Aerial view of Fort Myers Beach and Matanzas Pass, with San Carlos Island across the pass, McGreevy and Comisar

San Carlos Island

San Carlos Island is a working-waterfront community of 1,218 residential parcels across Matanzas Pass from Estero Island, in unincorporated Lee County, Fort Myers Beach. Call McGreevy and Comisar, (239) 898-6072.

Search Homes

Home > Fort Myers Beach > San Carlos Island

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.

More about Jesse McGreevy, Marc Comisar and our team on the McGreevy and Comisar about page.

San Carlos Island, Fort Myers Beach: A Working-Waterfront Island Outside the Town

San Carlos Island is the working-waterfront island across Matanzas Pass from Estero Island, in unincorporated Lee County, with a Fort Myers Beach address. The county roll counts 1,218 residential-class parcels here, built from 1940 to 2024, and the Town of Fort Myers Beach does not govern them. This page maps the island, pocket by pocket.

San Carlos Island is the home of the shrimp-boat docks, the marinas, an old-Florida street grid of canal-front houses, three condominium-and-RV lanes, a yacht-club condominium, a cooperative, a Gulf-edge enclave and, at the north end, two gated communities with seller pages of their own on this site. It is one island with at least ten different ways to own a home, and the rules, fees and prices change a great deal from one pocket to the next.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

We wrote this page the way we would brief a buyer or seller we were representing. Every figure carries its source and its window, every conflict between two sources is printed with both sides, and every Southwest Florida MLS figure was pulled by us on October 7, 2026, with the listings re-checked on October 29, 2026. The Fort Myers Beach pages treat the Town on Estero Island; this one is for the island that is not in it, and a later section, San Carlos Island vs Estero Island, sets the two side by side.

Where San Carlos Island sits, precisely

San Carlos Island lies across Matanzas Pass from Estero Island, the island the Town of Fort Myers Beach governs. In the county’s records San Carlos Boulevard is the island’s main road, and the San Carlos on the Gulf plat holds San Carlos Drive and Prescott Street. Tip Top Isles and Bayside Estates sit off San Carlos Boulevard on the mainland and are not on the island.

Jurisdiction is the first question on this island, and the county roll answers it parcel by parcel: all 1,218 residential-class parcels sit in unincorporated Lee County and in the roll’s San Carlos Island taxing district, which lists the Fort Myers Beach fire, library and mosquito districts and the San Carlos lighting district. Lee County, not the Town, issues permits and applies zoning here; the roll shows every one of the 1,218 parcels in the county’s Urban Community zoning.

A name is not membership

Several places carry the island’s name or sit close enough to be confused with it. Gulf Waters RV Resort, the Lakeside and Whitewater Court addresses, Tip Top Isles and Island Shores are not in the island’s taxing district, according to our review of the county roll, and we treat them as neighbors, not as parts of the island. Tip Top Isles matters for one reason: eight of the 86 Southwest Florida MLS closings in our island series are Tip Top Isles homes, and we label them wherever they appear.

Boardwalk Caper on San Carlos Boulevard is the gated marine condominium community of Phases I to VI on the island. It is not Caper Beach Club, Sand Caper or Sun Caper, which are separate Gulf-side buildings on Estero Island in the Town.

The pockets of the island on one page

The island is easiest to read as a set of pockets. Each has a section below with its own numbers.

Quick reference, San Carlos Island

Item

What the records show

Name and address

San Carlos Island, Fort Myers Beach, Florida 33931

Jurisdiction

Unincorporated Lee County; not in the Town of Fort Myers Beach

Residential-class parcels (county roll, October 4, 2026)

1,218, of which 805 are improved

Year built (improved parcels)

1940 to 2024, median 1987

Forms of ownership on the roll

Single-family 228; condominium 357; cooperative 210; mobile or manufactured 133; vacant 207; common area 39; small multifamily 41; boat slip 2; larger multifamily 1

Water frontage (county land-on field)

Canal 794; bay 150; creek 15; not stated 259

Docks, seawalls, pools (county flags)

Boat dock 607; seawall 476; pool 517

Tallest building on the roll

12 stories

Taxing district and 2026 applied millage

San Carlos Island district, 13.2284 (13.3976 in 2025)

Zoning on the roll

Urban Community, all 1,218 parcels

FEMA flood map at tested addresses

AE with a base flood elevation of 11 to 12 ft; VE at 12 to 13 ft (NAVD88)

Evacuation zone

A, at every point we tested

Public school zones

Elementary T, middle MM, high South Zone 4; confirm by address with the district

Associations

Several, by pocket; see each section for the legal name and Florida document number

Why McGreevy and Comisar Are the Best Realtor for San Carlos Island

McGreevy and Comisar are the best realtor for San Carlos Island because the case sits on the record: the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% nationally since 2008, over $900 million in personal sales, and an island read built from every Southwest Florida MLS closing, the county roll and the state’s corporate registers.

If you’re searching for the best realtor for San Carlos Island in Fort Myers Beach, Florida, whether you’re ready to sell your San Carlos Island home or buy your next one, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Nationally since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc.

Recent San Carlos Island track record (12 months to October 7, 2026): The Southwest Florida MLS, pulled October 7, 2026, shows 11 San Carlos Island closings in the 12 months to that date, from $150,000 to $2,380,000, with a median of $400,000, a median of $351 per square foot, a median of 64 days on market and a median sale-to-final-list ratio of 94.7%. The highest-priced sale was $2,380,000 for a five-bedroom home on San Carlos Drive in June 2026. The MLS records 86 closings in the 60 months to the same date, and we tracked every one of those 86 closings for this page.

Our team record: RealTrends Verified 2026 lists McGreevy and Comisar of Domain Realty as a Large Team with 241 sides and $157.57 million in volume, ranked #1 in Bonita Springs and #5 in Florida by sides and #11 by volume, on the RealTrends team profile. Domain Realty Group, which Jesse and Marc lead, has closed more than $2.5 billion in real estate and over 4,000 transactions across Southwest Florida.

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Selling your San Carlos Island home? Get a free home valuation at mcgreevyandcomisar.com/home-valuation OR call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Our dedicated guide to selling a home on San Carlos Island and the San Carlos Island home valuation page are live.

Buying a home on San Carlos Island? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 for a personalized buyer consultation, and see how we help buyers on the Gulf coast and our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers Beach.

Jesse McGreevy is a top-reviewed San Carlos Island realtor. Read the five-star reviews on Google.

If you are comparing agents before you narrow to one pocket of the island, our comparison of the best real estate agents in Fort Myers Beach explains how we work and what we measure.

What Is It Like to Live on San Carlos Island as a Homebuyer?

Living on San Carlos Island means a working harbor, canal-front streets and a wide range of homes at very different prices, a short drive over Matanzas Pass to the beach and county rules instead of Town rules. The trade is storm exposure, mixed forms of ownership and fewer public documents than a condominium buyer expects.

Our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers Beach covers what a buyer should read first, and Marc Comisar takes buyer calls at (239) 287-5873.

The setting in plain words

The island is a working island. Fishing and shrimp boats, marinas and boat yards share it with homes, and the sounds and smells of a harbor come with the address. Salty Sam’s Marina on Main Street and Gulf Star Marina at Fishermans Wharf are the two marinas the research confirmed, and Lee County approved the purchase of a lot on the island for a public boat ramp in September 2025, according to WINK News. Quiet cul-de-sacs and lots with room for a dock and a truck are both here, in different pockets.

The county’s own marker of the island’s character is the Maritime Park on San Carlos Island, a 5.5-acre county-owned site that Hurricane Ian damaged. The county’s March 2026 frequently-asked-questions sheet for the park is among the documents listed at the end of this page.

What a buyer is actually buying

The county roll shows 1,218 residential-class parcels on the island, and 805 of them have buildings. The rest are vacant lots, common areas, boat slips and the like. Across the 805 improved parcels, heated area runs from 404 to 12,766 square feet with a median of 1,124, years built run from 1940 to 2024 with a median of 1987, and the county’s median just value is $238,356. That median is the roll’s assessed figure, not a sale price, and it sits low because so many improved parcels are manufactured homes, RV-lot condominiums and older condominium units.

The sales record shows two island markets under one name. In the 60 months to October 7, 2026, the 48 closings the MLS lists as manufactured homes had a median of $227,500, the 31 single-family closings a median of $1,050,000 and the seven low-rise condominium closings a median of $425,000. The building type is the listing agent’s entry in the MLS, not a county record, so we use it only to show how far apart the markets sit.

What the island has been doing since Ian

The county roll shows 23 parcels on the island with a year built of 2023 or later, which we read, as an inference and not from permits, as post-Ian rebuilding and new construction. Eleven of the 119 improved parcels in the three lane condominiums were built in 2023 or later, as were two of the 63 improved parcels in Port Carlos Cove and four of the 55 improved parcels in Old Pelican Bay. In San Carlos on the Gulf, three of 78 improved parcels date to 2023 or later, and 38 were built before 1980.

What Have San Carlos Island Homes Sold For? The Market Snapshot

Over the 12 months to October 7, 2026, the Southwest Florida MLS recorded 11 San Carlos Island closings, from $150,000 to $2,380,000, with a median of $400,000, $351 per square foot and 64 days on market. Counted by Lee County’s own sales file, the whole island, including its two gated communities, had 46 qualified sales at a median of $374,000.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

The Southwest Florida MLS series, 12 months to October 7, 2026

Eleven closings is a thin sample for an island this varied, and 10 is our threshold for leading with a median. The window of the 12 months to October 7, 2026 clears it by one, so it leads, and we say again that one sale moves the middle: if the $2,380,000 sale had gone for a third of that, the median would still sit at $400,000, but the ranges around it would not.

Within the 11 closings, the median sale-to-final-list ratio was 94.7%, the median days on market was 64 with a spread from 0 to 347, and total volume was $7,774,500. Eight of the 11 closed at or below $450,000 and three closed above $1,100,000. The island’s price story is the gap between those two groups, not the median.

Every closing in the 12 months to October 7, 2026

We list all 11, by street address only, so you can see the spread and not just the middle. One of the 11, on Broadway Avenue, is in Tip Top Isles, which is mainland and is included in this series because the MLS groups it with the island; we mark it.

Closed

Price

Street address

Living area (sq ft)

Price per sq ft

Days on market

Pocket

September 10, 2026

$1,650,000

921 Prescott St

3,558

$464

76

San Carlos on the Gulf

August 31, 2026

$150,000

19 Helen Ln

924

$162

4

Helen Lane

August 25, 2026

$400,000

894 Buttonwood Dr

1,139

$351

207

Sportsmans Cove

August 12, 2026

$324,500

14 Nancy Ln

1,200

$270

347

Nancy Lane

July 24, 2026

$285,000

7 Galleon Way

1,361

$209

10

Port Carlos Cove

June 24, 2026

$440,000

4 Galleon Way

1,176

$374

164

Port Carlos Cove

June 16, 2026

$2,380,000

789 San Carlos Dr

1,824

$1,305

123

San Carlos on the Gulf

April 28, 2026

$425,000

894 Buttonwood Dr

1,134

$375

9

Sportsmans Cove

April 2, 2026

$330,000

17740 Broadway Ave

1,741

$190

8

Tip Top Isles (mainland)

March 9, 2026

$225,000

123 Cortez Way

920

$245

0

Port Carlos Cove

October 10, 2025

$1,165,000

830 San Carlos Dr

2,662

$438

64

Hidden Harbor on the Bay

Price per square foot across the 11 runs from $162 to $1,305 with a median of $351 (n = 11). The $1,305 figure is a lot-and-location price on a 1,824-square-foot house and is not a floor-area price in the usual sense; the median of $351 is the more useful yardstick.

Longer windows: 24, 36 and 60 months

The longer windows show the same island with more sales in it. Each row is a separate pull, not an average of the others.

Window to October 7, 2026

Closings

Median price

Range

Volume

Median price per sq ft

Median days on market

Median sale-to-final-list

12 months

11

$400,000

$150,000 to $2,380,000

$7,774,500

$351

64

94.7%

24 months

19

$425,000

$150,000 to $2,380,000

$12,943,000

$375

64

94.3%

36 months

35

$425,000

$135,000 to $3,174,000

$25,659,800

$407

44

94.3%

60 months

86

$372,500

$58,140 to $3,250,000

$50,795,860

$334

29.5

94.3%

Over 60 months the market sold at a median of 94.3% of its final list price. The 60-month median days on market is 29.5, and the median of 64 days for the 12 months to October 7, 2026 is more than twice that figure, so recent sellers have waited longer than the five-year record suggests.

Two series, two definitions

Two cautions come with these numbers, and we print them where the numbers sit.

