Home › Punta Gorda › Burnt Store Meadows › Burnt Store Meadows Home Valuation
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012. Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, over $900 million in personal sales, and more than $2.5 billion sold as the Domain Realty Group team.
By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar of Domain Realty.
Updated October 2026.
This page answers one question for owners in Punta Gorda Isles Section 18, the deed-restricted city neighborhood its association markets as Burnt Store Meadows: what would your home sell for today, measured against the Charlotte County deed record rather than a portal estimate. If you want the whole neighborhood first, from the plat and the 87.58 acres of greenbelts to the flood map, the schools and the storm history, our Burnt Store Meadows community guide covers it, and our Punta Gorda home valuation page covers the wider city. Here we stay on price: the recorded sales that set it, the cohorts of age and size that sort it, the streets and lots that move it, and the documents a buyer will read before agreeing to it.
A Burnt Store Meadows home in Punta Gorda is worth what the county's recorded sales of homes like it support: 42 home sales closed in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, at a $370,000 median, from $195,000 to $680,000. Your own figure turns on the home's age, size, street, flood zone and condition.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, roll of October 4, 2026, our analysis; state-qualified sales recorded September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026, the newest qualified sale in the county file).
In the 12 months to September 9, 2026 we tracked 42 Charlotte County recorded home sales in Burnt Store Meadows, and every opinion of value on this page starts from that list. The roll counts 895 residential parcels in the plat's residential blocks: 751 homes and 144 vacant lots. That mix is the first thing a valuation here has to respect. A home on this plat can be a 1980s house of 1,002 square feet or a 2025 house of more than 2,700, it can sit on a single-family lot or a 20,000 square foot multi-family zoned lot on the collector road, and it can sit in FEMA Zone AE at the west end or Zone X everywhere else. One median cannot price all of that, so we sort the record before we read it.
Each Burnt Store Meadows figure below answers its own question, with its own window and count, so the rows are read one at a time and never added, averaged or subtracted from one another. The first three describe the same 42 recorded sales, split by who sold the home.
| Figure | What it measures | Window and source |
|---|---|---|
| 42 sales, $370,000 median | Every recorded home sale on the plat, $195,000 to $680,000 | 12 months to September 9, 2026, Charlotte County recorded sales, our analysis |
| 37 resales, $363,000 median | Homes sold by an owner, $195,000 to $680,000 | Same window and source |
| 5 builder-direct sales, $630,000 median | A builder's first sale of a new home, $335,000 to $678,500 | Same window and source |
| $189.87 | Median price per square foot of county heated area, 41 sales with a heated area on the roll | Same window and source |
| 212 sales, $425,000 median | Every recorded home sale over five years, $195,000 to $960,000 | 60 months to September 9, 2026, same source |
| $480,000 | The calendar-year median at its 2023 peak, on 44 sales | Calendar 2023, same source |
| 11 lot sales, $55,000 median | Recorded lot sales (vacant land), $30,000 to $68,000 | 12 months to September 9, 2026, same source |
| 16.8148 mills | The 2026 property tax rate for tax district 150, which a buyer applies to your price | Charlotte County Property Appraiser, 2026 final rates |
The gap between the 2023 peak median of $480,000 and the 12-month median of $370,000 is $110,000, or 22.9 percent (our arithmetic). It compares two different sets of homes that happened to sell in two different periods, so it is not a repeat-sale index and it does not say that any one home lost that share of its value. What it does say is that a price opinion built on a 2023 sale needs a reason, not a habit.
The Burnt Store Meadows number that applies to your home depends on five answers: when the county says it was built, how much heated area the roll gives it, which street and zoning district the lot sits in, whether the lot reads Zone AE or Zone X on the FEMA map, and what a builder has closed or is building nearby.
Those five answers sort a home into one of a handful of cohorts that we price separately. A home built before 2002 with under 1,800 square feet of county heated area sits in a group that recorded 16 resales over 24 months at a $295,000 median. A home of 2,200 square feet or more built in 2002 or later sits in a group that recorded 10 sales over 12 months at a $498,150 median. Those two groups share a plat, a homeowners association and a ZIP code, and their medians sit more than $200,000 apart. That is why the first question we ask an owner is not the address but the year the roof went on and the square footage the roll shows.
The county record leads in Burnt Store Meadows because the multiple listing service undercounts this plat: a dated MLS file for a nearly matching year listed 8 closings under the Burnt Store Meadows name, while Charlotte County recorded 42 home sales in its 12 months. We price from the deeds and use the MLS only where it alone measures something.
The measures only the MLS can supply are days on market, sale-to-list ratio, months of supply and the active listing count. For this page each of them is Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). We do not borrow those figures from a neighboring community or from the wider city, because a borrowed pace figure describes someone else's market. When the MLS window opens, those four measures are added beside the county figures with their own pull date.
Burnt Store Meadows sellers call McGreevy and Comisar because we price on the records that decide a sale here: 42 county recorded sales sorted by age and size, the FEMA reading for the lot, the zoning and declaration behind it, and the builders closing new homes nearby. We have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files through September 9, 2026; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer and association documents read October 21, 2026).
Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and our Domain Realty Group team is the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026). McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Southwest Florida listing team. If you are still weighing the best real estate agents in Punta Gorda, the test on this plat is practical: ask who can tell you which of the 42 recorded sales a buyer's appraiser will pull against your home, who knows that the MLS name field misses most of them, and who can read your lot against the flood line before the buyer's lender does.
We build a Burnt Store Meadows number from the deed record outward: the recorded sales of homes in the same age and size cohort, read street by street, then the lot's zoning and flood reading, then the house itself. Every comparable comes to you in writing with its date, street, year built and heated area.
The method does not change from one home to the next. We pull the county's qualified sales for the plat, separate builder-direct sales from resales, place your home in the cohort the roll puts it in, and read the cohort's sales one by one. We note which of them sat on the same street, on the same zoning district and on the same side of the flood line as yours. We add the builders' current marketing prices beside the recorded sales, labelled as marketing and never mixed in. And we close the file with a net sheet, so the number you see is the number you keep after statutory costs.
We work Punta Gorda, Burnt Store Road and the rest of Charlotte County from our Bonita Springs office, and a Burnt Store Meadows valuation always includes a walkthrough by one of the two partners. The county record narrows the range; the house decides where in that range your price belongs.
Our office is at 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134. A walkthrough here means reading the roof permit date, the age of the air conditioner, the windows and shutters, the lanai and pool cage if there is one, and the view across the greenbelt behind the lot. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 to set a time.
The fastest route to a free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation is the address form at the top of this page. It takes about sixty seconds and goes straight to Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, and we answer with the recorded sales in your cohort, the flood reading for your lot and a seller net sheet.
Enter your address in the free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation form and tell us whether you are selling this season, next year or simply want to know. You will hear from a partner, not a call center.
If you would rather talk first, call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072 or Marc Comisar at (239) 287-5873. There is no obligation and no charge for the file. Owners who live out of state can ask for a video walkthrough, and we send the written range by email with the comparables attached.
A Burnt Store Meadows valuation from us arrives as a written file, not a single number: a likely selling range, every recorded sale used with its date, street, year built and heated area, the adjustments we made and why, and the flood, zoning and association facts a buyer will check.
The file also carries the FEMA zone and panel for your lot, whether it sits on a GS-3.5 or a GM-15 lot and which of the two recorded declarations governs it, the list of documents a buyer's title company will request, the builders' current marketing prices labelled as marketing, and a net sheet with documentary stamps and the owner's title premium worked at your price. When you decide to list, our Burnt Store Meadows seller guide lays out the marketing and negotiation plan built on the same file.
Automated estimates such as the Zestimate read public records and past sales, but in Burnt Store Meadows they cannot see the condition of a 1990s house, the flood line that crosses the plat, a new home still coded as a vacant lot, or a builder's price two streets over. We start from the county's recorded sales instead.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files through September 9, 2026; Federal Register; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, queried October 21, 2026).
Federal regulators now require mortgage lenders that use an automated valuation model in a credit decision to test it for accuracy and guard it against manipulation, under a joint rule published in the Federal Register in August 2024. A free instant estimate on a consumer website is not a credit decision, and it carries no such testing.
The Quality Control Standards for Automated Valuation Models rule, 89 FR 64538, was published on August 7, 2024 and took effect on October 1, 2025. The OCC, the Federal Reserve, the FDIC, the NCUA, the CFPB and the FHFA issued it together. It asks lenders to ensure a high level of confidence in the estimates, protect against data manipulation, avoid conflicts of interest, require random sample testing and reviews, and comply with nondiscrimination law. None of that applies to the number a portal shows you, which is why we treat a portal estimate as a starting rumor rather than evidence.
The MLS name field hides most Burnt Store Meadows sales, so any estimate trained on listing data starts with too few comparables. A dated MLS file for a nearly matching year listed 8 closings under the community's name; the county recorded 42 home sales in its 12 months.
That gap is not a quirk of one year. Homes on this plat are often listed under the legal name, Punta Gorda Isles Section 18, under a street name, or under nothing more specific than Punta Gorda. An estimate built on the 8 named closings has a thin and possibly unrepresentative sample: if most of them happened to be newer homes, every older home looks underpriced, and if most were older, every newer home looks overpriced. We start from all 42 and sort them.
A new Burnt Store Meadows home can close while the county roll still codes its parcel as a vacant lot, so a model reading the roll can mistake a $678,500 house for a $55,000 lot. The Schefflera sale of May 8, 2026 is the live example on this plat.
The roll lags construction. We checked the vacant-coded parcels for any sale of $150,000 or more and found none in the 12, 24 or 36 months, and six in all history, from 2013 to 2022, at $190,000 to $269,900. The Schefflera home is counted with the homes in every figure on this page. A model that cannot make that check either drops the sale or prices land with it, and both mistakes move an estimate for the homes around it.
Condition is the variable an automated estimate cannot observe in Burnt Store Meadows, and it matters more here than in a new community because 364 of the 751 homes on the roll carry a year built before 2002. A replaced roof, new windows or a remodeled kitchen leave no trace in the county's sale fields.
The plat's own record shows how much condition can move a price. One 1996 home on Acalypha with 1,973 square feet of county heated area recorded a sale at $280,000 on February 21, 2025 and a second sale at $429,900 on May 7, 2025, 75 days later and $149,900 or 53.5 percent higher (our arithmetic). The record does not say what changed between the two deeds, and we do not guess. A model sees two prices for one house and averages them into the neighborhood; a walkthrough sees the house.
Burnt Store Meadows homes on the county roll run from 1982 to 2025, with a median year built of 2002, so the plat holds four decades of construction side by side. A model that prices by neighborhood averages treats a 1987 house and a 2025 house on the same block as near neighbors in value.
The roll counts 66 homes from the 1980s, 240 from the 1990s, 249 from the 2000s, 113 from the 2010s and 83 from 2020 to 2025. The first Florida Building Code took effect on March 1, 2002, and the split around that date runs almost down the middle: 364 homes before it, 387 on or after it. An insurer, an inspector and an appraiser will all sort your home by that line, and so do we.
The FEMA flood line crosses Burnt Store Meadows: 148 of the 882 mapped residential parcels sit in Zone AE at the west end with a base flood elevation of 9 feet, and the rest read Zone X. A model that assigns one zone to a ZIP code or a neighborhood cannot price that difference.
Zone AE is part of FEMA's special flood hazard area, where a buyer's lender generally requires flood insurance, and Zone X is outside it. That changes what a buyer will pay each month, and it changes which comparables belong beside your home. We test the parcel, not a point on a map, and we read the elevation certificate where one exists.
Several nearby names sound like Burnt Store Meadows and are not: Burnt Store Isles is Punta Gorda Isles Section 15, Burnt Store Village is Section 16, Burnt Store Lakes is Section 21 and Burnt Store Marina is Section 22 in Lee County. A tool that blends them by place name prices your home against the wrong market.
Even the initials collide. The Burnt Store Meadows association uses the initials BSM, and so does the Burnt Store Marina community. In the 12 months to September 9, 2026 the canal homes of Burnt Store Isles recorded a $657,200 median and Burnt Store Village recorded $329,000. A blended estimate that drags either of those into a Burnt Store Meadows value is wrong by tens of thousands of dollars before it starts. We price yours on Charlotte County recorded sales from Section 18 only.
We value a Burnt Store Meadows home with a comparative market analysis built from Charlotte County recorded sales on the Section 18 plat, sorted into cohorts by county year built and heated area, then read street by street against zoning, the greenbelt and the flood line, set beside the builders' dated prices and adjusted for condition. You receive every comparable.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, roll of October 4, 2026, sales through September 9, 2026; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, City of Punta Gorda zoning and association documents read October 21, 2026).
Step one places a Burnt Store Meadows home in its cohort, the group of homes on the plat with a similar county year built and heated area, because that is the group a buyer's appraiser will draw from. We use three eras (before 2002, 2002 to 2016, 2017 and later) and three size bands (under 1,800, 1,800 to 2,199, and 2,200 square feet and up).
The roll puts 363 single-family homes before 2002, 241 from 2002 to 2016 and 143 in 2017 or later, and it puts 234 under 1,800 square feet, 353 from 1,800 to 2,199 and 160 at 2,200 or more. Crossing the two gives the cohorts we price from, and each one has its own recorded sales list later on this page. A home that sits on the edge of a cohort, for example a 2001 home just under 2,200 square feet, is read against both neighbors.
