1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

What’s Your Stillwater Home Worth?

What’s Your Stillwater Home Worth?

Your Home Valuation

Thank You! We are going to prepare a customized report with information on the value of your home.
View Our Listings

Key Takeaways for Stillwater Home Values

Stillwater home values in late 2026 split into two markets. County records show 19 older-plat resales at a $315,000 median and 16 Pulte first sales at Shores at Stillwater at $523,250 in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, or $203 against $267 per heated square foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar of Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026. This page values one place: Stillwater in Englewood, Florida, five recorded plats reached through Medical Boulevard in unincorporated Sarasota County, with Englewood 34223 mailing addresses. Stillwater on the Bay, a set of 7 parcels with Sarasota 34231 addresses, is a different place, and none of its sales are counted here (our Stillwater neighborhood guide, citing the county file). The streets, parks, utilities and storm history live in that guide, and the steps of a listing live in our Stillwater seller guide. This page answers a narrower question: what is your Stillwater home worth today, and why does the county record point there?

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012. Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, over $900 million in personal sales, and more than $2.5 billion sold as the Domain Realty Group team.

Our counts cover all 394 Sarasota County parcels in five recorded plats on the parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026: STILLWATER UNIT 1 (77 parcels), STILLWATER UNIT 2 (36), STILLWATER UNIT 3 (141), SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1A (54) and SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1B (86). On that file Unit 1 holds 76 homes with a median 2,204 heated square feet, Unit 2 holds 35 with a median 2,181, Unit 3 holds 140 with a median 1,349, and Shores at Stillwater, Pulte's section, holds 27 finished homes with a median 1,948 plus 107 lots still coded vacant (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Units 1 and 2 carry use code 0100, single-family. All 140 Unit 3 homes carry use code 0101, and the file does not say whether a given Unit 3 home is attached or detached, so we describe Unit 3 as what the file shows: the small-home section coded 0101. A Stillwater value starts with three facts the street name does not give you: which plat, how many heated square feet, and whether the home was a resale or a builder's first sale.

How to read these figures: every Stillwater count and median on this page is our tabulation of the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, using qualified sales of improved homes over $1,000; the newest qualified sale in our set is dated October 13, 2026. The 12-month window runs October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, the 24-month window from October 15, 2024 and the 36-month window from October 15, 2023. A "resale" is a sale in the older plats, Units 1 to 3. A "first sale" is the first qualified sale of a new Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater; every Shores sale on the file is one. Per square foot always means per square foot of the county's heated (living) area. Any group under 10 sales is called a small group, printed with its count, and we draw no percentage conclusion from it alone (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

  • The 12-month median: we tracked 35 qualified Stillwater home sales at a $485,000 median, middle half $305,000 to $570,000, a blend of two very different groups (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • Older-plat resales: 19 resales closed at a $315,000 median, middle half $280,000 to $550,000, at a median $203 per heated square foot; that is 19 of the 251 older-plat homes, 7.6 percent, in 12 months, and 37 homes, 14.7 percent, in 24 months (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • Shores at Stillwater first sales: 16 Pulte first sales closed at a $523,250 median, middle half $419,450 to $662,575, at a median $267 per heated square foot; the first one recorded in February 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • Unit 3: 10 resales in 12 months at a $282,500 median and $198 per heated square foot, a median price equal to 54.0 percent of the Shores first-sale median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • Unit 1: 7 resales in 12 months, a small group, at a $550,000 median and $214 per heated square foot; over 24 months 12 resales closed at $562,500 and $261 per foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • The new-home gap shrinks with the window: the Shores per-foot median sat 31.3 percent above the older-plat resale median over 12 months, 20.0 percent over 24 months and 13.0 percent over 36 months, and only 2.3 percent above Unit 1 alone over 24 months (Unit 1, 12 sales) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • The long run: older-plat resales carried a median $143 per heated square foot in 2015, $191 in 2021, $282 at the 2023 high and $203 in 2026 through October 13 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • The latest half-years: the older-plat per-foot median read $257 in the first half of 2025 (11 sales), $215 in the second half (6 sales, a small group) and $200 in the first half of 2026 (15 sales) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • Repeat sales: 15 of the 19 resales had an earlier qualified sale of the same home on file; they resold a median 12.2 percent above the price recorded at the earlier sale, 12 above and 3 below, a median 98 months apart (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  • MLS-only measures: days on market, sale-to-list ratio, months of supply and active listings for Stillwater: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026).

Talk to McGreevy and Comisar before you list. The record behind the team that will value your Stillwater home:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Table of Contents

What Is a Stillwater Home Worth in 2026?

A Stillwater home in 2026 is worth roughly what the same plat and size recorded lately: a $282,500 median for 10 Unit 3 resales, $550,000 for 7 Unit 1 resales and $523,250 for 16 Shores at Stillwater first sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; qualified improved sales over $1,000 in Stillwater Units 1, 2 and 3 and Shores at Stillwater Phases 1A and 1B, newest October 13, 2026; 12-month window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, 24 months from October 15, 2024, 36 months from October 15, 2023; plat, size band, bedroom and build-year cuts tabulated November 18, 2026).

What did Stillwater homes sell for in the last 12 months?

Stillwater in Englewood recorded 35 qualified home sales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026, at a $485,000 median with the middle half from $305,000 to $570,000. Nineteen were older-plat resales at a $315,000 median and 16 were Pulte first sales at Shores at Stillwater at $523,250 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Stillwater qualified home sales, October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026.

Group Sales Median price Middle half of prices Median per heated sq ft (middle half)
All qualified home sales 35 $485,000 $305,000 to $570,000 see the rows below
Older-plat resales, Units 1 to 3 19 $315,000 $280,000 to $550,000 $203 ($192 to $246)
Unit 1 resales 7 (a small group) $550,000 $454,000 to $570,000 $214 ($197 to $261)
Unit 2 resales 2 (too few for a median) sales at $550,000 and $620,000 not computed not computed
Unit 3 resales 10 $282,500 $266,875 to $302,750 $198 ($186 to $223)
Units 1 and 2 combined 9 (a small group) $550,000 $477,000 to $580,000 $246 ($199 to $263)
Shores at Stillwater first sales 16 $523,250 $419,450 to $662,575 $267 ($241 to $329)

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation. Per-foot figures use the county's heated area for each sold home.

The $485,000 headline median describes almost no actual Stillwater home. It falls between a resale median of $315,000 and a first-sale median of $523,250 because 16 of the 35 sales, 45.7 percent by our arithmetic, were brand-new Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Read as a value, it would put a Unit 3 home about $202,500 above its own plat's median (our arithmetic), so we never value a Stillwater home from the all-sales line.

The Shores first sales arrived in a short burst. The county file shows one first sale in February 2026, four in April, three each in May and June, one in July, three in August and one in October, the newest on October 13, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Every Shores sales figure on this page, in every window, describes those same 16 homes, with a median 1,962 heated square feet.

What do Stillwater homes sell for per square foot?

Stillwater older-plat resales sold at a median $203 per heated square foot over the 12 months to October 14, 2026, against $267 for Pulte's first sales at Shores at Stillwater. Over 24 months the resale figure was $222 and over 36 months $236, because the longer windows hold more 2023 to 2025 sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Stillwater median price per heated square foot, by plat and window.

Group 12 months: sales 12 months: median (middle half) 24 months: sales 24 months: median (middle half) 36 months: sales 36 months: median (middle half)
Older-plat resales 19 $203 ($192 to $246) 39 $222 ($203 to $261) 47 $236 ($208 to $265)
Unit 1 7 (a small group) $214 ($197 to $261) 12 $261 ($204 to $269) 13 $261 ($207 to $268)
Unit 2 2 (too few for a median) not computed 6 (a small group) $251 ($220 to $268) 8 (a small group) $262 ($227 to $271)
Unit 3 10 $198 ($186 to $223) 21 $215 ($198 to $233) 26 $222 ($202 to $258)
Shores at Stillwater first sales 16 $267 ($241 to $329) 16 $267 ($241 to $329) 16 $267 ($241 to $329)

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation by the county's heated area. Windows end October 14, 2026. The Shores row is identical in every window because all 16 first sales closed in 2026.

As a worked illustration, not a value: a Unit 3 home at that plat's median 1,349 heated square feet comes to $250,914 at $186 per foot, $267,102 at $198 and $300,827 at $223, the 12-month middle half for Unit 3 (our multiplication on the Sarasota County Property Appraiser figures). A Unit 1 home at the roll's median 2,204 square feet comes to $449,616 at $204, $575,244 at $261 and $592,876 at $269, the 24-month Unit 1 middle half, which we use because the 12-month Unit 1 group has only 7 sales (our multiplication). A per-foot figure places a Stillwater home in a band; the roof, the systems, the lot and the condition place it inside the band.

Two cautions apply to Stillwater per-foot figures. First, Pulte quotes its plans by its own square footage, and the county's heated area can differ: Pulte lists the Ellenwood villa at 1,579 square feet, while the four Phase 1B villa first sales the county recorded each carry 1,574 heated square feet (Pulte, Ellenwood plan, builder-stated, read November 18, 2026; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Divide a builder's price by the county's area, never by the brochure's. Second, Unit 3 sizes sit in a narrow band, so the spread in Unit 3 per-foot prices comes mostly from condition and timing, not size.

How do Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3 and Shores at Stillwater differ in value?

Stillwater's four sections are four different products. Unit 1 and Unit 2 hold 2000s single-family homes near 2,200 heated square feet, Unit 3 holds 2007 to 2013 homes near 1,349 square feet, and Shores at Stillwater holds Pulte's 2025 and 2026 homes. Their 12-month medians run from $282,500 to $550,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Stillwater by section: the roll and the sales, 12 and 24 months to October 14, 2026.

Measure Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3 Shores at Stillwater
Homes on the roll 76 35 140 27, plus 107 lots coded vacant
Use code of the homes 0100 0100 0101 0100 (17) and 0101 (10)
Median heated sq ft (middle half) 2,204 (2,068 to 2,466) 2,181 (2,181 to 2,333) 1,349 (1,349 to 1,525) 1,948 (1,574 to 1,992)
Years built on the roll 2000 to 2007, most 2003 to 2005, plus one 2016 2005 (12) and 2006 (23) 2007 to 2013 2025 (8) and 2026 (19)
12-month sales and median 7, $550,000 2, at $550,000 and $620,000 10, $282,500 16, $523,250
12-month median per heated sq ft $214 too few for a median $198 $267
24-month sales and median (middle half) 12, $562,500 ($507,500 to $612,500) 6, $546,000 ($495,750 to $605,000) 21, $305,000 ($282,500 to $340,000) 16, $523,250 ($419,450 to $662,575)
24-month median per heated sq ft $261 $251 $215 $267

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation of the file dated October 21, 2026. One parcel in each older plat and six in Shores, beyond the 107 lots coded vacant, carry other use codes and are not counted as homes.

Size explains most of the dollar gap between Unit 3 and the rest. The median Unit 1 home on the roll has 855 more heated square feet than the median Unit 3 home, 63.4 percent more (our arithmetic), and over 12 months the Unit 1 resale median sat $267,500 above the Unit 3 median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). On the foot, the plats sit much closer: $214 against $198 over 12 months and $261 against $215 over 24. A Unit 3 home is never a comparable for a Unit 1 home.

Units 1 and 2 behave as one market with two names. Both are coded 0100 and center near 2,200 heated square feet, and combined they recorded 9 resales over 12 months at a $550,000 median and 18 over 24 months at $555,000 and $259 per foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A Unit 2 home's first comparables are usually Unit 1 sales of similar size.

The Shores side splits by phase. The 12 first sales in Phase 1A closed at a $564,750 median and $290 per heated square foot, while the 4 in Phase 1B, a small group, closed at $390,300 and $248 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). All four Phase 1B first sales were homes of 1,574 heated square feet coded 0101, at $375,000, $379,000, $401,600 and $407,600, so Phase 1B's figures describe one villa size.

Affordability within Stillwater runs in two directions. The Unit 3 12-month median of $282,500 equals 54.0 percent of the Shores first-sale median of $523,250, while the Unit 1 median of $550,000 equals 105.1 percent of it, with Unit 1 a small group of 7 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). No recorded Shores home sold near the Unit 3 price, while a buyer at the Unit 1 price can choose a 2000s Unit 1 home or a new Pulte home for about the same money, the comparison the next section takes up.

What do older Stillwater homes sell for by heated size and bedrooms?

Older Stillwater homes sort into two size groups with little in between. Over 24 months, resales of 1,200 to 1,399 heated square feet closed at a $300,000 median (11 sales) and 1,400 to 1,799 at $318,750 (10 sales), while 1,800 to 2,199 closed at $560,000 and 2,200 to 2,599 at $550,000, both small groups of 9 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Older-plat Stillwater resales by heated size, 12 months, October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026.

Heated size band Sales Median price Middle half of prices Median per heated sq ft (middle half)
Under 1,200 sq ft 0 none recorded none recorded none recorded
1,200 to 1,399 sq ft 6 (a small group) $283,750 $261,250 to $305,250 $211 ($194 to $227)
1,400 to 1,799 sq ft 4 (a small group) $282,500 $279,250 to $300,000 $186 ($184 to $199)
1,800 to 2,199 sq ft 3 (a small group) $565,000 not computed $265
2,200 to 2,599 sq ft 6 (a small group) $525,000 $453,000 to $597,500 $207 ($196 to $246)
2,600 sq ft and up 0 none recorded none recorded none recorded

Older-plat Stillwater resales by heated size, 24 months, October 15, 2024 to October 14, 2026.

Heated size band Sales Median price Middle half of prices Median per heated sq ft (middle half)
1,200 to 1,399 sq ft 11 $300,000 $267,500 to $350,000 $222 ($200 to $259)
1,400 to 1,799 sq ft 10 $318,750 $283,750 to $335,000 $207 ($186 to $222)
1,800 to 2,199 sq ft 9 (a small group) $560,000 $536,000 to $600,000 $268 ($261 to $280)
2,200 to 2,599 sq ft 9 (a small group) $550,000 $477,000 to $610,000 $215 ($199 to $253)

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation by the county's heated area. No older-plat resale in any window was under 1,200 or over 2,599 heated square feet.

The step between 1,799 and 1,800 square feet is a plat line, not a size premium. Every older-plat resale under 1,800 heated square feet in these windows was a Unit 3 home, and the 1,800-and-up bands are Units 1 and 2 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Within Unit 3 the resale list shows the same few heated areas again and again, 1,338, 1,349, 1,501, 1,524 and 1,538 square feet, which points to a handful of repeated plans; within Units 1 and 2 the sold homes run from about 1,960 to about 2,570 square feet.

Inside the larger homes, the per-foot figure falls as size rises. Over 36 months, homes of 1,800 to 2,199 square feet sold at $268 per foot (10 sales) and homes of 2,200 to 2,599 at $246 (11 sales), even though the bigger band's median price was higher, $590,000 against $562,500 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The same pattern appears in Unit 3: 1,200 to 1,399 square foot homes at $224 and 1,400 to 1,799 at $211 over 36 months. A larger Stillwater home sells for more dollars but fewer dollars per foot, so we never apply a small home's per-foot rate to a large one.

Stillwater resales by bedrooms, 12, 24 and 36 months to October 14, 2026.

Group 12 months: sales, median, per sq ft 24 months: sales, median (middle half), per sq ft 36 months: sales, median (middle half), per sq ft
Unit 3, 2 bedrooms 6 (a small group), $291,000, $202 12, $316,250 ($285,500 to $328,500), $209 15, $320,000 ($302,000 to $350,000), $220
Unit 3, 3 bedrooms 4 (a small group), $282,000, $186 9 (a small group), $300,000 ($282,000 to $355,000), $222 11, $300,000 ($285,000 to $370,000), $222
Unit 1, 3 bedrooms 6 (a small group), $525,000, $207 10, $555,000 ($488,500 to $585,000), $261 11, $560,000 ($500,000 to $590,000), $262
Unit 1, 4 bedrooms 1 sale, $590,000 2 sales, $590,000 and $620,000 2 sales, $590,000 and $620,000

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation by the bedroom count the county records.

Bedroom count matters less in Stillwater than buyers expect. In Unit 3, where the roll lists 82 two-bedroom and 58 three-bedroom homes and every one has 2 baths, two-bedroom resales closed at or above three-bedroom resales in every window: $320,000 against $300,000 over 36 months, at $220 and $222 per foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Some two-bedroom Unit 3 plans carry more heated area than some three-bedroom plans, so a third bedroom carved from the same footprint does not lift the price on its own.

How do build years change value?

Build year in Stillwater mostly tells you which plat a home is in. Over 24 months, older-plat homes built 2000 to 2004 resold at a $560,000 median and 2005 to 2006 at $550,000, while homes built 2010 to 2016, all of them Unit 3, resold at $300,000 because they are smaller (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Older-plat Stillwater resales by roll build year, 12, 24 and 36 months to October 14, 2026.

Build years 12 months: sales, median, per sq ft 24 months: sales, median (middle half), per sq ft 36 months: sales, median (middle half), per sq ft
2000 to 2004 5 (a small group), $550,000, $214 9 (a small group), $560,000 ($515,000 to $605,000), $261 9 (a small group), $560,000 ($515,000 to $605,000), $261
2005 to 2006 4 (a small group), $560,000, $255 9 (a small group), $550,000 ($491,500 to $610,000), $257 12, $580,000 ($510,500 to $615,000), $265
2007 to 2009 2 sales, $280,000 and $305,000 6 (a small group), $318,750 ($298,750 to $325,500), $207 8 (a small group), $322,000 ($308,125 to $375,000), $209
2010 to 2016 8 (a small group), $282,000, $198 15, $300,000 ($279,000 to $350,000), $222 18, $308,500 ($283,500 to $360,625), $227
Shores at Stillwater, 2025 and 2026 16 first sales, $523,250, $267 same 16 same 16

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation by the roll's year built. The 2010 to 2016 band would also hold the one Unit 1 home the roll dates to 2016, but that home did not resell in these windows; every resale in the band was a Unit 3 home.

Build year still matters to a buyer for reasons the sales table cannot show: the building code a home was permitted under, the age of its roof, and how an insurer reads both. Florida's first statewide building code replaced local codes on March 1, 2002, the 2007 edition took effect March 1, 2009, and the 2010 edition March 15, 2012 (Florida Building Commission milestones). On the Stillwater roll, 12 Unit 1 homes are dated 2000 to 2002, so some may have been permitted before the first code took effect, while Unit 3 homes dated 2009 and later were most likely permitted under the 2007 code or later; the permit date, not the roll year, settles which code applied (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The second part of this page covers what those dates mean for wind mitigation credits, roof rules and value.

How Do Stillwater Resales Compare With Pulte's First Sales at Shores?

Stillwater in Englewood resales trade below Pulte's first sales per foot overall, but not against Unit 1. Over 24 months, Shores first sales carried a median $267 per heated square foot against $222 for all older-plat resales, 20.0 percent higher, yet only 2.3 percent above Unit 1's $261 (12 sales). Shores has no recorded resales yet (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Every Shores sale on the county file is a first sale, so there is no Shores resale record to compare with, and a Shores owner's comparables today are Pulte's own closings plus the older plats next door. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide says that "a subdivision is considered new when there are limited or no resales or the builder or developer is involved in the marketing or sale of the properties," and for a new subdivision the appraisal must include at least one settled sale from inside it, where "A resale is preferable if it is verifiable and does not involve the subject builder or developer," and at least one from outside (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08). On today's file Shores at Stillwater meets that test, and the nearest outside sales a lender's appraiser can reach are Units 1, 2 and 3.

The same guide adds that with builder sales "the appraisal must include discussion and analysis of sales concessions and upgrades for the subject property relative to concessions and upgrades for each builder sale" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08). That matters for a Unit 1 seller in a practical way: when an appraiser sets a Unit 1 home beside a Pulte first sale at a similar price, the Pulte sale's concessions and options get examined, and the Unit 1 home's own roof, windows and condition get compared with a 2026 home's. The recorded prices are close; the homes behind them are not.

Pulte's price sheet today adds a second comparison. On November 18, 2026, Pulte listed seven plans at Shores at Stillwater from $309,990 for the 1,321 square foot Colton villa to $565,990 for the Mystique Grande, with its Distinctive Collection from $399,990 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 18, 2026, subject to change). The Colton's base price sits $27,490 above the Unit 3 12-month median, 9.7 percent higher by our arithmetic, before options, lot and the Shores CDD, on a home 28 square feet smaller than Unit 3's 1,349 square foot median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Pulte's quick move-in homes sit lower still. Its Ellenwood villa was listed at $364,990, marked down from $405,880, and a Prosperity home at $444,990, marked down from $518,780 (Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in; Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in, builder-stated, read November 18, 2026, subject to change). The county recorded four Phase 1B villa first sales at 1,574 heated square feet, at $375,000, $379,000, $401,600 and $407,600, so the builder's Ellenwood asking price today sits below every villa first sale on the record (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). For anyone valuing a Shores villa, the builder's own asking price is now the low reference point, below the recorded sales; Fannie Mae treats current listings and contract offerings as supporting data, not as closed comparables (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08).

Want a Number for Your Own Stillwater Home?

Talk to McGreevy and Comisar before you list. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar will set your Stillwater home against the sales that match it: same plat, same size band, same build era, resales weighted first and Pulte's first sales read with their incentives in mind. Request your free Stillwater home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

Shopping for a home in Stillwater or elsewhere in Englewood instead? Marc leads the buying side: call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or read our guide to buying a home in Englewood.


How Have Stillwater Home Values Moved Since 2015?

Stillwater's older-plat resales rose from a median $143 per heated square foot in 2015 to $282 in 2023, then eased to $203 in 2026 through October 13. Unit 1 started from $153 and Unit 3 from $143 in 2015, and both still sit well above those baselines today (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, every qualified improved resale in Stillwater Units 1, 2 and 3 from January 1, 2015 to the newest on October 13, 2026, by calendar year and half-year, and every Shores at Stillwater first sale; REALTOR Association of Sarasota and Manatee October 2026 report published November 16, 2026; Florida Realtors October 2026 metro summary; FHFA House Price Index for the North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton metro through 2026 Q2).

What do calendar-year sales by unit show from 2015 to 2026?

Stillwater in Englewood's calendar-year record shows a slow climb to 2021, a sharp step up in 2022 and 2023, and a step back since. The older-plat per-foot median ran $143 in 2015, $191 in 2021, $282 in 2023 and $203 in 2026, with each plat a small group most years (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Stillwater older-plat resales by calendar year and plat, 2015 to 2026.

Year All older plats: sales, median per sq ft Unit 1: sales, median, per sq ft Unit 2: sales, median, per sq ft Unit 3: sales, median, per sq ft
2015 19, $143 7, $347,000, $153 4, $318,500, $144 8, $207,500, $143
2016 11, $163 3, $350,000, $143 1 sale 7, $223,500, $164
2017 11, $150 6, $363,000, $144 1 sale 4, $246,900, $171
2018 27, $167 8, $377,500, $167 5, $345,000, $162 14, $251,000, $170
2019 18, $167 7, $360,000, $167 5, $330,000, $156 6, $256,450, $178
2020 13, $185 3, $449,500, $205 1 sale 9, $255,000, $181
2021 13, $191 5, $392,000, $191 3, $425,000, $210 5, $275,000, $185
2022 11, $263 4, $667,750, $266 none 7, $380,000, $263
2023 10, $282 4, $790,000, $316 1 sale 5, $403,000, $260
2024 13, $264 1 sale 3, $592,000, $271 9, $370,000, $260
2025 17, $230 7, $560,000, $262 3, $542,000, $257 7, $324,000, $220
2026, to October 13 17, $203 5, $565,000, $248 2 sales 10, $282,500, $198

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation of qualified improved resales. Plat cells with fewer than 10 sales are small groups; cells with one or two sales print no median.

The all-plats column is the steadiest line here because it carries 10 or more sales every year. On it, the 2026 per-foot median of $203 sits 42.0 percent above 2015's $143 and 28.0 percent below 2023's $282 (our arithmetic on the Sarasota County Property Appraiser figures). Read both numbers together: a Stillwater owner who bought before 2020 is usually comparing against a lower base, and one who bought in 2022 or 2023 is comparing against the high.

The plat columns tell the same story with more noise. Unit 3's median price went from $207,500 (8 sales) in 2015 to $403,000 (5 sales) in 2023 and $282,500 (10 sales) in 2026, and its per-foot median from $143 to $260 to $198 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Unit 1 went from $153 per foot (7 sales) in 2015 to $316 (4 sales) in 2023, then $262 (7 sales) in 2025 and $248 (5 sales) in 2026. Most of those cells are small groups, so we read them for direction, not for a percentage: both plats rose to a high in 2022 or 2023 and both sit lower in 2026.

What do half-year sales show from 2022 to 2026?

Stillwater's half-year record narrows the recent turn to 2025. The older-plat per-foot median held between $257 and $269 from early 2023 through the first half of 2025, apart from 3 sales at $316, then read $215 in the second half of 2025 and $200 in the first half of 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Stillwater older-plat resales by half-year, 2022 to 2026.

Half-year Sales Median price Median per heated sq ft Plat mix
2022, first half 9 (a small group) $400,000 $263
2022, second half 2 too few for a median too few for a median
2023, first half 7 (a small group) $410,000 $267
2023, second half 3 (a small group) $860,000 $316
2024, first half 6 (a small group) $392,500 $262
2024, second half 7 (a small group) $370,000 $269
2025, first half 11 $530,000 $257 Unit 1: 4, Unit 2: 2, Unit 3: 5
2025, second half 6 (a small group) $500,000 $215 Unit 1: 3, Unit 2: 1, Unit 3: 2
2026, first half 15 $302,000 $200 Unit 1: 5, Unit 2: 1, Unit 3: 9
2026, July 1 to October 13 2 too few for a median too few for a median Unit 2: 1, Unit 3: 1

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation; the plat mix for 2025 and 2026 is counted from the county's resale list for the 36-month window.