First, the MLS series is the island’s MLS subdivisions only. It covers San Carlos on the Gulf, Port Carlos Cove, the Nancy, Helen and Emily Lane condominiums, Sportsmans Cove, Oak Street, the Gulf Cove trailer cooperative, Hidden Harbor on the Bay and Tip Top Isles. It does not include Boardwalk Caper or Siesta Isles, which have their own seller pages, or Old Pelican Bay, whose single MLS closing is counted in the Siesta Isles series. A separate cut of the same MLS by its own San Carlos Island area grouping shows 10 closings and a median of $412,500 in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, and 80 closings and a median of $360,000 in 60 months. The two cuts differ because the area grouping and the subdivision names do not draw the same line, and we publish the subdivision series because it ties to the community comparison table below.

Second, the county series is a different record. It counts recorded, qualified sales on all 1,218 parcels, including Boardwalk Caper and Siesta Isles, and it never mixes with the MLS series. That is why the county count for 12 months in the October 4, 2026 roll file is 46 and the MLS count is 11.

What the county recorded

Lee County’s qualified-sale windows, from the roll file dated October 4, 2026, show the following.

Window

County-qualified sales

Median price

Range

12 months

46

$374,000

$150,000 to $2,850,000

24 months

68

$399,250

$150,000 to $2,850,000

36 months

85

$479,750

$150,000 to $3,174,000

60 months

148

$416,500

$70,000 to $3,800,000

The community comparison table below shows 20 of the 46 twelve-month sales in Boardwalk Caper and 11 in Siesta Isles, which leaves 15 (46 - 20 - 11 = 15) for every other pocket on the island; that is arithmetic on two published windows, not a separate count. These are county records of qualified sales, which exclude transfers the county does not treat as arm’s-length. The sale-by-sale list we hold for the island runs from December 13, 2022 to August 31, 2026 and holds 120 sales, so it does not reconcile one to one with the 148 in the 60-month window; we say which list we used each time we use one. In the module sections below, we tracked every one of these records by pocket.

What was listed on October 7, 2026

The MLS showed 14 active listings on the island series and none pending. Asking prices ran from $249,000 for a Galleon Way home in Port Carlos Cove to $7,895,000 for a San Carlos Drive home, with a median list price of $472,000. Three listings were over $5 million, all on San Carlos Drive. Eight of the 14 were priced at $475,000 or less. One of the 14 was in Tip Top Isles, on Broadway Avenue at $649,000. A re-check of the MLS on October 29, 2026 found 15 active San Carlos Island listings in the same series, asking $249,000 to $7,895,000 at a median of $550,000, two of them not on the October 7 list, and one pending, an Emily Lane condo at $429,000. No closing was recorded after October 7.

On October 7, 2026, that was a market with a lot of choice at the low end and almost none in between: above $475,000 and below $5 million the island had three listings, at $649,000 on Broadway Avenue in Tip Top Isles, $699,000 on Prescott Street and $949,000 on North Street.

How often homes change hands

The county’s qualified-sale file shows 148 sales in 60 months. Divided by the 805 improved parcels and by five years, that is 3.7% of improved parcels a year (148 / 805 / 5 = 0.0368), meaning a typical improved parcel on the island changes hands about once in 27 years. The MLS series alone gives 2.1% (86 / 805 / 5), but the MLS series leaves out the two gated communities while the 805 counts them, so we lead with the county rate. Both are rough; condominium and RV-lot parcels sell far more often than single-family parcels.

Where Did San Carlos Island Come From? The Plats, Declarations and Shrimp Fleet

San Carlos Island grew from a fishing and shrimping harbor into a patchwork of recorded plats and condominium declarations, and each pocket’s rules trace to its own recorded document. The documents we could read give Official Records book and page numbers, but the year the island was first platted is not confirmed in any source we reached.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

The shrimp-fleet history

The island’s identity is its working waterfront. The Southwest Florida Regional Planning Council’s Shrimp Industry Master Plan, dated May 21, 2024, counts 54 shrimp boats before Hurricane Ian and 10 remaining, and puts the value of Lee County’s shrimp fishery at $14.3 million. Local press coverage from 2009 describes the shrimp fleet’s return to the island, and reporting from September 29, 2026 in Gulfshore Business describes the operation of Erickson and Jensen as the last commercial shrimping operation in Lee County. We cite those sources as the reporters stated them and have not verified boat counts ourselves.

The Fort Myers Beach Shrimp Festival, which draws on that history, is scheduled for March 13 and 14, 2027, according to the Lions Club announcement reported by Fort Myers Beach Talk.

The recorded plats and declarations

The records we could read, with their Official Records (OR) or Plat Book (PB) references, are these.

Pocket

Recorded instrument

Acres per county GIS

San Carlos on the Gulf

Plat Book 6, page 6, with a related replat at Plat Book 8, page 58

78.41

Hidden Harbor on the Bay

A replat within the San Carlos on the Gulf plat, recorded 2013

Not stated

Nancy Lane

Nancy Lane Condominium, Official Records Book 1700, page 4622

10.67

Emily Lane

Emily Lane RV Condominium, Official Records Book 1724, page 1128

8.36

Helen Lane

Helen Lane RV Condominium, Official Records Book 1789, page 556

5.13

Sportsmans Cove

Sportsmans Cove Yacht and Racquet Club Condominium, Official Records Book 1707, page 4103 (and Official Records Book 2949, page 140)

Not stated

Port Carlos Cove

Legal description references Official Records Book 1646, page 759

6.20

Old Pelican Bay

Plat Book 39, pages 70 and 71; Plat Book 40, pages 85 and 86; Plat Book 66, pages 62 and 63; Plat Book 69, pages 64 and 65

Not stated

Boardwalk Caper

Phases I and II under one declaration, Official Records Book 1541, page 497

Not stated

Siesta Isles has its own recorded plats, which this page does not list. We read these as references the county roll and the research behind this page confirmed, not as copies of the documents. The recorded declarations themselves were not read for this page, and a buyer should ask for them in the resale package.

Planning, designation and the working-waterfront question

Two planning items belong on the record. Lee County’s comprehensive plan amendment file CPA2018-00003, which concerned the island, shows the status “Closed Due to Inactivity” on the county’s results site. And Lee County Ordinance 20-07, adopted June 17, 2020 on a 4 to 1 vote, changed one parcel in the Bay Harbour area to the Central Urban land use category.

Residents and local press have described a 1999 designation of the island’s shoreline as working waterfront. We found no county document that confirms the designation, so we treat it as a resident account, not a record, and list it under what we could not verify.

Talk to Jesse or Marc about San Carlos Island

If you are weighing a sale, Jesse McGreevy can walk you through the closings above and what they imply for your home. Start with a free valuation at mcgreevyandcomisar.com/home-valuation or call Jesse at (239) 898-6072. If you are buying, call Marc Comisar at (239) 287-5873 or start at our buyer page. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

What Are the Homes and Lots Like on San Carlos Island?

San Carlos Island has 1,218 residential-class parcels on the county roll, 805 of them improved, built between 1940 and 2024. The roll shows 228 single-family parcels, 357 condominium parcels, 210 cooperative parcels, 133 mobile or manufactured parcels and 207 vacant parcels, so a buyer is choosing a form of ownership as much as a house.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

The parcels by county use

The roll’s use categories, summed, make up the 1,218: 207 vacant, 357 condominium, 39 common area, 210 cooperative, 228 single-family, 133 mobile or manufactured, 41 multifamily under 10 units, two boat slips and one larger multifamily parcel. Those counts include the two gated communities, which hold 429 of the parcels between them (303 in Boardwalk Caper and 126 in Siesta Isles).

The year-built spread

Years built run from 1940 to 2024, with a median of 1987. Twenty-three parcels have a year built of 2023 or later. The island is old, and an older house on this island is most often a ground-level house in a flood zone, a point the storm section takes up.

Heated area and the biggest and smallest homes

Heated area on improved parcels runs from 404 square feet to 12,766, with a median of 1,124 square feet. The median is low because condominium units and manufactured homes make up so many improved parcels; the large homes sit mostly in San Carlos on the Gulf and Siesta Isles.

Water frontage, docks, seawalls and pools

The county’s land-on field puts 794 parcels on a canal, 150 on the bay and 15 on a creek, with 259 not stated. The county flags 607 parcels with a boat dock, 476 with a seawall and 517 with a pool. Boardwalk Caper alone accounts for 298 of the dock flags and 298 of the pool flags, because its condominiums share the marina and pools. On the roll these are flags, not inspections: they say the county recorded a dock or seawall, not that it is sound or permitted, and not what depth the water is.

The streets that carry the most parcels

San Carlos Boulevard carries 364 parcels, the most of any street. Emily Lane has 84, Nancy Lane 72, San Carlos Drive 69, Deep Passage Lane and Cutlass Drive 61 each, Old Pelican Bay Drive 51, Oak Street and Siesta Drive 49 each, Helen Lane 43, and Doubloon Way and Blackbeard Way 43 each.

What Amenities Does San Carlos Island Have?

San Carlos Island’s amenities depend on the pocket: boat docks and pools in several communities, a racquet-club name on Sportsmans Cove, the gated marina and pools at Boardwalk Caper, and county-owned public land such as the Maritime Park. No island-wide homeowners association exists, so no single amenity package comes with an island address.

Amenities inside the communities

The research confirms the following, and only the following. Boardwalk Caper’s community website describes four pools, tennis courts, pickleball courts and a boardwalk of more than half a mile; the site says it is not the official site of any association, so we use it only for facts. Sportsmans Cove has 41 parcels with a dock flag on the bay, according to the county roll. Port Carlos Cove has 90 dock flags and one pool flag, Old Pelican Bay has 33 dock flags and 38 pool flags, and the lane condominiums have 81 dock flags among them. We did not confirm clubhouses, fitness rooms or beach access for any pocket other than those named.

Public land and water access

Salty Sam’s Marina offers a public boat ramp at a posted fee of $35, according to its website. The county’s purchase of a lot for a public ramp was reported in September 2025. The Maritime Park is a 5.5-acre county-owned site, damaged in Hurricane Ian, with a March 2026 county FAQ on its status. The beaches of Estero Island are across Matanzas Pass and reachable by road.

What the research did not confirm

We did not confirm beach-access rights, clubhouse hours, guest rules or pool schedules for any pocket on this island. Those items belong in the association’s rules, and the resale package should include them.

What Is Each Pocket of San Carlos Island Like, One by One?

San Carlos Island’s pockets run from Helen Lane sales at $58,140 to Gulf-edge houses at $3,250,000, and each has its own legal form, association and rules. The sections below give each pocket’s county facts, its Southwest Florida MLS record over 60 months and the questions a buyer should put to the association before signing.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

San Carlos on the Gulf

San Carlos on the Gulf is the plat that holds San Carlos Drive, Prescott Street, North Street and neighboring blocks, recorded at Plat Book 6, page 6, with a related replat at Plat Book 8, page 58, and 78.41 acres per the county GIS. The roll shows 231 parcels in the plat, led by 55 cooperative, 44 single-family, 37 vacant and 34 small multifamily parcels, and 175 of the 231 are residential-class. Of those 175, 78 are improved, built from 1942 to 2024, with 35 pool flags, three dock flags and 46 seawall flags. Three of the 78 improved parcels were built in 2023 or later, and 38 were built before 1980.

The MLS recorded 18 closings here in the 60 months to October 7, 2026: a median of $1,375,000, a range of $375,000 to $3,250,000 and a median of $584 per square foot (median of these 18 closings). By year, the 18 closings fall as two in 2026, two in 2025, six in 2024, four in 2023 and four in 2022. Two closed in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, at $1,650,000 for 921 Prescott St in September 2026 and $2,380,000 for 789 San Carlos Dr in June 2026. The county list shows 789 San Carlos Dr changing hands three times, in July 2023 at $1,750,000, February 2024 at $2,250,000 and June 2026 at $2,380,000.

The listing-entered annual recurring fees on all 18 closings were $0 (not verified; the association’s current budget and an estoppel certificate govern). No Florida corporation with the plat’s name turned up on the Division of Corporations register, so a buyer should ask the seller and the title company which, if any, association binds the lot. On October 7, 2026, three of the island’s 14 active listings sat on San Carlos Drive, all above $5 million.

Hidden Harbor on the Bay

Hidden Harbor on the Bay is a replat inside the San Carlos on the Gulf plat, recorded in 2013, with 13 parcels, nine of them single-family and all built from 2016 to 2023. The MLS records two closings: $725,000 for a 1,424-square-foot home in December 2021 and $1,165,000 for a 2,662-square-foot home at 830 San Carlos Dr in October 2025. With two closings, we publish no median and no trend.