Step two pulls the cohort's recorded sales, starting with the latest 12 months and widening to 24, 36 or 60 months until the cohort has at least 10 sales. Under 10, we list the sales themselves instead of quoting a median, because a median of three homes is not a market.
Every window is anchored to September 9, 2026, the newest qualified sale in the county file, so "12 months" on this page always means September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026. Medians with an even count are the mean of the middle pair. Sales are state-qualified deeds of improved property above $1,000, and builder-direct first sales of new homes are split from resales, because a builder's price includes things a resale does not.
Step three reads each comparable for its street, its zoning district and its side of the flood line, and moves the closest matches to the top of the list. A Zone X home on a single-family GS-3.5 lot is priced first from other Zone X GS-3.5 sales, and a west-end home from the AE sales.
The appraiser's roll gives zoning of GS-3.5 on 750 parcels and GM-15 on 134. GS-3.5 lots run about 9,687 square feet at the median and GM-15 lots about 20,000 (our analysis of the county lots layer). Seven streets at the west end are entirely Zone AE, five straddle the line, and every other street reads Zone X, so the street name alone tells us which list to start from, and the parcel test confirms it.
Step four checks which of the two recorded declarations governs the lot, because they set different minimum sizes, setbacks and uses that a buyer or a builder will price. The single-family declaration covers most lots; the multi-family declaration covers 129 of the 134 GM-15 parcels.
The single-family declaration requires at least 1,000 square feet of living area, a lot of at least 7,200 square feet and 75 feet wide, and setbacks of 25 feet front, 15 feet rear and 7.5 feet on the sides. The multi-family declaration allows multi-unit or single-unit residential use, requires at least 1,200 square feet per building with each unit at least 800 square feet unless authorized, and sets 25 foot front and rear setbacks. A buyer who might add on, or a builder looking at a lot next door, reads those numbers before an offer.
Step five screens insurability before we talk price, because in Burnt Store Meadows the insurance quote can change what a buyer will pay. We gather the roof permit date, the wind mitigation form, any elevation certificate and the age of the major systems.
Citizens Property Insurance counted 2,121 personal residential multi-peril policies in Charlotte County on August 31, 2026, down from 14,624 on September 30, 2024, so most buyers now shop the private market, and a private insurer reads the same documents more strictly. Citizens also requires flood coverage with wind coverage in the special flood hazard area, and is phasing it in outside that area, for Coverage A above $400,000 from January 1, 2026 and for all policies from January 1, 2027. A west-end home with an elevation certificate in the file and a Zone X home with a recent roof both price more cleanly than homes without the paperwork.
Step six sets the builders' prices beside the recorded resales as a separate list, dated and labelled, so you can see the choice a buyer is weighing. In the 12 months, builders closed 5 new homes on the plat at a $630,000 median, from $335,000 to $678,500.
Nearby, Pulte's Cassia Bay page, seen October 21, 2026, markets homes from $295,990 to $429,990 about half a mile from Section 18. Those are builder marketing prices, not recorded sales, and they include and exclude things a resale does not. We never average them into your range. We show them so the buyer's comparison is answered before the buyer makes it.
Step seven is the walkthrough, where the house decides where inside the cohort's range your price belongs. We look at the roof, the windows and shutters, the air conditioner and water heater, the kitchen and baths, the lanai and any pool, and the view to the greenbelt.
Then we write the range and the reasons for it. You get the cohort's recorded sales with the closest matches marked, the adjustments in plain words, the builders' marketing prices beside them, the flood and zoning facts for your lot, and a net sheet. You keep the file whether or not you list with us.
Burnt Store Meadows home values move first with age and size, then with the lot's street, zoning and flood reading, then with condition and the builders' prices nearby. In the 12 months to September 9, 2026 the plat's 42 recorded sales ran from $195,000 for a 1987 home of 1,002 square feet to $680,000 for a 2017 home of 2,616.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files through September 9, 2026; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer and City of Punta Gorda zoning read October 21, 2026; builder page seen October 21, 2026).
| Value driver | How we treat it | What the Burnt Store Meadows record shows |
|---|---|---|
| Year built before or after March 1, 2002 | Priced inside its own era | Homes built before 2002: 16 sales in 12 months at a $322,500 median; built 2002 to 2016: 16 at $435,000 |
| County heated area | Priced inside its size band | Under 1,800 sq ft: 18 resales over 24 months at $297,000; 2,200 sq ft and up: 13 sales in 12 months at $477,000 |
| Size and age together | The cohort that actually prices the home | Large homes built 2002 or later: 10 sales in 12 months at $498,150 |
| Royal Poinciana frontage | Read against the spine-road sales | 14 sales over 60 months at $627,500 and $281.21 per sq ft |
| GM-15 multi-family zoned lot | Read against the GM-15 sales | 10 sales over 24 months at $484,000 and $228.05 per sq ft |
| Zone AE at the west end | Read against the nearest AE resales | 7 sales in 12 months at $350,000; 18 over 36 months at $441,500 |
| Greenbelt behind the lot | Treated as a plat feature, not a premium | 829 of 882 mapped lots share 10 percent or more of their boundary with it |
| Builder inventory nearby | Shown as a separate set beside the resales | 5 builder-direct sales at $630,000; 144 vacant lots still on the roll |
| Roof, windows and wind mitigation form | Documented before pricing | The county counts 30,939 roofing permits countywide from October 2022 to June 15, 2023 |
| Open violation or unapproved exterior work | Cleared before listing | It appears on the association's estoppel certificate |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis; each row names its own window. Medians of different groups are not subtracted unless the windows match.
The era a Burnt Store Meadows home was built in is the first price tag a buyer reads, because the insurer, the inspector and the appraiser all sort by it. Homes built before 2002 recorded a $322,500 median over 12 months; homes built from 2002 to 2016 recorded $435,000 in the same window.
Those two groups are not the same houses with different birthdays. The newer group is larger on average and sits more on the west end and the collector road, so the $112,500 gap between their medians (our arithmetic) blends age, size and position. When we hold size roughly constant, the gap narrows. Over the same 36 months, homes of 1,800 to 2,199 square feet recorded a $375,000 median when built before 2002 and a $427,500 median when built from 2002 to 2016, $52,500 apart (our arithmetic). That narrower figure is closer to what the era alone is worth to a buyer, and even it carries differences in street and condition.
Heated area moves a Burnt Store Meadows price, but not in a straight line, because the larger homes skew newer and the smaller ones skew older. A 1,349 square foot home on Philodendron recorded $295,000, or $218.68 per square foot, while a 2,325 square foot home on Trumpet Tree recorded $300,000, or $129.03 (our arithmetic).
Both closed in the same 12 months, both were built in the 1990s, and the larger home sold for only $5,000 more. A per square foot rule would have priced the Trumpet Tree home at about $441,448 (our arithmetic: 2,325 square feet times $189.87) and been wrong by more than $140,000. The plat median of $189.87 per square foot describes the middle of 41 sales, not a rate to multiply by your square footage. We use it to spot outliers in a comparable list, never to set a price.
Forty-two Burnt Store Meadows homes recorded sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, and 18 of them closed between $300,000 and $400,000, so your listing will be judged against a crowded middle. Start with a free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation built on those recorded sales, or read how we sell homes in Burnt Store Meadows, and Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. If you are buying here instead, see how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida or our guide to buying a home in Burnt Store Meadows, and call Marc at (239) 287-5873. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
The lot and the road it fronts can move a Burnt Store Meadows price more than any interior upgrade. Homes on Royal Poinciana, the collector that runs through the plat, recorded 14 sales over 60 months at a $627,500 median, and homes on the larger GM-15 multi-family zoned lots recorded 10 sales over 24 months at $484,000.
Both figures need care. The Royal Poinciana window is five years long and leans on a run of seven 2023 sales between $529,000 and $719,000, and every home in it was built from 2003 to 2022. The GM-15 lots line Royal Poinciana, N Plum Tree and S Plum Tree, so the two groups overlap. What the record supports is that newer, larger homes on the collector and on the 20,000 square foot lots have sold at the top of the plat's range. What it does not support is a fixed premium for an address on the collector, and we never quote one.
The greenbelt behind a Burnt Store Meadows lot is a feature nearly every home shares, so it is part of the plat's price rather than a premium for one house. Lots sharing 10 percent or more of their boundary with the greenbelt recorded 39 sales in 12 months at a $370,000 median, the same as the plat.
The association owns one 87.58 acre greenbelt parcel, and 873 of the 882 mapped residential parcels share at least 5 percent of their boundary with it (our analysis of county GIS parcel polygons). The declarations make the greenbelt walkways and park areas a private park for lot owners and guests, with no cars, trucks or motorcycles and no cutting of trees or plants. A seller can describe the open view behind the lanai with confidence. What a seller cannot claim is that the greenbelt adds a measured amount, because the record compares almost every lot with almost every other lot.
The flood line moves a Burnt Store Meadows price through the buyer's insurance quote, not through a fixed discount. Seven Zone AE sales at the west end recorded a $350,000 median in 12 months against 35 Zone X sales at $380,000, but the AE group is small, newer and mixes builder-direct new homes with resales.
Over 36 months the Zone AE sales numbered 18 at a $441,500 median and $210.18 per square foot, which is higher than the plat's 12-month figures, because 2023 and 2024 sales sit in the longer window. We do not tell a west-end owner that the zone costs a set amount. We price from the nearest AE resales, put the base flood elevation of 9 feet and any elevation certificate in the file, and ask for a flood quote early so the buyer's number is known before the offer.
The roof's permit date is the single document that moves a Burnt Store Meadows price most after the comparables are chosen, because a buyer's insurer sorts by it. The county counts 30,939 roofing permits countywide from October 2022 to June 15, 2023, after Hurricane Ian, so buyers ask which side of that storm a roof was replaced on.
A current wind mitigation form, the state's uniform verification form revised effective April 1, 2026 and valid for up to five years without a material change, lets a buyer price the insurance before writing an offer. A four-point inspection is part of Citizens' application for a home more than 20 years old, which on this plat means any home the roll dates before 2006 (our arithmetic). We list what a buyer will price in, and we set the number within the band the recorded sales support.
Recorded sales show a Burnt Store Meadows market of steady resales with a few new homes: 42 home sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026 at a $370,000 median, 37 of them resales at $363,000 and 5 builder-direct at $630,000. Turnover was 5.6 percent of the plat's 751 homes (our arithmetic).
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, roll of October 4, 2026; sales recorded through September 9, 2026, the newest qualified sale in the county file).
The Burnt Store Meadows window ladder shows the same plat measured over five lengths of time, each ending September 9, 2026. The 12-month window is the first with 10 or more sales, so it is the one we lead with, and the longer windows show where those sales sit against the plat's own history.
| Window ending September 9, 2026 | Recorded home sales | Median | Low | High |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 months | 42 | $370,000 | $195,000 | $680,000 |
| 24 months | 79 | $380,000 | $195,000 | $680,000 |
| 36 months | 125 | $415,000 | $195,000 | $680,000 |
| 60 months | 212 | $425,000 | $195,000 | $960,000 |
| All recorded history since January 22, 2009 | 746 | $281,700 | $74,900 | $960,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. Each window counts the plat's state-qualified improved sales above $1,000.
Each longer window contains the shorter ones, so the medians are not a sequence of separate years. The 36-month and 60-month medians sit above the 12-month median because they hold more of the 2022 to 2024 sales, when prices on this plat ran higher. The $960,000 high in the 60-month window does not repeat in the shorter ones.
First sales of new homes and resales are two different markets on the Burnt Store Meadows plat, and we read them apart. In the 12 months, the 5 builder-direct sales recorded a $630,000 median and the 37 resales $363,000, a $267,000 gap that compares new homes with older resales rather than like with like (our arithmetic).
Builder-direct sales were 11.9 percent of the 12-month total, 5 of 42 (our arithmetic). That is a smaller share than in the busiest building years: in calendar 2021 builders accounted for 13 of 78 sales. For a resale seller, the useful reading is that most buyers here are choosing among existing homes, and the new homes set a ceiling that a renovated resale can approach but rarely needs to match.
The 42 Burnt Store Meadows sales in the latest 12 months clustered in the middle: 18 closed between $300,000 and $400,000 and 10 between $400,000 and $500,000, so 28 of the 42, two thirds, closed between $300,000 and $500,000 (our arithmetic).
| Price band, 12 months to September 9, 2026 | Recorded home sales |
|---|---|
| Under $200,000 | 1 |
| $200,000 to $300,000 | 5 |
| $300,000 to $400,000 | 18 |
| $400,000 to $500,000 | 10 |
| $500,000 to $750,000 | 8 |
| $750,000 and up | 0 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
A home priced inside the $300,000 to $400,000 band competes with the most recent sales and the most buyers' alerts; a home priced above $500,000 competes with eight sales in a year, most of them newer or larger homes. That is not a reason to price lower. It is a reason to know exactly which band your home's cohort supports before the first showing.
