 0000; all 16 Shores sales in the window were homes the roll dates to 2025 or 2026, the first closing recorded on February 27, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). A Shores home finished after January 1 is taxed that year as land; the next year it is taxed at its completed value. Three lines step up at once:

First full year on a new Shores at Stillwater home

Lot-only year

Completed-home year

Ad valorem tax

On the lot's value

On the home's just value, for example $5,483.80 on $485,000 without homestead at 2026 rates

Englewood Area Fire assessment

$63.95 (vacant lot)

$290.78 (residential), up $226.83

CDD debt and O&M

Per the district's collection method for that year

About $1,659 (34-foot) or $2,190 (52-foot) a year

Sources: Florida Statutes 192.042; EAFCD, Assessments, Fees and Charges; Shores at Stillwater CDD Phase One methodology and FY2026/27 budget; our arithmetic. Read November 17, 2026.

Homestead adds one more step. A buyer who closes in 2026 and lives in the home on January 1, 2027 can file by March 1, 2027 for the 2027 roll; Save Our Homes caps begin the year after that first homestead year. A buyer who closes after January 1 pays a full non-homestead year first. Budget the second year from your price, not from the builder's lot-only bill.

What Non-Ad Valorem Lines Does a Stillwater Tax Bill Carry?

Several things on a Stillwater budget share the word "assessment", and they come from different bodies:

Line

Who sets it

Older Stillwater

Shores at Stillwater

Ad valorem tax

Taxing authorities, on taxable value

11.3068 mills in 2026

11.3068 mills in 2026

Englewood Area Fire assessment

Englewood Area Fire Control District

$290.78 a home

$290.78 a home, $63.95 a vacant lot

Solid waste assessment

Sarasota County

On the TRIM notice

On the TRIM notice

Stormwater assessment

Sarasota County stormwater utility

On the TRIM notice

On the TRIM notice

CDD debt assessment

Shores at Stillwater CDD

None

About $1,383 (34-foot) or $1,915 (52-foot) a year, to 2056 unless prepaid

CDD O&M assessment

Shores at Stillwater CDD

None

$276 a unit; collected at closing for 2026 to 2027

HOA dues

The association

Not published

Not published; Pulte says "Community Association fees required"

Sources: Sarasota County Tax Collector 2026 millage; EAFCD; Shores at Stillwater CDD methodology and budget; Pulte. Read November 17, 2026.

The Tax Collector lists "Englewood Fire Control: 941.474.3311" and "Englewood Water/Sewer: 941.460.1022" among the non-ad valorem levying authorities and explains that these assessments are merged with ad valorem taxes into one bill (Sarasota County Tax Collector, Non-Ad Valorem, read November 17, 2026). Paying early earns a discount: Florida law sets "4 percent in the month of November", 3 percent in December, 2 percent in January and 1 percent in February (section 197.162(1)) (Florida Statutes 197.162, read November 17, 2026). That is the 4 percent the CDD builds into its gross-up.

A worked example for a Shores at Stillwater 52-foot home with no homestead at 2026 rates: $5,483.80 ad valorem, plus $290.78 fire, plus $1,914.48 CDD debt, plus $276 CDD O&M, is $7,965.06 a year before solid waste and stormwater (our arithmetic). The same arithmetic for a 34-foot villa lot with the same $485,000 value gives $7,433.26, though most villas sell below that value. An older Stillwater home at the same value, with no CDD, would carry $5,774.58 for the first two lines (our arithmetic). Those are illustrations on one value, not bills.

What Closing Costs Come With a Stillwater Purchase?

Florida's deed documentary stamp tax is "70 cents" on each $100 of consideration (section 201.02(1)(a)) (Florida Statutes 201.02, read November 17, 2026). On the $485,000 median that is $3,395.00 (our arithmetic). A purchase mortgage adds two state taxes: documentary stamps on the note and mortgage of "35 cents on each $100 or fraction thereof" (section 201.08) (Florida Statutes 201.08, read November 17, 2026), and a "one-time nonrecurring tax of 2 mills" on the amount secured (section 199.133(1)) (Florida Statutes 199.133, read November 17, 2026).

Closing cost line

Rate or rule

Example on a $485,000 purchase with a $388,000 loan

Deed documentary stamps

70 cents per $100 of consideration

$3,395.00

Mortgage documentary stamps

35 cents per $100 of the amount secured

$1,358.00

Intangible tax on the mortgage

2 mills on the amount secured

$776.00

Owner's title insurance

Premiums set by state rule 69O-186.003

See below

Shores at Stillwater CDD O&M

"To Be Collected At Closings" for 2026 to 2027

Per the closing statement

CDD bond prepayment, if chosen

Lot's principal balance

Up to $18,580.37 (34-foot) or $25,726.66 (52-foot) at issue

HOA transfer or capital contribution

Per the declaration

Not published

Property tax and HOA proration

A contract term

Per the contract

Examples are our arithmetic on the rates stated, with an illustrative 80 percent loan; not a closing statement. Sources as named above, read November 17, 2026.

Title insurance premiums in Florida are set by rule (Rule 69O-186.003, read November 17, 2026). Its reissue rates, which can apply when the prior owner's policy is under three years old, are $3.30 per $1,000 up to $100,000 and $3.00 per $1,000 to $1 million (Cornell LII copy, read November 17, 2026): $1,485 on a $485,000 resale of a Shores home within three years of the first policy (our arithmetic, if the conditions are met). We did not read the original first-tier rate from a primary copy, so a title agent should quote the full premium.

Who pays the deed stamps and the owner's title policy on a Pulte sale at Shores at Stillwater is a contract term the builder's pages do not state, and Pulte's November savings offer could be applied "toward closing costs" (builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). On an older Stillwater resale, those lines are negotiated in the purchase contract. Ask for an estimated closing statement early either way.

What Does a Year of Ownership Look Like Line by Line?

Here is the structure without invented totals. Add the lines that apply to your Stillwater home when you have the documents:

  • Mortgage and insurance. From your lender and insurers, including flood coverage from January 1, 2027 if Citizens writes your wind policy.
  • County property tax. Taxable value times 11.3068 mills at 2026 rates, from the TRIM notice, with a March 1 homestead filing.
  • Englewood Area Fire. $290.78 for a home in 2026 to 2027.
  • Solid waste and stormwater. From the parcel's TRIM notice.
  • CDD, Shores at Stillwater only. About $1,383 or $1,915 of debt by lot width, plus $276 O&M, unless the debt was prepaid.
  • HOA dues. From the association's budget or an estoppel certificate. At Shores they also carry pond, preserve and pipe maintenance.
  • Water and sewer. About $116.87 a month at 5,000 gallons at the October 1, 2026 Englewood Water District rates, more with potable irrigation.
  • Electric, gas, internet. FPL for electric; gas and internet providers by address.
  • Maintenance. Roof, air conditioning, water heater, pool and landscaping. On an older Stillwater home, ask the age of each; on a new Shores home, track the Pulte warranty dates from closing.

How Did the Shores at Stillwater Land Become a Pulte Community?

Shores at Stillwater began as two vacant parcels on Medical Boulevard that PulteGroup bought from J and L LLC in August 2024, according to Sarasota Magazine. A county rezoning under Ordinance 2023-060 created the PUD, a 2025 water use permit and 2026 plats followed, and the first Shores home closing recorded on the county file was on February 27, 2026.

Who Sold the Land to Pulte, and When?

The best account we read is Sarasota Magazine's report of November 8, 2024. It said PulteGroup "purchased two parcels for The Shores at Stillwater, both on Medical Boulevard", a "32-acre lot west of the YMCA" and, across the street, "a 45-acre lot east of HCA Florida Englewood Hospital", from "J & L LLC for $12 million each in August", and that the project "spans 77 acres near Pine Street, on Medical Boulevard" (Sarasota Magazine, New Residential Construction Is Breaking Ground in Englewood, read November 17, 2026). The article is dated November 2024, so the August purchase was August 2024.

"$12 million each" can be read per parcel or for the pair, and we did not read the recorded deeds, whose documentary stamps would settle the price. J and L LLC's full legal name and the deed instruments are Information not available at time of publishing; they sit in the Sarasota County Clerk's records and on Sunbiz. The article's 77 acres also differs from the district's surveyed 79.83 acres, which we use.

The 2024 plan the article described, 256 homes, single-level, 1,579 to 2,080 square feet, from the "mid-$300,000s", groundbreaking in early 2025, has since changed: Pulte's 2026 page lists seven plans from 1,321 to 2,870 or more square feet, including the two-story Mystique Grande, and the district record shows 255 homes (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

What the land was before it was vacant, whether pasture, grove or pine flatwoods, is Information not available at time of publishing. Historic aerial photographs held by Sarasota County are where a person finds it.

Where Does Shores at Stillwater Sit Against the Older Stillwater Plats?

The district's legal description draws the map in words. One tract is bounded in part by "Englewood Medical Center, according to the plat thereof, recorded in Plat Book 35, page 20" and Morningside Drive per "WELLINGTON ACRES ... Plat Book 20, page 1". The other begins at "the Southeast corner of STILLWATER, UNIT TWO" and runs along Unit Two's east boundary to Medical Boulevard (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026).

So the Shores South Parcel shares its west line with Stillwater Unit Two, and the North Parcel sits at the east end of Medical Boulevard beyond the hospital plat. The assessment notice places the whole "north of Seahorse Lane, east of Pine Street, west of Winchester Boulevard, and south of Morningside Drive" (same book). The shared name ties Shores at Stillwater to its older neighbor, but the records keep them apart: separate plats, separate zoning history, and a CDD that stops at the Unit Two line. The CDD ordinance records that the Shores land was "previously designated as Special Planning Area 2" and "rezoned to a Planned Unit Development form with unified control per Ordinance No. 2023-060" (Ordinance 2025-032, text copy, read November 17, 2026).

What Do the Recorded Plats Show?

Plat

Recorded reference (as cited)

Parcels on the county roll

Homes with heated area on the roll

Stillwater Unit 1

Not found

77

76

Stillwater Unit 2

Plat Book 45, Pages 12 through 12C

36

35

Stillwater Unit 3

Not found

141

140

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A

Plat Book 59, Pages 140 to 147

54

19

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B

Plat Book 59, Pages 122 to 127

86

8

All five

394

278

Sources: plat references from the Shores at Stillwater CDD April 20, 2026 and June 15, 2026 meeting books; parcel and home counts from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

The district's Phase One description lists 52 lots on the Phase 1A plat and 84 on the Phase 1B plat, 136 in all (June book); the roll carries two more parcels in each phase, consistent with separately numbered common tracts, which we did not verify. The Phase 1A and 1B recording dates, the Unit 1 and Unit 3 plat references, and who platted and built the older Stillwater sections from 2000 are Information not available at time of publishing; the plat dedications at the Sarasota County Clerk name each developer, and we do not name a builder from a listing page.

What Permits and Environmental Records Exist?

What we read, strongest first:

  • Water use permit. The Southwest Florida Water Management District issued Pulte Home Company, LLC of Bonita Springs a new water use permit on July 2, 2025 for two wells at Shores at Stillwater, application number 20 021234.000, received January 31, 2025, for residential lawn and landscape use, at 26,100 gallons per day annual average, 30,400 gallons per day in drought and 82,900 gallons per day in the peak month, with zero gallons for frost protection (Business Observer legal notice 25-01328S, July 11, 2025, read November 17, 2026).
  • Site plan and utility permits. The engineer's report says the site development construction plans "have been approved by Sarasota County, the Englewood Water District, and the Southwest Florida Water Management District (SWFWMD)" and that "water and sewer permits from the Florida Department of Environmental Protection have been obtained" (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026).
  • Stormwater design. The same report describes wet detention ponds designed to the water management district's Basis of Review and the county's Land Development Code and Stormwater Technical Manual, providing "100-year flood control" (same book).

What we did not find: the environmental resource permit for the Shores ponds, any U.S. Army Corps of Engineers permit and any gopher tortoise relocation permit are Information not available at time of publishing; a person searches the water management district's ePermitting portal and the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission's permit locator. The commission's rule applies to any lot clearing: "A permit is required when a potentially occupied gopher tortoise burrow will be disturbed or otherwise damaged" (FWC, Gopher tortoise permits, read November 17, 2026).

When Did the First Shores at Stillwater Homes Close?

The county file answers this one directly. The first qualified sale of a Shores at Stillwater home was recorded on February 27, 2026, the next two on April 1 and April 9, 2026, and the newest on October 13, 2026, for 16 first sales in all through October 14, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Twelve were in Phase 1A at a $564,750 median and four in Phase 1B at $390,300 (same file). The roll dates the 27 Shores homes it shows with heated area to 2025 (8 homes) and 2026 (19 homes), with a median of 1,948 heated square feet; Phase 1B's eight homes on the roll all measure 1,574 square feet (same file).

Calendar years show the effect. Stillwater in Englewood recorded 13 qualified home sales in 2024 and 17 in 2025, all in the older plats, and 33 from January 1 to October 14, 2026: 17 older Stillwater resales and 16 Shores first sales, at a $455,000 median (same file). Medians swing with which plat sold, so we read no price trend into them.

The county file also shows the land moving before the homes: three vacant-lot deeds on Shores land in 2026, two in February and one in September, all coded unqualified (same file). Unqualified deeds are not market sales, and a vacant-parcel sale during development is not a public lot price, so we print no prices for them. A buyer of a new Shores home buys the home and lot together from Pulte.

What Is Still Being Built at Shores at Stillwater?

The October 21, 2026 roll shows 107 Shores at Stillwater lots still coded vacant, against 27 homes with heated area (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). The district record plans four phases and 255 homes, of which 136 are platted in Phase One, so about 119 homes remain for later phases on lots not yet on the roll as platted parcels (our arithmetic on the district's figures). On the Phase One roll prepared in June 2026, 125 of the 136 lots listed Pulte Home Company LLC as owner and 11 listed individual buyers (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026).

Pulte's page on November 17, 2026 said "Quick Move-Ins Available" and carried its November offers for to-be-built homes, which tells you the builder is selling both finished inventory and new starts (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). The sales center at 2048 Silver Shores Blvd is the place to ask which phase is next, when its plat will record and whether a second CDD bond series is planned for it. If you are weighing Shores at Stillwater against the other new construction around Englewood, our Englewood guide is the place to start.

What Flood Zones Cover Stillwater, and What Does Insurance Involve?

Stillwater in Englewood has one published flood reading so far: an earlier check by our team on November 14, 2026 found Zone X at one Lake Victoria Court address in Stillwater Unit 1 on FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer. Every other Stillwater and Shores at Stillwater lot still needs its own check before you buy.

Sarasota County's current FEMA flood maps took effect on March 27, 2024; ABC7 reported that the new maps meant fewer people with federally backed mortgages would need flood insurance, and that residents could check their status at scgov.net/floodmaps or by calling 311 (ABC7 mysuncoast, February 28, 2024, read November 17, 2026). FEMA's map services do not permit the automated lookups our research tools use, so this page has one reading, on one street, in one of the five plats, and explains how you get the reading for your own lot.

What Do We Know About Flood Zones in Stillwater, Englewood?

Part of Stillwater

Streets

FEMA flood zone

Source and date

Stillwater Unit 1

Lake Victoria Ct (one address)

Zone X

Earlier check by our team, FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, November 14, 2026

Stillwater Unit 3, other streets

Niagara Ct, Ontario Ct and others

Not checked

Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026)

Stillwater Units 1 and 2

Abercrombie Dr, Abercrombie Ave, Clear Lake Dr, Lake Tahoe Ct, Montigello Ct

Not checked

Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026)

Shores at Stillwater Phases 1A and 1B

Silver Shores Blvd, Tavira Pl

Not checked

Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026)

Data updated: November 2026 (one FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer reading by our team on November 14, 2026; plat and street names from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel file dated October 21, 2026)

Sources: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer; Sarasota County Property Appraiser. The earlier reading did not record the FIRM panel number or whether the Zone X was shaded or unshaded, so treat it as a single data point, not a flood determination for that lot or any other. Which street a plat uses is from the county roll, which lists Stillwater Unit 3's 141 parcels separately from Units 1 and 2 and lists Silver Shores Blvd (53 parcels) and Tavira Pl (86 parcels) for Shores at Stillwater.

