Home › Punta Gorda › Burnt Store Meadows › Sell Your Home in Burnt Store Meadows
By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar of Domain Realty.
Updated October 2026.
A Burnt Store Meadows sale turns on three things a buyer can check before the first showing: where your lot sits on the FEMA map, which of the two recorded declarations governs it, and how your home's age and size line up with the recorded resales around it. Charlotte County recorded 42 home sales here in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, at a median of $370,000. For the full neighborhood record, from the plat and the greenbelts to the schools and the storm history, read our Burnt Store Meadows community guide. McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, wrote this seller guide for owners of the 751 homes and 144 vacant lots in Punta Gorda Isles Section 18, the deed-restricted neighborhood inside the City of Punta Gorda that its association markets as Burnt Store Meadows. For the city around it, see our Punta Gorda area guide.
Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, or ask for a free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation. We send back every recorded sale we used, each with its date, street and source. Buying your next home too? Read our guide to buying a home in Burnt Store Meadows.
To sell a Burnt Store Meadows home in 2026, price it against the county's recorded resales for homes of the same age, size and position, order the association's estoppel certificate at listing, and put the flood reading, the roof year and the declaration for your lot in the file before buyers ask. The county recorded 42 home sales in 12 months.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; association documents, City and county records and FEMA read October 21, 2026)
Every price opinion we write here starts with the deed record, because Charlotte County counts each state-qualified sale whether or not the home was ever on the Southwest Florida MLS. In this plat that matters more than usual: a dated MLS pull for a nearly matching year found 8 closings under the Burnt Store Meadows name, while the county recorded 42 home sales. The MLS still holds three measures the county cannot supply, days on market, sale-to-list ratio and months of supply, and none of them was available to us when we published: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07).
Burnt Store Meadows is easy to mix up with its neighbors. Burnt Store Isles is Punta Gorda Isles Section 15, a canal neighborhood with a country club. Burnt Store Village is Section 16, outside the city. Burnt Store Lakes is Section 21, and Burnt Store Marina is Section 22, across the line in Lee County. Burnt Store Meadows is Section 18: no canals, no boat access, no gate and no clubhouse, but 87.58 acres of association greenbelts that touch almost every lot. A listing that gets the name and the section right on the first line saves a buyer's agent from pulling the wrong comparables.
Six facts move a sale here more than paint colors do. The first is age: in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, single-family homes built before 2002 recorded 16 sales at a $322,500 median, and homes built from 2002 to 2016 recorded 16 sales at $435,000. The second is size: homes of 2,200 square feet of county heated area or more recorded 13 sales at a $477,000 median. The third is the flood line, because 148 of the 882 mapped residential lots sit in FEMA Zone AE at the west end and the rest read Zone X. The fourth is the lot itself, single-family GS-3.5 zoning or multi-family GM-15 zoning, with GM-15 lots at a 20,000 square foot median. The fifth is the paperwork, starting with the estoppel certificate, because the annual association assessment is not published anywhere public. The sixth is competition from new homes, since 5 of the 42 sales were a builder's first sale.
A resale here competes with three groups at once. The first is other resales in the plat, 37 of the 42 recorded sales, at a $363,000 median. The second is the builders, who closed 5 new homes in the same 12 months at a $630,000 median and still have 144 vacant lots on the roll to choose from. The third is the neighbors a buyer cross-shops: Seminole Lakes across the greenbelt edge, the canal homes of Burnt Store Isles and the larger platted sections farther south and east. The listing that wins answers the buyer's questions about the flood line, the fees and the roof before the buyer has to ask.
We cover the recorded market by window, age, size, price band and street; why the MLS shows so few sales here; how the neighborhood benchmarks against its neighbors; whether now is a good time to sell; how we price a home and how a resale competes with new construction and vacant lots; the yearly cost a buyer will calculate; what you need from the association; the greenbelts and what is not inside the plat; the disclosures a seller owes; flood, wind and insurance; schools, hospitals and drive times; marketing and negotiation; the cost of selling; Burnt Store Meadows against Seminole Lakes; selling a condominium unit or a lot; and more than 30 seller questions answered directly.
McGreevy and Comisar price Burnt Store Meadows homes on the records that decide them: the county's recorded resales by age and size, the City millage on your tax bill, the FEMA reading for your lot, the association's recorded declarations and the builders' recent closings. We lead the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and both partners work every listing personally.
Data updated: October 2026 (county records through September 9, 2026; association and City documents read October 21, 2026)
We are the partners who price your home, sit at the negotiating table and pick up the phone when a buyer's agent calls with a question about the flood line. Here is the record behind that promise:
Our Domain Realty Group team is the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026). Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar bring over 45 years of combined direct experience to every Burnt Store Meadows listing. If you are still choosing who should sell your home, our guide to the best real estate agents in Punta Gorda lays out the questions we think a seller should ask any agent, and we are glad to be measured against them.
A Burnt Store Meadows listing agent has to know that every parcel owner is a mandatory member of one association, the Burnt Store Meadows Property Owner's Association, Inc., but that two recorded declarations govern the lots: one for single-family lots and one for multi-family lots. The City adds a third layer through its zoning, GS-3.5 on 750 parcels and GM-15 on 134. A buyer's attorney and a buyer's builder will each ask which set applies to your lot, and the answer belongs in the first paragraph of the listing.
Burnt Store Meadows homes change hands two ways at once: resales on streets that were mostly built out by 2004, and first sales of new homes by builders on the remaining lots. The county's deed record counts both. We pull the recorded sales around your address, separate builder-direct sales from resales, split the resales by age and county heated area, and read the street and the flood zone beside each one. Where the roll trails new construction, as with a new home on Schefflera that closed at $678,500 on May 8, 2026 while still coded vacant, we say so instead of letting a mis-coded parcel move your price.
Jesse and Marc both work every listing. The person who priced your home is the person who answers the buyer's question about the greenbelt behind your lanai, reads the lender's flood determination and negotiates the repair credit after the four-point inspection. In a neighborhood where an older resale can sit two lots from a new build, that continuity is what keeps a price from sliding between contract and closing.
We will not quote your home's value from a portal estimate, print an association assessment the association has not published, or tell a buyer the west end is out of the flood zone. Where a record is not public or was not available to us, we say so and name the document that holds it. Candor in the listing is what keeps a contract from being renegotiated at the inspection.
For sellers, Burnt Store Meadows is a resale market with a steady trickle of new homes. Charlotte County recorded 42 home sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, at a $370,000 median: 37 resales at $363,000 and 5 builder-direct new homes at $630,000. The median has eased from its 2023 peak, and MLS timing measures are not available to us.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, roll of October 4, 2026; newest qualified sale in the county file September 9, 2026)
Charlotte County is county-first for us: local MLS coverage is thin, so every count and median below comes from the county's recorded, state-qualified sales, run through one tool with one set of rules (improved parcels, a price above $1,000, and a builder's first sale of a new home counted apart from resales). Each figure names its window, and "12 months" always means September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026. The source line under every county figure on this page reads: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
| Window ending September 9, 2026 | Recorded home sales | Median price |
|---|---|---|
| Latest 12 months | 42 | $370,000 |
| Latest 24 months | 79 | $380,000 |
| Latest 36 months | 125 | $415,000 |
| Latest 60 months | 212 | $425,000 |
| Every recorded sale in the file since January 22, 2009 | 746 | $281,700 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. The windows overlap: each longer window contains the shorter ones.
The 12-month window already holds more than 10 sales, so it is the one we lean on; the longer rows show whether it is typical. In every longer window from 24 to 60 months the median sits higher, which tells a seller that the recorded level in the latest year is below the multi-year level. The county file does not say why, and the mix of homes changes from window to window, so we price from the latest comparable sales and not from the trend line.
| 12 months to September 9, 2026 | Sales | Median | Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Every home sale | 42 | $370,000 | $195,000 to $680,000 |
| Resales | 37 | $363,000 | $195,000 to $680,000 |
| A builder's first sale of a new home | 5 | $630,000 | $335,000 to $678,500 |
| Single-family homes only | 41 | $370,000 | $195,000 to $680,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. The median per square foot of county heated area across the 42 sales was $189.87 (41 sales with a heated area on the roll).
Five of the 42 sales, 11.9 percent (our arithmetic), were a builder's first sale. The $267,000 gap between the builder-direct and resale medians (our arithmetic) compares new homes with older ones, so it is not a premium any resale can claim. What it tells a resale seller is that buyers in this plat can, and do, pay above $600,000 for a new home here, which sets the ceiling a buyer sees when touring.
| Price band, 12 months | Recorded sales |
|---|---|
| Under $200,000 | 1 |
| $200,000 to $300,000 | 5 |
| $300,000 to $400,000 | 18 |
| $400,000 to $500,000 | 10 |
| $500,000 to $750,000 | 8 |
| $750,000 and up | 0 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
Twenty-eight of the 42 sales, two in three (our arithmetic), closed between $300,000 and $500,000. Eight closed between $500,000 and $750,000, and the highest recorded price in the 12 months was $680,000. A seller asking more than $680,000 is asking above every home sale recorded here in the latest year, which a rare size, age and position can support, but the price conversation should say so out loud.
| Calendar year | Recorded home sales | Median | Builder-direct sales |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | 57 | $290,000 | 12 |
| 2020 | 61 | $285,000 | 11 |
| 2021 | 78 | $352,450 | 13 |
| 2022 | 34 | $452,500 | 5 |
| 2023 | 44 | $480,000 | 1 |
| 2024 | 49 | $443,500 | 3 |
| 2025 | 32 | $390,000 | 6 |
| 2026 through September 9 | 33 | $363,000 | 3 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis.
The calendar-year median peaked at $480,000 in 2023, and the latest 12-month median of $370,000 is $110,000, or 22.9 percent, lower (our arithmetic). Those are medians of different groups of homes, not a repeat-sale index, so they describe what sold rather than what any one house lost. Volume moved too: 78 sales in 2021 against 32 in 2025. A seller should read the table as a record of what buyers paid, not as a forecast.
| Recording period | Recorded home sales |
|---|---|
| September 10 to 30, 2025 | 3 |
| October to December 2025 | 6 |
| January to March 2026 | 10 |
| April to June 2026 | 14 |
| July 1 to September 9, 2026 | 9 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our count of the 42 listed sales by deed date.
Twenty-four of the 42 sales recorded from January through June 2026 (our arithmetic). One year is not a season, and the county file trails the market by weeks, so the late-summer count may still grow as deeds arrive. The narrow lesson for a seller is that the recorded year was busiest from January to June, and a home that is photographed, documented and priced by the start of the year has more of the buying season ahead of it.
Days on market: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). Sale-to-list ratio: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). Months of supply: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). Active listings and an MLS closing count for the same window are also unavailable to us. These are MLS measures, and we would rather leave the gap than borrow a figure from another neighborhood. When we prepare your price opinion, we bring the live MLS figures for comparable homes beside the county record.
