1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

What’s Your Stillwater Home Worth?

What’s Your Stillwater Home Worth?

Your Home Valuation

Thank You! We are going to prepare a customized report with information on the value of your home.
View Our Listings

How Do I Sell My Home in Stillwater in 2026?

To sell a Stillwater home in 2026, price it by plat and size against Pulte's new homes next door and today's lower resale price per square foot, not the 2023 peak. Older Stillwater resales closed at a $203 median per heated square foot in the latest 12 months, against $282 in 2023 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar of Domain Realty. Updated November 2026.

This page is the seller companion to our Stillwater neighborhood guide, which covers the place itself: its five recorded plats, Pulte's plans at Shores at Stillwater, the streets, utilities, schools, parks, flood maps and storms. Here we cover what the county sales record says to an owner who wants to sell. Every count and median below comes from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser's parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, for qualified sales of improved homes over $1,000 from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 unless another window is named; the newest qualified sale in our set is dated October 13, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). We never mix in portal estimates or listing-feed medians. For the wider town, read our Englewood seller guide.

On this page, Stillwater means Stillwater in Englewood, Florida: five recorded plats reached through Medical Boulevard beside the HCA Florida Englewood Hospital campus, in unincorporated Sarasota County, with Englewood 34223 mailing addresses. Stillwater on the Bay, a set of 7 parcels on Bay Harbor Lane with Sarasota 34231 addresses, is a different place, and none of its sales are in our figures (our Stillwater neighborhood guide, citing the county file). Our figures cover all 394 Sarasota County parcels in the five recorded plats STILLWATER UNIT 1 (77 parcels), STILLWATER UNIT 2 (36), STILLWATER UNIT 3 (141), SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1A (54) and SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1B (86). On the October 21, 2026 file those plats hold 278 homes with heated area. The older plats, Units 1 to 3, hold 251 homes built from 2000 to 2016; Shores at Stillwater, Pulte's section, holds 27 homes built in 2025 and 2026 and 107 lots still coded vacant (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Units 1 and 2 are coded 0100, single-family detached. All 140 Unit 3 homes carry use code 0101, the same code the roll gives the finished Shores at Stillwater villas, and the roll does not say whether a given Unit 3 home is attached or detached, so we describe Unit 3 as what the file shows: the small-home section coded 0101, with a median of 1,349 heated square feet.

A few public bodies settle most of a Stillwater seller's questions. The Sarasota County Tax Collector's certified 2026 sheet puts the countywide total for unincorporated parcels at 11.3068 mills, down from 11.4737 in 2025, and the Englewood Area Fire Control District bills a flat $290.78 per home instead of millage (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Englewood Area Fire Control District). The Shores at Stillwater Community Development District covers Shores at Stillwater only: the district's own boundary description begins at the southeast corner of Stillwater Unit Two and runs along that plat's east line, and the district does not appear on the Tax Collector's 2026 list of levying authorities, which together indicate that the older Stillwater plats are outside it (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book; Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage). An older-plat seller should still confirm it on the home's own tax bill. Three associations are listed in Florida corporate filings as copied by directory sites: Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed March 7, 2000), Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed March 10, 2006) and Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed February 24, 2025) (CommunityPay directory, Stillwater Homeowners Association; CommunityPay directory, Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association). Confirm each on the state's Sunbiz records. Which association governs which older plat is not settled by any public source we found; the estoppel certificate and the recorded declaration settle it for your parcel.

The center of this page is the paired record: the price recorded at a home's earlier qualified sale set beside the price the open market paid its owner later. Of the 19 older-plat resales in the 12-month window, 15 had an earlier qualified sale on file. The median resold 12.2 percent above the earlier recorded price, 12 above and 3 below, from 10.3 percent below to 77.4 percent above, after a median 98 months between the two sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). When the owner bought decided most of the result. The 10 owners whose earlier sale came before 2020 resold at a median 50.5 percent above it, all 10 above; the 2 whose earlier sale was in 2020 or 2021 resold 6.4 and 10.1 percent above, too few for a median; and the 3 whose earlier sale was in 2022 or later resold at a median 8.7 percent below, all 3 below, from 10.3 to 4.8 percent below. Over 24 months, 31 matched resales show a median 54.0 percent above, 26 above and 5 below.

The reason a recent buyer meets a different market sits in two numbers. Older-plat resales sold at a median $282 per heated square foot in calendar 2023 and $203 in 2026 to date, about 28.0 percent lower by our arithmetic, while Pulte's 16 first sales at Shores at Stillwater in the latest 12 months closed at a $267 median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). And Pulte's own prices next door have moved. On November 17, 2026 Pulte listed seven plans at Shores at Stillwater from $309,990 for the Colton villa to $565,990 for the Mystique Grande, two quick move-in homes marked down, and an offer for contracts accepted November 2 to November 30, 2026 of a pool valued at $69,500 or a credit of up to $77,000, not both (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). The county recorded four Phase 1B villa first sales at 1,574 heated square feet, at $375,000, $379,000, $401,600 and $407,600, and Pulte's quick move-in Ellenwood villa of 1,579 square feet was listed that day at $364,990, marked down from $405,880: below every recorded villa sale (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). A buyer touring your Stillwater home can stop at Pulte's sales center the same afternoon, so the buyer is pricing your home against today's builder offer, not against 2023.

Stillwater at a glance (Sarasota County record and Pulte's pages, November 2026):

  • Location and governance: five recorded plats off Medical Boulevard beside HCA Florida Englewood Hospital, in unincorporated Sarasota County, mailing city Englewood, ZIP 34223, inside no city; 11.3068 mills for 2026 and a $290.78 Englewood Area Fire Control District charge per home; the Shores at Stillwater CDD covers Shores at Stillwater only (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Englewood Area Fire Control District; our Stillwater neighborhood guide).
  • Size: 394 parcels; 278 homes with heated area; 251 homes in Units 1 to 3 built 2000 to 2016; 27 Shores at Stillwater homes built 2025 to 2026 and 107 Shores lots still coded vacant on the October 21, 2026 file (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • Last 12 months, all homes (October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026): 35 qualified sales at a $485,000 median, from $250,000 to $766,700, middle half $305,000 to $570,000 (same source).
  • Resales and first sales: 19 older-plat resales at a $315,000 median (middle half $280,000 to $550,000); 16 Shores at Stillwater first sales at $523,250 (middle half $419,450 to $662,575) (same source and window).
  • By plat: Unit 3, 10 resales at a $282,500 median and $198 per heated square foot, median 1,349 square feet sold; Unit 1, 7 resales at $550,000 and $214 per square foot; Unit 2, 2 sales at $550,000 and $620,000, too few for a median (same source and window).
  • Price per heated square foot: resales a $203 median, middle half $192 to $246; Shores first sales $267, middle half $241 to $329 (same source and window).
  • Resale against the earlier sale: 15 of 19 resales matched; median 12.2 percent above, 12 above and 3 below, median 98 months between the two sales (same source and window).
  • By when the earlier sale happened: before 2020, 10 resales at a median 50.5 percent above; 2022 or later, 3 resales at a median 8.7 percent below, all 3 below (same source and window).
  • Older-plat resale price per square foot by calendar year: $191 in 2021, $263 in 2022, $282 in 2023, $264 in 2024, $230 in 2025 and $203 in 2026 to date (same source).
  • Pulte on November 17, 2026: seven plans from $309,990 to $565,990; quick move-ins at $444,990 (marked down from $518,780) and $364,990 (marked down from $405,880); a $69,500 pool or a credit of up to $77,000 on contracts accepted November 2 to 30, 2026, not combined (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated).
  • Shores at Stillwater CDD, for Shores owners only: Series 2026 bonds of $2,970,000 maturing May 2056; maximum annual debt assessment $1,382.68 on a 34-foot lot and $1,914.48 on a 52-foot lot; operations assessment for 2026/27 collected at closings rather than on the tax bill (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; Shores at Stillwater CDD, Final Budget 2026-2027).
  • Flood: one published reading, Zone X at one Lake Victoria Court address in Stillwater Unit 1 (checked November 14, 2026); Sarasota County's current FEMA maps in force since March 27, 2024; every other lot needs its own lookup (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).
  • Sarasota County, countywide, Q3 2026: single-family median $485,000, 52 median days to contract, 3.7 months of supply, 94.4 percent of original list price received (Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, Q3 2026 Sarasota County single-family summary).
  • Listing-service measures for Stillwater: days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active resale listings in Stillwater, months of supply in Stillwater and rents: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

Talk to McGreevy and Comisar before you list. Start with a free Stillwater home valuation built from your plat's recorded sales, or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying in Stillwater or elsewhere in Englewood instead? Read how to buy a home in Stillwater, or call Marc at (239) 287-5873.

The record behind the team that will price your Stillwater home:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008

  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)

  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012

  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate

  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales

  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors

  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 ·

  • Marc Comisar: (239) 287-5873

  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Jesse McGreevy (license SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (license BK3060671) are licensed Florida real estate professionals regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) under Chapter 475, Florida Statutes.


Table of Contents

Why List Your Stillwater Home With McGreevy and Comisar?

List your Stillwater home with McGreevy and Comisar because we price it from Sarasota County's recorded sales for its own plat, use code and size, set against the home's own earlier sale and Pulte's current prices next door. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar lead the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with over 45 years of combined experience.

That experience is the whole team's record across Southwest Florida, not a Stillwater sales count, and we keep the two apart on purpose. In the 2026 RealTrends rankings, our Domain Realty Group team was the #5 real estate team in Florida, with 241 transactions and $157M+ in volume, and the #1 real estate team in Bonita Springs by sales volume and by transaction sides; Domain Realty Group has closed 4,000+ transactions as a team (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). What we bring to Stillwater in Englewood specifically is method. For this page we traced every qualified home sale in the five plats, 35 in the last 12 months, 55 over 24 months, 63 over 36 months and 86 over 60 months; we split them into older-plat resales and Shores at Stillwater first sales, by unit, phase and use code; we matched each resale to the price the same home brought at its earlier qualified sale, 15 pairs in 12 months and 39 over 36 months; and we cut older-plat resales by calendar year back to 2012 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). We also read Pulte's community, plan and quick move-in pages, PulteGroup's latest quarterly report, the Shores at Stillwater CDD's methodology and budgets, the Tax Collector's certified 2026 millage sheet and the Florida statutes a buyer's agent will raise, so a seller can see what a buyer will set beside the asking price. That is the work a Stillwater price should start from.

We are the partners who price your home, sit at the negotiating table and answer your phone. Nobody hands your Stillwater offer to an assistant.

What Does Partner-Level Service Mean for a Stillwater Listing?

Partner-level service means the partner who priced your Stillwater home answers the buyer's questions about the roof's age, the four-point inspection, the Citizens flood rule, the CDD next door, the HOA estoppel, your earlier recorded price and Pulte's price for a similar new home, usually the same day.

A Stillwater negotiation turns on details a junior agent would pass along without reading. The roof comes first. Florida law says an insurer "may not refuse to issue or refuse to renew a homeowner's policy insuring a residential structure with a roof that is less than 15 years old solely because of the age of the roof," and for a roof at least 15 years old the insurer must allow an inspection and may not refuse solely for age if the roof "has 5 years or more of useful life remaining" (Florida Statutes 627.7011). By the roll's year built, every older Stillwater home built from 2000 to 2011 is 15 years or older in 2026 if it still has its original roof, and many may have been reroofed since; the roll does not say which, so the permit and the invoice for your roof are the first papers we ask for (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

The four-point inspection comes next. Citizens says it "requires a four-point inspection for all property owner, dwelling and mobile home applications for properties more than 20 years old," covering the electrical system, plumbing, heating and cooling and the roof (Citizens Property Insurance, Inspections). Every Unit 2 home, built in 2005 or 2006, and the Unit 1 homes built from 2000 to 2006 are at or past that line by our arithmetic on the roll years, and the Unit 3 homes, built from 2007 to 2013, reach it from 2027 to 2033. Other sources put the age trigger elsewhere, and the buyer's own insurer sets its rule, so we treat Citizens as the reference point and ask the buyer's agent which carrier is quoting. Then flood: Citizens says personal residential policies with wind coverage must carry flood coverage, and from January 1, 2027 that reaches "All policies, regardless of value" (Citizens Property Insurance, Flood). A buyer who places a Citizens wind policy on a Zone X Stillwater home will need a flood policy too.

Then the Pulte questions. A buyer's agent will have Pulte's November 17, 2026 page open: the Colton villa from $309,990 for 1,321 square feet, the Prestige from $452,990 for 2,080+ square feet, the Mystique Grande from $565,990 for 2,870+, and the November offer of a pool valued at $69,500 or a credit of up to $77,000 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). We answer with the record: what the plat's own resales closed at, what Pulte's recorded first sales closed at, and what a Shores at Stillwater home carries that an older Stillwater home does not. A Shores at Stillwater lot owes the CDD a maximum annual debt assessment of $1,382.68 on a 34-foot lot or $1,914.48 on a 52-foot lot on bonds that mature in May 2056, while the district boundary and the 2026 levy list indicate that the older plats carry no district line (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; Shores at Stillwater CDD, Amended Final Budget 2025-2026). Pulte's payment illustrations leave the CDD out, so we put it back in for the buyer.

The association questions close the loop. Florida's estoppel statute, section 720.30851, requires the association to issue the certificate "Within 10 business days" of a request, and DBPR's adjusted caps are $299 for preparation and delivery, $119 more for delivery within 3 business days and up to $179 more on a delinquent account (Florida Statutes 720.30851; DBPR, estoppel certificate fees). The certificate must list "all other associations of which the parcel is a member," which is how an older Stillwater parcel's association structure is settled for good (same statute). Jesse and Marc read the papers and give those answers themselves.

How Does the County Record Change the Way We Price a Stillwater Home?

The county record lets us price a Stillwater home against the right group of sales: older-plat resales or Shores at Stillwater first sales, its own unit and use code, its size, and the price the same home brought at its earlier qualified sale. A blended Stillwater median of $485,000 describes almost no single home.

Here is what the record changes in practice. First, the sale type. In the latest 12 months, older Stillwater resales sold at a median $203 per heated square foot, with the middle half from $192 to $246, while Pulte's first sales at Shores at Stillwater sold at $267, with the middle half from $241 to $329 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). That gap is $64 a square foot, about 31.5 percent at the medians (our arithmetic). Part of it is what a new home includes: Pulte lists "Impact Glass & Tile Roof Included" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). Part of it is what a first sale's recorded price may contain, such as options, lot choice and pools the county file does not itemize. A resale priced from Pulte's median per square foot starts high; one priced from the older plats' 2023 peak starts high too.

Second, the plat. The 12-month resale medians were $282,500 on 10 Unit 3 sales and $550,000 on 7 Unit 1 sales, and Unit 2 recorded 2 sales at $550,000 and $620,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The plats barely overlap in size: on the roll, the smallest Unit 1 home has 1,961 heated square feet and the largest Unit 3 home 1,730 (our Stillwater neighborhood guide, citing the roll). We never set a Unit 3 home beside a Unit 1 home to pick a price.

Third, the use code. Across all five plats in the same window, the 21 sales coded 0100 closed at a $550,000 median and the 14 coded 0101 at $301,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The 0101 group mixes Unit 3 resales with Pulte's Phase 1B villa first sales, so it is a size and code group, not a statement about construction type.

Fourth, the home's own history. Of the 278 homes on the roll, 227 have at least one qualified sale on the file and 102 have two or more (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A buyer's agent can look up your earlier price in minutes, so the fourth section of this page shows how Stillwater resales sat against theirs.

Fifth, time. Older-plat resale prices per heated square foot rose from $191 in 2021 to $282 in 2023 and have come down each year since, to $203 in 2026 to date (same source). A price built from a 2023 comparable sale in your own plat can be a long way above today's market even when the home is identical.

Why Can't a Listing-Feed Comparison See the Whole Stillwater Market?

A listing-feed comparison cannot see the whole Stillwater market because the name covers five plats with three price levels, Pulte's first sales sit beside older resales, and the name is shared with other places. The Sarasota County parcel file avoids those problems parcel by parcel.

Our review of search results on November 17, 2026 found no page written for a Stillwater seller. A search for selling a home in Stillwater, Englewood returned sold and active listing pages and one ZIP-wide cash-offer page, and none separated the five plats, matched a resale to its earlier price or set an older home against Pulte's current prices. Listing pages give the older sections names that are not plat names, and they give conflicting counts of homes, not all of which match the county roll's 140 Unit 3 homes coded 0101 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). New-home portals listed Shores at Stillwater quick move-in homes and prices that differed from Pulte's own page that day. We do not name or use any of those figures.

The name itself needs handling. Stillwater on the Bay, a Sarasota 34231 set on Bay Harbor Lane, is on the same county file, so a careless search folds it into Englewood figures; there are also cities named Stillwater in Minnesota and Oklahoma, a Shores at Stillwater in Park City, Utah, and a Stillwater Cay in Estero (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). And ZIP 34223 covers a large part of Englewood, so a ZIP median says little about any one Stillwater plat.

The county record has its own limits, and we name them. It carries no days on market, no sale-to-list ratio and no active listing count, because those are listing-service fields. It lags the market: the newest qualified sale in our Stillwater set is dated October 13, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). It records a first sale at the recorded price and does not show the options, lot premium, pool or incentive behind it. When we prepare a pricing opinion for a specific Stillwater home, we add the listing-side measures for its own plat at that time, show you where they came from, and keep the county record as the base.

Which Stillwater Documents Do We Gather Before We Suggest a Price?

Before we suggest a price for a Stillwater home, we gather your purchase closing statement, your owner's title policy, the roof permit and invoice, any four-point and wind mitigation reports, permits for anything added, HOA approvals, the 2026 tax bill, your flood zone papers and, for Shores at Stillwater owners, the Pulte warranty and CDD papers.

Each document answers a question the buyer's agent will ask:

  1. Your purchase closing statement. The county file shows one price for your purchase; your closing statement shows what sat around it. The IRS counts settlement costs such as "Recording fees, Survey fees, Transfer or stamp taxes, and Owner's title insurance" in basis (IRS Publication 523). Those papers explain your earlier recorded price better than any median.
  2. Your owner's title policy. Florida's promulgated title rule applies reissue rates to "Policies issued with an effective date of less than 3 years after the effective date of the policy insuring the seller," where a copy of the prior owner's policy is retained (Florida Administrative Code rule 69O-186.003, via Cornell LII). At $315,000, the 12-month older-plat resale median, the reissue premium is $975.00 against $1,650.00 at the full promulgated rate (rule arithmetic). Every Shores at Stillwater owner is inside that window, because the first Shores closing on the file is dated February 27, 2026.
  3. The roof permit and invoice. Florida law counts roof age "using the last date on which 100 percent of the roof's surface area was built or replaced" (Florida Statutes 627.7011). For a 2000 to 2011 Stillwater home, the reroof date is the single most important line on the insurance application.
  4. A four-point inspection. Citizens requires one for homes more than 20 years old, and says "Any serious hazards or deficiencies (such as exposed wiring, active leaks or evidence of leaks) should be repaired before an application for coverage is submitted" (Citizens Property Insurance, Inspections). A pre-listing report tells us what the buyer's inspector will find first.
  5. A wind mitigation report. Insurers' rate filings "must include actuarially reasonable discounts, credits, or other rate differentials" for wind-resistive construction (Florida Statutes 627.0629), and Citizens says inspections on or after April 1, 2026 "must use the revised form," OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26) (Citizens, Uniform Mitigation Verification Inspection Form Changes).
  6. Permits for anything added. The Florida Realtors AS IS contract has the seller state that the seller does not know of improvements "made without required permits or made pursuant to permits which have not been properly closed" (Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS Residential Contract), and Florida law lets an owner close an old permit with the original contractor or "a different contractor appropriately licensed in this state" (Florida Statutes 553.79). A reroof, an air conditioner change-out, a water heater, a screen enclosure and shutters are the permits most likely to need a final inspection on a 2000s home.
  7. HOA approvals and the estoppel. The association's architectural approvals for anything you added sit beside the permits, and the estoppel certificate states "The regular periodic assessment levied against the parcel" and whether any "capital contribution fee, resale fee, transfer fee, or other fee" is due (Florida Statutes 720.30851). Stillwater dues are not published in any source we could verify, so we read yours from the estoppel.
  8. The 2026 tax bill. At 11.3068 mills plus the $290.78 fire charge, your bill shows the buyer what the year costs today, though Florida's Save Our Homes rule resets the buyer's assessment to just value "as of January 1 of the year following a change of ownership" (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Florida Statutes 193.155).
  9. Flood papers. Look up your own address on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center, record the zone and the panel, and hand the buyer any elevation certificate you have. Florida's flood disclosure must be given "at or before the time the sales contract is executed" (Florida Statutes 689.302).
  10. For Shores at Stillwater owners, the warranty and CDD papers. Pulte's warranty page says "Warranties are transferable to subsequent owner who takes title within the applicable warranty period" (Pulte, Warranty, builder-stated, as read for our guide); hand over your warranty documents and ask Pulte in writing what remains. The district's site lists a "Request CDD Debt and Assessment Information" link for payoff figures (Shores at Stillwater CDD).

If you would like us to pull the record for your address first, request a free Stillwater home valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

Have McGreevy and Comisar Sold a Home in Stillwater?

Whether McGreevy and Comisar have closed a Stillwater sale is a listing-service question, and the Sarasota County record used for this page does not name agents. For our own Stillwater sales: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). What we offer a Stillwater seller is the record and method on this page.

We would rather say that plainly than borrow another market's numbers. The figures on this page describe the Stillwater in Englewood market, not our share of it, and every one of them names its source and its window. The team record in the accolade list above is our record across Southwest Florida. What carries over to a Stillwater listing is the discipline behind it: price from closings, compare homes in the same plat and of the same size, keep Pulte first sales and older resales apart, read the roof, insurance, CDD, HOA, flood and permit papers before the buyer does, and keep a partner at the table from the first call to the closing.

How Should You Compare Listing Agents for a Stillwater Home?

Compare listing agents for a Stillwater home on the public record: license history, verified reviews and published production, and then one Stillwater test. Ask each agent which plat your parcel is in, what that plat's resales closed at, and how your home sits against Pulte's current price for a similar new home.

Our page on the best real estate agents in Englewood sets out how to compare the agents and teams working in Englewood on Google reviews, license dates and published production, and we are comfortable being measured against the criteria it sets out. Whoever you interview, ask for the full scope in writing: how the price was built, which comparable sales were used and from which file, how the listing will answer the roof, four-point, flood, HOA and CDD questions, the photography and marketing plan, and who negotiates. An agent who answers the Stillwater test from memory, with a plat median and a price per square foot for your size of home, has done the homework. An agent who answers with one ZIP code number has not, because Stillwater's 12-month resale medians alone ran from $282,500 in Unit 3 to $550,000 in Unit 1, and no Unit 3 resale in that window topped $315,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).


What Does the Recorded Sales Record Say About Stillwater?

The recorded sales record says Stillwater in Englewood is two markets on one road. The Sarasota County Property Appraiser recorded 35 qualified home sales at a $485,000 median from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026: 19 older-plat resales at $315,000 and 16 Pulte first sales at Shores at Stillwater at $523,250.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, newest qualified sale October 13, 2026; qualified sales of improved homes over $1,000, October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026)

For this page we tracked every qualified sale of an improved home in the five Stillwater plats, parcel by parcel, rather than relying on a listing feed: 35 in the last 12 months, 55 over 24 months, 63 over 36 months and 86 over 60 months, each tagged as an older-plat resale or a Shores at Stillwater first sale and by unit, phase and use code. We matched every resale to the same home's earlier qualified sale, which is the basis of the next section, and cut older-plat resales by calendar year back to 2012 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

How we counted (method note). The parcel set is every Sarasota County parcel in the five recorded plats STILLWATER UNIT 1 (77 parcels), STILLWATER UNIT 2 (36), STILLWATER UNIT 3 (141), SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1A (54) and SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1B (86), 394 parcels on the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; on that file they hold 278 homes with heated area: 251 in the older plats, built 2000 to 2016, and 27 at Shores at Stillwater, built 2025 to 2026, with 107 Shores lots still coded vacant (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Units 1 and 2 are coded 0100 (single-family detached); all 140 Unit 3 homes and the finished Shores villas carry use code 0101. Whether a given Unit 3 home is attached or detached is not stated on the file, so we describe Unit 3 as the small-home section coded 0101, with a median of 1,349 heated square feet. A sale counts if it is marked qualified, the parcel is improved and the price is over $1,000. The 12-month window is October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; the 24-month window starts October 15, 2024, the 36-month window October 15, 2023 and the 60-month window October 15, 2021. A "resale" is a sale of a home in the older plats, Units 1 to 3. A "first sale" is the first qualified sale of a new Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater, and every Shores sale in the file is one; the file does not name sellers, so we do not describe any sale by who sold it. The earliest qualified sale on file for these plats is dated January 6, 2009, so "earlier sale" means the earliest such sale on that file. Price per heated square foot divides the sale price by the roll's heated area and should not be set beside a listing figure that uses a different area measure. Where a group has fewer than 3 sales, we print the count and the values and say it is too few for a median. Where a figure is our own arithmetic from the file, it says so.

What Did Stillwater Homes Sell For in the Last 12 Months?

Stillwater homes sold at a $485,000 median across 35 qualified sales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, middle half $305,000 to $570,000. The 19 older-plat resales had a $315,000 median at $203 per heated square foot; the 16 Shores at Stillwater first sales had $523,250 at $267.

Stillwater qualified home sales. Window: October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser.

Measure All home sales Older-plat resales (Units 1 to 3) Shores at Stillwater first sales
Qualified sales 35 19 16
Median sale price $485,000 $315,000 $523,250
Lowest to highest $250,000 to $766,700 $250,000 to $620,000 $375,000 to $766,700
Middle half of sales $305,000 to $570,000 $280,000 to $550,000 $419,450 to $662,575
Median per heated sq ft $241 $203 $267
Middle half, per heated sq ft $200 to $268 $192 to $246 $241 to $329
Lowest to highest, per heated sq ft $183 to $385 $183 to $268 $234 to $385
Median heated sq ft of homes sold 1,948 1,536 not computed

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales of improved homes October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; heated area from the roll)

Three readings matter to a seller. First, the market is split almost in half. Resales were 19 of 35, about 54.3 percent, and Pulte first sales 16, about 45.7 percent (our arithmetic; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The all-sales median, $485,000, sits between two clusters and is the number a buyer's agent will quote if nobody separates them.

Second, the clusters barely touch. The 12-month sales spread across $50,000 price bands like this: 6 from $250,000 to $299,999, 4 from $300,000 to $349,999, 2 from $350,000 to $399,999, 2 from $400,000 to $449,999, 4 from $450,000 to $499,999, 5 from $500,000 to $549,999, 6 from $550,000 to $599,999, 2 from $600,000 to $649,999, 1 from $650,000 to $699,999, 2 from $700,000 to $749,999 and 1 at $750,000 or more (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our band count from the file). The bottom ten are all Unit 3 resales; the top of the range is Pulte's larger Phase 1A homes.

Third, the extremes are single sales. The $766,700 top was a 1,989 square foot Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A first sale in June 2026, and the $250,000 bottom was a 1,338 square foot Unit 3 resale in January 2026, by our reading of the sales lists (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Neither sets a price for anyone else. The homes that sold in the window had a median of 1,948 heated square feet and a 2013 median year built, against a 1,616 square foot median for all 278 homes on the roll (our Stillwater neighborhood guide, citing the roll), which says the window leaned toward larger homes, mostly Pulte's.

How Do Resales and Shores First Sales Compare Over 12, 24, 36 and 60 Months in Stillwater?

Over 24 months Stillwater recorded 55 qualified home sales at a $455,000 median, 39 older-plat resales at $362,500 and the same 16 Shores first sales at $523,250. The older-plat resale median falls as the window shortens, from $402,750 over 60 months to $315,000 over 12.

Stillwater resales and first sales over four windows ending October 14, 2026. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser.

Measure 12 months (from October 15, 2025) 24 months (from October 15, 2024) 36 months (from October 15, 2023) 60 months (from October 15, 2021)
All qualified home sales 35 at a $485,000 median 55 at $455,000 63 at $454,000 86 at $444,950
Middle half, all sales $305,000 to $570,000 $320,000 to $565,000 $330,000 to $570,000 $359,000 to $592,550
Older-plat resales 19 at $315,000 39 at $362,500 47 at $390,000 70 at $402,750
Resale middle half $280,000 to $550,000 $302,000 to $550,000 $315,000 to $560,000 $341,250 to $590,000
Shores at Stillwater first sales 16 at $523,250 16 at $523,250 16 at $523,250 16 at $523,250
Resale share of all sales (our arithmetic) 54.3 percent 70.9 percent 74.6 percent 81.4 percent
Median per heated sq ft, resales $203 $222 $236 $258
Median per heated sq ft, Shores first sales $267 $267 $267 $267

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; each window ends October 14, 2026)

All 16 Shores at Stillwater first sales fall inside the 12-month window; the first is dated February 27, 2026, so every longer window simply adds older resales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). That is why the resale share climbs to 81.4 percent over 60 months, and why Pulte's line is identical across the table.

The resale line moved steadily down as the window shortened. The older-plat resale median per heated square foot was $258 over 60 months, $236 over 36, $222 over 24 and $203 over 12 (same source). Each shorter window drops older, higher-priced sales from 2022 and 2023 and keeps the 2025 and 2026 sales, so the table reads as a price that peaked and has been easing, not as a mix effect alone. The calendar-year table below makes that plain, and it is the backdrop for every resale on this page.

How Do Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3 and the Shores Phases Compare?

Stillwater Unit 3 recorded 10 resales at a $282,500 median in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, Unit 1 recorded 7 at $550,000 and Unit 2 recorded 2. At Shores at Stillwater, Phase 1A recorded 12 first sales at $564,750 and Phase 1B 4 at $390,300.

Stillwater sales by plat. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser.

Plat 12 months: sales and median 12-month middle half 12-month median per heated sq ft 24 months: sales and median 36 months: sales and median Homes on the roll Median heated sq ft on the roll Years built on the roll (median)
Stillwater Unit 1 7 at $550,000 $454,000 to $570,000 $214 12 at $562,500 13 at $565,000 76 2,204 2000 to 2016 (2004)
Stillwater Unit 2 2 sales, $550,000 and $620,000, too few for a median not computed 2 sales, $246 and $268 6 at $546,000 8 at $571,000 35 2,181 2005 to 2006 (2006)
Stillwater Unit 3 10 at $282,500 $266,875 to $302,750 $198 21 at $305,000 26 at $318,750 140 1,349 2007 to 2013 (2011)
Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A 12 at $564,750 (first sales) not computed $290 12 at $564,750 12 at $564,750 19 1,977 2025 to 2026 (2026)
Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B 4 at $390,300 (first sales) not computed $248 4 at $390,300 4 at $390,300 8 1,574 2026
All five plats 35 at $485,000 $305,000 to $570,000 $241 55 at $455,000 63 at $454,000 278 1,616 2000 to 2026 (2009)

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; 12, 24 and 36 months ending October 14, 2026; roll counts, sizes and years from the same file)

Stillwater sales by use code. Same source.

Use code on the roll 12 months: sales and median 12-month range 24 months: sales and median 60 months: sales and median
0100 (Units 1 and 2 and Shores Phase 1A homes) 21 at $550,000 $450,000 to $766,700 30 at $555,000 43 at $592,000
0101 (Unit 3 homes and Shores Phase 1B villas) 14 at $301,000 $250,000 to $407,600 25 at $317,500 43 at $360,000

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; windows ending October 14, 2026)

The plat medians mostly tell you which homes sold. Unit 3 is a tight market: all 10 of its 12-month resales closed between $250,000 and $315,000, and the homes that sold had a median of 1,349 heated square feet, from 1,338 to 1,536 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). On the roll, Unit 3's middle half runs from 1,349 to 1,525 square feet, a narrow band, so a Unit 3 price rests on condition, roof, updates, lot and timing more than on size (our Stillwater neighborhood guide, citing the roll).

Units 1 and 2 are the larger-home market. Unit 1's 7 resales closed from $450,000 to $590,000 at a median 2,368 heated square feet sold, and Units 1 and 2 together recorded 9 resales at a $550,000 median, from $450,000 to $620,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Unit 1 is also the widest range on the roll, from 1,961 to 3,548 heated square feet, so a Unit 1 price comes from the few recent sales nearest it in size, never from the plat median.

The two Shores phases are two products. Phase 1A's 12 first sales closed from $455,000 to $766,700 at a $290 median per square foot, and Phase 1B's 4 first sales were all 1,574 square foot villas at $375,000 to $407,600, a $248 median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Pulte's page lists its Villa Collection "$309,990+" for "1321+ sqft" and its Distinctive Collection "$399,990+" for "1670+ sqft" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026), so a Unit 3 owner competes most directly with Pulte's villas and a Unit 1 or Unit 2 owner with the Distinctive homes.

What Does a Heated Square Foot Bring in a Stillwater Resale?

A heated square foot brought a $203 median in the 19 older Stillwater resales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, with the middle half from $192 to $246, against $267 for Pulte's 16 Shores at Stillwater first sales. Over 36 months resales brought $236.

Stillwater price per heated square foot. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser.

Group 12 months: sales 12-month median 12-month middle half 12-month lowest to highest 24-month median (sales) 36-month median (sales) 60-month median (sales)
Older-plat resales 19 $203 $192 to $246 $183 to $268 $222 (39) $236 (47) $258 (70)
Unit 1 resales 7 $214 $197 to $261 $192 to $265 $261 (12) $261 (13) $264 (21)
Unit 2 resales 2 2 sales, $246 and $268 too few too few $251 (6) $262 (8) $262 (10)
Unit 3 resales 10 $198 $186 to $223 $183 to $235 $215 (21) $222 (26) $237 (39)
Units 1 and 2 together 9 $246 $199 to $263 $192 to $268 $259 (18) $261 (21) $264 (31)
Shores at Stillwater first sales 16 $267 $241 to $329 $234 to $385 $267 (16) $267 (16) $267 (16)

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; heated area from the roll; windows ending October 14, 2026)

The gap between the two Stillwater markets is real in the record and its cause is mixed. Shores first sales sold above older resales per square foot in every window (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Some of that is what a new Pulte home carries: Pulte's included-features list names a "Tile roof," "Whole house impact-resistant vinyl windows," "Steel-reinforced concrete block construction" and an "Energy-efficient, tankless gas water heater" (Pulte, Colton plan, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Some of it is what a first sale's recorded price may hold that the county file does not itemize, such as options, a pool or a lot premium. A seller who prices an older home from the Shores figure meets a buyer holding Pulte's price sheet; one who prices from the 2023 resale figure meets a buyer holding the 2026 resales.

Pulte's own asking prices make the comparison from the other side. Dividing Pulte's November 17, 2026 prices by Pulte's stated plan areas gives about $235 per square foot for the Colton ($309,990 for 1,321 square feet), about $210 for the Ellenwood base price ($331,990 for 1,579), about $231 for the Ellenwood quick move-in ($364,990 for 1,579) and about $264 for the Prosperity quick move-in ($444,990 for 1,686), our arithmetic from builder-stated figures (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater; Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in, builder-stated). Those are list prices before options and before the November offer, on Pulte's area measure, and the county's figures are recorded closings on the roll's heated area, so set them side by side only as a range. On that basis Pulte's quoted prices per square foot sit above the $203 older-resale median but inside the older plats' 12-month range of $183 to $268.

Price per square foot also favors smaller homes, because the garage, lanai and lot are in the price but not in the heated area. That is one reason Unit 3's $198 and Unit 1's $214 sit closer together than their $282,500 and $550,000 medians.

How Have Older Stillwater Resale Prices Moved by Calendar Year?

Older Stillwater resale prices per heated square foot rose from $191 in 2021 to $263 in 2022 and a $282 peak in 2023, then eased to $264 in 2024, $230 in 2025 and $203 in 2026 through October 13. The 2026 figure is about 28.0 percent below the 2023 peak and about 6.3 percent above 2021.

Older Stillwater resales by calendar year and unit. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026.

Sale year All older-plat resales Median, all Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3 Median per heated sq ft, all
2012 34 $160,400 4 at $255,000 1 sale 29 at $156,800 not computed
2013 47 $176,700 5 at $325,900 0 42 at $175,400 not computed
2014 18 $247,000 8 at $325,000 2 sales, too few for a median 8 at $214,750 not computed
2015 19 $295,000 7 at $347,000 4 at $318,500 8 at $207,500 $143
2016 11 $235,000 3 at $350,000 1 sale 7 at $223,500 $163
2017 11 $335,000 6 at $363,000 1 sale 4 at $246,900 $150
2018 27 $269,900 8 at $377,500 5 at $345,000 14 at $251,000 $167
2019 18 $322,000 7 at $360,000 5 at $330,000 6 at $256,450 $167
2020 13 $271,000 3 at $449,500 1 sale 9 at $255,000 $185
2021 13 $377,600 5 at $392,000 3 at $425,000 5 at $275,000 $191
2022 11 $400,900 4 at $667,750 0 7 at $380,000 $263
2023 10 $539,950 4 at $790,000 1 sale 5 at $403,000 $282
2024 13 $390,000 1 sale 3 at $592,000 9 at $370,000 $264
2025 17 $500,000 7 at $560,000 3 at $542,000 7 at $324,000 $230
2026, January 1 to October 13 17 $305,000 5 at $565,000 2 sales, too few for a median 10 at $282,500 $203

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, newest qualified sale October 13, 2026; qualified sales of improved homes in Units 1 to 3 by calendar year of sale; groups under 3 sales shown as counts)

Read the medians with care, because the mix moves them. The all-resale median jumped to $539,950 in 2023 because 4 of that year's 10 resales were Unit 1 homes at a $790,000 median, and fell to $305,000 in 2026 because 10 of the 17 resales so far are Unit 3 homes (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Price per square foot strips out part of that size effect, which is why the last column is the one to read. By that column, 2026 resales are trading about 28.0 percent below the 2023 peak and about 23.1 percent below 2024 (our arithmetic), and they are back near the 2021 level of $191.

The Unit 3 column shows the same path in dollars. Unit 3's median went from $275,000 in 2021 to $380,000 in 2022 and $403,000 in 2023, then $370,000 in 2024, $324,000 in 2025 and $282,500 in 2026 to date (same source). The Unit 1 column is thinner, with 1 to 8 resales a year, and moved from $392,000 in 2021 to $790,000 on 4 sales in 2023 and $565,000 on 5 sales in 2026 to date. Small counts can swing a yearly median a long way, so we price a Unit 1 home from its nearest recent sales in size, not from a yearly median.

The resale count is its own signal. Older-plat resales ran 10 to 13 a year from 2020 to 2024 and 17 in 2025, and 2026 had already reached 17 by October 13 while Pulte recorded 16 first sales next door (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). That is 33 qualified Stillwater sales in 2026 to date, the most in any calendar year since 2013 on the file by our reading of the yearly counts. A 2026 Stillwater seller is listing into more competition, not less.

What Did Pulte's First Sales at Shores at Stillwater Record?

Pulte's 16 recorded first sales at Shores at Stillwater, from February 27 to October 13, 2026, closed from $375,000 to $766,700 at a $523,250 median. The four Phase 1B villas, each 1,574 heated square feet, closed from $375,000 to $407,600, and all sit above Pulte's November villa price.

Every Shores at Stillwater first sale on the file. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser. No addresses.

Sale date Sale price Heated sq ft Per heated sq ft Year built Beds / baths Use code Phase
Feb 27, 2026 $594,200 1,948 $305 2026 3/2 0100 Phase 1A
Apr 1, 2026 $401,600 1,574 $255 2026 2/2 0101 Phase 1B
Apr 9, 2026 $535,300 1,948 $275 2026 2/2 0100 Phase 1A
Apr 13, 2026 $407,600 1,574 $259 2026 2/2 0101 Phase 1B
Apr 24, 2026 $532,400 1,704 $312 2026 3/2 0100 Phase 1A
May 1, 2026 $500,000 2,088 $239 2025 3/3 0100 Phase 1A
May 13, 2026 $701,000 2,098 $334 2026 2/2.5 0100 Phase 1A
May 27, 2026 $726,000 2,088 $348 2026 4/3 0100 Phase 1A
Jun 8, 2026 $680,900 1,977 $344 2026 2/2 0100 Phase 1A
Jun 12, 2026 $766,700 1,989 $385 2026 5/3 0100 Phase 1A
Jun 24, 2026 $375,000 1,574 $238 2026 2/2 0101 Phase 1B
Jul 30, 2026 $607,600 2,204 $276 2026 3/2 0100 Phase 1A
Aug 19, 2026 $485,000 1,992 $243 2025 2/2 0100 Phase 1A
Aug 26, 2026 $379,000 1,574 $241 2026 2/2 0101 Phase 1B
Aug 27, 2026 $514,100 1,992 $258 2026 3/2 0100 Phase 1A
Oct 13, 2026 $455,000 1,948 $234 2026 2/2 0100 Phase 1A

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; every qualified first sale of a new home in Shores at Stillwater Phases 1A and 1B; heated area, year built and bedroom and bath counts from the roll)

The villa rows are the most important competitive fact on this page. The county recorded four Phase 1B villa first sales at 1,574 heated square feet: $401,600 in April, $407,600 in April, $375,000 in June and $379,000 in August 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). On November 17, 2026 Pulte listed a quick move-in Ellenwood villa of 1,579 square feet, 2 bedrooms and 2 baths, at $364,990, marked down from $405,880, and the Ellenwood plan from $331,990 (Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). Pulte's quoted villa price today sits below every recorded villa sale: $10,010 below the lowest and $25,310, about 6.5 percent, below the four-sale median of $390,300 (our arithmetic). Pulte measures its own area and the county measures heated area, a 5 square foot difference here. Whatever the cause, a Unit 3 owner should expect a buyer to hold Pulte's November villa price, not the April recorded ones.

The Phase 1A rows show how wide a new-home price can run for similar sizes. Three 1,948 square foot homes recorded $594,200 in February, $535,300 in April and $455,000 in October 2026, and two 1,992 square foot homes $485,000 and $514,100 in August (same source). The roll's area does not name the plan, and the file does not show the options, lot or pool inside each price, so we read the spread as evidence of what the record cannot itemize, not as a trend. The October sale at $455,000, $234 per square foot, is the lowest per square foot on the list.

Pulte's community is not finished. Pulte's page lists "255 future front doors," while the roll shows 140 Shores at Stillwater parcels in the two recorded phases, 107 of them still coded vacant (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The district engineer's report says the development "will be developed in four (4) phases" and that "The current approved site development plans include 255 units" (our Stillwater neighborhood guide, citing the Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book); later phases not yet platted may explain the difference, which we have not verified lot by lot. A Stillwater seller should plan on Pulte inventory next door through the coming selling seasons. PulteGroup's quarterly report for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 says "we expect our sales incentives to remain elevated" and puts the Florida cancellation rate at 13 percent, against 16 percent company-wide (PulteGroup Form 10-Q, quarter ended September 30, 2026).

How Does Stillwater Compare With Sarasota County as a Whole?

Stillwater's all-sales median matches the Sarasota County single-family median, and its older resales sit well below it. Florida Realtors data for the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee put the countywide Q3 2026 median at $485,000; Stillwater's 12-month median was also $485,000, and its resale median $315,000.

Sarasota County single-family sales, countywide, Q3 2026. Source: Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, Q3 2026 Sarasota County single-family summary.

Measure, countywide Q3 2026 Q3 2025
Closed sales 2,071 2,010
Median sale price $485,000 $467,500
Median percent of original list price received 94.4 percent 91.9 percent
Median time to contract 52 days 68 days
Median time to sale 92 days 107 days
Active listings at quarter end 2,629 3,137
Months supply of inventory 3.7 4.8

Data updated: November 2026 (Florida Realtors data for the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, released October 16, 2026, read November 17, 2026; countywide figures only, not Stillwater)

These are countywide listing-service figures, and they are not comparable line by line with the county deed record on this page: different source, different definitions and different windows. Read them as context. The match at $485,000 is a coincidence of mix, because Stillwater's median sits between its Unit 3 resales and Pulte's larger homes (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The countywide measure of price received is the median percent of the original list price, not of the final list price, so it should not be read as a sale-to-list ratio.

What the countywide numbers show is the backdrop. Countywide, the median rose about 3.7 percent from Q3 2025, time to contract fell from 68 to 52 days and months of supply fell from 4.8 to 3.7, a market that tightened over the year (Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, Q3 2026). Stillwater's own record points the other way for older homes: resale prices per square foot fell from $230 in 2025 to $203 in 2026 to date, and all 3 owners whose earlier sale was in 2022 or later resold below it (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). That difference is consistent with new-construction competition next door, but the county figures cannot prove it, so we state both and do not merge them.

Which Stillwater Market Measures Does the County Record Not Show?

The county record does not show days on market, the sale-to-list ratio, active resale listings in Stillwater, months of supply in Stillwater or rents, because those come only from the multiple listing service. For each of those fields: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). We do not estimate them.

We do not borrow them from a portal or an aggregator either, because a portal's Stillwater statistics can draw on different windows, boundaries and area measures, and can fold in Shores at Stillwater or Stillwater on the Bay, as the second section explains. Three more limits apply to the county figures. First, the file lags the market: its newest qualified sale in our Stillwater set is dated October 13, 2026, so any change since mid-October is not in these tables (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Second, the counts are small: 19 resales in 12 months, and 2 in Unit 2, so a plat or a year with a handful of sales can move a median a long way, and we print counts where a group is too small. Third, the file cannot see what sits behind a Pulte first sale, the options, lot, pool and incentive, or what an older owner spent on a roof or windows, which the fifth section takes up. When we prepare a pricing opinion for a specific Stillwater home, we add the listing-side measures for its plat at that time, show you where they came from, and keep the county record as the base.

Ready to see where your home sits in that record? Request a free Stillwater home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.


What Happened When Stillwater Owners Resold?

When Stillwater owners resold in the latest 12 months, most closed above the price recorded at the home's earlier qualified sale, and how far above depended on when they bought. Of 19 older-plat resales, 15 had an earlier sale on file; the median resold 12.2 percent above it, 12 above and 3 below (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; older-plat resales October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, and over 24, 36 and 60 months, each matched to the same home's earlier qualified sale in the same file, the earliest of which is dated January 6, 2009)

This is the most important section on this page for a Stillwater in Englewood owner, and it needs to be read carefully. We matched each resale in Units 1 to 3 to the same home's earlier qualified sale in the county's own file (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Because the older Stillwater homes were built from 2000 to 2016, the earlier sale can be the home's first sale, a resale a decade ago or a purchase a year ago, and the gap between the two sales is long: a median 98 months in the 12-month window, a little over eight years. No Shores at Stillwater home has resold yet; every Shores sale on the file is a first sale.

The comparison is honest only with its limits stated. The record shows neither what the owner spent on a new roof, impact windows, a pool or an air conditioner between the two sales, nor the closing costs paid at either end, nor the taxes, HOA dues and insurance carried in between, nor how the purchase was financed, nor what eight years of inflation did to the dollars. So this page does not describe a profit or a loss for any owner. It says what the record says: the owner resold above, or below, the price recorded at the earlier sale. The fifth section lists what those two prices leave out.

How Many Stillwater Homes Have Resold, and How Did They Compare With the Earlier Price?

In the latest 12 months, 15 of Stillwater's 19 older-plat resales had an earlier qualified sale on file, and the median resold 12.2 percent above it. Over 24 months, 31 matched resales show a median 54.0 percent above, and over 36 months 39 show 55.8 percent above.

Stillwater older-plat resales against the same home's earlier qualified sale. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser.

Measure 12 months (from October 15, 2025) 24 months (from October 15, 2024) 36 months (from October 15, 2023) 60 months (from October 15, 2021)
Older-plat resales in the window 19 39 47 70
Resales with an earlier qualified sale on file 15 31 39 55
Median change from the earlier recorded price 12.2% above 54.0% above 55.8% above 67.9% above
Resold above the earlier price 12 26 33 49
Resold below the earlier price 3 5 6 6
Resold at exactly the earlier price 0 0 0 0
Lowest to highest change 10.3% below to 77.4% above 16.0% below to 116.6% above 16.0% below to 145.2% above 16.0% below to 145.2% above
Median months between the two sales 98 98 107 93
Months between, shortest to longest 11 to 190 11 to 190 11 to 190 11 to 190
Months between, middle half 63 to 150 63 to 153 63 to 150 50 to 137

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; resales in the stated windows, each matched to the same home's earlier qualified sale)

In shares, 80.0 percent of the matched 12-month resellers resold above the earlier price, 83.9 percent over 24 months and 84.6 percent over 36 months (our arithmetic from 12 of 15, 26 of 31 and 33 of 39). That is the first fact a Stillwater seller should take in: on the record, most owners resold above their earlier price, and the share above is lower in the latest 12 months than over longer windows (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The median change also shrinks as the window shortens, from 67.9 percent above over 60 months to 12.2 percent above over 12, because the latest window holds more owners who bought recently and fewer who bought before 2015.

The practical point is direct. Your earlier price is on the public record, and a buyer's agent will see it. If you bought before 2020, your asking price will almost certainly sit above it, and the buyer will not care; the buyer cares about the 2026 resales in your plat and Pulte's price next door. If you bought in 2022 or later, your asking price may sit near or below your earlier price, and your answer to the buyer has to be the home: its plat, size, roof, windows and what you added since.

Each pair compares one home with itself, so the mix effects that move a yearly median, such as more Unit 3 homes selling one year than another, do not move the median change. That is why the median change, not the difference between two yearly medians, is the right measure here.

Does the Result Depend on When the Stillwater Owner Bought?

More than on anything else in the Stillwater record. In the latest 12 months, the 10 owners whose earlier sale came before 2020 resold at a median 50.5 percent above it, all 10 above, while the 3 whose earlier sale was in 2022 or later resold at a median 8.7 percent below it, all 3 below.

Stillwater older-plat resales by when the earlier qualified sale happened. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser.

When the earlier sale happened 12 months: resales 12-month median change 12 months: above / below 12-month range 24 months: resales, median, above / below 36 months: resales, median, above / below 60 months: resales, median, above / below
Before 2020 10 50.5% above 10 / 0 6.4% above to 77.4% above 22, 72.2% above, 22 / 0 28, 74.4% above, 28 / 0 41, 75.9% above, 41 / 0
2020 to 2021 2 2 sales, 6.4% and 10.1% above, too few for a median 2 / 0 6.4% to 10.1% above 5, 10.1% above, 4 / 1 5, 10.1% above, 4 / 1 7, 10.1% above, 6 / 1
2022 or later 3 8.7% below 0 / 3 10.3% below to 4.8% below 4, 9.5% below, 0 / 4 6, 8.8% below, 1 / 5 7, 8.7% below, 2 / 5
All matched resales 15 12.2% above 12 / 3 10.3% below to 77.4% above 31, 54.0% above, 26 / 5 39, 55.8% above, 33 / 6 55, 67.9% above, 49 / 6

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; windows ending October 14, 2026; the 12-month 2020 to 2021 row is two sales, so we give no median)

The split lines up with the price per square foot record. An owner whose earlier sale came before 2020 bought when older-plat resales traded at $167 or less per heated square foot in every year from 2015 to 2019, by the calendar-year table above, and sold into a 2026 market at $203 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). An owner who bought in 2022 or 2023 bought at $263 to $282 and sold into the same $203 market, with Pulte's new homes recording first sales next door from February 2026. We do not know what any one owner paid for repairs or upgrades, and the county record cannot tell us.