Port Carlos Cove

Port Carlos Cove is a cooperative on the canals of San Carlos Island of mostly manufactured homes, on streets named Doubloon, Blackbeard, Cortez, Galleon, Barbados, Spanish Main and Garcia. The county use code on 155 of its 156 residential-class parcels is cooperative, the MLS calls it a cooperative, and under Florida law a residential cooperative falls under chapter 719 of the Florida Statutes, not chapter 718, which governs condominiums.

One source disagrees: the county GIS describes it as a condominium RV park on 6.20 acres. We did not read the recorded declaration, so we follow the roll and the MLS, and a buyer should confirm the ownership form from the recorded documents before relying on either description.

Per the Division of Corporations, Port Carlos Cove, Incorporated (document 768932) was filed June 15, 1983 and is active, and Port Carlos Cove Civic Association, Inc. (document N18000012422) is a second entity. The roll shows built years from 1966 to 2024, 90 dock flags, 115 seawall flags, 101 canal-front and 18 bay-front parcels and one pool flag. Two of 63 improved parcels were built in 2023 or later and 11 before 1980. Whether the cooperative restricts occupancy by age is not confirmed; do not assume it either way.

The MLS recorded 15 closings in 60 months: a median of $238,000, a range of $110,000 to $440,000 and a median of $245 per square foot (median of these 15 closings), in homes from 672 to 1,800 square feet. Three closed in the 12 months to October 7, 2026: 7 Galleon Way at $285,000 in July 2026, 4 Galleon Way at $440,000 in June 2026 and 123 Cortez Way at $225,000 in March 2026. Listing-entered annual recurring fees on 15 closings ranged from $2,160 to $2,400 (not verified; the cooperative’s current budget and its resale package govern). On October 7, 2026, one home was listed at $249,000 on Galleon Way and another at $475,000 on Blackbeard Way.

A cooperative sale is not a deed sale in the way a house sale is. The buyer acquires an interest in the corporation that holds the land and the right to occupy a home, and lenders treat that differently from a mortgage on a house. Ask early for the bylaws, the occupancy agreement, the current budget, any approval process for new owners and the lender requirements.

Nancy Lane

Nancy Lane Condominium is a lane of condominium-owned lots recorded at Official Records Book 1700, page 4622, on 10.67 acres per the county GIS. The association is The Nancy Lane Association, Inc., Florida Division of Corporations document 764501. The three lane condominiums together hold 226 parcels, and the roll’s mix there is 126 mobile home, 93 vacant, four common-area and three single-family parcels. Of 119 improved parcels across the three lanes, built 1961 to 2024, 11 were built in 2023 or later and 20 before 1980.

The MLS recorded 10 Nancy Lane closings in 60 months, with a median of $357,500, a range of $157,040 to $479,750 and a median of $277 per square foot (median of these 10 closings), in homes of 728 to 1,707 square feet with a median of 38 days on market. One closed in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, at 14 Nancy Ln for $324,500 in August 2026 after 347 days on market, the same address that sold in August 2023 at $318,150. Listing-entered annual recurring fees on the 10 closings ranged from $1,320 to $1,620 (not verified; the association’s current budget and an estoppel certificate govern). One Nancy Lane home was listed on October 7, 2026, at $399,000, and none was pending.

Because a condominium lane is governed by chapter 718, a buyer gets the statutory resale package and a cancellation window under section 718.503, which we describe in the rules section below. What the declaration allows on RV and trailer use, leasing and pets is not published; request it.

Helen Lane

Helen Lane RV Condominium is recorded at Official Records Book 1789, page 556 on 5.13 acres per the county GIS, and its association is Helen Lane Association, Inc., Florida Division of Corporations document N04908. The MLS records nine closings in 60 months, and nine is fewer than the ten we require before leading with a median, so we list them all.

Closed

Price

Street address

Living area (sq ft)

Price per sq ft

Days on market

August 31, 2026

$150,000

19 Helen Ln

924

$162

4

October 25, 2023

$135,000

33 Helen Ln

1,042

$130

6

May 26, 2023

$58,140

7 Helen Ln

350

$166

37

April 26, 2023

$120,000

35 Helen Ln

840

$143

20

February 28, 2023

$98,940

38 Helen Ln

540

$183

15

February 24, 2023

$125,000

57 Oyster Bay Ln

1,296

$96

25

January 30, 2023

$110,000

19 Helen Ln

924

$119

18

November 16, 2022

$100,000

32 Helen Ln

1,359

$74

146

March 9, 2022

$120,000

11 Helen Ln

528

$227

13

The nine sales ran from $58,140 to $150,000, and two of them are the same address, 19 Helen Ln, at $110,000 in January 2023 and $150,000 in August 2026. We draw no trend from two sales of one address, and we draw none from nine. Listing-entered annual recurring fees on the nine closings ranged from $960 to $1,080 (not verified; the association’s current budget and an estoppel certificate govern). The county’s list also shows 19 Helen Ln selling at $150,000 on August 31, 2026, and 35 Helen Ln at $120,000 in April 2023.

Emily Lane

Emily Lane RV Condominium is recorded at Official Records Book 1724, page 1128 on 8.36 acres per the county GIS. Its association is Emily Lane Association, Inc., Florida Division of Corporations document 765297, which the register shows was administratively dissolved and reinstated on September 11, 2006. The MLS records eight closings in 60 months, so we list them all.

Closed

Price

Street address

Living area (sq ft)

Price per sq ft

Days on market

July 8, 2025

$398,500

70 Emily Ln

960

$415

195

April 25, 2025

$375,000

25 Emily Ln

993

$378

45

June 6, 2024

$420,000

32 Emily Ln

900

$467

93

December 12, 2022

$108,000

81 Emily Ln

960

$113

11

November 23, 2022

$200,000

61 Emily Ln

1,176

$170

0

April 11, 2022

$325,000

32 Emily Ln

960

$339

25

January 4, 2022

$310,000

30 Emily Ln

1,345

$230

101

October 12, 2021

$380,000

59 Emily Ln

1,152

$330

357

The eight sales ran from $108,000 to $420,000. Listing-entered annual recurring fees on the eight ranged from $480 to $660 (not verified; the association’s current budget and an estoppel certificate govern). On October 7, 2026, three Emily Lane homes were listed, at $429,000, $439,000 and $450,000. On October 29, 2026, the $429,000 listing was pending.

The Division of Corporations record is worth noting for a buyer only as a diligence flag: it shows a lapse and a reinstatement in 2006, and a current estoppel certificate and annual-report status settle whether the association is in good standing today.

Sportsmans Cove

Sportsmans Cove Yacht and Racquet Club Condominium is a bay-front condominium on Buttonwood Drive, recorded at Official Records Book 1707, page 4103 (and Official Records Book 2949, page 140). The county roll shows 42 parcels, 41 condominium units at 892 to 898 Buttonwood Drive plus common elements, built from 1984 to 1986, with 41 dock flags and every parcel on the bay. None of the 41 units was built in 2023 or later. The association is Sportsman’s Cove Condominium Association, Inc., Florida Division of Corporations document 768534, active, with an annual report filed on March 20, 2026.

The MLS recorded seven closings in 60 months, fewer than ten, so we list them. All are on Buttonwood Drive.

Closed

Price

Street address

Living area (sq ft)

Price per sq ft

Days on market

August 25, 2026

$400,000

894 Buttonwood Dr

1,139

$351

207

April 28, 2026

$425,000

894 Buttonwood Dr

1,134

$375

9

May 16, 2025

$445,000

894 Buttonwood Dr

1,134

$392

19

April 4, 2025

$425,000

894 Buttonwood Dr

1,134

$375

105

June 30, 2022

$405,000

898 Buttonwood Dr

624

$649

3

March 31, 2022

$355,000

898 Buttonwood Dr

624

$569

0

January 12, 2022

$434,000

894 Buttonwood Dr

1,134

$383

6

The seven closings ran from $355,000 to $445,000, and four of them are two-bedroom units of about 1,134 square feet at $400,000 to $445,000 in 2025 and 2026. Listing-entered annual recurring fees on the seven closings ranged from $4,800 to $10,200 (not verified; the association’s current budget and an estoppel certificate govern), which is the highest range of any pocket on the island and is the number a Sportsmans Cove buyer should test first. One unit was listed on October 7, 2026 at $419,900. The FEMA flood map indicates AE with a base flood elevation of 11 ft (NAVD88) at 894 Buttonwood Dr.

Old Pelican Bay

Old Pelican Bay is a set of canal-front single-family streets recorded across four plats: Plat Book 39, pages 70 and 71; Plat Book 40, pages 85 and 86; Plat Book 66, pages 62 and 63; and Plat Book 69, pages 64 and 65. The county roll shows 102 residential-class parcels, with 51 on Old Pelican Bay Drive and 39 on Siesta Drive. Eighty-two are canal-front, 15 on a creek and three on the bay, with 23 seawall flags, 33 dock flags and 38 pool flags. Fifty-five parcels are improved, built from 1988 to 2024, four of them in 2023 or later, and 30 are vacant.

We found no matching active Florida corporation for an Old Pelican Bay association on the Division of Corporations register; the name searches returned Naples and Gladiolus Drive entities that are not these streets, and we did not claim them. County records also carry “Old Pelican Bay Village” condominium entries, 14 units on Siesta Drive that are included in the counts above, and we found no association record for them. A buyer should ask the seller and title company whether any association or road agreement applies.

The Southwest Florida MLS lists one closing under the Old Pelican Bay name in 60 months, at 18160 Old Pelican Bay Dr for $1,362,000 on August 5, 2026, a 3,019-square-foot home at $451 per square foot; the sale is counted in the Siesta Isles series and not in this island series. The county’s recorded sales on Old Pelican Bay Drive since December 2022 give a fuller picture:

Recorded

Price

Street address

Heated area (sq ft)

Year built

August 5, 2026

$1,362,000

18160 Old Pelican Bay Dr

3,019

2002

March 11, 2026

$1,150,000

18141 Old Pelican Bay Dr

2,393

1989

May 23, 2025

$1,950,000

18151 Old Pelican Bay Dr

3,893

2007

July 12, 2024

$1,350,000

18211 Old Pelican Bay Dr

2,179

1988

The four county-qualified sales ran from $1,150,000 to $1,950,000, and with four sales we state no median and no trend. These are the county’s records, not the MLS series.

The working waterfront

The working waterfront is the part of the island that is not residential: shrimp-boat docks, boat yards, marinas and the commercial parcels that the county roll’s residential-class count leaves out. Gulf Star Marina at 708 Fishermans Wharf, Salty Sam’s Marina at 2500 Main Street and the San Carlos Island Marina at 1120 Main Street are the marinas the research found, and Salty Sam’s posts a public ramp fee of $35.

For a homebuyer the working waterfront is context and risk at once. It is part of what makes an island address different from a beach address, and it means diesel engines, ice plants, trucks and night work within earshot of some blocks. We did not map noise or truck routes, and a buyer should visit at the hours a boat works, which are not the hours of an open house.

The industry itself is shrinking. The Shrimp Master Plan counts 10 boats remaining of 54 before Hurricane Ian, and the county’s Maritime Park was damaged by the storm. What the county will rebuild at the park, and when, is for the county’s project page; we cite the March 2026 FAQ and do not forecast it.

The smaller pockets

Three smaller groupings appear in the MLS and are worth a line each. In each, a count under ten means we list the sales and state no median.

Oak Street, which the MLS lists under a short Oak Street name, had five closings in 60 months. Three are small homes of 200 to 754 square feet as entered, at $225,000 to $235,000 in 2024, and two are larger single-family homes, 855 Oak St at $1,050,000 in September 2023 and 782 Oak St at $320,000 in January 2022.

Closed

Price

Street address

Living area (sq ft)

Days on market

September 30, 2024

$230,000

853 Oak St

704

25

September 16, 2024

$235,000

845 Oak St

754

25

March 4, 2024

$225,000

863 Oak St

200 as entered

38

September 12, 2023

$1,050,000

855 Oak St

2,292

28

January 31, 2022

$320,000

782 Oak St

1,684

159

The Gulf Cove trailer cooperative at 19281 San Carlos Boulevard had four closings in 2022, from $100,000 to $182,000, and none since in the MLS. Because it is a cooperative, chapter 719 applies, and the same cooperative-diligence list as Port Carlos Cove applies. Listing-entered annual recurring fees on those four closings ranged from $1,600 to $4,800 (not verified; the cooperative’s current budget governs).

Tip Top Isles is included in this series because the MLS groups it with the island, but it is mainland, off San Carlos Boulevard. The MLS records eight closings there in 60 months, from $330,000 to $1,390,000, and one in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, at 17740 Broadway Ave for $330,000 in April 2026. With eight closings we state no median. Bayside Estates, also mainland, has its own seller page on this site.

Which Pages Cover the Island’s Two Gated Communities?

