Burnt Store Meadows in Punta Gorda: a deed-restricted city neighborhood of 751 homes on greenbelt lots. Recorded sales, the city tax and fee layers, flood readings by street and the rules. Call McGreevy and Comisar at (239) 898-6072.
Updated October 2026 · Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty
McGreevy and Comisar are the team Burnt Store Meadows sellers call first, and the team buyers call when they want the city tax line, the fee layers, the flood reading by street and the county's recorded sales answered before they write an offer. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar lead the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012 and have been among the Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
Burnt Store Meadows is a deed-restricted neighborhood of single-family homes in Punta Gorda, Florida, platted as Punta Gorda Isles Section 18 and set inside the city limits between US 41 and Burnt Store Road. It is not Burnt Store Isles, Burnt Store Village, Burnt Store Lakes or Burnt Store Marina, which are different places with different governments and different rules. Its ZIP code, 33955, is mostly unincorporated, but every home here is inside the City of Punta Gorda.
This guide is built from the Charlotte County Property Appraiser's public roll and sales files, the City's rules and rates, the association's recorded documents, FEMA's flood maps and the school district's own tools. Every figure carries its source and date, and where a record is not public we say so instead of estimating.
McGreevy and Comisar price Burnt Store Meadows homes on the records that move them: 42 Charlotte County recorded sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, the City's tax district 150, the west-end flood line and builder-direct new homes. The team has been #1 in Southwest Florida since 2012 and Top 1% nationally since 2008.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026, roll and sales files of October 4, 2026).
If you're searching for the best realtor for Burnt Store Meadows, whether you're ready to sell your Burnt Store Meadows home or buy your next one, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Nationally since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc.
The Burnt Store Meadows market record (the 12 months to September 9, 2026, Charlotte County recorded sales): 42 home sales · median $370,000 · 37 resales at a $363,000 median · 5 builder-direct new homes at a $630,000 median · highest recorded sale $680,000 · median $189.87 per square foot of county heated area · 11 recorded lot sales (vacant land) at a $55,000 median. Days on market and sale-to-list: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.)
For luxury Burnt Store Meadows sellers: Premium marketing, cinematic video, drone, professional photography, qualified-buyer database, discretion and off-market capability when needed.
Honors and recognition:
Selling your Burnt Store Meadows home? Get a free home valuation at https://mcgreevyandcomisar.com/home-valuation OR call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 (confidential conversations welcome for luxury listings). Selling here? Start with our guide to selling a home in Burnt Store Meadows.
Buying a home in Burnt Store Meadows? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 for a personalized buyer consultation.
Sellers comparing the best real estate agents in Punta Gorda can start with the county record on this page. As the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate, and every Burnt Store Meadows valuation we write starts from Charlotte County's recorded sales, not a portal estimate.
Burnt Store Meadows is a deed-restricted neighborhood of 751 homes and 144 vacant lots inside the City of Punta Gorda, with one mandatory association, a city tax line, greenbelts behind the lots and a flood map that changes on the west end. These eight points carry the rest of the page.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; FEMA, county and city records read October 21, 2026).
Burnt Store Meadows is covered here in the order a buyer or seller meets the questions: what the neighborhood is, what sold, how it started and is laid out, who governs it, what it costs, the rules, the parts, storms and flood, daily life, the comparison with Seminole Lakes and the FAQs.
Living in Burnt Store Meadows means owning a single-family home in a deed-restricted Punta Gorda neighborhood of greenbelts and streets named for trees and flowers, with one mandatory association, city services, no gate and no on-site pool, clubhouse or golf course. Publix and Home Depot are about 5 minutes away, and downtown Punta Gorda about 12.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll of October 4, 2026, our count; FEMA, county, city and association records read October 21, 2026; estimated drive times from the center of the neighborhood, computed October 21, 2026).
Burnt Store Meadows is a deed-restricted, non-waterfront neighborhood of single-family homes on a platted grid of streets, with park-like greenbelts behind most of the lots. The neighborhood's association describes it as "a Deed Restricted Community in Punta Gorda, Florida", "located directly off US 41 or Burnt Store Road", with "Park-like greenbelts behind homes" and "City living with a rural atmosphere" (Burnt Store Meadows POA).
The county roll supplies the numbers behind that description. In residential blocks 361 to 406 it lists 895 parcels: 744 coded single-family, 3 single-family variants, 4 small multi-family buildings and 144 vacant residential lots. Of the 895, 751 carry a year built, so 751 is the number of homes this guide counts. The first was built in 1982, the newest in 2025, and the median is 2002 (county roll, our count; Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll, October 4, 2026).
Section 18 has no canals and no boat access. That single fact separates Burnt Store Meadows from several neighbors that share its name, and it is why this guide never borrows a canal fact from a different section.
Five places share the Burnt Store name, and mixing them up changes the taxes, the rules and the flood map. Burnt Store Meadows is Punta Gorda Isles Section 18, inside the City of Punta Gorda. Burnt Store Isles is Punta Gorda Isles Section 15, a canal community around Twin Isles Country Club. Burnt Store Village is Section 16, outside the city limits. Burnt Store Lakes is Section 21. Burnt Store Marina is Section 22, in Lee County, with its own marina and country club.
Three more names belong to separate plats: Burnt Store Golf Villas (on San Rocco Dr, with its own homeowners association), Burnt Store Park and Burnt Store Square. They are not part of this neighborhood.
ZIP code does not settle the question either. Every home in Burnt Store Meadows is in ZIP 33955, but ZIP 33955 is mostly unincorporated, so the code alone does not tell you whether a home is in the City. The commercial frontage on US 41 carries ZIP 33950. "Punta Gorda Isles" is a platting program, not a single place, and Section 18 has no canals, no seawalls and no canal maintenance district. Online, the same short name is used for more than one association: the Meadows association's website is bsmpoa.com, and the Marina association uses a different site.
(Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and county subdivision layer, our analysis; association websites read October 21, 2026.)
Burnt Store Meadows is inside the City of Punta Gorda (tax district 150). The county parcel record for a home on Satsuma Dr shows tax district 150 and "In City of Punta Gorda: YES", the county's city-boundary layer contains every point we sampled, and the City's Land Development Regulations, Sec. 3.13, write the Special Residential Overlay District for the Punta Gorda Isles plats, naming Section 18 (City of Punta Gorda, Chapter 26 Land Development Regulations).
The City's comprehensive plan adds a boundary marker: it says the southern boundary of the city "generally follows the southern boundary of the Burnt Store Meadows Subdivision" (City of Punta Gorda, Comprehensive Plan 2045). The original recorded declarations, which carry no recording date on the association's copies, already provide that the land "may hereinafter be taken into the City of Punta Gorda".
For an owner, being in the City decides four practical things. The tax bill carries the City of Punta Gorda levy of 3.9928 mills in place of the county's law enforcement and lighting levies. Zoning, permits and code enforcement come from the City. The City is the certificated water and wastewater provider on the county's service-area layers. And the Special Residential Overlay adds City rules on top of the recorded declarations. The sections on governance, cost and rules take each in turn.
Burnt Store Meadows sits at the southern edge of the City of Punta Gorda, between US 41 (Tamiami Trail) and Burnt Store Road. It is platted as Punta Gorda Isles Section 18, Plat Book 10, Page 4 (the recorded declarations cite pages 4-A through 4-Q), in residential blocks 361 to 406, with 46 street names from a botanical set: Royal Poinciana has the most parcels (79), then Gold Tree (58), N Plum Tree (57), S Blue Sage (52), N Blue Sage (43), Trumpet Tree (30), Satsuma Dr (27) and Carambola (26).
Measured as free-flow drives from the center of the neighborhood on October 21, 2026, Publix at Burnt Store Marketplace (3941 Tamiami Trl) is about 2.5 road miles and 5 minutes away, Punta Gorda Airport is about 4.7 miles and 13 minutes, and Punta Gorda City Hall is about 6.1 miles and 12 minutes. Add time for traffic and signals. The full drive-time table is in the drive-time section of this guide.
Residents reach the neighborhood from US 41 and from Burnt Store Road. The association's own words are "located directly off US 41 or Burnt Store Road", and its January 2026 newsletter placed yard-sale volunteers "at the Burnt Store Road and 41 entrances" (Meadows Connection, January 2026). The association's documents name no gate and no guardhouse, and neither does this guide.
Royal Poinciana is the spine road. The City's comprehensive plan calls it a primary collector. The US 41 side carried 21,620 vehicles a day between Zemel Rd and Taylor Rd in 2025 (Florida Department of Transportation 2025 traffic counts). The 2020 US 41 Corridor Vision Plan has a "Burnt Store Meadows Study Segment" and notes the U-turns at Taylor Road and Royal Poinciana (US 41 Corridor Vision Plan), and the City council agenda of November 1, 2023 raised the Royal Poinciana turn lane (City council agenda, November 1, 2023).
The roll shows a neighborhood that is mostly built but not finished. Of the 895 residential parcels, 144 are vacant lots, 16.1 percent (our arithmetic): 95 coded 0000 and 49 coded 0001. The 751 homes by decade built are 66 from the 1980s, 240 from the 1990s, 249 from the 2000s, 113 from the 2010s and 83 from 2020 to 2025. 488 homes are dated 2004 or earlier, building nearly stopped from 2008 to 2012 (3, 0, 1, 1 and 1 homes), 25 homes are dated 2016, and 33 are dated 2023 or later (county roll, our count).
Counting the two condominiums as well, the roll holds 775 dwellings: 751 homes plus 24 condominium units (our arithmetic). The roll carries no bedroom count, so this guide does not print one.
Streets show the range. Philodendron, Ligustrum, Clusia Rosea, N Ficus Tree, S Ficus Tree, Coco Plum, Vitex and Scarlet Sage Ct are fully built on the roll. The most vacant lots sit on Royal Poinciana (20 of 79), S Plum Tree (9 of 18) and Lucky Nut (3 of 4).
The county record describes size, age and lot, not style. For the 747 single-family parcels, county heated area runs from 1,002 to 3,433 square feet with a median of 1,969. By band: 81 are under 1,500 square feet, 332 are 1,500 to 1,999, 299 are 2,000 to 2,499, 28 are 2,500 to 2,999 and 7 are 3,000 or more (county roll, our count).
Lots are mostly modest. The median lot is about 9,946 square feet, the single-family zoned lots have a median of 9,687, and the multi-family zoned lots along the collector roads have a median of 20,000 square feet (county Lots layer, our analysis). Blocks 387 to 391 are an 80 by 120 foot grid of 9,600 square foot lots. The single-family declaration sets a 1,000 square foot minimum for living area and 25 foot front, 15 foot rear and 7.5 foot side setbacks (single-family declaration, association copy).
Age is the other dimension. 364 of the 751 homes carry a county year built before 2002, 48.5 percent, and 387 are 2002 or later (county roll, our count and arithmetic). The first Florida Building Code took effect on March 1, 2002, which is why the insurance and storm sections of this guide split the homes there.
Burnt Store Meadows has one mandatory master association and a City government on top of it, and no special district. The pieces fit together this way:
The tax line is public, and the association line is not. For 2026 a home in tax district 150 pays 16.8148 mills, which is 1.4443 mills more than unincorporated district 104, about $144.43 per $100,000 of taxable value (our arithmetic; 2026 final rates). The Burnt Store Meadows POA bills one assessment per original platted parcel once a year, due within 60 days after the October 1 fiscal year starts, and vacant lots pay. The association does not publish the amount, and the estoppel certificate for a parcel states it. The condominium associations' dues are not published either. At a sale, the state's published ceiling for an estoppel certificate is $299, plus $119 if delivered within 3 business days and up to $179 more if the parcel is delinquent (Florida DBPR). The full layer-by-layer table is in the cost-to-own section.
The greenbelt is the signature feature of the plat. The county roll lists one common parcel, "PUNTA GORDA ISLES SECTION 18 GREENBELTS 87.58 AC. AS PER PLAT BOOK 10 PG. 4", owned by the Burnt Store Meadows POA. Of the 882 mapped residential parcels, 873 share at least 5 percent of their boundary with it and 829 share 10 percent or more (county parcel map, our analysis).
The recorded declarations treat the greenbelt as a private park: each lot holds an equal undivided interest that cannot be partitioned, no automobiles, trucks or motorcycles are allowed on it (bicycles, horses and approved golf carts are), trees and plants may not be cut, and no permanent fixtures may be added. The association's January 2026 newsletter says it maintains the greenbelts, entrance areas, the Burnt Store Road right of way and interior drainage ditches from the annual fee, and the association's April 2026 newsletter says mowing is triggered at about nine inches of growth (Meadows Connection, April 2026).
For an owner the edge matters. The association's July 2026 new-construction rules keep 15 feet at the rear lot line clear for maintenance access to the greenbelt and ditch, and require hardwood trees at least 10 feet from the rear lot line (ARB New Construction requirements). A Little Free Library sponsored by the association stands on the Royal Poinciana greenbelt between South Plum Tree and South Blue Sage.
Burnt Store Meadows has no clubhouse, no community pool and no golf course. No parcel carries a golf, park, club or marina use code, the county shows no park, trail or facility features inside the plat, and the association's documents name no hall. The two condominiums each have a pool on their own common parcels, which are those buildings' own common parcels, not neighborhood facilities.
Next door, Seminole Lakes is a gated community whose association lists a heated pool and other facilities, with a separate golf club inside it. Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club is semi-private, 18 holes, par 62, and sits about 2.0 road miles and 6 minutes from the center of Burnt Store Meadows. For a pool without a membership, South County Regional Park (670 Cooper St) has a heated 25-yard pool, pickleball and tennis courts, a recreation center and disc golf, about 5.7 miles and 12 minutes away (Charlotte County, South County Regional Park).
Neither recorded declaration read sets an age restriction. The rules in those declarations apply to every owner, and they are summarized in the rules section of this guide.
Flood is the one condition that is not uniform. FEMA's map puts the west end of the plat, including the west end of Royal Poinciana and Trumpet Tree, in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 9 ft. The center of the plat reads Zone X, an area of minimal flood hazard. Of 882 mapped residential parcels, 148 sit in Zone AE, 127 in shaded Zone X and 607 in unshaded Zone X (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, effective December 15, 2022, with the county parcel map, our analysis). A map zone is not a determination for a building, and any address can be checked at FEMA's Map Service Center.
For schools, the district's boundary locator returned the same four schools at all eight points we sampled: East Elementary and Sallie Jones Elementary, Punta Gorda Middle and Charlotte High. The tool does not mark either elementary school as the zoned school. The 2025-26 state grades are A for Sallie Jones Elementary, B for East Elementary, A for Punta Gorda Middle and B for Charlotte High.
For daily errands, Publix (about 2.5 miles, 5 minutes), Home Depot (the same address), Walmart Supercenter (about 2.1 miles, 6 minutes) and Walgreens (about 3.2 miles, 7 minutes) are all close. For health care, no hospital or emergency room has operated inside the City of Punta Gorda since the ShorePoint Health Punta Gorda hospital closed after Hurricanes Helene and Milton in 2024 (WINK News, December 20, 2024). The nearest open emergency rooms are about 21 minutes away.
Five questions come before price, because each one changes what a home costs or what it can become:
Burnt Store Meadows recorded 42 sales at a $370,000 median in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, and the right first step for a buyer is a conversation about the street, the flood reading and the documents before a contract. Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 for a personalized buyer consultation, or read how we represent buyers in Punta Gorda.
★★★★★ "Marc Comisar is a true professional. He's a great communicator, highly knowledgeable, in very well connected with all ancillary business partners necessary for a successful transaction. I would recommend him and his firm to anyone." Verified Zillow review
Burnt Store Meadows recorded 42 home sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, at a $370,000 median and a range of $195,000 to $680,000. Thirty-seven were resales at a $363,000 median and five were builder-direct new homes at a $630,000 median (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis).
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026, roll and sales files of October 4, 2026; MLS fields not available).
Group | Parcels or homes on the roll | Sales | Median | Range | Per sq ft of county heated area (n) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
All homes (residential blocks) | 751 homes on 895 parcels | 42 | $370,000 | $195,000 to $680,000 | $189.87 (41) |
Resales | n/a | 37 | $363,000 | $195,000 to $680,000 | n/a |
Builder-direct new homes | n/a | 5 | $630,000 | $335,000 to $678,500 | n/a |
Single-family only | 747 | 41 | $370,000 | $195,000 to $680,000 | $189.87 (41) |
All residential products, including both condominiums | 775 dwellings (751 homes and 24 condominium units) | 43 | $370,000 | $125,000 to $680,000 | $188.72 (42) |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis, the 12 months to September 9, 2026. Every figure counts DOR-qualified improved sales above $1,000; the county's sales file starts in 2009.
The 12 months to September 9, 2026 is the window this whole guide uses, so a figure here and the same figure in a later section always describe the same sales. A median is the middle price when the sales are lined up from lowest to highest. With 42 sales it is the mean of the middle pair, which are both $370,000, so the median is exact.
Five of the 42 sales, 11.9 percent (our arithmetic), were the first sale of a new home by a builder. They are listed here by street and date: S Blue Sage at $650,000 (September 12, 2025), N Ficus Tree at $370,000 (November 12, 2025), N Moss Rose at $630,000 (March 6, 2026), Schefflera at $678,500 (May 8, 2026, a new home still coded vacant on the roll) and South Seagrape Rd at $335,000 (May 28, 2026).
The other 37 were resales, at a $363,000 median. Builder-direct homes at a $630,000 median sit $267,000 above the resale median (our arithmetic), but that gap compares new homes with older resales and is not like-for-like. A seller of a resale should price against recorded resales, not against what a builder's first sale brought.
Window | Recorded sales | Median |
|---|---|---|
12 months (September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026) | 42 | $370,000 |
24 months | 79 | $380,000 |
36 months | 125 | $415,000 |
60 months | 212 | $425,000 ($195,000 to $960,000) |
All recorded history from January 22, 2009 | 746 | $281,700 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis, windows ending September 9, 2026.
Each row is its own window, and the rows overlap: the 42 sales of the 12-month window are inside the 79 of the 24-month window. A longer window is not a better answer, only a different one. The median falls from $425,000 at 60 months to $370,000 at 12 months, but each window holds a different set of homes, including different shares of new construction, so we never present a longer-window figure beside the 12-month median without naming both windows.
Year | Sales | Median | Builder-direct |
|---|---|---|---|
2019 | 57 | $290,000 | 12 |
2020 | 61 | $285,000 | 11 |
2021 | 78 | $352,450 | 13 |
2022 | 34 | $452,500 | 5 |
2023 | 44 | $480,000 | 1 |
2024 | 49 | $443,500 | 3 |
2025 | 32 | $390,000 | 6 |
2026 through September 9 | 33 | $363,000 | 3 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
The calendar-year median peaked at $480,000 in 2023. The 12-month median of $370,000 is $110,000, or 22.9 percent, lower (our arithmetic). Those are medians of different sets of homes, not a repeat-sale index, so they describe what sold and not what any one home lost. Builder-direct sales were more common in the early years: 13 of 78 sales in 2021 were a builder's first sale, against 5 of 42 in the latest 12 months.
Price band, 12 months | Recorded sales |
|---|---|
Under $200,000 | 1 |
$200,000 to $300,000 | 5 |
$300,000 to $400,000 | 18 |
$400,000 to $500,000 | 10 |
$500,000 to $750,000 | 8 |
$750,000 and up | 0 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis, the 12 months to September 9, 2026.
The market has one thick band. Eighteen of the 42 sales closed between $300,000 and $400,000, and 28 closed between $300,000 and $500,000 (our arithmetic). Eight closed between $500,000 and $750,000, none at $750,000 or more, and one closed under $200,000.