The Burnt Store Meadows median price per square foot of county heated area was $189.87 across 41 sales in the 12 months, but we use it only to flag outliers in a comparable list, never to price a home. County heated area is not the living area an MLS listing prints.
Per square foot figures swing widely on this plat because the smaller homes are mostly older and the larger homes mostly newer. By cohort, the 24-month figure for homes under 1,800 square feet was $197.12, the 12-month figure for homes of 1,800 to 2,199 square feet was $187.56, and the 12-month figure for homes of 2,200 square feet and up was $199.41. The homes on the collector road reached $281.21 over 60 months. A single plat-wide rate hides all of that.
Single-family homes make up almost the whole Burnt Store Meadows record: 41 of the 42 recorded home sales in the 12 months were single-family, at a $370,000 median. Adding the improved sales of the two condominiums to the plat's home sales gives 43 sales at the same $370,000 median; vacant-land sales are counted separately and never enter that figure.
The two small condominiums inside the plat, Meadows of Punta Gorda and Plum Creek, carry their own roll designators and their own sales, which we list in the lot and condominium section. Their prices sit far below the single-family homes and never enter a home median on this page. If you own a condominium unit, ask for the condominium file instead of this one.
Burnt Store Meadows home prices are lower than their 2023 peak: the calendar-year median reached $480,000 in 2023, and the 12-month median to September 9, 2026 is $370,000, $110,000 or 22.9 percent lower (our arithmetic). Those medians compare different sets of homes, so they describe the market, not any one house.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files; calendar years through September 9, 2026).
Eight calendar years of Burnt Store Meadows recorded sales show a climb from 2019 to a 2023 peak and a decline since. The count of sales also moved: 78 in 2021, the busiest year, against 32 in 2025.
| Calendar year | Recorded home sales | Median | Low | High | Builder-direct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | 57 | $290,000 | $111,000 | $465,000 | 12 |
| 2020 | 61 | $285,000 | $135,000 | $545,000 | 11 |
| 2021 | 78 | $352,450 | $189,500 | $650,000 | 13 |
| 2022 | 34 | $452,500 | $335,000 | $960,000 | 5 |
| 2023 | 44 | $480,000 | $315,000 | $719,000 | 1 |
| 2024 | 49 | $443,500 | $250,000 | $680,000 | 3 |
| 2025 | 32 | $390,000 | $280,000 | $650,000 | 6 |
| 2026 through September 9 | 33 | $363,000 | $195,000 | $680,000 | 3 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
The mix of homes that sold moves the Burnt Store Meadows medians along with the market. The 2023 peak year recorded only 1 builder-direct sale, and a run of seven Royal Poinciana resales from $529,000 to $719,000, so its median leaned toward newer, larger homes on the collector.
Older and smaller homes do not explain the rest of the drop. Homes built before 2002 or under 1,800 square feet made up 24 of the 44 sales in 2023 and 15 of the 33 in 2026 to date (our count from the county record), a smaller share now than at the peak. The lowest recorded price of the past five years, $195,000 for a 1987 home of 1,002 square feet, closed in June 2026, and in every cohort below the 12-month median sits under the 36-month median (our comparison of the cohort sheets). That is why we price your home from its own cohort's recent sales, not from the plat's yearly median.
The cleanest way to see price movement in Burnt Store Meadows is the same kind of home sold at two dates. On Royal Poinciana, a 2015 home of 2,349 square feet recorded $690,000 in May 2023, and a home with the same county year built and heated area on the same street recorded $650,000 in June 2025.
The record shows matching year built and heated area on the same street; it does not let us print the parcel, so we describe it as a matching pair rather than a proven repeat sale. A 2016 home of 2,261 square feet on Royal Poinciana shows the other direction across an earlier stretch, recording $650,000 in December 2021 and $710,000 in March 2023. Pairs like these are the evidence we bring to a price conversation, because they hold the house roughly constant and let the date do the talking.
Recorded lot sales (vacant land) in Burnt Store Meadows tell a steadier story than the homes: the lot median held near $55,000 across the 12, 24 and 36 month windows, and the calendar-year lot median ran from $54,000 in 2024 to $59,000 in 2025 and $55,000 in 2026 to date.
Land that has held its price while finished-home medians fell suggests that the change in home prices is about the houses that sold and the cost of owning and insuring them, not about the location. A buyer pays roughly the same for the ground here as three years ago. That is useful context for an owner of an older home, whose value is mostly in the land and the structure's condition.
We do not forecast Burnt Store Meadows prices, because no public record we read supports a forecast and a forecast cannot be checked until it is too late to matter. What we publish is the recorded past, sorted so that your home is compared with homes like it.
If you need a decision now, the useful questions are narrower: what did the last 10 to 20 homes in your cohort sell for, how many builder homes are competing with yours, and what will your buyer pay each year to insure and own it. Those answers are on this page or in your valuation file, and they hold up whichever way the next year goes.
How long a Burnt Store Meadows home takes to sell is measured by the MLS, not the county, and the MLS figures were not available to us: days on market, sale-to-list ratio, months of supply and the active listing count are each Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files through September 9, 2026; MLS fields checked October 7, 2026).
The county file can say how often Burnt Store Meadows homes change hands but not how long each one took. In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, 42 of the plat's 751 homes recorded a sale, a turnover of 5.6 percent (our arithmetic), and the sales spread through the year rather than bunching in one season.
The 12-month list runs from two sales on September 12, 2025 to a sale on August 27, 2026, with at least one recorded sale in every calendar month from September 2025 through August 2026. The deed date is the closing date, not the contract date, and the county records no listing date, so the file cannot produce a days-on-market figure. We do not estimate one.
We do not borrow days on market or sale-to-list from a neighboring community or from Punta Gorda as a whole, because those figures describe a different set of homes. Burnt Store Isles is a canal community and Burnt Store Village is outside the city, and their pace has nothing to do with yours.
A pace figure from the wrong market is worse than none, because it sets an expectation that the listing then has to fight. When the MLS window opens, the four missing measures are added here with their own pull date, drawn from a query that names this plat by its legal and marketed names so that the undercount does not repeat.
We plan a Burnt Store Meadows timeline backward from the date you need to close, using the steps whose length we do know. Under Florida law an association must deliver an estoppel certificate within 10 business days of a request, and a buyer's lender orders an appraisal and a flood determination on its own schedule.
So we order the estoppel certificate at listing, put the roof permit, the wind mitigation form and any elevation certificate in the file before the first showing, and price inside the cohort's recorded range from day one. Those three habits are the parts of a sale's pace a seller can control, whatever the market's average turns out to be.
The best Burnt Store Meadows comparables are recorded sales from your own cohort, homes with a similar county year built and heated area, read for street, zoning and flood side. Below are the six cohorts we price from, each with its window, count, median and every sale listed by street, so you can find the homes a buyer's appraiser will pull.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, roll of October 4, 2026, our analysis of county parcel lists by year built and heated area; sales through September 9, 2026).
The six Burnt Store Meadows cohorts below cross three eras with three size bands, and each uses the first window with 10 or more sales, so their windows differ. Read each row on its own. The per square foot column divides by county heated area.
| Cohort (single-family) | Homes on the roll | Window used | Recorded sales | Median | Per sq ft of county heated area |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under 1,800 sq ft, built before 2002 | 166 | 24 months | 16, all resales | $295,000 | $197.12 |
| 1,800 to 2,199 sq ft, built before 2002 | 156 | 24 months | 14, all resales | $366,500 | $188.72 |
| 1,800 to 2,199 sq ft, built 2002 to 2016 | 121 | 36 months | 16, all resales | $427,500 | $220.18 |
| 1,800 to 2,199 sq ft, built 2017 or later | 76 | 24 months | 14: 7 builder-direct at $380,000, 7 resales at $468,000 | $397,500 | $211.99 |
| 2,200 sq ft and up, built before 2002 | 41 | 36 months | 12, all resales | $433,000 | $185.91 |
| 2,200 sq ft and up, built 2002 or later | 119 | 12 months | 10: 1 builder-direct, 9 resales at $496,300 | $498,150 | $205.12 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis of county parcel lists. Even-numbered medians are the mean of the middle pair. Homes of under 1,800 square feet built in 2002 or later are too few to form a cohort and are read against both neighbors.
The cohorts hold 679 of the plat's 747 single-family homes with a heated area on the roll; the rest, small homes built in 2002 or later, are read against the nearest cohort on each side (our arithmetic: 166 + 156 + 121 + 76 + 41 + 119). When windows match, the cohorts line up as a buyer would expect. Over the same 36 months, the small pre-2002 group recorded 28 sales at $309,500, the mid-size pre-2002 group 21 at $375,000, and the large pre-2002 group 12 at $433,000, steps of $65,500 and $58,000 as size rises within one era (our arithmetic).
Smaller Burnt Store Meadows homes built before 2002, under 1,800 square feet of county heated area, recorded 16 resales over the 24 months to September 9, 2026 at a $295,000 median, from $195,000 to $392,000. This is the plat's entry price, and condition separates its sales more than size does.
| Recorded | Street | County year built | County heated sq ft | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| October 4, 2024 | Sweet Alyssum | 1990 | 1,553 | $392,000 |
| November 5, 2024 | Satsuma Dr | 1996 | 1,474 | $295,000 |
| November 15, 2024 | Parkinsonia | 2001 | 1,480 | $355,000 |
| December 9, 2024 | Powder Puff | 1993 | 1,431 | $250,000 |
| March 14, 2025 | Carambola | 1990 | 1,555 | $285,000 |
| March 24, 2025 | Scarlet Sage | 1998 | 1,594 | $335,000 |
| March 28, 2025 | N Plum Tree | 1997 | 1,720 | $299,000 |
| April 9, 2025 | Tabebuia Tree | 1998 | 1,624 | $355,000 |
| July 31, 2025 | Pon Kan | 1998 | 1,643 | $328,000 |
| November 26, 2025 | Philodendron | 1994 | 1,349 | $295,000 |
| April 8, 2026 | Tabebuia Tree | 1991 | 1,477 | $275,000 |
| April 29, 2026 | Tabebuia Tree | 1998 | 1,585 | $255,600 |
| May 28, 2026 | Carambola | 1999 | 1,512 | $350,000 |
| June 23, 2026 | Acalypha | 1995 | 1,477 | $266,000 |
| June 29, 2026 | Parkinsonia | 1987 | 1,002 | $195,000 |
| July 24, 2026 | S Blue Sage | 1982 | 1,381 | $230,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. Street names only. The 12-month window alone holds 7 of these sales, at a $266,000 median.
Three Tabebuia Tree homes in this list, built in 1991 and 1998 with 1,477 to 1,624 square feet, recorded $355,000 in April 2025 and $275,000 and $255,600 in April 2026. Similar houses on one street, a year apart and $80,000 to $99,400 apart (our arithmetic), is the clearest sign on this plat that condition and timing, not size, set the price of an older small home.
Mid-size Burnt Store Meadows homes built before 2002, 1,800 to 2,199 square feet, recorded 14 resales over 24 months at a $366,500 median, from $280,000 to $431,000. This is the plat's most common older home, and its sales sit in a tight band.
| Recorded | Street | County year built | County heated sq ft | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| October 18, 2024 | S Blue Sage | 2000 | 1,912 | $379,000 |
| December 3, 2024 | Podocarpus | 1997 | 1,810 | $415,000 |
| February 21, 2025 | Acalypha | 1996 | 1,973 | $280,000 |
| March 21, 2025 | Scarlet Sage | 1989 | 1,952 | $355,000 |
| May 7, 2025 | Acalypha | 1996 | 1,973 | $429,900 |
| May 20, 2025 | Coral Tree | 1989 | 2,034 | $422,000 |
| May 21, 2025 | Parkinsonia | 1997 | 2,145 | $370,000 |
| May 27, 2025 | S Moss Rose | 1989 | 1,995 | $431,000 |
| October 17, 2025 | Sweet Alyssum | 1992 | 1,930 | $362,000 |
| January 13, 2026 | N Blue Sage | 1990 | 2,009 | $345,000 |
| February 13, 2026 | N Plum Tree | 1999 | 1,939 | $363,000 |
| May 26, 2026 | S Blue Sage | 1997 | 2,080 | $425,000 |
| August 13, 2026 | Ligustrum | 1998 | 1,896 | $360,000 |
| August 14, 2026 | Allamanda Ln | 2001 | 1,901 | $300,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. The two Acalypha rows are one home recorded twice, 75 days apart.
Twelve of the 14 sales closed between $345,000 and $431,000. The two below that band are the Acalypha home's first sale at $280,000, which the same home's second sale at $429,900 shows was not the home's full value in finished condition, and a 2001 home on Allamanda Ln at $300,000. When we price a home in this cohort, the question is whether it reads like the top of the band or the bottom, and the walkthrough answers it.