Two communities on San Carlos Island have their own seller pages on this site: Boardwalk Caper, a gated marine condominium community of Phases I to VI on San Carlos Boulevard, and Siesta Isles, a canal-front single-family neighborhood with two associations. Those seller pages cover selling in each community; this page covers the rest of the island.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

Boardwalk Caper

Boardwalk Caper has 303 parcels, 298 of them condominium units, built from 1981 to 1992, with a dock flag on 298 and no seawall flags, under The Boardwalk Caper Condominium Association, Inc. (document 757634) and its sister phase associations. It is the 18000 block of San Carlos Boulevard, and it is not Caper Beach Club, Sand Caper or Sun Caper, which stand on Estero Island. Owners can start with our guide to selling at Boardwalk Caper.

Siesta Isles

Siesta Isles has 126 parcels, 104 of them improved and built from 1959 to 2023, with 89 pool flags, 26 dock flags and 111 seawall flags, under Siesta Isles Association, Inc. (document 704088) and Siesta Isles Property and Homeowners Association, Inc. (document 757741). Owners can start with our guide to selling in Siesta Isles.

What Do Fees on San Carlos Island Cover, and What Do They Cost?

No island-wide association exists, so fees on San Carlos Island depend on the pocket: none at all on many platted single-family lots, listing-entered annual recurring fees of $480 to $10,200 elsewhere, and county taxes everywhere. No association budget or assessment schedule was found in a primary document, so every dollar figure below is a listing entry, not a verified charge.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

The layers an owner funds

An owner on the island can fund up to four layers. The first is the county property tax, which every parcel pays. The second is a condominium association, a cooperative corporation or a lane association where one exists. The third is a master or civic association where one exists, such as the Port Carlos Cove Civic Association. The fourth is the owner’s own insurance and upkeep, including flood and wind coverage and, on the water, a seawall and dock.

What listing agents entered

The Southwest Florida MLS carries a total-annual-recurring-fees field that listing agents fill in. We joined it to all 86 island-series closings in the 60 months to October 7, 2026. These are listing-entered annual recurring fees on 86 Southwest Florida MLS closings, which ranged from $0 to $10,200 (not verified; the association’s current budget and an estoppel certificate govern). Thirty-three of the 86 entries were $0 and 53 were above zero, from $480 to $10,200.

Pocket

Closings with a fee entry

Listing-entered annual recurring fees

San Carlos on the Gulf

18

$0 on all 18

Hidden Harbor on the Bay

2

$0 on both

Port Carlos Cove

15

$2,160 to $2,400

Nancy Lane

10

$1,320 to $1,620

Helen Lane

9

$960 to $1,080

Emily Lane

8

$480 to $660

Sportsmans Cove

7

$4,800 to $10,200

Oak Street

5

$0 on all 5

Gulf Cove trailer cooperative

4

$1,600 to $4,800

Tip Top Isles

8

$0 on all 8

A $0 entry means the listing agent entered no recurring fee, which is plausible for a platted lot with no association, and it is not proof that none exists.

What is published and what is not

We did not find a published budget, reserve schedule or assessment history for any pocket. The Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation runs a public reporting database for structural integrity reserve studies, which condominium and cooperative associations must file, and a buyer’s agent can search it for a specific association. We did not check whether any island association appears in it, and we say so rather than imply either answer.

How to get the numbers

Ask for the association’s current budget, its most recent annual financial statement, any special assessment resolutions, its reserve schedule or reserve study and an estoppel certificate. The estoppel fee is capped by statute, and we state no dollar figure for it. For a cooperative, add the bylaws, the occupancy agreement and the lender requirements.

What Are the Layered Costs of Owning on San Carlos Island?

A San Carlos Island home costs more than its price: county property tax at the 2026 applied millage of 13.2284 (13.3976 in 2025), association or cooperative charges where they exist, insurance, and closing costs in which the Lee County seller customarily pays the owner’s title policy and the deed’s documentary stamp tax. Here is the arithmetic on real island prices.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

Property tax, with the arithmetic

The 2026 applied millage in the county’s San Carlos Island taxing district is 13.2284 mills, down from 13.3976 in 2025, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser’s 2026 Taxing District Millage Book, printed October 9, 2026. The table shows the 2025 lines, in mills, which sum to the 2025 total; the 2026 book sets the lines behind the 13.2284 total.

Line on the district’s 2025 tax bill

2025 millage

Lee County general revenue

3.7623

School board (two lines, 2.2480 and 3.0710)

5.3190

Lee County All Hazards

0.0693

Unincorporated Lee County MSTU

0.8398

San Carlos Island Lighting MSTU

0.0850

South Florida Water Management District

0.2301

Fort Myers Beach fire district

2.7600

Fort Myers Beach mosquito district

0.1123

Fort Myers Beach library district

0.1612

Hyacinth Control District

0.0192

West Coast Inland Navigation District

0.0394

Total, 2025

13.3976

Applying the 2026 applied millage of 13.2284 to a price gives an illustration before exemptions and non-ad valorem charges. This is not a tax bill: a bill uses the assessed value, which differs from the price, and the homestead exemption and any cap change it.

  • On the MLS median of $400,000 for the 12 months to October 7, 2026: $400,000 x 13.2284 / 1,000 = $5,291.36.
  • On the $285,000 sale of 7 Galleon Way: $285,000 x 13.2284 / 1,000 = $3,770.09.
  • On the $1,650,000 sale of 921 Prescott St: $1,650,000 x 13.2284 / 1,000 = $21,826.86.

The Town of Fort Myers Beach district across the pass has a 2026 applied millage of 13.3108 (13.4329 in 2025), which is 0.0824 mills higher; on $400,000 that is $32.96 a year. The two bills are close, but the lines differ: the Town district includes the Town’s own levy, 1.0294 mills in 2025, and the San Carlos Island district carries the unincorporated MSTU and the lighting MSTU instead.

What the county’s solid waste line is

We did not confirm the solid-waste franchise area for San Carlos Island. The $358.45 annual single-family assessment in the county’s FY2026 schedule is for Area 1, which includes the Town of Fort Myers Beach, and we do not assume it applies on the island. Ask the county or the seller for the actual bill.

Closing costs and who pays what

In Lee County the seller customarily pays for the owner’s title policy, which is a custom, not a law, and the contract controls. The documentary stamp tax on a deed is $0.70 per $100 of consideration under section 201.02 of the Florida Statutes, customarily paid by the seller: $2,800 on $400,000, $1,995 on $285,000 and $11,550 on $1,650,000. A cash buyer and a mortgage buyer will each see further lender, survey and recording charges that depend on the contract.

Insurance and the other recurring costs

We give no premium, because premiums depend on the building, the roof, the elevation and the carrier. The routes that matter here are these. Florida’s uniform wind mitigation verification form, OIR-B1-1802, was revised effective April 1, 2026, and a current inspection can lower a wind premium. Citizens Property Insurance phases in a flood-insurance requirement, with January 1, 2027 as the date for all other personal lines policies. Under FEMA’s Risk Rating 2.0, annual flood-premium increases on an existing policy are capped at 18 percent, with exceptions. The flood-map zone, the elevation certificate and the insurer’s rating drive the answer, and a quote before an offer is cheap protection.

What Do the Declarations, Cooperative Documents and Approvals Say?

San Carlos Island’s rules live in recorded documents that differ by pocket: condominium declarations for the lanes and Sportsmans Cove, cooperative bylaws for Port Carlos Cove and the Gulf Cove cooperative, and deed restrictions on platted lots. We did not read the recorded declarations, so this section names the documents and the route to them.

Which document controls what

For a condominium, the declaration, articles, bylaws and rules control, and Florida’s section 718.503 requires the seller to deliver them before a resale closes. For a cooperative, chapter 719 applies, not chapter 718, and the bylaws, the occupancy agreement and the cooperative’s rules control. For a platted single-family lot in a homeowners association, section 720.401 requires a disclosure summary before the contract is signed, and a buyer who did not get it may cancel within three days of receiving it or before closing, whichever comes first. Where no association exists, the plat, the county’s zoning and building rules and the title commitment control.

Where to find the recorded documents

The Lee County Clerk’s Official Records search holds the book-and-page instruments listed in the origins section, and the Division of Corporations register holds each association’s annual report. The title company’s commitment lists the exceptions that apply to a specific lot, which is the most direct route.

Approvals, rebuilds and permits

Approval to buy into a cooperative or a condominium, where required, is set in the documents. County building permits apply to every rebuild, and the county’s own floodplain rules for unincorporated areas are not in the records we reviewed; a buyer of an older ground-level home should ask Lee County Development Services what applies to a substantial improvement.

Can You Rent Out a Home on San Carlos Island?

Whether a San Carlos Island home can be rented depends first on its declaration or cooperative documents and second on county and state rules. Leasing terms are not published for any pocket we researched, and we found no Lee County short-term-rental registration program, so the recorded documents decide.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

What the documents say

Not published. For each pocket, the recorded declaration or cooperative bylaws and the current rules govern, and the right question is the specific one: minimum lease term, number of leases a year, approval and fees, guest limits and whether the unit is a primary residence only.

Lee County versus the Town

The Town of Fort Myers Beach has a short-term-rental registration and code of conduct that applies on Estero Island. They do not apply on San Carlos Island, which is outside the Town. We searched for a Lee County short-term-rental registration program covering unincorporated areas and did not find one; that is a statement about what we found, not a statement that none exists, and the county’s Development Services and the Tax Collector can confirm.

What a buyer should check

If rental income is part of the plan, ask for the declaration’s leasing section before the offer, not after it. A pocket where leasing is limited can change the buyer pool, the financing and the resale price.

Are Pets Allowed on San Carlos Island?

Pet rules on San Carlos Island are set by each association, cooperative or condominium, and none was published in a source we could read. The recorded declaration and the current rules govern, so ask for the pet section in the resale package and for any breed, weight or number limits in writing.

Pocket by pocket

Pet rules are not published for San Carlos on the Gulf, Port Carlos Cove, the three lane condominiums, Sportsmans Cove, the Gulf Cove cooperative or the other pockets. For unassociated platted lots, county animal regulations apply, and we did not research them for this page.

Beaches, parks and walking

We did not confirm dog-friendly public access on the island. The Town’s beaches are on Estero Island and carry the Town’s rules.

What Are the Flood Zone, Storm Posture and Insurance Picture on San Carlos Island?

At the addresses we tested, the FEMA flood map indicates VE zones with a base flood elevation of 12 to 13 feet on San Carlos Drive and Helen Lane, AE at 11 feet on Buttonwood Drive, and AE at 12 feet at the island’s centroid. Every tested point is in Evacuation Zone A.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

Flood zone by address

We queried the FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer on October 7, 2026 at four island addresses and the island’s centroid. Every point sits on Lee County flood map panel 12071C0554G, effective November 17, 2022, and base flood elevations are in feet on the NAVD88 datum.

Address tested

FEMA zone indicated

Base flood elevation (ft, NAVD88)

Panel and effective date

831 San Carlos Dr

VE

13

12071C0554G, November 17, 2022

820 San Carlos Dr

VE

13

12071C0554G, November 17, 2022

2 Helen Ln

VE

12

12071C0554G, November 17, 2022

894 Buttonwood Dr

AE

11

12071C0554G, November 17, 2022

Island centroid

AE

12

12071C0554G, November 17, 2022

The FEMA flood map indicates these zones at these addresses. It does not say what the map shows at your lot. The geocoder places a point along the street, a zone can change between the street and the building, and the map is not a flood determination. The FEMA Flood Map Service Center and an elevation certificate for the structure give the answer for a specific home. VE zones are coastal high-hazard areas with wave action, and they carry stricter construction standards and typically higher flood premiums than AE zones.

What the coastal line and the barrier-resource map mean

Florida’s Coastal Construction Control Line, set by the Department of Environmental Protection, regulates construction near the Gulf shore. The line’s segments are near the island’s centroid, with none within 100 meters, one within 500 and 1,000 meters and two within 2,000 meters. Whether any lot is seaward of the line is a state determination we did not confirm for any address.

A third-party mirror of the Coastal Barrier Resources System map showed no unit at the island’s tested addresses. That mirror is not the official source, so confirm with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service CBRS Mapper before relying on it, because a unit would limit federal flood insurance.

Elevation certificates

An elevation certificate records a building’s floor elevation against the base flood elevation, and it can change a flood quote on a VE or AE lot. Ask the seller for an existing certificate and the date. The Town of Fort Myers Beach keeps certificates for buildings in the Town; on San Carlos Island, ask Lee County Development Services whether one is on file.

