Carriedale Cottages

Carriedale Cottages

Carriedale Cottages is 24 one-story villas on Carriedale Lane inside Fiddlesticks Country Club, Fort Myers. Lee County recorded a $575,000 median since May 2025. Call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072.

Search Homes

Updated November 2026 · Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.

McGreevy and Comisar are the team Carriedale Cottages owners call first when they decide to sell, and the team buyers call when they want every recorded Carriedale Cottages sale, plan by plan and building by building, before they write an offer. Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with over $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc, we wrote this guide sellers first: what a villa in Carriedale Cottages is worth today, which sales recorded by Lee County set that price, and what a buyer will ask about the two condominiums behind the name, the mandatory club and its joining fee, the club dues and capital assessment, the condominium assessment, the roofs and reserves, the flood zone and the evacuation zone before signing.

Carriedale Cottages is 24 one-story attached villas in eight three-unit buildings on the odd side of Carriedale Lane, inside gated Fiddlesticks Country Club off Daniels Parkway in Fort Myers, Florida, ZIP 33912, in unincorporated Lee County; our Fiddlesticks Country Club guide covers the wider community. On the public record it is two condominiums, Carriedale Cottages Section I and Section II, built in 1986 and 1987. Lee County records show 7 qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, from $500,000 to $665,000, at a $575,000 median, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser.

If you are choosing who should represent you, our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers sets out the criteria we think every Fort Myers seller and buyer should use. Owners can read our Fiddlesticks Country Club seller guide or request a free Fiddlesticks Country Club home valuation; buyers can read how to buy a home in Fiddlesticks Country Club. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.

Why McGreevy and Comisar Are the Best Realtor for Carriedale Cottages

McGreevy and Comisar are the best realtor for Carriedale Cottages because we price a villa from Lee County’s recorded sales in the two condominiums themselves, read by plan, building and county size, not from a ZIP code average, and we answer the two-condominium, club joining fee, dues, capital assessment, condo assessment, roof, reserve, flood and evacuation questions a buyer asks before the buyer asks them. Our team, Domain Realty Group, has been the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012.

If you’re searching for the best realtor for Carriedale Cottages in Fort Myers, whether you’re ready to sell your Carriedale Cottages villa or buy your next one, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. We are also ranked the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026).

Recent Carriedale Cottages market record (May 2025 to September 1, 2026): From May 2025 to September 1, 2026 Lee County recorded 7 qualified Carriedale Cottages sales · a range of $500,000 to $665,000 · a median of $575,000 · about $274 to about $318 per county square foot, median about $300 · record $665,000, unit 4C, a 2,093 square foot C plan villa at 15643 Carriedale Ln, in March 2026 · newest qualified sale in the county file $550,000, unit 7B, on September 1, 2026. Days on market and the ratio of sale price to asking price are not part of the county record; the county carries recorded prices and dates, so we read those two figures for your exact villa when we prepare your pricing.

For Carriedale Cottages sellers: professional photography, drone video that shows your building’s golf frontage and its place near the clubhouse, cabana and resort pool, sale-by-sale pricing from the county record for your plan, your building and your county size, and a qualified-buyer database built over our years leading Domain Realty Group.

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Selling your Carriedale Cottages villa? Get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 (confidential conversations welcome).

Buying a villa in Carriedale Cottages? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 for a personalized buyer consultation, and see how we represent buyers in Fiddlesticks Country Club.

Key Takeaways: What Should You Know About Carriedale Cottages?

Carriedale Cottages’ key takeaways are its identity, its size, its price position and its costs: the MLS name “Carriedale” for two recorded condominiums of 12 villas each, 24 one-story, three-bedroom, golf-front villas of 1,827 to 2,093 county square feet built in 1986 and 1987, recent qualified sales of $500,000 to $665,000, a mandatory club with a $150,000 joining fee, and FEMA Zone X with Lee County Evacuation Zone C.

  • One name, two condominiums. Carriedale Cottages Section I (12 units, recorded September 29, 1986) and Section II (12 units, recorded June 16, 1987) together make the 24 villas at the odd addresses 15621 to 15685 Carriedale Ln.
  • 24 villas, three plans. Eight A villas of 1,966 square feet with 2.5 baths, eight B villas of 1,827 square feet with 2 baths and eight C villas of 2,093 square feet with 2.5 baths; every villa has three bedrooms, one story, a garage and a “GOLF FRONT” county code.
  • Built 1986 and 1987. Buildings 1 to 4 date from 1986 and Buildings 5 to 8 from 1987; the roofs were torn off and replaced with fiberglass shingle in 2013 and 2014.
  • Recorded prices. Lee County recorded 7 qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, $500,000 to $665,000, median $575,000; the record is $665,000, unit 4C, in March 2026.
  • The club is mandatory. Every owner holds a Fiddlesticks Resident Equity membership; the joining fee rose from $115,000 to $150,000 on November 1, 2026, and 2026-27 dues are $2,319.50 a month.
  • Three cost layers. Club dues, a listing-reported condo assessment of $2,500 a quarter and a $295 monthly Capital Improvement Assessment come to about $3,448 a month before property tax and insurance; no association budget is public.
  • No milestone inspection or SIRS. All eight buildings are one story, so Florida’s milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study do not apply; roof, paint and paving reserves still do unless owners vote to waive them.
  • Flood and evacuation. Lee County’s FEMA layer places the whole street in Zone X on panel 12071C0439H, effective November 17, 2022, and the county places it in Evacuation Zone C.

