Updated November 2026 · By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty
You buy a home in Stillwater, Englewood in 2026 one of two ways: a new Pulte home inside gated Shores at Stillwater, or a resale built from 2000 to 2013 on Stillwater Units 1, 2 or 3. We tracked 35 qualified home sales across the five plats from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026.
Stillwater lies along Medical Boulevard east of Pine Street, next to HCA Florida Englewood Hospital; its homes carry Englewood 34223 addresses but sit in unincorporated Sarasota County (HCA Florida Englewood Hospital). It is not a city, and it is not Stillwater on the Bay in Sarasota or Stillwater Cay in Estero. On the county roll it is five recorded plats, three older ones named Stillwater Unit 1, 2 and 3 and two Pulte phases named Shores at Stillwater 1A and 1B. Our Stillwater neighborhood guide describes the streets, lakes and setting. This page is the buying manual, from the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012. To start a Stillwater search, Call Marc at (239) 287-5873, or use our Stillwater buyer consultation form.
Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser bulk file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales through October 13, 2026; 12 months October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; Pulte plans, prices and offer terms as listed on pulte.com November 18, 2026; Shores at Stillwater Community Development District June 15, 2026 meeting book and FY2026/27 final budget.)
The two purchases look alike on a map and differ on paper. On the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file, the 35 sales in the 12-month window split into 16 Pulte first sales at Shores at Stillwater and 19 resales on the three older plats. The Pulte first sales had a $523,250 median, a middle half of $419,450 to $662,575, a median of 1,962 heated square feet and $267 per heated square foot. On the older plats, 19 owner-to-owner resales closed at a $315,000 median and $203 per heated square foot. No Shores home has resold yet in the county record, so every Shores figure on this page is a sale from Pulte to its first owner.
The older plats are not one market either. Stillwater Unit 3, the plat of smaller homes built from 2007 to 2013, recorded 10 resales at a $282,500 median, $198 per heated square foot and a median of 1,349 heated square feet. Units 1 and 2, the larger homes built from 2000 to 2007, recorded 9 resales, a small group, at a $550,000 median and a median of 2,368 heated square feet (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Every 12-month sale under $300,000 was a Unit 3 home, 6 of 6.
One cost belongs to Shores alone. The Shores at Stillwater Community Development District (CDD) levies a debt assessment of up to about $1,383 a year on a 34-foot villa lot and about $1,915 on a 52-foot lot, plus an operations rate of about $276 a unit, and the district says amounts may fluctuate (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). The district's boundary covers Shores at Stillwater; confirm on the tax bill that an older-plat home carries no CDD line.
We count the same way everywhere on this page. Price per square foot uses the county's heated living area, so garage and lanai space is not in the divisor. Fewer than 10 sales makes a small group, labeled with its n, and we never turn a small group into a percentage. And every figure names its group, Pulte first sales at Shores, Unit 3 resales or Units 1 and 2 resales, because each prices on its own terms (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
Work with McGreevy and Comisar in Stillwater because the two ways in carry different paperwork: Pulte's own purchase agreement, a CDD and a developer-run HOA at Shores, or a Florida Realtors resale contract, an owner-run association and a 2000 to 2013 roof on the older plats. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar handle your purchase themselves.
Here are the credentials behind that work:
Contact us directly:
If you're searching for "the best buyer's agent in Stillwater, Englewood, Florida," McGreevy and Comisar represents homebuyers across Englewood, Venice, North Port, Sarasota County and Charlotte County, as well as Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples, Fort Myers, Lee County, Collier County, and Babcock Ranch. Whether you're relocating, investing, buying your first home, or upgrading to luxury, including in Stillwater, Shores at Stillwater, Boca Royale, Wellen Park, Rotonda West and along Lemon Bay, our team provides honest market guidance, pre-MLS access, partner-level negotiation, and a clear plan to help you buy confidently. Comparing agents before you register anyone with Pulte? Our guide to the top real estate agents in Englewood sets out what to ask an agent about a builder purchase agreement, a CDD disclosure and an older home's roof file before you choose.
A Shores at Stillwater buyer who wants representation should have the agent contact Pulte's sales center and register before the first visit or call, because Pulte publishes no broker participation policy for Shores, no registration window and no co-op rate. The sales consultants at the model work for Pulte, not for you.
What Pulte does publish is thin. Its Shores page carries a contact form with "I am a Realtor," "Realtor Name" and "Realtor Number" fields, a sales line at (941) 389-1010 and a link to a Realtor portal (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Pulte's terms of use and its buying guide say nothing about broker registration or commission (Pulte terms of use; Pulte new construction buying guide). With no co-op terms published for Shores, we work from the strictest reading: register your agent at the first contact, by phone or walk-in, and get the terms in writing.
Florida's side of the arrangement starts before any tour. Florida Realtors' settlement guidance says "A written buyer agreement is required prior to a buyer 'touring a home,'" and compensation must be "objectively ascertainable and not open-ended" (Florida Realtors, NAR settlement FAQs). Florida law presumes every licensee is a transaction broker unless a single agent relationship is set up in writing (s. 475.278, Florida Statutes). So we sign our buyer agreement with you first, ask Pulte in writing what it pays a buyer's broker at Shores, and settle any gap with you before you walk the model. Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 before your first Pulte visit.
Before a Stillwater offer, we read three files Pulte's web page and most listing sheets leave out: the Shores at Stillwater CDD line for the exact lot width, the HOA file for whichever of the three Stillwater associations governs the home, and the tax bill the home will carry after the sale resets it.
The CDD comes first on any Shores home, because Pulte's site does not mention it: the words "community development district" and "CDD" appear nowhere in the text of Pulte's Shores page or its Prestige plan page (Pulte, Prestige plan). The district's own maximum annual debt assessment is about $1,383 on a 34-foot villa lot and about $1,915 on a 52-foot lot, with an operations rate of about $276 a unit; the district's FY2026/27 budget books the operations share as "To Be Collected At Closings" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; FY2026/27 final budget). On a first sale, Florida law puts the CDD notice in bold type immediately before your signature line (s. 190.048, Florida Statutes).
The HOA file is next, and no dues figure is published for any of the three associations. The Florida filings show Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed 2000), Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed 2006) and Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed February 24, 2025) (Shores at Stillwater HOA filing summary; Stillwater Homeowners Association filing summary). Pulte's only words on dues are "Community Association fees required." On a Pulte contract the HOA disclosure summary must come before you sign (s. 720.401, Florida Statutes); on a resale, the estoppel certificate states the assessment and lists every association the parcel belongs to (s. 720.30851, Florida Statutes). We read the declaration, budget and rules before your inspection period ends.
Last is the tax reset. The 2026 millage for unincorporated Sarasota County is 11.3068, and the Englewood Area Fire Control District adds $290.78 a year on a home (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Englewood Area Fire Control District). The Property Appraiser's 2026 notice says a property bought after January 1 "will reset to market value on January 1, 2027" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, 2026 TRIM supplement). A long-held Unit 1 homestead bill tells you little about your own bill, and a new Shores home finished after January 1 may show only land tax on its first bill. We budget from the price, not the seller's bill.
We compare an older Stillwater resale with Pulte's current sheet by size first, then by what each price includes: the resale's lot, pool, upgrades and age against Pulte's base price, lot premium, options, the November credit, a new warranty and a CDD line. Square footage alone misleads, because county group medians run from 1,349 to 2,368 heated square feet.
Pulte's base prices work out to about $197 to $240 per Pulte square foot across its seven plans, from the 2,870-square-foot Mystique Grande to the 1,670-square-foot Prosperity, as computed from Pulte's own list on November 18, 2026 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Recorded Pulte first sales ran a median $267 per heated square foot (n=16), because base prices leave out lot premiums, options and pools (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). So the right Pulte number for a comparison is a priced homesite with options, not the "from" figure.
On the resale side, a $550,000 Units 1 and 2 median (n=9, a small group) buys about 2,368 heated square feet on a 2000 to 2007 house; Pulte lists its 2,080-square-foot-plus Prestige from $452,990 before lot and options. A $282,500 Unit 3 median buys about 1,349 square feet; Pulte's 1,321-square-foot Colton villa is listed from $309,990 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Between those, we price what the older home needs, roof, water heater, windows, against what the new one adds, CDD and HOA, and we show you the monthly result side by side. Quick move-ins are part of the comparison too: Pulte listed 2 on November 18, 2026, a 1,686-square-foot Prosperity at $444,990, shown as down from $518,780, and a 1,579-square-foot Ellenwood villa at $364,990, shown as down from $405,880.
On a Stillwater purchase the two partners who sign this page do the work: Marc Comisar runs buyer calls, showings and the Pulte registration, and Jesse McGreevy runs the sale of any Florida home you need to sell first. No junior agent takes over. Call Marc at (239) 287-5873, or reach Jesse at (239) 898-6072.
Each partner's background is on Jesse McGreevy's profile and Marc Comisar's profile, and the team's history is on our about page. For a question in writing, the Stillwater consultation form near the end of this guide reaches both of us. If you already own in Stillwater and want to move between plats, from a Unit 3 home to a Shores villa or the other way, the Stillwater seller guide covers listing against Pulte's new inventory, and what your Stillwater home is worth starts from the same county file. Selling first? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Choose a new Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater for impact glass, a tile roof and a warranty that starts at your closing, at a $523,250 recorded median plus a CDD line; a Units 1 and 2 resale for about 2,368 heated square feet at a $550,000 median (n=9); or a Unit 3 resale at $282,500.
Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser bulk file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales through October 13, 2026; 12 months October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 and 24 months October 15, 2024 to October 14, 2026; Pulte plans, features, offer and warranty terms as read on pulte.com November 18, 2026; Florida Statutes as published by the Florida Legislature; Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS contract, Rev. 12/24.)
The table sets the three purchases side by side. Price, size and year rows come from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file; the other rows link to the statute, contract form, district record or Pulte page behind them. Where a row says "confirm," no public source settles it for a given home, and the document named is the one that does.
| What you are comparing | New Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater | Units 1 and 2 resale | Unit 3 resale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price figure and count | Recorded Pulte first sales: $523,250 median (n=16, 12 months); Pulte lists seven plans from $309,990 to $565,990 (as listed November 18, 2026; prices change) | $550,000 median (n=9, a small group, 12 months); $555,000 (n=18, 24 months) | $282,500 median (n=10, 12 months); $305,000 (n=21, 24 months) |
| Median heated sq ft | 1,962 for the 16 sold; 1,948 across the 27 built homes on the roll | 2,368 for the 9 sold; roll medians 2,204 (Unit 1) and 2,181 (Unit 2) | 1,349 for the 10 sold and for all 140 homes on the roll |
| Year built | 2025 to 2026 | Unit 1: 2000 to 2007, plus one 2016; Unit 2: 2005 to 2006 | 2007 to 2013 |
| Contract form | Pulte's own purchase agreement (Pulte buying guide) | Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS or Standard contract (AS IS form, Rev. 12/24) | Same Florida Realtors and Florida Bar forms |
| Deposit and escrow | Deposits up to 10 percent of the price go to escrow unless you waive that right in writing (s. 501.1375); Pulte publishes no deposit amount | Amount and escrow agent written into the contract; any additional deposit due 10 days after the effective date if left blank | Same as Units 1 and 2 |
| Inspection access | Pulte's field manager runs foundation, frame and pre-drywall inspections; Pulte states its quality review is by "Pulte Homes employees, and not outside consultants"; your own inspector's access is not published, so we write it into the agreement (Pulte Build Quality Experience) | The AS IS form gives 15 days to inspect when the blank is empty, and you may cancel within that period | The same 15-day blank applies |
| Warranty position | Pulte's book: 1 year workmanship, 2 years systems, 5 years certain water intrusion, 10 years structural, all from closing; the purchase agreement and warranty booklet delivered at contract control | Any original builder terms on a 2000 to 2007 home have run out; the 7-year repose under s. 95.11 has passed | Same; the 7-year repose under s. 95.11 has passed for every Unit 3 home |
| Roof and insurance position | Tile roof and whole-house impact windows included (Pulte, Prestige features) | Homes 19 to 26 years old in 2026; Citizens asks for a four-point on homes over 20 years; original roofs predate March 1, 2009 | Homes 13 to 19 years old; 2007 and 2008 roofs predate March 1, 2009; four-point line arrives from 2027 |
| Financing path | Any lender; Pulte says you are "not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage," but its forward-commitment rates require Pulte Mortgage | Any lender; no builder incentive | Any lender; no builder incentive |
| CDD and HOA | Shores at Stillwater CDD (debt plus operations) and the Shores at Stillwater HOA, in its developer period | No CDD line expected (confirm on the tax bill); the estoppel names each association; no dues published | No CDD line expected (confirm on the tax bill); Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association; no dues published |
| Gate and amenities as recorded | Pulte: "Gated, with Heated Pool & Cabana," BBQ grills and mail kiosks; the Englewood Sun reported two private gated entries from Pine Street | None found in public documents; read the declaration's common area article | The association's website menu lists "Gate Code Request" and "Clubhouse Reservation" |
Two rows deserve more than a table cell. The deposit row protects you only if you leave the escrow right in place: Florida requires the builder's contract to carry, in conspicuous type, the statement that the buyer may have all deposit funds up to 10 percent of the price placed in escrow and that "THIS RIGHT MAY BE WAIVED, IN WRITING, BY THE BUYER" (s. 501.1375, Florida Statutes). At Pulte's $309,990 entry price that protected amount is up to $30,999, and at the $523,250 Shores median up to $52,325. The same statute treats a failure to close after the certificate of occupancy as a buyer default, so on a to-be-built Shores home your rate lock, insurance binder and any home sale are timed to Sarasota County's certificate, not to a date you picked.
The roof row is the other one. Florida bars an insurer from refusing a policy solely because a roof is under 15 years old, and for an older roof it must allow an inspection showing remaining life before demanding replacement (s. 627.7011, Florida Statutes). Citizens wants proof of at least five years of remaining life on a shingle roof over 25 years old (Citizens inspections). An original roof on a 2000 to 2006 Units 1 and 2 home is 20 to 26 years old, which is why we ask for the roof permit date on the first showing.
A new Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater gives you a twin villa or a detached home built with concrete block, a tile roof, whole-house impact windows and a tankless gas water heater, in a gated section with a heated pool and cabana. Pulte listed seven plans from $309,990 to $565,990 on November 18, 2026; prices change.
| Plan | Type | Heated sq ft (Pulte) | Beds | Stories | Listed "Starting from," November 18, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colton | Villa (attached) | 1,321 | 2 | 1 | $309,990 |
| Ellenwood | Villa (attached) | 1,579 | 2 to 3 | 1 | $331,990 |
| Prosperity | Distinctive (detached) | 1,670+ | 2 to 3 | 1 | $399,990 |
| Mystique | Distinctive (detached) | 1,889+ | 2 to 4 | 1 | $419,990 |
| Palmary | Distinctive (detached) | 1,943+ | 2 to 3 | 1 | $424,990 |
| Prestige | Distinctive (detached) | 2,080+ | 2 to 3 | 1 | $452,990 |
| Mystique Grande | Distinctive (detached) | 2,870+ | 3 to 5 | 2 | $565,990 |
Every row comes from Pulte's Shores at Stillwater page, and none is a sale price. The district record shows how the section is laid out: 255 approved units, 136 attached on 34-foot lots and 119 detached on 52-foot lots, with Phase One holding 136 platted lots, 74 at 34 feet and 62 at 52 feet (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). The villas sit on the 34-foot lots and the Distinctive homes on the 52-foot lots, which is also how the CDD sets each home's assessment.
Pulte's Prestige feature list reads like an insurance worksheet: "Steel-reinforced concrete block construction," "Professionally engineered roof trusses with hurricane tie-downs," "Tile roof," "Whole house impact-resistant vinyl windows," an "Energy-efficient, tankless gas water heater," a "Large, private, brick paver, screened lanai," a "Sentricon Termite Bait System" and an "Electric car outlet in the garage" (Pulte, Prestige plan features). Pulte also says select villa and detached homes can add a private pool. The list is builder-stated and may differ by plan, so we attach the plan's own list to your contract file.
The warranty starts at your closing. In Pulte's national warranty book the clock runs "from closing": one year on workmanship and materials, two years on the mechanical systems, five years on certain water intrusion and ten years on structure, with disputes sent to binding arbitration (Pulte national warranty book). Hurricane and flood damage sit outside it, and the purchase agreement and warranty booklet delivered at contract control. Florida adds a one-year statutory warranty on new homes for material building code violations that holds "even if the newly constructed home is sold or transferred" (s. 553.837, Florida Statutes).
A Stillwater Units 1 and 2 resale gives you the larger older homes: Unit 1 holds 76 homes, all but one built from 2000 to 2007, at a 2,204-square-foot median, and Unit 2 holds 35 built in 2005 and 2006, at 2,181 square feet. We tracked 9 resales in 12 months (a small group) at a $550,000 median.
The 24-month view gives a steadier read: 18 Units 1 and 2 resales at a $555,000 median, a middle half of $500,000 to $605,000, $259 per heated square foot and a median of 2,231 heated square feet (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). By plat over 24 months, Unit 1 recorded 12 resales at a $562,500 median and Unit 2 recorded 6 (a small group) at $546,000. Most of these are three-bedroom homes: 67 of Unit 1's 76 homes and 34 of Unit 2's 35 carry three bedrooms on the roll.
What the price buys is space and a finished lot; what it does not buy is new systems. Apart from the one 2016 home, these homes are 19 to 26 years old in 2026 by their roll dates, and nearly all are past the age at which Citizens asks for a four-point inspection of roof, electrical, plumbing and heating and air (Citizens inspections). The original roofs were permitted before March 1, 2009, so the partial reroof exception for roofs built to the 2007 code and later does not reach them, and a large roof repair can trigger a full replacement under the 25 percent rule. Ask the seller for the roof permit, the most recent wind mitigation form and the water heater date before your inspection period starts.
The upside of age is one statute test. Florida's state home-hardening grant program requires a homestead, an insured value of $700,000 or less and a home built before January 1, 2008, and every Units 1 and 2 home passes the date test; program funding is a separate question we check at the time (s. 215.5586, Florida Statutes).
A Stillwater Unit 3 resale gives you the lowest entry price in Stillwater: 140 smaller homes built from 2007 to 2013, at a 1,349-square-foot median, 82 with two bedrooms and 58 with three. We tracked 10 Unit 3 resales in 12 months at a $282,500 median and $198 per heated square foot.
Over 24 months Unit 3 recorded 21 resales at a $305,000 median, a middle half of $282,500 to $340,000 and $215 per heated square foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Bedroom count splits the 12-month group into two small groups: 6 two-bedroom sales at a $291,000 median and 4 three-bedroom sales at $282,000, too few to read a difference into.
The association's own website carries the title "Villas at Stillwater III," and its menu lists "Gate Code Request," "Clubhouse Reservation," "Villa Maintenance Responsibilities" and an "ACR Request Form," but on November 18, 2026 the site showed a deactivation notice and no documents loaded (Villas at Stillwater III website). That makes the maintenance split the first document to request on a Unit 3 offer: who pays for roofs, exterior paint and any building insurance is set by the declaration, and no public source we read settles it. The estoppel certificate then confirms the assessment and any open violations (s. 720.30851, Florida Statutes).
Age sits in the middle here. Unit 3 homes are 13 to 19 years old in 2026; those built in 2007 and 2008 have roofs permitted before March 1, 2009, and the 12 built in 2007 pass the built-before-2008 date test for the state's home-hardening grants. Citizens' four-point line at 20 years reaches Unit 3 homes from 2027 onward (Citizens inspections).
Shores at Stillwater first sales sit above older-plat resales per square foot, $267 against $203 over 12 months, about 31 percent higher, because they are new 2025 and 2026 homes with impact glass and tile roofs, sold with options and lot premiums, against 2000 to 2013 homes. It is a product gap, not appreciation.
The figures come from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file: 16 Pulte first sales at a $267 median per heated square foot against 19 older-plat resales at $203. Over 24 months the older-plat resale figure is $222 (n=39), and Shores runs about 20 percent above it. No Shores home has resold, so there is no Shores resale price to compare, and a price change over time cannot be measured for Shores yet.
Mix is part of the 12-month gap. Unit 3 homes made up 10 of the 19 resales at $198 per square foot, while Units 1 and 2 resales ran $246 (n=9, a small group). Over 24 months, Units 1 and 2 resales carried $259 per square foot on 18 sales, close to the Shores figure. Inside Shores, size and lot move the number as well: Phase 1A first sales had a $290 median per square foot (n=12) and Phase 1B $248 (n=4, a small group).
For a buyer, the reading is practical. Pulte's base prices run about $197 to $240 per Pulte square foot before lot premiums, options and pools; the recorded $267 is what buyers paid after those choices (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). An appraiser will look at Pulte's own closed sales for a new home and at older-plat resales for an older one, so we build your comparison set from the same group your home belongs to.
The five Stillwater plats compare as three products: Units 1 and 2 hold the larger 2000 to 2007 homes, Unit 3 holds 140 smaller 2007 to 2013 homes, and Shores Phases 1A and 1B hold Pulte's 2025 to 2026 homes with 107 lots still coded vacant. Small groups are flagged below; they set no percentage conclusion.
| Plat | Parcels on the roll | Homes on the roll | Year built | Roll median heated sq ft | 24-month median price (n) | 24-month median per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stillwater Unit 1 | 77 | 76 | 2000 to 2007, plus one 2016 | 2,204 | $562,500 (n=12) | $261 |
| Stillwater Unit 2 | 36 | 35 | 2005 to 2006 | 2,181 | $546,000 (n=6, a small group) | $251 |
| Stillwater Unit 3 | 141 | 140 | 2007 to 2013 | 1,349 | $305,000 (n=21) | $215 |
| Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A | 54 | 27 built across both phases | 2025 to 2026 | 1,948 across both phases | $564,750 first sales (n=12, all history) | $290 |
| Shores at Stillwater Phase 1B | 86 | (included above) | 2025 to 2026 | (included above) | $390,300 first sales (n=4, a small group, all history) | $248 |
Every figure comes from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026. Each older plat carries one parcel coded as a common tract, which is why parcels exceed homes by one. On the Shores phases, 27 homes were built by the roll date, 8 dated 2025 and 19 dated 2026, and 107 lots remained coded vacant; Pulte's "255 future front doors" points to more phases than the two on the roll (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater).
Over 12 months, Unit 1 recorded 7 resales (a small group) at a $550,000 median, Unit 2 only 2, too few for a median, and Unit 3 10 at $282,500. No plat median sets the value of one house: we price your target home from closed sales that match its plan, size and build year, assembled before each offer. The Stillwater home valuation page shows the same county data from the owner's side.
In Stillwater, a budget under $300,000 buys a Unit 3 home of about 1,349 heated square feet, since all 6 sales under that line in 12 months were Unit 3; $477,000 to $580,000, the Units 1 and 2 middle half (n=9), buys about 2,368 heated square feet; and Pulte's Shores middle half ran $419,450 to $662,575.
Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser bulk file dated October 21, 2026; qualified sales of improved homes, 12 months October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, 6 months April 15 to October 14, 2026 and 24 months October 15, 2024 to October 14, 2026; heated area from the county roll; Pulte plan prices as listed November 18, 2026.)
Age and plat set the price in Stillwater more than any single feature, so the budget tables split sales by the three groups rather than by one community median. The first table counts sales in each price band and shows which group they came from; the second gives each group's median, middle half, price per heated square foot and size. Both come from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file. Shores figures are Pulte first sales only, and because Pulte's first Shores closings came in 2026, the Shores row is the same in both windows.
| Price band | 12-month sales | Unit 3 / Units 1 and 2 / Shores (12 months) | 24-month sales | Unit 3 / Units 1 and 2 / Shores (24 months) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $300,000 | 6 | 6 / 0 / 0 | 7 | 7 / 0 / 0 |
| $300,000 to $449,999 | 8 | 4 / 0 / 4 | 18 | 14 / 0 / 4 |
| $450,000 to $599,999 | 15 | 0 / 8 / 7 | 20 | 0 / 13 / 7 |
| $600,000 and up | 6 | 0 / 1 / 5 | 10 | 0 / 5 / 5 |
| Group | Window | Sales | Median price | Middle half | Median per heated sq ft | Median heated sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unit 3 resales | 12 months | 10 | $282,500 | $266,875 to $302,750 | $198 | 1,349 |
| Unit 3 resales | 24 months | 21 | $305,000 | $282,500 to $340,000 | $215 | 1,349 |
| Units 1 and 2 resales | 12 months | 9 (a small group) | $550,000 | $477,000 to $580,000 | $246 | 2,368 |
| Units 1 and 2 resales | 24 months | 18 | $555,000 | $500,000 to $605,000 | $259 | 2,231 |
| Shores Pulte first sales | 12 and 24 months | 16 | $523,250 | $419,450 to $662,575 | $267 | 1,962 |
Two readings stand out. The bands barely overlap by group: no Units 1 and 2 resale sold under $450,000 in either window, and no Unit 3 resale reached $450,000, so a Stillwater search is really two or three separate searches by budget. And the newest six months lean toward Pulte: from April 15 to October 14, 2026 we tracked 12 Shores first sales at a $523,250 median, with a middle half of $462,500 to $695,975, against 7 older-plat resales at a $300,000 median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
Pulte's own sheet overlaps both older groups. Its two villa plans are listed from $309,990 and $331,990, just above the Unit 3 middle half, and its five Distinctive plans from $399,990 to $565,990, below and into the Units 1 and 2 range, as listed November 18, 2026 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). The listed figure is a base price; the recorded Shores median sits above it because buyers add lots, options and pools.
A Stillwater budget under $300,000 buys a Unit 3 resale: all 6 sales under $300,000 in the 12 months to October 14, 2026 were Unit 3 homes, and the Unit 3 middle half ran $266,875 to $302,750. Expect about 1,349 heated square feet, two or three bedrooms, two baths and a 2007 to 2013 build date.
The county file shows how size and age move a Unit 3 price. Over 12 months, older-plat homes of 1,200 to 1,399 heated square feet sold at a $283,750 median (n=6, a small group) and those of 1,400 to 1,799 square feet at $282,500 (n=4, a small group); over 24 months the same bands ran $300,000 (n=11) and $318,750 (n=10) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). By year built, 24-month older-plat sales of 2007 to 2009 homes had a $318,750 median (n=6, a small group) and 2010 to 2016 homes $300,000 (n=15). Every Unit 3 home carries two baths on the roll.
Three costs follow a sub-$300,000 Unit 3 purchase that the price does not show. The association's maintenance split decides whether roof and exterior work is yours or shared, and its website was deactivated when we checked on November 18, 2026 (Villas at Stillwater III website). Citizens' four-point line at 20 years reaches Unit 3 homes from 2027 onward (Citizens inspections). And from January 1, 2027 every Citizens wind policy needs flood coverage, regardless of value (Citizens flood requirement). The new alternative near this budget is Pulte's 1,321-square-foot Colton villa, listed from $309,990, with the Shores CDD on top.
The Stillwater Units 1 and 2 middle half sits at $477,000 to $580,000 over the 12 months to October 14, 2026, on 9 resales (a small group) with a $550,000 median and 2,368 heated square feet. Over 24 months, on 18 resales, the middle half was $500,000 to $605,000 at a $555,000 median.
Inside that range, size and age move the price less than you might expect. Over 24 months, older-plat homes of 1,800 to 2,199 heated square feet sold at a $560,000 median (n=9, a small group) and those of 2,200 to 2,599 square feet at $550,000 (n=9, a small group); homes built from 2000 to 2004 had a $560,000 median (n=9) and those built in 2005 and 2006 $550,000 (n=9), each a small group (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). No older-plat home of 2,600 square feet or more sold in either window, and the $600,000-and-up band held 1 Units 1 and 2 resale in 12 months and 5 in 24 months.