Read the 2022-or-later row closely, because it is the row a recent buyer is in. Its 3 resales in the 12-month window were a 1,338 square foot Unit 3 home bought in May 2024 at $345,000 and resold in February 2026 at $315,000, 8.7 percent below; a 2,376 square foot Unit 1 home bought in March 2025 at $620,000 and resold in March 2026 at $590,000, 4.8 percent below; and a 2,167 square foot Unit 1 home bought in March 2025 at $630,000 and resold in March 2026 at $565,000, 10.3 percent below, by our reading of the resale list (same source). Over 36 months the row grows to 6, adding a Unit 2 home resold in August 2024 at 8.9 percent below a 2023 price, a Unit 1 home resold in May 2025 at 12.5 percent below a 2022 price and the one 2022-or-later owner who resold above, a 1,649 square foot Unit 3 home resold in May 2024 at 16.0 percent above a March 2022 price.

The 2020 to 2021 row sits between the two. Those owners bought at $185 to $191 per square foot, close to today's $203, and the 5 matched resales over 24 months show a median 10.1 percent above, 4 above and 1 below; the one below was a Unit 2 home bought in December 2021 at $595,000 and resold in July 2025 at $500,000, 16.0 percent below (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The groups are small, and none of these figures predicts what any one home will bring.

Does the Plat Change the Stillwater Resale Result?

Partly, and mostly through purchase year. In the latest 12 months, Stillwater Unit 3's 9 matched resales closed at a median 12.2 percent above the earlier price, 8 above and 1 below, while Unit 1's 5 closed at a median 11.1 percent above, 3 above and 2 below. Unit 2 had one matched resale.

Stillwater older-plat resales by plat. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser.

Plat 12 months: matched resales 12-month median change 12 months: above / below 12-month range 24 months: matched, median, above / below 36 months: matched, median, above / below 60 months: matched, median, above / below
Stillwater Unit 1 5 11.1% above 3 / 2 10.3% below to 71.3% above 9, 30.9% above, 6 / 3 10, 42.9% above, 7 / 3 14, 42.9% above, 11 / 3
Stillwater Unit 2 1 one sale only, 77.4% above 1 / 0 one sale only 5, 47.7% above, 4 / 1 7, 47.7% above, 5 / 2 7, 47.7% above, 5 / 2
Stillwater Unit 3 9 12.2% above 8 / 1 8.7% below to 76.2% above 17, 75.9% above, 16 / 1 22, 76.1% above, 21 / 1 34, 76.1% above, 33 / 1
All older plats 15 12.2% above 12 / 3 10.3% below to 77.4% above 31, 54.0% above, 26 / 5 39, 55.8% above, 33 / 6 55, 67.9% above, 49 / 6

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; windows ending October 14, 2026; Unit 2's 12-month row is one sale, so we give no median)

The plat result is mostly a purchase-year result. Unit 3 has the most owners with long holds: over 36 months, 21 of its 22 matched resales were above the earlier price, at a median 76.1 percent above, and its one resale below followed a May 2024 purchase (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our reading of the resale list). Unit 1 and Unit 2 hold more of the 2021 to 2025 purchases that resold below: 3 in Unit 1 and 2 in Unit 2 over 36 months. So the larger-home plats show lower median changes partly because more of their recent sellers bought near the top.

That reading matters for a seller in each plat. A Unit 3 owner who bought before 2015 is the owner most likely to resell well above the earlier price, and the pricing question is where the home sits among the 2026 Unit 3 resales, all of which closed from $250,000 to $315,000 in the 12-month window. A Unit 1 or Unit 2 owner who bought from 2021 to 2025 is the owner most likely to face an offer near or below the earlier price, and the listing has to show why the home is worth more than a Pulte Distinctive home of similar size, with its roof, windows and updates documented. Over 36 months, Unit 1's 10 matched resales show a median 42.9 percent above, 7 above and 3 below (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

How Long Did Stillwater Owners Hold Before Reselling?

Stillwater owners who resold in the latest 12 months did so a median 98 months after the earlier sale, from 11 to 190 months. Every resale after a hold under 60 months closed below the earlier price, and every resale after a hold of 60 months or more closed above it.

Stillwater older-plat resales by months between the earlier sale and the resale, counts only. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser; bands are our count from the resale list.

Months between the two sales 12 months: matched resales 12 months: above / below 36 months: matched resales 36 months: above / below
Under 60 (under 5 years) 3 0 / 3 9 3 / 6
60 to 119 (5 to under 10 years) 6 6 / 0 14 14 / 0
120 to 179 (10 to under 15 years) 5 5 / 0 13 13 / 0
180 or more (15 years or more) 1 1 / 0 3 3 / 0
All matched resales 15 12 / 3 39 33 / 6

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; months between as printed in the resale list; counts only, because each band holds 1 to 14 resales)

The pattern follows from the dates. Over 36 months, every Stillwater resale that came 60 months or more after the earlier sale closed above it, 30 of 30, and the 9 resales after shorter holds split 3 above and 6 below; the 3 above all followed purchases from January 2021 to March 2022 (our count; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The shortest holds were the hardest: the 4 resales on the 36-month list that came less than 24 months after the earlier sale, at 11, 12, 16 and 21 months, all closed below it.

The whole roll tells the same story about tenure. Of the 211 older-plat homes with a qualified sale on the file, the median is 9 years since the last one: 36 homes changed hands less than 2 years ago, 26 from 2 to 5 years ago, 56 from 5 to 10 years ago and 93 ten or more years ago, and 40 older-plat homes have no qualified sale on the file at all (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). So about 44.1 percent of the homes with a sale on file last changed hands 10 or more years ago, and about 17.1 percent under 2 years ago (our arithmetic). The first group is the one the before-2020 row describes; the second is the group a buyer's agent will test hardest on price.

The hold also matters for tax. Federal law excludes gain on a principal residence when the seller has owned the home and used it as the seller's principal residence for 24 months of the 5 years before the sale: IRS Publication 523 says "If you owned the home for at least 24 months (2 years) out of the last 5 years leading up to the date of sale (date of the closing), you meet the ownership requirement" (IRS Publication 523). Months between two recorded sales are not the same as months of ownership and use, and the third part of this page covers the rule; ask your tax adviser before you set a closing date.

What Does Every Stillwater Resale in the Last 36 Months Look Like?

Every older Stillwater resale from February 15, 2024 to September 18, 2026, 47 in all, is listed below beside the same home's earlier qualified sale where the file has one. Nineteen fall in the latest 12-month window. We print dates, prices, the change, size, year built, rooms, use code and plat only, never an address or an owner's name.

All 47 Stillwater older-plat resales in the 36 months to October 14, 2026, each beside the same home's earlier qualified sale. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser.

Resale date Resale price Earlier sale date Earlier price Change Months between Heated sq ft Year built Beds / baths Use code Plat In the 12-month window
Feb 15, 2024 $395,000 Jan 31, 2013 $161,100 145.2% above 132 1,349 2013 3/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Mar 28, 2024 $390,000 Jun 30, 2010 $163,600 138.4% above 165 1,525 2010 3/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Apr 3, 2024 $390,000 May 13, 2015 $227,500 71.4% above 107 1,501 2009 2/2 0101 Unit 3 No
May 17, 2024 $435,000 Mar 15, 2022 $375,000 16.0% above 26 1,649 2008 2/2 0101 Unit 3 No
May 30, 2024 $345,000 Jun 11, 2012 $151,500 127.7% above 144 1,338 2012 2/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Jun 17, 2024 $590,000 Mar 10, 2017 $318,000 85.5% above 87 2,229 2005 3/2 0100 Unit 1 No
Aug 23, 2024 $592,000 Apr 28, 2023 $650,000 8.9% below 16 2,181 2005 3/2 0100 Unit 2 No
Oct 1, 2024 $630,000 Mar 2, 2015 $365,500 72.4% above 115 2,269 2005 3/2 0100 Unit 2 No
Oct 17, 2024 $320,000 No earlier qualified sale on file 1,538 2008 2/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Nov 14, 2024 $362,500 Nov 22, 2013 $177,800 103.9% above 132 1,349 2013 2/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Nov 19, 2024 $370,000 Jun 7, 2013 $173,500 113.3% above 137 1,349 2010 3/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Dec 5, 2024 $483,000 Nov 30, 2018 $327,000 47.7% above 72 2,181 2006 3/2 0100 Unit 2 No
Dec 6, 2024 $350,000 Jan 4, 2018 $250,000 40.0% above 83 1,349 2013 2/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Jan 31, 2025 $350,000 Oct 26, 2011 $170,100 105.8% above 159 1,524 2011 3/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Feb 18, 2025 $685,000 Oct 8, 2015 $396,000 73.0% above 112 2,178 2005 3/2 0100 Unit 1 No
Feb 28, 2025 $542,000 Jan 19, 2021 $425,000 27.5% above 49 2,020 2005 3/2 0100 Unit 2 No
Mar 17, 2025 $630,000 No earlier qualified sale on file 2,167 2001 3/2 0100 Unit 1 No
Mar 25, 2025 $360,000 Jun 28, 2010 $166,200 116.6% above 177 1,524 2010 3/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Mar 31, 2025 $620,000 Feb 2, 2018 $400,000 55.0% above 86 2,376 2000 4/3 0100 Unit 1 No
Apr 15, 2025 $330,000 No earlier qualified sale on file 1,501 2007 2/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Apr 30, 2025 $324,000 No earlier qualified sale on file 1,538 2007 2/2 0101 Unit 3 No
May 5, 2025 $600,000 Feb 25, 2021 $385,000 55.8% above 50 2,333 2006 3/2 0100 Unit 2 No
May 23, 2025 $530,000 Feb 2, 2022 $605,500 12.5% below 40 1,961 2003 3/2 0100 Unit 1 No
Jun 26, 2025 $300,000 Jul 28, 2010 $157,400 90.6% above 179 1,349 2010 3/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Jul 21, 2025 $560,000 Dec 26, 2018 $357,000 56.9% above 79 2,141 2001 3/2 0100 Unit 1 No
Jul 25, 2025 $500,000 Dec 15, 2021 $595,000 16.0% below 43 2,326 2006 3/2 0100 Unit 2 No
Aug 22, 2025 $317,500 Jan 28, 2010 $164,900 92.5% above 187 1,538 2009 2/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Sep 10, 2025 $290,000 May 28, 2010 $149,100 94.5% above 183 1,349 2010 3/2 0101 Unit 3 No
Nov 13, 2025 $500,000 Oct 21, 2015 $382,000 30.9% above 121 2,501 2004 3/2 0100 Unit 1 Yes
Nov 19, 2025 $550,000 No earlier qualified sale on file 2,565 2003 3/2 0100 Unit 1 Yes
Jan 16, 2026 $454,000 Mar 26, 2010 $265,000 71.3% above 190 2,368 2005 3/3 0100 Unit 1 Yes
Jan 20, 2026 $250,000 Oct 14, 2016 $235,000 6.4% above 111 1,338 2011 3/2 0101 Unit 3 Yes
Feb 10, 2026 $302,000 May 7, 2013 $171,700 75.9% above 153 1,349 2013 2/2 0101 Unit 3 Yes
Feb 13, 2026 $450,000 Dec 30, 2019 $405,000 11.1% above 73 2,281 2004 3/2 0100 Unit 1 Yes
Feb 20, 2026 $279,000 Nov 9, 2020 $253,500 10.1% above 63 1,524 2011 3/2 0101 Unit 3 Yes
Feb 23, 2026 $265,000 Mar 19, 2020 $249,000 6.4% above 71 1,349 2013 2/2 0101 Unit 3 Yes
Feb 24, 2026 $315,000 May 30, 2024 $345,000 8.7% below 21 1,338 2012 2/2 0101 Unit 3 Yes
Mar 6, 2026 $590,000 Mar 31, 2025 $620,000 4.8% below 11 2,376 2000 4/3 0100 Unit 1 Yes
Mar 10, 2026 $565,000 Mar 17, 2025 $630,000 10.3% below 12 2,167 2001 3/2 0100 Unit 1 Yes
Mar 23, 2026 $620,000 No earlier qualified sale on file 2,525 2006 4/2 0100 Unit 2 Yes
Apr 15, 2026 $285,000 Jul 2, 2018 $254,000 12.2% above 93 1,536 2010 3/2 0101 Unit 3 Yes
Apr 15, 2026 $267,500 Jun 20, 2012 $151,800 76.2% above 166 1,338 2012 2/2 0101 Unit 3 Yes
Apr 22, 2026 $280,000 No earlier qualified sale on file 1,501 2007 2/2 0101 Unit 3 Yes
May 28, 2026 $570,000 No earlier qualified sale on file 2,152 2005 3/2 0100 Unit 1 Yes
Jun 9, 2026 $300,000 Sep 10, 2014 $204,000 47.1% above 141 1,349 2010 3/2 0101 Unit 3 Yes
Jul 20, 2026 $550,000 May 31, 2018 $310,000 77.4% above 98 2,056 2005 3/2 0100 Unit 2 Yes
Sep 18, 2026 $305,000 Mar 25, 2014 $198,000 54.0% above 150 1,501 2007 2/2 0101 Unit 3 Yes

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; every qualified resale of an improved home in Stillwater Units 1 to 3 from October 15, 2023 to October 14, 2026; heated area, year built, bedrooms and baths and use code from the roll; months between as printed in the file's resale list)

Read the list as 47 separate stories, not one trend. The largest moves above, 145.2 and 138.4 percent, are single Unit 3 homes bought in 2013 and 2010 and resold in early 2024, near the top of the market (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The largest move below, 16.0 percent, is one Unit 2 home bought in December 2021. Three homes on the list appear twice, by our reading of matching dates, prices and sizes: a 1,338 square foot Unit 3 home that resold in May 2024 at $345,000 and again in February 2026 at $315,000, and two Unit 1 homes that resold in March 2025 at $620,000 and $630,000 and again a year later at $590,000 and $565,000. Those three repeat sales are the clearest evidence on this page of how far the older-plat market moved in a short time.

Eight of the 47 resales have no earlier qualified sale on the file, which reaches back to January 6, 2009, so they are counted in the medians of the third section but not in the paired figures here. Three are Unit 1 homes, at $630,000 in March 2025, $550,000 in November 2025 and $570,000 in May 2026, and one is a 4-bedroom Unit 2 home at $620,000 in March 2026, the highest older-plat price in the 12-month window (same source).

What Do Same-Size Stillwater Resales Show About the Market?

Same-size Stillwater resales show the older-plat price trend more clearly than any median. Nine 1,349 square foot Unit 3 homes resold in the 36 months to October 14, 2026: four in 2024 at $350,000 to $395,000, two in 2025 at $290,000 and $300,000, and three in 2026 at $265,000 to $302,000.

Stillwater resales grouped by heated area on the roll, two or more resales. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser; groups are our reading of the resale list.

Heated sq ft and plat Resales (36 months) Resale prices by year Earlier prices recorded Above / below the earlier price
1,338, Unit 3 4 2024: $345,000; 2026: $250,000, $267,500 and $315,000 $151,500 to $345,000 3 / 1
1,349, Unit 3 9 2024: $350,000 to $395,000 (4); 2025: $290,000 and $300,000; 2026: $265,000 to $302,000 (3) $149,100 to $250,000 9 / 0
1,501, Unit 3 4 2024: $390,000; 2025: $330,000; 2026: $280,000 and $305,000 $198,000 and $227,500 (2 with an earlier sale) 2 / 0
1,524, Unit 3 3 2025: $350,000 and $360,000; 2026: $279,000 $166,200 to $253,500 3 / 0
1,538, Unit 3 3 2024: $320,000; 2025: $317,500 and $324,000 $164,900 (1 with an earlier sale) 1 / 0
2,167, Unit 1 2 (the same home) 2025: $630,000; 2026: $565,000 $630,000 (its 2025 sale) 0 / 1
2,181, Unit 2 2 2024: $483,000 and $592,000 $327,000 and $650,000 1 / 1
2,376, Unit 1 2 (the same home) 2025: $620,000; 2026: $590,000 $400,000 and $620,000 1 / 1

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; all 47 resales in the 36 months to October 14, 2026, grouped where two or more share a heated area and plat)

The 1,349 square foot group is the closest thing on the record to a controlled test, and it says a Unit 3 home of that size brought roughly $350,000 to $395,000 in 2024 and $265,000 to $302,000 in 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The year built, rooms and condition differ within the group, so we read it as a range, not a rule. All 9 resold above their earlier prices, because all 9 earlier prices were $250,000 or less; a 2026 seller in that group who bought in 2024 would be in a very different position.

For a seller, that changes where the conversation starts. If your earlier price sits well below the 2026 resales in your size group, the market has room above it, and the pricing question is where your home sits inside the 2026 range. If your earlier price sits near or above the 2026 range, as it does for the Unit 1 homes bought in March 2025, the relevant number is what the buyer can get today, from the other resales in your group and from Pulte, and the next section walks through what sits inside and around your earlier price.


What Does "Resold Above the Earlier Price" Leave Out?

"Resold above the earlier price" leaves out what each Stillwater owner spent, added, borrowed and paid between the two sales, so it is not a measure of profit or loss. The county file holds two prices; it does not hold roofs, impact windows, pools, air conditioners, closing costs, taxes, insurance, financing or inflation.

Nine things sit outside the two recorded prices for a Stillwater in Englewood home:

  1. A roof replacement. An original roof on a 2000 to 2011 Stillwater home is 15 years or older in 2026, the line where Florida's roof-age protection becomes an inspection test (Florida Statutes 627.7011). The county file does not show which homes were reroofed or what it cost.
  2. Impact windows and shutters. Pulte includes "Impact glass windows" in every Shores at Stillwater home (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated); an older owner who added them paid for them outside both recorded prices.
  3. Pools, screen enclosures and other additions. IRS Publication 523 lists a "Swimming pool" among improvements that add to basis (IRS Publication 523); neither recorded price itemizes one.
  4. Air conditioning, water heaters and other systems. Citizens' four-point inspection checks the "heating/cooling system (HVAC)" on homes more than 20 years old (Citizens Property Insurance, Inspections); replacements are invisible in the county file.
  5. Closing costs at both ends. Deed stamps of $2,205 at the $315,000 resale median, title, estoppel and recording charges, and the buyer-side costs paid at the earlier purchase all sit outside the two prices (Florida Statutes 201.02).
  6. Taxes and the fire charge. At 11.3068 mills for 2026 plus a flat $290.78 fire charge, every year of ownership carried a bill neither price reflects (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Englewood Area Fire Control District).
  7. HOA dues and insurance. Stillwater dues are not published in any source we could verify, and homeowners premiums for a given address come only from a quote; both ran through every month of the hold.
  8. Financing. Interest paid on a mortgage, or the return given up on a cash purchase, is not in the record.
  9. Inflation and federal tax. This page does not adjust either price for inflation, so every "above" and "below" is in nominal dollars over a median 98 months, and federal tax on a sale depends on facts the county file does not hold.

What the record does show is useful in itself: so far, the open market has paid most Stillwater resellers well above the price recorded at their earlier sale when that sale came before 2020, and below it when that sale came in 2022 or later. That is the starting fact for pricing, not a verdict on anyone's purchase.

How Does a Roof Replacement Sit Inside a Stillwater Resale Price?

A roof replacement sits inside a Stillwater resale price without appearing in either recorded price. Florida protects roofs under 15 years old from refusal "solely because of the age of the roof," and an original roof on a 2000 to 2011 Stillwater home is past that line in 2026.

The statute sets the test a buyer's insurer applies. For a roof "at least 15 years old," the insurer must allow an inspection "at the homeowner's expense before requiring the replacement of the roof," and it "may not refuse to issue or refuse to renew a homeowner's insurance policy solely because of roof age if an inspection of the roof ... indicates that the roof has 5 years or more of useful life remaining"; roof age is counted from "the last date on which 100 percent of the roof's surface area was built or replaced" (Florida Statutes 627.7011). Citizens adds its own line: "Roofs older than 25 years (soft such as shingle or similar) or 50 years (hard such as tile, slate, clay, concrete or metal) require documentation showing at least five years of remaining useful life" (Citizens Property Insurance, Inspections).

Older Stillwater build years against the roof and inspection lines. Sources: Sarasota County Property Appraiser (years built); Florida Statutes 627.7011; Citizens Property Insurance, Inspections; ages are our arithmetic for 2026 on an original roof.

Plat Years built on the roll Age of an original roof in 2026 15-year roof inspection line Citizens four-point (homes more than 20 years old)
Stillwater Unit 1 2000 to 2016 (half from 2003 to 2005) 10 to 26 years Crossed for homes built through 2011 At or past the line for homes built 2000 to 2006
Stillwater Unit 2 2005 to 2006 20 to 21 years Crossed At or past the line
Stillwater Unit 3 2007 to 2013 (half from 2010 to 2013) 13 to 19 years Crossed for homes built through 2011 Reached from 2027 to 2033
Shores at Stillwater 2025 to 2026 0 to 1 year Not reached Not reached

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; statute and Citizens rules as read November 17, 2026; many older Stillwater homes may have been reroofed, which the roll does not show)

Many older Stillwater homes may have been reroofed already; the county roll does not record roof dates, so each home's age comes from its permit and invoice. Where a roof has been replaced, the cost sits inside the resale price and outside the earlier one. IRS Publication 523 lists a "New roof" among the improvements that "add to the value of your home, prolong its useful life, or adapt it to new uses," so the invoice also belongs in your basis file (IRS Publication 523). We have no source that prices a Stillwater reroof, so this page prints no figure.

The building code era matters for repairs. Florida's 25 percent rule lets only the repaired portion meet current code when "an existing roofing system or roof section was built, repaired, or replaced in compliance with the requirements of the 2007 Florida Building Code, or any subsequent editions," and the 2007 code took effect March 1, 2009 (Florida Statutes 553.844; Florida Building Commission, code effective dates). A Stillwater home with an original roof permitted before that date does not get the exception, so a large storm repair could require the whole roof to meet current code; the permit date, not the year built, decides. A buyer who sees an original 2004 roof prices in a replacement; a buyer who sees a permitted reroof under the current code does not.

What Do Impact Windows, Shutters and Wind Mitigation Add That the Stillwater Record Does Not Show?

Impact windows, rated shutters and a current wind mitigation report add value a Stillwater buyer can see and the county record cannot. Pulte includes impact glass in every Shores at Stillwater home, and Florida requires insurers to offer wind-loss credits for "opening protection, and window, door, and skylight strength."

The comparison a buyer makes is direct. Pulte's included-features list for Shores at Stillwater names "Whole house impact-resistant vinyl windows- High Velocity Hurricane Zone Rated Windows," "Professionally engineered roof trusses with hurricane tie-downs for wind protection" and a "Tile roof" (Pulte, Colton plan, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). An older Stillwater home may have shutters, owner-added impact windows or neither; the wind mitigation form records which. Florida law requires rate filings to include "actuarially reasonable discounts, credits, or other rate differentials, or appropriate reductions in deductibles" for those features (Florida Statutes 627.0629), so a documented upgrade can lower the buyer's premium as well as raise the price.

The code era sets the starting point. The Florida Building Commission's chart gives the first statewide code, the 2001 Florida Building Code, an effective date of March 1, 2002; the 2004 code October 1, 2005; the 2007 code March 1, 2009; the 2010 code March 15, 2012; and the 8th Edition (2023) December 31, 2023 (Florida Building Commission, code effective dates). By our mapping on the roll years, the earliest Unit 1 homes may predate the statewide code, Units 1 and 2 fall mostly in the 2001 and 2004 code eras, Unit 3 spans the 2004, 2007 and 2010 codes, and Pulte's 2025 and 2026 homes fall under the 8th Edition; the permit date, not the year built, decides each home.

Citizens says the revised Uniform Mitigation Verification Inspection Form, OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26), "will be effective April 1, 2026," that inspections on or after that date "must use the revised form," and that it will continue to accept the previous version if it was completed within five years before April 1, 2026 and the home is unchanged (Citizens, Uniform Mitigation Verification Inspection Form Changes). For an older Stillwater seller who added impact windows or rated shutters, a fresh report on the current form, with product approval numbers, is the paper that turns an upgrade the county file cannot see into a credit the buyer's insurer applies. We print no premium figures; only a quote on the address gives one.

What About Pools, Screen Enclosures, Air Conditioning and Open Permits in Stillwater?

Pools, screen enclosures, air conditioning and water heaters added to a Stillwater home raise what a buyer pays at resale without appearing in the earlier recorded price, and each one needs a closed permit. Florida's open-permit statute lets an owner close an old permit before a buyer's review finds it.

IRS Publication 523 lists "Swimming pool," "Central air conditioning," "Storm windows/doors," "New roof," "Water heater" and "Kitchen modernization" among improvements, and says painting and "fixing leaks, filling holes or cracks" are repairs, not improvements (IRS Publication 523). On a 2000s Stillwater home, those are exactly the items a long-term owner is likely to have replaced. A Stillwater owner who added a pool and cage and replaced the air conditioner after a 2015 purchase has a resale price that includes them and an earlier price that never did, so a resale "above the earlier price" can be closer to what the owner spent in total than it looks.

The four-point inspection is where the systems show up. Citizens says a Florida-licensed inspector "will check the home's electrical system, plumbing, heating/cooling system (HVAC) and roof" on homes more than 20 years old (Citizens Property Insurance, Inspections). An original 2005 air conditioner in a Unit 2 home will be on that report, and the buyer will price it.

Permits close the loop. The Florida Realtors AS IS contract has the seller state that the seller does not know of improvements "made without required permits or made pursuant to permits which have not been properly closed," and if the buyer's inspection finds open or needed permits the seller "shall promptly deliver to Buyer all plans" (Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS Residential Contract). The statute lets an owner close a permit with the original contractor "or hire a different contractor appropriately licensed in this state," and says a local agency may not fine "an arms-length purchaser ... solely because a building permit applied for by a previous owner of the property was not closed" (same statute). The tax roll sees improvements too: for a homestead, Florida law assesses them "at just value as of the first January 1 after the changes, additions, or improvements are substantially completed" (Florida Statutes 193.155).

What Did Closing Costs Take at Both Ends of a Stillwater Resale?

Closing costs come out at both ends of a Stillwater resale and appear in neither recorded price. At the sale, Florida's deed tax is 70 cents per $100, which is $2,205 at the $315,000 older-plat resale median; at the earlier purchase, the buyer paid recording, survey and title costs the IRS counts in basis.

Florida law sets the deed rate: "on each $100 of the consideration therefor the tax shall be 70 cents," and the Department of Revenue applies it to "each $100 or portion thereof," so a partial $100 counts as a full one (Florida Statutes 201.02; Florida Department of Revenue, documentary stamp tax). In Sarasota County the seller customarily pays the deed stamps (Barnes Walker, Sarasota and Manatee closing customs). The owner's title premium is set by state rule, and its reissue rate applies to "Policies issued with an effective date of less than 3 years after the effective date of the policy insuring the seller" (Florida Administrative Code rule 69O-186.003, via Cornell LII).

Deed stamps and the promulgated owner's title premium at Stillwater price points. Sources: Florida Statutes 201.02; rule 69O-186.003; Sarasota County Property Appraiser.

Example price Basis Deed stamps at 70 cents per $100 Owner's title premium, full promulgated rate Owner's title premium, reissue rate Each 1% of price (no rate implied)
$282,500 12-month Unit 3 resale median (10 sales) $1,977.50 $1,487.50 $877.50 $2,825
$315,000 12-month older-plat resale median (19 sales) $2,205.00 $1,650.00 $975.00 $3,150
$550,000 12-month Unit 1 resale median (7 sales) $3,850.00 $2,825.00 $1,680.00 $5,500

Data updated: November 2026 (Florida Statutes 201.02 and rule 69O-186.003 as read November 17, 2026; medians from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; arithmetic per the rule, before endorsements; the reissue column assumes the seller's prior owner's policy is under 3 years old and at least the new price)

Who pays the owner's title policy in Sarasota County is a custom, not a law, and the custom favors the buyer. Barnes Walker's Sarasota customs table answers "Who pays for owner's title insurance?" with "Buyer" and "Who selects the closing agent?" with "Buyer," and Chicago Title's Florida customs page says the seller pays "but Buyer pays in some counties," naming Sarasota among them (Barnes Walker, Sarasota and Manatee closing customs; Chicago Title, Real Estate Laws and Customs, Florida). The contract decides, and the closing agent confirms the split for your sale. If a contract shifts the policy to the seller, the premium at $315,000 is $1,650.00 at the full rate or $975.00 at reissue.

The smaller lines add up too. Recording a deed under Florida Statutes 28.24 runs $10.00 for the first page and $8.50 for each additional page, so a 2-page deed records for $18.50 by our arithmetic on the statute (Florida Statutes 28.24). The HOA estoppel certificate is capped at $299, $119 more for 3-business-day delivery and up to $179 more on a delinquent account (DBPR, estoppel certificate fees), and a parcel under two associations may receive two certificates. The municipal lien search, the settlement fee and any inspections a seller orders vary by provider, so we name them and print no price. Commission is negotiated: NAR's buyer-agreement rules require a disclosure that "broker commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable" (NAR, Written Buyer Agreements 101), and for scale each 1 percent of price is $3,150 at $315,000 (our arithmetic).

Two Stillwater resales from the list show how the lines sit against the recorded difference. A 1,536 square foot Unit 3 home resold in April 2026 at $285,000, 12.2 percent above its July 2018 price of $254,000, a $31,000 recorded difference over 93 months (Sarasota County Property Appraiser); deed stamps on $285,000 are $1,995.00, each 1 percent of commission is $2,850, and the estoppel and prorations come on top (our arithmetic). A 1,338 square foot Unit 3 home resold in February 2026 at $315,000 after a May 2024 purchase at $345,000, a $30,000 recorded difference in the other direction, 21 months apart; its owner was inside the title reissue window, so if the 2024 purchase produced an owner's policy and the contract put the owner's policy on the seller the premium would have been $975.00 against $1,650.00, with $2,205.00 of deed stamps either way (our arithmetic per the rule; same sources). The examples are ours, not any owner's closing statement, and they are why we read your own closing statement before we talk about price.

What Do Taxes, the Fire Charge, the HOA and Insurance Cost a Stillwater Owner While Holding?

Taxes, the fire charge, HOA dues and insurance cost a Stillwater owner every month the home is held, and none of it shows in either recorded price. At the 2026 countywide rate of 11.3068 mills, a $315,000 taxable value with no exemption carries $3,561.64 of ad valorem tax, plus the flat $290.78 fire charge.

Lines on a 2026 Stillwater tax bill. Sources: Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Englewood Area Fire Control District; Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book.

Line Older Stillwater, Units 1 to 3 Shores at Stillwater
Ad valorem millage, 2026 (2025) 11.3068 mills (11.4737) 11.3068 mills (11.4737)
Englewood Area Fire Control District $290.78 per home, flat $290.78 per home; $63.95 per vacant lot
Shores at Stillwater CDD debt assessment None, per the district boundary and the 2026 levy list; confirm on your bill Maximum $1,382.68 (34-foot lot) or $1,914.48 (52-foot lot) a year, to May 2056 unless prepaid
Shores at Stillwater CDD operations assessment None Collected at closings for 2026/27, not on the tax bill
Solid waste and stormwater On the TRIM notice; parcel amounts not read for this page On the TRIM notice; parcel amounts not read for this page
HOA dues Not published in any source we could verify Not published; Pulte says "Community Association fees required"

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Tax Collector certified 2026 millage, read November 17, 2026; Englewood Area Fire Control District 2026-2027 assessments; Shores at Stillwater CDD Phase One methodology and Final Budget 2026-2027)

Ad valorem tax is the largest holding cost, and Save Our Homes kept it low for a long-held homestead. The Sarasota County Property Appraiser's table gives the annual cap on homestead assessment increases as 1.4 percent for 2021, 3.0 percent for 2022, 2023 and 2024, 2.9 percent for 2025 and 2.7 percent for 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Save Our Homes). Compounded, the six caps from 2021 through 2026 come to about 17.1 percent (our arithmetic), while older-plat resale prices per square foot rose and fell through a $191 to $282 range over the same years. The fire charge does not move with value: the district says its assessments are not based on value "nor are they affected by the Homestead Exemption" (Englewood Area Fire Control District).

The buyer will not inherit your bill. Florida law says property "shall be assessed at just value as of January 1 of the year following a change of ownership" (Florida Statutes 193.155), so a long-held Stillwater homestead's bill understates the buyer's next one, and the property tax disclosure tells the buyer not to rely on it. You may be able to carry part of your Save Our Homes difference to your next Florida homestead: the statute allows "the lesser of $500,000 or the difference between the just value and the assessed value of the prior homestead" for an upsize (same statute). Taxes are paid in arrears, and in Sarasota County the proration runs "Through day before closing" (Barnes Walker, Sarasota and Manatee closing customs).

Insurance is the line that moves most. A premium for a given Stillwater address comes from an agent's quote, and we print none. For scale only, Citizens' 2026 approved rate changes by county list Sarasota County's personal lines policies at a current average premium of $2,614 and an approved average of $2,470, a 5.5 percent decrease, and its HO3 multiperil policies at $3,134 and $2,901 (Citizens, 2026 Approved Rate Changes by County). Those are countywide Citizens averages across every kind of home, not a Stillwater figure. Pulte's payment calculator assumed $1,209 to $2,207 a year of homeowners insurance on new Shores at Stillwater homes, a builder assumption and not a quote (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). And Citizens' flood rule reaches all of its wind policies on January 1, 2027, so a Citizens policyholder in a Zone X Stillwater home adds a flood premium from that date (Citizens Property Insurance, Flood). Sarasota County's Community Rating System Class 5 gives a 25 percent discount on eligible flood policies (FEMA, CRS eligible communities, October 2026). None of those premiums is in the two prices.

What About Inflation, Financing and Federal Tax in Stillwater?

The Stillwater county record does not adjust for inflation, show how an owner financed the purchase or say what federal tax is owed on a sale. The median gap between the two sales in the latest 12 months was 98 months, so every "above" in the Stillwater record is in dollars of two different decades.

Inflation first. We found no source in our research that converts a Stillwater purchase price into 2026 dollars, so this page does not adjust either price for inflation, and every "above" and "below" in the tables is nominal. A resale 12.2 percent above a 2018 price, the 12-month median pair, covers eight years of rising costs for everything from roofing to insurance, and a seller should read it that way.

Financing next. An owner who bought with a mortgage paid interest the record does not show, and an owner who paid cash gave up the return on that money. The buyer's financing matters as much: on November 17, 2026 Pulte's payment calculator showed a 6.5 percent conventional 30-year rate (6.552 percent APR), a 5.25 percent FHA rate (5.916 percent APR) and a 5.125 percent 7/6 ARM introductory rate (6.007 percent APR), "based on an average of 30-year conventional or FHA loans, respectively, locked with Pulte Mortgage LLC from 11/02/2026 to 11/15/2026," with incentives applied and "a FICO Score of 780" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). A resale seller cannot offer Pulte's forward-commitment rate, but can offer a credit toward the buyer's closing costs or a rate buydown within lender limits. Fannie Mae caps interested-party contributions on a principal residence at 3 percent of value above 90 percent loan-to-value, 6 percent from 75.01 to 90 percent and 9 percent at 75 percent or less (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02); on a $315,000 sale with a 95 percent conventional loan, that is $9,450 (our arithmetic). The same caps apply to a builder's credit used for closing costs on a conventional loan, and Pulte's own fine print says its offer "may affect the amount of loan for which a buyer may be eligible" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated).

Federal tax last, and briefly, because the third part of this page covers it in full. Federal law lets a seller exclude up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly, on a home owned and used as a principal residence for 24 months of the 5 years before the sale (IRS Publication 523). With a median 9 years since the last qualified sale across 211 older-plat homes, and 93 of them at 10 years or more, many long-held Stillwater owners meet the time tests, and their basis records decide how much of the difference is gain at all (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The IRS says "if you hold the asset for more than one year before you dispose of it, your capital gain or loss is long-term" (IRS Topic 409), and a seller who receives a Form 1099-S "must report the sale of the home even if the gain from the sale is excludable" (IRS Topic 701). Florida levies no tax "upon the income of natural persons who are residents or citizens of the state" (Florida Constitution, Article VII, Section 5). A seller who is a foreign person meets a separate rule: the buyer generally withholds "15%" of the amount realized, and the IRS lists exceptions, including one for some residence purchases (IRS, FIRPTA withholding; IRS, Exceptions from FIRPTA withholding). That is why we describe Stillwater sellers only as having resold above or below the price recorded at the earlier sale.

Thinking of Selling in Stillwater? Talk to McGreevy and Comisar Before You List

In Stillwater, the typical older-plat resale in the latest 12 months closed 12.2 percent above the price recorded at the home's earlier sale, but owners who bought in 2022 or later resold a median 8.7 percent below it, so we price your home against Pulte's current offer and your own plat's 2026 resales before you list.

That is the record from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser, and the gap between those two figures is what this part of the page is about. Start with a free Stillwater home valuation built from your plat's recorded sales.

Prefer our full Englewood process? Use our Englewood home valuation page. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying in Stillwater or elsewhere in Englewood as well? Read how we help buyers find a home in Englewood. Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.

How Do You Compete With Pulte at Shores at Stillwater When You Sell?

You compete with Pulte at Shores at Stillwater by pricing against what the builder is asking and offering this week, then selling what Pulte cannot: a finished older Stillwater home that the district record indicates carries no district debt line, at a lower price per square foot. Over 12 months, 16 of Stillwater's 35 qualified home sales were Shores first sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, qualified improved sales October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; Pulte pages read November 17, 2026, builder-stated; PulteGroup Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, filed October 22, 2026; Shores at Stillwater CDD records as dated)

A resale in Stillwater in Englewood competes first with the builder across the road, not with older houses across town. Of the 35 qualified home sales in the five recorded Stillwater plats over the last 12 months, 19 were resales in the older plats, Stillwater Units 1 to 3, and 16 were first sales, the first qualified sale of a new Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). That is about 45.7 percent first sales (our arithmetic). A buyer who tours your home on Abercrombie Avenue or Clear Lake Drive can drive to Pulte's sales center inside Shores at Stillwater, read a Pulte price sheet and hear Pulte's November offer the same afternoon (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

Two facts set the frame for every Stillwater seller. First, the recorded prices are far apart: the 12-month median for older Stillwater resales was $315,000 at a median $203 a heated square foot, and the Shores first-sale median was $523,250 at $267 a square foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Second, Pulte's prices on its own pages have moved down: its quick move-in Ellenwood villa was offered on November 17, 2026 at $364,990, below every one of the four Phase 1B villa first sales the county recorded at 1,574 heated square feet (Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in, builder-stated). The sections below set out what Pulte is selling and asking, what its November offer is worth, what PulteGroup's own filing says about incentives, and what your older Stillwater home offers that a new Pulte home does not. For the full description of the five plats, see our Stillwater neighborhood guide.

What Is Pulte Selling at Shores at Stillwater Today?

On November 17, 2026, Pulte listed seven plans at Shores at Stillwater in Englewood, from the 1,321 square foot Colton villa at $309,990 to the 2,870+ square foot Mystique Grande at $565,990, under a "New Low Pricing" banner, with feature tags reading "Impact Glass & Tile Roof Included" and "Quick Move-Ins Available" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated).

Pulte groups the plans in two collections: a Villa Collection, "$309,990+" and "1321+ sqft," which Pulte calls "The attached villa floor plan," and a Distinctive Collection of single-family plans, "$399,990+" and "1670+ sqft" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Every plan has a two-car garage, and the Mystique Grande is the only two-story plan.

Pulte's Shores at Stillwater plans and "Starting From" prices, as Pulte's own pages showed them on November 17, 2026. Builder-stated; base prices exclude options, homesite premiums and pools, and change without notice. Price per square foot is our arithmetic on Pulte's stated plan size. Sources: Pulte, Colton; Pulte, Ellenwood; Pulte, Prosperity; Pulte, Mystique; Pulte, Palmary; Pulte, Prestige; Pulte, Mystique Grande.

Pulte plan Series and type Sq ft (Pulte) Bedrooms Baths Starting from (Pulte) Base price per sq ft (our arithmetic) Older Stillwater homes of similar size
Colton Villa (attached) 1,321 2 2 $309,990 $234.66 Unit 3 (roll median 1,349 sq ft)
Ellenwood Villa (attached) 1,579 2 to 3 2 $331,990 $210.25 Larger Unit 3 homes (up to 1,730 sq ft)
Prosperity Distinctive, single-family 1,670+ 2 to 3 2 $399,990 $239.51 Largest Unit 3 homes
Mystique Distinctive, single-family 1,889+ 2 to 4 2 to 3 $419,990 $222.33 Smaller Unit 1 homes (from 1,961 sq ft)
Palmary Distinctive, single-family 1,943+ 2 to 3 2 $424,990 $218.73 Smaller Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes
Prestige Distinctive, single-family 2,080+ 2 to 3 2.5 $452,990 $217.78 Unit 1 and Unit 2 (roll medians 2,204 and 2,181 sq ft)
Mystique Grande Distinctive, single-family, two-story 2,870+ 3 to 5 3 to 4 $565,990 $197.21 Largest Unit 1 homes (up to 3,548 sq ft)

Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte pages read November 17, 2026, builder-stated, not market values and not county sale prices; Stillwater size ranges from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026)

The size column is the point of the table for an older Stillwater seller. Unit 3's homes, with a roll median of 1,349 heated square feet and a range of 1,338 to 1,730, overlap Pulte's two villa plans; Units 1 and 2, with roll medians of 2,204 and 2,181 square feet, overlap the Prestige and the larger Distinctive plans (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Your buyer will compare you plan to plan, so we find the Pulte plan nearest your heated size before we look at any community median.

Pulte's base prices are not the prices its buyers paid. The 16 recorded Shores first sales had a median of $523,250 and a range of $375,000 to $766,700, above most base prices, because a base price excludes options, the homesite and the pool, which Pulte's own November offer values at $69,500 for a standard pool (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). The county file does not itemize what each buyer bought, so we do not tie any recorded sale to any one plan.

The entry price has also moved since the project was announced. In November 2024, Sarasota Magazine reported plans "ranging from 1,579 square feet to 2,080 square feet" with starting prices "expected to be in the mid-$300,000s" (Sarasota Magazine, November 8, 2024, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's 2026 page adds the smaller Colton at $309,990 and the two-story Mystique Grande, so a Stillwater buyer today can enter new construction next door at a lower base price than the 2024 reporting described (our comparison).

Which Finished Pulte Homes Compete With a Stillwater Resale This Month?

Two finished Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater were marked "Available Now" on November 17, 2026: a 1,686 square foot Prosperity at $444,990, marked down from $518,780, and a 1,579 square foot Ellenwood villa at $364,990, marked down from $405,880. They are a Stillwater buyer's closest substitutes for a resale that can close soon (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated).

Pulte quick move-in homes at Shores at Stillwater on November 17, 2026. Builder-stated asking prices, not recorded sales; street addresses omitted. Price per square foot and percentages are our arithmetic. Sources: Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in; Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in.

Pulte quick move-in Plan and series Sq ft, beds, baths (Pulte) Asking Pulte "Was" Pulte's savings figure Savings as a share of "Was" (ours) Asking per sq ft (ours)
Distinctive single-family home Prosperity, Distinctive 1,686, 3, 2 $444,990 $518,780 "$73,790 in Savings" ("Home of the Week") 14.2 percent $263.93
Attached villa Ellenwood, Villa 1,579, 2, 2 $364,990 $405,880 $40,890 10.1 percent $231.15

Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte quick move-in pages read November 17, 2026; builder-stated, prices change without notice)

Both homes are the most direct competition for an older Stillwater resale, because they can close without a construction wait. Pulte describes the Prosperity with an "oversized island," a "Gourmet built-in wall oven and microwave," an "Upgraded laundry room with sink," an "Extended lanai for outdoor living" and "Porcelain tile flooring," and the Ellenwood with "Tile throughout," "9' ceilings with 8' interior doors" and an "Outdoor kitchen Pre-Plumb w/privacy wall" (Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in; Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

Read the "Was" figures as Pulte's own framing. The markdowns, $73,790 and $40,890, tell you the builder is pricing finished inventory to move in November 2026; they do not tell you what an appraiser will value either home at (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). Pulte's asking rates of $231 and $264 a square foot sit above the $203 median for older Stillwater resales but inside the older plats' 12-month range of $183 to $268 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). In plain terms: a Unit 1 or Unit 2 home at the top of the older range is already priced like a new Pulte home per square foot, and it needs the size, the condition and the documents to earn that rate.

Portal snapshots of Pulte inventory lag the builder's own page. Search results on November 17, 2026 showed third-party pages listing quick move-ins and starting prices that differed from Pulte's own figures that day, which is why we quote only Pulte's pages, dated (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

Why Does Pulte's Villa Price Sit Below Every Recorded Shores Villa Sale?

Pulte's quick move-in Ellenwood villa at Shores at Stillwater asked $364,990 on November 17, 2026, below all four Phase 1B villa first sales the county recorded at 1,574 heated square feet: $401,600 and $407,600 in April 2026, $375,000 in June and $379,000 in August (Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in, builder-stated; Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B villa first sales against Pulte's current Ellenwood villa price. Recorded sales from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov); Pulte price builder-stated, read November 17, 2026 (Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in). Differences are our arithmetic. The county records 1,574 heated square feet; Pulte states 1,579 for the Ellenwood plan, and the two measure differently.

Phase 1B villa first sale (county) Recorded price Heated sq ft (county) Price per sq ft (county) Pulte Ellenwood quick move-in below this sale by (ours)
April 1, 2026 $401,600 1,574 $255 $36,610 (9.1 percent)
April 13, 2026 $407,600 1,574 $259 $42,610 (10.5 percent)
June 24, 2026 $375,000 1,574 $238 $10,010 (2.7 percent)
August 26, 2026 $379,000 1,574 $241 $14,010 (3.7 percent)
Median of the four $390,300 1,574 $248 $25,310 (6.5 percent)
Pulte Ellenwood quick move-in, November 17, 2026 $364,990 asking 1,579 (Pulte) $231 (ours)

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; Pulte quick move-in page read November 17, 2026, builder-stated)

This is the key competitive fact for a Stillwater seller. The builder's current asking price for a finished villa sits below what its own villa buyers recorded earlier in 2026, before any part of the November offer is applied (Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in, builder-stated; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Pulte's Ellenwood base price, $331,990, is lower still, and its Colton villa starts at $309,990 for 1,321 square feet (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

Three cautions keep the comparison fair. Four sales are a small sample. A recorded first-sale price can include options and lot premiums a quick move-in may or may not carry, and the county record does not show any incentive behind a recorded price. And an asking price is not a closed sale: Pulte's own fine print says the price paid is in the purchase agreement, and offers change without notice (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated).

What it means for you depends on your plat. For a Unit 3 seller, the nearest new alternative is a Pulte villa that now asks less than the recorded villa sales, so your resale has to answer a lower builder price, not the spring 2026 villa closings. Unit 3 resales recorded a 12-month median of $282,500 at a median 1,349 square feet, $198 a square foot, which sits $27,490 below the Colton's base price before any incentive (our arithmetic; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). For a Unit 1 or Unit 2 seller, the nearest new alternatives are Pulte's single-family plans, and the comparison runs through the next sections.

How Do Pulte's November Offers Change What a Stillwater Buyer Will Pay You?

Pulte's November offers change a Stillwater buyer's math because the buyer weighs your price against Pulte's price minus Pulte's offer. For contracts Pulte accepts November 2 to November 30, 2026, a buyer at Shores at Stillwater could take a standard pool valued at $69,500 or a credit of up to $77,000, not both (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated).

The fine print, as Pulte printed it on November 17, 2026 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated):

  • The pool offer. "Pool offer valid on new purchase agreements on select homesites for select to-be-built homes accepted by Pulte Homes in the Shores at Stillwater community between 11/2/2026 and 11/30/2026." "Eligible buyers shall receive a standard pool, valued at $69,500." "Any credit received may not be used to decrease the base price of the home."
  • The savings offer. For "new purchase agreements for select homes" accepted in the same dates, the "builder will credit buyer $77,000 to be used toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins as a reduction to the total purchase price of the home. Maximum credit amounts vary by community." "Any unused credit is the property of the builder." "Offer cannot be combined with other offers or incentives." "Offer may affect the amount of loan for which a buyer may be eligible."
  • The dates. The banner reads "Nov 9-30" while the fine print says accepted "between 11/2/2026 and 11/30/2026"; the fine print governs.

Pulte's November credit and pool against Pulte's own prices, Shores at Stillwater. Offer values and prices builder-stated, read November 17, 2026 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater); shares are our arithmetic and assume the full $77,000 applies, which Pulte does not promise for any given home.

Pulte price used Pulte figure $77,000 credit as a share of it (ours) $69,500 pool as a share of it (ours)
Colton villa base $309,990 24.8 percent 22.4 percent
Ellenwood villa quick move-in asking $364,990 21.1 percent Not applicable (pool offer is for to-be-built homes)
Prosperity base $399,990 19.3 percent 17.4 percent
Prosperity quick move-in asking $444,990 17.3 percent Not applicable (pool offer is for to-be-built homes)
Mystique Grande base $565,990 13.6 percent 12.3 percent

Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte community page and offer fine print read November 17, 2026; builder-stated; offers end November 30, 2026 as written)

A credit is not a price cut dollar for dollar, and a Stillwater seller should not read it as one. Pulte says the credit can go to "closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins," and lender rules limit how much of any seller or builder money a financed buyer can use: Fannie Mae's Selling Guide caps interested-party contributions on conventional loans at 3, 6 or 9 percent of value depending on the loan-to-value ratio (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02, read November 17, 2026). How Pulte allocates the credit in a given contract is not published, so some of it may land as design options or a lower total price rather than closing-cost help (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated).

Pulte also advertises rates. Pulte's payment calculator showed, on November 17, 2026, a 30-year conventional rate of 6.5 percent (6.552 percent APR) with 20 percent down, a 30-year FHA rate of 5.25 percent (5.916 percent APR) with 3.5 percent down and a conventional 7/6 ARM introductory rate of 5.125 percent (6.007 percent APR), described as "illustrative only, based on an average of 30-year conventional or FHA loans, respectively, locked with Pulte Mortgage LLC from 11/02/2026 to 11/15/2026" and "based on a FICO Score of 780" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). Pulte adds: "You are not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage to purchase a home from seller; but use of Pulte Mortgage is necessary to receive BFC-related rate offers where and when available," and that the forward-commitment rate is "limited to new home agreements only" (Pulte, Colton, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

A resale seller cannot offer a builder forward commitment. What a Stillwater seller can offer is a seller credit or a rate buydown inside the same lender caps, usable with any lender the buyer chooses (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02). Pulte's calculator also says "Estimated payments do not include monthly homeowners' association dues," and none of the ten Pulte pages read on November 17, 2026 mentions the Shores at Stillwater district's assessments (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). Pulte's Colton example shows "Estimated Taxes" of $368.01 a month on $309,990; what that estimate includes, and whether it carries any district or fire line, Pulte does not say (UNVERIFIED as to its contents; Pulte, Colton, builder-stated). That gap is where an older Stillwater listing makes its case, in the next section but one.