Turnover is the first reading: 42 sales on 751 homes is 5.6 percent in a year (our arithmetic), so a buyer sees few comparable closings and each one counts. Mix is the second: the median describes no single house, and a buyer's agent will pull the three nearest sales by age, size and street. Timing is the third: a recorded sale is a closing, entered some weeks after the price was agreed, so the newest deed in the file understates how recently the market moved. We show you all three before you choose a list price.
The MLS shows few Burnt Store Meadows sales because it sorts listings by a subdivision field that agents fill in by hand, and that field undercounts this plat. A dated MLS pull counted 8 closings against 42 county recorded sales in a nearly matching year. A seller needs the county record for counts and the MLS for timing.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS file for closings from September 25, 2025 to September 24, 2026; Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026)
A Southwest Florida MLS file in our records, covering closings from September 25, 2025 to September 24, 2026, lists 8 Burnt Store Meadows closings with a median of $387,500. In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, the county recorded 42 home sales in the same plat. The windows are not identical, but the difference is far too large to be timing. A buyer's agent who runs only an MLS subdivision search will think the neighborhood is a fraction of its real size, and will pull comparables from wherever the search lands.
The MLS measures how long a listed home sat, what it sold for against its last asking price, how many homes are active at once and how many listings closed. Those are the figures that tell a seller how far a list price can stretch. They describe only homes entered through the MLS, so a seller deserves to know that the MLS count and the county count can differ, and here they differ by a wide margin.
The county record shows every qualified deed, the year the home was built, its county heated area, its zoning and the block it sits in. It lets us separate the 5 builder-direct sales from the 37 resales, split the resales by age and size, and read the flood zone and the street beside each sale. It also shows the 11 recorded lot sales (vacant land) that never enter a home median but tell a builder what the remaining lots cost.
We open the file with the recorded sales nearest your home, add the MLS days on market and sale-to-list figures for those same sales when the MLS has them, and reconcile any sale that appears in one source and not the other. That is the trail a buyer's appraiser follows, and a price that holds up to the appraiser is a price that closes. For the full list of the 42 recorded sales, see the market section of the Burnt Store Meadows community guide.
Burnt Store Meadows benchmarks above Seminole Lakes, Burnt Store Village and the Deep Creek plats on recorded medians, and well below the canal homes of Burnt Store Isles. In the 12 months to September 9, 2026 it recorded 42 sales at $370,000, against $305,000 in Seminole Lakes and $657,200 in Burnt Store Isles. These medians describe very different homes.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files; each community run with the same tool and the same 12-month window)
| Community, 12 months to September 9, 2026 | Recorded home sales | Median | Per sq ft of county heated area | Builder-direct sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Burnt Store Meadows | 42 | $370,000 | $189.87 | 5 |
| Seminole Lakes | 25 | $305,000 | $183.96 | 0 |
| Burnt Store Isles | 78 | $657,200 | $286.50 | 0 |
| Burnt Store Village | 83 | $329,000 | $175.13 | 40 |
| Burnt Store Lakes | 66 | $433,500 | $235.23 | 17 |
| Deep Creek single-family plats | 316 | $360,000 | $178.14 | 46 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis; each row from that community's own run. Burnt Store Isles is homes only, with the golf-course parcel sale excluded.
Each peer differs from Burnt Store Meadows in kind. Seminole Lakes is a gated golf community built from 1992 to 2003 with no builder-direct sales in the window. Burnt Store Isles is a canal neighborhood, and its median reflects water. Burnt Store Village and Burnt Store Lakes are larger platted sections where builders still sell a large share of new homes, so their medians are partly builder price levels. Deep Creek is a far larger set of plats. A buyer looking at Burnt Store Meadows is shopping some of these too, and the listing should say what this plat offers that they do not: city services, a greenbelt behind most lots and no canal or golf dues to carry.
The table cannot tell you which neighborhood a buyer prefers, how fast homes sold or what asking prices were. It cannot turn the $65,000 gap between the Burnt Store Meadows and Seminole Lakes medians (our arithmetic) into a premium either: Seminole Lakes sold no new homes in the window, while 5 of the Burnt Store Meadows sales were new builds at a $630,000 median, and the homes differ in age and lot. The benchmark is context, not a price.
We use three yardsticks and never blend them. The first is the recorded resale median for homes like yours inside Burnt Store Meadows, which is the price comparison. The second is the community benchmark above, which is context for the buyer's alternatives. The third is the builders' recent closings and current marketing, which is competition. Blending them into one figure is how a seller ends up with a price no appraiser supports.
Now is a workable time to sell in Burnt Store Meadows if the home is priced on the latest recorded resales and the documents are ready, because the recorded year was busiest from January to June and resales are most of the market. We do not forecast prices; we set out the dated facts a buyer will weigh this winter and spring.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County capital program adopted September 22, 2026; City budget documents of August 2026; Citizens Property Insurance county data through August 31, 2026)
The county record shows 42 sales in the latest 12 months and a median below its 24, 36 and 60 month levels. It does not show how long each home was listed, how many price cuts came first or how many listings were withdrawn. A seller deciding whether to list now needs the MLS half of the picture, which we bring to the price conversation, and an honest look at the cost of waiting: a year of City property tax at 16.8148 mills on $300,000 of taxable value is $5,044.44 (our arithmetic, no exemptions applied), before insurance and the association assessment.
Charlotte County's FY2027 capital program, adopted September 22, 2026, carries the Burnt Store Road East/West Connector, a new two-lane road from US 41 to Burnt Store Road along the Tuckers Grade extension, at $44,783 thousand across FY2027 to FY2029, with its funding marked "Pending Sales Tax 2026." The county's sales tax project sheet prices it at $46,176,000 under the one-cent sales tax extension, which Charlotte County voters approved on November 3, 2026, 56,284 votes to 38,396 on unofficial results from the Supervisor of Elections (Charlotte Sun). A signal at Burnt Store Road and the Home Depot entrance is an MPO priority at $1.95 million in present-day cost, and the City's February 2026 capital update shows $1,338,000. The US 41 Corridor Vision Plan of 2020 even names a "Burnt Store Meadows Study Segment" and the U-turns at Taylor Road and Royal Poinciana. A buyer who asks about traffic deserves those dated facts rather than a guess.
Cassia Bay, on 68.43 acres east of Burnt Store Road about half a mile from Section 18, has county plat and site-plan filings, and the City's FY2027 proposed budget lists Phase 1A at four tracts and 100 units. Pulte's community page, seen October 21, 2026, markets homes there from $295,990 to $429,990; that is builder marketing, not a recorded price. Sage Pointe, adopted by Charlotte County Ordinance 2026-024 on July 28, 2026, allows up to 999 units including up to 300 RV sites on 277.55 acres at Burnt Store Road and Zemel Road, about 5 to 6 miles north, so it is not a neighbor. The county's Burnt Store Area Plan deck of June 11, 2024 counts 10,599 entitled units in the plan area. A resale seller should expect buyers to compare a 2000s home here with a new one at Cassia Bay, and price for that comparison.
No hospital or emergency room operates inside the City of Punta Gorda today. The ShorePoint Health Punta Gorda hospital on East Marion Avenue closed after Hurricane Helene and Milton in 2024 and has not reopened. AdventHealth has announced a 12-bed emergency department as Phase 1 of a campus on 17.46 acres at 26072 Glasgow Ave off Jones Loop Road, about 2.5 road miles from the center of the plat; the Board of Zoning Appeals recommended a parking variance in a report of October 1, 2026, and groundbreaking was expected in November 2026. It is not open, and we say so in every listing conversation where it comes up.
Citizens Property Insurance reported 14,624 personal residential multi-peril policies in Charlotte County on September 30, 2024 and 2,121 on August 31, 2026. Citizens requires flood coverage with wind coverage inside the special flood hazard area, phases the rule in outside it for Coverage A above $400,000 from January 1, 2026 and for all policies from January 1, 2027, and asks for a four-point inspection on homes more than 20 years old. Whatever the reasons behind the policy count, a buyer shopping for a policy on a 1990s home will ask for the roof year and a wind mitigation report, and a seller with both is ahead of that question.
Only about one home in eighteen here changed hands in the latest 12 months, so the next owner who sells should call us first. Request a free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation and we will send the recorded resales for homes of your age, size and flood zone, with the date and source beside each, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012. Buying your next home as well? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or read how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida.
Charlotte County tax bills mail in November 2026. A sale that closes before the bill is paid prorates the year's tax between buyer and seller, and the title company works from the bill on the parcel. The City adopted 3.9928 mills for its FY2027 levy, about 0.36 percent below the 4.0074 rollback rate, so the City share of the 2026 bill is set.
If you need to close by a date, we count backward from it. The association has up to 10 business days to deliver the estoppel certificate, a buyer's insurance quote and four-point inspection take their own time, and a lender's appraisal and flood determination follow. Starting the paperwork before you pick a list price is the cheapest way to protect the closing date.
We price a Burnt Store Meadows home from recorded resales of homes like it, narrowed by year built, county heated area, street, lot zoning, greenbelt edge and flood zone, then adjust for roof, systems and condition. The 37 resales in the 12 months had a $363,000 median, but a 1980s home of 1,400 square feet and a 2016 home of 2,400 are different markets.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, roll of October 4, 2026; newest qualified sale September 9, 2026)
| Single-family homes by county year built | Homes on the roll | Window used | Recorded sales | Median | Per sq ft of county heated area |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Built before 2002 | 363 | 12 months | 16, all resales | $322,500 | $186.70 |
| Built 2002 to 2016 | 241 | 12 months | 16, all resales | $435,000 | $200.30 |
| Built 2017 or later | 143 | 24 months (first window with 10 or more) | 21: 8 builder-direct at $397,500, 13 resales at $519,000 | $468,000 | $227.35 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis of county parcel lists. Even-numbered medians are the mean of the middle pair: $300,000 and $345,000 for the homes built before 2002, and $430,000 and $440,000 for the homes built from 2002 to 2016. The Schefflera new home is not yet on the roll and sits in none of these rows.
Era matters here for a reason a buyer can see on paper. The first Florida Building Code took effect on March 1, 2002, and 364 of the 751 homes on the roll carry a year built before 2002. An insurer, an inspector and an appraiser will all sort your home by that line. In the 12 months, homes built from 2002 to 2016 recorded a median $112,500 above the homes built before 2002 (our arithmetic), but they are also larger and on different streets, so the gap is not a code premium. It is the reason we never price a 1995 home from a 2006 sale.