The median price column moves with what sold, and the plat mix column shows it. The first half of 2026 printed a $302,000 median because 9 of its 15 resales were Unit 3 homes, while the first half of 2025 printed $530,000 with 6 of 11 from Units 1 and 2 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Neither median is a price for a Stillwater home; each is a snapshot of which plats happened to sell. The per-foot column adjusts for size and is the better guide, but it still mixes plats that carry different per-foot levels.

The 2023 second half shows how far a small group can pull the line. Three resales at a median $860,000 and $316 per foot made that half the highest on the table, and Unit 1's 2023 calendar-year median of $790,000 came from 4 sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A handful of sales set those figures. We do not treat $316 per foot as the Stillwater peak value of an ordinary Unit 1 home.

Why did per-square-foot prices peak in 2022 and 2023?

Stillwater's per-foot peak lines up with the metro's. The federal repeat-sales index for the North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton metro rose from 324.54 in the first quarter of 2021 to a high of 501.99 in the third quarter of 2023, while Stillwater's older-plat median went from $191 in 2021 to $282 in 2023 (FHFA House Price Index via FRED).

FHFA all-transactions index, North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton metro, selected quarters (1995 Q1 = 100).

Quarter Index Stillwater older-plat median per sq ft, same calendar year
2021 Q1 324.54 $191 (2021, 13 sales)
2022 Q2 467.98 $263 (2022, 11 sales)
2022 Q4 493.13 $263 (2022)
2023 Q3 501.99, the high of the series shown $282 (2023, 10 sales)
2024 Q4 497.24 $264 (2024, 13 sales)
2025 Q3 476.07 $230 (2025, 17 sales)
2026 Q2 478.67, the latest quarter $203 (2026 to October 13, 17 sales)

Sources: FHFA House Price Index via FRED, series ATNHPIUS35840Q, last updated August 25, 2026; Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation.

The two lines climbed together and then parted. From 2021 to 2023 Stillwater's older-plat per-foot median rose 47.6 percent by our arithmetic, while the metro index rose 54.7 percent from the first quarter of 2021 to its 2023 high (FHFA House Price Index via FRED; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). After 2023 the metro index slipped only a little, while Stillwater's older plats gave back far more. The index measures repeat sales across a whole metro, so it cannot show what happened inside one community such as Stillwater once Pulte began closing homes next door.

Two Stillwater-specific facts also shaped the high. First, the 2023 figure rests on 10 resales, and the 3 in the second half of 2023 closed at a median $860,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Second, the homes bought most recently are the ones now resold below their earlier price: of the 12-month resales with an earlier qualified sale on file, the 3 whose earlier sale was in 2022 or later (on the county list, those earlier sales fell in 2024 and 2025) all resold below the price recorded at that earlier sale, a small group (same source). The peak was real, but it was set by a small, uneven group of homes, which is why we price from the latest sales rather than from the 2023 figure.

What do 2025 and 2026 show, and why does the mix matter?

Stillwater's 2025 and 2026 resales show lower per-foot prices inside Unit 1 and Unit 3, not only a shift toward smaller homes. Unit 3's per-foot median went from $220 in 2025 (7 sales) to $198 in 2026 (10 sales), and Unit 1's from $262 (7 sales) to $248 (5 sales); most are small groups (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

The mix does explain part of the move. The older-plat per-foot median fell from $257 in the first half of 2025 to $200 in the first half of 2026, 22.2 percent lower by our arithmetic, and over the same months the share of Unit 3 homes in the resales rose from 5 of 11 to 9 of 15 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Because Unit 3 carries a lower per-foot level than Units 1 and 2, more Unit 3 sales pull the combined median down even if no single home changed value. That part of the move is arithmetic, not a market signal.

The rest of the move shows up inside the plats. The second half of 2025 printed $215 per foot even though 4 of its 6 resales came from Units 1 and 2, the higher per-foot plats, and both Unit 1 and Unit 3 recorded lower per-foot medians in 2026 than in 2025 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Those are small groups, so we draw a direction from them and no percentage: Stillwater resale prices per foot are lower in 2026 than in 2025 in both plats that printed a median in each year. Unit 1's price median, $560,000 in 2025 and $565,000 in 2026, barely moved while its per-foot median fell, which suggests the 2026 Unit 1 sales were, as a group, somewhat larger homes.

The record also shows when the resales happened. County records list 10 older-plat resales in the first quarter of 2026, 5 in the second and 2 in the third, while Shores first sales ran 1, 10 and 4 in the same quarters (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The months when Pulte's closings picked up were the months when older-plat resales thinned out. The record cannot prove why, and seasonality plays a part, but a Stillwater seller in 2026 has been listing beside a builder that recorded first sales in most months since April.

How does the gap with Shores change across 12, 24 and 36 months?

Stillwater's new-home gap depends on the window more than on the homes. The 16 Shores first sales sit at $267 per heated square foot in every window, so the gap moves only with the resale side: 31.3 percent over 12 months, 20.0 percent over 24 and 13.0 percent over 36 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Shores at Stillwater first sales against older-plat resales, median per heated square foot, by window.

Window Older-plat resales Resale median per sq ft Shores first sales Shores median per sq ft Shores above resales
12 months 19 $203 16 $267 +31.3%
24 months 39 $222 16 $267 +20.0%
36 months 47 $236 16 $267 +13.0%
24 months, Unit 1 only 12 $261 16 $267 +2.3%
36 months, Unit 1 only 13 $261 16 $267 +2.3%
24 months, Unit 2 only 6 (a small group) $251 16 $267 not drawn (small group)
36 months, Unit 2 only 8 (a small group) $262 16 $267 not drawn (small group)

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation. Gaps are computed from the unrounded medians.

Much of the 12-month gap is the 2025 to 2026 fall in older resale per-foot prices, not a fixed premium for a new home. If the gap were a stable new-construction premium, it would read about the same in every window; instead it more than doubles from 13.0 percent to 31.3 percent as the window shortens and the older 2023 and 2024 resales drop out (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Against Unit 1, the larger-home plat with the most resales, Pulte's first sales sit only 2.3 percent higher on the foot over both 24 and 36 months.

Which window an appraiser uses therefore changes the story a Stillwater seller hears. Fannie Mae says "Comparable sales that have closed within the last 12 months should be used in the appraisal," and gives the example of using "a nine month old sale with a time adjustment" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08). A Unit 1 owner whose appraiser reaches back past 12 months for size-matched Unit 1 sales should expect a time adjustment on them, because the 12-month Unit 1 per-foot median of $214 (7 sales, a small group) sits below the 24-month $261 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). We build the same adjustment into a listing price before the appraiser does.

How does Stillwater compare with Sarasota County and the metro?

Stillwater ran softer than its county in 2026. Sarasota County's single-family median was $490,000 in October 2026, up 10.1 percent on the year, with 4.0 months of supply and 40 median days to contract, while Stillwater's older-plat per-foot median sat 28.0 percent below its 2023 high (REALTOR Association of Sarasota and Manatee, October 2026; Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Stillwater against Sarasota County and the metro, latest readings.

Measure Figure Period and source
Sarasota County single-family median $490,000, up 10.1% October 2026, RASM, published November 16, 2026
Sarasota County months of supply 4.0 October 2026, same source
Sarasota County median days to contract 40 (61 a year earlier) October 2026, same source
Sarasota County median share of original list price 95.5% (92.4% a year earlier) October 2026, same source
North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton metro single-family median $491,480, up 5.8% October 2026, Florida Realtors
Metro repeat-sales index 478.67, down 0.5% on the year, 4.6% below the 2023 Q3 high 2026 Q2, FHFA via FRED
Stillwater, all 35 qualified sales $485,000 median 12 months to October 14, 2026, Sarasota County Property Appraiser
Stillwater Unit 3 resales $282,500 median (10 sales) Same window and source
Stillwater Unit 1 resales $550,000 median (7 sales) Same window and source
Stillwater older-plat median per sq ft $203 in 2026, $282 in 2023 Calendar years, same source
Stillwater days on market, sale-to-list, months of supply Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). MLS-only fields

The county and the metro figures describe every kind of home across a wide area, so they set a backdrop rather than a value. The Unit 3 12-month median of $282,500 equals 57.5 percent of the metro single-family median of $491,480, while the Unit 1 median of $550,000, from a small group of 7 sales, sits above it (our arithmetic on the Florida Realtors and Sarasota County Property Appraiser figures). Stillwater straddles the metro median rather than sitting on it, so a county headline about the median home describes neither Stillwater product.

The direction is the more useful comparison. The metro repeat-sales index stood only 4.6 percent below its 2023 high in the second quarter of 2026, and the county median was up on the year in October, while Stillwater's older-plat per-foot median sat 28.0 percent below its own 2023 figure (FHFA via FRED; RASM, October 2026; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Some of that gap is the small 2023 Stillwater sample, and some is mix, as shown above. Even allowing for both, the older Stillwater plats have reset further than the area around them. The record cannot prove why, but two local factors fit it: new Pulte homes next door and the age of the 2000s housing stock. The association's own president put it this way in the October report: "October's numbers show why it's important to look beyond the overall market trends" (RASM, October 2026).


How Do I Get a Free Stillwater Home Valuation?

The fastest way to a free Stillwater home valuation is the address form below the page header: about a minute, no fee, and the request goes to Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, who price your Stillwater in Englewood home by hand from the county's recorded sales for your plat, size and build era, never from a website estimate.

How do I request a free Stillwater valuation in 60 seconds?

Enter your Stillwater address in the valuation form below the page header and tell us your timing: listing soon, sometime next year, or simply checking. Prefer to talk first? Call Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc Comisar at (239) 287-5873. There is no fee and no obligation.

You will be working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012. Request your free Stillwater home valuation from anywhere on this page. We start with your parcel on the county file: its plat, its use code, the heated area, bedrooms and year built the county records, and the sales that belong beside it among the 35 qualified Stillwater sales of the latest 12 months and the 63 of the latest 36 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). If you are still deciding whether to sell, our Stillwater seller guide walks through the listing, and our Stillwater neighborhood guide covers the plats, streets and services around your home.

If you own elsewhere in town, the same method runs on our Englewood home valuation page, and our guide to selling a home in Englewood and Englewood area guide cover the wider market. If you are weighing Pulte's homes at Shores at Stillwater, or other builders' homes, against your own, our page on new construction in Englewood covers the builders a Stillwater buyer may also visit.

What should a Stillwater owner have ready?

Nothing is required to start a Stillwater valuation, but six kinds of paper sharpen it: your closing statement, permits for a reroof, windows or a pool, your 2026 tax bill, your insurance declarations with the wind mitigation form, any four-point report, and any flood elevation certificate. Each one answers a question the county record leaves open.

  • Your closing statement. For a Shores at Stillwater owner it is the one paper that shows what the deed does not: any Pulte credit, rate buydown or included option that came with the purchase. Fannie Mae says comparable sales "that include sales or financing concessions must be adjusted to reflect the impact, if any, on the sales price of the comparables" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09), so knowing what your own price included tells us how to read the Pulte sales around it. For an older-plat owner it shows the price and date your home's value is measured against.
  • Permits for a reroof, windows, a pool or an addition. Stillwater's older homes date mostly from 2000 to 2013 on the roll, so a buyer's insurer asks about the roof first (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A permit dates the work, and a dated reroof or impact window package is what lets a resale stand beside a 2026 Pulte home.
  • Your 2026 tax bill. Taxes on every Stillwater home start from the same countywide rate: 11.3068 mills for unincorporated Sarasota County in 2026, down from 11.4737, plus a flat Englewood Area Fire Control District charge of $290.78 per home (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage; 2025 millage; Englewood Area Fire Control District). For Shores owners, the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District does not appear on the Tax Collector's 2026 list, and its 2026/2027 budget marks the operations charge "To Be Collected At Closings" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, final budget 2026/2027), so your closing statement may be where that line shows. Older-plat records indicate those plats are outside the district; your bill confirms it.
  • Insurance declarations and the wind mitigation form. Florida's form OIR-B1-1802 was revised in April 2026, and the version Citizens' guide describes asks "which version of the Florida (or South Florida) Building Code was in effect when the structure's building permit was first submitted" (Citizens Property Insurance, Wind Loss Mitigation Guide, Rev. 04/26). A buyer who sees your premium and your form can price the carrying cost before making an offer.
  • Any four-point report and the roof's age. For a home built in the early 2000s, a recent inspection tells a buyer's insurer what it needs to know before the buyer commits.
  • Flood papers. Flood zones vary by lot in Stillwater, and the only lot-level reading we hold is an earlier Zone X reading at one Unit 1 address, a single data point rather than a flood determination (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). An elevation certificate for your own lot is the paper a buyer's lender and insurer will want.

HOA dues for any Stillwater association: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). The estoppel certificate for your home states them, and we read it with you.

What do we check before we give a Stillwater number?

Before we give a Stillwater number we check seven things: plat, use code and heated size, bedrooms, build year and code era, roof and systems, the lot, and what a buyer could buy from Pulte that day. Most of them show up in the record above, and together they narrow a plat median to a range for one home.

  1. Plat. Unit 3 resales sat at $282,500 and Unit 1 at $550,000 over 12 months, the widest single split in the record (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  2. Use code and heated size. Units 1 and 2 are coded 0100 and Unit 3 0101; the size bands above show per-foot levels from $207 to $268 at the 24-month medians (same source).
  3. Bedrooms. In Unit 3, two-bedroom resales matched or beat three-bedroom resales in every window, so we read bedrooms against heated area, never alone (same source).
  4. Build year and code era. A 2000 to 2002 Unit 1 home, a 2005 Unit 2 home and a 2013 Unit 3 home can sit in different code eras, which affects wind credits and a buyer's insurance (Florida Building Commission milestones).
  5. Roof, windows and systems. The age of each, with permits, because a buyer measures them against Pulte's tile roof and impact windows next door (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 18, 2026).
  6. The lot. Lake, preserve or interior, corner or mid-block. No public source measures a Stillwater lot premium, so we read the lot from the closest sales and say so plainly; we print no lot-premium figure.
  7. Pulte's sheet that day. The plans, quick move-in homes and offer a buyer could choose instead, dated, because those prices change and the recorded sales do not show them.

What will your written Stillwater valuation contain, and when?

You receive a written comparative market analysis for your Stillwater home: a price range, every recorded Stillwater sale we used with its plat, heated area and month, the adjustments for each, the Pulte homes your buyer can tour instead, and an estimate of your net. Under Florida law it is an opinion of value, never an appraisal.

Florida's licensing law says its appraisal-standards ground "does not apply to" a broker or sales associate who "performs a comparative market analysis, gives a broker price opinion, or gives an opinion of value of real estate," but adds that "in no event may this comparative market analysis, broker price opinion, or opinion of value of real estate be referred to as an appraisal" (Florida Statutes 475.25). Your buyer's lender orders its own appraisal; our job is to set a price that appraisal will support, using the Stillwater resales and Pulte first sales the appraiser will reach for.

What the file holds:

  • A written price range, with the reason your Stillwater home sits where it does among the sales for its plat, size band and build era.
  • The recorded sales we used, each with month, plat, county heated area, bedrooms, build year, price and price per heated square foot, resales and first sales marked.
  • The builder comparison: the Pulte homes on sale that day at Shores at Stillwater that a buyer could choose instead, with Pulte's stated prices and any posted offer, dated and labeled builder-stated.
  • The carrying-cost view: the tax line, the fire charge, the CDD line for a Shores home, the HOA, the flood zone of your lot and the insurance a buyer should expect.
  • A seller net sheet. Our Florida seller closing costs guide covers the full list.

On timing: the form takes about a minute, and Jesse or Marc follows up directly to confirm your home's details. The written analysis follows once we have your parcel and papers; a home with its roof permit, wind mitigation form and closing statement in hand is the quickest to value.

Still choosing who should prepare it? Our page on the best real estate agents in Englewood sets out what to ask any listing agent and where to check the answers. Talk to McGreevy and Comisar before you list: request your free Stillwater home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.


Why Can't an Online Estimate Value a Stillwater Home?

An online estimate struggles with a Stillwater home because one name covers two markets. In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, Stillwater's 19 older-plat resales sold at a median $203 per heated square foot and its 16 Pulte first sales at $267, and the deeds show none of the builder incentives behind the new-home prices (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; one national brokerage's published estimate accuracy figures, read November 18, 2026; Pulte's Shores at Stillwater pages and PulteGroup's Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, read November 18, 2026; the federal AVM rule, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae guidance as cited).

How do two markets in one community trip an automated estimate?

Stillwater in Englewood trips automated estimates because a model sees one community where the record holds two. A 1,349 square foot Unit 3 home priced at the Shores first-sale median of $267 per foot comes to $360,183; at Unit 3's own $198 it comes to $267,102, a $93,081 difference by our multiplication (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Three features of the Stillwater record make the blend likely. First, the two groups sit side by side under one name and one entrance, and 16 of the latest 12 months' 35 sales were Pulte first sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Second, the county's use code does not separate them cleanly: all 140 Unit 3 homes and 10 finished Shores homes carry the same code, 0101, so a model that groups by property type can put a 2010 Unit 3 home beside a 2026 Pulte villa (same source). Third, the resale per-foot level moved fast, from $257 in the first half of 2025 to $200 in the first half of 2026, so a model that weights older sales too heavily prices high, and one that leans on Pulte's 2026 closings prices higher still.

What a model does with plats shows the risk on a larger home too. Over 24 months, Unit 1 resales carried a median $261 per foot and Unit 3 resales $215 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A model that blends the older plats into one Stillwater rate underprices a Unit 1 home and overprices a Unit 3 home. On a 2,204 square foot Unit 1 home, the full $46 per-foot gap between the two plats comes to $101,384 (our multiplication), nearly a fifth of the Unit 1 median price; a blended rate would miss by part of that.

One national brokerage publishes accuracy figures for its own online estimate, and for Florida homes not on the market its page, read November 18, 2026, gives a 7.56 percent median error, with 36.36 percent of estimates within 5 percent. For homes listed for sale in Florida, the same page gives a 2.06 percent median error, because the estimate can lean on the list price. On the Unit 3 median of $282,500 the off-market median error is about $21,357, on the Unit 1 median of $550,000 about $41,580, and on the Shores median of $523,250 about $39,558 (our arithmetic on the Sarasota County Property Appraiser medians).

Those are statewide figures; the published table we read gives no error figure for Stillwater, Englewood or Sarasota County. A median error is the middle case, so half of off-market estimates miss by more. In Unit 3, where the 12-month middle half of prices spans $266,875 to $302,750, a $21,357 miss can move a home from the middle of its band to outside it (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). We name online estimates because owners ask about them; we never use them as data.

How do builder incentives stay off the Stillwater deed?

Pulte's incentives stay off the Stillwater deed because the county records one price per sale and itemizes nothing. An included pool, a closing-cost credit or a rate buydown changes what a Shores at Stillwater buyer received without changing the recorded price, and Pulte's current offer shows their size (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, read November 18, 2026).

Pulte's Shores at Stillwater page, read November 18, 2026, offers buyers a pool or a credit for purchase agreements accepted between November 2 and November 30, 2026. The fine print says eligible buyers "shall receive a standard pool, valued at $69,500" on select to-be-built homes, or that the "builder will credit buyer $77,000 to be used toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins," that "Maximum credit amounts vary by community," and that the "Offer cannot be combined with other offers or incentives" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater, builder-stated, subject to change). On a Shores home at the $523,250 first-sale median, $77,000 would be 14.7 percent of the price (our arithmetic on the Sarasota County Property Appraiser figure).

The builder expects to keep offering them. PulteGroup's quarterly report for the period ended September 30, 2026 says the company is "focusing sales incentives on discounts, closing cost incentives, and mortgage interest rate buydowns" and that "we expect our sales incentives to remain elevated" (PulteGroup Form 10-Q, quarter ended September 30, 2026). Each of those three kinds of incentive can leave the recorded price untouched, which means each Shores first sale on the county file may hide a different deal.

None of that reaches the record an online estimate reads, and appraisers have rules for it. Freddie Mac's guidance for appraisers says any adjustment "should approximate the market's reaction to the financing or concessions," and that the appraiser "typically doesn't have access to the sales contract for the comparable sales" (Freddie Mac, Considering Financing and Sales Concessions). Fannie Mae adds that "Positive adjustments for sales or financing concessions are not acceptable" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09). An appraiser can adjust a concession-loaded Pulte sale down toward a cash price, but can never adjust a Unit 1 resale up to match it; an online estimate does neither.

The builder's own markdowns tell the same story from the other side. Pulte's two quick move-in homes were listed $73,790 and $40,890 below their earlier prices on November 18, 2026, the Prosperity at $444,990 and the Ellenwood villa at $364,990 (Pulte, Prosperity quick move-in; Pulte, Ellenwood quick move-in, builder-stated, subject to change). A model trained on the four recorded Phase 1B villa first sales at $375,000 to $407,600 would value a Shores villa above what Pulte is asking for a new one today (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

What does the federal AVM rule cover, and who does it protect?

The federal automated valuation model rule, effective October 1, 2025, makes lenders and secondary market issuers hold the models they use on a borrower's principal dwelling to quality control standards. It covers a lender's model on a Stillwater loan; it does not cover the estimate a Stillwater owner sees on a home-value website (Federal Register, FR Doc. 2024-16197).

Six federal agencies issued the rule in 2024. The CFPB's July 17, 2024 release says it is "designed to help ensure the credibility and integrity of models used in valuations for certain mortgages secured by a consumer's principal dwelling" (CFPB, July 17, 2024). Under the published rule, covered institutions must "adhere to quality control standards designed to ensure a high level of confidence in the estimates produced by AVMs; protect against the manipulation of data; seek to avoid conflicts of interest; require random sample testing and reviews; and comply with applicable nondiscrimination laws," and "This final rule is effective October 1, 2025" (Federal Register, FR Doc. 2024-16197, via GovInfo).

Three points follow for a Stillwater owner. The rule protects the lending process: when a lender uses a model for a Stillwater buyer's loan, that model is under quality control. The rule sets process standards, not an accuracy limit, so it does not make any figure right, and a model that is well controlled can still blend Unit 3 with Shores at Stillwater if it is fed one community name. And the rule does not reach consumer websites, so the number on a home-value page about a Stillwater address falls outside this rule. Use it as a rough starting point at most, and test it against the plat medians on this page.

Why does the Stillwater on the Bay name confuse searches?

Searches confuse Stillwater in Englewood with Stillwater on the Bay because they share a county and part of a name. Stillwater on the Bay is 7 parcels with Sarasota 34231 addresses; Stillwater in Englewood is 394 parcels with Englewood 34223 addresses. A value for one says nothing about the other (our Stillwater neighborhood guide, citing the county file).

The name is common well beyond Sarasota County. Our guide lists cities named Stillwater in Minnesota and Oklahoma, a "Shores at Stillwater" in Park City, Utah, and a "Stillwater Cay" in Estero, Florida, none connected to Stillwater in Englewood (our Stillwater neighborhood guide). Our search audit on November 18, 2026 also found a home-value page for ZIP code 34295 among the first results for a Stillwater value search, a ZIP that is not Stillwater's 34223. A "homes sold nearby" panel or an estimate built on a name match can pull in any of these.

The names inside Stillwater add a second layer. The county records the older plats as STILLWATER UNIT 1, UNIT 2 and UNIT 3 and Pulte's section as SHORES AT STILLWATER PHASE 1A and PHASE 1B, while Pulte markets the section as Shores at Stillwater (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). A site that searches the word "Stillwater" can return the older plats, the Pulte section and the Sarasota parcels together, or a site that indexes "Shores at Stillwater" alone can miss the 251 older-plat homes entirely. Every figure on this page is drawn from the 394 parcels of the five Englewood plats and nothing else. When you compare any outside number with ours, check first that it describes the same place.

Why are Unit 2 sales too thin for a model?

Stillwater Unit 2 has 35 homes and recorded only 2 qualified resales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026, at $550,000 and $620,000, then 6 over 24 months at a $546,000 median and 8 over 36 months at $571,000. A model needs recent sales to learn from, and Unit 2 rarely supplies them (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

The two latest Unit 2 sales were different homes. The county records them at 2,056 and 2,525 heated square feet, one with 3 bedrooms and one with 4, which helps explain why their prices sit $70,000 apart (our arithmetic) and why neither alone describes the plat (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). On the roll, Unit 2 is uniform in other ways: all 35 homes were built in 2005 or 2006, 34 have 3 bedrooms, every one has 2 baths, and the median is 2,181 heated square feet. A buyer sees a consistent plat; a model sees two data points.

The calendar-year record shows how long the drought has run. Unit 2 produced 1 qualified resale in each of 2016, 2017, 2020 and 2023, none in 2022, and 3 in each of 2021, 2024 and 2025 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A model that requires a minimum number of same-plat sales will reach outside Unit 2, and the question is where it reaches. If it reaches into Unit 3, it borrows a 1,349 square foot price for a 2,181 square foot home; if it reaches into Shores at Stillwater, it borrows a new home's price and incentives.

We reach into Unit 1. The two plats share a use code, a size range near 2,200 heated square feet and overlapping building years (Unit 1 mostly 2003 to 2005, Unit 2 2005 and 2006), and over 24 months the Units 1 and 2 combined record holds 18 resales at a $555,000 median and $259 per foot, middle half $215 to $268 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Fannie Mae's guide says "Sale activity from within the neighborhood is the best indicator of value" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08), and for a Unit 2 home the neighborhood that actually trades is Unit 1 plus Unit 2's own occasional sale.

Talk to McGreevy and Comisar before you list: request your free Stillwater home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, and you will have the recorded Stillwater sales behind your number, in writing. If you are weighing a sale, our Stillwater seller guide shows what comes next, and our Stillwater neighborhood guide maps the plats your number depends on. Shopping for a home in Stillwater instead? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or read our guide to buying a home in Englewood.

What Moves a Stillwater Home's Value Up or Down?