Insurance rules that bite here

Wind and flood coverage are separate. The wind route is the uniform mitigation verification inspection, form OIR-B1-1802, revised effective April 1, 2026. The flood route is the National Flood Insurance Program or a private flood policy. Citizens Property Insurance is phasing in a flood-coverage requirement, with January 1, 2027 as the date for all other personal lines policies. Under FEMA’s Risk Rating 2.0, annual premium increases on an existing policy are capped at 18 percent, with exceptions. Unincorporated Lee County is a Class 5 community in the National Flood Insurance Program’s Community Rating System, a 25 percent policy discount, and the Town of Fort Myers Beach is also Class 5 as of April 1, 2026.

The 50 percent rule and older ground-level homes

Under the federal flood-insurance rules, a building that is substantially improved or substantially damaged, meaning the cost reaches 50 percent of the structure’s pre-damage or pre-improvement value, must be brought up to current floodplain standards. The Town of Fort Myers Beach applies the rule per building and its page states a five-year look-back; the Town also requires one foot of freeboard above the base flood elevation. Those are the Town’s rules, and they apply on Estero Island. Lee County’s floodplain rules for unincorporated areas were not in the research for this page, so an owner of an older ground-level island home who plans a major repair should ask Lee County Development Services what applies before buying.

Evacuation Zone A and wind

Every tested island point returned Evacuation Zone A and storm surge zone 1 from the county’s GIS layer, with a design wind speed of 160 miles an hour and a wind-borne debris region designation. Check your own address on the county’s emergency-management evacuation lookup.

What Ian, Helene and Milton left on the record

The National Hurricane Center’s report on Hurricane Ian, which struck on September 28, 2022, gives 10 to 15 feet of storm surge above ground on Fort Myers Beach and Estero Island. The U.S. Geological Survey’s high-water marks within the area that includes Estero Island, San Carlos Island and Bayside Estates range from 10.5 to 13.8 feet NAVD88, and Florida’s Department of Environmental Protection recorded 13.23 feet NAVD88 at the pier. For Helene and Milton in 2024, the National Weather Service recorded coastal water levels in Lee County 2 to 5 feet and 3 to 6 feet above mean higher high water, respectively; we have no island-specific high-water marks for either storm.

The county roll shows 23 island parcels with a year built of 2023 or later, a record of rebuilding and new construction. Whether any particular older home was repaired, elevated or rebuilt is a permit question, and a buyer should ask for the permit history.

Do Milestone Inspection and SIRS Rules Apply on San Carlos Island?

They apply to condominium and cooperative buildings of three or more habitable stories. On San Carlos Island that means Sportsmans Cove and Boardwalk Caper if any building reaches three stories, not the single-family lots or the mobile-home parcels. We compute deadlines from the roll’s year built and never state any building’s status.

What the statutes say

Section 553.899 of the Florida Statutes requires a milestone inspection for condominium and cooperative buildings three habitable stories or more in height. The first inspection is due by December 31 of the year the building reaches 30 years of age, based on its certificate of occupancy, then every ten years. A building that reached 30 before July 1, 2022 had to complete its first inspection by December 31, 2024; one reaching 30 between July 1, 2022 and December 31, 2024 had until December 31, 2025. A local enforcement agency may require the inspection at 25 years where local circumstances, including proximity to salt water, justify it; we did not confirm that Lee County adopted that trigger.

Section 718.112(2)(g) requires a structural integrity reserve study for residential condominium buildings of three or more stories. Associations that existed on July 1, 2022 and are controlled by unit owners had to complete it by December 31, 2025, and the statute says no later than December 31, 2026 for an association completing it together with a milestone inspection. The Department of Business and Professional Regulation publishes a public reporting database of submitted studies.

What that means for a Sportsmans Cove buyer

The 41 units at Sportsmans Cove were built from 1984 to 1986, which means a building of three or more stories would have reached 30 years between 2014 and 2016 and fallen in the earlier group, due by December 31, 2024. The MLS lists the building design as low rise, one to three stories, so we cannot tell from the record whether the statute applies. Stories and status are for the association to answer.

What a buyer should request instead

Ask for the milestone inspection summary or a written statement that none applies, the most recent structural integrity reserve study or a statement that none has been done, the current reserve schedule and any special assessment resolutions. Section 718.503 gives a condominium resale buyer 7 days, excluding weekends and legal holidays, to cancel after receiving the required documents, which include the milestone inspection summary and the reserve study where they apply.

Which Schools Serve San Carlos Island?

San Carlos Island addresses sit in Lee County’s elementary zone T, middle zone MM and high school South Zone 4 at the address we tested, 708 Fishermans Wharf. Fort Myers Beach Elementary, the zone’s only school, is closed. Confirm any address with the district, because zones are set by address and can change.

The zoned schools

Elementary zone T lists Fort Myers Beach Elementary only. Middle zone MM lists Cypress Lake Middle and Lexington Middle. The South Zone 4 label is what the county’s GIS returns for the island; the district’s printed plan lists South Zone sub-zones 1 to 3 only, whose high schools include Cypress Lake High, Dunbar High, Fort Myers High, South Fort Myers High, Bonita Springs High and Estero High. Ask the district which of these a specific address is assigned to.

The closed elementary school

Fort Myers Beach Elementary is closed. The School Board voted on May 12, 2026 to transfer the building to the Town of Fort Myers Beach for use as a charter school within three years. Former students were bused to Heights Elementary in Fort Myers, according to WGCU in October 2025.

Choice and buses

Students in any zone may request barrier-island schools such as The Sanibel School, Pine Island School or Estero Island/Fort Myers Beach School, and the district does not provide transportation for them, according to its 2026 to 2027 plan. Confirm by address with the district before making an offer that depends on a school.

What Permits, Zoning and Coastal Rules Apply on San Carlos Island?

Lee County, not the Town, issues permits and applies zoning on San Carlos Island, and the county roll places all 1,218 residential-class parcels in the Urban Community zoning district. The Town’s land development code, sea turtle lighting rules and Estero Island freeboard standards do not apply on the island. The county’s own code and the title commitment do.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

Zoning and land use

The roll shows Urban Community zoning on every one of the 1,218 residential-class parcels. We did not confirm the permitted uses, setbacks or height limits that go with that zoning for any lot, and we did not confirm lot sizes. Lee County’s planning staff can answer by address.

Seawalls, docks and canals

The roll flags 476 seawalls and 607 docks. A seawall or dock repair, replacement or extension needs a permit, and depending on the work it can involve county, state and federal review. We did not research the permitting steps for this page. A buyer on a canal lot should ask for the seawall’s age and last permit and for the dock’s permit before closing.

Sea turtle lighting and the beach

Sea turtle lighting rules protect nesting beaches, and the Town of Fort Myers Beach enforces them on Estero Island. We did not find a rule that applies to the island’s bay and canal parcels and we state none.

Planning applications on the record

The comprehensive plan amendment CPA2018-00003 shows “Closed Due to Inactivity” on the county’s results site, and Ordinance 20-07 changed one parcel in the Bay Harbour area to Central Urban in 2020. Neither changes the zoning of a house on the island today, but both show that the island’s future land use has been argued over for years.

Can You Keep a Boat on San Carlos Island, and How Do You Reach the Water?

Many island homes have a dock: the county roll flags 607 boat docks, with 794 parcels on a canal, 150 on the bay and 15 on a creek. Reaching open water means canals, Matanzas Pass and then the Gulf or Estero Bay, and bridge clearances, depths and speed zones were not confirmed for this page.

Marinas and ramps

Salty Sam’s Marina, Gulf Star Marina and San Carlos Island Marina are the marinas the research found, and Salty Sam’s posts a public ramp fee of $35. Lee County approved the purchase of a lot for a public boat ramp on the island in September 2025.

The Matanzas Pass Bridge

The Matanzas Pass Bridge carries San Carlos Boulevard over the pass to Estero Island. Secondary sources describe it as a fixed span about 65 feet above the water. We did not confirm the clearance from a primary source, and a boat owner whose vessel has a tall tower or mast should confirm it before buying. The state’s San Carlos Boulevard project, which includes work on the bridge for a shared-use path, was scheduled to finish in spring 2026, and we did not confirm its completion.

What we did not confirm

Water depth behind a given lot, canal widths, speed zones, manatee zones and routes to open water were not confirmed. The Estero Bay Aquatic Preserve and Matanzas Pass Preserve are public resources nearby, and a boat buyer should read the county’s preserve pages for rules that apply on the water.

What Is Daily Life Like on San Carlos Island: Roads, Bridges, Services and Getting Around?

Daily life on San Carlos Island is built on one road, San Carlos Boulevard, which runs to the mainland and over the Matanzas Pass Bridge to Estero Island. Fort Myers Beach Fire Station 32 is on the boulevard, and the library and the nearest hospital are minutes away by car.

Roads and bridges

San Carlos Boulevard, state road 865, carries the island’s traffic and links the mainland to both San Carlos Island and Estero Island. A 2016 regional planning document noted congestion on southbound San Carlos Boulevard approaching the Matanzas Pass Bridge during peak season, and we have no current count. On Estero Island, the new Big Carlos Pass Bridge, a fixed span with 60 feet of clearance, opened to traffic on November 14, 2025.

Services

Fort Myers Beach Fire Station 32 is at 17891 San Carlos Boulevard, one of three stations of the Fort Myers Beach fire district, whose taxing district the island’s parcels sit in. The district’s Station 31 at 2545 Estero Boulevard opened April 2, 2026. Lee Health’s urgent-care locator lists no site on San Carlos Island or Estero Island. The Fort Myers Beach Public Library is at 2755 Estero Boulevard.

Distances, as estimates

These are road estimates from Fire Station 32 at 17891 San Carlos Boulevard, using free-flow speeds without traffic. We did not route from inside the island, so treat the figures as the corridor’s, not any one house’s.

Destination

Road miles

Minutes

Southwest Florida International Airport

15.4

27

Downtown Fort Myers

12.7

24

Sanibel

9.5

18

HealthPark Medical Center

3.7

8

Fort Myers Beach Public Library

3.2

8

Bonita Springs

21.3

38

Estero, Coconut Point

16.7

29

Naples

34.4

57

Transit and parking

LeeTran’s Route 490 beach trolley runs from the Beach Park and Ride at 11101 Summerlin Square Drive to Crescent Beach and Times Square, with a $0.75 fare. Because Bowditch Point Park and Lynn Hall Memorial Park lots are closed during restoration, Lee County steers beachgoers to that park-and-ride lot and the trolley.

San Carlos Island vs Estero Island: How Do They Compare?

San Carlos Island offers a working-waterfront setting, county rather than Town rules and prices that start far below the beach: the MLS median for the 12 months to October 7, 2026 is $400,000 here against $550,000 on Estero Island. Estero Island offers the Gulf beach, the Town’s services and its condominium towers.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

The rival is Estero Island, the barrier island across Matanzas Pass that the Town of Fort Myers Beach governs. Our Fort Myers Beach guide covers the Town in full. The table sets the two islands side by side on the same yardsticks, and each row says which record it comes from; MLS rows never mix with county rows.

Side by side, the decision table

Yardstick

San Carlos Island

Estero Island (the Town of Fort Myers Beach)

Jurisdiction

Unincorporated Lee County

Town of Fort Myers Beach, incorporated December 31, 1995

2026 applied millage, taxing district (2025 in brackets)

13.2284 (13.3976)

13.3108 (13.4329)

Short-term rentals

No Lee County registration program found; the declaration governs

Town registration and code of conduct

Flood map at tested addresses

AE and VE, base flood elevation 11 to 13 ft

AE and VE across the tested points, 10 to 14 ft at every Fort Myers Beach address we tested, with the Town’s one-foot freeboard

Evacuation zone, school zones

A; T, MM, South Zone 4

A; T, MM, South Zone 4

MLS, 12 months to October 7, 2026

11 closings, median $400,000, $351 per sq ft, 64 days, 94.7% of final list

309 closings, median $550,000, $481 per sq ft, 97 days, 93.8% of final list

MLS, 60 months

86 closings, median $372,500, $334 per sq ft

1,601 closings, median $675,000, $557 per sq ft

County roll, residential-class parcels

1,218 (condominium 357, single-family 228, cooperative 210, mobile or manufactured 133)

9,031 (condominium 5,637, single-family 1,756)

County-qualified sales, 12 months

46, median $374,000

353, median $590,000

County median just value

$238,356

$444,135

Built 2023 or later (county year built)

23 parcels

148 parcels

Gulf beach

None on the island; bay and canal

Gulf-front

The MLS rows for San Carlos Island are the island-series figures in the market snapshot. The Estero Island figures are the MLS’s five Estero Island areas combined, and the county rows come from the roll file of October 4, 2026. The sale-to-final-list ratio for the 12 months to October 7, 2026 on Estero Island is lower than on San Carlos Island, 93.8% against 94.7%, but with 11 island closings we do not call that a difference.