Mid-size Burnt Store Meadows homes built from 2002 to 2016 recorded 16 resales over 36 months at a $427,500 median, from $335,000 to $640,000, and $220.18 per square foot of county heated area. These are the first homes built under the statewide code, and buyers read them that way.
| Recorded | Street | County year built | County heated sq ft | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| November 6, 2023 | Satsuma Dr | 2016 | 2,035 | $615,000 |
| February 27, 2024 | Trumpet Tree | 2002 | 2,005 | $583,000 |
| March 26, 2024 | N Plum Tree | 2004 | 1,814 | $505,000 |
| April 26, 2024 | N Blue Sage | 2005 | 2,196 | $485,000 |
| July 17, 2024 | Satsuma Dr | 2014 | 1,960 | $459,000 |
| July 26, 2024 | Satsuma Dr | 2008 | 2,010 | $415,000 |
| August 13, 2024 | Vitex | 2016 | 2,134 | $640,000 |
| November 14, 2024 | Paspalum | 2005 | 2,106 | $370,000 |
| June 17, 2025 | Ligustrum | 2006 | 1,969 | $417,000 |
| December 1, 2025 | Royal Poinciana | 2004 | 2,003 | $340,000 |
| May 7, 2026 | S Plum Tree | 2003 | 1,978 | $335,000 |
| May 29, 2026 | Paspalum | 2003 | 1,959 | $430,000 |
| June 2, 2026 | S Tulip Tree | 2004 | 1,864 | $375,000 |
| June 19, 2026 | N Plum Tree | 2003 | 1,878 | $460,000 |
| July 13, 2026 | Soursop | 2002 | 1,838 | $422,000 |
| August 27, 2026 | Trumpet Tree | 2006 | 2,199 | $425,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
The 36-month window is needed because only 7 of these homes sold in the latest 12 months, at a $422,000 median. The list falls in two clusters by date: the 2023 and 2024 sales mostly above $450,000, and the 2025 and 2026 sales all from $335,000 to $460,000. For a home in this cohort today, the recent cluster carries the weight, and the older sales show what the best-presented homes reached at the peak.
Mid-size Burnt Store Meadows homes built in 2017 or later recorded 14 sales over 24 months at a $397,500 median: 7 builder-direct new homes at $380,000 and 7 resales at $468,000. Here the resale median sits above the builders' median, because several new homes closed on west-end streets at the low end.
| Recorded | Street | Sale type | County year built | County heated sq ft | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| September 30, 2024 | N Plum Tree | Resale | 2021 | 2,046 | $468,000 |
| October 1, 2024 | Pon Kan | Resale | 2019 | 1,820 | $470,000 |
| March 28, 2025 | Gold Tree | Builder-direct | 2025 | 1,816 | $460,000 |
| May 16, 2025 | N Plum Tree | Resale | 2021 | 1,896 | $519,000 |
| July 22, 2025 | Gold Tree | Builder-direct | 2025 | 1,860 | $415,000 |
| July 30, 2025 | Carissa | Resale | 2020 | 2,104 | $522,000 |
| August 12, 2025 | N Ficus Tree | Builder-direct | 2025 | 1,952 | $380,000 |
| August 26, 2025 | Soursop | Builder-direct | 2025 | 1,860 | $370,000 |
| September 12, 2025 | S Blue Sage | Builder-direct | 2025 | 2,019 | $650,000 |
| September 17, 2025 | W Cashew | Resale | 2022 | 2,000 | $370,000 |
| November 12, 2025 | N Ficus Tree | Builder-direct | 2025 | 1,842 | $370,000 |
| May 7, 2026 | Carissa | Resale | 2017 | 1,803 | $335,000 |
| May 28, 2026 | South Seagrape Rd | Builder-direct | 2025 | 1,952 | $335,000 |
| August 12, 2026 | S Moss Rose | Resale | 2022 | 2,001 | $310,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
New homes of about 1,800 to 2,000 square feet recorded anywhere from $335,000 to $650,000 in this list, which says the builder, the finish and the street matter more than the size. A resale of a recent home has two advantages a buyer will weigh, finished landscaping and a closed permit file, and one disadvantage, a builder offering the same size with a new warranty. We price a recent resale against both lists at once.
Larger Burnt Store Meadows homes built before 2002, 2,200 square feet and up, recorded 12 resales over 36 months at a $433,000 median, from $295,000 to $540,000, and $185.91 per square foot of county heated area, the lowest rate of any cohort.
| Recorded | Street | County year built | County heated sq ft | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| September 28, 2023 | S Plum Tree | 1989 | 2,237 | $475,000 |
| April 4, 2024 | Sweet Alyssum | 1998 | 2,412 | $520,000 |
| April 30, 2024 | Carissa | 1994 | 2,450 | $450,000 |
| May 3, 2024 | Gold Tree | 2001 | 2,309 | $368,000 |
| July 19, 2024 | Sweet Alyssum | 1993 | 2,728 | $540,000 |
| December 2, 2024 | Clusia Rosea | 1993 | 2,211 | $416,000 |
| December 24, 2024 | Powder Puff | 1993 | 2,473 | $295,000 |
| January 9, 2025 | Carissa | 1994 | 2,450 | $485,000 |
| August 13, 2025 | Scarlet Sage | 1993 | 2,304 | $315,000 |
| December 3, 2025 | Paspalum | 1998 | 2,232 | $470,000 |
| January 9, 2026 | Trumpet Tree | 1999 | 2,325 | $300,000 |
| August 24, 2026 | Vinca Rosea | 1993 | 2,313 | $350,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. Only 3 of these homes sold in the latest 12 months.
This cohort has the widest spread for its size. Homes of 2,304 to 2,473 square feet recorded from $295,000 to $520,000, a range wider than the gap between some cohorts. A large older home is priced on its roof, systems, kitchens and baths more than on its square footage, and a buyer pays for space only when the space does not need work.
Larger Burnt Store Meadows homes built in 2002 or later, 2,200 square feet and up, recorded 10 sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026 at a $498,150 median, the mean of $496,300 and $500,000, from $380,000 to $680,000. This cohort holds the plat's highest recorded resale of the year.
| Recorded | Street | Sale type | County year built | County heated sq ft | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| September 12, 2025 | S Blue Sage | Resale | 2006 | 2,230 | $400,000 |
| October 1, 2025 | Royal Poinciana | Resale | 2004 | 2,675 | $500,000 |
| January 13, 2026 | N Plum Tree | Resale | 2017 | 2,616 | $680,000 |
| February 10, 2026 | Paspalum | Resale | 2002 | 2,392 | $477,000 |
| February 17, 2026 | Scarlet Sage Ct | Resale | 2002 | 2,246 | $440,000 |
| February 23, 2026 | Wedelia | Resale | 2014 | 2,354 | $496,300 |
| March 6, 2026 | N Moss Rose | Builder-direct | 2025 | 2,771 | $630,000 |
| March 20, 2026 | Scarlet Sage | Resale | 2015 | 2,472 | $650,000 |
| April 20, 2026 | Royal Poinciana | Resale | 2016 | 2,476 | $605,000 |
| July 21, 2026 | N Plum Tree | Resale | 2022 | 2,365 | $380,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
The four sales at $605,000 and above were homes built in 2015, 2016, 2017 and 2025, three of them on Scarlet Sage, Royal Poinciana and N Plum Tree. The 2022 home of 2,365 square feet on N Plum Tree that recorded $380,000 is the outlier, and an outlier on the low side usually has a reason the deed does not show. Before we price a large newer home, we find out which side of that line it reads on.
The repeat sale on Acalypha is the plainest lesson in this record: one 1996 Burnt Store Meadows home of 1,973 square feet recorded $280,000 on February 21, 2025 and $429,900 on May 7, 2025, 75 days later and $149,900 higher (our arithmetic).
The deed record does not say why. A gap that size in that time usually reflects something done to the house or something about how the first sale happened, and either way the second price, not the first, is what a finished home of that age and size could command that spring. When a buyer's agent pulls the $280,000 sale against your home, we put the second sale beside it.
The street, the lot and the flood line change a Burnt Store Meadows price by changing which comparables apply and what a buyer will pay to own the home. The collector road and the larger multi-family zoned lots have recorded the plat's highest sales; the west end sits in Zone AE; the greenbelt touches nearly every lot.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files through September 9, 2026; county GIS parcel and lot layers and FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, read October 21, 2026).
Burnt Store Meadows sales in the latest 12 months spread across 28 streets, and no street recorded more than 5, so street medians are lists, not markets. N Plum Tree recorded 5 sales, S Blue Sage 4, Royal Poinciana and Paspalum 3 each, and three more streets 2 each.
| Street, 12 months to September 9, 2026 | Recorded home sales | Median of that street's sales |
|---|---|---|
| N Plum Tree | 5 | $380,000 |
| S Blue Sage | 4 | $412,500 |
| Royal Poinciana | 3 | $500,000 |
| Paspalum | 3 | $470,000 |
| W Cashew | 2 | $442,500 |
| Trumpet Tree | 2 | $362,500 |
| Tabebuia Tree | 2 | $265,300 |
| 21 other streets | 1 each | In the cohort tables above; the Schefflera new home in the builders section below |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. Under 10 sales per street, so these are read as lists and not compared as medians.
A street median of two or three sales mostly reflects which houses happened to sell. The five N Plum Tree sales, for example, ran from $300,000 for a 2002 home of 1,714 square feet to $680,000 for a 2017 home of 2,616. We use the street to choose neighbors in a comparable list, not to rank streets.
Royal Poinciana is the Burnt Store Meadows collector, the street with the most parcels on the roll, 79, and the most vacant ones, 20. Homes on it recorded 14 sales over the 60 months to September 9, 2026 at a $627,500 median and $281.21 per square foot of county heated area.
| Recorded | Sale type | County year built | County heated sq ft | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| December 28, 2021 | Resale | 2016 | 2,261 | $650,000 |
| June 2, 2022 | Builder-direct | 2022 | 2,127 | $679,900 |
| March 15, 2023 | Resale | 2016 | 2,261 | $710,000 |
| May 2, 2023 | Resale | 2015 | 2,349 | $690,000 |
| May 11, 2023 | Resale | 2022 | 2,127 | $719,000 |
| May 22, 2023 | Resale | 2003 | 2,197 | $529,000 |
| June 7, 2023 | Resale | 2018 | 2,093 | $700,000 |
| June 12, 2023 | Resale | 2005 | 2,051 | $550,000 |
| August 9, 2023 | Resale | 2003 | 1,960 | $560,000 |
| April 12, 2024 | Resale | 2005 | 2,287 | $525,000 |
| June 26, 2025 | Resale | 2015 | 2,349 | $650,000 |
| October 1, 2025 | Resale | 2004 | 2,675 | $500,000 |
| December 1, 2025 | Resale | 2004 | 2,003 | $340,000 |
| April 20, 2026 | Resale | 2016 | 2,476 | $605,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. Street name only.
The Royal Poinciana list has two halves. Homes built from 2015 to 2022 recorded $605,000 to $719,000 every time they sold; homes built from 2003 to 2005 recorded $340,000 to $560,000. On the collector, as everywhere else on the plat, the year the house was built sorts the price first. The three sales in the latest 12 months, $340,000, $500,000 and $605,000, follow the same split.
The GM-15 lots in Burnt Store Meadows are multi-family zoned under the City's code, run about 20,000 square feet at the median, and line Royal Poinciana, N Plum Tree and S Plum Tree. Homes on them recorded 10 sales over 24 months at a $484,000 median and $228.05 per square foot of county heated area.
Single-family zoned GS-3.5 homes, by contrast, recorded 35 sales in the latest 12 months at $363,000 (our analysis of the county parcel list). The windows differ, so we do not subtract the two. The GM-15 list itself, from $335,000 for a 2003 home on S Plum Tree to $680,000 for a 2017 home on N Plum Tree, shows that the larger lot helps when the house is newer and larger, and matters less when it is not.
GM-15 zoning allows single-family homes, duplexes, multi-family and cluster housing with development plan approval, up to 15 units per acre and 40 feet above base flood elevation to the tie beam. Of the 134 GM-15 parcels, 49 are vacant on the roll, and no City agenda, development plan or rezoning was found for them. A buyer of a home next to a vacant GM-15 lot will ask what may be built there, and the answer is the zoning and the multi-family declaration, which we put in the file.
Burnt Store Meadows homes north and south of Royal Poinciana recorded nearly the same prices in the latest 12 months: 19 sales north at a $370,000 median and $190.24 per square foot (18 with heated area), and 20 south at $361,000 and $194.64 (our analysis). The gap is inside sampling noise.
We say so because buyers ask. Neither side of the collector carries a premium the record can measure, and we do not invent one. What does differ by block is the evacuation zone: blocks 361 to 367 and 383 to 388 are in evacuation Zone B, most of the plat is Zone C, and block 391 on S Blue Sage, with one parcel in block 379, is Zone D. Those zones matter for a storm plan, not for a price.
The west end of Burnt Store Meadows is FEMA Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 9 feet, and it is also the newer part of the plat: 113 homes with a median year built of 2004, against 625 homes in the Zone X rest with a median of 2001. Seven streets there are entirely AE.
| West-end AE sales, 36 months to September 9, 2026 | Recorded sales | Median |
|---|---|---|
| South Seagrape Rd | 3 | $510,000 |
| North Seagrape Rd | 2 | $490,000 |
| Trumpet Tree | 2 | $441,500 |
| S Tulip Tree | 2 | $415,000 |
| S Moss Rose | 2 | $370,500 |
| N Ficus Tree | 2 | $375,000 |
| N Tulip Tree, Royal Poinciana, S Ficus Tree, N Moss Rose, Vinca Rosea | 1 each | $320,000, $525,000, $452,000, $630,000 and $350,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis of parcels in FEMA Zone AE. 18 sales in all, 5 builder-direct at $380,000 and 13 resales at $452,000.