What Does PulteGroup's Own Filing Say About Incentives and Florida?

PulteGroup, the company behind Shores at Stillwater, says in its filing for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 that it is "focusing sales incentives on discounts, closing cost incentives, and mortgage interest rate buydowns" and that "we expect our sales incentives to remain elevated." Its Florida segment reported a 13 percent cancellation rate, against 16 percent company-wide (PulteGroup Form 10-Q).

PulteGroup results for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, from its Form 10-Q filed October 22, 2026. Company-wide and Florida segment figures, not Shores at Stillwater figures. Source: PulteGroup Form 10-Q, SEC EDGAR.

Measure Quarter ended September 30, 2026 Same quarter, 2025
Florida segment, closings 1,904 homes 1,932 homes
Florida segment, average selling price $579,000 $569,000
Florida segment, net new orders 1,823 homes 1,721 homes
Florida segment, cancellation rate 13 percent 16 percent
Florida segment, unit backlog at September 30 3,097 homes 2,694 homes
Company, cancellation rate 16 percent 16 percent
Company, home sale gross margin 24.8 percent 26.2 percent
Company, unsold completed homes at September 30, 2026 1,696 (2,027 a year earlier)

Data updated: November 2026 (PulteGroup Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, read November 17, 2026)

The filing explains the margin drop in its own words: "The decreases in home sale gross margins were primarily attributable to the aforementioned pricing actions, including elevated sales incentives, and increased land acquisition and development costs" (PulteGroup Form 10-Q, read November 17, 2026). It adds that the company has "continued to manage our spec inventory levels, leveraging sales incentives as needed," and that "net new orders in units decreased 6% compared to the prior year period" company-wide, while "higher volumes in our Florida segment" partly offset declines elsewhere. The filing does not print an incentive percentage, and we do not print one.

The company's earnings release for the same quarter quotes its chief executive, Ryan Marshall: "The rapid increase in interest rates has stretched affordability even further, made selling an existing home even harder, and has pushed even more consumers to the sidelines" (PulteGroup Q3 2026 earnings release, read November 17, 2026). A Stillwater seller should take two readings from these documents. PulteGroup is still selling volume in Florida, with Florida orders and backlog up while the company total fell, so expect the builder next door to keep using incentives through 2027. And a Florida cancellation rate of 13 percent means roughly one in eight gross new orders was cancelled in the quarter (our arithmetic), so some Pulte buyers return to the market, and some of them will tour resales.

None of these are Shores at Stillwater figures, and we do not claim PulteGroup cut any Stillwater price beyond the "Was" and asking prices its own pages print (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated).

What Does an Older Stillwater Home Offer That a New Pulte Home Does Not?

An older Stillwater home offers no Shores at Stillwater district debt line on the older plats, as the district's boundary description indicates, larger floor plans in Units 1 and 2, a lower recorded price per square foot, established landscaping, and a closing on the date the parties agree, not a construction schedule (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book).

Start with what Pulte includes, because a buyer will not pay you for it twice. Pulte lists a "Tile roof," "Professionally engineered roof trusses with hurricane tie-downs for wind protection," "Steel-reinforced concrete block construction," "Whole house impact-resistant vinyl windows- High Velocity Hurricane Zone Rated Windows," an "Energy-efficient, tankless gas water heater," "R-30 ceiling insulation," an "Electric car outlet in the garage" and a "Doorbell with camera" among the Colton's included features, and "an industry leading 10-year limited structural new home warranty" for the community (Pulte, Colton; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Ben Crisafulli, president of sales, told Sarasota Magazine in 2024, "We're seeing many choose new construction rather than absorbing steep renovation costs on existing homes" (Sarasota Magazine, November 8, 2024), which is a builder's view, not data. An older Stillwater listing answers it with documents, not adjectives.

What an older Stillwater home can offer against a new Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater, what Pulte offers against it, and the document that proves each item. Sources as cited in each row.

Item Older Stillwater home (Units 1 to 3) New Pulte home (Shores at Stillwater) Document that settles it
District debt line The district's boundary description begins at the corner of Stillwater Unit Two and runs along its east line, and the Phase One roll lists only Shores lots, which indicates the older plats are outside the district (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book) Maximum annual debt assessment of $1,382.68 on a 34-foot lot or $1,914.48 on a 52-foot lot, through May 2056 unless prepaid (June 15, 2026 meeting book) Your own tax bill; the district's disclosure for a Shores lot
Price per square foot 12-month resale median $203 ($192 to $246 middle half) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser) 12-month first-sale median $267 ($241 to $329) (same source) Recorded sales for your plat
Floor plan size Unit 1 roll median 2,204 heated sq ft, Unit 2 2,181, the largest Unit 1 home 3,548 (same source) Shores roll median 1,948; Pulte plans 1,321 to 2,870+ (Pulte, builder-stated) County record card; your survey and floor plan
Closing date Set by the contract Quick move-ins "Available Now"; to-be-built homes, including the pool offer, wait on construction (Pulte, builder-stated) Your contract
Landscaping and lot Established plantings, 10 to 26 years after the home was built (roll years 2000 to 2016) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser) "Professionally landscaped home site with full sod coverage" on a new homesite (Pulte, Colton, builder-stated) Photos; HOA approvals for changes
Roof Original roofs on homes built 2000 to 2011 are 15 years or older; many may have been replaced (per home, unverified) "Tile roof" included (Pulte, Colton, builder-stated) Roof permit and final inspection
Windows Varies by home: original, shutters or owner-added impact glass "Impact glass windows included with every home" (Pulte, builder-stated) Wind mitigation form OIR-B1-1802
Code era Built 2000 to 2016 under the code in force at each permit date Built 2025 and 2026 under the 7th (2020) or 8th (2023) Edition by permit date (unverified per home); the 8th Edition took effect December 31, 2023 (Florida Building Commission) County permit record
Builder warranty None from Pulte; Pulte did not build the older plats 1 year workmanship, 2 years systems, 5 years certain water infiltration, 10 years structural (Pulte National Warranty Book, builder-stated) Warranty book delivered at closing
Lender Any lender the buyer picks Forward-commitment rate offers require Pulte Mortgage (Pulte, Colton, builder-stated) Your contract's financing terms

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; Shores at Stillwater CDD meeting books of April 20 and June 15, 2026; Pulte pages and warranty book read November 17, 2026, builder-stated; Florida Building Commission page read November 17, 2026)

The district line is the largest dollar item an older Stillwater seller can name. For a Shores owner the Phase One methodology allocates $18,580.37 of bond principal to a 34-foot lot and $25,726.66 to a 52-foot lot, with the maximum annual debt assessments above, on $2,970,000 of Series 2026 bonds at 4.10 to 5.8 percent maturing in May 2056 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; Amended Final Budget 2025-2026, read November 17, 2026). The district also adopted a $276 operations rate for 2026 to 2027, with those assessments shown as "To Be Collected At Closings" rather than on the tax bill (Final Budget 2026-2027, read November 17, 2026). The district is not on the Tax Collector's 2026 list of levying authorities (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage), so no 2026 Stillwater bill carries it yet; an older-plat seller should still confirm on the home's own tax bill that no district line appears before a listing says "no CDD."

The roof and code rows cut the other way, and an honest listing says so. Florida Statutes 627.7011(5) says an insurer "may not refuse to issue or refuse to renew a homeowner's policy insuring a residential structure with a roof that is less than 15 years old solely because of the age of the roof," and for a roof "at least 15 years old" the insurer may not refuse solely for age if an inspection shows it "has 5 years or more of useful life remaining" (Florida Statutes 627.7011, read November 17, 2026). Citizens requires a four-point inspection on homes more than 20 years old (Citizens, Inspections, read November 17, 2026), which reaches the older Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes now and the rest of Unit 2 in 2027 (see the build-year table below); the buyer's own insurer sets its own rule. A Pulte home has none of those questions yet, so an older Stillwater home with a recent roof permit, a current wind mitigation form and a clean four-point is the version that competes. Later sections on this page cover the roof, insurance and permit file in full.

One warranty note for Shores owners who sell later. Pulte's warranty page reads "Warranties are transferable to subsequent owner who takes title within the applicable warranty period" (Pulte, Warranty, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). If you are selling a Shores at Stillwater home, hand your buyer the warranty documents delivered at your closing and ask Pulte in writing how the remaining coverage passes, rather than promising it yourself.

How Long Will Pulte Keep Building Next to Stillwater?

Pulte will likely keep selling new homes next to Stillwater for several more seasons. On the October 2026 county file, 107 of Shores at Stillwater's 140 parcels were coded vacant, and the district engineer plans "four (4) phases" and 255 units (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book).

The record lines up as follows. Pulte's page says "255 future front doors" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026); the district engineer's report says "The PUD approval allows for a maximum of 269 units" and "The current approved site development plans include 255 units," of which 136 are attached homes on 34-foot lots and 119 detached homes on 52-foot lots, with 136 units in Phase One (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The county roll holds 140 parcels in the two recorded phases, 1A and 1B, with 27 homes built in 2025 and 2026, 107 lots coded vacant and the rest coded as tracts (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Later phases not yet platted may explain the difference between Pulte's 255 and the 140 parcels on the roll (UNVERIFIED).

Shores at Stillwater on the county roll and in the district record. Sources: Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov); Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book.

Measure Figure Source
Parcels in Phases 1A and 1B 140 (54 and 86) County roll
Homes with heated area on the roll 27 (8 built 2025, 19 built 2026) County roll
Parcels coded vacant (0000) 107 County roll
First sales recorded, February 27 to October 13, 2026 16 County sales file
Units in the approved site plans 255 (136 attached, 119 detached) District engineer
Units allowed by the PUD approval 269 District engineer
Phases planned Four District engineer

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; district record read November 17, 2026)

The first Shores closing on the file was recorded February 27, 2026, and the sixteenth on October 13, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Because the roll values property as of January 1, homes not substantially completed by January 1 can still show as vacant lots on this year's roll, so some of the 107 vacant-coded parcels may already hold homes. Even so, the arithmetic of 255 planned units against 27 homes on the roll leaves most of the build-out ahead. For a Stillwater seller, that means builder competition for the foreseeable future: plan to sell against Pulte, not to wait it out.

Pulte is not the only builder a Stillwater buyer can tour. On November 17, 2026, DiVosta, a PulteGroup brand, listed BeachWalk by Manasota Key at an Englewood 34223 address from $349,990 with the same "pool included OR up to $77,000" November offer; Lennar listed Island Lakes at Coco Bay from $292,999; and Neal Communities listed Boca Royale Golf and Country Club at Wellen Park "From $352,990" (DiVosta, BeachWalk; Lennar, Island Lakes at Coco Bay; Neal Communities, Boca Royale, all builder-stated). BeachWalk's county was not confirmed in the sources we read. All are base or "from" prices, most with impact glass included and with builder offers, so a Unit 3 resale at a $282,500 median sits just below that entry band, and a Unit 1 or Unit 2 resale competes with the larger new plans (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

How Do We Position a Stillwater Listing Against Pulte?

We position a Stillwater listing against Pulte by pricing to the builder's effective price for the nearest plan, net of the offer a buyer would get, then adding back what the new home costs that a resale does not, starting with the district line. Pulte's Ellenwood quick move-in asked $364,990 on November 17, 2026 (Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in, builder-stated).

In practice that is six steps for a home in Stillwater, Englewood, Florida:

  • Confirm your plat and size. Unit 1, Unit 2 and Unit 3 sell at different levels, so we read the plat on your Property Appraiser record and your heated area before anything else (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • Find Pulte's live price for the nearest plan. For a Unit 3 home that is the Colton or the Ellenwood; for Units 1 and 2, the Palmary, the Prestige or the Mystique Grande. We read Pulte's dated base price and any quick move-in the week you list (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated).
  • Subtract what Pulte's buyer would receive, and add what the buyer would carry. A buyer weighing a builder price with a credit of up to $77,000 compares that net figure with yours. Then add the Shores district line, up to $1,382.68 or $1,914.48 a year of debt assessment by lot width, and the association fees Pulte says are "required" without a figure (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; Pulte, builder-stated).
  • Answer the roof, windows and systems in writing. Roof permit date, wind mitigation form, four-point report and any impact glass or shutters, so the buyer's insurer can quote your home on day one (Citizens, Inspections).
  • Offer any concession in a form any lender accepts. A seller credit or buydown stays inside the lender's interested-party cap and does not tie the buyer to one lender (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02).
  • Lead with size and ready. A Unit 1 home of 2,204 square feet, the roll median, is larger than the stated base size of every Pulte single-story plan, which tops out at the Prestige's 2,080+ square feet, and it closes on your date (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Pulte, builder-stated).

If you are buying your next home as well, new or resale, Marc leads our buyer side: Call Marc at (239) 287-5873, or read our guide to buying a home in Englewood and how we work with buyers. For a buyer who wants a new home, our guide to new construction in Englewood explains how we represent buyers on builder contracts.

Selling a Stillwater home while Pulte is still selling next door? We price it against Pulte's dated prices and offer for the nearest plan and the county's recorded resales for your plat. Request your free Stillwater valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

Why Do Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3 and Shores Homes Price Differently?

Stillwater's plats price differently because each holds a different home: larger single-family homes in Units 1 and 2, smaller homes with their own use code in Unit 3, and new Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater. Over 12 months Unit 3 resales had a $282,500 median and Unit 1 resales $550,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; 12-month window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; 24 months from October 15, 2024; 36 months from October 15, 2023; 60 months from October 15, 2021)

The four names are recorded plats, not four neighborhoods with four sets of buyers. Stillwater in Englewood shares one Medical Boulevard entrance, one ZIP code, 34223, and one county, unincorporated Sarasota County, yet its plats were recorded and built years apart with different products (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). The plat named in your legal description decides which recorded sales are your closest comparables. A blended Stillwater median hides that: the 12-month median for all 35 qualified home sales was $485,000, a figure that describes almost no house in Stillwater, because it sits between Unit 3's cluster near $282,500 and the Unit 1, Unit 2 and Shores cluster above $500,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

With 19 resales in 12 months, every plat-level figure below is a small sample (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). We print counts and ranges beside every median, we give two-sale cuts as the two prices ("too few for a median"), and we widen to 24 and 36 months where the 12-month count is thin.

What Does the County Roll Hold in Each Stillwater Plat?

The October 21, 2026 county roll holds 76 homes in Stillwater Unit 1, 35 in Unit 2 and 140 in Unit 3, all built from 2000 to 2016, plus 27 Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater built in 2025 and 2026, with 107 Shores lots still coded vacant (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Stillwater's five recorded plats on the county roll. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov). Use code 0100 is the county's single-family detached code; 0101 is the code every Unit 3 home carries.

Plat on the roll Parcels Homes with heated area Use code of the homes Median heated sq ft (range) Middle half Years built (median)
Stillwater Unit 1 77 76 0100 2,204 (1,961 to 3,548) 2,068 to 2,466 2000 to 2016 (2004)
Stillwater Unit 2 36 35 0100 2,181 (1,976 to 2,525) 2,181 to 2,333 2005 to 2006 (2006)
Stillwater Unit 3 141 140 0101 1,349 (1,338 to 1,730) 1,349 to 1,525 2007 to 2013 (2011)
Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A 54 19 0100 or 0101 1,977 (1,574 to 2,204) 1,948 to 2,088 2025 to 2026 (2026)
Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B 86 8 0100 or 0101 1,574 (all 8) 1,574 2026
All five plats 394 278 128 coded 0100, 150 coded 0101 1,616 (1,338 to 3,548) 1,349 to 2,181 2000 to 2026 (2009)

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026)

Two features of the roll matter most for a seller. The older plats do not overlap in size: the smallest Unit 1 home, 1,961 heated square feet, is larger than the largest Unit 3 home, 1,730 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). And Unit 2 is the most uniform plat in Stillwater, with all 35 homes built in 2005 or 2006 and a middle half of 2,181 to 2,333 square feet, so Unit 2 homes compare closely with each other when they do sell.

Each older plat also holds one parcel coded 0900, which we read as a common tract, and Shores at Stillwater holds 4 parcels coded 0900 and 2 coded 0001 by the same reading (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Those parcels carry no homes and no sales in our figures.

How Did Each Stillwater Plat Sell Over 12, 24, 36 and 60 Months?

Each Stillwater plat recorded its own price level in every window. Over 36 months Unit 3's 26 resales had a $318,750 median, Unit 1's 13 resales $565,000 and Unit 2's 8 resales $571,000, while Shores at Stillwater's 16 first sales, all recorded in 2026, had a $523,250 median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Stillwater qualified home sales by plat and window. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, qualified improved sales over $1,000 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov). Every older-plat sale is a resale; every Shores sale is a first sale. Figures are medians with the middle half in brackets unless stated.

Plat 12 months: sales, median price, median $ per heated sq ft 24 months 36 months 60 months
Unit 1 7; $550,000 (range $450,000 to $590,000); $214 12; $562,500 ($507,500 to $612,500); $261 13; $565,000 ($515,000 to $605,000); $261 21; $590,000 ($540,000 to $702,500); $264
Unit 2 2; $550,000 and $620,000 (too few for a median); $246 and $268 6; $546,000 ($495,750 to $605,000); $251 8; $571,000 ($510,500 to $615,000); $262 10; $593,500 ($531,500 to $622,500); $262
Unit 3 10; $282,500 ($266,875 to $302,750); $198 21; $305,000 ($282,500 to $340,000); $215 26; $318,750 ($288,750 to $360,625); $222 39; $350,000 ($302,000 to $390,000); $237
Units 1 and 2 combined 9; $550,000 ($477,000 to $580,000); $246 18; $555,000 ($500,000 to $605,000); $259 21; $565,000 ($515,000 to $610,000); $261 31; $592,000 ($542,000 to $640,000); $264
All older-plat resales 19; $315,000 ($280,000 to $550,000); $203 39; $362,500 ($302,000 to $550,000); $222 47; $390,000 ($315,000 to $560,000); $236 70; $402,750 ($341,250 to $590,000); $258
Shores at Stillwater first sales 16; $523,250 ($419,450 to $662,575); $267 Same 16 Same 16 Same 16

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026)

Read the table across, then down. Across, Unit 3's median price fell from $350,000 over 60 months to $282,500 over the last 12, and its rate per square foot from $237 to $198; Unit 1's median rate fell from $264 to $214 over the same windows (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Longer windows include the 2022 and 2023 sales that set the peak, so the shorter the window, the closer it sits to today's price. Down, the gap between Unit 3 and Units 1 and 2 held in every window: Unit 3's 12-month median was about 51.4 percent of Unit 1's (our arithmetic, $282,500 against $550,000), and the two never overlapped at the median.

The 12-month Unit 1 rate deserves a second look. Unit 1's $214 median per square foot over 12 months sits well below its $261 over 24 and 36 months, and the 12-month Unit 1 sales included three of the larger Unit 1 homes, at 2,281, 2,368 and 2,501 heated square feet, which recorded $197, $192 and $200 a square foot (our reading of the 36-month resale list; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Larger homes often record a lower rate per square foot, and the next H2 on size covers why. A Unit 1 seller should compare with Unit 1 sales of similar size, not with the plat median rate.

What Do the Use Codes 0100 and 0101 Tell a Stillwater Seller?

The county's use codes tell a Stillwater seller which sales compare. All 111 homes in Units 1 and 2 carry code 0100, single-family detached; all 140 Unit 3 homes carry code 0101, as do the finished Shores villas. Over 12 months, 0100 sales recorded a $550,000 median and 0101 sales $301,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

The roll does not say how the Unit 3 homes are built or joined, and we found no plat, declaration or county record that does, so this page describes Unit 3 only as Stillwater's small-home section coded 0101, with a median of 1,349 heated square feet (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). Whether a Unit 3 home is attached or detached: UNVERIFIED. The recorded plat and declaration for Unit 3 settle it, and a buyer's lender will ask, which a later section on financing explains.

Stillwater 12-month and 24-month qualified sales by use code. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov). Each code mixes older-plat resales and Shores first sales.

Use code 12 months: sales, median, range 24 months: sales, median, range Which homes carry it
0100 21; $550,000; $450,000 to $766,700 30; $555,000; $450,000 to $766,700 All Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes; 17 finished Shores homes
0101 14; $301,000; $250,000 to $407,600 25; $317,500; $250,000 to $407,600 All 140 Unit 3 homes; 10 finished Shores homes, including the 1,574 sq ft Phase 1B villas

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026)

At Shores the code is not a pure product label. Nine of the 10 Shores parcels coded 0101 are 1,574 square foot homes, and the tenth, 2,204 square feet, is the parcel at Pulte's sales center address (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). The district record counts the product by lot: 136 attached homes on 34-foot lots and 119 detached homes on 52-foot lots in the approved plans (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026).

For pricing, the code is a first filter. A Unit 3 home's 0101 code puts its closest recorded comparables in Unit 3 first and in the Shores villas second, and the Shores villas' recorded range, $375,000 to $407,600, sat above every Unit 3 resale in the last 12 months, whose top was $315,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). That gap is what a new villa's age, glass, roof and warranty buy, and it is the gap Pulte's $364,990 quick move-in villa has narrowed.

How Do Years Built Split Stillwater Into Price Groups?

Years built split Stillwater into three groups: Unit 1 homes from 2000 to 2016, half of them from 2003 to 2005; Unit 2 homes in 2005 and 2006; and Unit 3 homes from 2007 to 2013, half from 2010 to 2013. Shores at Stillwater's 27 roll homes date to 2025 and 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Stillwater homes by years built on the county roll. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov); age in 2026 is our arithmetic.

Plat Years built (median) Age in 2026 Original roof 15 years or older in 2026? (our arithmetic) More than 20 years old in 2026?
Unit 1 2000 to 2016 (2004) 10 to 26 years Yes for homes built 2000 to 2011 Yes for homes built 2000 to 2005
Unit 2 2005 to 2006 (2006) 20 to 21 years Yes Yes for the 2005 homes; the 2006 homes pass 20 in 2027
Unit 3 2007 to 2013 (2011) 13 to 19 years Yes for homes built 2007 to 2011 No; the first reach 20 in 2027
Shores at Stillwater 2025 to 2026 0 to 1 year No No

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026)

Build year shows up in a Stillwater price through insurance, not through age alone. Florida Statutes 627.7011(5) protects a roof under 15 years old from refusal solely for age, and for an older roof an inspection showing at least 5 years of remaining useful life protects eligibility (Florida Statutes 627.7011, read November 17, 2026). Many original roofs in Stillwater may already have been replaced, which is unverified per home; the permit record shows it. Citizens requires a four-point inspection on homes "more than 20 years old" (Citizens, Inspections, read November 17, 2026), and each buyer's insurer sets its own rule.

The repeat-sale record by plat reflects the same split in time. Over 24 months, Unit 3 resales recorded a median 75.9 percent above the same home's earlier qualified sale across 17 pairs, Unit 2 47.7 percent across 5 and Unit 1 30.9 percent across 9; many of Unit 3's earlier sales were recorded from 2010 to 2013, when those homes were new and recorded prices were low (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Those are recorded prices only, not profit: they leave out roofs, systems, closing costs, financing and carrying costs, which the earlier section on what the comparison leaves out covers.

How Do Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A and Phase 1B First Sales Differ?

Shores at Stillwater's two phases sold different products. Over 12 months Phase 1A's 12 first sales had a $564,750 median at $290 a heated square foot, and Phase 1B's 4 first sales, all 1,574 square foot villas, a $390,300 median at $248 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Shores at Stillwater first sales by phase, 12 months (October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026). Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov). Every Shores sale in the file is a first sale.

Phase First sales Median price Price range Median $ per heated sq ft (range) Heated sq ft of the homes sold
Phase 1A 12 $564,750 $455,000 to $766,700 $290 ($234 to $385) 1,704 to 2,204
Phase 1B 4 $390,300 $375,000 to $407,600 $248 ($238 to $259) 1,574 (all four)
Both phases 16 $523,250 $375,000 to $766,700 $267 ($234 to $385) 1,574 to 2,204

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026)

The Phase 1A range is wide because Pulte's single-family buyers choose plans, options, homesites and pools. Three Phase 1A homes the county records at 1,948 heated square feet closed at $594,200 in February 2026, $535,300 in April and $455,000 in October, a $139,200 spread for the same recorded size (our arithmetic on the Shores first-sales list; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The highest rate, $385 a square foot, belongs to a 1,989 square foot home that closed at $766,700 in June 2026. A Unit 1 or Unit 2 seller should not take the Phase 1A median as a target; the recorded spread shows how much of a Shores price is options and lot.

No Shores at Stillwater home has resold on the county file yet. Every Shores sale through October 14, 2026 is a first sale, and the first was recorded February 27, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A Shores owner who sells in 2027 will be the first resale in a section where the builder is still selling new homes beside it, which is the Unit 3 seller's position today in reverse.

Which Plat Is Your Stillwater Home In, and Why Does the Street Not Settle It?

Your Stillwater plat is printed in the legal description on your Property Appraiser record, and that, not the street name, sets your comparables. The county roll groups older Stillwater streets by section, not by unit: Abercrombie Drive alone holds 87 parcels and Clear Lake Drive 51 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Stillwater streets on the county roll. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov), as published in our Stillwater neighborhood guide. No house numbers are printed.

Street on the roll Parcels Section
Abercrombie Dr 87 Older Stillwater
Clear Lake Dr 51 Older Stillwater
Niagara Ct 32 Older Stillwater
Ontario Ct 21 Older Stillwater
Abercrombie Ave 19 Older Stillwater
Lake Tahoe Ct 18 Older Stillwater
Lake Victoria Ct 14 Older Stillwater
Montigello Ct 9 Older Stillwater
Tavira Pl 86 Shores at Stillwater
Silver Shores Blvd 53 Shores at Stillwater
Medical Blvd 2 One in each section

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026)

Abercrombie Drive and Abercrombie Avenue are two different streets, and listings near both appear in search results under one community name, so a buyer's agent can pull the wrong comparables if the plat is not checked (our reading of the roll). Before we price a Stillwater home we read the plat on the record card, then the use code, then the heated area, then the sales in that plat. The street confirms the address; it does not choose the price.

Is your home in Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3 or Shores at Stillwater? We price it against its own plat's recorded sales, its own use code and the Pulte plan nearest its size. Request your free Stillwater valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How Do Size and Bedrooms Change a Stillwater Price?

Size changes a Stillwater price more than bedrooms do. Over 36 months, older Stillwater resales under 1,400 heated square feet recorded a $302,000 median and resales of 1,800 to 2,199 square feet $562,500, while two-bedroom and three-bedroom Unit 3 homes sold in the same band (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; 36-month window October 15, 2023 to October 14, 2026, 47 qualified older-plat resales; Pulte pages read November 17, 2026, builder-stated)

We use 36 months for size and bedrooms in Stillwater in Englewood because 12 months holds only 19 older-plat resales, too few to split by size and room count. The 36-month window holds 47 resales, 13 in Unit 1, 8 in Unit 2 and 26 in Unit 3 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). It includes 2024 sales recorded at higher prices than today's, so every band below reads a little above the 2026 level, and we say where that matters. Heated area is the county's figure, which excludes garages and covered lanais.

How Does Heated Size Change a Stillwater Price?

Heated size sorts Stillwater resales into two price levels with a gap between them. Over 36 months the two bands under 1,800 square feet, essentially Unit 3, recorded medians of $302,000 and $324,000; the two bands from 1,800 to 2,599 square feet, Units 1 and 2, recorded $562,500 and $590,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Older Stillwater resales by heated size, 36 months (October 15, 2023 to October 14, 2026). Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov). Qualified improved sales over $1,000; middle half in brackets.

Heated size band Resales Median price (middle half) Price range Median $ per heated sq ft (middle half) Rate range
Under 1,400 sq ft 13 $302,000 ($278,750 to $356,250) $250,000 to $395,000 $224 ($207 to $264) $187 to $293
1,400 to 1,799 sq ft 13 $324,000 ($295,000 to $375,000) $279,000 to $435,000 $211 ($195 to $246) $183 to $264
1,800 to 2,199 sq ft 10 $562,500 ($539,000 to $601,500) $483,000 to $685,000 $268 ($261 to $276) $221 to $315
2,200 to 2,599 sq ft 11 $590,000 ($500,000 to $620,000) $450,000 to $630,000 $246 ($200 to $261) $192 to $278
2,600 sq ft and up 0 No resale in the window

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026)

The jump between the second and third bands is the plat boundary, not a price for 400 extra square feet. Every resale under 1,800 square feet in the window was a Unit 3 home, and every resale of 1,800 square feet or more was in Unit 1 or Unit 2 (our reading of the 36-month resale list; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The $238,500 gap between the 1,400 to 1,799 band median and the 1,800 to 2,199 band median (our arithmetic) is what a buyer pays to move from Stillwater's small-home section to its single-family plats.

No older Stillwater home of 2,600 square feet or more resold in 36 months. The roll holds homes up to 3,548 square feet in Unit 1, so a seller of one of the largest Unit 1 homes has no recent same-size resale in Stillwater to point to (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). For those homes we widen to 60 months, where Unit 1's range reached $900,000 and its largest sold home 3,253 square feet, and then to comparable homes outside Stillwater, dated and adjusted.

Why Does Price per Square Foot Fall in the Largest Stillwater Homes?

Price per square foot falls in the largest Stillwater homes because a buyer pays for the house and lot as a whole, and the last few hundred square feet add less than the first. Over 36 months the 1,800 to 2,199 square foot band recorded $268 a square foot and the 2,200 to 2,599 band $246 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

The record shows the pattern inside Unit 1. In the 36-month list, Unit 1 homes of 2,141 to 2,229 heated square feet recorded $261 to $315 a square foot, while the Unit 1 homes of 2,281, 2,368 and 2,501 square feet that sold from November 2025 to February 2026 recorded $197, $192 and $200 (our reading of the 36-month resale list; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Part of that is timing, because those three closed in the 2025 to 2026 market rather than 2024 and early 2025, and part is size.

Unit 1 resales in the 36-month window by heated size. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov); rates per square foot are our arithmetic on the recorded price and heated area. No addresses.

Sale month Recorded price Heated sq ft $ per heated sq ft (ours) Year built Beds and baths (roll)
May 2025 $530,000 1,961 $270 2003 3 and 2
July 2025 $560,000 2,141 $262 2001 3 and 2
May 2026 $570,000 2,152 $265 2005 3 and 2
March 2025 $630,000 2,167 $291 2001 3 and 2
March 2026 $565,000 2,167 $261 2001 3 and 2
February 2025 $685,000 2,178 $315 2005 3 and 2
June 2024 $590,000 2,229 $265 2005 3 and 2
February 2026 $450,000 2,281 $197 2004 3 and 2
January 2026 $454,000 2,368 $192 2005 3 and 3
March 2025 $620,000 2,376 $261 2000 4 and 3
March 2026 $590,000 2,376 $248 2000 4 and 3
November 2025 $500,000 2,501 $200 2004 3 and 2
November 2025 $550,000 2,565 $214 2003 3 and 2

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026)

Two rows show the same home twice. A 2,167 square foot Unit 1 home recorded $630,000 in March 2025 and $565,000 in March 2026, and a 2,376 square foot home $620,000 in March 2025 and $590,000 in March 2026, each resold below the price recorded at the earlier sale, 10.3 and 4.8 percent (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Condition, updates and contract terms are not in the record, so the table shows a direction, not a price for your home. What it does say: a large Unit 1 home cannot be priced at the plat's median rate per square foot times its size, because the largest homes recorded the lowest rates.

How Wide Is the Price Range for the Same Unit 3 Size?

The price range for one Unit 3 size in Stillwater is wide, mostly because of when each home sold. Over 36 months, nine Unit 3 resales the county records at 1,349 heated square feet closed from $265,000 to $395,000, a $130,000 spread for the same recorded size (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Unit 3 resales by recorded heated size, 36 months. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov); grouping, medians and spreads are our arithmetic on the 36-month resale list.

Recorded heated size Resales Recorded prices, low to high Median (ours) Rate per sq ft range (ours)
1,338 sq ft 4 $250,000; $267,500; $315,000; $345,000 $291,250 $187 to $258
1,349 sq ft 9 $265,000 to $395,000 $302,000 $196 to $293
1,501 sq ft 4 $280,000; $305,000; $330,000; $390,000 $317,500 $187 to $260
1,524 to 1,538 sq ft 8 $279,000 to $390,000 $322,000 $183 to $256
1,649 sq ft 1 $435,000 One sale $264

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026)

Time explains most of the spread. Unit 3's calendar-year resale median was $370,000 on 9 sales in 2024, $324,000 on 7 in 2025 and $282,500 on 10 in 2026 to October 14 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The four 1,349 square foot homes that recorded $350,000 to $395,000 all sold in 2024, and the five that recorded $265,000 to $302,000 sold in 2025 and 2026 (our reading of the 36-month list). A Unit 3 seller who sees a 2024 sale of the same size quoted as a comparable should know the market it closed in.

Size steps inside Unit 3 are small. The 1,501 and 1,524 to 1,538 square foot groups recorded medians of $317,500 and $322,000, about $15,500 to $20,000 above the 1,349 square foot group's $302,000 (our arithmetic), for 150 to 190 more square feet (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A larger Unit 3 home earns more, but not at the full plat rate per square foot.

Do Bedrooms Add Value in Stillwater?

Bedrooms add little to a Stillwater price once size and plat are known. Over 36 months, two-bedroom Unit 3 resales recorded a $320,000 median on 15 sales and three-bedroom Unit 3 resales $300,000 on 11, so the third bedroom in Unit 3 did not carry a higher recorded price (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Older Stillwater resales by bedroom count on the county roll, 36 months. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov). Unit 3 rows are our arithmetic on the 36-month resale list.

Bedrooms (roll) Resales Median price Price range or middle half Where
2 bedrooms 15 $320,000 Middle half $302,000 to $350,000; range $265,000 to $435,000 All in Unit 3
3 bedrooms 29 $500,000 Middle half $355,000 to $567,500; range $250,000 to $685,000 Unit 3, Unit 1 and Unit 2
4 bedrooms 3 $620,000 Range $590,000 to $620,000 Units 1 and 2
Unit 3, 2 bedrooms 15 $320,000 $265,000 to $435,000 Unit 3
Unit 3, 3 bedrooms 11 $300,000 $250,000 to $395,000 Unit 3

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026)

The three-bedroom row is a blend, not a premium. Its $500,000 median mixes 11 Unit 3 homes with 18 Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes, so it mostly reports which plat the three-bedroom homes sit in (our arithmetic on the list; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Inside Unit 3 the two-bedroom median ran $20,000 above the three-bedroom median, which likely reflects size and sale year more than room count: the 1,649 square foot Unit 3 home that recorded $435,000 in May 2024 is a two-bedroom home on the roll. The roll counts for the 251 older homes are 83 two-bedroom, 159 three-bedroom and 9 four-bedroom homes, and 231 of the 251 have 2 baths (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

Roll room counts are the county's record, not an inspection. If your home has a converted den or an added bath, the permit file and the floor plan prove it, and an appraiser will count rooms from what is permitted. We price a Stillwater home by plat, size and condition first, and treat bedroom count as a check on the buyer pool, not a price step.

How Does Your Stillwater Home's Size Compare With Pulte's Plans?

A Stillwater home's size decides which Pulte plan a buyer will hold it against. Unit 3's 1,349 square foot median sits beside the 1,321 square foot Colton at $309,990, larger Unit 3 homes beside the 1,579 square foot Ellenwood, and Units 1 and 2 beside the Prestige (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

Stillwater resale sizes against the nearest Pulte plan. Stillwater figures from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov); Pulte figures builder-stated, read November 17, 2026 (Pulte). County heated area and Pulte's plan area are measured differently. Differences are our arithmetic.

Stillwater group, 12 months Median recorded price Median heated sq ft sold Nearest Pulte plan and size Pulte base price Pulte base minus the Stillwater median (ours)
Unit 3 resales (10) $282,500 1,349 Colton, 1,321 $309,990 $27,490
Larger Unit 3 homes (1,501 to 1,538 sq ft; 36-month median $317,500 to $322,000) $317,500 to $322,000 1,501 to 1,538 Ellenwood, 1,579 $331,990 (quick move-in $364,990) $9,990 to $14,490 at base
Unit 1 resales (7) $550,000 2,368 Prestige, 2,080+ $452,990 $97,010 below the Unit 1 median
Unit 2 resales (2) $550,000 and $620,000 2,056 and 2,525 Palmary, 1,943+, or Prestige, 2,080+ $424,990 and $452,990 Too few for a median

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; Pulte pages read November 17, 2026, builder-stated)

The comparison reverses between the plats. A Unit 3 resale is priced below Pulte's nearest base price, before options, lot and offer, so the Unit 3 case is value: a finished home that the district record indicates carries no district debt line, at a lower recorded price (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Pulte, builder-stated). A Unit 1 resale at the $550,000 median is priced above the Prestige's base price, so the Unit 1 case is size, finished extras and the missing district line, and the Shores first-sale record of $523,250 shows what Pulte's single-family buyers actually paid once options and lots were added.

Does a Lake View or a Pool Change a Stillwater Price?

A lake view or a pool may change what a buyer offers for a Stillwater home, but the public record does not measure either, so we print no premium for them. The county sales cuts we use carry no waterfront or pool flag, and no source we read measures either effect (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

What we can say is what each feature means for a buyer comparing you with Pulte. Pulte's November offer valued a standard pool at $69,500 on select to-be-built homes, which tells a buyer what Pulte says a new pool is worth, not what a used one adds to a resale (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). Pulte also markets "Water and preserve views" at Shores (same page). The street names in older Stillwater suggest its internal lakes, which the plats and county aerials show; whether a given lot faces water is a fact for the plat and the record card (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

For a listing, that means three rules. Say a home faces a lake only if the plat or record card shows it. Show the pool, cage and any permitted lanai with their permits and final inspections. And price both through the comparable sales that had them, identified from each comparable's listing history when we prepare your pricing opinion, not from a rule of thumb.

How does your Stillwater home's size compare with the recorded sales and Pulte's nearest plan? We set your heated area, bedrooms and plat against the county record and Pulte's dated prices before we give you a number. Request your free Stillwater valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How Do We Price a Stillwater Home?

We price a Stillwater home from same-plat resales first, then by heated size and condition, then against Pulte's live price for the nearest plan net of its offer, then by the roof, insurance and permit file. Over 12 months older Stillwater resales recorded a median $203 a heated square foot, down from $282 in calendar 2023 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; 12-month window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; calendar years 2015 to 2026, with 2026 through October 14; Florida Statutes and Property Appraiser publications read November 17, 2026; Pulte pages read November 17, 2026, builder-stated)

A community median is context, not a price. The $485,000 median for all of Stillwater in Englewood blends Pulte first sales with older resales and Unit 3's small homes with Unit 1's larger ones, so it describes no actual house (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The steps below are how we narrow the county record to yours, and they differ from pricing in an older Englewood neighborhood in one way: in Stillwater the builder next door is still a seller, so its dated price for the nearest plan is part of the comparable set. For our full Englewood listing process, from pricing to marketing to negotiation, read how we sell homes in Englewood.

Why Do We Start a Stillwater Price With the Plat?

We start a Stillwater price with the plat because the plat sets the comparable pool. Over 12 months Unit 3 resales ran $250,000 to $315,000 and Unit 1 resales $450,000 to $590,000, with no overlap, and their median rates were $198 and $214 a heated square foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

We confirm the plat on your Property Appraiser record before anything else: the legal description names STILLWATER UNIT 1, UNIT 2 or UNIT 3, or SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1A or 1B (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). Then we read the use code, 0100 in Units 1 and 2 and 0101 in Unit 3, the heated area and the year built. Only then do we pull sales, and we pull them from your plat first, because a Unit 1 price built on Unit 3 sales, or the reverse, would miss by more than $200,000 at the median.

We also exclude the wrong Stillwater. The county file holds 7 parcels under "Stillwater on the Bay," with Sarasota 34231 addresses, which share part of the name and none of the market (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). Every figure on this page is limited to the five Englewood plats, 394 parcels, all Englewood 34223 addresses (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

How Do We Use Price per Square Foot on a Stillwater Home?

We use price per heated square foot to bracket a Stillwater price, never to set it. For a Unit 3 home of the roll's 1,349 square foot median, the 12-month Unit 3 middle half of $186 to $223 a square foot brackets about $250,900 to $300,800, before condition, roof, updates and the file (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Illustration only: Stillwater 12-month middle-half rates per heated square foot applied to the roll's median home of each plat. Rates and sizes from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov); the bracket column is our arithmetic, not a price or an appraisal.

Group, 12 months Sales Median $ per heated sq ft Middle half $ per sq ft Median home of the group on the roll Bracket (our arithmetic)
Unit 3 resales 10 $198 $186 to $223 1,349 sq ft $250,914 to $300,827
Unit 1 resales 7 $214 $197 to $261 2,204 sq ft $434,188 to $575,244
Units 1 and 2 resales 9 $246 $199 to $263 2,181 sq ft (Unit 2) $434,019 to $573,603
Shores at Stillwater first sales 16 $267 $241 to $329 1,948 sq ft $469,468 to $640,892
Unit 3 resales, 24 months 21 $215 $198 to $233 1,349 sq ft $267,102 to $314,317

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026)

The table shows why a bracket is only a start. The Unit 3 bracket, $49,913 wide, sits around the Unit 3 median of $282,500, which is what a uniform product should show; the Unit 1 bracket is $141,056 wide (our arithmetic), because it rests on 7 sales of different sizes, ages and condition (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The 24-month Unit 3 bracket runs about $16,000 higher at the low end than the 12-month one, which is the 2024 and early 2025 market showing through, and it is why we date every comparable we use.

Inside any bracket, the items that move a Stillwater home up or down are the ones a buyer's inspector, insurer and lender check: heated size and layout, roof age and permit, windows and opening protection, HVAC age, any pool or lanai with permits, the flood file, the association's estoppel figures and condition. The section on size above shows why the largest Unit 1 homes sit at the low end of their plat's rate range.

What Does the Calendar-Year Trend Say About Today's Stillwater Price?

The calendar-year trend says today's Stillwater price sits below the 2023 peak, so a listing priced from the peak sits. The median rate for older Stillwater resales rose from $143 a heated square foot in 2015 to $282 in 2023, then fell to $264 in 2024, $230 in 2025 and $203 in 2026 to date (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Older Stillwater resales by calendar year: count, median price and median $ per heated square foot, with Unit 3 and Unit 1 medians. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov). 2026 runs through October 14. Where a unit had fewer than 3 sales we give the count only.

Calendar year Resales Median price Median $ per heated sq ft Unit 1 (sales, median) Unit 2 (sales, median) Unit 3 (sales, median)
2015 19 $295,000 $143 7, $347,000 4, $318,500 8, $207,500
2016 11 $235,000 $163 3, $350,000 1, too few for a median 7, $223,500
2017 11 $335,000 $150 6, $363,000 1, too few for a median 4, $246,900
2018 27 $269,900 $167 8, $377,500 5, $345,000 14, $251,000
2019 18 $322,000 $167 7, $360,000 5, $330,000 6, $256,450
2020 13 $271,000 $185 3, $449,500 1, too few for a median 9, $255,000
2021 13 $377,600 $191 5, $392,000 3, $425,000 5, $275,000
2022 11 $400,900 $263 4, $667,750 0 7, $380,000
2023 10 $539,950 $282 4, $790,000 1, too few for a median 5, $403,000
2024 13 $390,000 $264 1, too few for a median 3, $592,000 9, $370,000
2025 17 $500,000 $230 7, $560,000 3, $542,000 7, $324,000
2026 to October 14 17 $305,000 $203 5, $565,000 2, too few for a median 10, $282,500

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026)

The rate column is the better guide, because the median price column swings with how many Unit 3 homes sold that year: 2026's $305,000 median reflects 10 Unit 3 sales out of 17, and 2025's $500,000 reflects 10 Unit 1 and Unit 2 sales out of 17 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). By rate, the 2026 median of $203 is about 28.0 percent below 2023's $282 and about 6.3 percent above 2021's $191 (our arithmetic). Within Unit 3, where the product is uniform, the median fell from $403,000 in 2023 to $282,500 in 2026 to date.

We price against the most recent sales, not the peak. A seller who bought in 2022 or 2023 should expect the comparables we show to sit below that purchase: in the last 12 months, all 3 resales whose earlier qualified sale was in 2022 or later recorded below that earlier price, a median 8.7 percent below, from 10.3 to 4.8 percent (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Those are recorded prices only; they leave out what each owner spent on the home and the costs on both ends of each sale.

Why Shouldn't a Stillwater Price Start From What You Paid?

A Stillwater price should not start from what you paid, because a buyer pays what today's comparables and Pulte's offer support. Over 12 months, 15 older resales with an earlier qualified sale resold a median 12.2 percent above it, but ranged from 10.3 percent below to 77.4 percent above (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Older Stillwater resales against the same home's earlier qualified sale, 12 months, by when the earlier sale happened. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov). "Above" and "below" compare recorded prices only; the earliest qualified sale on the file is dated January 6, 2009.

Earlier qualified sale Resales Median change Above / below Range
Before 2020 10 50.5 percent above 10 / 0 6.4 to 77.4 percent above
2020 to 2021 2 Too few for a median 2 / 0 6.4 and 10.1 percent above
2022 or later 3 8.7 percent below 0 / 3 10.3 to 4.8 percent below
All with an earlier sale 15 12.2 percent above 12 / 3 10.3 percent below to 77.4 percent above

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026)

The rows sort by purchase date because the market did. An owner whose earlier sale predates 2020 is selling into today's prices from a much lower base; an owner who bought in 2022 or later bought near the peak the calendar-year table shows (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Neither group's purchase price tells a buyer anything about your home's value today. For pricing, we read your own earlier sale the same way: we show you where same-plat homes bought in your year landed and why, and we never set a list price from a purchase price, up or down.

Is the County's Just Value the Price of a Stillwater Home?

No. A Stillwater tax notice shows the Property Appraiser's January 1 value, and a sale later in the year can record above or below it. Florida law also resets a buyer's assessment after a sale: property "shall be assessed at just value as of January 1 of the year following a change of ownership" (Florida Statutes 193.155).

Three rules explain why the county figure lags a sale in Stillwater. First, the valuation date: Florida values property as of January 1 (the reset rule above is written to that date), so a tax notice describes values as of a date months before your sale, in a market where older Stillwater resale rates moved from $230 a square foot in 2025 to $203 in 2026 to date (Florida Statutes 193.155; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Second, new homes: "Improvements or portions not substantially completed on January 1 shall have no value placed thereon" (Florida Statutes 192.042, read November 17, 2026), which is why 107 Shores at Stillwater parcels were still coded vacant on the 2026 roll while 16 first sales closed during the year. Third, the caps: the Property Appraiser's 2026 supplement says "Property assessment increases for this year are capped by statute at 2.7% for homesteaded properties and 10% for non- homesteaded properties" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, 2026 supplement, read November 17, 2026), so an assessed value on a long-held homestead can sit far below just value.

The same supplement warns buyers directly: "If you purchased property after January 1, 2026, it may show assessment limitations and applicable exemptions from the previous owner. Per Florida Statute, the property will reset to market value on January 1, 2027" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, 2026 supplement). Long tenure is common in older Stillwater: of 211 older-plat homes with a qualified sale on file, the median is 9 years since the last one, and 93 are at 10 years or more (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). For those homes the seller's tax bill understates the buyer's next bill, and neither the just value nor the assessed value is an offer. Parcel-level just and assessed values for Stillwater homes were not read for this page, so we print no ratio. The tax section later on this page explains what your buyer's first bill will look like.

Why Do Online Figures for Stillwater Differ From the County Record?

Online figures for Stillwater differ from the county record because most sites count only listing-service sales, measure area differently, report at the Englewood or ZIP level, and may fold the wrong Stillwater in. Stillwater's 35 qualified sales in 12 months include 16 Pulte first sales, and builder closings are not always listed (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

We do not cite home-value websites as sources. Five generic differences explain why their numbers will not match this page:

  • Which sales count. A count built from listing-service sales can leave out builder closings that never appeared there, and an average can mix the few listed new homes with resales.
  • What a square foot is. The county's heated area excludes the garage and covered lanai; a site that divides by total area under roof prints a lower rate than the county record supports, and Pulte's plan sizes are measured on Pulte's own basis (the county records the Phase 1B villas at 1,574 square feet against Pulte's 1,579 for the Ellenwood) (Pulte, Ellenwood, builder-stated; Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • Which place. Englewood-wide and ZIP-wide pages blend beach, canal and older inland homes with Stillwater's 2000 to 2016 and 2025 to 2026 builds, and a search for "Stillwater" can catch Stillwater on the Bay in Sarasota 34231.
  • Which plat. A Stillwater-wide average hides the Unit 3 and Unit 1 split described above.
  • Which date. Builder pages change prices and offers often, and copies of old builder prices stay indexed after the builder's own page changes.

Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active resale listings in Stillwater and months of supply in Stillwater come from the multiple listing service: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). We do not estimate them. When we prepare your pricing opinion, we pair the county's recorded sales with each comparable's listing history at the time, so you see the asking price, the recorded price and how long each took.

How Will an Appraiser Read a Stillwater Price?

An appraiser will read the same Stillwater county record we do: closed sales near your home in plat, size, age and condition, dated and adjusted. With Unit 3 resales recorded at a $198 median rate over 12 months, a Unit 3 contract well above the recent same-plat sales needs evidence an appraiser can see (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

We send that evidence, through the buyer's lender, before the appraisal: the roof permit with final inspection, the wind mitigation form, any impact window or shutter permits, the HVAC replacement date, permits for any pool, cage or lanai, any elevation certificate, and the association's estoppel figures. For a Shores at Stillwater seller, add the Pulte purchase documents showing plan, options and homesite, and the district's disclosure for your lot (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). For a Unit 3 home, also expect the lender to ask how the home is built and joined, which the recorded plat and declaration answer; the financing section later on this page explains why.

Our valuation for a Stillwater home is built from the recorded sales in your plat and size band, your heated area and year built, Pulte's dated price and offer for the nearest plan, your updates and permits, and your insurance file, then checked against each comparable's listing history. Start with our free Englewood home valuation built from recorded sales, or use the form on this page.

What is your Stillwater home worth against its own plat's resales and Pulte's price for the nearest plan? We read your plat, size, year built, roof and file before we give you a number. Request your free Stillwater valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

When Is the Best Time to Sell in Stillwater?

The best time to sell in Stillwater is when your file is ready and your closing can land in the months Stillwater resales have historically recorded most. From 2015 to October 2026, 69 of 180 older Stillwater resales, about 38.3 percent, recorded in February, March and April, and only 13 in August and September (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; Sarasota County single-family figures for Q3 2026 from Florida Realtors data for the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, released October 16, 2026; Pulte pages read November 17, 2026, builder-stated; Citizens, FEMA, National Hurricane Center and state sources as dated)

A closing follows a contract by weeks, so a sale recorded in March usually reflects a contract signed in January or February. Stillwater in Englewood also runs two calendars at once: older resales, which follow buyers, and Shores at Stillwater first sales, which follow Pulte's construction and delivery schedule (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). The tables below separate the two, then add the countywide calendar, storm season and the dated items that can move a Stillwater sale this winter. We show counts, not monthly medians: a median on one or two sales describes those homes, not the month.

