Best Real Estate Agents in Punta Gorda, FL (2026): Compared on the Public Record, McGreevy and Comisar

Who are the best real estate agents in Punta Gorda, FL, on the public record in 2026?

McGreevy and Comisar of Domain Realty compared 12 Punta Gorda real estate agents and teams on eight public, dated criteria, all retrieved on one day, 24 September 2026. On that record McGreevy and Comisar sit eighth of the 12 on Google review count, 76 at 4.9, and first on RealTrends Verified dollar volume, $157.57M across 241 closed sides in 2025.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, founding partners of McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Brokered by Domain Realty. Updated September 2026 (data date 24 September 2026). This page is the comparison companion to our Punta Gorda real estate guide and sits under our Charlotte County guide.

This page is published by McGreevy and Comisar of Domain Realty; rankings reflect the criteria stated above on the data date shown.

Criteria and data date: Google Business Profile review count and rating, years licensed per the Florida DBPR licence record, brokerage of record per DBPR, office city per the Google Business Profile place page, team or solo, languages listed on the public profile, published production only where RealTrends Verified published it, and the public record ids behind every cell. All retrieved 24 September 2026. Selection rule: every real estate agent or team with a Google Business Profile whose place-page address city is Punta Gorda, FL carrying 50 or more reviews on the data date, plus any RealTrends Verified 2026 team based in Punta Gorda; if fewer than 8 qualify the floor drops to 25 reviews, and if more than 11 others qualify the table is capped at the 11 with the most Google reviews plus the publisher’s own row. On 24 September 2026, 17 Punta Gorda-addressed profiles cleared 50 reviews and 11 RealTrends Verified teams were based in Punta Gorda, so the cap applied: the 11 profiles below carried 58 or more Google reviews, and McGreevy and Comisar appear in their measured position, eighth.

Data updated: September 2026 (Google Business Profile as displayed on Google Maps, Florida DBPR licensee portal, RealTrends Verified 2026 program, all retrieved 24 September 2026).

Every cell in the table is a record, not an opinion. Where a record could not be retrieved on the data date, the cell says so rather than carrying a guess. Nothing on this page characterises any agent or team other than McGreevy and Comisar; the table shows the public record and the reader does the reading.

How were the agents on this list selected and compared?

McGreevy and Comisar selected the Punta Gorda roster by a rule written before the data was pulled, the same rule used on our Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers pages, then compared every row on the same eight criteria on one day, 24 September 2026. Nothing was ranked on private knowledge, on unverified production, or on anything a reader cannot check against a public record with a licence number or a Google listing.

Data updated: September 2026 (Florida DBPR licensee portal, Google Business Profile, RealTrends Verified, retrieved 24 September 2026).

The yardstick. The selection rule is stated above the table: a Google Business Profile whose place-page city is Punta Gorda, FL, 50 or more reviews on the data date, plus any RealTrends Verified 2026 team based in Punta Gorda, with a cap of 11 rows by Google review count plus the publisher’s own row. For this page we tracked 267 distinct Google listings returned for real estate agents in and around Punta Gorda, across ten Google local-results queries including the 33950, 33955, 33982 and 33983 ZIP codes, and read the Google place page and the DBPR record behind every listing that met the rule. On 24 September 2026, 17 Punta Gorda-addressed profiles cleared 50 reviews and 11 RealTrends Verified teams were based in Punta Gorda, so the cap applied and the cut line fell at 58 reviews. The profile ranked twelfth on review count carried 56. Four of the 11 RealTrends teams are on the table through their Google profile; the other seven qualified under the rule but sat below the cut line on Google reviews, which is the only criterion the cap uses.

What each criterion measures, and where it comes from.

1. Google reviews and rating. The count and the star average displayed on the agent’s Google Business Profile on the data date. Google computes the rating as the average of all published ratings and removes reviews that violate its policies, so a count is a snapshot, not a permanent fact. That is why every count on this page is dated.
2. Years licensed. The original licensure date on the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation record, counted in complete years to 24 September 2026. For a corporation listing, the corporation’s own licence date is shown and labelled as such, with the qualifying broker’s date beside it where the record returned one. One corporation record on this table carries no licensure date at all, and the cell says so.
3. Brokerage of record. The employing broker or corporation shown on the DBPR record’s Related License Information view. Florida law requires a sales associate to work under a broker, and the record shows who that is.
4. Office city. The city on the Google Business Profile place page, which is the criterion that put a profile on the list. Punta Gorda, FL on Google spans the incorporated city in 33950 and the unincorporated Charlotte County ZIPs that share the mailing address, 33955, 33982 and 33983, and excludes Port Charlotte and North Port. McGreevy and Comisar’s headquarters is at 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101 in Bonita Springs, FL 34134, and the row appears here as the publisher’s row.
5. Team or solo. Read from the profile’s own category and name; a listing is described as it presents itself, and where the listing is a brokerage office or carries a property-management name the cell says so.
6. Languages. Only where the public profile lists them. No Google Business Profile in this roster lists a language, so the column is honest about that.
7. Published production. Shown only where RealTrends Verified published it for the 2025 sales year, cited to that publication. RealTrends rankings are built from submitted production that RealTrends states it verifies, so a RealTrends figure is a published third-party number and an absent one means nothing was published, not that nothing was sold.
8. Public record ids. The DBPR licence numbers and the Google listing behind each row, so any cell can be re-checked by anyone.