In a straight line on the Census Bureau's 2024 TIGER water layer, Stillwater, Englewood is about 1.1 to 1.6 miles from Lemon Bay and 2.3 to 2.8 miles from the Gulf (Census TIGER/Line 2024 area water, Sarasota County, read November 17, 2026). Those are distances, not elevations.

What Do Zone X, Shaded Zone X and Zone AE Mean for a Stillwater Home?

FEMA's own glossary gives the definitions every Stillwater buyer should know (FEMA, Glossary: flood zones, read November 17, 2026):

  • Special Flood Hazard Area (Zones A, AE, VE and others). "The area that will be inundated by the flood event having a 1-percent chance" of being equaled or exceeded in any year.
  • Moderate flood hazard (Zone B or shaded Zone X). "The areas between the limits of the base flood and the 0.2-percent-annual-chance (or 500-year) flood."
  • Minimal flood hazard (Zone C or unshaded Zone X). Areas outside the Special Flood Hazard Area and higher than the 0.2 percent annual chance flood.

A Zone X reading means the point sits outside the Special Flood Hazard Area. It does not mean a lot cannot flood, and it does not tell you whether that point is shaded or unshaded X. FEMA says flood insurance rate maps still drive floodplain building rules and the mandatory purchase requirement on federally backed loans, which is why your lender's flood determination for the exact parcel matters more than any sample on this page (FEMA, Risk Rating 2.0, read November 17, 2026).

Flood zone and evacuation level are two separate facts. The FEMA zone is an insurance and building map. Sarasota County's evacuation levels, A through E, are an emergency planning label, with Level A "considered to be the most vulnerable" and "evacuated first" (WUSF, Sarasota County hurricane evacuation zone map, published April 30, 2025, updated May 28, 2026, read November 17, 2026). A Zone X home can still be in an evacuation level that is ordered out.

How Do You Check the Flood Zone for One Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater Lot?

Use these sources, in this order, for the exact parcel you are buying or selling:

  1. FEMA's Flood Map Service Center. Open msc.fema.gov in a browser, search the street address, and record the zone, whether Zone X is shaded or unshaded, the FIRM panel number and the effective date, which for Sarasota County is March 27, 2024 (ABC7 mysuncoast, read November 17, 2026).
  2. Any Letter of Map Change on the panel. New lots are often regraded during construction, so for a Shores at Stillwater home look on the same Map Service Center page for any letter that changes the map for that lot. Whether any such letter exists for Shores at Stillwater: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).
  3. The elevation certificate, if one exists. It is the document that compares the building to the map (next subsection).
  4. Your lender's flood determination and a written flood quote on the address, inside your inspection period.

Silver Shores Boulevard and Tavira Place are too new for the Census Bureau's 2024 address file (Census TIGER/Line 2024 address features, read November 17, 2026), so if a map tool cannot find a Shores address, search by parcel number.

Elevation Certificates, Lot Grades and the Shores at Stillwater Ponds

An elevation certificate is a surveyor's form that records a building's elevations against the flood map. We found no elevation certificate for any Stillwater, Englewood or Shores at Stillwater home in the sources we read: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Ask the Pulte sales team at 2048 Silver Shores Blvd, (941) 389-1010, or the seller of an older home whether one exists; if not, a licensed surveyor can prepare one during the inspection period (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated sales center details, read November 17, 2026).

Shores at Stillwater's drainage is a public record because its community development district finances it. The district engineer's report describes "a comprehensive system of surface water management ponds, consisting primarily of wet detention ponds," designed to the Southwest Florida Water Management District's Basis of Review and the Sarasota County Land Development Code, providing water quality treatment and "100-year flood control," and says the system "will be owned and maintained by the District" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, Master Report of District Engineer, read November 17, 2026). The stormwater line is $4,509,741 of the district's $11,060,350 master estimate (same book). The June 15, 2026 minutes record that lake bank, preserve and pipe maintenance would move to the homeowners association budget under an agreement, so the district's FY2026/2027 budget shows those lines at $0, with $20,000 for engineering and inspections (Shores at Stillwater CDD, Final Budget 2026-2027, read November 17, 2026).

"100-year flood control" is a design standard for the pond system, not a promise about any one house. The older Stillwater sections are not in that district, and their pond design: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

How Is a Stillwater Flood Policy Priced, and What Does the County's CRS Class Do?

FEMA prices National Flood Insurance Program policies under Risk Rating 2.0. New policies were rated that way from October 1, 2021; "All remaining policies renewing on or after April 1, 2022, were subject to the new pricing approach"; the rating considers "flood frequency, multiple flood types," distance to a water source, elevation and the cost to rebuild; and "Existing statutory limits on rate increases require that most rates not increase more than 18% per year" (FEMA, Risk Rating 2.0, read November 17, 2026).

Sarasota County is a Community Rating System Class 5 community. FEMA's eligible-communities list with an October 1, 2026 effective date shows "FL 125144 Sarasota County" at Class 5 with a 25 percent discount (FEMA, CRS Eligible Communities, October 2026, read November 17, 2026). Stillwater, Englewood is in unincorporated Sarasota County, so the county's community number is the one that applies (our reading). FEMA says the CRS discount applies to NFIP policies "including policies outside of the Special Flood Hazard Area (SFHA)," unless the structure is out of compliance, and that a Class 10 community receives no discount (FEMA, Community Rating System, read November 17, 2026).

A flood premium for a given Stillwater home: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026); only a quote on the address gives it, and the Citizens rule below may require coverage even where a lender does not.

What Changes for Citizens Policyholders in Stillwater on January 1, 2027?

Citizens Property Insurance has phased in a flood insurance requirement for personal residential policies with wind coverage. For homes outside the Special Flood Hazard Area, the steps are by dwelling value, Coverage A (Citizens Property Insurance, Flood, read November 17, 2026):

Citizens policy outside the Special Flood Hazard Area

Flood coverage required when dwelling value (Coverage A) is

Effective January 1, 2024

$600,000 or more

Effective January 1, 2025

$500,000 or more

Effective January 1, 2026

$400,000 or more

Effective January 1, 2027

All policies, regardless of value

Data updated: November 2026 (Citizens Property Insurance flood requirement page, read November 17, 2026)

Inside a Special Flood Hazard Area (Zones A, AO, AH, A1 to A30, AE, A99, V, V1 to V30 and VE), a Citizens policy with wind coverage must already carry flood coverage. Not required: "Condominium unit-owner policies, tenant content policies, and policies that exclude windstorm or hail coverage." The flood limit must be "Equal to or greater than your Citizens policy dwelling value, (Coverage A)," or the most the NFIP offers the insured, which Citizens lists as "Regular program: $250,000 Coverage A" (same page).

What that means in Stillwater, Englewood: from January 1, 2027, a Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater home insured by Citizens with wind coverage needs a flood policy even at a Zone X address (our reading of the Citizens table). Coverage A is the policy's dwelling value, not the sale price, so the earlier steps may already have reached some homes. Ask your agent for the Coverage A figure on the current declarations page.

Wind Mitigation, Code Vintage and Opening Protection in Stillwater

Wind mitigation credits are the main insurance lever for a Florida home. Florida Statutes 627.0629 says rate filings "must include actuarially reasonable discounts, credits, or other rate differentials" for wind-resistive construction, that fixtures or techniques "that meet the minimum requirements of the Florida Building Code must be included in the rate filing," and that the Office of Insurance Regulation reevaluates them "On or before January 1, 2025, and every 5 years thereafter" (Florida Statutes 627.0629, read November 17, 2026).

The inspection form changed in 2026. Citizens says the revised Uniform Mitigation Verification Inspection Form, OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26), "will be effective April 1, 2026," that inspections on or after that date "must use the revised form," and that it updates the building code, roof covering, roof deck attachment, roof-to-wall attachment, secondary water resistance and opening protection items while adding FORTIFIED Home certificate eligibility, roof slope for multi-slope homes and "Region - location is based on design wind speed." Citizens still accepts Rev. 01/12 forms completed within five years before April 1, 2026 if the structure is unchanged (Citizens, Uniform Mitigation Verification Inspection Form Changes, March 19, 2026, read November 17, 2026).

The two Stillwater markets start from different places:

  • Older Stillwater homes, Units 1 to 3. The county roll shows the 251 older homes built from 2000 to 2016, with a 2008 median: Unit 1 from 2000 to 2016, Unit 2 in 2005 and 2006, Unit 3 from 2007 to 2013 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). The code edition for each home turns on its permit date in the county permit record: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).
  • Shores at Stillwater homes. The roll shows the 27 Shores homes on it built in 2025 (8) and 2026 (19) (same file). Pulte lists "Impact Glass & Tile Roof Included" and "Impact glass windows included with every home" for Shores at Stillwater (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). PulteGroup's president of sales, Ben Crisafulli, told Sarasota Magazine that "For many, buying new construction is a practical choice, with lower insurance costs and warranties" (Sarasota Magazine, November 8, 2024, read November 17, 2026); that is a builder's general comment, not a quote for any home. Ask for the wind mitigation report at closing so your insurer can apply the credits.

The design wind speed for Stillwater and Shores at Stillwater addresses was not read for this page: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Sarasota County building services or the engineer of record can confirm it for a lot.

Hurricanes, Evacuation and Storm Readiness in Stillwater

Stillwater, Englewood has no published storm damage record of its own: the National Hurricane Center and National Weather Service reports on Charley, Ian, Helene and Milton describe Englewood and Sarasota County without naming Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater, and the evacuation level for Stillwater addresses is not verified (checked November 17, 2026).

This section stays with what the official reports say. The older Stillwater homes were built from 2000 to 2016, so every one of them predates Ian, Helene and Milton, and the oldest Unit 1 homes predate Charley; the Shores at Stillwater homes were built in 2025 and 2026, after all four storms (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, parcel file dated October 21, 2026). All storm sources below were read November 17, 2026.

Which Evacuation Level Is Stillwater In?

The evacuation level for Stillwater and Shores at Stillwater addresses: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). The county's evacuation map was not reachable by our research tools on that date, so we print no level.

Here is how the system works and where you get the answer. Sarasota County uses evacuation levels A through E: "the evacuation levels are divided from A-E, with A being shown on the map as the color red and E as light blue," and "Those in evacuation A are considered to be the most vulnerable and would be evacuated first"; the county map lets a reader "type in your address to see your evacuation zone" (WUSF, Sarasota County hurricane evacuation zone map, read November 17, 2026). Sarasota County prints each parcel's evacuation level on the TRIM notice and in its Know Your Zone lookup, so the TRIM notice for the parcel and the county lookup are the two places to read it. The Florida Division of Emergency Management's Know Your Zone page links the statewide map: click "Know Your Zone Map," then "Type in your address" (Florida Division of Emergency Management, Know Your Zone, read November 17, 2026).

Record the level for your address with the date you checked it, and keep it in your hurricane plan and your purchase file.

What Evacuation Orders Did Sarasota County Issue in 2024?

The two 2024 storms show how the levels are used. For Hurricane Helene, the National Weather Service's Tampa Bay office lists Sarasota County's evacuations as "Zone A and manufactured homes" (NWS Tampa Bay, Hurricane Helene county impact narratives, read November 17, 2026). For Hurricane Milton, it lists them as "Mandatory for zones A, B, and C, and for mobile and manufactured homes and boat homes" (NWS Tampa Bay, Hurricane Milton county impact narratives, read November 17, 2026). Sarasota Magazine's October 8, 2024 update reported that "Sarasota County has expanded its evacuation orders to include Zones A, B and C," with county evacuation centers opening at 10 a.m. that Tuesday (Sarasota Magazine, Hurricane Milton evacuation orders, read November 17, 2026).

Once you know your Stillwater level, compare it with those orders. The roads matter too. Sarasota County says "The South River Road corridor serves as an important evacuation route for Englewood and the barrier islands," and its widening of South River Road and Winchester Boulevard, a 7.3-mile corridor at $95 million, is scheduled for Spring 2027 to Summer 2029 (WGCU and Suncoast Searchlight, November 13, 2026, read November 17, 2026). In Ian, "A portion of Interstate 75 in southern Sarasota County was shut down due flooding from the Myakka River" (NHC Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian, read November 17, 2026), so plan more than one route out.

Hurricane Charley, August 2004

The National Hurricane Center says Charley "caused catastrophic wind damage in Charlotte County, Florida," and that it "made landfall on the southwest coast of Florida near Cayo Costa, just north of Captiva, around 1945 UTC 13 August with maximum sustained winds near 130 kt. Charley's eye passed over Punta Gorda at about 2045 UTC, and the eyewall struck that city and neighboring Port Charlotte with devastating results" (NHC Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Charley, read November 17, 2026).

The measured surge in the report was 4.2 feet in Estero Bay and 3.4 and 3.6 feet on the Caloosahatchee River, with no Englewood value (same report). Stillwater Unit 1 homes on the roll date from 2000, so some of the oldest Stillwater, Englewood homes stood in 2004; Stillwater-specific Charley effects: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

Hurricane Ian, September 2022

Ian "made landfall on the barrier island of Cayo Costa, Florida, at 1905 UTC 28 September with an intensity of 130 kt," and at 2035 UTC "the center of Ian's large eye made another landfall near Punta Gorda, Florida, with an estimated intensity of 125 kt" (NHC Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian, read November 17, 2026).

Near Englewood, the surge forecast did not come true. The final report says "The majority of the sensors placed in Port Charlotte and Englewood, as well as northward through Tampa Bay, remained dry and did not measure storm surge due to offshore winds," and "The Storm Surge Warning did not verify north of Englewood due to a southward shift in the track of Ian" (NHC Ian report).

Rain was the bigger story inland. The report's highest storm total was "26.95 inches in Grove City, Florida," and counties including Charlotte and Sarasota "experienced significant flooding when the Peace, Myakka, and Alafia Rivers, and Horse Creek all crested to record levels" (same report).

Next door, HCA Florida Englewood Hospital's chief executive described "minor damage to our facility caused by Hurricane Ian," and the hospital reopened on Thursday, October 6, 2022 after utilities were restored (Chief Healthcare Executive, October 12, 2022, read November 17, 2026). Stillwater-specific Ian damage or flooding: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

Hurricane Helene, September 2024

Helene made landfall far to the north in Florida's Big Bend, but the National Weather Service's Sarasota County narrative records peak gusts "generally between 60 to 70, with a maximum gust of 69 mph near Venice at 2:55 PM EST on September 26" and rainfall of 1 to 3 inches, with a maximum of 2.51 inches near North Port (NWS Tampa Bay, Helene county impact narratives, read November 17, 2026).

Water levels were the record. "A peak water level of 5.42 feet above MHHW was measured at the mouth of the Myakka River at North Port Charlotte at 12:45 AM EST on September 27, surpassing the previous site record of 3.57 feet above MHHW set during Hurricane Idalia on August 30, 2023. Peak water levels measured elsewhere along coastal Sarasota County generally ranged from 3 to 6 feet above MHHW" (same narratives).

MHHW, mean higher high water, is a tide datum, so those figures are water heights above a tide line, not depths at any house. No Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater reading appears in the narratives: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

Hurricane Milton, October 2024

Milton's maximum winds "decreased to near 100 kt (category 3 ...) by the time the center made landfall on Siesta Key, Florida, at 0030 UTC 10 October" (NHC Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Milton, read November 17, 2026). South of landfall, "Storm surge inundation of 6 to 9 ft above ground level (AGL) occurred from Venice southward to Boca Grande, with an isolated peak of up to 10 ft AGL estimated near Manasota Key"; the report adds that "no in situ observations were available from the hardest hit areas south of Venice" and that imagery shows "destructive storm surge impacts to the Manasota Key beach front community" (same report).

The National Weather Service's Sarasota County narrative records gusts "generally between 80 to 100 mph," including 97 mph at the Venice CMAN and 102 mph at the Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport, rainfall of 4 to 8 inches with an "isolated maximum total of 10.24 inches near North Port," and "A peak water level of 5.3 feet above MHHW was measured at the USGS Venice gauge at 10:15 PM EST on October 9" (NWS Tampa Bay, Milton county impact narratives, read November 17, 2026).