Fewer than 10 homes built in 2017 or later sold in the 12 months, so we list them rather than quote a median.
| Recorded | Street | Sale type | County year built | County heated sq ft | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| January 13, 2026 | N Plum Tree | Resale | 2017 | 2,616 | $680,000 |
| September 12, 2025 | S Blue Sage | Builder-direct | 2025 | 2,019 | $650,000 |
| March 6, 2026 | N Moss Rose | Builder-direct | 2025 | 2,771 | $630,000 |
| July 21, 2026 | N Plum Tree | Resale | 2022 | 2,365 | $380,000 |
| September 17, 2025 | W Cashew | Resale | 2022 | 2,000 | $370,000 |
| November 12, 2025 | N Ficus Tree | Builder-direct | 2025 | 1,842 | $370,000 |
| May 7, 2026 | Carissa | Resale | 2017 | 1,803 | $335,000 |
| May 28, 2026 | South Seagrape Rd | Builder-direct | 2025 | 1,952 | $335,000 |
| August 12, 2026 | S Moss Rose | Resale | 2022 | 2,001 | $310,000 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. Street names only.
The spread inside this short list is the lesson. New homes of similar size closed at $335,000 and $370,000 on the west end and at $630,000 and $650,000 elsewhere, and three resales of 2022 homes closed from $310,000 to $380,000. Size, finish, lot and flood zone separate them, not the year alone. A seller of a recent home should expect the buyer's agent to pull exactly these sales.
| Single-family homes by county heated area | Homes on the roll | Window used | Recorded sales | Median | Per sq ft of county heated area |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under 1,800 sq ft | 234 | 24 months (first window with 10 or more) | 18, all resales | $297,000 | $197.12 |
| 1,800 to 2,199 sq ft | 353 | 12 months | 19: 3 builder-direct at $370,000, 16 resales at $362,500 | $363,000 | $187.56 |
| 2,200 sq ft and up | 160 | 12 months | 13: 1 builder-direct, 12 resales at $473,500 | $477,000 | $199.41 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis of county parcel lists. Heated area is the county's, never compared with an MLS living-area figure.
The middle band, 1,800 to 2,199 square feet, holds the most homes and the most sales, and its 16 resales sat at $362,500, almost exactly the plat's resale median. The smaller homes needed a 24-month window to reach 10 sales; in the 12 months alone, 9 homes under 1,800 square feet sold, from $195,000 on Parkinsonia to $515,000 for a 2016 home on W Cashew. A small home that was built recently can outprice a large older one, which is why size is the second step and not the first.
Position moves a Burnt Store Meadows price in four ways the county record can show. Homes on Royal Poinciana itself, the spine road, recorded 14 sales over 60 months at a $627,500 median and $281.21 per square foot of county heated area, against 3 sales in the 12 months at $340,000, $500,000 and $605,000. Homes on multi-family zoned GM-15 lots, which run 20,000 square feet at the median, recorded 10 sales over 24 months at a $484,000 median, while homes on single-family zoned GS-3.5 lots recorded 35 sales in 12 months at $363,000; those windows differ, so we do not subtract them. Homes whose lots share 10 percent or more of their boundary with the greenbelt recorded 39 sales in 12 months at $370,000, which is nearly every sale, so the greenbelt is a feature of the plat rather than a premium for one lot. And the flood line: 7 sales in Zone AE at the west end had a $350,000 median, against 35 sales in the Zone X rest at $380,000 (all our analysis).
The 7 Zone AE sales and the 35 Zone X sales are different homes on different streets, in a small sample. The west end is also the newer part of the plat, with a median year built of 2004 against 2001 elsewhere, and it is where several builders closed new homes at the low end of the new-home range. Over 36 months the Zone AE homes recorded 18 sales at a $441,500 median and $210.18 per square foot. So we never tell a west-end owner that the flood zone costs a set amount; we price from the nearest Zone AE resales, show the buyer the base flood elevation of 9 feet and the elevation certificate if one exists, and let the insurance quote speak.
Buyers sometimes ask whether one side of the spine road sells higher. In the 12 months, 19 sales north of Royal Poinciana recorded a $370,000 median at $190.24 per square foot (18 with heated area), and 20 sales south of it recorded $361,000 at $194.64 (our analysis). That gap sits inside sampling noise, and we say so instead of inventing a premium for either side.
After the record narrows the comparables, the house itself decides where in the range your price lands. The roof's permit date matters most. The county's recovery plan counts 30,939 roofing permits countywide from October 2022 to June 15, 2023, after Hurricane Ian, so a buyer and the buyer's insurer will ask whether your roof was replaced before or after that storm, and the permit answers it. The air conditioner's age, the water heater, impact windows or shutters, the pool cage and any open permit come next. We walk the home, list what a buyer will price in, and set the number within the band the recorded sales support.
These are recorded resales from the 12 months that a buyer's agent or an appraiser is likely to pull for a typical home here. They are listed by street only.
| Price | Street | County year built | County heated sq ft | Recorded |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $650,000 | Scarlet Sage | 2015 | 2,472 | March 20, 2026 |
| $605,000 | Royal Poinciana | 2016 | 2,476 | April 20, 2026 |
| $496,300 | Wedelia | 2014 | 2,354 | February 23, 2026 |
| $460,000 | N Plum Tree | 2003 | 1,878 | June 19, 2026 |
| $425,000 | Trumpet Tree | 2006 | 2,199 | August 27, 2026 |
| $422,000 | Soursop | 2002 | 1,838 | July 13, 2026 |
| $362,000 | Sweet Alyssum | 1992 | 1,930 | October 17, 2025 |
| $350,000 | Vinca Rosea | 1993 | 2,313 | August 24, 2026 |
| $266,000 | Acalypha | 1995 | 1,477 | June 23, 2026 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. We send the full list of the 42 recorded sales to every owner who asks for a valuation.
A worked reading, using only the record: a 1999 home of about 1,950 square feet in Zone X, on a GS-3.5 lot backing the greenbelt, sits in the era group that recorded a $322,500 median and the size band that recorded $363,000. In the 12-month list, the five resales built from 1990 to 2001 with 1,890 to 2,010 square feet of county heated area closed at $300,000 (Allamanda Ln), $345,000 (N Blue Sage), $360,000 (Ligustrum), $362,000 (Sweet Alyssum) and $363,000 (N Plum Tree), so the record points to a range in the mid $300,000s before condition. A new roof and a current wind mitigation report argue for the upper part of that range, and an original roof and an open permit argue for the lower part. That is how we build a price, and the free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation does the same for your address.
A Burnt Store Meadows resale competes with new homes built on the plat's 144 vacant lots and with new communities nearby, so it wins on price, finished landscaping and a known history. In the 12 months, builders closed 5 new homes here at a $630,000 median, and 11 recorded lot sales (vacant land) closed at a $55,000 median.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files through September 9, 2026; builder page seen October 21, 2026)
The five builder-direct sales in the 12 months were S Blue Sage at $650,000 (September 12, 2025), N Ficus Tree at $370,000 (November 12, 2025), N Moss Rose at $630,000 (March 6, 2026), Schefflera at $678,500 (May 8, 2026, still coded vacant on the roll) and South Seagrape Rd at $335,000 (May 28, 2026). Two of the five, N Ficus Tree and South Seagrape Rd, sit on streets that are entirely Zone AE, and they closed at the low end. A resale seller near any of these streets should expect a buyer to bring the new home's price to the showing.
The roll shows 144 of 895 residential parcels vacant, 16.1 percent (our arithmetic), and the most vacant streets are Royal Poinciana (20 of 79 parcels), S Plum Tree (9 of 18) and Lucky Nut (3 of 4). Some streets are fully built: Philodendron, Ligustrum, Clusia Rosea, N Ficus Tree, S Ficus Tree, Coco Plum, Vitex and Scarlet Sage Ct. Build-out came in waves, with 488 homes dated 2004 or earlier, almost none from 2008 to 2012, 25 in 2016 and 83 from 2020 to 2025. A seller on a fully built street can say so; a seller next to a vacant lot should expect a buyer to ask what may be built there, and the answer is the lot's zoning and the declaration that governs it.
A new home on a Burnt Store Meadows lot goes through the association's Architectural Review Board at a monthly board meeting, with documents due the Friday before, a copy of the City building permit within 14 days or the approval is rescinded, a performance and completion bond and a $500 refundable Clean Site deposit held to final inspection. The ARB's July 2026 rules keep 15 feet at the rear lot line clear for access to the greenbelt and ditch, put hardwood trees at least 10 feet from the rear line and recommend a stem wall instead of fill. Those rules protect a resale owner's view and drainage, and a seller next to a vacant lot can point to them.
Pulte's Cassia Bay page, seen October 21, 2026, markets homes from $295,990 to $429,990 about half a mile from Section 18; those are builder marketing prices, not recorded sales. A buyer comparing a resale here with a new home there is weighing a finished lot, mature trees, the greenbelt and city services against a new roof and a builder's warranty. We put that comparison in writing for the buyer, because a resale that is priced against it in the open holds better than one that pretends it does not exist.
| Window ending September 9, 2026 | Recorded lot sales (vacant land) | Median |
|---|---|---|
| 12 months | 11 | $55,000 ($30,000 to $68,000) |
| 24 months | 20 | $55,950 |
| 36 months | 29 | $55,000 |
| 60 months | 61 | $55,900 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis. Lot prices never enter a home median.
Lot prices have held near $55,000 for three years, and the multi-family zoned GM-15 lots price higher, with 13 vacant-land sales over 60 months at a $94,900 median on lots that run about twice the size. A lot owner who wants to sell should know both numbers, and a home seller should know that a builder can buy the lot next door for a small fraction of what a finished home costs, which is part of why new homes keep arriving.
The roll lags new construction, so a finished home can close while its parcel is still coded vacant. We checked: no recorded sale of $150,000 or more on a vacant-coded parcel appears in the 12, 24 or 36 months, and six appear in all history, from 2013 to 2022, at $190,000 to $269,900. The 11 lot sales in the latest 12 months are therefore lots, and the one new home still coded vacant, on Schefflera, is counted with the homes.
A buyer will add the City property tax, the association assessment, City water and wastewater, and insurance. Burnt Store Meadows sits in tax district 150 at 16.8148 mills for 2026, with no community development district, no county MSBU and no canal assessment, but the association's annual assessment is not published, so the estoppel certificate is where a buyer learns it.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser 2026 final rate chart; City water and wastewater rates effective October 1, 2026; association documents read October 21, 2026)
Every home here is inside the City of Punta Gorda, so the 2026 bill carries the City's millage in place of the county's law enforcement and lighting levies. The 2026 final rate in district 150 is 16.8148 mills: County 6.1275, Environmentally Sensitive Lands debt 0.2000, City of Punta Gorda 3.9928, West Coast Inland Navigation District 0.0394, Southwest Florida Water Management District 0.1831, school state 3.0240 and school local 3.2480. The unincorporated district 104 pays 15.3705 mills, so district 150 pays 1.4443 mills more, about $144.43 per $100,000 of taxable value (our arithmetic). In 2025 the gap was 1.5330 mills.
| Taxable value (no exemptions applied) | District 150, 16.8148 mills | District 104, 15.3705 mills | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| $100,000 | $1,681.48 | $1,537.05 | $144.43 |
| $300,000 | $5,044.44 | $4,611.15 | $433.29 |
| $370,000 | $6,221.48 | $5,687.09 | $534.39 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser 2026 final rate chart; our arithmetic. The $370,000 row uses the 12-month median sale price as a round illustration of taxable value, not a forecast of any bill.