A Stillwater home's value moves first with its plat, because Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3 and Shores at Stillwater are different products, then with heated size, build year, roof, wind paperwork and condition. Over 12 months Unit 3 resales recorded a $282,500 median and Unit 1 resales $550,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales of improved homes over $1,000; 12 months October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; 24 months from October 15, 2024; 36 months from October 15, 2023; Pulte pages read November 18, 2026; Cost vs Value 2025, Sarasota market).

Stillwater in Englewood is four plats under one name: three built out between 2000 and 2013, and Shores at Stillwater, which Pulte is still building off the same Medical Boulevard entrance. A buyer can tour a 2004 Unit 1 home and a never-occupied Pulte home the same afternoon, so every lever below is read against that comparison. Per-square-foot figures are per square foot of the county's heated (living) area. For streets and amenities, see our Stillwater neighborhood guide; for the listing steps, see our Stillwater seller guide.

How do plat and home type change a Stillwater home's value?

Stillwater's plat is the first value lever because each plat holds one kind of house. County records show Units 1 and 2 coded 0100 with medians near 2,200 heated square feet and Unit 3 coded 0101 with a 1,349 square foot median, so the two rarely compare (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

The October 21, 2026 roll holds 76 Unit 1 homes at a 2,204 square foot median, 35 Unit 2 homes at 2,181 and 140 Unit 3 homes at 1,349, with a Unit 3 middle half of only 1,349 to 1,525 square feet (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Whether each Unit 3 home is attached or detached is not settled by any record we read, so we describe Unit 3 as the small-home section coded 0101 and check the plat and declaration for each home we value. Shores already shows both codes: 17 finished homes coded 0100, 10 coded 0101 and 107 lots coded vacant (same source).

The sales follow the codes. Over 12 months, 10 Unit 3 resales recorded a $282,500 median at $198 per heated square foot, 7 Unit 1 resales $550,000 at $214 (a small group), and Unit 2 only two sales, at $550,000 and $620,000, too few for a median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The Unit 3 median is 54.0 percent of the $523,250 Shores first-sale median; the Unit 1 median is 105.1 percent of it (same file).

Appraisers sort comparables the same way. Fannie Mae says "Sale activity from within the neighborhood is the best indicator of value," and treats a subdivision as new "when there are limited or no resales or the builder or developer is involved in the marketing or sale of the properties" (Fannie Mae B4-1.3-08). Shores meets that test; the older plats do not. So a Unit 3 valuation starts from Unit 3 resales (21 in 24 months), and a Unit 1 or Unit 2 valuation pools the two large-home plats (12 and 6 sales in 24 months) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

How do heated size and bedrooms change a Stillwater home's value?

In Stillwater, heated size moves the total price more than the per-foot rate, and an extra bedroom has not shown a price lift on its own in Unit 3. Over 24 months Unit 3 two-bedroom resales recorded a $316,250 median (n=12) against $300,000 for three-bedroom homes, a small group of 9 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Older Stillwater resales by plat and bedrooms, 24 months (October 15, 2024 to October 14, 2026).

Plat and bedrooms Sales Median price Median per heated sq ft
Unit 3, 2 bedrooms 12 $316,250 $209
Unit 3, 3 bedrooms 9 (a small group) $300,000 $222
Unit 1, 3 bedrooms 10 $555,000 $261
Unit 1, 4 bedrooms 2 ($590,000 and $620,000) too few for a median too few for a median
Unit 2, 3 bedrooms 5 (a small group) $542,000 $257

Source: our cut of the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; bedroom counts are the county's.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; qualified improved sales, 24 months to October 14, 2026).

The Unit 3 pattern repeats in every window. Over 12 months two-bedroom homes recorded $291,000 (n=6) and three-bedroom homes $282,000 (n=4); over 36 months, $320,000 (n=15) and $300,000 (n=11) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). These are small groups, so we draw no percentage conclusion, only a direction: where footage is so tightly bunched, a third bedroom may simply divide the same space differently, and the recorded medians have not shown extra paid for the count alone (our reading).

Size behaves as appraisers expect inside each plat. Over 24 months, older-plat homes of 1,200 to 1,399 heated square feet sold at $222 per foot (n=11) and 1,400 to 1,799 at $207 (n=10), almost all Unit 3; homes of 1,800 to 2,199 sold at $268 (n=9) and 2,200 to 2,599 at $215 (n=9), from Units 1 and 2 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Within each pair the larger homes carried the lower rate, likely because kitchens, baths and lots cost about the same in a slightly bigger house (our reading, on groups of 9 to 11); the step between pairs is the plat.

How do build year and the code era change a Stillwater home's value?

A Stillwater home's build year sets the building code it was permitted under, and that code sets the floor of its wind insurance rating. The first Florida Building Code replaced local codes on March 1, 2002, the 2007 code took effect March 1, 2009 and the 2010 code March 15, 2012 (Florida Building Commission milestones).

Stillwater build years and the likely code at permit (our mapping of the roll's build years onto the Commission's dates).

Plat Homes by year built Likely code at permit Wind form code answer
Unit 1, earliest 2000 (8), 2001 (2), 2002 (2) Local code if permitted before March 1, 2002 Possibly "D": code discounts not applied
Unit 1, main build 2003 to 2007 (63) 2001 or 2004 code "A. FBC 2001 & 2004"
Unit 2 2005 (12), 2006 (23) 2001 or 2004 code "A. FBC 2001 & 2004"
Unit 3, early 2007 (12), 2008 (12) 2004 code with 2006 Supplement "B" only with a permit application after December 8, 2006
Unit 3, later 2009 to 2013 (116) 2007 or 2010 code "B. FBC 2007 or newer"
Shores at Stillwater 2025 (8), 2026 (19) Current code "B. FBC 2007 or newer"

Sources: Sarasota County Property Appraiser roll; Florida Building Commission milestones; Citizens Wind Loss Mitigation Guide.

The sharpest line falls inside Unit 1. The 2026 wind mitigation form asks which code "was in effect when the structure's building permit was first submitted," and Citizens' guide says "FBC discounts are not applied when D is selected," the answer for a home that is unknown or does not meet the code tests (Citizens Wind Loss Mitigation Guide). Twelve Unit 1 homes are coded 2000 to 2002, so some may predate March 1, 2002 permits (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). For those, credits depend on what an inspector documents (clips or wraps, roof shape, secondary water resistance, openings), not on the code year.

The county sales cannot isolate the code effect, because build year tracks plat. Over 24 months homes built 2000 to 2004 recorded $261 per foot (n=9) and 2005 to 2006 $257 (n=9), both Units 1 and 2, against $207 for 2007 to 2009 (n=6) and $222 for 2010 to 2016 (n=15), almost all Unit 3 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Age also ends a safety net: a construction claim must be "commenced within 7 years" of the certificate of occupancy (Fla. Stat. 95.11), which every older-plat home has passed, while a Shores home carries Pulte's "10-Year Limited Structural Warranty," "transferable to subsequent owner" (Pulte warranty flyer).

How do roof age and the insurer's view change a Stillwater home's value?

Roof age is where Stillwater's older plats and Shores part ways. Florida bars an insurer from refusing a policy solely for age when a roof is under 15 years old, and an original roof on a 2000 to 2007 Unit 1 home is 19 to 26 years old in 2026 (Fla. Stat. 627.7011).

Past 15 years the burden shifts to paper. An insurer "may not refuse to issue or refuse to renew a homeowner's insurance policy solely because of roof age if an inspection ... indicates that the roof has 5 years or more of useful life remaining," and age runs from "the last date on which 100 percent of the roof's surface area was built or replaced" (Fla. Stat. 627.7011). Unit 3 homes built in 2012 and 2013 reach 15 years in 2027 and 2028 on an original roof (our arithmetic).

Citizens uses longer clocks with a harder test: roofs "Older than 25 years for shingle" or "50 years for tile, slate, concrete or metal" need "at least five years of remaining useful life," measured from "the oldest part of the roof" (Citizens roof rule changes). If they are original shingle, the oldest Unit 1 roofs (2000 and 2001) are 25 or 26 years old in 2026 (our arithmetic; roof material per home is not in the county file we used). For new business applications on policies effective on or after August 1, 2026, "The year of last roof update will be provided by Virtual Roof/Verisk," and an agent who changes it must "provide documentation to support the change" (Citizens bulletin, July 1, 2026). Citizens also requires a four-point inspection "for properties more than 20 years old" (Citizens inspections), which reaches most Unit 1 homes now and the 2006 Unit 2 homes from 2027 (our arithmetic on the roll's build years); the buyer's insurer sets its own rule.

A new roof recovers less than it costs on paper. The 2025 Cost vs Value report puts an asphalt shingle replacement in the Sarasota market at $34,028 with 64.9 percent recouped, and metal at $53,458 with 55.6 percent (JLC Cost vs Value 2025, Sarasota). That understates its role. At 7.11 percent with 20 percent down, each $1,000 a year a buyer saves on premium supports about $13,200 of price (our estimate; Freddie Mac PMMS), and a roof that blocks insurance can block the sale. With "Impact Glass & Tile Roof Included" on every Shores home (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater), a documented recent roof closes the most visible part of the gap.

How do wind mitigation credits change a Stillwater home's value?

A current wind mitigation form can change a Stillwater buyer's insurance quote, and the quote changes what the buyer can pay. Florida's consumer guide says homes built to the 2001 code or later are "automatically eligible for a minimum 68% discount on the windstorm coverage of the premium," with larger discounts possible for added features (Florida CFO hurricane mitigation guide).

Rate filings "must include actuarially reasonable discounts, credits, or other rate differentials" for wind-resistant features, including "opening protection, and window, door, and skylight strength" (Fla. Stat. 627.0629). The credits "apply only to the windstorm coverage," a form "is valid for five years provided no material changes are made," and inspections on or after April 1, 2026 use the new form (Florida CFO hurricane mitigation guide). Citizens calls the OIR-B1-1802 (Rev. 04/26) "more comprehensive than the prior version," and warns it "is not acceptable proof of roof condition or replacement" (Citizens Wind Loss Mitigation Guide), so the roof permit travels with it.

Roof shape and openings separate Stillwater homes on the form. A hip roof earns a discount when it slopes on all sides "with no other roof shape greater than 10% of the total roof perimeter," and opening protection is graded from hurricane-rated (9A) down to unprotected (same source). Pulte includes impact glass "with every home" at Shores (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater), so an older-plat home with documented impact windows or rated shutters answers the buyer's first comparison.

What do updates and remodeling recover in a Stillwater home's value?

Updates in a Stillwater home recover less than they cost, with small visible projects the exception. The 2025 Cost vs Value report for the Sarasota market puts a garage door replacement at 204 percent recouped and a midrange minor kitchen remodel at 104.4 percent, while an upscale major kitchen remodel recoups 35.6 percent (JLC Cost vs Value 2025, Sarasota).

What projects recouped at resale in the Sarasota market, 2025 report (survey estimates, not Stillwater sales).

Project Job cost Resale value Share recouped
Garage door replacement $5,302 $10,817 204 percent
Entry door replacement, steel $2,383 $4,655 195.4 percent
Minor kitchen remodel, midrange $28,579 $29,834 104.4 percent
Backup power generator $13,516 $13,628 100.8 percent
Bath remodel, midrange $26,113 $19,282 73.8 percent
HVAC conversion, electrification $19,382 $13,492 69.6 percent
Major kitchen remodel, midrange $81,115 $40,308 49.7 percent
Bath remodel, upscale $80,449 $30,706 38.2 percent
Major kitchen remodel, upscale $161,192 $57,344 35.6 percent
Solar power installation $55,694 $15,994 28.7 percent

Source: JLC Cost vs Value 2025, Sarasota, the nearest market to Stillwater in the 2025 report. Roof rows appear in the roof section above.

Data updated: November 2026 (Cost vs Value 2025 report, Sarasota market; the latest report found).

In a 20-year-old Unit 1 or Unit 2 house, the refresh projects at the top apply; the large remodels below recover about half or less. Pulte's own pitch explains the buyer's math: a PulteGroup executive said in 2024 that "What used to cost $40,000 to renovate a kitchen just a few years ago is now $100,000," and that buyers choose new "rather than absorbing steep renovation costs on existing homes" (Sarasota Magazine, November 2024). A resale whose kitchen and baths are done removes that objection.

Appraisers capture it through condition. Fannie Mae rates a home that has "not previously been occupied" C1, a well-maintained one with "limited physical depreciation" C3, and one with "some minor deferred maintenance" C4 (Fannie Mae B4-1.3-06). Every Shores first sale is a C1 comparable; an updated older-plat home holds C3 more easily than an original one (the appraiser decides).

Pools need their own evidence. Pulte's November 2026 offer values "a standard pool" at $69,500 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater), a builder-stated replacement reference, not a resale premium; the county file has no pool flag, so we print none. A Florida pool must have at least one listed safety feature to pass final inspection (Fla. Stat. 515.27), so a permitted, closed-out pool and cage is something an appraiser can count.

Does lot position change a Stillwater home's value?

Lot position moves a Stillwater value in direction only, because no public source measures it here. The county file we used carries no lake, preserve or view flag, and Pulte markets "Water and preserve views" at Shores at Stillwater without printing a homesite premium on its pages read November 18, 2026 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater).

Paired evidence is thin. Only 19 of the 251 older-plat homes, 7.6 percent, sold in 12 months, and 37, or 14.7 percent, in 24 months (Sarasota County Property Appraiser); split by plat, size and lot, the groups shrink to one or two. So in a Stillwater CMA a lake view, a preserve backdrop or a cul-de-sac places your home higher within the range its plat and size set, and a busier street places it lower, with no dollar or percentage premium printed.

Which disclosure duties touch a Stillwater home's value?

Florida's disclosure duties touch a Stillwater value because a defect a buyer finds late reopens price. Johnson v. Davis (Fla. 1985) holds that a seller who knows of facts "materially affecting the value of the property which are not readily observable" must disclose them, and its facts involved a roof (Johnson v. Davis).

For a 2000s Stillwater home, the facts most likely to fall under that duty are a past roof leak, water intrusion around sliders, a failed air handler or a flood claim. Florida adds a written flood disclosure "at or before the time the sales contract is executed" (Fla. Stat. 689.302), and the initial sale of a CDD home must carry the boldface notice that the district "MAY IMPOSE AND LEVY TAXES OR ASSESSMENTS, OR BOTH" (Fla. Stat. 190.048); on a Shores resale, the estoppel and tax bill show the line.

The value point is timing. A disclosed defect is priced once, at listing, with a repair or credit the seller chooses; the same defect found by the buyer's inspector is priced again under deadline. We read your disclosure answers with you before we set a number, and our Stillwater seller guide covers the full list.

Want a number that counts your plat, roof and paperwork? Request a Stillwater home valuation built from your plat, roof date and wind mitigation form. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How Does Pulte's Price Sheet at Shores at Stillwater Set the Ceiling for Resales?

Pulte's live price sheet at Shores at Stillwater is the number every Stillwater resale buyer checks first. Read November 18, 2026, builder-stated and subject to change, Pulte lists seven plans from $309,990 for the Colton villa to $565,990 for the Mystique Grande, plus two marked-down quick move-in homes (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater).

Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte community, plan and quick move-in pages read November 18, 2026, builder-stated and subject to change; PulteGroup Form 10-Q and earnings release for the quarter ended September 30, 2026; Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026).

A builder selling inside the same community name is the hardest comparable a resale seller can face. Shores at Stillwater in Englewood shares the Medical Boulevard address area with Units 1, 2 and 3, and Pulte markets the same location an older-plat home has, "Next door to HCA Florida Englewood Hospital" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Pulte counts "255 future front doors," and the district's master assessment covers 255 units, against 140 Shores parcels on the roll, 107 still coded vacant (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The builder will be selling beside Stillwater resales for some time.

What does Pulte list at Shores at Stillwater today?

On November 18, 2026, Pulte's Shores at Stillwater page listed a Villa Collection from $309,990 and a Distinctive Collection from $399,990, with homes from 1,321 to 2,870 square feet. These are builder-stated base prices, subject to change, before lot premiums, options and upgrades (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater).

Pulte's Shores at Stillwater plans (builder-stated, read November 18, 2026, subject to change).

Plan Collection Pulte sq ft Bedrooms (Pulte) Builder-stated starting price Base per sq ft (our arithmetic)
Colton Villa 1,321 2 $309,990 $235
Ellenwood Villa 1,579 2 to 3 $331,990 $210
Prosperity Distinctive 1,670 and up 2 to 3 $399,990 $240
Mystique Distinctive 1,889 and up 2 to 3 $419,990 $222
Palmary Distinctive 1,943 and up 2 to 3 $424,990 $219
Prestige Distinctive 2,080 and up 2 to 3 $452,990 $218
Mystique Grande Distinctive 2,870 and up 3 to 4 $565,990 $197

Sources: Pulte, Shores at Stillwater; plan pages for the Colton, Ellenwood, Prosperity, Mystique, Palmary, Prestige and Mystique Grande. Per-foot figures divide Pulte's starting price by Pulte's stated square footage; they are our arithmetic, not Pulte's.

The base sheet has come down since launch. In November 2024 Sarasota Magazine reported starting prices "expected to be in the mid-$300,000s" (Sarasota Magazine, November 2024); today the entry plan is the smaller Colton at $309,990, under a "New Low Pricing" tag (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater).

The included list is what a Stillwater resale is compared against: a "Tile roof," "Whole house impact-resistant vinyl windows," an "Energy-efficient, tankless gas water heater," "Silestone countertops" and a "Large, private, brick paver, screened lanai" (Pulte Prosperity plan page), plus "Natural gas appliances" and a 10-year limited structural warranty (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater).

Two things are missing. Pulte states no HOA dollar figure, only "Community Association fees required," and none of the Pulte pages our researcher read mentions the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). The CDD section below fills that gap from the district's records.

How do Pulte's base prices per square foot compare with recorded Stillwater medians?

Pulte's base prices work out to $197 to $240 per square foot at Shores at Stillwater, our arithmetic from builder-stated price and footage. Recorded Shores first sales closed well above that, at a $267 median per heated square foot over 12 months (n=16), as expected once options, pools and lot premiums ride on top of base (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Pulte base prices beside the nearest recorded Stillwater groups (builder prices read November 18, 2026; county sales to October 14, 2026).

Pulte plan (Pulte sq ft) Base per sq ft (our arithmetic) Nearest recorded Stillwater group Sales Median price Median per heated sq ft
Colton (1,321) $235 Unit 3 resales, 12 months 10 $282,500 $198
Ellenwood (1,579) $210 Shores Phase 1B first sales, all on file 4 (a small group) $390,300 $248
Prosperity (1,670 and up) $240 Shores first sales under 1,800 sq ft 5 (a small group) $401,600 $255
Mystique, Palmary, Prestige (1,889 to 2,080 and up) $218 to $222 Shores first sales 1,800 to 2,199 sq ft 10 $564,750 $290
Prestige (2,080 and up) $218 Unit 1 resales, 24 months 12 $562,500 $261
Mystique Grande (2,870 and up) $197 Shores first sales 2,200 sq ft and up 1 ($607,600) too few for a median too few for a median

Sources: Pulte, Shores at Stillwater; our cut of the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026. County figures use heated area; Pulte figures use Pulte's stated footage, which can count space differently.

Data updated: November 2026 (Pulte pages read November 18, 2026; Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; Shores first sales recorded February to October 2026).

The gap between base and closed price is the first lesson. Phase 1A first sales recorded a $564,750 median at $290 per heated foot (n=12), while Distinctive plans of similar size start at $218 to $222 per Pulte foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). A Unit 1 or Unit 2 seller who reads "from $452,990" as Pulte's price for a 2,080 square foot home is reading the floor, not what Pulte's buyers closed at.

The second lesson cuts the other way for Unit 3. The Unit 3 12-month median of $282,500 is 91.1 percent of the Colton's $309,990 base (our arithmetic), and the 1,321 square foot Colton is the closest new substitute for a 1,349 square foot Unit 3 home (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A Unit 3 resale priced near $310,000 asks a buyer to pass on a new villa with impact glass, a tile roof and a warranty. Below that line, Unit 3 is the less expensive way into the same location, and we position it that way.

For Unit 1 the comparison is closer than the 12-month figures suggest. The Unit 1 median of $550,000 equals 121 percent of the Prestige base and 97 percent of the Mystique Grande base (our arithmetic), and over 24 months the Shores first-sale median per foot sat only 2.3 percent above Unit 1's (n=12) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Against all older-plat resales the Shores premium was 31.3 percent over 12 months, 20.0 percent over 24 and 13.0 percent over 36: much of the 12-month gap is the 2025 to 2026 fall in older resale prices per foot, not a fixed new-home premium.

How do Pulte's quick move-in markdowns compare with recorded villa sales?

Pulte's quick move-in prices at Shores at Stillwater now sit below Pulte's own 2026 villa closings. Read November 18, 2026, an Ellenwood villa of 1,579 square feet asked $364,990, marked down from $405,880, while the county recorded four Phase 1B villa first sales of 1,574 square feet at $375,000 to $407,600 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater; Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Recorded Phase 1B villa first sales beside Pulte's current villa ask (county sales; Pulte read November 18, 2026, builder-stated).

Record Month Heated sq ft Price Per sq ft
County first sale, Phase 1B April 2026 1,574 $401,600 $255
County first sale, Phase 1B April 2026 1,574 $407,600 $259
County first sale, Phase 1B June 2026 1,574 $375,000 $238
County first sale, Phase 1B August 2026 1,574 $379,000 $241
Pulte Ellenwood quick move-in, asking November 2026 1,579 (Pulte) $364,990 (was $405,880) $231 (our arithmetic)

Sources: our cut of the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; Pulte Ellenwood quick move-in. The county figure is the deed price; Pulte's is an asking price.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; Pulte pages read November 18, 2026, builder-stated and subject to change).

Together the two sources say what neither says alone. Pulte's villa ask is $10,010 below the lowest recorded villa first sale and $25,310 below the Phase 1B median of $390,300, and its "was" price of $405,880 sits between the two April closings (our arithmetic; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A seller who prices from the April deeds is pricing from a sheet the builder no longer uses.

The single-family quick move-in tells the same story. Pulte's 1,686 square foot Prosperity asked $444,990, down from $518,780 ("$73,790 in Savings"), a 14.2 percent markdown at $264 per square foot (our arithmetic), almost exactly the $267 Shores first-sale median (Pulte Prosperity quick move-in; Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Deed prices also hide part of a builder's deal. Freddie Mac notes that "the appraiser typically doesn't have access to the sales contract for the comparable sales" (Freddie Mac concessions guide), so a Shores first sale may have carried a credit or buydown the deed never shows. We read Pulte's live sheet and offers on the day we value a Stillwater home.

How does Pulte's November offer compete with a Stillwater resale?

Pulte's November offer at Shores at Stillwater gives buyers a choice a Stillwater resale seller must answer. For agreements accepted November 2 to 30, 2026, Pulte offers a standard pool "valued at $69,500" on select to-be-built homes or a credit of up to $77,000, and the offer "cannot be combined" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater).

The fine print says Pulte will credit $77,000 "toward closing costs, rate buy down, design options, and quick move-ins as a reduction to the total purchase price of the home," that "Any unused credit is the property of the builder," and that the "Offer may affect the amount of loan for which a buyer may be eligible" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater).

The offer is large next to Stillwater prices: $77,000 equals 24.8 percent of the Colton's base (our arithmetic). Applied in full to the Prosperity quick move-in as a price reduction, it would leave $367,990, about $218 per square foot, against a 12-month older-plat resale median of $203 (our arithmetic; whether that home qualifies is not stated) (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater; Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Pulte's calculator rates were tied to a lock window that ended November 15, 2026, so we do not print them; the benchmark is the Freddie Mac 30-year average of 7.11 percent for the week of November 12, 2026 (Freddie Mac PMMS).

A resale seller cannot match the offer in kind. About 85 percent of PulteGroup's financed buyers used its own mortgage company in the third quarter of 2026 (PulteGroup third quarter 2026 results). A seller credit is capped instead: Fannie Mae limits interested party contributions to 3 percent above 90 percent loan-to-value, 6 percent from 75.01 to 90 percent and 9 percent at 75 percent or less, and deducts any excess from the price (Fannie Mae B3-4.1-02). On the Unit 3 median of $282,500 the 3 and 6 percent caps are $8,475 and $16,950; on the Unit 1 median of $550,000, $16,500 and $33,000 (our arithmetic).

Appraisers treat concessions one way only: "Positive adjustments for sales or financing concessions are not acceptable" (Fannie Mae B4-1.3-09). A Unit 1 resale with no credit is never adjusted up to match a Pulte sale that came with a buydown; the Pulte comparable is adjusted down. The seller's answer is a price set against Pulte's net, plus what Pulte cannot offer: an assumable FHA or VA loan where the seller has one, a move-in date with no construction wait, mature landscaping and, in the older plats, no CDD line.

What do PulteGroup's filings say about incentives and Southwest Florida?

PulteGroup's third-quarter 2026 filing tells Stillwater sellers that the builder next door expects to keep discounting. The Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 says "we expect our sales incentives to remain elevated," with incentives focused on "discounts, closing cost incentives, and mortgage interest rate buydowns" (PulteGroup Form 10-Q).

The same filing says "Demand conditions further weakened during the third quarter of 2026"; company-wide net new orders fell 6 percent, and gross margin was 24.8 percent against 26.2 percent a year earlier, which the filing ties primarily to "pricing actions, including elevated sales incentives" (PulteGroup Form 10-Q).

PulteGroup's Florida segment, third quarter 2026 (company-reported, all Florida divisions combined).

Measure Q3 2026 Q3 2025 Change
Closings (homes) 1,904 1,932 down 1 percent
Average selling price $579,000 $569,000 up 2 percent
Net new orders (homes) 1,823 1,721 up 6 percent
Cancellation rate 13 percent 16 percent lower
Unit backlog at September 30 3,097 2,694 up 15 percent

Source: PulteGroup Form 10-Q, quarter ended September 30, 2026.

Data updated: November 2026 (PulteGroup Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, and its earnings release dated October 22, 2026).