Of the 42 sales, 41 were single-family (use codes 0100 and 0108), at a $370,000 median and a range of $195,000 to $680,000. Four of the 41 were builder-direct, at a $500,000 median, and 37 were resales at $363,000. The per-square-foot median is the same $189.87 (41 sales).
Zoning splits the single-family stock in two. Homes on single-family zoned GS-3.5 lots recorded 35 sales at a $363,000 median in the 12 months. Homes on multi-family zoned GM-15 lots recorded 7 sales in the 12 months, too few for a median; the first window with 10 or more is 24 months, with 10 sales at a $484,000 median and $228.05 per square foot (county parcel list, our analysis). Those two medians cover different windows and different homes, so they are not subtracted. The GM-15 lots are larger, 20,000 square feet at the median, and the homes on them tend to be newer and larger. That is lot size and age, not a measured effect of the declaration.
The 43 residential products in the all-products row add one condominium sale to the 42 homes. Plum Creek recorded one sale in the 12 months, $125,000 on July 15, 2026, for a 1,079 square foot unit. The Meadows of Punta Gorda condominium recorded none in the 12 months and one in 24 months ($156,900, March 6, 2025). With fewer than 10 sales in every short window, the sales are listed and not summarized. The condominium section of this guide covers both buildings in full.
Street | Sales, 12 months | Median |
|---|---|---|
N Plum Tree | 5 | $380,000 |
S Blue Sage | 4 | $412,500 |
Royal Poinciana | 3 | $500,000 |
Paspalum | 3 | $470,000 |
W Cashew | 2 | $442,500 |
Trumpet Tree | 2 | $362,500 |
Tabebuia Tree | 2 | $265,300 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis, the 12 months to September 9, 2026.
Twenty-one more streets recorded one sale each: Sweet Alyssum, N Ficus Tree, Philodendron, N Blue Sage, Scarlet Sage Ct, Wedelia, N Moss Rose, Scarlet Sage, Carissa, S Plum Tree, Schefflera, South Seagrape Rd, Carambola, S Tulip Tree, Acalypha, Parkinsonia, Soursop, S Moss Rose, Ligustrum, Allamanda Ln and Vinca Rosea. With fewer than 10 sales on every street, these are a list and not a ranking. One sale on a street says what that home brought, not what the street is worth.
Date | Price | Type | Street | Year built | County heated sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sep 12, 2025 | $650,000 | builder-direct | S Blue Sage | 2025 | 2,019 |
Sep 12, 2025 | $400,000 | resale | S Blue Sage | 2006 | 2,230 |
Sep 17, 2025 | $370,000 | resale | W Cashew | 2022 | 2,000 |
Oct 1, 2025 | $500,000 | resale | Royal Poinciana | 2004 | 2,675 |
Oct 17, 2025 | $362,000 | resale | Sweet Alyssum | 1992 | 1,930 |
Nov 12, 2025 | $370,000 | builder-direct | N Ficus Tree | 2025 | 1,842 |
Nov 26, 2025 | $295,000 | resale | Philodendron | 1994 | 1,349 |
Dec 1, 2025 | $340,000 | resale | Royal Poinciana | 2004 | 2,003 |
Dec 3, 2025 | $470,000 | resale | Paspalum | 1998 | 2,232 |
Jan 9, 2026 | $300,000 | resale | Trumpet Tree | 1999 | 2,325 |
Jan 13, 2026 | $345,000 | resale | N Blue Sage | 1990 | 2,009 |
Jan 13, 2026 | $680,000 | resale | N Plum Tree | 2017 | 2,616 |
Feb 10, 2026 | $477,000 | resale | Paspalum | 2002 | 2,392 |
Feb 13, 2026 | $363,000 | resale | N Plum Tree | 1999 | 1,939 |
Feb 17, 2026 | $440,000 | resale | Scarlet Sage Ct | 2002 | 2,246 |
Feb 23, 2026 | $496,300 | resale | Wedelia | 2014 | 2,354 |
Mar 6, 2026 | $630,000 | builder-direct | N Moss Rose | 2025 | 2,771 |
Mar 20, 2026 | $650,000 | resale | Scarlet Sage | 2015 | 2,472 |
Mar 31, 2026 | $300,000 | resale | N Plum Tree | 2002 | 1,714 |
Apr 8, 2026 | $275,000 | resale | Tabebuia Tree | 1991 | 1,477 |
Apr 20, 2026 | $605,000 | resale | Royal Poinciana | 2016 | 2,476 |
Apr 29, 2026 | $255,600 | resale | Tabebuia Tree | 1998 | 1,585 |
May 7, 2026 | $335,000 | resale | Carissa | 2017 | 1,803 |
May 7, 2026 | $335,000 | resale | S Plum Tree | 2003 | 1,978 |
May 8, 2026 | $678,500 | builder-direct | Schefflera | not yet on the roll | not yet on the roll |
May 26, 2026 | $425,000 | resale | S Blue Sage | 1997 | 2,080 |
May 28, 2026 | $335,000 | builder-direct | South Seagrape Rd | 2025 | 1,952 |
May 28, 2026 | $350,000 | resale | Carambola | 1999 | 1,512 |
May 29, 2026 | $430,000 | resale | Paspalum | 2003 | 1,959 |
Jun 2, 2026 | $375,000 | resale | S Tulip Tree | 2004 | 1,864 |
Jun 19, 2026 | $460,000 | resale | N Plum Tree | 2003 | 1,878 |
Jun 23, 2026 | $266,000 | resale | Acalypha | 1995 | 1,477 |
Jun 29, 2026 | $195,000 | resale | Parkinsonia | 1987 | 1,002 |
Jul 13, 2026 | $422,000 | resale | Soursop | 2002 | 1,838 |
Jul 21, 2026 | $380,000 | resale | N Plum Tree | 2022 | 2,365 |
Jul 24, 2026 | $230,000 | resale | S Blue Sage | 1982 | 1,381 |
Aug 12, 2026 | $310,000 | resale | S Moss Rose | 2022 | 2,001 |
Aug 13, 2026 | $360,000 | resale | Ligustrum | 1998 | 1,896 |
Aug 14, 2026 | $300,000 | resale | Allamanda Ln | 2001 | 1,901 |
Aug 21, 2026 | $515,000 | resale | W Cashew | 2016 | 1,798 |
Aug 24, 2026 | $350,000 | resale | Vinca Rosea | 1993 | 2,313 |
Aug 27, 2026 | $425,000 | resale | Trumpet Tree | 2006 | 2,199 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis, the 12 months to September 9, 2026. Street names only; heated area is the county's, not an MLS living-area figure.
Reading the list is more useful than reading any single average. The resales above $600,000 are a 2017 home on N Plum Tree, a 2015 home on Scarlet Sage and a 2016 home on Royal Poinciana, and the sales below $270,000 are older and smaller homes built from 1982 to 1998. Age, heated area and street position explain most of the spread, which is why a valuation here starts from the recorded sales nearest the home in size, year built and position.
The median across the 12 months is $189.87 per square foot of county heated area (41 sales with a heated area on the roll), and $188.72 (42 sales) when the condominium sale is included. These are per square foot of the county's heated area, which is never compared with an MLS living-area figure.
Several cuts use other windows, and each is named. The multi-family zoned homes ran $228.05 per square foot over 24 months. Homes on Royal Poinciana itself recorded 14 sales over 60 months at a $627,500 median and $281.21 per square foot. On the west-end flood line, homes in Zone AE recorded 18 sales over 36 months at a $441,500 median and $210.18 per square foot. North of Royal Poinciana, 19 sales in the 12 months ran $190.24 per square foot (18 with heated area), and south of it, 20 sales ran $194.64, a gap that sits inside sampling noise (all our analysis of county parcel lists). Because the windows differ, none of these is set against the 12-month figure.
Window | Recorded lot sales (vacant land) | Median |
|---|---|---|
12 months | 11 | $55,000 ($30,000 to $68,000) |
24 months | 20 | $55,950 |
36 months | 29 | $55,000 |
60 months | 61 | $55,900 ($30,000 to $240,000) |
All history since May 27, 2009 | 279 | $36,000 |
Calendar year | Lot sales | Median |
|---|---|---|
2019 | 8 | $37,750 |
2020 | 18 | $45,500 |
2021 | 30 | $45,000 |
2022 | 21 | $57,000 |
2023 | 7 | $58,000 |
2024 | 10 | $54,000 |
2025 | 11 | $59,000 |
2026 through September 9 | 7 | $55,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. Lot prices are recorded lot sales (vacant land) and never enter a home median. Calendar-year rows with fewer than 10 sales are shown for context, as a handful of sales and not a trend.
The multi-family zoned GM-15 lots price differently from the rest: 13 vacant-land sales over 60 months at a $94,900 median. Those lots are 20,000 square feet at the median, against about 9,687 on the single-family zoned lots, and we do not read the two prices against each other as a premium.
The roll lags new construction, so a newly built home can sit on a parcel the county still codes as vacant. Schefflera, at $678,500 on May 8, 2026, is the example in the 12-month list, and it is counted as a home sale in the table above. As a check, we looked for recorded sales priced at $150,000 or more and coded vacant: there are none in the 12, 24 or 36 months, and six in all history, from 2013 to 2022, between $190,000 and $269,900. The 11 lot sales in the 12 months are therefore lot sales, not new homes in disguise.
The highest sale in the 12 months was $680,000, a resale on N Plum Tree built in 2017 with 2,616 square feet of county heated area, recorded January 13, 2026. The lowest was $195,000, a resale on Parkinsonia built in 1987 with 1,002 square feet, recorded June 29, 2026. Both are single data points, not a price range for the neighborhood, which is why we price each home against its own comparable sales and not against the top or bottom of the file.
In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, 42 sales on 751 homes is 5.6 percent of the homes (our arithmetic). That is turnover, not a measure of demand, and it counts first sales of new homes along with resales.
The county records every deed. The MLS records only what a listing agent enters, and it sorts listings by a subdivision field that does not capture this plat well. A dated Southwest Florida MLS (Matrix) pull for closings from September 25, 2025 to September 24, 2026 lists Burnt Store Meadows at 8 closings with a median of $387,500, against 42 county recorded sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026. The MLS subdivision field undercounts this plat, so we lead with the county record for counts and prices.
MLS closing count and median for the 12 months to September 9, 2026: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
Measure | Burnt Store Meadows |
|---|---|
Median days on market | Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). |
Median sale-to-list ratio | Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). |
These are the two measures only the MLS carries. We do not substitute a figure from another community. Our guide to Burnt Store Village shows the format these measures take when they are available.
Start with the 12-month county record: 42 sales at $370,000, with resales at $363,000. Price a resale against recorded resales nearest the home in size, year built and position, and keep the five builder-direct sales and the lot sales out of that comparison. Read the street list for the closest matches, and treat a single sale on a street as one data point.
Two cautions apply. The west end of the plat sits in Zone AE, and 7 sales there in the 12 months had a $350,000 median, against 35 sales at $380,000 for the Zone X rest (our analysis); those are different homes in a small sample, so they describe what sold and not a flood discount. And the roll lags new construction, so a home finished this month may still be coded as a vacant lot. A valuation here that starts from a portal estimate misses all of this, and we start from the county record.
Burnt Store Meadows began as Punta Gorda Isles Section 18, a plat from the developer Punta Gorda Isles, Inc. The association's 2020 restated Articles say the developer completed the development in December 1980. The oldest home on the county roll is dated 1982, and the neighborhood's association was incorporated in 1984.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County roll of October 4, 2026, our count; Florida Division of Corporations, association and City records read October 21, 2026).
The county's Subdivisions layer names the plat Punta Gorda Isles Section 18, Plat Book 10, Page 4, and the two recorded declarations cite Plat Book 10, Pages 4-A through 4-Q. "Punta Gorda Isles" is a platting program of numbered sections rather than a single neighborhood, which is why several places with Burnt Store in their names sit close together and are not the same place. Readers comparing the sections can start with the Punta Gorda Isles page. Section 18 has no canals and no boat access, so nothing written about the canal sections applies here.
The developer was Punta Gorda Isles, Inc., incorporated in 1958, renamed PGI Incorporated in 1990 and administratively dissolved in 2022. The commercial replat of Tracts A and B along US 41 is a separate recorded plat, Plat Book 13, Page 29 (pages 29A to 29D). The association's own statement of the developer's work is in its Amended and Restated Articles of Incorporation.
Two declarations of restrictions run with the land. The single-family declaration was first recorded at Official Records Book 358, page 247, and the multi-family declaration at Official Records Book 358, page 239. Both were later amended in Official Records Book 552 and then amended and re-recorded, the single-family one at Official Records Book 2803, page 1974 and the multi-family one at Official Records Book 2620, page 1851.
The association hosts copies of both on its public documents page: the single-family declaration and the multi-family declaration. The copies print no recording date, and the plat's recording date and dedication language were not read, because the Clerk of Court's plat images sit behind a verification screen. We give book and page only and no year.
Both original declarations also carry an annexation covenant: the land "may hereinafter be taken into the City of Punta Gorda" (paragraph 26 of the single-family declaration and paragraph 24 of the multi-family one). That sentence shows the possibility was written into the original paper. It does not give a date.
Two separate records give two separate dates, and we print both with their sources. The association's 2020 restated Articles say the developer "completed the development of Punta Gorda Isles, Section 18, Burnt Store Meadows, in December, 1980." The Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll shows the oldest home built in 1982 (county roll, our count).
The roll's year-built field is a county data field, not a certificate of occupancy, and the Articles are the association's statement, not a recorded survey. Read together, they say the plat was finished before the first home on today's roll was dated.
The place name Burnt Store is older than the neighborhood. Charlotte County's Burnt Store Area Plan, dated 2005, gives two legends: a store built by German settlers, or a trading post burned by Seminole raiders in 1848. A Charlotte Sun history column of March 5, 2025 says the Kennedy trading post was abandoned in 1849, that the burning is undocumented, and that an 1883 map marks a "Burnt Store" area. The county also keeps a Burnt Store Area Plan page.
The name "Burnt Store Meadows" was in use by 1984, because the association was incorporated under it that year. Who coined the name, and when, is not on the public record we read.
The Burnt Store Meadows Property Owner's Association, Inc. was incorporated in 1984 as Florida corporation N03230 and shows as active on the Florida Division of Corporations record. Its Articles were restated and recorded in October 2020. The governing H2 below covers what the association does today; the point here is that it has existed for most of the neighborhood's life.
The county roll carries a year built for 751 homes in Burnt Store Meadows. They range from 1982 to 2025, with a median of 2002. By decade, the roll counts them this way (county roll, our count; Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis):
Decade | Homes with that year built |
|---|---|
1980s | 66 |
1990s | 240 |
2000s | 249 |
2010s | 113 |
2020 to 2025 | 83 |
The two middle decades hold the largest share, 240 and 249 homes, and 488 homes are dated 2004 or earlier. The 83 homes dated 2020 to 2025 mean the neighborhood is still being built, not only resold.
Building nearly stopped from 2008. The roll shows 3 homes dated 2008, none in 2009, and 1 each in 2010, 2011 and 2012 (county roll, our count). Infill came back later: 25 homes carry a 2016 year built, and 83 are dated 2020 through 2025, of which 33 were built in 2023 or later.
Infill has a limit here. Of the 895 residential parcels on the roll, 144 are still vacant lots, 16.1 percent (our arithmetic), so the neighborhood continues to add homes on lots that were platted decades ago. The market section above has the recorded lot sales and the builder-direct homes in numbers, and the vacant-lot section below covers what building here involves.
Several facts that readers ask about are not in any public document we could read. We state them as unknown instead of estimating:
Burnt Store Meadows is one platted grid with 46 botanical street names. The City of Punta Gorda zones it GS-3.5 for single-family homes (750 parcels on the appraiser record) and GM-15 for multi-family (134 parcels), and the City's Special Residential Overlay adds rules on top of the recorded declarations.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County roll of October 4, 2026, our count; county GIS and City Land Development Regulations read October 21, 2026).
The residential part of Section 18 runs through blocks 361 to 406 on the roll. Here is the roll profile (county roll, our count; Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis):
Roll group | Parcels |
|---|---|
Single-family, use code 0100 | 744 |
Single-family variants, use code 0108 | 3 |
Small multi-family, use code 0800 | 4 |
Vacant residential lots, use code 0000 | 95 |
Vacant residential lots, use code 0001 | 49 |
Residential parcels in blocks 361 to 406 | 895 |
Of those, 751 carry a year built. Two small condominiums stand inside the plat on their own roll designators, and the commercial replat adds 15 parcels on US 41. With them, the roll for Section 18 and the two condominiums totals 938 parcels (912 in Section 18 plus 26 condominium parcels) and 775 dwellings (751 homes plus 24 condominium units), our arithmetic.
The roll counts 46 street names, all drawn from a botanical set. Royal Poinciana has the most parcels, then the streets below (county roll, our count):
Street | Parcels |
|---|---|
Royal Poinciana | 79 |
Gold Tree | 58 |
N Plum Tree | 57 |
S Blue Sage | 52 |
N Blue Sage | 43 |
Trumpet Tree | 30 |
Satsuma Dr | 27 |
Carambola | 26 |
Eight streets are fully built on the roll: Philodendron, Ligustrum, Clusia Rosea, N Ficus Tree, S Ficus Tree, Coco Plum, Vitex and Scarlet Sage Ct. The streets with the most vacant lots are Royal Poinciana (20 of 79), S Plum Tree (9 of 18) and Lucky Nut (3 of 4).
Royal Poinciana is the neighborhood's spine road. The City's 2045 comprehensive plan calls it a primary collector and says the City's southern boundary "generally follows the southern boundary of the Burnt Store Meadows Subdivision" (City of Punta Gorda Comprehensive Plan 2045).
Royal Poinciana is also where the multi-family zoning concentrates: 75 of the 134 GM-15 parcels line it, with the rest along N Plum Tree and S Plum Tree. The association's January 2026 newsletter placed yard-sale volunteers "at the Burnt Store Road and 41 entrances," which tells a reader that the neighborhood opens onto both roads (Meadows Connection, January 2026).
County GIS lot polygons give a median lot of 9,946 square feet across the neighborhood (our analysis, October 21, 2026). Lots zoned GS-3.5 have a median of 9,687 square feet, and the GM-15 lots have a median of 20,000 square feet. Blocks 387 to 391 are an 80 by 120 foot grid, which is 9,600 square feet per lot. Plat frontage was not read.
Two minimums apply and they differ. The single-family declaration sets a minimum lot of 7,200 square feet and 75 feet wide, and the City's GS-3.5 district requires 9,600 square feet. We print each in its own sentence because the declaration and the City code are separate documents.
GS-3.5 is the City's General Single-Family Residential district, written for the completion and annexation of previously approved subdivisions. It covers 750 parcels on the appraiser record. Under the City's Chapter 26 Land Development Regulations, it allows single-family homes, with a minimum lot of 9,600 square feet, setbacks of 25 feet in front, 7.5 feet at the sides and 15 feet at the rear, a height limit of 35 feet above base flood elevation and a density of 3.5 units per acre.
GM-15 is the General Multi-Family district. It covers 134 parcels, and 129 of them sit on lots covered by the multi-family declaration. The district allows single-family homes, duplexes, multi-family and cluster housing with development plan approval, with a minimum lot of 8,000 square feet, a front setback of 25 feet, a height limit of 40 feet above base flood elevation to the tie beam with no more than 3 habitable floors below it, and up to 15 units per acre.
Of the 134 GM-15 parcels, 49 are vacant on the roll. The 20,000 square foot lots fill blocks 365 (in part), 369, 381 and 382 (county roll and county GIS, our analysis). The two condominiums are also on GM-15 land.