Over 36 months the 13 AE resales recorded a $452,000 median, which is above the plat's 12-month median. So the flood zone has not, on this record, pushed west-end resales below the rest of the plat; the newer homes there have held their own. What the zone does change is the buyer's insurance quote, and a west-end seller who has an elevation certificate, a recent roof and a flood quote in hand removes the buyer's largest unknown.
A Letter of Map Amendment can change how a Burnt Store Meadows west-end home is insured, and an elevation certificate tells a buyer how high the floor sits. Inside Section 18, two letters on S Ficus Tree and Vinca Rosea kept the structure in the special flood hazard area, and one on N Blue Sage removed the property.
The City's elevation certificate layer flags a certificate on 38 of 154 AE address points in the plat, and the county's flood portal holds downloadable certificates. If your home has one, it belongs in the listing file on day one. If it does not, a surveyor can prepare one, and we tell you before listing whether the cost is likely to be worth it for your street.
Builders affect a Burnt Store Meadows resale value by setting a visible alternative: 5 new homes closed on the plat in the 12 months to September 9, 2026 at a $630,000 median, 144 vacant lots remain on the roll, and a new community half a mile away markets homes from $295,990 to $429,990.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files through September 9, 2026; association ARB rules read October 21, 2026; builder page seen October 21, 2026).
The 5 builder-direct Burnt Store Meadows sales in the latest 12 months recorded from $335,000 to $678,500, so a new home here is not one price. Two of them, on N Ficus Tree and South Seagrape Rd, are on streets entirely in Zone AE and closed at $370,000 and $335,000.
The other three closed at $630,000 on N Moss Rose, $650,000 on S Blue Sage and $678,500 on Schefflera, the last still coded vacant on the roll. A buyer touring a resale near any of these streets will know the new home's price. If your resale is near the $335,000 to $370,000 new homes, the buyer is comparing a new roof and a builder's warranty with your finished lot and mature trees; if it is near the $630,000 homes, the comparison is finish and size. We prepare the answer for whichever comparison your street invites.
Burnt Store Meadows still has 144 vacant residential lots on the roll, 16.1 percent of 895 parcels (our arithmetic), and recorded lot sales (vacant land) ran at a $55,000 median in the latest 12 months, 11 sales from $30,000 to $68,000.
A lot at the $55,000 median is about 8.7 percent of the $630,000 builder-direct median (our arithmetic: $55,000 divided by $630,000). That ratio is why new homes keep arriving, and it is why a resale seller should expect a builder's spec home on the next street at some point. The fully built streets on the roll, Philodendron, Ligustrum, Clusia Rosea, N Ficus Tree, S Ficus Tree, Coco Plum, Vitex and Scarlet Sage Ct, are the ones where that question does not arise.
A builder on a Burnt Store Meadows lot must pass the association's architectural review, post a performance and completion bond and a $500 refundable Clean Site deposit, and keep 15 feet at the rear lot line clear for access to the greenbelt and ditch under the July 2026 rules.
The same rules put hardwood trees at least 10 feet from the rear line and recommend a stem wall instead of fill. For a resale owner beside a vacant lot, those rules are part of the value case: they limit how a new home can sit against your view and your drainage. A copy of the City building permit is due within 14 days of approval or the approval is rescinded, so a stalled lot next door does not stay approved forever.
Pulte's Cassia Bay, about half a mile from Section 18 east of Burnt Store Road, has county plat and site-plan filings on 68.43 acres, and the City's FY2027 proposed budget lists Phase 1A at 100 units. The builder's page, seen October 21, 2026, markets homes from $295,990 to $429,990.
Those are builder marketing prices, not recorded sales, and a new community's base price rarely includes the lot premiums, options and closing terms a buyer adds. Even so, a buyer who sees $295,990 on a sign will bring that figure to your showing. A resale under $430,000 here is priced against that alternative whether or not the listing mentions it, so we mention it first, in writing, with what your home has that a new plat does not: a finished lot, the greenbelt behind it and a known history.
Builder-direct Burnt Store Meadows sales have ranged from 1 a year to 13 a year since 2019, and the share they make of each year's sales changes what that year's median means. In 2021 builders closed 13 of 78 sales; in 2023, 1 of 44; in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, 5 of 42.
| Calendar year | Builder-direct sales | All recorded home sales |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 | 12 | 57 |
| 2020 | 11 | 61 |
| 2021 | 13 | 78 |
| 2022 | 5 | 34 |
| 2023 | 1 | 44 |
| 2024 | 3 | 49 |
| 2025 | 6 | 32 |
| 2026 through September 9 | 3 | 33 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
The roll dates 83 homes from 2020 to 2025 and 33 from 2023 or later, so building has continued since Hurricane Ian. A resale seller does not need to fear that. A newer home next door raises the floor of what a buyer expects on the street, and the recorded resales of 2017 and later homes, a 13-sale median of $519,000 over 24 months, show that recent homes on this plat have resold well above the builders' own median of $397,500 over the same window.
Burnt Store Meadows recorded 42 home sales at a $370,000 median in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, measured on the same county tool as five neighbors: more sales than Seminole Lakes and a higher median, fewer sales than Burnt Store Village and Burnt Store Lakes, and far below the canal homes of Burnt Store Isles.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files through September 9, 2026; one county tool, one window and one set of definitions for every row).
The seller benchmark below sets Burnt Store Meadows beside five named neighbors on one Charlotte County file, one 12-month window and one set of qualification rules, so the rows can be read side by side even though the places differ.
| Community | Recorded home sales, 12 months to September 9, 2026 | Median | Per sq ft of county heated area (n) | Builder-direct | Valuation page |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Burnt Store Meadows | 42 | $370,000 | $189.87 (41) | 5 | The figures on this valuation |
| Seminole Lakes | 25 | $305,000 | $183.96 (25) | 0 | Seminole Lakes home valuation |
| Burnt Store Village | 83 | $329,000 | $175.13 (69) | 40 | Burnt Store Village home valuation |
| Burnt Store Lakes | 66 | $433,500 | $235.23 (60) | 17 | Burnt Store Lakes home valuation |
| Deep Creek (single-family plats) | 316 | $360,000 | $178.14 (309) | 46 | Deep Creek home valuation |
| Burnt Store Isles (homes only) | 78 | $657,200 | $286.50 (77) | 0 | Burnt Store Isles home valuation |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. Each linked valuation page uses its own window and plat match, so its figures can differ from this table's; within this table every row uses the same rules.
Read the Burnt Store Meadows row against the builder-direct column first. Only 5 of the 42 sales here were new homes, against 40 of 83 in Burnt Store Village and 17 of 66 in Burnt Store Lakes, so this plat's median is mostly a resale median and theirs blend in more new construction.
That matters when a buyer cross-shops. A buyer touring Burnt Store Village is seeing a market in which almost half the recent sales were new homes at a $334,000 builder-direct median; a buyer touring here is seeing mostly resales. The per square foot column tells a similar story: $189.87 here against $175.13 in Burnt Store Village, $178.14 in Deep Creek and $183.96 in Seminole Lakes. Burnt Store Lakes at $235.23 and Burnt Store Isles at $286.50 sit higher, and Burnt Store Isles is a canal community with a country club, which is a different product.
The benchmark cannot say that one neighborhood is a better buy or a better sale than another. Medians move with the mix of homes sold, and each community here has a different mix of ages, sizes, lots, water and amenities.
Burnt Store Village is unincorporated, outside the City of Punta Gorda. Burnt Store Lakes has 1,848 parcels on the roll and 991 coded vacant, so its sales come from a plat that is still mostly open land. Deep Creek is a roll of 6,703 parcels, many times the size of this plat. The table is a yardstick for pace and price level, and the useful next step is always the same: line up your cohort here against the same cohort there, which is a pull we make from the county file on request.
Days on market, sale-to-list ratio and months of supply are the seller's real yardsticks against a neighbor, and for Burnt Store Meadows each is Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). We do not set a missing figure here against a neighbor's published one.
When the MLS window opens, the same query runs for this plat and for each neighbor, with the same dates, so the comparison is like for like. Until then, the county's recorded counts and medians are the comparison we can stand behind, and they are the ones in the table above.
Burnt Store Meadows and Seminole Lakes share a greenbelt edge, the City of Punta Gorda and ZIP 33955, but they sell different things: an open platted neighborhood with a wide range of home ages and new construction here, a gated golf-course community of 450 homes there. In the same 12 months, 42 sales at $370,000 here and 25 at $305,000 there, $65,000 apart.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files through September 9, 2026; Seminole Lakes association and club websites read October 21, 2026).
Buyers tour both, and a Burnt Store Meadows seller should know what the buyer is weighing. The decision table uses only county records and each community's own published descriptions. For the Seminole Lakes side in depth, our Seminole Lakes home valuation page prices homes there on its own window and plat match.
| Factor | Burnt Store Meadows | Seminole Lakes |
|---|---|---|
| Government | City of Punta Gorda, tax district 150 | City of Punta Gorda |
| Homes | 751 homes and 144 vacant lots on 895 residential parcels | 450 homes, by its association's count |
| Years built | 1982 to 2025, median 2002 | 1992 to 2003 |
| Recorded home sales, 12 months to September 9, 2026 | 42, median $370,000 | 25, median $305,000 |
| Per sq ft of county heated area | $189.87 | $183.96 |
| Builder-direct sales, same window | 5 | 0 |
| Gate | None named in any association document read | "A gated community", in its association's words |
| Golf | None on site; Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club about 2.0 road miles away | A semi-private 18-hole club inside the community, a separate organization from its association |
| Shared amenities | 87.58 acres of association greenbelts, a Little Free Library, association events | Bocce courts, a heated pool, a workout room, a library and a tiki hut, per its association |
| Lots | Median about 9,946 sq ft; 20,000 sq ft GM-15 lots on the collector (our analysis) | Not measured on this page |
| Community development district | None | None |
Sources: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis; Seminole Lakes Property Owners Association home page; Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club website.
The $65,000 gap between the Burnt Store Meadows and Seminole Lakes medians (our arithmetic) compares two different housing stocks, not the same house on two sides of a greenbelt. Seminole Lakes homes were built from 1992 to 2003 and none of its 25 sales were builder-direct; Burnt Store Meadows sales include 2015 to 2025 homes and five new ones.
The fairer comparison is cohort to cohort. A Burnt Store Meadows home built before 2002 sits in an era group that recorded a $322,500 median over 12 months, and a mid-size home of that era recorded $366,500 over 24 months. Those are the figures to set beside a similar Seminole Lakes home, and the gap shrinks when you do.
A buyer who wants a gate, an on-site pool and a golf course outside the back door looks first at Seminole Lakes. A buyer who wants open greenbelt behind the yard, a wider range of home ages and sizes, a newer home or a lot to build on, and no club amenities to carry, looks first at Burnt Store Meadows.
Both lists describe only what each plat offers. Your listing should name what yours offers plainly, because a buyer who has toured both arrives with the comparison already made.
Market your Burnt Store Meadows home to the buyer it fits, and price it against its own cohort here, not against the Seminole Lakes median. A listing that claims a gate or a pool it does not have invites trouble; one that leads with the lot, the greenbelt, the age and size of the home and the documents ready on day one holds its price.
If your buyer is choosing between the two, the honest comparison is the all-in yearly cost on a named home in each, in writing: the tax bill at the buyer's price, the association assessment from each estoppel certificate, the flood and wind quotes, and any club dues the buyer intends to pay. We prepare that sheet for a buyer who asks.
A vacant lot in Burnt Store Meadows recorded a $55,000 median across 11 lot sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, from $30,000 to $68,000, while the larger GM-15 lots recorded a $94,900 median over 60 months. The two small condominiums inside the plat recorded too few sales for a median, so we list them.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files through September 9, 2026; association ARB rules and City of Punta Gorda FY2027 budget read October 21, 2026).
| Window ending September 9, 2026 | Recorded lot sales (vacant land) | Median |
|---|---|---|
| 12 months | 11 | $55,000 ($30,000 to $68,000) |
| 24 months | 20 | $55,950 |
| 36 months | 29 | $55,000 |
| 60 months | 61 | $55,900 ($30,000 to $240,000) |
| All history since May 27, 2009 | 279 | $36,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. Lot prices never enter a home median.
The lot median rose from $37,750 in 2019 to $57,000 in 2022 and has held between $54,000 and $59,000 in each calendar year since, on 7 to 11 lot sales a year. A lot buyer is usually a builder or an owner who means to build, and both read the same three things before an offer: the zoning, the declaration and the flood zone.
A Burnt Store Meadows lot buyer asks first whether the lot is GS-3.5 or GM-15, which declaration governs it and which side of the flood line it sits on, because those three answers set what can be built and what it will cost. GM-15 lots run about 20,000 square feet; GS-3.5 lots about 9,687.
A GS-3.5 lot takes a single-family home with a 9,600 square foot minimum lot under the City code and setbacks of 25 feet front, 7.5 feet side and 15 feet rear. A GM-15 lot can take single-family, duplex, multi-family or cluster housing with development plan approval. A lot in Zone AE needs the finished floor set for the base flood elevation of 9 feet. We put each answer in a lot seller's file with the document that states it.