The Florida Department of Environmental Protection's March 2025 report says Helene and Milton together caused "major structural damage to 226 major structures within the Coastal Building Zone of Sarasota County," including 143 single-family dwellings, with overwash on Siesta Key, Casey Key, Venice Beach and Manasota Key (FDEP, Hurricane Helene and Milton Impact Report in Southwest Florida, March 2025, read November 17, 2026). The Coastal Building Zone is the barrier island and beachfront strip, not mainland Stillwater in Englewood.

Before Milton arrived, HCA Florida Englewood Hospital moved 21 patients to other HCA Florida facilities, and the report we read describes no physical damage there (SRQ Magazine, October 12, 2024, read November 17, 2026). Stillwater-specific Milton damage or flooding: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

What the Record Does Not Say, and What to Do Before the Next Storm

We found no news report, county report or National Weather Service narrative that names Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater in Ian, Helene or Milton. That does not mean Stillwater did not flood; the seller's disclosure, claim history and permit record answer it for a given home.

The National Hurricane Center's National Storm Surge Risk Maps show maximum surge by storm category, representing "the near worst-case scenario of flooding under ideal storm conditions" (NHC, National Storm Surge Risk Maps, read November 17, 2026). The bands at Stillwater sit in the NHC's interactive viewer, which we did not query: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

What a Stillwater, Englewood owner can do with what is known:

  • Look up your evacuation level. Use the Sarasota County lookup or your TRIM notice, and write the level and date in your plan.
  • Read the permit file. The county permit record shows when the home was permitted and what roof, windows and shutters were installed, which drives both wind credits and storm resistance.
  • Get a current wind mitigation report. Use the Rev. 04/26 form for inspections on or after April 1, 2026.
  • Price flood coverage now. From January 1, 2027, the Citizens rule reaches Citizens personal residential policies with wind coverage regardless of dwelling value.

Amenities, Parks, Beaches and Recreation Near Stillwater

Stillwater in Englewood splits on amenities: Pulte lists a gated entry, a heated community pool, a pool cabana, grills and mail kiosks for Shores at Stillwater (builder-stated), while no citable source confirms the older Stillwater sections' amenities, and county beaches, bay parks and boat ramps sit a short drive west (read November 17, 2026).

Every place below carries its operator and address as its operator or an official tourism page published them on November 17, 2026. Measured distances are free-flow routing estimates from the 150 block of Abercrombie Avenue in Stillwater, computed that day with the OSRM public routing service on OpenStreetMap data, with no traffic, so real drives take longer (OSRM routing table service, computed November 17, 2026). Where we have only Pulte's own distance, we label it builder-stated; where we have neither, we say so. Pulte's page also mentions a nearby state park and an "Ainger Creek Trails and Preserve" at the community entrance; we could not match either claim to an official source, so we do not repeat them as places.

The Sarasota County parks site returned an access error to our tools on November 17, 2026, so the county's own hours, parking fees and rules for its parks are not printed; call Sarasota County at (941) 861-5000 or open the county parks site in a browser.

What Amenities Does Shores at Stillwater List, and What About the Older Stillwater Sections?

Pulte lists these community amenities for Shores at Stillwater: "Heated community pool," "Pool cabana with covered seating," "BBQ grills" and "Mail kiosks," with the feature tags "Gated, with Heated Pool & Cabana," "Natural Gas Community" and "Impact Glass & Tile Roof Included," and neighborhood features including "Gated community," "Water and preserve views" and "Personalized pool options for both the villas and single-family homes" (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). Private home pools are an option: "Select villa and single-family homes offer the opportunity to add a pool," and Pulte's November 2026 offer includes "a standard pool, valued at $69,500" on select to-be-built homes accepted November 2 to November 30, 2026 (same page, builder-stated; offers change).

The district record settles who owns what. The district engineer says Shores at Stillwater "will consist of single-family detached and attached residential units, an amenity center, and various open spaces for resident use," and that "The roadways, irrigation, landscaping and amenity center will be private and are not included in the CIP" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). So the pool and cabana belong to the private side of Shores at Stillwater, not to the CDD. Pool hours, guest rules and the association's budget for them are not on Pulte's pages: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). The HOA documents from Pulte hold those answers.

For the older Stillwater, Englewood sections, Units 1 to 3, a gate, pool, clubhouse or spa: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Listing sites describe amenities there, but we do not cite listing sites, and no association document was readable. Whether owners in the older sections may use the Shores at Stillwater pool, or the reverse, is not stated in any primary source we read. The recorded declaration at the Sarasota County Clerk, the association's management company or an estoppel letter settles it for a given home.

The Englewood YMCA and the Englewood Sports Complex

The Englewood YMCA, part of the SKY Family YMCA, is at 701 Medical Blvd, Englewood, FL 34223, phone 941-475-1234, on the same Medical Boulevard that carries traffic into Stillwater, Englewood. Branch hours listed are Monday to Thursday 5:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m., Friday 5:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m., Saturday 7:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. and Sunday 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. (SKY Family YMCA, Englewood YMCA, read November 17, 2026).

The Englewood Sports Complex, 1300 S River Rd, Englewood, FL 34223, is a "136-acre sports complex" with "six little league Fields," two softball fields, "four soccer fields," "four tennis courts," "18 pickleball courts," basketball, an "11,000 square foot multi purpose/gymnasium," two meeting rooms and a locker room with showers; the contact listed is Visit Sarasota, (941) 955-0991 (Visit Sarasota Sports, Englewood Sports Complex, read November 17, 2026). Pulte puts it "only 2.5 miles away" (builder-stated).

Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park

Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park, 2100 N Beach Road, Englewood, FL 34223, is Charlotte County's beach on Manasota Key, about 3.4 road miles and 8 minutes from Stillwater by our routing estimate (OSRM routing table service, computed November 17, 2026). The beach sits in Charlotte County even though its address uses ZIP 34223 (Census TIGER/Line 2024 address features, Charlotte County, read November 17, 2026). Pulte says beaches are "less than 3.5 miles away" and Sarasota Magazine says "about 3.5 miles" (builder-stated and news figures, Pulte; Sarasota Magazine, November 8, 2024, read November 17, 2026).

Englewood Beach item

What Charlotte County publishes

Hours

6 a.m. to 9 p.m.

Parking

Pay to park, 75 cents an hour; seasonal or annual passes at county recreation centers, the Charlotte County Tax Collector or 941.625.7529

Facilities

900-foot boardwalk with three covered lookouts, restrooms, showers, water stations, grills, picnic tables and shelters, three large pavilions, volleyball and basketball courts, horseshoe pits, playground, fishing pier

Pavilion rental

From $10 an hour plus tax; 941.681.3742

Southern lot

Reopened April 2, 2025

Shuttle

Free park-and-ride from Tringali Park, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., Monday to Saturday

Dogs

"Dogs are not permitted on beaches or fishing piers, per County Ordinance."

Data updated: November 2026 (Charlotte County Beaches and Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park pages, read November 17, 2026)

Sources: Charlotte County, Beaches; Charlotte County, Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park, both read November 17, 2026. Parking notices and shuttle schedules change, so check the county page before you go.

Manasota Beach, Blind Pass Beach and Stump Pass

North of Englewood Beach, Sarasota County runs two Gulf beaches on Manasota Key. Manasota Beach, 8570 Manasota Key Road, Manasota Key, FL 34223, phone (941) 861-5000, lists "Beach, lifeguard, boardwalk, fishing, boat ramps, docks, canoe/kayak launch, picnic areas," plus grills, a volleyball court, restrooms, parking, a fishing pier, hiking trails and wildlife watching (Visit Sarasota, Manasota Beach, read November 17, 2026). Blind Pass Beach, 6725 Manasota Key Road, also called Middle Beach, has "almost 3,000 feet of beach frontage" with "Gulf-to-bay access," and across the road on the bay side a mangrove trail and fishing dock, with a canoe launch, hiking trails, picnic facilities, a playground and restrooms (Visit Sarasota, Blind Pass Beach, read November 17, 2026).

Neither Visit Sarasota page states hours or parking fees, and Sarasota County's parks site returned an access error to our tools, so hours and fees: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

Stump Pass Beach State Park, on the south end of Manasota Key, is run by Florida State Parks. We did not open the state parks site for this page, so its hours, fee and rules: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026); check floridastateparks.org before you go.

Lemon Bay Park and Environmental Center

Lemon Bay Park and Environmental Center, 570 Bay Park Blvd, Englewood, FL 34223, phone (941) 861-5000, is a "210-acre nature-based park located in Englewood with 1.7 miles of shoreline on the beautiful Lemon Bay Aquatic Preserve," with black mangrove forest, mangrove shoreline, pine and scrubby flatwoods, nature trails with interpretive signs, "a canoe/kayak launch" and a building "with a large veranda" (Visit Sarasota, Lemon Bay Park and Environmental Center, read November 17, 2026). The page lists guided walks, a fishing pier and restrooms, and calls it a pet-friendly park.

Pulte says Lemon Bay Park is 5 miles from Shores at Stillwater, with "trails (paved and unpaved) along with birding, boating, and fishing areas" (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). Hours, program fees and pet rules from the county itself: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

Indian Mound Park and the Boat Ramps Near Stillwater

Stillwater, Englewood is an inland community, so boats launch at public ramps. Indian Mound Park, 210 Winson Ave, Englewood, FL 34223, phone (941) 861-5000, is "a key boat launching site in southern Sarasota County," whose "contoured landscape is a direct result of Indian habitation," with a boat ramp, canoe launch, hiking trails, picnic facilities and restrooms (Visit Sarasota, Indian Mound Park, read November 17, 2026). The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission's boating guide lists the ramp with "Ramps/Lanes 1/4," "Ramp Fee: No," parking, docks and restrooms, managed by "Sarasota County Parks and Recreation," open "6AM to Midnight" (FWC Boating and Angling Guide to Charlotte Harbor, Indian Mound Park, read November 17, 2026). The FWC page prints the ZIP as 34236; the park's address is Englewood 34223.

Ramp

Operator

Fee

Hours

Facilities

Indian Mound Park, 210 Winson Ave

Sarasota County Parks and Recreation

No fee (FWC guide)

6 a.m. to midnight (FWC guide)

Docks, parking, restrooms

Manasota Beach, 8570 Manasota Key Rd

Sarasota County

Not stated

Not stated

Boat ramps and docks listed by Visit Sarasota

Data updated: November 2026 (FWC Boating and Angling Guide to Charlotte Harbor and Visit Sarasota pages, read November 17, 2026)

Pulte invites buyers to "take the boat out for the day at one of the many marinas nearby" but names none (builder-stated). Marinas, dry storage and private ramps near Stillwater were not verified from an official source: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

Ann and Chuck Dever Regional Park and Cedar Point Environmental Park

Across the county line in Charlotte County, Ann and Chuck Dever Regional Park, 6961 San Casa Drive, Englewood, FL 34224, park phone 941.681.3760 and pool 941.681.3743, offers a heated 25-yard competition pool and a diving well, a 23,000 square foot recreation center with a fitness center, gymnasium and community garden, football and cricket fields, basketball, pickleball and tennis courts, trails, a dog park, disc golf and a skate park (Charlotte County, Ann and Chuck Dever Regional Park, read November 17, 2026). The Oyster Creek Waterfront Trail links it with Cedar Point.

Cedar Point Environmental Park, 2300 Placida Road, Englewood, FL 34224, phone 941.475.0769, says "With 115 acres pine flatwoods cover over 60 % of the park," and lists birding, an environmental center, fishing, historic features, a nature preserve and trail, picnic tables, a playground and restrooms; its notice reads "The fishing dock at Cedar Point Environmental Park remains closed" (Charlotte County, Cedar Point Environmental Park, read November 17, 2026). The page's rules image suggests a no-dogs rule for environmental parks; confirm with the park before you bring a pet. Neither park has a routing estimate from Stillwater in our data.

Golf, Dearborn Street and the Lemon Bay Playhouse

Pulte lists no golf course among Shores at Stillwater's amenities (builder-stated). Two clubs near Stillwater in Englewood publish their own pages:

  • Boca Royale Golf and Country Club, 1601 Englewood Road, Englewood, FL 34223, (941) 475-6464, describes itself as a "Private Country Club" with a "newly redesigned par-71 course" by Gordy Lewis, plus tennis, pickleball, fitness, dining and social activities (Boca Royale Golf and Country Club, read November 17, 2026).
  • Lemon Bay Golf Club, 9600 Eagle Preserve Drive, Englewood, FL 34224, (941) 697-3729, says its course was "Designed by Drew Rogers In 2023," calls it a "Protected Eagle Preserve; certified Audubon Cooperative Sanctuary," and handles membership by inquiry; the page does not state public access (Lemon Bay Golf Club, read November 17, 2026).

Public course access, rates and tee times near Stillwater: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

Dearborn Street in Old Englewood Village, about 2.3 road miles and 5 minutes from Stillwater by our routing estimate, "features several blocks of independent shops & eateries in the Old Englewood Village rich in historic charm," with boutiques, galleries, coffee shops, restaurants, live music, Pioneer Plaza events and a farmers market "every Thursday (Oct to May)" (Visit Sarasota, Dearborn Street Englewood, read November 17, 2026). The Lemon Bay Playhouse, 96 W Dearborn Street, (941) 475-6756, box office (941) 474-9610, was "Founded in 1987" and runs live theater September through June (Visit Sarasota, Lemon Bay Playhouse, read November 17, 2026).

Which Schools Serve Stillwater Addresses?

Stillwater, Englewood addresses are in Sarasota County Schools, and for the two addresses we checked on November 17, 2026, one in Stillwater Unit 3 and one in Shores at Stillwater, the district's School Zone Lookup returned Englewood Elementary Zone, L.A. Ainger Middle Zone and Wellen Park High Zone. Confirm your exact address in the same tool.

This section names the zones the district's own tool returned and shows you how to run the check yourself. It does not rate or rank any school. School zoning is address specific and can change, so the tool, not this page, is the answer for a particular Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater home.

Which School Zones Did the Lookup Return for Stillwater?

Sarasota County Schools' Back 2 School page, under Step 3, "Determine which school zone you live in," links the district's official tool, the Sarasota County School Zone Lookup (Sarasota County Schools, Back 2 School, read November 17, 2026). For both addresses we entered, the tool answered, "According to our data, your address is located in the following school zones," and returned the same three zones, each with "Zone Update Info: No Update Info" (Sarasota County School Zone Lookup, read November 17, 2026):

Level

Zone returned

Stillwater Unit 1 address (Lake Victoria Ct)

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A address (Silver Shores Blvd)

Elementary

Englewood Elementary Zone

Yes

Yes

Middle

L.A. Ainger Middle Zone

Yes

Yes

High

Wellen Park High Zone

Yes

Yes

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County School Zone Lookup results for two Stillwater, Englewood addresses, read November 17, 2026)

Two addresses are a sample, not a boundary map.

The Two Stillwater Addresses We Checked

We chose one address in each of the two Stillwater markets. The first is on Lake Victoria Court, a Stillwater Unit 1 street; the county roll lists 14 parcels on Lake Victoria Ct (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, parcel file dated October 21, 2026). The second is on Silver Shores Boulevard in Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A, a street with 53 parcels on the same roll. Both carry Englewood 34223 addresses. We list results by street, without house numbers.

Units 1 and 2 and Tavira Place in Phase 1B were not checked: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

How to Use the Sarasota County School Zone Lookup

  1. Start from the district page. Open the Back 2 School page and follow Step 3 to the School Zone Lookup (Sarasota County Schools, Back 2 School).
  2. Enter the address as the property appraiser shows it. The Sarasota County Property Appraiser record gives the situs address and ZIP 34223 for every Stillwater and Shores at Stillwater parcel (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026).
  3. Read all three zones. The tool returns elementary, middle and high school zones together, with a "Zone Update Info" line for each.
  4. Save the result with the date. A dated screenshot belongs in your purchase file, because zone lines change.