Section 3.13 of the City's regulations writes a Special Residential Overlay District for the Punta Gorda Isles plats, Sections 1 through 12, 14, 15, 17, 18, 24, 26 and 27. Burnt Store Meadows is Section 18, so the overlay applies. The association's welcome letter says Burnt Store Meadows "is considered a Special Residential Overlay District within the city, and therefore more stringent than the city" (Welcome New Neighbor Letter, October 2026 file).
The overlay rules that reach a homeowner are:
The City also publishes a Special Residential Overlay map.
The replat of Tracts A and B puts 15 parcels on Tamiami Trail between 10261 and 10901, zoned Highway Commercial, with 13 of them vacant. They carry ZIP 33950 and are never part of a home statistic on this page. The bylaws of the association also reach these parcels, because the association administers the commercial replat.
Burnt Store Meadows is inside the City of Punta Gorda. The parcels carry tax district 150, the county city-boundary layer contains every point sampled, and the City's own regulations name Section 18 in the overlay. The mailing ZIP is a separate matter: every home here is in ZIP 33955, which is mostly unincorporated Charlotte County, while the commercial frontage on US 41 carries 33950. Being inside the City is a fact about government, taxes and services, covered in the next two sections. You can read more about the wider city on our Punta Gorda page.
Burnt Store Meadows is governed by one mandatory association, the Burnt Store Meadows Property Owner's Association, Inc., which administers two recorded declarations. The City of Punta Gorda supplies zoning, code enforcement and utilities, and the neighborhood has no community development district and no county special assessment district.
Data updated: October 2026 (Florida Division of Corporations, association documents and City records read October 21, 2026).
Membership in the association is mandatory. Article 4.1 of the Amended and Restated Articles makes every fee simple owner of a parcel in Punta Gorda Isles Section 18 a member, "including a condominium unit owner," with one vote per parcel. The Articles were recorded at Official Records Book 4651, page 2114 on October 26, 2020.
Here is who governs what, stated consistently across this page:
Layer | What it governs |
|---|---|
Burnt Store Meadows POA | Every lot and both condominiums' unit owners; the two declarations; the 87.58-acre greenbelt parcel; greenbelts, entrance areas, the Burnt Store Road right of way and interior drainage ditches; architectural review |
Meadows of Punta Gorda Condominium Association, Inc. and Plum Creek Condominium Association, Inc. | Each condominium's own buildings and common areas, as a second layer inside the master POA |
City of Punta Gorda | City government, zoning (GS-3.5, GM-15 and the Special Residential Overlay), code enforcement, building permits, and water and sewer as the certificated provider |
Charlotte County | The county millage, the property appraiser's roll and the county's own services |
Community development district or county MSBU | None |
The legal name on the Florida Division of Corporations record is Burnt Store Meadows Property Owner's Association, Inc., a Florida not-for-profit corporation, N03230, active. The association's own forms print the name as "Property Owners' Association," and we use the state record's spelling and the short form "the Burnt Store Meadows POA." Its public site is bsmpoa.com.
The county roll lists one parcel owned by the Burnt Store Meadows POA whose legal description names the Section 18 greenbelts at 87.58 acres per Plat Book 10, page 4. The association's January 2026 newsletter lists what it maintains: entrance areas, greenbelts, the right of way along Burnt Store Road and interior drainage ditches, paid from the annual fee (Meadows Connection, January 2026). Vacant lots are not maintained by the association; they fall to the City, with the expense charged to the lot owner.
Both documents were restated and recorded on October 26, 2020: the Articles at Official Records Book 4651, page 2114 and the Bylaws at Official Records Book 4651, page 2074. The Bylaws set the money mechanics:
No transfer fee, resale fee or capital contribution clause appears in the Bylaws we read. The estoppel certificate for a parcel states whether any such fee is due.
The association is managed by Star Hospitality Management, which is also its registered agent, from the management office at 26530 Mallard Way. The board of five meets on the third Monday of the month at 6:30 pm at the management office or by Zoom. The annual meeting is held in September, and the fiscal year runs from October 1 to September 30.
The association's newsletter, Meadows Connection, ceased after the September 2026 issue; the publisher cited insufficient advertising revenue. The association's Bulletin Board page carries notices.
Approval comes before exterior changes and new construction. Reviews happen at the monthly board meeting, and documents are due the Friday before. After approval, a copy of the City building permit must reach the association within 14 days or the approval is rescinded. New construction also requires a performance and completion bond, the amount of which is not published, and a $500 refundable Clean Site deposit held to final inspection.
The ARB new construction requirements of July 2026, the Clean Site Policy and the Additions, Alterations and Improvements form are on the association's site, and the ARB page indexes the forms.
The Bylaws allow fines of up to $100 per violation per day with a $2,500 aggregate. A hearing committee of three non-board members hears fines after 14 days' notice. The Violation Protocol Table, revised July 17, 2023, sets how long an owner has to cure before fines begin:
Item | Time to cure |
|---|---|
Parking and commercial vehicles | 24 hours |
Overnight boats, trailers, campers or RVs, 7 pm to 7 am | 24 hours |
Trash cans left at the curb | 24 hours after pickup |
Grass over 12 inches | 14 days |
Hedge over 4 ft | 14 days |
Vacant lots | 30 days |
Worked example (our arithmetic): at $100 a day, a continuing violation reaches the $2,500 cap after 25 days.
The welcome letter says violations that are not cured go to City Code Enforcement. That route exists because the Special Residential Overlay is City law and the association's protocol cites its sections. The City's rules apply to every owner regardless of the association's own process, and we make no claim about response times for either.
Tax district 150 carries no community development district levy, and the county's MSBU layer returned no features at any of the 11 sample points inside Section 18, while the same layer returned features elsewhere in the county. A reader asking whether Burnt Store Meadows has a CDD or a special assessment district can read the answer from the tax rate chart: it has neither. The City's canal maintenance districts concern canal sections, and Section 18 has no canals.
Everything below is public on the association's site and does not need a login. We never link member-only pages.
The budget is not public. It goes to members and into the welcome packet.
Owning a home in Burnt Store Meadows means paying the Burnt Store Meadows POA assessment, which is not published, plus property tax in City of Punta Gorda district 150 at 16.8148 mills for 2026. The neighborhood has no community development district, no county MSBU and no canal assessment.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser 2026 final rates; City of Punta Gorda rates effective October 1, 2026; Florida DBPR fee page; association documents read October 21, 2026).
# | Layer | Single-family home | Condominium unit | Vacant lot | Covers (public record only) | Period | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Burnt Store Meadows POA assessment | Not published | Not published (unit owners are members; whether billed per unit or through the condominium is not published) | Not published; vacant lots pay | Greenbelts, entrance areas, Burnt Store Road right of way, interior drainage ditches, administration (January 2026 newsletter) | Once a year in advance, due within 60 days of October 1 | Amount not published; the estoppel certificate states it | |
2 | Condominium association dues (Meadows of Punta Gorda; Plum Creek) | None | Not published | None | Building and common areas, each condominium's pool | Not published | Not published | |
3 | Property tax, tax district 150 | 16.8148 mills (2026) on taxable value | Same | Same | County, ESL debt, City of Punta Gorda (3.9928), WCIND, SWFWMD, schools | Year; bill mails November 2026 | Published | |
4 | Community development district | None | None | None | Not applicable | Not applicable | None exists | |
5 | County MSBU | None | None | None | Not applicable | Not applicable | Layer empty inside Section 18 | County GIS (not linked) |
6 | City canal maintenance assessment | None (no canals) | None | None | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable | |
7 | City lot mowing assessment | Not applicable | Not applicable | $285 listed in the City's FY2027 budget; which lots it covers was not found | Mowing of unkept vacant lots | Year | Coverage not published | |
8 | City water and wastewater (inside city limits column, effective October 1, 2026) | Water base 15.18 plus customer charge 6.60 plus tiers from 4.51; wastewater base 36.91 plus 4.66 | Same | None until built | Water and wastewater; refuse billed by the City (amount not published) | Monthly | Published rates; per-address connection confirmed on the bill | |
9 | At a sale: estoppel certificate | DBPR cap $299, plus $119 if expedited, plus up to $179 if delinquent | Same (condominium estoppel is separate) | Same | Assessment and lien status, any fee due | Per sale | Cap published; the POA's charge not published | |
10 | At a sale: transfer, resale or capital fee | None in the Bylaws read | Not read | None in the Bylaws read | Not applicable | Per sale | The estoppel states any fee due | |
11 | New construction: ARB Clean Site deposit and bond | Not applicable | Not applicable | $500 refundable deposit; performance and completion bond (amount not published); City impact fees | Site cleanup; completion | One time | Deposit published; bond and impact fee amounts not read |
Rows 1, 2 and 10 are not in any public document; the estoppel certificate for the specific parcel states the current assessment, anything owed and any fee due at a sale. Nothing in this table is a dues estimate.
Each row names a layer an owner might pay, the three kinds of parcel it could touch, what it covers on the public record, how often it bills and whether the amount is published. "Not published" is a finding about the record, not a hidden number we hold back. Where a layer does not exist here, such as a community development district, the row says so.
Three layers are absent here: there is no community development district, no county MSBU and no canal assessment. What remains are the association assessment, the condominium layer for unit owners, the property tax bill and City utilities.
The Bylaws bill one assessment per original platted parcel, once a year, in advance, due within 60 days after the October 1 start of the fiscal year. Vacant lots pay. The association's home page says only "Low Annual Association fee," and we do not repeat that as our own claim because no dollar figure appears in any public document.
The dollar amount lives in the annual budget, the welcome packet and the estoppel certificate for a parcel, and none of those is public. For the same reason, association dues as entered in MLS listings: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
Because Burnt Store Meadows is inside the City, it pays the City's levy and not the two county services that unincorporated owners pay. The 2026 final millage by levy, from the Charlotte County Property Appraiser's rate chart:
Levy (2026 final mills) | District 150, Burnt Store Meadows | District 104, unincorporated Charlotte County |
|---|---|---|
Charlotte County | 6.1275 | 6.1275 |
County Law Enforcement MSTU | None | 2.3578 |
County Lighting | None | 0.1907 |
Environmentally Sensitive Lands debt | 0.2000 | 0.2000 |
City of Punta Gorda | 3.9928 | None |
West Coast Inland Navigation District | 0.0394 | 0.0394 |
Southwest Florida Water Management District | 0.1831 | 0.1831 |
School, state | 3.0240 | 3.0240 |
School, local | 3.2480 | 3.2480 |
Total | 16.8148 | 15.3705 |
District 150 pays 1.4443 mills more than district 104, about $144.43 per $100,000 of taxable value (our arithmetic). In 2025 the totals were 16.6185 and 15.0855. The City levy of 3.9928 replaces the two county services, which together run 2.5485 mills in district 104. District 150 has 3,006 parcels and district 104 has 108,798.
Worked example (our arithmetic): $300,000 of taxable value at 16.8148 mills is $5,044.44 a year, and at district 104's 15.3705 mills it is $4,611.15, a difference of $433.29. Per $100,000, that is $1,681.48 against $1,537.05. This is an illustration of the millage, not a bill; exemptions and assessment limits are not applied.
District 150's total rose from 16.6185 mills in 2025 to 16.8148 in 2026, an increase of 0.1963 mills (16.8148 minus 16.6185, our arithmetic). The City portion rose from 3.8686 to 3.9928 mills. The City adopted 3.9928 mills for fiscal year 2027, about 0.36 percent below the rollback rate of 4.0074. Tax bills mail in November 2026, and the county Tax Collector is the place to look up a parcel's bill.
On the public record, living inside the City means City zoning and the Special Residential Overlay, City Code Enforcement, City building permits, and City utilities as the certificated water and sewer provider. We make no claim about response times, staffing or comparisons with the county's services, because we found no document that measures them.
Section 18 has no canals, so the City's Punta Gorda Isles and Burnt Store Isles canal maintenance districts do not apply, and their assessment amounts do not belong in a Burnt Store Meadows budget. The one City assessment that could touch a lot here is the lot mowing program, listed at $285 in the City's FY2027 budget. Which lots it covers was not found. If your reading of a tax bill shows it, the City's assessment resolution is the document that explains it.
The City of Punta Gorda is the certificated water and sewer provider for the section. Its rate page prints an inside city limits column and an outside column, both effective October 1, 2026. Inside the city limits, the numbers as the City prints them are:
Item | Inside city limits |
|---|---|
Water base | 15.18 |
Customer charge | 6.60 |
Residential tier, 0 to 5,000 gallons | 4.51 |
Residential tier, 5,000 to 10,000 gallons | 5.20 |
Residential tier, 10,000 to 20,000 gallons | 6.43 |
Residential tier, 20,000 to 40,000 gallons | 7.88 |
Residential tier, over 40,000 gallons | 9.60 |
Wastewater base | 36.91 |
Wastewater use, per 1,000 gallons | 4.66 |
The outside column is higher, with a water base of 18.97 and a wastewater base of 46.14. Whether every lot is connected to central sewer was not found; the 1970s declarations provide for a sewer availability charge if a sewer system was installed later. The utility bill for the specific address confirms the connection and the rate column. The stormwater and refuse amounts were not found; the City's account page says monthly charges include water, wastewater and refuse.
An estoppel certificate states what the association says is owed on a parcel and whether any transfer-type fee is due. Florida's Department of Business and Professional Regulation publishes the caps, and the current figures are on its estoppel fee page: not more than $299, an additional $119 for delivery within 3 business days, and an additional fee not to exceed $179 if the parcel is delinquent. The statute requires delivery within 10 business days, and DBPR's next update is due by July 1, 2027.
Worked example (our arithmetic): $299 plus $119 plus $179 is $597 at most, on a delinquent parcel with an expedited request. Those are ceilings, and what this association charges is not published. The governing statute is s. 720.30851, Florida Statutes.
New construction on a vacant lot passes through two layers. The association requires ARB approval, a $500 refundable, non-interest-bearing Clean Site deposit held to final inspection, a performance and completion bond whose amount is not published, silt fence on three sides, a dumpster and one site sign up to 2 by 3 feet. The City permits the work because the lots are inside the City, and new construction pays City impact fees; the schedule is on the City's impact fee page, and we did not read it into a dollar figure.
Four documents settle what an owner pays. First, the estoppel certificate for the parcel, which states the assessment and anything owed. Second, the association's budget and records, which owners may inspect under s. 720.303, Florida Statutes. Third, the county tax bill and the property appraiser's rate chart. Fourth, the City utility account, which shows the water, wastewater and refuse charges for the address. A buyer also receives the disclosure summary under s. 720.401.
Homes in Burnt Store Meadows come with private rules from two recorded declarations and public rules from the City's Special Residential Overlay. The declarations cover use, parking, fences, signs and the greenbelt, an architectural review applies to exterior changes, and fines run up to $100 a day with a $2,500 cap.
Data updated: October 2026 (declarations, Bylaws, violation protocol and City regulations read October 21, 2026).
Topic | What the record says | Source document |
|---|---|---|
Use | Single-family residential on single-family lots; multi-unit or single-unit residential on multi-family lots | |
Rentals | Renting "for residential use" allowed; no minimum term stated; no short-term rental rule found | Both declarations |
Home business | No trade or business without consent | Single-family declaration |
Boats, trailers, campers, RVs | No overnight parking without written consent; 24 hours to cure 7 pm to 7 am; special permits up to 4 occasions of 2 nights a year, City permit plus POA form | |
Commercial vehicles | 24 hours to cure; the City overlay regulates | |
Fences and hedges | Walls, hedges and fences over 3 ft on side or rear lines need approval (declaration); a hedge over 4 ft is a 14-day item (protocol); City overlay: side and rear yards only | Declaration, protocol, City regulations |
Sheds and accessory buildings | Not without consent; no detached garage or carport except in multi-family districts | Declaration, City regulations |
Pets | Allowed if not kept commercially and not a nuisance | Single-family declaration |
Signs | One for-sale or for-rent sign up to 6 by 8 inches | Single-family declaration |
Minimum home size | 1,000 sq ft (single-family); 1,200 sq ft per building, 800 per unit (multi-family) | Both declarations |
Exterior changes | ARB approval first; City permit copy within 14 days | |
Fines | Up to $100 a day per violation, $2,500 cap | Bylaws, protocol |
Greenbelt | No vehicles; no cutting of trees or plants; no permanent fixtures | Both declarations |
Age | Neither recorded declaration read sets an age restriction | Both declarations |
The two declarations share a core and differ on size. Both limit use to residential, allow renting for residential use, cap walls, hedges and fences at 3 feet on side or rear lot lines without approval, and create the shared greenbelt. The single-family declaration also sets setbacks of 25 feet in front, 15 feet at the rear and 7.5 feet at the sides, easements of 6 feet at the sides and 10 feet at the rear, and a minimum lot of 7,200 square feet and 75 feet wide.
The multi-family declaration sets a minimum of 1,200 square feet per building and 800 per unit unless authorized, 25 foot front and rear setbacks, a minimum lot of 8,000 square feet and 75 feet wide, and 1.5 paved parking spaces per unit. Which declaration covers a given lot is shown in the recorded documents, not on a map we could read lot by lot.
The recorded declarations allow renting for residential use and state no minimum term; no short-term rental rule was found in the public record. We do not say that short-term rentals are allowed or that they are banned. A rule could sit in a City ordinance or an association rule amendment that we did not locate, and the association's records, which owners may inspect, are where a buyer would confirm it.
The single-family declaration bars trailers, trucks, boats, boat trailers, campers and mobile homes from being parked overnight without written consent. The violation protocol turns that into a 24-hour cure period for overnight parking between 7 pm and 7 am.
For occasional visits, a special parking permit covers a maximum of 4 occasions of up to 2 nights each per calendar year. Both the City permit, which carries no charge, and the association's waiver form are required. On the driveway, the City overlay allows one camping trailer or habitation vehicle from 7 am to 7 pm, and it bars parking on vacant residential land or the public right of way from 1 am to 5 am.
Most lots back onto the greenbelt, so fences and hedges meet the common property at the rear line. Three documents speak to it, each with its own figure: the declaration requires written approval for walls, hedges and fences over 3 feet on side or rear lines, the protocol gives 14 days to cure a hedge over 4 feet, and the City overlay allows fences in side and rear yards only, with no solid boundary wall. We print each in its own sentence rather than reconcile them.
For new construction, the ARB rules ask owners to keep 15 feet at the rear lot line clear for maintenance access to the greenbelt and ditch, and to plant hardwood trees at least 10 feet from the rear lot line. A stem wall is recommended instead of fill.
The single-family declaration bars tents and accessory buildings without consent. The City overlay bars a detached garage or carport except in multi-family districts. Together they mean a detached garage on a single-family lot is not an option here, and a shed starts with the association's written consent and ARB review.
Pets are allowed if they are not kept commercially and are not a nuisance. One for-sale or for-rent sign is allowed, up to 6 by 8 inches. No trade or business may run without consent. The City's GS-3.5 district conditionally allows a limited home occupation, and the stricter private rule governs on the lot.
Approval comes first for pools, lanais, repainting, roofing, fencing and similar work, using the Additions, Alterations and Improvements form. A copy of the City building permit goes to the association within 14 days or the approval is rescinded. The minimum home size is 1,000 square feet in the single-family declaration.
Chapter 720 of the Florida Statutes governs homeowners' associations, and three of its provisions matter to a buyer here. Owners may inspect the association's official records under s. 720.303. A buyer of a parcel in a homeowners' association receives the disclosure summary under s. 720.401. And the estoppel certificate under s. 720.30851 must be delivered within 10 business days, within the fee caps in the Fee Stack above.
The statute does not replace the declarations. The recorded declaration for the lot, the Bylaws and the Violation Protocol Table are the documents that say what an owner may and may not do, and they are linked above.