Holding a Burnt Store Meadows lot costs the yearly association assessment, which every platted parcel pays including vacant lots, the property tax at the district's millage, and the cost of keeping the lot mowed. The association does not maintain vacant lots; the City does, and charges the owner.
The City's FY2027 budget lists a lot mowing program assessment of $285; which lots it covers was not found. The violation protocol gives a vacant lot owner 30 days to cure an overgrowth notice. The association assessment amount is not published anywhere public; the estoppel certificate for the parcel states it. A lot owner deciding whether to sell or to keep should put those three carrying costs beside the $55,000 median.
Meadows of Punta Gorda is a 12-unit condominium inside Burnt Store Meadows, built in 1989 on Royal Poinciana, with 1,164 square foot units on the roll. It recorded no sale in the latest 12 months, 1 in 24 months at $156,900 on March 6, 2025, and 3 in 60 months from $156,900 to $230,000.
Across all recorded history since 2012 it recorded 22 sales at a $79,950 median. With so few recent sales, a unit here is valued from the three five-year sales, the unit's condition and the condominium association's own documents, which set dues and reserves that are not published. The unit owner is also a member of the Burnt Store Meadows POA under the 2020 restated Articles.
Plum Creek is a condominium inside Burnt Store Meadows whose county roll carries 12 units in Building C, built in 2006, at 1,079 or 1,457 square feet. It recorded 1 sale in the latest 12 months, $125,000 on July 15, 2026 for a 1,079 square foot unit, 2 in 24 months and 4 in 60 months from $125,000 to $245,000.
Across all history since 2011 it recorded 20 sales at a $120,750 median. The state condominium register lists 38 units declared, and whether more buildings will be built is not on the public record we read. A Plum Creek valuation reads the unit size first, because the two floor plans sit 378 square feet apart (our arithmetic), then the unit's condition and the association's documents.
A buyer of your Burnt Store Meadows home will pay property tax at 16.8148 mills in 2026 on a value reset to market after the sale, one yearly association assessment that is not published, City water and wastewater, and insurance. There is no community development district and no county MSBU on the plat.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser 2026 and 2025 final rates; City of Punta Gorda water and wastewater rates effective October 1, 2026; association bylaws; county GIS read October 21, 2026).
Burnt Store Meadows sits in Charlotte County tax district 150, inside the City of Punta Gorda, where the 2026 final millage is 16.8148: County 6.1275, City 3.9928, school state 3.0240, school local 3.2480, Environmentally Sensitive Lands debt 0.2000, the water management district 0.1831 and the inland navigation district 0.0394.
The unincorporated district 104 nearby is 15.3705 mills, so district 150 pays 1.4443 mills more, about $144.43 per $100,000 of taxable value (our arithmetic). The City's levy of 3.9928 takes the place of the county's law enforcement and lighting levies, 2.5485 mills together, which district 104 pays. In 2025 the district 150 rate was 16.6185. The City adopted its 3.9928 mills for FY2027, about 0.36 percent below the 4.0074 rollback rate.
The tax line matters to your price because a buyer adds it to the monthly payment before deciding what to offer, and the buyer's bill will not match yours. A Florida home is reassessed at just value as of January 1 after a change of ownership, so a long-held homestead's capped value does not carry to the buyer.
As an illustration only, with no exemption applied: $300,000 of taxable value at 16.8148 mills is $5,044.44 a year, against $4,611.15 at district 104's rate, a difference of $433.29 (our arithmetic). Each $10,000 of taxable value adds about $168.15 a year at 16.8148 mills (our arithmetic: $10,000 times 16.8148 divided by 1,000). A buyer comparing your home with one outside the city sees that difference, and the City's services, its CRS flood discount and its utilities are the answer to it.
The Burnt Store Meadows POA bills one assessment per original platted parcel each year, in advance for an October 1 fiscal year and due within 60 days, but the amount is not in any public document. The association's home page says only "Low Annual Association fee", and the estoppel certificate for your parcel states it.
That gap is one a seller can close early. Ordering the estoppel certificate at listing puts the exact assessment, any balance and any open violation in the buyer's hands before the offer, instead of after it. The bylaws make new and previous owners jointly and severally liable for unpaid assessments, with interest after 60 days and a continuing lien, so a buyer's title company will not close without it. No transfer fee, resale fee or capital contribution clause appears in the bylaws we read; the certificate must state whether any such fee is due.
A Burnt Store Meadows buyer pays no community development district levy, no county MSBU and no City canal maintenance assessment, because the plat has none of them. Tax district 150 carries no CDD, the county's MSBU layer returned no features at 11 sample points inside Section 18, and the plat has no canals.
That is a real advantage against many nearby communities and a fact a seller can state with its source. It also means the yearly cost of owning here is mostly the tax bill, the association assessment, the utilities and the insurance, and of those only the assessment is unknown until the estoppel certificate arrives.
Burnt Store Meadows is inside the City's certificated service area for both water and sewer at every sample point tested. The City's rates effective October 1, 2026, inside the city limits, set a water base of 15.18 and a customer charge of 6.60 a month, with residential tiers from 4.51 per 1,000 gallons, and a wastewater base of 36.91 with 4.66 per 1,000 gallons.
Whether every lot is connected to central sewer was not found in the records we read; the 1970s declarations provide for a sewer availability charge on later installation. If your home has a septic system, it belongs in the disclosure and in the valuation, and we ask before we price. Stormwater and refuse amounts were not found; the City's account page says monthly charges include water, wastewater and refuse.
The Burnt Store Meadows POA and its two recorded declarations shape your price through the estoppel certificate, open violations, the rules a buyer must live with and the greenbelt every lot shares. Membership is mandatory for every parcel owner, including condominium unit owners, and the association has no sale approval clause in the documents we read.
Data updated: October 2026 (association Articles, bylaws, declarations, violation protocol and ARB rules read October 21, 2026; Florida DBPR estoppel fee caps; Sunbiz record re-checked October 21, 2026).
The Burnt Store Meadows Property Owner's Association, Inc. is a Florida not-for-profit corporation filed in 1984 and active on the state's corporate register, with restated Articles recorded on October 26, 2020. A board of five meets on the third Monday at 6:30 pm, and the fiscal year runs October 1 to September 30.
The association maintains the entrance areas, the greenbelts, the right of way along Burnt Store Road and the interior drainage ditches from the annual fee. A new landscape contractor started in January 2026. A buyer who asks how the common areas are kept can be pointed to those documents, and to the neighborhood newsletter, The Meadows Connection, which ended after its September 2026 issue.
The estoppel certificate is the Burnt Store Meadows document that settles the assessment, any balance and any open violation for your parcel, and Florida caps its fee: not more than $299, an additional $119 for delivery within 3 business days, and up to $179 more if the account is delinquent, $597 at the most (our arithmetic).
The association must deliver it within 10 business days of a request. Ordering it at listing avoids the rush fee and puts the figures in front of the buyer when they help you, before an offer, rather than when they surprise someone, after it. The next DBPR update to the caps is due by July 1, 2027.
Open violations reduce what a buyer will pay for a Burnt Store Meadows home because they appear on the estoppel certificate and transfer with the parcel. The bylaws allow fines up to $100 per violation per day and $2,500 in total, heard by a committee of three non-board members on 14 days notice.
The violation protocol, revised July 17, 2023, gives short cure windows a seller can beat before the photographs: a day for a parked commercial vehicle or a trash can left out after pickup, two weeks for a lawn past 12 inches or a hedge past 4 feet, and a month for an overgrown vacant lot. The association's welcome letter adds that uncured violations go to City Code Enforcement, because the neighborhood is a Special Residential Overlay District within the city. Clearing an open item before the photographs is the cheapest price protection there is.
The Burnt Store Meadows rules a buyer will price in are the ones that touch daily use: renting for residential use is allowed with no minimum term stated, pets are allowed if not kept commercially and not a nuisance, and boats, trailers, campers and trucks cannot be parked overnight without written consent.
The City's overlay adds that one camping trailer or habitation vehicle may sit on the driveway from 7 am to 7 pm, and that no one may park on vacant residential land or the right of way from 1 am to 5 am. Special parking permits allow up to 4 occasions of up to 2 nights a year with both the City permit and the association's waiver. A for-sale sign is limited to one, no larger than 6 by 8 inches, under the single-family declaration. A buyer with a boat or an RV reads those rules before an offer, so we put them in the file.
Past exterior work on a Burnt Store Meadows home can affect your price if it was done without the association's architectural approval, because an unapproved change can surface as an open violation. Approval is required before exterior changes and new construction, with reviews at the monthly board meeting.
If your home has a newer fence, a pool cage, a driveway or an addition, we ask whether it went through the board and whether the City permit was closed. Walls, hedges or fences over 3 feet on side or rear lines need written approval under both declarations, and driveways in single-family districts must be concrete or pavers under the City's overlay. A closed permit and an approval letter in the file answer the question before the buyer's inspector asks it.
A Burnt Store Meadows seller owes a buyer the homeowners' association disclosure summary under section 720.401 before the contract is signed, the flood disclosure under section 689.302, and known facts that materially affect the home's value and are not readily observable. A condominium unit adds its own regime. This is information, not legal advice.
Data updated: October 2026 (Florida Statutes sections 720.401, 720.303, 689.302, 689.261 and 553.79, read October 21, 2026).
Florida section 720.401 requires that a buyer of a parcel in a homeowners' association receive a disclosure summary before signing the contract, and on a resale the parcel owner supplies it. Burnt Store Meadows has a mandatory association, so every single-family sale here carries the duty.
The contract must carry the statute's voidability language in conspicuous type, and a buyer who does not receive the summary in time has a right to cancel within 3 days after receiving it or before closing, whichever comes first; the right ends at closing. Owners may inspect the association's official records under section 720.303, which is how a seller assembles the documents behind the summary.
The section 720.401 summary does not apply to associations under chapter 718, so a Burnt Store Meadows condominium sale follows the condominium statute for the condominium association while the unit owner remains a member of the POA. That fork is a question for your closing agent or attorney, not a form to fill in from this page.
Milestone inspections under section 553.899 and structural integrity reserve studies under section 718.112 apply to buildings of three habitable stories or more. Both condominiums here read as two-story from their unit numbering, so neither statute would apply, but no filing or document confirming height was read, and a buyer's attorney may ask.
Florida section 689.302 requires a seller of residential property to give a buyer a flood disclosure at or before the contract, stating whether the seller has filed a flood insurance claim or received federal assistance for flood damage, and whether the seller knows of flood damage to the home. On the west end of this plat, a buyer reads it beside the Zone AE map.
The disclosure asks about the seller's knowledge and claims history, not the zone. A Zone X home can have a claim history and a Zone AE home can have none. Answer it from your records, and put any elevation certificate or Letter of Map Amendment beside it.
Florida section 689.261 requires a property tax disclosure summary that tells a buyer not to rely on the seller's current taxes, because a change of ownership resets the assessed value. In Burnt Store Meadows, where many owners have held homes for years, the buyer's first bill can be far higher than yours.
That statement protects you. A buyer who expected your tax bill and receives a larger one has no claim against you when the summary was given. It is also why our net sheet and a buyer's monthly estimate use the 16.8148 mill rate at the buyer's price, not your bill.
A Burnt Store Meadows seller must disclose known facts that materially affect value and are not readily observable to the buyer, such as a roof leak, water intrusion or a failed system. An open permit of a prior owner is also a question a buyer's title search can raise under section 553.79.
On a home built before 2002, the usual items are the roof's age and permit, the electrical panel, plumbing materials and any past storm repair. We recommend a pre-listing check of the City's permit records so that an open permit is closed before a buyer finds it, because an open permit found late becomes a credit at the negotiating table.
Flood zone and insurance affect a Burnt Store Meadows price through the buyer's monthly cost: 148 of 882 mapped lots sit in FEMA Zone AE at the west end with a base flood elevation of 9 feet, the rest read Zone X, and the City's Community Rating System Class 5 cuts flood premiums by 25 percent inside the special flood hazard area.
Data updated: October 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer queried at eight sample points and a parcel overlay, October 21, 2026; City of Punta Gorda flood pages; Citizens Property Insurance county reports; National Hurricane Center reports).
FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer, read at eight sample points across Burnt Store Meadows on October 21, 2026, shows Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 9 feet at the west end of Royal Poinciana and on Trumpet Tree, and Zone X at the other six points, on panels effective December 15, 2022.
The Zone X points were N Plum Tree at two places, Satsuma Dr, Royal Poinciana at the center, Gold Tree and S Blue Sage. Seven of the eight points sit on panel 12015C0407G and the northern N Plum Tree point on 12015C0244G. No Letter of Map Revision applied at any point.
Every mapped residential lot in Burnt Store Meadows was tested against the flood layer: 148 sit in Zone AE, 127 in shaded Zone X (the 0.2 percent annual chance flood hazard) and 607 in unshaded Zone X, and FEMA's layer and the county's copy agree on all 882 (our analysis).