Wellen Park High School Opened in August 2026

Wellen Park High School is new. ABC7 reported that Sarasota County Schools began the 2026 to 2027 year the week of August 10, 2026 with Wellen Park High, the district's "first new public high school in 25 years," "eclipsing 1,200 students for their first year" (ABC7 mysuncoast, August 10, 2026, read November 17, 2026). Its address is "1 Eaglerise Drive, Venice, Florida"; the campus "sits within North Port city limits" and is "served by the Venice Post Office" (ABC7 mysuncoast, August 11, 2026, read November 17, 2026).

Older web pages may still name a different high school for Stillwater, Englewood; the district's lookup controls. The Wellen Park High attendance zone map itself was not found on an official page we read: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

How Far Are the Zoned Schools From Stillwater?

From the 150 block of Abercrombie Avenue in Stillwater, free-flow routing estimates to two of the three zoned schools are below (OSRM routing table service, computed November 17, 2026):

School

Distance (routing estimate)

Drive time (routing estimate, no traffic)

Englewood Elementary

2.6 road miles

about 6 minutes

L.A. Ainger Middle (Rotonda West campus)

5.5 road miles

about 11 minutes

Wellen Park High

Not computed

Not computed

Data updated: November 2026 (OSRM routing estimates on OpenStreetMap data, free-flow, from one Stillwater address point, computed November 17, 2026)

Wellen Park High's campus is not in the Census Bureau's 2024 address file, so we have no routing estimate for it (Census TIGER/Line 2024 address features, read November 17, 2026). Real drive times depend on traffic, the hour and the SR 776 construction scheduled through mid 2027.

Why Does a Charlotte County Campus Appear in a Sarasota County Result?

The L.A. Ainger Middle campus used for our routing estimate is in Rotonda West, which the Census Bureau's address file places in Charlotte County (ZIP 33947), while Stillwater, Englewood is in Sarasota County (Census TIGER/Line 2024 address features, Charlotte County, read November 17, 2026). The Sarasota County School Zone Lookup still returned "L.A. Ainger Middle Zone" for both Stillwater addresses, so the zone, not the county the building sits in, is what the district assigns. The written agreement behind that arrangement: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026); ask Sarasota County Schools.

Stillwater vs Coco Bay vs Boca Royale vs Beachwalk vs Manasota Key: How Do They Compare?

Stillwater recorded 35 qualified home sales at a $485,000 median in the Sarasota County Property Appraiser's 12 months to October 14, 2026, against 86 at $576,500 in Boca Royale, 206 at $672,300 in Beachwalk, 25 at $2,200,000 on Manasota Key's Sarasota side and 129 at $315,000 in Coco Bay, each in its own file and window.

Each column below keeps its own county file, its own measure of home size and its own 12-month window, and we never add or average them. Every Coco Bay, Boca Royale, Beachwalk and Manasota Key figure comes from our published guides to those communities and the sources they cite: our Coco Bay guide, our Boca Royale guide, our Beachwalk by Manasota Key guide and our Manasota Key guide. Stillwater, Englewood figures are from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, with sales through October 14, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), and from the district and builder sources named on this page.

The Decision Table

Yardstick

Stillwater (with Shores at Stillwater)

Coco Bay

Boca Royale

Beachwalk by Manasota Key

Manasota Key, Sarasota side

County and ZIP

Unincorporated Sarasota County, Englewood 34223

Unincorporated Charlotte County, Englewood 34224

Unincorporated Sarasota County, 34223

Unincorporated Sarasota County, 34223

Unincorporated Sarasota County, 34223

Builder now

Pulte Homes at Shores at Stillwater; original Stillwater builder not found

Lennar

Neal Communities

DiVosta Homes, a PulteGroup brand

Not applicable

Homes on the roll

278: 251 older homes (Units 1 to 3) and 27 Shores homes, plus 107 vacant Shores lots

445 homes: 287 detached, 158 attached villas

949 parcels with a home

897 parcels with a home

298 single-family homes with living area

Years built (roll)

Older sections 2000 to 2016 (median 2008); Shores 2025 and 2026

444 of 445 homes 2023 to 2025

1999 to 2025 in the platted units

2021 to 2026

1945 to 2025, median 1983

County file and 12-month window

SCPA file October 21, 2026; October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026

CCPA roll November 5, 2026; September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026

SCPA file October 21, 2026; October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026

SCPA file October 21, 2026; October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026

SCPA file October 21, 2026; October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026

Qualified sales, 12 months

35 (19 older Stillwater, 16 Shores first sales)

129 improved

86

206

25

Median sale price, 12 months

$485,000 (older $315,000; Shores $523,250)

$315,000

$576,500

$672,300

$2,200,000

Median price per square foot

$241 (heated area)

$173 (heated area)

$266 (living area)

$327 (living area)

$775 (living area)

Community development district

Shores at Stillwater only (Ordinance 2025-032); older Stillwater not in it

No district named in any source; Lennar states a "special assessment"

Original Boca Royale not in WVID

"No CDD"

None named in our guide; I051 Manasota Key Beach Restoration line on the tax bill

Association dues

Names and dues not found for either section

Lennar-stated HOA figure, period not stated

Master POA; dues not published

$367.29 to $400.71 a month, 2026

Not covered as one association in our guide

Flood profile

One earlier reading: Zone X on Lake Victoria Ct; others not checked

11 of 12 address points Zone X, 1 AE

10.8% of 1,245 address points AE

About 20% of address points AE

Points checked VE and AE

Evacuation

Not verified

Zone B at 12 points (Charlotte County)

1,117 of 1,245 points Level C

About 89% Level C

Zone A

Data updated: November 2026 (Stillwater, Boca Royale, Beachwalk and Manasota Key Sarasota side: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; Coco Bay: Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026, qualified improved sales September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026; sister figures as published in our guides to those communities; Stillwater district facts from the Shores at Stillwater CDD records read November 17, 2026)

Sources for the Stillwater column: Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, one earlier reading by our team on November 14, 2026. The other columns are from our guides and the sources each cites. Stillwater's price per square foot uses the roll's heated area field; the Boca Royale, Beachwalk and Manasota Key guides label their measure living area from the same county file.

How Do the Price Records Compare?

Four of the five columns share a county file and a window: the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026, with qualified sales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). On that footing, Stillwater's 35 sales carried a $485,000 median and $241 per heated square foot, Boca Royale's 86 a $576,500 median and $266, Beachwalk's 206 a $672,300 median and $327, and the Sarasota side of Manasota Key's 25 a $2,200,000 median and $775, per our guides to those communities.

Stillwater's median hides a split that matters more than any comparison. The 19 older Stillwater sales had a $315,000 median and $203 per square foot, and the 16 Shores at Stillwater first sales a $523,250 median and $267 per square foot (same file). Inside the older sections, Unit 3's 10 sales had a $282,500 median and Unit 1's 7 sales a $550,000 median. A buyer choosing between a Unit 3 home and a Beachwalk home is comparing very different price levels; a buyer choosing between Shores at Stillwater and Beachwalk is comparing two PulteGroup brands, Pulte and DiVosta, at medians of $523,250 and $672,300, per our Beachwalk guide.

Coco Bay comes from the Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026, with a window ending September 9, 2026, per our Coco Bay guide; its $315,000 median matches older Stillwater's, but its homes are almost all 2023 to 2025 Lennar builds.

How Do Districts, Associations and Assessments Differ?

Stillwater in Englewood is the only one of the five where a community development district covers part of the community and not the rest. The Shores at Stillwater CDD, created by Sarasota County Ordinance 2025-032, carries Series 2026 bond debt of $18,580.37 per 34-foot lot and $25,726.66 per 52-foot lot, with maximum annual debt assessments of $1,382.68 and $1,914.48, and an O&M rate of $276 per unit that for FY2026/2027 is "To Be Collected At Closings" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; CDD Final Budget 2026-2027, read November 17, 2026). The older Stillwater sections are outside the district's legal description.

Beachwalk states "No CDD" and publishes HOA dues of $367.29 to $400.71 a month for 2026, per our Beachwalk guide. Original Boca Royale is outside the West Villages Improvement District and its master property owners association publishes no dollar dues, per our Boca Royale guide. Coco Bay shows a Lennar-stated HOA figure and a separate Lennar-stated "special assessment" without a named district or a stated period, per our Coco Bay guide. For Stillwater, association legal names and dues were not found for either section: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

How Do Flood, Evacuation and Build Age Compare?

Stillwater's flood column is the thinnest: one earlier reading by our team, Zone X on Lake Victoria Court, on November 14, 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer). Boca Royale's guide counts 10.8 percent of 1,245 address points in Zone AE, Beachwalk's about 20 percent, and Manasota Key's checked points all fell in VE or AE, per our guides. Coco Bay read Zone X at 11 of 12 points, per our Coco Bay guide. The methods differ in size, so use them to decide which lots to check first, not to rank communities.

Sarasota County and Charlotte County draw separate evacuation maps, so Coco Bay's Charlotte County Zone B and Boca Royale's or Beachwalk's Sarasota County Level C are separate county judgments, per our guides. Manasota Key is in Zone A, per our Manasota Key guide. Stillwater's level is not verified (checked November 17, 2026).

Build age separates them clearly. Older Stillwater homes date from 2000 to 2016 and Shores at Stillwater homes from 2025 and 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026); Coco Bay's are 2023 to 2025, Beachwalk's 2021 to 2026, Boca Royale's 1999 to 2025 and the Sarasota side of Manasota Key's a 1983 median, per our guides.

  • If your budget is the first filter, Stillwater Unit 3's 12-month median of $282,500 sits below every community-wide median in the decision table, including Coco Bay's $315,000 on a different county file (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; our Coco Bay guide).
  • If you want new construction, Shores at Stillwater (Pulte), Beachwalk (DiVosta), Coco Bay (Lennar) and Boca Royale (Neal) all have builders selling, per this page and our guides, at different price levels and with different district and dues structures.
  • If you want no community development district, the older Stillwater sections, Beachwalk and original Boca Royale have none in the sources we and our guides read; Shores at Stillwater has one.
  • If flood exposure is your main worry, check the lot first. Stillwater has one Zone X reading, Manasota Key's checked points are all in the Special Flood Hazard Area, and the mainland Sarasota County communities vary lot by lot.

Comparing Stillwater With Other Englewood Communities? Talk to McGreevy and Comisar

Weighing a Unit 3 home in Stillwater, Englewood against a Lennar villa at Coco Bay, or a new Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater against a DiVosta home at Beachwalk? We will pull the parcel records, sale history, flood reading, district lines and permit history for the specific homes you are considering. Call (239) 898-6072.

The credentials behind every Stillwater comparison we prepare:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Buying in Stillwater? Start With Our Buyer Team

Buying in Stillwater, Englewood starts with which of two markets you are in: an older Stillwater home in Unit 1, 2 or 3, built from 2000 to 2016 with no community development district, or a new Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater with district debt, a builder contract and a builder warranty. McGreevy and Comisar checks each before you sign.

How We Represent a Stillwater Buyer

We price every Stillwater purchase from recorded sales in the same plat and home type, not from a ZIP code average. On the county record, the 12 months from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 held 35 qualified improved sales at a $485,000 median, with the middle half from $305,000 to $570,000 and a median of $241 per heated square foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026). Plat medians ran from $282,500 in Unit 3 to $585,000 in Unit 2 (same file), which is why a single Stillwater number misleads.

On a builder purchase, the person at the Pulte sales center works for Pulte. We work for you. Whether Pulte requires a buyer's agent to be named or present on the first visit to Shores at Stillwater was not stated in any source we read: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Ask before your first visit, or call us first and we will register with the sales team.

Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active listings, months of supply and rents: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). We pair each listing with the parcel's recorded sale history, the flood reading for the lot, the district and association lines and the permit file. Our guide to buying a home in Englewood covers flood checks and special districts across the wider Englewood area, and our new construction guide for Englewood covers builder contracts, timelines and inspections.

What We Check Before You Sign

  • Agent representation on a Pulte contract. Who is named on the purchase agreement, and whether any builder rule affects our role.
  • Contract and deposit terms. The deposit schedule, price-change language, closing-date windows, financing contingencies and incentives. Pulte's public Shores at Stillwater pages do not publish a deposit amount or a standard contract, so the purchase agreement you are handed governs: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).
  • Pulte Mortgage terms. Pulte states, "You are not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage to purchase a home from seller; but use of Pulte Mortgage is necessary to receive BFC-related rate offers," and its payment examples say estimated payments "do not include monthly homeowners' association dues" (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). We compare the incentive against an outside lender's quote.
  • Inspections before drywall and at completion. An independent inspector of your choosing before drywall and again before closing. Pulte's Build Quality Experience includes a "Pre-Drywall Orientation" (Pulte, Build Quality Experience, read November 17, 2026); that is the builder's meeting, not an independent inspection. For an older Stillwater home, a full inspection plus a wind mitigation inspection and a roof review.
  • CDD debt: pay it off or carry it. At Shores at Stillwater, the Series 2026 debt is $18,580.37 per 34-foot lot and $25,726.66 per 52-foot lot, with maximum annual debt assessments of $1,382.68 and $1,914.48, payable for up to 30 annual installments to May 2056 unless prepaid (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). If every installment were the maximum, 30 payments would total $41,480.40 on a 34-foot lot and $57,434.40 on a 52-foot lot (our arithmetic; actual payments depend on the board's annual levy and the early-payment discount). The district's amended FY2025/2026 budget records "Bond Prepayments" of $25,727 (CDD Amended Final Budget 2025-2026, read November 17, 2026). We ask the district manager, Special District Services, (561) 630-4922, for the payoff figure in writing. Older Stillwater homes carry no district line.
  • The required CDD disclosure. Florida Statutes 190.048 requires the initial sale contract for a unit in a CDD to carry, just above the buyer's signature, the bold notice that the district "MAY IMPOSE AND LEVY TAXES OR ASSESSMENTS, OR BOTH TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS, ON THIS PROPERTY" (Florida Statutes 190.048, read November 17, 2026).
  • The survey and the elevation certificate. Lot lines, easements and the flood reading at the house, not the street. We have one earlier Zone X reading on Lake Victoria Court and none for the other streets (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, reading by our team November 14, 2026).
  • HOA documents. The association's legal name, the declaration, the budget, the dues, the leasing rules and any special assessment. None of these was found for either section in the sources we read. Under Florida Statutes 720.306, an association may still limit rentals of less than six months and "prohibit the rental of a parcel for more than three times in a calendar year" (Florida Statutes 720.306, read November 17, 2026).
  • Warranty and arbitration terms. Pulte's national warranty book covers materials and workmanship for one year, heating, air conditioning, electrical and plumbing systems for two years, "Certain kinds of water infiltration and internal leaks" for five years and structural elements for ten years; it disclaims implied warranties "To the fullest extent permitted by law" and provides for arbitration "binding on the Homeowner and the Builder" (Pulte National Warranty Book, August 2024, read November 17, 2026). Under Florida Statutes 558.004, a homeowner serves written notice of a construction defect claim "at least 60 days before filing any action" (Florida Statutes 558.004, read November 17, 2026), and Florida Statutes 95.11(3)(b) says such an action "must be commenced within 7 years" after the certificate of occupancy (Florida Statutes 95.11, read November 17, 2026).
  • Utilities. The district engineer says the Shores at Stillwater water and sewer lines will be owned and maintained by the Englewood Water District (CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). Englewood Water District serves this part of Englewood; confirm with the district for a given address at (941) 474-3217 (Englewood Water District, read November 17, 2026).

Buying a New Pulte Home at Shores at Stillwater

Pulte lists seven plans at Shores at Stillwater, from the 1,321 square foot Colton villa at $309,990 to the 2,870-plus square foot two-story Mystique Grande at $565,990, as "Starting From" prices on November 17, 2026 (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). Those are the builder's published prices that day, not market values, and they change.