Which Months Did Stillwater Resales and Shores First Sales Close In?

Stillwater resales and Shores first sales closed on different calendars. From January 2025 to October 14, 2026, older-plat resales recorded 17 in 2025 and 17 in 2026, with February 2026's 5 the busiest month, while all 16 Shores first sales recorded from February to October 2026, peaking at 4 in April (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Stillwater qualified home sales by month, older-plat resales and Shores at Stillwater first sales, January 2025 to October 2026. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov). October 2026 runs through October 14 only.

Month Resales Shores first sales Month Resales Shores first sales
January 2025 1 0 January 2026 2 0
February 2025 2 0 February 2026 5 1
March 2025 3 0 March 2026 3 0
April 2025 2 0 April 2026 3 4
May 2025 2 0 May 2026 1 3
June 2025 1 0 June 2026 1 3
July 2025 2 0 July 2026 1 1
August 2025 1 0 August 2026 0 3
September 2025 1 0 September 2026 1 0
October 2025 0 0 October 2026 (to the 14th) 0 1
November 2025 2 0
December 2025 0 0

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026)

The months sum to 17 resales in 2025 and 17 in January to October 14, 2026, matching the calendar-year counts in the same file (our arithmetic; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Two readings follow. In 2026, 10 of the 17 resales recorded from January to March, before the first Shores villas closed in April; from April through September, when Pulte recorded 14 of its 16 first sales, older resales recorded 7. That is consistent with Pulte's new homes taking a share of Stillwater's buyers as they came to market, though 12 months of counts this small cannot prove it. And since July 2026, older Stillwater resales recorded 2 in three and a half months, against 5 Shores first sales.

Which Months Have Stillwater Resales Closed In Since 2015?

Older Stillwater resales have closed most in late winter and spring. Of 180 recorded from January 2015 to October 14, 2026, February had 24, April 23, March 22 and May 20, while August had 6 and September 7 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Older Stillwater resales by month of the year, January 2015 to October 14, 2026. Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (sarasotapropertyappraiser.gov). Shares are our arithmetic. November and December cover 11 years (2015 to 2025); October 2026 is partial.

Month recorded Resales, 2015 to 2026 Share of 180 (ours) Contract usually signed (weeks earlier)
January 14 7.8 percent November or December
February 24 13.3 percent December or January
March 22 12.2 percent January or February
April 23 12.8 percent February or March
May 20 11.1 percent March or April
June 16 8.9 percent April or May
July 11 6.1 percent May or June
August 6 3.3 percent June or July
September 7 3.9 percent July or August
October 11 6.1 percent August or September
November 16 8.9 percent September or October
December 10 5.6 percent October or November

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026)

The pattern gives a Stillwater seller a working calendar. Closings from February to May, 89 of 180 resales, about 49.4 percent (our arithmetic), follow contracts signed from about December to April, so a home photographed, documented and listed by December or January meets the deepest part of the recorded year (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). August and September, 13 resales in nearly twelve years, are the thinnest closing months, which lines up with the storm months described below. November's 16 resales show that a fall listing can still close before year end.

Two cautions. The counts are small, about 15 resales a year on average (our arithmetic; Sarasota County Property Appraiser), so one busy year can tilt a month. And the pattern is a record of older Stillwater homes only; the Shores calendar since February 2026 follows Pulte's deliveries. We do not forecast a month for your home; we use the calendar to plan when to be ready.

How Does Pulte's Calendar Change When to List in Stillwater?

Pulte's calendar matters most to Stillwater Unit 3 sellers, whose homes compete with Pulte's villas. Pulte's November offers end November 30, 2026, two quick move-ins were "Available Now" on November 17, and 107 Shores lots were coded vacant in October, so new homes keep coming (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated; Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

For a Stillwater seller the useful windows come out of Pulte's own dates. A buyer shopping in late November 2026 may carry a Pulte quote with a credit of up to $77,000 or a $69,500 pool that expires November 30; what Pulte offers in December is not published (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's pool offer is for to-be-built homes, which close after construction, so a buyer who needs to be in a home within weeks is choosing between Pulte's two finished homes and the resales on the market. A ready Stillwater resale listed when Pulte's finished inventory is thin meets that buyer with fewer alternatives; we read Pulte's quick move-in list the week you decide.

PulteGroup's own outlook says "we expect our sales incentives to remain elevated and for our pace of house starts to remain dynamic in response to market conditions" (PulteGroup Form 10-Q, read November 17, 2026). For a seller that means there is no month when the builder steps away. Waiting for Pulte to finish is not a plan in 2027; listing a better-documented home than Pulte's next quick move-in is.

What Do Sarasota County's Countywide Figures Add for a Stillwater Seller?

For a Stillwater seller, Sarasota County's countywide figures show a market that tightened in the third quarter of 2026. Single-family homes countywide recorded a $485,000 median, 52 median days to contract, 3.7 months of supply and 94.4 percent of original list price received in Q3 2026 (Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, Q3 2026 Sarasota County single-family summary).

Sarasota County single-family market, Q3 2026, Florida Realtors data for the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, released October 16, 2026. Countywide figures, not Stillwater figures. Source: RASM, Sarasota County Single Family Homes Q3 2026 summary.

Measure, Sarasota County single-family Q3 2026 Q3 2025
Closed sales 2,071 2,010
Median sale price $485,000 $467,500
Median percent of original list price received 94.4 percent 91.9 percent
Median time to contract 52 days 68 days
Median time to sale 92 days 107 days
Active listings (inventory) 2,629 3,137
Months supply of inventory 3.7 4.8

Data updated: November 2026 (RASM Q3 2026 Sarasota County single-family summary, released October 16, 2026, read November 17, 2026)

Stillwater's own record points the other way for recent buyers. The countywide median rose 3.7 percent year over year while older Stillwater resale rates fell from $230 a square foot in 2025 to $203 in 2026 to date (RASM; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The difference is consistent with new-construction competition next door, but county data cannot prove that, and we do not merge the two. The county figure blends every age and area of Sarasota County, so it is context only. Stillwater's 12-month median of $485,000 for all 35 sales happens to equal the county median, but Stillwater's older resale median, $315,000, sits about 35.1 percent below it (our arithmetic). Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active resale listings and months of supply for Stillwater itself: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).

The countywide measure is percent of original list price, not of the final asking price, so it includes any price reductions. A median of 94.4 percent says a typical Sarasota County seller in Q3 2026 accepted about 5.6 percent less than the first asking price (our arithmetic; RASM), which is one reason we price a Stillwater home to the recent same-plat record from the first day rather than leaving room to cut.

How Does Storm Season Change a Stillwater Sale?

Storm season changes a Stillwater sale through insurance, evacuation and the closing calendar. The storms that shaped this coast arrived in September and October: Ian in 2022, Helene and Milton in 2024. Older Stillwater resales have recorded fewest in August and September, 13 of 180 since 2015 (NHC, Hurricane Milton; Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

The National Hurricane Center's reports set the dates. Ian made landfall on Cayo Costa on 28 September 2022; near Englewood, "The majority of the sensors placed in Port Charlotte and Englewood ... remained dry and did not measure storm surge due to offshore winds" (NHC, Hurricane Ian, read November 17, 2026). Helene in late September 2024 brought surge of "4 to 6 ft AGL" "from Venice to south of Englewood" (NHC, Hurricane Helene). Milton "made landfall on Siesta Key, Florida, at 0030 UTC 10 October" 2024, and Sarasota County's evacuation orders were "Mandatory for zones A, B, and C, and for mobile and manufactured homes and boat homes" (NHC, Hurricane Milton; NWS Tampa Bay, Milton county impact narratives, read November 17, 2026). None of those reports names Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater, and we found no report of storm damage inside Stillwater; that does not mean no home was affected, and each seller's disclosure and claim history answers it for a given home.

For a sale, the season shows up in four places:

  • The buyer's insurance quote. A buyer who places wind coverage with Citizens on a Stillwater home needs a flood policy for policies effective from January 1, 2027, "All policies, regardless of value"; outside the high-risk zone the threshold reached $400,000 of dwelling coverage on January 1, 2026 (Citizens, Flood, read November 17, 2026). Whether an insurer will write a new policy while a named storm threatens is set by each insurer, and none of the sources we read publishes a rule for Stillwater, so we ask the buyer to get quotes early in the contract, not the week of closing.
  • The insurer's inspections. Citizens requires a four-point inspection on homes more than 20 years old, and roofs older than 25 years (shingle) need "documentation showing at least five years of remaining useful life" (Citizens, Inspections, read November 17, 2026); other insurers set their own rules. A seller who has a current four-point and wind mitigation report before the season has both answers ready when a buyer's insurer asks.
  • The wind mitigation form. Inspections on or after April 1, 2026 "must use the revised form," OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26), and Citizens still accepts the earlier form if completed within five years before April 1, 2026 with no changes (Citizens, mitigation form bulletin, March 19, 2026).
  • The evacuation calendar. Stillwater's evacuation level is not verified for this page; it appears on Sarasota County's Know Your Zone lookup and on the parcel's TRIM notice (Florida Division of Emergency Management, Know Your Zone). A listing active in late summer needs a storm plan: photos taken before the season, a list of what to secure, and a written note of any post-storm inspection.

Insurance cost has moved in a seller's favor in 2026. Citizens announced it "will reduce rates for its homeowners multiperil policyholders by an average of 8.8% in 2026," with new rates effective July 1 for new policyholders and at renewal for existing ones (Citizens, March 4, 2026, read November 17, 2026). Sarasota County is a Community Rating System Class 5 community, worth a 25 percent discount on NFIP flood policies, on FEMA's list dated October 1, 2026 (FEMA, CRS Eligible Communities, October 2026). Neither is a quote for any Stillwater home.

Which Dated Items Can Change a Stillwater Sale This Winter?

Several dated items can change a Stillwater sale before spring 2027: Pulte's November 30 offer deadline, the 2026 tax bill's early-payment discounts, the Citizens flood rule and the assessment date on January 1, 2027, and the March 1 homestead deadline. Each shifts what a buyer asks or what the closing statement shows (Citizens, Flood).

Dated items for a Stillwater sale, November 2026 to 2029. Sources as cited in each row; all read November 17, 2026.

Date Item Why it matters for a Stillwater sale
November 30, 2026 Pulte's pool and $77,000 credit offers end for contracts accepted from November 2 (Pulte, builder-stated) Buyers shopping now may carry a Pulte quote that expires; the next offer's terms are unknown
November 2026 to February 2027 2026 tax bills discount 4 percent in November, 3 in December, 2 in January, 1 in February (Florida Statutes 197.162) A winter closing settles who pays the 2026 bill, which taxes in arrears
January 1, 2027 Citizens flood requirement reaches "All policies, regardless of value" (Citizens) Every Citizens buyer prices a flood policy; your flood file speeds the quote
January 1, 2027 Assessment date for the 2027 roll; a buyer's value resets to just value on the January 1 after the sale (Florida Statutes 193.155) A closing in late 2026 resets the buyer's assessment for 2027; Shores homes finished in 2026 first appear with building value
Pending Amendment 3: passed with about 62 percent of the vote on unofficial returns on November 3, 2026; not certified and implementing law pending as of November 17, 2026; as written it sets a $150,000 non-school homestead exemption from January 1, 2027 and $250,000 from January 1, 2028 (WGCU, November 4, 2026; HJR text) Not law in force; non-ad valorem lines such as the $290.78 Englewood fire charge are not reduced by it
March 1, 2027 Homestead and portability filing deadline (Florida Statutes 196.011) A buyer who owns the home as a permanent residence on January 1 files by March 1; a seller moving within Florida files at the new home
Mid 2027 FDOT's State Road 776 median and turn-lane project, Charlotte County line to Tangerine Woods Blvd., scheduled to finish (SWFLRoads, FDOT 447882-1) Lane work on State Road 776 near Stillwater through mid 2027
Spring 2027 to Summer 2029 South River Road and Winchester Boulevard widening, $95 million, 7.3 miles (WGCU, November 13, 2026) Construction on the River Road corridor north and east of Stillwater

Data updated: November 2026 (sources as cited, read November 17, 2026)

One more date is personal. The federal home-sale exclusion turns on owning and using the home as a principal residence for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale, and 36 of the 211 older Stillwater homes with a qualified sale on file are under 2 years since that sale (IRS Publication 523; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). An owner close to that line should talk with a tax professional before choosing a closing date; the capital gains section later on this page explains the rule and its partial exclusions as the IRS words them.

Thinking about when to list your Stillwater home? We line up your closing against the recorded Stillwater calendar, Pulte's finished inventory, the insurance calendar and your own two-year date before we pick a list date. Request your free Stillwater valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

What Does Stillwater's Location Add to a Sale?

Stillwater's location adds a mainland Englewood address off Medical Boulevard, beside HCA Florida Englewood Hospital, with Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park about 3.4 road miles and 8 minutes away and Dearborn Street about 2.3 miles and 5 minutes, by routing estimates from an Abercrombie Avenue point on November 17, 2026 (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

Data updated: November 2026 (OSRM free-flow routing estimates computed November 17, 2026 from a point on the 150 block of Abercrombie Avenue, as published in our neighborhood guide; county, state, federal, operator and Pulte sources as dated, all read November 17, 2026)

Every place and rule below is one our neighborhood guide or a county, state, federal or operator source confirms, and each is something a buyer asks about on a showing. The point for a seller in Stillwater in Englewood is to describe the location accurately for your own address: Stillwater is in unincorporated Sarasota County with an Englewood 34223 mailing address and no city of its own, and Pulte's web address files Shores at Stillwater under a "sarasota" market path, which is Pulte's sales label, not the City of Sarasota (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). Stillwater on the Bay, with Sarasota 34231 addresses, is a different place. A listing that gets the county, the roads, the schools and the flood file right sells the location without giving a buyer's agent anything to correct. For the wider town, our Englewood guide covers the area around it.

Which Roads Lead to Stillwater, and What Should a Listing Say About Them?

Medical Boulevard is the way into Stillwater. In the Census Bureau's 2024 road file, Abercrombie Drive and Clear Lake Drive meet Medical Boulevard, which connects to Pine Street, and the district engineer places Shores at Stillwater "approximately 0.8 miles east of Pine Street" (Census TIGER/Line 2024 roads, Sarasota County; Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book).

Pine Street runs north to south along the west edge of older Stillwater, and Abercrombie Avenue links Clear Lake Drive, Abercrombie Drive and Ontario Court inside it (same Census file). Pulte's own directions to Shores at Stillwater run from U.S. 41 along West River Road for 6.5 miles, left on Pine Street, then left on Medical Boulevard to "continue straight for .8 miles" (Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). The same route serves older Stillwater, which is the selling point an older home shares with Pulte: every location claim Pulte makes for Shores at Stillwater rests on the same entrance road.

The larger roads are a short distance away. Measured in a straight line from the center of older Stillwater, State Road 776 is about 1.2 miles west and south, River Road about 1.0 mile north and east, East Dearborn Street about 1.0 mile and Power Line Road about 0.5 mile (Census TIGER/Line 2024 roads, Sarasota County, read November 17, 2026). Those are straight-line distances, not drive distances, and a listing should say "off Medical Boulevard near Pine Street" and leave turn-by-turn directions to the buyer's map app.

How Far Is Stillwater From the Beach, the Hospital, Shopping and Airports?

From an Abercrombie Avenue point in older Stillwater, routing estimates put HCA Florida Englewood Hospital about 0.6 miles and 2 minutes away, Dearborn Street 2.3 miles and 5 minutes, Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park 3.4 miles and 8 minutes, and Punta Gorda Airport 28.7 miles and 49 minutes (OSRM routing table service, computed November 17, 2026).

Drive estimates from older Stillwater. Source: OSRM public routing service, free-flow estimates without traffic, computed November 17, 2026 from a point on the 150 block of Abercrombie Avenue, as published in our Stillwater neighborhood guide; real drive times vary with traffic, construction, season and the exact address.

Destination Road distance, about Drive time, about Straight line
HCA Florida Englewood Hospital, 700 Medical Blvd 0.6 mi 2 min 0.5 mi
Dearborn Street, 100 W Dearborn St block 2.3 mi 5 min 1.5 mi
Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park, 2100 N Beach Rd (Charlotte County) 3.4 mi 8 min 2.1 mi
Venice City Hall, 401 W Venice Ave 13.8 mi 27 min 12.6 mi
I-75 Exit 193, Jacaranda Blvd interchange 14.1 mi 26 min 11.7 mi
North Port City Hall 15.7 mi 28 min 11.8 mi
Boca Grande village (published coordinate) 16.1 mi 31 min 14.5 mi
Port Charlotte Town Center 16.5 mi 25 min 12.6 mi
Punta Gorda Airport (PGD) 28.7 mi 49 min 21.4 mi
Sarasota Bradenton International Airport (SRQ) 42.5 mi 65 min 33.7 mi
Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) 65.8 mi 86 min 45.8 mi

Data updated: November 2026 (OSRM routing estimates computed November 17, 2026; destination points from Census TIGER/Line 2024 address-range files and published airport coordinates)

No agency publishes drive times from a Stillwater street, so a listing should quote these as estimates. Two published claims agree closely with the beach estimate: Pulte says the beaches are "less than 3.5 miles away" from Shores at Stillwater, and Sarasota Magazine put the community "about 3.5 miles from Englewood's beaches" in November 2024 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated; Sarasota Magazine, November 8, 2024, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's other distances, "Only 2.5 miles to Lemon Bay Playhouse" and the Englewood Sports Complex "only 2.5 miles away," are builder-stated and were not routed. One Pulte distance claim could not be matched to an official source, so we do not repeat it.

For groceries, Publix lists Olde Village Publix, store 737, at 55 N Indiana Ave, Englewood, and its newsroom reports a new 54,964 square foot store at Merchants Crossing, 1500 Placida Rd., which opened November 5, 2026 (Publix, Olde Village Publix; Publix newsroom, read November 17, 2026). We did not route a drive time to either store. For a walkable district, Visit Sarasota describes Dearborn Street in Old Englewood Village as "several blocks of independent shops & eateries," with a farmers market "every Thursday (Oct to May)" (Visit Sarasota, Dearborn Street).

What Sits Next Door to Stillwater on Medical Boulevard?

Two public-facing facilities share Medical Boulevard with Stillwater in Englewood. HCA Florida Englewood Hospital, 700 Medical Blvd, describes itself as "our 100-bed acute care hospital" with 24/7 emergency care and a Primary Stroke Center, and the Englewood YMCA is at 701 Medical Blvd (HCA Florida Healthcare, Englewood Hospital; SKY Family YMCA, Englewood YMCA).

The hospital lists "24/7 emergency care, cardiovascular care, general surgery, orthopedics, stroke care and advanced imaging services" (HCA Florida Healthcare, Englewood Hospital, read November 17, 2026). The district engineer places Shores at Stillwater's south parcel "across from the HCA Florida Englewood Hospital," and Pulte markets Shores as "Next door to HCA Florida Englewood Hospital" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; Pulte, builder-stated). We found no source that measures what the hospital does to a Stillwater price, so a listing should state the distance and leave the value to the buyer.

The YMCA, part of SKY Family YMCA, lists branch hours of 5:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. Monday to Thursday, 5:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. Friday, 7:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. Saturday and 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Sunday (SKY Family YMCA, Englewood YMCA, read November 17, 2026). Membership is set by the YMCA, so a listing names the facility and its address, not access. Sarasota Magazine described Pulte's land as "a 32-acre lot west of the YMCA, and across the street, a 45-acre lot east of HCA Florida Englewood Hospital" (Sarasota Magazine, November 8, 2024), which places the two Shores parcels on either side of these facilities.

Water and sewer in this part of Englewood come from Englewood Water District. The Shores at Stillwater engineer's report says its water and sewer lines tie into existing mains in Medical Boulevard and "will be owned and maintained by the Englewood Water District" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book); for an older Stillwater address, confirm service with the district at englewoodwater.com before the listing names a provider.

Which Beaches, Parks and Boat Ramps Can a Stillwater Listing Name?

A Stillwater listing can name Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park on Manasota Key, about 3.4 road miles away by routing estimate, Sarasota County's Manasota Beach and Blind Pass Beach, Lemon Bay Park and Environmental Center, Indian Mound Park's boat ramp, and the Englewood Sports Complex on River Road (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

Public places a Stillwater listing can name. Sources: operator and official tourism pages as read November 17, 2026 and published in our Stillwater neighborhood guide; distance from the OSRM routing estimate where one exists.

Place Operator and address What a listing can say Distance from Stillwater
Englewood Beach at Chadwick Park Charlotte County, 2100 N Beach Rd Gulf beach on Manasota Key; 900-foot boardwalk; pay to park, 75 cents an hour (Charlotte County) 3.4 mi, about 8 min
Manasota Beach Sarasota County, 8570 Manasota Key Rd Beach, lifeguard, boardwalk, boat ramps, docks, canoe and kayak launch (Visit Sarasota) Not measured
Blind Pass Beach Sarasota County, 6725 Manasota Key Rd "almost 3,000 feet of beach frontage" with "Gulf-to-bay access" (Visit Sarasota) Not measured
Lemon Bay Park and Environmental Center Sarasota County, 570 Bay Park Blvd "210-acre nature-based park" with "1.7 miles of shoreline" on Lemon Bay (Visit Sarasota) Pulte says 5 miles (builder-stated)
Indian Mound Park Sarasota County, 210 Winson Ave Boat ramp, canoe launch; FWC lists "Ramp Fee: No," open "6AM to Midnight" (Visit Sarasota; FWC) Not measured
Englewood Sports Complex 1300 S River Rd "136-acre sports complex" with "18 pickleball courts" and "four tennis courts" (Visit Sarasota Sports) Pulte says 2.5 miles (builder-stated)
Lemon Bay Playhouse 96 W Dearborn St Live theater, "Founded in 1987" (Visit Sarasota) Dearborn Street block 2.3 mi, about 5 min

Data updated: November 2026 (operator pages, Visit Sarasota, FWC and OSRM routing estimates, read or computed November 17, 2026)

Two cautions belong in any Stillwater listing that names these places. Sarasota County's own parks site returned an access error on November 17, 2026, so county hours, parking fees and rules for its parks: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026); point buyers to the county. And Stillwater is an inland community, so a listing names public ramps, not a private dock, unless the lot's own record shows one (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

Inside the gate at Shores at Stillwater, the amenities a listing can name are Pulte's, builder-stated: a "Heated community pool," a "Pool cabana with covered seating," "BBQ grills" and "Mail kiosks" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). For the older Stillwater sections, a gate, pool or clubhouse: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026), and whether older-plat owners may use the Shores amenities is not stated in any primary source we read. An older-plat listing should not claim a Shores amenity.

What Road Projects Should a Stillwater Seller Know About?

A Stillwater seller should know three road projects, none of which changes the Medical Boulevard route in: FDOT's State Road 776 median project and its companion resurfacing, both scheduled from mid 2026 to mid 2027, and the county's $95 million South River Road and Winchester Boulevard widening, scheduled from spring 2027 to summer 2029 (SWFLRoads, FDOT 447882-1).

FDOT project 447882-1, "SR 776 From Charlotte County Line to Tangerine Woods Blvd.," is a 2.189-mile project to "improve safety by implementing improved access control, enhancing traffic flow, and reducing crashes," with raised medians, turn lanes and protected bike lanes on the south portion; its page lists the construction phase, a "Mid 2026" start and "Mid 2027" completion, last updated October 20, 2026 (SWFLRoads, FDOT 447882-1, read November 17, 2026). Its companion, project 451014-1, resurfaces about 8 miles of State Road 776 at a construction cost of "$15.4 Million" on the same schedule (SWFLRoads, FDOT fact sheet 451014-1, read November 17, 2026). Trips from Stillwater to Venice, Dearborn Street and the beaches use segments inside those limits.

Suncoast Searchlight, reporting through WGCU on November 13, 2026, said the South River Road and Winchester Boulevard widening covers a 7.3-mile corridor from Tamiami Trail to the Charlotte County line at "$95 million," with a timeline of "Spring 2027 to Summer 2029," and quoted the county: "The South River Road corridor serves as an important evacuation route for Englewood and the barrier islands" (WGCU, November 13, 2026, read November 17, 2026). Final designs were still being drawn, so the schedule may move.

For a listing, the rule is to state these as scheduled public projects with their sources and dates, not as finished improvements, and not to predict their effect on value; no source we read measures one. We found no county or FDOT project that names Medical Boulevard or Pine Street (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

How Does Stillwater Compare With Boca Royale, Coco Bay, Grove City and Englewood East for a Seller?

Stillwater sells two products, 2000 to 2016 homes in three older plats and new Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater, on one hospital-side road in the Sarasota County part of Englewood. Buyers often tour several Englewood communities in the same week, so a Stillwater seller should know the alternatives in words, not in another community's numbers (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

Each of our sister seller guides covers its own community from its own county record. Our guide to selling a home in Boca Royale covers that Englewood golf community, where Neal Communities also lists new homes at Wellen Park, builder-stated (Neal Communities, Boca Royale). Our guide to selling a home in Coco Bay covers the Lennar community at Island Lakes at Coco Bay in Englewood (Lennar, Island Lakes at Coco Bay, builder-stated). Our guide to selling a home in Grove City and our guide to selling a home in Englewood East cover two more Englewood-area markets.

Against those alternatives, an older Stillwater home's case rests on three facts from its own record: a Sarasota County address beside the hospital and YMCA on Medical Boulevard, recorded resale rates below the new homes next door ($203 a square foot against $267 over 12 months), and an older-plat parcel that the Shores at Stillwater district's boundary description indicates is outside the district (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book). A Shores at Stillwater home's case is the reverse: a 2025 or 2026 Pulte home with impact glass and a tile roof as Pulte lists them, with the district line and association fees on the other side of the ledger.

What Should a Stillwater Listing Leave Out or Confirm First?

A Stillwater listing should leave out what no record supports and confirm the rest first: a City of Sarasota label, school claims beyond the district lookup, a Shores amenity on an older-plat home, a lake or pool premium, copied association names or dues, and the evacuation level. Each has a settling document (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

The record behind each point:

  • County and name. Stillwater is unincorporated Sarasota County with an Englewood 34223 address; it is not Stillwater on the Bay in Sarasota 34231 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Say "Stillwater in Englewood" or "Stillwater, Englewood, Florida."
  • Plat and home type. Name the plat from the legal description. For a Unit 3 home, describe it by its heated area and roll use code; whether it is attached or detached is UNVERIFIED in public records, and the recorded plat and declaration settle it.
  • Schools. For the two Stillwater addresses we checked, on Lake Victoria Court and Silver Shores Boulevard, the Sarasota County School Zone Lookup returned Englewood Elementary Zone, L.A. Ainger Middle Zone and Wellen Park High Zone on November 17, 2026 (Sarasota County School Zone Lookup). Quote the lookup result for your own address with its date; a listing names zones, it does not describe or rank schools.
  • Flood zone. The only parcel-level reading we have is Zone X at one Lake Victoria Court address in Stillwater Unit 1, from an earlier check on November 14, 2026, on maps in force since March 27, 2024 (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). Look up your own address on FEMA's Map Service Center and hand buyers any elevation certificate.
  • Evacuation level. Not verified for this page; it appears on the county's Know Your Zone lookup and the TRIM notice (Florida Division of Emergency Management, Know Your Zone). Do not state a level you have not read for your address.
  • Associations and the district. Name an association only from its recorded documents and the estoppel certificate, not from another listing. For an older-plat home, confirm on your own tax bill that no Shores at Stillwater district line appears; for a Shores home, state the district line from the district's disclosure (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book).
  • Water and lot. Say a home faces a lake only if the plat or record card shows it, and print no lake or pool premium; none is measured in the public record.

What a listing can say with confidence is still strong: a home in one of Stillwater's five recorded plats in Sarasota County, off Medical Boulevard beside HCA Florida Englewood Hospital and the Englewood YMCA, about 8 minutes from Englewood Beach and 5 from Dearborn Street by routing estimates, priced from its own plat's recorded sales against the builder next door (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

Selling a Stillwater home in Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3 or Shores at Stillwater this season? We price it from your plat's recorded sales and Pulte's dated prices, and we describe the roads, schools, flood file and amenities accurately for your address. Start your free Stillwater valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

What Must a Stillwater Seller Disclose?

A Stillwater seller in Englewood must disclose known facts that materially affect value and are not readily observable, under Johnson v. Davis; deliver the section 689.302 flood disclosure at or before signing; carry the radon notice; give the section 689.261 property tax summary; supply the section 720.401 HOA disclosure summary; and, at Shores at Stillwater, name the CDD.

This is general information, not legal advice; your closing agent or a Florida real estate attorney decides which duties apply to your sale. Stillwater in Englewood is two markets for disclosure purposes. The older plats, Stillwater Units 1, 2 and 3, hold 251 homes built from 2000 to 2016, and Shores at Stillwater holds 27 Pulte homes built in 2025 and 2026 plus 107 lots still coded vacant on the Sarasota County roll dated October 21, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026). An older Stillwater seller's disclosure questions are mostly about a roof, windows, storms and permits across up to two decades of ownership. A Shores seller's questions are about the builder warranty, an association in a community where Pulte is still the developer and the district debt on the lot. We answer both sets in writing before the listing goes live.

What Is the Known-Defect Duty for a Stillwater Seller?

Under Johnson v. Davis (Fla. 1985), a Stillwater seller who knows of facts materially affecting value that are not readily observable and not known to the buyer must disclose them. The duty covers "all forms of real property, new and used," from a 2004 Unit 1 home to a 2026 Shores villa.

The court's holding: "where the seller of a home knows of facts materially affecting the value of the property which are not readily observable and are not known to the buyer, the seller is under a duty to disclose them to the buyer. This duty is equally applicable to all forms of real property, new and used," and "One should not be able to stand behind the impervious shield of caveat emptor and take advantage of another's ignorance" (Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985), university-hosted copy, read November 17, 2026). The case itself was a roof case: the home was "three years old," it sold for "$310,000" in 1982, and the court found "the Johnsons knew of and failed to disclose that there had been problems with the roof of the house" (same opinion). For Stillwater in Englewood, where every older home was built from 2000 to 2016, that fact pattern is the one to take seriously.

The Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS contract turns the rule into your own written statement in paragraph 10(j): "Seller knows of no facts materially affecting the value of the Real Property which are not readily observable and which have not been disclosed to Buyer" (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline, read November 17, 2026). The same paragraph adds that, except as disclosed in writing, the seller "has received no written or verbal notice from any governmental entity or agency as to a currently uncorrected building, environmental or safety code violation" (same form).

The facts we ask a Stillwater seller about are specific to the home's age and plat. These are our questions, not a statutory list:

  1. Roof history. Any leak, ceiling stain that was painted over, partial repair or full replacement, the year, the contractor and the permit, and any insurer letter about roof age.
  2. Storm water. Water that entered the home, the garage or the lanai, or that stood in the yard, during Ian (2022), Helene or Milton (2024), even if nothing was claimed.
  3. Insurance claims. Any wind, water or flood claim during your ownership, what was paid and what was repaired.
  4. Work without a final inspection. A reroof, air conditioner change-out, water heater, screen enclosure, shutters or windows whose permit was never closed.
  5. Association notices. Any open violation, fine or architectural denial from your Stillwater association.
  6. At Shores at Stillwater. Any Pulte warranty request, what was repaired and whether the repair held; any construction defect notice; and the CDD debt on the lot.

The Florida Realtors seller's property disclosure form, SPDR-4x, is the customary way to document these answers. Florida has no statute requiring that form; its own notice says "Florida law requires a Seller of a home to disclose to the Buyer all known facts that materially affect the value of the property being sold and that are not readily observable or known by the Buyer," citing Johnson v. Davis, and it adds "This disclosure is not a guaranty or warranty of any kind" (Florida Realtors, Seller's Property Disclosure, SPDR-4x Rev 3/25, read November 17, 2026). Its roof section asks "The age of the roof is ___ years OR date installed ___" and "Has the roof ever leaked during your ownership?", and its water section asks "Has past or present water intrusion affected the Property?" and "Do you have an elevation certificate? If yes, please attach a copy" (same form).

Two items Florida says need not be disclosed: the fact that an occupant "is infected or has been infected with human immunodeficiency virus or diagnosed with acquired immune deficiency syndrome," and the fact that a property "was, or was at any time suspected to have been, the site of a homicide, suicide, or death" (Florida Statutes 689.25, read November 17, 2026). One that must: when a sinkhole claim was made and paid, section 627.7073(2)(c) "requires the seller to disclose to the buyer that a claim was paid and whether or not the full amount paid was used to repair the sinkhole damage," as the SPDR form summarizes it (SPDR-4x).

What Does Florida's Flood Disclosure Require in Stillwater?

Section 689.302 requires a Stillwater seller to complete a flood disclosure and give it to the buyer "at or before the time the sales contract is executed." The form asks about flooding, claims and aid during your ownership, not your FEMA zone, so it applies on every Stillwater lot in Englewood, including the one Zone X reading we have.

The duty, verbatim: "A seller must complete and provide a flood disclosure to a purchaser of residential real property at or before the time the sales contract is executed" (Florida Statutes 689.302, read November 17, 2026). The form opens: "Flood Insurance: Homeowners' insurance policies do not include coverage for damage resulting from floods. Buyer is encouraged to discuss the need to purchase separate flood insurance coverage with Buyer's insurance agent." It then asks three questions (same statute):

  1. "Seller has [ ] has no [ ] knowledge of any flooding that has damaged the property during Seller's ownership of the property."
  2. "Seller has [ ] has not [ ] filed a claim with an insurance provider relating to flood damage on the property, including, but not limited to, a claim with the National Flood Insurance Program."
  3. "Seller has [ ] has not [ ] received assistance for flood damage to the property, including, but not limited to, assistance from the Federal Emergency Management Agency."

"Flooding" means "a general or temporary condition of partial or complete inundation of the property caused by any of the following: (a) The overflow of inland or tidal waters. (b) The unusual and rapid accumulation of runoff or surface waters from any established water source, such as a river, stream, or drainage ditch. (c) Sustained periods of standing water resulting from rainfall" (same statute). The statute's history line reads "s. 1, ch. 2024-215; s. 2, ch. 2025-166": the original law took effect October 1, 2024 and the amendment October 1, 2025 (Florida Senate, HB 1049 (2024); Florida Senate, SB 948 (2025), read November 17, 2026).

Flood disclosure point What it means for a Stillwater seller
Timing At or before contract signing, never at closing
Zone Applies in Zone X as well as a Special Flood Hazard Area; the questions ask about your history, not the map
Period covered "During Seller's ownership": up to 26 years for a Unit 1 owner who bought new in 2000, months for a 2026 Shores owner
Standing water Rain that pooled on the lot or lanai for a sustained period falls inside item (4)(c)
Claims and aid Any NFIP or private flood claim, or FEMA aid, is a "has" even if repairs are finished
Storms inside most older-plat ownerships Ian (2022), Helene and Milton (2024), and Charley (2004) for the earliest Unit 1 homes

Data updated: November 2026 (Florida Statutes 689.302, read November 17, 2026; Stillwater build years from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; our reading, not legal advice)

Ownership length is why this form matters more in Stillwater than in a new community. Of 211 older-plat Stillwater homes with a qualified sale on the county file, the median is 9 years since the last one, and 93 have gone 10 or more years; another 40 older-plat homes have no qualified sale on a file whose earliest qualified sale for these plats is January 6, 2009 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026; tenure measured to that date). For most of those owners, Ian, Helene and Milton all fell inside "Seller's ownership."

No official report or news story we read names Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater in Ian, Helene or Milton, so we print no damage claim either way; the seller's own knowledge answers the form (NHC Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Helene; NHC Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Milton, read November 17, 2026). At Shores at Stillwater, the district engineer describes wet detention ponds designed for "100-year flood control" that "will be owned and maintained by the District" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). That is a design standard, not a flood history, and it does not change any seller's answers.

What Must the Radon Notice Say in a Stillwater Sale?

Florida requires a radon notice on a Stillwater sale, not a radon test. Section 404.056(5) says the statutory "RADON GAS" paragraph must appear on at least one document signed at or before the contract, and the AS IS contract's paragraph 10(a) already prints it, so a Stillwater seller using that form meets the statute.

The rule: "Notification shall be provided on at least one document, form, or application executed at the time of, or prior to, contract for sale and purchase of any building or execution of a rental agreement for any building." The required language: "RADON GAS: Radon is a naturally occurring radioactive gas that, when it has accumulated in a building in sufficient quantities, may present health risks to persons who are exposed to it over time. Levels of radon that exceed federal and state guidelines have been found in buildings in Florida. Additional information regarding radon and radon testing may be obtained from your county health department" (Florida Statutes 404.056, read November 17, 2026). The subsection does not apply to "residential transient occupancy" of "45 days or less in duration" (same statute).

No radon test result for any Stillwater home appeared in the sources we read, and no Sarasota County radon figure was read for this page. A buyer may test inside the inspection period, which is 15 days on the AS IS form if the blank is left empty (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline). If you have tested, put the report in the file; if not, the notice meets the statute.

What Does the Property Tax Disclosure Summary Mean for a Stillwater Buyer?

Section 689.261 requires that a Stillwater buyer receive a summary warning that the seller's current taxes are not the buyer's. For a long-held older Stillwater homestead the warning is concrete, because a sale resets the assessment. A 2026 amendment adds that from February 1, 2027 listing platforms must show a buyer-based estimate instead of the seller's bill.

The duty: "A prospective purchaser of residential property must be presented a disclosure summary at or before execution of the contract for sale." The required text: "BUYER SHOULD NOT RELY ON THE SELLER'S CURRENT PROPERTY TAXES AS THE AMOUNT OF PROPERTY TAXES THAT THE BUYER MAY BE OBLIGATED TO PAY IN THE YEAR SUBSEQUENT TO PURCHASE. A CHANGE OF OWNERSHIP OR PROPERTY IMPROVEMENTS TRIGGERS REASSESSMENTS OF THE PROPERTY THAT COULD RESULT IN HIGHER PROPERTY TAXES. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS CONCERNING VALUATION, CONTACT THE COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER'S OFFICE FOR INFORMATION." And: "Unless included in the contract, the disclosure summary must be provided by the seller" (Florida Statutes 689.261, read November 17, 2026). The AS IS form prints the summary word for word in paragraph 10(h) (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline).

The statute's history line now ends "s. 39, ch. 2026-239," and the new subsection (3) reads as follows (same statute, read November 17, 2026):

New listing rule, section 689.261(3) Text as quoted
Online listings "Beginning February 1, 2027, any property visible on a listing platform must include the estimated ad valorem taxes for such property"
What the estimate may not use "the current owner's ad valorem assessment or taxes may not be used to calculate the estimated ad valorem taxes"
Printed materials "Beginning February 1, 2027, the current owner's ad valorem taxes may not be included in any printed listing materials concerning a property"
State formula The department "shall publish on its website the formula" "Beginning December 15, 2026, and annually thereafter"
Disclaimer Estimates "do not include all applicable non-ad valorem assessments"
Liability "There is no liability on the part of, and no cause of action may arise against, any person for an inaccurate estimation of ad valorem taxes"

Data updated: November 2026 (Florida Statutes 689.261, read November 17, 2026; read from the statute text and history line only, not the bill)

Two Stillwater facts make the summary more than boilerplate. First, the gap: Save Our Homes capped a homestead's assessed value at 2.7 percent for 2026 and no more than 3 percent in each of 2022 to 2025, while older Stillwater resales whose earlier sale came before 2020 recorded a median 50.5 percent above that earlier price in the latest 12 months (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Save Our Homes; Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). The buyer's bill starts from just value. Second, the estimate leaves out the flat lines: every improved Stillwater home pays the Englewood Area Fire Control District's $290.78 residential assessment for 2026 to 2027, which is not based on value and is not affected by homestead (Englewood Fire, assessments, read November 17, 2026). From February 2027 we will name those lines in the listing remarks, because the platform estimate will not.

How Do You Disclose the Shores at Stillwater CDD on a Resale?

Shores at Stillwater sits inside the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District, and section 190.048 writes its boldface statement into "each contract for the initial sale," which was Pulte's sale. On a Shores resale, the duty rests on Johnson v. Davis, so we name the district and its debt in writing. District records indicate the older Stillwater plats have no CDD to disclose.

The statute's text for the initial sale: "THE (Name of District) COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT MAY IMPOSE AND LEVY TAXES OR ASSESSMENTS, OR BOTH TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS, ON THIS PROPERTY. THESE TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS PAY THE CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION, AND MAINTENANCE COSTS OF CERTAIN PUBLIC FACILITIES AND SERVICES OF THE DISTRICT AND ARE SET ANNUALLY BY THE GOVERNING BOARD OF THE DISTRICT. THESE TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS ARE IN ADDITION TO COUNTY AND OTHER LOCAL GOVERNMENTAL TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS AND ALL OTHER TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS PROVIDED FOR BY LAW" (Florida Statutes 190.048, read November 17, 2026). On its face that binds the first sale, not a later owner's resale; that reading is ours, and your closing attorney should confirm it.

Four other rules point a Shores at Stillwater buyer to the district anyway:

  • The HOA disclosure summary. Item 4 of the section 720.401 form says "YOU MAY BE OBLIGATED TO PAY SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS TO THE RESPECTIVE MUNICIPALITY, COUNTY, OR SPECIAL DISTRICT. ALL ASSESSMENTS ARE SUBJECT TO PERIODIC CHANGE" (Florida Statutes 720.401). For a Shores lot, the special district is the Shores at Stillwater CDD.
  • The recorded notice. "Within 30 days after the effective date of a rule or ordinance establishing a community development district," the district must record a "Notice of Establishment" that includes "the legal description of the district and a copy of the disclosure statement specified in s. 190.048" (Florida Statutes 190.0485). The district's June 15, 2026 meeting book also refers to a "Notice of Series 2026 Assessments" in the official records, so a title commitment should show both; we did not search the recording references.
  • The lien. District assessments "shall constitute a lien on the property against which assessed from the date of imposition thereof until paid, coequal with the lien of state, county, municipal, and school board taxes" (Florida Statutes 190.021, read November 17, 2026).
  • The seller's form. SPDR-4x section 10(b) asks "Are you aware of any existing or proposed municipal or county special assessments affecting the Property?" (SPDR-4x).

Pulte's pages do not mention the district: none of the ten Pulte pages read on November 17, 2026 names the Shores at Stillwater CDD, its debt or its assessment (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). Your buyer may have toured Pulte's sales center and never seen the figure, so the resale listing should carry it. The district's own disclosure of public financing prints a maximum annual debt assessment of $1,382.98 for a 34-foot lot and $1,914.89 for a 52-foot lot, with the note that the amounts "may fluctuate"; the assessment methodology table prints $1,382.68 and $1,914.48 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). We use the methodology figures and attach the district's payoff or assessment letter.

For the older plats the answer is the opposite. The district's legal description begins at "the Southeast corner of STILLWATER, UNIT TWO" and runs along that plat's east boundary, and the district was not on the Sarasota County Tax Collector's 2026 list of levying authorities, which together indicate that Units 1, 2 and 3 are outside it (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book; Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage, read November 17, 2026). Confirm on your own tax bill, and say so in writing.

What HOA Disclosure Summary Must a Stillwater Seller Give?

A Stillwater seller, not the association, must hand the buyer the section 720.401 homeowners' association disclosure summary before the contract is signed. If it is late, the buyer may void the contract within 3 days after receiving it or before closing, whichever comes first, and Florida law says any waiver of that right "has no effect."

Section 720.401(1)(a): "A prospective parcel owner in a community must be presented a disclosure summary before executing the contract for sale," and "The disclosure must be supplied by the developer, or by the parcel owner if the sale is by an owner that is not the developer" (Florida Statutes 720.401, read November 17, 2026). The contract must carry the voidability clause in conspicuous type: "IF THE DISCLOSURE SUMMARY REQUIRED BY SECTION 720.401, FLORIDA STATUTES, HAS NOT BEEN PROVIDED TO THE PROSPECTIVE PURCHASER BEFORE EXECUTING THIS CONTRACT FOR SALE, THIS CONTRACT IS VOIDABLE BY BUYER BY DELIVERING TO SELLER OR SELLER'S AGENT OR REPRESENTATIVE WRITTEN NOTICE OF THE BUYER'S INTENTION TO CANCEL WITHIN 3 DAYS AFTER RECEIPT OF THE DISCLOSURE SUMMARY OR PRIOR TO CLOSING, WHICHEVER OCCURS FIRST. ANY PURPORTED WAIVER OF THIS VOIDABILITY RIGHT HAS NO EFFECT. BUYER'S RIGHT TO VOID THIS CONTRACT SHALL TERMINATE AT CLOSING" (same statute). The AS IS form repeats the warning in paragraph 10(g): "BUYER SHOULD NOT EXECUTE THIS CONTRACT UNTIL BUYER HAS RECEIVED AND READ THE HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATION/COMMUNITY DISCLOSURE, IF APPLICABLE" (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline).

Summary item (section 720.401) What it says The Stillwater fact behind it
1 "YOU WILL BE OBLIGATED TO BE A MEMBER OF A HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATION" Three associations appear in Florida corporate filings for Stillwater (next section); which one governs your parcel is on your estoppel
3 Assessments "MAY BE SUBJECT TO PERIODIC CHANGE," with "THE CURRENT AMOUNT IS $___ PER ___" No Stillwater dues figure was published in a source we read; fill it from the association's budget or estoppel
4 Possible special assessments to a "SPECIAL DISTRICT" Shores at Stillwater CDD for a Shores lot; none indicated for Units 1 to 3
5 Failure to pay "COULD RESULT IN A LIEN ON YOUR PROPERTY" Section 720.3085 lien and successor liability (next section)
7 "THE DEVELOPER MAY HAVE THE RIGHT TO AMEND THE RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS" without owner approval Live at Shores at Stillwater, where Pulte is still the developer

Data updated: November 2026 (Florida Statutes 720.401, read November 17, 2026; Pulte's developer status from the Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book)

Item 7 is not theoretical at Shores at Stillwater: the district's June 15, 2026 meeting book records Pulte Home Company, LLC as owner of 125 of the 136 Phase One lots on the roll it used (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). Section 720.401(2) excludes associations "regulated under chapter 718, chapter 719, chapter 721, or chapter 723" (condominiums, cooperatives, timeshares and mobile home parks) (same statute). The three Stillwater associations appear in Florida records as Chapter 720 homeowners' associations, so the summary applies; the recorded declarations were not read for this page, so confirm the regime with your closing agent, especially for Unit 3.

What Belongs in a Stillwater Seller's Disclosure File?

A complete Stillwater disclosure file holds the signed section 689.302 flood disclosure, the radon notice, the property tax summary, the section 720.401 HOA summary, a seller's property disclosure, the roof and permit history, any insurance or FEMA claim records and FIRPTA status, plus, for a Shores home, the CDD statement and Pulte warranty papers.

File item Legal source Older Stillwater, Units 1 to 3 Shores at Stillwater
Flood disclosure F.S. 689.302 Required; covers your full ownership Required; covers months, not years
Radon notice F.S. 404.056(5) In AS IS paragraph 10(a) Same
Property tax summary F.S. 689.261 In AS IS paragraph 10(h) Same
HOA disclosure summary F.S. 720.401 Seller supplies, before the buyer signs Seller supplies (Pulte supplied it on the first sale)
CDD statement F.S. 190.048 Not applicable; district boundary indicates outside Disclose in writing on resale, with the district's letter
Seller's property disclosure SPDR-4x (voluntary) Customary Customary
Roof and permit history AS IS paragraph 10(b) Reroof, air conditioning, windows, enclosure Any pool, cage, shutter or other work added after the Pulte closing
Construction defect notice F.S. 558.004 Outside the 7-year outer limit (our reading) Inside it; disclose any notice
FIRPTA status 26 U.S.C. 1445 Non-foreign certification or notice Same

Data updated: November 2026 (statutes and forms read November 17, 2026; our checklist, not a statutory list)

The permit paragraph is the one older Stillwater sellers underrate. AS IS paragraph 10(b) has the seller say "Seller does not know of any improvements made to the Property which were made without required permits or made pursuant to permits which have not been properly closed or otherwise disposed of pursuant to Section 553.79, F.S.," and if the seller identifies any, "Seller shall promptly deliver to Buyer all plans, written documentation or other information in Seller's possession" (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline). On the construction defect point, section 95.11(3)(b) requires a construction action to be "commenced within 7 years after the date the authority having jurisdiction issues a temporary certificate of occupancy, a certificate of occupancy, or a certificate of completion" (Florida Statutes 95.11, read November 17, 2026); the last older Stillwater home on the roll was built in 2016, so that window has run for the older plats on our reading, while a Shores buyer is a "subsequent purchaser" who can be a claimant under section 558.002(3) (Florida Statutes 558.002). Ask a Florida attorney before relying on either reading.

We assemble the file before the listing goes live, so a buyer's first look at your home in Stillwater, Englewood is also a first look at a complete record. Request a free Stillwater home valuation and we will start the file with you. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How Do the HOAs, the Estoppel Certificate and the Shores CDD Work in a Stillwater Sale?

A Stillwater sale in Englewood involves up to two bodies. Every parcel sits under a homeowners' association, which issues the estoppel certificate showing dues, fees and violations. A Shores at Stillwater parcel also sits in the Shores at Stillwater CDD, whose bond debt is prorated, not paid off, on the standard contract. The older plats indicate no district.

Stillwater in Englewood is unusual in one respect: three associations appear in Florida corporate filings, and which one governs which older plat is not settled by any public document we read. The estoppel certificate and the recorded declaration settle it for your parcel, so we order the estoppel early. This is general information, not legal advice. Below, every association fact we print is labeled with its source, and every gap with the document that closes it.

Which Associations Govern Stillwater, Englewood Homes?

Three Stillwater associations are listed in Florida corporate filings as copied by directory sites: Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed March 7, 2000), Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed March 10, 2006) and Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed February 24, 2025). Confirm each on Sunbiz before you rely on it.

Association, as listed in Florida corporate filings Filed Plats it most likely relates to Confidence
Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. March 7, 2000 Older Stillwater; the filing date matches the first Unit 1 homes on the roll (2000) Name and date from three directory copies of state records that agree; which plats it governs is unverified
Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc. March 10, 2006 Stillwater Unit 3, the small-home section coded 0101 Same; its own website is titled "Villas at Stillwater III"
Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. February 24, 2025 Shores at Stillwater Phases 1A and 1B (Pulte) Same

Data updated: November 2026 (CommunityPay directory, Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc.; CommunityPay directory, Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc.; copies of Florida Division of Corporations records, read November 17, 2026; confirm on Sunbiz)

The filing dates line up with the county roll's build years: Unit 1 homes from 2000, Unit 3 homes from 2007 and Shores homes from 2025 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Stillwater Unit 2's 36 parcels have no association of their own in any result we read. One directory files the 2000 association under a Charlotte County address, which is an office address, not the community's location: every Stillwater parcel is in unincorporated Sarasota County with an Englewood 34223 mailing address (same file).