That is why we test your parcel rather than quote the neighborhood. Seven west-end streets are entirely AE, five straddle AE and shaded X, Philodendron and Carissa are entirely shaded X, W Cashew is almost all shaded X, and every other street is unshaded X. A buyer's lender orders its own flood determination, and ours should match it before the listing goes live.
Punta Gorda's Community Rating System Class 5 gives a 25 percent flood insurance premium discount inside the special flood hazard area and 10 percent outside it, and the City's flood page says the 25 percent discount remained in place as of October 19, 2025. Every Burnt Store Meadows home is inside the City and eligible.
The City also applies the 50 percent rule in A zones: a substantial improvement or repair at 50 percent or more of market value brings the whole building into compliance, with the finished floor at base flood elevation plus 1 foot. For a west-end owner planning a large renovation before selling, that threshold matters, and we raise it before any work is priced.
Burnt Store Meadows evacuation zones do not follow its flood zones: 212 parcels are in evacuation Zone B, 650 in Zone C and 20 in Zone D, and 65 Zone X parcels sit in evacuation Zone B (our analysis). An evacuation zone is a storm plan, not an insurance rating.
The county ordered Zones A and B to evacuate for Hurricane Ian on September 27, 2022 and for Hurricane Milton on October 7, 2024, adding Zone C on October 8, 2024. A buyer may ask which zone your home is in, and the answer is a fact with a source. It does not set a flood premium and it does not move a recorded price.
The storm record for Burnt Store Meadows is the record for Punta Gorda: Hurricane Charley's eye passed over the city on August 13, 2004, and Hurricane Ian made mainland landfall near Punta Gorda on September 28, 2022. No public record we read shows surge or a damage count inside the plat for any storm.
The Florida Building Commission's report on Charley found that homes built to the new statewide code fared far better than older homes, and that older tile roofs in Punta Gorda Isles had 40 percent or more damage against 10 percent or less on newer homes, a figure not broken out for Section 18. That is the history behind the 2002 line that sorts every valuation on this page.
Roof age and a wind mitigation report are the Burnt Store Meadows documents that most change a buyer's insurance quote, and the insurance quote changes what a buyer will pay. Citizens counted 2,121 personal residential policies in Charlotte County on August 31, 2026, down from 14,624 two years earlier, so most buyers now shop private carriers.
The uniform mitigation verification form was revised effective April 1, 2026 and stays valid up to five years without a material change. My Safe Florida Home offers inspections and grants subject to legislative funding. A seller with a post-Ian roof permit and a current form in the listing file gives a buyer a quote in days; a seller without them leaves the buyer guessing, and a guessing buyer offers less.
We print the flood zone, panel and base flood elevation for your lot, the CRS discount, the evacuation zone and the insurance rules we can source. We do not print a premium, because a flood or wind premium depends on the house, the carrier and the buyer, and no public record states one for your address.
A buyer's agent who asks for a premium gets the documents an insurer needs instead: the elevation certificate where one exists, the roof permit, the wind mitigation form and the four-point inspection if the home is more than 20 years old. With those in hand, a quote is a phone call away for the buyer, not a reason to wait.
Roads and projects near Burnt Store Meadows can change what a buyer asks about, but no public record we read supports a claim that any of them changes value. The largest is the Burnt Store Road East/West Connector, funded from the one-cent sales tax extension Charlotte County voters approved on November 3, 2026 (unofficial results).
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County FY2027 adopted capital program, adopted September 22, 2026; county sales tax project sheet; City of Punta Gorda FY2027 proposed budget dated August 15, 2026; county ordinances and plats read October 21, 2026; sales tax result read November 18, 2026).
The Burnt Store Road East/West Connector is a new two-lane road from US 41 to Burnt Store Road, the Tuckers Grade extension, carried in Charlotte County's FY2027 adopted capital program at $44,783 thousand across design, right of way and construction in FY2027 to FY2029. Voters approved the sales tax extension that helps fund it, 56,284 to 38,396 on unofficial results.
The county's sales tax project sheet prices the road at $46,176,000, a different document on a different basis, so we show both with their dates. The records we read do not state the road's alignment relative to Section 18, so we make no claim about whether it passes close to any street here or about its effect on any price. A buyer who asks gets the documents.
Cassia Bay is a new Pulte community about half a mile from Section 18 east of Burnt Store Road, and Sage Pointe is a county-approved plan of up to 999 units including up to 300 RV sites on 277.55 acres at Burnt Store Road and Zemel Road, about 5 to 6 miles north. Sage Pointe is not a neighbor.
Cassia Bay is the one a resale seller should know, because its builder marketing prices, $295,990 to $429,990 as seen October 21, 2026, overlap the plat's middle price bands. We covered how we price against it in the builders section above.
AdventHealth has announced an emergency department on 17.46 acres at 26072 Glasgow Ave off Jones Loop Road, about 2.5 road miles and 6 minutes from the center of Burnt Store Meadows; groundbreaking was expected in November 2026, and it is not open. County Fire Station 17 at 11711 Tamiami Trail is under construction.
No hospital or emergency room operates inside the City of Punta Gorda today; the nearest open emergency rooms are about 21 minutes away at free-flow speeds. Buyers ask about both projects, and a seller can answer with the dated facts. Neither is a reason to change a price until it opens.
US 41 beside Burnt Store Meadows carried about 21,620 vehicles a day from Zemel Road to Taylor Road in the state's 2025 counts, and a signal at Burnt Store Road and the Home Depot entrance is a planning priority. The plat's 15 commercial parcels on US 41 are zoned Highway Commercial, and 13 are vacant.
No City agenda, development plan or rezoning was found for those vacant commercial parcels or for the vacant GM-15 lots. For a home near the US 41 edge, a buyer may ask what could be built on the frontage, and the answer is the zoning and the replat, which we include in the file for homes on those blocks.
None of these projects is a reason to price a Burnt Store Meadows home up or down today, and we do not adjust for them. A project that is funded but not designed, approved but not built, or announced but not open is a question for the listing file, not a line in the valuation.
What a seller can do is answer the question before it costs anything: the connector's program entry and the sales tax result, the emergency department's status, the Cassia Bay builder's dated prices and the frontage's zoning. A buyer who gets dated answers has nothing to discount for.
Selling a Burnt Store Meadows home costs documentary stamp tax of $0.70 per $100 of the price and the owner's title insurance premium, which the seller customarily pays in Charlotte County, plus the estoppel certificate, the commission you agree to and prorations. The contract controls who pays what. At the $370,000 median, stamps are $2,590.00.
Data updated: October 2026 (Florida Statutes section 201.02; Florida Administrative Code Rule 69O-186.003; Florida DBPR estoppel fee caps; Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026).
The statutory costs of a Burnt Store Meadows sale scale with the price, so we show them at the median of each cohort rather than one figure for the plat. Every row is our arithmetic from the stamp rate and the promulgated owner's title premium.
| Cohort median used as the price | Deed stamps at $0.70 per $100 | Promulgated owner's title premium | Stamps and title together |
|---|---|---|---|
| $295,000 (smaller homes built before 2002, 24 months) | $2,065.00 | $1,550.00 | $3,615.00 |
| $366,500 (mid-size homes built before 2002, 24 months) | $2,565.50 | $1,907.50 | $4,473.00 |
| $427,500 (mid-size homes built 2002 to 2016, 36 months) | $2,992.50 | $2,212.50 | $5,205.00 |
| $498,150 (larger homes built 2002 or later, 12 months) | $3,487.40 | $2,566.00 | $6,053.40 |
Source: our arithmetic from the stamp rate in section 201.02 and the promulgated owner's premium in Rule 69O-186.003: $5.75 per $1,000 to $100,000, then $5.00 per $1,000 to $1,000,000, with any fraction of $100 counted as a full $100. The stamp tax is also charged on each $100 or portion of $100, so $498,150 counts as 4,982 units: 4,982 times $0.70 is $3,487.40, and the premium is computed on $498,200: $575.00 plus $1,991.00. A title agent's quote controls.
Each extra $10,000 of a Burnt Store Meadows sale price adds about $120 in statutory closing charges, $70 in deed stamps and $50 in owner's title premium in the $100,000 to $1,000,000 tier (our arithmetic). That is why a pricing decision should be made on the net, not on the headline.
The bigger variable is the commission. Since August 17, 2024, under the national settlement rules, offers of compensation to a buyer's agent are no longer made through the MLS, and a buyer signs a written agreement with the buyer's own agent. Whether and how much you offer toward the buyer's agent is a term you negotiate, and our net sheet shows it both ways.
The association charge on a Burnt Store Meadows sale is the estoppel certificate, capped at $299 for standard delivery, $119 more for delivery within 3 business days and up to $179 more on a delinquent account. Order it at listing and the rush fee never applies.
No transfer fee, resale fee or capital contribution clause appears in the bylaws we read, and the certificate must state whether any such fee is due. If you own a condominium unit, the condominium association issues its own certificate under its own statute, and both certificates belong in the file.
Property tax and the association assessment are prorated to the closing date on a Burnt Store Meadows sale, and because the assessment is billed once a year in advance for an October 1 fiscal year, the buyer often credits the seller for months already paid. The title company's statement and the estoppel certificate decide the final figures.
Your mortgage payoff, any repair credit, a home warranty if you offer one and your tax position on the gain sit outside the statutory table. IRS Publication 523 explains the federal exclusion of gain on the sale of a main home, and your own tax adviser applies it. Our net sheet lays out every line we can source and marks the ones that only your contract or your adviser can fill.
A free in-person comparative market analysis is the most accurate Burnt Store Meadows valuation short of an appraisal, and it costs you nothing. One of the two partners walks the house, reads the lot against its cohort's recorded sales, the zoning and the flood line, and returns a written range with every comparable and a net sheet.
Call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072 or Marc Comisar at (239) 287-5873, or request your free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation and we will schedule the visit around you, including a video walkthrough for owners who are out of state.
When you are ready to list, our Burnt Store Meadows seller guide lays out the marketing and negotiation plan. If you are also buying, see how we represent Southwest Florida buyers or our Burnt Store Meadows buyer guide, and call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
Burnt Store Meadows owners often weigh a move within the Punta Gorda area. Our Punta Gorda home valuation page covers values across the city, our Punta Gorda seller guide covers listing anywhere in it, and our Punta Gorda buyer guide covers the next purchase.
For the neighborhood itself, the Burnt Store Meadows community guide holds the full record, and the Seminole Lakes community guide covers the neighbor across the greenbelt edge. Each neighbor's valuation page is linked in the benchmark table above.
Burnt Store Meadows owners ask us about value in many forms: what the home is worth, whether prices are falling, what the flood line or the collector road does to a price, and what a sale will cost. Every answer is drawn from the county's deed and parcel files or from a document the issuer posts, and an unpublished figure is named as unpublished.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files through September 9, 2026; association, City, county, state and FEMA documents read October 21, 2026).
Your home is worth what the recorded sales in its cohort support, adjusted for its street, lot, flood reading and condition. Across the plat, 42 homes recorded sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026 at a $370,000 median, but cohort medians run from $295,000 for smaller pre-2002 homes to $498,150 for larger newer ones. Request a free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation for your address.
In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, Burnt Store Meadows homes recorded sales from $195,000 to $680,000, and 28 of the 42 closed between $300,000 and $500,000 (our arithmetic). The 37 resales recorded a $363,000 median and the 5 new homes sold by builders a $630,000 median.
The median recorded home sale price in Burnt Store Meadows was $370,000 for the 12 months to September 9, 2026, on 42 Charlotte County recorded sales. Over 24 months it was $380,000 on 79 sales, and over 60 months $425,000 on 212 sales. Each figure names its own window.
We do not publish an average for Burnt Store Meadows, because one high or low sale pulls an average further than it moves the market. The median, the middle sale, was $370,000 for the 12 months to September 9, 2026, and the price bands in our recorded sales section show how the 42 sales spread.
The Burnt Store Meadows calendar-year median peaked at $480,000 in 2023 and the 12-month median to September 9, 2026 is $370,000, 22.9 percent lower (our arithmetic). Part of that is which homes sold, since 2023 included seven Royal Poinciana resales from $529,000 to $719,000, but older and smaller homes were a smaller share of 2026 sales (15 of 33) than of 2023 sales (24 of 44), so the drop is not only a change in mix. Lot prices held near $55,000 through the same years.
We do not forecast Burnt Store Meadows prices, and no public record we read supports a forecast in either direction. What the record shows is steady resales, 42 in 12 months on a plat of 751 homes, a lot market that has held its price for three years, and a small, continuing flow of new homes.
An automated estimate cannot see a Burnt Store Meadows home's condition, its exact flood reading, a new home still coded as a vacant lot or the MLS undercount on this plat, so it can miss by a wide margin. A dated MLS file listed 8 closings here against 42 county recorded sales, and a model trained on the 8 starts thin.
A comparative market analysis is our written opinion of a likely selling range, built from recorded sales and a walkthrough, and it is free. An appraisal is a licensed appraiser's opinion of value, usually ordered by a buyer's lender. In Burnt Store Meadows both should draw from the same cohort of recorded sales, and our CMA lists them.
The MLS and county numbers for Burnt Store Meadows differ because many sales here are not listed under the community's name, and some never reach the MLS at all. The county counts every state-qualified deed; the MLS counts what agents entered under a name. For a nearly matching 12 months the MLS file showed 8 closings and the county 42.