Plan (builder-stated)

Type

Sq ft

Stories

Starting from

Colton

Villa (attached)

1,321

1

$309,990

Ellenwood

Villa (attached)

1,579

1

$331,990

Prosperity

Single-family

1,670+

1

$399,990

Mystique

Single-family

1,889+

1

$419,990

Palmary

Single-family

1,943+

1

$424,990

Prestige

Single-family

2,080+

1

$452,990

Mystique Grande

Single-family

2,870+

2

$565,990

Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater community page, builder-stated "Starting From" prices read November 17, 2026)

On the same day Pulte advertised two quick move-in homes as "Available Now": a Prosperity at $444,990, "Was $518,780," and an Ellenwood villa at $364,990, "Was $405,880" (builder-stated, Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's November offer gave a choice, on select homes accepted November 2 to November 30, 2026: a standard pool "valued at $69,500" on select to-be-built homes, or a builder credit of "$77,000 to be used toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins"; the credit "cannot be combined with other offers or incentives" (same page, builder-stated). Read the offer in force on the day you sign, and get it in the contract.

The county record shows what Shores at Stillwater homes actually closed at. The first qualified sale on the file is dated February 27, 2026, and the 16 sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, all first sales of homes built in 2025 or 2026, had a $523,250 median, from $375,000 to $766,700, at $267 per heated square foot; Phase 1A's 12 sales had a $564,750 median at $290 per square foot and Phase 1B's 4 sales a $390,300 median at $248 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Recorded prices include each buyer's options and lot premiums.

Buying an Older Stillwater Home

The older Stillwater sections, Units 1 to 3, hold 251 homes on the roll, built from 2000 to 2016 with a 2008 median and a 1,538 square foot median heated area (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). The roll counts 83 two-bedroom, 159 three-bedroom and 9 four-bedroom homes among them, and 231 with two baths (same file).

In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, older Stillwater recorded 19 qualified sales at a $315,000 median, from $250,000 to $620,000, at $203 per heated square foot (same file). Over longer windows, 24 months held 39 older Stillwater sales at a $362,500 median and 60 months held 70 at $402,750; the medians move with the mix of Unit 3 and Unit 1 homes that sold, so they are not a price trend.

For 15 of the 19 resales, the county file also holds the same home's earlier qualified sale. Measured against that earlier sale, the resales sold a median 12.2 percent higher, ranging from 10.3 percent lower to 77.4 percent higher, with a median of 8 years between the two sales (same file). Fifteen is a small sample: read it as direction only.

An older Stillwater home has no community development district line on its tax bill. What it brings instead is age: its roof, windows, systems and permit history are what the inspection and insurance quotes turn on.

Unit 3 and Units 1 and 2: Two Different Older Markets

The older Stillwater, Englewood plats are two products. The county roll gives Units 1 and 2 homes the single-family detached use code 0100 and gives all 140 Unit 3 homes, and the finished Shores villas, a separate single-family use code (0101) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). The Unit 3 homes are smaller homes: a 1,349 square foot median heated area, from 1,338 to 1,730, built 2007 to 2013. Unit 1 homes have a 2,204 square foot median, from 1,961 to 3,548, and Unit 2 homes 2,181, from 1,976 to 2,525 (same file).

Older Stillwater plat

Homes on the roll

Median heated sq ft

Built

12-month sales

12-month median

Median per sq ft

Stillwater Unit 1

76

2,204

2000 to 2016 (median 2004)

7

$550,000

$214

Stillwater Unit 2

35

2,181

2005 to 2006

2

$585,000

$257

Stillwater Unit 3

140

1,349

2007 to 2013 (median 2011)

10

$282,500

$198

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

What the roll does not say is how the Unit 3 homes are built, whether attached or detached: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). The plat and the recorded declaration settle that for a given home, and it matters for insurance, maintenance and what the association covers. By use code across the whole set, the 21 sales on 0100 parcels had a $550,000 median and the 14 sales on 0101 parcels a $301,000 median, the latter including Shores villa first sales (same file).

Start Here

The credentials behind every Stillwater purchase we handle:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Thinking of Selling Your Stillwater Home? List With the #1 Team in Southwest Florida Since 2012

Selling in Stillwater, Englewood means pricing against 35 qualified home sales at a $485,000 median in the Sarasota County Property Appraiser's 12 months to October 14, 2026, of which 19 were older Stillwater resales at $315,000 and 16 were first sales of new Pulte homes, so McGreevy and Comisar prices every listing plat by plat, then markets, negotiates and closes.

If you are thinking, "I need someone to sell my house in Stillwater," or you are searching for the best listing agent for a home in Stillwater Unit 1 or Unit 2, a smaller home in Stillwater Unit 3 or a resale at Shores at Stillwater, McGreevy and Comisar helps homeowners price, market, negotiate and sell with a local strategy built for Stillwater's five plats, its new-construction competition next door and its flood and storm profile. We lead Domain Realty Group, and the credentials you hire when you list with us are the same ones on every page we publish (about McGreevy and Comisar):

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

RealTrends 2026 ranked the team the #5 real estate team in Florida, with 241 transactions and $157M+ in volume, and the #1 real estate team in Bonita Springs by sales volume and by transaction sides. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar bring over 45 years of combined direct experience between them, and the Domain Realty Group team has closed 4,000+ transactions.

Selling an Older Stillwater Home While Pulte Sells New Next Door

A Stillwater buyer's agent and an appraiser will look at the same county record we do. These figures are qualified improved sales over $1,000 from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, for the five Stillwater and Shores at Stillwater plats only (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The newest qualified sale in our set is dated October 13, 2026.

Stillwater, 12 months

Recorded sales

Median price

Range

Median per heated sq ft

All qualified improved sales

35

$485,000

$250,000 to $766,700 (middle half $305,000 to $570,000)

$241

Older Stillwater, Units 1 to 3

19

$315,000

$250,000 to $620,000

$203

Shores at Stillwater, all first sales of new homes

16

$523,250

$375,000 to $766,700

$267

Stillwater Unit 1

7

$550,000

$450,000 to $590,000

$214

Stillwater Unit 2

2

$585,000

$550,000 and $620,000

$257

Stillwater Unit 3

10

$282,500

$250,000 to $315,000

$198

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A

12

$564,750

$455,000 to $766,700

$290

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B

4

$390,300

$375,000 to $407,600

$248

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active listings, months of supply and rents: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

What the table tells a seller of an older Stillwater home:

  • The new homes next door sell at a higher price per square foot. Older Stillwater's $203 per heated square foot sits $64 below Shores at Stillwater's $267 (our arithmetic from the table). Plat to plat, Unit 1's $214 sits $76 below Phase 1A's $290, and Unit 3's $198 sits $50 below Phase 1B's $248. Buyers pay that gap for a new home, a builder warranty and current-code construction; your listing has to show what your home offers instead, such as size, lot, condition and the absence of district debt.
  • The CDD difference is a selling point. An older Stillwater home carries no community development district line. A Phase One home at Shores at Stillwater carries a maximum annual debt assessment of $1,382.68 on a 34-foot lot or $1,914.48 on a 52-foot lot, plus a $276 O&M rate, about $1,658.68 or $2,190.48 a year before any board change (our arithmetic from the district's figures), unless the debt was prepaid (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; CDD Final Budget 2026-2027, read November 17, 2026). We put that comparison in front of every buyer who is also touring Pulte.
  • Pulte prices and incentives move. On November 17, 2026 Pulte advertised a Prosperity quick move-in at $444,990, "Was $518,780," and offered up to $77,000 in builder credit on select homes (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). A buyer comparing your home with a Pulte home sees those numbers, so we price your home against them, not just against the last resale.

Vacant lot sales in the set, 3 in 2026, were land and builder transfers, not public lot sales, so they are not a guide to lot value.

What Is Your Stillwater Home Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds.

Start with our free Stillwater home valuation. It takes about a minute, and Jesse or Marc follows up with a value built from recorded Stillwater sales in your own plat and home type, your heated area, your flood reading and elevation record, your association dues and, at Shores at Stillwater, your remaining CDD debt and Pulte warranty, not an automated estimate.

Prefer to talk it through? Call or text Jesse McGreevy direct: (239) 898-6072, text or call. We respond same-day.

For the full listing process, pricing method and marketing plan, read our guide to selling a home in Stillwater or to selling your home in Englewood.

What a Recent Seller Said

★★★★★ "Their recommendation on pricing my unit was sound and proved prescient. I never questioned their integrity and found it easy to rely on their recommendations. I would work with them again in a heartbeat." Charlie Carroll, Verified Google review of McGreevy and Comisar

McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Southwest Florida realtor team, and that is the standard we bring to every Stillwater sale. The full Seller Edition FAQ sits further down this page. These are the five questions Stillwater sellers ask us first.

How Do I Price My Stillwater Home Against Recorded Sales?

Start with your plat, then narrow by size and age. Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2 and Unit 3 trade as different markets, and in the 12 months to October 14, 2026 their medians were $550,000, $585,000 and $282,500, at $214, $257 and $198 per heated square foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Median heated area on the roll is 2,204 square feet in Unit 1, 2,181 in Unit 2 and 1,349 in Unit 3 (same file).

Twelve months is thin for Units 1 and 2, so we widen the window. Over 24 months (October 15, 2024 to October 14, 2026), Unit 1 recorded 12 sales at a $562,500 median, Unit 2 6 at $546,000 and Unit 3 21 at $305,000; over 60 months (from October 15, 2021), Unit 1 recorded 21 at $590,000, Unit 2 10 at $593,500 and Unit 3 39 at $350,000 (same file). Those medians swing with which homes sold, so we use them to bracket a price, not to claim a trend.

In $50,000 bands, the 12 months held 6 sales from $250,000 to $299,999, 4 from $300,000 to $349,999, 2 each in the $350,000 and $400,000 bands, 4 from $450,000 to $499,999, 5 from $500,000 to $549,999, 6 from $550,000 to $599,999, 2 from $600,000 to $649,999, 1 from $650,000 to $699,999, 2 from $700,000 to $749,999 and 1 from $750,000 to $799,999 (same file). The bands show two clusters: 10 sales from $250,000 to $349,999, where Unit 3 homes trade, and 11 from $500,000 to $599,999, where Unit 1 homes and many Shores homes trade (our sums of the bands).

How Much Does It Cost to Sell a Stillwater Home?

Selling costs come from the commission, which is negotiable and set in your listing agreement; Florida documentary stamp tax on the deed; title charges and prorations under your contract; and any repairs or credits you agree to after inspection. Your title agent's settlement statement gives the final figure.

Florida's deed tax is set in Florida Statutes 201.02: "on each $100 of the consideration therefor the tax shall be 70 cents" (Florida Statutes 201.02, read November 17, 2026). At the Stillwater 12-month median of $485,000 that is $3,395.00; at the Unit 3 median of $282,500, $1,977.50; at the Unit 1 median of $550,000, $3,850.00 (our arithmetic). Who pays the deed tax and the owner's title policy on a Stillwater resale is a contract term, so we do not state a custom. There is no set or standard commission rate, and we do not publish one; we walk every seller through a net sheet before listing.

How Do Flood Zone, Insurance and Storm History Affect My Stillwater Sale?

They are the first questions your buyer's lender and insurer will ask. We have one earlier reading in Stillwater, Englewood, Zone X on Lake Victoria Court in Unit 1 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, reading by our team November 14, 2026), so pull your own lot's reading from the FEMA Map Service Center before you list and put the printout in the listing file (FEMA Flood Map Service Center).

The 2027 insurance change is the part to plan for: from January 1, 2027, Citizens policies with wind coverage need flood coverage "regardless of value," and from January 1, 2026 the rule already reached homes with a dwelling value of $400,000 or more outside the Special Flood Hazard Area (Citizens Property Insurance, Flood, read November 17, 2026). Put your flood declarations, a current wind mitigation report on the Rev. 04/26 form and your roof permit in the listing file, so a buyer can get a quote in a day.

On storm history, be specific. Your home was built between 2000 and 2016, so it stood for Ian, Helene and Milton; say what repairs, if any, were made and where the permits are. No public report we found names Stillwater in those storms (checked November 17, 2026).

What Should I Tell Buyers About the HOA, the CDD and the Warranty?

Tell them early and in writing, because each one changes what a buyer will pay.

  • Association dues. Give buyers the current dues in writing, the billing period, what the dues cover and the association's legal name; none of these was published in a source we read for the older Stillwater sections, so we confirm them from your closing documents and the association's estoppel.
  • No CDD on an older home. State plainly that your Unit 1, 2 or 3 home is outside the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District; the district's legal description runs along the east line of Stillwater Unit Two (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026).
  • If you are reselling a Shores at Stillwater home. Give the buyer the district's payoff figure or the remaining annual debt line, and the HOA estoppel. Pulte says its "Warranties are transferable to subsequent owner who takes title within the applicable warranty period" (Pulte, Warranty, read November 17, 2026), so state how much of each term remains.

When Is the Best Time to List a Stillwater Home?

List when your plat's recent sales support your price and your file is ready. The county record shows sales in all but one month of the window: 2 in November 2025, none in December, 2 in January 2026, 6 in February, 3 in March, 7 in April, 4 in May, 4 in June, 2 in July, 3 in August, 1 in September and 1 from October 1 to 14 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). The newest qualified sale in our set is dated October 13, 2026, so the last weeks of the window may be thin. We do not read a seasonal pattern from one window of 35 sales.

Two dates matter for a Stillwater, Englewood seller. The Citizens flood requirement reaches Citizens personal residential policies with wind coverage, regardless of dwelling value, on January 1, 2027 (Citizens Property Insurance, Flood, read November 17, 2026), so a listing that already shows a flood quote answers the question before the buyer asks. And Pulte is still selling at Shores at Stillwater, with 107 vacant Shores lots on the October 21, 2026 roll, which gives buyers a new-home alternative next to your listing for some time to come. Days on market for Stillwater: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

Ready to talk numbers? Request your free Stillwater valuation or call Jesse at (239) 898-6072, text or call. We respond same-day.

What We Could Not Verify, and Exactly Where You Get It

Stillwater in Englewood has public records that answer most questions, but some facts sit in recorded documents, map tools or association files we could not open. This section lists what we could not verify for Stillwater and Shores at Stillwater as of November 17, 2026, and the office, site or document that settles each item. Nothing below is guessed.

Market Measures We Do Not Print for Stillwater

Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active listings, months of supply and rents: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Those measures come from the multiple listing service, and this page prints sales only from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, with the newest qualified sale in the Stillwater, Englewood set recorded October 13, 2026. Asking prices on listing portals carry different dates and definitions, so none are printed as market evidence. Pulte's prices appear only where labelled builder-stated, as Pulte's own figures on November 17, 2026.

The county file also shows 3 vacant-lot deeds at Shores at Stillwater in 2026, all coded unqualified. Those were land and builder transfers, not lots a member of the public could buy, so we print no per-lot price. The county file does not name the seller on a deed, which is why this page calls the 16 Shores at Stillwater closings "first sales of new homes" rather than naming who sold them.

Item

What we found

Where you get it

Days on market, sale-to-list, active listings, months of supply, rents

Not printed; MLS-only measures

A licensed agent's MLS report for your exact plat and home type

Lot prices at Shores at Stillwater

3 vacant-lot deeds in 2026, all coded unqualified; land and builder transfers

Not a public lot market; ask Pulte about homesite premiums

Who sold each new Shores home

Not on the county sales file

The recorded deed at the Sarasota County Clerk of the Circuit Court

Associations, Dues, Gates and the Original Builder

We found no primary source for the legal name of any homeowners association in Stillwater, Englewood (Units 1 to 3) or at Shores at Stillwater, and no dues amount, dues period, management company, lease minimum, pet rule or architectural rule for either. The Shores at Stillwater CDD minutes of June 15, 2026 say lake, preserve and pipe maintenance items "are currently included in the HOA budget," which confirms an association exists at Shores (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's own disclaimers say "Community Association fees required" and that payment estimates "do not include monthly homeowners' association dues," with no dollar figure (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

The original builder or developer of Stillwater Units 1 to 3 (homes built 2000 to 2016 on the county roll) was not found in any plat, news story or builder filing we could read, so we name none. The county roll gives Unit 3 and the finished Shores villas a separate single-family use code (0101); whether the Unit 3 homes are attached was not confirmed from a plat or declaration, so we describe them only as smaller homes (median 1,349 sq ft heated). Whether the older Stillwater sections are gated, and whether owners there share any amenity with Shores at Stillwater, was also not confirmed.