Burnt Store Meadows is one platted section, Punta Gorda Isles Section 18, run by one mandatory association, so it has no villages or separate sub-communities. Its parts are geographic: the collector lots on Royal Poinciana and Plum Tree, the Zone AE west end, and the blocks north and south of the spine road.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; FEMA, county and city records read October 21, 2026).
Every lot in Burnt Store Meadows belongs to one platted section and answers to the same Burnt Store Meadows Property Owner's Association, Inc. Article 4.1 of the association's restated Articles makes every owner of a parcel in Section 18 a member, condominium unit owners included, with one vote per parcel (Amended and Restated Articles, 2020). The roll shows 46 street names from a botanical set, and no sub-association, village name or separate gate sits inside the plat. When a buyer hears a section name such as "the west end" or "the collector lots," that is a description of where a street runs, not a separate community with its own rules.
Royal Poinciana is the spine road, and the lots along it, together with N Plum Tree and S Plum Tree, carry GM-15 multi-family zoning. The county roll puts GM-15 on 134 parcels, 49 of them vacant, and 129 of the 134 sit on lots covered by the Multi-Family declaration (county roll, our count). The lots are larger: the median GM-15 lot is 20,000 square feet, against 9,687 for GS-3.5 lots (county Lots layer, our analysis).
In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, GM-15 homes recorded 7 sales, too few for a median. The first window with 10 sales is 24 months: 10 sales at a $484,000 median and $228.05 per square foot of county heated area. GS-3.5 homes recorded 35 sales at $363,000 in the 12-month window. Those two figures use different windows, so we do not subtract one from the other. The difference reflects lot size and newer, larger homes, not a measured effect of the declaration. Homes on Royal Poinciana itself recorded 3 sales in the 12 months ($340,000, $500,000 and $605,000) and 14 sales in 60 months at a $627,500 median.
Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
The west end of Burnt Store Meadows is the part of the plat that carries FEMA Zone AE. Of 882 mapped residential parcels, 148 sit in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 9 feet NAVD88, 127 in shaded Zone X and 607 in unshaded Zone X (our analysis, October 21, 2026). N Seagrape Rd, S Seagrape Rd, S Ficus Tree, N Ficus Tree, S Moss Rose, N Moss Rose and S Tulip Tree are entirely in Zone AE.
This end is also the newer part of the plat: 113 homes with a median year built of 2004, 31 of them built before 2002, against 625 homes in the Zone X rest with a median of 2001 (county roll, our count). In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, the Zone AE west end recorded 7 sales at $350,000 and the Zone X rest recorded 35 at $380,000. A map zone is not a determination for a building. Check any address on FEMA's Map Service Center.
Royal Poinciana divides the plat into a northern and a southern half. In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, the north recorded 19 sales at a $370,000 median and $190.24 per square foot of county heated area, and the south recorded 20 at $361,000 and $194.64. The gap is inside sampling noise, so we draw no conclusion about one side commanding a premium. Both halves share the same association and the same greenbelt design.
Royal Poinciana has the most parcels of any street, 79, followed by Gold Tree with 58, N Plum Tree with 57, S Blue Sage with 52, N Blue Sage with 43, Trumpet Tree with 30, Satsuma Dr with 27 and Carambola with 26 (county roll, our count). Several streets are fully built: Philodendron, Ligustrum, Clusia Rosea, N Ficus Tree, S Ficus Tree, Coco Plum, Vitex and Scarlet Sage Ct. The most vacant are Royal Poinciana with 20 of its 79 parcels, S Plum Tree with 9 of 18 and Lucky Nut with 3 of 4. A buyer who wants a settled street and a buyer who wants a lot to build on are looking at different parts of the same plat.
The Meadows of Punta Gorda and Plum Creek condominiums sit inside the plat and inside the master association, so this page covers them. Their unit owners are members of the Burnt Store Meadows POA under Article 4.1, and their buildings share the same streets, zoning and flood readings as the homes around them.
Several places share the name and are not part of this page. Burnt Store Isles is Punta Gorda Isles Section 15, a canal community around Twin Isles Country Club. Burnt Store Village is Section 16, outside the city limits. Burnt Store Lakes is Section 21, and Burnt Store Marina is Section 22 in Lee County. Burnt Store Golf Villas (San Rocco Dr, with its own association), Burnt Store Park and Burnt Store Square are separate plats. The Burnt Store Meadows association's site is bsmpoa.com, and the Burnt Store Marina association uses bsm22.org, so check the domain before relying on a document or fee sheet.
Burnt Store Meadows holds two small condominiums inside its plat: Meadows of Punta Gorda, with 12 units built in 1989, and Plum Creek, with 12 units on the county roll built in 2006 and 38 units declared at the state. Each has its own association inside the master Burnt Store Meadows POA.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; state condominium register, Sunbiz and county records read October 21, 2026).
Item | Meadows of Punta Gorda | Plum Creek |
|---|---|---|
Where | 449 Royal Poinciana | N Plum Tree (Building C) |
Association | Meadows of Punta Gorda Condominium Association, Inc. (Sunbiz N29543, filed 1988, active) | Plum Creek Condominium Association, Inc. (Sunbiz N05000008475, filed 2005, active) |
State register | 12 units, recorded June 20, 1989 | 38 units declared, recorded September 1, 2005 |
On the county roll | 12 units, built 1989, 1,164 sq ft | 12 units in Building C, built 2006, 1,079 or 1,457 sq ft |
Common parcel | 0.91 acre, one 450 sq ft pool | 3.59 acres in total, one 480 sq ft pool, a restroom building, carports |
Height | reads as two-story from unit numbering; not documented | reads as two-story from unit numbering; not documented |
Zoning, flood | GM-15; Zone X | GM-15; Zone X |
Recorded sales | 0 in 12 months; 1 in 24 months ($156,900); 22 since 2012, median $79,950 | 1 in 12 months ($125,000); 20 since 2011, median $120,750 |
Under 10 sales in every short window, so the sales are listed, not summarized. Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis; Sunbiz; Florida DBPR condominium register.
Meadows of Punta Gorda Condominium Association, Inc. is an active Florida not-for-profit filed on December 5, 1988 (Sunbiz). The state condominium register lists 12 units, recorded June 20, 1989 (Florida DBPR, condominium public records). The county roll agrees: 12 units on Royal Poinciana, built 1989, each 1,164 square feet. The buildings sit on a 0.91 acre common parcel with one 450 square foot pool. The roll designates the zoning as GM-15 and FEMA's map reads Zone X.
Plum Creek Condominium Association, Inc. is an active Florida not-for-profit filed on August 17, 2005 (Sunbiz). The two public records give two counts. The state register lists 38 units declared, recorded September 1, 2005. The county roll carries 12 units, all in Building C on N Plum Tree, built in 2006, at 1,079 or 1,457 square feet. Whether more buildings will be built is not on the public record we read, so we print both numbers and neither as the final count. The common parcel totals 3.59 acres, with one 480 square foot pool, a restroom building and carports. The zoning is GM-15 and the flood reading is Zone X.
A unit owner here answers to two layers. The condominium association governs the building and its common areas. The Burnt Store Meadows POA governs the plat, and Article 4.1 makes condominium unit owners members. Whether the POA bills each unit or bills through the condominium association is not published, and neither condominium's dues are published. The estoppel certificate for a specific unit states what is owed. We print no dues figure for either building.
Condominium sales are rare here, so each window is under 10 sales and we list rather than summarize.
Condominium sales are kept out of the 42-sale home median. Counting both condominiums, the 12-month residential total is 43 sales at the same $370,000 median. Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
Florida requires milestone inspections (s. 553.899) and structural integrity reserve studies (s. 718.112) for condominium buildings of three habitable stories or more. Both condominiums read as two-story from their unit numbering, so neither statute would apply, but no filing or document confirming building height was read. The state's reporting page is where a filed study would appear. Treat the height as unconfirmed until a recorded document shows it.
A condominium buyer here reads four things before a contract: the condominium declaration and bylaws, the association's budget and any reserve schedule, the estoppel certificate for the unit, and the Burnt Store Meadows POA's declarations and assessment status. The unit's flood reading also matters: both buildings read as Zone X on FEMA's map, and a map zone is not a determination for a building. Condominium dues for both buildings are unknown on the public record, so the estoppel certificate is the first place the figure appears.
Burnt Store Meadows has 144 vacant residential lots among its 895 parcels, 16.1 percent, and builders are still putting up new homes on them. The 12 months to September 9, 2026 brought 11 recorded lot sales at a $55,000 median and 5 builder-direct new homes at a $630,000 median.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; city and association documents read October 21, 2026).
The county roll codes 144 of 895 residential parcels as vacant: 95 coded 0000 and 49 coded 0001 (county roll, our count; 144 of 895 is 16.1 percent, our arithmetic). Of the 134 GM-15 parcels, 49 are vacant. The 13 vacant Highway Commercial parcels on the US 41 frontage are not residential lots and are kept out of every home statistic. Lots listed for sale on the MLS: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, Burnt Store Meadows recorded 11 lot sales (vacant land) at a $55,000 median, ranging from $30,000 to $68,000. The window ladder gives 20 sales at $55,950 in 24 months, 29 at $55,000 in 36 months, and 61 at $55,900 in 60 months, with a $30,000 to $240,000 range. All recorded history since May 27, 2009 holds 279 lot sales at a $36,000 median.
Set that beside the $630,000 builder-direct median for finished new homes: the difference covers construction, site work and builder profit, and it is not a build cost estimate. Lot prices never enter a home median on this page.
Recorded lot sales (vacant land) by calendar year, sales and median: 2019, 8 at $37,750; 2020, 18 at $45,500; 2021, 30 at $45,000; 2022, 21 at $57,000; 2023, 7 at $58,000; 2024, 10 at $54,000; 2025, 11 at $59,000; and 2026 through September 9, 7 at $55,000. The pace peaked in 2021, and the median has held between $54,000 and $59,000 since 2022.
For the larger multi-family zoned lots, GM-15 vacant-land sales recorded 13 sales in 60 months at a $94,900 median. Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
A single-family lot comes with the recorded declaration and the City's GS-3.5 rules. The declaration sets a home of at least 1,000 square feet of living area, setbacks of 25 feet at the front, 15 feet at the rear and 7.5 feet at the sides, a lot of at least 7,200 square feet and 75 feet wide, and easements of 6 feet at the sides and 10 feet at the rear. No accessory buildings or tents are allowed without consent, and no water wells. GS-3.5 under the City's Land Development Regulations sets a 9,600 square foot minimum lot, a height of 35 feet above base flood elevation and 3.5 units per acre. Read the single-family declaration before choosing a plan.
GM-15 lots allow single-family homes, duplexes, multi-family and cluster housing with development plan approval, a minimum lot of 8,000 square feet and a front setback of 25 feet. Height is 40 feet above base flood elevation to the tie beam, with no more than three habitable floors below it, and density can reach 15 units per acre under the City's rules. The multi-family declaration adds its own terms: at least 1,200 square feet per building with each unit at least 800 square feet unless authorized, 25 feet at the front and at the rear, a lot of at least 8,000 square feet and 75 feet wide, and 1.5 paved parking spaces per unit. No plan, rezoning or agenda item was found for the vacant GM-15 lots.
The Architectural Review Board approves exterior changes and new construction before work starts, at its monthly board meeting, with documents due the Friday before. A copy of the City building permit is due within 14 days or the approval is rescinded. The ARB new construction requirements of July 2026 add a performance and completion bond, whose amount is not published, and a $500 refundable, non-interest-bearing Clean Site deposit held to final inspection. Sites need silt fence on three sides, a dumpster and one site sign up to 2 by 3 feet. Owners keep 15 feet at the rear lot line clear for maintenance access to the greenbelt and ditch, plant hardwood trees at least 10 feet from the rear lot line, and are told a stem wall is recommended instead of fill.
The county roll shows 83 homes built from 2020 to 2025, 33 of them dated 2023 or later (county roll, our count). The five builder-direct sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026 were on S Blue Sage ($650,000, September 12, 2025), N Ficus Tree ($370,000, November 12, 2025), N Moss Rose ($630,000, March 6, 2026), Schefflera ($678,500, May 8, 2026, a new home still coded vacant on the roll) and South Seagrape Rd ($335,000, May 28, 2026). The records we read do not name the builders, so we print none. For the wider picture, see new construction in Punta Gorda. The county's sales file shows no new-home closings coded as vacant land in the 12, 24 or 36 month windows.
The 12-month record splits two ways: 37 resales at a $363,000 median and 5 builder-direct new homes at $630,000. That is a $267,000 gap, and it compares new homes with older resales, so it is not like-for-like. Builder-direct sales are 5 of 42, or 11.9 percent of the window. Buyers who want more new-construction choice nearby look at Burnt Store Village, where 40 of 83 recorded sales in the same 12 months were a builder's first sale. In Burnt Store Meadows, a buyer wanting new construction is weighing a handful of homes a year against a larger resale pool, plus the option of buying a lot.
The greenbelt in Burnt Store Meadows is one 87.58-acre common parcel owned by the Burnt Store Meadows POA, and 873 of the 882 mapped residential lots share at least 5 percent of their boundary with it. The recorded declarations call it a private park in which every lot holds an equal undivided interest.
Data updated: October 2026 (county roll and GIS parcel polygons, association documents and newsletters read October 21, 2026).
The county roll shows a single parcel owned by the Burnt Store Meadows POA, legally described as "Punta Gorda Isles Section 18 Greenbelts 87.58 Ac. as per Plat Book 10 Pg. 4," coded use 9400 and zoned GS-3.5. Every lot owner holds a share of it through the declarations.
Both the single-family and the multi-family declarations make the greenbelt walkways and private park areas a private park for lot owners and their guests. Each lot holds an equal undivided interest that cannot be partitioned. No automobiles, trucks or motorcycles may enter; bicycles, horses and approved golf carts are allowed. Trees and plants may not be cut, and no permanent fixtures may be placed on the common ground. Upkeep is shared equally by the lots. Read the recorded wording in the single-family and multi-family declarations.
The association's January 2026 newsletter lists what it maintains: entrance areas, greenbelts, the right of way along Burnt Store Road and interior drainage ditches, paid from the annual fee (Meadows Connection, January 2026). Vacant lots are not maintained by the association. They fall to the City, with the expense charged to the lot owner. A new landscape contractor started in January 2026. Mowing is triggered at about nine inches of growth in the green space.
The green space includes the ground along ditches and swales and "the four triangles, such as at the end of Ligustrum." The City owns the cul-de-sacs, and residents may plant and maintain them under the City's Cul-De-Sac Maintenance Policy (April 2026 newsletter; policy). A cul-de-sac planting is therefore a City-policy matter, not an association-maintained one.
The association sponsors a Little Free Library on the Royal Poinciana greenbelt between South Plum Tree and South Blue Sage (Meadows Connection, March 2026). The association's newsletters also mention a community bulletin board. We describe both as the association's own publications do and draw no legal conclusion about them.
The plat places park-like greenbelts behind most homes. Of 882 mapped residential parcels, 873 share at least 5 percent of their boundary with the greenbelt and 829 share 10 percent or more (our analysis of county GIS parcel polygons). The association describes the neighborhood as having "park-like greenbelts behind homes." In practice that means a rear lot line that meets common ground, with a 15 foot clear strip on new construction and rules on fences, hedges and sheds that look to the greenbelt edge. We found no measured price effect from greenbelt contact and print none.
Burnt Store Meadows has no clubhouse, golf course, community pool, marina, gate, tennis court or restaurant inside its boundaries. The county record shows no golf, park, club or marina use on any parcel, and the association's documents name no gate and no hall. Each amenity here is a short drive away.
Data updated: October 2026 (county records and association documents read October 21, 2026).
No clubhouse or community hall appears on the county record or in the association's documents. Zero county park, trail, facility or landmark features sit inside the plat. The two condominiums each keep a small pool for their own owners (450 square feet at Meadows of Punta Gorda, 480 at Plum Creek), and those are condominium common areas, not a neighborhood amenity. A buyer who wants a pool and a clubhouse looks next door at Seminole Lakes or at the county's South County Regional Park.
No parcel in Burnt Store Meadows carries a golf use code. The nearest courses are Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club at about 2.0 road miles and Twin Isles Country Club at about 2.9 road miles, both covered below.
Section 18 has no canals and no boat access. The county Waterways layer shows one 0.09 acre pond-sized feature inside the plat, and we make no claim beyond that. Boaters keep a boat at a marina or launch from a county or City ramp, listed below. Gulf access, bridge clearances and lock routes from any launch are not established on the public record we read.
Burnt Store Meadows is inland. Englewood Beach is about 31.7 road miles and 54 minutes away, and Boca Grande about 36.0 miles and 64 minutes, measured from the center of the neighborhood on October 21, 2026. Gasparilla Island State Park charges $3 per vehicle.
The plat holds no tennis or pickleball courts. South County Regional Park at 670 Cooper St, about 5.7 miles and 12 minutes away, offers tennis courts, pickleball courts, a heated 25-yard pool, a recreation center and disc golf on 84.3 acres.
Neither recorded declaration nor the association's documents name a gate or a guardhouse. The association describes the neighborhood as "located directly off US 41 or Burnt Store Road," and its January 2026 newsletter placed volunteers "at the Burnt Store Road and 41 entrances" for the yard sale. Neither entrance is described as gated.
The plat holds no restaurant. The nearest places to eat are on the US 41 frontage: Tamiami Tavern, open 8 am to 9 pm daily by its own site, and Jay's Smokin BBQ, both about 1.6 miles and 4 minutes from the center. Publix and Home Depot at Burnt Store Marketplace are about 2.5 road miles and 5 minutes away.
Burnt Store Meadows residents golf, boat and play outside the plat: Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club is about 2.0 road miles away, Twin Isles Country Club about 2.9, and the nearest paddle launch about 1.9. Boat ramps, preserves and a regional park with a heated pool fill out the list.
Data updated: October 2026 (club, county, City and state park pages read October 21, 2026).
The course sits inside Seminole Lakes, about 2.0 road miles and 6 minutes from the center of Burnt Store Meadows, and its operator calls it semi-private (Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club). It is an 18-hole, par 62 course of 4,400 yards from the championship tees, with tee ratings and slopes of Blue 60.7/100, White 59.7/95 and Red 58.5/96. The course reopened on October 21, 2026 after renovation with new TifEagle greens. The club is a separate organization from the Seminole Lakes Property Owners Association, whose home page describes a gated community of 450 homes.
The club stands in Burnt Store Isles, not in Burnt Store Meadows. At 301 Madrid Blvd, about 2.9 road miles and 7 minutes away, it is an 18-hole, par 72 course of 6,722 yards with private club amenities, public tee times and public dining (Twin Isles Country Club). On the club's form revised May 1, 2025, Full Club golf initiation is $1,500 and a single membership is $4,500 a year (membership application). The county record shows a sale of the club parcel on December 19, 2025 for $4,970,000. Confirm current terms with the club's own materials.
St. Andrews South describes itself as "a private, member owned golf club," with 18 holes and membership limited to 250 golf members (St. Andrews South Golf Club). It is about 6.3 road miles and 14 minutes from the center of Burnt Store Meadows.
The Burnt Store Marina Country Club sits in Lee County in Punta Gorda Isles Section 22. It has 27 holes in three nines and is semi-private, with the public welcome (Burnt Store Golf and Activity Club). Its 2026 to 2027 membership sheet lists Full Golf at $4,000 a year for a single and $5,500 for a couple, plus 6.5 percent tax (membership sheet).