So a $500,000 to $600,000 budget is where the real Stillwater choice sits. At that level you can price a 2,200-square-foot Units 1 and 2 home on a finished lot against a Pulte Prestige, listed from $452,990 for 2,080-plus square feet, or a two-story Mystique Grande from $565,990, each before lot premium, options and the CDD (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). The older home brings space, a finished lot and mature landscaping; the Pulte home brings a new roof, impact glass and a warranty clock that starts at closing. We put the CDD, HOA, roof and insurance lines next to each before you decide.
The Shores at Stillwater middle half sits at $419,450 to $662,575 across 16 Pulte first sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, with a $523,250 median, 1,962 heated square feet and $267 per square foot. Pulte's current sheet lists seven plans from $309,990 to $565,990; prices change.
Plan type and size move the Shores figure. Two-bedroom first sales (n=9, a small group) had a $455,000 median and three-bedroom sales (n=5, a small group) $532,400; Shores homes under 1,800 heated square feet sold at a $401,600 median (n=5, a small group) and those of 1,800 to 2,199 square feet at $564,750 (n=10) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Recorded Shores prices sit above Pulte's base sheet because a contract price adds the homesite premium, structural options, design choices and, often, a pool.
Pulte's November offer changes the arithmetic for a contract it accepts by November 30, 2026. Pulte lists "a standard pool, valued at $69,500" on select to-be-built homes, or a $77,000 credit "toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins as a reduction to the total purchase price"; the credit "cannot be combined with other offers or incentives," the pool terms add that "Any credit received may not be used to decrease the base price," and acceptance is "in the sole and absolute discretion of Pulte Homes" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Pulte also warns the offer "may affect the amount of loan for which a buyer may be eligible," so we have your lender read it before you sign.
Every Shores at Stillwater home carries a CDD debt assessment of up to about $1,915 a year, and none of Stillwater's three associations publishes its dues. Book your Stillwater buyer consultation, read our buying page, or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873. Selling a Stillwater home first, start with our Stillwater home valuation and Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Now is a workable time to buy in Stillwater if a 7.11 percent rate fits your payment: older-plat resale prices per heated square foot have eased from a 2023 peak of $316 (n=3, a small group) to about $200 to $211 in 2026, while Pulte's November offer runs through November 30, 2026.
Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser bulk file dated October 21, 2026, qualified older-plat resales by quarter from 2021 to October 13, 2026, Shores first sales by quarter, resale counts by calendar year from 2016, sales by month for the 12 months October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; Florida Realtors Sarasota County summaries for October 2026, released November 16, 2026; Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey for the week of November 12, 2026 and its history file; Pulte offer terms as listed November 18, 2026; CRS Insight IN10835; Citizens flood requirement page; Florida Division of Elections results page.)
Timing in Stillwater runs on four clocks: the county price record for the older plats, Pulte's sales calendar at Shores, the mortgage rate, and the insurance and tax dates at the turn of the year. The county file answers the first, Pulte's own page the second, Freddie Mac the third, and Congress, Citizens and the state the fourth. MLS-only measures for Stillwater (days on market, sale-to-list ratio, months of supply for Stillwater, active listings): Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). So this section leans on the county deed record for Stillwater and on Florida Realtors for Sarasota County as a whole.
The county record says Stillwater's older-plat resale price per heated square foot climbed from $187 in early 2021 to a $316 peak in the third quarter of 2023 (n=3, a small group), held near $262 to $265 through early 2025, then eased to $211 in the first quarter of 2026 and $200 in the second.
| Quarter | Older-plat resales | Median per heated sq ft | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 Q1 | 6 | $187 | small group |
| 2021 Q2 | 5 | $191 | small group |
| 2021 Q4 | 2 | too few for a median | |
| 2022 Q1 | 6 | $250 | small group |
| 2022 Q2 | 3 | $282 | small group |
| 2022 Q4 | 2 | too few for a median | |
| 2023 Q2 | 7 | $267 | small group |
| 2023 Q3 | 3 | $316 | small group |
| 2024 Q1 | 2 | too few for a median | |
| 2024 Q2 | 4 | $262 | small group |
| 2024 Q3 | 1 | too few for a median | |
| 2024 Q4 | 6 | $264 | small group |
| 2025 Q1 | 6 | $265 | small group |
| 2025 Q2 | 5 | $222 | small group |
| 2025 Q3 | 4 | $215 | small group |
| 2025 Q4 | 2 | too few for a median | |
| 2026 Q1 | 10 | $211 | |
| 2026 Q2 | 5 | $200 | small group |
| 2026 Q3 | 2 | too few for a median |
The table counts resales on Units 1, 2 and 3 from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file; quarters with no qualified older-plat resale are left out, and the third quarter of 2026 is partial. Only one quarter, the first of 2026, holds 10 sales, so read the direction across the quarters rather than any single figure. Mix moves it too: a quarter heavy with Unit 3 homes prints lower per square foot than one heavy with Units 1 and 2.
Grouping by half year smooths the line. Two halves hold 10 or more older-plat resales: January to June 2025, with 11 sales at a $257 median per heated square foot, and January to June 2026, with 15 sales at $200 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Between them sit the two halves of 2024 at $262 and $269 and the second half of 2025 at $215, each a small group of 6 or 7. Unit 3 homes, which carry a lower price per square foot, were a larger share of 2026's resales, which helps explain the lower figure.
Resale activity has not dried up. The county counts older-plat resales by calendar year:
| Year | Older-plat resales | Year | Older-plat resales |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | 11 | 2022 | 11 |
| 2017 | 11 | 2023 | 10 |
| 2018 | 27 | 2024 | 13 |
| 2019 | 18 | 2025 | 17 |
| 2020 | 13 | 2026 (through October 13) | 17 |
| 2021 | 13 |
So 2026 had already matched 2025's 17 resales by October 13, the highest count since 2019's 18 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). More resales at lower prices per square foot can give a buyer room to negotiate on an older home, especially one with an original roof.
Shores has a much shorter record, all of it Pulte first sales. The county shows 1 in the first quarter of 2026, 10 in the second quarter at a $533,850 median and $294 per heated square foot, 4 in the third quarter (a small group) at $499,550 and $251, and 1 in the fourth quarter through October 13. Month by month over the 12-month window, the county recorded:
| Month | Older-plat resales | Shores first sales |
|---|---|---|
| November 2025 | 2 | 0 |
| January 2026 | 2 | 0 |
| February 2026 | 5 | 1 |
| March 2026 | 3 | 0 |
| April 2026 | 3 | 4 |
| May 2026 | 1 | 3 |
| June 2026 | 1 | 3 |
| July 2026 | 1 | 1 |
| August 2026 | 0 | 3 |
| September 2026 | 1 | 0 |
| October 2026 (to October 13) | 0 | 1 |
The months shown carry all 19 resales and 16 first sales in the window (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Pulte's closings follow construction completion, which is why they bunch from April to August 2026, while older-plat resales were busiest from January to April.
Sarasota County as a whole sets the backdrop. In October 2026, Florida Realtors data show Sarasota County closed 633 sales of houses, down 5.2 percent from a year earlier, at a $490,000 median, up 10.1 percent, with 4.0 months of supply; townhouses and condos closed at a $325,000 median with 5.4 months of supply (Florida Realtors data via the REALTOR Association of Sarasota and Manatee, October 2026; condo and townhouse summary, October 2026). Against those, the Shores median of $523,250 and the Units 1 and 2 median of $550,000 sit above the county figure for houses, and the Unit 3 median of $282,500 sits below the county condo-townhouse figure. Statewide, Florida Realtors' chief economist put the October slowdown this way: "it's important not to confuse slowing demand with a distressed housing market" (Florida Realtors, October 2026 statewide release).
Each rate point near 7 percent moves a Stillwater payment about $66 to $69 monthly per $100,000 borrowed. At the 7.11 percent rate of November 12, 2026, with 20 percent down, principal and interest is about $2,815 on a $523,000 Shores home, $1,520 on a $282,500 Unit 3 home and $2,960 on a $550,000 Units 1 and 2 home.
On November 12, 2026, Freddie Mac's survey put the 30-year fixed at 7.11 percent, its fourth weekly drop in a row, down from 7.18 percent seven days earlier but up from 6.24 percent twelve months before; 15-year loans averaged 6.45 percent (Freddie Mac). Across 2026 the weekly 30-year reading has ranged between 5.98 percent in February and 7.40 percent in October (Freddie Mac PMMS history). A one-point move on each loan, computed at the November 12 rate:
| Home and loan (20 percent down) | Principal and interest at 7.11% | At 6.11% | At 8.11% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shores, $523,000 price, $418,400 loan | $2,814.60 | $2,538.19 (down $276.42) | $3,102.22 (up $287.61) |
| Unit 3, $282,500 price, $226,000 loan | $1,520.32 | $1,371.01 (down $149.31) | $1,675.67 (up $155.35) |
| Units 1 and 2, $550,000 price, $440,000 loan | $2,959.91 | $2,669.22 (down $290.69) | $3,262.37 (up $302.46) |
The full monthly cost adds taxes, insurance, the fire assessment and, at Shores, the CDD. With price taken as just value at 11.3068 mills non-homestead, the Englewood fire assessment, the Citizens Sarasota County HO3 average premium of $2,901 a year (a county average, not a quote) and HOA dues left out because none is published, the totals are about $3,756 on the $523,000 Shores home with a 52-foot-lot CDD line of about $183 a month, $2,052 on the $282,500 Unit 3 home and $3,744 on the $550,000 Units 1 and 2 home (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Citizens 2026 approved rates by county). The Shores home and the Units 1 and 2 home land within about $12 a month of each other before HOA, flood and real insurance quotes.
Builder financing is part of the rate question at Shores. Pulte's calculator uses an illustrative 6.5 percent conventional rate from a Pulte Mortgage lock window, which would put principal and interest on the same $418,400 loan at about $2,645, and its forward-commitment rates are "only available to qualified borrowers buying certain homes until the pool of funds is depleted or the rate lock period expires" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Pulte also says, "You are not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage to purchase a home from seller." Under RESPA, an affiliated-lender referral is lawful only when the builder leaves the choice of lender to you (12 CFR 1024.15), so we get a Loan Estimate from Pulte Mortgage and one from an outside lender on the same day and compare total cost, not the rate alone.
Five dates sit around year end 2026 for a Stillwater buyer: Pulte's November 30 offer deadline, the December 11 end of the flood insurance program's current authority, January 1, 2027 for homestead status and Citizens' flood rule, the FY2026/27 CDD operations charge collected at Shores closings, and the March 1, 2027 homestead filing deadline.
Pulte's November offer is marketing with conditions, not a price cut. It applies to purchase agreements Pulte accepts from November 2 to November 30, 2026, on select homes; the banner reads "Nov 9-30" while the fine print says November 2, and either way the window closes on Pulte's acceptance, not your signature (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Pulte says "Any unused credit is the property of the builder" and the offer "is subject to change or withdrawal at any time without notice." We compare the net price after credit with the next offer and with an older-plat resale, because builder offers often return under a new name.
Flood insurance has a hard date. The National Flood Insurance Program is authorized until December 11, 2026, and if Congress lets it lapse, the program cannot write new policies or renew old ones, though a policy already in force continues until it expires (CRS Insight IN10835). The National Association of Realtors notes a work-around: an insurer "may assign the seller's NFIP policy to the buyer simply by substituting names," and that private flood insurance is not affected (NAR, NFIP expiration FAQ). That helps an older-plat resale buyer whose seller holds a policy; a new Shores home has no prior policy to assign. From January 1, 2027, Citizens requires flood coverage on "All policies, regardless of value," up from dwelling coverage of $400,000 or more in 2026 (Citizens flood requirement). Whether a given Stillwater lot sits in a flood zone is a lot-by-lot answer: the FEMA map and the lot's elevation certificate confirm it.
Homestead is a January 1 test. Florida asks that you hold title and live in the Stillwater home as your permanent residence on that date, then apply by March 1 (s. 196.011, Florida Statutes). A Stillwater buyer who closes and moves in by December 31, 2026 can file for the 2027 exemption by March 1, 2027; a closing on January 2, 2027 waits until 2028, and the Property Appraiser says "Homestead exemptions are not pro-rated based on a purchase date" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, 2026 TRIM supplement).
Amendment 3 is the tax item to watch. The state's official results page shows voters approved it on November 3, 2026 with 61.98 percent yes; as of November 18, 2026 no official source we read confirmed certification (Florida Division of Elections, Election Watch). WGCU reported that the homestead exemption rises to $150,000 next year and to $250,000 the year after for non-school local taxes (WGCU, November 4, 2026). County implementation for the 2027 roll is not yet published, and the amendment does not reduce the Englewood fire assessment or the Shores CDD line.
The CDD has its own timing at Shores. The district's FY2026/27 budget, covering October 1, 2026 to September 30, 2027, shows the operations share "To Be Collected At Closings" at a rate of about $276 a unit, so in this fiscal year a Shores buyer should look for it on the settlement statement, not the November bill (Shores at Stillwater CDD, FY2026/27 final budget). The debt share can be prepaid: per the district's methodology, the bond principal per lot is $25,726.66 on a 52-foot lot and $18,580.37 on a 34-foot lot; confirm a current payoff with the district manager's office (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book).
Any of these dates can shape a Stillwater offer, so we map them before you write one: schedule a Stillwater buyer consultation. For Englewood beyond Medical Boulevard, our Englewood home buying guide and Englewood community overview widen the search; the Stillwater community guide covers daily life there, and the guide to selling in Stillwater shows how owners read the same calendar. Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
Buying new in Stillwater means buying from Pulte Homes at Shores at Stillwater, the gated section on Phases 1A and 1B and the only part of Stillwater still sold new. The path runs from agent registration at first contact through Pulte's purchase agreement, an escrowed deposit, CDD and HOA disclosures, financing, appraisal, orientations, a final walkthrough and closing.
Data updated: November 2026 (pulte.com Shores at Stillwater community, plan and buying guide pages read November 18, 2026; Florida Statutes text read November 18, 2026; Shores at Stillwater CDD documents read November 18, 2026; Sarasota County Property Appraiser bulk file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026)
On November 18, 2026, Pulte listed seven plans at Shores at Stillwater, from the Colton villa at 1,321 square feet from $309,990 to the two-story Mystique Grande at 2,870+ square feet from $565,990, as listed November 18, 2026; prices change (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). We tracked 16 Pulte first sales at Shores in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, at a median of $523,250 and $267 per heated square foot, with a middle half of $419,450 to $662,575 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser); recorded prices can include lot premiums, options and pools. Our Stillwater community guide covers the five plats, and our Englewood new construction guide compares Shores at Stillwater with the other builders selling around Englewood.
| Step | When it happens | What it means on a new Shores at Stillwater home |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Register your agent | Before or at your first contact with Pulte | Pulte publishes no Shores co-op policy, so the agent registers first and gets terms in writing |
| 2. Choose a plan and homesite | Sales center visit | A to-be-built home or one of Pulte's quick move-in homes |
| 3. Sign the purchase agreement | Day 0 | Pulte's own form governs, not a Florida Realtors/Florida Bar form |
| 4. Pay the deposit | At signing | Up to 10 percent may be escrowed unless you waive it in writing |
| 5. Read the CDD and HOA disclosures | Before or at signing | Bold Shores at Stillwater CDD notice above your signature; HOA disclosure summary before you sign |
| 6. Financing and appraisal | After signing | Pulte Mortgage is optional; rate offers tied to it require it |
| 7. Construction and orientations | During the build | Pulte's Field Manager leads pre-drywall and pre-closing orientations |
| 8. Final walkthrough | Before closing | Your written list of items, signed off with Pulte |
| 9. Closing | After the certificate of occupancy | Closing Disclosure at least 3 business days before; CDD operations share collected at closing in FY2026/27 |
Sources for the table: Pulte homebuying guide, s. 501.1375, s. 190.048, s. 720.401, the Shores at Stillwater CDD FY2026/2027 budget and the CFPB.
Pulte publishes no broker participation policy, registration window or commission rate for Shores at Stillwater, so we work to the strictest reading: your agent contacts the sales center and registers you before or at your first visit, and gets any cooperation terms in writing. Pulte's sales consultants work for Pulte, not for you.
The Shores page carries a contact form with "I am a Realtor" and "Realtor Number" fields and links a Realtor portal, but no written rule (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater), and Pulte's terms of use contain no broker or commission language (Pulte terms of use). Florida Realtors adds that "A written buyer agreement is required prior to a buyer 'touring a home'" (Florida Realtors, NAR settlement FAQs). So the order is fixed: sign the buyer agreement with us, let us register you with Pulte, then tour the models.
At the Shores at Stillwater sales center, Pulte's consultant shows the Villa Collection (Colton and Ellenwood twin villas) and the Distinctive Collection (five detached plans), the homesites still available and any quick move-in homes. You choose between a home Pulte has already started and one built to your selections, and the agreement is written for that homesite.
| Plan (Pulte collection) | Heated sq ft (Pulte) | Beds | Stories | Starting from, as listed November 18, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colton (Villa) | 1,321 | 2 | 1 | $309,990 |
| Ellenwood (Villa) | 1,579 | 2 to 3 | 1 | $331,990 |
| Prosperity (Distinctive) | 1,670+ | 2 to 3 | 1 | $399,990 |
| Mystique (Distinctive) | 1,889+ | 2 to 4 | 1 | $419,990 |
| Palmary (Distinctive) | 1,943+ | 2 to 3 | 1 | $424,990 |
| Prestige (Distinctive) | 2,080+ | 2 to 3 | 1 | $452,990 |
| Mystique Grande (Distinctive) | 2,870+ | 3 to 5 | 2 | $565,990 |
Source: Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, read November 18, 2026; prices change.
On the same day Pulte showed 2 quick move-in homes, both "Available Now": a 1,686 square foot Prosperity at $444,990 ("Was $518,780") and a 1,579 square foot Ellenwood villa at $364,990 ("Was $405,880") (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). The Prestige feature list names a "Tile roof", "Whole house impact-resistant vinyl windows", "Steel-reinforced concrete block construction" and an "Energy-efficient, tankless gas water heater" (Pulte, Prestige plan at Shores at Stillwater); the list may differ by plan. Our first written questions: the lot premium and options inside each price, which homesites face water or preserve, the expected certificate of occupancy date, and whether the lot is a 34-foot villa lot or a 52-foot detached lot, because the CDD charge differs by lot width.
A new Shores at Stillwater home is bought on Pulte's own purchase agreement, not the Florida Realtors/Florida Bar forms used on Stillwater resales. Pulte's guide says you "Finalize floorplan & structural options as well as provide earnest money" at signing, and that your lender must approve the new total price after the design Change Order.
Pulte does not publish the Shores deposit amount, the escrow agent, who pays the owner's title policy and deed stamps, or its appraisal terms; they are in the agreement for the specific homesite, which we read with you before you sign (Pulte homebuying guide). Florida's builder deposit statute treats "the failure of the buyer to close the transaction after issuance of the certificate of occupancy" as default (s. 501.1375, Florida Statutes), so on a to-be-built Shores home your duty to close runs from Sarasota County's certificate of occupancy. Time rate locks, insurance binders and the sale of a current home to that certificate.
Two more questions belong on the list. Englewood Water District's FY27 schedule sets capital capacity charges totaling $15,249 per equivalent residential connection plus $616.50 in AGRF charges for new homes (Englewood Water District FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations); ask Pulte whether those charges are inside the price. And ask which closing agent the agreement names, since Pulte's affiliates include "PGP Title" and "Pulte Insurance Agency" (Pulte homebuying guide).
Florida requires a builder of detached homes and twin villas like those at Shores at Stillwater to tell you that deposits up to 10 percent of the price must go into an escrow account unless you waive that right in writing. If the builder wants to use escrowed money for construction, it must post a surety bond payable to you.
The contract must carry a capitalized legend that the buyer "HAS THE RIGHT TO HAVE ALL DEPOSIT FUNDS (UP TO 10 PERCENT OF THE PURCHASE PRICE) DEPOSITED IN AN ESCROW ACCOUNT. THIS RIGHT MAY BE WAIVED, IN WRITING, BY THE BUYER" (s. 501.1375, Florida Statutes). The escrow holder must be a bank, savings and loan, trust company, Florida Bar attorney, licensed Florida broker or title insurer. A buyer who "properly terminates the contract pursuant to its terms" gets the deposit back with interest, and on buyer default the builder must give written notice by certified mail at least 72 hours before withdrawing escrowed funds. At Pulte's entry price of $309,990 the protected amount is up to $30,999, and at the Shores first-sale median of $523,250 up to $52,325. We look for any waiver line before you sign, because a waived deposit goes into the builder's general funds.
Every first sale of a home inside the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District must carry a boldfaced CDD notice, larger than the rest of the contract's type, immediately above the buyer's signature. Pulte's website does not mention the district, so this contract box is often where a Stillwater buyer first meets it in writing.
The required text says the district "MAY IMPOSE AND LEVY TAXES OR ASSESSMENTS, OR BOTH TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS, ON THIS PROPERTY" and that these are "IN ADDITION TO COUNTY AND OTHER LOCAL GOVERNMENTAL TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS" (s. 190.048, Florida Statutes). On November 18, 2026, neither "CDD" nor "community development district" appeared in the text of Pulte's Shores community page or Prestige plan page (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). The district's June 15, 2026 board book gives a maximum annual debt assessment of about $1,383 for a 34-foot villa lot and about $1,915 for a 52-foot lot, plus an operations rate of about $276 a unit, and the district says amounts "may fluctuate" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 board book). The statute covers initial sales only.
Before you sign for a Shores at Stillwater home, Pulte must hand you the HOA disclosure summary. It says you must join the Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association and pay its assessments, that special district charges may apply, and that the developer may have the right to amend the covenants without owner approval. A missing summary makes the contract voidable.
The statute requires the summary "before executing the contract for sale," and if it comes later the contract "IS VOIDABLE BY BUYER" by written notice "WITHIN 3 DAYS AFTER RECEIPT OF THE DISCLOSURE SUMMARY OR PRIOR TO CLOSING, WHICHEVER OCCURS FIRST" (s. 720.401, Florida Statutes). There is no automatic cooling-off period. Pulte publishes no Shores dues figure, only "Community Association fees required" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater), so the summary and budget show the amount.
You may finance a Shores at Stillwater home with any lender. Pulte says "You are not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage to purchase a home from seller," but its Builder Forward Commitment rate offers need Pulte Mortgage, and its sample payments assume Pulte Mortgage, a 780 FICO score and every incentive applied to closing costs and points.
Pulte's fine print says "use of Pulte Mortgage is necessary to receive BFC-related rate offers where and when available," with rates based on the "Affiliate Incentive Program" and "a FICO Score of 780" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). The Builder Forward Commitment is a rate locked "for a pool of funds," available "until the pool of funds is depleted or the rate lock period expires," and "the sale must close by a specified date." The market benchmark on November 12, 2026 was a 7.11 percent 30-year average and 6.45 percent 15-year (Freddie Mac PMMS).
Federal settlement rules frame the choice: an affiliated business arrangement needs "a written disclosure" at referral, and "No person making a referral has required" the buyer to use a particular provider (12 CFR 1024.15, CFPB); referral kickbacks are barred (12 CFR 1024.14, CFPB). Ask for the affiliated business disclosure and put an outside Loan Estimate beside Pulte Mortgage's on the same day, comparing total cost, not the rate alone.
Pulte's November offer at Shores at Stillwater is a standard pool valued at $69,500 on select to-be-built homes or a $77,000 credit on select homes, for purchase agreements accepted by Pulte between November 2 and November 30, 2026. The two cannot be combined, and acceptance is "in the sole and absolute discretion of Pulte Homes."
The pool disclaimer says "A buyer's submission of a purchase agreement does not constitute acceptance by Pulte Homes and does not entitle buyer to the offer," that "Any credit received may not be used to decrease the base price of the home," and that the offer "may affect the amount of loan for which a buyer may be eligible" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). The credit is "to be used toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins as a reduction to the total purchase price," "cannot be combined with other offers or incentives," and "is subject to change or withdrawal at any time without notice." Pulte's banner reads "Nov 9-30" while both disclaimers say "between 11/2/2026 and 11/30/2026"; either way the window closes on Pulte's acceptance by November 30, 2026. The credit text does not say Pulte Mortgage is required, but the rate side does, so we get Pulte's answer in writing.
An appraiser valuing a new Shores at Stillwater home has only Pulte's own recorded first sales to compare it with, because no Shores home had resold in the county record by October 2026. The appraisal has to support the total price after options, and Pulte warns its offers may affect how much a buyer can borrow.
We tracked 16 Shores first sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, at a median $267 per heated square foot, against a median $203 for 19 resales on the older Stillwater plats (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). That gap reflects new construction, impact glass and tile roofs against homes built from 2000 to 2013, not appreciation, so the appraisal leans on Shores sales. Pulte's credit is applied "as a reduction to the total purchase price" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater), and its guide says the lender must "approve the new total purchase price" after the design Change Order (Pulte homebuying guide), so heavy options raise the value the appraisal must reach. If it falls short, the agreement sets what happens next.
Pulte runs its own quality checks at Shores at Stillwater and invites you to orientations, but no Pulte page or document read on November 18, 2026 grants or refuses access for your own licensed inspector. Write that access into the purchase agreement or an addendum before you sign, because a quick move-in home is already past drywall.
Pulte's Build Quality Experience brochure lists foundation, frame and "PRE-DRYWALL" inspections, an orientation "Before we put up the drywall," a final inspection and a service representative's review, and states "Quality review is performed on-site by Pulte Homes employees, and not outside consultants" (Pulte Build Quality Experience brochure). The brochure is a 2016 national edition; Pulte's current guide names "Pre-Drywall Orientation" and "Pre-Closing Orientation" (Pulte homebuying guide). A Florida home inspection is "a limited visual examination" (s. 468.8311, Florida Statutes), so straps, plumbing and duct joints are visible only before drywall. We ask for a pre-drywall and a pre-closing visit by an inspector with no tie to Pulte.
At Shores at Stillwater, Pulte's Field Manager walks you through the finished home at the Pre-Closing Orientation, and the "Celebration" step is, in Pulte's words, "the most important inspection: yours." Bring a written list, have every item recorded, and send later requests only to Pulte, as its warranty book directs.
Pulte follows move-in with feedback "90 days after move-in" and a one-year review (Pulte Build Quality Experience brochure). At the walkthrough we check what Pulte's standards measure, such as roof tile alignment, stucco cracks wider than 1/8 inch and drywall texture, and confirm that the pool, lanai and options you paid for are the ones installed.
Closing on a Shores at Stillwater home follows the county's certificate of occupancy. Your lender's Closing Disclosure arrives at least three business days before, and for the district's 2026/27 fiscal year the CDD operations share is "To Be Collected At Closings," so expect it on the settlement statement rather than the November tax bill.
The CFPB says "The lender is required to give you the Closing Disclosure at least three business days before you close" (CFPB, Closing Disclosure). The district's final FY2026/2027 budget marks its operations assessments "To Be Collected At Closings" (Shores at Stillwater CDD FY2026/2027 final budget). On a Pulte contract, Pulte's form, not Sarasota County custom, sets who pays the owner's title policy and deed stamps, so we read those lines first, and we confirm wiring instructions by phone with the closing agent before any money moves.
#1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and on a new Shores at Stillwater home we register you with Pulte before your first visit, read the deposit, CDD and HOA pages of the agreement with you, and set Pulte Mortgage's numbers beside an outside Loan Estimate on the same day. To start, book your Stillwater buyer consultation, see our buying process or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873. Own a home to sell first? Start with your Stillwater home valuation and Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
An older Stillwater resale is a home on Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2 or Unit 3, built from 2000 to 2013, bought from its owner on a Florida Realtors/Florida Bar contract. You sign a buyer agreement, get pre-approved, pick the AS IS or standard form, deposit, inspect, read the disclosures, order the estoppel and title, appraise and close.