A buyer's first bill will not be your bill. After a change of ownership, a home is reassessed at just value as of the next January 1, and your Save Our Homes cap does not pass to the buyer. We tell buyers that plainly in the listing file, so the higher number does not surprise them after contract.
Membership in the Burnt Store Meadows Property Owner's Association, Inc. is mandatory for every owner of a parcel in Section 18, including condominium unit owners, with one vote per parcel. Under the 2020 bylaws the assessment is levied once a year per original platted parcel, in advance, and due within 60 days after the October 1 start of the fiscal year; vacant lots pay, and an owner of several parcels pays for each. The amount is not in any public document: the association's home page says only "Low Annual Association fee," and the budget goes to members. The estoppel certificate for your parcel states it, and we order that certificate at listing.
The association's January 2026 newsletter lists what it maintains from the annual fee: the entrance areas, the greenbelts, the right of way along Burnt Store Road and the interior drainage ditches, with a new landscape contractor from January 2026. Vacant lots are not maintained by the association; the City handles them and charges the owner. The City's FY2027 budget lists a lot mowing program assessment of $285, and which lots it covers was not found in what we read.
There is no community development district levy in tax district 150, and the county's MSBU layer returned no special benefit unit at 11 sample points inside the plat. The City's canal maintenance districts cover canal sections of Punta Gorda Isles and Burnt Store Isles, and Section 18 has no canals, so no canal assessment applies. For a buyer comparing a canal home or a CDD community, those absences are real money, and we say them in the listing.
The City's certificated service-area layers show City of Punta Gorda water and sewer service at every sample point we read across the plat. The City's inside-city rate table, effective October 1, 2026, prints a water base of 15.18 and a customer charge of 6.60 per month, residential water tiers from 4.51 per 1,000 gallons for the first 5,000 gallons up to 9.60 above 40,000 gallons, a wastewater base of 36.91 and a wastewater use charge of 4.66 per 1,000 gallons. Stormwater and refuse amounts were not found. Whether every lot is connected to central sewer is not established on the record we read, and the 1970s declarations provide for a sewer availability charge on later installation, so a buyer of an older home may ask for the utility account history.
A buyer adds those lines to an insurance quote for the address, which depends on the roof, the year built, the wind mitigation features and the flood zone. Because the association assessment and the insurance premium are the two numbers we cannot publish for you, the listing file should carry the estoppel figure and, if you will share it, your current declarations page, so the buyer's total is built from your home and not from a guess.
A Burnt Store Meadows seller needs a current estoppel certificate, copies of the declaration that governs the lot and the 2020 bylaws and articles, any ARB approvals for past exterior work, and a clean violation record. The association must deliver the estoppel within 10 business days, and Florida caps its fee at $299 plus set add-ons.
Data updated: October 2026 (Florida Statutes 720.30851 and 720.303; DBPR estoppel fee schedule; association documents read October 21, 2026)
The estoppel certificate is the document a buyer's title agent uses to learn what you owe the association: the assessment, any balance, any fines and any fee due at transfer. Florida's Department of Business and Professional Regulation publishes the current caps: not more than $299 for the certificate, an additional $119 for delivery within 3 business days and an additional fee of up to $179 if the parcel is delinquent, which is $597 at the most (our arithmetic). The statute requires delivery within 10 business days, and DBPR's next update to the caps is due by July 1, 2027. We order it when you sign the listing agreement, so a contract never waits on it.
Unlike many associations, the Burnt Store Meadows POA posts its core documents on its own website without a log-in: the single-family and multi-family declarations, the 2020 Amended and Restated Articles and Bylaws, the violation protocol, the ARB rules and the welcome letter. That is an advantage for a seller, because a buyer's attorney can read them before the offer instead of after it. We attach the ones that apply to your lot to the listing, and owners may also inspect the association's official records under section 720.303.
No transfer fee, resale fee or capital contribution clause appears in the bylaws we read. Whether any such fee is due on your sale is therefore unknown until the estoppel certificate states it, and the certificate must. We tell buyers exactly that: no clause found in the bylaws, and the estoppel is the controlling answer.
The bylaws we read contain no clause requiring the association to approve a buyer before a sale. A seller can therefore set a closing date without building in a board interview, though the estoppel and any open violation still need to be clear before closing.
The bylaws allow fines of up to $100 per violation per day, up to $2,500 in the aggregate, heard by a committee of three non-board members on 14 days' notice. The violation protocol, revised July 17, 2023, sets cure times such as 24 hours for parking and commercial vehicles, 14 days for grass over 12 inches or a hedge over 4 feet, 24 hours for trash cans after pickup and 30 days for a vacant lot. The association's welcome letter says Burnt Store Meadows is a Special Residential Overlay District within the City, "more stringent than the city," and that uncured violations go to City Code Enforcement. Any open item shows up on the estoppel, so we clear it before listing.
Exterior changes and new construction need ARB approval before work starts. If you added a pool cage, a fence, a driveway extension or new windows, gather the approval letter and the City permit. A buyer's agent will look at the City permit record, and an approval letter in the file answers the question before it is raised.
The single-family declaration bars trailers, trucks, boats, boat trailers, campers and mobile homes parked overnight without written consent, and the City overlay allows one camping trailer or habitation vehicle on the driveway from 7 am to 7 pm and no parking on vacant land or the right of way from 1 am to 5 am. Special parking permits allow up to 4 occasions of up to 2 nights each per calendar year, with both the free City permit and the association's waiver form. During a listing, a boat or RV parked overnight at the house invites a violation notice in the middle of your showings, so we plan around it.
The single-family declaration allows one for-sale or for-rent sign no larger than 6 by 8 inches, which is far smaller than a standard yard sign, so our marketing does not lean on one. The declaration allows renting "for residential use" and states no minimum term. Whether short-term rentals are allowed under any other rule or City ordinance is not established on the record we read, so a seller marketing to an investor should say the rental rule is the declaration's sentence and nothing more.
Say what the records say: the association owns 87.58 acres of greenbelts that run behind nearly every lot as a private park for owners, and there is no clubhouse, pool, golf course, marina, canal or gate inside the plat. Golf, paddling and boat ramps are a short drive away, and the association runs a busy calendar of outdoor events.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser parcel card and GIS read October 21, 2026; association documents, newsletters and calendar read October 21, 2026)
The county shows one parcel owned by the Burnt Store Meadows POA with the legal description "Punta Gorda Isles Section 18 Greenbelts 87.58 AC. as per Plat Book 10 Pg. 4." Our analysis of county parcel outlines found that 873 of the 882 mapped residential parcels share at least 5 percent of their boundary with the greenbelt, and 829 share 10 percent or more. For a seller, that means the green space behind your yard is not an empty lot waiting for a house; it is association ground, and that is a fact a buyer can verify on the county card.
Both declarations make the greenbelt walkways and park areas a private park for lot owners and their guests. Each lot holds an equal undivided interest that cannot be partitioned. No cars, trucks or motorcycles are allowed on it, while bicycles, horses and approved golf carts are; no trees or plants may be cut and no permanent fixtures placed; and upkeep is shared equally by the lots. A listing can describe the greenbelt as a shared private park under the recorded declaration, which is accurate and easy for a buyer's attorney to confirm.
Green space also includes the ground along the ditches and swales and "the four triangles, such as at the end of Ligustrum," and mowing starts at about nine inches of growth, per the association's April 2026 newsletter. The City owns the cul-de-sacs, and residents may plant and maintain them under the City's Cul-De-Sac Maintenance Policy. If you have planted the cul-de-sac in front of your home, a buyer may ask who keeps it up, and the policy is the answer.
No parcel in the plat carries a golf, park, club or marina use code, and the county's park, trail, facility and landmark layers show nothing inside it. There is no clubhouse, community pool, tennis or pickleball court, gate or guardhouse, and no canal or boat access; the county's waterways layer shows one pond-sized feature of 0.09 acre. The two small condominiums each have their own pool for their own owners. We write "no community pool or clubhouse" in the listing rather than leave a buyer to discover it, because the absence is also why there are no club dues.
Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club, a semi-private 18-hole par 62 course of 4,400 yards from the championship tees, is about 2.0 road miles and 6 minutes from the center of the plat, and it reopened on October 21, 2026 after a renovation with new TifEagle greens; the club is a separate organization from the Seminole Lakes association. Twin Isles Country Club in Burnt Store Isles, a par 72 course of 6,722 yards with public tee times and public dining, is about 2.9 road miles and 7 minutes away. St. Andrews South Golf Club, member-owned with membership limited to 250 golf members, is about 6.3 miles away, and Burnt Store Marina Country Club in Lee County has 27 holes and a 2026 to 2027 single full golf rate of $4,000 a year plus 6.5 percent tax.
Allapatchee Shores Park on Hickory Ct, where the county lists canoeing, kayaking and paddling, fishing and picnic tables, is about 1.9 road miles and 5 minutes away, and Alligator Creek Park's Taylor Road access is about 1.7 miles and 5 minutes away. The nearest county boat ramp is at Darst Park, about 7.1 road miles and 15 minutes away; Laishley Park Municipal Marina is about 6.3 miles and 14 minutes away, and Ponce de Leon Park about 8.2 miles away. Gulf access, bridge clearances and lock routes from those launches are not established on the public record we read, so a listing should never promise a boater a route.
The association's calendar is the closest thing to a clubhouse here. The Car Show and Family Fun Festival ran on Saturday, March 21, 2026 on the greenspace between Plum Tree and Blue Sage on both sides of Royal Poinciana; the 17th annual Holiday Decorations Contest ran in December 2025; the Annual Community Yard Sale ran on Saturday, February 7, 2026; Food Truck Fridays on the 400 block of Royal Poinciana launched on November 21, 2025; and a Halloween Trunk-or-Treat is set for October 31, 2026, from 4 to 6 pm. A Little Free Library sponsored by the association stands on the Royal Poinciana greenbelt between South Plum Tree and South Blue Sage. The association's newsletter, The Meadows Connection, stopped after its September 2026 issue when the publisher cited insufficient advertising revenue, so current news runs through the association's website and calendar.
A Burnt Store Meadows seller owes the homeowners' association disclosure summary before the buyer signs, the statutory flood disclosure at or before contract, disclosure of known facts that materially affect value and are not readily observable, and the property tax disclosure in the contract. A condominium unit inside the plat adds a separate regime. Your closing agent confirms which duties apply.
Data updated: October 2026 (Florida Statutes 720.401, 689.302, 689.261, 193.155 and 553.79; Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985); association documents read October 21, 2026)
This is general information, not legal advice. Your closing agent or a real estate attorney confirms which duties apply to your parcel. We make sure the right documents are in the file before a buyer signs, because several of these duties give the buyer a cancellation or renegotiation right if they are missed.