The nearest paddle access is Allapatchee Shores Park at 3100 Hickory Ct, about 1.9 road miles and 5 minutes away. The county lists canoeing, kayaking and paddling, fishing and picnic tables there (Charlotte County). We call it a county paddle launch. The Taylor Road access to Alligator Creek Park is about 1.7 road miles and 5 minutes away.
The county lists Darst, Harbour Heights, Hathaway and Riverside as boat ramps for Punta Gorda (Charlotte County fishing and ramps page). Darst Park is about 7.1 road miles and 15 minutes from the center. Ponce de Leon Park, a City park at 3400 Ponce de Leon Pkwy, is about 8.2 miles and 19 minutes. Laishley Park Municipal Marina is about 6.3 miles and 14 minutes away (City of Punta Gorda), and the Safe Harbor marina in Lee County about 10.2 miles and 19 minutes. On October 21, 2026 the county reported seven fishing piers closed for restoration and Port Charlotte Beach Park boat ramp A closed, so check the county's park page before a trip.
The Charlotte Harbor Environmental Center runs Alligator Creek Preserve at 10941 Burnt Store Rd, with trails open seven days a week from dawn to dusk and a welcome center open October to April, about 1.7 road miles and 5 minutes from the center (CHEC). Charlotte Harbor Preserve State Park covers 45,507 acres, is open sunrise to sunset with no fee, and has its park office at 12301 Burnt Store Rd, about 2.3 miles and 5 minutes away (Florida State Parks). Trail mileage is described differently by the two operators, so we print none.
South County Regional Park at 670 Cooper St is an 84.3 acre county park with a heated 25-yard pool, pickleball and tennis courts, a recreation center and disc golf, about 5.7 miles and 12 minutes from the center (Charlotte County).
Burnt Store Meadows holds a calendar of association events on its own greenspace: a Car Show and Family Fun Festival on March 21, 2026, a Holiday Decorations Contest now in its 17th year, an Annual Community Yard Sale, Food Truck Fridays on Royal Poinciana, and a Halloween Trunk-or-Treat on October 31, 2026.
Data updated: October 2026 (association newsletters and calendar read October 21, 2026).
The Car Show and Family Fun Festival ran on Saturday, March 21, 2026, from 10 am to 2 pm, on the greenspace between Plum Tree and Blue Sage on both sides of Royal Poinciana (Meadows Connection, March 2026). The May 2026 newsletter calls it "a wonderful success" (Meadows Connection, May 2026). We found no record of how many attended.
The association's December 2025 newsletter announced the 17th annual Holiday Decorations Contest (Meadows Connection, December 2025). It is a contest the association runs among homes, and we describe nothing beyond what the newsletter says.
The Annual Community Yard Sale ran on Saturday, February 7, 2026, from 8 am to 1 pm (Meadows Connection, February 2026). The January 2026 newsletter placed volunteers at the Burnt Store Road and US 41 entrances for it.
Food Truck Fridays launched on November 21, 2025, from 5:00 to 7:30 pm on the 400 block of Royal Poinciana (Meadows Connection, November 2025). We print the launch only. No public record we read gives an ongoing schedule.
The Halloween Trunk-or-Treat is listed for October 31, 2026, from 4 to 6 pm, on the south side of Royal Poinciana between Plum Tree and Blue Sage (association calendar).
The Meadows Connection newsletter ceased after its September 2026 issue, when the publisher cited insufficient advertising revenue. The back issues cited above stay on the association's site, and the association's home page carries its calendar of meetings and events. The board of five meets on the third Monday at 6:30 pm, and the annual meeting is in September.
Burnt Store Meadows sits in Charlotte County evacuation zones B, C and D, with most of its parcels in Zone C. Hurricane Charley crossed Punta Gorda in 2004 and Ian made mainland landfall near Punta Gorda in 2022, but no public record we read gives a damage, surge or claim count for the neighborhood itself.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County evacuation zone layer, orders and Disaster Planning Guide; National Hurricane Center reports; Florida Building Commission; NOAA storm surge risk layers; Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll, all read October 21, 2026).
Charlotte County sorts its neighborhoods into lettered evacuation zones built from National Hurricane Center surge data, elevation and evacuation routes, so a zone letter is not the same thing as a flood zone. We overlaid the county's evacuation layer on 882 mapped residential parcels in Burnt Store Meadows (Charlotte County GIS, our analysis, October 21, 2026).
Evacuation zone | Parcels in Burnt Store Meadows |
|---|---|
Zone B | 212 |
Zone C | 650 |
Zone D | 20 |
Zone D is the smallest group, 20 parcels that include lots on S Blue Sage. Of the 212 parcels in Zone B, 65 sit in FEMA Zone X, so the two maps must be read separately: the evacuation zone tells you when the county may ask you to leave, and the flood zone tells you how FEMA rates the lot for insurance. Look up any address on the county's Know Your Zone page before hurricane season starts.
The National Hurricane Center reports that the eye of Hurricane Charley passed over Punta Gorda at about 2045 UTC on August 13, 2004 and that the eyewall struck the city. The Punta Gorda airport weather station measured 78 knots sustained with a 97-knot gust before its wind sensor failed (National Hurricane Center, Charley report).
The county roll gives Burnt Store Meadows homes built from 1982 to 2025, so Charley came in the middle of that span. We found no damage count for Section 18 in any public record, so this page does not describe how any Burnt Store Meadows home fared.
On September 28, 2022 the National Hurricane Center places the mainland landfall of Hurricane Ian near Punta Gorda. The Punta Gorda airport station read 76 knots sustained with a peak gust of 117 knots at about 2025 UTC before it stopped reporting (National Hurricane Center, Ian report). That 117-knot figure is the one we use, with the caveat that the station stopped reporting.
Charlotte County's long-term recovery plan counts 30,939 roofing permits countywide from October 2022 to June 15, 2023 (Charlotte County, Ian Long-Term Recovery Plan). That is a countywide count, not a Burnt Store Meadows count. The county ordered Zone A to leave on September 26, 2022 (release) and Zones A and B on September 27 (release).
Hurricanes Helene and Milton in 2024 were harbor and river surge events for this part of Charlotte County. The National Hurricane Center places Milton's surge at 5 to 8 feet above ground in northern Charlotte Harbor (National Hurricane Center, Milton report; Helene report). The county ordered evacuation by area for Helene on September 24, 2024 (order), Zones A and B for Milton on October 7 (order) and Zone C added on October 8 (order).
The table below puts the storms side by side. The last column is the same in every row because the record is the same: we found no public damage count for the neighborhood.
Storm | Date | What the record says near Punta Gorda | Evacuation order | Burnt Store Meadows record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Charley | August 13, 2004 | Eye over Punta Gorda; airport station 78 knots sustained, 97-knot gust, then failed | Not found in the records read | No damage count for the neighborhood in any public record read |
Irma | September 2017 | National Hurricane Center report on file; no measurement printed here | Not found in the records read | No damage count for the neighborhood in any public record read |
Ian | September 28, 2022 | Landfall near Punta Gorda; airport station 76 knots sustained, 117-knot gust, then stopped reporting | Zone A, then A and B | No damage count for the neighborhood in any public record read |
Helene | September 2024 | Harbor and river surge event | By area | No damage count for the neighborhood in any public record read |
Milton | October 2024 | Surge 5 to 8 feet above ground in northern Charlotte Harbor | A and B, then C | No damage count for the neighborhood in any public record read |
The first edition of the Florida Building Code took effect statewide on March 1, 2002 (Florida Building Commission milestones). On the county roll, 364 of the 751 homes in Burnt Store Meadows carry a year built before 2002 (48.5 percent) and 387 are 2002 or later, 47 of them dated 2002 exactly (county roll, our count). Because a year built is not a permit date, treat 364 as a clean floor for pre-code homes and not an exact split.
After Charley, the Florida Building Commission's after-action report found that homes built to the new statewide code fared far better than older homes, and that in Punta Gorda Isles older tile roofs had 40 percent or more damage while newer homes had 10 percent or less (after-action report). The report does not break out Section 18, so it describes the wider Punta Gorda Isles area, not a particular street here. On the roll, 146 homes are dated 2017 or later and 33 are dated 2023 or later, after Ian.
NOAA's National Storm Surge Risk Maps model the worst case for each hurricane category, which is not a forecast and not a flood zone (NOAA National Hurricane Center, storm surge risk maps). At eight sample points across the neighborhood on October 21, 2026, the west-end Royal Poinciana point was the only one wet in a Category 1 scenario, with under 3 feet of water above ground.
The two west-end points are wet from Category 2. The Zone X points stay dry through Category 2, and most stay dry through Category 3. Every point is wet in a Category 5 scenario. That pattern lines up with the flood map in the next section: the west end is the part of the neighborhood that the models treat as exposed first.
Charlotte County publishes a Disaster Planning Guide that explains evacuation zones, the difference between a flood zone and an evacuation zone, and what to bring if you leave (Charlotte County Disaster Planning Guide). Shelters are opened by county Emergency Management as a storm approaches, so which ones open is announced for each storm rather than fixed in advance.
We make no claim about how any Burnt Store Meadows home would perform in a future storm. For a specific house, the useful record is its own file: the permit history, roof covering and age, wind mitigation report and any prior claims.
Burnt Store Meadows does not have one flood zone. FEMA's flood map puts 148 of 882 mapped residential parcels on the west end in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 9 feet, 127 in shaded Zone X and 607 in unshaded Zone X, so the reading depends on the street and the lot.
Data updated: October 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer and the county copy, intersected with the Charlotte County parcel map, our analysis; City of Punta Gorda flood pages; read October 21, 2026).
We read FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer at eight sample points on October 21, 2026. A zone on a map is not a determination for a building, so check any address on FEMA's Map Service Center.
Street | Position | Zone | Base flood elevation | FIRM panel | Effective |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
N Plum Tree | North | X | None shown | 12015C0244G | December 15, 2022 |
N Plum Tree | Plum Creek | X | None shown | 12015C0407G | December 15, 2022 |
Satsuma Dr | Center | X | None shown | 12015C0407G | December 15, 2022 |
Royal Poinciana | Center | X | None shown | 12015C0407G | December 15, 2022 |
Royal Poinciana | West end | AE | 9 ft NAVD88 | 12015C0407G | December 15, 2022 |
Trumpet Tree | West end | AE | 9 ft NAVD88 | 12015C0407G | December 15, 2022 |
Gold Tree | Sample point | X | None shown | 12015C0407G | December 15, 2022 |
S Blue Sage | Sample point | X | None shown | 12015C0407G | December 15, 2022 |
Zone AE here is the coastal floodplain. Zone X in the table is the area of minimal flood hazard. No Letter of Map Revision showed at any of the eight points.
The line between Zone AE and Zone X cuts across several streets rather than following a block edge. This table sorts the streets by how they read on the FEMA layer. It is a street pattern from address points, not a lot-by-lot determination.
Entirely Zone AE | Straddles AE and shaded X | Entirely shaded X |
|---|---|---|
North Seagrape Rd, South Seagrape Rd, S Ficus Tree, N Ficus Tree, S Moss Rose, N Moss Rose, S Tulip Tree | Royal Poinciana, Trumpet Tree, Carambola, Vinca Rosea, N Tulip Tree | Philodendron, Carissa |
W Cashew is almost all shaded X. Every other street in Burnt Store Meadows reads as unshaded Zone X.
Parcels by zone | Count of 882 mapped parcels |
|---|---|
Zone AE (base flood elevation 9 ft) | 148 |
Shaded Zone X | 127 |
Unshaded Zone X | 607 |
FEMA's layer and the county's copy agree on all 882 parcels. The AE west end is also the newer part of the plat: 113 homes with a median year built of 2004 and 31 built before 2002, against 625 homes in the Zone X remainder with a median of 2001 and 328 built before 2002 (county roll, our count).
Shaded Zone X is the area FEMA maps as having a 0.2 percent annual chance of flood hazard. In Burnt Store Meadows 127 parcels sit in it. It is not the same as unshaded Zone X, and it is not Zone AE, so a lender or insurer may treat it differently from both. We therefore never describe Burnt Store Meadows as being in Zone X; the accurate statement is the three-way split above.
Six Letters of Map Amendment sit in the plat envelope. Inside Section 18, two on S Ficus Tree and Vinca Rosea kept the structure in the special flood hazard area, and one on N Blue Sage removed the property from it. A Letter of Map Amendment applies to a specific property, so the map zone for a parcel and the FEMA determination for the structure on it can differ. Ask for any letter that exists for the address.
Zone AE is part of the special flood hazard area. A federally backed mortgage on a building in that area carries a mandatory flood insurance purchase requirement, and Citizens Property Insurance requires flood coverage alongside wind coverage there (City of Punta Gorda, flood safety and protection; Citizens flood requirement). Outside the special flood hazard area flood insurance is optional unless a lender asks for it, and it is still available.
Flood is also not the same as wind. A home in unshaded Zone X can carry wind exposure and a home in Zone AE can be an older or a newer build. The flood zone, the evacuation zone and the building's age answer three different questions.
The City of Punta Gorda participates in the National Flood Insurance Program's Community Rating System at Class 5. That class gives a 25 percent premium discount in the special flood hazard area and 10 percent outside it. The class took effect October 1, 2016, and the City's flood readiness page says the 25 percent discount remained as of October 19, 2025 (City of Punta Gorda, flood readiness; City CRS certification letter).
Because Burnt Store Meadows is inside the City, its flood policies sit under the City's class and not the unincorporated county's. A discount is not a premium quote. The policy price depends on the building and its elevation, and we do not print a premium.
For buildings in Zone AE, the City applies a 50 percent rule. If the cost of a substantial improvement or repair reaches 50 percent or more of the building's market value, the whole building must be brought into compliance, with the finished floor at base flood elevation plus 1 foot in A zones. Flood panels, the removable barriers some owners use at doors, need a permit (City of Punta Gorda, 50 percent rule).
For a west-end buyer the rule matters most when a renovation, a storm repair or an addition is planned. Ask the City's building division how it would treat the planned work at the address.
An elevation certificate records the surveyed height of a building against the base flood elevation. The City's elevation certificate layer flags a certificate on 38 of 154 Zone AE address points in the plat. The layer holds a yes or no flag, not the elevation, so the number sits in the certificate itself. Charlotte County's flood portal holds downloadable certificates for some addresses.
We did not find elevation values for Burnt Store Meadows homes in any public record we read. A buyer in Zone AE can ask the seller for the certificate, and a surveyor can issue one when none exists.
Insurance for a Burnt Store Meadows home depends on the roof, the year built, the wind features and, on the west end, the flood zone. We print no premium, because premiums come only from an insurer quote, and we describe the public rules that insurers and Citizens apply instead.
Data updated: October 2026 (Citizens Property Insurance Detail by County reports through August 31, 2026; Citizens and Florida Office of Insurance Regulation pages; Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll, read October 21, 2026).
The county roll gives a year built for each home, not a roof date. Of the 751 homes, 364 carry a year built before 2002 and 146 are dated 2017 or later (county roll, our count). A 1982 home may have a roof replaced after Ian, and a 2019 home keeps its original roof, so the roll alone cannot tell an insurer the roof age.
Charlotte County counted 30,939 roofing permits from October 2022 to June 15, 2023, so many roofs in the area were replaced after Ian (Charlotte County, Ian Long-Term Recovery Plan). For a particular house, the permit record and the roofer's paperwork show the date. We found no insurer-filed premium for a Section 18 home.
Citizens Property Insurance, the state-backed insurer of last resort, publishes policy counts by county. Its Charlotte County personal residential multi-peril policies went from 14,624 on September 30, 2024 to 2,121 on August 31, 2026 (Citizens, Detail by County, September 30, 2024; August 31, 2026).
Citizens publishes county counts only, so there is no Burnt Store Meadows count. The reports give no cause for the change. The figures describe the county, and they say nothing about any one policy.
Citizens requires flood coverage with its wind coverage for any home in the special flood hazard area, which on this page means the Zone AE west end. Outside that area the requirement is phasing in by building value: it applies from January 1, 2026 for Coverage A above $400,000 and from January 1, 2027 for all policies (Citizens flood requirement).
A buyer who expects a Citizens policy should price flood coverage into the budget from the start. A private insurer sets its own rules, which can differ from Citizens.
Citizens asks for a four-point inspection on homes more than 20 years old on its applications (Citizens, inspections). A four-point inspection reviews the roof, electrical, plumbing and HVAC systems. Florida's statute on wind mitigation does not use the phrase four-point; it is an insurer requirement, not a state form (Florida Statutes 627.711).
With 364 of the 751 homes carrying a year built before 2002, a large share of the neighborhood is old enough that a new Citizens application would ask for one. Private insurers set their own age thresholds, which we did not read.
A wind mitigation inspection documents features such as roof shape, roof deck attachment, roof-to-wall connections and opening protection. Florida's uniform mitigation verification inspection form (OIR-B1-1802) was revised effective April 1, 2026, and a completed form stays valid for up to five years without a material change (Florida Office of Insurance Regulation).
My Safe Florida Home offers grants and inspections subject to legislative funding (My Safe Florida Home). Whether money is available changes, so read the program page when you are ready to apply.
Burnt Store Meadows includes two condominiums, Meadows of Punta Gorda (built 1989) and Plum Creek (Building C built 2006), each with its own association inside the master Burnt Store Meadows Property Owner's Association. Both parcels read as Zone X on FEMA's layer. A condominium association typically carries insurance on the building and common areas, and an owner carries a policy on the unit contents and interior.
Which exact coverage the association carries, and what it costs, is in the association's own budget and insurance documents, which the estoppel certificate and the association's records under Florida Statute 718 provide. We did not find those documents in a public source.
Before you write an offer on a Burnt Store Meadows home, ask for these documents:
For Burnt Store Meadows addresses, the Charlotte County school district's boundary locator lists East Elementary and Sallie Jones Elementary, Punta Gorda Middle and Charlotte High. The district assigns the school at registration, so the locator is a guide. The 2025-26 state grades run from A to B across the four schools.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Public Schools boundary locator, choice chart and calendars; Florida Department of Education school grades for 2025-26; OSRM road distances computed October 21, 2026).
The district's locator returned the same four schools at all eight sample points across the neighborhood: East Elementary and Sallie Jones Elementary (two elementary rows), Punta Gorda Middle and Charlotte High. The tool does not mark either elementary school as the zoned one, and the association's own site names East Elementary. We therefore say what the locator says and nothing more: both elementary schools appear, and the district's registration office makes the assignment.
School | Grades | Address | Calendar | 2025-26 state grade (percent of points) | Road miles from the center |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sallie Jones Elementary | Elementary | 1230 Narranja St | Year-round | A (69) | 5.4 |
East Elementary | Elementary | 27050 Fairway Dr | Year-round | B (56) | 7.2 |
Punta Gorda Middle | Middle | 1001 Education Ave | Traditional | A (64) | 5.8 |
Charlotte High | High | 1250 Cooper St | Traditional | B (63) | 5.4 |
The Florida Department of Education issued 2025-26 grades of A for Sallie Jones Elementary at 69 percent of points, B for East Elementary at 56, A for Punta Gorda Middle at 64 and B for Charlotte High at 63 (Sallie Jones, East, Punta Gorda Middle, Charlotte High). The district earned its first A in 15 years in the same cycle (Charlotte County Public Schools).
A grade is a snapshot of one year on one state formula. It is not a measure of a particular classroom or child.
East Elementary and Sallie Jones Elementary run the district's year-round calendar. For 2026-27 the first student day was July 16, 2026, the fall intersession runs October 19 to 30, 2026 and the last day is May 28, 2027 (year-round calendar). Punta Gorda Middle and Charlotte High start August 10, 2026 on the traditional calendar (traditional calendar). Charlotte High posts bell times of 7:10 am to 2:10 pm on its own site.