Which Association Governs Your Older Stillwater Plat?

Which association governs which older Stillwater plat in Englewood is unverified. The 2000 association most likely covers Unit 1 and perhaps Unit 2, and Unit 3 has its own 2006 association, but whether the 2000 association is also a master over Unit 3 is not in any public document we read. Your estoppel answers it.

The estoppel form is built for this question. Section 720.30851 item 10 requires the association to "Provide a list of, and contact information for, all other associations of which the parcel is a member" (Florida Statutes 720.30851, read November 17, 2026). If a Unit 3 parcel answers to two associations, each may issue its own certificate and charge its own fee (our reading of the statute). The recorded declaration for each plat names the declarant and the association; the declarations' official records references were not searched for this page, so a title search or the association manager supplies them.

Unit 3's size brings in a website rule. Section 720.303(4)(b)1 says "By January 1, 2025, an association that has 100 or more parcels shall post the following documents on its website or make available such documents through an application that can be downloaded on a mobile device," starting with "The articles of incorporation of the association and each amendment thereto" (Florida Statutes 720.303, read November 17, 2026). Stillwater Unit 3 has 141 parcels on the roll (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). On November 17, 2026 the "Villas at Stillwater III" website showed an account notice rather than its documents, and its menu listed items such as "Villa maintenance responsibilities," "ACR request form" and "Community documents" (Villas at Stillwater III, read November 17, 2026). The menu tells us the association divides villa maintenance between owner and association and reviews architectural changes; the actual split for roofs, exterior paint and insurance is in the declaration, which we did not read. Ask the association for the declaration, rules and budget on the first day of the listing so the buyer's reviews are not delayed.

Stillwater association question Status in public records we read Document that settles it
Which association governs Units 1 and 2 Unverified Recorded declaration; estoppel item 10
Whether Unit 3 also sits under a master association Unverified Estoppel item 10; recorded declaration
Regular dues and billing period Not published Estoppel; association budget
Transfer, resale or capital contribution fee Not published Estoppel item 6
Board approval of a sale Not published Estoppel item 8
Right of first refusal Not published Estoppel item 9
Leasing rules Not published Recorded declaration and amendments
Unit 3 home type, attached or detached villa Unverified Recorded plat and declaration
Roads in the older plats, private or public Unverified Plat dedication

Data updated: November 2026 (directory copies of state records, association website and statutes read November 17, 2026; items marked unverified were not found in any primary document)

Leasing deserves one line in every Stillwater conversation even though no rule was published: under section 720.306(1)(h), a rental rule adopted after July 1, 2021 "applies only to a parcel owner who acquires title to the parcel after the effective date of the governing document or amendment, or to a parcel owner who consents" (Florida Statutes 720.306, read November 17, 2026). A rule that did not bind you can bind your buyer, so the declaration and its amendments belong in the file.

What Does the Stillwater Estoppel Certificate Show, and What Does It Cost?

The Stillwater estoppel certificate is the association's binding statement of what your parcel owes. Florida requires it within 10 business days of a request, caps the fee (DBPR's adjusted caps are $299 standard, $119 more for a 3-business-day rush and up to $179 more if delinquent), and the AS IS contract makes the estoppel fee a seller cost.

Section 720.30851: "Within 10 business days after receiving a written or electronic request for an estoppel certificate from a parcel owner or the parcel owner's designee, or a parcel mortgagee or the parcel mortgagee's designee, the association shall issue the estoppel certificate. Each association shall designate on its website a person or entity with a street or e-mail address for receipt of a request for an estoppel certificate" (Florida Statutes 720.30851, read November 17, 2026). Among the items it must answer:

  • "6. Is there a capital contribution fee, resale fee, transfer fee, or other fee due? (Yes) (No). If yes, specify the type and amount of the fee."
  • "7. Is there any open violation of rule or regulation noticed to the parcel owner in the association official records?"
  • "8. Do the rules and regulations of the association applicable to the parcel require approval by the board of directors of the association for the transfer of the parcel? (Yes) (No). If yes, has the board approved the transfer of the parcel?"
  • "9. Is there a right of first refusal provided to the members or the association?"
  • "10. Provide a list of, and contact information for, all other associations of which the parcel is a member."
  • "11. Provide contact information for all insurance maintained by the association."
Estoppel rule Statute or DBPR figure Stillwater arithmetic or effect
Delivery deadline 10 business days after request Order it at listing, not at contract
Fee if late "a fee may not be charged" $0 if the association misses the deadline
Standard fee cap Statute text $250; DBPR adjusted cap $299 Up to $299 for one current account
Rush, delivered within 3 business days Statute $100; DBPR $119 additional Up to $418 with rush
Delinquent account Statute $150; DBPR up to $179 additional Up to $478, or $597 rushed and delinquent
Two associations on one parcel Each issues its own certificate Two fees (our reading)
Effective period 30 days hand or e-mail; 35 days regular mail A delayed closing may need an amended certificate, which carries no fee
Reliance Association "waives the right to collect any moneys owed in excess of the amounts specified" The buyer and title agent close on its numbers
Refund if no closing Refunded within 30 days of a written request made within 30 days after the planned closing Applies to a payor who is not the parcel owner
Next DBPR update "The next update will be released by July 1, 2027" Caps hold for Stillwater closings until then

Data updated: November 2026 (Florida Statutes 720.30851; DBPR, Estoppel Certificate Fees, read November 17, 2026; Stillwater totals are our arithmetic)

The statute's own fees "shall be adjusted every 5 years in an amount equal to the total of the annual increases for that 5-year period in the Consumer Price Index," and DBPR publishes the adjusted figures (same statute). Who pays: AS IS paragraph 9(a) lists "HOA/Condominium Association estoppel fees" among the seller's costs, and the Barnes Walker customs table lists "HOA estoppel letter" as "Seller" for Sarasota (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline; Barnes Walker, Sarasota and Manatee closing customs, read November 17, 2026).

Why Does Your Buyer's Title Agent Insist the Stillwater Dues Are Paid?

A Stillwater buyer's title agent insists that every association balance is paid at closing because section 720.3085 makes a new owner "jointly and severally liable with the previous parcel owner for all unpaid assessments that came due up to the time of transfer of title." The payoff, interest and any delinquent estoppel fee come from your proceeds.

The statute: "A parcel owner is jointly and severally liable with the previous parcel owner for all unpaid assessments that came due up to the time of transfer of title. This liability is without prejudice to any right the present parcel owner may have to recover any amounts paid by the present owner from the previous owner" (Florida Statutes 720.3085, read November 17, 2026). The lien, "When authorized by the governing documents," "shall relate back to the date on which the original declaration of the community was recorded" (same statute), which for the older Stillwater plats means the 2000s declarations.

The cost of falling behind is statutory. "If no rate is provided in the declaration or bylaws, simple interest accrues at the rate of 18 percent per year," and a late fee may not exceed "the greater of $25 or 5 percent of the amount of each installment that is paid past the due date"; before recording a claim of lien the association must allow "45 days following the date the notice is deposited in the mail to make payment" (same statute). A Stillwater seller who is behind should bring the account current before listing: it avoids the extra delinquent estoppel fee of up to $179, and it keeps the estoppel clean for the buyer (DBPR, Estoppel Certificate Fees). DBPR's own page notes a limit buyers sometimes misread: "the division does not have authority to investigate complaints under Chapter 720, Florida Statutes" (DBPR, Homeowners' Associations, read November 17, 2026).

What Does the Shores at Stillwater CDD Charge, and Why?

The Shores at Stillwater CDD repays $2,970,000 of Series 2026 bonds, at coupons of 4.10 to 5.8 percent maturing May 2056. Each of the 136 Phase One lots carries an original principal of $18,580.37 (34-foot lot) or $25,726.66 (52-foot lot) and a maximum annual debt assessment of $1,382.68 or $1,914.48.

Sarasota County created the district by Ordinance No. 2025-032 on Pulte Home Company's petition, effective February 11, 2026, and it "encompasses approximately 79.83 acres" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; Ordinance 2025-032, read November 17, 2026). On April 13, 2026, the Twelfth Judicial Circuit validated "an aggregate principal amount not to exceed $14,000,000 in Special Assessment Bonds," and the district sold $2,970,000 (June 15, 2026 meeting book; Shores at Stillwater CDD, Amended Final Budget 2025-2026, read November 17, 2026).

Shores at Stillwater CDD, Series 2026 Figure Source
Original par amount $2,970,000 Amended FY2025/2026 budget
Interest rate 4.10% to 5.8% Same
Maturity May 2056 Same
Court-validated ceiling Not to exceed $14,000,000 June 15, 2026 meeting book
34-foot lots 74 lots, original principal $18,580.37 each, maximum annual debt assessment $1,382.68 Phase One methodology, Tables D and F
52-foot lots 62 lots, original principal $25,726.66 each, maximum annual debt assessment $1,914.48 Same
Operations and maintenance, FY2026/2027 "To Be Collected At Closings"; "O&M Rate Would Be $276 (255 Units)" if on the roll Final Budget 2026-2027
2026 tax roll No Shores at Stillwater CDD levy code on the Tax Collector's 2026 list Sarasota County Tax Collector

Data updated: November 2026 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, Amended Final Budget 2025-2026; June 15, 2026 meeting book; Final Budget 2026-2027; Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; all read November 17, 2026)

The maximum annual figures are "Grossed up to include 1% collection fee of the County Tax Collector, 1% service fee of the County Property Appraiser and 4% for early payment of taxes," and "Actual amounts may be adjusted to reflect actual County collection costs" (June 15, 2026 meeting book). Adding the $276 operations rate the budget shows "if District Were On The Assessment Roll" gives about $1,658.68 a year for a 34-foot lot and $2,190.48 for a 52-foot lot (our arithmetic on the district's figures). The district's FAQ says "The debt service component is the larger amount and goes towards paying of the bonds," and that if taxes are escrowed, "your assessments will be included in your monthly mortgage payment" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, FAQs, read November 17, 2026).

What stays outside the district matters to a Shores buyer too: "The roadways, irrigation, landscaping and amenity center will be private and are not included in the CIP" (April 20, 2026 meeting book), and the June 15, 2026 minutes note that pond, preserve and pipe maintenance items "would be included in an agreement with the HOA and are currently included in the HOA budget" (June 15, 2026 meeting book). So the gated streets, the pool and cabana and the lake upkeep are association costs, not district costs. The court validated up to $14,000,000 and the district sold $2,970,000; later phases may carry their own series, and whether any later series could reach a Phase One lot is unverified, although the methodology says the Series 2026 debt "will be assigned to those platted units" (same book).

Can a Shores at Stillwater Seller Prepay the CDD Debt, and Who Pays at Closing?

A Shores at Stillwater seller may prepay the lot's remaining CDD balance at any time, but nothing requires it. On the Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS contract, a CDD's assessments are prorated under Standard K like taxes, so the buyer takes over the remaining installments unless the contract says otherwise.

The AS IS form's paragraph 9(f) carves districts out of the seller's lien payoff: a CDD lien "pursuant to Chapter 190, F.S., or special assessment(s) imposed by a special district pursuant to Chapter 189, F.S., which lien(s) or assessment(s) shall be prorated pursuant to STANDARD K" (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline, read November 17, 2026). The district's master assessment resolution sets the prepayment terms: "The owner of property subject to the Special Assessments may prepay the entire remaining balance of the Special Assessments at any time or a fifty percent (50%) portion of the remaining balance of the Special Assessment once if there is also paid, in addition to the prepaid principal balance of the Special Assessment, an amount equal to the interest that would otherwise be due on such prepaid amount on the next succeeding interest payment date," and "Prepayment of Special Assessments does not entitle the property owner to any discounts for early payment" (April 20, 2026 meeting book).

The district's amended FY2025/2026 budget shows a "Prepayment Account Balance = $25,726," which equals one 52-foot lot's original principal, so at least one Shores lot appears to have been prepaid (our reading; the lot is not named) (Amended Final Budget 2025-2026). If yours is that lot, or you prepaid through an impact fee credit purchase the district offers "on a first come first serve basis when available," say so in the listing: it removes the debt line a buyer would otherwise carry (June 15, 2026 meeting book).

Two closing-statement points for 2026 and 2027. First, with operations "To Be Collected At Closings" for FY2026/2027, a Shores resale closing in that year should show an operations line, so check whether your own Pulte closing already paid it (Final Budget 2026-2027). Second, the payoff figure for a lot is not published; the district site's "Payoff Information" link asks owners to "Request CDD Debt and Assessment Information," and the district manager, Special District Services, Inc., lists (561) 630-4922 (Shores at Stillwater CDD; June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). We request it at listing.

What Should an Older Stillwater Seller Say About the CDD?

An older Stillwater seller in Units 1, 2 or 3 should say in writing that the district boundary and the 2026 tax roll both indicate the home is outside the Shores at Stillwater CDD, attach the current tax bill to show no district line, and make that a selling point against the new homes next door.

The boundary language is specific. The district's South Parcel begins "at the South 1/4 corner of said Section 32, also being the Southeast corner of STILLWATER, UNIT TWO, according to the Plat thereof, recorded in Plat Book 45, Pages 12 through 12C," and runs "along the East boundary of said STILLWATER, UNIT TWO" to Medical Boulevard; the North Parcel is bounded by "the East boundary of Englewood Medical Center" (April 20, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). The two parcels total 34.041 and 45.789 acres, which is the district's stated 79.83 acres (our arithmetic), and the Phase One assessment roll lists only Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A and 1B lots (same book; June 15, 2026 meeting book). The Tax Collector's 2026 list of non-ad valorem levying authorities names other Sarasota County districts and no Shores at Stillwater code (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage). We did not read an individual older-plat bill, so your bill is the proof.

The dollar point is simple. A Phase One Shores home carries up to about $1,658.68 or $2,190.48 a year in district charges at the methodology maximums plus the budget's $276 operations rate, unless prepaid, while district records indicate an older Stillwater home carries none (our arithmetic on the district's figures). Pulte's payment illustrations do not show district lines, so a buyer comparing payments may not see the difference until we show it. Want that comparison worked for your Stillwater home? Request a free Stillwater home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

Will a Buyer's Insurer Accept Your Stillwater Roof?

A buyer's insurer will judge a Stillwater roof on proof of its age and condition. Florida bars refusal solely for roof age under 15 years and, at 15 years or more, requires the insurer to allow an inspection; a finding of 5 or more years of useful life protects eligibility. Original roofs on 2000 to 2011 homes are past 15.

Stillwater in Englewood is where this rule bites, because the older plats were built from 2000 to 2016 and the roll shows no roof dates (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). The insurer's questions come in a fixed order: how old is the roof, what is it made of, what does a licensed inspector say about remaining life, what do the electrical, plumbing and air conditioning look like on a four-point report, and what wind mitigation features can be documented. A Shores at Stillwater home answers most of them with a 2025 or 2026 build date; an older home answers them with paper. This section is general information; the buyer's insurer applies its own underwriting rules.

What Does Florida's Roof-Age Law Say for a Stillwater Home?

Florida Statutes 627.7011(5) says an insurer may not refuse to issue or renew a homeowner's policy on a Stillwater home "with a roof that is less than 15 years old solely because of the age of the roof," and for an older roof must allow an inspection; 5 or more years of remaining useful life bars refusal solely for age.

The text of (5)(b): "An insurer may not refuse to issue or refuse to renew a homeowner's policy insuring a residential structure with a roof that is less than 15 years old solely because of the age of the roof." And (5)(c): "For a roof that is at least 15 years old, an insurer must allow a homeowner to have a roof inspection performed by an authorized inspector at the homeowner's expense before requiring the replacement of the roof of a residential structure as a condition of issuing or renewing a homeowner's insurance policy. The insurer may not refuse to issue or refuse to renew a homeowner's insurance policy solely because of roof age if an inspection of the roof of the residential structure performed by an authorized inspector indicates that the roof has 5 years or more of useful life remaining" (Florida Statutes 627.7011, read November 17, 2026).

Three details decide how the rule applies to your Stillwater roof (same statute):

  • How age is counted. "a roof's age shall be calculated using the last date on which 100 percent of the roof's surface area was built or replaced in accordance with the building code in effect at that time." A partial repair does not restart the clock; a full replacement does.
  • Who may inspect. Authorized inspectors include a "home inspector licensed under s. 468.8314" and "A general, building, or residential contractor licensed under s. 489.111 or a roofing contractor."
  • When it applies. "This subsection applies to homeowners' insurance policies issued or renewed on or after July 1, 2022," and the history line ends "s. 8, ch. 2024-182."

The law protects issuance and renewal against refusal solely for age. It does not set a buyer's premium, and it does not stop an insurer from acting on a roof with active leaks or other condition problems. That is why we ask Stillwater sellers for an inspection that states remaining useful life in writing, not only a permit date.

How Old Are Stillwater Roofs by Year Built?

Stillwater roof ages follow build years if the roof is original: Unit 1 homes built 2000 to 2016 would be 10 to 26 years old in 2026, Unit 2 homes from 2005 and 2006 about 20 to 21, and Unit 3 homes from 2007 to 2013 about 13 to 19. Reroofs are unverified home by home.

Stillwater plat Homes with heated area Years built (median) Original roof age in 2026 15-year line under 627.7011(5) Citizens four-point (homes more than 20 years old)
Stillwater Unit 1 76 2000 to 2016 (2004; middle half 2003 to 2005) 10 to 26 years Past it for homes built 2000 to 2011 Homes built 2005 or earlier now; the rest later
Stillwater Unit 2 35 2005 to 2006 (2006) 20 to 21 years Past it 2005 homes now; 2006 homes from 2027
Stillwater Unit 3 140 2007 to 2013 (2011) 13 to 19 years Past it for homes built 2007 to 2011; 2012 and 2013 homes cross in 2027 and 2028 More than 20 years old from 2028 to 2034
Shores at Stillwater 27 2025 to 2026 (2026) Under 2 years Under it Not for many years

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, parcel file dated October 21, 2026; roof ages are our arithmetic on year built and assume an original roof; Florida Statutes 627.7011; Citizens, Inspections, read November 17, 2026)

Roof material for the older plats is not in any public record we read; Pulte lists impact glass and a tile roof as included at Shores at Stillwater, and its Colton included-features list names a "Tile roof" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater; Pulte, Colton, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Material matters because Citizens draws different lines for shingle and tile (next subsection). Whether an older Stillwater roof is shingle, tile or metal, and when it was last replaced, comes from the county permit record and your own invoices.

A Unit 3 seller has one more question to answer before listing: who is responsible for the roof. The Unit 3 association's website lists a "Villa maintenance responsibilities" page (Villas at Stillwater III, read November 17, 2026), which suggests a written split between owner and association, but the page could not be read and the declaration was not read, so whether the association or the owner replaced or insures a given Unit 3 roof is unverified. The answer changes what you disclose and what the buyer's insurer will ask for.

What Do Citizens' Four-Point and Roof Rules Require in Stillwater?

For a Stillwater buyer, Citizens Property Insurance requires a four-point inspection on homes more than 20 years old, and shingle roofs older than 25 years, or tile and metal older than 50, need proof of at least five years of remaining life. The buyer's own insurer sets its rule, and sources disagree on private carriers' age triggers.

Citizens' inspection page: "Citizens requires a four-point inspection for all property owner, dwelling and mobile home applications for properties more than 20 years old. A Florida-licensed inspector will check the home's electrical system, plumbing, heating/cooling system (HVAC) and roof," and "Any serious hazards or deficiencies (such as exposed wiring, active leaks or evidence of leaks) should be repaired before an application for coverage is submitted" (Citizens, Inspections, read November 17, 2026). On roofs: "Roofs older than 25 years (soft such as shingle or similar) or 50 years (hard such as tile, slate, clay, concrete or metal) require documentation showing at least five years of remaining useful life," and "When a roof has less than five years of remaining useful life, the property owner must provide proof of a full-roof replacement to the inspector before any policy is written" (same page). Citizens' support page adds that the four-point must be done by a verifiable Florida-licensed inspector and "completed within the last year" (Citizens, four-point inspection answer, read November 17, 2026).

Citizens rule Threshold Stillwater homes it reaches in 2026 (our arithmetic on year built)
Four-point inspection Home "more than 20 years old" Unit 1 homes built 2005 or earlier and Unit 2 homes built in 2005
Shingle roof documentation Older than 25 years Original shingle roofs on 2000 homes, and 2001 homes from 2027
Tile or metal roof documentation Older than 50 years None
Full replacement before a policy Less than five years of remaining useful life Any roof an inspector rates that way, regardless of age
Underwriting survey "at no cost to the policyholder"; may require repairs Any Citizens policy

Data updated: November 2026 (Citizens, Inspections, read November 17, 2026; Stillwater build years from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026)

Citizens' sample four-point form shows what the inspector records: roof "Covering material," "Roof age (years)," "Remaining useful life (years)" and "Date of last roofing permit"; electrical hazards such as aluminum branch wiring, double taps and scorching; the HVAC "Age of system" with a "dated manufacturer's plate" photo; and plumbing pipe type, including "Polybutylene" (Citizens, Sample 4-Point Inspection Form, read November 17, 2026). On a 2000s Stillwater home those are the lines a buyer's insurer reads first.

Private carriers are another matter. Search results we reviewed disagree on the age at which private insurers ask for a four-point (20 to 25 years, 25 years, or a roof-age trigger), and Citizens' sample form states no trigger, so treat any single number you hear as one carrier's rule (Citizens, Sample 4-Point Inspection Form). CBS12 reported on August 11, 2026 an agent's comment that "the guidance is for a 15-year-old shingle roof to be the maximum age limit that carriers want," with tile roofs typically accepted for about 25 to 30 years and metal about 40 (CBS12, read November 17, 2026). That is reporting, not a rule, but it explains why a Stillwater buyer's agent asks about the roof in the first showing.

How Does a Wind Mitigation Report Help a Stillwater Sale?

A wind mitigation report lets a Stillwater buyer's agent quote insurance with credits applied, because Florida requires rate filings to include discounts for wind-resistive features. Since April 1, 2026, inspections must use form OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26); Citizens still accepts the older form only if done within five years before that date with no changes.

The statute: a rate filing "must include actuarially reasonable discounts, credits, or other rate differentials, or appropriate reductions in deductibles" for features that "enhance wind uplift prevention, roof strength, roof covering performance, roof-to-wall strength, wall-to-floor-to-foundation strength, opening protection, and window, door, and skylight strength"; "Effective October 1, 2023, each insurer ... must provide information on the insurer's website describing the hurricane mitigation discounts available" (Florida Statutes 627.0629, read November 17, 2026). Section 627.711(2)(a) requires "a uniform mitigation verification inspection form that shall be used by all insurers when submitted by policyholders for the purpose of factoring discounts for wind insurance" (Florida Statutes 627.711, read November 17, 2026).

Citizens' March 19, 2026 bulletin: "The revised form, OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26), will be effective April 1, 2026. Inspections conducted on or after April 1, 2026, must use the revised form"; Citizens "will continue to accept the previous version of the form, OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 01/12), if it was completed within five years prior to April 1, 2026" when no changes were made; the changed items are "Building Code," "Roof covering," "Roof deck attachment," "Roof to wall attachment," "Secondary water resistance (SWR)" and "Opening protection," and new items include FORTIFIED Home certificates at the "Roof, Silver, and Gold" levels (Citizens, Uniform Mitigation Verification Inspection Form Changes, read November 17, 2026). Citizens adds that "These additional changes and new features will not result in any difference to the credits available and applied at this time" (same bulletin).

For a Stillwater seller the practical reading is: a report on the old form dated before April 1, 2021 is outside the five-year window, so order a new one on the Rev. 04/26 form (our arithmetic on Citizens' dates). On an older Stillwater home, the lines that separate it from a 2026 Shores home are opening protection and roof deck and roof-to-wall attachment; Pulte lists "Whole house impact-resistant vinyl windows- High Velocity Hurricane Zone Rated Windows" and "Professionally engineered roof trusses with hurricane tie-downs for wind protection" on its Colton list (Pulte, Colton, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). If you added rated shutters or impact windows, keep the product approval numbers and permit with the report so the inspector can credit them. We print no premium figures; only a quote on the address gives one.

Which Building Code Era Is Your Stillwater Home?

A Stillwater home's code era turns on its permit date, not its year built. Unit 1 homes from 2000 and early 2002 may predate the first statewide Florida Building Code (March 1, 2002); Unit 1, 2 and 3 homes span the 2001, 2004, 2007 and 2010 codes; Shores at Stillwater homes fall under the 8th Edition (2023) era.

Florida Building Code edition Effective date Stillwater homes most likely permitted under it (permit dates not read)
Before the statewide code Before March 1, 2002 Unit 1 homes built 2000 to early 2002
2001 Florida Building Code March 1, 2002 Unit 1 homes built 2002 to 2005; some Unit 2 homes
2004 Florida Building Code October 1, 2005 Unit 2 homes (2005 to 2006); Unit 3 homes permitted before March 1, 2009
2007 Florida Building Code March 1, 2009 Unit 3 homes permitted March 1, 2009 to March 14, 2012
2010 Florida Building Code March 15, 2012 Later Unit 3 homes (2012 to 2013)
5th Edition (2014) June 30, 2015 A Unit 1 home built in 2016, depending on permit date
8th Edition (2023) December 31, 2023 Shores at Stillwater homes built 2025 to 2026

Data updated: November 2026 (Florida Building Commission, code effective dates, read November 17, 2026; Stillwater build years from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; mapping is our arithmetic and the permit application date controls)

The Building Commission adds a point that narrows the gap: "Wind speeds for the peninsula are unchanged and effectively have not changed since the 2010 FBC" (Florida Building Commission, ASCE 7-22 Wind Loads Fact Sheet, read November 17, 2026). The design wind speed at Stillwater addresses and whether they lie in the wind-borne debris region were not read for this page; the county building office or an engineer confirms them for a lot. The code era is the first line on the wind mitigation form and the first question in the next subsection.

Does a Partial Roof Repair Force a Whole New Roof in Stillwater?

A partial roof repair on a Stillwater home forces a full current-code roof only if the existing roof predates the 2007 Florida Building Code. Section 553.844(5) lets a roof built or replaced under the 2007 code or later repair 25 percent or more with only the repaired part brought to current code. Older Stillwater roofs do not get that exception.

The text: "if an existing roofing system or roof section was built, repaired, or replaced in compliance with the requirements of the 2007 Florida Building Code, or any subsequent editions of the Florida Building Code, and 25 percent or more of such roofing system or roof section is being repaired, replaced, or recovered, only the repaired, replaced, or recovered portion is required to be constructed in accordance with the Florida Building Code in effect" (Florida Statutes 553.844, read November 17, 2026). And for a replacement: "A roof replacement must incorporate the techniques specified in subparagraphs (2)(b)2. and 4.," which are secondary water barriers and "Strengthening or correcting roof-decking attachments and fasteners during reroofing" (same statute).

With the 2007 code effective March 1, 2009, an original roof on a Stillwater Unit 1 or Unit 2 home, and on any Unit 3 home permitted before that date, sits outside the exception on our reading (Florida Building Commission, code effective dates). A roof that was fully replaced after March 1, 2009 is inside it. That is a reason to find the reroof permit: it can change both the insurer's answer and the buyer's storm-repair risk. For site-built homes in the wind-borne debris region with an insured or just value of $300,000 or more, a roof replacement must also address roof-to-wall connections, which "shall not be required unless evaluation and installation of connections at gable ends or all corners can be completed for 15 percent of the cost of roof replacement" (Florida Statutes 553.844); whether Stillwater lies in that region was not verified.

Why Do Permits for Reroofs and Windows Matter in a Stillwater Sale?

Permits for a Stillwater reroof, windows, shutters or air conditioner matter because the permit date proves roof age for the insurer, sets the code era for the wind mitigation inspector, and answers the AS IS permit disclosure. Under section 553.79(17)(a) the county keeps its remedies against the owner on an open permit, so close it before listing.

The buyer protection: "A local enforcement agency may not deny issuance of a building permit to; issue a notice of violation to; or fine, penalize, sanction, or assess fees against an arms-length purchaser of a property for value solely because a building permit applied for by a previous owner of the property was not closed. The local enforcement agency shall maintain all rights and remedies against the property owner and contractor listed on the permit" (Florida Statutes 553.79, read November 17, 2026). The fix is also in the statute: "A property owner, regardless of whether the property owner is the one listed on the application for the building permit, may close a building permit by complying with the following requirements: 1. The property owner may retain the original contractor listed on the permit or hire a different contractor appropriately licensed in this state," and an expired permit whose requirements "have been substantially completed" may be closed "without having to obtain a new building permit" under the code in effect when the application was received (same statute).

Stillwater improvement What the permit proves Who reads it
Full reroof Roof age under 627.7011(5)(d); code era for 553.844(5) Buyer's insurer; four-point inspector; wind mitigation inspector
Impact windows or rated shutters Opening protection and product approval Wind mitigation inspector; Citizens
Air conditioner change-out System age on the four-point Four-point inspector
Water heater Plumbing line on the four-point Four-point inspector
Screen enclosure or pool Closed permit for the AS IS 10(b) statement; pool safety feature Buyer's attorney and title agent
Shores at Stillwater additions after closing Work outside Pulte's build permits Buyer's inspector; association

Data updated: November 2026 (statutes and forms read November 17, 2026; Sarasota County permit records were not searched for any Stillwater parcel)

If the buyer's inspection turns up an open permit, AS IS paragraph 12(c) obliges the seller to "promptly deliver to Buyer all plans" and cooperate in the close-out (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline). For a pool, the SPDR form reminds sellers that "Florida law requires swimming pools, hot tubs, and spas that received a certificate of completion on or after October 1, 2000, to have at least one" of the features in section 515.27 (SPDR-4x); every older Stillwater home was built in 2000 or later, so any private pool there falls in that window (our reading). Any change to the exterior, a pool or a fence also needs association approval alongside the county permit, so keep both in the file.

What Is Law and Ordinance Coverage, and Why Does It Matter on an Older Stillwater Home?

Law and ordinance coverage pays for code upgrades a repair triggers, and Florida requires insurers to offer it at 25 or 50 percent of the dwelling limit. It matters most on an older Stillwater home whose roof predates the 2007 code, because a large repair there can require current-code work beyond the damaged area.

Section 627.7011(1): the offer "may be limited to 25 percent or 50 percent of the dwelling limit, as selected by the policyholder," "except that the insurer must offer the law and ordinance coverage limited to 50 percent of the dwelling limit" (Florida Statutes 627.7011, read November 17, 2026). On claims, "the insurer must initially pay at least the actual cash value of the insured loss, less any applicable deductible," and "the insurer may limit the claim payment as to the roof to the actual cash value of the loss to the roof" when the policy so provides (same statute).

For a seller, the point is disclosure and preparation, not coverage advice. A buyer of a 2004 Unit 1 home who learns that the roof predates the 553.844(5) exception will ask the agent about this coverage, so the roof permit and inspection in your file shorten that conversation. Grant help for a roof before listing is uncertain: the state hardening grant program's site returned an error on November 17, 2026, so program status could not be read, and WPTV's undated report said its grants "top out at $10,000" (state grant program site; WPTV, read November 17, 2026). Rates have eased somewhat: Citizens announced that homeowners multiperil rates would fall by an average 8.8 percent in 2026, with new rates taking effect July 1 for new policyholders and at renewal for existing ones (Citizens, March 4, 2026, read November 17, 2026). The underwriting gates above still apply to most older Stillwater homes. We put the roof and insurance file together with you before listing; request a free Stillwater home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

What Will a Buyer Ask About Flood Zones and Elevation Certificates in Stillwater?

A Stillwater buyer will ask your FEMA flood zone, whether an elevation certificate exists, what flood coverage costs, and from January 1, 2027 whether a Citizens policy needs flood coverage regardless of zone. One reading exists: Zone X at one Lake Victoria Court address in Stillwater Unit 1. Every other lot needs its own lookup.

Stillwater in Englewood sits under Sarasota County's countywide FEMA flood maps in force since March 27, 2024, as ABC7 reported when they took effect (ABC7 mysuncoast, February 29, 2024, as read for our Stillwater guide on November 17, 2026). FEMA's map services do not permit the automated lookups our research tools use, so this page holds one reading in one of the five plats and explains how you get the reading for your own lot. In a straight line on the Census Bureau's 2024 water layer, Stillwater is about 1.1 to 1.6 miles from Lemon Bay and 2.3 to 2.8 miles from the Gulf (Census TIGER/Line 2024 area water, Sarasota County); those are distances, not elevations.

What Do We Know About Flood Zones in Stillwater, Englewood?

Stillwater, Englewood has one recorded FEMA reading: Zone X at one Lake Victoria Court address in Stillwater Unit 1, from our team's check of FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer on November 14, 2026. It did not record the panel or the Zone X shading, so it is one data point, not a determination.

Part of Stillwater Streets on the county roll FEMA flood zone Source and date
Stillwater Unit 1 Lake Victoria Ct (one address) Zone X Check by our team, FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, November 14, 2026
Stillwater Units 1 and 2, other streets Abercrombie Dr, Abercrombie Ave, Clear Lake Dr, Lake Tahoe Ct, Montigello Ct Not checked Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026)
Stillwater Unit 3 Niagara Ct, Ontario Ct and others Not checked Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026)
Shores at Stillwater Phases 1A and 1B Silver Shores Blvd, Tavira Pl Not checked Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026)

Data updated: November 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, one reading by our team on November 14, 2026; street names from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel file dated October 21, 2026)

Whether any Shores at Stillwater lot carries a Letter of Map Revision based on fill was not verified; new lots are often regraded, so check the Map Service Center page for your panel. Do not take the Lake Victoria Court reading as your lot's zone, and do not let a buyer take it that way either.

How Do You Look Up the Flood Zone for Your Own Stillwater Lot?

Look up your Stillwater lot on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center by street address, and record the zone, whether Zone X is shaded or unshaded, the FIRM panel number and the March 27, 2024 effective date. Print the result for the listing file, then add any elevation certificate and your current flood declarations page.

The steps we use for a Stillwater, Englewood listing:

  1. FEMA's Flood Map Service Center. Open msc.fema.gov in a browser, search the address, and record the zone, shading, panel and effective date.
  2. Any Letter of Map Change shown for the panel, especially for a Shores at Stillwater lot.
  3. The elevation certificate, if one exists (next subsection).
  4. The current flood declarations page, if you carry flood coverage, so the buyer can see the real premium and ask about assignment.
  5. The county map line. ABC7 reported that residents could check their status at scgov.net/floodmaps or by calling 311 (ABC7 mysuncoast).

Silver Shores Boulevard and Tavira Place are too new for the Census Bureau's 2024 address file, so if a map tool cannot find a Shores address, search by parcel number (Census TIGER/Line 2024 address features). The FEMA zone also drives a contract right: AS IS paragraph 10(d) advises the buyer "to verify by elevation certificate which flood zone the Property is in, whether flood insurance is required by Buyer's lender, and what restrictions apply to improving the Property and rebuilding in the event of casualty," and gives a buyer in a Special Flood Hazard Area with a lowest floor below minimum elevation a right to terminate within "(if left blank, then 20) days after Effective Date" (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline, read November 17, 2026). Pulling the zone before listing removes the surprise from that 20-day window.

What Do Zone X, Shaded Zone X and a Special Flood Hazard Area Mean for a Stillwater Home?

For a Stillwater home, a Special Flood Hazard Area (Zones A, AE and others) is land FEMA expects a 1 percent annual chance flood to inundate; shaded Zone X is moderate hazard, between that and the 0.2 percent flood; unshaded Zone X is minimal hazard. Only the first triggers the federal lender mandate.

FEMA's glossary: Special Flood Hazard Areas "are defined as the area that will be inundated by the flood event having a 1-percent chance" of being equaled or exceeded in a given year and "are labeled as Zone A, Zone AO, Zone AH, Zones A1-A30, Zone AE"; moderate hazard areas, Zone B or shaded Zone X, "are the areas between the limits of the base flood and the 0.2-percent-annual-chance (or 500-year) flood"; minimal hazard areas are "labeled Zone C or Zone X (unshaded)" (FEMA, Glossary: flood zones, read November 17, 2026).

Federal law directs regulated lenders not to make a loan secured by improved real estate "located or to be located in an area that has been identified by the Administrator as an area having special flood hazards ... unless the building ... is covered for the term of the loan by flood insurance" (42 U.S.C. 4012a, read November 17, 2026). FEMA adds that its pricing "does not use flood zones to determine flood risk," but that maps still inform "floodplain management building requirements and the mandatory purchase requirement" (FEMA, Risk Rating 2.0, read November 17, 2026). So at a Zone X Stillwater lot no federal mandate applies, a buyer may still want coverage, and the Citizens rule below may require it.

Does a Stillwater Seller Need an Elevation Certificate?

A Stillwater seller does not need an elevation certificate to sell, but one can lower a buyer's flood premium and settles the AS IS flood-zone question. We found no elevation certificate for any Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater home in the sources we read; if you have one, attach it, as the SPDR form asks.

FloodSmart: "Elevation certificates aren't required to get flood insurance, but they can help you pay less," and "Your flood insurance premium is unique to your property" (FloodSmart, Flood insurance cost, read November 17, 2026). The SPDR form asks "Do you have an elevation certificate? If yes, please attach a copy" (SPDR-4x). An elevation certificate for any Stillwater, Englewood home: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). A Shores at Stillwater owner should ask Pulte's sales team whether one was prepared for the lot; an older-plat owner may find one in the original closing papers. If neither exists, a licensed surveyor can prepare one, and the buyer may order one during the inspection period.

The pond system behind Shores at Stillwater is public because the district finances it: "a comprehensive system of surface water management ponds, consisting primarily of wet detention ponds," designed for water quality treatment and "100-year flood control" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book, read November 17, 2026). District records indicate the older Stillwater sections are not in that district, and their pond design was not read for this page.

What Changes for a Stillwater Buyer With Citizens on January 1, 2027?

From January 1, 2027, every Citizens personal residential policy with wind coverage needs flood coverage, "regardless of value," even at a Zone X Stillwater address. From January 1, 2026 the rule already reached homes outside the Special Flood Hazard Area with a dwelling value of $400,000 or more.

Citizens policy outside the Special Flood Hazard Area Flood coverage required when dwelling value (Coverage A) is
Effective January 1, 2024 $600,000 or more
Effective January 1, 2025 $500,000 or more
Effective January 1, 2026 $400,000 or more
Effective January 1, 2027 All policies, regardless of value

Data updated: November 2026 (Citizens Property Insurance, Flood, read November 17, 2026; Florida Statutes 627.351(6), read November 17, 2026)

The statute behind the table says all personal lines residential policyholders "must have flood coverage in place" on those dates and that "The corporation may deny coverage of a personal lines residential risk to an applicant or insured who refuses to secure and maintain flood insurance" (Florida Statutes 627.351). Citizens lists the exemptions as "Condominium unit-owner policies, tenant content policies, and policies that exclude windstorm or hail coverage," and the flood limit must equal or exceed Coverage A or the NFIP maximum, "Regular NFIP program: up to $250,000 Coverage A" (Citizens, Flood).

Coverage A is a rebuild cost, not a price. The older-plat Stillwater resale median was $315,000 in the latest 12 months, with Unit 3 at $282,500 and Unit 1 at $550,000, and the Shores first-sale median was $523,250 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026), so a larger Unit 1 home or a Shores single-family home may already have crossed the $400,000 step in 2026, and every remaining Stillwater Citizens wind policy reaches it on January 1, 2027 (our reading of the Citizens table). Two other Citizens limits a Stillwater buyer may meet: a structure with a dwelling replacement cost of "$700,000 or more" is generally not eligible, and a primary residence renewing on or after April 1, 2023 is not eligible "unless the premium for coverage from the authorized insurer is more than 20 percent greater than the corporation's renewal premium for comparable coverage" (Florida Statutes 627.351). A listing that already shows a flood quote answers the 2027 question before the buyer asks it.

Can a Stillwater Buyer Take Over Your Flood Policy?

A Stillwater buyer can take over your National Flood Insurance Program policy by assignment at closing, keeping its rating and discount, and FEMA's rules limit most annual increases to 18 percent. A newly purchased policy normally waits 30 days to take effect, except when it is bought in connection with the buyer's loan.

FEMA: "Policyholders are able to transfer their discount to a new owner by assigning their flood insurance policy"; "As of April 1, 2023, FEMA fully implemented new pricing approach"; rating considers "flood frequency, multiple flood types: river overflow, storm surge, coastal erosion and heavy rainfall" plus elevation and the cost to rebuild; and "Existing statutory limits on rate increases require that most rates not increase more than 18% per year" (FEMA, Risk Rating 2.0, read November 17, 2026). FloodSmart's agent page: "If the building is sold, the policy can transfer to the new owner, allowing them to keep the lower rate," and "Continuous coverage is required to maintain the discount" (FloodSmart, Moving in, read November 17, 2026). FloodSmart also warns that "Flood insurance policies do not automatically renew" (FloodSmart).

The waiting period: new NFIP coverage becomes effective "upon the expiration of the 30-day period," except for "the initial purchase of flood insurance coverage ... when the purchase of insurance is in connection with the making, increasing, extension, or renewal of a loan" (42 U.S.C. 4013, read November 17, 2026). For a cash buyer, that 30-day clock is a reason to bind early or take an assignment. Ask your agent whether your policy can be assigned and put the declarations page in the file.

What Does Sarasota County's CRS Class Mean for a Stillwater Flood Policy?

Sarasota County is a Community Rating System Class 5 community, which carries a 25 percent discount on National Flood Insurance Program policies, and Stillwater in unincorporated Sarasota County is covered by the county's community number. FEMA says the discount applies "including policies outside of the Special Flood Hazard Area."

FEMA's eligible-communities list with an October 1, 2026 effective date shows the row "FL 125144 Sarasota County 10/1/1992 5/1/2007 5 25" (community number, name, original and current effective dates, class and percent discount) (FEMA, CRS Eligible Communities, October 2026, read November 17, 2026). FEMA explains that "Flood insurance premium discounts in CRS communities range from 5% to 45% and are discounted in increments of 5%," that Class 5 corresponds to 2,500 to 2,999 credit points, and that the discount applies to Regular Program policies "including policies outside of the Special Flood Hazard Area (SFHA)" unless a structure is out of compliance (FEMA, Community Rating System, read November 17, 2026).

Stillwater is in unincorporated Sarasota County, so community 125144 applies (our reading of the FEMA list). A flood premium for any Stillwater home: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026); your declarations page already shows the CRS discount, and handing it to a buyer early shows the real number.

Which Evacuation Level Is Your Stillwater Home In?

The evacuation level for Stillwater addresses is not verified for this page. Sarasota County uses levels A through E, with A evacuated first; your level appears on the county's Know Your Zone lookup and on your TRIM notice. Flood zone and evacuation level are different maps, so a Zone X home can still be in an ordered level.

WUSF describes the system: Sarasota County uses levels A through E, "with A being shown on the map as the color red and E as light blue," and "Those in evacuation A are considered to be the most vulnerable and would be evacuated first" (WUSF, Sarasota County hurricane evacuation zone map, published April 30, 2025, updated May 28, 2026, read November 17, 2026). The Property Appraiser's 2026 TRIM guide says the notice shows "Know your hurricane evacuation level" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, 2026 TRIM supplement, read November 17, 2026), and the state's Know Your Zone page links the statewide map.

Storm Sarasota County evacuation orders as reported Source
Ian, September 2022 "Zones A and B were ordered to evacuate" Your Observer, September 28, 2022
Helene, September 2024 "Zone A and manufactured homes" NWS Tampa Bay county narratives
Milton, October 2024 "Mandatory for zones A, B, and C, and for mobile and manufactured homes and boat homes" NWS Tampa Bay county narratives

Data updated: November 2026 (Your Observer, September 28, 2022; NWS Tampa Bay, Helene narratives; NWS Tampa Bay, Milton narratives; all read November 17, 2026)

The storms themselves, as official reports describe them near Englewood: in Ian, "The majority of the sensors placed in Port Charlotte and Englewood ... remained dry and did not measure storm surge due to offshore winds" (NHC Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian); in Helene, inundation of "4 to 6 ft AGL occurred from Venice to south of Englewood" (NHC, Hurricane Helene); and in Milton, Sarasota County gusts were "generally between 80 to 100 mph" with rainfall of "4 to 8 inches" (NWS Tampa Bay, Milton narratives, all read November 17, 2026). No report we read names Stillwater, so we claim no damage there and no absence of it. Write your level and the date you checked it into the listing file.

What Will a Buyer's Lender Ask About a Stillwater Home?

A Stillwater buyer's lender will ask whether the home is in a PUD or a condominium, what the association charges and owes, the flood zone, the insurance binder and, at Shores at Stillwater, the CDD line in escrow. Conventional PUD loans waive project review except basic requirements. Unit 3's home type is unverified, so we settle it early.

Stillwater in Englewood mixes three products on the county roll: detached homes coded 0100 in Units 1 and 2, the small-home section coded 0101 in Unit 3 with a median of 1,349 heated square feet, and Pulte's single-family homes and twin villas at Shores at Stillwater (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, parcel file dated October 21, 2026). Each product meets lender rules a little differently, and the buyer's loan type decides which rules apply. A lender's questions are easiest to answer when the association documents, insurance quotes and flood reading are in the file before the first offer.

What Does a Conventional Lender Need for a Stillwater Home?

A conventional lender treats a Stillwater home in an HOA-governed subdivision as a unit in a PUD, where Fannie Mae waives project review "with the exception of some basic requirements." The lender must still confirm whether the unit is in a condo or a PUD, which is why the Unit 3 question matters.

Fannie Mae's Selling Guide defines a PUD as a project where "The unit owners in the project have title to a residential property (lot and structure) and an interest in the HOA that owns or manages the common area," lists "Unit in a PUD project: Project review is waived, with the exception of some basic requirements that apply," and says lenders "must determine if the subject unit is located in a condo or PUD and use the appropriate mortgage documents and appraisal forms" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-2.1-01, dated August 5, 2026, read November 17, 2026). It also lists "Detached unit in a new or established condo project: Project review is waived, with the exception of some basic requirements that may apply" (same section).

On our reading, if Stillwater Units 1, 2 and 3 are platted fee-simple lots under an HOA, as the plat names suggest, a conventional buyer faces no condominium project review; that reading is ours, because the recorded plats and declarations were not read. What a lender will want regardless is proof that the association exists, what it charges and that the account is current, which the estoppel and budget give. We ask the association for both at listing.

Why Does Unit 3's Home Type Matter to a Stillwater Buyer's Lender?

Stillwater Unit 3's home type, attached or detached villa and fee simple or condominium, is unverified, and it matters because a condominium unit triggers project rules that a PUD lot does not, for FHA and VA loans especially. The roll codes all 140 Unit 3 homes 0101; the recorded plat and declaration settle the legal form.

What the record shows: all 140 Unit 3 homes carry use code 0101 on the county roll, the median Unit 3 home has 1,349 heated square feet, and the association's website is titled "Villas at Stillwater III" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Villas at Stillwater III, read November 17, 2026). The association was filed as a homeowners' association, and the Unit 3 homes appear on the roll as parcels in a recorded plat, which points toward platted lots rather than condominium units, but that is our inference, not a reading of the declaration. At Shores at Stillwater, the district engineer's product table lists "52' SF Detached 119" and "34' SF Attached 136," and Pulte describes its Villa Collection as "The attached villa floor plan" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated).

Stillwater product Roll use code What is known What a lender may ask
Units 1 and 2 0100 (single-family detached) Platted lots under an HOA (association names from Florida filings) PUD basics, HOA status
Unit 3 0101 140 homes, median 1,349 sq ft; "Villas at Stillwater III"; legal form unverified Whether the unit is a PUD lot or a condominium unit; attached or detached
Shores at Stillwater, 52-foot lots 0100 Detached single-family (district engineer) PUD basics, HOA, CDD line
Shores at Stillwater, 34-foot lots 0101 for finished villas Attached twin villas (district engineer; Pulte) Attached PUD basics, HOA, CDD line

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026; Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-2.1-01; read November 17, 2026)

For a Unit 3 seller, the step is simple: get the recorded plat and declaration from your closing papers or the association before listing, so the buyer's lender does not discover the answer in week three. It also tells the buyer who insures and maintains the roof and exterior.

What Will an FHA or VA Lender Ask About a Stillwater Home?

An FHA or VA lender will ask a Stillwater seller's file for the flood zone, the property's condition against program standards, and whether the home is a condominium unit needing project approval. VA lets a borrower "Buy a condo in a VA-approved project" and lists "Fewer closing costs, which may be paid by the seller."

VA's purchase-loan page lists those uses and says the borrower must qualify for a Certificate of Eligibility and meet the lender's standards (VA, Purchase loan, read November 17, 2026). FHA's rules sit in HUD's Single Family Housing Policy Handbook 4000.1 (HUD, Handbook 4000.1, read November 17, 2026). On flood, FHA's regulation says "No mortgage may be insured that covers property improvements located in an area that has been identified by FEMA as an area having special flood hazards unless the community ... is participating in the National Flood Insurance Program," and the parties must "obtain and maintain either NFIP flood insurance or private flood insurance" (24 CFR 203.16a, read November 17, 2026). Sarasota County participates in the NFIP as community 125144 (FEMA, CRS Eligible Communities, October 2026).

On our reading, a fee-simple Stillwater home needs no VA condominium approval, and the seller's negotiation with a VA buyer is about the appraisal and any seller-paid closing costs. FHA's condominium rules were not re-read for this page, which is one more reason to settle Unit 3's legal form before listing. USDA eligibility for Stillwater addresses was not tested; a buyer's lender confirms it by address.

How Much Can a Stillwater Seller Contribute to a Buyer's Closing Costs?

A Stillwater seller can contribute to a buyer's closing costs within the loan program's limit on interested-party contributions. On a conventional loan for a principal residence, Fannie Mae caps them at 3 percent above 90 percent loan-to-value, 6 percent from 75.01 to 90 percent, and 9 percent at 75 percent or less.

Fannie Mae's Selling Guide sets the caps: principal residence or second home, LTV or CLTV "Greater than 90%": 3%; "75.01%" to "90%": 6%; "75% or less": 9%; investment property: 2%. Contributions may pay "Borrower closing costs, including prepaids," and if an interested party or its affiliated lender funds a rate buydown, "the cost of that subsidy must be included in the IPC calculation" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02, read November 17, 2026).

Stillwater example (our arithmetic) Price Cap Maximum seller contribution
Older-plat resale median, 95% conventional loan $315,000 3% $9,450
Older-plat resale median, 80% conventional loan $315,000 6% $18,900

Data updated: November 2026 (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02, read November 17, 2026; $315,000 is the 12-month older-plat resale median from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026)

The same cap limits how much of a builder's credit can go to closing costs on a conventional loan. Pulte's November offer of up to $77,000 can go "toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins as a reduction to the total purchase price," and Pulte's own fine print says the offer "may affect the amount of loan for which a buyer may be eligible" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). So some of that headline figure lands as price or options rather than closing-cost help on a given loan; how Pulte allocates it per contract is unverified. A resale seller's credit, written as a closing-cost credit the buyer can use with any lender, competes directly.