How the table is ordered. By Google review count on the data date, highest first, which is the criterion most readers check first. McGreevy and Comisar sit eighth of twelve on that column with 76 reviews at 4.9, between a brokerage listing at 87 and two listings at 72, and the page leaves the row exactly there rather than reordering the table to put the publisher on top. Where two rows tie on count, they appear in the order Google’s own local results listed them.

What is deliberately not on the table. No review text from any profile other than our own. No home addresses, even where the DBPR record carries one. No production figure that an agent or RealTrends has not published. No adjective about anyone.

Thinking of selling or buying in Punta Gorda? The record on this page is the record you get.

McGreevy and Comisar closed $157.57M across 241 sides in 2025 on the RealTrends Verified record, the largest published dollar volume on this page, at an average price of $653.8K. If you are selling a Punta Gorda home, start with a free valuation of your Punta Gorda home and call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. If you are buying, see how McGreevy and Comisar represent Punta Gorda buyers and call Marc Comisar at (239) 287-5873. Every number on this page can be checked against the record ids in the table, which is exactly how we would want you to check us. Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Brokered by Domain Realty.

Which Punta Gorda real estate agents have the most Google reviews in September 2026?

Seven Punta Gorda-addressed profiles carried more Google reviews than McGreevy and Comisar on 24 September 2026, led by team listings at 744, 559 and 420, against McGreevy and Comisar’s 76 at a 4.9 rating; four rostered profiles carried fewer. The table names them. Google reviews measure the volume of feedback on one platform; they do not measure closings, licence history or price tier.

Data updated: September 2026 (Google Business Profile counts as displayed on Google Maps place pages, retrieved 24 September 2026).

McGreevy and Comisar hold 76 Google reviews at 4.9 on the data date, on a profile addressed at the headquarters at 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134, with the direct line (239) 898-6072. That profile carries every review our clients leave, whichever county the home was in, which is why the row sits on a Bonita Springs address and still appears here: the page ranks the team a Punta Gorda seller or buyer would actually hire. The Domain Realty brokerage keeps a separate Google profile of its own; it is not in the table, because the table’s row is the team, and the point of a criteria-based page is that the criterion does not move to flatter the publisher.

Three things to read into a Punta Gorda count before you compare two of them. First, whose reviews it aggregates: the three rows above 400 are team listings that gather every client of a multi-agent team onto one profile, while the smaller rows include two brokerage office listings and a solo agent. Second, how new the profile is: a count accumulates from the day a profile is created, not from the day an agent was licensed, and the table shows licence dates from 2002 to 2018 beside counts that do not track them. Third, what the rating is an average of: Google’s own help pages explain that the score is the average of all published ratings and that Google removes reviews that break its policies, which is why counts drift and why this page carries a date on every number.

Florida law does not require an agent to collect reviews anywhere, and in a market like Punta Gorda, where a large share of buyers are relocating retirees and second-home owners who close once and leave, some experienced agents carry small counts because their business runs on repeat and referral clients rather than on public feedback. Read the count next to the licence date, the brokerage and the published production, not on its own. If you want reviews you can read rather than count, the client review block further down this page quotes McGreevy and Comisar’s own verified Google reviews, and only those.

How long have McGreevy and Comisar been licensed in Florida, and how do you check any agent’s licence?

Jesse McGreevy has held Florida licence SL3101296 since 4 November 2004 and Marc Comisar has held Florida licence BK3060671 since 25 September 2003, both Current and Active with DomainRealty.com LLC as brokerage of record, per the Florida DBPR portal on 24 September 2026. That is 21 and 22 complete years, over 45 years of combined direct experience between Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar.

Data updated: September 2026 (Florida DBPR licensee portal, records retrieved 24 September 2026; the portal reported its data current as of 24 September 2026, 12:15 PM).

The Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation publishes every real estate licence at myfloridalicense.com, and checking one takes about a minute. Choose Search by Name or Search by License Number, pick the Real Estate board, enter the agent, and open the record. The record shows the licence type (Sales Associate, Broker Associate or Broker), the status (Current and Active is the one you want), the original licensure date, the expiry date, the brokerage of record under Related License Information, and any disciplinary history. Marc Comisar’s record shows the Broker Sales rank, which means he holds a broker licence and practises as a broker associate under Domain Realty; Jesse McGreevy’s record shows Sales Associate. Both records carry the Professional Association qualification, which is the P.A. after their names.

Every years-licensed figure on the Punta Gorda table came from that portal on the same day. Where a row is a corporation listing rather than a person, the table shows the corporation’s licence date and says so, because a corporation’s date and a person’s date are different facts; four rows on this table are corporation listings, and two of them also show the qualifying broker’s own licence date. One corporation record returned no licensure date in the portal at all, and that cell reports the blank rather than filling it from the profile’s own years-in-business line. On the person rows, the licence dates on the table run from 2002 to 2018.

Licence tenure is a floor, not a ranking. A licence issued in 2004 proves twenty-one years of standing with the state; it does not prove twenty-one years of Punta Gorda closings. Read the column next to the published production column, which is the only place on this page where closings appear, and only where a third party published them.

What does the Florida DBPR record show about brokerage of record, and why does it matter?

Every Florida sales associate works under a licensed broker, and the DBPR record names that broker or corporation as the brokerage of record. On this table McGreevy and Comisar’s brokerage of record is DomainRealty.com LLC, doing business as Domain Realty, licence CQ1049052, since July 2015, with Jesse McGreevy as a co-founder of that brokerage; the other rows show five national franchise networks and four independent Punta Gorda corporations.