Because membership in the Burnt Store Meadows POA is mandatory for every parcel owner, a single-family home or lot here is a parcel in a homeowners' association, and section 720.401 applies. The statute sets four facts. The disclosure summary is due before the contract is executed, not at closing. On a resale, the owner supplies it, not the developer. The contract must carry the statute's voidability clause in conspicuous type. If the summary is not provided, the buyer may cancel within 3 days after receiving it or before closing, whichever comes first, and that right cannot be waived. We attach the summary to every Burnt Store Meadows offer package before the buyer signs.
The two small condominiums inside the plat, Meadows of Punta Gorda and Plum Creek, sit under their own condominium associations, which are governed by chapter 718, while their unit owners are also members of the Burnt Store Meadows POA under Article 4.1 of its 2020 articles. Section 720.401 says it does not apply to an association regulated under chapter 718, and a condominium sale carries its own disclosure rules. If you are selling a condominium unit here, both regimes may touch your sale, and your closing agent or attorney should tell you which documents the buyer gets and when. We will not tell a condominium seller that the 720.401 summary alone covers the sale.
Section 689.302 requires a seller of residential property to give the buyer a flood disclosure at or before the contract is executed. It asks whether the seller knows of flooding that damaged the property, whether the seller filed a flood insurance claim and whether the seller received federal assistance for flood damage. The duty does not depend on the FEMA zone, so it applies on a Zone X street as much as on a Zone AE street at the west end. If you do not know whether the home ever took water, say that rather than guessing.
The Florida Supreme Court held in Johnson v. Davis (1985) that a seller who knows of facts materially affecting the value of a home that are not readily observable and not known to the buyer must disclose them. An "as is" clause does not remove that duty for a residential seller. A known roof leak, a prior water intrusion, a failed screen cage or an addition built without a permit belongs in the written disclosure.
Section 689.261 requires a property tax disclosure summary that warns the buyer not to rely on the seller's current taxes. Under section 193.155, a homestead is reassessed at just value as of January 1 after a change of ownership, so a buyer's first bill can differ sharply from yours, and your homestead benefit may be ported to a new Florida homestead under the same section if you qualify. The Florida Department of Revenue explains the homestead exemption and portability on its own page.
Section 553.79 limits what a local building agency can do to a new owner because a previous owner left a permit open, but it does not stop a lender, a title underwriter or a buyer from asking for the permit to be closed. Because every home here is permitted by the City of Punta Gorda, we check the City's permit record before listing, especially for roofs, screen cages, pools, fences and additions.
Florida's milestone inspection rule (section 553.899) and the structural integrity reserve study rule (section 718.112) reach condominium buildings of three habitable stories or more. Both condominiums here read as two-story buildings from their unit numbering, so neither rule would apply, but no filing or document confirming their height was read, so their height is unknown on the record. A condominium seller should ask the condominium association for its own statement, and single-family homes are outside both rules.
The IRS says an owner who meets its conditions may exclude up to $250,000 of gain on the sale of a main home, or $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly, under the rules in Publication 523. Whether you qualify is a question for your tax adviser, and we raise it before you list so that the net sheet you see is the net sheet you keep.
A Burnt Store Meadows buyer will ask for the flood zone, the evacuation zone, the roof year and the insurance quote. FEMA reads Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 9 feet at the west end and Zone X across most of the plat; 148 of 882 mapped residential lots are in Zone AE, and the evacuation zone differs from the flood zone.
Data updated: October 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer queried October 21, 2026; county evacuation layer read October 21, 2026; Citizens Property Insurance data through August 31, 2026)
At eight sample points read on October 21, 2026, FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer put Royal Poinciana at the west end and Trumpet Tree in Zone AE, a coastal floodplain with a base flood elevation of 9 feet NAVD88, and put N Plum Tree (two points), Satsuma Dr, the center of Royal Poinciana, Gold Tree and S Blue Sage in Zone X, minimal flood hazard. The panels are 12015C0407G and 12015C0244G, effective December 15, 2022, with no Letter of Map Revision at any point. A buyer can check any address on FEMA's Map Service Center.
Our overlay of the 882 mapped residential parcels against FEMA's layer placed 148 in Zone AE, 127 in shaded Zone X (the 0.2 percent annual chance area) and 607 in unshaded Zone X, and FEMA's layer and the county's copy agree on all 882. North Seagrape Rd, South Seagrape Rd, S Ficus Tree, N Ficus Tree, S Moss Rose, N Moss Rose and S Tulip Tree are entirely Zone AE. Royal Poinciana, Trumpet Tree, Carambola, Vinca Rosea and N Tulip Tree straddle Zone AE and shaded Zone X; Philodendron and Carissa are entirely shaded Zone X, and W Cashew is almost all shaded Zone X. Every other street is unshaded Zone X. We hand a buyer the reading for your lot, never a sentence about the whole neighborhood.
In Zone AE, a federally backed lender requires flood insurance, and the premium follows the building's elevation against the base flood elevation of 9 feet. The City's elevation certificate layer flags a certificate on 38 of 154 Zone AE address points in the plat, recording a yes or no rather than the elevation. If your home has one, it is the most valuable page in your listing file. Six Letters of Map Amendment sit in the plat's envelope; inside Section 18, two on S Ficus Tree and Vinca Rosea kept the structure in the special flood hazard area and one on N Blue Sage removed the property, which shows that an amendment is worth checking for and is not automatic.
The City of Punta Gorda takes part in the National Flood Insurance Program's Community Rating System at Class 5, which gives a 25 percent premium discount inside the special flood hazard area and 10 percent outside it; the class took effect October 1, 2016, and the City's flood page said the 25 percent discount remained as of October 19, 2025. In Zone AE, a substantial improvement or repair at 50 percent or more of the building's market value brings the whole building into compliance with a finished floor at base flood elevation plus 1 foot, and flood panels need a City permit. A buyer planning a large remodel on the west end will ask, and the City's rule is the answer.
The county's evacuation layer puts 212 of the 882 parcels in Zone B (blocks 361 to 367 and 383 to 388), 650 in Zone C and 20 in Zone D, and 65 Zone X parcels sit in evacuation Zone B (our analysis). For Hurricane Ian the county ordered Zone A on September 26, 2022 and Zones A and B on September 27; for Helene it ordered by area on September 24, 2024; for Milton it ordered A and B on October 7, 2024 and added C on October 8. A buyer who reads "Zone B" or "Zone C" should be told it is a county evacuation category, a different system from FEMA's flood map.
The National Hurricane Center reports that Hurricane Charley's eye passed over Punta Gorda on August 13, 2004, with the Punta Gorda station measuring 78 knots sustained and a 97 knot gust before its wind sensor failed. Hurricane Ian made mainland landfall near Punta Gorda on September 28, 2022, and the Punta Gorda station read 76 knots sustained with a 117 knot gust before it stopped reporting. Helene and Milton in 2024 were harbor and river surge events, with Milton's surge put at 5 to 8 feet above ground in northern Charlotte Harbor. No public record we read shows surge or a damage count inside Burnt Store Meadows for any of these storms, and we say that plainly because a buyer's agent will ask.
NOAA's storm surge risk maps, which model a worst case for each hurricane category and are not a forecast, show the west-end Royal Poinciana point as the only sample point wet in a Category 1 scenario, under 3 feet above ground. Both west-end points are wet from Category 2. The Zone X points stay dry through Category 2 and most stay dry through Category 3, and every point is wet in Category 5. That is the honest version of the "has it flooded" question, and we give it to buyers in those words.
The first Florida Building Code took effect on March 1, 2002. On the roll, 364 of the 751 homes carry a year built before 2002, 48.5 percent, while 387 are dated 2002 or later, including 47 dated 2002 exactly, so the county year alone cannot place those homes on one side of the line. 146 homes are dated 2017 or later and 33 are dated 2023 or later, after Ian. The state's report on Charley found that homes built to the new code fared far better than older ones, and that in Punta Gorda Isles older tile roofs had 40 percent or more damage while newer homes had 10 percent or less, though it does not break out Section 18. A seller should know which era the house belongs to and what has been replaced since.
Citizens Property Insurance asks for a four-point inspection on homes more than 20 years old, and its flood rule now reaches policies outside the special flood hazard area in stages through January 1, 2027. A home built before 2006 is past 20 years in 2026 (our arithmetic), so most resales here will face that inspection. The roll shows the year built, not the roof year, so the roof permit and a recent four-point report are the documents that matter.
A current wind mitigation report gives an insurance agent something to quote from. The state's uniform mitigation verification form, OIR-B1-1802, was revised effective April 1, 2026 and is valid for up to five years without a material change. My Safe Florida Home offers inspections and grants subject to legislative funding. A buyer who sees a current report in the file has one fewer step after contract.
Gather the FEMA reading for your lot, any elevation certificate, the wind mitigation report, the roof permit and the date of the last roof, the air conditioner's age, shutter or impact window records and any ARB approvals, and any insurance claim history you are willing to disclose. A buyer asks for these in the first week, and a file that already has them removes a reason to renegotiate.
A Burnt Store Meadows buyer will ask which schools serve the address, how far the nearest emergency room is and how long the drives are. At eight sample points the district's locator returned East Elementary and Sallie Jones Elementary, Punta Gorda Middle and Charlotte High, and the nearest open emergency rooms are about 21 minutes away in Port Charlotte.
Data updated: October 2026 (school district boundary locator run October 21, 2026; FLDOE 2025-26 grades; free-flow drive times measured October 21, 2026 with no traffic)
The Charlotte County Public Schools boundary locator returned the same schools at all eight sample points: East Elementary and Sallie Jones Elementary as two elementary rows, Punta Gorda Middle and Charlotte High. The tool does not mark either elementary as the zoned school, so a buyer should confirm assignment with the district at enrollment. The 2025-26 state grades were A for Sallie Jones Elementary (69 percent of points), B for East Elementary (56), A for Punta Gorda Middle (64) and B for Charlotte High (63), and the district earned its first A in 15 years. A grade is a state measure of a school, not a promise about a student.
East and Sallie Jones run the district's year-round calendar, with the first student day on July 16, 2026, a fall intersession from October 19 to 30, 2026 and the last day on May 28, 2027, while Punta Gorda Middle and Charlotte High started on August 10, 2026. The district's open enrollment chart lists East at 668 students against a capacity of 792, closed to transfers in kindergarten and first grade, and Sallie Jones at 600 against 676, closed in kindergarten and third grade, with the next update on November 2, 2026. The district runs no bus within two miles of the assigned school; Sallie Jones and Charlotte High are each about 5.4 road miles from the center of the plat, Punta Gorda Middle about 5.8 and East Elementary about 7.2.