How Do Pulte Mortgage's Advertised Rates Compare With a Stillwater Resale Loan?

Pulte's payment calculator for Shores at Stillwater showed, on November 17, 2026, illustrative rates of 6.5 percent for a 30-year conventional loan (6.552 percent APR), 5.25 percent for FHA (5.916 percent APR) and 5.125 percent for a 7/6 ARM introductory rate (6.007 percent APR), locked with Pulte Mortgage from November 2 to 15, 2026, on a 780 FICO.

Loan type in Pulte's calculator Rate APR Down payment
Conventional 30-year 6.5% 6.552% 20%
FHA 30-year 5.25% 5.916% 3.5%
Conventional 7/6 ARM, introductory 5.125% 6.007% 20%

Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, payment calculator settings, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026; illustrative, not an offer)

The fine print: the rates are "illustrative only, based on an average of 30-year conventional or FHA loans, respectively, locked with Pulte Mortgage LLC from 11/02/2026 to 11/15/2026," and assume "participation in the Affiliate Incentive Program, including financing through Pulte Mortgage LLC (NMLS 1791), and application of all incentives toward closing costs, including any discount points, based on a FICO Score of 780. You are not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage to purchase a home from seller; but use of Pulte Mortgage is necessary to receive BFC-related rate offers where and when available." The Builder Forward Commitment "is limited to new home agreements only and the sale must close by a specified date," and "Estimated payments do not include monthly homeowners' association dues" (same page). A Stillwater resale cannot offer a forward commitment, but it can offer a seller-paid buydown or credit inside the caps above, usable with the buyer's choice of lender.

What Does a Shores at Stillwater Lender See in Escrow?

A Shores at Stillwater lender sees the CDD assessment as part of the escrowed tax payment once it is on the tax roll, which raises the qualifying payment; district records indicate older Stillwater homes carry no district line. For FY2026/2027 the district's operations charge is collected at closings, and no Shores CDD code is on the 2026 roll.

The district's FAQ: "The assessment will appear on the property tax bill sent in November of each year. If you have a mortgage on your property and your taxes are escrowed, your assessments will be included in your monthly mortgage payment" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, FAQs, read November 17, 2026). The Tax Collector's 2026 list carries no Shores at Stillwater CDD code, and whether the debt assessments will be placed on the 2027 roll or billed directly is unverified (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage). At the methodology maximums the debt line is up to $1,382.68 a year on a 34-foot lot and $1,914.48 on a 52-foot lot (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book), about $115 or $160 a month in escrow (our arithmetic), before operations.

Buying rather than selling? Our buyer team reads Pulte contracts and resale files side by side; see buying a home in Englewood, or call Marc at (239) 287-5873. Selling a Stillwater home and want the lender file ready before the first offer? Request a free Stillwater home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

What Happens to Property Taxes When You Sell in Stillwater?

When you sell in Stillwater, your 2026 taxes are prorated to the day before closing because Florida bills in arrears, your homestead and Save Our Homes cap end with the sale, and the buyer's assessment resets to just value the next January 1. Your Save Our Homes difference may move to your next Florida homestead, up to $500,000.

Stillwater in Englewood is in unincorporated Sarasota County, so no city millage applies: the 2026 countywide rate for the area is 11.3068 mills, down from 11.4737 in 2025, plus flat non-ad valorem charges such as the Englewood Area Fire Control District's $290.78 per home (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2025 millage; Englewood Fire, assessments, read November 17, 2026). No actual Stillwater tax bill was read for this page, so solid waste, stormwater and any special-area lines on your bill are unverified until you pull it. The figures below are rates and rules; your own bill and TRIM notice give your numbers.

What Millage Applies to a Stillwater Home in 2026?

A Stillwater home pays the 2026 Sarasota County countywide rate for areas outside Longboat Key, North Port and Venice: 11.3068 mills, made up of 4.6478 county mills, 5.9290 school mills and 0.7300 for emergency medical services. The 2025 total was 11.4737 mills.

Levy on the 2026 roll, as printed 2026 mills
Sarasota County General Revenue 3.2317
Mosquito Control 0.0490
Sarasota Co. Hospital District 1.0420
West Coast Inland Navigation 0.0394
SW FL Water Management 0.1831
Bonds, Debt Service 0.0653
Legacy Trail, Debt Service 0.0373
Total county, not including school 4.6478
School Board, State 2.6810
School Board, Local Non-Voted 2.2480
School Board, Local Voted 1.0000
Total school 5.9290
Emergency Medical Services (all but Longboat Key, North Port and Venice) 0.7300
Total countywide (all but Longboat Key, North Port and Venice) 11.3068

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 ad valorem taxes and non-ad valorem assessments, tax roll certified September 29, 2026, read November 17, 2026)

The non-school portion is 5.3778 mills (11.3068 minus 5.9290, our arithmetic on the Tax Collector's sheet), which matters because homestead exemptions treat school and non-school levies differently (below). The same sheet lists special-area codes for Englewood lighting, Englewood Water District capital and sewer areas, county stormwater and the solid waste district; whether a Stillwater parcel sits inside any of them is unverified without a bill (same sheet).

What Non-Ad Valorem Lines Does a Stillwater Bill Carry?

Every improved Stillwater home pays the Englewood Area Fire Control District's flat $290.78 residential assessment for 2026 to 2027, and a vacant Shores lot pays $63.95. The fire charge is not based on value and homestead does not reduce it. Other non-ad valorem lines are unverified, and older-plat bills indicate no CDD line.

The district's page: "2026-2027 Englewood Fire Department Non-Ad-Valorem Assessments Residential $290.78 Commercial $0.41 sq. ft. Church $0.29 sq. ft. Vacant Lot $63.95," and "The Englewood Area Fire Control District receives no funds from county taxes"; non-ad valorem assessments are not based on value "nor are they affected by the Homestead Exemption" (Englewood Fire, assessments, read November 17, 2026). The Tax Collector lists it as "F092 Englewood Fire Control" with no millage (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage).

Stillwater bill line Older plats, Units 1 to 3 Shores at Stillwater Status
Ad valorem at 11.3068 mills Yes Yes (lot only until the home is on the January 1 roll) Tax Collector 2026 sheet
Englewood Area Fire Control District $290.78 per home $290.78 per home; $63.95 per vacant lot District page, FY 2026 to 2027
Shores at Stillwater CDD No line indicated Not on the 2026 roll; operations collected at closings for FY2026/2027 District budget; Tax Collector list
Solid waste, stormwater, lighting, water district areas Unverified Unverified No bill read

Data updated: November 2026 (Englewood Fire, assessments; Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Shores at Stillwater CDD, Final Budget 2026-2027; all read November 17, 2026)

Florida's rule on new construction explains the Shores column: "Improvements or portions not substantially completed on January 1 shall have no value placed thereon" (Florida Statutes 192.042, read November 17, 2026). A Shores home finished after January 1, 2026 is taxed on the lot for 2026, so a Shores seller's 2026 bill is not a guide to a full year with the house, and the buyer will see a larger bill once the home is assessed.

How Does Save Our Homes Reset for Your Stillwater Buyer?

Your Stillwater buyer does not inherit your Save Our Homes cap. Section 193.155(3)(a) says homestead property "shall be assessed at just value as of January 1 of the year following a change of ownership," so a long-held Stillwater homestead's capped value ends with the sale and the buyer starts from market value.

The Property Appraiser's 2026 guide: "A transfer of ownership or control of real property, with few exceptions, resets the assessed and taxable value to market value for the following year. Assessment limitations and exempt status are NOT inheritable, transferable, or continued," and "If you purchased property after January 1, 2026, it may show assessment limitations and applicable exemptions from the previous owner. Per Florida Statute, the property will reset to market value on January 1, 2027" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, 2026 TRIM supplement; Florida Statutes 193.155, read November 17, 2026).

Year Save Our Homes cap applied
2021 1.4%
2022 3.0%
2023 3.0%
2024 3.0%
2025 2.9%
2026 2.7%

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Save Our Homes; Florida Department of Revenue, Save Our Homes, revised January 2026, read November 17, 2026)

Set that cap against what Stillwater resales recorded. In the latest 12 months, the 10 older-plat resales whose earlier qualified sale was before 2020 sold a median 50.5 percent above the earlier recorded price, all 10 above it (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026). The caps above compound to well under that over the same years, so a long-held Stillwater homestead typically carries an assessed value well below market (our inference; the gap for any one home was not read, because parcel and TRIM pages were not available to our tools). That gap is what the section 689.261 summary warns your buyer about, and what portability may let you carry with you.

Non-homestead property has its own cap: after the first year, "Any change resulting from such reassessment may not exceed 10 percent of the assessed value of the property for the prior year" (Florida Statutes 193.1555), and the appraiser notes "the school board levy on non-homesteaded property is always based on its full market value" (2026 TRIM supplement).

What Might a Stillwater Buyer Pay in Property Tax?

At the $315,000 older-plat Stillwater resale median and 2026 rates, a buyer assessed at the price would owe about $3,561.64 in ad valorem tax as a second home or rental, or about $3,136.94 with a homestead under 2026 exemption rules, before the $290.78 fire charge and other non-ad valorem lines. These are illustrations, not bills.

Illustration at 2026 rates (our arithmetic, not a bill) Older-plat resale median, $315,000 Unit 1 median, $550,000
Non-homestead, 11.3068 mills on the price $3,561.64 $6,218.74
Homestead under 2026 rules ($25,000 on all levies; $26,411 more on non-school levies) $3,136.94 $5,794.04
Plus Englewood Area Fire Control District $290.78 $290.78

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Florida Department of Revenue, additional homestead exemption; Florida Statutes 196.031; Englewood Fire; prices are 12-month medians from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser; all read November 17, 2026)

The homestead figures use the $25,000 exemption "from all taxation, except for assessments for special benefits," and the indexed additional exemption, which the Department of Revenue lists at "$26,411" for 2026 and applies "to the assessed value greater than $50,000" (sources in the table). Solid waste and stormwater are not included because no Stillwater bill was read. Pulte's own estimate runs higher: its Colton payment example shows "Estimated Taxes" of $368.01 a month on a $309,990 price, about $4,416 a year, against about $3,505 at 11.3068 mills on that price (Pulte, Colton, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026); Pulte does not say what its figure includes, so what makes up the difference is unverified.

How Does Portability Work When You Leave Stillwater?

Portability lets a Stillwater homestead seller move the Save Our Homes difference, up to $500,000, to a new Florida homestead established within the 3 years after the last homestead year. You apply with form DR-501T as part of the new homestead application, by March 1 of the year you claim it.

The statute: property "shall be assessed at less than just value when the person who establishes a new homestead has received a homestead exemption as of January 1 of any of the 3 immediately preceding years"; for a larger home, "the assessed value of the new homestead shall be the just value of the new homestead minus an amount equal to the lesser of $500,000 or the difference between the just value and the assessed value of the prior homestead as of January 1 of the year in which the prior homestead was abandoned" (Florida Statutes 193.155(8), read November 17, 2026). The statute notes that amendments by chapter 2026-239 "first apply to the 2027 ad valorem tax roll"; what that chapter changed in section 193.155 was not extracted for this page.

The Property Appraiser's FAQ answers the questions Stillwater sellers ask: "Do I have to sell my previous homestead before I qualify for portability? No. The previous homestead must have been abandoned by all homesteaders, but there is no requirement that the property be sold"; "A portability application, form DR-501T Transfer of Homestead Assessment Difference, will be provided to you as part of the homestead application process"; downsizing uses "the ratio of the Market to the Assessed Value of your previous homestead"; and "To transfer 100% of a Cap, all homesteaded owners of the previous homestead must move to the new homestead" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Portability FAQ, read November 17, 2026).

A worked example with hypothetical values: a Unit 1 homestead with a $550,000 just value and a $350,000 assessed value on January 1 of the year it is abandoned carries a $200,000 difference; upsizing moves the full $200,000, and downsizing to a $400,000 home moves about $145,455 (200,000 x 400,000 / 550,000, our arithmetic on the FAQ's ratio rule). Your own just and assessed values are on your TRIM notice. Ownership length makes this a live question in Stillwater: the median older-plat home has gone 9 years since its last qualified sale (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026).

When Does a Stillwater Homestead End, and What Should You File?

A Stillwater homestead ends for the next January 1 when you sell, because the change of ownership resets value and the exemption does not transfer. If you move out or rent the home before selling, you may lose the exemption for that year; tell the Property Appraiser to avoid back taxes, a 50 percent penalty and 15 percent interest.

The appraiser's deadlines: "you must be a Florida resident and own and occupy the property as your permanent residence on January 1st of the year you claim the exemption," and "you must apply by March 1st of the year for which you are claiming the exemption" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Homestead overview, read November 17, 2026). Among the ways the appraiser lists to lose homestead: "If you rent your property on January 1, or, rent your property for more than 30 days per calendar year in two consecutive years," and a residency-based exemption or homestead claimed elsewhere (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Top ways to lose your homestead, read November 17, 2026).

The penalty for an improper exemption within the prior 10 years is the unpaid taxes plus "a penalty of 50 percent of the unpaid taxes for each year, plus 15 percent interest per year," secured by a recorded tax lien (Florida Statutes 196.161, read November 17, 2026). On our reading, the year of sale stays exempt if you qualified on January 1 of that year, and a Stillwater seller who is buying another Florida home should file the new homestead and DR-501T by March 1 of the following year. Questions about your parcel go to the Property Appraiser; the TRIM guide lists the Tax Collector at (941) 861-8300 (2026 TRIM supplement).

How Are Taxes Prorated at a Stillwater Closing?

Taxes at a Stillwater closing are prorated as of the day before closing, because Florida's bill for each year is due in November of that year. The seller credits the buyer for January 1 through the day before closing and the buyer pays the bill; without a current bill, last year's is used and readjusted on request.

The payment rule: "All taxes shall be due and payable on November 1 of each year or as soon thereafter as the certified tax roll is received by the tax collector. Taxes shall become delinquent on April 1 following the year in which they are assessed" (Florida Statutes 197.333), with discounts of 4 percent in November, 3 percent in December, 2 percent in January and 1 percent in February (Florida Statutes 197.162, read November 17, 2026). The contract language: "The following items will be made current (if applicable) and prorated as of the day before Closing: real estate taxes (including special benefit tax assessments imposed by a community development district ("CDD")), interest, bonds, assessments, association fees, insurance, rents," and "If taxes and assessments for the current year cannot be determined, taxes will be prorated on the basis of taxes for the preceding year as of the day before Closing and will be computed and readjusted, at either party's request, when the current taxes are determined with adjustment for exemptions and improvements" (Florida Realtors, Contract for Residential Sale and Purchase, CRSP-16, paragraph 9(d), read November 17, 2026).

Stillwater proration illustration (our arithmetic) Figure
Closing date June 30, 2026
Estimated 2026 bill $3,000
Seller's days, January 1 to June 29 180
Seller credit to buyer 3,000 x 180 / 365 = $1,479.45
Who pays the November 2026 bill The buyer, in full

Data updated: November 2026 (illustration only; contract terms and the closing agent's figures control; Florida Statutes 197.333)

The Tax Collector confirms the buyer side: taxes "are usually prorated on the closing statement," "This credit is between you and the seller," and the owner of record is "responsible for paying the entire tax bill" (Sarasota County Tax Collector, property tax, read November 17, 2026). For a Stillwater closing in November or December 2026, the 2026 bill is out, so the agent can prorate on the actual bill and may pay it at the discount in force. Two Stillwater cautions: a homestead seller's bill understates the buyer's next bill, and a Shores bill for a home finished after January 1 is a lot-only bill, so the contract's improvement clause applies.

What Does Amendment 3 Mean for a Stillwater Sale?

For a Stillwater sale, treat Amendment 3 as not yet law in force: unofficial returns from the November 3, 2026 ballot show about 62 percent yes, but as of November 17, 2026 certification was not found and implementing law was pending. Its text would raise the non-school homestead exemption from January 1, 2027.

What the sources say, and only that:

  • The vote. WGCU reported on November 4, 2026 that "Amendment 3 passed with 62 percent of the vote," above the 60 percent amendments need; that is an unofficial count, and certification by the state canvassing commission was not found as of November 17, 2026 (WGCU, November 4, 2026, read November 17, 2026).
  • The text. The joint resolution filed with the Department of State would set the non-school homestead exemption "Beginning on January 1, 2027, up to the assessed valuation of one hundred and fifty thousand dollars" and "Beginning on January 1, 2028, up to the assessed valuation of two hundred and fifty thousand dollars," keep school levies at "twenty-five thousand dollars," and lower the non-homestead residential cap from "ten percent (10%)" to "five percent (5%)" beginning January 1, 2027 (CS/HJR 1F, full text, read November 17, 2026).
  • New residents. Under the same text, a person who "had not maintained a permanent residence in this state as of December 31, 2026" would receive $25,000 for school levies and "up to the assessed valuation of fifty thousand dollars" for other levies until "the fifth year of exemption"; implementing legislation for that rule was not found (same text).
  • What it does not touch. The text keeps the exemption's "except assessments for special benefits" wording, so the $290.78 fire charge and any CDD line are unchanged, and Save Our Homes stays in place (our reading of the text).

If the text takes effect as written and 2026 rates held, a homestead buyer at the $315,000 median would owe about $2,606.75 in ad valorem tax for 2027 rather than $3,136.94 under 2026 rules (our arithmetic, illustration only; CS/HJR 1F; Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage). For a seller, the timing points are the buyer's: a buyer who owns the Stillwater home and makes it a permanent residence on January 1, 2027 and files by March 1, 2027 is positioned for whatever exemption is in force for 2027. We will update this section when certification and implementing law are published.

Do You Owe Capital Gains Tax When You Sell a Stillwater Home?

Most long-held Stillwater homes sell inside the federal exclusion: Section 121 lets you exclude up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 on a joint return, if you owned the home and used it as your principal residence for 2 of the 5 years before the sale. Florida has no personal income tax. This is general information, not tax advice.

Stillwater in Englewood is a long-tenure community by the county record: of 211 older-plat homes with a qualified sale on file, the median is 9 years since the last one, and in the latest 12 months the 15 resales that could be matched to an earlier sale had been held a median 98 months, at a median 12.2 percent above the earlier recorded price (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). The recorded change is not a gain figure: your gain is the amount realized minus your adjusted basis, which adds improvements and purchase costs and subtracts selling costs. A tax adviser settles your number; the rules below frame the conversation.

What Are the Section 121 Tests for a Stillwater Home?

For a Stillwater home, Section 121 requires that you owned it and used it as your principal residence for periods totaling 2 years or more during the 5 years ending on the sale date. The exclusion is $250,000, or $500,000 on a joint return if either spouse meets the ownership test and both meet the use test.

The statute: "Gross income shall not include gain from the sale or exchange of property if, during the 5-year period ending on the date of the sale or exchange, such property has been owned and used by the taxpayer as the taxpayer's principal residence for periods aggregating 2 years or more," and the exclusion "shall not exceed $250,000," or "$500,000" on a joint return when "either spouse meets the ownership requirements" and "both spouses meet the use requirements" (26 U.S.C. 121, read November 17, 2026). IRS Publication 523: "If you owned the home for at least 24 months (2 years) out of the last 5 years leading up to the date of sale (date of the closing), you meet the ownership requirement"; "All that is required is a total of 24 months (730 days) of residence during the 5-year period"; and "You may take the exclusion only once during a 2-year period" (IRS Publication 523, read November 17, 2026).

IRS Topic 701 adds two points sellers miss: "You can meet the ownership and use tests during different 2-year periods. However, you must meet both tests during the 5-year period ending on the date of the sale," and "Generally, you're not eligible for the exclusion if you excluded the gain from the sale of another home during the two-year period prior to the sale" (IRS Topic 701, read November 17, 2026). A Stillwater home used as a second home or rental for part of the period needs an adviser, because gain equal to depreciation "allowed or allowable ... for periods after May 6, 1997" cannot be excluded (IRS Publication 523).

How Long Have Stillwater Owners Held Before Selling?

Stillwater owners have held a long time: of 211 older-plat homes with a qualified sale on file, 93 have gone 10 or more years since the last one and 56 have gone 5 to 10, while 36 changed hands in the last 2 years. For most, the 2-of-5-year test is met; the question is basis.

Older Stillwater homes, years since last qualified sale (as of October 21, 2026) Homes
Under 2 years 36
2 to 5 years 26
5 to 10 years 56
10 years or more 93
Median 9 years (middle half 4 to 14)
Older-plat homes with no qualified sale on file 40

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; improved homes in Stillwater Units 1 to 3; earliest qualified sale on file for these plats January 6, 2009)

The 36 homes under 2 years are the group the partial-exclusion rules (below) were written for, along with every Shores at Stillwater home, all of which closed their first sale in 2025 or 2026: the first Shores sale on the county file is dated February 27, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The resale record also shows how timing played out. In the latest 12 months, resales whose earlier sale was before 2020 recorded a median 50.5 percent above that price, the 2 with an earlier sale in 2020 or 2021 recorded 6.4 and 10.1 percent above, and all 3 with an earlier sale in 2022 or later recorded below it, at a median 8.7 percent below (same file). Those are recorded prices, not anyone's gain or loss: improvements, roofs, closing costs and financing are not in the county record.

What Counts in the Basis of a Stillwater Home?

The basis of a Stillwater home is what you paid plus certain purchase costs and the cost of improvements, such as a new roof, impact windows, a pool or central air conditioning. Repairs, such as painting or fixing leaks, do not count. A larger basis means a smaller gain, so the invoices matter.

Publication 523 lists settlement costs that add to basis: "Abstract fees (abstract of title fees), Charges for installing utility services, Legal fees (including fees for the title search and preparing the sales contract and deed), Recording fees, Survey fees, Transfer or stamp taxes, and Owner's title insurance"; not included are "Fire and casualty insurance premiums" and loan charges such as "Fee for an appraisal required by a lender" (IRS Publication 523, read November 17, 2026). On improvements: "Improvements add to the value of your home, prolong its useful life, or adapt it to new uses. You add the cost of additions and improvements to the basis of your property," with examples including "Swimming pool," "Central air conditioning," "Storm windows/doors," "New roof," "Water heater" and "Kitchen modernization"; not included are "painting (interior or exterior), fixing leaks, filling holes or cracks," and "replacing broken windowpanes is a repair, but replacing the same window as part of a project of replacing all the windows in your home counts as an improvement" (same publication).

Stillwater project Basis treatment under Publication 523 Where it also matters on this page
Full reroof Improvement ("New roof") Insurer roof age; 553.844(5) code era
Impact windows replacing all windows Improvement (whole-house window project) Wind mitigation opening protection
Storm shutters or storm doors Improvement ("Storm windows/doors") Wind mitigation
New central air conditioning Improvement Four-point HVAC age
Pool and screen enclosure Improvement ("Swimming pool") Permit and pool safety feature
Repainting, leak repair Repair, not basis Disclose a leak under Johnson v. Davis

Data updated: November 2026 (IRS Publication 523, read November 17, 2026; our mapping of Stillwater projects to the publication's examples)

Selling costs reduce the amount realized: Worksheet 2 includes sales commissions, advertising fees, legal fees, loan charges the seller paid that the buyer would normally pay, and "Any other fees or costs to sell the home" (IRS Publication 523). For a Shores at Stillwater owner, IRS Publication 551 says to "Increase the basis of property by assessments for items such as paving roads and building ditches that increase the value of the property assessed," while maintenance and interest charges are treated differently (IRS Publication 551, read November 17, 2026); whether any CDD amount you paid belongs in basis is a question for your adviser.

Is There a Partial Exclusion If You Sell a Stillwater Home Early?

A Stillwater owner who sells before meeting the 2-year tests may still exclude part of the gain if the main reason is a work-related move, a health-related move or an unforeseeable event, as Publication 523 defines them. The excluded amount is prorated: the qualifying time divided by 24 months, times $250,000.

Publication 523's qualifying reasons include a "Work-Related Move," where the new job is "at least 50 miles farther from the home than your old work location"; a "Health-Related Move"; and "Unforeseeable Events," including "Your home suffered a casualty loss because of a natural or man-made disaster," death, divorce or legal separation, and others the publication lists (IRS Publication 523, read November 17, 2026). The worksheet takes the smallest of the time used as a residence, the time owned and the time since the last exclusion sale, and says to "divide that number by 730 (if using days) or 24 (if using months)," then "Multiply the result from Step 2 by $250,000," repeating for a spouse on a joint return (same publication; statute at 26 U.S.C. 121(c)).

A worked illustration: a single Stillwater owner who used the home 12 months before a qualifying work move computes 12 / 24 x $250,000 = $125,000 as the maximum exclusion (our arithmetic on the worksheet). Whether a storm-related casualty counts for a particular early sale is a question for a tax adviser. For a short-hold seller, the more common outcome in the recent record is no gain at all: all 3 older-plat resales in the latest 12 months whose earlier sale was in 2022 or later recorded below that price (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), and IRS Topic 409 says "Losses from the sale of personal-use property, such as your home or car, aren't tax deductible" (IRS Topic 409, read November 17, 2026).

Is a Stillwater Gain Short-Term or Long-Term?

A Stillwater gain is long-term if you held the home more than one year and short-term if you held it one year or less; any gain the exclusion does not cover is taxed at the matching federal rate. For 2025 returns the IRS says the rate on most net capital gain is no higher than 15 percent for most individuals.

IRS Topic 409: "Generally, if you hold the asset for more than one year before you dispose of it, your capital gain or loss is long-term. If you hold it one year or less, your capital gain or loss is short-term," and "For taxable years beginning in 2025, the tax rate on most net capital gain is no higher than 15% for most individuals"; a 0 percent rate applies up to $48,350 of taxable income for single filers, and "a capital gains rate of 20% applies to the extent that your taxable income exceeds the thresholds set for the 15% capital gain rate" (IRS Topic 409, read November 17, 2026). Net investment income tax may also apply (same topic).

In Stillwater the short-term case is not hypothetical. Two Unit 1 resales in March 2026 followed earlier sales of the same homes 11 and 12 months before, and one Unit 3 resale in February 2026 followed an earlier sale 21 months before (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026); all three recorded below the earlier price, at 4.8, 10.3 and 8.7 percent below. Holding period, exclusion and loss rules all turned on dates there, which is why we put the purchase date in the first conversation.

How Do FIRPTA, Florida's Constitution and Form 1099-S Apply to a Stillwater Sale?

FIRPTA requires a buyer to withhold 15 percent of the amount realized when a Stillwater seller is a foreign person, though exceptions exist. Florida's constitution bars a state tax on residents' income, so no state income tax applies to a Florida resident's gain. Most Stillwater closings produce a Form 1099-S unless the seller certifies an excludable residence sale.

FIRPTA: the buyer must withhold "15% (10% for dispositions before Feb. 17, 2016) of the amount realized on the disposition"; "In most cases, the buyer (transferee) is the withholding agent"; and "If the transferor is a foreign person and the transferee fails to withhold, the transferee may be held liable for the tax" (IRS, FIRPTA Withholding, read November 17, 2026). The IRS publishes the exceptions separately (IRS, Exceptions from FIRPTA Withholding), and the contract says the parties "will comply with the Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act, which may require Seller to provide additional cash at Closing if Seller is a 'foreign person'" (CRSP-16, paragraph 9(f)). Withholding is a prepayment against tax, not a fee; a foreign Stillwater seller should talk to a tax adviser before listing.

Florida: "No tax upon estates or inheritances or upon the income of natural persons who are residents or citizens of the state shall be levied by the state, or under its authority, in excess of the aggregate of amounts which may be allowed to be credited upon or deducted from any similar tax levied by the United States or any state" (Florida Constitution, Article VII, Section 5, read November 17, 2026). A seller resident in another state may owe tax there.

Form 1099-S: the closing agent generally files it, and a residence sale is not reportable at "$250,000 or less if you received an acceptable written assurance (certification) from the seller that such residence is the principal residence (within the meaning of section 121) of the seller and the full amount of the gain on such sale is excludable," with "$500,000" for a married seller's certification (IRS, Instructions for Form 1099-S, read November 17, 2026). Every older-plat Stillwater resale in the latest 12 months closed at $250,000 or more, from $250,000 to $620,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), so most Stillwater sellers should expect a 1099-S, and IRS Topic 701 says a seller who receives one "must report the sale of the home even if the gain from the sale is excludable" (IRS Topic 701). Bring your purchase closing statement and improvement invoices to your adviser; request a free Stillwater home valuation and we will give you the net sheet that goes with them, or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How Do You Prepare a Stillwater Home for Sale?

Prepare a Stillwater home for sale by building the file a buyer's insurer, lender and attorney will ask for before you list: roof permit and age, a current wind mitigation report, a four-point report on an older home, your FEMA reading and any elevation certificate, HOA approvals and closed permits, and, at Shores at Stillwater, the Pulte warranty papers.

Stillwater in Englewood sells on documents more than on staging, because most older homes are 13 to 26 years old and most buyers will also tour Pulte's new homes next door, where the build date answers the insurer's questions by itself (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated). We do not price inspections or services on this page; prices vary by provider. What we can tell you is which documents to gather, in what order, and how long each takes.

Which Documents Should a Stillwater Seller Gather Before Listing?

A Stillwater seller should gather the deed and purchase closing statement, the owner's title policy, the roof permit or invoice, a wind mitigation report on the current form, a four-point report if the home is more than 20 years old, the FEMA printout, insurance declarations, HOA documents and approvals, permit close-outs and, for Shores, warranty and CDD papers.

Document Why a Stillwater buyer or agent asks Older plats Shores at Stillwater
Owner's title policy from your purchase Reissue rate if under 3 years old If bought within 3 years Yes, from the Pulte closing
Roof permit, invoice or inspection with remaining life 627.7011(5); Citizens roof rules Essential on 2000 to 2011 homes Build date answers it
Wind mitigation report, OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26) Wind credits for the buyer's quote Order new if older than the 5-year window Ask Pulte or order one
Four-point report Citizens rule for homes more than 20 years old Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes from 2005 or earlier Not needed
FEMA printout and any elevation certificate Lender, insurer, AS IS 10(d) Every lot Every lot
Insurance declarations, wind and flood Real premium; possible flood assignment Yes Yes
HOA declaration, rules, budget, approvals 720.401 summary; estoppel; architectural approvals Yes; ask early for Unit 3 Yes
Permit close-outs AS IS 10(b) and 12(c) Reroof, air conditioning, windows, enclosure Work added after closing
Pulte warranty book and service records Transfer to the next owner Not applicable Yes
CDD payoff or assessment letter Debt disclosure; prepayment option Not applicable Yes
Mortgage payoff letter Section 701.04, 10 days If mortgaged If mortgaged

Data updated: November 2026 (statutes, forms and rules read November 17, 2026, as cited in the sections above; Stillwater build years from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026)

The mortgage payoff letter has its own statute: "Within 10 days after receipt of the written request of a mortgagor, a record title owner of the property ... the mortgagee or mortgage servicer shall send or cause to be sent an estoppel letter setting forth the unpaid balance of the loan," including "Interest accruing on a per-day basis" (Florida Statutes 701.04, read November 17, 2026). Water and sewer in Stillwater are Englewood Water District accounts; the district lists "Transfer Service" and its local number, 941.474.3217, so ask it for a final reading date (Englewood Water District, read November 17, 2026).

How Do You Document a Stillwater Roof's Age and Condition?

Document a Stillwater roof with the permit for the last full replacement, the contractor's invoice and warranty, and, if the roof is original or 15 years or older, an inspection by an authorized inspector stating remaining useful life. Roof age runs from the last date 100 percent of the roof was replaced.

The steps, in the order we use them for a Stillwater listing:

  1. Find the last full reroof. The county permit record shows the date and scope; your invoice shows the material. Under section 627.7011(5)(d) the age runs from "the last date on which 100 percent of the roof's surface area was built or replaced" (Florida Statutes 627.7011).
  2. If there is none, assume the build year. For an original roof, that means 10 to 26 years in Unit 1, about 20 to 21 in Unit 2 and 13 to 19 in Unit 3 in 2026 (our arithmetic on the county roll).
  3. Order an inspection that states remaining life. For a roof 15 years or older, a finding of "5 years or more of useful life remaining" is the statutory protection; for Citizens, a shingle roof older than 25 years needs that documentation (Citizens, Inspections).
  4. Check the code era. A full replacement permitted after March 1, 2009 brings the roof inside the 553.844(5) partial-repair rule (Florida Building Commission, effective dates).
  5. Settle responsibility in Unit 3. Confirm from the declaration whether the owner or the association is responsible for the roof.
  6. Keep any assignable warranty. AS IS paragraph 12(d): "At Buyer's option and cost, Seller will, at Closing, assign all assignable repair, treatment and maintenance contracts and warranties to Buyer" (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline).

Whether to replace a roof before selling is a cost against insurability decision. CBS12 reported an agent's view that a new roof "may open more insurance options and possibly qualify for wind mitigation discounts" (CBS12, August 11, 2026, read November 17, 2026). A roof inspection stating remaining life is the lower-cost first step under the statute, and it tells you whether the replacement question is real.

Should a Stillwater Seller Order Inspections Before Listing?

A Stillwater seller of an older home should consider ordering a four-point, a wind mitigation report and a roof inspection before listing, because those are the documents the buyer's insurer will request inside the 15-day inspection period. A wood destroying organism report is optional and usually the buyer's order. Prices vary by inspector.

Pre-listing report Rule behind it When it helps a Stillwater seller
Four-point (roof, electrical, plumbing, HVAC) Citizens: "mandatory on any Personal Residential Multiperil application for homes more than 20 years old"; completed within the last year Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes from 2005 or earlier; any older home with original systems
Wind mitigation, OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26) Required form for inspections from April 1, 2026 Every older home; Shores homes without a report
Roof inspection with remaining useful life 627.7011(5)(c) Any roof 15 years or older
Wood destroying organism report F.S. 482.226; report "does not constitute a guarantee" Optional; prices treatment before a buyer finds it

Data updated: November 2026 (Citizens, four-point answer; Citizens, form changes; Florida Statutes 627.7011; Florida Statutes 482.226; all read November 17, 2026)

The inspection window is short. AS IS paragraph 12(a) gives the buyer "(if left blank, then 15) days after Effective Date" to inspect and terminate "in Buyer's sole discretion," and otherwise "Buyer accepts the physical condition of the Property ... and Buyer shall be responsible for any and all repairs and improvements required by Buyer's lender" (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline). A buyer who gets an insurance quote in day two instead of day twelve is a buyer who stays. Any defect a pre-listing report finds becomes a known fact you disclose, so we read the reports with you before deciding what to fix and what to price.

Which HOA Approvals and Permits Should a Stillwater Seller Have in Hand?

A Stillwater seller should have the association's written approval for every exterior change, pool, fence, screen enclosure or addition, plus the county permit and final inspection for each. The estoppel will report any open violation, and an unapproved change found by the buyer becomes a negotiation item.

For a pool, fence, screen enclosure or addition in Stillwater, you need a county permit and, separately, association approval; the permit history also shows which roofs, air conditioning systems and windows have been replaced, which is what a wind mitigation inspector asks (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). The Unit 3 association's website lists an "ACR request form" and "Landscape work order" among its menu items, which indicates architectural review there (Villas at Stillwater III, read November 17, 2026). Item 7 of the estoppel asks "Is there any open violation of rule or regulation noticed to the parcel owner in the association official records?" (Florida Statutes 720.30851), so an approval letter in your file answers it before the buyer's title agent does.

If you find an open permit, close it before listing. The owner may close a permit with the original or a new licensed contractor, and an expired permit whose requirements "have been substantially completed" may be closed "without having to obtain a new building permit" (Florida Statutes 553.79, read November 17, 2026). Sarasota County permit records were not searched for any Stillwater parcel for this page, so we pull yours with you.

Why Does the Reissue Rate Matter to Recent Stillwater Buyers?

A Stillwater seller who bought within the last 3 years can cut the owner's title premium by producing the prior owner's policy, because Florida's reissue rate applies when the new policy's effective date is less than 3 years after the policy insuring the seller. At $315,000 the premium is $975.00 at reissue against $1,650.00 at the full rate.

Rule 69O-186.003(2): reissue rates apply "Provided a previous owner's policy was issued insuring the seller or the mortgagor in the current transaction and that both the reissuing agent and the reissuing underwriter retain for their respective files copies of the prior owner's policy," to "Policies issued with an effective date of less than 3 years after the effective date of the policy insuring the seller or mortgagor in the current transaction," and "Any amount of new insurance, in the aggregate, in excess of the amount under the previous policy shall be computed at the original owner's or leasehold rates" (Fla. Admin. Code R. 69O-186.003, read November 17, 2026).

Stillwater case from the county file (no addresses) New price Original rate premium Reissue premium
Older-plat resale median $315,000 $1,650.00 $975.00
Unit 3 resale, February 24, 2026, 21 months after a $345,000 purchase $315,000 $1,650.00 $975.00
Unit 1 resale, March 6, 2026, 11 months after a $620,000 purchase $590,000 $3,025.00 $1,800.00
Unit 1 resale, March 10, 2026, 12 months after a $630,000 purchase $565,000 $2,900.00 $1,725.00

Data updated: November 2026 (Fla. Admin. Code R. 69O-186.003; sale dates and prices from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; premiums are our arithmetic on the rule's table, premium only; whether an owner's policy was issued at each earlier sale is not in the county file)

Who pays matters here. In Sarasota County, the two customs sources we read say the buyer customarily pays the owner's policy: Barnes Walker's table lists "Who pays for owner's title insurance?" as "Buyer" for Sarasota, and Chicago Title lists Sarasota among counties where the buyer pays; "Closing customs are traditions that can be modified by contract" (Barnes Walker, Sarasota and Manatee closing customs; Chicago Title, Florida Laws and Customs, read November 17, 2026). The contract decides and the closing agent confirms. Either way, the prior policy in your file saves money for whoever pays. Every Shores at Stillwater owner is a candidate until about February 2029, if the Pulte closing produced an owner's policy, since the first Shores closing on the county file is dated February 27, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

What Should a Shores at Stillwater Owner Gather Before Reselling?

A Shores at Stillwater owner should gather the Pulte warranty book and service records, the lot's CDD payoff or assessment letter, the HOA documents and estoppel contact, the owner's title policy from the Pulte closing, and permits for work added after closing. No Shores resale is on the county file yet.

Pulte's national limited warranty book (August 2024 edition) states that "materials and workmanship are warranted for one year from the time of closing," heating, air conditioning, electrical and plumbing systems "are warranted for two years from closing," "Certain kinds of water infiltration and internal leaks are warranted for a period of five years," and structural elements "are warranted for ten years from closing" (Pulte National Warranty Book, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's warranty page says "Warranties are transferable to subsequent owner who takes title within the applicable warranty period," and notes separate documents for agreements signed before September 1, 2024 (Pulte, Warranty, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).

Pulte limited warranty term (August 2024 book) Years from the first closing Remaining for a buyer of a home first closed in mid 2026, resold in mid 2027 (our arithmetic)
Materials and workmanship 1 About none
Heating, air conditioning, electrical and plumbing systems 2 About 1 year
Certain water infiltration and internal leaks 5 About 4 years
Structural elements 10 About 9 years

Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte National Warranty Book, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026; the warranty document delivered with your contract controls)

Hand the buyer the warranty documents and ask Pulte in writing how the transfer works for your home; the warranty delivered with your contract controls, not this table. The same book says disputes go to binding arbitration, so a buyer's attorney will want to read it (Pulte National Warranty Book). Every Shores sale through October 14, 2026 was a first sale, the first recorded February 27, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

How Long Does the Stillwater Seller File Take to Assemble?

The Stillwater seller file takes about two weeks to assemble if you start the clocks together: an estoppel within 10 business days, a mortgage payoff letter within 10 days, inspection reports in days, and the HOA documents as fast as the manager answers. Starting at listing, not at contract, keeps the buyer's 15-day inspection period clean.

Clock Length Source
HOA estoppel certificate 10 business days after request; effective 30 days (35 if mailed) F.S. 720.30851
Mortgage payoff letter 10 days after written request F.S. 701.04
Flood disclosure At or before contract F.S. 689.302
HOA disclosure summary Before the buyer signs; otherwise voidable within 3 days after receipt or before closing F.S. 720.401
Buyer's inspection period 15 days if left blank AS IS Residential Contract, paragraph 12(a)
Buyer's flood-zone termination right 20 days if left blank, in a Special Flood Hazard Area below minimum elevation Same form, paragraph 10(d)
Citizens four-point report Completed within the last year Citizens
CDD payoff letter (Shores) On request to the district manager Shores at Stillwater CDD
Construction defect notice (Shores) At least 60 days before suit F.S. 558.004

Data updated: November 2026 (statutes, forms and rules read November 17, 2026)

We start every clock the week we list your Stillwater home, so the file is complete when the first buyer's agent asks. Request a free Stillwater home valuation to begin, or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How Do We Market a Stillwater Home Against New Construction?

We market a Stillwater home against what a buyer can buy from Pulte at Shores at Stillwater this week: Pulte's posted plans, prices and quick move-in homes, its November incentive, and the recorded prices of the new homes it has already closed. The listing leads with what the new homes lack, and puts the insurance and district facts in writing.

Stillwater in Englewood became a two-market community in 2026. In calendar 2026 through mid October, the county file records 17 older-plat resales and 16 Shores at Stillwater first sales, and in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, resales recorded a median $203 per heated square foot against $267 for Shores first sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026). Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active resale listings and months of supply for Stillwater are MLS fields: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). For context only, Sarasota County single-family sales in Q3 2026 recorded a $485,000 median, 52 median days to contract, 3.7 months of supply and 94.4 percent of original list price received, countywide (Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, Sarasota County Q3 2026, read November 17, 2026). We never present those county figures as Stillwater's.

What Is Pulte Offering at Shores at Stillwater That a Stillwater Resale Competes With?

On November 17, 2026, Pulte listed seven Shores at Stillwater plans from $309,990 (Colton villa) to $565,990 (Mystique Grande), two quick move-in homes marked down to $444,990 and $364,990, and, for contracts accepted November 2 to 30, 2026, a pool valued at $69,500 or a credit of up to $77,000, not both. All figures are builder-stated and change often.

Pulte plan, Shores at Stillwater Series Sq ft (builder-stated) Beds / baths "Starting from," November 17, 2026
Colton Villa 1,321 2 / 2 $309,990
Ellenwood Villa 1,579 2 to 3 / 2 $331,990
Prosperity Distinctive 1,670 2 to 3 / 2 $399,990
Mystique Distinctive 1,889+ 2 to 4 / 2 to 3 $419,990
Palmary Distinctive 1,943+ 2 to 3 / 2 $424,990
Prestige Distinctive 2,080+ 2 to 3 / 2.5 $452,990
Mystique Grande Distinctive 2,870+ 3 to 5 / 3 to 4 $565,990

Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater; Pulte, Colton; Pulte, Prestige; Pulte, Mystique Grande; builder-stated base prices before options, homesite premiums and pools, not market values, read November 17, 2026)

Pulte quick move-in home, Shores at Stillwater Sq ft, beds, baths Asking Pulte's earlier "Was" price Markdown (Pulte's figure) Asking per sq ft (our arithmetic)
Prosperity, Distinctive series, "Available Now" 1,686, 3, 2 $444,990 $518,780 $73,790 $264
Ellenwood villa, "Available Now" 1,579, 2, 2 $364,990 $405,880 $40,890 $231

Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in; Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in; builder-stated, read November 17, 2026; no street addresses printed)

The November offer, in Pulte's fine print: the pool is "valid on new purchase agreements on select homesites for select to-be-built homes accepted by Pulte Homes in the Shores at Stillwater community between 11/2/2026 and 11/30/2026," and "Eligible buyers shall receive a standard pool, valued at $69,500"; the credit is "$77,000 to be used toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins as a reduction to the total purchase price of the home," "Maximum credit amounts vary by community," "Any unused credit is the property of the builder" and "Offer cannot be combined with other offers or incentives" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). The page also carries a "New Low Pricing" banner and the line "Community Association fees required," with no dues figure (same page).

Behind those numbers is PulteGroup's own outlook. Its 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 says the company is "focusing sales incentives on discounts, closing cost incentives, and mortgage interest rate buydowns" and that "we expect our sales incentives to remain elevated"; the Florida segment's cancellation rate was 13 percent for the quarter, against 16 percent company-wide, and Florida net new orders rose 6 percent to 1,823 homes (PulteGroup Form 10-Q, quarter ended September 30, 2026, read November 17, 2026). Pulte says "255 future front doors" at Shores at Stillwater, while the county roll holds 140 parcels in Phases 1A and 1B, 107 of them coded vacant; later phases may explain the difference, which is unverified (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A Stillwater resale should expect a builder next door through 2027 at least.

Why Is Pulte's Villa Price Today the Key Fact for a Stillwater Seller?

Pulte's Ellenwood villa quick move-in at Shores at Stillwater asks $364,990 for 1,579 square feet, below every villa first sale the county has recorded there: four Phase 1B villas of 1,574 heated square feet closed at $375,000 to $407,600 from April to August 2026. The newest builder price sits under the builder's own recorded sales.

Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B villa Date Price Heated sq ft Per sq ft
First sale April 1, 2026 $401,600 1,574 $255
First sale April 13, 2026 $407,600 1,574 $259
First sale June 24, 2026 $375,000 1,574 $238
First sale August 26, 2026 $379,000 1,574 $241
Pulte Ellenwood villa quick move-in, asking November 17, 2026 $364,990 1,579 (Pulte's figure) $231

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, qualified first sales from the file dated October 21, 2026; Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in, builder-stated asking price, read November 17, 2026; county and Pulte square footage bases differ by 5 sq ft)

For a Stillwater Unit 3 seller, this is the competitive frame. Unit 3 resales in the latest 12 months recorded a median $282,500 at a median 1,349 heated square feet, $198 per square foot, while Pulte's base prices start at $309,990 for the 1,321 square foot Colton, about $235 per square foot by our arithmetic (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Pulte, Colton, builder-stated). The gap between a Unit 3 resale and a new villa is real, but it is narrower when Pulte's asking price falls and the November credit applies. We price a Unit 3 home against the villa a buyer can actually buy this month, not against Pulte's April closings.

Recorded first sales also include options, pools and homesite premiums that base prices do not, so they are not a like-for-like comparison with "Starting from" figures; Phase 1A first sales recorded a median $564,750 and $290 per square foot across 12 sales, and Phase 1B $390,300 and $248 across 4 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, 12 months to October 14, 2026). That is why our listing comparisons use recorded prices for the past and Pulte's posted prices, with the read date, for the present.

How Do We Match a Stillwater Home to the Pulte Plan a Buyer Is Touring?

We match each Stillwater home to the Pulte plan of similar size, because buyers tour both. A Unit 3 home of about 1,349 square feet competes with the Colton and Ellenwood villas; a Unit 1 or Unit 2 home of 2,000 to 2,500 square feet competes with the Prestige and the Mystique Grande, before Pulte's options.

Stillwater resale (12 months to October 14, 2026) Recorded price Heated sq ft Per sq ft Closest Pulte plans by size (base, builder-stated)
Unit 3, median of 10 resales $282,500 1,349 (median sold) $198 Colton 1,321 sq ft, $309,990; Ellenwood 1,579 sq ft, $331,990
Unit 1, median of 7 resales $550,000 2,368 (median sold) $214 Prestige 2,080+ sq ft, $452,990; Mystique Grande 2,870+ sq ft, $565,990
Unit 2 resale $550,000 2,056 $268 Prestige 2,080+ sq ft, $452,990
Unit 2 resale $620,000 2,525 $246 Mystique Grande 2,870+ sq ft, $565,990

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026; Unit 2 had 2 resales, too few for a median)

The table explains a pattern sellers in Units 1 and 2 notice: Pulte's base prices for comparable sizes sit below the recorded Unit 1 median, but base prices exclude options, homesite premiums and pools, and Phase 1A's recorded median of $564,750 sits close to the Unit 1 median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Larger older homes also have floor plans most of Pulte's line does not offer: Unit 1's roll median is 2,204 heated square feet and Unit 2's 2,181, while six of Pulte's seven Shores plans start between 1,321 and 2,080 square feet (same file; Pulte, builder-stated). We lead a Unit 1 or Unit 2 listing with size, bedrooms and lot, and a Unit 3 listing with price per square foot and readiness.

What Does an Older Stillwater Home Offer That a New Pulte Home Does Not?

An older Stillwater home offers no CDD line, per the district boundary; larger floor plans in Units 1 and 2; a lower recorded price per square foot; a home and yard in place since 2000 to 2016; and a closing on a resale timeline instead of a build schedule. We document each.

  • No district debt. The Shores at Stillwater CDD's legal description runs along the east line of Stillwater Unit Two and its assessment roll lists only Shores lots, which indicates the older plats are outside it; a Phase One Shores lot carries a maximum annual debt assessment of $1,382.68 or $1,914.48 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book; June 15, 2026 meeting book).
  • Size. Unit 1 and Unit 2 roll medians of 2,204 and 2,181 heated square feet (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • Price per square foot. $203 for older-plat resales against $267 for Shores first sales in the latest 12 months (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • A finished home now. Pulte's pool offer applies to "select to-be-built homes," so the pool buyer waits for construction; a resale buyer closes on a contract timeline (Pulte, builder-stated).
  • Any lender. Pulte says "use of Pulte Mortgage is necessary to receive BFC-related rate offers"; a resale buyer chooses the lender, and a seller credit can go to any lender within program caps (same page; Fannie Mae B3-4.1-02).

What a Pulte home offers, stated fairly: Pulte lists "Tile roof," "Whole house impact-resistant vinyl windows- High Velocity Hurricane Zone Rated Windows," "Steel-reinforced concrete block construction," an "Energy-efficient, tankless gas water heater" and "an industry leading 10-year limited structural new home warranty" (Pulte, Colton; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026), and its homes sit under the 8th Edition code era. PulteGroup's president of sales told Sarasota Magazine that "For many, buying new construction is a practical choice, with lower insurance costs and warranties" (Sarasota Magazine, November 8, 2024); that is a builder's view, not a quote for any home. Our answer on an older home is the file: a documented roof, a current wind mitigation report and a flood quote turn the new-home advantage into a number the buyer can weigh.

How Do We Describe the HOA, CDD, Flood and Taxes in a Stillwater Listing?

We describe each in a Stillwater listing with its source: the association's legal name as filed and the dues from the estoppel, the CDD status with the district boundary, the FEMA reading for the lot with the panel and date, and, from February 1, 2027, a tax line that follows the new statutory estimate rather than your own bill.

The tax line changes on a date. From February 1, 2027, "any property visible on a listing platform must include the estimated ad valorem taxes for such property," "the current owner's ad valorem assessment or taxes may not be used to calculate the estimated ad valorem taxes," and "the current owner's ad valorem taxes may not be included in any printed listing materials concerning a property" (Florida Statutes 689.261, read November 17, 2026). For a long-held Stillwater homestead that is helpful: the buyer sees a realistic estimate rather than a capped bill. The estimate will not include the $290.78 fire charge or, at Shores, the district line, so our remarks will name them (Englewood Fire).