Data updated: September 2026 (Florida DBPR licensee records and Related License Information views, retrieved 24 September 2026).

Brokerage of record matters for three practical reasons. The broker is who holds your escrow deposit under Florida law, who is accountable to the Florida Real Estate Commission for the associate’s conduct, and whose name must appear in any team advertising under Rule 61J2-10.026 of the Florida Administrative Code, which is why every mention of the team on this page reads McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty. A team name that never shows its brokerage is not following the rule.

The Punta Gorda record shows something the southern tables did not: two pairs of rows on this table sit under the same corporation, because a Google listing can belong to a team, to its broker, or to an agent inside an office, and each is a separate profile with its own count. The table reports the DBPR string exactly as the portal shows it rather than the name on the sign, so you can see which listings answer to the same broker. McGreevy and Comisar’s brokerage, Domain Realty, was co-founded by Jesse McGreevy in 2015 and is the brokerage behind Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012. What that means for a client is that the people whose names are on the door and the people whose licences are on the file are the same people.

The employed-by date on a DBPR record is also useful. It tells you how long an agent has been at the current brokerage, and a series of short stints is a fact you may want to ask about. Both McGreevy and Comisar records show Domain Realty as brokerage of record since July 2015, the year the brokerage was founded.

Which criterion do McGreevy and Comisar lead on, and which do they not?

On the 24 September 2026 record McGreevy and Comisar lead the Punta Gorda table on published dollar volume, $157.57M in 2025, and on published average sale price, $653.8K. They do not lead on published sides, where one row published 337 to their 241, on Google review count, where seven rows carry more, or on licence tenure, where two person rows show 23 years and one qualifying broker 25, to their 22 and 21. Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 is the accolade they carry into that record.

Data updated: September 2026 (RealTrends Verified 2026 program based on 2025 sales data; Florida DBPR; Google Business Profile; all retrieved 24 September 2026).

That is the honest reading of the table, and it is the reading a Punta Gorda seller should want. Published production is the criterion that most directly measures what a listing agent does, and RealTrends is the one third party on this page that publishes a verified figure: McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty, closed 241 sides and $157.57M in 2025, with an average home price of $653.8K, ranking 1 by volume and 1 by sides in their city, 11 by volume and 5 by sides in Florida, and 129 by volume and 131 by sides nationally. Four other rows on the table carry a RealTrends figure, at 337, 202, 123 and 123 sides, and the table shows each exactly as published, including one team whose Google listing names no licensee, where the row is matched to the licensee at the brokerage RealTrends lists for that team.

Punta Gorda is also where the published-production column says the most about price tier. The Punta Gorda city single-family median was $670,000 in July 2026 per Florida Realtors SunStats as published on our Punta Gorda guide, and the RealTrends average prices on this table run from $398.0K to $653.8K. The column shows each team’s published 2025 average beside its volume, so you can see which price tier its published business sits in before you call.

On review count the record says what it says. McGreevy and Comisar’s 76 Google reviews at 4.9 sit eighth on this table. We could have chosen a criterion or a platform that put us first, and we chose not to, because a page that ranks the publisher first on every column is a brochure, and you already know what a brochure is for. On office city, the headquarters at 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 is a Bonita Springs address, and the row reports it as the record shows it; the first-hand block below says what we do in Punta Gorda and what we do not claim.

Is it better to hire a team or a solo agent in Punta Gorda?

Neither structure is better on the record; the Florida DBPR treats a team as a group of individually licensed associates under one broker, and the Punta Gorda table shows teams, solo agents and brokerage offices with strong review histories. McGreevy and Comisar operate as a team under Domain Realty, RealTrends Verified as a large team, led by two principals with 21 and 22 years licensed.

Data updated: September 2026 (Florida Administrative Code Rule 61J2-10.026; RealTrends Verified 2026 team profile; retrieved 24 September 2026).

What a team changes is coverage and continuity. A solo agent is one licence, one phone and one calendar. A team can show a canal home in Punta Gorda Isles the same afternoon a buyer calls from out of state, run a listing’s marketing while the lead agent is at a closing, and keep a transaction moving through the 181 days the median Punta Gorda city single-family sale took from list to close in July 2026. What a team does not change is who is accountable: under Florida law every associate on a team works under the same broker, and under Rule 61J2-10.026 the team must advertise with the brokerage name attached, which is why the team name on this page never appears without Domain Realty beside it.

The question to ask any team is who actually handles your file. At McGreevy and Comisar the answer is the two names on the page: Jesse McGreevy runs the office, the research and the appointment desk, which in Punta Gorda means the seawall-zone lookup, the permit history and the plat and parcel work behind a price, and Marc Comisar runs the field, the listing appointments and the buyer side, in the houses and on the canals. The team behind them, Domain Realty Group, is the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and its 4,000+ transactions are the depth behind two principals rather than a substitute for them.

The question to ask a solo agent is what happens when they are unavailable, and the question to ask a brokerage office listing is which of its associates you will actually get. Both have good answers when the agent is good. The table lets you weigh all three structures on the same record and decide which answer you prefer.

Which kind of move fits McGreevy and Comisar in Punta Gorda?

McGreevy and Comisar fit a Punta Gorda seller pricing a canal or harbor home into a slow-to-contract market, a buyer who needs the city limits, the seawall zones and the flood file read before the first showing, a luxury or waterfront move where their 2025 RealTrends average sale price was $653.8K, and a relocating buyer comparing Punta Gorda with the Lee and Collier markets they also sell. The table gives you the same criteria for every row.