Florida ran better than the company as a whole, but not everywhere. Over nine months, Florida income before taxes "decreased 10% primarily due to lower revenues and closings in our Southwest Florida operations" (PulteGroup Form 10-Q). The filing does not say which division reports Shores at Stillwater, so we do not assume Englewood is inside that phrase. What it does show is a builder with rising Florida orders, a plan to keep incentives elevated and 107 Shores lots still coded vacant, whose sheet will stay in front of Stillwater buyers through 2027 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

How does other new construction near Stillwater affect value?

Stillwater resales also compete with new homes outside Shores. M/I Homes' Sandpiper Pointe page, read November 18, 2026, lists 85 single-family homes in Englewood 34223 "FROM THE LOW $400S," from 1,521 to 2,583 square feet, and markets "NO CDD FEES," all builder-stated and subject to change (M/I Homes, Sandpiper Pointe).

M/I's page also lists a "10-Year Transferable Structural Warranty" and a "low HOA" with no dollar figure, and its overview gives the top size as 2,559 square feet, so the page disagrees with itself (same source). Its size band overlaps the 2,181 and 2,204 square foot medians of Units 2 and 1 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), and its "NO CDD FEES" banner aims at the line a Shores buyer carries, which a Unit 1 or Unit 2 home, by the records we read, does not carry either.

New construction across south Sarasota County keeps adding choices, and buyers shop it by payment. For the full list of builders and communities nearby, see our guide to new construction in Englewood. If you are weighing a new build while you sell, call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or read our guide to buying a home in Englewood.

Other Englewood communities price against their own mix of builders, resales and district lines, and we have written each one up separately: our Coco Bay home valuation guide, our Boca Royale home valuation guide, our Beachwalk by Manasota Key home valuation guide, our Grove City home valuation guide and our Englewood East home valuation guide. If you own in more than one, or are moving between them, the method is the same: same-plat resales first, the builder's net price second.

What do the Beige Book and NAHB say about builder buydowns and resales?

Regional and national surveys say builders around Stillwater are leaning on price cuts and rate buydowns. The Atlanta Fed's October 14, 2026 Beige Book reports that "more homes in the District sold below asking price, especially in Florida," and that some builders expect rate buydowns to remain "a long-term competitive advantage over resales" (Federal Reserve Beige Book, Atlanta).

The report adds that "sellers offered discounts and incentives" and "many buyers had difficulty qualifying for a mortgage" (Federal Reserve Beige Book, Atlanta). The NAHB/Wells Fargo index for November 2026 found builder confidence "fell four points to 25," 46 percent of builders cut prices, "the highest share in the post-Covid period," the average cut "held at 6% for an eighth straight month," and 68 percent offered incentives (NAHB Housing Market Index).

Stillwater's older-plat record fits that backdrop, with one warning. Older-plat resales recorded $257 per heated foot in the first half of 2025 (n=11), $215 in the second half (n=6) and $200 in the first half of 2026 (n=15) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Half-year medians shift with the mix sold, and 2026 holds 10 Unit 3 resales against 5 in Unit 1 and 2 in Unit 2. We read a softer resale market meeting an active builder, on small groups, not a single cause. The practical step: price from same-plat resales, then test the number against Pulte's net price for the nearest plan.

Want your home priced against Pulte's live sheet? Request a Stillwater valuation that compares your home with today's Pulte plans, quick move-ins and offer. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How Do the Shores CDD and the HOAs Affect a Stillwater Home's Value?

Only Shores at Stillwater sits inside a community development district, so the CDD splits Stillwater's value math in two. Phase One debt runs to a maximum annual $1,382.68 on a 34-foot lot and $1,914.48 on a 52-foot lot, while the records indicate the older plats sit outside any district (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book).

Data updated: November 2026 (Shores at Stillwater CDD meeting books of April 20, June 15 and October 19, 2026, FY 2026/27 final budget and amended FY 2025/26 budget; Florida statutes and Fannie Mae Selling Guide read November 18, 2026; Freddie Mac PMMS for the week of November 12, 2026).

A community development district is a special taxing district that finances and maintains infrastructure. The Shores at Stillwater Community Development District "was established pursuant to F.S. Chapter 190," is governed by "a five-member Board of Supervisors elected by landowners," and its assessments have two parts, operations and maintenance, and "Debt service (annual principal & interest) on the capital improvement bonds" (Shores at Stillwater CDD). The district's methodology says Sarasota County's Ordinance No. 2025-032 was "enacted on February 10, 2026 and effective on February 11, 2026" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). The homeowners' associations are separate and bill separately. Both matter to a Stillwater in Englewood value for the same reason: a buyer's lender counts them in the monthly payment.

Which Stillwater homes pay the CDD?

Stillwater's CDD falls on Shores at Stillwater lots, and the district's records indicate the older plats sit outside it. The legal description begins at the southeast corner of Stillwater Unit Two and runs along Unit Two's east boundary to Medical Boulevard, so Unit 2 is the district's neighbor, not its member (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book).

The description reads "BEGIN at the South 1/4 corner of said Section 32, also being the Southeast corner of STILLWATER, UNIT TWO," then runs "along the East boundary of said STILLWATER, UNIT TWO" north "to a point on the South Right-of-Way of MEDICAL BOULEVARD" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book). The district's assessment tables use 79.83 acres (same source). The district is also absent from the Tax Collector's 2026 levy sheet (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage and assessments), so no 2026 tax bill in any Stillwater plat carries a CDD line. Owners in Units 1, 2 and 3 should still confirm on their own tax bill; the records indicate, but the bill is the proof.

For Shores owners the collection method is still in motion. The FY 2026/27 budget (October 1, 2026 to September 30, 2027) shows operations assessments "To Be Collected At Closings," with "Developer Funding For Expenditures That Exceed $276 O&M Rate," and notes "If District Were On The Assessment Roll ... O&M Rate Would Be $276 (255 Units)" (Shores at Stillwater CDD FY 2026/27 final budget). The supplemental assessment resolution adopted October 19, 2026 says the choice between the tax roll and a direct bill is made each year and "does not mean that such method will be used to collect Series 2026 Assessments in future years" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, October 19, 2026 meeting book). The district's FAQ says the assessment "will appear on the property tax bill sent in November of each year" once it is on the roll (Shores at Stillwater CDD FAQs). A Shores seller should bring the closing statement that shows what was collected at closing, so a buyer sees the real figure.

How large are the Shores bonds and the per-lot debt?

Shores at Stillwater's Phase One bonds are $2,970,000 of Series 2026 special assessment bonds with final maturity in May 2056, assigned to 136 platted lots. The district's methodology sets original principal at $18,580.37 per 34-foot lot and $25,726.66 per 52-foot lot (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book).

Shores at Stillwater CDD, Phase One per-lot figures (district documents; combined and monthly figures are our arithmetic).

Lot width Phase One lots Original principal per lot Maximum annual debt assessment O&M per unit if on the roll, FY 2026/27 Combined annual maximum Monthly equivalent
34-foot 74 $18,580.37 $1,382.68 $276 $1,658.68 $138.22
52-foot 62 $25,726.66 $1,914.48 $276 $2,190.48 $182.54

Sources: Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book (Tables D and F; maximum figures are "Grossed up to include 1% collection fee of the County Tax Collector, 1% service fee of the County Property Appraiser" and an early-payment discount); Shores at Stillwater CDD FY 2026/27 final budget. If the district bills directly, the methodology notes the collection costs and discounts "may not apply." Your closing papers state which lot width you own.

Data updated: November 2026 (district documents dated April 20, May 28, June 15 and October 19, 2026; FY 2026/27 budget; amended FY 2025/26 budget dated October 9, 2026).

The bond terms are fixed and long. The district's amended FY 2025/26 budget lists "Original Par Amount = $2,970,000," "Interest Rate = 4.10% ... 5.8%" and "Maturity Date = May 2056" (Shores at Stillwater CDD amended FY 2025/26 budget), and the bond sale was reported as $2,970,000 of "Special Assessment Bonds, Series 2026 (Phase One Project)" dated June 17, 2026 and due "May 1, 2027 to 2056" (The Bond Buyer, May 29, 2026). A Sarasota County circuit court validated the district's ability to issue up to $14,000,000 for all phases on April 13, 2026, and the master allocation covers 255 units (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book; Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book). Those are legal ceilings for later phases, not charges on any Phase One home.

The lien is as strong as a tax lien. The Series 2026 assessments "shall be and shall remain a legal, valid and binding first lien on such parcels until paid," coequal with state and county taxes, and "All assessments levied run with the land" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). An owner "may prepay the entire remaining balance of the Special Assessments at any time" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 meeting book), and the amended budget records $25,727 of bond prepayments in FY 2025/26 (Shores at Stillwater CDD amended FY 2025/26 budget). A Shores home with its debt share paid off carries only the operations line going forward, which an appraiser and a buyer should treat differently from the same home with three decades of installments ahead. The district manager quotes a payoff for a specific lot; the district says "Interested persons are encouraged to contact the District Manager for information regarding special assessments on a particular lot or parcel" (June 15, 2026 meeting book).

How do appraisers treat the Shores CDD assessment?

Fannie Mae's appraisal rule for special districts reads as if written for Stillwater, where a CDD home sits beside homes with none. Guide section B4-1.4-09 says district properties "often compete against properties that are either subject to a significantly different assessment or no assessment at all," and tells appraisers to analyze "similarly affected comparable sales" (Fannie Mae B4-1.4-09).

The rule starts with the lender. Fannie Mae "expects the lender to know if a property is located in one of these districts and to be aware of the effect that assessments levied by the district could have on property values and the marketability of the subject property," and its appraiser "must give special consideration to the valuation of properties located in these districts" (Fannie Mae B4-1.4-09). The appraiser must "report any special assessments that affect the property" and note any district "experiencing financial difficulty" (same source).

The same section explains why build-out matters. Districts "often base their financial plans and the amount of the assessment to be charged to each property owner on the expected number of properties," and "If, for any reason, development stops short," the district "may need to impose an additional assessment on the existing homeowners" (Fannie Mae B4-1.4-09). With 107 Shores lots still coded vacant on the October 2026 roll, a Shores buyer's appraiser will look at whether development is continuing (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The district's budget shows developer funding covering costs above the $276 rate in FY 2026/27 (Shores at Stillwater CDD FY 2026/27 final budget).

The hard part in Stillwater is the evidence. Shores has no recorded resales on the October 21, 2026 file: all 16 qualified Shores sales are first sales by Pulte (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). So no paired data yet shows how much buyers discount a CDD home against a no-CDD Unit 1 or Unit 2 home of similar size. Fannie Mae's new-subdivision rule adds that an appraisal in a new subdivision needs at least one settled sale from inside and one from outside it, and "must include discussion and analysis of sales concessions and upgrades" for each builder sale (Fannie Mae B4-1.3-08). A Unit 1 or Unit 2 resale is the natural outside comparable for a Shores single-family home, which is one more reason the two markets are priced against each other.

What is the Shores CDD worth in a buyer's borrowing power?

The Shores CDD line costs a Stillwater buyer borrowing power, and older-plat homes do not carry it. At the Freddie Mac 30-year rate of 7.11 percent with 20 percent down, the 52-foot line of about $182.54 a month displaces about $28,900 of price and the 34-foot line about $21,900, our estimate, not a district or lender figure (Freddie Mac PMMS).

Lenders count the line, which is why it becomes price. Fannie Mae's monthly housing expense for the subject property includes "special assessments" and "owners' association dues" (Fannie Mae B3-6-03). Under the inputs below, each $1 a month of carrying cost equals about $158 of price to a payment-limited buyer (our arithmetic).

The same $425,000 Stillwater home, with and without the Shores CDD (our estimate; every input shown).

Line Shores at Stillwater, 52-foot lot Older Stillwater plat, no CDD
Principal and interest (7.11 percent, 30 years, 20 percent down, loan $340,000) $2,287.20 $2,287.20
Property tax (11.3068 mills on price, first year, no homestead) $400.45 $400.45
Homeowners insurance ($2,901 a year, Citizens Sarasota County HO3 average) $241.75 $241.75
Englewood Area Fire Control District ($290.78 a year) $24.23 $24.23
CDD (debt maximum plus $276 O&M) $182.54 $0
HOA dues excluded, no primary source states dues excluded, no primary source states dues
Monthly total $3,136.17 $2,953.63

Sources: Freddie Mac PMMS (week of November 12, 2026); 2026 millage from the Sarasota County Tax Collector; Citizens 2026 approved rate changes by county; Englewood Area Fire Control District assessments; Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book. Solid waste and stormwater lines, flood insurance and HOA dues are not included.

Data updated: November 2026 (Freddie Mac PMMS for the week of November 12, 2026; 2026 Sarasota County millage; Citizens 2026 approved rates; Englewood Area Fire Control District FY 2026/27; Shores at Stillwater CDD documents).

The $182.54 difference is the structural reason a Shores price per foot has to be read net of the district when it is compared with a Unit 1 or Unit 2 resale (our estimate). It is not a discount on Shores homes: the district's bonds finance Shores infrastructure, including its stormwater ponds, and Shores buyers get a gated community with a heated pool and cabana, by Pulte's description (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). The table explains a competitive edge for the older plats, not a defect in the new one.

Shores sellers have a lever of their own. A prepaid debt share removes $1,914.48 or $1,382.68 a year from the line, restoring about $25,200 or $18,200 of buying power under the same inputs (our estimate). If you prepaid, it belongs on the first page of your listing file, with the district's confirmation. If you have not, prepaying before a sale is a decision to make with the district manager's quote in hand.

What do HOA dues and the estoppel certificate tell a Stillwater buyer?

HOA dues for Stillwater associations do not appear in any primary source we could read, so the estoppel certificate is where a buyer learns them. HOA dues for any Stillwater association: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). Florida's estoppel statute makes the association state the figure on request (Fla. Stat. 720.30851).

The statute sets the clock. "Within 10 business days after receiving a written or electronic request for an estoppel certificate from a parcel owner or the parcel owner's designee," the association must issue it, and each association must designate on its website where requests go (Fla. Stat. 720.30851). The state's current fee caps are "not more than $299" for preparation, an additional $119 for delivery within 3 business days, and up to $179 more if the parcel is delinquent (DBPR estoppel certificate fee caps). We ask for it at listing, not at contract, so dues and any special assessment are in the price discussion from day one.

Pulte does not fill the gap. Its pages say "Community Association fees required" and that payment estimates "do not include monthly homeowners' association dues," with no dollar figure (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). The CDD's June 2026 minutes add a detail that matters for Shores comparisons: maintenance items, "with the exception of engineering, would be included in an agreement with the HOA and are currently included in the HOA budget" (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). At Shores, part of the upkeep a buyer might expect on the CDD line rides on HOA dues instead.

Dues move price the same way the CDD does. Under the inputs above, each $100 a month of dues displaces about $15,800 of a payment-limited buyer's price (our estimate; Freddie Mac PMMS). Two Stillwater homes that differ only in their association's dues are not the same value to a financed buyer, and the estoppel is the only document that settles the number.

Which associations appear in Florida filings for Stillwater?

Three Stillwater associations appear in Florida corporate filings, as copied by directory sites that mirror state records: Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc., Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc. and Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc. Which one governs which older plat is not settled by any record we read, so confirm yours on Sunbiz and in your recorded declaration.

The names suggest the outline but do not prove it. A Unit 3 owner may answer to the Unit 3 association, and possibly to a broader one as well; if a parcel answers to more than one association, each issues its own estoppel and each sets its own dues. A Unit 1 or Unit 2 owner should check which association the recorded declaration names. Shores owners answer to the Shores association, alongside the separate CDD.

For value, the association matters through three papers: the estoppel (dues, assessments, approval for transfer), the declaration (what owners may change, such as fences, pools and hurricane protection), and the approvals file for improvements you have made. A pool cage, an impact window upgrade or a generator that the association approved in writing is easier to count in a valuation than one with no record. Bring those approvals, and we will read them with the county file before we set a number.

Want the CDD and HOA lines worked into your number? Request a Stillwater valuation that prices your district line, dues and estoppel. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How Do Flood Zones and Insurance Affect Stillwater Values?

Flood zone and insurance cost reach a Stillwater price through the buyer's monthly payment. Flood zone varies by lot, the only lot-level reading on record is Zone X at one Unit 1 address, and Citizens will require flood coverage on all of its wind policies, regardless of value, from January 1, 2027 (Citizens flood requirement).

Data updated: November 2026 (Citizens flood page and 2026 county rate filing; Florida Office of Insurance Regulation market overview, data as of October 2026; FEMA Risk Rating page updated April 9, 2026; Congressional Research Service IN10835 updated September 11, 2026; Florida statutes and National Hurricane Center reports read November 18, 2026).

Stillwater, Englewood, Florida sits inland on Medical Boulevard, about 1.1 to 1.6 miles from Lemon Bay in a straight line (Census TIGER/Line 2024 area water, Sarasota County), but inland is not a flood determination. A lender and an insurer look at the lot's FEMA zone, the elevation certificate if there is one, the flood claim history and the policy terms. The Federal Reserve's 2026 study of 465,000 Florida home sales found that "Expected weather losses show the strongest association with prices," while "Insurance premiums have a statistically significant but economically more modest negative effect on home prices" (Federal Reserve, Premiums or Peril). For a Stillwater valuation that means the lot's own flood file and the home's own insurance papers count more than Englewood's storm headlines.

Why does flood zone vary by lot in Stillwater?

Flood zones in Stillwater are read lot by lot from FEMA's maps, so the zone belongs to the lot. Our team's November 14, 2026 check of FEMA's flood layer returned Zone X at one Stillwater Unit 1 address; we hold no reading for Unit 2, Unit 3 or either Shores phase (our Stillwater neighborhood guide).

That single reading is a starting point, not a rule. Two lots on the same Stillwater street can sit at different ground elevations, and the internal lakes in the older plats and the wet detention ponds at Shores sit at the low points by design. The Shores at Stillwater CDD describes its ponds as providing "100-year flood control," a design standard for the stormwater system rather than a FEMA zone for any lot (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 meeting book). The zone on your lot is a fact you look up, not one you infer.

Look it up on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center by address, and find your elevation certificate if one was issued. Sarasota County takes part in the National Flood Insurance Program's Community Rating System at Class 5, which FEMA's October 1, 2026 list ties to a 25 percent discount on eligible NFIP policies (FEMA Community Rating System list, October 2026). Under the federal program's current pricing, "the NFIP's pricing approach does not use flood zones to determine flood risk"; it rates each home on factors such as "elevation and the cost to rebuild," and "most rates" may not rise "more than 18% per year" (FEMA Risk Rating 2.0). FEMA adds that "Policyholders are able to transfer their discount to a new owner by assigning their flood insurance policy" (same source). A Stillwater owner who has carried a flood policy for years should find the declarations page before listing: an assignable policy is part of what a buyer is paying for.

What does Citizens' flood requirement mean for a Stillwater buyer?

Citizens' flood rule already reaches larger Stillwater homes and reaches every Citizens wind policy on January 1, 2027. Policies with a dwelling value of $400,000 or more have needed flood coverage since January 1, 2026, and from 2027 the rule covers "All policies, regardless of value," inside or outside the high-risk zone (Citizens flood requirement).

The steps came one year at a time: $600,000 of dwelling value from January 1, 2024, $500,000 from January 1, 2025, $400,000 from January 1, 2026, and all policies from January 1, 2027 (Citizens flood requirement). The exemptions are "Condominium unit-owner policies, tenant content policies, and policies that exclude windstorm or hail coverage," and the flood limit must equal the dwelling coverage or the federal program's maximum, $250,000 of building coverage under the regular program (same source). Dwelling value here means the cost to rebuild, not the sale price, so a larger Unit 1 or Unit 2 home may already be past the 2026 step while a Unit 3 home reaches the rule only in 2027. Whether any Stillwater home qualifies for the condominium exemption depends on its recorded form of ownership, which the declaration and title show.

For value, the rule adds a line to some buyers' payments and not others. A buyer with a private carrier on a Zone X lot may face no flood requirement; a Citizens buyer will. Under our inputs, each $500 a year of flood premium is about $41.67 a month and displaces about $6,600 of price for a payment-limited buyer (our estimate; Freddie Mac PMMS). Insurance and flood quotes for a specific Stillwater home: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). We ask buyers' agents for real quotes early, because a quote that arrives late arrives as a renegotiation.

What does the NFIP authorization date mean for a Stillwater sale?

A Stillwater closing that needs a new federal flood policy after December 11, 2026 could stall if Congress lets the program lapse. The Congressional Research Service says "The NFIP is currently authorized until December 11, 2026," and that during a lapse the "authority to provide new flood insurance contracts will expire" (Congressional Research Service IN10835).

Policies already in force run to the end of their term during a lapse, and the program's borrowing authority drops from $30.425 billion to $1 billion (Congressional Research Service IN10835). CRS warns that "Without available flood insurance, real estate transactions in an SFHA potentially could be significantly hampered," and that in the June 2010 lapse "over 1,400 home sale closings were canceled or delayed each day" (same source). Insurance Journal reported on October 7, 2026 that "there have been 36 short-term extensions of the NFIP since the end of fiscal year 2017," and that during the November 2025 shutdown "No new federal flood insurance policies were sold or renewed during the timeframe" (Insurance Journal, October 7, 2026). We found no further extension enacted as of November 18, 2026.

For a Stillwater sale the exposure is narrow but real. A Zone X lot with a private wind carrier may need no flood policy at all. A Citizens buyer from January 1, 2027, or any lot in a high-risk zone, needs one, and a lapse would leave three paths: the buyer takes an assignment of your existing NFIP policy, uses a private flood carrier, or waits. If your home carries an NFIP policy, keep it in force through closing and tell us its term; in a lapse, it is a closing tool.

What must a Stillwater seller disclose about flooding under s. 689.302?

Florida's s. 689.302 requires a Stillwater seller to hand the buyer a flood disclosure at or before signing the sales contract. The form asks whether the seller knows of flood damage during ownership, filed a flood insurance claim, including with the NFIP, or received flood assistance, including from FEMA (Fla. Stat. 689.302).

The statute's definition is broader than a river over its banks. "Flooding" includes "The overflow of inland or tidal waters," "The unusual and rapid accumulation of runoff or surface waters from any established water source," and "Sustained periods of standing water resulting from rainfall" (Fla. Stat. 689.302). For a Stillwater home on one of the internal lakes or near a Shores pond, a lake that rose into a lanai during a storm is the kind of event the form asks about. Answer from what happened, not from the zone on the map.

The disclosure covers only your ownership, and that differs sharply across Stillwater. A Unit 1 owner since the mid-2000s answers for Ian in 2022 and Helene and Milton in 2024; a Shores first owner answers only from 2025 or 2026. A clean disclosure is a document that supports value. A "yes" will show up in the buyer's insurance quote and inspection anyway, and it costs less handled at pricing than at renegotiation. The general disclosure duty under Johnson v. Davis, covered in the value-drivers section above, still applies alongside the flood form.

How do insurance premiums shape what a buyer pays for a Stillwater home?

Insurance premiums change what a buyer can pay for a Stillwater home, and 2026 averages fell. Citizens' approved 2026 rates put the Sarasota County HO3 homeowners average at $2,901, down from $3,134, while the state's admitted-market average including wind was $3,736 on October 2026 data (Citizens 2026 approved rate changes by county; Florida Office of Insurance Regulation).

Homeowners premium benchmarks a Stillwater buyer may see (averages and builder estimates, not quotes for any home).

Measure Policies Before After or current
Citizens, Sarasota County, multiperil HO3 9,090 $3,134 $2,901 approved (down 7.4 percent)
Citizens, Sarasota County, wind-only HW2 4,987 $2,246 $2,132 approved (down 5.1 percent)
Citizens, Sarasota County, all personal lines 24,104 $2,614 $2,470 approved (down 5.5 percent)
Florida admitted market, average including wind statewide not applicable $3,736 (data as of October 2026)
Florida admitted market, average excluding wind statewide not applicable $2,124 (data as of October 2026)
Pulte's calculator assumption, $309,990 Colton builder estimate not applicable $1,209.00 a year
Pulte's calculator assumption, $444,990 Prosperity builder estimate not applicable $1,735.44 a year

Sources: Citizens 2026 approved rate changes by county; Florida Office of Insurance Regulation market overview; Pulte, Shores at Stillwater (calculator fields, builder-stated estimates, read November 18, 2026).

Data updated: November 2026 (Citizens 2026 approved rates by county; OIR market overview, data as of October 2026; Pulte calculator read November 18, 2026).

The gap between Pulte's estimate and the county average is the insurance story of Stillwater in one line. Pulte assumes about 0.39 percent of price for a new impact-glass, tile-roof home (our arithmetic on Pulte's $1,735.44 at $444,990), well under the $2,901 Citizens Sarasota HO3 average (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). PulteGroup's own executive told Sarasota Magazine that buyers choose new for "lower insurance costs and warranties" (Sarasota Magazine, November 2024). An older-plat seller answers with documents: a roof permit, a current wind mitigation form, a four-point report and, where it applies, an assignable flood policy. Each $1,000 a year those papers save a buyer supports about $13,200 of price at 7.11 percent (our estimate; Freddie Mac PMMS).

The market is moving in sellers' favor. OIR reports that it has "approved twenty-one additional property & casualty insurers to enter Florida's market," and its 30-day average homeowners rate request was a 2.3 percent decrease (Florida Office of Insurance Regulation market overview). Commissioner Mike Yaworsky said in September 2026, "I expect to see more aggressive rate cuts in the near future and going into 2027" (Florida Realtors, September 24, 2026). Lower premiums raise what a financed buyer can pay for an older Stillwater home, but only when the home's papers let the buyer's carrier write it at the going rate.

What did Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton mean for Stillwater values?

No public report we found names Stillwater or Shores at Stillwater as damaged in Hurricanes Ian, Helene or Milton, so storm history reaches Stillwater values through insurance and disclosure rather than a measured discount. The National Hurricane Center's reports place all three storms' surge forecasts or effects along the Englewood coast (National Hurricane Center, Hurricane Ian report).