A request to change between the year-round and traditional elementary calendars goes through reassignment within the window the district sets at the start of the year-round calendar. The elementary and secondary schools listed here run on different calendars, so their breaks fall at different times.
The district's controlled open enrollment chart for 2026-27, read October 21, 2026, lists programmatic capacity and enrollment for each school (Charlotte County Public Schools, school choice).
School | Capacity | Enrollment | Status on the chart |
|---|---|---|---|
East Elementary | 792 | 668 | Closed to K and 1 |
Sallie Jones Elementary | 676 | 600 | Closed to K and 3 |
Punta Gorda Middle | 1,260 | 1,134 | Open |
Charlotte High | 1,760 | 1,860 | Enrollment above capacity |
The next chart update is November 2, 2026. Under the district's choice rules, an application to attend a school outside the assigned one may be made in any month if that school is not at capacity.
The district gives no bus service within two miles of the assigned school (Charlotte County Public Schools, transportation). From the center of Burnt Store Meadows the nearest listed school is 5.4 road miles away, so the two-mile rule does not remove bus eligibility. Whether a bus stop serves a particular street was not found; the district's transportation office issues stops at registration.
A boundary locator, a capacity chart and a state grade can each change between the day we read them and the day you register. The district can move attendance lines, and a school that is open today can close to new students. Run the district's own locator for the exact address and confirm the assignment at registration before you rely on any school in a purchase decision.
No hospital operates inside the City of Punta Gorda, and the nearest open emergency rooms to Burnt Store Meadows are in Port Charlotte, about 21 minutes away by free-flow drive time. AdventHealth has announced an emergency department off Jones Loop Road, about 6 minutes away, which is not open.
Data updated: October 2026 (HCA Florida, AdventHealth and Sarasota Memorial operator pages; Florida Department of Health trauma center list updated July 23, 2026; news reports; OSRM free-flow estimates from the center of the neighborhood, October 21, 2026).
The ShorePoint Health Punta Gorda hospital on East Marion Avenue closed after Hurricane Helene on September 25, 2024 and was further damaged by Milton. It has not reopened, and Ian did not close it (WINK News; Charlotte Sun). Sources differ on the building's address and the details of its sale, so we name the campus by street only. A buyer in Punta Gorda should plan around a city with no hospital.
AdventHealth has announced an emergency department on 17.46 acres at 26072 Glasgow Ave off Jones Loop Road, about 2.5 road miles and 6 minutes from the center of Burnt Store Meadows. Phase 1 is a 12-bed emergency department. The City's Board of Zoning Appeals recommended a parking variance, reported October 1, 2026, and groundbreaking was expected in November 2026 (AdventHealth; Charlotte Sun).
It is not open and has no confirmed opening date. Do not count it as a nearby emergency room when planning.
Facility | Operator | Status | Road miles | Minutes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
AdventHealth Port Charlotte | AdventHealth | Open emergency department | 10.9 | 21 |
HCA Florida Fawcett Hospital | HCA Florida | Open 24/7 emergency room | 11.0 | 21 |
HCA Florida Tamiami Trail Emergency | HCA Florida | Free-standing emergency room, open 24 hours | 17.9 | 32 |
Sarasota Memorial ER and Health Care Center at North Port | Sarasota Memorial | Free-standing emergency room | 17.9 | 33 |
Sources: HCA Florida Fawcett; HCA Florida Tamiami Trail Emergency; Sarasota Memorial, North Port. We print no hospital bed count. The sources disagree and the count is not needed to compare drive times.
Charlotte County has no designated trauma center on the Florida Department of Health list updated July 23, 2026 (Florida Department of Health). The nearest Level II trauma center is Gulf Coast Medical Center in Lee County, about 26.4 road miles and 41 minutes away. Sarasota Memorial Hospital is the other, about 55.9 miles and 70 minutes away.
Punta Gorda Fire Station 2 at 2601 Acline Rd is about 2.0 road miles and 5 minutes from the center of the neighborhood (NERIS station listing). The county fire layer places the tested points in Punta Gorda response area R5A. No automatic-aid agreement between the City and the county was read, so we state the nearest station and the layer reading only.
From the center of Burnt Store Meadows, Publix is about 5 minutes away, downtown Punta Gorda about 12, Punta Gorda Airport 13 and Interstate 75 about 8. Fort Myers is about 28 minutes, Port Charlotte Town Center 27 and Sarasota 72. These are free-flow estimates.
Data updated: October 2026 (OSRM free-flow road estimates from the center of the neighborhood on October 21, 2026; Florida Department of Transportation interchange list; operator pages).
Destination | Road miles | Minutes |
|---|---|---|
Tamiami Tavern and Jay's Smokin BBQ, US 41 | 1.6 | 4 |
Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club | 2.0 | 6 |
Punta Gorda Fire Station 2, Acline Rd | 2.0 | 5 |
Walmart Supercenter, 5001 Taylor Rd | 2.1 | 6 |
Publix and Home Depot, Burnt Store Marketplace | 2.5 | 5 |
AdventHealth planned emergency department site | 2.5 | 6 |
Twin Isles Country Club | 2.9 | 7 |
Walgreens, 3795 Tamiami Trl | 3.2 | 7 |
I-75 northbound entrance, Jones Loop Road (Exit 161) | 3.0 | 8 |
I-75 southbound access toward Tuckers Grade (Exit 158) | 3.5 | 7 |
Punta Gorda Airport | 4.7 | 13 |
Punta Gorda Charlotte Library | 5.5 | 11 |
South County Regional Park | 5.7 | 12 |
Fishermen's Village | 5.9 | 13 |
Downtown Punta Gorda, City Hall | 6.1 | 12 |
St. Andrews South Golf Club | 6.3 | 14 |
Laishley Park Municipal Marina | 6.3 | 14 |
Darst Park boat ramp | 7.1 | 15 |
Ponce de Leon Park | 8.2 | 19 |
Safe Harbor Burnt Store marina (Lee County) | 10.2 | 19 |
Port Charlotte Town Center | 14.2 | 27 |
Downtown Fort Myers | 19.2 | 28 |
Cape Coral City Hall | 21.5 | 32 |
North Port City Hall | 25.9 | 35 |
Englewood Beach | 31.7 | 54 |
Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) | 34.8 | 43 |
Boca Grande | 36.0 | 64 |
Downtown Venice | 40.2 | 54 |
Downtown Sarasota | 58.0 | 72 |
Downtown Tampa | 107.1 | 123 |
These are OSRM free-flow estimates from the center of the neighborhood on October 21, 2026. Add time for traffic and signals, especially on US 41 in season.
The fastest northbound entrance to Interstate 75 from the center of the neighborhood is at Jones Loop Road, Exit 161, about 3.0 road miles and 8 minutes away. The fastest southbound access heads toward Tuckers Grade, Exit 158, about 3.5 miles and 7 minutes away (Florida Department of Transportation, I-75 exit numbers). The routing engine chooses whichever entrance is fastest for the destination.
Punta Gorda Airport (PGD) is about 4.7 road miles and 13 minutes away. Allegiant flies there, and Sun Country adds seasonal service to Minneapolis-St. Paul from December through April 2027. Long-term parking is $14.00 a day at most and short-term parking is $24.00 (Punta Gorda Airport, airlines; parking).
Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) in Fort Myers is about 34.8 miles and 43 minutes away, which gives the larger route network a reasonable alternative.
Burnt Store Meadows is not on the water, and the nearest Gulf beaches are a longer drive. Englewood Beach is about 31.7 miles and 54 minutes away. Boca Grande is about 36.0 miles and 64 minutes away, and Gasparilla Island State Park charges $3 per vehicle (Florida State Parks, hours and fees).
County closures on October 21, 2026 included the Englewood Beach boardwalk, with the park and lot open (Charlotte County, facilities status). Check that page before a beach trip.
We routed from the center of the neighborhood with the OSRM open routing engine on OpenStreetMap road data, free-flow with no traffic, on October 21, 2026. Destinations were geocoded to street addresses. The same method was used for every row, so the rows compare with each other, but an actual drive varies by time of day and season.
Around Burnt Store Meadows, the largest public project is the Burnt Store Road East/West Connector, a new two-lane road from US 41 to Burnt Store Road funded from the one-cent sales tax extension that Charlotte County voters approved on November 3, 2026 (unofficial results). Pulte's Cassia Bay is the nearest new community, and nothing has been filed for the neighborhood's vacant commercial lots.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County FY2027 adopted capital program, adopted September 22, 2026; Charlotte County sales tax project sheet; City of Punta Gorda FY2027 proposed budget dated August 15, 2026; Charlotte County ordinances and plats; read October 21, 2026; sales tax result read November 18, 2026).
Item | Where | Status on the record |
|---|---|---|
Burnt Store Road East/West Connector (Tuckers Grade extension) | New two-lane road, US 41 to Burnt Store Road | FY2027 program $44,783 thousand, "Pending Sales Tax 2026", in progress; sales tax sheet $46,176,000; ballot November 3, 2026 |
Burnt Store Road Phases 2 and 3 | North of Zemel Rd to the Lee County line | Phase 3 closed; Phase 2 in debt service |
Burnt Store Road and Home Depot signal | US 41 corridor retail | MPO priority $1.95 million; City table $1,338,000 |
Cassia Bay (Pulte) | About 0.5 mile, east of Burnt Store Road | County plat and site-plan filings; City budget lists Phase 1A of 100 units |
County Fire Station 17 | 11711 Tamiami Trail | Under construction |
AdventHealth emergency department | 26072 Glasgow Ave, Jones Loop Road | Parking variance recommended; groundbreaking expected November 2026; not open |
Sage Pointe | Burnt Store Rd and Zemel Rd, about 5 to 6 miles north | County Ordinance 2026-024, up to 999 units |
13 vacant commercial parcels and vacant GM-15 lots | Inside the plat | No agenda, plan or rezoning found |
City pathways | Citywide | Goal of 18 miles complete by June 2028; nothing found inside Section 18 |
US 41 traffic | Zemel Rd to Taylor Rd | 21,620 vehicles a day (2025) |
Charlotte County's FY2027 adopted capital program, adopted September 22, 2026, carries $44,783 thousand for the Burnt Store Road East/West Connector: $4,409 thousand for design, $6,263 thousand for right of way and $34,111 thousand for construction across FY2027 to FY2029. The funding source is "Pending Sales Tax 2026" and the status is in progress (Charlotte County, FY2027 Capital Improvement Program).
The county's sales tax project sheet prices the road at $46,176,000 under the one-cent sales tax extension, which Charlotte County voters approved on November 3, 2026, 56,284 votes to 38,396 on unofficial results from the Supervisor of Elections (Charlotte Sun) (project sheet). The two numbers are different documents on different bases, so we show both with their dates. The road runs from US 41 to Burnt Store Road, a Tuckers Grade extension. The records we read do not state its alignment relative to Section 18, so we make no claim about whether it passes close to any street here.
Burnt Store Road Phase 3, north of Zemel Road to the Lee County line, is closed in the FY2027 program, and Phase 2 is in debt service. The county's Burnt Store Area Plan, in a June 11, 2024 presentation, counts 10,599 entitled units and 511,500 square feet of commercial space in the plan area (Charlotte County, Burnt Store Area Plan).
That plan covers the corridor in general. It is context for growth along Burnt Store Road, not a schedule for any road next to Burnt Store Meadows.
State counts for 2025 show 21,620 vehicles a day on US 41 from Zemel Road to Taylor Road and 24,000 from the Lee County line to Zemel Road (Florida Department of Transportation 2025 traffic counts). We print no Burnt Store Road count, because the sources we read disagree.
The 2020 US 41 Corridor Vision Plan has a "Burnt Store Meadows Study Segment" and notes the U-turns at Taylor Road and Royal Poinciana (Charlotte County, US 41 Corridor Vision Plan). The City council agenda of November 1, 2023 raised the Royal Poinciana turn lane. A separate project, a traffic signal at Burnt Store Road and the Home Depot entrance, is an MPO priority at $1.95 million, while the City's February 2026 capital update shows $1,338,000 (City CIP update).
Cassia Bay is a Pulte community on 68.43 acres east of Burnt Store Road, about 0.5 mile from Section 18. The county has plat and site-plan filings on it, and the City's FY2027 proposed budget also lists Phase 1A with four tracts and 100 units (City of Punta Gorda, FY2027 proposed budget). We do not say which body approves it.
Pulte's own page, builder marketing seen October 21, 2026, shows homes from $295,990 to $429,990 (Pulte, Cassia Bay). Those are builder marketing prices, not recorded sales, so they do not compare directly with the 12-month Burnt Store Meadows resale median of $363,000.
County Fire Station 17 at 11711 Tamiami Trail is under construction (City of Punta Gorda, FY2027 proposed budget). AdventHealth's planned emergency department at 26072 Glasgow Ave is described in the hospitals section above. It is recommended for a parking variance, groundbreaking is expected in November 2026 and it is not open.
Sage Pointe is Charlotte County Ordinance 2026-024 (petition PD-25-13), adopted July 28, 2026, for up to 999 units, including up to 300 RV sites, on 277.55 acres at Burnt Store Road and Zemel Road (Charlotte County, PD-25-13). It sits about 5 to 6 miles north of Burnt Store Meadows. We mention it as corridor context only; it is not a neighbor.
Burnt Store Meadows has 13 vacant Highway Commercial parcels on the US 41 frontage and a group of vacant GM-15 lots. We found no City agenda, development plan or rezoning for either set on October 21, 2026. Zoning allows a use; it does not mean one is planned.
A buyer who cares about what could be built on a commercial or GM-15 lot should read the City's land development regulations and then ask the City's planning office for any application on file for that parcel.
The City's FY2027 proposed budget sets a goal of completing the 18-mile pedestrian and bicycle pathway that connects all neighborhoods by June 2028. We found no pathway or sidewalk project inside Section 18. Harborwalk, the downtown harbor trail, runs 2.5 miles from Trabue Park to Fishermen's Village (City of Punta Gorda, Pathways).
South County Regional Park, an 84.3 acre county park with a heated 25-yard pool, pickleball and tennis courts, a recreation center and disc golf, is about 5.7 road miles away (Charlotte County, South County Regional Park).
Burnt Store Meadows has no restaurant inside the neighborhood, but a Publix with a pharmacy and a Home Depot are about 5 minutes away on Tamiami Trail, Walmart is 6 minutes away and downtown Punta Gorda is about 12. Every distance below is measured from the center of the neighborhood.
Data updated: October 2026 (store, park and City pages read October 21, 2026; OSRM free-flow road estimates from the center of the neighborhood).
Publix store 1557 at Burnt Store Marketplace, 3941 Tamiami Trl, is open from 7 am to 10 pm daily and has a pharmacy. It is about 2.5 road miles and 5 minutes from the center of the neighborhood. A Home Depot (store 6950) shares the same address at the same distance (Publix; Home Depot).
Walmart Supercenter 778 at 5001 Taylor Rd is open from 6 am to 11 pm daily with a pharmacy, about 2.1 miles and 6 minutes away (Walmart). Walgreens 5017 at 3795 Tamiami Trl is about 3.2 miles and 7 minutes away (Walgreens). Aldi at 26279 Jones Loop Rd is open 9 am to 8 pm daily and about 7 minutes away (Aldi).
Two restaurants stand on US 41 beside the neighborhood's frontage: Tamiami Tavern at 10361 Tamiami Trl, open from 8 am to 9 pm daily by its own site, and Jay's Smokin BBQ at 10175 Tamiami Trail. Both are about 1.6 road miles and 4 minutes away (Tamiami Tavern; Jay's Smokin BBQ). No restaurant operates inside Burnt Store Meadows.
Downtown Punta Gorda, measured to City Hall, is about 6.1 road miles and 12 minutes away. Fishermen's Village is about 5.9 miles and 13 minutes away (Fishermen's Village). Harborwalk runs 2.5 miles from Trabue Park to Fishermen's Village, and the City's Pathways network covers about 18 miles of bicycle and pedestrian trails.
Three markets operate in Punta Gorda on a weekly schedule: the Saturday Downtown Punta Gorda Farmers Market at Taylor and Olympia, 8 am to 1 pm from October to April; the History Park Sunday Market at 501 Shreve St, 9 am to 1 pm; and the Punta Gorda Isles Civic Association Wednesday market at 2001 Shreve St, 8 am to 1 pm (Chamber event record; History Park; PGICA). Dates were seen between October 2025 and August 2026, so confirm the season before you go.
The Punta Gorda Charlotte Library at 401 Shreve St is about 5.5 road miles and 11 minutes from the center of the neighborhood (Charlotte County, Punta Gorda Charlotte Library). The neighborhood association also sponsors a Little Free Library on its Royal Poinciana greenbelt.
The county utilities mapbook's certificated service-area layers return the City of Punta Gorda for both water and sewer at five sample points across the plat. Whether every lot is connected to central sewer was not found, and the 1970s declarations provide for a sewer availability charge on later installation, so confirm the connection from the address's utility bill or a septic permit record.
City water and wastewater rates effective October 1, 2026, in the inside-city-limits column, are a water base of 15.18 plus a customer charge of 6.60 and residential tiers per 1,000 gallons of 4.51 for 0 to 5,000, 5.20 for 5,000 to 10,000, 6.43 for 10,000 to 20,000, 7.88 for 20,000 to 40,000 and 9.60 over 40,000, with a wastewater base of 36.91 plus 4.66 per 1,000 gallons (City of Punta Gorda, water and wastewater rates). The outside-city column is higher, with a water base of 18.97 and a wastewater base of 46.14.
The City's account page says monthly charges include water, wastewater and refuse (City of Punta Gorda, utility accounts). Stormwater and refuse fee amounts were not found.
Charlotte Rides, the county's curbside reservation service, covers most of the county, but we did not find whether Section 18 is inside its map (Charlotte County, Charlotte Rides service area). No fixed-route bus stop was found. A resident should plan around a car, and should check the county's service-area map for a specific address.
Burnt Store Meadows in Punta Gorda recorded 42 home sales at a $370,000 median in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, more than Seminole Lakes with 25 and fewer than Burnt Store Village with 83. This section sets six neighborhoods side by side on one county tool and one window.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; one county tool, one window and one set of definitions for every row).
Each row below counts recorded sales for the 12 months to September 9, 2026, from the same Charlotte County file and the same qualification rules. Medians are the middle value of that row's own sales, and the per square foot column divides by county heated area.
Community | Recorded home sales, the 12 months to September 9, 2026 | Median | Per sq ft of county heated area (n) | Builder-direct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Burnt Store Meadows | 42 | $370,000 | $189.87 (41) | 5 |
25 | $305,000 | $183.96 (25) | 0 | |
83 | $329,000 | $175.13 (69) | 40 | |
66 | $433,500 | $235.23 (60) | 17 | |
Deep Creek (single-family plats) | 316 | $360,000 | $178.14 (309) | 46 |
Burnt Store Isles (homes only) | 78 | $657,200 | $286.50 (77) | 0 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. Every row uses the same county tool and window; the per square foot denominator is county heated area. Burnt Store Isles is a canal community and Burnt Store Village is unincorporated, so neither is like-for-like with Burnt Store Meadows.
Start with the count, then the builder-direct column. Burnt Store Meadows had 5 builder-direct sales among its 42, so most of its sales were resales. Burnt Store Village had 40 builder-direct sales among its 83, and Burnt Store Lakes had 17 among its 66, which means their medians blend new homes with resales in a different proportion. Seminole Lakes and Burnt Store Isles recorded no builder-direct sales in the window.
Then read what each row is a row of. The Burnt Store Isles row counts homes only; the sale of the Twin Isles golf-course parcel is excluded, because a golf-course parcel is not a home. Burnt Store Lakes has 1,848 parcels on the county roll and 991 of them are coded vacant, so its sales come from a plat that is still mostly open land. Deep Creek is a roll of single-family plats with 6,703 parcels, so its 316 sales describe a much larger place.