Data updated: September 2026 (RealTrends Verified 2026 profile; Florida Realtors SunStats, Punta Gorda (City), single-family, July 2026, as published on our Punta Gorda guide; retrieved 24 September 2026).

A seller who needs the price right the first time. In July 2026 Punta Gorda city single-family homes took a median 147 days to go under contract and closed at a median 92.2 percent of original list price, with cash paying for 54.3 percent of closings, per Florida Realtors SunStats as published on our Punta Gorda guide. In a market that slow to contract, the first price is the one that decides how many of those days you spend waiting. Start with a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

A buyer choosing between the historic district, Punta Gorda Isles, Burnt Store Isles, the Burnt Store corridor and Babcock Ranch. A Punta Gorda mailing address can sit inside the city, in unincorporated Charlotte County, or, at Burnt Store Marina, in Lee County, and the difference shows up on the tax bill, the seawall responsibility and which government answers the phone. Sailboat water and powerboat water are different canal routes, and the agent you pick should know which one a dock actually reaches. Our Punta Gorda guide publishes that work, and the new-town side of the same ZIP is covered in our Babcock Ranch guide. See how McGreevy and Comisar represent Punta Gorda buyers.

A luxury or waterfront move. McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales, and the 2025 RealTrends average sale price of $653.8K sits within a few thousand dollars of the Punta Gorda city single-family median of $670,000 for July 2026, which is the canal-and-harbor tier of this market rather than the county’s $353,545.

A relocation from out of state. A relocating buyer needs an agent who can explain Florida’s transaction-broker default, the homestead rules, the flood and insurance picture after Hurricane Ian in 2022 and the 2024 season, and the difference between Punta Gorda, Port Charlotte and the Lee County markets to the south before the first showing. That is the content of our Punta Gorda guide, our Port Charlotte guide and our guide to things to do in Punta Gorda, all written by the people whose licences are on this page.

A move that turns on language. The public record on this criterion is thin: no Google Business Profile on the table lists a language. McGreevy and Comisar’s team profile lists English, Spanish, French and Italian, and the honest note is that Google does not carry that field for anyone here, so ask.

For every row on the table, the same criteria apply and the same public records are the place to check. Pick the criterion that matters to your move, read down that column, and then call the agent whose record fits.

What does published production mean, and why is it only shown where RealTrends published it?

Published production on this page means a closed-sides and dollar-volume figure that RealTrends Verified published for the 2025 sales year, cited to that publication and to nothing else. McGreevy and Comisar’s published figure is 241 sides and $157.57M; four other rows carry a RealTrends figure and seven carry none, which means nothing was published, not that nothing was sold.

Data updated: September 2026 (RealTrends Verified 2026 program, program release 10 July 2026, based on 2025 sales data, retrieved 24 September 2026).

RealTrends Verified is a submission-based ranking program: agents and teams submit their production for the prior calendar year, RealTrends classifies them by size, and RealTrends states that it verifies submissions before publishing city, state and national ranks. Its Punta Gorda pages for 2026 list 24 individual agents, 7 small teams, 1 medium team, 3 large teams and no mega team. It is the closest thing the industry has to a public, third-party production record, and it is the only production source this page uses. Aggregator sites publish sales figures of their own, and on our own profiles those figures disagree with each other and with RealTrends by wide margins, which is exactly why they are not on the table.

An MLS record would be more complete, but it is not public. Members can pull any agent’s closed sides from the Southwest Florida MLS, and a seller interviewing agents is entitled to ask each one for that pull. McGreevy and Comisar will hand you theirs. What a page like this cannot do is publish a competitor’s private MLS production and call it a ranking, so it does not.

The RealTrends figure also settles a question sellers ask about teams. A team figure counts every side the team closed, so a large team’s 241 sides and a small team’s 123 are different kinds of number. Both are on the table as published, with the classification beside them, and you can divide for yourself. The city a RealTrends entry is ranked in is the city the team names as its base, which is why McGreevy and Comisar rank in Bonita Springs and appear here as the publisher’s row rather than in the Punta Gorda team lists.

What is the Punta Gorda market doing in 2026, and why does the agent you pick matter in a 147-day market?

Punta Gorda city single-family homes closed 46 sales in July 2026 at a median sale price of $670,000, up 22.9 percent from July 2025, with 153 active listings and 3.4 months of supply, but a median 147 days to go under contract, per Florida Realtors SunStats as published on the McGreevy and Comisar Punta Gorda guide. Inventory is tight and contracts are slow, and a market like that rewards pricing precision over listing volume.

MLS check, 25 September 2026: the Southwest Florida MLS recorded 1,077 closed home sales with a Punta Gorda address in the 12 months to 24 September 2026, at a $350,000 median, 75 median days on market and 96.9% of list price. Babcock Ranch accounts for 497 of them (median $390,000); the other 580 closed at a $360,000 median in a median 79 days (Southwest Florida MLS Matrix, City field Punta Gorda, closed 0 to 365 days, retrieved 25 September 2026).

Data updated: July 2026 (Florida Realtors SunStats, Punta Gorda (City) preset, single-family, July 2026 against July 2025, pulled 28 August 2026 and published on our Punta Gorda guide, retrieved 24 September 2026; RealTrends market widget sourced to Altos Research, 24 September 2026).