Each storm touched Englewood differently. For Ian, on September 28, 2022, the Hurricane Center records that "The Storm Surge Warning did not verify north of Englewood due to a southward shift in the track of Ian" (National Hurricane Center, Hurricane Ian report). Helene passed offshore in September 2024, and its "Maximum storm surge inundation of 3 to 5 ft AGL occurred from south of Englewood to Bonita Beach including Charlotte Harbor" (National Hurricane Center, Hurricane Helene report). Milton made landfall "on Siesta Key, Florida, at 0030 UTC 10 October" 2024 and "caused hurricane conditions along the west coast from Clearwater Beach and Tampa southward across Sarasota to near Venice" (National Hurricane Center, Hurricane Milton report). Sarasota County's early Milton estimate for the unincorporated county counted 103 structures destroyed, 878 with major damage and 2,436 with minor damage, without naming Englewood neighborhoods (Business Observer, October 18, 2024).

The price research points to documents, not headlines. The Federal Reserve study found that "Recent hurricane exposure has only a marginal effect on house prices" (Federal Reserve, Premiums or Peril). What carries a storm into a Stillwater price is narrower: a roof replaced after 2022 or 2024 (a plus, if permitted), a claim on the insurance record, an answer on the s. 689.302 form, and a buyer's insurer reading all three. If your home had storm work done, bring the permits, the adjuster's report and the contractor's invoice, and we will put them in front of buyers before they ask.

For values in Englewood communities with different flood files and housing ages, see our Englewood home valuation guide; for the selling steps across town, our Englewood seller guide; and for the town itself, our Englewood guide.

Want your flood and insurance papers read before a buyer reads them? Request a Stillwater valuation with your flood zone, roof permit and wind mitigation form reviewed. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How Do We Value a Stillwater Home?

We value a Stillwater home by starting with recorded resales from its own plat, Unit 1, Unit 2 or Unit 3, matched on heated size, bedrooms, build year and roof and system age. Pulte's first sales at Shores at Stillwater come second, tested for incentives, and every older sale gets a supported time adjustment.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales of improved homes over $1,000; 12-month window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026; 24 months from October 15, 2024; 36 months from October 15, 2023; Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, HUD and VA guidance as dated below; our tabulation).

Stillwater in Englewood is really two valuation problems sharing one entrance off Medical Boulevard. The 251 homes in the three older plats were built from 2000 to 2016 and have more than a decade of owner-to-owner resales behind them, while the 27 finished Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater, with 107 more lots still coded vacant on the October roll, have only builder first sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Of the 35 qualified home sales in the latest 12 months, 19 were older-plat resales and 16 were Shores first sales, and not one Shores home has resold yet. Our method keeps those two record sets apart from the first step, and every per-square-foot figure here uses the county's heated (living) area, never a listing sheet's measure. For the place itself, our Stillwater neighborhood guide covers plats, streets and location.

What are the steps in our Stillwater CMA?

Our comparative market analysis for a Stillwater home follows eight steps: keep the plat, match heated size and bedrooms, read the build year and code era, rate roof and system age, weight resales over Pulte's first sales, strip out builder concessions, adjust older sales for time, and show you a range with every sale behind it.

Step 1: keep the plat. Unit 1 and Unit 2 are coded 0100 on the roll, with medians of 2,204 and 2,181 heated square feet, while all 140 Unit 3 homes carry use code 0101 at a median of 1,349 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Over the latest 12 months, 10 Unit 3 resales recorded a $282,500 median and 7 Unit 1 resales a $550,000 median, so a Unit 3 sale is never a comparable for a Unit 1 home or the reverse. Unit 2 had only 2 sales in that window, at $550,000 and $620,000, which is why a Unit 2 valuation leans on the 24-month record and on Unit 1 sales of the same size.

Step 2: match heated size and bedrooms. Unit 3 holds 82 two-bedroom and 58 three-bedroom homes, the middle half between 1,349 and 1,525 heated square feet; over 24 months two-bedroom resales recorded a $316,250 median on 12 sales and three-bedroom resales $300,000 on 9, a small group, so we read no bedroom premium into the gap (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). In Unit 1, 67 of 76 homes have three bedrooms, so the size band carries the adjustment. The table shows how thin each pool is before any further filter.

How many recorded comparables each Stillwater home type has

Subject home 12 months 24 months 36 months
Unit 1, any size 7, a small group 12 13
Unit 1, three bedrooms 6, a small group 10 11
Unit 2, any size 2, too few for a median 6, a small group 8, a small group
Unit 3, any size 10 21 26
Unit 3, two bedrooms 6, a small group 12 15
Unit 3, three bedrooms 4, a small group 9, a small group 11
Shores at Stillwater, Pulte first sales 16 16 16
Shores at Stillwater, resales 0 0 0

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales of improved homes, our tabulation.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; windows ending October 14, 2026).

Step 3: read the build year and code era. The first statewide Florida Building Code took effect March 1, 2002 (Florida Building Commission), and ten Unit 1 homes are coded as built in 2000 or 2001 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Build year moves value mainly through the buyer's insurance quote, so we note the era and ask for the wind mitigation form rather than adjusting by year alone.

Step 4: rate roof, systems and condition. An original shingle roof on a 2000 to 2006 home is past the 15-year line in Florida's roof statute; past that line, an insurer may not refuse coverage solely for roof age if an inspection shows 5 years or more of useful life remaining (Florida Statutes s. 627.7011). We rate each comparable for roof, air conditioning, water heater, kitchen and baths, the gap between a C3 and a C4 home on a lender's appraisal.

Step 5: give resales more weight than Pulte's first sales. A resale shows what a buyer paid an owner with Pulte's homes for sale next door; a Shores first sale shows what Pulte accepted, minus anything the deed hides. The Shores per-foot median sat 31.3 percent above older-plat resales over 12 months, 20.0 percent over 24 and 13.0 percent over 36, and only 2.3 percent above Unit 1 over 24 months (n=12) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Much of the 12-month gap is the recent fall in older resale prices, so Shores sales are a ceiling check, not a level.

Step 6: test every builder sale for concessions. On November 18, 2026, Pulte's Shores page showed two quick move-in homes marked down, one to $444,990 from $518,780 and an Ellenwood villa to $364,990 from $405,880, and an offer for contracts accepted November 2 to 30, 2026 of a pool valued at $69,500 or a credit of up to $77,000 (builder-stated, read November 18, 2026, subject to change) (Pulte). The county recorded four Phase 1B villa first sales at 1,574 heated square feet, at $375,000, $379,000, $401,600 and $407,600 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), so Pulte's Ellenwood ask today sits below every recorded villa first sale.

The lender rules let a concession adjustment run one way only: a comparable that carried a seller-paid concession is adjusted for its effect on price, and an upward adjustment for a concession is never allowed (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09). Freddie Mac asks appraisers a plain question, "How much would the comparable have sold for without the concessions?", and warns that the appraiser "typically doesn't have access to the sales contract for the comparable sales" (Freddie Mac). So a Shores first sale that came with a Pulte credit may be adjusted down for the market's reaction to that credit before it is compared with your home, never up, and finding out which buyers took a credit is part of our job.

Step 7: adjust older sales for time. The older-plat median per heated square foot was $257 in the first half of 2025 (n=11), $215 in the second half (n=6, a small group) and $200 in the first half of 2026 (n=15) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Those medians shift with the plat mix, so we read the direction, not a rate. Fannie Mae wants evidence behind any time adjustment, or behind skipping one, and accepts price indices and paired sales (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09); the best Stillwater pairs are the same homes selling twice, covered at the end of this part.

Step 8: give you a range, with the sales behind it. You get a low, middle and high figure, the specific recorded sales behind each one, the adjustment we made to each, and the Pulte homes a buyer will tour the same week.

What separates a CMA, a broker price opinion and an appraisal on a Stillwater home in Florida?

Florida law treats a Stillwater CMA and a broker price opinion as lawful pricing work any licensed agent may do, on one condition: neither can be labeled an appraisal. A written appraisal report, the document a lender, court or estate asks for, comes only from a licensed or certified appraiser regulated under Part II of Chapter 475.

Chapter 475 of the Florida Statutes draws the line in two places. Section 475.25(1)(t) keeps a broker or sales associate who prepares a comparative market analysis, a broker price opinion or an opinion of value outside the appraisal-standards discipline ground, as long as that work is never "referred to as an appraisal" (Florida Statutes s. 475.25). Section 475.612 reserves the appraisal report, and direct payment for it, to certified or licensed appraisers, while letting a licensed agent charge for valuation work "so long as they do not represent themselves as certified, licensed, or registered under this part" (Florida Statutes s. 475.612).

So an estate, divorce or court matter needs a report from a Florida certified residential or licensed appraiser, a buyer's lender orders its own, and a list price needs a CMA that reads Pulte's current sheet. One Stillwater wrinkle: a bank keeping a loan in its own portfolio may use a lighter "evaluation," defined in section 475.611, at or below the federal $400,000 residential threshold (Federal Register; s. 475.611), and the Unit 3 median of $282,500 sits under that line while the Unit 1 median of $550,000 sits above it (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

What will a lender's appraiser do with a Stillwater home?

A lender's appraiser treats Stillwater's two halves under different rules. Shores at Stillwater counts as a new subdivision, so the report needs comparables inside and outside it plus a concession analysis. Units 1, 2 and 3 are established plats, where Fannie Mae calls sales inside the neighborhood "the best indicator of value."

The new-subdivision test. Fannie Mae says "a subdivision is considered new when there are limited or no resales or the builder or developer is involved in the marketing or sale of the properties" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08). Shores at Stillwater meets that test today: Pulte is still selling, and the county shows 16 first sales and no resales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A Shores appraisal therefore needs a settled sale from inside Shores and one from outside, with a written concession and upgrade analysis on every builder sale; the older Stillwater plats, recorded as separate subdivisions, are the natural outside comparables.

The established-plat rule. A Unit 1, 2 or 3 resale needs at least three closed comparables, normally from the past 12 months, and an older sale may be used with a supported time adjustment (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08). Listings and contract offerings can only support the closed sales, so Pulte's posted prices at Shores can inform a Stillwater resale appraisal but never stand in for one of the three. A home that sold before, as most long-held Stillwater homes have, may also appear as a fourth comparable or as supporting data.

Condition and quality ratings. Fannie Mae's C1 rating means improvements that "have been very recently constructed and have not previously been occupied"; C3 homes are "well-maintained" with some components updated; C4 homes have "some minor deferred maintenance" and need "only minimal repairs" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-06). A never-occupied Shores home is C1; a 2004 Unit 1 home with its original roof, air handler and kitchen leans toward C4, and the same home with a newer roof and systems can rate C3.

The redesigned appraisal form. UAD 3.6 became mandatory for new reports submitted on or after November 2, 2026 (Freddie Mac UAD FAQ). New construction is marked "Fully Updated" so it reads as C1, and the grid gives a lanai or patio and an inground pool their own rows (GSE UAD 3.6 job aid). A Unit 2 home with original 2006 kitchens and baths will show "Not Updated" rows beside a "Fully Updated" Shores comparable, putting the condition gap in front of the underwriter line by line. Only Shores sits in a CDD, so every Shores to Unit 1 or Unit 2 comparison also raises Fannie Mae's special-assessment rule, which the CDD section of this page covers (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.4-09).

Can a Stillwater buyer's loan close without an appraisal?

Sometimes. Fannie Mae's automated underwriting may offer value acceptance, with no appraisal, on an eligible Stillwater resale under $1,000,000, which covers every Stillwater sale in the 36-month county record. A brand-new Pulte home at Shores qualifies only when an "as is" appraisal already exists, so plan for a full appraisal either way (Fannie Mae).

Fannie Mae's Desktop Underwriter decides case by case; the topic excludes proposed construction, construction-to-permanent loans, prices at or above $1,000,000 and sales where the seller gifts part of the home's value to the buyer (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.4-10). The Appraisal Institute put the combined Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac waiver share at 28 percent for March 2026, with about half of no-cash-out refinances using waivers (Appraisal Institute, August 4, 2026). No seller can ask for a waiver, so price your Stillwater home on the assumption that an appraiser will walk through it.

How do FHA and VA appraisals treat a Stillwater home?

FHA and VA appraisers follow their own rule books on a Stillwater home. FHA prefers arm's length resales inside an established plat, treats a Shores home occupied less than a year as existing, and caps seller help at 6 percent. VA's Tidewater step gives the parties two business days to send better sales (HUD; VA).

FHA. In the HUD Handbook 4000.1 version we read (pages marked "Last Revised: 08/14/2019"; lenders apply the current Handbook and later mortgagee letters), resales inside an established plat are named as often the best evidence of value, and an occupied home less than a year past its certificate of occupancy is treated as an existing property (HUD Handbook 4000.1). When the past six months hold too few comparables, the appraiser must use at least three sales from the past 12; with 2 older-plat resales in the third quarter of 2026 and none so far in the fourth (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), an FHA appraiser this winter will likely reach back the full year. Seller help is capped at 6 percent of the price, $16,950 on the Unit 3 median of $282,500 (our arithmetic), and anything above is "an inducement to purchase."

Conventional seller credits. For a principal residence or second home, Fannie Mae limits seller and other interested-party help to 3 percent when the loan is above 90 percent of value, 6 percent between 75.01 and 90 percent, and 9 percent at 75 percent or below; any excess comes off the sales price used for the loan (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02). At the Unit 3 median of $282,500 those caps are $8,475, $16,950 and $25,425 (our arithmetic), so a seller trying to match a $77,000 Pulte credit in cash hits the cap long before the figures meet.

VA. When a VA appraiser expects to come in under the contract price, the Tidewater notice opens a 2 business day window for the parties to send more sales; if the Notice of Value still disappoints, VA staff review a reconsideration request within 5 business days (VA appraisal policies bulletin, December 16, 2021).

Which documents should you gather before we value your Stillwater home?

Your paperwork fills the gaps in the Stillwater county record: the dates your roof, air conditioning and water heater were replaced, what you updated inside, a current wind mitigation form, any flood papers and your latest tax bill. Shores owners should add the Pulte contract, the closing statement and any CDD payoff letter.

The Stillwater valuation checklist

Item Why it moves the number
Roof permit and invoice, with the roof material A roof under 15 years old cannot be refused coverage solely for age (s. 627.7011); the permit proves the roof's age to the buyer's insurer
Uniform mitigation verification form (OIR-B1-1802) "A completed form is valid for five years provided no material changes are made to the structure" (Florida CFO guide); it can lower a buyer's windstorm premium
Air conditioning, water heater, kitchen, bath and window dates They drive the four-point inspection, the UAD 3.6 update rows and the condition rating
Pool, screen enclosure or lanai work, with permits Not in the county's heated area or your earlier recorded price
Any elevation certificate or flood policy declarations Zones vary by lot in Stillwater; an assignable policy can travel to the buyer
Your latest tax bill Shows your exemptions and the flat lines a buyer will see
HOA estoppel or statement States dues and their billing period; HOA dues for Stillwater associations: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026).
Shores owners: Pulte purchase agreement, closing statement and any CDD payoff letter Shows the credit or rate program behind your recorded price and whether the CDD debt was prepaid
Your mortgage type and rate, if FHA or VA A below-market note a buyer can take over changes what that buyer can pay (carrying-cost section below)

A partial folder is fine. Start with the roof permit and the wind mitigation form, since those two most often change a Stillwater buyer's insurance quote, and we will flag anything else worth chasing. Get your free Stillwater home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. For listing strategy, preparation and timing, see our Stillwater seller guide; for the Florida costs taken out of a sale price, see our seller closing costs page.

How Do Just Value, Save Our Homes and the Tax Roll Relate to Your Stillwater Home's Value?

The just value on a Stillwater TRIM notice is the Sarasota County Property Appraiser's mass-appraisal estimate of market value as of January 1, built from sales that closed before that date. It is a tax figure, set months before you read it, and it is not the price a buyer will pay this year.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser appraisal, exemption and TRIM pages and 2026 TRIM supplement; Sarasota County Tax Collector 2026 and 2025 millage sheets; Englewood Area Fire Control District 2026 to 2027 assessments; Florida Division of Elections Election Watch, read November 18, 2026; our arithmetic).

What is the difference between just, assessed and taxable value on a Stillwater home?

A Stillwater TRIM notice prints three numbers that are easy to confuse. The Property Appraiser sets just value, its January 1 market estimate. Caps under Save Our Homes or the 10 percent non-homestead rule turn that into assessed value, and exemptions such as homestead reduce it to the taxable value the millage applies to (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

The office describes just value as "the only value determined by the Property Appraiser," and defines it, citing 12D-1.002(5) of the Florida Administrative Code, as the price a property would bring in the open market, with a reasonable time to find a buyer, between parties who both know the uses of the property and neither of whom is under pressure (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Appraisal Process). Its FAQ adds that the Florida Supreme Court treats just value as legally the same as "full cash value" and "fair market value" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser FAQ). The 2026 TRIM supplement says the office's appraisers "analyze market sales, construction costs, and for income-producing properties market-based income data," and sums up the philosophy in one line: "We do not create value; buyers create value by their transactions in the marketplace" (2026 TRIM supplement).

Florida law lists eight factors the appraiser must weigh, among them location, size, replacement cost, condition and, last, the seller's net proceeds after "the usual and reasonable fees and costs of the sale," with an "allowance for unconventional or atypical terms of financing arrangements" (Florida Statutes s. 193.011). That last phrase is the tax-roll cousin of the concession rule above: a Pulte first sale with a closing-cost credit or a forward-commitment rate is the kind of atypical financing it reaches (our reading). After a purchase, the office mails the buyer a sales questionnaire to judge "whether the sale price was representative of market value" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), which is one way a sale is sorted into or out of the qualified sales that every figure on this page uses.

Four Stillwater value figures and what each one is for

Figure Who sets it Date it speaks to Used for
Just value on the TRIM notice Sarasota County Property Appraiser, by mass appraisal January 1 of the tax year Property taxes only
Recorded sale price Buyer and seller Closing date The county sales file and every comparable
Lender appraisal A Florida licensed or certified appraiser The effective date of the report The buyer's loan
Our CMA McGreevy and Comisar The week you ask Setting a list price against current sales and Pulte's sheet

For Stillwater in Englewood, we do not print a just-value-to-price ratio on this page. Your own record card is the one to read, and it is a sanity check on a price, never the source of one. If the number on your notice looks far from what you think the home would bring, request a free Stillwater home valuation and we will show you the recorded sales that explain the gap.

Why does the January 1 date matter so much for Stillwater values in 2026?

Stillwater's 2026 just values were set on January 1, 2026 from sales through that date, so they mostly predate the 2026 drop in older-plat resale prices per square foot. A Pulte home at Shores finished after January 1 sits on the 2026 roll as land only, so its first bill misleads a buyer (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

The office explains its calendar plainly: for the current tax year, "comparable properties having sold through January 1 of the current tax year are considered," and "Properties selling after January 1 of the current tax year are included in the analysis for next year's valuations" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser FAQ). The older-plat median per heated square foot was $215 in the second half of 2025 (n=6, a small group) and $200 in the first half of 2026 (n=15) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The 2026 sales feed the January 1, 2027 roll, so the TRIM notice a Stillwater owner opens in August 2027 is the first one that can reflect them.

For Shores at Stillwater, the date works the other way. State law says "Improvements or portions not substantially completed on January 1 shall have no value placed thereon" (Florida Statutes s. 192.042), and the county reminds new owners that "There are no partial assessments in Florida" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The October 2026 parcel file shows 27 finished Shores homes, 8 built in 2025 and 19 in 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A 2026-built home that was not substantially complete on January 1, 2026 is taxed as a lot this year, and its house value first appears on January 1, 2027. A buyer who budgets from that lot-only bill will see a much larger notice the next August, which is why our payment examples below use the buyer's own numbers.

How does Save Our Homes shape a Stillwater owner's bill, and what does a buyer inherit?

Save Our Homes holds a Stillwater homestead's assessed value increase to 2.7 percent for 2026, so long-held Unit 1, 2 and 3 homesteads can carry assessed values well under just value. None of that passes to a buyer: the assessed value resets to just value on the January 1 after the sale (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

The cap is the lower of 3 percent or the change in the Consumer Price Index for the prior year (Florida Statutes s. 193.155). Here is how it has run in the years that matter for Stillwater owners.

Save Our Homes annual cap, Sarasota County

Tax year CPI change Cap applied
2018 2.1 percent 2.1 percent
2019 1.9 percent 1.9 percent
2020 2.3 percent 2.3 percent
2021 1.4 percent 1.4 percent
2022 7.0 percent 3.0 percent
2023 6.5 percent 3.0 percent
2024 3.4 percent 3.0 percent
2025 2.9 percent 2.9 percent
2026 2.7 percent 2.7 percent

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Save Our Homes and portability.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser cap table, read November 18, 2026).

Compounded, the caps from 2021 through 2026 allow about a 17.1 percent rise in assessed value for a homestead held since before 2021 (our arithmetic from the table). Over a similar span, the older-plat calendar-year median per heated square foot went from $191 in 2021 (n=13) to $282 in 2023 (n=10) before settling at $203 in 2026 (n=17) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The record does not let us measure any one home's cap gap, but a homestead held through the 2022 and 2023 run-up had its assessed value held to 3 percent a year while recorded per-foot prices moved much faster.

Many Stillwater homes have been held a long time. Of the 211 older-plat homes with a qualified sale on the county file, the median time since that sale is 9 years; 93 last sold 10 or more years ago, 56 between 5 and 10 years, 26 between 2 and 5 years and 36 within 2 years, and another 40 older-plat homes have no qualified sale on the file at all (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Those long holds are where the largest gaps between assessed and just value usually sit.

What the buyer inherits. Nothing of the cap. The statute says homestead property "shall be assessed at just value as of January 1 of the year following a change of ownership" (Florida Statutes s. 193.155), and the county puts it more bluntly: "Exemptions and caps belong to the seller, not the buyer" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). If a home changed hands after January 1, 2026, its 2026 notice may still show the previous owner's limits, and it "will reset to market value on January 1, 2027" (2026 TRIM supplement). A buyer who will not claim homestead pays school taxes on full market value and gets a 10 percent yearly cap on the other levies only from the year after the reset (Florida Statutes s. 193.1555).

A buyer who will claim homestead gets the $25,000 base exemption plus the 2026 additional exemption of up to $26,411 on assessed value above $50,000 (2026 TRIM supplement), after owning and occupying the home on January 1 and applying by March 1 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Homestead).

What you can take with you. Portability can move up to $500,000 of your Save Our Homes difference to a new Florida homestead within the three-year lookback, using form DR-501T (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Portability FAQ). It is personal to the owner: it changes your next home's bill, not the market value of the Stillwater house you sell.

What are the 2026 millage rates and flat charges on a Stillwater tax bill?

Every Stillwater parcel sits in unincorporated Sarasota County, where the 2026 countywide total is 11.3068 mills, down from 11.4737 in 2025, almost all of the drop from the school levy. On top come flat charges such as the Englewood fire assessment of $290.78 per home, which no homestead exemption reduces (Sarasota County Tax Collector).

Sarasota County millage for unincorporated parcels such as Stillwater, 2026 and 2025

Levy 2026 mills 2025 mills
County general revenue 3.2317 3.2273
Mosquito control 0.0490 0.0520
Sarasota County Hospital District 1.0420 1.0420
West Coast Inland Navigation District 0.0394 0.0394
Southwest Florida Water Management District 0.1831 0.1831
Bonds, debt service 0.0653 0.0667
Legacy Trail, debt service 0.0373 0.0382
County subtotal 4.6478 4.6487
School, all levies 5.9290 6.0950
Emergency medical services 0.7300 0.7300
Countywide total 11.3068 11.4737

Sources: Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage (tax roll certified September 29, 2026) and 2025 millage. The 2026 school total is State 2.6810, Local Non-Voted 2.2480 and Local Voted 1.0000.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Tax Collector millage sheets, read November 18, 2026).

The flat lines are separate. The Englewood Area Fire Control District charges $290.78 per residence for 2026 to 2027 and $63.95 per vacant lot (Englewood Area Fire Control District), so each Shores lot still coded vacant pays the lot rate until its house is on the roll (our reading). No Shores at Stillwater CDD code appears on the Tax Collector's 2026 sheet (Sarasota County Tax Collector), and the district's 2026 to 2027 budget lists operations money as "To Be Collected At Closings" (Shores at Stillwater CDD budget). The CDD section of this page covers which homes the district reaches and its bonds. Other non-ad valorem lines on a Stillwater bill, such as solid waste or stormwater charges, are not confirmed in the sources we read; your own bill shows them.

To show what the millage means at Stillwater prices, here is the 2026 ad valorem tax on four recorded medians, treated as if each were the taxable value before exemptions. This is an illustration, not a bill for any home.

Illustration: 2026 Stillwater ad valorem tax at recorded medians

Price used as value No exemption With 2026 homestead exemptions Add flat fire charge
$282,500 (Unit 3 12-month median) $3,194.17 $2,769.47 $290.78
$390,300 (Shores Phase 1B first-sale median) $4,413.04 $3,988.34 $290.78
$523,250 (Shores 12-month first-sale median) $5,916.28 $5,491.58 $290.78
$550,000 (Unit 1 12-month median) $6,218.74 $5,794.04 $290.78

Sources: medians from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser file; millage from the Tax Collector; homestead figures apply $25,000 to all levies and $26,411 more to non-school levies, per the 2026 TRIM supplement; our arithmetic. Shores homes add the CDD once it is billed.

Pulte's own payment tooltip at Shores shows estimated taxes of $408.07 a month on the $364,990 Ellenwood quick move-in home (builder-stated, read November 18, 2026) (Pulte), which works out to about 1.34 percent of price a year against 1.13 percent for 11.3068 mills (our arithmetic). Pulte does not say what its estimate includes, so a buyer should budget from the millage, the fire charge and the CDD figures rather than from the calculator.

How do TRIM notices and the Value Adjustment Board work for a Stillwater owner?