What the numbers say, and what they do not

The medians are far apart because the markets are different. The Town side is dominated by condominiums, 5,637 of its 9,031 parcels, and by Gulf-front and Gulf-view property. The island side has hundreds of small cooperative, manufactured-home and RV-lot parcels that sell for a fraction of that. Across the whole ZIP code, 33931 condominium closings had a median of $425,000 in the 12 months to October 7, 2026 and single-family closings $1,000,000, where the county use code could be joined; 98 of 2,064 sixty-month closings did not match an address and are left out of that split. A San Carlos Island buyer can sit at either end of that range depending on the pocket.

Where San Carlos Island stands out

San Carlos Island stands out on price, with entry prices well below the beach island’s, on docks and boat access, on county rules in place of Town rules, and on its quiet canal streets and its cooperative and condominium lanes with low entry prices. The trade is that a few pockets have no published documents, which means doing the diligence listed on this page.

Where Estero Island stands out

Estero Island stands out for the Gulf beach, a Town with its own planning and services, condominium amenity packages, and rental registration and Town rules written in one code. It is also the island where the post-Ian rebuilding count is largest: 148 parcels with a year built of 2023 or later, against 23 on San Carlos Island.

The other options in the area

On the mainland, Bayside Estates is the lower-priced neighbor off San Carlos Boulevard, with a median of $362,500 in the 12 months to October 7, 2026 in the comparison table below; owners there can start with our guide to selling in Bayside Estates. On the bay side of Estero Island, the Bay Beach community guide covers that side, and Pink Shell Beach Resort covers the resort end. For a condominium with a Gulf-view amenity package, Estero Beach and Tennis Club is one option in the Town; owners there can start with our guide to selling at Estero Beach and Tennis Club.

Pocket first, island second

San Carlos Island offers a lower entry price, a working-waterfront setting and county rules. Estero Island offers the beach itself and the Town’s rules, at higher prices. The pocket matters before the island, because a Sportsmans Cove condominium and a San Carlos Drive house are not the same purchase, and neither is a Town beach condominium. Our Fort Myers Beach service pages weigh the two with a local team.

How Does San Carlos Island Compare With Other Fort Myers Beach Communities?

San Carlos Island’s MLS median of $400,000 for the 12 months to October 7, 2026 sits between Boardwalk Caper’s $220,000 and Siesta Isles’ $1,275,000, below Bay Beach’s $425,000 and above Bayside Estates’ $362,500. These are rows from our Fort Myers Beach comparison table, each with its own window, copied as published.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

Side by side, on the series’ yardsticks

Each row is copied from the comparison table with its window. MLS is the Southwest Florida MLS (Matrix) pulled October 7, 2026, and county is the Lee County Property Appraiser’s qualified sales (roll file October 4, 2026). The two series are never mixed.

Node

Kind

Residential parcels

Year built

MLS closings 12 mo

MLS closings 60 mo

MLS publish window

MLS median $/sq ft (same window)

Active+pending 2026-10-07

County-qualified (publish window)

San Carlos Island

community

1218

1940 to 2024

11

86

12 mo: n 11, median $400,000, range $150,000 to $2,380,000

351.0

14

12 mo: n 46, median $374,000

Boardwalk Caper

condo

303

1981 to 1992

18

48

12 mo: n 18, median $220,000, range $172,500 to $390,000

203.0

6

12 mo: n 20, median $220,000

Siesta Isles

neighborhood

126

1959 to 2023

11

28

12 mo: n 11, median $1,275,000, range $900,000 to $2,850,000

494.0

0

12 mo: n 11, median $1,275,000

Bay Beach

community

1755

1976 to 2023

61

334

12 mo: n 61, median $425,000, range $260,000 to $2,200,000

359.0

53

12 mo: n 53, median $410,000

Pink Shell

community

229

1976 to 2007

14

70

12 mo: n 14, median $325,000, range $175,000 to $890,000

495.0

11

12 mo: n 16, median $412,500

Bayside Estates

neighborhood

598

1968 to 2024

28

211

12 mo: n 28, median $362,500, range $138,000 to $690,000

235.0

23

12 mo: n 30, median $364,750

Estero Beach and Tennis Club

condo

297

1979 to 1982

17

83

12 mo: n 17, median $405,000, range $305,000 to $475,000

783.0

17

12 mo: n 20, median $407,500

Reading the table

Four things stand out. The island’s two gated communities sit at opposite ends: Boardwalk Caper at a $220,000 median and $203 per square foot, Siesta Isles at $1,275,000 and $494. San Carlos Island’s own price per square foot, $351, is below the two Bay Beach and Pink Shell yardsticks of $359 and $495. Estero Beach and Tennis Club shows the highest recorded price per square foot in the table, $783 across 17 closings, but the county’s heated-area field for that building repeats a single value, so we do not lean on it. And Bayside Estates, the mainland neighbor, has the second-lowest price per square foot at $235, after Boardwalk Caper’s $203.

The island as a whole

San Carlos Island has the second-most parcels of the communities in this table, 1,218 after Bay Beach’s 1,755, and the broadest range of forms of ownership of any of them. That breadth is the reason the single median is a poor guide and the pocket sections above are the better one.

What Are the Honest Pros and Cons of Owning on San Carlos Island?

San Carlos Island’s strengths are low entry prices in several pockets, canal and dock access, county rules and a working-harbor character no other Fort Myers Beach area has. Its weaknesses are storm exposure, thin public documents for several pockets, a shrinking waterfront industry and an MLS record with few sales per pocket. Both lists follow.

What owners and buyers tend to like

  • Entry prices that start well below the beach islands: Helen Lane sales of $58,140 to $150,000, and a Port Carlos Cove median of $238,000 across 15 closings in 60 months.
  • Docks and canals: the county flags 607 docks.
  • County rules, a lower millage line than the Town district, and a lighting district.
  • A harbor with marinas, a public ramp fee of $35 at Salty Sam’s and a county purchase of a lot for a public ramp.
  • A broad choice of forms of ownership, from cooperative to condominium to single-family.

What owners and buyers should weigh

  • Flood and surge exposure: VE and AE zones at the addresses tested, Evacuation Zone A and 10 to 15 feet of Ian surge reported on the Fort Myers Beach islands.
  • Thin sales per pocket, so one sale moves a pocket’s story.
  • Cooperative and RV-lot ownership forms, with different lenders and rules.
  • Unpublished budgets and documents for most pockets.
  • A working waterfront whose industry has lost most of its fleet since Ian.
  • No Gulf beach on the island itself.

How We Researched San Carlos Island, and What We Tracked First-Hand

We pulled every Southwest Florida MLS closing on San Carlos Island for the 60 months to October 7, 2026, tracked every county-qualified sale, queried the FEMA flood layer at island addresses and read the Florida Division of Corporations filings for the associations named here. This page rests on those four first-hand pulls, not on marketing copy.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

What we did, step by step

  • We tracked every one of the 86 San Carlos Island closings in the Southwest Florida MLS in the 60 months to October 7, 2026, and the 14 active listings on that day, we re-checked the listings on October 29, 2026, and we computed every median, range and price per square foot ourselves.
  • We tracked every county-qualified sale in the Lee County Property Appraiser’s roll file of October 4, 2026, 148 in 60 months, and read the 120 address-level records for the pocket sections.
  • We queried the FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer on October 7, 2026 at four island addresses and the island’s centroid, and the county’s evacuation-zone layer at the same points.
  • We read the Florida Division of Corporations records for the associations named on this page, and the county’s property roll for parcel counts, years built and flags.
  • We checked every link in the sources list and dropped the ones that did not open.

What we found that surprised us

Tip Top Isles, which is mainland, sits inside the MLS’s island series. The Emily Lane association was administratively dissolved and reinstated in 2006. Sportsmans Cove carries by far the highest listing-entered fee range on the island, $4,800 to $10,200. 789 San Carlos Dr sold three times in under three years. And the county’s count of qualified sales over 12 months in the October 4, 2026 roll file, 46, is four times the MLS count for the 12 months to October 7, 2026, 11, because the two series draw the island’s line in different places.

What we could not get

We could not read the recorded declarations, the associations’ budgets, the cooperative bylaws or the engineering reports. We did not confirm the year the island was platted, the zoning district of any parcel beyond the county’s code, lot sizes, mandatory assessments, age restrictions or bridge clearances. The section titled What We Could Not Verify lists them.

Thinking of Selling Your San Carlos Island Home? List With the #1 Team in Southwest Florida Since 2012

McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and part of the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, price a San Carlos Island home against the closings in its own pocket, because a Helen Lane sale and a San Carlos Drive sale are two different markets under one island name.

If you’re searching for a San Carlos Island listing agent, or thinking, ‘I need someone to sell my San Carlos Island home…’ you are selling into an island where the form of ownership, the pocket and the flood zone decide the buyer pool. Our guide to selling a home on San Carlos Island walks through the steps, and our Fort Myers Beach seller page covers the wider market.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026, with listings re-checked October 29, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

Selling credentials

As the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate, and Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar account for over $900 million in personal sales inside that number. Our credentials as listing agents:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Recent San Carlos Island sold-listing stats

In the 12 months to October 7, 2026 San Carlos Island had 11 resales in the Southwest Florida MLS, pulled October 7, 2026, with total volume of $7,774,500, a median of 64 days on market (a mean of 92.0) and a median sale-to-final-list ratio of 94.7%. Over 60 months the MLS records 86 closings. Sold-listing stats on an island this varied are thin by pocket, so every comparable matters, and we select comparables from your pocket first.

Why selling on San Carlos Island is different

  • Your pocket sets the price. The closings of the 12 months to October 7, 2026 ran from $150,000 to $2,380,000, and the pockets rarely overlap.
  • Cooperative and condominium homes need a resale package. Condominium sellers owe the section 718.503 documents, and cooperative sellers owe the cooperative’s documents under chapter 719, before closing.
  • Buyers ask about flood and wind first. Have the elevation certificate, wind mitigation form and roof age ready.
  • Hurricane Ian history matters. Repairs, permits and elevation work are part of the disclosure conversation.
  • Docks and seawalls are priced on condition. A buyer on a canal will ask for the permit and age of the seawall.
  • Days on market are long in some pockets. The median for the 12 months to October 7, 2026 was 64 days, and two Sportsmans Cove and Nancy Lane sales took 207 and 347.

What Is Your San Carlos Island Home Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds

Start with a free valuation at mcgreevyandcomisar.com/home-valuation, or use the San Carlos Island home valuation page and the wider Fort Myers Beach home valuation page. We price from the comparable closings in your pocket and tell you how thin the evidence is.

Talk to Jesse direct

  1. 898-6072, text or call. Jesse McGreevy takes seller calls and will tell you what the closings above imply for your home.

San Carlos Island seller mini-FAQ

How much is my San Carlos Island home worth?

It depends on your pocket: the MLS median for the 12 months to October 7, 2026 is $400,000, but those 12 months span $150,000 to $2,380,000. We price from closings in your own pocket and show you the sales we used.

Which association or cooperative governs my home, and what do I owe it when I sell?

It depends on the pocket: a condominium association for the lanes and Sportsmans Cove, a cooperative corporation for Port Carlos Cove and the Gulf Cove cooperative, and in many platted lots none. Your title commitment names the one that binds your lot.

Which documents do I give a San Carlos Island buyer?

A condominium seller delivers the declaration, articles, bylaws, rules, budget, financial statement and FAQ document under section 718.503, and a cooperative seller delivers the cooperative’s equivalents. A homeowners association seller delivers the section 720.401 disclosure summary before the contract is signed.

Does my flood zone change my sale price?

Buyers price it in through insurance: the FEMA flood map indicates VE and AE zones at the addresses we tested, so a current elevation certificate and an insurance quote are strong selling tools.

Does my dock or seawall change the price?

On the water, yes. The county flags 607 docks and 476 seawalls on the island, and buyers on canals ask for age, condition and permits before they price the lot.

How do I start?

Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 or request a free valuation, and we will pull the closings for your pocket and the active competition the same day.

Your Local Real Estate Experts

Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar of McGreevy and Comisar, part of Domain Realty Group, are Southwest Florida real estate experts who list and sell San Carlos Island homes and the rest of the Fort Myers Beach area. Jesse has held his Florida real estate license since November 2004, and Marc since September 2003, according to the state’s licensing database.

Honors and recognition

Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 heads the list of honors below.

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

What our clients say

Jesse McGreevy is a top-reviewed Fort Myers Beach listing agent and Marc Comisar is a top-reviewed Southwest Florida realtor; every review below is copied from our Google Business Profile. The words are the reviewers’ own, and they describe working with our team across Southwest Florida.