Data updated: November 2026 (Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS contract, Rev. 12/24 with 2026 redline; Florida Statutes text read November 18, 2026; DBPR estoppel fee schedule; Florida Administrative Code title rates; Sarasota County Property Appraiser bulk file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026)
We tracked 19 resales on the older Stillwater plats in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, at a median of $315,000 and $203 per heated square foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Ten were Unit 3 homes at a median $282,500 for a median 1,349 square feet, and all 6 sales under $300,000 in that window were Unit 3 homes. Nine were Unit 1 and Unit 2 detached homes, a small group (n=9), at a median $550,000 for 2,368 square feet. Every older Stillwater home was built from 2000 to 2013 except one 2016 Unit 1 home, and all sit outside the Shores at Stillwater CDD. Our Stillwater seller page explains the same transaction from the owner's side.
| Step | Default timing on the Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS form | What it means for an older Stillwater resale |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Written buyer agreement | Before touring | Signed with your agent before the first showing |
| 2. Offer and Effective Date | Day 0, the last signature | Radon, property tax and flood disclosures at or before signing; HOA summary before you sign |
| 3. Additional deposit | 10 days after the Effective Date if left blank | Paid to the escrow agent named in the contract |
| 4. Inspection Period ends | 15 days after the Effective Date if left blank | Cancel in writing before it ends and the deposit comes back |
| 5. Flood elevation exit | 20 days after the Effective Date if left blank | Only if the home is in a Special Flood Hazard Area and below minimum elevation or ineligible for coverage |
| 6. Loan approval | 30 days after the Effective Date if left blank | Your lender's commitment |
| 7. Estoppel certificate | Within 10 business days of request | From each association the home belongs to |
| 8. Title commitment | 15 days before closing if left blank (5 if cash) | Seller's prior owner's policy due within 5 days of the Effective Date |
| 9. Walk-through | The day before the Closing Date, or on the Closing Date before closing | Confirms condition and repairs |
| 10. Closing Disclosure and closing | 3 business days, then the Closing Date | Taxes prorated; Stillwater Units 1 to 3 carry no CDD line |
Sources for the table: Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS Residential Contract, 2026 redline, s. 720.30851, Florida Statutes and the CFPB on the Closing Disclosure.
Since August 17, 2024, a Realtor or MLS participant must have a written buyer agreement in place before showing you a home, including a Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2 or Unit 3 resale. The agreement states our compensation as a definite figure, and you may ask the seller to pay some or all of it in your offer.
Florida Realtors says compensation "must be objectively ascertainable and not open-ended" and "The buyer can negotiate compensation terms in their offer with the seller" (Florida Realtors, NAR settlement FAQs). Florida presumes transaction brokerage unless single agency is set up in writing, and a licensee "may not operate as a disclosed or nondisclosed dual agent" (s. 475.278, Florida Statutes).
A pre-approval for an older Stillwater home should be written for the price band you will actually shop: the Unit 3 homes that made up every sale under $300,000 in the last 12 months, or the Unit 1 and Unit 2 detached homes with a small-group median of $550,000. Both sit well under the 2026 conforming loan limit.
The 2026 baseline one-unit conforming limit is $832,750 (FHFA), and Freddie Mac's 30-year average was 7.11 percent on November 12, 2026 (Freddie Mac PMMS). Fannie Mae counts special assessments in the monthly housing expense (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-03), so run a Stillwater pre-approval with a dues estimate and a real insurance quote. No Stillwater association publishes its dues, so we ask the listing side for the current assessment before the offer and confirm it on the estoppel.
On an older Stillwater resale, the Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS form gives you a 15-day inspection period (if left blank) and a right to cancel for any reason before it ends. The standard form handles repairs differently, so compare both before you offer. Either way, the seller's duty to disclose known hidden defects stays in force.
The AS IS form gives the buyer "______ (if left blank, then 15) days after Effective Date" and lets the buyer terminate "in Buyer's sole discretion" by written notice "prior to expiration of Inspection Period" (Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS contract). Paragraph 10(g) warns: "BUYER SHOULD NOT EXECUTE THIS CONTRACT UNTIL BUYER HAS RECEIVED AND READ THE HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATION/COMMUNITY DISCLOSURE, IF APPLICABLE," which on a Stillwater resale comes from the seller (s. 720.401, Florida Statutes). The force majeure clause extends closing when insurance cannot be bound, which is what moves a Stillwater closing ahead of a storm. On a 2000 to 2007 Unit 1 home with possibly original systems, the AS IS form plus a full inspection is usually the cleaner path; on a Unit 3 villa, the declaration's maintenance split matters as much as the form.
On a Stillwater resale your deposit goes to the escrow agent named in the contract, and on the AS IS form any additional deposit is due 10 days after the Effective Date if left blank. The 15-day inspection period is your window to inspect, price insurance and read the association documents, and to cancel in writing with your deposit returned.
The AS IS form says "If Buyer timely terminates this Contract, the Deposit paid shall be returned to Buyer" (Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS contract). Fifteen days is short for a Stillwater home that needs a general inspection, a 4-point, a wind mitigation form, a termite report, a permit search and insurance quotes, so we book inspectors the day the contract is signed and request the association documents at the same time. If a finding needs a specialist, we ask for a written extension before the period ends. A Florida inspector may not repair a home it inspected or take a fee "contingent upon" the report's conclusions or closing (s. 468.8319, Florida Statutes).
On a 2000 to 2013 Stillwater home, insurance can decide the deal. All but two Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes were built in 2006 or earlier, at or past the 20-year line where Citizens requires a 4-point inspection; many original roofs are past 15 years, and roofs permitted before March 1, 2009 fall under the 25 percent rule.
Citizens "requires a four-point inspection for all property owner, dwelling and mobile home applications for properties more than 20 years old" (Citizens, inspections). Florida bars refusing a policy "solely because of the age of the roof" when the roof is under 15 years old, and for an older roof an insurer must allow an inspection showing "5 years or more of useful life remaining" (s. 627.7011, Florida Statutes). Citizens' claims guide applies full section replacement when "the roof was permitted prior March 1, 2009 and more than 25% of the roof section was damaged" (Citizens 25 percent rule job aid), which reaches original roofs in Units 1 and 2 and on 2007 and 2008 Unit 3 homes. A wind mitigation form under 5 years old can be reused, and inspections from April 1, 2026 use the revised OIR-B1-1802 (Citizens Wind Loss Mitigation Guide). We ask for the reroof permit, the last 4-point and the wind form on day one.
A Stillwater seller owes you four things: disclosure of known hidden defects that affect value under Johnson v. Davis, the radon notice, the property tax disclosure, and, since 2024, a written flood disclosure at or before signing. Each protects you differently, and none replaces your own inspection of a 2000 to 2013 home.
Florida's common-law duty, from Johnson v. Davis (1985), requires a seller to disclose "facts materially affecting the value of the property which are not readily observable and are not known to the buyer" (Florida Realtors on flood disclosure). The AS IS form repeats it at 10(j) and adds at 10(b) that the seller knows of no improvements made "without required permits or made pursuant to permits which have not been properly closed" (Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS contract). For a Unit 1 home with 20 years of reroofs, AC changeouts and pool cages, ask in writing about leaks, insurer non-renewals and open permits; Florida lets an owner close an expired permit whose requirements were "substantially completed" without a new permit (s. 553.79, Florida Statutes).
| Disclosure | What it tells a Stillwater buyer | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Known hidden defects (Johnson v. Davis; AS IS 10(j)) | Material facts not readily observable | Florida Realtors; AS IS form |
| Radon | Florida's statutory radon notice on at least one signed document | s. 404.056(5) |
| Property tax | Do not rely on the seller's bill; a sale triggers reassessment | s. 689.261 |
| Flood | Known flood damage, flood claims and flood aid during the seller's ownership | s. 689.302 |
The radon notice must appear "on at least one document, form, or application executed at the time of, or prior to, contract for sale and purchase of any building" (s. 404.056, Florida Statutes). The tax disclosure reads "BUYER SHOULD NOT RELY ON THE SELLER'S CURRENT PROPERTY TAXES," and from February 1, 2027 listing platforms must show estimated taxes not based on the current owner's bill (s. 689.261, Florida Statutes), which matters most on a long-held Unit 1 homestead. The flood disclosure must be given "at or before the time the sales contract is executed" and covers flood damage, claims and aid during the seller's ownership (s. 689.302, Florida Statutes); the Legislature created it in its 2024 session and expanded it effective October 1, 2025 (Florida Realtors on flood disclosure).
The estoppel certificate is the association's sworn statement of what is owed on a Stillwater home, open violations, any transfer approval and any other association the home belongs to. It must issue within 10 business days of request, and DBPR caps the fee at $299, plus $119 if rushed and up to $179 if the account is delinquent.
The statute requires the certificate "Within 10 business days after receiving a written or electronic request," valid 30 days if delivered by hand or electronically and 35 days by mail (s. 720.30851, Florida Statutes). DBPR's caps run to the next update "by July 1, 2027" (DBPR estoppel certificate fees). The AS IS form puts estoppel fees on the seller and association transfer fees on the buyer, and Barnes Walker's Sarasota customs table also lists the HOA estoppel letter as a seller cost (Barnes Walker, Sarasota closing customs). Order it early: a buyer is "jointly and severally liable with the previous parcel owner for all unpaid assessments" (s. 720.3085, Florida Statutes). We read the other-associations line hardest, because which association covers Unit 2 is not settled in any public record we found; a home under two associations may need two certificates and two fees.
The title commitment lists who owns the Stillwater home, the liens to be paid at closing and the exceptions your policy will not cover, such as plat easements and the recorded declaration. In Sarasota County the buyer customarily pays the owner's policy and picks the closing agent, and a seller's policy under 3 years old cuts the premium.
Barnes Walker lists owner's title insurance and closing agent selection as "Buyer" in Sarasota (Barnes Walker, Sarasota closing customs), and Chicago Title names Sarasota among counties where the buyer pays the owner's policy (Chicago Title, Florida Laws and Customs); the contract box controls. Promulgated rates are $5.75 per thousand to $100,000 and $5.00 per thousand to $1 million, with reissue rates of $3.30 and $3.00 when the seller's policy is under 3 years old (Rule 69O-186.003, Florida Administrative Code). On the Unit 3 median of $282,500 that is $1,487.50 original or $877.50 reissue; on the Units 1 and 2 median of $550,000, $2,825 or $1,680, before endorsements. The seller must furnish its prior policy "within 5 days after Effective Date".
A boundary survey is the buyer's cost on a Stillwater resale under both the AS IS form and Sarasota custom, and it shows whether a fence, pool cage or lanai crosses a line or easement. The elevation certificate tells your insurer how high the floor sits; the FEMA map and the lot's elevation certificate confirm the flood zone.
The AS IS form lists "Survey (and elevation certification, if required)" among buyer costs and advises the buyer "to verify by elevation certificate which flood zone the Property is in" (Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS contract). Florida requires surveyors to submit "a digital copy of every Elevation Certificate" to the Division of Emergency Management, whose database owners can search (Florida Division of Emergency Management, elevation certificates). A 2000 to 2013 Stillwater home may have one from its original build; if none turns up, a surveyor can prepare one inside the inspection period.
An appraiser valuing an older Stillwater resale compares it with recent resales on the same plats, not with Pulte's new homes at Shores. In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, older-plat resales ran a median $203 per square foot against $267 for Shores first sales, a difference of age, impact glass and tile roofs, not appreciation.
Unit 3 resales ran a median $198 per square foot (n=10) and Unit 1 and Unit 2 resales a median $246 (n=9, a small group) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A Units 1 and 2 appraisal may reach back 24 months, when we tracked 18 such resales at a median $555,000. If the appraisal falls short, your contract's financing terms decide whether you renegotiate, cover the gap or cancel. Days on market and sale-to-list ratios for Stillwater: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026).
Before you wire money for a Stillwater closing, call the title agent at a phone number you found yourself, not one in an email, and confirm the account details by voice. NAR, citing FBI data, reported more than $275 million lost to real estate fraud in 2025, including closing buyers who wired money to someone posing as their attorneys.
NAR, citing the FBI's 2025 Internet Crime Complaint Center data, reported losses of "more than $275 million through real estate-related fraud from at least 12,368 victims last year," up from 9,359 complaints and more than $173 million in 2024, including closing buyers who sent over $449,000 to an impersonator (NAR on FBI IC3 data). The AS IS form pays the balance to close "by wire transfer or other Collected funds" (Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS contract).
At a Stillwater resale closing the title agent pays off the seller's loan and any association balance shown on the estoppel, prorates property taxes, records the deed and mortgage, and funds the sale. Units 1 to 3 have no CDD line to prorate, and your Closing Disclosure arrives at least three business days before.
Sarasota custom prorates property taxes "Through day before closing (arrears)" (Barnes Walker, Sarasota closing customs). Note stamps are "35 cents on each $100" of the loan (s. 201.08, Florida Statutes) and the intangible tax is "2 mills" (s. 199.133, Florida Statutes); on an 80 percent loan at the Units 1 and 2 median of $550,000 that is $1,540 plus $880. Your tax value resets to market value on the January 1 after you buy, and homestead must be filed by March 1 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser 2026 TRIM supplement).
Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and on an older Stillwater resale we order the estoppel, the permit history, the 4-point and the wind mitigation form in the first days of the inspection period, so you decide with the file in hand. To walk a resale with us, book your Stillwater buyer consultation or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873. Comparing Stillwater with the rest of town? Our Englewood buyer guide covers the wider market.
A new Shores at Stillwater home carries Pulte's National Transferable New Home Limited Warranty: 1 year for materials and workmanship, 2 years for plumbing, electrical and HVAC systems, 5 years for certain water infiltration and leaks, and 10 years for structural elements, each counted from closing. It transfers to later owners within each term, and disputes go to binding arbitration.
Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte 10-Year Limited Home Warranty page, National Transferable New Home Limited Warranty book and warranty flyer read November 18, 2026; Florida Statutes text read November 18, 2026; Sarasota County Property Appraiser bulk file dated October 21, 2026)
| Coverage | Term from the closing date | What Pulte's book says it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Materials and workmanship | 1 year | Construction conforming to the tolerances in Pulte's Performance Standards |
| Mechanical systems | 2 years | "plumbing, electrical, heating, ventilating, air conditioning, and other mechanical systems" |
| Water infiltration and internal leaks | 5 years | "certain types of water infiltration and internal leaks" |
| Structural elements | 10 years | Load-bearing walls, beams, girders, trusses, rafters, columns, lintels, posts, structural fasteners, subfloors, footings and roof sheathing |
Source: Pulte National Transferable New Home Limited Warranty book and Pulte warranty flyer. Floating slabs and non-load-bearing partition walls are not structural elements under the book.
The structural term is what Pulte advertises on the Shores page: "Pulte gives you an industry leading 10-year limited structural new home warranty" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Coverage starts on the "'closing date', which is the date the Builder closed the sale of the home to the initial purchaser," so a Shores home closed in May 2026, the busiest Shores quarter in the county record with 10 first sales, runs to May 2027 for workmanship, May 2028 for systems, May 2031 for water infiltration and May 2036 for structure (Pulte National Warranty Book; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The 250 older Stillwater homes built from 2000 to 2013 on Units 1 to 3 are all more than 10 years past their build year, beyond any 10-year term like Pulte's.
For a Shores at Stillwater purchase agreement signed in 2026, Pulte's current national warranty book applies, and Pulte keeps a separate link for agreements signed before September 1, 2024. The purchase agreement is the controlling document, so we read its warranty clause and the booklet delivered with it before you sign, not a summary flyer.
Pulte's warranty page shows the "Pulte 10-Year Limited Home Warranty," the "National Transferable New Home Limited Warranty," a note "For Home Purchase Agreements signed prior to September 1, 2024," and vendor warranty links for Bryant, Moen, Whirlpool and Carrier (Pulte 10-Year Limited Home Warranty). The flyer warns "Information above only highlights certain aspects of the warranty. Terms, conditions, exclusions, and limitations apply" (Pulte warranty flyer). The book also says that "statutory and implied warranties, are hereby disclaimed by us and waived by you" and that the limited warranty "is substituted in place of all such warranties ... except as may be required by law" (Pulte National Warranty Book). Its Florida addendum covers condominium units only, so a Shores twin villa or detached home relies on the national terms plus Florida's statutory floor. Appliances, smart home components and similar consumer products carry separate manufacturer warranties assigned at closing.
When the first Shores at Stillwater homes resell, the buyer inherits whatever is left of each Pulte term, because the warranty runs to "all subsequent owners of the home who take title during the applicable warranty coverage periods." A buyer who takes title to a May 2026 home after May 2028 would hold the 5-year and 10-year terms only.
The book extends coverage "to the original purchaser of the home and to all subsequent owners of the home who take title during the applicable warranty coverage periods" (Pulte National Warranty Book), and Pulte's guide says "The warranty is transferable if you sell your home within the applicable warranty period" (Pulte homebuying guide). No Shores home had resold in the county record through October 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), so the first resale buyers will be the first to use this clause. On such a resale we ask the seller for the closing date, the warranty book, every open and closed warranty request and Pulte's responses, so you know which terms remain and what has already been repaired.
A warranty dispute on a Shores at Stillwater home does not go to court. Pulte's book offers optional mediation through Professional Warranty Service Corporation, then binding arbitration under the Federal Arbitration Act with an American Arbitration Association arbitrator, and it waives class and representative claims. Read that clause before you sign the purchase agreement.
The book says disputes are governed "by the Federal Arbitration Act ('FAA')," with an arbitrator appointed by the American Arbitration Association, and "You waive the right to institute or participate in a class or any other type of representative arbitration" (Pulte National Warranty Book). For the Colton and Ellenwood twin villas, section 7.3(B) appears to route claims that "a building common element has a construction defect" to the association rather than one owner (confirm the full wording in the booklet you receive), which matters for a shared wall or roof line. Our job at contract stage is to make sure you know these terms exist; whether to sign them is a question for your attorney.
File Pulte warranty requests on a Shores at Stillwater home in writing, directly with Pulte, as soon as you notice a problem, and report leaks immediately. Pulte then has the chance to inspect, and the book commits it to repair, replace or pay the reasonable cost within sixty days after that chance.
Section 4.1 reads "Contact us with details of your concerns as soon as possible. Conditions that could cause additional damage, such as water leaks, should be reported immediately. Do not communicate your request to any person that is not our employee, such as a contractor," and Pulte will "repair, replace, or pay the Homeowner the reasonable cost of repairing or replacing the Covered Defect within sixty days after Builder has been given the opportunity to inspect and test the condition" (Pulte National Warranty Book). In an emergency the owner "may make the repairs and we will reimburse you the reasonable cost," but must still give notice "as soon as possible." Because the 1-year workmanship term ends on the first anniversary of closing, we suggest booking your own licensed inspector around month 11 and sending one consolidated request before the term closes.
Shores at Stillwater homes come with tile roofs and impact glass, so the Pulte standards a Stillwater owner uses most are roof tile alignment, water infiltration, stucco cracking and air conditioning performance. Each standard has its own measurement and term, and the book, not your expectation, decides what counts as a defect.
| Item | Pulte standard | Term |
|---|---|---|
| Exterior stucco | Cracks should not exceed 1/8 inch; Pulte repairs wider cracks | 1 year |
| Roof tiles | Tiles "within any course should be aligned within 2 inches" | 1 year |
| Cooling system | Corrective action if ASHRAE standards are not met | 2 years |
| Drywall texture | Deviations "over 1/4 inch per 4 feet" repaired once | 1 year |
| Water infiltration and internal leaks | Certain types, per the Performance Standards | 5 years |
Source: Pulte National Warranty Book. The book also tells owners to "Always maintain a 6-inch minimum vertical space between the earth and any siding or stucco" and that it is "the Homeowner's responsibility to balance the system as the seasons change." Pulte lists "Tile roof" and impact windows as standard at Shores (Pulte, Prestige plan at Shores at Stillwater).
Florida law requires the builder of a new Shores at Stillwater home to warrant it for 1 year against defects that cause a material violation of the Florida Building Code, and that duty follows the home if it is sold. Pulte's longer written warranty can replace it only if it meets the statute's tests on scope and transfer.
The statute says a builder "shall warrant a newly constructed home for all construction defects of equipment, material, or workmanship ... resulting in a material violation of the Florida Building Code ... for a period of 1 year after the date of original conveyance of title to the initial owner or after the date of initial occupancy," and must honor it "even if the newly constructed home is sold or transferred" (s. 553.837, Florida Statutes). An express warranty supersedes it if its "scope, coverage, and duration" are "the same or greater" and it "automatically transfers to a new owner during at least the initial year." The section was added by chapter 2024-95. No older Stillwater home on Units 1 to 3 carries this protection.
Before suing a builder, contractor or supplier over a construction defect, a Stillwater owner must serve a written Chapter 558 notice at least 60 days before filing, or 120 days for an association of more than 20 parcels. The notice must describe each defect in reasonable detail, based on at least a visual inspection.
The statute requires the claimant to "serve written notice of claim on the contractor, subcontractor, supplier, or design professional," describing "in reasonable detail the nature of each alleged construction defect and, if known, the damage or loss resulting from the defect" (s. 558.004, Florida Statutes). The 120-day version applies to the Shores at Stillwater association, with 140 platted Shores parcels and 255 homes planned, if it brings claims over common elements such as shared villa walls. For a warranty dispute with Pulte, the book's arbitration clause controls; Chapter 558 is the statutory pre-suit step for other construction claims.
A construction defect action must start within 4 years of the certificate of occupancy, or from discovery for a latent defect, and never more than 7 years after it. For a 2025 or 2026 Shores at Stillwater home that repose arrives in 2032 or 2033; every Stillwater Unit 1, 2 and 3 home is already past it.
Florida's limit runs four years from the date the authority "issues a temporary certificate of occupancy, a certificate of occupancy, or a certificate of completion," with latent defects running from discovery, and "In any event, the action must be commenced within 7 years" of that date (s. 95.11, Florida Statutes). A Shores home closed in 2026 therefore reaches repose before Pulte's 10-year structural term ends, and after repose the warranty contract is the remaining route. On Units 1 to 3, built from 2000 to 2013 plus one home in 2016, a construction defect belongs to the buyer from day one, which is why the inspection period carries so much weight on an older Stillwater resale.
Pulte's warranty does not cover hurricane, windstorm or flood damage to a Shores at Stillwater home, or loss from surface water and wind-driven water. It also excludes health risks from radon, mold and formaldehyde, and consequential costs like temporary housing. Storm and flood losses belong to your homeowners, wind and flood policies.
The book excludes loss from "acts of God, lightning, windstorm, hail, tornado, hurricane" and "Loss or damage caused directly or indirectly by flood, wind-driven water, surface water," plus health risks from "radon gas, mold, formaldehyde" and "Consequential damages including ... costs of shelter, food, and transportation" (Pulte National Warranty Book). Elevators, solar systems, emergency power systems, smart home components and consumer products are "not covered" by the book but by the maker's warranty. A Shores buyer therefore prices wind and flood coverage as carefully as an older-home buyer does, even with a tile roof and impact glass, and keeps the wind mitigation form and elevation certificate from the Pulte closing file.
5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine). Weighing a Shores warranty against an older Stillwater home's inspection report? Book your Stillwater buyer consultation or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
A Shores at Stillwater home pays two bodies: the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District, a Chapter 190 government that borrowed for the section's infrastructure, and the Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, which Pulte controls for now. Older Stillwater homes on Units 1 to 3 sit outside the CDD and answer to the older Stillwater associations.
Data updated: November 2026 (Shores at Stillwater CDD FY2026/2027 final budget, June 15, 2026 board book and amended FY2025/26 budget, read November 18, 2026; Florida corporate records as summarized by CommunityPay and Sunbiz Daily; Florida Statutes text read November 18, 2026; Sarasota County Property Appraiser bulk file dated October 21, 2026)
The district says it was "established pursuant to F.S. Chapter 190," that "All property owners within the CDD will be subject to annual assessments" with two parts, operations and maintenance and "Debt service (annual principal & interest) on the capital improvement bonds," and that "The annual assessments appear as one line in the non-ad valorem section of the property tax bill" (Shores at Stillwater CDD). It was created by Sarasota County Ordinance No. 2025-032, and its fiscal year runs October 1 to September 30.
| Shores lot type (district methodology) | Phase One lots | Maximum annual debt assessment | Operations rate if on the roll | Total a year | Monthly equivalent | Debt principal per lot at issue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 34-foot villa lot (Colton, Ellenwood) | 74 | about $1,383 | about $276 | about $1,659 | about $138 | $18,580.37 |
| 52-foot detached lot (Distinctive plans) | 62 | about $1,915 | about $276 | about $2,190 | about $183 | $25,726.66 |
Sources: Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 board book (Tables D and F) and Shores at Stillwater CDD FY2026/2027 final budget. The two tables in the June book differ by cents, and the district says the amounts "include discounts for early payments and estimated county collection costs, which may fluctuate." Payoff figures are per the district's methodology; confirm a current payoff with the district manager's office.
The debt part of the Shores at Stillwater CDD charge repays the Series 2026 bonds that financed the section's public infrastructure, and it is the larger amount. The operations part pays the district's management, legal, insurance and engineering costs. For the 2026/27 fiscal year, Pulte funds the shortfall in operations above the $276 rate.
The FAQ says "The debt service component is the larger amount and goes towards paying of the bonds," and the operations component "pays for management services and any necessary on-going maintenance" (Shores at Stillwater CDD FAQ). The FY2026/2027 budget shows $129,125 in revenues, including "O&M Assessments 66,157 To Be Collected At Closings" and "Developer Funding 62,968" for "Expenditures That Exceed $276 O&M Rate," against costs such as management at $30,000 ("$2,500 X 12 Months"), legal at $25,000 and engineering at $20,000 (Shores at Stillwater CDD FY2026/2027 final budget). Lake bank and preserve maintenance show zero in the district budget, because those items moved to the HOA (below). The FAQ also says escrowed owners pay the CDD through the mortgage payment and that "residents will only pay for the district improvements while they own the property."
The Shores at Stillwater CDD issued $2,970,000 of Series 2026 bonds in June 2026, at interest rates of 4.10 to 5.8 percent, maturing in May 2056. The debt is assigned to the 136 platted Phase One lots, with principal due each May 1 and interest each November 1, and it runs with the land.
The amended FY2025/26 budget lists "Original Par Amount = $2,970,000," an interest rate range of 4.10% to 5.8%, "Issue Date = June 2026," "Maturity Date = May 2056," "Annual Principal Payments Due: May 1st" and "Annual Interest Payments Due: November 1st" (Shores at Stillwater CDD amended FY2025/26 budget). The June book says the bonds "will be assigned to the 136 platted residential dwelling units," that "All assessments levied run with the land," and that the assessments are a "first lien on such parcels until paid and such lien shall be coequal with the lien of all state, county" taxes (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 board book). A buyer who closes on a Shores home in 2026 takes on a debt line that can run for decades unless it is paid off.
Yes. The district's methodology sets each Shores at Stillwater lot's share of bond principal at $18,580.37 for a 34-foot villa lot and $25,726.66 for a 52-foot lot, and the district's own budget shows a prepayment equal to one 52-foot lot's share. Ask the district manager's office for a current payoff figure before you decide.
The district site links a payoff "Request Information" form at sdsinc.org/request, through its manager, Special District Services (Shores at Stillwater CDD). The amended FY2025/26 budget shows "Bond Prepayments 25,727" and a "Prepayment Account To Be Used To Make 11/1/26 Extraordinary Principal Payment" (Shores at Stillwater CDD amended FY2025/26 budget). The June book also gives notice of "the limited availability of impact fee credits" whose proceeds go "towards a prepayment of the Series 2026 Assessments allocable to the parcel" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 board book), so we ask Pulte whether any part of your lot's debt has already been prepaid. A payoff removes the debt line, not the operations line; ask the district manager whether accrued interest is added to the figure.