Sarasota County mails TRIM notices in mid-August, and a Stillwater owner who thinks the January 1 just value is too high can file a Value Adjustment Board petition within 25 days of the mailing date. The 2026 window has closed; the next chance is the August 2027 notice, based on January 1, 2027 value (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

The mailing comes "No later than 55 days (August 24th) after certification of the value" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Important Dates), the notice is "NOT A BILL," and the bill follows in November (2026 TRIM supplement). The petition cut-off is printed on the notice itself (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, VAB petitions).

The Stillwater owner's path for a value challenge

  1. Compare the notice with sales near January 1. Use recorded sales of your plat and size, not today's market.
  2. Ask for an informal conference. The county calls it "highly recommended, but not required" (2026 TRIM supplement) and invites "sales comparison data" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).
  3. File within 25 days if it does not settle.
  4. Send your evidence early. The petitioner must give the Property Appraiser a list of evidence and copies "At least 15 days before the hearing" (Florida Statutes s. 194.011).
  5. Expect a special magistrate. Counties over 75,000 people must appoint them to take testimony (Florida Statutes s. 194.035).
  6. Court is the last step. A suit must be filed within 60 days after the roll is certified for collection, typically in early October (Florida Statutes s. 194.171; 2026 TRIM supplement).

The board hears value, classification and exemption disputes only; an owner objecting to the tax rate itself goes to the taxing authorities' budget hearings instead (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). For a Unit 3 owner, the strongest evidence is recorded Unit 3 sales of the 1,349 or 1,524 square foot homes close to January 1; for a Shores owner, whether the house was substantially complete on January 1 can matter as much as price. If you plan to look hard at the 2027 notice, a Stillwater CMA dated near January 1, 2027 is exactly the kind of sales comparison the county asks for. Ask us for that Stillwater valuation early in the new year, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

What is the status of Amendment 3 for Stillwater homeowners?

Results posted on the Florida Division of Elections' Election Watch site show Amendment 3 with about 62 percent yes, but no official source we read on November 18, 2026 confirmed that the result had been certified. Stillwater owners should treat any change to homestead exemptions or caps as pending (Florida Election Watch).

Election Watch listed the measure, titled "Increased Homestead Exemption; Lower Cap On Increases In Non-Homestead Property Assessments," with 4,922,977 yes votes, or 61.98 percent, under the heading "Official Election Results" (Florida Election Watch). The state's Elections Canvassing Commission was scheduled to meet at 8:00 AM on November 17, 2026 to certify the official results (Florida Election Watch timeline), but the Department of State's press page carried no certification notice when we checked (Florida Department of State). So the status on this page is: about 62 percent yes on the posted results, not confirmed certified as of November 18, 2026, with implementing law still to come.

As written, the measure's text moves the yearly assessment cap on non-homestead property from 10 percent to 5 percent beginning January 1, 2027, and keeps the rule that "No assessment shall exceed just value" (Amendment text, CS/HJR 1F). We print no exemption dollar effects here, because they depend on certification and on legislation not yet published. One limit is already clear in current law: the homestead exemption does not reach "assessments for special benefits" (Florida Statutes s. 196.031), so neither the $290.78 fire charge nor any Shores CDD line would shrink under a larger homestead exemption (our reading).

For valuation, the point is who benefits. Any homestead change belongs to the buyer's tax status, not to the house: it can lower a resident buyer's payment on a Stillwater home, while a buyer who will not claim homestead sees none of the exemption change. We will update this section once certification and the implementing statute are published.

Are Stillwater Home Prices Dropping? Values in 2026

Older Stillwater resale prices per square foot are lower in 2026 than in 2025, while Sarasota County's single-family median rose. The older-plat median was $200 per heated square foot in the first half of 2026, against $257 a year earlier, with more small Unit 3 homes selling. That is a local reset (county records; RASM).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; RASM Sarasota County October 2026 report published November 16, 2026; Florida Realtors October 2026 MSA release of November 16, 2026; FHFA House Price Index through 2026 Q2; Census Bureau Building Permits Survey through September 2026; Freddie Mac PMMS for the week of November 12, 2026; our tabulation).

Stillwater in Englewood shows two price stories in 2026 that a single headline number would blur. Older-plat resales recorded lower per-foot prices than in 2025, while Pulte's first sales at Shores closed at higher per-foot medians on brand-new homes with options and pools.

What do the 2026 older-plat Stillwater sales show?

Through mid-October 2026, the county recorded 17 older-plat Stillwater resales at a $305,000 median and $203 per heated square foot. Ten were Unit 3 homes at a $282,500 median, so the overall figure leans toward the smaller plat; Unit 1's five sales recorded a $565,000 median, a small group (county records).

Older-plat Stillwater resales, calendar 2025 against 2026 so far

Group 2025 sales 2025 median 2025 median per heated sq ft 2026 sales 2026 median 2026 median per heated sq ft
All older plats 17 $500,000 $230 17 $305,000 $203
Unit 1 7, a small group $560,000 $262 5, a small group $565,000 $248
Unit 2 3, a small group $542,000 $257 2, too few for a median not stated not stated
Unit 3 7, a small group $324,000 $220 10 $282,500 $198

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026, qualified sales of improved homes, our tabulation. 2026 runs through the newest older-plat resale on the file, September 18, 2026.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026).

The all-plat median fell from $500,000 to $305,000 mostly because the 2026 mix tilted to Unit 3: 10 of the 17 resales in 2026 were Unit 3 homes, against 7 of 17 in 2025 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Per square foot, which corrects for much of that, the drop was smaller: $230 to $203. Within Unit 1, the median price held near $560,000 to $565,000 while the per-foot median moved from $262 to $248, both on small groups.

The quarters tell the same story with even smaller groups. Older-plat resales ran 10 in the first quarter of 2026 at a $211 median per heated square foot, 5 in the second at $200 and 2 in the third, too few for a median, with none so far in the fourth (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). February 2026 was the busiest month, with 5 resales. Quarterly medians shift with which plat sold, so we read them as a direction, not as a quarterly rate of change.

The cleanest evidence that some prices actually fell, rather than the mix changing, comes from the same homes selling twice. Three older-plat homes resold in early 2026 after an earlier sale in 2024 or 2025, and all three recorded prices below the earlier sale: a Unit 3 home bought in May 2024 and two Unit 1 homes bought in March 2025 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Three sales are a small group, and none of the three prices captures what changed in the home in between, but the direction matches the per-foot record. The repeat-sale section at the end of this part covers every pair.

How did Shores at Stillwater first sales run in 2026?

Pulte's first sales at Shores at Stillwater began recording in February 2026. The county shows 16 through October 13: one in the first quarter, 10 in the second at a $533,850 median, 4 in the third at $499,550, and one in October. Quarterly medians move with which plans closed (county records).

Per heated square foot, the second-quarter median was $294 on 10 sales and the third-quarter median $251 on 4 sales, a small group (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The second quarter included the four highest per-foot first sales on record, all in Phase 1A, so the lower third-quarter figure reads as mix, not as a price cut on the deed. By plat, Phase 1A recorded 12 first sales at a $564,750 median and $290 per heated square foot, and Phase 1B recorded 4 villa first sales, a small group, at a $390,300 median and $248.

Shores at Stillwater first sales by heated size, all on record

Heated size Sales Median price Median per heated sq ft
Under 1,800 sq ft 5, a small group $401,600 $255
1,800 to 2,199 sq ft 10 $564,750 $290
2,200 sq ft and up 1, too few for a median not stated not stated

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026; every Shores sale on the file is a first sale; our tabulation.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026).

What the record cannot show is the price after incentives, which the Pulte section of this page reads in detail. For an older Stillwater home, the Shores figures above are a ceiling built from new homes with options, not a level to expect.

What do Sarasota County and metro figures say about 2026 prices?

Sarasota County's single-family market firmed in the third quarter and October of 2026. RASM reported an October median of $490,000, up 10.1 percent, with 4.0 months of supply and a 40-day median to contract, and Florida Realtors put the metro single-family median at $491,480. Neither figure describes Stillwater's older plats directly (RASM; Florida Realtors).

Sarasota County and metro single-family figures, October 2026

Measure Sarasota County (RASM) North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton MSA (Florida Realtors)
Closed sales 633, down 5.2 percent 1,234, down 2.4 percent
Median sale price $490,000, up 10.1 percent $491,480, up 5.8 percent
Year-to-date median not in this release $485,000, up 2.5 percent
Median percent of original list price received 95.5 percent (92.4 percent a year earlier) not in this table
Active inventory 2,824, down 14.2 percent not in this table
Months of supply 4.0 not in this table
Median days to contract 40 (61 a year earlier) not in this table

Sources: RASM, Sarasota County October 2026, published November 16, 2026; Florida Realtors October 2026 MSA summary, released November 16, 2026. The MSA covers Sarasota and Manatee counties, so the two columns are different geographies.

Data updated: November 2026 (RASM and Florida Realtors October 2026 releases).

For the third quarter, the Business Observer reported a Sarasota County single-family median that "rose 3.7% to $485,000," with sellers receiving a median 94.4 percent of original list price against 91.9 percent a year earlier (Business Observer, October 16, 2026). Florida Realtors' chief economist described the single-family market statewide this way: "Inventory remains relatively contained, particularly in the single-family home market" (Florida Realtors, November 16, 2026).

Stillwater sits on both sides of those county figures. The Unit 3 12-month median of $282,500 is about 58 percent of the October metro median, and the Unit 1 median of $550,000 is about 112 percent of it (our arithmetic from the county file and Florida Realtors). A county median rising 10 percent while Stillwater's older-plat per-foot median fell tells you the pressure on Stillwater is local. The market measures that would normally complete this picture are not published for Stillwater alone: Stillwater days on market, sale-to-list ratio, months of supply and active listings: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026).

What does the FHFA index show next to Stillwater?

The FHFA all-transactions index for the North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton metro read 478.67 in the second quarter of 2026, 0.5 percent below a year earlier and 4.6 percent below its 2023 third-quarter peak. Stillwater's older plats fell further, which points to local causes rather than the metro trend (FRED, FHFA metro index).

FHFA all-transactions index, North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton MSA (1995 Q1 = 100)

Quarter Index
2021 Q1 324.54
2022 Q4 493.13
2023 Q3 (peak) 501.99
2024 Q4 497.24
2025 Q2 480.88
2025 Q4 486.70
2026 Q1 483.12
2026 Q2 (latest) 478.67

Source: FRED, FHFA House Price Index for the North Port-Sarasota-Bradenton MSA, last updated August 25, 2026. The index measures repeat sales of the same homes with conforming loans.

Data updated: November 2026 (FHFA through 2026 Q2; the 2026 Q3 reading was not yet published when we checked).

The metro index stood 47.5 percent above its 2021 first-quarter level in mid-2026 (our arithmetic from FRED), while Stillwater's older-plat median per heated square foot was $191 in 2021 and $203 in 2026, both on more than 10 sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Different measures, but a clear contrast: the metro index kept most of its 2021 to 2022 rise, and Stillwater's older-plat per-foot median gave most of its rise back. Within the plats, Unit 3's per-foot median was $260 in 2023 (n=5, a small group) and $198 in 2026 (n=10), and Unit 1's was $316 in 2023 (n=4, a small group) and $248 in 2026 (n=5), so the direction holds in both plats even though the small 2023 groups make the size uncertain.

Our reading of why, which no source measures directly: Pulte's homes began closing next door in 2026 with incentives, the 2000 to 2006 homes reached the age where roof questions shape every insurance quote, and the 2023 record leaned on a few large sales, three third-quarter 2023 resales at an $860,000 median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). FHFA excludes new-construction first sales, so it cannot see the Shores effect.

How much new-home supply competes with Stillwater resales?

New supply sits inside the Stillwater name itself. Shores at Stillwater still had 107 lots coded vacant on the October 2026 roll, and Sarasota County issued 3,176 single-family permits from January to September 2026, 2.0 percent fewer than a year earlier. Every Pulte closing becomes a comparable for older Stillwater homes (county records; Census).

Sarasota County one-unit building permits, Census Bureau

Period Units permitted Reported construction value per unit (our arithmetic)
2023 4,491 $391,604
2024 5,259 $388,054
2025 4,283 $457,046
January to September 2025 3,241 $454,254
January to September 2026 3,176 $457,629

Sources: Census Bureau Building Permits Survey county files for 2023, 2024, 2025, January to September 2025 and January to September 2026. Construction value excludes land and is not a sale price; county totals include every permit office in Sarasota County.

Data updated: November 2026 (Census Bureau county files through September 2026).

Permits fell 18.6 percent in 2025 and are running slightly below that pace in 2026, but about 3,200 single-family permits in nine months is still a steady flow of new homes competing for the same buyers (Census).

The builder next door is still leaning in. PulteGroup's Florida segment booked 1,823 net new orders in the third quarter of 2026 against 1,721 a year earlier, ended September with a backlog of 3,097 homes, up 15 percent, and reported a 13 percent cancellation rate against 16 percent (PulteGroup Form 10-Q). The same filing blames lower nine-month Florida income partly on "lower revenues and closings in our Southwest Florida operations"; whether Shores at Stillwater reports inside that division is not stated. Our new construction in Englewood page tracks the communities a Stillwater buyer is likely to tour.

How do mortgage rates feed into Stillwater prices in 2026?

Freddie Mac's 30-year average was 7.11 percent for the week of November 12, 2026, against 6.24 percent a year earlier and a 2026 low of 5.98 percent in February. A Stillwater resale seller absorbs that rate move in full, while a builder can buy part of it down for its own buyers (Freddie Mac; FRED).

The path through the fall: the weekly average hit 7.40 percent on October 8 and October 15, then eased to 7.32, 7.24, 7.18 and 7.11 percent (FRED, Freddie Mac 30-year series). On the $440,000 loan behind a $550,000 Unit 1 home with 20 percent down, principal and interest is $2,959.91 a month at 7.11 percent against $2,706.29 at 6.24 percent, $253.62 more for the same house (our arithmetic from the PMMS rates). The months when the rate climbed from its February low to its October high were also the months older-plat resales thinned from 10 in the first quarter to 2 in the third (Sarasota County Property Appraiser); we note the timing without claiming one caused the other.

What one monthly budget buys in an older Stillwater plat at different rates

30-year rate Price supported by the same total payment
6.00 percent $468,343
6.24 percent $458,427
7.00 percent $429,018
7.11 percent $425,000
7.40 percent $414,680

Source: our computation on a $2,953.63 total monthly payment, the $425,000 no-CDD case in the carrying-cost section below (20 percent down, 11.3068 mills, the Citizens Sarasota County HO3 average and the Englewood fire charge, HOA excluded); rates from Freddie Mac PMMS and FRED. A budget estimate, not a loan quote.

At that budget, each quarter point of rate is worth roughly $9,000 to $10,000 of price to a Stillwater buyer (our arithmetic from the table). Florida Realtors' chief economist put it simply in November: "Going forward, mortgage rates will remain the biggest variable to watch" (Florida Realtors, November 16, 2026).

When during the year do Stillwater homes sell?

Stillwater's older-plat resales cluster in late winter and spring. Of 180 qualified resales recorded from 2015 through October 2026, 89 closed from February through May, while August and September together held only 13. Sarasota and Manatee board closings show the same pattern, peaking from March through June in 2026 (county records; RASM board report).

Older-plat Stillwater resales by month of closing, 2015 through October 2026

Month Resales Month Resales
January 14 July 11
February 24 August 6
March 22 September 7
April 23 October 11
May 20 November 16
June 16 December 10

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026, qualified older-plat resales, our tabulation.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026).

The board-wide picture matches. Across Sarasota and Manatee, 2026 closings averaged about 1,755 a month from March through June and about 1,335 from August through October, roughly a quarter fewer (RASM board report, October 2026, our arithmetic). The board notes its counts reflect only sales published through the multiple listing service, so treat them as approximate. Shores first sales follow Pulte's construction schedule more than the season, which is why April through June 2026 held 10 of the 16.

Closings in March through May mean contracts signed from January into April. A Stillwater owner who wants the widest pool of buyers is usually best served by having the roof permit, wind mitigation form and any flood papers ready, and the home photographed and priced, by late January.

What should Stillwater owners watch next?

Over the coming year, Stillwater values will respond to five things we can track by date: how hard Pulte keeps discounting at Shores, the weekly mortgage rate, new FHFA and RASM readings, the flood program's December 11, 2026 authorization deadline, and the fate of Amendment 3. Each one shifts what a buyer can afford (CRS).

  1. Pulte at Shores. PulteGroup expects its incentives "to remain elevated" (PulteGroup Form 10-Q). With 107 lots still coded vacant on the roll, every new offer at Shores is the price an older Stillwater listing is shown against.
  2. The rate. Each quarter point is roughly $9,000 to $10,000 of price at a fixed Stillwater budget (table above, from the PMMS rate). Freddie Mac's next weekly release was due Thursday, November 19, 2026.
  3. County and metro readings. The FHFA 2026 Q3 metro reading had not been published when we checked (FRED), and Florida Realtors' next data release is Wednesday, December 16, 2026 (Florida Realtors).
  4. Flood insurance authority. The NFIP is authorized until December 11, 2026; in a lapse, the authority to write new flood contracts expires while policies in force run to term (CRS Insight IN10835). That matters to any Stillwater closing that needs a new NFIP policy.
  5. Amendment 3. Certification and the implementing law decide what changes for homestead and non-homestead buyers; status above.

None of these tells you what your own house would bring this month against the Pulte homes a buyer can tour this weekend. That takes a CMA, which takes days, not weeks. Request your free Stillwater home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. For the wider town, our Englewood home valuation page applies the same method across Englewood, our Englewood area page gives the bigger picture, and our Englewood seller guide covers selling anywhere in town.

How Do Carrying Costs Change What Buyers Pay for a Stillwater Home?

Stillwater buyers who finance shop by monthly payment, and the lender's number covers more than the mortgage: county taxes, the Englewood fire charge, insurance, HOA dues and, at Shores only, the CDD. Every added monthly dollar trims what a payment-limited buyer can bid for a Stillwater home, so carrying costs act as a price ceiling.

Data updated: November 2026 (Freddie Mac PMMS for the week of November 12, 2026; Sarasota County Tax Collector 2026 millage; Englewood Area Fire Control District 2026 to 2027 assessment; Shores at Stillwater CDD FY 2026/27 budget and June 15, 2026 assessment methodology; Citizens 2026 approved rate changes by county; OIR market overview with October 2026 data; FHFA and HUD 2026 loan limits; VA funding fee page; our computation).

What goes into a Stillwater buyer's monthly payment?

Lenders size a Stillwater loan on the whole housing payment: principal and interest, ad valorem tax, flat charges such as the fire assessment and any CDD, homeowners and flood insurance, and association dues. Fannie Mae counts special assessments and association dues as housing expense, so each line trims what the buyer can borrow for a Stillwater home (Fannie Mae).

Fannie Mae's housing-expense topic names "special assessments" and "owners' association dues" alongside taxes and insurance (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-03), so a Shores buyer's CDD line counts against income exactly as a tax would. For loans run through Desktop Underwriter, "the maximum allowable DTI ratio is 50%"; manually underwritten loans stop at 36 percent, or 45 percent with credit score and reserve standards met (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-02). For Stillwater in Englewood, that means two homes at the same price can qualify very different buyers if one sits inside the CDD and the other does not.

The inputs behind our Stillwater payment examples

Input Figure used Source and note
Mortgage rate 7.11 percent, 30-year fixed Freddie Mac PMMS, week of November 12, 2026
Down payment 20 percent conventional, no mortgage insurance FHA at 3.5 percent and VA at 0 percent shown separately
Ad valorem tax 11.3068 mills on a taxable value equal to price Sarasota County Tax Collector; a ceiling, since a first-year value can sit below price
Homestead case $25,000 off all levies plus $26,411 off non-school levies (school 5.9290 mills, other levies 5.3778) 2026 TRIM supplement
Homeowners insurance $2,901 a year, the Citizens Sarasota County HO3 approved average (down from $3,134); an average, not a quote Citizens 2026 approved rate changes by county
Insurance sensitivity $3,736 a year, OIR's admitted-market average including wind, statewide OIR, October 2026 data
Fire assessment $290.78 a year Englewood Area Fire Control District
Shores CDD, 52-foot lot $1,914.48 maximum annual debt plus $276 operations = $2,190.48 a year ($182.54 a month) CDD methodology; FY 2026/27 budget
Shores CDD, 34-foot lot $1,382.68 plus $276 = $1,658.68 a year ($138.22 a month) Same sources
Older-plat CDD None; the district's boundary and the 2026 levy sheet indicate Units 1 to 3 sit outside it Confirm on your own tax bill
HOA dues Excluded. Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). The association's estoppel certificate states the dues and their period
Flood insurance $0 in the base case (no lender mandate) Each $500 a year adds $41.67 a month
Not included County solid waste and stormwater lines, mortgage insurance, utilities Not confirmed in the sources we read

The $276 operations figure is the district budget's per-unit equivalent; for 2026 to 2027 the budget shows operations money "To Be Collected At Closings" rather than on the tax roll (Shores at Stillwater CDD budget). Whether the 2027 Shores bills carry the CDD on the tax roll or by direct bill is left to an annual board resolution, so we use the full combined amount as the planning figure.

What do $285,000, $425,000 and $550,000 Stillwater homes cost per month?

At 7.11 percent with 20 percent down, our estimate is about $2,068 a month for a $285,000 older-plat home, $2,954 for a $425,000 older-plat home, $3,136 for a $425,000 Shores at Stillwater home with the CDD, and $3,744 for a $550,000 Unit 1 home, before HOA dues and as a first year without homestead (PMMS rate).

Estimated monthly cost of a Stillwater home at three price points

Line $285,000, older plat $425,000, older plat $425,000, Shores 52-foot lot $550,000, Unit 1 $550,000, Shores 52-foot lot
Principal and interest at 7.11 percent $1,533.77 $2,287.20 $2,287.20 $2,959.91 $2,959.91
Ad valorem tax, no exemption $268.54 $400.45 $400.45 $518.23 $518.23
Homeowners insurance (Citizens Sarasota HO3 average) $241.75 $241.75 $241.75 $241.75 $241.75
Englewood fire assessment $24.23 $24.23 $24.23 $24.23 $24.23
Shores at Stillwater CDD $0 $0 $182.54 $0 $182.54
HOA dues not included not included not included not included not included
Total, no homestead $2,068.29 $2,953.63 $3,136.17 $3,744.12 $3,926.66
Total with 2026 homestead exemptions $2,032.90 $2,918.24 $3,100.78 $3,708.73 $3,891.27
Total at last year's 6.24 percent rate $1,936.87 $2,757.66 $2,940.20 $3,490.50 $3,673.04
Total with OIR's $3,736 insurance average $2,137.87 $3,023.22 $3,205.76 $3,813.70 not computed
FHA, 3.5 percent down, 1.75 percent upfront premium financed, 0.55 percent annual premium, 7.11 percent $2,543.06 $3,661.62 not computed not computed not computed
VA, 0 down, 2.15 percent funding fee financed, 7.11 percent $2,492.95 not computed not computed $4,563.64 not computed

Sources: our computation from Freddie Mac PMMS, the Tax Collector's 2026 millage, the 2026 TRIM supplement, the Citizens county rate table, OIR, the fire district, the CDD methodology, HUD Mortgagee Letter 2023-05 and the VA funding fee page. FHA and VA rows use the PMMS conventional rate for comparison, since FHA rates are not in PMMS. A budget estimate, not a loan quote.

Data updated: November 2026 (inputs as listed in the table above).

The $285,000 column sits in the Unit 3 band, where the 12-month Unit 3 median was $282,500; the $550,000 column is the Unit 1 12-month median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). With no other debts, the $285,000 home's payment needs about $80,063 a year of income at a 31 percent housing ratio, $68,943 at 36 percent and $49,639 at the 50 percent DU maximum; the $425,000 Shores home needs $121,400, $104,539 and $75,268; and the $550,000 Unit 1 home needs $144,934, $124,804 and $89,859 (our arithmetic) (Fannie Mae). Car loans and credit cards bind real buyers sooner.

Three cautions keep these numbers honest. The tax line treats price as taxable value, which overstates the first-year bill for many buyers and is a deliberate ceiling. The insurance line is an average: Pulte's own calculator assumes $1,423.44 to $1,735.44 a year on its new Shores homes (builder-stated, read November 18, 2026) (Pulte), while an original-roof 2000 to 2006 home may quote higher. And the state's consumer guide says homes "built in compliance with the 2001 Florida Building Code or later edition" are "automatically eligible for a minimum 68% discount on the windstorm coverage of the premium" (Florida CFO guide), which is why a current wind mitigation form on a Stillwater home can move a real quote well away from any average.

If you are shopping for a home rather than selling one, Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or see our Englewood buyer's guide. If you own in Stillwater and want a price that reflects what your buyer will actually carry each month, ask for your free Stillwater valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How does the Shores CDD change what a buyer pays at the same price?

At the same $425,000 price, a Shores at Stillwater home on a 52-foot lot carries about $182.54 a month more than an older Stillwater home, the CDD's debt and operations lines combined. At 7.11 percent, our estimate is that this line displaces about $28,900 of the price a buyer could otherwise finance (CDD methodology).

The district's legal description begins at the southeast corner of Stillwater Unit Two and runs along Unit Two's east line, and no Shores at Stillwater CDD code appears on the Tax Collector's 2026 levy sheet (CDD meeting book, April 20, 2026; Tax Collector). Those records indicate that Unit 1, 2 and 3 homes sit outside the district; older-plat owners should still confirm it on their own tax bill. Shores lots carry the Series 2026 bonds: $2,970,000 issued, final maturity May 2056, with original principal of $18,580.37 on a 34-foot lot and $25,726.66 on a 52-foot lot (CDD amended FY 2025/26 budget; CDD methodology).