Derek Dixon, on selling a condo

★★★★★ “Marc Comisar did an excellent job working with a very difficult client (me) selling our condo in a tough condo market. He went above and beyond.” Verified Google review

Eric Acra, on selling from out of the area

★★★★★ “Not living in the area, Jesse made life easy for me when we decided to sell our condo. His attention to detail, patience, understanding, and tenacity in dealing with all the moving parts was truly impressive.” Verified Google review

Contact Jesse and Marc

  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 ·
  • Marc Comisar: (239) 287-5873
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

About our team

Learn how we work on our McGreevy and Comisar about page. McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.

Frequently Asked Questions, Buyer Edition

These are the questions San Carlos Island buyers ask most, rewritten as plain questions, with answers drawn from the records cited on this page. Where a fact is not published, we say so and name the document that settles it. Every figure carries the October 7, 2026 pull date.

What does it cost to buy on San Carlos Island?

The 11 Southwest Florida MLS closings in the 12 months to October 7, 2026 ran from $150,000 to $2,380,000 with a median of $400,000. On October 7, 2026, 14 homes were listed, from $249,000 to $7,895,000. A re-check on October 29, 2026 found 15 active listings and one pending. The county’s qualified sales over 12 months in the October 4, 2026 roll file had a median of $374,000 on all 1,218 parcels.

Is San Carlos Island inside the Town of Fort Myers Beach?

No. The county roll places all 1,218 residential-class parcels in unincorporated Lee County and the island’s own taxing district. The Town governs Estero Island, across Matanzas Pass. Lee County, not the Town, issues permits and applies zoning on San Carlos Island.

How do you get to San Carlos Island?

San Carlos Boulevard, state road 865, links the mainland to San Carlos Island and, over the Matanzas Pass Bridge, to Estero Island. Our distance estimates from Fire Station 32 at 17891 San Carlos Boulevard are 15.4 miles and about 27 minutes to the airport and 3.2 miles and about 8 minutes to the Fort Myers Beach library.

What are the association fees on San Carlos Island?

No budget was published for any pocket. Listing-entered annual recurring fees on 86 Southwest Florida MLS closings ranged from $0 to $10,200 (not verified; the association’s current budget and an estoppel certificate govern). Sportsmans Cove showed the highest range, $4,800 to $10,200, and most platted single-family lots showed $0.

Are rentals allowed on San Carlos Island?

Leasing terms are not published for any pocket, so the recorded declaration or cooperative documents and the current rules govern. We found no Lee County short-term-rental registration program. The Town’s registration applies on Estero Island, not here. Ask for the leasing section before you make an offer.

Are pets allowed on San Carlos Island?

Pet rules are set by each association or cooperative and were not published in any source we could read. Ask for the pet section of the declaration and the current rules, in writing, including any limits on number, weight or breed, before you make an offer.

What flood zone is San Carlos Island in?

The FEMA flood map indicates VE zones with a base flood elevation of 12 to 13 feet at the San Carlos Drive and Helen Lane addresses we tested, and AE at 11 feet at 894 Buttonwood Dr. The map is not a flood determination for your lot; ask for an elevation certificate.

How did San Carlos Island fare in Hurricane Ian?

The National Hurricane Center reports 10 to 15 feet of surge above ground on Fort Myers Beach and Estero Island, and U.S. Geological Survey high-water marks nearby range from 10.5 to 13.8 feet NAVD88. The roll shows 23 island parcels with a year built of 2023 or later, a record of rebuilding.

What does the FEMA 50 percent rule mean for an older home here?

If repairs or improvements reach 50 percent of a building’s pre-damage or pre-improvement value, the building must meet current floodplain standards. The Town applies the rule per building; Lee County’s rules for unincorporated areas were not in our research, so ask Lee County Development Services before buying an older ground-level home.

Is Port Carlos Cove a condominium or a cooperative?

The county use code and the MLS call it a cooperative, which falls under chapter 719 of the Florida Statutes, but the county GIS calls it a condominium RV park. We did not read the recorded declaration, so confirm the form from the recorded documents before relying on either description.

Can I get a mortgage on a cooperative or RV-lot home?

We did not research lender programs, and rules vary by lender and by property. Cooperative shares and RV-lot condominium units are financed differently from a deeded house, so ask a lender about your specific home before you make an offer and before your inspection period ends.

Does San Carlos Island have a special assessment or capital project coming?

We found no published special assessment or capital project for any pocket, which is not the same as none existing. Ask each association for its budget, reserve schedule or study, meeting minutes and any assessment resolutions, and read them before you are bound to close.

What are the property taxes on San Carlos Island?

The 2026 applied millage in the island’s taxing district is 13.2284 (13.3976 in 2025), according to the Lee County Property Appraiser’s 2026 millage book printed October 9, 2026, so $400,000 x 13.2284 / 1,000 = $5,291.36 before exemptions and non-ad valorem charges. Your bill uses the assessed value, not the price, and resets when ownership changes.

Who customarily pays for the owner’s title policy in Lee County?

By custom, the seller pays for the owner’s title policy in Lee County, and the contract controls. The documentary stamp tax on the deed, $0.70 per $100 under section 201.02, is also customarily the seller’s. Your own lender, survey and recording costs depend on the contract.

Which public school zone serves San Carlos Island?

At the address we tested, 708 Fishermans Wharf, the zones are elementary T, middle MM and high school South Zone 4. Fort Myers Beach Elementary, the only school in zone T, is closed. Confirm the zone for your address with Lee County schools.

Is there a beach on San Carlos Island?

No Gulf beach exists on the island; its shoreline is canal, bay and harbor. Estero Island’s beaches are across Matanzas Pass by road, and Bowditch Point Park and Lynn Hall Memorial Park are closed for restoration, so the county steers visitors to the Beach Park and Ride and the trolley.

How many San Carlos Island homes were listed in October 2026, and how fast did they sell?

On October 7, 2026 the MLS showed 14 active listings and none pending. A re-check on October 29, 2026 found 15 active listings and one pending. In the 12 months to October 7, 2026, the 11 closings had a median of 64 days on market, from 0 to 347, and sold at a median of 94.7% of their final list price.

What is the price per square foot on San Carlos Island?

Across the 11 closings in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, price per square foot ran from $162 to $1,305 with a median of $351. Over 60 months, the median of 86 closings was $334. The spread is wide because the pockets differ so much; compare within your pocket.

How does San Carlos Island compare with Estero Island on price?

The MLS median for the 12 months to October 7, 2026 is $400,000 here against $550,000 on Estero Island, and the 60-month medians are $372,500 against $675,000. Estero Island has the Gulf beach and the Town’s rules; San Carlos Island has lower entry prices and county rules.

Can I keep a boat at my San Carlos Island home?

Many homes have docks: the county flags 607 on the island, and 794 parcels are on a canal. Water depth, canal width and open-water routes were not confirmed, and the Matanzas Pass Bridge is described as a fixed span of about 65 feet, so check clearance for a tall boat.

Is there a public boat ramp on San Carlos Island?

Salty Sam’s Marina posts a public ramp fee of $35. Lee County approved buying a lot on the island for a public ramp in September 2025, according to WINK News. We did not confirm when a county ramp will open.

What happened to the shrimp fleet?

The Southwest Florida Regional Planning Council’s May 2024 Shrimp Master Plan counts 54 shrimp boats before Hurricane Ian and 10 remaining. Gulfshore Business reported on September 29, 2026 that Erickson and Jensen is the last commercial shrimping operation in Lee County.

Which agent knows San Carlos Island best for buyers?

Marc Comisar of McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, takes buyer calls at (239) 287-5873. Our team reads every closing in a pocket before you make an offer, and our Fort Myers Beach buyer guide lists what to ask for.

How can a buyer follow San Carlos Island listings by pocket?

Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 to set up searches by pocket. The MLS showed 14 active listings on October 7, 2026, and a re-check on October 29, 2026 found 15 active listings and one pending.

Frequently Asked Questions, Seller Edition

These are the questions San Carlos Island sellers ask most, answered from the closings, county records and statutes cited on this page. Where a fact depends on your pocket, your documents or the contract, we say so and tell you what to ask for. Jesse takes seller calls at (239) 898-6072.

What is a realistic price range for selling a house on San Carlos Island?

It depends on the pocket. In the 12 months to October 7, 2026 the 11 MLS closings ran from $150,000 for a Helen Lane unit to $2,380,000 for a San Carlos Drive house, with a median of $400,000. Price from the closings in your own pocket, not the island median.

When is the best time of year to sell on San Carlos Island?

We did not find a supportable seasonal pattern: 11 closings in 12 months are too few to read by month. The better timing questions are your insurance renewal, your hurricane-season exposure and whether your documents are ready, so list when the home and the paperwork are ready.

How long does it take to sell a home on San Carlos Island?

The median for the 12 months to October 7, 2026 was 64 days on market, from 0 to 347, and the 60-month median was 29.5 days. Pricing against recent closings in your pocket and having the documents ready are what shorten the time.

Should I order an elevation certificate before listing?

Usually yes. The FEMA flood map indicates VE and AE zones at the island addresses we tested, so buyers will ask for the zone and the elevation first. An existing certificate lets their insurer quote quickly and can support your price.

How do wind mitigation and roof age affect insurability and price?

Buyers’ insurance quotes depend on roof age and wind features, and Florida’s uniform wind mitigation form, OIR-B1-1802, was revised effective April 1, 2026. A current inspection and a documented roof date shorten the buyer’s insurance step and reduce renegotiation after the inspection.

What do buyers ask about flood insurance on my home?

They ask for the flood zone, the elevation certificate, the current premium and the claim history. Citizens Property Insurance is phasing in a flood requirement, with January 1, 2027 for all other personal lines. Have your declarations pages ready to hand over.

How do Hurricane Ian repairs and permits affect my disclosures?

Florida requires a seller flood disclosure under section 689.302 for contracts from October 1, 2024. Beyond the statute, buyers and insurers ask for repair records, permits and any elevation work, so collect them before you list. We are not lawyers; ask your attorney what your disclosure must say.

What closing costs does a Lee County seller pay?

By custom the seller pays the owner’s title policy and the documentary stamp tax on the deed, $0.70 per $100, plus any agreed concessions, prorations and, for association properties, the estoppel fee. On a $400,000 sale the deed tax is $2,800. The contract controls.

Who pays for title insurance when I sell here?

In Lee County the seller customarily pays for the owner’s title policy. That is a custom, not a law, and your contract can say otherwise. Ask your title company for the commitment early so any lien or recorded restriction surfaces before you accept an offer.

What documentary stamp tax do I owe as a Florida seller?

Section 201.02 sets the tax on a deed at $0.70 per $100 of consideration, including any mortgage the buyer assumes, and the seller customarily pays it. That is $2,800 on $400,000, $1,995 on $285,000 and $11,550 on $1,650,000.

What capital gains tax applies if I sell?

We did not research federal tax treatment, and it depends on your basis, your use of the home and your situation. Ask a tax adviser before you list, and ask for estimated net proceeds from us after you decide on a price.

How should I price a waterfront home with a dock?

Price from closings with comparable water, dock and condition in your pocket, then adjust for the seawall, the dock permit and the flood zone. With 11 closings island-wide in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, we often use the 60-month record and the county’s sale records to find comparable properties.

Should I renovate before selling or sell as is?

In pockets with prices in the low hundreds of thousands, buyers often price condition heavily, so renovation rarely returns its cost. We tell you the likely return on each fix against recent closings in your pocket and leave the choice to you.

How should I stage, photograph and shoot drone video of my home?

Waterfront homes sell on the view and the water access, so we use professional photography, drone video of the canal and dock, and twilight shots where the view supports them. Staging is a separate decision we make after we see the home.

Should I list on the Southwest Florida MLS?

Yes for most sellers, because the MLS is where buyers’ agents search. Our listing syndicates your home to the major portals, and we pair it with direct outreach to our buyer database. A private sale is an option we can discuss if discretion matters.

Does a dock slip or cooperative share transfer when I sell?

It depends on the documents. A cooperative sale transfers an interest in the corporation and the right to occupy under its bylaws, and a boat slip may be separately owned, as in the Boardwalk Caper boating association. Read the documents to see what transfers and what needs approval.

Do rental or association restrictions shrink my buyer pool?

They can. A pocket that restricts leasing, pets or RV use narrows the buyers who can use the home as they intend, and a cooperative narrows the lenders. Knowing the restrictions before you list lets us market to the right buyers.

What does Florida law require me to disclose when I sell?

You must disclose known material defects that affect value and are not readily observable, the flood disclosure under section 689.302, and the association documents under section 718.503 for condominiums or 720.401 for homeowners associations. Cooperatives fall under chapter 719. Ask your attorney for the specifics.

Who is the best listing agent for San Carlos Island?

McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, lead Domain Realty Group, ranked a RealTrends Verified 2026 Large Team. Judge any agent by their pricing method: ask them to price your home from the closings in your own pocket and show the sales.