The rest of the July 2026 snapshot tells the same story. The average sale price rose 10.7 percent to $723,038. Cash paid for 54.3 percent of closings. Sellers recovered a median 92.2 percent of original list price, up from 86.5 percent a year earlier. The median time to contract rose from 90 days to 147, and the median time from list to sale from 140 days to 181. Active inventory fell 41.4 percent from 261 to 153, which is why months of supply dropped from 7.4 to 3.4 in twelve months. Across Charlotte County in the same month, single-family homes sold at a median $353,545 and went under contract in a median 78 days, which is why a countywide statistic describes almost none of the city. A separate market widget published by RealTrends and sourced to Altos Research on 24 September 2026 showed a median list price in Punta Gorda of $429,000, inventory of 759 and a median of 91 days on market, list-side figures for the wider Punta Gorda mailing area that sit well below the city’s sold-side median.

What that means for the choice on this page. A 3.4-month supply says buyers are competing for what is listed; a 147-day median to contract says they are taking their time about it. Both are true at once in Punta Gorda because the city market is small, 46 single-family sales in a month, and many of its homes sit on canals, behind seawalls and on flood files that a buyer’s inspector, insurer and lender all read slowly. The listing agent’s job is to put those documents in front of the buyer before the buyer asks, so the 147 days are spent on a contract rather than on questions. The 92.2 percent ratio is the market telling sellers that overpricing costs about eight percent.

For every Punta Gorda pricing conversation we tracked the city snapshot above against the closed comparables on the same canal system and in the same seawall zone, and that is the conversation to have with Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 before you set a list price. If you want to see the homes behind these numbers, every home for sale in Punta Gorda is on Domain Realty Group, the team site McGreevy and Comisar lead; this page stays on the question of who to hire.

Why McGreevy and Comisar work Punta Gorda, and what the documents taught them

Jesse McGreevy moved to Estero in October 2003 and has sold Southwest Florida real estate since October 2004; Marc Comisar has held his Florida broker licence since September 2003. Charlotte County is one of their primary markets, where Domain Realty Group has established agents after selling heavily in the county since 2019, and Punta Gorda is where the county’s paperwork runs deepest.

Data updated: September 2026 (Florida DBPR licence records for SL3101296 and BK3060671; McGreevy and Comisar records; NOAA National Hurricane Center tropical cyclone reports; retrieved 24 September 2026).

In Jesse’s words. I had been in Southwest Florida less than a year when the eye of Hurricane Charley passed over Punta Gorda in August 2004, two months before my licence was issued. Eighteen years later Hurricane Ian made landfall on Cayo Costa, at the mouth of Charlotte Harbor, and the questions Punta Gorda sellers bring to us now are the questions that storm taught everyone to ask: whose seawall is it, what did the last permit cover, and what does the flood file say about the next one.

That is why our Punta Gorda work starts with documents rather than finishes. Marc and I split it the way the market splits itself. I run the office and the research: the seawall-zone lookup, the permit history, the plat section, the Property Appraiser card and the flood panel for an address, before anyone talks about price. Marc runs the field: he is in the houses and on the canals, and he is the one standing on a dock telling a buyer which bridge it clears and telling a seller what the street will bear. We published the method, city against county, seawall zone by seawall zone, in our Punta Gorda guide, and the county around it in our Charlotte County guide, so you can judge it before you call.

What I will not do on this page is claim an office we do not have. Our headquarters is in Bonita Springs, our Fort Myers office is on College Parkway, and the Punta Gorda appointment you book with us is with Marc or with me. The table is how you check us. This block is why we are comfortable being checked, in a city where we sit eighth on the one column most people read first.

What do McGreevy and Comisar clients say?

McGreevy and Comisar’s Google Business Profile carried 76 reviews at a 4.9 rating on 24 September 2026, and the three quotations below are verbatim client reviews from that profile, quoted with nothing changed. This page quotes no review from any other profile and counts none beyond the dated numbers in the table.

Data updated: September 2026 (McGreevy and Comisar Google Business Profile, CID 14023824600866387372, retrieved 24 September 2026).

McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Southwest Florida realtor team serving Punta Gorda, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with a long record of genuine five star client reviews on Google.

Client Reviews

★★★★★ “We had been on the market for several months with no offers. When we signed with Marc our house was sold in 2 weeks. He has a unique system for selling homes.” Verified Google review

★★★★★ “Their recommendation on pricing my unit was sound and proved prescient. I never questioned their integrity and found it easy to rely on their recommendations. I would work with them again in a heartbeat.” Verified Google review

★★★★★ “Marc’s knowledge of the Southwest Florida real estate market is unmatched. He took the time to understand exactly what I was looking for in a home and quickly identified properties that checked all my boxes.” Verified Google review

Honors and recognition, verbatim as published:

• Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
• 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
• #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
• McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
• McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
• RealTrends Verified 2026: #5 real estate team in Florida by sides, 241 transactions, $157M+ volume
• Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
• Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

How to reach McGreevy and Comisar about a Punta Gorda home

McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty, are reached at the headquarters at 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134, by calling Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc Comisar at (239) 287-5873, or by email at [email protected]. Both partners take Punta Gorda and Charlotte County appointments, and the appointment is with one of them.