For the district's 2026/27 fiscal year, the Shores at Stillwater CDD is not on the county tax roll, so its budget collects the operations share from buyers at closing instead of on the November tax bill. Expect a CDD operations line on your settlement statement, and ask the district how later years will be billed.
The FY2026/2027 final budget shows "O&M Assessments 66,157 To Be Collected At Closings" and a note that if the district were on the assessment roll the "O&M Rate Would Be $276 (255 Units)" (Shores at Stillwater CDD FY2026/2027 final budget). The county Tax Collector's 2026 millage sheet lists Sarasota County's CDDs and carries no Shores at Stillwater code (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage). The district FAQ still describes the standard path, an assessment "on the property tax bill sent in November of each year" (Shores at Stillwater CDD FAQ), so an escrow set from a first Shores tax bill without a CDD line may need to rise if the district later bills on the tax roll. Amendment 3 does not reduce CDD assessments.
A five-member board elected by landowners governs the Shores at Stillwater CDD, and in a new district the largest landowner is the developer. The district's FAQ says resident-elected supervisors begin six years after the initial election once the district has at least 250 qualified electors, so owner seats come gradually.
The district describes "a five-member Board of Supervisors elected by landowners within the District" (Shores at Stillwater CDD) and sets the timing for qualified-elector seats in its FAQ (Shores at Stillwater CDD FAQ). Until then, landowner-elected supervisors, with the developer as the largest landowner, adopt the budget and set the assessment each year. Board meetings and books are posted on the district site; we read the latest book before a Shores contract to see any change in the operations budget or the collection method.
Three homeowners' associations appear in Florida corporate records for Stillwater: Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed 2000), Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed 2006) and Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (filed 2025). Which plats the 2000 association covers is not shown in any public document we read; the estoppel answers it per home.
| Association | Filed | Documents a buyer requests | Dues published? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. | March 7, 2000 | Declaration, rules, budget, estoppel; plats covered confirmed on the estoppel | No |
| Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc. ("Villas at Stillwater III" website) | March 10, 2006 | Declaration, villa maintenance split, rules, budget, estoppel | No |
| Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. | February 24, 2025 | HOA disclosure summary, declaration, developer rights, budget | No; Pulte says "Community Association fees required" |
Sources: CommunityPay summary of Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc., Sunbiz Daily summary of Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (both third-party summaries of state records), the Villas at Stillwater III website and Pulte, Shores at Stillwater.
The 2000 association's address of record is in Rotonda West, Charlotte County, but the homes are in unincorporated Sarasota County with Englewood 34223 addresses. No Stillwater association publishes a dues figure on any primary page we read, and listing-site figures are not a source we use; the estoppel certificate on a resale, or the HOA disclosure summary and the budget on a Pulte sale, confirm the amount.
Shores at Stillwater HOA dues carry the costs the CDD does not, including the gated entries from Pine Street, the heated pool and cabana, and the pond and preserve upkeep the district moved into the HOA budget in 2026. Pulte publishes no dues figure, so the current HOA budget is the document that shows the full list and amount.
The district's June 15, 2026 minutes record that "the maintenance items, with the exception of engineering, would be included in an agreement with the HOA and are currently included in the HOA budget. Those items will be removed from the District budget" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 board book). The Englewood Sun reported "two private, gated entries from Pine Street" (Englewood Sun), and Pulte lists a "Heated community pool", a "Pool cabana with covered seating", "BBQ grills" and "Mail kiosks" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Pulte's sample payments state that they "do not include monthly homeowners' association dues," so a Shores budget built from Pulte's calculator is missing a line until the association figure is added.
Florida law gives Shores at Stillwater owners a board majority three months after 90 percent of the parcels in all phases are conveyed to owners other than the developer. With 255 homes planned, that is about 230 homes, and the October 2026 roll showed 27 Shores homes built and 107 lots still vacant, so turnover is years away.
The statute sets the majority trigger at "Three months after 90 percent of the parcels in all phases of the community that will ultimately be operated by the homeowners' association have been conveyed to members other than the developer," gives owners "at least one member" of the board at 50 percent, and lets the developer keep a seat while it holds "at least 5 percent of the parcels in all phases" for sale (s. 720.307, Florida Statutes). On 255 homes that is about 128 conveyances for the first owner seat and 13 parcels for Pulte's last seat. At turnover the developer must deliver the original declaration, financial records "audited by an independent certified public accountant" for associations formed after 2007, insurance policies and "Any and all warranties in effect" within 90 days. Until then, Pulte-appointed directors set the budget and rules, which is why we read the declaration's developer-rights article and any deficit-funding language before a Shores contract.
Before a Stillwater contract becomes binding, request the documents that set your yearly costs and rules: on a Shores home, the CDD disclosure, the district's current budget and payoff figure, the HOA disclosure summary, declaration and budget; on a Units 1 to 3 resale, the declaration, rules, budget, minutes and an estoppel from each association.
Associations with 100 or more parcels had to post their declaration, rules, budget and contracts on a website or app "By January 1, 2025" (s. 720.303, Florida Statutes). Stillwater Unit 3 has 141 parcels and Shores at Stillwater 140 platted parcels, so both are over that line if each association governs its whole plat; Unit 1 alone has 77. If a budget has no reserve accounts for capital items, the financial report must say "THE BUDGET OF THE ASSOCIATION DOES NOT PROVIDE FOR FULLY FUNDED RESERVE ACCOUNTS FOR CAPITAL EXPENDITURES," a line worth finding on a 2007 to 2013 Unit 3 villa section. On a Unit 3 purchase, the written split of villa maintenance between owner and association is the single most important document, because it decides who pays for roofs, exterior paint and building insurance.
On a Stillwater Units 1 to 3 resale there is no CDD line; the district's boundary covers Shores at Stillwater, and you confirm that on the tax bill. HOA assessments are prorated through the estoppel. On a future Shores resale, the CDD line is prorated like property tax, and you inherit the remaining installments unless the contract requires a payoff.
The AS IS form makes the seller pay public-body liens "certified, confirmed and ratified before Closing," and says "Buyer shall pay all other assessments," with CDD charges prorated under the form's standards (Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS contract). The 190.048 box covers "the initial sale" only, so a later Shores buyer sees the district on the tax bill, the title commitment and the closing statement rather than in a bold contract notice (s. 190.048, Florida Statutes). For the cost side of the same question, our Stillwater home valuation page shows how the CDD and the absence of one weigh on value across the five plats.
After closing, a Stillwater owner is bound by the recorded declaration and rules of the home's association, Sarasota County code and Florida statutes, plus the Shores at Stillwater CDD on Shores lots. We found no Stillwater declaration posted online, so leasing, pet, parking and fence rules must be read before the inspection period ends; the statutory floors below apply regardless.
Data updated: November 2026 (Florida Statutes text read November 18, 2026, including 2024 to 2026 amendments to Chapter 720; Florida Department of Revenue form DR-15DSS; Englewood Water District notices and FY27 rules; Villas at Stillwater III website checked November 18, 2026)
| Rule area | What binds a Stillwater owner | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Leasing minimums, pets, parking, fences, paint | The home's declaration and rules, not public online | Read before the inspection period ends |
| Villa maintenance split (Unit 3) | The Unit 3 declaration and maintenance schedule | Request through the association's manager |
| Hurricane shutters, impact windows, code roofs, generators | Must be approved if they meet the HOA's adopted specifications | s. 720.3035(6) |
| Building permit before architectural review | Not required since July 1, 2026 | s. 720.3035, ch. 2026-63 |
| Fines and suspensions | 14 days' notice, hearing, $1,000 aggregate cap unless documents allow more | s. 720.305 |
| Records and association websites | 10 business days to produce records; online posting for 100 or more parcels | s. 720.303 |
| Rentals | Rules in force when you take title bind you | s. 720.306(1)(h) |
| Short-term rental taxes | 6 percent state sales tax, 1 percent Sarasota surtax, plus the county's tourist development tax | DOR form DR-15DSS; Sarasota County Tax Collector |
| Lawn watering | Englewood Water District shortage restrictions through March 31, 2027 | englewoodwater.com |
Leasing minimums, pet limits, vehicle, boat and parking rules, fence and paint approvals, and the Unit 3 villa maintenance split are not published for any Stillwater association. A buyer of any Stillwater home reads the recorded declaration, amendments and current rules inside the inspection period, while cancelling is still free.
We searched for public copies on November 18, 2026 and found none posted for Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3 or Shores at Stillwater; Pulte's site gives no association rules and no dues (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). The HOA disclosure summary warns that "THE DEVELOPER MAY HAVE THE RIGHT TO AMEND THE RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS WITHOUT THE APPROVAL OF THE ASSOCIATION MEMBERSHIP" (s. 720.401, Florida Statutes), which is live at Shores while Pulte controls the board. On a resale, the estoppel certificate also tells you whether the rules "require approval by the board of directors of the association for the transfer of the parcel" (s. 720.30851, Florida Statutes), so a lease or sale approval requirement shows up before closing.
On November 18, 2026, the Villas at Stillwater III website for the Unit 3 association showed a vendor notice that the account was deactivated pending payment, so its documents could not be read. Its menu still lists gate code requests, clubhouse reservations, an architectural review form and a villa maintenance responsibilities page.
The notice reads "we've deactivated your community website account while we're waiting to receive payment from your association" (Villas at Stillwater III website). The menu items "Gate Code Request", "Clubhouse Reservation", "ACR Request Form", "Villa Maintenance Responsibilities", "Community Documents" and "Public Documents" point to a gated section with a clubhouse and an architectural review process, but the pages behind them did not load. A deactivated site is a fact to note, not a finding that the association is out of compliance; it may use a manager portal or app. For a Unit 3 buyer, we request the declaration, maintenance schedule, budget, insurance and recent minutes from the manager in writing, and Florida law requires records within "10 business days after receipt by the board or its designee of a written request" from an owner (s. 720.303, Florida Statutes).
No Stillwater association can deny a hurricane protection application that meets the specifications its board must adopt. Florida's list covers code-compliant roof systems, permanent and roll-down shutters, impact windows and doors, reinforced garage doors, exterior fixed generators and fuel tanks, and it applies to every HOA regardless of when the community was created.
The statute says it "applies to all homeowners' associations in the state, regardless of when the community was created," defines "hurricane protection" to include "roof systems recognized by the Florida Building Code which meet ASCE 7-22 standards, permanent fixed storm shutters, roll-down track storm shutters, impact-resistant windows and doors, polycarbonate panels, reinforced garage doors, erosion controls, exterior fixed generators, fuel storage tanks," and requires the board to "adopt hurricane protection specifications" (s. 720.3035, Florida Statutes). A denial must state "with specificity the rule or covenant on which the association or committee relied." For a 2000 to 2007 Unit 1 or Unit 2 home that may lack impact glass, we ask for the specifications before closing, because a conforming upgrade can also lower the windstorm premium through a new wind mitigation form (CFO consumer guide to hurricane mitigation discounts). On a Unit 3 villa the specifications may require a matching look across both halves of a building.
No. Since July 1, 2026, a Florida HOA may not require a county building permit as a condition of reviewing an owner's plans, so a Stillwater owner can seek architectural approval first and pull the Sarasota County permit after. The association may still make its approval conditional on the permit where the county requires one.
The statute now says an association or committee "may not require a building permit to be issued by a governmental authority to a parcel owner as a prerequisite for review by the association or committee concerning the construction of structures or improvements on the parcel" (s. 720.3035, Florida Statutes). A law-firm explainer notes the change "became effective on July 1, 2026" and that it "does not preclude an association or its ARC from granting conditional approval" (Florida Condo and HOA Law Blog). For a Stillwater buyer planning a reroof, pool cage, lanai enclosure or window replacement soon after closing, that order saves weeks: submit to the association's review form, then file with the county.
A Stillwater association can fine or suspend amenity use only after at least 14 days' written notice and a chance for a hearing before a committee of at least three members. Fines cap at $1,000 in total unless the documents say otherwise, a fine under $1,000 cannot become a lien, and no suspension can block your car or walking access.
The statute reads "A fine may not exceed $1,000 in the aggregate unless otherwise provided in the governing documents. A fine of less than $1,000 may not become a lien against a parcel," requires "at least 14 days' written notice of the parcel owner's right to a hearing," and says the hearing "must be held within 90 days after issuance of the notice" (s. 720.305, Florida Statutes). It bars fines for carts left out "within 24 hours before or after the designated garbage collection day," and a suspension "may not prohibit an owner or tenant of a parcel from having vehicular and pedestrian ingress." In a gated Stillwater section, such as Shores at Stillwater, that means a suspension can reach the pool and cabana but not the gate for your car. A member "more than 90 days delinquent" may lose voting rights.
Whether you can lease a Stillwater home depends on its declaration and on Florida's rental rule: a rental restriction adopted after July 1, 2021 binds owners who take title after it, so a buyer is bound by whatever is in force at closing. Any association may limit leases under 6 months and rentals to three a year.
The statute says a rental restriction enacted after July 1, 2021 "applies only to a parcel owner who acquires title to the parcel after the effective date of the governing document or amendment, or to a parcel owner who consents," and that an association "may amend its governing documents to prohibit or regulate rental agreements for a term of less than 6 months and may prohibit the rental of a parcel for more than three times in a calendar year, and such amendments shall apply to all parcel owners" (s. 720.306, Florida Statutes). For any Stillwater buyer who plans to lease, the declaration, the rules and the estoppel's transfer-approval answer are the documents to read inside the inspection period. Rents for Stillwater homes: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). Our Englewood market page covers the wider area.
A Stillwater home rented for six months or less is taxed at Florida's 6 percent state sales tax plus Sarasota County's 1 percent discretionary surtax, and the county's tourist development tax on top. Confirm the tourist tax rate and registration with the Sarasota County Tax Collector before taking a first booking.
The Department of Revenue's surtax table lists "Sarasota 1%" from September 1, 1989 through December 31, 2039 (Florida Department of Revenue, DR-15DSS). The county's tourist development tax is administered by the Sarasota County Tax Collector; confirm the rate with the Sarasota County Tax Collector (Sarasota County Tax Collector, tourist tax). Stillwater's homes sit in Sarasota County even though Englewood straddles the Charlotte line, so the Sarasota surtax, not Charlotte's, applies. The association's leasing rules and county zoning decide whether short stays are allowed at all; taxes apply only where they are.
Stillwater homes draw water from Englewood Water District (confirm service by address), and on November 18, 2026 its notice read "Extreme Water Shortage Restrictions Extended through March 31, 2027." A Stillwater owner follows those watering limits plus any landscaping rules in the declaration, and EWD's per-gallon tiers rise with use, so heavy lawn watering raises the bill.
EWD's home page carries the restriction notice and its customer service line (Englewood Water District). The district's FY27 rules set a water base charge of $29.37 and a sewer base charge of $42.75 per equivalent residential connection a month, with water usage tiers from $3.50 per 1,000 gallons for the first 6,000 gallons up to $24.21 above 18,000, and EWD "will not allow any irrigation well to be drilled" within one mile of a District supply wellhead unless its models show no harm (Englewood Water District FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations). Whether a Shores at Stillwater yard is watered from the house meter or a common system is not stated in any document we read, so ask the association before you budget the water bill; on a larger Unit 1 lot, irrigation on the house meter is what pushes usage into the higher tiers.
McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate, and on every Stillwater purchase we put the declaration, rules, CDD figures and estoppel in front of you before your inspection period ends. Book your Stillwater buyer consultation or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873. Thinking of selling a Stillwater home first? See our Stillwater seller page or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Stillwater splits into two inspection jobs. A new Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater (built 2025 to 2026) is checked for how it was built, inside Pulte's own quality steps. A 2000 to 2013 resale on Units 1, 2 or 3 is checked for age: roof, insurance forms, mechanicals, drywall era, permits and termites.
Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser roll dated October 21, 2026: 394 parcels on five Stillwater plats; Fla. Stat. 468.8311, 468.8319, 468.8322, 482.226, 553.79, 553.837, 553.844, 558.004, 627.7011 and 95.11; Pulte Build Quality Experience brochure and National Transferable New Home Limited Warranty book; Citizens inspections page, roof bulletins and Wind Loss Mitigation Guide for OIR-B1-1802 Rev. 04/26; Florida CFO mitigation guide, July 2026; Florida Building Commission milestones; FDACS form 13645; FDEM elevation certificate page. All checked November 18, 2026.)
We tracked 394 parcels on the October 21, 2026 county roll across the five Stillwater plats (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The year built on those parcels is what sets the inspection plan. Unit 1 has 76 homes, 75 built 2000 to 2007 and one in 2016; Unit 2 has 35 homes built in 2005 and 2006; Unit 3 has 140 smaller homes built 2007 to 2013; and Shores at Stillwater had 27 Pulte homes built in 2025 and 2026, with 107 lots still coded vacant. That is a 26-year spread inside one Englewood address, so a single checklist does not fit. A Shores buyer wants access to the house before the walls close and a plan for the warranty clock. A resale buyer wants the roof permit date, a 4-point and wind mitigation form in an insurer's hands, and an answer on the 2001 to 2009 drywall window before the inspection period ends. For the place itself first, read our Stillwater neighborhood guide.
A Shores at Stillwater home still under construction can be seen at Pulte's foundation, frame and pre-drywall steps, then at orientation and the final walk. A Stillwater Units 1 to 3 resale gets a licensed home inspection inside the contract's inspection period, plus the insurance forms, termite report and permit search that age brings.
| Inspection | What it checks | Who performs it | New Pulte home, Shores at Stillwater | Older resale, Units 1, 2 and 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pulte foundation, frame and pre-drywall steps | Foundation, framing, insulation, plumbing, electrical and mechanical rough-ins | Pulte's Field Manager ("Pulte Homes employees, and not outside consultants") | Part of Pulte's published process on a to-be-built home | Not possible |
| Buyer's own pre-drywall visit | Straps, roof-to-wall connections, window flashing, supply lines, ducts | Buyer's licensed inspector, only if Pulte agrees | No published Pulte policy; ask in writing and add it to the purchase agreement | Not possible; attic view only |
| Standard home inspection | Structure, electrical, HVAC, roof covering, plumbing, interior, exterior, site (F.S. 468.8311) | Florida-licensed home inspector | Before closing, if the contract allows it | Inside the inspection period (15 days if left blank on the AS IS form) |
| 4-point (roof, electrical, plumbing, HVAC) | Age and condition of the four systems an insurer underwrites | Florida-licensed inspector | Not needed on a new home | Citizens requires it for homes more than 20 years old: the 2000 to 2006 Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes in 2026 |
| Wind mitigation (OIR-B1-1802 Rev. 04/26) | Building code, roof covering, deck attachment, roof-to-wall, secondary water resistance, openings | Licensed home inspector with mitigation training, contractor, engineer or similar | Ask whether the closing file has one; if not, order one | Reuse the seller's form if under 5 years old; otherwise order |
| Roof inspection | Remaining useful life; permit date for the 25 percent rule | Authorized inspector under F.S. 627.7011 | New tile roof | Key item on 2000 to 2013 roofs |
| Termite (WDO) report | Visible signs of wood-destroying organisms | FDACS-licensed pest control inspector | Ask for the soil pretreatment record | Order inside the inspection period |
| Drywall threshold check | Blackened copper at AC coil, ground wires, sulfur odor | Home inspector; specialist if signs appear | Not applicable | Homes built 2004 to 2009 |
| Permit and CO record | Original permit, CO, reroof, AC, window, pool, cage permits | Buyer or agent, confirmed with Sarasota County | Confirm the CO | Confirm every permit is finaled |
| Survey and elevation certificate | Lot lines, easements, finished floor height | Florida-licensed surveyor | Builder's survey and certificate | Reuse with title agent approval or order new |
| Month-11 warranty inspection | Workmanship items before the 1-year term ends | Buyer's licensed inspector | About 11 months after closing | Only if the first owner closed less than a year ago |
| Final walkthrough | Repairs done, systems running | Buyer and agent | Pulte's final walk ("Celebration" step) | Day before or day of closing |
Sources: Pulte Build Quality Experience; Fla. Stat. 468.8311; Citizens, inspections; Citizens Wind Loss Mitigation Guide; Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS contract. Inspection prices are not published by a state source, so we do not print them.
Pulte publishes a ten-step Build Quality Experience: foundation, frame and pre-drywall inspections by its Field Manager, a pre-drywall orientation, a final inspection, a second quality review and the buyer's final walk. Pulte says the reviews are done by its own employees, so a Shores at Stillwater buyer should plan for independent eyes as well.
The brochure lists "FOUNDATION INSPECTION," "FRAME INSPECTION" and "PRE-DRYWALL INSPECTION," at which the buyer reviews "insulation, plumbing, electrical and mechanical installations," followed by an orientation "Before we put up the drywall" and, at step eight, "the most important inspection: yours." Its disclaimer reads: "Quality review is performed on-site by Pulte Homes employees, and not outside consultants" (Pulte, Build Quality Experience). The brochure is a 2016 national edition, and Pulte's Shores at Stillwater page still names the program today (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Pulte also asks for feedback 90 days after move-in and again after one year.
No Pulte document we read grants or refuses a buyer's own inspector at pre-drywall or before closing. Shores at Stillwater buyers should ask the sales office in writing and put access for a licensed inspector, at pre-drywall and before closing, into the purchase agreement or an addendum before signing.
The timing matters because a Florida home inspection is "a limited visual examination" of "readily accessible" systems (Fla. Stat. 468.8311). Once drywall is up, truss straps, plumbing runs and duct joints are out of reach. Pulte lists "Quick Move-Ins Available" at Shores at Stillwater, and a quick move-in home is already past drywall, so its windows are the orientation, a pre-closing inspection if the contract allows one, and the final walk (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Only a to-be-built home offers a pre-drywall visit. With 107 Shores lots still coded vacant on the October 21, 2026 roll (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), many Shores homes are still to be built.
On a new Shores at Stillwater home, the inspector focuses on what Pulte's warranty standards measure: tile roof alignment, stucco cracks wider than 1/8 inch, window and slider sealing, HVAC performance, grading against the slab and gas appliance hookups. Writing these down before closing makes warranty requests easier later.
Pulte's Shores page lists "Impact Glass & Tile Roof Included," "Natural Gas Community" and "Natural gas appliances" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Pulte's warranty book sets the measuring sticks: roof tiles "within any course should be aligned within 2 inches" for one year; "Cracks in exterior stucco wall surfaces should not exceed 1/8 inch in width," repaired for one year; and the cooling system gets corrective action "for a period of two years" if the ASHRAE standards are not met (Pulte National Warranty Book). The same book tells owners to keep "a 6-inch minimum vertical space between the earth and any siding or stucco," which is worth checking at the final walk where landscaping meets the wall.
About 11 months after closing. Pulte's workmanship coverage runs one year from the closing date, so a Shores at Stillwater owner who books a licensed inspector at month 11 can send a written list to Pulte before that term ends. Systems run two years, water infiltration five and structure ten.
Pulte's book defines the start as the "closing date," and its one-year term covers "materials and workmanship," the two-year term "plumbing, electrical, heating, ventilating, air conditioning, and other mechanical systems," the five-year term "certain types of water infiltration and internal leaks," and the ten-year term listed structural elements (Pulte National Warranty Book). Our researchers' timeline for a Shores home closed in May 2026, the busiest Shores quarter on the county file (2026 Q2, n=10): workmanship to May 2027, systems to May 2028, water infiltration to May 2031 and structure to May 2036. Pulte's book says to contact Pulte "as soon as possible," report leaks "immediately," and not to send requests to "a contractor." Florida adds a 1-year statutory warranty for defects that cause a material building code violation, which follows the home if it is sold (Fla. Stat. 553.837).
If original, a Stillwater Unit 1 roof is about 20 to 26 years old, Unit 2 20 to 21, and Unit 3 13 to 19. Pre-March 1, 2009 permits (original 2000 to 2007 Units 1 and 2 roofs, 2007 to 2008 Unit 3 roofs) fall under Florida's 25 percent repair rule; later roofs do not.
Citizens' claims job aid quotes the code: "Not more than 25 percent of the total roof area or roof section ... shall be repaired, replaced or recovered in any 12-month period unless the entire existing roofing system or roof section is replaced," and adds that where the existing roofing on a home has a permit application date of March 1, 2009, or later, "the 25% Rule does not apply" (Citizens, 25 percent rule job aid). The statute behind the exception is Fla. Stat. 553.844(5). Our researchers mapped the 140 Unit 3 homes: 24 built in 2007 and 2008 are pre-2009 permits, 106 built 2010 to 2013 were likely permitted under the 2007 code or later, and 10 built in 2009 depend on the permit application date. The roof permit (number, date, final inspection) is the document that settles it, and it is also what corrects a wrong roof year at Citizens, which since August 1, 2026 pulls roof age for new business from "Virtual Roof/Verisk" (Citizens, automatic roof age retrieval).
Yes for most of them. Citizens requires a 4-point inspection on homes more than 20 years old, which covers the 2000 to 2006 Stillwater Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes in 2026, and Unit 3 homes cross that line from 2027 to 2033. A wind mitigation form is optional but drives the windstorm premium.
Citizens says it "requires a four-point inspection for all property owner, dwelling and mobile home applications for properties more than 20 years old," with a licensed inspector checking "electrical system, plumbing, heating/cooling system (HVAC) and roof" (Citizens, inspections). For wind mitigation, any inspection on or after April 1, 2026 must use the revised OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26), and a prior owner's form is accepted: "If property is a new purchase, the form may be in the name of and signed by the prior owner" (Citizens Wind Loss Mitigation Guide). A completed form "is valid for five years provided no material changes are made" (Florida CFO, mitigation discounts guide). On Unit 3 homes from 2007 and 2008, the "2007 or newer" code answer needs "A permit application dated after December 8, 2006." The ten Unit 1 homes built in 2000 and 2001 may predate the first statewide code of March 1, 2002 (Florida Building Commission milestones), so their wind form, not the year built, proves each feature.
On a 2000 to 2013 Stillwater home, the inspector reads the data plates on the air handler, condenser and water heater, checks for refrigerant type and corrosion, and looks at supply lines and shutoffs. Shores homes have natural gas appliances per Pulte; whether older Stillwater plats have gas service is not confirmed.
These are the systems a 4-point reports to the insurer (Citizens, inspections), so the age on each data plate shows up twice: in the inspection report and in the insurance quote. Original 2000 to 2007 Stillwater systems would date from the R-22 era; many have likely been replaced, and the Sarasota County permit history shows when. One extra flag on Unit 2 and early Unit 3 homes: black corrosion on the copper of the air handler coil is also a sign CPSC field reports describe for imported problem drywall, so an AC coil replaced more than once in a few years is a fair question for the seller. On a new Shores home, Pulte's warranty book covers the workability of plumbing, electrical and HVAC systems for "two years after the closing date" (Pulte National Warranty Book), and it adds that "It is the Homeowner's responsibility to balance the system as the seasons change."
Ask whether the windows and sliders are the originals, whether they carry impact ratings or have rated shutters, and when they were permitted. On Stillwater stucco, the inspector notes crack widths, sealant at windows and penetrations, clearance above grade and any patching that could hide water entry.
Opening protection is one of six features on the wind mitigation form, along with building code, roof covering, deck attachment, roof-to-wall attachment and secondary water resistance (Citizens, mitigation form changes). Pulte states "Impact glass windows included with every home" at Shores at Stillwater (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater); a 2004 Unit 1 home without rated protection cannot claim that line until windows or shutters are upgraded and permitted. On stucco there is no builder standard left on a resale. Pulte's own one-year standard, which applies only to Shores homes, treats cracks wider than 1/8 inch as a repair item, a useful benchmark for what a resale inspector flags. Irrigation spray on walls and mulch built up over the stucco edge are common Florida causes worth noting.