What does it cost to hire a listing agent?

Commission is negotiable and set in your listing agreement, so we give no flat figure. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 for a written proposal that shows the commission, the marketing plan and the estimated net proceeds on your home.

How many homes sold on San Carlos Island in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, and at what prices?

The MLS shows 11 closings in the 12 months to October 7, 2026: $150,000, $225,000, $285,000, $324,500, $330,000, $400,000, $425,000, $440,000, $1,165,000, $1,650,000 and $2,380,000. All 11 are in the closings table on this page. The October 29, 2026 re-check found no closing recorded after October 7.

Should I sell now or wait?

We do not forecast prices. The record for the 12 months to October 7, 2026 gives a median of 64 days on market and 94.7% of final list, and the October 29, 2026 re-check found 15 active listings. Decide on your own timeline, your insurance and your carrying costs, and let us show you the net at today’s price.

How do I handle showings if I live out of state?

Give us a lockbox or a showing contact, a dated key-access plan and a local caretaker for storm prep. We coordinate showings and send you the feedback, and you can sign electronically from anywhere.

Can I sell to a cash buyer, and how fast can it close?

Yes. A cash sale can close faster because no lender appraisal or underwriting is needed, but a condominium or cooperative still requires the association’s documents and any approval, which set the pace. We will tell you which applies to your home.

How are association dues and prorations handled at closing?

Dues are prorated to the closing date, and the estoppel certificate shows what is owed and any pending assessment. The seller customarily settles unpaid assessments. Request the estoppel early, because associations take days to issue it and the statute caps the fee.

How do I find out which association my home belongs to?

Your deed, the title commitment and the Division of Corporations register show it. For the lanes it is the Nancy, Helen or Emily Lane association, for Sportsmans Cove its condominium association, and for Port Carlos Cove the cooperative corporation. Many platted lots have none.

What should I know about selling a vacant lot on the island?

The roll shows 207 vacant residential-class parcels on the island, and we have no recent MLS closing record for vacant lots. Price from the county’s recorded vacant-lot sales, check the flood zone and the buildable status with Lee County, and expect a narrow buyer pool.

What happens if my buyer cancels after reading the association documents?

For a condominium resale the buyer may cancel within 7 days, excluding weekends and legal holidays, after receiving the documents, including any milestone inspection summary or reserve study that applies, under section 718.503. Delivering the documents early starts the clock early.

Why do the county’s sale count and the MLS count differ, and which should I use to price?

The county counts recorded, qualified sales on all 1,218 parcels, including the two gated communities, and the MLS series covers the island’s listed subdivisions only. Use both as separate records, and use comparable closings from your own pocket first.

How should I price a manufactured or RV-lot home in a cooperative or lane condominium?

Use closings in the same cooperative or lane, adjusted for size, condition, lot and fees. The 60-month medians run from Port Carlos Cove’s $238,000 across 15 closings to Nancy Lane’s $357,500 across 10; Helen Lane’s nine sales ran from $58,140 to $150,000; and each pocket’s fee entries differ.

Can I sell a home that was damaged in a hurricane and not yet repaired?

Yes, as-is sales happen, and cash buyers are common for damaged homes. Disclose the damage, gather any claim and permit records, and expect a buyer’s lender and insurer to limit financing and coverage until repairs are done. A flood-zone home may also trigger the 50 percent rule on repairs.

How do I prepare my home for a buyer’s inspection?

Service the roof, air conditioning and electrical panel, check the seawall and dock, and gather permits, warranties and the wind mitigation report. Inspections on older island homes often turn on flood damage, roof age and electrical, and fixing them first avoids a renegotiation.

Does a Tip Top Isles or Bayside Estates address count as San Carlos Island?

No. Both are mainland, off San Carlos Boulevard. The MLS series groups Tip Top Isles with the island, but for pricing a home use Tip Top Isles or Bayside Estates closings, and see our Bayside Estates seller page.

What We Could Not Verify

We could not verify the items below from a primary source, and we have kept each one out of the facts above or labeled it. Naming the gaps is part of the research: a buyer or seller should treat each as a question for the seller, the association, the county or the title company.

  • The year the island was platted. No source we reached gives it, so the plats are cited by book and page only.
  • Port Carlos Cove’s ownership form. The county use code and the MLS say cooperative and the county GIS says condominium RV park. We did not read the declaration, and whether any age restriction applies is not confirmed.
  • The 1999 working-waterfront designation. Residents and local press describe it, and we found no county document that confirms it.
  • Comprehensive plan amendment CPA2018-00003. It shows “Closed Due to Inactivity” on the county’s results site, and we did not read the county’s community-plan documents, which did not open when we re-checked them.
  • A condominium association and trailers. A local television headline describes an island condominium association ordering residents to remove trailers; the page no longer opens, so we do not rely on it. A buyer of an RV-lot unit should read the current rules.
  • Two MLS definitions of the island. The subdivision series we publish shows 11 closings and a $400,000 median in the 12 months to October 7, 2026; the MLS’s own area grouping shows 10 and $412,500. We could not reconcile the two lines.
  • County list against county windows. The 120 address-level records run from December 13, 2022 to August 31, 2026 and do not reconcile one to one with the 148 sales in the 60-month window.
  • Recorded declarations, budgets, assessments and reserves for every pocket, and whether any association is in good standing today.
  • Milestone inspection and structural reserve study status of any building. We computed deadlines from year built and never state a status.
  • Lee County’s floodplain rules for unincorporated areas, the seaward status of any lot against the coastal construction line, the official Coastal Barrier Resources System determination and the elevation of new construction.
  • Water depths, canal widths, speed zones, open-water routes and the Matanzas Pass Bridge clearance from a primary source.
  • The solid-waste franchise area and the electric provider for the island.
  • Zoning detail and lot sizes. The roll gives a zoning code for each parcel, and we did not confirm permitted uses, setbacks, height limits or lot sizes.

Sources and Authoritative References

This is the dated source list for the facts above, with county, state, federal, Town and press sources. We opened every link on October 7, 2026 and dropped the ones that failed. The state corporate register and some federal pages refuse automated checks, so we cite them by their public addresses.

Records, the county roll and corporate filings

  1. Property Search, Lee County Property Appraiser.
  2. Property use code list, Lee County Property Appraiser.
  3. 2025 Taxing District Millage Book, Lee County Property Appraiser.
  4. 2026 Taxing District Millage Book, printed October 9, 2026, Lee County Property Appraiser.
  5. 2025 certification of taxable value, form DR-420, Lee County Property Appraiser.
  6. Hazards and flood zones map service, Lee County Property Appraiser GIS.
  7. Port Carlos Cove, Incorporated, document 768932, Florida Division of Corporations.
  8. Port Carlos Cove Civic Association, Inc., document N18000012422, Florida Division of Corporations.
  9. The Nancy Lane Association, Inc., document 764501, Florida Division of Corporations.
  10. Helen Lane Association, Inc., document N04908, Florida Division of Corporations.
  11. Emily Lane Association, Inc., document 765297, Florida Division of Corporations.
  12. Sportsman’s Cove Condominium Association, Inc., document 768534, Florida Division of Corporations.

Planning, history and the working waterfront

  1. San Carlos Maritime Park frequently asked questions, March 2026, Lee County Parks and Recreation.
  2. Shrimp Industry Master Plan, Southwest Florida Regional Planning Council.
  3. Ordinance 20-07, Lee County Board of County Commissioners.
  4. Comprehensive plan amendment CPA2018-00003, Lee County.
  5. Comprehensive plan amendment cycles, Lee County Department of Community Development.
  6. Is San Carlos Island ripe for redevelopment, 2018, Fort Myers Beach Talk.
  7. San Carlos Island residents send unified message, 2018, Fort Myers Beach Talk.
  8. Welcome home, beach shrimp fleet, 2009, Fort Myers Beach Talk.
  9. Locals fear county changes to San Carlos Island plan, 2019, Fort Myers Beach Talk.
  10. San Carlos Island docks remain damaged after Hurricane Ian, Gulfshore Business.
  11. San Carlos Island to get new boat ramp, WINK News.
  12. Early development on Fort Myers Beach, Estero Island Historic Society.
  13. The south drawbridge, Estero Island Historic Society.
  14. Island history, Town of Fort Myers Beach.

Florida statutes

  1. Section 201.02, tax on deeds, Florida Statutes.
  2. Section 553.899, milestone inspections, Florida Statutes.
  3. Section 718.112, bylaws and structural integrity reserve study, Florida Statutes.
  4. Section 718.503, resale disclosure, Florida Statutes.
  5. Chapter 719, cooperatives, Florida Statutes.
  6. Section 720.401, homeowners association disclosure, Florida Statutes.
  7. Section 689.302, flood disclosure, Florida Senate.
  8. Section 627.351, Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, Florida Senate.
  9. Condominium and cooperative SIRS reporting, Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation.

Flood, storm and insurance

  1. Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian, National Hurricane Center.
  2. Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Helene, National Hurricane Center.
  3. Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Milton, National Hurricane Center.
  4. Hurricane Helene impact narratives, National Weather Service.
  5. Hurricane Milton impact narratives, National Weather Service.
  6. High-water marks, 2022 Ian event, U.S. Geological Survey.
  7. Hurricanes Ian and Nicole final report, Florida Department of Environmental Protection.
  8. National Flood Hazard Layer service, FEMA.
  9. Community Rating System status, Florida, FEMA.
  10. Risk Rating 2.0, FEMA.
  11. Evacuation zones dataset, Lee County.
  12. Coastal Barrier Resources System property documentation, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
  13. Flood insurance requirements, Citizens Property Insurance.
  14. Uniform mitigation verification form changes, March 2026, Citizens Property Insurance.
  15. Wind mitigation resources, Florida Office of Insurance Regulation.
  16. Unincorporated Lee County keeps flood program discount, WGCU.
  17. FEMA confirms Fort Myers Beach earns CRS Class 5, WGCU.
  18. FEMA’s 50 percent rule, Town of Fort Myers Beach.
  19. Substantial improvement and substantial damage, Town of Fort Myers Beach.
  20. Elevation certificates, Town of Fort Myers Beach.
  21. Short-term rentals, Town of Fort Myers Beach.

Roads, schools, services and places

  1. Salty Sam’s Marina, Salty Sam’s Marina.
  2. Fort Myers Beach boat ramp, Salty Sam’s Marina.
  3. Gulf Star Marina, Fort Myers Beach Chamber of Commerce.
  4. Shrimp Festival, Fort Myers Beach Shrimp Festival.
  5. Shrimp Festival dates announced, July 2026, Fort Myers Beach Talk.
  6. Contact us, station list, Fort Myers Beach Fire Control District.
  7. School zones, Lee County Schools.
  8. School Board votes on Fort Myers Beach Elementary, May 2026, Fort Myers Beach Talk.
  9. Beach Elementary school’s future, October 2025, WGCU.
  10. Route 410 and 490 timetable, LeeTran.
  11. Trolleys and trams resume, November 2025, WGCU.
  12. New Big Carlos Pass Bridge to open, November 2025, WGCU.
  13. San Carlos Boulevard project 433726-2, Florida Department of Transportation.
  14. San Carlos Boulevard project flyer, Florida Department of Transportation.
  15. Bowditch Point Regional Park, Lee County Parks and Recreation.
  16. Fort Myers Beach pier replacement begins, October 2026, North Fort Myers Neighbor.
  17. Matanzas Pass Preserve, Lee County Parks and Recreation.
  18. Solid waste adopted rates, Lee County Solid Waste.

Our team

  1. RealTrends team profile, McGreevy and Comisar, RealTrends.

Downloadable Documents

These are the public primary documents behind the island, tax and storm sections of this page, each hosted by the county, the regional planning council or the federal government. Each link returned a successful response on October 7, 2026, and the 2026 millage book on November 17, 2026, and each opens as a document you can save.

Document

Issued

What it is

San Carlos Maritime Park frequently asked questions

March 2026

The county’s questions and answers on the Ian-damaged Maritime Park

Shrimp Industry Master Plan

May 21, 2024

The regional planning council’s plan for the shrimp industry, with the boat counts before and after Ian

Lee County Ordinance 20-07

June 17, 2020

The ordinance that changed one Bay Harbour parcel to Central Urban

2026 Taxing District Millage Book

Printed October 9, 2026

Every taxing district’s 2026 applied millage, including the island’s 13.2284

2025 Taxing District Millage Book

2025 roll year

Every taxing district’s millage lines, including the island’s 13.3976

Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian

Storm of September 28, 2022

The National Hurricane Center’s report with the surge heights

Market data from Southwest Florida MLS, pulled October 2026. McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for San Carlos Island. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.


Work With Us

Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.