The per square foot figures divide a price by the county's heated area, which is not the same measure an MLS listing prints as living area. Compare them only with each other. A median also moves with the mix of homes sold, so two neighborhoods with similar medians can hold very different houses.
Nothing in this table ranks one neighborhood above another. If a specific comparison matters, the useful version lines up the recorded sales of two streets or two lot sizes side by side, and that is a pull we can make from the county file.
Burnt Store Meadows and Seminole Lakes share a greenbelt edge, the same city and the same ZIP, but they differ on the gate, the golf club and the sales record: 42 sales at $370,000 here and 25 at $305,000 there in the same 12 months, $65,000 apart.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; association and club websites read October 21, 2026).
Factor | Burnt Store Meadows | Seminole Lakes |
|---|---|---|
Government | City of Punta Gorda | City of Punta Gorda |
Homes | 751 homes and 144 vacant lots on 895 residential parcels, plus two 12-unit condominiums | 450 homes (its association's count) |
Built | 1982 to 2025, median 2002; new homes still being built | Development began in 1992 |
Gate | No gate | "A gated community" (its association) |
Golf | None on site; Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club about 2 road miles away, semi-private | The semi-private club inside the community is a separate organization from its association |
Common amenities | Greenbelts, a Little Free Library, association events; no pool or clubhouse | Bocce courts, a heated pool, a workout room, a library and a tiki hut (its association) |
Recorded sales, 12 months | 42, median $370,000 | 25, median $305,000 |
Per sq ft of county heated area | $189.87 | $183.96 |
Builder-direct sales | 5 | 0 |
Vacant lots | 144 | None of note on its roll profile |
Lots | Median about 9,946 sq ft (our analysis); 20,000 sq ft GM-15 lots on the collector | Not measured here |
Flood | 148 of 882 mapped lots in Zone AE on the west end, the rest Zone X | Not measured here (see its guide) |
Association fee | Not published | Not measured here (see its guide) |
CDD | None | None |
Sources: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis; the Seminole Lakes Property Owners Association home page; the Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club about page.
Burnt Store Meadows sits in Charlotte County tax district 150 at 16.8148 mills for 2026, carries no community development district and no county MSBU, and bills one Burnt Store Meadows POA assessment per platted parcel each year. The amount of that assessment is not published; the estoppel certificate for a parcel states it. The two condominiums add their own association layer.
Seminole Lakes is also inside the City of Punta Gorda and shows no community development district, so the same kinds of layers apply there: a City levy, an association assessment and, for anyone who joins, the golf club's separate dues. This page measured the tax bill and the fee stack for Burnt Store Meadows only. For the Seminole Lakes association fee and its millage, use its own guide, and for either neighborhood confirm the figures on the estoppel certificate and the tax bill for the address.
The clearest difference is the gate. Seminole Lakes' association describes "a gated community within the confines of Punta Gorda, FL city limits." No document read for Burnt Store Meadows names a gate or a guardhouse, and the association says the neighborhood is located directly off US 41 or Burnt Store Road.
Golf is the second difference. The Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club is a semi-private 18-hole, par 62 course of 4,400 yards from the championship tees, and the club is a separate organization from the Seminole Lakes POA (club website). It reopened on October 21, 2026 after renovation with new TifEagle greens. From the center of Burnt Store Meadows it is about 2.0 road miles and 6 minutes away.
On common amenities, the Seminole Lakes association lists bocce courts, a heated pool, a workout room, a library and a tiki hut. Burnt Store Meadows has greenbelts, a Little Free Library and association events, and no community pool or clubhouse. The owners of the two condominiums inside Burnt Store Meadows have a pool at each condominium.
Burnt Store Meadows homes were built from 1982 to 2025 with a county-roll median year of 2002, and 83 were built from 2020 to 2025. Seminole Lakes development began in 1992, and its homes were built from 1992 to 2003. Burnt Store Meadows has 144 vacant lots and 5 builder-direct sales in the 12 months; Seminole Lakes recorded none.
The sales counts reflect that mix. Burnt Store Meadows turned over 42 of its 751 homes in the window, 5.6 percent, against 25 sales for Seminole Lakes' 450 homes by its association's count.
A buyer who wants a gate, an on-site pool and lake and golf views, and accepts older homes and smaller lots, looks first at Seminole Lakes. A buyer who wants an open greenbelt plat with larger lots, a chance at a newer home or a lot to build on, and no on-site pool or clubhouse, looks first at Burnt Store Meadows. Either way, the flood reading, the fee layers and the governing documents are checked by address and by document before a contract.
The pros of Burnt Store Meadows are city jurisdiction with no CDD, 87.58 acres of greenbelt, public governing documents, a wide price spread and newer homes still being built. The cons are an unpublished association assessment, a flood split on the west end, an older housing stock, no on-site amenities and no hospital inside the City.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; county roll of October 4, 2026, our count; FEMA, county and City records read October 21, 2026).
Neither list is a verdict. Each trade-off is a document to read before a contract, and each strength is a fact to confirm at the address.
If you're searching for the best Burnt Store Meadows listing agent, or thinking, "I need to sell my house in Burnt Store Meadows...", start with the county record: 42 recorded sales at a $370,000 median in the 12 months to September 9, 2026. McGreevy and Comisar prices from that record and prepares the fee, flood and document answers buyers ask.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; FEMA, county and City records read October 21, 2026).
Honors and recognition:
The Burnt Store Meadows record in brief (the 12 months to September 9, 2026, Charlotte County recorded sales): 42 home sales, median $370,000; 41 single-family sales at the same median; 37 resales at a $363,000 median; 5 builder-direct new homes at a $630,000 median; 11 recorded lot sales (vacant land) at a $55,000 median. Days on market and sale-to-list: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.)
Request your free valuation at https://mcgreevyandcomisar.com/home-valuation, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome. For the wider Punta Gorda picture, read selling a home in Punta Gorda and the Punta Gorda home valuation guide.
For this neighborhood alone, read selling a home in Burnt Store Meadows and the Burnt Store Meadows home valuation guide.
★★★★★ "Marc helped me through the home selling process every step. He was very responsive and knows the market well. With another agent my house did not sell for one year, but Marc got me 3 offers within a few months." Verified Zillow review
Burnt Store Meadows has 751 homes on the county roll, so 42 recorded sales in the window is turnover of 5.6 percent (our arithmetic). The sales ranged from $195,000 to $680,000 and ran $189.87 per square foot of county heated area (41 sales with a measured area). The highest was a resale on N Plum Tree and the lowest a resale on Parkinsonia. Price bands: 1 sale under $200,000, 5 from $200,000 to $300,000, 18 from $300,000 to $400,000, 10 from $400,000 to $500,000, 8 from $500,000 to $750,000 and none above that.
The calendar-year medians show the shape of the last three years: $480,000 in 2023 (44 sales), $443,500 in 2024 (49), $390,000 in 2025 (32) and $363,000 for 2026 through September 9 (33). Those are medians of different sets of homes, not a repeat-sale index. Association dues as entered in MLS listings, active listings and months of supply: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
Four questions come up before price. First, what the Burnt Store Meadows POA assessment is and whether anything is owed, which the estoppel certificate answers. Second, where the home sits on the flood map, since 148 of 882 mapped lots on the west end are in Zone AE and the rest are Zone X. Third, the roof and the insurance picture, because 364 of 751 homes predate the 2002 statewide building code. Fourth, which declaration governs the lot and what it allows for fences, parking and exterior changes.
A seller who has those four answers in hand, with the declarations and the estoppel ordered early, spares the buyer's side a round of questions. The documents are listed on the association's Deed Restrictions page and in the downloads at the end of this page.
Five of the 42 sales were builder-direct new homes, with a $630,000 median and a range of $335,000 to $678,500. The 37 resales had a $363,000 median. The $267,000 gap compares new homes with older resales, so it is not like-for-like and it is not an estimate of what a resale is worth. Builder-direct sales were 11.9 percent of the window.
A resale prices against resales first: the same street, a similar size and year built, and the condition. The new homes set the ceiling a buyer sees when comparing, which is why we list the sales street by street in the market section and price from the closest ones.
The west end of the plat is the part of Burnt Store Meadows on the FEMA map's Zone AE, with a base flood elevation of 9 ft NAVD88. It is also the newer part: 113 homes with a median year built of 2004, 31 of them built before 2002 (county roll, our count). In the 12 months there were 7 sales in Zone AE, too few to read a median from, against 35 in the rest of the plat at $380,000 (our analysis).
A buyer will ask for the elevation certificate if the home has one. The City's layer flags a certificate on 38 of 154 address points in Zone AE in the plat, though it records a yes or no and not the elevation. The City's Community Rating System Class 5 gives a 25 percent flood premium discount inside the special flood hazard area (City flood readiness page).
There were 11 recorded lot sales (vacant land) in the 12 months, at a $55,000 median and a range of $30,000 to $68,000. Over 60 months there were 61 at $55,900. Vacant lots pay the association assessment, and the violation protocol gives the owner 30 days to cure a vacant-lot violation. A builder will price a lot against what the declaration and the City allow on it, so the zoning (GS-3.5 or GM-15) and the flood reading belong in the first conversation.
Who is the best listing agent for Burnt Store Meadows? McGreevy and Comisar, who lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with a record built on county facts like those on this page.
What is my Burnt Store Meadows home worth? The county record puts the 12-month median at $370,000, and the free valuation at mcgreevyandcomisar.com/home-valuation prices your street and size. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
How long does it take to sell a home in Burnt Store Meadows? Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
Do I need association approval to sell? The bylaws read contain no sale-approval clause and no transfer fee; the estoppel certificate states any fee due.
What will my buyer ask first? The assessment and estoppel, the flood reading by street, the roof age and the declaration for the lot.
Can I sell while builders are selling new homes here? Yes. Five builder-direct sales and 37 resales closed in the same 12 months, and a resale prices against resales first.
Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar of Domain Realty advise Burnt Store Meadows buyers and sellers from the county record, the recorded documents and the agency maps rather than from guesswork, and they answer for the figures on this page. As the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate, and McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in sales. Both have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Learn how the team works on the about page.
McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Burnt Store Meadows realtor. ★★★★★ "Best realtor experience ever! We were out of own buyers coming in for the weekend to look for a new home, Marc was extremely organized in taking us to see a number of houses and shuffling the schedule, as we arrived early, to make the best use of our time. He was extremely helpful in negotiating what we thought was a great deal on the new home that we purchased that same weekend. Beyond that he was kind enough to take some measurements at the house for us weeks later to keep us from making a trip back to town before the closing. We will most definitely be using this realtor again if the need arrives in the future." Verified Google review
Honors and recognition:
Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC).
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.
Burnt Store Meadows buyers ask where it is, whether it is in the city, what the association charges, what the rules allow and how flood, schools and drive times work. The answers below use county records, association documents and agency pages, with each figure tied to its source and window.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; county roll of October 4, 2026, our count; FEMA, county, City and association records read October 21, 2026).
Burnt Store Meadows is a deed-restricted neighborhood of single-family homes in Punta Gorda, Charlotte County, Florida, set between US 41 and Burnt Store Road. The association describes it as "located directly off US 41 or Burnt Store Road" (association home page). Royal Poinciana is the spine road, and every home is in ZIP 33955. The City's comprehensive plan says the city's southern boundary generally follows the southern boundary of the Burnt Store Meadows Subdivision (Comprehensive Plan 2045).
Yes. Every Burnt Store Meadows home is inside the City of Punta Gorda, and the parcels carry Charlotte County tax district 150, the city district. The City's Land Development Regulations, Sec. 3.13, list Punta Gorda Isles Section 18 among the plats in the Special Residential Overlay District (Chapter 26). The date the land came into the City was not found in any public record read, so we print none.
Punta Gorda Isles Section 18 is the platted name of Burnt Store Meadows. The county's subdivisions layer shows Plat Book 10, Page 4, and the recorded declarations cite pages 4-A through 4-Q. The developer was Punta Gorda Isles, Inc., and the association's 2020 restated Articles say it completed the development in December 1980 (Articles). The oldest home on the county roll is dated 1982. The plat's recording date was not read. The wider platting program is covered on our Punta Gorda Isles guide.
Burnt Store Meadows is Punta Gorda Isles Section 18, inside the City. Burnt Store Isles is Section 15, a canal community around Twin Isles Country Club. Burnt Store Village is Section 16, outside the city limits. Burnt Store Lakes is Section 21, and Burnt Store Marina is Section 22 in Lee County. Burnt Store Golf Villas, Burnt Store Park and Burnt Store Square are separate plats. The Meadows association site is bsmpoa.com, and the Marina association uses bsm22.org.
The record gives two legends and no certainty. The county's Burnt Store Area Plan tells of a German settlers' store, or of Seminole raiders burning a trading post in 1848 (Burnt Store Area Plan, 2005). A Charlotte Sun history column says the trading post was abandoned in 1849, that the burning is undocumented, and that an 1883 map marks a "Burnt Store" area (Charlotte Sun). The name Burnt Store Meadows was in use by 1984; who coined it was not found.
Every Burnt Store Meadows home is in ZIP 33955. The commercial frontage on US 41, 15 parcels zoned Highway Commercial, carries ZIP 33950. Because ZIP 33955 is mostly unincorporated, the ZIP does not tell you whether an address is in the City. The tax district does: Burnt Store Meadows parcels are in district 150, the city district (2026 final rate chart).
Yes. The Burnt Store Meadows Property Owner's Association, Inc. is a Florida not-for-profit corporation, Sunbiz number N03230, incorporated in 1984 (Sunbiz record). Article 4.1 of its 2020 Amended and Restated Articles makes every fee simple owner of a parcel in Section 18, "including a condominium unit owner," a member, with one vote per parcel (Articles). Star Hospitality Management manages the association.
The amount is not published. The Bylaws set one assessment per original platted parcel, made annually in advance and due within 60 days after the October 1 start of the fiscal year, and vacant lots pay (Bylaws). The association's home page prints no dollar figure. The estoppel certificate for a parcel states the current assessment. Association dues as entered in MLS listings: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
The association's January 2026 newsletter lists entrance areas, greenbelts, the right of way along Burnt Store Road and interior drainage ditches, paid from the annual fee (January 2026 newsletter). It does not maintain vacant lots; those fall to the City, with the expense charged to the lot owner. The City owns the cul-de-sacs, and residents may plant and maintain them under the City's Cul-De-Sac Maintenance Policy (policy; April 2026 newsletter).
There is no community development district and no county MSBU; tax district 150 carries no CDD levy, and the county MSBU layer returned nothing at any sample point inside Section 18. No City canal assessment applies because Section 18 has no canals. The City's FY2027 budget lists a lot mowing program assessment of $285, and which lots it covers was not found (City FY2027 budget process).
District 150, Burnt Store Meadows, is 16.8148 mills for 2026, and unincorporated district 104 is 15.3705. The difference is 1.4443 mills, about $144.43 per $100,000 of taxable value (our arithmetic). On $300,000 of taxable value that is $5,044.44 against $4,611.15, or $433.29 a year. It is an illustration of the millage, not a bill; exemptions and assessment limits are not applied. In 2025 the totals were 16.6185 and 15.0855 (2026 rate chart; 2025 rate chart).
Two recorded declarations govern: one for single-family lots and one for multi-family lots. The single-family declaration allows single-family residential use only, bars a trade or business without consent, allows renting "for residential use," requires at least 1,000 square feet of living area, and limits for-sale signs to 6 by 8 inches. The multi-family declaration requires 1,200 square feet per building and 800 per unit unless authorized (single-family; multi-family). Fines run up to $100 a day with a $2,500 cap under the Bylaws.
The association posts both declarations, the Bylaws, the Articles and the violation protocol on its Deed Restrictions page and in its document library: single-family declaration, multi-family declaration, Bylaws and violation protocol table. A buyer of a parcel in a homeowners association also receives the disclosure summary under s. 720.401, Florida Statutes, and owners may inspect official records under s. 720.303.
The recorded declarations allow renting "for residential use" and state no minimum term. No short-term rental rule was found in the public record read, and we do not say short-term rentals are allowed. Before relying on any rental plan, read the declaration for the lot, ask whether the association has adopted a rule amendment, and ask the estoppel certificate what it states (single-family declaration).
Not overnight without written consent. The single-family declaration bars trailers, trucks, boats, boat trailers, campers and mobile homes parked overnight without it, and the violation protocol gives 24 hours to cure an overnight boat, trailer, camper or RV between 7 pm and 7 am (protocol). Special permits cover up to 4 occasions of up to 2 nights each per calendar year, and both the City permit and the association's waiver form are required (parking permit page; City permit; welcome letter).
With approval. The declaration requires written approval for walls, hedges or fences over 3 ft on side or rear lines. The violation protocol treats a hedge over 4 ft as a 14-day item. The City's overlay allows fences in side and rear yards only, with no solid boundary wall (Chapter 26). For new construction, the architectural rules ask owners to keep 15 ft at the rear lot line clear for maintenance access to the greenbelt and ditch (ARB new construction rules).
No. The association's documents name no gate and no guardhouse, and the association describes the neighborhood as located directly off US 41 or Burnt Store Road. Its January 2026 newsletter places volunteers "at the Burnt Store Road and 41 entrances" (newsletter). Next door, Seminole Lakes describes itself as a gated community, which is a different place.
No community pool, clubhouse, golf course, marina, canal, tennis or pickleball court stands inside the neighborhood: no parcel carries a golf, park, club or marina use code. The two condominiums each have a pool for their own owners. The semi-private Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club, an 18-hole par 62 course, is about 2.0 road miles and 6 minutes from the center (club website), and Twin Isles Country Club in Burnt Store Isles is about 2.9 road miles.
Neither recorded declaration read sets an age restriction. The declarations' rules apply to every owner (single-family declaration; multi-family declaration).
The county roll shows 751 homes on 895 residential parcels: 744 single-family, 3 single-family variants and 4 small multi-family, plus 144 vacant lots. Homes were built from 1982 to 2025 with a median of 2002, and county heated area for single-family homes runs from 1,002 to 3,433 square feet with a median of 1,969. The roll carries no bedroom count. Two 12-unit condominiums sit inside the plat as well (county roll, our count).
The median lot is about 9,946 square feet (our analysis of the county lots layer); lots in the single-family GS-3.5 district have a median of 9,687, and the multi-family GM-15 lots along the collector median 20,000. One group of blocks is an 80 by 120 ft grid, 9,600 square feet. The single-family declaration sets a 7,200 square foot, 75 ft minimum, and the City's GS-3.5 district requires 9,600; plat frontage was not read.
The roll shows 144 vacant lots among 895 residential parcels, 16.1 percent. The county recorded 11 lot sales (vacant land) in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, at a $55,000 median and a range of $30,000 to $68,000. Over 24 months there were 20 at $55,950, over 36 months 29 at $55,000 and over 60 months 61 at $55,900. Lot prices stay out of every home median.
Lots here are zoned for homes, and the roll shows 83 homes built from 2020 to 2025. Building needs architectural review approval first, then a City building permit, and a copy of the permit goes to the association within 14 days. The association also holds a $500 refundable Clean Site deposit and requires a performance and completion bond whose amount is not published (ARB new construction rules; Clean Site Policy). New construction pays City impact fees (City impact fees).
The records we read do not name the builders, so we print none. The county recorded 5 builder-direct sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, at a $630,000 median and a range of $335,000 to $678,500, and the roll shows 83 homes built from 2020 to 2025. The builder-direct figures describe first sales of new homes and are not comparable with resale prices.