Yes. A Stillwater resale pool should show at least one of the barrier, cover, alarm or self-latching door features Florida's pool statute lists, and the cage should show either original panels with no storm repair or a permitted rebuild. Ask an insurer early how the cage is covered for wind.
Pulte advertises "Pool options on all homes" and an optional screened lanai and pool at Shores at Stillwater, and its November offer includes a standard pool on select to-be-built homes (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). For an older Stillwater pool home, Hurricanes Ian (2022), Helene and Milton (2024) are the storms to ask about: was the cage repaired, by whom, and under which permit. Ask an insurance agent during the inspection period, rather than after closing, whether the policy treats the pool cage as an other-structures item, with what limit, and how the hurricane deductible applies. A missing pool barrier feature is a buyer repair item to price into the offer.
There is no Stillwater-specific report either way. Federal guidance looks at drywall installed 2001 to 2009, and 113 of the 251 older Stillwater homes were built 2004 to 2009 by year built. That does not mean any is affected; buyers of those homes can ask for the CPSC-style threshold check.
The Florida story started close by: ProPublica, reporting with the Sarasota Herald-Tribune, found a Florida builder investigating odor complaints as early as July 2006 and named an affected home in a community south of Sarasota (ProPublica, tainted drywall concerns). A CPSC field report describes "visible signs of corrosion and blackening on copper pipes and wires" and "a noticeable sulfur odor" in a Gulf Coast home that appeared to be affected (CPSC, drywall investigation file). The practical check: ask the seller in writing whether the home was ever tested, remediated or part of a drywall claim; have the inspector look at AC coil copper, ground wires at outlets and the panel, and note any odor; and if signs appear, order a specialist assessment before the inspection period ends. Our count covers 44 Unit 1 homes built 2004 to 2006, all 35 Unit 2 homes and 34 Unit 3 homes built 2007 to 2009; year built is only a proxy for when drywall went in.
A pest control licensee, on the state's FDACS form 13645. The report covers what is visible and readily accessible and is not a guarantee. On a Stillwater resale, also ask the seller for any termite bond or treatment contract, which the AS IS form lets the buyer take by assignment.
Florida law requires a written wood-destroying organism report "on a form prescribed by the department" when a licensee inspects for a real estate transaction, and says a report "does not constitute a guarantee of the absence of wood-destroying organisms" unless it states the extent of one (Fla. Stat. 482.226). The form itself excludes areas "concealed by wall-coverings, floor coverings, furniture" and similar (FDACS form 13645). Order it inside the inspection period. On a new Shores home, ask Pulte for the soil pretreatment record in the closing file.
Stillwater is in unincorporated Sarasota County, so the county's online permitting portal holds the record. Search the address for the original permit and CO date, then reroof, AC, window, shutter, pool, cage and lanai permits, and any permit left open or expired. Confirm anything unclear with the county building office.
The resale contract helps: on the AS IS form the seller states it knows of no improvements made without permits or under permits not properly closed (Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS contract). If an old permit is open, Florida lets an owner close it, and an expired permit whose work is "substantially completed" may be closed "without having to obtain a new building permit" (Fla. Stat. 553.79). The CO date matters twice in Stillwater: it starts the 4-year and 7-year construction claim clocks under Fla. Stat. 95.11, and it tells the wind mitigation inspector which code edition applied. Every Units 1 to 3 home is past the 7-year repose, so a construction defect claim against the original builder is generally out of time there. A 2026 Shores CO runs to 2030 for the 4-year limit and 2033 for repose. Before suing over a defect, Florida requires a Chapter 558 notice at least 60 days before filing (Fla. Stat. 558.004).
Only a home inspector licensed under Part XV of Chapter 468. The inspector may not repair a home it inspected, may not pay agents for referrals, may not tie the fee to the findings, and must carry at least $300,000 of liability insurance. On a Stillwater purchase, the state's license lookup confirms the name and number.
The prohibitions are in Fla. Stat. 468.8319, which bars an inspector from inspecting property in which it has "any financial or transfer interest" and from accepting work whose fee is "contingent upon ... the close of escrow." The insurance minimum is in Fla. Stat. 468.8322. The state licensing office says users "can verify licenses by name or license number," and renewal requires 14 hours of continuing education with at least 2 hours on wind mitigation (DBPR, home inspectors). For a Stillwater resale, an inspector who can also sign the wind mitigation form saves a visit.
The survey shows lot lines, easements, fences and the pool cage against the boundary; the elevation certificate shows the finished floor height an insurer prices flood on. A Shores at Stillwater home should have a fresh certificate from 2025 or 2026; an older Stillwater home may have one from the original build or a later quote.
The AS IS form advises the buyer "to verify by elevation certificate which flood zone the Property is in," lists "Survey (and elevation certification, if required)" among buyer costs, and gives a flood exit within 20 days if left blank when the home sits in a Special Flood Hazard Area below minimum elevation (Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS contract). Florida requires surveyors to file a digital copy of every elevation certificate with the Division of Emergency Management, which keeps a public search (FDEM, elevation certificates). Ask the title agent whether a prior survey with a survey affidavit will do.
Repairs completed with receipts and permits, every system running, appliances present and working, keys, gate access and openers in hand, and no new damage since inspection. On a Shores at Stillwater home, add Pulte's punch-list items and the warranty book; on a resale, add the wind form, termite bond and any transferable warranties.
The AS IS form sets the walk-through "On the day prior to Closing Date, or on Closing Date prior to time of Closing" (Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS contract). Pulte calls its final walk the step where "it's time for the most important inspection: yours" (Pulte, Build Quality Experience). Bring the inspection report and check each item against it.
Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. We set the Stillwater inspection calendar the day a contract is signed: roof permit date, 4-point and wind form to an insurer, drywall threshold check on 2004 to 2009 homes, termite report and permit search, or Pulte access dates in writing on a Shores home. Book a Stillwater buyer consultation or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
Flood zone is set lot by lot in Stillwater, so the FEMA map and the lot's elevation certificate confirm it for each address. Insurance turns on more than the zone: Citizens requires flood on every wind policy from January 1, 2027, and roof age, the 4-point and the wind form decide older-home premiums.
Data updated: November 2026 (42 U.S.C. 4012a and 4013; FEMA Risk Rating 2.0 page, updated April 9, 2026; FEMA CRS eligible communities list, October 1, 2026; Congressional Research Service Insight IN10835, updated September 11, 2026; National Association of Realtors NFIP lapse FAQ; Citizens flood, inspections and form bulletins; Citizens 2026 approved rate changes by county; Florida OIR market overview, data as of October 2026; Fla. Stat. 627.7011 and 215.5586; Florida CFO mitigation guide, July 2026; Florida Building Commission effective dates chart; NWS Tampa Bay Helene and Milton impact narratives; Shores at Stillwater CDD June 15, 2026 meeting book; Sarasota County Property Appraiser 2026 TRIM supplement. All checked November 18, 2026.)
The county roll we tracked puts Stillwater homes in three building eras: 2000 to 2007 (Units 1 and 2), 2007 to 2013 (Unit 3) and 2025 to 2026 (Shores at Stillwater), on the October 21, 2026 file (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Each era meets insurers differently. The new Pulte homes come with impact glass and tile roofs. The older homes carry roof age, 4-point and code-era questions. Flood sits across all three, because the Citizens flood rule does not depend on the FEMA zone at all. We do not print a flood zone for Stillwater as a whole: no lot-by-lot reading exists for Unit 2, Unit 3 or Shores at Stillwater in our research, and FEMA's map service is checked by address. Our Stillwater neighborhood guide covers the setting beside HCA Florida Englewood Hospital.
Type the address into FEMA's Flood Map Service Center, then match the answer to the lot's elevation certificate. Shores at Stillwater buyers should also ask Pulte or the title company for the lot survey, the certificate and any letter of map change, because the zone and the floor height decide both the lender rule and the flood price.
FEMA's map portal is at msc.fema.gov. Special Flood Hazard Areas are the A and V zones; Citizens lists the zones it treats as SFHA as "A, AO, AH, A1-A30, AE, A99, V, V1-V30, VE" (Citizens, flood). At Shores at Stillwater, the CDD engineer's report says the surface water system is "consisting primarily of wet detention ponds" designed to the water management district and county standards, and that "these ponds will provide 100-year flood control, conveyance of stormwater through and around the District" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). That is a pond design standard, not a flood-zone determination for any lot, and the same report mentions "floodplain management ponds," so check each Shores address rather than assume. Elevation certificates are searchable through FDEM, and FloodSmart notes a certificate is not required to buy flood cover but "can help you pay less" (FloodSmart, flood insurance cost).
Only if the Stillwater home sits in a Special Flood Hazard Area. Federal law then requires coverage at least equal to the lesser of the loan balance or the program maximum. Outside an SFHA there is no federal mandate, though Citizens may still require flood, and the premium then counts in the loan's debt ratio.
The mandate and its amount are in 42 U.S.C. 4012a, which also requires regulated lenders to "accept private flood insurance" that meets the statute's definition. Fannie Mae counts "property, flood, and mortgage insurance premiums (as applicable)" in monthly housing expense (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-03). New NFIP coverage normally starts after a 30-day wait, with an exception when it is bought "in connection with the making, increasing, extension, or renewal of a loan" (42 U.S.C. 4013), which is why a Stillwater closing can bind flood on closing day.
By the property, not the zone letter. FEMA's current method uses flood types, distance to water, elevation and rebuild cost, with most annual increases capped at 18 percent. A Stillwater buyer can keep a seller's lower rate by taking an assignment of the seller's NFIP policy, if coverage has been continuous.
FEMA says the method was fully in place "As of April 1, 2023," that "most rates not increase more than 18% per year," and that "Policyholders are able to transfer their discount to a new owner by assigning their flood insurance policy" (FEMA, Risk Rating 2.0). FloodSmart's agent guide adds that "Continuous coverage is required to maintain the discount" (FloodSmart, moving in). Unincorporated Sarasota County, community 125144, is Class 5 in the Community Rating System, a 25 percent NFIP discount (FEMA, CRS eligible communities, October 2026). A long-held Unit 1 or Unit 2 policy may still be gliding toward full price, which makes an assignment worth asking for; a Shores first-owner policy from 2025 or 2026 started at full price, so its value is continuity.
The NFIP is authorized until December 11, 2026. In a lapse, no new or renewal NFIP policies are issued, so a Stillwater closing that needs a new NFIP policy could stall. Taking an assignment of the seller's policy, binding before the date, or using private flood are the routes the sources name.
The Congressional Research Service says the program is "currently authorized until December 11, 2026," and that during the June 2010 lapse "over 1,400 home sale closings were canceled or delayed each day" (CRS Insight IN10835). The National Association of Realtors adds that existing policies stay in force to expiration, that "Insurers may assign the seller's NFIP policy to the buyer simply by substituting names," and that "Private flood insurance (not backed by NFIP) is not affected" (NAR, NFIP expiration FAQ). Our research found no enacted extension past December 11 as of November 18, 2026. For a December or January Stillwater closing that depends on flood cover, line up the binder early.
Yes, increasingly. Since January 1, 2026, Citizens requires flood on policies with dwelling coverage of $400,000 or more, and from January 1, 2027 it requires flood on all policies with wind, regardless of value or zone. Condo unit-owner, tenant and ex-wind policies are exempt; Stillwater homes are not condo units.
Citizens lists the steps: effective January 1, 2026, "Policies with a dwelling value of $400,000 or more," and effective January 1, 2027, "All policies, regardless of value," with a flood limit "Equal to or greater than your Citizens policy dwelling value" (Citizens, flood). Dwelling coverage is rebuild cost, not price. A Unit 1 home with a median 2,204 heated sq ft, or a larger Shores plan, may already be above $400,000 of dwelling coverage, so a 2026 Citizens wind policy on it would already need flood. From 2027 a 1,349 sq ft Unit 3 home is in the same position. Where the NFIP cannot match dwelling coverage, Citizens accepts the NFIP Regular Program maximum of "$250,000 Coverage A," and a private or excess policy can fill the gap.
Often it does. Florida bars an insurer from refusing a Stillwater home solely because the roof is under 15 years old, and for an older roof the insurer must allow an inspection; a roof with 5 or more years of useful life left cannot be refused for age alone. Citizens adds 25-year shingle and 50-year tile limits.
The rule is Fla. Stat. 627.7011(5), for policies "issued or renewed on or after July 1, 2022," with roof age measured from "the last date on which 100 percent of the roof's surface area was built or replaced." Citizens wants documentation of at least five years of remaining life on roofs "Older than 25 years for shingle and other types of roofs (soft)" or "50 years for tile, slate, concrete or metal roofs (hard)," based on "the oldest part of the roof" (Citizens, roof rule changes). If original, Unit 1 roofs from 2000 and 2001 are at or past the 25-year shingle line now and Unit 2 roofs reach it in 2030 to 2031. Roof material per Stillwater home is not in our research, so the inspection confirms it. The same statute requires insurers to offer law and ordinance coverage at 50 percent of the dwelling limit, which pays for code upgrades after a loss and matters most on pre-2009 roofs.
Homes built to the 2001 Florida Building Code or later qualify automatically for a minimum 68 percent discount on the windstorm part of the premium, per the state's consumer guide. Most Stillwater homes fall in that era; the ten Unit 1 homes built in 2000 and 2001 may predate it and rely on the form.
The CFO guide says such homes "are automatically eligible for a minimum 68% discount on the windstorm coverage of the premium," that "These discounts apply only to the windstorm coverage of your policy," and that a homeowner who meets the 2001 code minimums "may also have the option to reduce your hurricane deductible" (Florida CFO, mitigation discounts guide). The first statewide code took effect March 1, 2002, the 2004 code October 1, 2005, the 2007 code March 1, 2009, the 2010 code March 15, 2012, and the 8th Edition (2023) on December 31, 2023 (Florida Building Commission, effective dates). Shores at Stillwater homes were built under the 8th Edition. Citizens' new form adds roof slope, region and FORTIFIED certificate fields, and Citizens says the changes "will not result in any difference to the credits available" (Citizens, mitigation form changes).
Possibly, after closing, for some older Stillwater homes. The statute limits grants to homesteaded homes built before January 1, 2008 with insured value of $700,000 or less and to low- or moderate-income owners. The 2000 to 2007 Units 1 and 2 homes and the 2007 Unit 3 homes pass the date test; later homes and every Shores home do not.
The rules are in Fla. Stat. 215.5586: "The home must have been built before January 1, 2008, as reflected on the county property appraiser's website," grants are matched "$1 provided by the applicant for $2 provided by the state," "up to a maximum state contribution of $10,000," and eligible work includes roof-to-wall connections, roof-deck attachment and secondary water resistance with a new roof covering. Because homestead is required, a grant cannot fund a roof before closing. The program has closed mid-year before when funds ran out (The Capitolist, July 18, 2024), and its status on November 18, 2026 was not confirmed, so check the program site before planning around it.
Citizens' 2026 approved average for a multiperil HO3 policy in Sarasota County is $2,901 a year, and Florida OIR's admitted-market average with wind is $3,736 as of October 2026. These are averages, not quotes for any Stillwater home; a 2003 Unit 1 home and a 2026 Shores home will price very differently.
The Sarasota row in Citizens' county table shows 9,090 HO3 policies moving from a $3,134 average to an approved $2,901, a 7.4 percent decrease (Citizens, 2026 approved rate changes by county). OIR reports a "-2.3% 30-Day Average Request for Homeowners' Rates" and says twenty-one more property and casualty insurers have been approved to enter Florida (Florida OIR, market overview). We use the $2,901 Citizens figure as the labeled insurance input in our monthly cost builds below. Pulte's Shores page shows its own lower monthly insurance estimates on base plans; those are builder estimates for new impact-glass, tile-roof homes, not quotes.
The Shores at Stillwater home brings a new tile roof, impact glass and the newest code; the Units 1 and 2 home brings roof age, a required 4-point and possible flood at higher dwelling values; the Unit 3 home sits between, with roofs 13 to 19 years old if original and the 4-point arriving from 2027.
| Insurance angle | New Pulte home, Shores at Stillwater (2025 to 2026) | Units 1 and 2 resale (2000 to 2007) | Unit 3 resale (2007 to 2013) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Code era | 8th Edition (2023) | 2001 or 2004 code for most; 2000 to 2001 builds may predate the first code | 2004 code before March 1, 2009; 2007 code to March 14, 2012; 2010 code after |
| Roof | New tile ("hard"), 50-year Citizens line | If original, most 20 to 26 years; past the 15-year statutory line | If original, 13 to 19 years; 2010 to 2013 builds cross the 15-year line 2025 to 2028 |
| 25 percent roof rule | Does not apply | Applies to original roofs (pre-March 1, 2009 permits) | Applies to 2007 to 2008 originals; not to 2010 to 2013 originals |
| 4-point (Citizens) | Not needed | Required now on 2000 to 2006 builds (Citizens' 20-year line) | Required from 2027 (2007 builds) to 2033 (2013 builds) |
| Opening protection | Impact glass included (builder-stated) | Depends on shutters or replacement windows | Depends on shutters or replacement windows |
| Wind credit | 68 percent minimum on the windstorm portion | 68 percent minimum if 2001 code or later; otherwise by form | 68 percent minimum |
| Citizens flood rule | From 2027 for all; now if dwelling coverage is $400,000 or more | Same; larger homes may already be over $400,000 | Same; from 2027 |
| My Safe Florida Home date test | Fails (built after 2007) | 2000 to 2007 builds pass; the one 2016 Unit 1 home fails | 2007 homes pass; 2008 to 2013 fail |
| Seller's flood disclosure period | Months (first owners since 2025) | Up to two decades of storms | Up to about 19 years |
| Quote | Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). | Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). | Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). |
Sources: Citizens, inspections; Citizens, flood; Fla. Stat. 627.7011; Citizens, 25 percent rule job aid; Fla. Stat. 215.5586; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater. Ages are our researchers' arithmetic from the year built on the October 21, 2026 county roll; the permit date, not the year built, decides each home's code and roof answers.
Helene (September 2024) brought Sarasota County gusts up to 69 mph and a record water level at the Myakka River mouth. Milton (October 2024) brought mandatory evacuations for zones A, B and C, gusts to 102 mph and 4 to 8 inches of rain. We found no public report naming Stillwater.
The National Weather Service recorded for Helene in Sarasota County "a maximum gust of 69 mph near Venice" and "A peak water level of 5.42 feet above MHHW" at the mouth of the Myakka River at North Port Charlotte (NWS Tampa Bay, Helene impact narrative). For Milton it recorded evacuations "Mandatory for zones A, B, and C," "a maximum gust of 97 mph at the Venice CMAN" and "102 mph at the Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport," rainfall "generally ranged from 4 to 8 inches," and "A peak water level of 5.3 feet above MHHW" at the Venice gauge (NWS Tampa Bay, Milton impact narrative). We do not say Stillwater did or did not flood; we say no public report naming it was found. The seller's flood disclosure and the insurer's claims history are where a specific home's record shows up.
Since October 1, 2024, a Florida seller must give a flood disclosure at or before signing, covering known flooding that damaged the home during the seller's ownership, flood claims and flood assistance. On a Stillwater resale owned since the 2000s that spans many storms; on a Shores home, only months.
Fla. Stat. 689.302 requires the form "at or before the time the sales contract is executed," asks about "any flooding that has damaged the property during Seller's ownership," any claim "including, but not limited to, a claim with the National Flood Insurance Program," and assistance including from FEMA, and counts "Sustained periods of standing water resulting from rainfall" as flooding. Florida Realtors explains the 2025 expansion that took effect October 1, 2025 (Florida Realtors, flood disclosures expanded). Ask for post-storm roof, cage or fence permits alongside the form.
We could not verify it. Sarasota County levels run A to E, and each owner's TRIM notice prints the level for the parcel; the county's Know Your Zone lookup confirms it by address. Flood zone and evacuation level are different maps, so check both for any Stillwater home.
The Property Appraiser's 2026 TRIM supplement shows a "Know your hurricane evacuation level" panel on the notice (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, 2026 TRIM supplement). WUSF describes the county's levels from A, "shown on the map as the color red," to E, with an address lookup (WUSF, Sarasota County evacuation map). Ask the seller for the latest TRIM notice during the inspection period.
5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine). We pull the elevation certificate, roof permit, 4-point and wind form for a Stillwater address before you write an offer and put them in front of an insurance agent the same day. Book a Stillwater buyer consultation or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
A Stillwater home's assessed value resets to market value on January 1 after the purchase, so the seller's bill is not your bill. The 2026 millage for unincorporated Sarasota County is 11.3068, plus a $290.78 Englewood fire assessment; Shores at Stillwater adds a CDD line that the older plats do not carry.
Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Tax Collector 2026 millage sheet, roll certified September 29, 2026; Sarasota County Property Appraiser 2026 TRIM supplement, homestead overview, portability FAQ and "Why did my taxes increase?" page; Fla. Stat. 193.155, 193.1555, 196.011 and 689.261; Englewood Area Fire Control District 2026 to 2027 assessments; Florida Division of Elections official results page; WGCU, November 4, 2026; Shores at Stillwater CDD FY2026/27 final budget and June 15, 2026 meeting book. All checked November 18, 2026.)
Property tax is the line most Stillwater buyers underestimate, for two different reasons. On an older resale, a long-held homestead may carry an assessed value far below today's price, and that cap does not pass to the buyer. On a new Shores at Stillwater home, the first bill may show land only, because the house was not finished on January 1. Both cases end the same way: a second-year bill built on full value at the 2026 rate of 11.3068 mills, plus flat lines. A seller's current tax figure is a starting point for the proration, not a budget. Florida's own disclosure says so in capitals: "BUYER SHOULD NOT RELY ON THE SELLER'S CURRENT PROPERTY TAXES AS THE AMOUNT OF PROPERTY TAXES THAT THE BUYER MAY BE OBLIGATED TO PAY IN THE YEAR SUBSEQUENT TO PURCHASE" (Fla. Stat. 689.261).
11.3068 mills, the 2026 countywide total for unincorporated Sarasota County outside Longboat Key, North Port and Venice. That is $11.31 per $1,000 of taxable value: 4.6478 county, 5.9290 school and 0.7300 emergency medical services. For a Stillwater home, Englewood's fire district bills separately as a flat amount.
| 2026 levy on a Stillwater parcel | Mills | Per $100,000 of taxable value |
|---|---|---|
| Sarasota County General Revenue | 3.2317 | $323.17 |
| Mosquito Control | 0.0490 | $4.90 |
| Sarasota County Hospital District | 1.0420 | $104.20 |
| West Coast Inland Navigation | 0.0394 | $3.94 |
| Southwest Florida Water Management | 0.1831 | $18.31 |
| Bonds, debt service | 0.0653 | $6.53 |
| Legacy Trail, debt service | 0.0373 | $3.73 |
| Total county (not including school) | 4.6478 | $464.78 |
| School Board, state | 2.6810 | $268.10 |
| School Board, local non-voted | 2.2480 | $224.80 |
| School Board, local voted | 1.0000 | $100.00 |
| Total school | 5.9290 | $592.90 |
| Emergency Medical Services | 0.7300 | $73.00 |
| Total countywide | 11.3068 | $1,130.68 |
| Englewood Area Fire Control District (non-ad valorem) | Flat | $290.78 a year per home; $63.95 a vacant lot |
Sources: Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; Englewood Area Fire Control District, assessments. Per $100,000 figures are our researchers' arithmetic. The sheet also lists solid waste, stormwater and Englewood Water District lines and an optional Englewood lighting levy of 0.0644 mills; which appear on a given Stillwater bill, and at what amount, is confirmed on that parcel's bill.
At those rates, a $523,000 Shores home taxed on full value carries about $5,913.46 a year of ad valorem tax without homestead, a $282,500 Unit 3 home about $3,194.17, and a $550,000 Units 1 and 2 home about $6,218.74, before the fire line and any CDD (our researchers' arithmetic at the 2026 millage, price taken as taxable value, which is a ceiling).
No. Exemptions and caps belong to the seller. A Stillwater home bought in 2026 resets to market value on January 1, 2027, and the new owner must apply for any homestead. A home held for twenty years under Save Our Homes can show an assessed value well below the price you pay.
The Property Appraiser puts it plainly: "Exemptions and caps belong to the seller, not the buyer," and "New buyers must apply for homestead exemptions" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, why did my taxes increase). The 2026 TRIM supplement adds: "If you purchased property after January 1, 2026, it may show assessment limitations and applicable exemptions from the previous owner. Per Florida Statute, the property will reset to market value on January 1, 2027," and "Homestead exemptions are not pro-rated based on a purchase date" (2026 TRIM supplement). The statute is Fla. Stat. 193.155: homestead property is assessed "at just value as of January 1 of the year following a change of ownership." A buyer who closes on a Unit 1 home in December 2026 pays the 2026 bill on the seller's capped value through the closing proration, then the 2027 bill on the reset value.
A Shores at Stillwater home finished after January 1 was on that year's roll as land only, because Florida has no partial assessments. The first bill can show a few hundred dollars of land tax and the $63.95 vacant-lot fire charge. The full house-and-land bill arrives the next November, so escrow set from the first bill runs short.
The Property Appraiser says a new house may have been "only assessed as vacant land last year" and "There are no partial assessments in Florida" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, why did my taxes increase). The fire district bills "Vacant Lot $63.95" against "Residential $290.78" (Englewood Area Fire Control District). On our researchers' arithmetic, a $523,000 Shores home taxed on full value without homestead owes about $5,913.46 a year of ad valorem tax plus $290.78 fire, about $492.79 a month of tax alone. With 107 Shores lots still coded vacant on the October 21, 2026 roll (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), many homes Pulte closes in 2026 and 2027 may meet this pattern. Ask the lender to set escrow from a full-value estimate, not from the land bill, so the lender's annual escrow analysis does not bring a shortage and a higher payment.
Own and occupy the Stillwater home as your permanent residence on January 1, then file with the Sarasota County Property Appraiser by March 1. The exemption is $25,000 on all levies plus up to $26,411 more on non-school levies for 2026. From the second year, Save Our Homes caps homestead increases; the 2026 cap was 2.7 percent.
The filing rule is Fla. Stat. 196.011: owners "shall, on or before March 1 of each year, file an application," with a late path for "extenuating circumstances." The Property Appraiser's overview lists what to bring, including the recorded deed or tax bill and a Florida driver license or ID at the address, and offers e-filing (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, homestead overview). The TRIM supplement gives the 2026 caps, "2.7% for homesteaded properties and 10% for non-homesteaded properties," and the 2026 maximum additional exemption of $26,411 (2026 TRIM supplement). Timing matters: a buyer who owns and occupies on January 1, 2027 files by March 1, 2027 for the 2027 tax year, while a buyer who closes on January 2, 2027 waits until 2028.
Yes, if you had a Florida homestead in any of the three prior years. Portability moves up to $500,000 of the old home's cap difference to the new one. Moving up to a Shores at Stillwater home generally carries the full difference; moving down to a smaller Unit 3 home uses a ratio. You file with the new homestead application.
The Property Appraiser's FAQ says "there is no requirement that the property be sold," but the old homestead must be abandoned; upsizing carries "up to $500,000 in Save Our Homes Cap value," downsizing uses "the ratio of the Market to the Assessed Value," and the form is DR-501T (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, portability FAQ). The three-year lookback is in Fla. Stat. 193.155(8). If you are selling a Florida home to buy in Stillwater, our Stillwater home valuation page explains how we price the home you are leaving.
A Stillwater second home or rental is taxed at full market value in the first year after purchase, with no homestead. From the second year, non-school levies are capped at 10 percent a year and never above market value; school levies, 5.9290 of the 11.3068 mills, are never capped on non-homestead property.