Item

What we found

Where you get it

HOA legal names (older Stillwater and Shores)

Not confirmed; Sunbiz was not reachable by our tools

Sunbiz.org entity search in a browser; the recorded declaration at the Sarasota County Clerk

Dues, what dues cover, management company

Not found

An estoppel certificate on a resale; the Pulte sales team (941) 389-1010 for Shores

Lease minimums, pets, architectural rules

Not found

The recorded declaration and rules; the association's manager

Gate at the older Stillwater sections

Not confirmed

The HOA documents or a site visit

Original Stillwater builder or developer

Not found

The plat dedication page for each Stillwater plat at the Clerk; the declarant named in the declaration

Unit 3 home type

Use code 0101 on the roll; type not confirmed

The Stillwater Unit 3 plat and declaration

Plats, Zoning and Approvals in Stillwater, Englewood

The Shores at Stillwater CDD's legal description cites "STILLWATER, UNIT TWO, according to the Plat thereof, recorded in Plat Book 45, Pages 12 through 12C" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026), and the Phase One assessment area cites Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A in Plat Book 59, Pages 140 to 147, and Phase 1B in Plat Book 59, Pages 122 to 127 (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The plat book and page for Stillwater Unit 1 and Unit 3, and the recording dates of all five plats, were not found.

The district engineer's report states the Shores at Stillwater North Parcel is zoned RSF-1/PUD (45.79 acres) and the South Parcel RSF-4/PUD (34.04 acres), with a PUD maximum of 269 units and approved site plans for 255 (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The text copy of Sarasota County Ordinance 2025-032 that the district posts says the land was "previously designated as Special Planning Area 2" and "rezoned to a Planned Unit Development form with unified control per Ordinance No. 2023-060" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, Ordinance 2025-032, text copy, read November 17, 2026). The zoning district of the older Stillwater Units 1 to 3, the adoption date and stipulations of Ordinance 2023-060, and the day and month of the 2026 adoption stamp on Ordinance 2025-032 (illegible in the text copy) were not read.

Item

What we found

Where you get it

Unit 1 and Unit 3 plat book and page

Not found

Sarasota County Clerk official records and plat index

Recording dates of all five plats

Not found

Same Clerk records

Zoning of Stillwater Units 1 to 3

Not confirmed

Sarasota County Planning and Development Services, 941-861-5000, or the county zoning map by address

Shores rezoning ordinance

Ordinance No. 2023-060, as cited in Ordinance 2025-032; its date and stipulations not read

Sarasota County Board of County Commissioners agenda and minutes; the Clerk's ordinance index

Ordinance 2025-032 adoption date

Day and month of the 2026 stamp illegible; the Florida Department of State filing letter is dated February 11, 2026

The Clerk's ordinance records or the Florida Department of State

SWFWMD environmental resource permit, Army Corps permit, FWC gopher tortoise permit

None found

SWFWMD ePermitting by project name; Corps Jacksonville District notices; the FWC permit locator

Shores land deed and price

Sarasota Magazine reported two parcels bought from "J & L LLC" "for $12 million each" in August 2024; the deed was not read

The recorded deeds to Pulte Home Company, LLC at the Clerk

The Shores at Stillwater CDD Figures Still Moving

The acreage of the district conflicts across its own records. The two parcels in the legal description total about 79.83 acres (45.789 plus 34.041), and the methodology and bond documents use that figure, but the district's October 2026 audit request for proposals says the district "encompasses 223.29 acres in Sarasota County" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, October 19, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). We use 79.83 acres until the district explains the larger number.

The per-lot debt a later buyer at Shores at Stillwater will carry after any future bond series is not known. The Series 2026 bonds ($2,970,000) cover Phase One's 136 lots; the court validated up to $14,000,000, and the June 2026 methodology says unfunded work may be paid by Pulte "or in the District's sole discretion a future series of bonds" (June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The October 2026 supplemental methodology "updated to reflect the bond pricing" was presented, but its tables were not in the text we read, so the per-lot figures on this page come from the May 28, 2026 report.

Item

What we found

Where you get it

District acreage

79.83 acres (legal description) vs 223.29 acres (October 2026 audit request)

Special District Services, (561) 630-4922

Debt per lot after a later bond series

Not set; Phase One only so far

A future supplemental methodology; the recorded notice of assessments

Final Phase One per-lot table after pricing

May 28, 2026 table used ($1,382.68 and $1,914.48 a year); the Disclosure of Public Financing prints $1,382.98 and $1,914.89

The district manager; the recorded Supplemental Notice of Assessments

Ordinance effective date

Documents say February 10 or February 11, 2026; the state filing letter is dated February 11, 2026

The Clerk's ordinance records

Current board chair

Minutes list different chairs in May and October 2026

The district office

Continuing disclosure filings for the Series 2026 bonds

Not searched

EMMA (emma.msrb.org), issuer search for the district's name

Flood, Evacuation, Surge and Wind at Stillwater

A lot-by-lot FEMA flood zone check of Stillwater, Englewood and Shores at Stillwater addresses was not done for this page, because the FEMA map tools do not permit automated lookups. The one reading we hold is an earlier check by our team on November 14, 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer) that returned Zone X at one Lake Victoria Ct address in Stillwater Unit 1. ABC7 reported that FEMA's current Sarasota County flood maps took effect March 27, 2024 (ABC7, read November 17, 2026).

Evacuation level for Stillwater addresses: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Sarasota County uses levels A to E, with A evacuated first, and its map lets you enter an address (WUSF, read November 17, 2026). The National Hurricane Center's category-by-category surge bands and the Florida Building Code design wind speed at a Stillwater address were also not read.

Item

What we found

Where you get it

Flood zone and panel for each lot

One earlier Zone X reading (November 14, 2026)

FEMA Flood Map Service Center, address by address; the lot's elevation certificate

Letters of map revision at Shores at Stillwater

Not checked

FEMA Map Service Center; Pulte's surveyor

Evacuation level

Not verified

Sarasota County's evacuation map by address; the state's Know Your Zone page

Storm surge bands, Category 1 to 5

Not read

The NHC Storm Surge Risk Map viewer

Design wind speed

Not read

The ASCE Hazard Tool by address, or Sarasota County Building

Storm damage at Stillwater in Ian, Helene or Milton

No public report found

Not a finding that no home was damaged; ask the seller and the insurer

Utilities, Assessments and Services for Stillwater

The district engineer states the Shores at Stillwater water and sewer systems "will be owned and maintained by the Englewood Water District" (April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). For the older Stillwater sections, Englewood Water District serves this part of Englewood; confirm with the district for a given address. No 2026 tax bill for a Stillwater parcel was read, so the solid waste, stormwater and street lighting lines on a given bill are not printed.

Item

What we found

Where you get it

Water and sewer for Units 1 to 3

Inferred Englewood Water District

EWD Customer Service, (941) 474-3217

Solid waste and stormwater amounts per parcel

Codes listed by the Tax Collector; amounts not read

The parcel's TRIM notice or tax bill at the Sarasota County Tax Collector

Englewood street lighting district (L015)

Not confirmed for Stillwater

The parcel's tax bill

Trash hauler service area and pickup day

Not confirmed (North or South service area)

Sarasota County's collection map

Internet providers

No official statement found

The FCC National Broadband Map by address

Natural gas provider at Shores at Stillwater

Pulte says "Natural Gas Community"; provider not named

The Pulte sales team

Who paid each new home's EWD capacity charges

Not stated

Englewood Water District; the Pulte contract

Location and Other Details Near Stillwater

A free-flow routing estimate to I-75 Exit 191 (River Road) returned an unreliable figure, so we print only Exit 193. Pulte's line that "Sarasota Ainger Creek Trails and Preserve are right at the entrance" names a place we could not find in county records, and Pulte's "5 miles from Myakka State Park" distance was not checked, so neither is repeated as fact. Sarasota County park hours and parking fees for Manasota Beach, Blind Pass Beach, Lemon Bay Park and Indian Mound Park were not on the pages we could read.

Item

What we found

Where you get it

Drive to I-75 Exit 191

Routing error; not printed

A map app at the hour you drive

"Ainger Creek Trails and Preserve"

No Sarasota County preserve found by that name

Ask Pulte what it refers to

Sarasota County park hours and fees

Not printed

Sarasota County Parks, (941) 861-5000

Current traffic counts on SR 776, River Road, Pine St, Medical Blvd

Only 2013 counts read

FDOT Florida Traffic Online

Build time for a new Pulte home

Not stated by Pulte

The Pulte contract and construction schedule

Out-of-zone school requests

Not read

Sarasota County Schools

Facts We Saw Only in Summaries

Some figures about Stillwater, Englewood surfaced only in search summaries or brokerage excerpts, including HOA dues amounts, a gate description for the older sections, a builder name for the villa section, a short-term rental rule text for Sarasota County, a land price of "$12.2 million," an 81-acre figure, and a "136 twin villas and 98 single-family homes" count. We did not open those pages and we print none of those figures as fact. Where a primary document disagreed, we used the primary document and named its date.

Your Local Real Estate Experts

Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, founding partners of McGreevy and Comisar, lead a top-producing real estate team serving Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples, Fort Myers, and Charlotte County, Florida. They lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and they sell and buy homes in Englewood on both county sides.

McGreevy and Comisar is the flagship brand of Domain Realty Group. Together Jesse and Marc bring over 45 years of combined direct experience between Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, and over $900 million in personal sales. The team they lead, Domain Realty Group, is a ~40-agent real estate team founded in 2008, serving Lee, Collier, and Charlotte County, Florida, and it has sold $2.5B+ and closed 4,000+ transactions as a team. The brokerage, Domain Realty (DomainRealty.com, LLC), is a Southwest Florida real estate brokerage headquartered in Bonita Springs, FL, co-founded by Jesse McGreevy in 2015.

Jesse McGreevy co-founded both McGreevy and Comisar and the Domain Realty brokerage. He has personally won the Gulfshore Life Five Star award every year since 2006, part of the team's 21 consecutive years of that honor. Selling an Englewood home? Call Jesse first. Read more on Jesse's agent page.

Marc Comisar is a Broker Associate and a founding partner of McGreevy and Comisar. Buying in Englewood? Call Marc first. Read more on Marc's agent page.

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

RealTrends 2026: #5 real estate team in Florida, with 241 transactions and $157M+ volume, and #1 real estate team in Bonita Springs by sales volume and by transaction sides.

Contact McGreevy and Comisar

  • Jesse McGreevy (selling): (239) 898-6072, text or call. We respond same-day. Start with a free home valuation.
  • Marc Comisar (buying): (239) 287-5873. Read our buying guide.
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134. Offices in Naples, Bonita Springs, Estero and Fort Myers.
  • Message us: contact McGreevy and Comisar.

Licensed in Florida: Jesse Eli McGreevy P.A., license SL3101296, and Marc J Comisar P.A., Broker Associate, license BK3060671. Brokerage: Domain Realty (DOMAINREALTY.COM, LLC), license CQ1049052, 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134.

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more at DomainRealtyGroup.com.

Looking for the best agents in the markets next door? See our guides to the best real estate agents in Port Charlotte and the best real estate agents in Punta Gorda.

Frequently Asked Questions, Stillwater Buyer Edition

Stillwater buyers ask most about the county, how the older Stillwater plats differ from Shores at Stillwater, Pulte's plans and terms, the CDD, flood and insurance rules, schools and taxes. Each answer below for Stillwater, Englewood draws on the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file, a government page, a Florida statute, the CDD's own records or Pulte's pages, with its date or window.

Where is Stillwater in Englewood, FL?

Stillwater, Englewood sits off Medical Boulevard in unincorporated Sarasota County, with Englewood 34223 addresses on all 394 parcels in the five plats (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). The Census Bureau's 2024 block group map places every older Stillwater street in Census Tract 27.33, Block Group 2, inside the Englewood census-designated place (Census TIGER/Line 2024, computed November 17, 2026). Our routing estimate from the community to HCA Florida Englewood Hospital at 700 Medical Blvd is 0.6 road miles, about 2 minutes (OSRM public routing service, free-flow estimate computed November 17, 2026).

Is Stillwater in Sarasota County or Charlotte County?

Sarasota County. The Shores at Stillwater CDD's bond records describe its land as "located entirely within the unincorporated area of Sarasota County" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026), and all five plats are on the Sarasota County roll. The Englewood census-designated place spans both counties, which is why the question comes up; read more in our Englewood guide.

Is Shores at Stillwater the same community as Stillwater?

No. The older Stillwater sections are three recorded plats, Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2 and Unit 3, with 251 homes built 2000 to 2016, while Shores at Stillwater is the gated Pulte Homes section beside them, with Phases 1A and 1B platted so far and 27 homes on the roll built 2025 and 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). They carry different costs: only Shores at Stillwater is inside a community development district.

What plats make up Stillwater, Englewood?

Five recorded plats: Stillwater Unit 1 (77 parcels, 76 homes), Unit 2 (36 parcels, 35 homes), Unit 3 (141 parcels, 140 homes), Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A (54 parcels, 19 homes on the roll) and Phase 1B (86 parcels, 8 homes on the roll) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). That is 394 parcels in all. The seven parcels of "Stillwater on the Bay" on Bay Harbor Lane in Sarasota 34231 are a different place and are not counted.

How many homes are in Stillwater?

The county roll dated October 21, 2026 shows 278 homes with heated area across the five plats: 251 in the older Stillwater sections and 27 at Shores at Stillwater (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Another 116 parcels had no heated area, including 107 vacant Shores lots coded 0000 plus tracts and common areas. The Shores count rises as Pulte finishes homes.

How many homes will Shores at Stillwater have?

The district engineer's report says the approved site plans include 255 units, 136 attached homes on 34-foot lots and 119 detached homes on 52-foot lots, built in four phases, with a PUD maximum of 269 units (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's page says "255 future front doors" (Pulte, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Earlier 2024 news counts were based on older plans.

Is Stillwater in Englewood the same as Stillwater on the Bay or Stillwater Cay?

No. Stillwater on the Bay is a seven-parcel set on Bay Harbor Lane with Sarasota 34231 addresses, and Stillwater Cay is in Estero in Lee County. Search results for "shores at stillwater" also return a Park City, Utah project and places in Minnesota and Oklahoma. This page covers only the five Englewood 34223 plats.

Why does Pulte list Shores at Stillwater under "Sarasota"?

Pulte files the community under its Sarasota market in its web address and breadcrumb (Florida, then Sarasota, then Englewood), which is a sales region label (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). The homes are in Englewood, in unincorporated Sarasota County, not in the City of Sarasota.

When were the older Stillwater homes built?

The roll shows the 251 older Stillwater homes built 2000 to 2016, with a median year of 2008 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). By plat, Unit 1 runs 2000 to 2016 (median 2004), Unit 2 was built 2005 to 2006 and Unit 3 was built 2007 to 2013 (median 2011). Because each home's permit date sets its code edition, ask for the permit history on any home you consider.

How big are the homes in Stillwater Unit 3?

Unit 3's 140 homes have a median of 1,349 heated square feet, with a range of 1,338 to 1,730 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). The county roll gives Unit 3 and the finished Shores villas a separate single-family use code (0101). Whether a Unit 3 home shares a wall is a question for the plat and declaration, which we could not read.

How big are the homes in Stillwater Units 1 and 2?

Unit 1's 76 homes have a median of 2,204 heated square feet (1,961 to 3,548), and Unit 2's 35 homes a median of 2,181 (1,976 to 2,525) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Both plats carry the roll's single-family detached use code, 0100.

How many bedrooms do older Stillwater homes have?

Across the 251 older Stillwater homes, the roll lists 83 with 2 bedrooms, 159 with 3 and 9 with 4; 231 have 2 baths, 6 have 2.5 baths and 14 have 3 baths (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Roll counts can lag remodels, so confirm in the home itself.

Who built the original Stillwater homes in Englewood?

We did not find the original builder or developer in a plat, news report or builder filing, so we name none. The dedication page of each recorded Stillwater plat, at the Sarasota County Clerk of the Circuit Court, names the owner who platted the land. Pulte built only Shores at Stillwater.

Who builds Shores at Stillwater?