Two small condominiums sit inside the plat. Meadows of Punta Gorda has 12 units built in 1989 of 1,164 square feet, on Royal Poinciana, with a pool on a 0.91 acre common parcel. Plum Creek has 12 units on the county roll, built in 2006 in Building C on N Plum Tree, of 1,079 or 1,457 square feet, while the state register lists 38 units declared (Meadows record; Plum Creek record). Owners are also members of the Burnt Store Meadows POA, and condominium dues are not published.
Florida requires milestone inspections (s. 553.899) and structural integrity reserve studies (s. 718.112; DBPR reporting page) for buildings of three habitable stories or more. Both condominiums read as two-story from their unit numbering, so neither statute would apply, but no document confirming building height was read. Treat the height as unconfirmed until a recorded document shows it.
The median is $370,000 across 42 recorded sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026. The 37 resales had a $363,000 median and the 5 builder-direct new homes $630,000, with a range of $195,000 to $680,000 and $189.87 per square foot of county heated area. Longer windows differ: 79 sales at $380,000 over 24 months, 125 at $415,000 over 36 months and 212 at $425,000 over 60 months (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis).
Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). Days on market comes from MLS listing records, and the county sales file does not hold it. The county file does show that 42 of 751 homes sold in the 12 months to September 9, 2026.
Part of it is, and the reading changes across the plat. Of 882 mapped lots, 148 on the west end sit in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 9 ft NAVD88, 127 in shaded Zone X and 607 in unshaded Zone X (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer and county parcel map, our analysis). A map zone is not a determination for a building. Check any address on FEMA's Map Service Center.
On the street pattern we read, North Seagrape Rd, South Seagrape Rd, S Ficus Tree, N Ficus Tree, S Moss Rose, N Moss Rose and S Tulip Tree are entirely Zone AE. Royal Poinciana, Trumpet Tree, Carambola, Vinca Rosea and N Tulip Tree straddle AE and shaded Zone X. Royal Poinciana is AE at its west end and Zone X at its center. Treat this as a street pattern, not a lot-by-lot reading (FEMA Map Service Center).
It depends on the parcel. Across 882 mapped parcels, 212 are in evacuation Zone B, 650 in Zone C and 20 in Zone D. The evacuation zone is not the flood zone: 65 Zone X parcels sit in evacuation Zone B. Look up an address on the county's Know Your Zone page. Ian prompted orders for Zone A on September 26, 2022 and Zones A and B on September 27, and Milton prompted A and B on October 7, 2024, then C on October 8 (Ian Zone A release; Ian Zones A and B release; Milton A and B; Milton Zone C).
A lender's flood determination for the address says whether a mortgage requires it. On the insurer side, Citizens requires flood coverage with wind coverage in the special flood hazard area, and phases it in outside that area for Coverage A above $400,000 from January 1, 2026 and for all policies from January 1, 2027 (Citizens flood requirement). The City's Class 5 rating gives a 25 percent premium discount inside the special flood hazard area and 10 percent outside (City flood readiness page).
The City of Punta Gorda is the certificated provider for both water and sewer in the section. Whether every lot is connected to central sewer was not found; the 1970s declarations provide for a sewer availability charge if a system was installed later, so the utility bill for the address confirms the connection. The City's rates effective October 1, 2026, inside city limits, start at a water base of 15.18 and a wastewater base of 36.91 (City rates; City account page).
The district's boundary locator lists East Elementary and Sallie Jones Elementary, Punta Gorda Middle and Charlotte High, and it does not mark either elementary as the zoned school, so the district assigns at registration. The 2025-26 state grades are A for Sallie Jones Elementary (69 percent of points), B for East Elementary (56), A for Punta Gorda Middle (64) and B for Charlotte High (63) (FLDOE report card; district choice chart).
No hospital or emergency room operates inside the City of Punta Gorda. The ShorePoint Health hospital on East Marion Avenue closed after Hurricane Helene on September 25, 2024 and Milton and has not reopened (Business Observer; Charlotte Sun). The nearest open emergency rooms by road are AdventHealth Port Charlotte at about 10.9 miles and 21 minutes and HCA Florida Fawcett at about 11.0 miles and 21 minutes (HCA Florida Fawcett). An AdventHealth emergency department is planned off Jones Loop Road and is not open (AdventHealth).
Publix 1557 at Burnt Store Marketplace, 3941 Tamiami Trl, is open 7 am to 10 pm daily with a pharmacy, about 2.5 road miles and 5 minutes away (Publix). Walmart Supercenter at 5001 Taylor Rd is about 2.1 miles and 6 minutes, and Aldi on Jones Loop Rd is about 7 minutes (OSRM free-flow estimates from the center of the neighborhood, October 21, 2026; Walmart; Aldi).
Seminole Lakes is gated, has 450 homes by its association's count and recorded 25 sales at a $305,000 median in the same 12 months. Burnt Store Meadows has no gate, 751 homes and recorded 42 sales at $370,000. The golf club inside Seminole Lakes is a separate organization, and Burnt Store Meadows has no golf on site. The comparison above sets out the rest (Seminole Lakes association).
Over the same 12 months, Burnt Store Village recorded 83 sales at a $329,000 median, 40 of them builder-direct at $334,000, and $175.13 per square foot of county heated area. Burnt Store Lakes recorded 66 sales at $433,500, 17 builder-direct at $429,900, and $235.23. Burnt Store Meadows recorded 42 at $370,000 and $189.87, with 5 builder-direct. Village is unincorporated, so its tax district differs.
The Burnt Store Road East/West Connector, a new two-lane road from US 41 to Burnt Store Road, is carried in the county's FY2027 adopted program at $44,783 thousand, funded from the one-cent sales tax extension that voters approved on November 3, 2026 (unofficial results) (FY2027 program). Cassia Bay, a Pulte community east of Burnt Store Road, has county filings, and County Fire Station 17 is under construction. The AdventHealth emergency department is not open. Sage Pointe, up to 999 units, is 5 to 6 miles north (connector sheet; Pulte, builder marketing; Sage Pointe ordinance).
Punta Gorda Airport is about 4.7 road miles and 13 minutes from the center of the neighborhood, and Southwest Florida International is about 34.8 miles and 43 minutes (airport site). Englewood Beach is about 31.7 miles and 54 minutes, and Boca Grande about 36.0 miles and 64 minutes; Gasparilla Island State Park charges $3 per vehicle (state park fees; Englewood Beach). Times are free-flow estimates; add time for traffic.
For a Burnt Store Meadows search, call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or start with buying a home in Burnt Store Meadows, or the wider guide to buying a home in Punta Gorda.
★★★★★ "Marc did a great job for us. He listened to our needs and was great throughout the process! He ensured we knew all of our options and informed us of the area, both positives and negatives. Surprisingly he was also knowledgeable about layouts of new homes when we bought our lot. Thank you Marc." Verified Zillow review
Burnt Store Meadows sellers ask what their home is worth, how many homes sell, what a sale costs, what the association requires at closing and how new homes and flood zones affect pricing. The answers below use county records and statute, with every figure tied to its window and source.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; county roll of October 4, 2026, our count; FEMA, county, City and association records read October 21, 2026).
McGreevy and Comisar. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team, and both of us have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Jesse and Marc together have $900 million in personal sales. What matters for a Burnt Store Meadows listing is the preparation: the county record, the documents and the flood reading, all on this page. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
The county record sets the frame: a $370,000 median across 42 recorded sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, a $363,000 median for 37 resales and a range of $195,000 to $680,000 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis). Your home prices against sales on its street, of its size and year built. Request a free valuation at mcgreevyandcomisar.com/home-valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
The county recorded 42 home sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026: 37 resales and 5 builder-direct new homes. Of those, 41 were single-family. Including the two condominiums the total is 43, and 11 recorded lot sales (vacant land) sit outside every home figure. On 751 homes, 42 sales is turnover of 5.6 percent (our arithmetic). The MLS count differs; see the answer on MLS and county sales below.
The 12-month median is $370,000. The calendar-year medians were $480,000 in 2023 (44 sales), $443,500 in 2024 (49), $390,000 in 2025 (32) and $363,000 for 2026 through September 9 (33). From the 2023 median to the 12-month median is $110,000 or 22.9 percent lower (our arithmetic). These are medians of different sets of homes, not a repeat-sale index, so they describe the mix sold, not the change in any one home's value.
Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). Days on market comes from MLS listing records, which this page does not have. What the county record does show is the pace of closings: 42 recorded sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, and 33 in 2026 through that date.
Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). The ratio compares a closing price with the last list price, and that comes from MLS records. The county file holds the recorded price and date, not the list price.
Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). Months of supply needs the count of active MLS listings, which this page does not have. Active and pending listings for homes and vacant lots: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
A dated MLS pull, for closings from September 25, 2025 to September 24, 2026, lists Burnt Store Meadows at 8 closings with a $387,500 median, against 42 county recorded sales. The MLS subdivision field undercounts this plat, so we use the county file for counts. The current MLS closing count: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
Price against resales first. In the 12 months, 5 builder-direct new homes sold at a $630,000 median ($335,000 to $678,500) and 37 resales at $363,000. The $267,000 gap compares new homes with older resales and is not like-for-like. Builder-direct sales were 11.9 percent of the window, and the roll shows 83 homes built from 2020 to 2025. A new home sets the ceiling a buyer sees; the nearest resale sets the price.
The record shows larger lots and different homes, not a measured premium. Homes on Royal Poinciana itself had 3 sales in the 12 months ($340,000, $500,000 and $605,000) and 14 over 60 months at a $627,500 median. Multi-family GM-15 homes had 7 sales in 12 months, too few for a median, and 10 over 24 months at $484,000, against 35 GS-3.5 sales over 12 months at $363,000. The windows differ, so we do not subtract them.
We measured no premium and print none. Almost every lot touches the greenbelt: 873 of 882 mapped lots share at least 5 percent of their boundary with it, so there is no comparison group without greenbelt contact. Parcels sharing 10 percent or more of their boundary with the greenbelt recorded 39 sales at a $370,000 median in the 12 months (our analysis). That says where the sales were, not what the greenbelt is worth.
The record gives facts, not an effect. The west end has 148 of 882 mapped lots in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 9 ft, and it is the newer part of the plat: 113 homes with a median year built of 2004. Zone AE had 7 sales in the 12 months, too few for a median; over 36 months it had 18 sales at $441,500, or $210.18 per square foot of county heated area. The Zone X rest had 35 sales at $380,000 in the 12 months (our analysis).
One cost is fixed by statute: Florida's documentary stamp tax on a deed is $0.70 per $100 of consideration (s. 201.02). At the $370,000 median that is $2,590.00; at the $363,000 resale median, $2,541.00; at the $630,000 builder-direct median, $4,410.00 (our arithmetic). Who pays is a term of the contract. Other costs include the estoppel certificate, any amounts owed to the association and the commission you agree to.
Florida's DBPR caps it at $299, plus $119 for delivery within 3 business days, plus up to $179 if the parcel is delinquent: $597 at most (our arithmetic). The statute requires delivery within 10 business days. What this association charges is not published, and who pays is a contract term (DBPR fee page; s. 720.30851).
No transfer fee, resale fee or capital contribution clause appears in the Bylaws read (Bylaws). The estoppel certificate must state whether any such fee is due, so it settles the question for your parcel. Condominium associations have their own documents, which were not read.
No sale-approval clause appears in the Bylaws read. The estoppel certificate states what the association says is owed and any fee due. Each condominium has its own declaration, which was not read, so a condominium seller reads that document for any approval language.
A buyer of a parcel in a homeowners association receives the disclosure summary under s. 720.401, and owners may inspect official records under s. 720.303. In practice the buyer reads the single-family or multi-family declaration, the Bylaws, the violation protocol table and the estoppel certificate you order.
No document read makes it a condition of listing. Open items still matter: fines run up to $100 a day with a $2,500 cap, a hearing committee of three non-board members hears them on 14 days notice, and uncured violations go to City Code Enforcement (violation protocol). An exterior change approved by the architectural board needs a copy of the City permit within 14 days or the approval is rescinded.
The Bylaws make the assessment a continuing lien, with interest after 60 days at the maximum legal rate, and make the new and previous owner jointly and severally liable for unpaid amounts (Bylaws). The estoppel certificate states what is owed, so the figure on it is the figure to settle. The record read does not say a sale is blocked.
It depends on the estoppel certificate. The assessment is billed once a year in advance, due within 60 days after the October 1 start of the fiscal year, so the amount paid or owed depends on when you close. The dollar amount is not published, and any fee due at a sale would be stated on the certificate. Proration is a term of the contract.
It can. 364 of 751 homes carry a year built before 2002, 48.5 percent, and 488 are dated 2004 or earlier (county roll, our count). Citizens asks for a four-point inspection on homes more than 20 years old on its applications, and Citizens' Charlotte County residential policies fell from 14,624 in September 2024 to 2,121 in August 2026 (Citizens inspections; Citizens county detail, August 2026; Citizens county detail, September 2024; Citizens flood requirement). Roof replacement dates are in City permit records, which we did not read.
A valid report documents a home's wind features for an insurer. The state's uniform mitigation verification form, OIR-B1-1802, was revised effective April 1, 2026 and is valid for up to five years without a material change (FLOIR). Whether it changes a premium is the insurer's decision, and no premium is published. My Safe Florida Home offers grants subject to legislative funding (My Safe Florida Home).
Possibly. Citizens' applications ask for one on homes more than 20 years old (Citizens inspections), and the county roll dates at least 488 homes in Burnt Store Meadows 2004 or earlier. Other insurers set their own rules, and we do not print what any insurer will require. Ordering the inspection and the wind mitigation form before listing gives a buyer's insurer the documents sooner.
The parking rules apply to the home whether or not it is listed. The declaration bars overnight boats, trailers, campers and trucks without written consent, and the violation protocol gives 24 hours to cure (protocol). Nothing in the documents read gives a listing an exception. Special parking permits cover up to 4 occasions of up to 2 nights each per calendar year.
Yes, within the declaration's limit. The single-family declaration allows one for-sale or for-rent sign no larger than 6 by 8 inches (single-family declaration).
The declarations allow renting "for residential use" with no minimum term stated, and nothing in them ties renting to listing status. No short-term rental rule was found in the public record read. A lease in place is a contract between you and the tenant, and its terms control access for showings.
Lots here sold at a $55,000 median across 11 recorded lot sales (vacant land) in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, with a range of $30,000 to $68,000; over 60 months, 61 sold at $55,900. Multi-family GM-15 lots had 13 sales over 60 months at a $94,900 median. Vacant lots pay the association assessment, and the violation protocol allows 30 days to cure a vacant-lot violation (protocol). Lots listed for sale on the MLS: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
The county record flags builder-direct sales on homes, and we do not interpret that flag for lots, so we print no price split between the two kinds of buyer. What a builder or an individual will pay depends on the lot's zoning (GS-3.5 or GM-15), its flood reading, its size and the declaration that governs it. The 11 lot sales in the window ranged from $30,000 to $68,000.
Two associations are involved: the condominium association and the Burnt Store Meadows POA, each with its own estoppel certificate. Sales are rare, so we list them. Meadows of Punta Gorda had 0 sales in the 12 months and 1 in 24 months ($156,900 on March 6, 2025). Plum Creek had 1 in 12 months ($125,000 on July 15, 2026, 1,079 square feet). Condominium dues are not published, so the condominium's estoppel is where they appear.
We make no claim about value. The Burnt Store Road East/West Connector, a new two-lane road from US 41 to Burnt Store Road, is carried in the county's FY2027 adopted program at $44,783 thousand funded from the one-cent sales tax extension that voters approved on November 3, 2026 (unofficial results), and its position relative to Section 18 is not published (FY2027 program). Cassia Bay is about 0.5 mile east of Burnt Store Road, and Sage Pointe is 5 to 6 miles north (connector sheet; Sage Pointe ordinance).
No City agenda, development plan or rezoning was found for the 13 vacant Highway Commercial parcels on the US 41 frontage or for the vacant GM-15 lots as of October 21, 2026. The frontage is 15 parcels in all, and it is kept out of every home statistic. If a filing appears, it will appear on a City agenda or development plan file.
It depends on your circumstances, and we do not give tax advice. The IRS explains the home-sale exclusion of capital gain in Publication 523. A tax professional can apply it to your ownership and use history.
It can. Under s. 193.155, Florida Statutes, the homestead benefit can be ported to a new Florida homestead. The Florida Department of Revenue's page on property tax exemptions explains how homestead and portability work (Florida Department of Revenue). A tax professional or the property appraiser can confirm the amount for your situation.
A home is reassessed at just value as of January 1 after a change of ownership (s. 193.155). That means the next owner's taxable value may differ from yours, even in the same district 150 at 16.8148 mills for 2026. Tax bills mail in November (Tax Collector).
We did not measure monthly seasonality; the county record here is annual. Calendar-year sales were 57 in 2019, 61 in 2020, 78 in 2021, 34 in 2022, 44 in 2023, 49 in 2024 and 32 in 2025, with 33 in 2026 through September 9. Monthly timing, days on market and months of supply: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
Premium marketing, cinematic video, drone, professional photography and a qualified-buyer database, with discretion and off-market capability when needed. For this neighborhood we add the documents a buyer asks for first: the declaration for the lot, the estoppel certificate, the flood reading for the street and the sales that price the home.
A Burnt Store Meadows sale has more moving parts than the price: two declarations, an estoppel certificate, a flood split on the west end, insurance questions on older homes and new homes selling nearby. We are the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Nationally since 2008, and we handle those pieces. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Yes. Most of the work is paperwork and preparation: the estoppel request, the disclosure documents, the pricing from the county record, the showing logistics and the closing with a title company. We coordinate the sequence and the property checks, and the details depend on the title company chosen. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
★★★★★ "Mark Comisar was great to work with! He was very knowledgeable in our area & made selling our house such an easy process! He always answered our calls or returned them in a very timely manner! We were also very happy with the money we made on the sale! We would highly recommend Mark to anyone selling their house. He will not disappoint!!" Verified Zillow review
Every source linked for Burnt Store Meadows in the comparison, seller and FAQ sections of this page is a primary source: Charlotte County and its Property Appraiser, the City of Punta Gorda, Florida agencies and statutes, FEMA and the National Hurricane Center, the school district and the Burnt Store Meadows POA's own documents. The list below holds those sources.
Burnt Store Meadows buyers and sellers can open the governing documents, tax rate chart, fee caps and storm reports below at the issuer's own site. Each row links the issuer's own file, and the association copies are the ones the Burnt Store Meadows POA posts publicly.
Document | Issuer | Link |
|---|---|---|
Declaration of Restrictions, single-family lots (association copy of the recorded declaration) | Burnt Store Meadows POA | |
Declaration of Restrictions, multi-family lots (association copy) | Burnt Store Meadows POA | |
Amended and Restated Articles of Incorporation, 2020 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | |
Amended and Restated Bylaws, 2020 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | |
Violation Protocol Table, revised July 17, 2023 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | |
ARB New Construction requirements, July 2026 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | |
Clean Site Policy, July 2026 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | |
Cul-De-Sac Maintenance Policy | City of Punta Gorda (association copy) | |
Chapter 26, Land Development Regulations | City of Punta Gorda | |
2026 Tax Roll Final Rates | Charlotte County Property Appraiser | |
Estoppel Certificate Fees | Florida DBPR | |
FY2027 Adopted Capital Improvement Program | Charlotte County | |
Burnt Store Road Area East/West Connector sales tax project sheet | Charlotte County | |
Charlotte County Disaster Planning Guide | Charlotte County | |
Hurricane Charley tropical cyclone report | National Hurricane Center | |
Hurricane Ian tropical cyclone report | National Hurricane Center |
Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.