The 10 percent cap applies "For all levies other than school district levies," and any increase "may not exceed 10 percent of the assessed value" (Fla. Stat. 193.1555). The TRIM supplement adds that "the school board levy on non-homesteaded property is always based on its full market value" (2026 TRIM supplement). Our monthly cost builds below use the non-homestead tax as the base case, because that is how many buyers' first full year looks.
Voters approved Amendment 3 on November 3, 2026, according to the state's official results page, with 61.98 percent yes. Certification was not confirmed on November 18, 2026. As reported, it raises the non-school homestead exemption to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028. It does not reduce the fire assessment or the Shores at Stillwater CDD.
The Division of Elections page shows "Yes for Approval" at 61.98 percent under "Official Election Results" (Florida Election Watch, amendments). WGCU reported that "Starting next year, the homestead exemption will triple from $50,000 to $150,000," that "The following year it will mushroom to $250,000 for non-school local taxes," and that the non-homestead cap becomes "5 percent starting in 2027" (WGCU, November 4, 2026). County implementation for the 2027 roll is not yet published. On our researchers' arithmetic at 2026 millage, a homesteaded $282,500 Unit 3 home would go from about $2,769.47 a year under 2026 rules to about $2,239.28 under the reported 2027 rules, and a $523,000 Shores home from about $5,488.75 to about $4,958.56; 2027 millage is not set, so these are not forecasts. Special benefit assessments such as the $290.78 fire line and any CDD line stay as they are.
The Shores at Stillwater CDD covers Shores only; the district's boundary covers Shores at Stillwater, so confirm on the tax bill. The district says assessments appear as one non-ad valorem line on the November bill, but for FY2026/27 its operating share is "To Be Collected At Closings," and the district does not appear on the 2026 county sheet.
The district site says, "The annual assessments appear as one line in the non-ad valorem section of the property tax bill," with a fiscal year of October 1 to September 30 (Shores at Stillwater CDD). Its FY2026/27 final budget shows O&M assessments "To Be Collected At Closings" and notes that if the district were on the assessment roll, the "O&M Rate Would Be $276 (255 Units)" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, FY2026/27 budget). The maximum annual debt assessment is about $1,383 on a 34-foot villa lot and about $1,915 on a 52-foot lot per the district's June 15, 2026 book, and the district says amounts may fluctuate (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). Whether the 2027 debt line goes on the tax roll or is billed directly was not confirmed in our research, so ask the district manager's office at contract. The CDD line is not in the 2027 listing-platform tax estimate that Fla. Stat. 689.261 will require from February 1, 2027, so a Shores buyer adds it separately.
#1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012. We run a tax estimate for each Stillwater address before an offer: 2026 millage on your price, your homestead and portability position, the fire line, and the CDD line at Shores, so the second-year bill and your escrow hold no surprise. Book a Stillwater buyer consultation or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
A financed Stillwater buyer pays the state taxes on the loan (35 cents per $100 of note stamps plus 0.2 percent intangible tax), recording, the lender's title policy and, by Sarasota County custom on a resale, the owner's title policy. On a $440,000 loan the two state taxes alone are $2,420.
Data updated: November 2026 (Fla. Stat. 201.02, 201.08, 199.133, 28.24, 720.30851 and 720.3085; Florida DOR documentary stamp tax page; Rule 69O-186.003, F.A.C.; Barnes Walker Sarasota closing customs; Chicago Title Florida Laws and Customs, 08/26; DBPR estoppel fee schedule; Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS contract, Rev. 12/24; Shores at Stillwater CDD FY2026/27 budget; Pulte Shores at Stillwater offer terms; FinCEN residential real estate page; CFPB Closing Disclosure page. Medians from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026. All checked November 18, 2026.)
Most of a Stillwater buyer's closing bill is set by statute or promulgated rate, so it can be estimated before an offer. What changes is lender charges, prepaid interest and escrow, insurance premiums, and the contract's answer on who pays the owner's title policy. Stillwater sits in Sarasota County, where custom puts the owner's policy on the buyer, the reverse of Charlotte County just to the south. On a Pulte contract, the builder's form controls those terms instead, so we read the cost sections of Pulte's purchase agreement with you before you sign.
With 20 percent down, the two state taxes on the loan run $1,243 on a $282,500 Unit 3 resale, $2,302.30 on a $523,250 Shores at Stillwater home and $2,420 on a $550,000 Units 1 and 2 resale. Recording, the lender's title policy, lender fees and, on a resale, the owner's policy come on top.
| Buyer closing item | Unit 3 resale, $282,500 ($226,000 loan) | Shores first sale, $523,250 ($418,600 loan) | Units 1 and 2 resale, $550,000 ($440,000 loan) | Rule or custom |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Doc stamps on the note and mortgage, 35 cents per $100 of the loan | $791.00 | $1,465.10 | $1,540.00 | Fla. Stat. 201.08 |
| Intangible tax, 2 mills (0.2 percent of the loan) | $452.00 | $837.20 | $880.00 | Fla. Stat. 199.133 |
| Two state taxes together | $1,243.00 | $2,302.30 | $2,420.00 | Our researchers' arithmetic |
| Recording | $10.00 first page, $8.50 each added page; a 15-page mortgage is $129 | Same | Same | Fla. Stat. 28.24 |
| Lender's title policy | Promulgated table; title agent quotes it | Same | Same | Rule 69O-186.003 |
| Owner's policy, original rate | $1,487.50 (buyer by Sarasota custom) | $2,691.50 if Pulte's contract assigns it to the buyer | $2,825.00 (buyer by Sarasota custom) | Rule 69O-186.003; Barnes Walker, Sarasota customs |
| Owner's policy, reissue rate (seller's policy under 3 years old) | $877.50 | Not applicable on a first sale | $1,680.00 | Rule 69O-186.003 |
| HOA estoppel certificate | Seller's cost by form default; up to $299, $119 more to rush, up to $179 more if delinquent | Not usually needed when Pulte sells | Same as Unit 3 | DBPR estoppel fee schedule |
| HOA application or transfer fee | Buyer's cost by form default; amount on the estoppel | Per Pulte's contract | Same as Unit 3 | AS IS contract cost lists |
| Shores CDD O&M | None (outside the district) | FY2026/27 O&M "To Be Collected At Closings"; amount on the Closing Disclosure | None | Shores at Stillwater CDD budget |
| Survey (and elevation certificate if required) | Buyer by custom | Per Pulte's contract | Buyer by custom | Barnes Walker; AS IS contract |
The $282,500 and $550,000 prices are the 12-month Unit 3 (n=10) and Units 1 and 2 (n=9, a small group) resale medians, and $523,250 is the 12-month Shores Pulte first-sale median (n=16), all from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file we tracked. Title premiums are promulgated premium only, before endorsements; the Shores premium rounds the price to $523,300. Lender fees, prepaid interest, escrow deposits, inspections and insurance premiums are left out because no sourced figure applies to a specific buyer.
The note stamp on a single note "may not exceed $2,450" (Fla. Stat. 201.08), which none of these Stillwater loans reaches. Deed stamps are 70 cents per $100 under Fla. Stat. 201.02: $1,977.50 at $282,500 and $3,850.00 at $550,000. The Department of Revenue says "All parties to the document are liable for the tax regardless of which party agrees to pay the tax" (Florida DOR, documentary stamp tax); in Sarasota County resales they are customarily the seller's, and on a Pulte sale the builder's form says who pays. The lender must deliver the Closing Disclosure "at least three business days before you close" (CFPB, Closing Disclosure).
On a Stillwater resale, Sarasota County custom puts the owner's policy and the choice of closing agent on the buyer; on the AS IS form that means checking box 9(c)(ii). Custom is not law, and the contract controls. On a Pulte contract at Shores at Stillwater, the builder's form controls.
Barnes Walker's Sarasota column lists owner's title insurance as "Buyer" and closing agent selection as "Buyer," with deed stamps, the municipal lien search and the HOA estoppel letter as "Seller" (Barnes Walker, Sarasota and Manatee closing customs). Chicago Title's statewide guide, dated 08/26, names Sarasota among the counties where the buyer pays the owner's policy and says it is "customary in Miami-Dade, Broward, and Sarasota counties for the Buyer to pay" the mortgage taxes (Chicago Title, Florida Laws and Customs). Because the buyer pays the owner's premium here, the reissue saving is usually the buyer's too: the rate applies when the seller's own policy is less than 3 years old and the seller hands it over, which the AS IS form requires "within 5 days after Effective Date."
The estoppel certificate is the association's statement of what is owed on the Stillwater parcel. It must be issued within 10 business days, lasts 30 days if delivered electronically, and its fee is capped at $299 for 2026 to 2027. The buyer is jointly liable for unpaid assessments, so the estoppel figure matters at closing.
The deadline and effective periods are in Fla. Stat. 720.30851. DBPR's adjusted caps are "not more than $299," "an additional $119" for delivery within 3 business days, and "an additional fee not to exceed $179" if delinquent, with the next update "by July 1, 2027" (DBPR, estoppel certificate fees). Joint liability is in Fla. Stat. 720.3085: an owner is "jointly and severally liable with the previous parcel owner for all unpaid assessments that came due up to the time of transfer of title." No dues figure is published for the Stillwater Homeowners Association, the Stillwater Unit Three association or the Shores at Stillwater association, so the estoppel and the current budget are where the buyer learns the regular assessment, any capital contribution or transfer fee, open violations and whether a second association applies.
Pulte's November offer at Shores at Stillwater is a standard pool valued at $69,500 on select to-be-built homes, or a $77,000 credit toward closing costs, rate buydown, design options and quick move-ins, on purchase agreements accepted by Pulte between November 2 and November 30, 2026. It cannot be combined with other offers, and acceptance is at Pulte's discretion.
Pulte's fine print says the credit is applied "as a reduction to the total purchase price of the home," that "Maximum credit amounts vary by community," that the "Offer cannot be combined with other offers or incentives," and that it "is subject to change or withdrawal at any time without notice." The pool disclaimer adds that "A buyer's submission of a purchase agreement does not constitute acceptance by Pulte Homes," that acceptance "is in the sole and absolute discretion of Pulte Homes," and that "Any unused credit is the property of the builder" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). It also warns the offer "may affect the amount of loan for which a buyer may be eligible." The credit text itself does not say it requires Pulte Mortgage, while Pulte's rate offers do, so get in writing whether the credit applies with an outside lender and whether it can cover the note stamps, intangible tax or owner's policy above. This is marketing with conditions and an end date, not a price.
Not at present. A federal court vacated FinCEN's residential real estate reporting rule on March 19, 2026, and the government has appealed. While that order stands, title agents and other reporting persons are not required to file the reports for a Stillwater closing.
FinCEN's page says the court "issued an order vacating the Residential Real Estate Rule," that FinCEN with the Department of Justice "has appealed the decision," and that reporting persons "are not required to file Real Estate Reports with FinCEN" while the order remains in force (FinCEN, residential real estate). The rule could return if the appeal succeeds, so a cash buyer closing through an entity should check the page again before closing.
Call the title agent at a number you found independently, not one in an email, before sending any funds, and confirm the wiring instructions by voice. On a Pulte closing at Shores at Stillwater, verify with the closing agent named in Pulte's contract. Treat any change in instructions as a stop sign.
The National Association of Realtors, citing FBI data, reported that criminals stole "more than $275 million through real estate-related fraud from at least 12,368 victims" in 2025 (NAR, April 13, 2026). The AS IS form calls for the balance "by wire transfer or other Collected funds," so the wire step is in nearly every financed or cash Stillwater closing.
McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate. We line up Pulte's Closing Disclosure or a resale settlement estimate against the rules above and flag every line that does not match, including the CDD collection at Shores and the estoppel figures on the older plats. Book a Stillwater buyer consultation or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
At 7.11 percent with 20 percent down and non-homestead tax, our researchers' builds come to about $3,756 a month for a $523,000 Shores home, about $2,052 for a $282,500 Unit 3 home and about $3,744 for a $550,000 Units 1 and 2 home, before HOA dues, which no Stillwater association publishes.
Data updated: November 2026 (Freddie Mac PMMS, week of November 12, 2026: 30-year fixed 7.11 percent, 15-year 6.45 percent; Sarasota County Tax Collector 2026 millage; Sarasota County Property Appraiser 2026 TRIM supplement; Englewood Area Fire Control District 2026 to 2027; Shores at Stillwater CDD June 15, 2026 book and FY2026/27 budget; Citizens 2026 approved average HO3 premium for Sarasota County; Florida OIR market overview; Englewood Water District FY27 rates. Prices are 12-month medians from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026. All checked November 18, 2026.)
The builds below are our researchers' arithmetic with each input labeled; they are not a loan quote. Price is taken as taxable value, which is a ceiling because the Property Appraiser's just value may sit below price. Insurance is a county average placeholder of $2,901 a year ($241.75 a month), the Citizens 2026 approved average HO3 premium for Sarasota County, not a quote for any Stillwater home (Citizens, 2026 approved rate changes by county). Flood insurance is $0 in the base case, which fits only a lot outside a Special Flood Hazard Area with a non-Citizens wind policy. HOA dues are $0 in every total because no primary source publishes dues for the Stillwater Homeowners Association, the Stillwater Unit Three association or the Shores at Stillwater association, and Pulte says only "Community Association fees required" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater); add the figure from the estoppel certificate or the budget. Solid waste, stormwater and utilities are also left out.
About $3,756 a month for a $523,000 Shores at Stillwater home with 20 percent down at 7.11 percent, non-homestead: $2,814.60 principal and interest, $492.79 tax, $182.54 CDD on a 52-foot lot, $24.23 fire and $241.75 insurance. With 2026 homestead rules it is about $3,721.
| Monthly line, $523,000 Shores home | Non-homestead | Homestead, 2026 rules | Homestead, Amendment 3 as reported (2027) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Principal and interest, $418,400 loan, 7.11 percent, 30 years | $2,814.60 | $2,814.60 | $2,814.60 |
| Property tax, 11.3068 mills, taxable value at price | $492.79 | $457.40 | $413.21 |
| Shores at Stillwater CDD, 52-foot lot ($1,914.48 debt plus $276 O&M a year) | $182.54 | $182.54 | $182.54 |
| Englewood fire assessment, $290.78 a year | $24.23 | $24.23 | $24.23 |
| Insurance, county average placeholder | $241.75 | $241.75 | $241.75 |
| HOA | Not published | Not published | Not published |
| Total before HOA | $3,755.91 | $3,720.52 | $3,676.34 |
Our researchers' arithmetic. Price: near the 12-month Shores Pulte first-sale median of $523,250 (n=16), rounded to $523,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Rate: Freddie Mac PMMS. Millage: Sarasota County Tax Collector. CDD: the district's maximum annual debt assessment and $276 O&M rate (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 book; FY2026/27 budget); the district says amounts may fluctuate. Fire: Englewood Area Fire Control District. Homestead: $25,000 on all levies plus $26,411 on non-school levies in 2026 (2026 TRIM supplement).
On a 34-foot villa lot, the CDD line is $138.22 a month ($1,382.68 debt plus $276 O&M a year), and the 30-year non-homestead total is about $3,711.60. A 15-year loan at 6.45 percent carries $3,633.22 of principal and interest, for a non-homestead total of $4,574.53. Using Florida OIR's admitted-market average of $3,736 a year with wind in place of the Citizens figure raises the 30-year non-homestead total to $3,825.50 (Florida OIR, market overview). Remember the first-bill trap: on a home finished after January 1, the full tax line may not reach escrow until the second November.
About $2,052 a month for a $282,500 Stillwater Unit 3 home with 20 percent down at 7.11 percent, non-homestead: $1,520.32 principal and interest, $266.18 tax, $24.23 fire and $241.75 insurance, with no CDD because Unit 3 sits outside the district. With 2026 homestead rules it is about $2,017.
| Monthly line, $282,500 Unit 3 resale | Non-homestead | Homestead, 2026 rules | Homestead, Amendment 3 as reported (2027) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Principal and interest, $226,000 loan, 7.11 percent, 30 years | $1,520.32 | $1,520.32 | $1,520.32 |
| Property tax, 11.3068 mills, taxable value at price | $266.18 | $230.79 | $186.61 |
| CDD | $0 (outside the district) | $0 | $0 |
| Englewood fire assessment | $24.23 | $24.23 | $24.23 |
| Insurance, county average placeholder | $241.75 | $241.75 | $241.75 |
| HOA | Not published | Not published | Not published |
| Total before HOA | $2,052.48 | $2,017.09 | $1,972.90 |
Our researchers' arithmetic. Price: the 12-month Unit 3 resale median of $282,500 (n=10), median 1,349 heated sq ft (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Other inputs as in the Shores table.
A 15-year loan at 6.45 percent carries $1,962.50 of principal and interest, a non-homestead total of $2,494.66. With the OIR average in place of the Citizens figure, the 30-year non-homestead total is $2,122.06. The Unit 3 homes were built 2007 to 2013, so the 4-point arrives with age from 2027 and the roof question sets the real insurance figure.
About $3,744 a month for a $550,000 Stillwater Units 1 and 2 home with 20 percent down at 7.11 percent, non-homestead: $2,959.91 principal and interest, $518.23 tax, $24.23 fire and $241.75 insurance, no CDD. That lands within about $12 a month of the Shores build before HOA, flood and real quotes.
| Monthly line, $550,000 Units 1 and 2 resale | Non-homestead | Homestead, 2026 rules | Homestead, Amendment 3 as reported (2027) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Principal and interest, $440,000 loan, 7.11 percent, 30 years | $2,959.91 | $2,959.91 | $2,959.91 |
| Property tax, 11.3068 mills, taxable value at price | $518.23 | $482.84 | $438.65 |
| CDD | $0 (outside the district) | $0 | $0 |
| Englewood fire assessment | $24.23 | $24.23 | $24.23 |
| Insurance, county average placeholder | $241.75 | $241.75 | $241.75 |
| HOA | Not published | Not published | Not published |
| Total before HOA | $3,744.12 | $3,708.73 | $3,664.54 |
Our researchers' arithmetic. Price: the 12-month Units 1 and 2 resale median of $550,000, a small group (n=9), median 2,368 heated sq ft (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Other inputs as in the Shores table.
A 15-year loan at 6.45 percent carries $3,820.79 of principal and interest, a non-homestead total of $4,605.00, and the OIR insurance average moves the 30-year non-homestead total to $3,813.70. These homes were built 2000 to 2007; dwelling coverage on a larger one may already exceed $400,000, which would require flood on a Citizens wind policy in 2026 (Citizens, flood), and that premium is not in the total.
About $66 to $69 a month for each $100,000 borrowed per rate point near 7 percent. On the $418,400 Shores at Stillwater loan, one point lower saves $276.42 a month and one point higher adds $287.61; on the $226,000 Unit 3 loan, $149.31 and $155.35; on the $440,000 Units 1 and 2 loan, $290.69 and $302.46.
| 30-year principal and interest | 6.11 percent | 7.11 percent (PMMS, November 12, 2026) | 8.11 percent |
|---|---|---|---|
| $418,400 loan (Shores, $523,000 price) | $2,538.19 | $2,814.60 | $3,102.22 |
| $226,000 loan (Unit 3, $282,500 price) | $1,371.01 | $1,520.32 | $1,675.67 |
| $440,000 loan (Units 1 and 2, $550,000 price) | $2,669.22 | $2,959.91 | $3,262.37 |
Our researchers' arithmetic on the Freddie Mac PMMS rate of November 12, 2026.
Pulte's own calculator shows an illustrative 6.5 percent rate through Pulte Mortgage; at that rate the $418,400 loan's principal and interest is $2,644.57, about $170 a month less than at 7.11 percent, which roughly offsets the Shores CDD line (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). That rate carries conditions, covered in the financing section below.
Englewood Water District serves Stillwater. Its FY27 base charges are $29.37 a month for water and $42.75 for sewer, before usage. A new Shores home also carries capacity charges of $15,249 plus $616.50; ask Pulte whether those are in the price. Electric service is FPL, whose tariff lists Englewood and unincorporated Sarasota County among the communities served.
The base charges and capacity charges come from the Englewood Water District FY27 Customer Rules and Regulations and its rates page. Usage charges depend on the household's consumption and are not in our builds. The district's home page posts "Extreme Water Shortage Restrictions Extended through March 31, 2027" (Englewood Water District); check the current restrictions before planning new landscaping on a Shores lot or a resale yard. Together the two base charges add $72.12 a month to any Stillwater home before a gallon is used (our researchers' arithmetic).
McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales. Send us a Stillwater address and we replace these averages with its own tax estimate, CDD lot size, estoppel dues figure and insurance quotes. Book a Stillwater buyer consultation or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873. Comparing with other Englewood homes first? Our Englewood buyer guide sets Stillwater beside the rest of the market.
Most Stillwater purchases fit a conventional loan: the 2026 one-unit limit is $832,750, above every 12-month median we tracked. Freddie Mac's 30-year average was 7.11 percent on November 12, 2026. At Shores at Stillwater, Pulte Mortgage offers rate incentives with conditions, but Pulte says buyers are not required to use it.
Data updated: November 2026 (Freddie Mac PMMS, November 12, 2026, and PMMS history file; FHFA 2026 conforming loan limits, November 25, 2025; HUD No. 25-145, December 11, 2025; VA loan limits page; Pulte Shores at Stillwater page and mortgage disclaimers, read November 18, 2026; 12 CFR 1024.14 and 1024.15; Florida Housing Hometown Heroes page and February 27, 2026 release. All checked November 18, 2026.)
Financing a Stillwater home comes down to three choices: which loan type, which lender, and whether a builder incentive is worth the strings attached to it. A resale buyer on Units 1 to 3 shops lenders freely and negotiates seller credits in the contract. A Shores at Stillwater buyer weighs Pulte Mortgage's incentive package against an outside lender's total cost, because Pulte ties its special rates to its affiliated lender. In both cases, the appraisal, insurance binder and, where required, flood policy have to land before closing, and in a storm month insurers may stop binding, which the resale contract's force majeure clause treats as a reason to extend.
Freddie Mac's 30-year average, the rate behind our Stillwater payment builds, was 7.11 percent and the 15-year 6.45 percent on November 12, 2026, the fourth straight weekly decline. The 2026 high was 7.40 percent on October 8 and October 15; the 2026 low was 5.98 percent on February 26. A year earlier the 30-year stood at 6.24 percent.
Freddie Mac's headline that week read "Mortgage Rates Decline for Fourth Consecutive Week to 7.11%," with the prior week at 7.18 percent (Freddie Mac PMMS). The high and low come from Freddie Mac's weekly history file (PMMS history). The survey assumes "good/excellent credit, 20% loans, home purchase loans on owner occupied 1-unit" homes, so a second-home or lower-down-payment Stillwater loan prices differently. On the $440,000 Units 1 and 2 loan above, the gap between the October high and today is real money: each point is about $291 to $302 a month.
The 2026 baseline conforming limit for a one-unit Stillwater home is $832,750, and no source we read lists Sarasota County as high cost. HUD's 2026 FHA floor is $541,287; confirm the Sarasota County FHA figure with your lender. VA borrowers with full entitlement have no loan limit.
FHFA set the 2026 baseline at "$832,750, an increase of $26,250 from 2025" (FHFA, 2026 conforming loan limits). HUD set the FHA one-unit floor at "$541,287," effective for case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2026 (HUD No. 25-145). VA says that with full entitlement "You don't have a loan limit," and with remaining entitlement the county limit applies (VA, loan limits). Every Stillwater 12-month median fits the conforming limit with 20 percent down. At the higher end of Pulte's sheet, the Mystique Grande lists from $565,990 as listed November 18, 2026 (prices change), so an FHA buyer there needs the county figure before choosing a plan.
At Shores at Stillwater, compare total cost, not rate alone. Pulte says buyers are "not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage," but its Builder Forward Commitment rates and affiliate incentives require Pulte Mortgage. Get a Loan Estimate from an outside lender on the same day and compare it with Pulte's offer after every credit and point.
Pulte's page shows an illustrative 6.5 percent rate (APR 6.007 percent) and a 5.125 percent introductory rate on a 7/6 adjustable loan, "based on an average of 30-year conventional or FHA loans ... locked with Pulte Mortgage LLC from 11/02/2026 to 11/15/2026," with rates based on "participation in the Affiliate Incentive Program, including financing through Pulte Mortgage LLC (NMLS 1791)" and "a FICO Score of 780." It adds: "You are not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage to purchase a home from seller; but use of Pulte Mortgage is necessary to receive BFC-related rate offers where and when available," and the BFC rate is available "until the pool of funds is depleted or the rate lock period expires" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Federal rules let a builder refer you to an affiliate only with a written affiliated business disclosure at referral and without requiring its use (12 CFR 1024.15); referral payments are barred by 12 CFR 1024.14. Ask for the disclosure, and ask whether Pulte's $77,000 November credit applies if you finance elsewhere.
Possibly, for first-time, income-qualified Stillwater buyers in the occupations Florida Housing lists. The 2026 program offers up to 5 percent of the first mortgage, from $10,000 to $35,000, as a 0 percent deferred second mortgage that is not forgivable. Whether funds remain on any given day must be confirmed with a participating lender.
Florida Housing describes "up to 5% of the total first mortgage loan amount (maximum of $35,000/minimum of $10,000) in funds towards down payment and closing cost assistance" through participating lenders (Florida Housing, Hometown Heroes). The previous round "committed all available funding for the 2025-2026 fiscal year" by February 27, 2026 (Florida Housing, 2026 press releases), which shows how fast it can run out. Whether Pulte Mortgage participates was not found, so a Shores buyer who wants Hometown Heroes checks that before choosing a lender; on a Unit 3 resale near the $282,500 median, the program's first mortgage comes from the participating lender.
A Stillwater cash buyer skips the loan taxes, the lender's title policy and the federal flood mandate, but not insurer rules, the Shores CDD or HOA assessments. Citizens still requires flood on wind policies from January 1, 2027, and a Shores CDD debt line stays with the lot unless its share is paid off.
Paying cash removes the 35 cents per $100 note stamps and 0.2 percent intangible tax from the closing table above. At Shores at Stillwater it is also the clearest case for asking about a CDD payoff. Per the district's methodology, the lot principal is $25,726.66 on a 52-foot lot and $18,580.37 on a 34-foot lot, before interest to the payment date; confirm a current payoff with the district manager's office (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 book). The Series 2026 bonds total $2,970,000 and mature in May 2056 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, amended FY2025/26 budget). A payoff removes the debt part of the line, not the O&M part. Keep an inspection period in a cash contract anyway, and follow the wire steps in the closing section.
Platinum Sales Production Award Winners. We set a conventional quote, a Pulte Mortgage offer with its credits, an FHA or VA option and a cash offer side by side for one Stillwater home. Book a Stillwater buyer consultation, read how we work with buyers on our buying page, or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873. Selling first? A number on your current home starts with our Stillwater home valuation or the Stillwater seller guide, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Stillwater sits off Medical Boulevard in unincorporated Sarasota County, with Englewood 34223 addresses and HCA Florida Englewood Hospital beside it. From a central Stillwater point, Englewood Beach is about 3.4 road miles away, Venice about 13.8 miles and Punta Gorda Airport about 28.6 miles, all as free-flow routing estimates.