No hospital or emergency room is open inside the City of Punta Gorda. The nearest open emergency rooms are AdventHealth Port Charlotte, about 10.9 miles and 21 minutes away, and HCA Florida Fawcett, about 11.0 miles and 21 minutes, with HCA Florida Tamiami Trail Emergency and Sarasota Memorial's North Port ER each about 17.9 miles away. There is no designated trauma center in Charlotte County; the nearest Level II center is Gulf Coast Medical Center in Lee County, about 26.4 miles and 41 minutes away. AdventHealth's planned emergency department off Jones Loop Road would sit about 2.5 miles from the plat, but it is not open. City of Punta Gorda Fire Station 2 on Acline Rd is about 2.0 road miles and 5 minutes away; that is a drive time, not a response time.
At free-flow speeds measured October 21, 2026, the I-75 northbound entrance at Jones Loop Road (Exit 161) is about 3.0 miles and 8 minutes away and the southbound access toward Tuckers Grade (Exit 158) about 3.5 miles and 7 minutes. Punta Gorda Airport is about 4.7 miles and 13 minutes away, City Hall downtown about 6.1 miles and 12 minutes, downtown Fort Myers about 19.2 miles and 28 minutes, Cape Coral City Hall about 32 minutes and Southwest Florida International about 34.8 miles and 43 minutes. Real times vary with traffic; these are our measurements, not promises.
Publix at Burnt Store Marketplace on Tamiami Trl, open 7 am to 10 pm daily with a pharmacy, and the Home Depot at the same address are about 2.5 road miles and 5 minutes away; the Walmart Supercenter on Taylor Rd is about 2.1 miles and 6 minutes away. Two restaurants sit on US 41 beside the plat's frontage. Alligator Creek Preserve and the Charlotte Harbor Environmental Center are about 1.7 miles away, Charlotte Harbor Preserve State Park's office about 2.3 miles, and South County Regional Park, with a heated 25-yard pool, pickleball and tennis courts and disc golf, about 5.7 miles. Punta Gorda Airport serves Allegiant and seasonal Sun Country flights, with long-term parking at a $14.00 daily maximum. For a destination-by-destination table, the Burnt Store Meadows community guide has the full list.
We market a Burnt Store Meadows home by leading with what a buyer cannot see in a portal photo: the greenbelt behind the lot, the flood reading for the address, the year and permit of the roof, and the City address with no CDD. Then we place the home against the recorded resales of its age and size so the price reads as earned.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser sales through September 9, 2026; association documents read October 21, 2026)
Most listing descriptions open with bedrooms and finishes. Here the lot carries more weight: a greenbelt edge on almost every parcel, a flood reading that changes across the plat, GS-3.5 or GM-15 zoning, and a street that may be fully built or still dotted with vacant lots. Our first paragraph names the street, the flood zone, the greenbelt and the year of the roof, and only then the rooms.
Buyers decide on the first photographs, so the listing opens with the front of the home and the street, then the view across the lanai to the greenbelt, then the kitchen and the main living space. Aerial views show how the greenbelt runs behind the row of lots, which a ground photo cannot. We do not photograph a neighbor's vacant lot as if it were yours, and we label the greenbelt as association land.
Before the first showing we attach the survey, the roof permit, the wind mitigation report, the FEMA reading, any elevation certificate, the declaration that governs your lot, the 2020 bylaws and the estoppel certificate once it arrives. The buyer's agent then opens a file instead of asking for one, which shortens the week after the contract and protects the price.
The listing enters the MLS under the right subdivision name, which matters here because the MLS subdivision field undercounts this plat, and it syndicates from there to the large portals. It also runs on our own sites with the Burnt Store Meadows community guide linked, so a buyer who wants the neighborhood record finds it in one click.
The single-family declaration limits a for-sale sign to 6 by 8 inches, so we do not rely on yard signs and we keep any open-house signage within the rules. We schedule the first weekend on purpose, collect price and condition feedback after each showing, and review it with you at day 14 rather than waiting a month.
We do not promise a sale price, a number of days or a number of showings. We promise the file, the pricing evidence and the follow-up call. The MLS fields that would let us quote days on market and sale-to-list are not available to us as we write, and the market section says so.
Negotiation here runs on price, inspection credits, insurance and the closing date. A four-point inspection on an older home and a flood quote on a west-end home often decide the second round. Buyer's agent compensation is a negotiated term since the National Association of Realtors settlement practice changes of August 17, 2024.
An offer of $370,000 with an $8,000 roof credit nets less than an offer of $364,000 with none. We build a net sheet for each offer so you compare the cash you leave with, not the number on the first page.
The listing commission is negotiable, and so is any compensation you choose to offer a buyer's agent. A buyer who works with an agent signs a written agreement with that agent before touring. We explain the options at the listing appointment and write the one you choose into the listing agreement, never as a surprise at the table.
A buyer's insurer will usually want a four-point inspection on a home more than 20 years old, and it focuses on the roof, the electrical panel, the plumbing and the air conditioner. A seller who already has a recent four-point and a roof permit can answer the request before it becomes a renegotiation. If a credit is needed, we price it against what the repair actually costs, not against the buyer's first number.
For a home in Zone AE, the buyer's lender will require flood insurance, and the quote can arrive late in the inspection period. An elevation certificate in the file lets the buyer price that policy before writing the offer, which takes a common late-stage objection off the table.
When an appraisal comes in under the contract price, the contract decides who bridges it. In a plat where a 2016 home and a 1993 home can sit on the same street, we give the appraiser the recorded resales of the same era and size, not the neighborhood median, and we include the five builder-direct sales only as context.
If you are moving away, a signing by power of attorney or remote notary is possible when the title company and the lender agree, and we raise it at listing so the closing date is not the last thing decided.
Selling a Burnt Store Meadows home at the $370,000 median costs $16,364.00 without a buyer's agent offer, or $25,614.00 with a 2.5 percent offer, in the worked net sheet below; your contract sets your real costs. In Charlotte County the seller customarily pays the owner's title policy and documentary stamp tax of $0.70 per $100, and the contract controls.
Data updated: October 2026 (Florida documentary stamp rate; promulgated title premium schedule; DBPR estoppel caps; Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026)
| Price | Deed stamps at $0.70 per $100 | Promulgated owner's title premium | 1 percent of price |
|---|---|---|---|
| $300,000 (illustrative) | $2,100.00 | $1,575 | $3,000 |
| $363,000 (12-month resale median) | $2,541.00 | $1,890 | $3,630 |
| $370,000 (12-month median) | $2,590.00 | $1,925 | $3,700 |
| $680,000 (highest 12-month sale) | $4,760.00 | $3,475 | $6,800 |
Source: our arithmetic from the stamp rate in section 201.02 and the promulgated owner's premium in Florida Administrative Code Rule 69O-186.003 ($5.75 per $1,000 to $100,000, then $5.00 per $1,000 to $1,000,000). A title agent's quote controls.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Sale price | $370,000.00 |
| Listing fee at 2.75 percent (illustration) | $10,175.00 |
| Offer to the buyer's agent at 2.5 percent (illustration) | $9,250.00 |
| Documentary stamps on the deed | $2,590.00 |
| Owner's title premium | $1,925.00 |
| Settlement and search charges (assumed) | $1,200.00 |
| Municipal lien search (assumed) | $175.00 |
| Association estoppel certificate (standard) | $299.00 |
| Total costs | $25,614.00 |
| Costs as a share of price | 6.92 percent |
| Net before mortgage payoff and prorations | $344,386.00 |
Without the buyer's agent offer, costs are $16,364.00 (4.42 percent) and the net is $353,636.00 (our arithmetic). The fee percentages, settlement charges and lien search are illustrations for the arithmetic; your listing agreement and your title agent set the real ones.
The association's fee for the certificate is capped at $299, with $119 more for delivery within 3 business days and up to $179 more on a delinquent account, $597 at the most. Ordering it at listing avoids the rush fee. Whether any transfer or capital fee is due is unknown until the certificate states it, because no such clause appears in the bylaws we read.
Property tax and the association assessment are prorated to the closing date. As an illustration of the method only, 181 days of a $5,044.44 tax bill is $2,501.49 (our arithmetic). Because the association levies its assessment once a year in advance for an October 1 fiscal year, the assessment proration usually runs the other way, with the buyer crediting you for the months you prepaid; the estoppel certificate and the title company's statement decide the final figures.
Your mortgage payoff, any repair credit, a home warranty, moving costs and your tax position on the gain are separate. The capital gains note in the disclosures section points you to IRS Publication 523 and to your own tax adviser.
Burnt Store Meadows and Seminole Lakes share a greenbelt edge, the City of Punta Gorda and ZIP 33955, so buyers often tour both. Seminole Lakes is a gated golf community of 450 homes with resident amenities; Burnt Store Meadows is an ungated platted neighborhood of 751 homes with association greenbelts and no clubhouse. Each suits a different buyer.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; association pages read October 21, 2026)
| Item | Burnt Store Meadows | Seminole Lakes |
|---|---|---|
| Homes | 751 homes and 144 vacant lots on 895 residential parcels | 450 homes, per its association |
| Recorded home sales, 12 months | 42 at a $370,000 median | 25 at a $305,000 median |
| Per sq ft of county heated area | $189.87 | $183.96 |
| Builder-direct sales, 12 months | 5 | none, all resales |
| Years built | 1982 to 2025, median 2002 | 1992 to 2003 |
| Gate | None | Gated, per its association |
| Shared amenities | 87.58 acres of association greenbelts | Bocce courts, a heated pool, a workout room, a library and a tiki hut, per its association; 8 lakes |
| Golf | None inside; Seminole Lakes and Twin Isles a few minutes away | Seminole Lakes Golf and Country Club, a separate organization from the association |
| City and ZIP | City of Punta Gorda, 33955 | City of Punta Gorda, 33955 |
Sources: Charlotte County Property Appraiser public roll and sales files, our analysis; the Seminole Lakes association home page; our Burnt Store Meadows research.
Do not argue that one is better. Tell the buyer what each offers and what each costs. A buyer who wants a gate, a pool and a short walk to a golf course will lean toward Seminole Lakes. A buyer who wants a larger range of home ages and sizes, newer construction, and green space behind the yard without club amenities to carry will lean toward Burnt Store Meadows. Our job is to describe your home so the buyer who fits it finds it. For the Seminole Lakes side of the comparison, see our Seminole Lakes seller guide.
The flood reading for the lot, the evacuation zone, the City tax district, the absence of a CDD, the declaration terms and the greenbelt ownership are all facts with a date and a source. What a seller cannot say is that either neighborhood will rise or fall, or that one is the better place to live.
Selling a condominium unit or a vacant lot in Burnt Store Meadows is a different sale from selling a house. The two small condominiums record only a handful of sales, so the sales are listed rather than averaged, and a lot is priced against recorded lot sales (vacant land), its zoning and its flood reading, for a builder or an owner who plans to build.