Pulte Homes, a PulteGroup brand. Pulte Home Company, LLC petitioned Sarasota County to create the Shores at Stillwater CDD (Ordinance 2025-032, text copy, read November 17, 2026), and the Phase One assessment roll listed Pulte Home Company LLC as owner of 125 of the 136 Phase One lots when it was prepared (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The sales center is at 2048 Silver Shores Blvd, (941) 389-1010 (builder-stated). For other new-home choices, see our Englewood new construction guide.

What floor plans does Pulte offer at Shores at Stillwater?

Pulte lists seven plans, each with a two-car garage: Colton villa (1,321 sq ft, from $309,990), Ellenwood villa (1,579, from $331,990), Prosperity (1,670+, from $399,990), Mystique (1,889+, from $419,990), Palmary (1,943+, from $424,990), Prestige (2,080+, from $452,990) and Mystique Grande (2,870+, from $565,990) (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Prices are Pulte's base prices on that date and change without notice.

What is the price range for new Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater?

Pulte's published range was $309,990 to $565,990 on November 17, 2026, with sizes of 1,321 to 2,870+ sq ft; its Villa Collection started at $309,990 and its Distinctive Collection at $399,990 (Pulte, builder-stated). Those are builder figures, not market values. The county file shows 16 first sales of new Shores homes in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, at a median of $523,250 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Does Shores at Stillwater have villas?

Yes. Pulte's Colton and Ellenwood plans are attached villas, which Pulte calls twin villas, and the district's plan counts 136 attached homes on 34-foot lots (Pulte, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026; CDD June 15, 2026 meeting book). The other five plans are single-family detached homes on 52-foot lots.

Is any plan at Shores at Stillwater two stories?

One. Pulte lists the Mystique Grande as "2 Story," with a loft that adds a bedroom and bath, and lists the other six plans as one story (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

Do Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater include impact glass and tile roofs?

Pulte's page lists "Impact Glass & Tile Roof Included" and "Impact glass windows included with every home," and calls Shores at Stillwater a "Natural Gas Community" with natural gas appliances (Pulte, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Confirm the exact features of a given home in its purchase agreement.

What amenities does Shores at Stillwater have?

Pulte lists a heated community pool, a pool cabana with covered seating, BBQ grills and mail kiosks, and describes the community as gated (Pulte, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). The district engineer states that the roadways, irrigation, landscaping and amenity center "will be private and are not included in" the CDD's plan, so they sit with the association (CDD June 15, 2026 meeting book).

What incentives is Pulte offering at Shores at Stillwater?

For select homes accepted November 2 to November 30, 2026, Pulte's page offered either a standard pool "valued at $69,500" on select to-be-built homes, or a credit of $77,000 toward closing costs, rate buydown, design options or quick move-ins, and said the offer "cannot be combined with other offers or incentives" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Offers change often, so get the current terms in writing with their date.

Do I have to use Pulte Mortgage to buy at Shores at Stillwater?

No, but Pulte ties some rate offers to it. Pulte's page says: "You are not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage to purchase a home from seller; but use of Pulte Mortgage is necessary to receive BFC-related rate offers where and when available" (Pulte, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Compare a written loan estimate from your own lender with Pulte Mortgage's before you choose.

What is a Builder Forward Commitment rate?

Pulte describes it as a rate "offered through Pulte Mortgage LLC, seller's affiliated lender, to lock in an interest rate for a pool of funds," available only to qualified borrowers on certain homes "until the pool of funds is depleted or the rate lock period expires," and limited to new home agreements that close by a set date (Pulte, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's sample payments assumed a FICO score of 780.

Do Pulte's payment estimates include HOA dues?

No. Every calculator on Pulte's Shores at Stillwater pages says "Estimated payments do not include monthly homeowners' association dues" (Pulte, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). They also leave out the CDD debt and operations assessments, so add those from the district's records.

What does the Pulte warranty cover?

Pulte's national warranty book (August 2024 edition) covers materials and workmanship for one year, heating, air conditioning, electrical and plumbing systems for two years, certain water infiltration and internal leaks for five years, and structural elements for ten years from closing (Pulte National Warranty Book, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's warranty page says the warranties are "transferable to subsequent owner who takes title within the applicable warranty period" (Pulte, Warranty, read November 17, 2026).

Does the Pulte warranty waive implied warranties or require arbitration?

Yes, on its face. The warranty book says statutory and implied warranties "are hereby disclaimed by us and waived by you," and that its dispute procedures include arbitration "which will be binding on the Homeowner and the Builder" (Pulte National Warranty Book, read November 17, 2026). Have a Florida real estate attorney read the purchase agreement and warranty before you sign.

What can I do in Florida if a builder will not fix a defect?

Florida's construction defect law requires written notice of claim at least 60 days before filing suit (120 days for an association representing more than 20 parcels); the builder may inspect within 30 days and must respond in writing within 45 days (Fla. Stat. 558.004, read November 17, 2026). A notice "shall not toll any statute of repose period," so act early.

How long do I have to bring a construction claim on a new Stillwater home?

Under Florida law, a claim founded on construction of an improvement runs four years from the certificate of occupancy (or from discovery of a latent defect), and in any event must be brought within 7 years after the certificate of occupancy or completion (Fla. Stat. 95.11, read November 17, 2026). The warranty's own deadlines and arbitration clause also apply.

Can I have a home inspected before drywall at Shores at Stillwater?

Pulte describes a "Pre-Drywall Orientation," a guided walk-through of the mechanical systems before drywall goes up, as one of four construction meetings (Pulte, Build Quality Experience, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's pages do not say whether a buyer's own inspector may attend, so ask for it in writing before you sign, and plan a second inspection before closing.

Does Shores at Stillwater have a CDD?

Yes. The Shores at Stillwater Community Development District was created by Sarasota County Ordinance No. 2025-032 in February 2026, on the petition of Pulte Home Company, LLC (Ordinance 2025-032, text copy); the Florida Department of State acknowledged the ordinance's filing on February 11, 2026 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, Ordinance 2025-032, read November 17, 2026). The district is managed by Special District Services, Inc., (561) 630-4922.

How much CDD debt comes with a Shores at Stillwater lot?

For Phase One, the district's May 28, 2026 methodology assigns $18,580 of Series 2026 bond principal to each 34-foot lot and $25,727 to each 52-foot lot, with maximum annual debt assessments of about $1,382.68 and $1,914.48 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The $2,970,000 Series 2026 bonds carry rates of 4.10 to 5.8 percent and mature in May 2056 (CDD Amended Final Budget FY2025/2026).

What is the Shores at Stillwater CDD operations assessment?

The FY2026/2027 budget totals $129,125 and sets the operations and maintenance rate at $276 per unit across 255 units if the district were on the assessment roll; for now the O&M assessments are "To Be Collected At Closings," with Pulte funding spending above that rate (CDD Final Budget FY2026/2027, read November 17, 2026). On these figures, a Phase One home's first full-year CDD total is about $1,658.68 (34-foot) or $2,190.48 (52-foot), our arithmetic.

Are the older Stillwater homes in the CDD?

No. The district's legal description covers two parcels of about 79.83 acres east of Stillwater Unit Two and at the east end of Medical Blvd, and its Phase One roll lists only Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A and 1B lots (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book; June 15, 2026 meeting book, both read November 17, 2026). A home in Stillwater Units 1 to 3 pays no Shores at Stillwater CDD assessment.

Can I pay off the CDD bond at closing?

The district's methodology says the Phase One debt assessments may be prepaid, and its amended FY2025/2026 budget records $25,727 of bond prepayments, the same as one 52-foot lot's share (CDD Amended Final Budget FY2025/2026, read November 17, 2026). Ask Special District Services, (561) 630-4922, for a written payoff figure for your lot before closing.

Will the CDD appear on my Sarasota County tax bill?

The district's FAQ says the assessment "will appear on the property tax bill sent in November of each year" once it is on the roll (Shores at Stillwater CDD, FAQs, read November 17, 2026). The Tax Collector's 2026 list of levying authorities does not include the district (Sarasota County Tax Collector, read November 17, 2026), so for FY2026/2027 the O&M is collected at closing; future years may move to the bill.

Could CDD debt at Shores at Stillwater grow with later phases?

The circuit court validated up to $14,000,000 of bonds on April 13, 2026 (Case No. 2026-CA-001067 NC), and only $2,970,000 has been issued, for Phase One (Business Observer legal notice; CDD June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). Lots in later phases may carry a later bond series, and the debt on those lots is not set yet. Read the recorded notice of assessments for your exact lot.

What CDD disclosure must a Pulte contract carry?

Florida law requires each contract for the initial sale of a parcel in a CDD to state, in bold type before the buyer's signature, that the district may levy taxes or assessments "in addition to county and other local governmental taxes and assessments" (Fla. Stat. 190.048, read November 17, 2026). The Shores at Stillwater board approved a Master and a First Supplemental Disclosure of Public Financing in 2026.

What are the HOA fees in Stillwater, Englewood?

Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). We found no dues figure from an association or builder document for either the older Stillwater sections or Shores at Stillwater. Get the amount from an estoppel certificate on a resale, or from Pulte's association budget at the sales center for a new home.

Who governs Stillwater, Englewood?

Sarasota County. Stillwater has no city government; land use, zoning, permits and code enforcement are county functions, and Englewood falls in County Commission District 5, whose commissioner Ron Cutsinger was chosen 2026 chair (Your Observer, December 19, 2025, read November 17, 2026). Fire protection comes from the separate Englewood Area Fire Control District.

What is the zoning at Shores at Stillwater?

The district engineer states the North Parcel is zoned RSF-1/PUD (45.79 acres) and the South Parcel RSF-4/PUD (34.04 acres), and that the PUD approval allows a maximum of 269 units (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The zoning of the older Stillwater plats was not confirmed; check the county zoning map by address.

Can I rent out a home in Stillwater?

That depends on county zoning and on each association's recorded rules, which we could not read. Florida law bars new local limits on vacation rental duration but keeps local rules adopted on or before June 1, 2011 (Fla. Stat. 509.032, read November 17, 2026). Under Fla. Stat. 720.306, an association may still limit rentals of less than six months, so read the declaration before you buy.

Who provides water and sewer in Stillwater?

The Englewood Water District will own and maintain the Shores at Stillwater water and sewer lines, per the district engineer (CDD April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026); Englewood Water District serves this part of Englewood, so confirm with the district for a given older Stillwater address. From October 1, 2026, EWD's base charges are $29.37 a month for water and $42.75 for sewer, about $116.87 a month at 5,000 gallons (EWD FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations, our arithmetic).

Who provides electricity in Stillwater, Englewood?

Florida Power and Light. FPL's tariff, effective January 1, 2026, lists Englewood and the unincorporated part of Sarasota County among the communities it serves (FPL Electric Tariff, Section 7, read November 17, 2026).

What is the property tax rate in Stillwater?

The total millage for an unincorporated Sarasota County parcel such as Stillwater was 11.4737 in 2025 and 11.3068 in 2026 (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2025 millage; 2026 millage, both read November 17, 2026). On a $485,000 taxable value with no homestead, 2026 rates give $5,483.80 of ad valorem tax, our arithmetic. Homestead lowers it: $25,000 off all levies plus up to $25,000 more on assessed value over $50,000 against non-school levies (Fla. Stat. 196.031).

What fire assessment does a Stillwater home pay?

The Englewood Area Fire Control District's 2026 to 2027 assessment is $290.78 per residential parcel and $63.95 per vacant lot, and it is "not affected by the Homestead Exemption" (Englewood Area Fire Control District, read November 17, 2026). A Shores lot billed as vacant moves to the residential rate once the home is on the roll, an increase of $226.83, our arithmetic.

Why could a new Shores at Stillwater home's second tax bill be higher?

Florida values property as of January 1, and improvements "not substantially completed on January 1 shall have no value placed thereon" (Fla. Stat. 192.042, read November 17, 2026). A home finished after January 1 is taxed that year largely on the lot, and the next bill reflects the completed home. Budget for the full-value bill, not the first one.

When can I file for homestead in Stillwater?

You must own and occupy the home as your permanent residence on January 1, and March 1 is the last day for a timely application for that year (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Homestead, read November 17, 2026). Voters approved Amendment 3 on November 3, 2026, which WGCU reported raises the non-school homestead exemption from $50,000 to $150,000 in 2027 (WGCU, November 5, 2026, read November 17, 2026); confirm how it applies to your purchase year.

What flood zone is Stillwater in?

We hold one reading: an earlier check by our team on November 14, 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer) returned Zone X at one Lake Victoria Ct address in Stillwater Unit 1. That does not settle any other lot, so check each address on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center and ask for the elevation certificate. FEMA's current Sarasota County maps took effect March 27, 2024 (ABC7, read November 17, 2026).

Do Citizens policyholders in Stillwater need flood insurance?

Yes, from January 1, 2027 for Citizens personal residential policies with wind coverage, regardless of value or flood zone (Citizens exempts condominium unit-owner and tenant contents policies); from January 1, 2026 the rule already reached homes with a dwelling value of $400,000 or more (Citizens Property Insurance, Flood, read November 17, 2026). The flood policy must equal the Citizens dwelling value or the NFIP maximum the home qualifies for.

What flood insurance discount applies in Stillwater, Englewood?

Unincorporated Sarasota County is a Class 5 community in FEMA's Community Rating System, worth a 25 percent discount on NFIP policies, on the list effective October 1, 2026 (FEMA CRS Eligible Communities, read November 17, 2026). FEMA says the discount also applies to policies outside the Special Flood Hazard Area for compliant structures (FEMA, Community Rating System).

What evacuation level is Stillwater in?

Evacuation level for Stillwater addresses: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Sarasota County uses levels A to E, with A evacuated first, and its map lets you look up an address (WUSF, read November 17, 2026). For Hurricane Milton in 2024, Sarasota County ordered evacuation of zones A, B and C and of mobile and manufactured homes (NWS Tampa Bay).

Did Stillwater flood in Hurricane Ian or Milton?

We found no public report naming Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater, which is not proof that no home was affected. In Ian, the National Hurricane Center reported that most sensors in Englewood "remained dry" because of offshore winds (NHC, Hurricane Ian report); in Milton, surge of 6 to 9 feet above ground struck the coast from Venice to Boca Grande, with up to about 10 feet near Manasota Key (NHC, Hurricane Milton report, both read November 17, 2026). Ask any seller for the home's claim history.

What schools serve Stillwater addresses?

For the two addresses we checked on November 17, 2026, one on a Stillwater Unit 3 street and one on Silver Shores Blvd at Shores at Stillwater, the Sarasota County School Zone Lookup returned Englewood Elementary Zone, L.A. Ainger Middle Zone and Wellen Park High Zone. Confirm your exact address in the same tool. Wellen Park High opened in August 2026 as the district's first new public high school in 25 years (ABC7, August 10, 2026, read November 17, 2026).

How far is Stillwater from the beach?

Our routing estimate from an older Stillwater street to Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park, 2100 N Beach Road on Manasota Key, is 3.4 road miles and about 8 minutes in free-flowing traffic (OSRM public routing service, computed November 17, 2026). Pulte describes beaches "less than 3.5 miles away" (builder-stated). Season and the SR 776 work in 2026 and 2027 lengthen real drives.

How far is Stillwater from I-75 and the airports?

Our free-flow routing estimates from Stillwater, Englewood are 14.1 miles and about 26 minutes to I-75 Exit 193 (Jacaranda Blvd), 28.7 miles and 49 minutes to Punta Gorda Airport, 42.5 miles and 65 minutes to Sarasota Bradenton International Airport, and 65.8 miles and 86 minutes to Southwest Florida International Airport (OSRM public routing service, computed November 17, 2026). Traffic and season change these figures.

What is the median sale price in Stillwater, Englewood?

The 12-month median was $485,000 across 35 qualified home sales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, with a range of $250,000 to $766,700 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). That blends three products: Unit 3 resales at a $282,500 median, Unit 1 and Unit 2 resales at $550,000 and $585,000, and 16 first sales of new Shores homes at $523,250. Compare a home only with sales in its own plat and type.

How do new Shores prices compare with older Stillwater resales per square foot?

In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, the 16 first sales of new Shores at Stillwater homes had a median of $267 per heated square foot, and the 19 older Stillwater resales a median of $203 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Part of that gap reflects new construction and current code features, and Shores homes also carry CDD debt that older homes do not.