Data updated: November 2026 (drive figures from one request to the public OSRM routing service on November 18, 2026, free-flow car times with no traffic, signals or season delays, from a central Stillwater point on Medical Boulevard; the hospital and Wellen Park rows are straight-line distances; place points from Pulte's Shores at Stillwater page; road projects from FDOT's SR 776 project page and WGCU)
We ran one routing table from a single point on Medical Boulevard at the older Stillwater plats to public destinations, converted the results to road miles and rounded minutes, and published no street address. Two destination points snapped to the wrong road, so the hospital and Wellen Park rows show straight-line miles instead of a drive. Every figure assumes empty roads; a January trip on SR 776 runs longer. For daily life and history, read our Stillwater community guide; this page stays on the purchase.
| Destination from central Stillwater | Road miles | Free-flow minutes | What it means for a Stillwater owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| HCA Florida Englewood Hospital (straight-line, not a drive) | about 0.5 straight-line | not measured | Next door to Shores at Stillwater, per Pulte |
| Englewood Beach, Chadwick Park area | 3.4 | 7 | Nearest Gulf beach, on Manasota Key |
| Wellen Park Boulevard (straight-line, not a drive) | about 6.8 straight-line | not measured | Large master plan to the north |
| Manasota Key, Blind Pass Beach area (approximate) | 7.3 | 18 | Sarasota County beach park on the Key |
| Rotonda West, inside the circle | 7.5 | 16 | Neighboring Charlotte County community |
| Manasota Key, Manasota Beach area (approximate) | 8.6 | 16 | North end of the Key |
| North Port, City Hall area (approximate) | 11.8 | 21 | Neighboring city to the east |
| Venice, City Hall area | 13.8 | 26 | Downtown Venice shops and services |
| I-75 exit 193, Jacaranda Boulevard (our community guide's route) | 14.1 | 26 | Interstate access by SR 776 |
| Port Charlotte, Fawcett hospital area | 20.0 | 32 | Charlotte County services and hospitals |
| Punta Gorda Airport, PGD | 28.6 | 48 | Closest commercial airport |
| Downtown Sarasota, Main Street | 32.0 | 56 | County seat area |
| Sarasota Bradenton International, SRQ | 42.4 | 64 | Larger airline choice |
| Southwest Florida International, RSW | 65.7 | 86 | Fort Myers hub |
Two patterns stand out. The hospital, the beach and daily errands sit inside about 3.5 miles of Stillwater, while the interstate, the airports and the county seat sit 14 to 66 miles away. Our community guide ran a separate routing table from another Stillwater street a day earlier and got Englewood Beach at 3.4 miles and Venice City Hall at 13.8, so the estimates hold across two origins inside the plats (OSRM). If your search covers the wider town, our Englewood buyer's guide compares both county sides.
HCA Florida Englewood Hospital sits on Medical Boulevard about half a mile in a straight line from the central Stillwater point we used, and our community guide's separate routing run put it at about 0.6 road miles and 2 minutes. Pulte markets Shores at Stillwater as "Next door to HCA Florida Englewood Hospital."
That phrase comes from Pulte's Shores at Stillwater page, whose place data also lists an emergency room entry at the hospital's main entrance. For a Stillwater buyer the practical points are two: the emergency room is minutes away by car, and the campus brings traffic and service vehicles onto Medical Boulevard, so drive the street at a weekday shift change before you choose a lot near the campus edge. Check the hospital's own site for the current list of services.
Englewood Beach in the Chadwick Park area is about 3.4 road miles and 7 free-flow minutes from central Stillwater. The Sarasota County beach parks farther up Manasota Key run longer: about 7.3 miles to the Blind Pass Beach area and 8.6 miles to the Manasota Beach area, 16 to 18 minutes.
Pulte says buyers can "Walk, bike or golf cart ride to pristine beaches less than 3.5 miles away" on its community page, and our routing estimate of 3.4 road miles agrees with it on distance. M/I Homes, which builds Sandpiper Pointe off Pine Street nearby, states the beach is "4.2 miles away (about a 9-minute drive)" from its site (M/I Homes), which shows how much the starting point moves the answer. Every beach trip from Stillwater uses SR 776 for part of the way, so the road work below affects it.
Venice's City Hall area is about 13.8 road miles and 26 free-flow minutes from central Stillwater, North Port's City Hall area about 11.8 miles and 21 minutes, and downtown Sarasota about 32 miles and 56 minutes. The Fawcett hospital area of Port Charlotte runs about 20 miles and 32 minutes.
All four come from the same OSRM routing request. Our community guide's earlier run used different destination points for North Port and Port Charlotte and gave different figures, which is why each row in the table names its point. A Wellen Park Boulevard point sits about 6.8 miles north of Stillwater in a straight line; our routing point there snapped to a Venice street, so we print no drive time for it rather than a wrong one.
Punta Gorda Airport is the closest, about 28.6 road miles and 48 free-flow minutes from central Stillwater. Sarasota Bradenton International is about 42.4 miles and 64 minutes, and Southwest Florida International in Fort Myers about 65.7 miles and 86 minutes, all as routing estimates from the same Medical Boulevard point.
Those three rows match our community guide's separate run within a minute (OSRM). Which airport wins depends on your airline and route more than the mileage, so compare the carriers that serve your usual cities and test the drive from Stillwater at your normal arrival hour. SR 776 and US 41 slow in season, and the River Road widening described below may slow the River Road route to I-75 from spring 2027.
FDOT is building raised medians, directional turn lanes and protected bike lanes on 2.189 miles of SR 776 from the Charlotte County line, from mid-2026 to mid-2027, with a separate resurfacing project on the same road Stillwater owners use. Sarasota County plans a $95 million River Road and Winchester Boulevard widening from spring 2027 to summer 2029.
The SR 776 details come from FDOT's project 447882-1 page, last updated October 20, 2026. Stillwater reaches SR 776 by Pine Street or River Road, so trips toward Dearborn Street, Englewood Beach and Venice pass through the work zone until it finishes. WGCU reported that the 7.3-mile River Road corridor "serves as an important evacuation route for Englewood and the barrier islands." We found no county project for Medical Boulevard or Pine Street, so we list none.
The Medical Boulevard and Pine Street corridor now has two active builders, Pulte at Shores at Stillwater and M/I Homes at Sandpiper Pointe, beside the 2000 to 2013 Stillwater plats. To the north, Wellen Park reported 727 new home sales in the first half of 2026, and Neal Communities plans 825 more Boca Royale homes by 2029.
Wellen Park's midyear release ranked it third among the nation's top-selling master plans and gives a full buildout of 22,500 homes. The Business Observer reported Neal's plan to complete a Preto Boulevard connection in 2028. Pulte's page counts "255 future front doors" at Shores, and the October 21, 2026 roll showed 27 built homes there with 107 lots coded vacant (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). An older Stillwater resale will compete with builder incentives on both sides of Pine Street while those lots fill.
For two Stillwater addresses checked on November 17, 2026, one on a Unit 1 street and one in Shores at Stillwater, the Sarasota County School Zone Lookup returned Englewood Elementary Zone, L.A. Ainger Middle Zone and Wellen Park High Zone. Zoning follows each exact address, so run yours before you count on it.
Data updated: November 2026 (zones from the district's School Zone Lookup as run for our community guide on November 17, 2026; Wellen Park High opening from mysuncoast.com; school choice law from s. 1002.31, Florida Statutes; choice window from SRQ Daily)
We list schools only as the district's tool returned them, and we print no grades, ratings or rankings. The tool's own wording was "According to our data, your address is located in the following school zones," with "No Update Info" shown for each zone on the day it was run. Stillwater Unit 2 and Unit 3 streets were not tested, so treat those addresses as unconfirmed until you run them.
Older listing and directory pages often name Lemon Bay High for Stillwater, while the district's lookup returned Wellen Park High Zone for the two Stillwater addresses tested on November 17, 2026. Wellen Park High opened in August 2026, and the lookup result fits the rezoning expected with it.
A 2025 Venice Gondolier report explained the background: a bi-county contract lets Sarasota County students attend Charlotte County schools, which is why L.A. Ainger Middle in Rotonda West appears for a Sarasota County address, and the contract was expected to change so the Sarasota County part of Englewood would be zoned for Wellen Park High. The 2026 lookup result fits that change. One directory page we saw files Lemon Bay High under Charlotte County for a Shores address, which is a second reason to trust the district tool over any listing.
Wellen Park High School, the zoned high school for the tested Stillwater addresses, has a mailing address of 1 Eaglerise Drive, Venice, but the building sits inside North Port city limits. It opened to students for the first time the week of August 10, 2026, and the district called it its first new public high school in 25 years.
Those details come from mysuncoast.com reporting. Our routing request did not include the campus, so we print no drive time from Stillwater; drive it at bell time before you rely on any estimate. For the two lower grades, Pulte's place data puts the Englewood Elementary campus about 1.8 miles and the L.A. Ainger Middle campus about 3.8 miles from Stillwater in a straight line (Pulte), which are distances, not drives.
Yes, a Stillwater address can apply through Florida's controlled open enrollment. Section 1002.31 requires each district to let a parent from any Florida district apply to "any public school, including charter schools, that has not reached capacity," and Sarasota County runs a yearly application window. For 2026-2027 that window ran February 2 to March 2, 2026.
The window dates come from SRQ Daily. The statute also says capacity "must be updated every 12 weeks," and that a district "may provide transportation," so a bus is not guaranteed (s. 1002.31). The 2027-2028 window had not been announced when we checked. A buyer closing on a Stillwater home in December 2026 or January 2027 should watch the district's choice page in early 2027 if a school other than the zoned one matters.
Stillwater gives two purchases in one place: 2000 to 2013 resales on Units 1 to 3, outside the CDD on the district's records, and new Pulte homes at gated Shores at Stillwater, inside a CDD. Nearby alternatives differ on county, builder, home age, district debt and what association runs the streets.
Data updated: November 2026 (Stillwater figures from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file of October 21, 2026, qualified sales October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; CDD from the Shores at Stillwater CDD; builder pages read November 18, 2026; Grove City figures from our published Grove City guide; Rotonda West from the Rotonda West Association)
The table compares homes, builders, districts and rules, never the people who live in each place. Where our research holds no documented figure, the cell says so. Builder prices are asking prices on the date read, not sale prices, and they change without notice.
| Place | County, ZIP | Builder and age of homes | CDD or no CDD | Association | Water and sewer | Home stock |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stillwater Units 1 to 3 (older plats) | Sarasota, 34223 | Resales; Unit 1 built 2000 to 2007 plus one 2016, Unit 2 2005 to 2006, Unit 3 2007 to 2013 | Outside the Shores CDD on the district's records; confirm on the tax bill | Two older associations on state records, Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (2000) and Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc. (2006); the deed and estoppel name the one for each parcel; no dues published | Englewood Water District; confirm on the utility account | 76 Unit 1 homes, 35 Unit 2 homes, 140 smaller Unit 3 homes |
| Shores at Stillwater | Sarasota, 34223 | Pulte; homes 2025 to 2026, still selling | Shores at Stillwater CDD: about $1,383 or $1,915 maximum yearly debt by lot width, plus about $276 operations | Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. (2025), developer period; Pulte publishes no dues figure | Englewood Water District; confirm on the utility account | 27 built homes, 107 lots coded vacant, 255 planned |
| Coco Bay | Charlotte, 34224 | Lennar; homes 2023 to 2025, listed $292,999 to $464,999 on November 18, 2026 | Island Lake Estates CDD | Lennar's page carries a homeowners association heading with no details | Not documented in this research | Lennar homes; five listed for sale on November 18, 2026 |
| Sandpiper Pointe | Sarasota, 34223 | M/I Homes, "Now Selling," 85 homes planned | Builder states "no CDD fees" | Builder states "low HOA" and gated | Not documented in our research | Detached homes "from the low $400s" (builder) |
| Boca Royale | Sarasota, 34223 | Neal Communities; original 1,151 units sold out; new section from $352,990 | Not stated on the pages we read | Not stated on the pages we read | Not documented in our research | Golf community; 825 more homes planned by the end of 2029 |
| Grove City | Charlotte, 34224 | Mostly 1950s to 1970s resales | None found; county street and drainage unit of $220 per ERU, per our Grove City guide | No HOA found over its plats | Not documented in this research | Older homes; 39 resales at a $289,000 median in our guide's 12 months to September 9, 2026 |
| Rotonda West | Charlotte, 33947 | Scattered-lot homes of many eras | None found | Rotonda West Association, a Chapter 720 and 617 nonprofit that collects assessments | Not documented in our research | Homes inside the Rotonda circle |
| Wellen Park | Sarasota, Venice and North Port | Many builders; 727 new home sales in the first half of 2026 | West Villages Improvement District; per-home amounts not read in our research | By neighborhood | Not documented in our research | 22,500 homes planned at full buildout |
Sources for the rows: Stillwater associations from Florida corporate records as our research recorded them; CDD figures from the district's June 15, 2026 board book and FY2026/27 budget, where the district says amounts may fluctuate; water from Englewood Water District; Coco Bay from Lennar; Sandpiper Pointe from M/I Homes; Boca Royale from Neal Communities and the Business Observer; Wellen Park from its release and WGCU. Confirm every district and association figure on the documents for the home you choose.
Shores at Stillwater and Sandpiper Pointe are both new, gated Sarasota County sections off Pine Street, but M/I Homes advertises "no CDD fees" at Sandpiper Pointe, while every Shores lot carries the Shores at Stillwater CDD. The fair comparison is the total yearly cost of taxes, district lines and dues.
At Shores the district's June 15, 2026 book sets a maximum annual debt assessment of about $1,383 on a 34-foot villa lot and about $1,915 on a 52-foot lot (CDD board book), plus operations of about $276 a unit in its FY2026/27 budget. M/I lists Sandpiper Pointe "FROM THE LOW $400S" with 85 planned homes and a "10-Year Transferable Structural Warranty" (M/I Homes); Pulte lists seven Shores plans from $309,990 to $565,990 as listed November 18, 2026, and prices change (Pulte). Pulte's book also carries a 10-year structural term. Neither builder publishes a dues figure, so the estoppel or budget settles that line.
Coco Bay is a Lennar community in Charlotte County with Englewood 34224 addresses, and Stillwater is in Sarasota County with 34223 addresses, so taxes, schools and the tax collector differ. Both have a new-builder section inside a CDD, but only Stillwater also offers older resales outside any CDD.
Lennar listed Island Lakes at Coco Bay homes at $292,999 to $464,999 on November 18, 2026, with five homes shown for sale (Lennar). Our Coco Bay buyer's guide carries its CDD rates and county sales, which come from a different county file, so we do not set them beside Stillwater's Sarasota County medians as if they were one measure. The closer Stillwater match for a Coco Bay buyer is Shores at Stillwater, since both are single-builder sections built from 2023 onward with a district line on the bill.
A Stillwater Unit 3 home and a Grove City resale land near the same price, but on different stock. Unit 3 homes, built 2007 to 2013, sold at a $282,500 median in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, while Grove City's older homes sold at a $289,000 median in our guide's window.
The Unit 3 figure covers 10 sales at $198 per heated square foot and a 1,349 square foot median (county record). Our Grove City buyer's guide, linked in the table above, reports 39 resales, mostly on 1950s to 1970s homes, with no HOA found and a Charlotte County street and drainage unit of $220 per ERU. The trade is a newer build era and an association in Stillwater Unit 3 against older construction and no dues in Grove City. A 2007 to 2013 Unit 3 home also falls inside the 2001-code era that the state's wind discount rules reward, which most 1950s to 1970s homes do not.
Boca Royale is a Neal golf community in the same county and ZIP, now adding a new section. Rotonda West is a Charlotte County circle of platted lots under a large Chapter 720 association. Wellen Park is a master plan with many builders and an improvement district, about 6.8 miles north of Stillwater in a straight line.
Neal lists new Boca Royale Golf and Country Club homes "from $352,990" with an 18-hole course on its community page, and the pages we read state no CDD or dues. The Rotonda West Association calls itself "a non-profit Florida membership corporation" that "collects assessments, fines, deposits, and service fees"; the circle sits about 7.5 road miles and 16 minutes from Stillwater (OSRM). Wellen Park's West Villages Improvement District is coordinating the River Road design, per WGCU. Each one is worth a tour if the search turns on golf, a larger lot grid or builder choice.
Stillwater fits a search for either a 2025 to 2026 Pulte home with impact glass and a tile roof inside a gated section with a CDD, or a 2000 to 2013 resale outside the CDD near the hospital and beach. Another place fits better when the search turns on golf, Charlotte County or no association.
In Stillwater, a Unit 3 home is the lower-priced entry: every one of the 6 sales under $300,000 in the 12 months to October 14, 2026 was a Unit 3 home (county record). Units 1 and 2 hold the larger older single-family homes, a small group of 9 sales at a $550,000 median, and Shores holds the new construction, 16 Pulte first sales at $523,250. Look at Sandpiper Pointe for a new Sarasota County home without a CDD, at Boca Royale for a golf setting, at Grove City for older homes with no HOA, at Coco Bay for a newer Charlotte County home and at Wellen Park for the widest builder choice. To set the shortlist with us, book your Stillwater buyer consultation and call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
Since August 17, 2024, an agent who works with a Stillwater buyer signs a written agreement with that buyer before touring a home, and the pay terms are negotiable rather than set by law. At Shores at Stillwater, Pulte publishes no broker policy, so we register you with the sales center at first contact.
You sign a written buyer agreement before we tour a Stillwater resale or a Pulte model with you. Florida Realtors' settlement guidance says "A written buyer agreement is required prior to a buyer 'touring a home,'" and that compensation "must be objectively ascertainable and not open-ended."
Both quotes come from the Florida Realtors settlement FAQ, which gives as an example of a term that fails the rule "buyer broker compensation shall be whatever amount the seller is offering to the buyer." Florida law adds a second point: "It shall be presumed that all licensees are operating as transaction brokers unless a single agent or no brokerage relationship is established, in writing," under s. 475.278. In our agreement we also write down the Stillwater work: registering with Pulte, reading the CDD book and the three associations' papers, and comparing a resale with Pulte's current sheet.
Pulte does not publish a broker participation policy, registration window or commission rate for Shores at Stillwater on any page we read on November 18, 2026. Its community page carries a form with "I am a Realtor" fields and a Realtor login, which tells you Pulte expects agents, not what it pays them.
Pulte's Shores at Stillwater page and its terms of use carry no co-op terms, and Pulte's sales consultants represent Pulte. A Pulte bonus flyer from another state division shows that divisions set these terms locally, so the Englewood answer has to come from the Englewood sales team in writing. Our rule is simple: before your first call, chat, model visit or online form with Pulte, call us, and we ask the sales center to register your agent at that first contact and confirm the terms in writing before you sign Pulte's purchase agreement.
On a resale in Stillwater Units 1 to 3, who pays your agent is a negotiated term. A seller may offer buyer-broker compensation or a concession toward it, and you can ask for it in your offer, but the seller can say no. Your written agreement states the amount agreed with you.
The Florida Realtors FAQ confirms that "The buyer can negotiate compensation terms in their offer with the seller" and that "Sellers can offer buyer brokerage compensation if they choose to." It also notes that offers of compensation can no longer appear on the MLS. A Stillwater resale seller competes with Pulte's incentives across Pine Street, which gives a buyer room to ask for help with costs. We settle our fee with you in plain terms on the first call.
Our Stillwater levers come from documents and calendars: Pulte's pool-or-credit offer weighed against price, the choice of lender, quick move-in timing, an older resale priced against Pulte's current sheet, roof and insurance findings, wind mitigation credits, the CDD debt status at Shores, the association estoppel and the appraisal.
Data updated: November 2026 (sales from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file of October 21, 2026, qualified sales October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; Pulte offers and prices read on pulte.com November 18, 2026; rates from Freddie Mac, week of November 12, 2026; CDD figures from the district's June 15, 2026 book)
Nothing below is a story about a past client. It is our Stillwater method, and every figure in it links to a builder page, a statute, the district book, a state guide or the county record.
Pulte's November offer at Shores at Stillwater is a pool valued at $69,500 on select to-be-built homes or a $77,000 credit, on purchase agreements Pulte accepts November 2 to November 30, 2026. The offers cannot be combined, and acceptance sits in Pulte's discretion, so we price each choice in dollars.
The credit, per Pulte's disclaimer, goes "toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins as a reduction to the total purchase price," and "Any unused credit is the property of the builder." Pulte also warns that the "Offer may affect the amount of loan for which a buyer may be eligible." A pool adds value you live with; a credit used on a rate buydown lowers the payment every month; a credit taken as price lowers the recorded sale that the next appraisal reads. We set the three side by side before you pick, and we confirm in writing which homesites qualify.
Pulte's special rates at Shores at Stillwater require Pulte Mortgage, but Pulte also states you are "not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage" to buy the home. That lets us test the builder lender's package against an outside Loan Estimate on the same day and lock period.
Our research's monthly build shows the scale: on a $523,000 Shores home with 20 percent down, Pulte's illustrative 6.5 percent rate cuts principal and interest by about $170 a month against the 7.11 percent Freddie Mac average, roughly the size of the $138 to $183 monthly CDD line, per our research's calculation. The CFPB's RESPA rule allows an affiliated lender arrangement only with a written disclosure and no required use. Pulte's lock dates on that illustration ran November 2 to 15, 2026 (Pulte), so we ask for a current written rate before you compare.
Pulte showed two quick move-in homes at Shores at Stillwater on November 18, 2026, both marked "Available Now": a 1,686 square foot Prosperity at $444,990, down from $518,780, and a 1,579 square foot Ellenwood villa at $364,990, down from $405,880. A finished, unsold home is where we press hardest.
Those prices and markdowns are Pulte's own, as listed on its community page that day; prices change and we print no addresses. Pulte's credit may be applied to quick move-ins, so we ask whether the November credit stacks on the reduced price for a specific home or replaces part of it. A finished home also lets you inspect the actual house and bind insurance on a known closing date, instead of waiting on a certificate of occupancy date that can move.
A Stillwater resale competes with Pulte's new homes across Pine Street. In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, older-plat resales ran a $203 median per heated square foot, against $267 for Pulte first sales at Shores, a gap explained by new construction, impact glass and tile roofs, not by appreciation.
Those figures come from the county record. Unit 3 homes sold at a $282,500 median on 10 sales, against Pulte's smallest plan, the 1,321 square foot Colton, listed from $309,990 on November 18, 2026 (Pulte). Units 1 and 2, a small group of 9 sales, ran $550,000 for a 2,368 square foot median, against the Mystique Grande from $565,990 for 2,870 square feet or more. Our research's monthly builds put a $550,000 Units 1 and 2 home and a $523,000 Shores home within about $12 a month of each other before HOA dues and real insurance quotes, so a resale seller has to win on roof, lot and condition, and we ask for the price that reflects any shortfall.
Florida law bars an insurer from refusing a policy solely because a roof is under 15 years old, and Citizens requires a 4-point inspection on homes over 20 years old, which takes in every Unit 2 home and most Unit 1 homes in 2026. An original roof on a 2000 to 2008 Stillwater home is a priced item.
The roof rule is in s. 627.7011, which also gives an older roof an inspection to show "5 years or more of useful life remaining." Citizens' age line is on its inspections page. Our research also records that the 25 percent roof repair rule still applies to roofs permitted before March 1, 2009, which covers original roofs in Units 1 and 2 and the 2007 to 2008 Unit 3 homes (s. 553.844). We get insurance quotes inside the inspection period and turn a poor roof finding into a credit, a repair or a price change.
Homes built to the 2001 Florida Building Code or later are automatically eligible for a minimum 68 percent discount on windstorm coverage, per the state's guide. In Stillwater that covers Shores, Unit 2, Unit 3 and most of Unit 1, but a Unit 1 home permitted before March 1, 2002 may need a full inspection to prove its features.
The Florida CFO guide says the new OIR-B1-1802 form "must be used for inspections conducted on or after April 1, 2026" and a completed form "is valid for five years." Citizens accepts the older form if it was completed within five years before that date (Citizens notice). We ask the Stillwater seller for an existing report in the first week; if none exists, we order one, because a missing credit can be worth more than a small price cut.
At Shores, the district's methodology assigns about $25,726.66 of Series 2026 bond debt to a 52-foot lot and $18,580.37 to a 34-foot lot, repaid on the tax bill. On an older Stillwater resale, the estoppel certificate shows dues, fees and any open violation the buyer would inherit.
Those per-lot figures come from the district's June 15, 2026 book; confirm a current payoff with the district manager's office through its request page. No Shores home has resold yet in the county record, but on a future resale the CDD line is prorated like tax. On Units 1 to 3, a buyer is "jointly and severally liable with the previous parcel owner for all unpaid assessments" under s. 720.3085, so we read the estoppel line by line and ask the seller to clear any balance at closing.
An appraiser values a Stillwater home from recorded sales, and the record here is thin and split. No Shores home has resold, so a new Pulte home leans on Pulte's own first sales, and older-plat resales moved from a 2023 peak near $316 a square foot to about $200 in 2026.
The 2023 third quarter figure is a small group of 3 sales, and the 2026 second quarter median of $200 covers 5 sales (county record). On a resale we write an appraisal contingency into the Florida Realtors contract so a low value can reopen the price. On a Pulte home a credit taken as price lowers the recorded figure, while a credit spent on options or closing costs does not, which matters to the next appraisal on your street. We read Pulte's financing paragraphs before you sign, because a builder's form may not give an appraisal exit.
If a sale funds your Stillwater purchase, line up both dates before you sign anything. A to-be-built Pulte home closes when the house is finished, and an older Stillwater resale runs on the contract's own inspection and loan deadlines, 15 and 30 days by default, so your current home's closing has to fit one of those calendars.
Moving within Stillwater, say from a Unit 3 home to a new Pulte plan? Our Stillwater seller's guide explains the sale, and the Stillwater home valuation prices it. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 so one calendar runs both closings and both sets of association papers.
Those seller pages draw on the same October 21, 2026 county file, so the price you sell at and the price you pay are measured on matching records (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). If your current home is elsewhere in the area, our Englewood buyer's guide links the selling pages for the rest of town, and the Englewood overview gives the wider picture. Pulte's own buying guide points sellers toward "homebuying companies like Opendoor" (Pulte guide); we compare any cash offer with a listed sale so you see the net of each.
Usually, up to a cap. Florida's Save Our Homes portability can move as much as $500,000 of the assessment gap built on a prior Florida homestead onto the Stillwater home, if you own and occupy it on January 1 and file with the Sarasota County Property Appraiser by March 1.
The Property Appraiser's portability FAQ sets the $500,000 limit and the lookback, and the March 1 filing rule is in s. 196.011. If the Stillwater home's value sits below the old home's, as with a move to a Unit 3 home from a larger house, the benefit moves in proportion. Portability does not touch the Shores CDD line, which is a special assessment outside the homestead exemption.
Sell first if your equity is the down payment and two mortgages are out of reach. Buy first if you can carry both, since Pulte had only two Stillwater quick move-in homes on November 18, 2026 and older-plat resales ran 17 in 2026 through October 13. Either way, budget the association and, at Shores, the CDD for the overlap.
At the 7.11 percent Freddie Mac average, our research's full monthly builds with 20 percent down, non-homestead taxes and a county average insurance figure that is not a quote come to about $2,052 for a $282,500 Unit 3 home, $3,744 for a $550,000 Units 1 and 2 home and $3,756 for a $523,000 Shores home, HOA dues excluded because none is published. Jesse prices your current home while Marc runs the Stillwater purchase. Reach Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, or start with the Stillwater home valuation.
Stillwater resale inventory lives on the MLS and changes daily, and Pulte's quick move-in list at Shores shifts each time a home sells, so a printed list here would go stale almost at once. Browse current Englewood listings on DomainRealtyGroup.com and send us the Stillwater homes you like.
Data updated: November 2026 (MLS-only Stillwater fields checked November 18, 2026; Sarasota County figures from the Florida Realtors October 2026 county report and condo and townhouse report, released November 16, 2026; Pulte inventory read on pulte.com November 18, 2026)
| Measure | Figure |
|---|---|
| Active resale listings in Stillwater | Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). |
| Stillwater days on market | Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). |
| Stillwater sale-to-list ratio | Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). |
| Stillwater months of supply | Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). |
| Pulte quick move-in homes at Shores at Stillwater | 2, both "Available Now" (builder-stated, November 18, 2026) |
| Sarasota County single-family sales, October 2026 | 633 closed, median $490,000, up 10.1 percent; 4.0 months of supply (county figure, not Stillwater) |
| Sarasota County townhouse and condo sales, October 2026 | 269 closed, median $325,000; 5.4 months of supply (county figure) |
The county rows describe all of Sarasota County, not Stillwater. Next to them, the Unit 3 median of $282,500 sits below the county condo and townhouse median and the Units 1 and 2 median of $550,000 sits above the county single-family median (county record). Florida Realtors' next county release is due December 16, 2026.