Data updated: October 2026 (Charlotte County recorded sales through September 9, 2026; DBPR condominium records and Sunbiz read October 21, 2026)
Meadows of Punta Gorda Condominium Association, Inc. is an active Florida corporation filed December 5, 1988, and the state's condominium register lists 12 units recorded June 20, 1989, in three buildings on Royal Poinciana with 1,164 square foot units on the roll and one pool on a 0.91 acre common parcel. It recorded no sale in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, one in 24 months ($156,900 on March 6, 2025) and three in 60 months, from $156,900 to $230,000. With so few sales, a unit here is priced from those sales, the unit's condition and the condominium association's own budget and reserves, which are not published.
Plum Creek Condominium Association, Inc. is an active Florida corporation filed August 17, 2005. The state register lists 38 units declared, recorded September 1, 2005, while the county roll carries 12 units in Building C, built in 2006, at 1,079 or 1,457 square feet, with a pool, a restroom building and carports on the common parcel. It recorded one sale in the 12 months, $125,000 on July 15, 2026 for a 1,079 square foot unit, and four in 60 months, from $125,000 to $245,000. Whether more buildings will be built is not on the public record we read, and a buyer will ask.
Condominium dues for both buildings are not published, and whether the Burnt Store Meadows POA bills each unit or the condominium association is not public either, so both estoppel certificates may be needed. Both buildings read as two-story from their unit numbering, but no document confirming their height was read, so whether the milestone inspection and reserve study rules could apply is not something we state as settled. The disclosures section sets out the condominium fork, and your closing agent decides which documents the buyer receives.
Recorded lot sales (vacant land) here ran 11 in the 12 months at a $55,000 median, from $30,000 to $68,000, and 61 over 60 months at $55,900. A lot buyer will ask about the zoning (GS-3.5 lots have a 9,600 square foot minimum and setbacks of 25 feet front, 7.5 feet side and 15 feet rear; GM-15 allows up to 15 units per acre with development plan approval), the flood zone, the City's impact fees on new construction and the ARB's building rules. The association assessment applies to vacant lots, and the violation protocol gives a lot owner 30 days to cure a violation, so a lot that is mowed and clear lists better.
Of the 134 GM-15 parcels, 129 sit on lots covered by the multi-family declaration, 75 of them on Royal Poinciana and the rest on N Plum Tree and S Plum Tree, and 49 are vacant on the roll. The multi-family declaration asks for at least 1,200 square feet per building, each unit at least 800 square feet unless authorized, 25 foot front and rear setbacks, a lot of at least 8,000 square feet and 1.5 paved parking spaces per unit. GM-15 lots recorded 13 vacant-land sales over 60 months at a $94,900 median. No City agenda, development plan or rezoning was found for the vacant GM-15 lots, and a seller should not imply that one exists.
A builder buys a lot to sell a home, so a builder's offer is anchored to recorded lot sales and to what a finished home sells for on that street. An individual building a home may pay more for a specific lot, such as one on a fully built street or with a deep greenbelt edge, but may take longer to close. We show you both buyer pools and the recorded lot sales before you choose.
Your Burnt Store Meadows home is worth what a buyer pays for a home of its age, size, street and flood zone with its roof and condition, and the county record puts the latest 12-month median at $370,000 with resales at $363,000. A free valuation turns those medians into a number for your address, with every sale we used listed.
The fastest route to a number is our Burnt Store Meadows home valuation. It uses the same county sales as this page and adds a walk through the home. If you would rather talk first, Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Year built, county heated area, street, lot zoning, flood zone and condition move a price far more than the neighborhood median does. The pricing section above shows the cohorts: homes built before 2002 at a $322,500 median, homes built from 2002 to 2016 at $435,000, and homes of 2,200 square feet or more at $477,000, each over the window named beside it.
It does not replace a lender's appraisal. It gives you a listing range with the recorded sales behind it, so you decide with evidence.
The right route depends on what you value most: price, speed, certainty or cost. Listing with an agent reaches the widest buyer pool, a cash sale trades price for speed and certainty, and selling by owner saves the listing fee but moves the pricing, marketing, disclosures and negotiation to you.
| Question | List with an agent | Sell for cash | Sell by owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who sets the price | You, from the recorded resales | The cash buyer's offer | You |
| Buyer pool | MLS, portals and our own sites | One buyer at a time | Whoever finds you |
| Disclosures (720.401 summary, flood disclosure, known defects) | Prepared with you | Still owed by you | Still owed by you |
| Estoppel and documents file | Ordered at listing | Usually ordered by the buyer's closing agent | Your job |
| Inspection and insurance requests | Negotiated for you | Often waived or priced into the offer | Your job |
| Listing fee | Per your agreement | None | None |
| Buyer's agent compensation | Negotiable | Usually none | Usually expected if the buyer has an agent |
Sources: Florida Statutes 720.401 and 689.302; the National Association of Realtors settlement practice changes of August 17, 2024.
A listing puts the home in front of the MLS buyer pool with a net sheet, a documents file and a negotiator. It carries the full cost lines in the net sheet above and gives you the widest pool of buyers who can pay the price the record supports.
A cash buyer can close quickly and skip the lender's appraisal and underwriting, usually at a discount to what a financed buyer would pay. Ask for the offer in writing, compare its net with a listed net sheet and check who the buyer is. We can show you both numbers side by side.
You may sell without an agent, and Florida law still requires the disclosures described above. A seller without an agent owns the pricing, the showings, the contract and the closing coordination, and in this plat the pricing is the hard part, because an MLS-only search finds only a fraction of the recorded sales. Some owners find the saving worth it; many find the work and the risk cost more than the fee.
Write down the date you need the money, the least you will accept and how much work you want to do. If the least you will accept sits above the recorded resales for your age and size, plan for time on the market. If the date matters more than the price, get a cash offer and a listed net sheet and compare them. Either way, Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 and we will put the numbers on one page.
McGreevy and Comisar are a top-reviewed Southwest Florida listing team, recognized with the Gulfshore Life Five Star award for customer satisfaction for 21 straight years. The three reviews below come from sellers and are quoted exactly as the clients wrote them on Google. We do not edit, combine or summarize client words.
★★★★★ "Very professional, knowledgeable and responsive. We have had experience with them in both selling and buying a home. We recommend them highly." Verified Google review
★★★★★ "Working with Jesse was easy, I was kept up to date on all feedback from showings and the many open houses. Highly recommend!" Verified Google review
★★★★★ "Not living in the area, Jesse made life easy for me when we decided to sell our condo. His attention to detail, patience, understanding, and tenacity in dealing with all the moving parts was truly impressive." Verified Google review
When you list with a top-reviewed team of Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, the partners who take your first call are the partners at your closing. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Burnt Store Meadows owners ask about price, the flood line, the association, the greenbelts, new construction next door, insurance, disclosures and what a sale costs. Each answer below rests on the Charlotte County record or a posted document, and where a figure is not published we say so and name the document that holds it.
Data updated: October 2026 (county records through September 9, 2026; association, City and county documents read October 21, 2026; FEMA queried October 21, 2026)
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. We price from the county's recorded resales for homes of your age and size, put the flood reading and documents in front of buyers early, and both partners work the listing. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, Charlotte County recorded 42 home sales here at a $370,000 median, ranging from $195,000 to $680,000. The 37 resales had a $363,000 median and the 5 builder-direct new homes a $630,000 median. Your own number depends on age, size, street, flood zone and condition, which our free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation works through.
The county recorded 42 home sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, on 751 homes, a turnover of 5.6 percent. By recording date there were 3 from September 10 to 30, 2025, 6 from October to December, 10 from January to March 2026, 14 from April to June and 9 from July 1 to September 9.
The calendar-year median was $480,000 in 2023, $443,500 in 2024, $390,000 in 2025 and $363,000 for 2026 through September 9. The 12-month median of $370,000 is $110,000 below the 2023 figure. These are medians of different groups of homes, not a repeat-sale index, so they describe what sold rather than what any one home lost.
Days on market comes from the MLS listing record, and the county deed record does not carry it. Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). At your listing appointment we pull the figure for homes of your age and size and show you the active competition, so your timeline rests on what is on the market now.
The ratio of closed price to last list price is an MLS field, and the county records only the closed price. Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). We compare your price with the active and recently closed comparables of your era and size, which is the evidence that matters when you set a list price.
Months of supply divides active listings by the monthly pace of closings, and both are MLS fields. Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-10-07). The county record does show 42 home sales in 12 months, an average of three to four a month, and we set that pace beside the current listings when we price your home.
Most online searches run on the MLS subdivision field, and a dated MLS pull counted 8 Burnt Store Meadows closings against 42 county recorded home sales in a nearly matching year, because the MLS subdivision field undercounts this plat. We lead with the county record so your comparables are the real ones.
Yes. In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, single-family homes built before 2002 recorded 16 resales at a $322,500 median and homes built from 2002 to 2016 recorded 16 at $435,000. Size and street differ between the groups too, so the gap is not a code premium, but an appraiser will compare your home with homes of its own era.
In the 12 months, 7 sales in Zone AE had a $350,000 median and 35 in the Zone X rest had $380,000, but those are different homes in a small sample, and over 36 months the Zone AE homes recorded 18 sales at $441,500. We price a west-end home from the nearest Zone AE resales and put the elevation certificate and an insurance quote in the file.
Homes on Royal Poinciana itself recorded 14 sales over 60 months at a $627,500 median, and homes on multi-family zoned GM-15 lots recorded 10 sales over 24 months at $484,000. Those lots are larger and the homes newer, and the windows differ from the 12-month figures, so we treat them as context for a specific home rather than a premium.
Nearly every lot touches the 87.58 acre greenbelt: 829 of 882 mapped residential parcels share 10 percent or more of their boundary with it, and those lots recorded 39 of the 42 sales in 12 months at a $370,000 median. The greenbelt is a feature of the whole plat rather than a premium for one lot, and we describe it that way.
The annual assessment is not published in any public document; the association's home page says only "Low Annual Association fee" and the budget goes to members. It is levied once a year per original platted parcel, due within 60 days after the October 1 fiscal year begins. The estoppel certificate for your parcel states the amount and any balance.
No transfer fee, resale fee or capital contribution clause appears in the 2020 bylaws we read. Whether any fee is due on your sale is therefore unknown until the estoppel certificate states it, and the certificate must state it. We order the certificate at listing so the answer is in the file early.
Florida DBPR's published caps are $299 for the certificate, $119 more for delivery within 3 business days and up to $179 more if the account is delinquent, $597 at the most. The association must deliver it within 10 business days. In Charlotte County the seller customarily orders and pays for it, and the contract controls.
The bylaws we read contain no clause requiring the association to approve a buyer. Your closing still needs a clean estoppel certificate, and any open violation or unpaid balance shows on it, so clear those before you list.
It can delay one. The bylaws allow fines of up to $100 per violation per day, up to $2,500 in the aggregate, and the association's lien for unpaid assessments continues with the new and previous owner jointly liable. The estoppel reports what is owed, so we clear open items before the first showing.