Listing fact How we state it for a Stillwater home Source we attach
Association Legal name as listed in Florida corporate filings; dues and period from the estoppel Sunbiz record; estoppel
CDD Units 1 to 3: district boundary and tax roll indicate outside the district. Shores: lot's debt line and payoff figure District meeting books; district letter
Flood FEMA zone, shading, panel and March 27, 2024 map date for the lot; any elevation certificate FEMA Map Service Center printout
Insurance Roof permit date, wind mitigation form date, four-point date Reports in the file
Taxes From February 1, 2027, the statutory estimate, plus named non-ad valorem lines Section 689.261(3); current bill
Unverified items Stated as unverified, with the document that settles them Same as above

Data updated: November 2026 (sources as cited in this page's sections; read November 17, 2026)

We do not write school quality claims, and we describe homes, lots and rules, never the people who might buy them. That keeps the listing within fair housing rules and keeps the comparison on the facts a buyer's appraiser and insurer will check anyway.

How Do We Reach Buyers Who Are Also Touring Pulte?

We reach Stillwater buyers where they compare: on the MLS and our own pages for resale shoppers, and through the buyer's agents who walk their clients through Pulte's sales center. Since August 17, 2024, those agents sign written agreements before touring, and a seller may still offer buyer-broker compensation in the amount the seller chooses.

The rules, as NAR states them: "These practice changes went into effect on August 17, 2024"; offers of compensation between agents "are no longer allowed on Multiple Listing Service (MLS) platforms"; "Agent compensation for home buyers and sellers continues to be fully negotiable"; "Sellers can still offer compensation off an MLS"; and "Sellers can offer buyer concessions on an MLS" (NAR, What the NAR settlement means, read November 17, 2026). An MLS Participant "working with" a buyer must enter into a written agreement "prior to touring a home" (NAR, Written Buyer Agreements 101). Florida Realtors: "Sellers can offer buyer brokerage compensation if they choose to and in the amount of their choice" (Florida Realtors, NAR settlement FAQs, read November 17, 2026).

Our approach for Stillwater, Englewood is to make a resale as easy to compare as the builder's offer: a concession written as a closing-cost credit or buydown the buyer can use with any lender, a clear decision on buyer-broker compensation if you choose to offer it, and listing text that uses the names buyers search, Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3 and the street name. Other builders near Englewood are courting the same buyers, all builder-stated on November 17, 2026: DiVosta at BeachWalk by Manasota Key from $349,990 with the same "pool included OR up to $77,000" November promotion, Lennar at Island Lakes at Coco Bay from $292,999, and Neal Communities at Boca Royale from $352,990 (DiVosta, BeachWalk; Lennar, Island Lakes at Coco Bay; Neal Communities, Boca Royale). A Unit 3 median of $282,500 sits just below that entry band.

Buying instead, or buying and selling at once? Our buyer team compares a Pulte contract with an older Stillwater home line by line; see buying a home in Englewood, or call Marc at (239) 287-5873. To see how your Stillwater home would be marketed against this month's Pulte inventory, request a free Stillwater home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How Do We Negotiate a Stillwater Sale?

We negotiate a Stillwater sale with the county record and Pulte's current offer in hand: recorded resales by plat and by when the earlier sale happened, Pulte's posted prices and incentives, and the documents that answer insurance, lending and association questions. In the latest 12 months, 15 matched Stillwater resales recorded a median 12.2 percent above the earlier price.

Data updated: November 2026

The figures below come from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales of improved homes over $1,000, for the five plats of Stillwater in Englewood only. They describe recorded prices, not anyone's profit or loss, because improvements, roofs, closing costs and financing are not in the county record. The buyer's agent will argue from the most recent resales and from Pulte's posted prices, and so will we.

What Does the Stillwater Resale Record Mean in a Negotiation?

The Stillwater resale record splits sharply by when the seller bought. In the latest 12 months, the 10 resales whose earlier sale was before 2020 recorded a median 50.5 percent above it, all 10 above, while all 3 whose earlier sale was in 2022 or later recorded below it, at a median 8.7 percent below.

Stillwater older-plat resales vs the same home's earlier qualified sale 12 months: resales 12 months: median change 12 months: above / below 24 months: resales 24 months: median change 24 months: above / below
All matched resales 15 +12.2% 12 / 3 31 +54.0% 26 / 5
Earlier sale before 2020 10 +50.5% 10 / 0 22 +72.2% 22 / 0
Earlier sale 2020 to 2021 2 (too few for a median: +6.4% and +10.1%) n/a 2 / 0 5 +10.1% 4 / 1
Earlier sale 2022 or later 3 -8.7% 0 / 3 4 -9.5% 0 / 4
Unit 1 5 +11.1% 3 / 2 9 +30.9% 6 / 3
Unit 2 1 (too few for a median: +77.4%) n/a 1 / 0 5 +47.7% 4 / 1
Unit 3 9 +12.2% 8 / 1 17 +75.9% 16 / 1

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026; 12 months October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; 24 months from October 15, 2024; 15 of 19 resales in 12 months and 31 of 39 in 24 months had an earlier qualified sale on file; 12-month range -10.3% to +77.4%, median 98 months between sales)

Read the table with care. "Above" means a home resold above the price recorded at its earlier sale; it does not mean the owner made money, because a roof, impact windows, a pool, two sets of closing costs and years of carrying costs are not in the record. What the table does show is where the open market has priced Stillwater resales, and that the recent buyers' experience is different from the long-held owners'. Older-plat resale medians per heated square foot by calendar year tell the same story: $191 in 2021, $263 in 2022, $282 in 2023 (the peak), $264 in 2024, $230 in 2025 and $203 in 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

What If You Bought Your Stillwater Home in 2022 or Later?

If you bought your Stillwater home in 2022 or later, the recent record says to price from today's resales, not from your purchase price. In the latest 36 months, 6 older-plat resales followed an earlier sale in 2022 or later: 1 recorded above that price and 5 below, at a median 8.8 percent below.

Resale date Resale price Earlier sale date Earlier price Change Months between Heated sq ft Year built Beds / baths Use code Plat
May 17, 2024 $435,000 March 15, 2022 $375,000 +16.0% 26 1,649 2008 2 / 2.0 0101 Unit 3
August 23, 2024 $592,000 April 28, 2023 $650,000 -8.9% 16 2,181 2005 3 / 2.0 0100 Unit 2
May 23, 2025 $530,000 February 2, 2022 $605,500 -12.5% 40 1,961 2003 3 / 2.0 0100 Unit 1
February 24, 2026 $315,000 May 30, 2024 $345,000 -8.7% 21 1,338 2012 2 / 2.0 0101 Unit 3
March 6, 2026 $590,000 March 31, 2025 $620,000 -4.8% 11 2,376 2000 4 / 3.0 0100 Unit 1
March 10, 2026 $565,000 March 17, 2025 $630,000 -10.3% 12 2,167 2001 3 / 2.0 0100 Unit 1

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, file dated October 21, 2026; 36 months October 15, 2023 to October 14, 2026; no street names, house numbers or owner names)

The calendar-year medians show why: Unit 3 resales recorded a median $403,000 in 2023 (5 sales) and $282,500 in 2026 (10 sales), and Unit 1 resales $790,000 in 2023 (4 sales) and $565,000 in 2026 (5 sales) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Those medians swing with which homes sold, so they bracket a price rather than measure a trend. For a recent buyer the negotiation goals change: protect net proceeds with the reissue rate on your title policy, a clean insurance file and a firm closing date, and decide your floor before the first offer, not after it.

How Do We Answer a Stillwater Buyer Holding a Pulte Quote?

We answer a Stillwater buyer holding a Pulte quote by putting both homes on one page: price, per-square-foot cost, the CDD line, the insurance file, the move-in date and the lender. Pulte's credit is real but has conditions, its posted villa price is below its own recorded villa sales, and Florida's cancellation rate shows builder contracts do fall through.

Comparison line Older Stillwater resale Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater
Price per heated sq ft, latest 12 months $203 median (resales) $267 median (recorded first sales); $231 to $264 on the two quick move-ins (asking)
CDD debt line None indicated by the district boundary Up to $1,382.68 or $1,914.48 a year maximum, plus operations
Builder incentive Seller credit, usable with any lender within program caps Pool valued at $69,500 or up to $77,000, not both, for agreements accepted November 2 to 30, 2026
Lender Buyer's choice BFC rate offers require Pulte Mortgage
Move-in Resale contract timeline Pool offer on "select to-be-built homes"
Roof and windows Documented in the seller's file Tile roof and impact glass included (builder-stated)
Warranty Any assignable contractor warranty; optional home warranty Pulte limited warranty, 1, 2, 5 and 10 years from closing (builder-stated)

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated; Pulte National Warranty Book; read November 17, 2026)

Three points usually move a buyer with a Pulte quote. First, Pulte's own fine print says the credit "may affect the amount of loan for which a buyer may be eligible" and "Any unused credit is the property of the builder," and on a conventional loan seller-paid closing help is capped at 3, 6 or 9 percent by loan-to-value (Pulte, builder-stated; Fannie Mae B3-4.1-02). Second, Pulte's payment illustrations "do not include monthly homeowners' association dues" and do not show the district line (same Pulte page). Third, PulteGroup's Florida segment recorded a 13 percent cancellation rate in Q3 2026 (PulteGroup Form 10-Q), which is one reason a resale's certainty of closing date carries value. We do not argue that a resale beats new construction; we show the buyer the full cost of each.

How Do Inspections, Insurance and Closing Customs Shape a Stillwater Contract?

On the AS IS contract a Stillwater buyer gets a 15-day inspection period with a right to walk away but no repair obligation for the seller, the seller pays the deed stamps and the estoppel fee, the CDD is prorated, and in Sarasota County the buyer customarily pays the owner's title policy. Each term can be negotiated.

Contract term (Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS form unless noted) What it says Stillwater effect
Inspection period, 12(a) "(if left blank, then 15) days"; buyer may terminate "in Buyer's sole discretion" The insurance file must be ready on day one
Repairs, 12(a) Unless terminated, "Buyer accepts the physical condition of the Property" Repair requests become price or credit talks
Maintenance, 11 Seller maintains the property "in the condition existing as of Effective Date," except wear and casualty Keep the lawn, pool and roof as shown
Insurance unavailable, 5(b) Force Majeure including unavailability of "hazard, wind, flood or homeowners' insurance" extends closing Storm season can move a closing date
Flood zone, 10(d) Termination right within 20 days if blank, in a Special Flood Hazard Area below minimum elevation Settle the zone before listing
Seller costs, 9(a) "Documentary stamp taxes and surtax on deed" and "HOA/Condominium Association estoppel fees" Seller's lines unless changed
CDD, 9(f) CDD liens "shall be prorated pursuant to STANDARD K" Shores buyer assumes remaining installments
Warranties, 12(d) Seller assigns "all assignable repair, treatment and maintenance contracts and warranties" at buyer's option and cost Roofer and Pulte warranties pass if assignable
Owner's title policy Sarasota custom: buyer pays (Barnes Walker; Chicago Title) The contract box decides

Data updated: November 2026 (AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline; Barnes Walker, Sarasota and Manatee closing customs; Chicago Title, Florida Laws and Customs; read November 17, 2026)

Florida's deed tax is fixed: "on each $100 of the consideration therefor the tax shall be 70 cents," and the Department of Revenue applies it to each "$100 or portion thereof" (Florida Statutes 201.02; Florida Department of Revenue, documentary stamp tax, read November 17, 2026). At the $315,000 older-plat median the deed stamps are $2,205.00, at the $282,500 Unit 3 median $1,977.50 and at the $550,000 Unit 1 median $3,850.00, so a $5,000 price concession saves the seller $35 in stamps (our arithmetic). DOR adds that "All parties to the document are liable for the tax regardless of which party agrees to pay the tax," and Barnes Walker lists deed stamps as a seller cost in Sarasota (same sources). On title, the two customs sources say the buyer customarily pays the owner's policy and selects the closing agent in Sarasota County; the contract decides and the closing agent confirms. If you agree to pay it, the premium at $315,000 is $1,650.00, or $975.00 at reissue (Fla. Admin. Code R. 69O-186.003).

How Do We Compare Offers on a Stillwater Home?

We compare Stillwater offers by net proceeds and by certainty, not by headline price. Cash or financing, the loan type, the buyer's insurance and flood quotes, the inspection period, credits, who pays the title policy, the HOA summary timing, FIRPTA and the closing date all change what you keep and how likely the sale is to close.

A financed offer at a higher price can net less than a cash offer once a closing-cost credit, a title-policy concession and a longer timeline are counted, and a buyer who has already quoted wind and flood coverage on your roof date and flood reading carries less risk than one who has not. Countywide, 778 of 2,071 Sarasota County single-family sales in Q3 2026 were paid in cash (Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, Q3 2026); the Stillwater share is an MLS field, Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Every 1 percent of a $315,000 price is $3,150, and of a $550,000 price $5,500 (our arithmetic), which is the scale to hold against any credit request.

Offer term Why it matters in Stillwater What we check
Financing type FHA and VA add property standards; Unit 3 legal form matters Lender, loan type, preapproval
Insurance quotes Roof age and the Citizens 2027 flood rule Wind and flood quotes on your address
Closing-cost credit Fannie Mae caps of 3, 6 or 9 percent Credit fits the buyer's loan
Inspection period 15 days if blank Shorter if your file is complete
Owner's title policy Sarasota custom: buyer pays Which box the offer checks
HOA disclosure summary If late, voidable within 3 days after receipt or before closing Delivered before you countersign
Closing date Buyer's homestead needs title and permanent residence on January 1 and a March 1 filing December or January dates against the buyer's plan
FIRPTA 15 percent withholding for a foreign seller, with exceptions Certification at contract

Data updated: November 2026 (sources as cited in this page's sections, read November 17, 2026)

Timing terms carry Stillwater weight. A buyer who wants homestead for 2027 needs to own the home and make it a permanent residence on January 1, 2027 and file by March 1 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Homestead), and an offer signed before the buyer received the HOA disclosure summary is voidable "WITHIN 3 DAYS AFTER RECEIPT OF THE DISCLOSURE SUMMARY OR PRIOR TO CLOSING, WHICHEVER OCCURS FIRST" (Florida Statutes 720.401), so we deliver it before any offer is countersigned. Commission is negotiable and set in your listing agreement; no rate is set by law (NAR, Written Buyer Agreements 101).

What is your home in Stillwater, Englewood worth against the latest recorded sales in your plat and the villa or plan Pulte is selling next door this month? Request your free Stillwater home valuation, or see our Englewood home valuation page and our guide to selling a home in Englewood. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. We will bring the county record, Pulte's posted prices and a net sheet to the first conversation.

What Does It Cost to Sell a Home in Stillwater?

Selling a home in Stillwater in Englewood costs Florida deed stamps at $0.70 per $100, a negotiated commission, an HOA estoppel certificate, prorated taxes, small recording charges and, only if your contract shifts it to you, the owner's title policy. At the $315,000 older-plat resale median, the deed stamps alone are $2,205 (Florida DOR; Florida Statutes 201.02).

Data updated: November 2026 (state rates, rules and customs read November 17, 2026; medians from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales recorded October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026)

Florida has no single closing-cost percentage, so this section builds a Stillwater seller's costs line by line from the statute, rule, customs table or published cap that sets each one. On this page Stillwater means the 394 Sarasota County parcels in five recorded plats: Stillwater Unit 1 (77 parcels), Unit 2 (36), Unit 3 (141), and Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A (54) and Phase 1B (86). Every one sits in unincorporated Sarasota County with an Englewood 34223 mailing address, so one clerk, one tax collector and one set of Sarasota closing customs apply. This is Stillwater in Englewood, Florida, off Medical Boulevard, not Stillwater on the Bay in Sarasota 34231. The worked examples use the county's recorded figures for the 12 months October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026: $282,500 for the 10 Unit 3 resales, $315,000 for all 19 resales in the older plats and $550,000 for the 7 Unit 1 resales, with $523,250 for the 16 first sales of new Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Three things make a Stillwater closing different from a typical Florida resale: Sarasota custom puts the owner's title policy on the buyer, an older-plat parcel may answer to more than one homeowners association, and only Shores at Stillwater lots carry a community development district.

What Are the Fixed Selling Costs at Stillwater Price Points?

At Stillwater's recorded price points the deed stamps are the one state-set cost every seller pays by custom: $1,977.50 on a $282,500 Unit 3 home, $2,205 at the $315,000 resale median and $3,850 at the $550,000 Unit 1 median. The owner's title premium appears only if your contract moves it from the buyer to you.

Cost line $282,500 (Unit 3 resale median) $315,000 (older-plat resale median) $523,250 (Shores first-sale median) $550,000 (Unit 1 resale median) $620,000 (highest older-plat resale) Source
Documentary stamp tax on the deed, $0.70 per $100 (seller by Sarasota custom) $1,977.50 $2,205.00 $3,663.10 rounded up ($3,662.75 unrounded) $3,850.00 $4,340.00 Section 201.02; Florida DOR; Barnes Walker
Owner's title premium, original promulgated rate (buyer by Sarasota custom; seller only if the contract shifts it) $1,487.50 $1,650.00 $2,691.50 $2,825.00 $3,175.00 Rule 69O-186.003
Same policy at the full reissue rate, if eligible $877.50 $975.00 $1,599.90 $1,680.00 $1,890.00 Rule 69O-186.003(2)
HOA estoppel certificate, current account, one association (seller by custom) up to $299 up to $299 up to $299 up to $299 up to $299 Section 720.30851; DBPR
Recording a 2-page deed (seller records the deed per Chicago Title) $18.50 $18.50 $18.50 $18.50 $18.50 Section 28.24
Each 1 percent of commission $2,825 $3,150 $5,232.50 $5,500 $6,200 Our arithmetic
Commission, settlement fee, municipal lien search, prorations, credits negotiated, quoted or prorated same same same same Your contract and closing agent

Data updated: November 2026 (price points: Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; rates, caps and customs read November 17, 2026)

Dollar figures are arithmetic on the published rates, not a quote (Florida Statutes 201.02; Rule 69O-186.003, Cornell LII; DBPR estoppel fee caps; Florida Statutes 28.24; Barnes Walker, Sarasota and Manatee closing customs; Chicago Title, Florida Real Estate Laws and Customs). At the $315,000 median under Sarasota custom, the deed stamps, one current-account estoppel and a 2-page deed recording come to $2,522.50, about 0.8 percent of price, before any negotiated, quoted or prorated line. If the contract also puts the original-rate owner's policy on the seller, the same lines come to $4,172.50, about 1.3 percent, or $3,497.50 at the reissue rate (our arithmetic). The settlement or closing fee, the title search and the municipal lien search are real lines on a Stillwater closing statement, but their prices vary by title company and vendor, so your closing agent quotes them and we print no guessed figure (Chicago Title, which lists "Closing Fees" as "Seller pays unless otherwise indicated in contract").

How Is the Documentary Stamp Tax Calculated on a Stillwater Deed?

The documentary stamp tax on a Stillwater deed is $0.70 for each $100 of the price "or portion thereof," so the price is divided by 100, any partial $100 counts as a full one, and the result is multiplied by $0.70. Sarasota County uses the statewide rate, and Sarasota custom puts it on the seller.

The arithmetic, shown so you can check it:

Sale price (Stillwater, 12 months to October 14, 2026) Taxable $100 units Deed stamps
$250,000 (lowest older-plat resale) 2,500 2,500 x $0.70 = $1,750.00
$282,500 (Unit 3 resale median, 10 sales) 2,825 2,825 x $0.70 = $1,977.50
$315,000 (older-plat resale median, 19 sales) 3,150 3,150 x $0.70 = $2,205.00
$450,000 (lowest Unit 1 resale) 4,500 4,500 x $0.70 = $3,150.00
$523,250 (Shores first-sale median, 16 sales) 5,233 rounded up (5,232.5 unrounded) $3,663.10 rounded up; $3,662.75 unrounded
$550,000 (Unit 1 resale median, 7 sales) 5,500 5,500 x $0.70 = $3,850.00
$620,000 (highest older-plat resale, a Unit 2 sale) 6,200 6,200 x $0.70 = $4,340.00

Data updated: November 2026 (rate from section 201.02 and the Florida Department of Revenue, read November 17, 2026; prices from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026)

Section 201.02 sets the rate in plain words: on deeds that convey real property, "on each $100 of the consideration therefor the tax shall be 70 cents," and consideration includes "the amount of any mortgage, purchase money mortgage lien, or other encumbrance, whether or not the underlying indebtedness is assumed" (Florida Statutes 201.02). So a buyer who assumed your loan would not shrink the tax, while your own mortgage paid off at closing does not add to it. The Florida Department of Revenue applies "70 cents on each $100 or portion thereof" in every county except Miami-Dade, says the tax "is paid to the county clerk of court or a recording official when the document is recorded," and states that "All parties to the document are liable for the tax regardless of which party agrees to pay the tax" (Florida Department of Revenue, documentary stamp tax). Prices that end in even hundreds, which covers every Stillwater worked example except the Shores median, give the same answer under either reading of the rounding rule.

Custom puts the deed stamps on the Stillwater seller. Barnes Walker's Sarasota customs table answers "Who pays doc stamps on the deed?" with "Seller" (Barnes Walker), and Chicago Title's Florida customs sheet lists the deed transfer tax as "Seller pays" (Chicago Title). The Florida Realtors AS IS contract lists "Documentary stamp taxes and surtax on deed, if any" among seller costs in paragraph 9(a) (Florida Realtors AS IS contract, 2026 redline). The buyer's new note and mortgage carry their own stamps at "35 cents per $100, or portion thereof," and Barnes Walker lists both those and the intangible tax as buyer items in Sarasota (Florida DOR; Barnes Walker).

Who Pays the Owner's Title Policy on a Stillwater Sale?

On a Stillwater sale the buyer customarily pays the owner's title policy and picks the closing agent, because Stillwater is in Sarasota County, where both customs sources we read say so. The contract still decides. If you agree to pay it, the premium is $1,650 at the $315,000 median, the same at every title company.

The two customs sources a Stillwater seller can check agree. Barnes Walker's Sarasota column answers "Who pays for owner's title insurance?" with "Buyer" and "Who selects the closing agent?" with "Buyer," and adds the disclaimer "Closing customs are traditions that can be modified by contract" (Barnes Walker, Sarasota and Manatee closing customs). Chicago Title's Florida customs sheet lists the residential owner's policy as "Seller pays but Buyer pays in some counties (Broward, Collier, Miami-Dade, Monroe, Sarasota)" (Chicago Title, Florida Real Estate Laws and Customs). The Florida Department of Financial Services adds the practical consequence: "The person paying the title insurance premium gets the first choice of closing/title agent" (Florida DFS, title insurance overview). Because Englewood straddles the Sarasota and Charlotte county line, an offer drafted by an agent who works mostly in Charlotte County may arrive with the policy assigned to you; read that line of the offer before you sign, because at the $550,000 Unit 1 median it is worth $2,825 at the original rate (our arithmetic from the rule below).

The premium is set by state rule and is identical at every title insurer: $5.75 per $1,000 of coverage up to $100,000 and $5.00 per $1,000 from $100,000 to $1 million, with the rate applied "considering any fraction of $100.00 as a full $100.00," and "The minimum premium for all conveyances except multiple conveyances shall be $100" (Rule 69O-186.003, Cornell LII). The Florida Administrative Register lists the rule's latest effective date as 1/27/2002, so the table has not changed in more than 24 years (Florida Administrative Register, Rule 69O-186.003). DFS adds that "Unlike other types of insurance, you pay a one-time premium for your title policy" (Florida DFS).

Sale price First $100,000 at $5.75 per $1,000 Balance at $5.00 per $1,000 Original owner's premium
$282,500 Unit 3 resale median $575.00 $182,500 = $912.50 $1,487.50
$315,000 older-plat resale median $575.00 $215,000 = $1,075.00 $1,650.00
$523,250 Shores first-sale median (rounded to $523,300) $575.00 $423,300 = $2,116.50 $2,691.50
$550,000 Unit 1 resale median $575.00 $450,000 = $2,250.00 $2,825.00
$620,000 highest older-plat resale $575.00 $520,000 = $2,600.00 $3,175.00

Data updated: November 2026 (Rule 69O-186.003 read November 17, 2026; prices from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026)

Under Sarasota custom these figures are the buyer's line, not yours. We print them because sellers sometimes offer to pay the policy as a concession, and because the reissue question below belongs to whoever pays. Endorsements, the title search and the settlement fee are separate charges that vary by company (Florida DFS).

When Does the Title Reissue Rate Apply to a Stillwater Seller?

The title reissue rate applies when the new owner's policy takes effect less than 3 years after the policy that insured you, and your old policy can be produced. In Stillwater that means recent buyers in the older plats and every Shores at Stillwater owner. At $315,000 the premium falls from $1,650 to $975.

Rule 69O-186.003(2) charges $3.30 per $1,000 up to $100,000 and $3.00 per $1,000 from $100,000 to $1 million, minimum $100, on "Policies issued with an effective date of less than 3 years after the effective date of the policy insuring the seller," provided "a previous owner's policy was issued insuring the seller" and both the reissuing agent and underwriter "retain for their respective files copies of the prior owner's policy." Any amount of new insurance "in excess of the amount under the previous policy shall be computed at the original owner's or leasehold rates" (Rule 69O-186.003, Cornell LII). DFS puts it shortly: "If a prior owner's policy exists, reissue rates should be charged" (Florida DFS).

Sale price Original owner's premium Full reissue premium Difference
$282,500 Unit 3 resale median $1,487.50 $330.00 + $547.50 = $877.50 $610.00
$315,000 older-plat resale median $1,650.00 $330.00 + $645.00 = $975.00 $675.00
$523,250 Shores first-sale median $2,691.50 $1,599.90 $1,091.60
$550,000 Unit 1 resale median $2,825.00 $330.00 + $1,350.00 = $1,680.00 $1,145.00
$620,000 highest older-plat resale $3,175.00 $330.00 + $1,560.00 = $1,890.00 $1,285.00

Data updated: November 2026 (Rule 69O-186.003 read November 17, 2026; prices from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026)

The county record shows who is likely inside the window. Of the 211 older-plat homes with a qualified sale on file, 36 had their last qualified sale less than 2 years before October 21, 2026, and 26 more at 2 to 5 years, while every Shores at Stillwater sale in the file is a 2026 first sale, the earliest recorded February 27, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Three recent resales show the pattern in practice: a Unit 3 home resold February 24, 2026 at $315,000, 21 months after a $345,000 purchase, where the reissue figure is $975 against $1,650; a Unit 1 home resold March 6, 2026 at $590,000, 11 months after a $620,000 purchase, $1,800 against $3,025; and a Unit 1 home resold March 10, 2026 at $565,000, 12 months after a $630,000 purchase, $1,725 against $2,900 (same source; premiums our arithmetic). Whether an owner's policy was actually issued at each earlier sale is not in the county file, so each case depends on the seller producing it. Under Sarasota custom the saving goes to the buyer who pays the premium, which is still worth raising: a lower closing cost on your home is a point in your favor when a buyer is weighing it against a new Pulte home next door.

What to do: find the owner's policy from your purchase closing package before you list, and hand a copy to the closing agent as soon as a contract is signed. A Shores at Stillwater owner who resells within 3 years of the Pulte closing should ask the title office that closed the first sale for a copy if it is missing; PulteGroup's 10-Q says its Financial Services segment includes "mortgage banking, title, and insurance agency operations" (PulteGroup Q3 2026 Form 10-Q).

What Do the HOA Estoppel Certificate and Association Charges Cost in Stillwater?

Every Stillwater sale needs an HOA estoppel certificate, and Florida caps its fee: DBPR's published caps are $299 for a current account, $119 more for delivery within 3 business days and up to $179 more if the account is delinquent, under section 720.30851. Sarasota custom and the AS IS contract both put the estoppel fee on the seller.

Three associations appear in Florida corporate filings for the Stillwater plats, as copied by directory sites that mirror state records: Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed March 7, 2000), Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed March 10, 2006) and Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed February 24, 2025) (CommunityPay, Stillwater Homeowners Association; CommunityPay, Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association). Confirm the current record on Sunbiz before you order. Which association governs which older plat, and whether a Unit 3 parcel answers to two associations, is not confirmed in any public document we read; the estoppel certificate and the recorded declaration settle it for your parcel. Dues, any transfer or capital contribution fee, leasing rules and resale approval rules were not confirmed from a citable source either, so we print none of them.

Section 720.30851 sets the timing and protections. The association "shall issue the estoppel certificate" within 10 business days after a written or electronic request, and if it fails to deliver in time "a fee may not be charged for the preparation and delivery of that estoppel certificate." A certificate "hand delivered or sent by electronic means has a 30-day effective period," and one sent by regular mail has 35 days. Each association "shall designate on its website a person or entity with a street or e-mail address for receipt of a request," and an association that issues a certificate "waives the right to collect any moneys owed in excess of the amounts specified" from anyone who relies on it in good faith (Florida Statutes 720.30851).

The statute still prints base caps of $250, $100 and $150 and says the fees "shall be adjusted every 5 years" by the Consumer Price Index. DBPR's current sheet publishes "not more than $299," "an additional $119" for expedited delivery within 3 business days, and "an additional fee not to exceed $179" for a delinquent parcel, and says "The next update will be released by July 1, 2027" (DBPR, estoppel certificate fees).

Estoppel situation (one association) Cap Source
Current account, standard delivery $299 DBPR fee sheet
Current account, delivered within 3 business days on an expedited request $299 + $119 = $418 DBPR fee sheet; our sum
Delinquent account, standard delivery $299 + $179 = $478 DBPR fee sheet; our sum
Delinquent account, expedited $299 + $119 + $179 = $597 DBPR fee sheet; our sum
Certificate not delivered within 10 business days $0 Section 720.30851
Two associations on one parcel (if your estoppel lists a second) each issues its own certificate under its own cap Section 720.30851, item 10

Data updated: November 2026 (DBPR estoppel fee sheet and section 720.30851 read November 17, 2026)

The certificate is also where the open Stillwater questions get answered. The statutory form asks "Is there a capital contribution fee, resale fee, transfer fee, or other fee due?", whether "the rules and regulations of the association applicable to the parcel require approval by the board of directors of the association for the transfer of the parcel," whether "a right of first refusal" exists, and for "a list of, and contact information for, all other associations of which the parcel is a member" (Florida Statutes 720.30851). That last item is the one that matters most for a Unit 3 seller. On the AS IS contract, "HOA/Condominium Association estoppel fees" are a seller cost (Florida Realtors AS IS contract), and Barnes Walker lists the "HOA estoppel letter" as "Seller" in Sarasota (Barnes Walker). An association with 100 or more parcels must post its governing documents on a website or app under section 720.303, and Unit 3 alone holds 141 parcels on the roll, so ask the manager for the declaration, rules and budget on the first day of the listing (Florida Statutes 720.303).

How Are Taxes, HOA Dues and the Shores CDD Prorated on a Stillwater Sale?

Stillwater property taxes are paid in arrears for the calendar year, so the seller credits the buyer for January 1 through the day before closing. HOA dues prorate from the estoppel's paid-through date. On a Shores at Stillwater resale, the CDD assessment is prorated rather than paid off, and 2026 to 2027 district operations are collected at closings.

The Sarasota County Tax Collector says "Tax bills are sent to the owner and address of record by November 1st each year," with a "4% discount if paid in November," 3 percent in December, 2 percent in January and 1 percent in February; "The gross amount is due by March 31st," and "Unpaid taxes become delinquent on April 1st of the following year." On sales it says "taxes are usually prorated on the closing statement" and "This credit is between you and the seller" (Sarasota County Tax Collector, property tax; Florida Statutes 197.162). Barnes Walker lists the Sarasota custom as "Through day before closing (arrears)" (Barnes Walker). The Florida Realtors residential contract prorates "real estate taxes (including special benefit tax assessments imposed by a community development district ("CDD")), interest, bonds, assessments, association fees, insurance, rents" as of the day before closing, and if the current year's taxes cannot be determined, they are prorated on the prior year and "computed and readjusted, at either party's request, when the current taxes are determined" (Florida Realtors CRSP-16 contract).

The arithmetic. The seller's share is the bill times the days owned divided by 365. As an illustration only, on a hypothetical $3,000 bill and a June 30 closing, the seller owns January 1 to June 29, 180 days, and credits the buyer $3,000 x 180 / 365 = $1,479.45; the buyer then pays the full bill in November (Florida Statutes 197.333). We did not read a Stillwater tax bill, so your own bill replaces that figure. What we can state for every Stillwater parcel: the 2026 countywide millage is 11.3068 mills (11.4737 in 2025) with no city levy, and the Englewood Area Fire Control District charges a flat $290.78 per home for 2026 to 2027, a line that is "not ... affected by the Homestead Exemption" (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Englewood Area Fire Control District, assessments). Solid waste, stormwater and any special-area lines on a Stillwater bill were not confirmed; the TRIM notice or bill for your parcel shows them.

Timing right now. Because the 2026 bills were mailed by November 1, a Stillwater closing in November or December 2026 can be prorated on the actual 2026 bill, and the closing agent may pay it from proceeds at the discount then in force; a closing before that year's bill issues is prorated on the prior year's bill and readjusted on request. Confirm the method with your closing agent (Sarasota County Tax Collector; Florida Realtors CRSP-16).

The January 1 problem at Shores. Florida assesses property as of January 1, and "Improvements or portions not substantially completed on January 1 shall have no value placed thereon" (Florida Statutes 192.042). A Shores at Stillwater home finished after January 1, 2026 is taxed for 2026 on the lot, so its 2026 bill is not a guide to a full year with the house. For improvements completed by January 1 of the closing year that did not exist a year earlier, the contract prorates "on the prior year's millage and at an equitable assessment to be agreed upon," failing which the County Property Appraiser is asked for an informal assessment (Florida Realtors CRSP-16).

The Shores at Stillwater CDD. The AS IS contract's special-assessment paragraph carves out a lien imposed by a CDD "pursuant to Chapter 190, F.S.," which "shall be prorated pursuant to STANDARD K" (Florida Realtors AS IS contract), so a Shores seller does not pay off the bond principal at closing unless the contract says so. The district's adopted 2026 to 2027 budget shows "O&M Assessments 66,157 To Be Collected At Closings" and notes that the operations rate "Would Be $276 (255 Units)" if the district were on the assessment roll (Shores at Stillwater CDD, FY2026/2027 final budget), and no Shores at Stillwater CDD code appears on the Tax Collector's 2026 list of levying authorities (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage). So a Shores resale closing in that window should expect a district operations line on the closing statement; check whether your own purchase already paid it for the year. The district's boundary description and its absence from the 2026 levy list both indicate the older Stillwater plats are outside the district; an older-plat seller should confirm on the parcel's own tax bill.

HOA dues. Association fees prorate as of the day before closing on the same contract paragraph. The estoppel states "The regular periodic assessment levied against the parcel is $ per (insert frequency of payment)," and your closing agent prorates from that line (Florida Statutes 720.30851).

What Lien Search, Payoff, Recording and Utility Items Apply in Stillwater?

A Stillwater seller should expect a municipal lien search, a lender payoff letter, small recording charges, a final Englewood Water District bill and, at Shores at Stillwater, a CDD debt and assessment letter. Recording fees are fixed by statute; the lien search, settlement fee and any district letter fee vary, so your closing agent quotes them.

Lien search. Sarasota custom puts the "Municipal lien search" on the seller (Barnes Walker). Stillwater is in unincorporated Sarasota County, not a city, so no city lien letter applies. The price varies by vendor and by how many agencies the search covers.

Open permits. A county may not "fine, penalize, sanction, or assess fees against an arms-length purchaser of a property for value solely because a building permit applied for by a previous owner of the property was not closed," but it "shall maintain all rights and remedies against the property owner and contractor listed on the permit" (Florida Statutes 553.79). The permits most likely to be open on a 2000s Stillwater home are a reroof, an air conditioner change-out, a water heater, a screen enclosure and shutters. An owner "may retain the original contractor listed on the permit or hire a different contractor" to close an old permit (same statute), so clear them before a buyer's lien search finds them.

Payoff and satisfaction. Your lender must send a payoff letter "Within 10 days after receipt of the written request," showing the unpaid balance and "Interest accruing on a per-day basis," and must send a release of the mortgage for recording within 60 days after payoff (Florida Statutes 701.04). Any servicer fee for the letter varies by lender.

Recording. Under section 28.24 the first page of an instrument costs $5.00 plus a $1.00 trust fund charge and a $4.00 clerk service charge, $10.00 in all, and each additional page $4.00 plus $0.50 plus $4.00, $8.50 in all, so a 2-page deed records for $18.50 and a 3-page deed for $27.00 (Florida Statutes 28.24; our arithmetic). Chicago Title says the seller pays to record the deed and the buyer pays to record the mortgage (Chicago Title). A deed must carry each signer's printed name and post-office address, the preparer's name and address, and the witnesses' and notary's names before the clerk will record it (Florida Statutes 695.26).

Water and sewer. Englewood Water District serves this part of Englewood; its site links "Transfer Service" and lists "Local: 941.474.3217," "Toll Free: 866.460.1080" and its office at 201 Selma Ave., Englewood (Englewood Water District). Its rules say service, assessments, purchased capacity and liens "run with the parcel" (EWD FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations). Confirm the provider for your address and schedule a final reading for the closing date.

Shores at Stillwater CDD letter. The district site's "Payoff Information" section says "Request CDD Debt and Assessment Information," and the district manager is Special District Services, 2501A Burns Road, Palm Beach Gardens, (561) 630-4922 (Shores at Stillwater CDD; Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). The fee for that letter is not published.

What Does a Stillwater Seller Net at $282,500, $315,000 and $550,000?

On our worked examples, a $282,500 Unit 3 seller pays about $2,295 in state-set costs before commission and quoted fees under Sarasota custom, a $315,000 seller about $2,522.50 and a $550,000 Unit 1 seller about $4,167.50. If the contract shifts the owner's title policy to the seller, add $1,487.50, $1,650 or $2,825.

Assumptions, stated plainly so you can change them:

  1. Prices. $282,500 for the 10 Unit 3 resales, $315,000 for all 19 older-plat resales and $550,000 for the 7 Unit 1 resales, October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  2. Title. Sarasota custom: the buyer pays the owner's policy. The second scenario shows what changes if your contract shifts it to you, at the original rate and at the reissue rate (Barnes Walker; Rule 69O-186.003, Cornell LII).
  3. Estoppel. One association, current account, standard delivery: $299. If your estoppel lists a second association, add its certificate (DBPR).
  4. Recording. A 2-page deed at $18.50 (Florida Statutes 28.24).
  5. Not priced. Tax and HOA prorations (they depend on your own bill and dues), the municipal lien search, the settlement fee and any mortgage payoff.
  6. Commission. Shown only per 1 percent of price; no rate is implied and none is our fee.
Line item $282,500 Unit 3 home $315,000 older-plat median $550,000 Unit 1 home Basis
Documentary stamp tax on the deed $1,977.50 $2,205.00 $3,850.00 $0.70 per $100
HOA estoppel certificate, one association $299.00 $299.00 $299.00 DBPR cap
Recording a 2-page deed $18.50 $18.50 $18.50 Section 28.24
Costs before commission, prorations and quoted fees (Sarasota custom) $2,295.00 (about 0.8 percent) $2,522.50 (about 0.8 percent) $4,167.50 (about 0.8 percent) Sum of lines
Estimated net before commission, prorations, quoted fees and payoff $280,205.00 $312,477.50 $545,832.50 Price minus costs
If the contract shifts the owner's policy to you, original rate costs $3,782.50; net $278,717.50 costs $4,172.50; net $310,827.50 costs $6,992.50; net $543,007.50 Rule 69O-186.003
Same, at the full reissue rate costs $3,172.50; net $279,327.50 costs $3,497.50; net $311,502.50 costs $5,847.50; net $544,152.50 Rule 69O-186.003(2)
Each 1 percent of commission $2,825 $3,150 $5,500 Our arithmetic
Property tax proration your bill x days owned / 365 same same Sarasota custom; contract
HOA dues proration and any association fee on the estoppel from the estoppel same same Section 720.30851
Municipal lien search and settlement fee quoted by your closing agent quoted quoted Seller by Sarasota custom; price varies
FIRPTA withholding, foreign seller only (held, not a fee) $0 if an individual buyer acquires it as a residence for $300,000 or less; otherwise 15 percent 15 percent ($47,250) unless an exception applies 15 percent ($82,500) unless an exception applies 26 U.S.C. 1445; IRS

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; rates, caps and customs read November 17, 2026)

Figures are arithmetic from the sources named, rounded to the cent. On a Shores at Stillwater resale, add the district's debt and assessment letter (fee not published) and any 2026 to 2027 operations line collected at closing, and check whether your Pulte-era owner's policy qualifies the buyer for the reissue rate (Shores at Stillwater CDD). The FIRPTA row applies only to a foreign seller: the IRS says "The rate of withholding generally is 15%" and "In most cases, the buyer (transferee) is the withholding agent," and withholding is generally not required when the buyer "acquires the property for use as a residence" and "the amount realized (sales price) is not more than $300,000"; other exceptions exist, so a foreign seller should talk to a tax adviser early (IRS, FIRPTA withholding; IRS, exceptions from FIRPTA withholding). Sales commissions and "Any other fees or costs to sell the home" reduce the amount realized for federal tax purposes (IRS Publication 523).

What the sheet does not show is the seller story. The 15 Stillwater resales with an earlier qualified sale on file closed at a median 12.2 percent above the price recorded at that earlier sale after a median 98 months, but the 3 whose earlier sale came in 2022 or later all resold below it, at a median 8.7 percent below (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). On a short hold, the costs above plus commission decide what a sale near your earlier price leaves at the table, so we put your own net sheet in writing before you list. For a net sheet on your own Stillwater address, request a free Stillwater home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.


Should You Sell Your Stillwater Home by Owner, to a Cash Buyer or With a Listing Team?

Most Stillwater owners are best served by listing, because a Stillwater resale competes with Pulte's new homes at Shores at Stillwater, and its value rests on documents a buyer must see: the roof permit, wind mitigation report, estoppel and, at Shores, the CDD figures. A cash offer trades price for speed; selling by owner leaves every disclosure to you.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; Pulte pages read November 17, 2026)

Florida lets an owner sell without an agent, and some cash buyers are legitimate. None of the routes changes the law on a sale in Stillwater, Englewood, Florida: the deed stamps are owed at $0.70 per $100, the flood disclosure is owed "at or before the time the sales contract is executed," the radon notice and the property tax disclosure summary still apply, and the HOA disclosure summary must reach the buyer "before executing the contract for sale" or the contract is voidable (Florida DOR; Florida Statutes 689.302; Florida Statutes 720.401). The Stillwater-specific fact is the competition. In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, 16 of the 35 qualified Stillwater home sales were first sales of new Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater, beside 19 resales in the older plats (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Pulte's sales center is next door, and on November 17, 2026 it listed seven plans from $309,990 to $565,990, two finished quick move-in homes and a November offer of a pool valued at $69,500 or a credit of up to $77,000 (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). The table compares the routes on facts, not invented percentages.

What you care about Sell by owner Sell to a cash buyer or instant-offer company List with McGreevy and Comisar
Who sees the home Whoever you reach on your own One buyer, the company making the offer MLS, our own sites, our Southwest Florida buyer database and targeted promotion
How the price is set By you, usually without the county record By the buyer's offer; no public record reports what cash-offer companies pay as a group From recorded Stillwater sales by plat, size and use code, and from Pulte's live plan and quick move-in prices with read dates
The Pulte comparison You answer it alone Not part of the offer Priced plan to plan against Pulte's dated prices, with what your home adds (district records indicate no CDD line in the older plats; larger Unit 1 and 2 plans; a finished lot)
Owner's title policy You must know Sarasota custom puts it on the buyer Set by the buyer's contract Read on every offer before you sign
Estoppel and HOA disclosure summary Owed by you, unaided Still owed by you Gathered and delivered before the buyer signs
Roof permit, 4-point, wind mitigation report You find and explain them Priced as risk by the buyer In the listing file from day one
Open permits for reroofs, AC change-outs, enclosures You find and close them, or negotiate them Often the buyer's main discount argument Searched before launch
Buyer's agent compensation Buyers sign written agreements with their own agents, so you may still be asked Usually not part of a direct sale Decided with you before launch; any offer made off the MLS
Deed stamps at $0.70 per $100 Seller by Sarasota custom Seller by Sarasota custom Seller by Sarasota custom

Data updated: November 2026 (sales: Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; builder pages and customs read November 17, 2026)

Sources for the table: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater (builder-stated), Barnes Walker, Sarasota closing customs, Florida Statutes 720.30851, Florida Statutes 627.7011, Florida Statutes 553.79, NAR, Written Buyer Agreements 101 and Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book.

What Do Stillwater Commissions Look Like After the NAR Settlement?

Stillwater commissions are negotiable, as they are everywhere in Florida: no law sets a rate, and the listing fee is agreed in writing with the brokerage you hire. Since August 17, 2024, anything a Stillwater seller offers toward a buyer's agent is a separate, optional decision that may not appear in the MLS.

NAR says "These practice changes went into effect on August 17, 2024," that offers of compensation between agents "are no longer allowed on Multiple Listing Service (MLS) platforms," that "Sellers can still offer compensation off an MLS" and that "Sellers can offer buyer concessions on an MLS" (NAR, what the settlement means for buyers and sellers). An agent "working with" a buyer must sign a written agreement "prior to touring a home," and that agreement must say "broker commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable" (NAR, Written Buyer Agreements 101). Florida Realtors adds that "Sellers can offer buyer brokerage compensation if they choose to and in the amount of their choice" (Florida Realtors, NAR settlement FAQs), and Florida law says "A real estate licensee may not operate as a disclosed or nondisclosed dual agent" and presumes licensees work as transaction brokers unless a single agent relationship is set in writing (Florida Statutes 475.278).

To size the decision on your own sale: each 1 percent of price is $2,825 at the $282,500 Unit 3 median, $3,150 at the $315,000 older-plat median and $5,500 at the $550,000 Unit 1 median (our arithmetic from Sarasota County Property Appraiser figures). In Stillwater the buyer-side question has an extra edge, because a buyer's agent touring your home is also showing Pulte's homes next door, where the builder's own sales staff and its affiliated lender work the other side. Florida Realtors' four ways a buyer can pay their brokerage include "Negotiate a credit from the seller in the purchase and sale agreement" (Florida Realtors, buyer options to compensate their brokerage firm). No primary source publishes a Stillwater commission statistic, so we set out the choices, and what each costs at your likely price, in writing before you list.

What Does a Cash Offer on a Stillwater Home Cost You?

A cash offer on a Stillwater home saves showings, a lender's appraisal and the inspection back-and-forth, and costs the gap between the offer and what the open market recorded for homes like yours. No public record reports what cash-offer companies pay, so we compare any offer with Stillwater's recorded resales by plat, size and use code.

The open-market side is public. Over the 12 months to October 14, 2026, the 19 older-plat resales recorded a $315,000 median, middle half $280,000 to $550,000, at a median $203 per heated square foot; Unit 3's 10 resales recorded $282,500 at $198 per square foot and Unit 1's 7 resales $550,000 at $214 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Countywide, 778 of the 2,071 Sarasota County single-family closings in the third quarter of 2026 were paid in cash (Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, Q3 2026 Sarasota County single-family summary), so a cash buyer is not rare and does not need to be a discount buyer. Ask any cash offer to show the recorded Stillwater sales behind it, by plat, heated square feet, use code and year built; a fair one can, and we will check them against yours. Portal and listing-site figures often mix listings, nearby communities and other measures of area, and differ from the county record, so they are not a fair yardstick either.

Watch the contract as closely as the price. A law firm's hurricane-season guidance for Florida sellers warns that investor contracts are "legally binding" and advises weighing "assignability of a contract" and the closing date before signing (DHC Law, selling a damaged home in Florida). Whatever the route, you still owe the flood disclosure and the Johnson v. Davis duty to disclose known material facts.

Can a Stillwater Resale Match Pulte's November Credit?

A Stillwater resale cannot offer a builder's forward-commitment rate, but a Stillwater seller can offer a closing-cost credit or a rate buydown that works with any lender, within the buyer's loan limits. Pulte's November credit of up to $77,000 is itself limited by the same lender caps, so the comparison is all-in cost, not the headline number.

Pulte's fine print says the builder "will credit buyer $77,000 to be used toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins as a reduction to the total purchase price of the home," that "Maximum credit amounts vary by community," that "Any unused credit is the property of the builder," that the offer "cannot be combined with other offers or incentives" and that it "may affect the amount of loan for which a buyer may be eligible"; the alternative is "a standard pool, valued at $69,500," and both apply to purchase agreements accepted between 11/2/2026 and 11/30/2026 (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). Pulte's special rates require its own lender: "use of Pulte Mortgage is necessary to receive BFC-related rate offers where and when available," and the forward-commitment rate "is limited to new home agreements only" (same page). A resale buyer cannot get either.

What a resale seller can do is set out in Fannie Mae's interested-party contribution caps for a principal residence or second home: 3 percent of value when the loan-to-value ratio is above 90 percent, 6 percent from 75.01 to 90 percent and 9 percent at 75 percent or less, and a seller-funded rate buydown counts toward the cap (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02). On a $315,000 Stillwater sale with a 95 percent conventional loan, that cap is $9,450; at 80 percent it is $18,900 (our arithmetic). The same caps limit how much of a builder credit can land as closing-cost help on a conventional loan, which is why some of a headline builder credit may arrive as price or options. FHA, VA and other investors use different caps, which we did not read, so your buyer's lender confirms.

The stronger answer in Stillwater is usually the price itself. Unit 3's 12-month median of $282,500 for a median 1,349 heated square feet sits $27,490 below Pulte's smallest base price, $309,990 for the 1,321-square-foot Colton villa, before any incentive, and the district's records indicate the older plats carry no CDD line (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; builder-stated, Pulte, Colton, read November 17, 2026; our arithmetic).

When Does Selling a Stillwater Home by Owner Work?

Selling a Stillwater home by owner can work when a buyer is already in hand and you are ready to assemble the estoppel, the HOA disclosure summary, the flood disclosure, the roof and permit history and, at Shores, the CDD figures yourself. It is hardest when your buyer is comparing your home with Pulte's.

The paperwork is the same with or without an agent. The HOA disclosure summary "must be supplied by the developer, or by the parcel owner if the sale is by an owner that is not the developer," and if it is not given before the contract is signed, the contract "IS VOIDABLE BY BUYER" within 3 days after receipt of the summary or prior to closing, whichever occurs first, and "ANY PURPORTED WAIVER OF THIS VOIDABILITY RIGHT HAS NO EFFECT" (Florida Statutes 720.401). The Johnson v. Davis rule that a seller who "knows of facts materially affecting the value of the property which are not readily observable and are not known to the buyer" must disclose them applies "to all forms of real property, new and used" (Johnson v. Davis). Buyers' agents now need signed buyer agreements before touring, so an owner-seller may still be asked about compensation (NAR, Written Buyer Agreements 101). The step owners most often miss in Stillwater is the custom itself: in Sarasota County the buyer customarily pays the owner's title policy, worth $1,650 at the $315,000 median, so an owner-seller who pays it by default gives that money away (Barnes Walker; Rule 69O-186.003, Cornell LII; our arithmetic).