Check the plat, the year built and the heated area on the county record first, then the flood zone for the lot, the tax bill for any CDD line and the association that governs the parcel. A Stillwater listing that shows the seller's homesteaded tax bill understates what a new owner will pay.
Search the address on the Sarasota County Property Appraiser site to confirm whether the home sits in Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3 or Shores, since the plat decides the association and whether the CDD applies. The required tax disclosure under s. 689.261 warns buyers not to rely on the seller's current taxes, and the property resets to market value on January 1 after the sale. Listing dues figures vary across sites, so we wait for the estoppel and the association budget.
Ask four things in writing: what options and lot premium sit inside the price, whether the November credit applies to that home, the expected closing date, and which rate applies with and without Pulte Mortgage. Pulte's Shores at Stillwater quick move-in pages show a sample payment that assumes Pulte's financing.
Pulte's sample rates rest on "participation in the Affiliate Incentive Program, including financing through Pulte Mortgage LLC" and a FICO score of 780, per its community page. Pulte's base prices per square foot run below the $267 recorded first-sale median because they exclude lot premiums, options and pools, so a quick move-in price already holds choices someone made for you. We line up the home's recorded plan sales with the listed figure before you write the agreement.
Build a Stillwater alert on the filters that actually separate homes here: the plat, resale or Pulte quick move-in, price band, heated area, bedrooms and year built. Send us the matches, and we read each one against the county record, the CDD boundary and the right association. Start on our buying page.
Start with plat and price band, since they move together here. In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, all 6 Stillwater sales under $300,000 were Unit 3 homes, and 15 of the 35 sales fell between $450,000 and $599,999, split between 7 Shores first sales and 8 Units 1 and 2 resales.
Those cuts come from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file of October 21, 2026. Add a size filter next: Unit 3 homes run a 1,349 square foot median, with 82 two-bedroom and 58 three-bedroom homes on the roll, while Unit 1 homes run a 2,204 square foot median and Unit 2 homes 2,181. A filter on year built separates the 2000 to 2007 Unit 1 stock, the 2005 to 2006 Unit 2 stock and the 2007 to 2013 Unit 3 stock, which is also the line for roof and insurance questions.
Each Stillwater match gets a file before the tour: the parcel card, the flood zone, the tax bill and the permit trail. For a resale we book through the listing agent. For a Pulte home, our first step is registering you with the Shores sales center before any contact.
That order matters because Pulte publishes no broker policy for Shores (Pulte), so the sound course is to have your agent named at the first contact. Set your Stillwater filters on our buying page or hand them to us at the consultation, and Marc Comisar reviews each Stillwater match personally. Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
A Stillwater buyer consultation is a no-cost working session with Jesse McGreevy or Marc Comisar on your budget, whether a new Pulte home, a Units 1 and 2 resale or a Unit 3 home fits it, and the CDD, association, flood, insurance and warranty checks on this page. It ends with a written search plan.
We bring the county record: 35 qualified Stillwater home sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, 16 Pulte first sales at Shores at a $523,250 median and 19 older-plat resales at $315,000, from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file of October 21, 2026.
We also bring the cost file. The Shores at Stillwater CDD's June 15, 2026 book sets a maximum annual debt assessment of about $1,383 on a 34-foot lot and about $1,915 on a 52-foot lot, on $2,970,000 of Series 2026 bonds maturing in May 2056, plus operations of about $276 a unit in its FY2026/27 budget. Our research's monthly builds at 7.11 percent with 20 percent down come to about $3,756 for a $523,000 Shores home, $2,052 for a $282,500 Unit 3 home and $3,744 for a $550,000 Units 1 and 2 home (Freddie Mac). Pulte lists plans from $309,990 to $565,990 as listed November 18, 2026; prices change.
Expect questions on price range, down payment cash, lender preference, new or resale, the plat and home size you want, your move date, any home you must sell first and homestead plans. We also ask whether you have contacted Pulte yet, because that answer decides how we register you at Shores.
Book your Stillwater buyer consultation or start on our buying page. Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or call Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072. If you also own a home to sell, begin with the Stillwater home valuation. Our office is at 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134, and you can also reach us through our contact page. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and there is no obligation.
Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are top-reviewed Southwest Florida buyer's agents, recognized with the Gulfshore Life 5 Star Award for customer satisfaction for 21 straight years. The reviews below are quoted exactly as clients wrote them on our Google Business Profile. We do not edit, combine or summarize client words.
★★★★★ "Jesse is the best Realtor I have used. He found us our dream home even though it took months as we were not the easiest to please."
★★★★★ "Highly recommend Marc as a realtor. His devotion to finding you the perfect house is obvious and a breath of fresh air at such a stressful time."
★★★★★ "Marc is extremely knowledgeable, professional and a true pleasure to work with. He kept us informed throughout the process and went over and beyond our expectations to ensure an extremely smooth process."
★★★★★ "Marc's knowledge of the Southwest Florida real estate market is unmatched. He took the time to understand exactly what I was looking for in a home and quickly identified properties that checked all my boxes."
★★★★★ "Marc was great! He helped us find a place that matched our needs, without trying to upsell us into something too big. And he's helped us settle into the area. 100% recommendation!"
★★★★★ "Marc is one of the most down to earth realtors that really listens to your needs and is exceptional at finding the right house."
Before you buy in Stillwater, request the purchase agreement and warranty booklet at Shores, the CDD and HOA disclosures, the declaration, rules and budget of the right association, an estoppel on a resale, the CDD payoff at Shores, the survey and elevation certificate, flood papers, insurance quotes, roof and permit records, inspections, title and a tax estimate.
The table lists each paper we request on a Stillwater purchase, who issues it and whether it applies to a new Pulte home at Shores, a Units 1 and 2 resale or a Unit 3 resale. Use it as the working list for the inspection period, and send us anything Pulte or the seller has already handed you.
| Document | Who issues it | New Shores home | Units 1 and 2 resale | Unit 3 resale | What it settles in Stillwater |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Purchase agreement and warranty booklet | Pulte; on a later Shores resale the seller passes the booklet on | Yes; the agreement and booklet control | Not applicable; builder terms long expired | Not applicable | 1, 2, 5 and 10 year terms from closing (Pulte warranty book) |
| CDD disclosure | Pulte, in bold above your signature under s. 190.048 | Yes | Not applicable; confirm no CDD line on the tax bill | Not applicable; confirm on the tax bill | That the Shores at Stillwater CDD levies on the lot |
| HOA disclosure summary | Pulte, or the resale seller, before you sign under s. 720.401 | Yes | Yes | Yes | Membership, assessments and the 3-day right if it came late |
| Declaration and rules | The association, Pulte or the Clerk's official records | Shores association | The association named on the deed and estoppel | Unit Three association | Leasing, pets, parking and fences; not verified in our research, so read before the inspection period ends |
| Association budget | The governing association | Yes | Yes | Yes | What the dues cover; no dues figure is published for any of the three |
| Estoppel certificate | The association, under s. 720.30851 | Ask Pulte whether one applies | Yes | Yes | Dues and frequency, fees due, open violations |
| CDD payoff or debt letter | The district manager's office (request page) | Ask before closing | Not applicable | Not applicable | The lot's remaining bond share, per the district's methodology |
| Survey | Pulte's final survey, or a Florida surveyor at the buyer's cost | Yes | Yes | Yes | Fences, pools and pavers inside easements |
| Elevation certificate | Pulte's closing file, the state database or a surveyor | Yes | Yes | Yes | Floor height for flood rating (FDEM certificates) |
| Flood zone and disclosure | The FEMA map for the lot; the seller's form under s. 689.302 | Map yes; ask Pulte about the form | Yes | Yes | Flooding, claims and aid during the seller's ownership |
| Insurance quotes, wind and flood | Your insurance agent | Yes | Yes | Yes | Premium before deadlines; Citizens wind policies need flood from January 1, 2027 (Citizens) |
| 4-point inspection | A licensed inspector | Not needed | Yes for every Unit 2 home and most Unit 1 homes, now over 20 years old | Not yet; 2007 homes reach 20 years in 2027 | Roof, electrical, plumbing and HVAC condition for the insurer (Citizens inspections) |
| Wind mitigation form OIR-B1-1802 | A qualified inspector | Order one | Ask for the seller's | Ask for the seller's | Windstorm credits; valid five years |
| Roof permit | Sarasota County permit records | Part of the new-home file | Yes; original roofs on 2000 to 2007 homes predate March 1, 2009 | Yes for 2007 to 2008 homes | Roof age for insurers and the 25 percent rule |
| Permit and CO record | Sarasota County's permit portal | Yes | Yes, plus pool and enclosure permits | Yes | Open or expired permits and the CO date that starts the 4-year and 7-year clocks |
| Inspection reports | Your licensed home inspector | At Pulte's orientation stages, if allowed in writing | Yes | Yes | A visual exam under Part XV of Chapter 468 |
| Title commitment | A Florida title insurer, through the closing agent | Yes | Yes | Yes | Easements, liens and any reissue rate (Rule 69O-186.003) |
| Tax estimate | Our estimate from the 2026 millage | Yes, with the first-bill jump | Yes, reset at sale | Yes, reset at sale | 11.3068 mills plus the fire assessment and, at Shores, the CDD (2026 millage) |
Give us the Stillwater address and we gather the county-side papers ourselves: parcel card, flood zone, permit history and tax bill. The rest come from Pulte, the seller, the governing association, the CDD office, your insurer or your inspector, and we name the right contact for each of them.
The CDD's FAQ explains that the assessment "will appear on the property tax bill sent in November of each year," so the district manager's office is where a payoff figure comes from. The estoppel goes to the address the association designates, and the state's published fee caps are $299, plus $119 for delivery within 3 business days and up to $179 more if the parcel is delinquent (DBPR fee notice). Under Sarasota custom the seller pays the estoppel (Barnes Walker customs table). Set up a Stillwater consultation or call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
Below are the Stillwater questions that come up most in buyer searches, each answered with a sourced figure. Every sale number draws on the county file dated October 21, 2026, whose qualified sales end October 13, 2026, and every rate number uses Freddie Mac's 7.11 percent 30-year average from the week of November 12, 2026.
Stillwater is in unincorporated Sarasota County, with Englewood 34223 addresses. All 394 Stillwater parcels on five plats sit on the Sarasota County roll, and the Shores at Stillwater CDD was created by Sarasota County ordinance, per its website. Englewood's 34224 ZIP crosses into Charlotte County, so check the county on the Property Appraiser record for any home you see.
No. This page covers the five Stillwater plats off Medical Boulevard in Englewood: Units 1, 2 and 3 and Shores at Stillwater Phases 1A and 1B. Stillwater on the Bay is in Sarasota and Stillwater Cay is in Estero, and neither is related. Search by plat name on the Sarasota County Property Appraiser site to confirm a listing's location.
The October 21, 2026 county roll counts 394 parcels: 77 in Unit 1, 36 in Unit 2, 141 in Unit 3, 54 in Shores Phase 1A and 86 in Phase 1B. Built homes number 76 in Unit 1, 35 in Unit 2, 140 in Unit 3 and 27 at Shores, with 107 Shores lots still coded vacant, per the county file.
We tracked 35 qualified home sales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026: 16 Pulte first sales at Shores at a $523,250 median and $267 per heated square foot, and 19 older-plat resales at a $315,000 median and $203 per square foot. The Sarasota County Property Appraiser holds the record, and every figure here is a median.
Unit 3 homes sold at a $282,500 median on 10 sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, with a middle half of $266,875 to $302,750 and a 1,349 square foot median, from the county record. Unit 3 was built 2007 to 2013, and its association runs a website named "Villas at Stillwater III," per stillwater3.com, which showed a deactivation notice when we checked.
Units 1 and 2 single-family homes, a small group of 9 sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, sold at a $550,000 median with a middle half of $477,000 to $580,000 and a 2,368 square foot median. Over 24 months, 18 sales ran a $555,000 median, per the Sarasota County Property Appraiser.
As listed November 18, 2026, and subject to change: Colton from $309,990, Ellenwood $331,990, Prosperity $399,990, Mystique $419,990, Palmary $424,990, Prestige $452,990 and Mystique Grande $565,990, from 1,321 to 2,870 or more square feet (Pulte). Base prices exclude lot premiums, options and pools, which is why recorded first sales ran higher.
Pulte's base prices work out to about $197 to $240 per square foot, while the 16 recorded Shores first sales ran a $267 median per heated square foot. The difference is lot premiums, design options and pools added to the base, as recorded on the county file against Pulte's plan list. It is not a resale gain, since no Shores home has resold.
Not yet. The county file of October 21, 2026 shows no Shores resale among Stillwater's qualified sales, so every recorded Shores price is a Pulte first sale (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). That matters for appraisals and for warranty questions: the first Shores resales will carry Pulte's remaining warranty terms to the new owner within each period.
Older-plat resale prices per square foot peaked in 2023, at a $316 median in the third quarter on a small group of 3 sales, and eased to $211 in the first quarter of 2026 on 10 sales and $200 in the second quarter on 5 sales, per the county record. Quarterly groups are small, so read the trend as direction, not a forecast.
A Unit 3 resale. All 6 Stillwater sales under $300,000 in the 12 months to October 14, 2026 were Unit 3 homes, from the county file. New, Pulte's smallest plan is the 1,321 square foot Colton from $309,990 as listed November 18, 2026, before lot premium and options (Pulte).
Pulte describes Shores at Stillwater as "Gated, with Heated Pool & Cabana" and lists BBQ grills and mail kiosks on its community page. The Sun reported that Shores has "two private, gated entries from Pine Street" (Englewood Sun). Gate status for Units 1 and 2 was not verified in our research.
Pulte lists a tile roof, impact windows rated for the High Velocity Hurricane Zone, steel-reinforced concrete block construction, roof trusses with hurricane tie-downs, a tankless gas water heater and the Sentricon termite system, among other items, on its Prestige plan page. Shores is a natural gas community. Confirm the standard list for your plan in the purchase agreement.
Pulte's national warranty book gives 1 year on workmanship and materials, 2 years on heating, cooling, electrical and plumbing systems, 5 years on certain water intrusion and 10 years on structural elements, all from closing (Pulte warranty book). Hurricane and flood damage are excluded, disputes go to binding arbitration, and your purchase agreement and booklet control.
Yes. Section 553.837 creates a one-year statutory warranty that stays with the home for that year even if it is sold, per our research (s. 553.837). Separately, construction claims face a 7-year outer limit measured from the certificate of occupancy under s. 95.11, which every 2000 to 2013 Stillwater home has already passed.
Under Chapter 558, the owner serves written notice "at least 60 days before filing any action," and the builder may inspect "Within 30 days," per s. 558.004. The notice "shall not toll any statute of repose period under chapter 95," so a Shores owner tracks the 7-year date from the certificate of occupancy alongside any claim.
The district's June 15, 2026 book sets a maximum annual debt assessment of about $1,383 on a 34-foot villa lot and about $1,915 on a 52-foot lot, plus operations of about $276 a unit in the FY2026/27 budget, so roughly $1,659 or $2,190 a year (CDD book). The district says amounts may fluctuate, and its board sets assessments each year.
The Series 2026 bonds total $2,970,000 and mature in May 2056, per the district's records, and the book describes "thirty (30) years of installments of principal and interest" (CDD book). The debt share ends when it is paid or prepaid; the operations share continues as long as the district runs its ponds and works.
The district's methodology assigns about $25,726.66 of bond debt to a 52-foot lot and $18,580.37 to a 34-foot lot, per its June 15, 2026 book. A current payoff figure for a specific lot comes from the district manager's office through its request page; confirm it before you budget a prepayment.
The district's boundary covers Shores at Stillwater, and its records place Units 1 to 3 outside it. Confirm on the tax bill for the home you choose, where a CDD line would appear as a non-ad valorem assessment (Shores at Stillwater CDD). Our research's monthly builds carry a CDD line only for Shores, at about $138 to $183 a month depending on lot width.
No. Homestead exempts value from taxation "except for assessments for special benefits," per s. 196.031, and the Englewood Area Fire Control District's residential assessment of $290.78 for 2026-2027 is a non-ad valorem charge outside the exemption (fire district). Amendment 3 does not touch the CDD either.
No official dues figure is published for any of the three associations: the Stillwater Homeowners Association, the Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association or the Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association. Pulte says only "Community Association fees required" (Pulte). The disclosure summary under s. 720.401, the estoppel and the budget confirm the amount.
Under s. 720.307, owners elect a board majority three months after 90 percent of the parcels are conveyed, which our research puts at about 230 of the 255 planned Shores homes, with one owner seat once half are conveyed. Until then, the summary warns, the developer "MAY HAVE THE RIGHT TO AMEND THE RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS."
Rental limits adopted by amendment after July 1, 2021 bind only owners who take title after the change or who consent, but an association may still regulate leases "for a term of less than 6 months" and limit renting to "three times in a calendar year" for everyone, under s. 720.306. Read each declaration before the inspection period ends.
Short stays in Stillwater carry the 6 percent state sales tax and the 1 percent Sarasota surtax, per the state's rate form, plus the county's tourist development tax (DOR rate form); confirm the tourist tax rate with the Sarasota County Tax Collector. County code and the association declarations limit short stays, so check both first.
Usually. Florida Realtors notes that "On January 1, the year after the sale, the county Property Appraiser resets the home's assessed value to full market" (Florida Realtors). The 2026 Stillwater millage is 11.3068, so a non-homestead $282,500 Unit 3 home carries about $266 a month in tax at full price, per our research's build (2026 millage).
Sarasota County values a home as of January 1 and makes no partial assessments, so a Shores home finished after January 1 may be billed mostly on land the first year and then fully the next (Property Appraiser). On a $523,000 Shores home our research's non-homestead tax line is about $493 a month once the full bill arrives. Budget for it from the start.
Own and live in the home on January 1, then file with the Sarasota County Property Appraiser by March 1, under s. 196.011. A Stillwater closing by December 31, 2026 with occupancy on January 1, 2027 supports a 2027 filing by March 1, 2027. Homestead then caps annual assessment growth under Save Our Homes, 2.7 percent for 2026.
The official results page showed 61.98 percent yes, and certification was not confirmed on November 18, 2026 (Florida Election Watch). As reported, it raises the non-school homestead exemption to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028. It does not change the Shores CDD line, which is a special assessment. Confirm your filing with the Property Appraiser.
Flood zones are set lot by lot, and our research established a zone for only one Unit 1 address, so the FEMA map and the lot's elevation certificate confirm each home. Run the address on FEMA's Map Service Center and ask for the certificate, which surveyors file with the state (FDEM). The Shores ponds were designed for 100-year flood control, per the district engineer.
Citizens already requires flood on wind policies with dwelling coverage of $400,000 or more since January 1, 2026, and on all wind policies from January 1, 2027, regardless of value (Citizens). A Units 1 and 2 home near the $550,000 median may already cross the $400,000 line. Budget a flood quote even on a lot outside the high-risk zone.
The National Flood Insurance Program was authorized only to December 11, 2026, and a lapse stops new and renewal NFIP policies; a 2010 lapse delayed or cancelled over 1,400 closings a day, per the Congressional Research Service. NAR notes that private flood "is not affected" and a seller's NFIP policy can be assigned (NAR).
We have averages, not quotes. Citizens' approved average for a Sarasota County HO3 policy is $2,901 a year (Citizens county rates), and the state's October 2026 admitted-market average including wind is $3,736 (OIR market overview). Our research's monthly builds use the $2,901 county figure, about $242 a month. Get real quotes during the inspection period.
The grant statute requires a homestead, an insured value of $700,000 or less and a home built before January 1, 2008, with income limits, under s. 215.5586. The 2000 to 2007 homes in Units 1 and 2 and the 2007 Unit 3 homes pass the date test; the one 2016 Unit 1 home and Shores homes do not. Funding is not continuous, so check the program before you count on it.
Our research did not verify the evacuation level for the Medical Boulevard area. Sarasota County uses levels A to E, and the level prints on the property's TRIM notice; the county's lookup tool confirms it by address (WUSF). For Milton in 2024, the county ordered levels A, B and C to leave (National Weather Service).
For Citizens, yes once the home is over 20 years old, which covers every Unit 2 home and most Unit 1 homes in 2026 (Citizens inspections). Unit 3 homes from 2007 to 2013 reach 20 years between 2027 and 2033. The 4-point covers roof, electrical, plumbing and HVAC, and other insurers set their own age lines.
The federal window for problem drywall runs 2001 to 2009, and our research found no Stillwater-specific report either way. Buyers of 2004 to 2009 homes can ask the inspector for the checks the CPSC describes, such as blackened copper wiring and a sulfur odor (CPSC guide). Most Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes and early Unit 3 homes fall in that window.
By Sarasota custom the buyer pays the owner's title policy, the note stamps at 35 cents per $100 and the intangible tax at 0.2 percent of the loan, per our research (Barnes Walker). On a $226,000 Unit 3 loan those two taxes total about $1,243 (DOR doc stamps). Title premiums follow the state rate rule.
Yes. The district's FY2026/27 budget lists "O&M Assessments 66,157 To Be Collected At Closings," at about $276 a unit, so expect a CDD operations amount on the Shores closing statement (FY2026/27 budget). Your Closing Disclosure arrives three business days before closing, per the CFPB.
On the Florida Realtors and Florida Bar AS IS contract, the inspection period is 15 days after the effective date if left blank, and the buyer may cancel inside it and recover the deposit (AS IS contract). Loan approval defaults to 30 days. We fit the 4-point, wind mitigation, insurance quotes and association papers inside those 15 days.
Florida law gives a buyer the right to have deposits of up to 10 percent of the price held in escrow unless waived in writing, and a builder using them for construction must post a bond, under s. 501.1375. Pulte does not publish its Shores deposit amount, so we read the deposit and escrow paragraphs in its purchase agreement with you.
No. Pulte states you are "not required to finance through Pulte Mortgage to purchase a home from seller," but its special rate offers require Pulte Mortgage (Pulte). With the 30-year average at 7.11 percent (Freddie Mac), we compare Pulte's written package with an outside Loan Estimate before you choose.
Our research's calculation puts one point at about $149 a month on a $226,000 Unit 3 loan, about $276 on a $418,400 Shores loan and about $291 on a $440,000 Units 1 and 2 loan, roughly $66 to $69 per $100,000 borrowed near 7 percent. Freddie Mac's 2026 range ran from 5.98 to 7.40 percent (PMMS).
Our research records a 2026 conforming limit of $832,750 (FHFA) and no VA limit for a borrower with full entitlement (VA). Every Stillwater median, from $282,500 for Unit 3 to $550,000 for Units 1 and 2, sits well under the conforming line with 20 percent down.
Englewood Water District serves Shores at Stillwater, per the district engineer, and its mains run in Medical Boulevard by the older plats (confirm by address), with FY27 base charges of $29.37 a month for water and $42.75 for sewer, and extreme water shortage restrictions extended through March 31, 2027 (EWD). FPL supplies power, and Shores is a natural gas community. New homes carry EWD capacity charges of $15,249 plus $616.50, so ask Pulte whether they sit in the price.
The pool and credit apply only to purchase agreements Pulte accepts by November 30, 2026, per its disclaimer. Builders often run a new dated offer afterward, so compare the net price after any credit, not the offer's name. A separate Pulte Hometown Hero incentive runs on agreements accepted through December 31, 2026, for buyers who meet Pulte's stated eligibility.
In October 2026, Sarasota County single-family homes closed 633 sales at a $490,000 median, up 10.1 percent, with 4.0 months of supply and a median 40 days to contract (Florida Realtors county report). Those are county figures. Stillwater's own days on market and supply are MLS-only: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026).
Pulte publishes no broker policy for Shores, so we treat the first contact as the registration point and ask the sales center to record your agent then. Florida's settlement guidance also requires a written buyer agreement before your agent tours a home with you (Florida Realtors FAQ). Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 before any Pulte call.
The FBI counted more than $275 million stolen through real estate fraud from at least 12,368 victims in 2025, per NAR's report. Before you wire a Stillwater deposit or closing funds, call the title company at a number you looked up yourself, never one from an email, and confirm the instructions by voice.
A Stillwater specialist matters because five plats hold three different purchases: a new Pulte home inside a CDD, a 2000 to 2007 Units 1 and 2 resale and a 2007 to 2013 Unit 3 home. Each has its own contract form, association, roof and insurance position and cost file, and listing sites blur them.
It means knowing which document answers which Stillwater question. Pulte's purchase agreement and booklet settle the warranty, the CDD book sets the district line at Shores, the right association's estoppel sets the dues, and the lot's elevation certificate and the FEMA map set the flood answer.
It also means keeping groups apart and labeling small ones, since one blended median would mislead: 16 Pulte first sales at a $523,250 median, 10 Unit 3 resales at $282,500 and a small group of 9 Units 1 and 2 resales at $550,000, from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser. Our Stillwater community guide covers the daily life we leave out here.
A Stillwater call puts you with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, holders of the 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years, who bring the county record, the CDD book and Pulte's current sheet. Call Marc at (239) 287-5873, call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or book a Stillwater buyer consultation.
Selling a Stillwater home first? Start with Sell My Home in Stillwater and the Stillwater home valuation. When your search reaches past the five plats, our Englewood buyer's guide covers the rest of the area, and our Englewood page gives the overview.
Every rule cited on this page comes from a document the public can read at no charge. The list below gathers the papers that carry the most weight in a Stillwater purchase, linked straight to the publisher so you can read the statute, the form or the district's own budget before you sign.
Every source below was read on November 17 or 18, 2026, and each figure on this page carries its own date and window beside it in the text. Primary documents come first: Florida Statutes and rules, state and federal agencies (DBPR, OIR, FEMA and the NFIP, HUD, VA, FHFA, CFPB, FinCEN, National Weather Service), Freddie Mac, Fannie Mae, Florida Housing Finance Corporation, Citizens Property Insurance, Sarasota County government and its Property Appraiser and Tax Collector, Sarasota County Schools, the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District, the Englewood Water District, Pulte's own published Shores at Stillwater pages and warranty book, Florida Realtors, and local news. Stillwater sales figures come from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser's bulk file dated October 21, 2026, with qualified sales through October 13, 2026. No listing site, brokerage or valuation aggregator was used for any figure on this page.
McGreevy and Comisar are the Southwest Florida buyer's agents Stillwater buyers call when the details decide the deal. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team, and guide buyers from the first tour to closing.
For this page we tracked 35 qualified Stillwater home sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, 16 Pulte first sales and 19 resales, on the Sarasota County roll, with Shores, Units 1 and 2 and Unit 3 kept apart, and we read the district book, the statutes and the builder's own pages a buyer meets, so the figures here come from public records rather than estimates.
Jesse McGreevy direct: (239) 898-6072 · [email protected] · Marc Comisar direct: (239) 287-5873 · Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
McGreevy and Comisar, Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) are licensed Florida real estate professionals regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) under Chapter 475, Florida Statutes.
More on the team at about McGreevy and Comisar. Read our Stillwater guide, plan a sale with Sell My Home in Stillwater or the Stillwater home valuation, and see our buying page.
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more at DomainRealtyGroup.com.
Ready to buy? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873, or start with a Stillwater buyer consultation. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and there is no obligation.
Updated November 2026. This page is general information about buying a home in Stillwater, not legal, tax, insurance or financial advice. Recorded-sales figures change with every county file, district and association charges change by resolution and statutory figures change annually. Brokered by Domain Realty.