Days on market for Burnt Store Meadows is Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). The county record shows 42 of 751 homes sold in 12 months, a 5.6 percent turnover (our arithmetic), with sales in every calendar month from September 2025 through August 2026. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 for the current pace once the MLS window opens.
The sale-to-list ratio for Burnt Store Meadows is Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). The county records the sale price but not the list price, so the ratio needs an MLS pull, and we do not borrow one from a neighboring community.
The Burnt Store Meadows median was $189.87 per square foot of county heated area across 41 sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026. By cohort it runs from $185.91 for larger pre-2002 homes to $220.18 for mid-size homes built 2002 to 2016, each in its own window. We use it to spot outliers, never to set a price.
The highest Burnt Store Meadows home sale in the 12 months to September 9, 2026 was $680,000, a resale on N Plum Tree of a 2017 home with 2,616 square feet of county heated area, recorded January 13, 2026. Over 60 months the high was $960,000.
The lowest Burnt Store Meadows home sale in the 12 months to September 9, 2026 was $195,000, a resale on Parkinsonia of a 1987 home with 1,002 square feet of county heated area, recorded June 29, 2026. It was also the lowest home sale in the 60-month window.
Homes built before 2002 in Burnt Store Meadows recorded a $322,500 median in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, against $435,000 for homes built 2002 to 2016, but the older homes are also smaller on average. Holding size at 1,800 to 2,199 square feet over 36 months, the gap was $52,500 (our arithmetic), and condition moves it further.
A larger Burnt Store Meadows home is worth more mainly when it is also newer. Over 36 months, pre-2002 homes recorded $309,500 under 1,800 square feet, $375,000 at 1,800 to 2,199 and $433,000 at 2,200 and up. Larger homes built 2002 or later recorded $498,150 over 12 months. A large home needing work can sell below a smaller finished one.
Newer homes on Royal Poinciana, the collector, have recorded the plat's highest sales: homes built 2015 to 2022 recorded $605,000 to $719,000 every time they sold in the 60 months to September 9, 2026. Older homes on the same road recorded $340,000 to $560,000. The street helps a newer home; it does not lift an older one by itself.
A vacant GM-15 lot in Burnt Store Meadows recorded a $94,900 median over 60 months, against a $55,000 median for all lot sales in the latest 12 months, and GM-15 lots run about twice the size. Homes on GM-15 lots recorded $484,000 over 24 months. The windows differ, so we read them side by side rather than subtract.
A greenbelt view is part of nearly every Burnt Store Meadows lot rather than a premium for a few: 829 of 882 mapped lots share 10 percent or more of their boundary with the association's 87.58 acre greenbelt, and those lots recorded 39 sales at the plat's $370,000 median in 12 months. Describe the view; do not price it separately.
Zone AE has not, on the recorded sales, pushed Burnt Store Meadows west-end resales below the rest of the plat: 13 AE resales recorded a $452,000 median over 36 months. What the zone changes is the buyer's flood insurance requirement and quote, so an elevation certificate and a recent roof in the listing file protect your price.
No statute requires a Burnt Store Meadows seller to provide an elevation certificate, but on a Zone AE lot it is the document a buyer's insurer asks for first. The City's layer flags a certificate on 38 of 154 AE address points in the plat. If you have one, put it in the file; if not, we tell you whether one is worth ordering.
Your roof's permit date affects a Burnt Store Meadows valuation through the buyer's insurance quote. The county counts 30,939 roofing permits countywide from October 2022 to June 15, 2023, after Ian, so buyers ask which side of that storm your roof dates from. A post-Ian roof and a current wind mitigation form support the top of your cohort's range.
New builder homes set a visible alternative rather than a lower value: in the 12 months, 5 new homes closed on the plat from $335,000 to $678,500, and over 24 months resales of homes built 2017 or later recorded a $519,000 median against the builders' $397,500. A finished, documented resale competes well with a new home.
A vacant lot in Burnt Store Meadows recorded a $55,000 median across 11 recorded lot sales (vacant land) in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, from $30,000 to $68,000. Larger GM-15 lots recorded a $94,900 median over 60 months. Zoning, declaration and flood zone set what a builder will pay.
Condominium units inside Burnt Store Meadows record too few sales for a median, so we list them. Plum Creek recorded one sale in 12 months, $125,000 for a 1,079 square foot unit on July 15, 2026, and four in 60 months from $125,000 to $245,000. Meadows of Punta Gorda recorded three in 60 months, $156,900 to $230,000.
Your buyer will pay 16.8148 mills in 2026 on a value reset to market after the sale, so the buyer's bill will not match yours. As an illustration with no exemption, $300,000 of taxable value is $5,044.44 a year (our arithmetic). Your property tax disclosure tells the buyer not to rely on your current bill.
The Burnt Store Meadows POA assessment is not published in any public document; the home page says only "Low Annual Association fee". It is billed once a year per platted parcel for an October 1 fiscal year. The estoppel certificate for your parcel states the amount, so order it at listing and give the buyer the number early.
Florida caps the estoppel certificate fee at $299 for standard delivery within 10 business days, plus $119 for delivery within 3 business days and up to $179 more if the account is delinquent, $597 at the most (our arithmetic). Ordering it at listing avoids the rush fee.
No sale approval clause and no transfer fee, resale fee or capital contribution clause appears in the Burnt Store Meadows bylaws we read. The estoppel certificate must state whether any such fee is due, so it is the document that settles the question for your parcel before closing.
In Charlotte County the seller customarily pays documentary stamp tax of $0.70 per $100 and the owner's title insurance premium, and the contract controls. At the $370,000 Burnt Store Meadows median, stamps are $2,590.00 and the promulgated title premium $1,925.00 (our arithmetic), before commission, the estoppel certificate and prorations.
You can list a Burnt Store Meadows home above the plat median when its cohort supports it: larger homes built 2002 or later recorded a $498,150 median in the 12 months, and newer homes on the collector have recorded above $600,000. Pricing above your own cohort's recorded range, without a reason a buyer can see, is what slows a sale.
Renovate only what a buyer will pay for or what an insurer will require. On this plat that is usually the roof, the wind mitigation features and any open violation or permit, because they change the buyer's quote and the estoppel certificate. On a west-end Zone AE home, keep any project below the City's 50 percent substantial improvement threshold unless you mean to elevate.
Save Our Homes portability under section 193.155 lets a Florida homestead owner carry part of the difference between market value and assessed value to a new Florida homestead, within the statute's limits and deadlines. For a long-held Burnt Store Meadows homestead it can matter to the next home's tax bill. The Department of Revenue explains the rules, and the property appraiser applies them.
No public record we read supports a claim that the Burnt Store Road East/West Connector will change any home's value here. It is carried in the county's FY2027 program at $44,783 thousand, funded from the sales tax extension voters approved on November 3, 2026 (unofficial results), and its alignment relative to Section 18 is not published.
Yes, the valuation is free, and no, you do not have to list with us. You receive a written range, every recorded sale used, the flood and zoning facts for your lot and a net sheet, and you keep the file. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or use the form at the top of this page.
We price Burnt Store Meadows homes from the full county record, sorted into the cohorts a buyer's appraiser will use, and we put the flood, zoning, association and builder facts in writing. McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
McGreevy and Comisar are a top-reviewed Southwest Florida listing team on our Google Business Profile, recognized with the Gulfshore Life Five Star award for customer satisfaction for 21 straight years. We publish no aggregate score. The reviews below come from sellers and are quoted exactly as they wrote them.
★★★★★ "I have had 13 real estate transactions and this is the most professional and helpful agency that I have ever worked with. Marc actually called me with a response to my questions and concerns on a Sunday evening. The resources that this agency has access to goes above and beyond any other I have ever worked with. The professional process that they use to present your home for sale goes beyond anything I have ever experienced. If any one is thinking about selling, Domain Realty should be the only agency that you should use to represent you and your home. You will not be disappointed." Verified Google review
★★★★★ "Marc made an extremely stressful time of selling my parents' house easier because of his expertise, compassion, and diligence. I cannot thank him enough and I would recommend him without reservation." Verified Google review
★★★★★ "We had been on the market for several months with no offers. When we signed with Marc our house was sold in 2 weeks. He has a unique system for selling homes." Verified Google review
★★★★★ "A total pleasure to work with in every aspect of our home selling process, Marc Comisar is THE consummate professional. His friendly personality coupled with his ability to identity and address every detail is irreproachable. He and his company successfully marketed and sold a home for us in the past as well as doing the same for several properties our family members owned. In my view he is THE ONLY Realtor to handle our real estate needs. AWESOME experience!" Verified Google review
The same partners who earned those reviews will price your Burnt Store Meadows home, from the first look at the county record to the closing table. Request a free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
Every document behind the Burnt Store Meadows rules and figures on this page is public, and a buyer's lender, insurer and title company will read many of them. The table lists the ones that bear most on a valuation here, and each link opens the publisher's own file rather than a reprint.
| Document | Issued by | Why a Burnt Store Meadows seller needs it | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Declaration of Restrictions, single-family lots (association copy) | Burnt Store Meadows POA | Use, setback, parking, sign, rental and greenbelt terms for most lots | Open the document |
| Declaration of Restrictions, multi-family lots (association copy) | Burnt Store Meadows POA | Terms for the GM-15 lots on the collector and the Plum Tree streets | Open the document |
| Amended and Restated Bylaws, 2020 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | Assessment timing, liens, fines and the hearing committee | Open the document |
| Violation Protocol Table, revised July 17, 2023 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | Cure times to clear before the listing photographs | Open the document |
| ARB New Construction requirements, July 2026 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | What a builder on a vacant lot next to you must meet | Open the document |
| 2026 Tax Roll Final Rates | Charlotte County Property Appraiser | The 16.8148 mill rate a buyer applies to your price | Open the document |
| Estoppel Certificate Fees | Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation | The $299, $119 and $179 caps | Open the document |
| Chapter 26, Land Development Regulations | City of Punta Gorda | GS-3.5, GM-15 and the Special Residential Overlay rules | Open the document |
| FY2027 Adopted Capital Improvement Program | Charlotte County | The East/West Connector entry a buyer may ask about | Open the document |
| Burnt Store Road Area East/West Connector project sheet | Charlotte County | The sales tax project figure for the connector | Open the document |
| Citizens Property Insurance, detail by county, August 31, 2026 | Citizens Property Insurance Corporation | The Charlotte County policy count behind the insurance discussion | Open the document |
| Quality Control Standards for Automated Valuation Models | Federal Register | The federal rule on automated estimates used by lenders | Open the document |
| IRS Publication 523, Selling Your Home | Internal Revenue Service | The federal rules on excluding gain | Open the document |
Each figure on this Burnt Store Meadows valuation page comes from a public source read on October 21, 2026 unless another date is shown. Recorded-sale figures are our analysis of the Charlotte County Property Appraiser's public sales and parcel files (roll of October 4, 2026), state-qualified sales recorded through September 9, 2026, in the window named beside each figure. Builder prices are builder marketing, not recorded prices. No listing portal, brokerage or valuation aggregator was used for any figure.
Charlotte County and its Property Appraiser
City of Punta Gorda
Burnt Store Meadows POA and the condominiums
Florida statutes, rules and agencies
Flood, storms and insurance
Health care, the rival and builders
Federal agencies and the commission rules
McGreevy and Comisar are the Southwest Florida listing team Burnt Store Meadows owners call when a home has to be valued on the record and sold without surprises. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar personally price every home they list, and they have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
If you are thinking, "I need someone to sell my house in Burnt Store Meadows, Florida," McGreevy and Comisar helps homeowners price, market, negotiate and sell with a local strategy built for Burnt Store Meadows, Punta Gorda, Port Charlotte, Charlotte County and the rest of Southwest Florida. Whether you are selling in Burnt Store Meadows, Seminole Lakes, Burnt Store Isles, Burnt Store Village, Burnt Store Lakes or Deep Creek, our team provides local market guidance, professional listing exposure and a clear plan to help you sell confidently.
#5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026). For this valuation page we tracked all 42 recorded home sales in Burnt Store Meadows over the latest 12 months, sorted them into six cohorts by age and size, and read the Charlotte County Property Appraiser's sales and parcel files, the association's declarations and bylaws, the City's zoning, tax and flood records and FEMA's flood layer, so the figures here come from public records rather than estimates.
Jesse McGreevy (license SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (license BK3060671) are licensed Florida real estate professionals regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) under Chapter 475, Florida Statutes.
Meet Jesse McGreevy, who leads the team's listing and seller strategy, and Marc Comisar, who leads buyer representation and negotiation, or read more about McGreevy and Comisar. For the whole neighborhood record, return to our Burnt Store Meadows community guide. Buying in Burnt Store Meadows or anywhere in Southwest Florida? See how we represent buyers or call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.
Ready for a number you can act on? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, or start with a free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and there is no obligation.
Updated October 2026. This page is general information about Burnt Store Meadows home values, not an appraisal and not legal, tax or insurance advice. Market figures change monthly and statutory figures change annually. County sales from Charlotte County Property Appraiser public files, analyzed October 2026. Brokered by Domain Realty.