Which Route Fits Which Stillwater Home?

The right route depends on the Stillwater home: a Unit 3 home at the $282,500 median sits below every Pulte base price, a Unit 1 or Unit 2 home competes in size with Pulte's larger single-family plans, and a Shores at Stillwater resale meets Pulte's own new inventory head on. Purchase year matters too: 2022 or later purchases resold below their earlier price.

The county record shows why purchase year matters. In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, the 10 resales whose earlier qualified sale came before 2020 all resold above that price, at a median 50.5 percent above; the 2 whose earlier sale came in 2020 or 2021 resold 6.4 and 10.1 percent above it (too few for a median); and the 3 whose earlier sale came in 2022 or later all resold below it, from 10.3 to 4.8 percent below, at a median 8.7 percent below (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The older-plat median price per heated square foot rose from $191 in 2021 to a $282 peak in 2023, then fell to $264 in 2024, $230 in 2025 and $203 in 2026 (same source), so a seller who bought near the peak is pricing against today's lower figure and against Pulte's new homes, not against 2023. The county record cannot show the roofs, improvements, closing costs or financing behind any of these prices, so these comparisons describe recorded prices only, not whether any owner made or lost money.

Stillwater home What it competes with next door (builder-stated, read November 17, 2026) What the recorded sales say (12 months) Route that usually fits
Unit 3, the small-home section coded 0101 Colton villa from $309,990 (1,321 sq ft); Ellenwood villa from $331,990 (1,579 sq ft); an Ellenwood quick move-in at $364,990, marked down from $405,880 10 resales, median $282,500, $198 per heated sq ft, median 1,349 sq ft List, priced below the new villas, with roof, 4-point and wind mitigation papers ready
Unit 1, coded 0100 Prestige from $452,990 (2,080+ sq ft); Mystique Grande from $565,990 (2,870+ sq ft) 7 resales, median $550,000, $214 per sq ft, median 2,368 sq ft sold List, priced plan to plan against the larger Pulte homes, with the district's boundary (older plats outside the CDD) stated
Unit 2, coded 0100 Same larger Pulte plans 2 resales, $550,000 and $620,000 (too few for a median) List; price from Unit 1 and Unit 2 sales over 24 and 36 months
Shores at Stillwater (Pulte, built 2025 to 2026) Pulte's own plans, quick move-ins and November offer 16 first sales, median $523,250, $267 per sq ft; no resale on file yet List, with the CDD figures, warranty papers and reissue-eligible owner's policy in hand

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026, window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; Pulte pages read November 17, 2026)

Sources for the table: Sarasota County Property Appraiser and Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, with the Ellenwood quick move-in page (builder-stated). One competitive fact stands out: the county recorded four Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B villa first sales at 1,574 heated square feet, for $375,000, $379,000, $401,600 and $407,600, so Pulte's quoted villa price today sits below every recorded villa sale (same sources). If you are unsure which route fits, a free valuation shows what each would likely net. Request one through the free Stillwater home valuation, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.


What Is Your Stillwater Home Worth? Get Your Free Valuation

Your Stillwater home is worth what comparable Stillwater resales recorded, matched by plat, heated square feet, use code and year built, then checked against Pulte's prices next door and adjusted for roof age, updates and condition. Get a free valuation through the free Stillwater home valuation form, by phone or with a walk-through, with the recorded sales we used.

We do not send an automated number. We send the recorded Stillwater, Englewood, Florida sales we used, from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 for the window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 and the wider 24 and 36 month windows when a plat is thin (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), Pulte's dated price for the nearest plan, your parcel's tax and assessment lines, its flood zone from FEMA's map, and a net sheet at the likely price. There is no obligation. For the community itself, read our Stillwater neighborhood guide. For the wider area, our Englewood home valuation page explains the same method, and our guide to selling a home in Englewood covers the town as a whole.

What Do We Need From You for a Stillwater Valuation?

For a Stillwater valuation we need your address and plat, your purchase closing statement, the owner's title policy, the roof permit or invoice, any 4-point or wind mitigation report, permits for anything added since you bought (reroof, impact windows, shutters, pool, screen enclosure, AC), any elevation certificate and your insurance declarations pages. That is enough to start.

The walk-through lets us see finish, updates and condition, which no county record holds. The closing statement shows what you paid, and the IRS treats purchase costs and later improvements, such as a "New roof," "Storm windows/doors," "Swimming pool" or "Central air conditioning," as part of your basis (IRS Publication 523). The roof permit matters twice: under section 627.7011(5), an insurer may not refuse a policy "solely because of the age of the roof" on a roof under 15 years old, and roof age is counted from "the last date on which 100 percent of the roof's surface area was built or replaced" (Florida Statutes 627.7011). A Stillwater home built 2000 to 2011 is 15 years or older in 2026 on an original roof, and many may have been reroofed, which only the permit shows. A wind mitigation report documents the features insurers must credit, including "roof strength, roof covering performance, roof-to-wall strength ... opening protection, and window, door, and skylight strength" (Florida Statutes 627.0629). For a Shores at Stillwater home, add the Pulte warranty documents and your CDD lot size (34-foot or 52-foot), because the district's assessment differs by lot width (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book).

How Do Plat, Size, Bedrooms and Purchase Year Move a Stillwater Valuation?

A Stillwater valuation moves most with plat and heated size, then with bedrooms and the year of your earlier purchase. Over the 12 months to October 14, 2026, Unit 3 resales recorded a $282,500 median against $550,000 for Unit 1, and older-plat resales ran $203 per heated square foot against $267 for Pulte's first sales at Shores.

12 months to October 14, 2026 Sales Median price (middle half or values) Median per heated sq ft Median heated sq ft of homes sold
Unit 3 resales (use code 0101) 10 $282,500 ($266,875 to $302,750) $198 1,349
Unit 1 resales (use code 0100) 7 $550,000 (range $450,000 to $590,000) $214 2,368
Unit 2 resales (use code 0100) 2 $550,000 and $620,000 (too few for a median) $246 and $268 2,056 and 2,525
All older-plat resales 19 $315,000 ($280,000 to $550,000) $203 ($192 to $246) n/a
Shores at Stillwater first sales (Pulte) 16 $523,250 ($419,450 to $662,575) $267 ($241 to $329) n/a

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; 12-month window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; qualified sales of improved homes over $1,000)

24 months to October 14, 2026 Sales Median price Median per heated sq ft
Unit 1 resales 12 $562,500 $261
Unit 2 resales 6 $546,000 $251
Unit 3 resales 21 $305,000 $215
All older-plat resales 39 $362,500 $222

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; 24-month window October 15, 2024 to October 14, 2026)

Heated size, older-plat resales, 36 months Sales Median price Median per heated sq ft
Under 1,400 sq ft 13 $302,000 $224
1,400 to 1,799 sq ft 13 $324,000 $211
1,800 to 2,199 sq ft 10 $562,500 $268
2,200 to 2,599 sq ft 11 $590,000 $246
2,600 sq ft and up 0 n/a n/a

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; 36-month window October 15, 2023 to October 14, 2026)

Bedrooms, older-plat resales, 36 months Sales Median price Range
2 bedrooms 15 $320,000 $265,000 to $435,000
3 bedrooms 29 $500,000 $250,000 to $685,000
4 bedrooms 3 $620,000 $590,000 to $620,000

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; 36-month window October 15, 2023 to October 14, 2026)

All four tables come from the county's parcel and sales file (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The plat groups are small, so the closest matches by heated size, bedrooms, year built and lot carry more weight than any one median, and Unit 2's two sales over 12 months are read beside its 6 over 24 months. The Shores first-sale figures are the contract prices recorded at Pulte's closings, including whatever options, pools and homesite premiums the buyer chose and after whatever incentives applied, which the county record does not show, so the gap between $203 and $267 per square foot is a difference in product and age, not a premium an older home can claim. The county's just value is a January 1 tax figure that lags the market, so we price from recorded sales and use just value only as a cross-check. Purchase year matters as much as plan: earlier sales before 2020 resold at a median 50.5 percent above the earlier recorded price, and those from 2022 or later at a median 8.7 percent below it, on 10 and 3 resales (same source).

What Does a Stillwater Valuation Leave Out?

A Stillwater valuation built from county records leaves out the MLS fields: days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active resale listings and months of supply in Stillwater. Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). We read the live market for your plat at the walk-through instead of printing an estimate here.

What the record does show is enough to anchor a price, as long as the window is stated: every Stillwater figure on this page comes from qualified recorded sales in the five plats in the Sarasota County Property Appraiser's file, not from listing sites (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Where a builder sells many of the homes, the county count leads. Countywide only, the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee reported for the third quarter of 2026 a Sarasota County single-family median of $485,000, a median 52 days to contract, 3.7 months of supply and 94.4 percent of original list price received; those are countywide MLS figures, not Stillwater ones (RASM, Q3 2026 Sarasota County single-family summary). Pulte's prices are part of the picture too, quoted only as builder-stated with the date read: on November 17, 2026 Pulte listed Shores at Stillwater from $309,990 (Colton villa) to $565,990 (Mystique Grande), with two quick move-in homes at $444,990 (marked down from $518,780) and $364,990 (an Ellenwood villa, marked down from $405,880), and PulteGroup's 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 says "we expect our sales incentives to remain elevated" (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater; PulteGroup Q3 2026 Form 10-Q).

Or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072

You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012. If you are buying your next home too, Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or read our Englewood home buyer guide.


What Do Sellers Say About Working With McGreevy and Comisar?

Sellers who work with McGreevy and Comisar describe partners who stay in touch, explain the plan and handle the moving parts, and that is the standard we bring to every Stillwater, Englewood, Florida sale, whether the home is in Stillwater Units 1 to 3 or a newer Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater. Their words are quoted exactly below.

We are a top-reviewed Southwest Florida team, recognized with the Gulfshore Life 5 Star Award for customer satisfaction for 21 straight years. The reviews below are quoted exactly as clients wrote them on our Google Business Profile. We do not edit, combine or summarize client words.

Donald Vogler, five stars

★★★★★ "Jesse was very professional, helpful and kept in touch with ideas and suggestions which developed into a sale. Highly recommend his company for their excellent follow through."

Beth Shaw, five stars

★★★★★ "Marc made an extremely stressful time of selling my parents' house easier because of his expertise, compassion, and diligence. I cannot thank him enough and I would recommend him without reservation."

Candy Gody, five stars

★★★★★ "I have had 13 real estate transactions and this is the most professional and helpful agency that I have ever worked with. Marc actually called me with a response to my questions and concerns on a Sunday evening. The resources that this agency has access to goes above and beyond any other I have ever worked with. The professional process that they use to present your home for sale goes beyond anything I have ever experienced."

Leslie Foster, five stars

★★★★★ "Marc was extremely helpful in the sale of our old home and getting our new home to the condition that we wanted it to make it ours. He has been available to us for every step of our journey, even after the transaction closed."

Eric Acra, five stars

★★★★★ "Not living in the area, Jesse made life easy for me when we decided to sell our condo. His attention to detail, patience, understanding, and tenacity in dealing with all the moving parts was truly impressive."

When you list your Stillwater home with a top-reviewed team of Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, the partners who answer your first call are the partners at your closing. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.


Frequently Asked Questions, Stillwater Seller Edition

These are the questions Stillwater, Englewood, Florida owners ask about selling, answered directly. Every sales figure covers the five Stillwater plats and comes from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, for qualified sales recorded October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 unless another window is named (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

What is my Stillwater home worth?

Your Stillwater home is worth what comparable resales in the same plat, at the same heated size and bedroom count, recorded, checked against Pulte's current price for the nearest plan. Over the 12 months to October 14, 2026, Unit 3 resales recorded a $282,500 median at $198 per heated square foot and Unit 1 resales $550,000 at $214 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Request a free Stillwater home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How many Stillwater homes sold in the last 12 months?

From October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, the county recorded 35 qualified Stillwater home sales at a $485,000 median, middle half $305,000 to $570,000. Of those, 19 were resales in the older plats at a $315,000 median and 16 were first sales of new Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater at a $523,250 median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Over 24 months the county recorded 55 sales and over 36 months 63.

Did Stillwater owners resell above what they paid?

Most did. Of the 19 resales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, 15 had an earlier qualified sale on file; they closed at a median 12.2 percent above the price recorded at that earlier sale, 12 above and 3 below, ranging from 10.3 percent below to 77.4 percent above, a median 98 months later (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Roofs, improvements, closing costs and financing are not in the record, so this compares recorded prices, not profit.

Why did Stillwater homes bought in 2022 or later resell below the earlier price?

Because they were bought near the peak. All 3 Stillwater resales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026 whose earlier sale came in 2022 or later closed below that price, at a median 8.7 percent below. The older-plat median per heated square foot peaked at $282 in 2023 and was $203 in 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Homes bought before 2020 resold at a median 50.5 percent above their earlier recorded price.

What does a square foot sell for in Stillwater?

Older-plat Stillwater resales recorded a median $203 per heated square foot in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, middle half $192 to $246, against $267 for Pulte's first sales at Shores at Stillwater, middle half $241 to $329. By plat, Unit 3 ran $198 and Unit 1 $214 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The Shores figures include options and lots the buyer chose, so the gap is product and age, not a premium.

How do Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2 and Unit 3 resales compare?

In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, Unit 3 recorded 10 resales at a $282,500 median and a median 1,349 heated square feet, Unit 1 recorded 7 at $550,000 and a median 2,368 square feet sold, and Unit 2 recorded 2, at $550,000 and $620,000, too few for a median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Units 1 and 2 are coded 0100 on the roll and Unit 3 is coded 0101, the small-home section.

Are Stillwater prices going up or down in 2026?

Down from the 2023 peak. The older-plat resale median per heated square foot ran $191 in 2021, $263 in 2022, $282 in 2023, $264 in 2024, $230 in 2025 and $203 in 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The yearly mix of Unit 3 and Unit 1 sales moves those medians, so read them as direction. Price against today's figure and Pulte's homes next door, not against 2023.

How long are Stillwater homes taking to sell?

Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Days on market and sale-to-list ratio are MLS fields, and the county record shows only the recorded sale. Countywide, the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee reported a median 52 days to contract for Sarasota County single-family homes in the third quarter of 2026 (RASM, Q3 2026 Sarasota County summary). We read the live market for your plat at the walk-through.

How many Stillwater resales are for sale right now?

Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). Active resale listings and months of supply in Stillwater come from the MLS. What we can date is Pulte's side: on November 17, 2026 Pulte listed two finished quick move-in homes at Shores at Stillwater, at $444,990 and $364,990, and seven plans to build (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Countywide supply was 3.7 months in the third quarter of 2026 (RASM).

What is the Sarasota County market doing?

Countywide only, the third quarter of 2026 showed a Sarasota County single-family median of $485,000, a median 52 days to contract, 3.7 months of supply and a median 94.4 percent of original list price received (RASM, Q3 2026 Sarasota County single-family summary). Stillwater's own record points another way for recent buyers: the older-plat median per square foot fell from $282 in 2023 to $203 in 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

What is Pulte asking for new homes at Shores at Stillwater today?

On November 17, 2026 Pulte listed seven plans at Shores at Stillwater, from $309,990 for the Colton villa (1,321 square feet) and $331,990 for the Ellenwood villa (1,579) up through Prosperity, Mystique, Palmary and Prestige to $565,990 for the Mystique Grande (2,870+). Pulte labels these "Starting From" prices and lists pools as options (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). We quote plan by plan, with the read date.

What quick move-in homes does Pulte have at Shores at Stillwater?

Two, both "Available Now" on November 17, 2026: a 1,686-square-foot Prosperity at $444,990, marked down from $518,780, and a 1,579-square-foot Ellenwood villa at $364,990, marked down from $405,880 (builder-stated, Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in; Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in). A finished Stillwater resale competes most directly with these.

What incentive is Pulte offering at Shores at Stillwater in November 2026?

For purchase agreements accepted between 11/2/2026 and 11/30/2026, Pulte offers either "a standard pool, valued at $69,500" on select to-be-built homes or a credit of up to $77,000 "toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins," and the offer "cannot be combined with other offers or incentives" (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). Pulte may "change or withdraw this offer at any time."

Can my buyer get Pulte's incentive on my Stillwater resale?

No. Pulte's offer applies to "new purchase agreements for select homes in the Shores at Stillwater community," and its forward-commitment rate "is limited to new home agreements only" (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). A resale seller can offer a closing-cost credit or rate buydown that works with any lender, subject to the buyer's loan limits, such as Fannie Mae's 3, 6 and 9 percent caps (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02).

Why does Pulte's villa price matter to my Stillwater sale?

Because it sets the ceiling a buyer sees. The county recorded four Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B villa first sales at 1,574 heated square feet, for $375,000, $379,000, $401,600 and $407,600 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), and on November 17, 2026 Pulte quoted its Ellenwood villa quick move-in at $364,990, below every recorded villa sale (builder-stated, Pulte, Ellenwood). A Unit 3 resale is priced against that number.

Have any Shores at Stillwater homes resold yet?

Not in the county file. Every Shores at Stillwater sale through October 14, 2026 was a first sale of a new Pulte home, the earliest recorded February 27, 2026; the 16 first sales had a $523,250 median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A Shores owner who sells soon will be one of the first resales in the plat, competing directly with Pulte's own inventory and offers next door.

How many homes will Shores at Stillwater have?

Pulte says "255 future front doors" (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). The county roll dated October 21, 2026 shows 140 parcels in Phases 1A and 1B, with 27 homes built in 2025 and 2026 and 107 lots still coded vacant (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Later phases may explain the difference, which we could not confirm. Either way, Pulte has new homes to sell for some time.

What does a new Pulte home include that my older Stillwater home may not?

Pulte's Colton included-features list names a "Tile roof," "Professionally engineered roof trusses with hurricane tie-downs," "Whole house impact-resistant vinyl windows," and an "Energy-efficient, tankless gas water heater," and the community page adds "an industry leading 10-year limited structural new home warranty" (builder-stated, Pulte, Colton; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 17, 2026). An older Stillwater home answers with documents: a reroof permit, impact windows or shutters, and a wind mitigation report.

Does PulteGroup expect to keep incentives high?

Yes. PulteGroup's 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 says "we expect our sales incentives to remain elevated" and that it focused incentives "on discounts, closing cost incentives, and mortgage interest rate buydowns." It reported a 13 percent cancellation rate in its Florida segment and 16 percent company-wide for the quarter (PulteGroup Q3 2026 Form 10-Q). Plan for builder competition at Shores at Stillwater to continue.

How much does it cost to sell a house in Stillwater?

At the $315,000 older-plat median, the state-set items are $2,205 in deed stamps and, if the contract shifts it to you, a $1,650 owner's title premium, or $975 at the reissue rate (Florida DOR; Rule 69O-186.003). Sarasota custom puts the title policy on the buyer. Add the HOA estoppel (up to $299), recording, prorated taxes, quoted title fees and a negotiated commission.

What are the deed stamps on a $282,500 Stillwater home?

$1,977.50. Florida's documentary stamp tax is 70 cents on each $100 of price "or portion thereof," so $282,500 is 2,825 units at $0.70 (Florida Department of Revenue; Florida Statutes 201.02). At the $315,000 older-plat median the tax is $2,205, and at the $550,000 Unit 1 median it is $3,850 (our arithmetic).

Who pays the deed stamps on a Stillwater sale?

The seller, by Sarasota custom. Barnes Walker's Sarasota customs table answers "Who pays doc stamps on the deed?" with "Seller" (Barnes Walker), and Chicago Title's Florida sheet lists the deed transfer tax as "Seller pays" (Chicago Title). The Department of Revenue adds that "All parties to the document are liable for the tax regardless of which party agrees to pay the tax" (Florida DOR).

Who pays the owner's title policy on a Stillwater sale?

In Sarasota County the buyer customarily pays it and chooses the closing agent. Barnes Walker lists "Buyer" for both in its Sarasota column, and Chicago Title names Sarasota among the counties where the buyer pays (Barnes Walker; Chicago Title). Custom is not law: "Closing customs are traditions that can be modified by contract," so read your offer before you sign.

Is the title insurance premium negotiable on a Stillwater sale?

No. Florida DFS says "Title insurance rates are established by rule 69O-186.003, Florida Administrative Code," and that "The person paying the title insurance premium gets the first choice of closing/title agent" (Florida DFS, title insurance overview). The rule's table has carried a 1/27/2002 effective date for more than 24 years (Florida Administrative Register). Search, settlement and endorsement charges vary by company; the premium does not.

Can my Stillwater buyer get the title reissue rate?

Possibly, if you bought less than 3 years before the new policy's effective date and a copy of your owner's policy can be produced; the rule then charges $3.30 and $3.00 per $1,000 instead of $5.75 and $5.00 (Rule 69O-186.003, Cornell LII). At $315,000 that is $975 against $1,650 (our arithmetic). Every Shores at Stillwater home first closed in 2026, and 36 older-plat homes last sold under 2 years before October 21, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

What does a Stillwater HOA estoppel certificate cost?

Florida caps it. Under section 720.30851, DBPR publishes caps of $299 for a current account, $119 more for delivery within 3 business days and up to $179 more if the account is delinquent (DBPR, estoppel certificate fees). Sarasota custom and the AS IS contract put the fee on the seller (Barnes Walker). If your parcel answers to two associations, each issues its own certificate under its own cap.

How fast must the HOA deliver the estoppel, and how long is it good for?

The association must issue it within 10 business days of a written or electronic request, or "a fee may not be charged" for it. A certificate "hand delivered or sent by electronic means has a 30-day effective period," and one sent by regular mail 35 days (Florida Statutes 720.30851). Order it as soon as a Stillwater contract is signed, and ask the manager for the estoppel contact on the day you list.

Is there a transfer or capital contribution fee when I sell my Stillwater home?

Not found in any public source we read. The statutory estoppel form asks "Is there a capital contribution fee, resale fee, transfer fee, or other fee due?" and requires the type and amount, so the certificate answers it for your parcel (Florida Statutes 720.30851). The form also asks whether the board must approve the transfer and whether a right of first refusal exists, two answers no published Stillwater document gives.

What are the Stillwater homeowners associations called?

Three associations appear in Florida corporate filings, as copied by directory sites that mirror state records: Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed March 7, 2000), Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed March 10, 2006) and Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed February 24, 2025) (CommunityPay). Confirm on Sunbiz; which one governs your plat is settled by your declaration and estoppel.

What are the Stillwater HOA fees?

No association document we read publishes them, and listing-site figures conflict, so we print none. Pulte says only "Community Association fees required" at Shores at Stillwater (builder-stated, Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Your estoppel certificate states "The regular periodic assessment levied against the parcel is $ per (insert frequency of payment)" (Florida Statutes 720.30851), and that is the figure a buyer and closing agent use.

Do I have to give my Stillwater buyer the HOA disclosure summary?

Yes, before the contract is signed. Section 720.401 says the summary "must be supplied by the developer, or by the parcel owner if the sale is by an owner that is not the developer." Without it the contract "IS VOIDABLE BY BUYER" within 3 days after receiving the summary or prior to closing, whichever occurs first, and "ANY PURPORTED WAIVER OF THIS VOIDABILITY RIGHT HAS NO EFFECT" (Florida Statutes 720.401).

Can my buyer be stuck with my unpaid Stillwater HOA dues?

Yes, which is why they are paid at closing. "A parcel owner is jointly and severally liable with the previous parcel owner for all unpaid assessments that came due up to the time of transfer of title" (Florida Statutes 720.3085). If no rate is set in the declaration, interest runs at 18 percent a year (same statute). Your closing agent deducts any balance shown on the estoppel from your proceeds, and the association is bound by the amounts it states.

Is my older Stillwater home in a community development district?

The records indicate not. The Shores at Stillwater CDD's boundary description begins at "the Southeast corner of STILLWATER, UNIT TWO" and runs along its east line, the district covers about 79.83 acres, and only Shores Phase 1A and 1B lots are assessed (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book). No Shores at Stillwater CDD code appears on the Tax Collector's 2026 levy list (2026 millage). Confirm on your own tax bill.

How much CDD debt is on a Shores at Stillwater lot?

The district's Series 2026 bonds total $2,970,000 at coupons of 4.10 to 5.8 percent, maturing May 2056, against a court-validated ceiling of $14,000,000. Original principal is $18,580.37 for a 34-foot lot and $25,726.66 for a 52-foot lot, with a maximum annual debt assessment of $1,382.68 and $1,914.48 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, amended FY2025/2026 budget; June 15, 2026 meeting book).

Do I have to pay off the Shores at Stillwater CDD when I sell?

Not on the standard AS IS contract. Its special-assessment paragraph carves out a CDD lien imposed "pursuant to Chapter 190, F.S.," which "shall be prorated pursuant to STANDARD K" (Florida Realtors AS IS contract). The buyer takes over future installments unless your contract says otherwise. The district says "All assessments levied run with the land" (June 15, 2026 meeting book).

Can I prepay the Shores at Stillwater CDD before selling?

Yes. The district's master assessment resolution says an owner "may prepay the entire remaining balance of the Special Assessments at any time," with interest to the next interest payment date, and that "Prepayment of Special Assessments does not entitle the property owner to any discounts for early payment" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book). Ask the district manager, Special District Services, (561) 630-4922, for your lot's figure, and weigh it against your likely price.

Do I have to disclose the CDD on a Shores at Stillwater resale?

Disclose it. Section 190.048 requires the CDD statement in "each contract for the initial sale," which was Pulte's sale (Florida Statutes 190.048). On a resale, treat it as a Johnson v. Davis matter: a seller who knows of facts "materially affecting the value of the property which are not readily observable" must disclose them (Johnson v. Davis). Naming the district and its amount up front is the sound practice.

What does recording cost on a Stillwater sale?

Under section 28.24 the first page costs $10.00 in all ($5.00 recording, $1.00 trust fund and $4.00 service charge) and each additional page $8.50, so a 2-page deed records for $18.50 and a 3-page deed for $27.00 (Florida Statutes 28.24; our arithmetic). Chicago Title's customs sheet says the seller pays to record the deed and the buyer pays to record the mortgage (Chicago Title).

What is the standard commission to sell a Stillwater home?

There is none. NAR says "Agent compensation for home buyers and sellers continues to be fully negotiable" (NAR), and Florida Realtors says sellers may offer buyer brokerage compensation "in the amount of their choice" (Florida Realtors, NAR settlement FAQs). Each 1 percent is $2,825 at the $282,500 Unit 3 median, $3,150 at the $315,000 older-plat median and $5,500 at the $550,000 Unit 1 median (our arithmetic).

Can one agent represent both me and my Stillwater buyer?

Not as a dual agent. Florida law says "A real estate licensee may not operate as a disclosed or nondisclosed dual agent," and "It shall be presumed that all licensees are operating as transaction brokers unless a single agent or no brokerage relationship is established, in writing, with a customer" (Florida Statutes 475.278). The brokerage relationship notice in your paperwork tells you which role your licensee has.

Can I offer closing cost help to compete with Pulte?

Yes. NAR says "Sellers can offer buyer concessions on an MLS" (NAR), subject to the buyer's loan program. Fannie Mae caps interested-party contributions on a principal residence at 3 percent above 90 percent loan-to-value, 6 percent from 75.01 to 90 percent and 9 percent at 75 percent or less (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02). On a $315,000 sale with 5 percent down that is $9,450 (our arithmetic).

What is the 2026 millage rate for a Stillwater home?

Stillwater is unincorporated, so a parcel pays the Tax Collector's countywide total with no city levy: 11.3068 mills in 2026, down from 11.4737 in 2025, of which 5.9290 mills is school tax (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage). The Englewood Area Fire Control District charge is a separate flat $290.78 per home for 2026 to 2027, not millage (Englewood Area Fire Control District).

What non-ad valorem charges are on a Stillwater tax bill?

Every improved Stillwater home pays the Englewood Area Fire Control District's $290.78 residential assessment for 2026 to 2027, which is "not ... affected by the Homestead Exemption" (EAFCD). The Tax Collector's 2026 sheet also lists solid waste and stormwater levies and Englewood Water District and lighting areas (2026 millage), but which of those reach a given Stillwater parcel, and for how much, we did not confirm. Your TRIM notice or bill shows every line.

How are property taxes prorated on a Stillwater sale?

Through the day before closing, with the seller crediting the buyer, because Florida taxes are paid in arrears; Barnes Walker lists the Sarasota custom as "Through day before closing (arrears)" (Barnes Walker). Bills go out by November 1 with discounts of 4 percent in November down to 1 percent in February, and unpaid taxes become delinquent April 1 (Sarasota County Tax Collector). If the year's bill is unknown, the prior year is used and readjusted on request.

Will my Stillwater buyer's property taxes be the same as mine?

Often not. Property "shall be assessed at just value as of January 1 of the year following a change of ownership" (Florida Statutes 193.155), and your exemptions do not transfer. The required disclosure tells buyers they "SHOULD NOT RELY ON THE SELLER'S CURRENT PROPERTY TAXES" (Florida Statutes 689.261). With a median 9 years since the last qualified sale on 211 older-plat homes, many Stillwater bills may sit well below a buyer's (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Can I take my Save Our Homes savings to my next Florida home?

Yes, up to $500,000 of the difference between just and assessed value, if you set up a new Florida homestead within the window in section 193.155(8) (Florida Statutes 193.155). The Property Appraiser says the old homestead must be abandoned, not necessarily sold, and that form DR-501T comes with the homestead application (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, portability FAQ). The 2026 Save Our Homes cap was 2.7 percent.

What did Amendment 3 change for Stillwater sellers and buyers?

Unofficial returns show Amendment 3 passing on November 3, 2026 with about 62 percent yes; statewide certification was not found, and implementing law was pending, as of November 17, 2026 (WGCU). The joint resolution text raises the non-school homestead exemption to $150,000 from January 1, 2027 and $250,000 from January 1, 2028, leaves the school exemption at $25,000 and keeps "assessments for special benefits" outside it (CS/HJR 1F text).

What will Stillwater listings show for taxes from February 1, 2027?

"Beginning February 1, 2027, any property visible on a listing platform must include the estimated ad valorem taxes for such property," and "the current owner's ad valorem assessment or taxes may not be used to calculate the estimated ad valorem taxes"; from the same date "the current owner's ad valorem taxes may not be included in any printed listing materials" (Florida Statutes 689.261). Tell Stillwater buyers about the fire assessment and, at Shores, the CDD separately.

Do I owe capital gains tax when I sell my Stillwater home?

Only on a gain above your exclusion. You may exclude up to $250,000, or $500,000 on a joint return, if you owned and used the home as your main home for at least 24 months of the 5 years before closing (IRS Publication 523; IRS Topic 701). Of 211 older-plat homes with a qualified sale on file, 93 last sold 10 or more years ago (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), so long-held gains are the ones to check with a CPA.

Is there a partial exclusion if I must sell my Stillwater home early?

Yes, if the sale is because of a work move, health reasons or an unforeseeable event as Publication 523 words them, such as a new job "at least 50 miles farther from the home than your old work location," a casualty from a natural or man-made disaster, death, divorce or unemployment. You divide the qualifying time by 24 months and multiply by $250,000 per qualifying person (IRS Publication 523). A tax adviser confirms whether your facts qualify.

Can I deduct a loss if my Stillwater home sells below what I paid?

No. The IRS says "Losses from the sale of personal-use property, such as your home or car, aren't tax deductible" (IRS Topic 409). That matters in Stillwater, where all 3 resales in the last 12 months whose earlier sale came in 2022 or later closed below that recorded price (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A home held more than one year produces long-term gain or loss; one year or less, short-term (same IRS page).

Do a new roof, impact windows or a pool count in my Stillwater basis?

Generally yes. Publication 523 says "You add the cost of additions and improvements to the basis of your property," listing a "New roof," "Storm windows/doors," "Swimming pool" and "Central air conditioning," while repairs such as painting or fixing leaks do not count, and replacing all the windows as one project is an improvement (IRS Publication 523). Purchase costs such as "Transfer or stamp taxes, and Owner's title insurance" add to basis too. Keep invoices and permits.

Will I get a Form 1099-S when I sell my Stillwater home?

Usually. A closing agent need not file one for a principal residence sold for $250,000 or less ($500,000 for a married seller) when the seller certifies the full gain is excludable (IRS, Instructions for Form 1099-S). Every older-plat Stillwater resale in the last 12 months recorded $250,000 or more (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). If you receive one, "you must report the sale of the home even if the gain from the sale is excludable" (IRS Topic 701).

What is FIRPTA withholding when a foreign owner sells a Stillwater home?

When the seller is a foreign person, "The rate of withholding generally is 15%" of the amount realized, and "In most cases, the buyer (transferee) is the withholding agent" (IRS, FIRPTA withholding). Withholding is generally not required when an individual buyer acquires the home "for use as a residence" and the price "is not more than $300,000," which can cover a Unit 3 sale at the $282,500 median; other exceptions exist (IRS, exceptions). Talk to a tax adviser before listing.

Does Florida tax the gain when I sell my Stillwater home?

No. Article VII, Section 5 of the Florida Constitution bars a state tax "upon the income of natural persons who are residents or citizens of the state" beyond federal credit amounts (Florida Constitution, Article VII). A Florida resident selling a Stillwater home owes only federal tax on any taxable gain; a seller resident in another state may owe that state's tax, so check with your adviser before closing.

What must a Stillwater seller disclose?

A Stillwater seller owes the section 689.302 flood disclosure "at or before the time the sales contract is executed," the radon notice, the property tax disclosure summary, the HOA disclosure summary before the contract is signed, and under Johnson v. Davis every known fact "materially affecting the value of the property" that is not readily observable (Florida Statutes 689.302; Florida Statutes 404.056; Johnson v. Davis). Past roof leaks and open permits belong on that list.

Is Stillwater in a flood zone?

Stillwater flood zones are read lot by lot. The only parcel-level reading we have is Zone X at one Lake Victoria Ct address in Stillwater Unit 1, from FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer on November 14, 2026, and Sarasota County's flood maps have been in force since March 27, 2024 (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). Look up your own address on FEMA's Map Service Center, and hand buyers any elevation certificate you have.

Will a Stillwater buyer using Citizens need flood insurance in 2027?

Yes. Citizens' schedule for homes outside the Special Flood Hazard Area ends with "01.01.27 All policies, regardless of value," so most new and renewing personal residential policies with wind coverage must carry flood coverage by January 1, 2027 (Citizens, flood insurance requirement). That reaches a Zone X Stillwater home as well. Sarasota County holds Community Rating System Class 5, a 25 percent NFIP discount, on FEMA's October 1, 2026 list (FEMA CRS list).

Can my Stillwater buyer take over my flood insurance policy?

An NFIP policy can go with the house. FEMA says "Policyholders are able to transfer their discount to a new owner by assigning their flood insurance policy" (FEMA, Risk Rating 2.0), and FloodSmart's agent guidance adds "If the building is sold, the policy can transfer to the new owner, allowing them to keep the lower rate. Continuous coverage is required to maintain the discount" (FloodSmart). Have your declarations page ready for the buyer's agent.

Will a buyer need a four-point inspection on my Stillwater home?

Probably, on most older Stillwater homes. Citizens says it "requires a four-point inspection for all property owner, dwelling and mobile home applications for properties more than 20 years old," covering electrical, plumbing, HVAC and roof (Citizens, inspections). By the build years on the county roll, Stillwater homes built 2000 to 2006, which include every Unit 2 home, now meet that age test. Sources disagree on the age trigger other carriers use, and the buyer's insurer sets its own rule.

Will a buyer's insurer accept my original Stillwater roof?

Under section 627.7011(5), "An insurer may not refuse to issue or refuse to renew a homeowner's policy insuring a residential structure with a roof that is less than 15 years old solely because of the age of the roof," and for an older roof, an inspection showing "5 years or more of useful life remaining" protects eligibility (Florida Statutes 627.7011). Stillwater homes built 2000 to 2011 are 15 or more years old on an original roof.

Should I give buyers a wind mitigation report on my Stillwater home?

Yes, if you have one or can order one. Insurers' rate filings "must include actuarially reasonable discounts, credits, or other rate differentials" for features such as roof-to-wall strength and opening protection (Florida Statutes 627.0629). Inspections from April 1, 2026 must use the revised form OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26), and Citizens accepts the older form only within its five-year window (Citizens, form changes).

Which hurricane evacuation level is Stillwater in?

We did not verify it, so we print no level. Sarasota County uses levels A to E, and its lookup asks you to "type in your address to see your evacuation zone" (WUSF, Sarasota County evacuation zones); the state's Know Your Zone page offers the same lookup (Florida Division of Emergency Management, Know Your Zone). Your 2026 TRIM notice also shows it. Evacuation level and flood zone are different maps.

Can a buyer use FHA, VA or conventional financing on a Stillwater home?

Usually, though the lender checks the project type. Fannie Mae says "Unit in a PUD project: Project review is waived, with the exception of some basic requirements" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-2.1-01), and VA loans can buy "a single-family home" or "a condo in a VA-approved project" (VA purchase loan). Whether Unit 3 homes are attached or detached is not confirmed from a recorded document, so the declaration and the lender settle it.

Can my Stillwater buyer use a USDA loan?

We did not test Stillwater addresses on USDA's map, so we make no claim either way. A buyer's lender confirms eligibility for the exact address on USDA's property eligibility map (USDA property eligibility). FHA, VA and conventional loans remain the usual routes, and VA lists "Fewer closing costs, which may be paid by the seller" among its benefits (VA purchase loan).

Does my Pulte warranty transfer to the buyer of my Shores at Stillwater home?

Pulte's warranty page says "Warranties are transferable to subsequent owner who takes title within the applicable warranty period," and its national book runs 1 year for materials and workmanship, 2 years for systems and 10 years for structural elements, counted from the first closing (builder-stated, Pulte, Warranty; Pulte National Warranty Book). Hand your buyer the warranty documents and ask Pulte to confirm the transfer.

Can the buyer of my Shores at Stillwater home bring a construction defect claim?

Yes. Chapter 558 defines "Claimant" as "a property owner, including a subsequent purchaser or association" (Florida Statutes 558.002), and an action "must be commenced within 7 years after" the certificate of occupancy (Florida Statutes 95.11). Shores homes were built in 2025 and 2026, so that window runs into the 2030s; for older Stillwater homes built through 2016 it has passed. Disclose any known claim, and ask a lawyer.

How do I handle an open permit before listing my Stillwater home?

Close it. Section 553.79 bars the county from fining an arm's-length buyer for a prior owner's open permit, but it "shall maintain all rights and remedies against the property owner and contractor listed on the permit," and an owner "may retain the original contractor listed on the permit or hire a different contractor" to close it (Florida Statutes 553.79). On the AS IS contract you disclose any open permits you know of.

Who provides water and sewer service to Stillwater homes?

Englewood Water District serves this part of Englewood; at Shores at Stillwater the district engineer says the water and sewer systems "will be owned and maintained by the Englewood Water District" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). For an older Stillwater address, confirm with the district at (941) 474-3217 (Englewood Water District) and schedule a final reading and service transfer for closing.

When is the best time to sell a Stillwater home?

Older-plat Stillwater resales recorded from 2015 to October 2026 cluster in February (24), March (22) and April (23), with the fewest in August (6) and September (7) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Closing month trails the listing month, so listing in winter aims at those closings. Pulte's first sales at Shores at Stillwater closed in most months from February to October 2026, so builder competition runs year round. Bind insurance well before a storm-season closing.

Can I sell my Stillwater house by owner?

Yes. Florida does not require a listing agent, and an owner selling alone still owes the flood disclosure, the radon notice, the property tax disclosure summary, the HOA disclosure summary before contract and the Johnson v. Davis duty, plus deed stamps at $0.70 per $100 (Florida Statutes 720.401; Florida DOR). Know the Sarasota custom too: the buyer customarily pays the owner's title policy (Barnes Walker).

Should I sell my Stillwater home to a cash buyer or list it?

Compare any cash offer with recorded sales first. Older-plat Stillwater resales recorded a $315,000 median in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, with Unit 3 at $282,500 and Unit 1 at $550,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). No public record reports what cash-offer companies pay. Countywide, 778 of 2,071 Sarasota County single-family closings in the third quarter of 2026 were cash (RASM), so listing still reaches cash buyers.

Who is the best realtor to sell my Stillwater home?

The best listing agent for your Stillwater home prices from the county record by plat and heated size, prices plan to plan against Pulte's dated prices, pulls your roof permit, wind mitigation report, estoppel and, at Shores, CDD figures before an offer arrives, and personally negotiates your sale. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012. Start with a free Stillwater home valuation.

What does McGreevy and Comisar do to sell a Stillwater home?

We price from Stillwater's recorded resales and Pulte's first sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), set your home against Pulte's live plan and quick move-in prices, search permits before launch, gather the roof, 4-point and wind mitigation papers and the association documents, negotiate as the partners who priced the home and manage the closing. Start with a free Stillwater home valuation, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying too? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.


Why Do Stillwater Sellers Call a Local Team?

Stillwater sellers call a local team because value in Stillwater in Englewood rests on details a distant agent rarely checks: which of the five plats holds the home, what Pulte charges next door this week, how old the roof is and whether the permit shows it, which association issues the estoppel, and whether the lot is in the Shores CDD.

If you are thinking, "I need someone to sell my house in Stillwater, Florida," McGreevy and Comisar helps homeowners price, market, negotiate, and sell with a local strategy built for Englewood, Sarasota County, Charlotte County, Venice and North Port. Whether you are selling in Stillwater, Shores at Stillwater, in Grove City, in Englewood East, on Manasota Key, in Boca Royale, Beachwalk by Manasota Key, Coco Bay, Oyster Creek or Englewood Isles, our team provides local market guidance, professional listing exposure, and a clear plan to help you sell confidently.

RealTrends ranked our Domain Realty Group team #5 in Florida in 2026, and Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar bring over 45 years of combined direct experience between them. For the community itself, from the five plats and Pulte's plans to flood zones, utilities, schools and parks, read our Stillwater neighborhood guide. For the wider town, read our guide to selling a home in Englewood.

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more at DomainRealtyGroup.com.

Where Do Stillwater Public Records Live?

Stillwater public records live with Sarasota County and the district: the Property Appraiser holds the parcel and recorded sales, the Tax Collector holds the bill and its levy list, the Clerk records deeds and declarations, FEMA's Map Service Center holds the flood map, and the Shores at Stillwater CDD posts its budgets and meeting books online.

That means the Sarasota County Property Appraiser and its homestead and portability pages (941-861-8200), the Sarasota County Tax Collector and its 2026 millage sheet ((941) 861-8300), FEMA's Map Service Center for your lot's zone, Sunbiz for the associations' state filings, and the Shores at Stillwater CDD documents page, which holds the ordinance, budgets and meeting books. The Sarasota County Clerk's official records hold the recorded declarations; their book and page numbers were not read for this page, so search by association name and document type "Declaration." For zoning on an older lot, Sarasota County Planning and Development Services answers at 941-861-5000 (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

Who Answers Stillwater CDD, HOA, Utility and Fire Questions?

Stillwater questions go to four separate bodies: the Shores at Stillwater CDD for its assessment and payoff, your homeowners association for dues and the estoppel, the Englewood Water District for water and sewer, and the Englewood Area Fire Control District, whose flat assessment rides on every tax bill. Each charge runs with the parcel, not the owner.

The Shores at Stillwater Community Development District "was established pursuant to F.S. Chapter 190 and is governed by a five-member Board of Supervisors elected by landowners within the District," and its district manager is Special District Services, 2501A Burns Road, Palm Beach Gardens, (561) 630-4922 (June 15, 2026 meeting book). The associations answer through the estoppel process under section 720.30851, and each must name on its website where estoppel requests go. For water and sewer, the Englewood Water District answers at (941) 474-3217. The Englewood Area Fire Control District sets the $290.78 residential assessment for 2026 to 2027 and says it "receives no funds from county taxes."

Buying Your Next Home, or Staying in Sarasota County?

If you are selling in Stillwater and buying your next home nearby, we handle both sides of the move with the same county-record method. Timing two closings, porting any Save Our Homes difference and checking the next home's flood zone, association and any district lines first are where a local team saves Stillwater owners the most.

Portability moves up to $500,000 of Save Our Homes difference to a new Florida homestead, and the Property Appraiser says form DR-501T "will be provided to you as part of the homestead application process" and that the old homestead must be abandoned, with "no requirement that the property be sold" (Florida Statutes 193.155; Sarasota County Property Appraiser, portability FAQ). Homestead applications are due by March 1 for a home you own and occupy on January 1 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, homestead overview). Read our Englewood home buyer guide, then Call Marc at (239) 287-5873. Before any of that, our Englewood home valuation page or a free Stillwater home valuation tells you what you are working with, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.


Downloadable Documents

Every document behind the figures on this page is public and free. These are the ones a Stillwater, Englewood, Florida seller uses, from the deed stamp statute and title rate rule to the estoppel caps, the Shores at Stillwater CDD's budgets and the flood, roof and tax rules, each linked to its publisher, not to a copy.

Document Publisher What a Stillwater seller uses it for Link
Documentary Stamp Tax guidance Florida Department of Revenue The $0.70 per $100 deed rate and the rounding method floridarevenue.com documentary stamp tax
Section 201.02, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The statute that sets the deed stamp tax Section 201.02
Rule 69O-186.003, Title Insurance Rates Florida Office of Insurance Regulation rule The promulgated owner's premium and the 3-year reissue rate Rule 69O-186.003
Title insurance overview Florida Department of Financial Services Who chooses the title agent and when reissue rates apply Florida DFS title insurance overview
Section 28.24, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The $10.00 and $8.50 recording fees Section 28.24
Section 695.26, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature What a deed must show to be recorded Section 695.26
Section 701.04, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The 10-day payoff letter and 60-day satisfaction deadlines Section 701.04
Section 720.30851, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature Estoppel timing, contents, validity and refunds Section 720.30851
Estoppel certificate fee caps Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation The $299, $119 and $179 caps in force DBPR estoppel fee sheet
Section 720.401, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The HOA disclosure summary owed before the contract Section 720.401
Section 720.3085, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature Joint liability for unpaid assessments at transfer Section 720.3085
Section 720.303, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The website document rule for associations of 100 or more parcels Section 720.303
Section 720.306, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature How post-2021 rental rules bind a buyer Section 720.306
Section 190.048, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The CDD disclosure statement on initial sales Section 190.048
Section 190.0485, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The recorded Notice of Establishment a title search shows Section 190.0485
FY2026/2027 final budget Shores at Stillwater Community Development District The O&M collected at closings and the $276 rate Shores at Stillwater CDD FY2026/2027 budget
Amended FY2025/2026 budget Shores at Stillwater Community Development District The Series 2026 bond par, coupons and maturity Shores at Stillwater CDD amended FY2025/2026 budget
June 15, 2026 meeting book Shores at Stillwater Community Development District Per-lot principal, maximum annual assessments and the district manager Shores at Stillwater CDD June 15, 2026 book
April 20, 2026 meeting book Shores at Stillwater Community Development District The district boundary and the prepayment terms Shores at Stillwater CDD April 20, 2026 book
Section 689.302, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The seller's flood disclosure Section 689.302
Section 689.261, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The property tax disclosure summary and the February 1, 2027 listing rule Section 689.261
Section 404.056, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The radon notice language Section 404.056
Section 553.79, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature Open permits and how an owner closes one Section 553.79
Section 627.7011, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The 15-year roof rule and roof inspection right Section 627.7011
Section 627.0629, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature Wind mitigation credits insurers must offer Section 627.0629
Flood insurance requirement Citizens Property Insurance The January 1, 2027 flood requirement for Citizens wind policies Citizens flood requirement
Inspections Citizens Property Insurance The four-point and roof documentation rules Citizens inspections
Map Service Center FEMA Your lot's flood zone and FIRM panel FEMA Map Service Center
CRS Eligible Communities, October 1, 2026 FEMA Sarasota County's Class 5, 25 percent NFIP discount FEMA CRS list
2026 millage sheet Sarasota County Tax Collector The 11.3068-mill rate and the list of levying authorities Sarasota County Tax Collector 2026 millage
Property tax calendar and discounts Sarasota County Tax Collector Bill dates, discounts, delinquency and proration Sarasota County Tax Collector
Assessments, fees and charges Englewood Area Fire Control District The $290.78 residential assessment EAFCD assessments
Section 193.155, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature Save Our Homes, the buyer's reassessment and portability Section 193.155
Portability FAQ Sarasota County Property Appraiser Form DR-501T and the transfer of your Save Our Homes difference Sarasota County Property Appraiser portability FAQ
AS IS Residential Contract for Sale and Purchase, 2026 redline Florida Realtors and The Florida Bar Seller costs, the CDD proration carve-out and the disclosures Florida Realtors AS IS contract
Seller's Property Disclosure, Residential (SPDR-4x) Florida Realtors The customary form for the Johnson v. Davis disclosure Florida Realtors SPDR-4x
Publication 523, Selling Your Home IRS The 2-of-5-year test, partial exclusions and basis IRS Publication 523
Instructions for Form 1099-S IRS When the closing agent reports your sale IRS Form 1099-S instructions
FIRPTA Withholding IRS Withholding rules for a foreign seller IRS FIRPTA withholding
Customer Rules and Regulations, FY27 Englewood Water District Service, liens and charges that run with the parcel EWD FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations
Property records and sales data Sarasota County Property Appraiser The recorded sales behind every Stillwater figure on this page Sarasota County Property Appraiser

Sources

Every source below was read on November 17, 2026, and each figure on this page carries its own date and window beside it in the text. Primary documents come first: Florida Statutes and rules, state and federal agencies, Sarasota County and its Property Appraiser, Clerk and Tax Collector, the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District, the Englewood Water District and the Englewood Area Fire Control District. Builder figures are quoted from Pulte's own pages and PulteGroup filings as builder-stated, with the date read. Stillwater sales figures come from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (12-month window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026), for the five recorded plats Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2 and Unit 3 and Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A and Phase 1B. No listing site, brokerage or valuation aggregator was used for any figure on this page.

Your Local Real Estate Experts

McGreevy and Comisar are the Southwest Florida listing team Stillwater sellers call when the details decide the price. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team, and personally handle every listing from pricing to closing, with over 45 years of combined direct experience between Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar.

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

For this page we tracked 35 qualified recorded home sales in Stillwater, Englewood, Florida for the 12 months to October 14, 2026, 55 over 24 months and 63 over 36 months, every resale against the same home's earlier recorded price, Pulte's live prices and offers next door at Shores at Stillwater, and every district and association charge named above, so the figures here come from public records rather than estimates. Our Domain Realty Group team has completed more than 4,000 transactions across Southwest Florida.

Jesse McGreevy direct: (239) 898-6072 · · Marc Comisar direct: (239) 287-5873 · Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Jesse McGreevy (license SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (license BK3060671) are licensed Florida real estate professionals regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) under Chapter 475, Florida Statutes.

More on the team at about McGreevy and Comisar. McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team; learn more at DomainRealtyGroup.com. Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, YouTube and LinkedIn.

Ready to sell? Call Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072, or start with your free Stillwater home valuation. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and there is no obligation.

Updated November 2026. This page is general information about selling a home in Stillwater, Englewood, Florida, not an appraisal and not legal or tax advice. Recorded-sales figures change with every county file and statutory figures change annually. Brokered by Domain Realty.