For a home or lot in this mandatory association, section 720.401 requires the disclosure summary before the buyer signs, supplied by you on a resale, with the voidability clause in the contract. Section 689.302 adds a flood disclosure at or before contract, and Johnson v. Davis requires disclosure of known material defects. This is information, not legal advice.
Not entirely. Your unit sits under a chapter 718 condominium association, and section 720.401 does not apply to an association regulated under chapter 718, even though condominium owners are also Burnt Store Meadows POA members. Ask your closing agent which documents your buyer receives, and expect two estoppel requests.
In Zone AE, a federally backed lender requires flood insurance; in Zone X it does not, though a policy can still be bought. Of 882 mapped residential lots, 148 are in Zone AE at the west end, 127 in shaded Zone X and 607 in unshaded Zone X. Citizens also phases in flood coverage with its wind policies outside the special flood hazard area through January 1, 2027.
Yes. The City of Punta Gorda is a Community Rating System Class 5 community, which gives a 25 percent flood premium discount inside the special flood hazard area and 10 percent outside it. The City's flood page said the 25 percent discount remained as of October 19, 2025. A buyer's agent will quote the policy with the discount applied.
Citizens asks for a four-point inspection on homes more than 20 years old, and 364 of the 751 homes here carry a county year built before 2002. A recent four-point report and the roof permit in the listing file answer the question before the buyer's insurer raises it.
Yes. The state's form OIR-B1-1802 was revised effective April 1, 2026 and is valid for up to five years without a material change. A current report lets the buyer's agent quote insurance during the showing week instead of after the contract, which protects your price.
Builders closed 5 new homes here in the 12 months at a $630,000 median, from $335,000 to $678,500, and 144 lots remain vacant. A buyer will compare your home with them, so we price against resales of your era and size and show the buyer what a finished lot, mature landscaping and a known history are worth to them.
Cassia Bay, about half a mile away, has county filings for its first 100 units, and Pulte markets homes there from $295,990 to $429,990. The Burnt Store Road East/West Connector is in the county's adopted capital program funded from the one-cent sales tax extension that voters approved on November 3, 2026 (unofficial results). Neither changes a recorded sale; both are facts a buyer will weigh, and we put them in writing.
The single-family declaration allows renting for residential use and states no minimum term. Whether short-term rentals are allowed under any other rule or City ordinance is not established on the record we read. A tenant in place also affects showings and the buyer pool, so we plan the timing with you.
The single-family declaration allows one for-sale or for-rent sign no larger than 6 by 8 inches. That is much smaller than a standard yard sign, so our marketing relies on the MLS, the portals and our own sites rather than a sign.
A buyer's home is reassessed at just value as of the next January 1 after the sale, and the 2026 rate in tax district 150 is 16.8148 mills. On $300,000 of taxable value that is $5,044.44 before exemptions (our arithmetic). The tax disclosure in the contract warns the buyer not to rely on your current bill.
Under section 193.155 you may be able to port part of your Save Our Homes benefit to a new Florida homestead if you qualify and apply on time. The Florida Department of Revenue explains portability on its exemptions page, and your county property appraiser handles the application.
The IRS lets an owner who meets its tests exclude up to $250,000 of gain on a main home, or $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly, under IRS Publication 523. Whether you qualify depends on your ownership and use, and your tax adviser should confirm it before you set your net figure.
At the $370,000 median, our worked net sheet shows $16,364.00 in costs without a buyer's agent offer and $25,614.00 with a 2.5 percent offer, including $2,590.00 in deed stamps, a $1,925 owner's title premium and the $299 estoppel. Your listing agreement and your title agent set the real figures.
Yes. We coordinate the documents file, the estoppel, showings and inspections for owners who are away, and a signing by power of attorney or remote notary is possible when the title company and the lender agree. We raise it at listing so the closing plan is set early.
Recorded lot sales (vacant land) ran 11 in the 12 months at a $55,000 median, and multi-family zoned GM-15 lots recorded 13 sales over 60 months at $94,900. A lot buyer asks about zoning, the flood zone, City impact fees and the ARB's building rules, so those belong in the listing with the survey.
Fix what an inspector will name and a buyer cannot see: roof leaks, air conditioning problems, water heater age, electrical panel issues and open permits. Cosmetic work matters less than a clean file. We walk the home with you and recommend only the work that pays back against the recorded resales of your era and size.
Request a free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation and we will build the number from the county's recorded sales for your era, size, street and flood zone, then walk the home to adjust for condition. You can also Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. There is no obligation, and it is not a lender's appraisal.
A Burnt Store Meadows specialist matters because value here turns on details a generalist misses: an MLS name field that hides most of the sales, a flood line that crosses the plat, two declarations and two zoning districts, an unpublished assessment, a greenbelt behind nearly every lot and new homes rising on the remaining lots. Buyers pay for certainty, and a specialist supplies it.
If you are thinking, "I need someone to sell my house in Burnt Store Meadows, Florida," McGreevy and Comisar helps homeowners price, market, negotiate and sell with a local strategy built for Burnt Store Meadows, Punta Gorda, Charlotte County and the rest of Southwest Florida. Whether you are selling a 1990s home on the greenbelt, a newer home on Royal Poinciana, a condominium unit or a vacant lot, our team provides local market guidance, professional listing exposure and a clear plan to help you sell confidently.
Burnt Store Meadows buyers are buying a city address off US 41 and Burnt Store Road with I-75 about 7 to 8 minutes away, Publix, Walmart and Home Depot about 5 to 6 minutes away, nature preserves within about 5 minutes and downtown Punta Gorda about 12 minutes away at free-flow speeds. Our Burnt Store Meadows community guide covers that whole picture, and it is the same record we use to describe your street to buyers.
The Charlotte County Property Appraiser holds the sales, parcel and tax rate records; the Clerk of the Circuit Court holds the recorded declarations; the City of Punta Gorda holds the zoning, permits, utilities and flood rules; FEMA publishes the flood maps; and the Burnt Store Meadows POA posts its governing documents on its own site. Knowing where each record lives is how we answer a buyer's question in a day instead of a week.
Burnt Store Meadows sits inside the larger Punta Gorda market, and the benchmark section above sets it beside its neighbors. Our Punta Gorda seller guide covers the city, and the Seminole Lakes seller guide covers the neighbor buyers most often compare.
Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar personally handle every listing from pricing to closing. For this guide we tracked every recorded Burnt Store Meadows sale in the latest 12 months, 42 homes and 11 lots, and read the association's declarations, bylaws and rules line by line. You get the pricing evidence in writing, a documents file that is ready before the first showing and a call when feedback arrives. Thinking of buying here instead? See the Burnt Store Meadows buyer guide.
Every document behind the rules and figures in this Burnt Store Meadows seller guide is public. These are the ones a seller here actually uses, each linked to the issuing authority's own copy or the association's posted copy.
| Document | Publisher | Why a seller needs it | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Declaration of Restrictions, single-family lots (association copy) | Burnt Store Meadows POA | The use, setback, parking, sign, rental and greenbelt terms for most lots | Open the document |
| Declaration of Restrictions, multi-family lots (association copy) | Burnt Store Meadows POA | The terms for the GM-15 lots on Royal Poinciana and the Plum Tree streets | Open the document |
| Amended and Restated Bylaws, 2020 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | Assessment timing, liens, fines and the hearing committee | Open the document |
| Amended and Restated Articles of Incorporation, 2020 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | Mandatory membership, including condominium owners | Open the document |
| Violation Protocol Table, revised July 17, 2023 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | Cure times to clear before listing | Open the document |
| ARB New Construction requirements, July 2026 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | What a builder next door must meet | Open the document |
| Welcome New Neighbor Letter, October 2026 | Burnt Store Meadows POA | The overlay district note and parking permit rules a buyer reads first | Open the document |
| 2026 Tax Roll Final Rates | Charlotte County Property Appraiser | The 16.8148 mill rate for tax district 150 | Open the document |
| Estoppel Certificate Fees | Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation | The $299, $119 and $179 caps | Open the document |
| Chapter 26, Land Development Regulations | City of Punta Gorda | GS-3.5, GM-15 and the Special Residential Overlay rules | Open the document |
| FY2027 Adopted Capital Improvement Program | Charlotte County | The East/West Connector entry a buyer may ask about | Open the document |
| Citizens Property Insurance, detail by county, August 31, 2026 | Citizens Property Insurance Corporation | The Charlotte County policy counts behind the insurance discussion | Open the document |
| Hurricane Ian tropical cyclone report | National Hurricane Center | The storm record buyers ask about | Open the document |
| IRS Publication 523, Selling Your Home | Internal Revenue Service | The federal rules on excluding gain | Open the document |
Each figure in this Burnt Store Meadows seller guide comes from a public source read on October 21, 2026 unless another date is shown: the Burnt Store Meadows POA's posted documents, Charlotte County and its Property Appraiser, the City of Punta Gorda, Florida statutes, rules and agencies, FEMA and the National Hurricane Center, the school district and the state's school grades, and the builder's own page, labelled as marketing.
Recorded-sale figures are our analysis of the Charlotte County Property Appraiser's public sales and parcel files (roll of October 4, 2026), state-qualified sales recorded in the 12 months to September 9, 2026 unless another window is named. Builder prices are builder marketing, not recorded prices. No listing portal, brokerage or valuation aggregator was used for any figure.
Burnt Store Meadows POA and the condominiums
Charlotte County and its Property Appraiser
City of Punta Gorda
Florida statutes, rules and agencies
Flood, storms and insurance
Schools, health care and daily life
Builders (builder marketing, seen October 21, 2026)
Federal agencies and the commission rules
McGreevy and Comisar are the Southwest Florida listing team Burnt Store Meadows sellers call when a home has to be priced on the record and sold without surprises. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar personally handle every listing from pricing to closing, with over 45 years of combined direct experience, and they have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
#5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026). For this seller guide we tracked all 42 recorded home sales in Burnt Store Meadows over the latest 12 months and read the Charlotte County Property Appraiser's sales and parcel files, the association's declarations, bylaws and rules, the City's zoning, utility and flood records and FEMA's flood layer, so the figures here come from public records rather than estimates.
Jesse McGreevy (license SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (license BK3060671) are licensed Florida real estate professionals regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) under Chapter 475, Florida Statutes.
Meet Jesse McGreevy, who leads the team's listing and seller strategy, and Marc Comisar, who leads buyer representation and negotiation, or read more about McGreevy and Comisar. Buying in Burnt Store Meadows or anywhere in Southwest Florida? See how we represent buyers or call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.
Ready to sell? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, or start with a free Burnt Store Meadows home valuation. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and there is no obligation.
Updated October 2026. This seller guide is general information about selling a home in Burnt Store Meadows, not an appraisal and not legal, tax or insurance advice. Market figures change monthly and statutory figures change annually. Brokered by Domain Realty.