Jesse McGreevy direct: (239) 898-6072. Marc Comisar direct: (239) 287-5873. Email: [email protected]. Headquarters: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134. Fort Myers office: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919. Naples office: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109. Domain Realty Group team line: 239-441-2816. Profiles: Google, Facebook, Jesse McGreevy on LinkedIn, Marc Comisar on LinkedIn, RealTrends Verified team profile.

Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) are licensed Florida real estate professionals, licensed and regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission under Chapter 475, Florida Statutes. McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

This page is published by McGreevy and Comisar of Domain Realty; rankings reflect the criteria stated above on the data date shown.

Frequently asked questions about choosing a real estate agent in Punta Gorda

How do I find the best real estate agent in Punta Gorda, Florida?

Start with the public record rather than the advertising: the Florida DBPR licence lookup for tenure, status and brokerage, the Google Business Profile for dated reviews, and RealTrends Verified for published production. Then interview two or three agents whose records fit your move and ask each for their own closed-sales pull. McGreevy and Comisar built this page so the Punta Gorda record is in one place.

What questions should I ask a Punta Gorda real estate agent before hiring them?

The National Association of Realtors and Florida Realtors publish ten questions for each side: how long you have been licensed and whether it is full time, whether you are a Realtor bound by the Code of Ethics, which communities you work most, how you arrived at a list price, what the marketing plan includes, and whether I can speak to recent clients. In Punta Gorda add two more: which seawall zone is this house in, and which bridges does this canal route pass under.

How do I check a Florida real estate licence?

Go to the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation licence portal, choose Search by Name or Search by License Number, and open the record. It shows licence type, status, the original licensure date, the expiry, the brokerage of record and any discipline. Jesse McGreevy is SL3101296 and Marc Comisar is BK3060671; both records read Current and Active with Domain Realty on 24 September 2026.

What is the difference between a sales associate, a broker associate and a broker in Florida?

Under Chapter 475, Florida Statutes, a broker may operate a brokerage and hold escrow; a sales associate performs the same real estate services under a broker’s direction; and a broker associate holds a broker licence but chooses to work under another broker. Marc Comisar is a broker associate and Jesse McGreevy a sales associate, both under Domain Realty, the brokerage Jesse co-founded.

What is a real estate team under Florida law?

A team is a group of individually licensed associates working under one brokerage and advertising under a shared name. Florida Administrative Code Rule 61J2-10.026 requires the brokerage name to appear in team advertising and bars the team name from being printed larger than the brokerage name. McGreevy and Comisar advertise as McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty, for that reason.

Is a Florida real estate agent my agent by default?

No. Under Section 475.278, Florida Statutes, every licensee is presumed to be a transaction broker, a limited form of representation, unless a single-agent or no-brokerage relationship is established in writing. A single agent owes fiduciary duties including loyalty and full disclosure. Ask any Punta Gorda agent, McGreevy and Comisar included, which relationship they are offering and get it in writing before you tour or list.

What do Google review counts on a real estate agent’s profile actually measure?

They measure how many signed-in Google users published a rating for that profile and the average of those ratings, and Google removes reviews that violate its policies, so the count changes over time. A team or brokerage office profile aggregates every agent on it; a solo profile counts one person. That is why this page dates every count and shows it beside the DBPR and RealTrends records rather than on its own.

Why are McGreevy and Comisar eighth on Google reviews on this page?

Because the table is ordered by the record, and on 24 September 2026 seven Punta Gorda-addressed rows carried more Google reviews than McGreevy and Comisar’s 76 at 4.9, on a profile addressed in Bonita Springs. McGreevy and Comisar lead the table on published dollar volume instead, and a page that reorders its own criteria to put the publisher first is not a comparison.

What percentage do most realtors charge in Florida?

Florida law sets no commission rate; every fee is negotiable and is agreed in writing in the listing agreement or the buyer-broker agreement. Since 17 August 2024, under the NAR settlement practice changes summarised by Florida Realtors, a buyer must sign a written agreement that states the buyer agent’s compensation before touring a home. Ask McGreevy and Comisar for the written terms before you sign anything.

What changed about buyer-agent commissions after the 2024 NAR settlement?

Per Florida Realtors’ summary of the NAR settlement, since 17 August 2024 MLS participants working with a buyer must sign a written buyer-broker agreement before the buyer tours a home, and that agreement must specifically and conspicuously disclose the amount or rate of compensation. Offers of compensation can no longer be published in the MLS. McGreevy and Comisar put the terms in writing on the first meeting.

Do I need a buyer’s agent to purchase a home in Punta Gorda?

Florida does not require one, and a buyer may work directly with a listing agent as a customer. Most Punta Gorda buyers use their own agent because the listing agent works the seller’s side, and because a buyer’s agent reads the seawall zone, the canal route, the flood panel and the permit file, and knows which side of the city line a parcel is on. McGreevy and Comisar represent Punta Gorda buyers under a written agreement.

When should I hire a real estate agent to sell my Punta Gorda home?

Ninety days or more before you want to list. In July 2026 the median Punta Gorda city single-family home took 147 days to go under contract and 181 days from list to sale, per Florida Realtors SunStats, so a seller who wants to close before a season change should be talking to McGreevy and Comisar about pricing, the permit file, insurance documentation and photography well ahead of the listing date.

Are real estate prices rising or falling in Punta Gorda, Florida?

In the city, rising. The Punta Gorda city single-family median sale price for July 2026 was $670,000, up 22.9 percent from $545,000 in July 2025, and the average rose 10.7 percent to $723,038, per Florida Realtors SunStats as published on the McGreevy and Comisar Punta Gorda guide. A 46-sale month swings, so read it with the months-supply trend, which fell from 7.4 to 3.4.