What closing taxes will I see on a Stillwater purchase?

Florida's deed documentary stamp tax is 70 cents per $100 of price, which is $3,395 on a $485,000 sale (Fla. Stat. 201.02, read November 17, 2026; our arithmetic). A new mortgage adds note stamps of 35 cents per $100 (Fla. Stat. 201.08) and a 2-mill intangible tax (Fla. Stat. 199.133): $1,358 and $776 on a $388,000 loan. The contract decides who pays each.

How do I start a search in Stillwater?

Start on our guide to buying a home in Stillwater or our Englewood buyer page, read our buying guide, or contact us. Call Marc Comisar at (239) 287-5873. We check the plat, the CDD status, the flood record and the association documents on every Stillwater home before you write an offer.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

Frequently Asked Questions, Stillwater Seller Edition

Stillwater sellers ask most about recorded prices in their own plat, how a resale competes with new Pulte homes next door, what buyers will ask about the CDD, flood and insurance, and what taxes change at closing. Each answer for Stillwater, Englewood draws on the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file, a government page, the CDD's records or a Florida statute, with its date or window.

Who is the best realtor to sell my house in Stillwater?

Hire the team with the strongest verified record and a plan for a market where an older Stillwater home competes with new Pulte homes a few streets away. McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and have over $900 million in personal sales and over $2.5 billion sold as a team. Read more about us or see our guide to the best real estate agents in Englewood.

How many Stillwater homes sold in the last 12 months?

There were 35 qualified home sales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026: 19 resales in the older Stillwater sections and 16 first sales of new homes at Shores at Stillwater (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Over the 24 months to October 14, 2026 there were 55, and over 60 months there were 86.

What is the median sale price in Stillwater, Englewood?

The 12-month median is $485,000, with a range of $250,000 to $766,700 and a middle half of $305,000 to $570,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026). The median price per heated square foot is $241, with a middle half of $200 to $268. The sold homes had a median of 1,948 sq ft and a median year built of 2013.

Why is the overall Stillwater median a poor guide to my home's value?

Because it blends three different products. The 19 older Stillwater resales had a median of $315,000 ($203 per sq ft), while the 16 first sales of new Shores homes had a median of $523,250 ($267 per sq ft) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026). Within the older sections, Unit 3 and Units 1 and 2 sell in separate price ranges, so price your home against its own plat.

What did Stillwater Unit 3 homes sell for?

Unit 3 recorded 10 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, at a median of $282,500, a range of $250,000 to $315,000, and a median of $198 per heated sq ft (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Over 24 months there were 21 at $305,000, and over 60 months 39 at $350,000.

What did Stillwater Unit 1 homes sell for?

Unit 1 recorded 7 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, at a median of $550,000 (range $450,000 to $590,000) and $214 per sq ft (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Over 24 months there were 12 at $562,500, and over 60 months 21 at $590,000.

What did Stillwater Unit 2 homes sell for?

Unit 2 recorded 2 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, at $550,000 and $620,000, a median of $585,000 and $257 per sq ft (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Two sales is a small sample; over 24 months there were 6 at $546,000, and over 60 months 10 at $593,500.

What did new homes at Shores at Stillwater sell for?

The 16 first sales of new Shores homes in the 12 months to October 14, 2026 had a median of $523,250 (range $375,000 to $766,700). Phase 1A recorded 12 at $564,750 ($290 per sq ft) and Phase 1B 4 at $390,300 ($248 per sq ft), and the first Shores closing on the file is dated February 27, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026).

How do detached homes and the 0101 homes compare in price?

Homes the roll codes 0100 (single-family detached) recorded 21 sales in the 12 months at a median of $550,000 (range $450,000 to $766,700), and homes coded 0101 recorded 14 at a median of $301,000 (range $250,000 to $407,600) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026). The 0101 code covers Unit 3 and the finished Shores villas.

Which price bands had the most Stillwater sales?

In $50,000 bands, the two busiest were $250,000 to $299,999 and $550,000 to $599,999, with 6 sales each, followed by $500,000 to $549,999 with 5; the $300,000 to $349,999 and $450,000 to $499,999 bands had 4 each (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026). Only 1 sale cleared $750,000.

Which months had the most Stillwater sales?

April 2026 had 7 sales and February 2026 had 6; February, March and April together recorded 16 of the 35 sales in the 12 months, and December 2025 recorded none (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026). The spring count includes Pulte's first Shores closings, so read it as direction only.

How did Stillwater resales compare with the same home's earlier sale?

Of the 19 older Stillwater resales in the 12 months, 15 had an earlier qualified sale on the county file; the median change was 12.2 percent higher, the range ran from 10.3 percent lower to 77.4 percent higher, and the median time between the two sales was 8 years (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). That is a small sample and shows direction only, not a forecast.

The county medians cannot answer that on their own. Calendar-year medians ran $269,900 (2018), $322,000 (2019), $271,000 (2020), $377,600 (2021), $400,900 (2022), $539,950 (2023), $390,000 (2024), $500,000 (2025) and $455,000 for January 1 to October 14, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026), but each year's median swings with which plat sold. Compare repeat sales in your own plat instead.

How does Pulte's new supply at Shores at Stillwater affect my sale?

We found no study measuring that effect, so we make no claim. What a buyer sees is concrete: Pulte's published range was $309,990 to $565,990 on November 17, 2026, and its quick move-in homes showed reduced "Was" prices, such as a Prosperity at $444,990, "Was $518,780" (Pulte, builder-stated). Your listing should answer that comparison with your home's own facts.

What can an older Stillwater home offer that a new Shores home does not?

No Shores at Stillwater CDD. A resale in Units 1 to 3 carries no CDD debt or operations assessment, while a Phase One Shores home carries a maximum annual debt assessment of about $1,382.68 or $1,914.48 through May 2056 unless prepaid, plus a planned $276 operations rate (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; FY2026/2027 budget, read November 17, 2026). A finished home with a full tax history also avoids the first-year lot-only bill a buyer of new construction faces.

How should I price against the gap in price per square foot?

In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, new Shores homes sold at a median of $267 per sq ft and older Stillwater resales at $203, a gap of $64 per sq ft (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our arithmetic). Price your home from sales in your own plat and type, then explain to buyers what the gap pays for: a new home and current code features on one side, no CDD debt on the other.

What will buyers ask about the CDD when I sell an older Stillwater home?

Many buyers see "Stillwater" on a Pulte sign and assume every home is in the CDD. The district's legal description covers only the Shores at Stillwater parcels, so a home in Units 1 to 3 is outside it (CDD April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). Put that fact, and your tax bill showing no CDD line, in your listing documents.

I own a Shores at Stillwater home. What CDD facts will my buyer need?

Your buyer will ask for the remaining Series 2026 debt on your lot, whether it was prepaid, the annual debt and O&M amounts and how they are collected. Get a written statement from Special District Services, (561) 630-4922, and the recorded notice of assessments; the district's FY2026/2027 O&M is "To Be Collected At Closings" (CDD Final Budget FY2026/2027, read November 17, 2026). The Pulte warranty transfers to a later owner within its periods (Pulte, Warranty).

What documents should I gather before listing a Stillwater home?

Gather your association's estoppel and dues statement, the declaration and rules, your last tax bill, your insurance declarations, any elevation certificate, a current wind mitigation report, roof and system permit records, and any warranty paperwork. For a Shores home, add the CDD payoff or assessment statement. Buyers in Stillwater, Englewood ask for these early, and having them ready shortens the inspection period.

Will buyers ask about flood insurance on my Stillwater home?

Yes. From January 1, 2027, a Citizens homeowner policy with wind coverage must carry flood insurance, whatever the flood zone or dwelling value (Citizens, Flood, read November 17, 2026). A buyer's lender and insurer will look up your lot on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center, so have your elevation certificate and any flood policy declarations ready.

Does a wind mitigation report help my Stillwater sale?

It can lower a buyer's wind premium, and Florida requires insurers to file discounts for wind-resistive features (Fla. Stat. 627.0629, read November 17, 2026). A revised inspection form, OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26), took effect April 1, 2026; Citizens still accepts older-form reports completed within five years before that date if the home is unchanged (Citizens, read November 17, 2026). For homes built 2000 to 2016, the permit date answers the building code item.

Will my buyer's property taxes be different from mine?

Usually yes. Florida resets a home to just value as of January 1 of the year after a change of ownership (Fla. Stat. 193.155, read November 17, 2026), so a long-held homestead's capped value does not pass to the buyer. The Save Our Homes cap was 2.7 percent for 2026 and 2.9 percent for 2025 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, read November 17, 2026). Tell buyers to budget from the 11.3068 total millage, not your bill.

Can I take my Save Our Homes benefit to my next home?

Florida portability lets a homestead owner reduce the new homestead's assessed value by the lesser of $500,000 or the old home's Save Our Homes difference, if the owner held a homestead on January 1 of any of the 3 preceding years (Fla. Stat. 193.155, read November 17, 2026). The Sarasota County Property Appraiser notes "each homestead has a unique portability scenario," so ask its office for your figure.

What transfer tax applies when I sell in Stillwater?

Florida's deed documentary stamp tax is 70 cents per $100 of the price, or $3,395 on a $485,000 sale (Fla. Stat. 201.02, read November 17, 2026; our arithmetic). Who pays it, and who pays the title policy, is set by the purchase contract, so settle both when you negotiate.

Does Amendment 3 change anything for a Stillwater seller?

Amendment 3 passed on November 3, 2026; WGCU reported it raises the non-school homestead exemption from $50,000 to $150,000 in 2027 and to $250,000 in 2028, and cuts the annual cap on assessment increases for non-homestead property in half (WGCU, November 5, 2026, read November 17, 2026). Implementing rules were still pending when we checked, so treat any estimate for a 2027 buyer as provisional.

Can I sell my Stillwater home to a buyer who plans to rent it?

Yes, but the buyer will ask about the rules. Under Fla. Stat. 720.306, an association may limit rentals of less than six months and may bar renting a parcel more than three times a year, and a newer rental restriction applies only to owners who take title after it is adopted (read November 17, 2026). Provide the declaration and any rental rules with your disclosures.

How long will my Stillwater home take to sell?

Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active listings, months of supply and rents: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Those are MLS measures, and we print only county sales. We pull current MLS figures for your exact plat when we prepare your pricing.

When is the best time to list a Stillwater home?

The county file shows sales in every month of the 12-month window except December 2025, with 16 of the 35 sales recorded in February, March and April 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026). Those spring months also hold Pulte's first Shores closings, so the pattern is direction only. A well-prepared listing in any month competes on its documents and price.

What utility costs will a Stillwater buyer ask me about?

Most buyers ask about water and sewer. Englewood Water District's rates from October 1, 2026 are a $29.37 water base and a $42.75 sewer base a month, about $116.87 a month at 5,000 gallons (EWD FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations, read November 17, 2026; our arithmetic). The same estimate at the earlier FY26 rates was $101.61 (EWD, rate adjustments effective October 1, 2025, read November 17, 2026; our arithmetic). Share 12 months of your own bills.

What is my Stillwater home worth?

The fastest answer is a valuation built from sales in your own plat. Start with our free home valuation, or read how we sell homes in Englewood. We price from the recorded sales in your plat and home type, then add the CDD status, flood, wind and association documents buyers ask for. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072, text or call.

Who do I call to start selling in Stillwater?

Call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072 about selling, and Marc Comisar at (239) 287-5873 about buying. Both are founding partners of McGreevy and Comisar; read more on Jesse's agent page and Marc's agent page, or contact us.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; window as stated)

Downloadable Documents

Stillwater's key records are public: the county parcel file, the Shores at Stillwater CDD's ordinance, budgets and bond records, Pulte's community and warranty pages, flood and storm references, the school zone tool, water district rates, tax pages and the Florida statutes cited on this page. Each link for Stillwater, Englewood below was read or located on November 17, 2026.

County, District and Builder Records for Stillwater

Document

Publisher and date

Link

Parcel and sales data downloads

Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file of October 21, 2026

SCPA download page

Homestead exemption overview (January 1 and March 1 rules)

Sarasota County Property Appraiser, current

Homestead overview

Save Our Homes and portability

Sarasota County Property Appraiser, current

SOH and portability

2026 millage and non-ad valorem levying authorities

Sarasota County Tax Collector, roll certified September 29, 2026

2026 millage, non-ad valorem page

Shores at Stillwater CDD website and FAQs

Shores at Stillwater CDD, current

CDD home, FAQs, Documents

Ordinance 2025-032 (district creation)

Sarasota County, filed February 11, 2026

Ordinance PDF

FY2026/2027 final budget ($276 O&M, collected at closings)

Shores at Stillwater CDD, 2026

Budget (PDF)

Phase One methodology, engineer's report and bond disclosure

Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book

Meeting book (PDF)

Master methodology and legal description

Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book

Meeting book (PDF)

Amended FY2025/2026 budget (Series 2026 bond summary)

Shores at Stillwater CDD, October 2026

Amended budget (PDF)

Bond validation notice, Case 2026-CA-001067 NC

Business Observer legal notice, March 13, 2026

Legal notice

Shores at Stillwater community page (builder-stated)

Pulte Homes, read November 17, 2026

Pulte, Shores at Stillwater

Pulte warranty page and national warranty book

Pulte Homes, August 2024 book

Warranty page, Warranty book (PDF)

Build Quality Experience (pre-drywall orientation)

Pulte Homes, current

Build Quality Experience

Data updated: November 2026 (document links read November 17, 2026)

Flood, Storm and School Documents for Stillwater

Document

Publisher and date

Link

Flood Map Service Center (zone and panel by address)

FEMA, current

FEMA MSC

Flood zone definitions

FEMA, current

FEMA glossary

Risk Rating 2.0 (NFIP pricing)

FEMA, current

Risk Rating 2.0

Community Rating System list (Sarasota County Class 5)

FEMA, effective October 1, 2026

CRS list (PDF)

Citizens flood insurance requirement

Citizens Property Insurance, current

Citizens flood page

Wind mitigation form changes (Rev. 04/26)

Citizens Property Insurance, March 19, 2026

Citizens notice

Know Your Zone (evacuation zones)

Florida Division of Emergency Management, current

Know Your Zone

National Storm Surge Risk Maps

NOAA National Hurricane Center, current

NHC surge maps

Hurricane reports: Ian and Milton

NOAA National Hurricane Center

Ian (PDF), Milton (PDF)

Sarasota County School Zone Lookup

Sarasota County Schools, current

School Zone Lookup, Back 2 School page

Data updated: November 2026 (document links read November 17, 2026)

Utility, Fire and Statute Documents for Stillwater

Document

Publisher and date

Link

Englewood Water District site and rates page

Englewood Water District, current

englewoodwater.com, rates

FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations (rates from October 1, 2026)

Englewood Water District, October 1, 2026

FY27 rules (PDF)

Assessments, fees and charges ($290.78 residential, 2026 to 2027)

Englewood Area Fire Control District, current

EAFCD assessments

Electric tariff, communities served

Florida Power and Light, effective January 1, 2026

FPL tariff Section 7 (PDF)

Broadband availability by address

Federal Communications Commission, current

FCC National Broadband Map

Chapter 558 notice of claim, and 553.835 implied warranty

Florida Legislature

558.004, 553.835

Construction claim limits and repose (95.11)

Florida Legislature

95.11

CDD contract disclosure (190.048)

Florida Legislature

190.048

Assessment date, Save Our Homes and homestead (192.042, 193.155, 196.031)

Florida Legislature

192.042, 193.155, 196.031

Documentary stamp and intangible taxes (201.02, 201.08, 199.133)

Florida Legislature

201.02, 201.08, 199.133

Vacation rentals (509.032) and HOA rental rules (720.306)

Florida Legislature

509.032, 720.306

Wind mitigation discounts (627.0629)

Florida Legislature

627.0629

Data updated: November 2026 (document links read November 17, 2026)

Sources and Authoritative References

Every source below was read between October 21 and November 17, 2026, and each figure on this page carries its own date and window beside it in the text. County sales and parcel figures come from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, with qualified sales recorded through October 14, 2026. No listing site or valuation aggregator was used for any sales figure on this page.


Work With Us

Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.