What each carrying-cost line is worth in price, at 7.11 percent with 20 percent down

Line Monthly amount About this much price (our estimate)
Each $1 a month of payment $1 $158.13
Each $100 a month, for example HOA dues $100 $15,800
Shores CDD, 52-foot lot $182.54 $28,900
Shores CDD, 34-foot lot $138.22 $21,900
CDD debt line alone, 52-foot lot ($1,914.48 a year; what a debt prepayment removes) $159.54 $25,200
CDD debt line alone, 34-foot lot ($1,382.68 a year; what a debt prepayment removes) $115.22 $18,200
$1,000 a year of homeowners premium, for example with or without a wind mitigation credit $83.33 $13,200
$500 a year of flood premium $41.67 $6,600

Source: our computation at the PMMS 7.11 percent rate, 20 percent down and the 2026 millage; CDD amounts from the district methodology. These are buying-power estimates, not discounts the market applies dollar for dollar.

Data updated: November 2026 (PMMS week of November 12, 2026; CDD methodology of June 15, 2026).

None of this says Shores homes are worth $28,900 less than they sell for. Shores buyers get new homes and community features Pulte lists as "Gated, with Heated Pool & Cabana" (builder-stated, read November 18, 2026) (Pulte), and the district itself explains that special districts let improvement costs "be spread over the life of the bonds rather than included in the price of the initial home sale" (Shores at Stillwater CDD FAQ). What the table does say is why a Shores price per square foot has to be read net of the CDD before anyone compares it with a Unit 1 or Unit 2 resale. The 31.3 percent 12-month per-foot gap between Shores first sales and older-plat resales exists even though Shores buyers carry a line the older plats do not, which is one more reason to read it as new-home and option value rather than as a level an older home can reach (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). For a Shores owner who resells, a CDD payoff letter from the district manager and the debt-prepaid status on the estoppel are documents with real dollar value.

What are the 2026 loan limits for a Stillwater home?

Loan limits do not cap Stillwater prices. FHFA's 2026 baseline conforming limit for a one-unit home is $832,750, above every Stillwater sale in the 36-month county record, and HUD's 2026 FHA floor is $541,287, which fits a Unit 1 home at the $550,000 median with FHA's minimum down payment (FHFA; HUD).

FHFA set the 2026 one-unit baseline at $832,750, "an increase of $26,250 from 2025," with a high-cost ceiling of $1,249,125 (FHFA, November 25, 2025). No source we read names Sarasota County as a high-cost county, so the baseline is the working figure; FHFA's county file was not checked for this page, and your lender confirms the county row. HUD set the 2026 FHA one-unit floor at $541,287 and ceiling at $1,249,125 for case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2026, with the floor applying where 115 percent of the area median is below it (HUD No. 25-145); HUD's own Sarasota County row was not retrieved either.

What that means at Stillwater prices: a $550,000 Unit 1 home with FHA's 3.5 percent minimum down leaves a $530,750 base loan, inside the floor (our arithmetic). Pulte's top Shores plan, the Mystique Grande, lists from $565,990 (builder-stated, read November 18, 2026) (Pulte); at 3.5 percent down its base loan of $546,180 would sit above a $541,287 limit, so that buyer would need about 4.4 percent down if Sarasota County sits at the floor (our arithmetic). FHA adds a 1.75 percent upfront premium and, above 95 percent loan-to-value on a 30-year loan at or under $726,200, a 0.55 percent annual premium (HUD Mortgagee Letter 2023-05). With the middle half of 36-month older-plat resales between $315,000 and $560,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), nearly every Stillwater home is within reach of conforming and FHA financing, which keeps the buyer pool wide.

Can a buyer take over a Stillwater owner's FHA or VA loan?

Sometimes, and the rate can carry real value. A Stillwater owner holding a below-market VA loan may be able to hand that rate to a qualified buyer, and VA's fee table lists a 0.5 percent funding fee on assumptions. FHA owners should ask their servicer what assumption terms apply (VA).

The arithmetic shows why it matters. A $300,000 balance at 5.5 percent costs $1,703.37 a month in principal and interest; the same balance at today's 7.11 percent costs $2,018.12, so the buyer who takes over the lower note saves $314.75 a month (PMMS rate, our arithmetic). At the $158.13-per-dollar multiplier in the table above, that saving is worth roughly $49,800 of price to a buyer who can cover the difference between your price and the loan balance in cash or a second loan (our estimate). The weekly average fell as low as 5.98 percent in February 2026 (FRED), so even a Stillwater owner who bought or refinanced this year may hold a rate below today's.

Two cautions. How many Stillwater owners hold FHA or VA loans, and at what rates, is not in any public source we read: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). And an assumption is a lender process with its own approval and timing, so it suits a buyer and seller who plan for it from the first offer. If you hold such a loan, tell us when you request your Stillwater home valuation; it can change who we market your home to and how we price it.

What Do Recorded Stillwater Resales Show?

Most recorded Stillwater resales closed above the home's earlier recorded price, largely because most earlier prices date from before 2020. Of 15 pairs in the latest 12 months, 12 resold above and 3 below, a median 12.2 percent above, after a median 98 months. All three below had an earlier sale in 2022 or later (county records).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026; repeat-sale pairs where the later qualified sale fell in the window ending October 14, 2026 and the earlier qualified sale is the earliest on the file, which begins January 6, 2009; our tabulation).

Every pair below is the same home in Stillwater, Englewood, Florida, recorded twice. We describe each result as resold above or below the price recorded at the earlier sale. Prior prices do not include later additions, and neither price shows what either owner spent to buy, hold or sell.

How did Stillwater resales in the last 12 months compare with the earlier recorded sale?

In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, 15 of the 19 older-plat Stillwater resales had an earlier qualified sale of the same home on the county file. Twelve resold above the price recorded at the earlier sale and three below, with a median 98 months between the two sales; most subgroups are small (county records).

Stillwater repeat sales, later sale in the 12 months to October 14, 2026

Group Pairs Resold above the earlier price Resold below the earlier price Median change
All older plats 15 12 3 12.2 percent above
Unit 1 5, a small group 3 2 not stated
Unit 2 1, a small group 1 0 not stated
Unit 3 9, a small group 8 1 not stated
Earlier sale before 2020 10 10 0 50.5 percent above
Earlier sale 2020 to 2021 2, a small group 2 0 not stated
Earlier sale 2022 or later 3, a small group 0 3 not stated

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation. No pair recorded exactly its earlier price. The middle half of the time between sales ran from 63 to 150 months.

The other 4 of the 19 resales had no earlier qualified sale on the file, so they cannot be paired (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The headline result is driven by the 10 pairs whose earlier sale came before 2020: every one resold above, at a median 50.5 percent above the earlier price. Strip those out and the five remaining pairs split 2 above and 3 below, which is too few for a percentage and is exactly the group whose earlier price was set in the 2020 to 2025 market.

What do the 24 and 36 month repeat-sale pairs add?

A longer window adds pairs and steadies the medians. Over 24 months, 31 Stillwater resales had an earlier recorded sale: 26 resold above and 5 below, a median 54.0 percent above. Over 36 months, 39 pairs ran 33 above and 6 below, a median 55.8 percent above, after a median 107 months (county records).

Stillwater repeat sales over 24 and 36 months

Group 24 months: pairs Above / below Median change 36 months: pairs Above / below Median change
All older plats 31 26 / 5 54.0 percent above 39 33 / 6 55.8 percent above
Unit 1 9, a small group 6 / 3 not stated 10 7 / 3 42.9 percent above
Unit 2 5, a small group 4 / 1 not stated 7, a small group 5 / 2 not stated
Unit 3 17 16 / 1 75.9 percent above 22 21 / 1 76.1 percent above
Earlier sale before 2020 22 22 / 0 72.2 percent above 28 28 / 0 74.4 percent above
Earlier sale 2020 to 2021 5, a small group 4 / 1 not stated 5, a small group 4 / 1 not stated
Earlier sale 2022 or later 4, a small group 0 / 4 not stated 6, a small group 1 / 5 not stated

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser, our tabulation. Median time between sales: 98 months over 24 months (middle half 63 to 153) and 107 months over 36 months (middle half 63 to 150).

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026).

Unit 3 dominates the longer windows, and its earlier prices mostly come from 2010 to 2013, often in or near the year the home was built (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). That is why Unit 3's 36-month median sits 76.1 percent above the earlier price: it measures the distance from the early 2010s to today, not a recent price change. Unit 1's earlier prices are spread across 2010 to 2025, so its median of 42.9 percent above over 36 months mixes long holds with recent purchases. Both medians describe when owners bought far more than how the homes changed.

Why does the year of the earlier sale matter so much in Stillwater?

In Stillwater, the year of the earlier purchase lines up closely with whether a home resold above or below that price. Across 36 months, all 28 pairs whose earlier sale came before 2020 resold above that price, while 5 of the 6 pairs with an earlier sale in 2022 or later resold below it, a small group (county records).

The calendar-year record explains it. The older-plat median per heated square foot was $191 in 2021, $263 in 2022, $282 in 2023, $264 in 2024, $230 in 2025 and $203 in 2026 so far (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). An owner who bought in 2022 through 2024 paid a per-foot level well above where 2026 sales are closing, so a resale today is likely to record below that earlier price even if the home was kept up. An owner who bought before 2020 paid well under today's level. Here are the six 36-month pairs whose earlier sale came in 2022 or later, with no addresses.

Stillwater pairs with an earlier sale in 2022 or later, 36 months to October 14, 2026

Later sale Plat Heated sq ft Earlier sale Earlier price Later price Months between Result
May 2024 Unit 3 1,649 March 2022 $375,000 $435,000 26 Above
August 2024 Unit 2 2,181 April 2023 $650,000 $592,000 16 Below
May 2025 Unit 1 1,961 February 2022 $605,500 $530,000 40 Below
February 2026 Unit 3 1,338 May 2024 $345,000 $315,000 21 Below
March 2026 Unit 1 2,376 March 2025 $620,000 $590,000 11 Below
March 2026 Unit 1 2,167 March 2025 $630,000 $565,000 12 Below

Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser resale list, qualified sales, our tabulation. Six pairs are a small group; we show them so the pattern is visible, not to measure it.

The 2020 to 2021 group points the same way at a smaller scale: of its 5 pairs over 36 months, 4 resold above and 1 below, and the one below had been bought in December 2021, at the start of the run-up (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). For a Stillwater owner, the practical reading is simple. If you bought in 2022 or later, your earlier price is not a floor for today's value, and a CMA built on 2026 sales of your plat and size is the number to plan around. If you bought before 2020, the earlier price tells you almost nothing about today's value either; the current sales do.

What can't repeat sales tell you about your Stillwater home's value?

A Stillwater repeat sale is just two deed prices for the same house, years apart. They cannot show a new roof, impact windows or a pool added between sales, the costs of buying and selling, or the financing behind either price. With 15 pairs in 12 months, they describe a pattern, not your home's value (county records).

Six things the pairs leave out:

  1. Work done between the sales. A replaced roof, new air conditioning, impact windows, a pool or a remodeled kitchen is inside the later price and absent from the earlier one. Prior prices do not include later additions, so "resold above" can simply reflect money the owner put in.
  2. The costs at both ends. Recorded prices are gross. Commission, title, documentary stamp tax and other seller costs come out of the later price before an owner receives anything; our seller closing costs page lists the Florida items.
  3. Holding costs over long holds. A median of 98 months between sales in the 12-month group (Sarasota County Property Appraiser) means years of taxes, insurance, dues and repairs that no deed records.
  4. What the earlier price was. Many Unit 3 earlier prices were recorded when those homes were new, from 2010 to 2013, so a pair can measure a builder-era price against today's resale market.
  5. Small groups. Unit 1 had 5 pairs and Unit 2 had 1 in the latest 12 months, so one unusual sale can swing any per-plat reading.
  6. Shores at Stillwater has no pairs at all. Every Shores sale on the file is a first sale, so there is no repeat-sale record yet for Shores owners. The first Shores resales will be compared with Pulte prices whose credits and rate programs never reached the deed.

That is why repeat sales are one input in a Stillwater CMA, beside current resales of your plat and size, Pulte's live price sheet and the monthly payment your buyer will carry. If you want a figure built that way for your home, request your free Stillwater home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Our Stillwater neighborhood guide covers the community itself, and our Stillwater seller guide explains how to prepare, list and negotiate once you have the number.

Want a Free In-Person CMA for Your Stillwater Home?

Yes, and it costs nothing. A comparative market analysis for a home in Stillwater in Englewood starts with a walk through the house, then prices it against recorded sales from its own plat (Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3 or Shores at Stillwater), with Pulte's dated price sheet beside it, because one Stillwater median blends two different markets.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026, qualified improved sales through October 14, 2026; Pulte pages, district records and agency pages read November 18, 2026).

Stillwater is two markets under one name, which is why the visit carries more weight here than a database search. County records show 35 qualified home sales in the 12 months to October 14, 2026: 19 resales in the older plats at a median $203 per heated square foot, and 16 first sales of new Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater at a median $267 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A recorded deed shows the price and the county's heated area. It does not show the roof date, the window type, the pool, the kitchen, the air conditioner's age or any builder credit behind a Shores sale. Our job at your door is to see those things and decide which of the 35 sales truly match your home. Our Stillwater neighborhood guide covers the plats, the Medical Boulevard entrance and the amenities, and our Stillwater seller guide covers the selling steps once you have a number.

Send the Stillwater valuation request on this page or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, and we will set a time, by video if you are away. Gathering a few Stillwater papers first, starting with your roof permit and wind mitigation form, lets us return a tighter written price range for your home.

The paper that moves an older Stillwater price most is the roof record. Florida bars an insurer from refusing to write or renew a policy solely because of roof age when the roof is under 15 years old, and a roof 15 years or older keeps that protection if an inspection shows 5 or more years of useful life left (Florida Statutes 627.7011). County records date Unit 1 homes from 2000 to 2007 (one from 2016), Unit 2 from 2005 and 2006 and Unit 3 from 2007 to 2013 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), so an original roof on any of them is at or near that line. For Citizens applications on policies effective on or after August 1, 2026, the roof year can arrive already filled in by a data vendor, and changing it takes documentation (Citizens, automatic roof age retrieval). Your permit and invoice are that documentation.

Bring your wind mitigation form too. Florida's consumer guide says homes built to the 2001 Florida Building Code or later are automatically eligible for a minimum 68 percent discount on the windstorm part of the premium, and a completed form stays valid for five years if the structure does not change (Florida Department of Financial Services, hurricane mitigation discounts). That code replaced local codes on March 1, 2002 (Florida Building Commission, milestones), and 12 Unit 1 homes carry a 2000 to 2002 build year on the roll (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). For those homes the inspector's findings, not the build year, set the credit.

Shores at Stillwater owners have a different packet. Bring your Pulte purchase agreement and options list, your closing statement (it shows any credit applied to closing costs or a rate buydown), and any letter from the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District confirming a prepayment of your lot's debt. The district's amended FY2025/26 budget records $25,727 of bond prepayments (Shores at Stillwater CDD, amended FY2025/26 budget), so prepayment does happen, and a lot with its debt prepaid would no longer carry the yearly debt line. Add your Pulte warranty booklet: Pulte's flyer says its warranties "are transferable to subsequent owner" (Pulte warranty flyer), and the remaining term is worth showing a buyer.

Every owner should bring flood papers: any elevation certificate, your flood policy declarations and your answers to the three questions on Florida's flood disclosure form, which a seller completes "at or before the time the sales contract is executed" (Florida Statutes 689.302). FEMA lets a flood policy be assigned to a buyer, who keeps its discount (FEMA, Risk Rating 2.0). You can also reach us through our contact page.

Buying your next home as well? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or see our Stillwater buyer guide. The visit carries no obligation, and it comes from Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

What Does a Stillwater CMA Cover That a Lender Appraisal Does Not?

A Stillwater CMA is our written price opinion, made before you list, and it names every Stillwater sale we used by plat, month, build year, county heated area and price. A lender's appraisal comes later, for the buyer's loan, and its comparable rules are written for the loan, not for your list price.

The comparison set starts in your own plat, because that is where the record shows the cleanest matches. The table shows where each Stillwater plat's CMA begins and which documents tend to move the number.

Stillwater plat Homes on the roll Comparables we start with Records that move the range
Unit 1 76 homes, median 2,204 heated sq ft, built mostly 2003 to 2005 Unit 1 resales, then Unit 2 resales of similar size Roof permit date, wind mitigation form (12 homes built 2000 to 2002), pool and cage permits
Unit 2 35 homes, median 2,181 sq ft, built 2005 and 2006 Unit 2 resales (2 in 12 months), so Unit 1 resales carry the weight Same as Unit 1, plus kitchen and bath update receipts
Unit 3 140 homes coded 0101, median 1,349 sq ft, built 2007 to 2013 Unit 3 resales of the same size and bedroom count Roof age, air conditioner date, impact glass or rated shutters
Shores at Stillwater 27 homes built 2025 and 2026, 107 lots coded vacant Pulte first sales of your plan and phase, read against Pulte's current sheet Closing statement credits, options list, CDD prepayment, warranty term

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser roll dated October 21, 2026).

Florida keeps the two documents apart by law: a broker may give a comparative market analysis or a broker price opinion, but "in no event" may it be called an appraisal (Florida Statutes 475.25). For a Shores at Stillwater home the gap between the two matters most. Fannie Mae treats a subdivision as new when there are "limited or no resales or the builder or developer is involved in the marketing or sale" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08), and every one of the 16 recorded Shores sales is a Pulte first sale (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A CMA that lays out each of those sales with its phase, size and month gives the buyer's appraiser a head start.

A Stillwater valuation tells you what your home is worth today. Most owners then ask how to sell it, what a buyer sees in Stillwater in Englewood, and how Stillwater prices sit beside the rest of Englewood, and each of those questions has its own page on our site, linked below.

Our Stillwater seller guide covers disclosures, the estoppel certificate, listing beside Pulte and a net sheet. Our Stillwater neighborhood guide walks through the five plats and the location on Medical Boulevard. The Florida seller closing costs guide explains each settlement line. For the wider town, open the Englewood home values page, the Englewood seller guide, our Englewood area guide and our Englewood new construction guide. Buying next? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.


Frequently Asked Questions About Stillwater Home Values

Stillwater owners ask these questions about value, and each answer rests on a county record, a district filing, a statute, a lender rule, a Pulte page read on a stated date or a primary market report. Unless an answer names another period, a sales figure counts qualified improved sales in the five Stillwater in Englewood plats recorded October 15, 2025 through October 14, 2026.

Those sales come from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A "resale" is a sale in Stillwater Units 1, 2 or 3; a "first sale" is the first qualified sale of a new Pulte home at Shores at Stillwater. Price per square foot always divides by the heated (living) area the county records. Where fewer than 10 sales sit behind a figure we call it a small group, show how many sales it holds and draw no percentage conclusion from it. Pulte prices are builder-stated, read November 18, 2026, and subject to change.

Data updated: November 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser file dated October 21, 2026, sales through October 14, 2026; Shores at Stillwater CDD Phase One methodology; Sarasota County Tax Collector 2026 millage; Freddie Mac rate for the week of November 12, 2026; Pulte, statute and agency pages read November 18, 2026).

What is my Stillwater home worth today?

Start with the plat, because Stillwater's sections sell in different price bands. In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, Unit 3 resales had a $282,500 median on 10 sales, Unit 1 a $550,000 median in a small group of 7, and Pulte's first sales at Shores at Stillwater a $523,250 median on 16 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Size, roof age and updates then narrow the number. Request a free Stillwater valuation and we will name the sales that match yours.

Is Stillwater in Englewood the same as Stillwater on the Bay in Sarasota?

No. Stillwater in Englewood sits in unincorporated Sarasota County with Englewood 34223 addresses, reached through Medical Boulevard, while Stillwater on the Bay is a separate place in Sarasota 34231. The county records five plats here: Stillwater Unit 1 (77 parcels), Unit 2 (36), Unit 3 (141), Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A (54) and Phase 1B (86) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). An online estimate that blends the two names values the wrong houses.

How many homes are in Stillwater, and how many lots are still unbuilt?

The October 21, 2026 roll lists 251 homes in the older plats (76 in Unit 1, 35 in Unit 2 and 140 in Unit 3) and 27 finished homes at Shores at Stillwater, built in 2025 and 2026, with 107 Shores lots still coded vacant (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Pulte's page speaks of "255 future front doors" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater), so new homes will keep closing next to the older plats.

What does a Stillwater Unit 3 home sell for?

Unit 3 is the small-home section coded 0101, with a median 1,349 heated square feet and build years from 2007 to 2013. Its 10 resales in the last 12 months had a $282,500 median and a middle half of $266,875 to $302,750, or $198 per heated square foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Over 24 months the median was $305,000 on 21 sales. Searchers often type "stillwater 3" for these homes.

What are the larger Stillwater Unit 1 homes worth?

Unit 1 holds 76 homes with a median 2,204 heated square feet, most built 2003 to 2005. Its 7 resales in 12 months, a small group, had a $550,000 median at $214 per square foot. Over 24 months, 12 sales recorded a $562,500 median at $261 per square foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The gap between those two per-foot figures is why a Unit 1 price must be built from the most recent sales, adjusted for time.

Why is a Stillwater Unit 2 home harder to price?

Unit 2 is small and sells rarely. Its 35 homes were built in 2005 and 2006, and only 2 sold in the last 12 months, at $550,000 and $620,000, too few for a median. Over 24 months, 6 sales recorded a $546,000 median at $251 per heated square foot (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Because Unit 1 homes are a similar size and era, an appraiser is likely to lean on Unit 1 resales as the closer evidence.

What do Stillwater homes sell for per square foot?

It depends on the plat and the age. Over 12 months the 19 resales in Units 1 to 3 recorded a $203 median per heated square foot, Unit 3 alone $198 and Unit 1 $214, while 16 Shores at Stillwater first sales recorded $267 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Divide your price by the county's heated area, not a listing's total under roof, or the comparison will mislead.

Does a third bedroom add value to a Stillwater Unit 3 home?

The recent record does not show it, but both groups are small. Over 12 months, 6 two-bedroom Unit 3 resales had a $291,000 median and 4 three-bedroom resales $282,000. Over 24 months, 12 two-bedroom sales had a $316,250 median and 9 three-bedroom sales $300,000 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Roof age, condition and updates appear to matter as much as the bedroom count, so we price both against matched sales.

Does a bigger older Stillwater home sell for more per square foot?

Not as a rule. Over 24 months, older-plat homes of 1,800 to 2,199 heated square feet recorded a $268 median per square foot on 9 sales, while 2,200 to 2,599 square foot homes recorded $215 on 9 sales and 1,200 to 1,399 square foot homes $222 on 11 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Two of those bands are small groups, and condition travels with size, so we compare like with like.

How do Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A and Phase 1B prices differ?

Phase 1B holds the villa product and Phase 1A the larger single-family plans. Across all first sales on file, Phase 1A recorded a $564,750 median at $290 per heated square foot on 12 sales, and Phase 1B, a small group of 4, $390,300 at $248 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The four Phase 1B sales were all 1,574 square foot homes, sold at $375,000, $379,000, $401,600 and $407,600.

Why do Shores at Stillwater homes sell for more per square foot than older Stillwater homes?

They are new. A never-occupied home is condition C1 under Fannie Mae's scale, while a well-kept older home with limited wear is C3 (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-06). Pulte also lists "Impact Glass & Tile Roof Included" (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater), and recorded first sales can include lot premiums, options and pools. Over 12 months that produced $267 per heated square foot against $203 for older resales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Is the Shores at Stillwater premium a fixed new-home premium?

No. The Shores first-sale median per heated square foot sits 31.3 percent above the older-plat resale median over 12 months, 20.0 percent over 24 months and 13.0 percent over 36 months. Against Unit 1 alone over 24 months the gap is 2.3 percent, on 12 Unit 1 sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Much of the 12-month gap reflects the 2025 to 2026 fall in older resale per-foot prices, not a set markup for new construction.

Are Stillwater home prices dropping?

Older Stillwater resales have recorded lower per-foot prices since 2025. The older-plat median ran $257 per heated square foot in the first half of 2025 (11 sales), $215 in the second half (a small group of 6) and $200 in the first half of 2026 (15 sales) (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Ten of the 17 older-plat resales recorded in 2026 were smaller Unit 3 homes, so part of that path is a change in which homes sold, not only in price.

Why did one 2023 quarter show a Stillwater median of $860,000?

Because only three homes sold. The third quarter of 2023 recorded 3 older-plat resales at a median $860,000 and $316 per heated square foot, a small group weighted toward large Unit 1 homes (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A quarter with so few sales says more about which houses sold than about the market. We read Stillwater by half-year and 12-month windows and by plat for that reason.

Is my Stillwater home still worth more per square foot than in 2015?

On the recorded medians, yes. Unit 3 resales ran $143 per heated square foot in 2015 (8 sales) against $198 in 2026 (10 sales), and Unit 1 ran $153 in 2015 (7 sales) against $248 in 2026, a small group of 5 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Different houses sold in each year, and prices do not reflect later roofs or remodels, so a single home's path can differ.

How often do Stillwater homes sell?

Not often, which makes each sale count. In the 12 months to October 14, 2026, 19 of the 251 older-plat homes sold, 7.6 percent; over 24 months the count was 37, or 14.7 percent (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). With so few sales a year, one unusual Stillwater sale can move a plat median, which is why we look at each comparable rather than only the average.

Will my Stillwater home sell for more than I paid?

Most recent resales did. Of the 19 older-plat resales in the last 12 months, 15 had an earlier qualified sale on file: 12 resold above the price recorded at the earlier sale and 3 below, with a median change of plus 12.2 percent over a median 98 months between sales (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The earlier price does not include a roof, pool or remodel added since, so it is not a like-for-like pair.

Does it matter when I bought my Stillwater home?

The record says it does, though the groups are small. Among the 15 repeat-sale pairs of the last 12 months, all 10 homes whose earlier sale came before 2020 resold above the earlier price. All 3 whose earlier sale came in 2022 or later resold below it (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). That pattern fits the older-plat per-foot medians, which ran $263 in 2022 and $282 in 2023 against $203 in 2026.

What is Pulte asking for a new home at Shores at Stillwater?