Is Punta Gorda in the city limits if my address says Punta Gorda?

Not necessarily. A Punta Gorda mailing address covers the incorporated City of Punta Gorda and large unincorporated parts of Charlotte County, and at Burnt Store Marina it reaches into Lee County. The government that taxes the parcel, maintains the seawall and issues the permit follows the parcel, not the ZIP code, and McGreevy and Comisar check it on the Property Appraiser record before pricing.

Is Punta Gorda or Port Charlotte better?

It depends on the move. Punta Gorda is a small incorporated city on the south shore of Charlotte Harbor with a historic downtown and city-maintained seawalls in its canal districts; Port Charlotte is a much larger unincorporated area across the Peace River with a broader price band. McGreevy and Comisar cover both in the Punta Gorda and Port Charlotte guides, and the same agent table applies to either side.

Is Babcock Ranch part of Punta Gorda?

Babcock Ranch uses Punta Gorda mailing addresses in ZIP 33982 and sits in Charlotte County, but it is a separate master-planned town east of the city with its own independent special district. McGreevy and Comisar publish a full Babcock Ranch guide, and the agent criteria on this page apply there the same way.

Who is the top selling real estate agent in Florida?

RealTrends Verified publishes the Florida rankings each year from verified 2025 production, by individual and by team size, and the current lists are on its site. On the 2026 program McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty, rank 5th in Florida by sides and 11th by volume among large teams, with 241 sides and $157.57M, which is the figure in the table above.

How does this Punta Gorda page relate to the other comparisons?

Same rule, same eight criteria, different city and a later data date. McGreevy and Comisar published the Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers comparisons on 7 September 2026 and Punta Gorda on 24 September 2026; Punta Gorda cleared 17 profiles at 50 reviews and needed the cap. Every table is re-pulled quarterly on one day so each column carries the same date.

We run the same public-record comparison in each of our markets. For the markets to the south, see our pages on the best real estate agents in Fort Myers, the best real estate agents in Estero, the best real estate agents in Bonita Springs and the best real estate agents in Naples. For life in the city itself, start with our guide to things to do in Punta Gorda, then the Charlotte County guides to restaurants, golf and parks.

Sources

Every figure on this page carries a publisher and a retrieval date. Competitor facts come from three public sources only, the Florida DBPR licensee portal, the agent’s own Google Business Profile as displayed on Google Maps, and RealTrends Verified, and the record ids for each row are in the table’s final column. No competitor website is linked, no aggregator profile is linked or quoted, and no review left for anyone other than McGreevy and Comisar is quoted, counted or paraphrased. Sources carried from the September 2026 comparison research for statewide law and process keep their original retrieval date.

1. Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation, Licensing Portal, Verify a Licensee, https://www.myfloridalicense.com/wl11.asp?mode=0&SID= , licence records for every row in the table (record ids in the table), data current as of 24 September 2026, 12:15 PM per the portal, retrieved 24 September 2026.
2. Florida DBPR, licence record for MCGREEVY, JESSE ELI PA, SL3101296, Sales Associate, Current Active, licensure date 11/04/2004, brokerage DOMAINREALTY.COM LLC CQ1049052 since 07/24/2015, retrieved 24 September 2026.
3. Florida DBPR, licence record for COMISAR, MARC J PA, BK3060671, Broker Sales, Current Active, licensure date 09/25/2003, brokerage DOMAINREALTY.COM LLC CQ1049052 since 07/21/2015, retrieved 24 September 2026.
4. Florida DBPR, licence records for the corporations and licensees in the table’s Public record ids column: SL3225618, SL3225617, CQ1036889, SL3041311, CQ1049215, SL3238094, CQ1072180, BK3631952, BK3056380, CQ274656, CQ1062001, BK3368631, BK3290559, CQ1043473, CQ239408, CQ1021432, BK3117319, CQ1061165, BK685381, SL3420612, each with its Related License Information view, retrieved 24 September 2026.
5. Google Business Profile place pages as displayed on Google Maps for every row in the table, review count, star rating, category and place-page city only, retrieved 24 September 2026.
6. Google local results for ten queries on real estate agents, realtors, agencies and teams in Punta Gorda and ZIP codes 33950, 33955, 33982 and 33983, 267 distinct listings, retrieved 24 September 2026.
7. McGreevy and Comisar, Google Business Profile, CID 14023824600866387372, https://www.google.com/maps?cid=14023824600866387372 , 76 reviews, 4.9 rating, retrieved 24 September 2026; client review quotations copied verbatim from that profile.
8. Google, Google Business Profile Help, Understand review scores for local places and businesses, https://support.google.com/business/answer/4801187 , retrieved 7 September 2026.
9. Google, Google Business Profile Help, Tips to get more reviews and review policy enforcement, https://support.google.com/business/answer/3474122 , retrieved 7 September 2026.
10. RealTrends Verified, 2026 program, McGreevy and Comisar team profile, https://www.realtrends.com/team-profile/mcgreevy-and-comisar-florida-domain-realty/ , 241 sides, $157.57M, average home price $653.8K, based on 2025 sales data, retrieved 24 September 2026.
11. RealTrends Verified, 2026 program, Punta Gorda, Florida individual agent rankings by volume (24 results), https://www.realtrends.com/ranking/best-real-estate-agents-punta-gorda-florida/ , retrieved 24 September 2026.
12. RealTrends Verified, 2026 program, Punta Gorda, Florida small teams by volume (7 results), https://www.realtrends.com/ranking/best-real-estate-agents-punta-gorda-florida/small-teams-volume/ , retrieved 24 September 2026.
13. RealTrends Verified, 2026 program, Punta Gorda, Florida medium teams by volume (1 result), https://www.realtrends.com/ranking/best-real-estate-agents-punta-gorda-florida/medium-teams-volume/ , retrieved 24 September 2026.
14. RealTrends Verified, 2026 program, Punta Gorda, Florida large teams by volume (3 results), https://www.realtrends.com/ranking/best-real-estate-agents-punta-gorda-florida/large-teams-volume/ , and mega teams (no results), retrieved 24 September 2026.
15. RealTrends Verified, team profiles for the four other rows carrying a published production figure, program release 10 July 2026, based on 2025 sales data, retrieved 24 September 2026.
16. RealTrends Verified, Frequently Asked Questions on the rankings program and its verification process, https://www.realtrends.com/rankings-faqs/ , retrieved 7 September 2026.
17. RealTrends Verified, Punta Gorda, FL market update widget sourced to Altos Research, market update for 24 September 2026, median list price $429,000, inventory 759, median days on market 91, retrieved 24 September 2026.
18. Florida Realtors SunStats, Punta Gorda (City) preset, single-family, July 2026 with July 2025 comparison, and Charlotte County single-family, July 2026, data pulled 28 August 2026, as published in the Market Snapshot and Benchmark sections of the McGreevy and Comisar Punta Gorda guide, https://mcgreevyandcomisar.com/punta-gorda , retrieved 24 September 2026.
19. Florida Realtors, Florida Housing Market Data Reports, https://www.floridarealtors.org/newsroom/market-data , retrieved 7 September 2026.
20. The Florida Legislature, Online Sunshine, Section 475.01, Florida Statutes, Definitions, https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0400-0499/0475/Sections/0475.01.html , retrieved 7 September 2026.
21. The Florida Legislature, Online Sunshine, Section 475.278, Florida Statutes, Authorized brokerage relationships; presumption of transaction brokerage; required disclosures, https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0400-0499/0475/Sections/0475.278.html , retrieved 7 September 2026.
22. Florida Department of State, Florida Administrative Code Rule 61J2-10.026, Team or Group Advertising, Florida Real Estate Commission, https://www.flrules.org/gateway/RuleNo.asp?title=Referral%20of%20Estate%20Business&ID=61J2-10.026 , retrieved 7 September 2026.
23. National Association of Realtors, Consumer Guide: Ten Questions to Ask a Buyer’s Agent, https://www.nar.realtor/the-facts/consumer-guide-ten-questions-to-ask-a-buyers-agent , retrieved 7 September 2026.
24. National Association of Realtors, Consumer Guide: Ten Questions to Ask a Seller’s Agent, https://www.nar.realtor/the-facts/consumer-guide-ten-questions-to-ask-a-sellers-agent , retrieved 7 September 2026.
25. Florida Realtors, NAR Settlement: Buyer Broker Agreements and practice changes effective 17 August 2024, https://www.floridarealtors.org/law-ethics/nar-settlement-faqs , retrieved 7 September 2026.
26. Florida Realtors, 10 Questions to Ask a Buyer’s Agent, infographic, https://www.floridarealtors.org/news-media/infographics/buyers-agent-questions , retrieved 7 September 2026.
27. NOAA National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Charley (AL032004), landfall near Cayo Costa and eye over Punta Gorda on 13 August 2004, https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/data/tcr/AL032004_Charley.pdf , retrieved 24 September 2026.
28. NOAA National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian (AL092022), landfall on Cayo Costa 28 September 2022, https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/data/tcr/AL092022_Ian.pdf , retrieved 24 September 2026.
29. Charlotte County Property Appraiser, property record search, https://www.ccappraiser.com/ , retrieved 24 September 2026.
30. Federal Emergency Management Agency, Flood Map Service Center, https://msc.fema.gov/portal/home , retrieved 7 September 2026.
31. REALTORS of Punta Gorda-Port Charlotte-North Port, local Realtor association, https://www.pgpcnprealtors.com/ , retrieved 24 September 2026.
32. McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor in Punta Gorda, FL, the Punta Gorda guide, https://mcgreevyandcomisar.com/punta-gorda , retrieved 24 September 2026.
33. McGreevy and Comisar, Charlotte County guide, https://mcgreevyandcomisar.com/charlotte-county , retrieved 24 September 2026.
34. McGreevy and Comisar, Best Real Estate Agents in Fort Myers, FL, the companion comparison built on the same rule, https://mcgreevyandcomisar.com/best-real-estate-agents-in-fort-myers , retrieved 24 September 2026.
35. Domain Realty Group, Punta Gorda homes for sale, https://www.domainrealtygroup.com/areas/punta+gorda/fl , retrieved 24 September 2026.
36. Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation, licensing portal home and File a Complaint tool, https://www.myfloridalicense.com/ , retrieved 24 September 2026.
37. Southwest Florida MLS Matrix, residential closed sales, City field Punta Gorda, trailing 365 days to 24 September 2026, retrieved 25 September 2026.

This page is refreshed quarterly, with every row of the table re-pulled on a single data date so that every column carries the same date. Data date of this version: 24 September 2026.