On November 18, 2026, Pulte listed seven plans from $309,990 (Colton villa, 1,321 square feet) to $565,990 (Mystique Grande, 2,870 square feet and up), with Distinctive single-family plans from $399,990 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). These are builder-stated base prices, read November 18, 2026, and subject to change. Lot premiums, options and pools can move the final figure, which helps explain why recorded first sales sit higher.

Does Pulte's Colton villa cap what a Stillwater Unit 3 home can bring?

It sets the ceiling a buyer will check first. The Colton starts at $309,990 for 1,321 square feet, builder-stated and read November 18, 2026 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Unit 3 resales recorded a $282,500 median at a median 1,349 heated square feet over 12 months (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), $27,490 below the Colton's base (our arithmetic). The new villa also carries a CDD line that the records indicate Unit 3 does not.

Why does Pulte's Ellenwood quick move-in matter to Shores villa owners?

Because it asks less than any recorded villa first sale. On November 18, 2026, Pulte listed an Ellenwood villa quick move-in at $364,990, marked down from $405,880 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). The county recorded four Phase 1B villa first sales of 1,574 square feet at $375,000, $379,000, $401,600 and $407,600 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A Shores villa resale competes with that asking price first.

Does Pulte's November credit lower what my Stillwater home is worth?

Not dollar for dollar. For contracts accepted November 2 to 30, 2026, Pulte offers a pool valued at $69,500 or a credit of up to $77,000, builder-stated (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). An appraiser using a Pulte sale must adjust it downward for concessions, and "positive adjustments for sales or financing concessions are not acceptable" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09). Buyers still compare your price with Pulte's net figure.

Will Pulte keep offering incentives next to Stillwater?

PulteGroup says so. Its quarterly report for the period ended September 30, 2026 states "we expect our sales incentives to remain elevated," while its Florida segment recorded 1,823 third-quarter net new orders, up 6 percent, and a 3,097 home backlog, up 15 percent; it also named lower revenues in its "Southwest Florida operations" (PulteGroup Form 10-Q). With 107 Shores lots still coded vacant, Stillwater resales will keep meeting an active builder.

What other new homes compete with Stillwater in Englewood?

M/I Homes markets Sandpiper Pointe in Englewood 34223 as 85 single-family homes "from the low $400s," with plans from 1,521 square feet, and advertises "NO CDD FEES," builder-stated and read November 18, 2026 (M/I Homes, Sandpiper Pointe). Those plan sizes overlap the larger Stillwater Unit 1 and Unit 2 homes. Our Englewood new construction guide covers the other builders a Stillwater buyer may tour.

Do Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater hold their value?

Too early to measure. The first Shores first sale on the county file closed in February 2026, and no Shores resale has been recorded yet; the 16 first sales closed at a $523,250 median (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Until owners resell, the evidence is Pulte's own price sheet, which on November 18, 2026 showed quick move-in homes marked down by $40,890 and $73,790 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater).

How will the first Shores at Stillwater resale be appraised?

As a sale in a new subdivision. Fannie Mae requires at least one settled sale from inside the subdivision and one from outside, and says "a resale is preferable if it is verifiable and does not involve the subject builder or developer" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08). Every one of the 16 recorded Shores sales so far is a Pulte first sale (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), so the first verifiable resale will weigh heavily in every later one.

Will an appraiser use Pulte's sales to value my older Stillwater home?

Possibly as one comparable, but the closer evidence is your own plat. Fannie Mae says "sale activity from within the neighborhood is the best indicator of value," and builder sales need "discussion and analysis of sales concessions and upgrades" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08). Over 24 months Unit 3 recorded 21 resales and Unit 1 recorded 12 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), enough for in-plat comparisons.

How old can the Stillwater sales in my appraisal be?

Fannie Mae says sales closed within the last 12 months "should be used," and an older sale may serve with a time adjustment, which "must be supported by evidence" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09). That matters in Stillwater, where the older-plat median moved from $257 per heated square foot in the first half of 2025 to $200 in the first half of 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A 2025 sale may need a supported time adjustment, though part of that shift reflects which homes sold.

How long is an appraisal good for on a Stillwater sale?

Fannie Mae requires the home to be appraised within the 12 months before the note date, with an update once the report is more than four months old (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.2-04). FHA's initial validity is 180 days, extendable by update to one year (HUD Mortgagee Letter 2022-11). Where the Stillwater older-plat median shifted between half-years, an older report may describe an older market.

Can a buyer of my Stillwater home skip the appraisal?

Sometimes. Fannie Mae's automated underwriting can offer value acceptance on eligible one-unit loans, excluding prices or values of $1,000,000 or more; a recently built home qualifies only when an "as is" prior appraisal exists (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.4-10). Every recorded Stillwater sale in the last 12 months sits below that line (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). The lender's system decides, not the seller.

What condition rating will my 2000s Stillwater home get?

That depends on what has been replaced. Fannie Mae's C3 covers a well-maintained home with limited depreciation where some components may be updated, and C4 covers some minor deferred maintenance (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-06). Older Stillwater homes were built from 2000 to 2013, plus one in 2016 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), so a newer roof, air conditioner and kitchen are what separate a C3 from a C4.

What can I do if a VA appraisal of my Stillwater home is coming in low?

Use the Tidewater window. Before a VA purchase appraisal is finished, the appraiser notifies the requester if value looks short of the price and allows 2 business days for more sales data (VA appraisal policies bulletin). For a Stillwater home that means handing over the closest in-plat resales, such as recent Unit 3 sales for a Unit 3 home, with their sizes and months of sale.

How much can I contribute toward a Stillwater buyer's costs?

It depends on the loan. Fannie Mae caps contributions on a principal residence at 3 percent above 90 percent loan-to-value, 6 percent from 75.01 to 90 percent and 9 percent at 75 percent or less (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02). FHA allows up to 6 percent, buydowns included (HUD Handbook 4000.1). On the $282,500 Unit 3 median, 3 percent is $8,475 and 6 percent $16,950 (our arithmetic).

How accurate is an online estimate for a Stillwater home?

Less accurate than most owners expect. One national brokerage's own accuracy page, read November 18, 2026, reports a 7.56 percent median error for off-market Florida homes, with 36.36 percent of estimates within 5 percent. On the $282,500 Unit 3 median that median miss is about $21,357, and on the $550,000 Unit 1 median about $41,580 (our arithmetic from Sarasota County Property Appraiser medians). A model that mixes Shores first sales with older resales misses further.

Does the federal AVM rule protect me from a bad online value?

No. The interagency rule, effective October 1, 2025, sets quality-control standards for models used in valuations for certain mortgages secured by a consumer's principal dwelling (Federal Register, AVM quality control rule; CFPB). It is written for mortgage valuations, not consumer website estimates. In Stillwater, where 19 resales and 16 builder first sales recorded in the same 12 months (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), a human read of each comparable still matters.

Do older Stillwater homes pay the Shores at Stillwater CDD?

The records indicate they do not. The district's legal description begins at the southeast corner of Stillwater Unit Two and runs along its east line (Shores at Stillwater CDD, April 20, 2026 board book), and the district does not appear on the 2026 Tax Collector levy sheet (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage). Owners in Units 1, 2 and 3 should confirm on their own tax bill.

How much is the Shores at Stillwater CDD, and how does it affect value?

For Phase One, the maximum annual debt assessment is $1,382.68 on a 34-foot lot and $1,914.48 on a 52-foot lot, from original principal of $18,580.37 and $25,726.66 per lot (Shores at Stillwater CDD, June 15, 2026 book). Add the $276 operations rate and, at 7.11 percent with 20 percent down, those lines displace about $21,900 and $28,900 of the price a payment-limited buyer can finance (our estimate).

Is the Shores at Stillwater CDD on my 2026 tax bill?

No CDD line for Shores at Stillwater appears on the 2026 Tax Collector levy sheet (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage). The district's FY2026/27 budget marks operations assessments "To Be Collected At Closings," at a $276 rate if the district were on the roll (Shores at Stillwater CDD, FY2026/27 budget). The $2,970,000 of bonds run to a final maturity in May 2056 (Shores at Stillwater CDD, amended FY2025/26 budget), so the debt line follows a Shores home for decades.

How does an appraiser treat the CDD on a Shores at Stillwater home?

As a cost the market may price. Fannie Mae notes that homes in these districts "often compete against properties that are either subject to a significantly different assessment or no assessment at all," and tells appraisers to analyze similarly affected sales (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.4-09). That is Stillwater's layout exactly: Shores carries the district, the records indicate Unit 2 next door does not, and no Shores resale exists yet to measure the effect (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

What are Stillwater HOA dues, and how do they change value?

Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). Florida corporate filings list three associations: Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc., Stillwater Unit Three Homeowners Association, Inc. and Shores at Stillwater Homeowners Association, Inc.; confirm each on Sunbiz. The estoppel certificate states the dues and any balance. Lenders count association dues in the buyer's monthly housing expense (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-03), so the figure affects what a Stillwater buyer can pay.

Is the county's just value what my Stillwater home is worth?

No. Just value is the Property Appraiser's market value as of January 1, the start of the line that runs through assessed and taxable value to the bill (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, appraisal process). The statute also tells the county to allow for "the usual and reasonable fees and costs of the sale" (Florida Statutes 193.011). A Stillwater sale in mid-2026 reflects a later market than the January figure.

Why did my new Shores at Stillwater home's first tax bill look so low?

Florida values property as of January 1, and improvements not substantially completed on that date carry no value (Florida Statutes 192.042). The county adds: "There are no partial assessments in Florida" (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, why did my taxes increase). Of the 27 finished Shores homes on the roll, 19 carry a 2026 build year (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), so many will see the house added on the next roll.

What property tax will a buyer of my Stillwater home pay?

The 2026 countywide rate for unincorporated parcels is 11.3068 mills (11.4737 in 2025), with the school share at 5.9290 (Sarasota County Tax Collector, 2026 millage), plus a flat $290.78 Englewood Area Fire Control District charge per home (Englewood Area Fire Control District). After a sale the assessment resets to just value the following January 1 (Florida Statutes 193.155), so your capped bill is not your buyer's.

Can I take my Save Our Homes benefit from Stillwater to my next home?

Yes, within limits. Florida lets a new homestead carry the lesser of $500,000 or the difference between just value and assessed value of the prior homestead (Florida Statutes 193.155), and the 2026 cap on homestead increases was 2.7 percent (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, Save Our Homes). Older-plat Stillwater homes with a sale on file show a median 9 years since that sale (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), so a homesteaded owner there may carry a sizable cap difference.

Can I still appeal my 2026 Stillwater value?

Not through the Value Adjustment Board this year. The cut-off for a value petition is 25 days after the TRIM notice is mailed, and the date is printed on the notice (Sarasota County Property Appraiser, VAB petitions). The 2026 window has closed; the next chance comes with the August 2027 notice, based on the January 1, 2027 value. Evidence then means sales from your own Stillwater plat near that January date.

Did Amendment 3 change what my Stillwater home is worth?

Not on any record we can price from yet. Florida Election Watch shows Amendment 3 with 61.98 percent yes, and certification was scheduled for November 17, 2026, but it is not confirmed certified as of November 18, 2026 (Florida Election Watch). Homestead exemptions do not reach "assessments for special benefits" (Florida Statutes 196.031), so the $290.78 fire charge and any Shores CDD line stay as they are.

Will my original roof lower my Stillwater sale price?

It can, through the buyer's insurance quote. Citizens requires documentation of at least five years of remaining life for shingle roofs older than 25 years and for tile, slate or metal roofs older than 50 years (Citizens, roof rule changes). An original shingle roof on a 2000 or 2001 Unit 1 home is 25 or 26 years old in 2026 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). A dated replacement permit removes that question for a buyer.

Is my 2000 or 2001 Stillwater Unit 1 home built to the Florida Building Code?

Possibly not. The first statewide code replaced local codes on March 1, 2002 (Florida Building Commission, milestones), and the roll shows 10 Unit 1 homes built in 2000 or 2001 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Citizens reads the code in effect when the building permit was first submitted, and on the April 2026 form an "unknown or does not meet" answer means code discounts are not applied (Citizens, wind loss mitigation guide), so the inspector's findings carry the credit.

Do impact windows add value to a Stillwater home?

Mostly through insurance and buyer comparison. Pulte says impact glass windows are "included with every home" at Shores at Stillwater (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater), so an older Stillwater home with documented impact glass or rated shutters competes more closely with its new neighbor. The 2025 Cost vs Value report for the Sarasota market shows vinyl window replacement recovering 84.6 percent of a $20,688 cost (JLC Cost vs Value 2025, Sarasota).

Which updates pay back best before selling a Stillwater home?

Small, visible ones. In the 2025 Cost vs Value report for the Sarasota market, a garage door replacement recovered 204 percent of its $5,302 cost and a midrange minor kitchen remodel 104.4 percent of $28,579, while a midrange major kitchen remodel recovered 49.7 percent of $81,115 and an asphalt shingle roof 64.9 percent of $34,028 (JLC Cost vs Value 2025, Sarasota). On an older Stillwater home the roof still decides insurability.

Does a pool add value to a Stillwater home?

Buyers notice one, but no Stillwater pool premium is published, and we print no figure. Pulte's November offer values "a standard pool" at $69,500 on select to-be-built Shores homes, builder-stated and read November 18, 2026 (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). An older Stillwater resale with a pool and cage saves a buyer the build and the wait, so we price it from permits, condition and any resales that have one.

Is a Stillwater lake or preserve lot worth more than an interior lot?

Buyers often look for water or preserve views, but no primary source gives a Stillwater lot premium, and we print no figure. Pulte markets "Water and preserve views" at Shores at Stillwater (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). An appraiser must support any location adjustment with market reaction (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09), so we look for resales on similar lots in your plat.

Is my Stillwater home in a flood zone?

It varies by lot, so we check yours. The only lot-level reading on file is Zone X at one Stillwater Unit 1 address; no other Stillwater lot has been read. Owners can look up their own address on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center. Florida's flood disclosure asks about flooding during your ownership, flood claims and federal flood assistance (Florida Statutes 689.302), so your answers travel with your value.

Do flood insurance changes in 2027 affect Stillwater buyers?

They can. Citizens already requires flood coverage on wind policies with a dwelling value of $400,000 or more, and from January 1, 2027 on all such policies, regardless of value (Citizens Property Insurance, flood). The National Flood Insurance Program is authorized only through December 11, 2026 (Congressional Research Service, IN10835). A Stillwater buyer prices that premium into the payment, and an assignable policy can help.

Did hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton change Stillwater values?

No public report naming Stillwater as damaged was found. The National Hurricane Center reports that most surge sensors placed in Port Charlotte and Englewood "remained dry" during Ian (NHC, Hurricane Ian report), and Milton made landfall on Siesta Key at 0030 UTC on October 10, 2024 (NHC, Hurricane Milton report). The storms most likely show up in Stillwater values through insurance cost and the roof and four-point questions buyers now ask of homes built 2000 to 2013.

How do today's mortgage rates change what buyers pay for a Stillwater home?

Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed rate was 7.11 percent for the week of November 12, 2026, against 6.24 percent a year earlier (Freddie Mac PMMS). On a $550,000 Unit 1 home with 20 percent down, principal and interest is $2,959.91 a month at 7.11 percent against $2,706.29 at 6.24 percent (our arithmetic). A seller credit toward a buydown, inside the loan's limits, can answer Pulte's financing without cutting the headline price.

What monthly payment does a Stillwater buyer face?

At 7.11 percent, 20 percent down, 11.3068 mills on the price, the $2,901 Citizens Sarasota HO3 average and the $290.78 fire charge, with HOA dues excluded because no primary source states them, a $285,000 older-plat home runs $2,068.29 a month and a $550,000 Unit 1 home $3,744.12 (our arithmetic from Freddie Mac, Sarasota County Tax Collector and Citizens). At $425,000, a Shores 52-foot lot adds $182.54 for the CDD.

Can an assumable FHA or VA loan add value to my Stillwater home?

It can, to a buyer who qualifies and can pay the gap between your price and the loan balance in cash. VA charges a 0.5 percent funding fee on an assumption (VA, funding fee and closing costs). On a $300,000 balance, 5.5 percent against today's 7.11 percent average (Freddie Mac PMMS) is $314.75 a month less in principal and interest (our arithmetic). Tell us the rate and type of your loan at the walkthrough.

How is the Sarasota County market doing beside Stillwater?

Firmer than the older Stillwater plats. Sarasota County's October 2026 single-family median was $490,000, up 10.1 percent, with 4.0 months of supply and a median 40 days to contract (REALTOR Association of Sarasota and Manatee, October 2026). FHFA's metro index read 478.67 in 2026 Q2, 0.5 percent lower than a year earlier and 4.6 percent below its 2023 Q3 peak (FHFA via FRED). Stillwater's older-plat per-foot medians fell further than the metro index, partly because of the mix of homes sold.

How long do Stillwater homes take to sell?

Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 18, 2026). Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, months of supply and active listings for Stillwater are MLS-only fields. For context only, Sarasota County single-family homes went under contract in a median 40 days in October 2026 and sellers received a median 95.5 percent of original list price (REALTOR Association of Sarasota and Manatee, October 2026). Those are county figures, not Stillwater figures.

When is the best time of year to sell a Stillwater home?

Late winter and spring, on the record. From 2015 to October 2026, older-plat Stillwater resales closed 24 times in February, 22 in March and 23 in April, against 6 in August and 7 in September (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Closings in spring mean contracts signed in winter, so a January listing with roof, wind mitigation and flood papers ready meets the most buyers.

Does any builder warranty still cover an older Stillwater home?

Not for construction defects in most cases. Florida requires construction claims to be brought within 7 years of the certificate of occupancy (Florida Statutes 95.11), and every Unit 1, 2 and 3 home was built from 2000 to 2016 (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Pulte advertises a 10-year limited structural warranty at Shores at Stillwater (Pulte, Shores at Stillwater). Recent system receipts help an older home close that gap.

What do I need to send for a free Stillwater valuation?

Your address, plat, any roof or air conditioner replacement dates, a list of updates with years, and your best time for a call. Shores owners should add the plan name and any options. We return a written range built from the 35 qualified Stillwater sales of the last 12 months and the older windows where they help (Sarasota County Property Appraiser). Request your free Stillwater home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.


What Sellers Say About Working With McGreevy and Comisar

A valuation is only as useful as the team that stands behind it at the negotiating table. These five-star reviews come from sellers who worked with McGreevy and Comisar, and they describe the pricing judgment, marketing and follow-through we bring to a Stillwater in Englewood listing.

McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Southwest Florida listing team, recognized with the Gulfshore Life 5 Star Award for customer satisfaction for 21 straight years. Each quote below is labelled with the site where the client posted it and is quoted exactly as written. We do not edit, combine or summarize client words.

Sandra Decker, five stars

★★★★★ "We had been on the market for several months with no offers. When we signed with Marc our house was sold in 2 weeks. He has a unique system for selling homes."

Verified Google review

Derek Dixon, five stars

★★★★★ "Marc Comisar did an excellent job working with a very difficult client (me) selling our condo in a tough condo market. He went above and beyond."

Verified Google review

Dennis Overton, five stars

★★★★★ "I can only say he is a refreshing and highly motivated professional. No tricks exaggerations nor falsehoods. His way of bringing quality clients is exceptional. He does not bring lookers. He brings buyers!"

Verified Google review

Katharine Shea, five stars

★★★★★ "Marc and Jesse were amazing to work with AGAIN! We just sold our 3rd home with them and couldn't have been happier! If we ever move again we'll always call Jesse and Marc!"

Verified Google review

Paul Schenck, five stars

★★★★★ "Marc helped me through the home selling process every step. He was very responsive and knows the market well. With another agent my house did not sell for one year, but Marc got me 3 offers within a few months."

Verified Zillow review

When you value your Stillwater home with a top-reviewed team of Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, the partners who price it are the partners who negotiate it. Read every client review on our Google Business Profile. Request your free Stillwater home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.


Downloadable Documents

Every figure on this Stillwater in Englewood valuation page traces to a public document. These are the ones a Stillwater owner opens when the question is value: county sales and roll files, just value and tax sources, district budgets and bond records, flood and insurance rules, builder filings and appraisal rules. Each link goes to the publisher.

Document Publisher What a Stillwater seller uses it for Link
Parcel and sales downloads Sarasota County Property Appraiser The qualified Stillwater sales and the October 21, 2026 roll behind every figure here SCPA download data
Appraisal process Sarasota County Property Appraiser How just, assessed and taxable value differ on a Stillwater TRIM notice SCPA appraisal process
2026 TRIM supplement Sarasota County Property Appraiser The January 1 valuation date and the reset after a sale SCPA 2026 TRIM supplement
Save Our Homes and portability Sarasota County Property Appraiser The 2.7 percent cap for 2026 and how a cap difference moves to a new homestead SCPA Save Our Homes
Value Adjustment Board petitions Sarasota County Property Appraiser The 25-day petition window after the TRIM notice SCPA VAB petitions
2026 ad valorem and non-ad valorem sheet Sarasota County Tax Collector The 11.3068 mill countywide rate for unincorporated Stillwater parcels Tax Collector 2026 millage
Assessments, fees and charges Englewood Area Fire Control District The flat $290.78 residential charge for 2026 to 2027 Englewood fire assessments
Section 193.011, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The factors behind just value, including costs of sale Section 193.011
Section 193.155, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The reset after a sale and the portability limit Section 193.155
Section 192.042, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature Why a Shores home finished after January 1 is taxed as a lot that year Section 192.042
FY2026/27 final budget Shores at Stillwater CDD The $276 operations rate and collection at closings Shores at Stillwater CDD budget
June 15, 2026 board book Shores at Stillwater CDD Per-lot principal and the maximum annual debt assessment by lot width Shores at Stillwater CDD June book
April 20, 2026 board book Shores at Stillwater CDD The district boundary along Stillwater Unit Two Shores at Stillwater CDD April book
Section 190.048, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The CDD disclosure in an initial sale contract Section 190.048
Flood requirement Citizens Property Insurance The $400,000 dwelling step now and the January 1, 2027 rule for all policies Citizens flood
Roof rule changes Citizens Property Insurance The 25-year and 50-year roof documentation lines Citizens roof rules
Section 627.7011, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The 15-year roof rule and the roof inspection right Section 627.7011
Section 689.302, Florida Statutes Florida Legislature The flood disclosure a seller completes before the contract is signed Section 689.302
Hurricane mitigation discounts Florida Department of Financial Services The minimum windstorm credit for homes built to the 2001 code or later DFS mitigation discounts
Commission milestones Florida Building Commission The 2002, 2009 and 2012 code dates behind each Stillwater plat FBC milestones
Form 10-Q, quarter ended September 30, 2026 PulteGroup (SEC) Pulte's incentive outlook and its Florida orders and backlog PulteGroup 10-Q
Selling Guide B4-1.3-08, Comparable Sales Fannie Mae The inside and outside comparable rule for a new subdivision Fannie Mae B4-1.3-08
Selling Guide B4-1.3-09, Adjustments Fannie Mae How builder concessions and time are adjusted on comparables Fannie Mae B4-1.3-09
Selling Guide B4-1.4-09, Special Assessments Fannie Mae How an appraiser reports the CDD on a Shores home Fannie Mae B4-1.4-09
October 2026 market report REALTOR Association of Sarasota and Manatee The Sarasota County single-family median, supply and days to contract RASM October 2026
Primary Mortgage Market Survey Freddie Mac The weekly 30-year fixed rate behind every payment example Freddie Mac PMMS

Sources

Every source below was read between October 21 and November 18, 2026, and each figure on this page carries its own date and window beside it in the text. Primary documents come first: Florida Statutes and rules, state and federal agencies, Fannie Mae, FHA and VA guides, Sarasota County, its Property Appraiser and Tax Collector, the Shores at Stillwater Community Development District, FEMA and Citizens. Builder prices come from Pulte's and M/I Homes' own pages, read November 18, 2026, and are builder-stated. Stillwater sales figures come from the Sarasota County Property Appraiser parcel and sales file dated October 21, 2026 (12-month window October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026), for the five recorded plats Stillwater Unit 1, Unit 2 and Unit 3 and Shores at Stillwater Phase 1A and Phase 1B. No listing site, brokerage or valuation aggregator was used for any figure on this page.

Talk To Us About Your Stillwater Home Value

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, who together bring over 45 years of combined direct experience. For this Stillwater in Englewood page we tracked 35 qualified home sales from October 15, 2025 to October 14, 2026 across the five recorded plats, 19 of them resales in Stillwater Units 1 to 3 and 16 first sales of new Pulte homes at Shores at Stillwater (Sarasota County Property Appraiser).

Those sales sit beside the county's roll for all 394 Stillwater parcels (Sarasota County Property Appraiser), Pulte's dated price sheet and the Shores at Stillwater CDD's own budget and bond records, and we tracked every tax, assessment, flood and insurance rule a buyer's lender, insurer and appraiser will apply to your home, so each figure here comes from a public record you can check. For the selling steps that follow a number, see our Stillwater seller guide, or reach us through our contact page.

If you are thinking, "I need someone to sell my house in Stillwater, Florida," McGreevy and Comisar helps homeowners price, market, negotiate, and sell with a local strategy built for Englewood, Charlotte County, Sarasota County, Port Charlotte, Punta Gorda, Babcock Ranch, Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers. Whether you are selling in Stillwater, at Englewood Beach, on Lemon Bay, on Manasota Key, Englewood Isles, Englewood East, Oyster Creek, Boca Royale, Beachwalk by Manasota Key or Grove City, our team provides local market guidance, professional listing exposure, and a clear plan to help you sell confidently.

Your Local Real Estate Experts

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Contact McGreevy and Comisar

Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072,

Marc Comisar: (239) 287-5873

Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more at DomainRealtyGroup.com, or read about McGreevy and Comisar. For buying questions, see how we represent Englewood buyers, and for a seller's first step, request your free Stillwater home valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and there is no obligation.

Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) are licensed Florida real estate professionals regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) under Chapter 475, Florida Statutes.

Updated November 2026. This page is general information about Stillwater home values, not an appraisal and not legal or tax advice. Market figures change with each county file and statutory figures change annually. For your specific property, ask us for the file.