Table of Contents

This guide answers the questions Carriedale Cottages sellers and buyers ask us most, in the order below.

What Is Carriedale Cottages at Fiddlesticks?

Carriedale Cottages is the name buyers and the MLS (“Carriedale”) use for two recorded condominiums of 12 villas each, Carriedale Cottages Section I, recorded at Official Records Book 1871, Page 443, and Section II, recorded at Book 1923, Page 2227. The 24 one-story villas sit in eight three-unit buildings at the odd addresses 15621 to 15685 Carriedale Ln, Fort Myers, ZIP 33912, inside Fiddlesticks Country Club.

Owners buy a deeded condominium unit plus a share of their section’s common elements, and every owner also holds a mandatory membership in the club, whose corporation is the master association. Our Fiddlesticks Country Club guide covers the wider community; this page covers the 24 villas alone.

Fact

Value

Address

Odd addresses 15621 to 15685 Carriedale Ln, Fort Myers, FL 33912

Legal names

Carriedale Cottages, a Condominium, Section I (Official Records Book 1871, Page 443) and Section II (Book 1923, Page 2227)

Jurisdiction

Unincorporated Lee County; South Trail Fire District; zoning PUD; no CDD

Parent community

Fiddlesticks Country Club: gated, 585 homes, 36 holes, off Daniels Parkway

Buildings

8 one-story buildings of 3 villas each

Villas

24, twelve per section

County sizes

1,827, 1,966 and 2,093 square feet heated

Bedrooms and baths

3 bedrooms; 2 or 2.5 baths

Year built

1986 (Buildings 1 to 4) and 1987 (Buildings 5 to 8)

Association land

Two pool and tennis parcels, 2.18 and 2.609 acres

Club membership

Mandatory Resident Equity membership

Flood zone

X, minimal flood hazard; Evacuation Zone C

Qualified sales, May 2025 to September 1, 2026

7, median $575,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll; Florida DBPR condominium registry; Fiddlesticks Country Club membership; Lee County FEMA flood layer.

Is “Carriedale” the same place as Carriedale Cottages?

Yes, and it is not Carriedale Gardens. The MLS name “Carriedale” maps to Carriedale Cottages: the county legal for an active 2026 listing at 15667 Carriedale Ln reads Carriedale Cottages Section 2, unit 6B, and the MLS closings filed as “Carriedale” match the county’s recorded Cottages sales of units 3B and 5B exactly, at 1,827 square feet for $549,000 and $577,150.

Carriedale Gardens is a separate condominium across the lane, recorded March 22, 1985: 28 two-story garden condos of 1,143 to 1,547 square feet on the even side, 15626 to 15676, filed under its own MLS name and covered in our own Carriedale Gardens guide. Nothing about its prices, sizes or fees applies to the villas.

The mix-up is easy to make: the two condominiums share a street and a manager, and one listing aggregator labels a Gardens unit as “Carriedale Cottages.” Listing labels do not settle it; the county legal description does. Our Fiddlesticks Country Club guide places both among the community’s other neighborhoods.

How many villas and buildings does Carriedale Cottages have?

The two condominiums hold 24 villas in eight one-story buildings of three. Section I covers Buildings 1 to 4, units 1A to 4C, addresses 15621 to 15647; Section II covers Buildings 5 to 8, units 5A to 8C, addresses 15653 to 15685. The state registry counts 12 units in each section, matching the 24 parcels on the Lee County roll.

Unit letters track the plan in every building: each A villa is 1,966 square feet with 2.5 baths, each B villa 1,827 square feet with 2 baths and each C villa 2,093 square feet with 2.5 baths, eight of each. A 2023 listing calls unit 4A an “end unit” in a building of “3 units.” That the B villa is the middle unit in all eight buildings is not confirmed; the declaration plot plans recorded at the Lee County Clerk show the physical order.

When was Carriedale Cottages built, and who developed it?

Section I was built in 1986 and Section II in 1987. The state registry dates Section I’s recording to September 29, 1986 and Section II’s to June 16, 1987. The Florida DBPR condominium developer file names Fiddlesticks, Ltd., a Florida limited partnership, as developer of Section I and Banyan Group, Inc. N. as developer of Section II.

No builder or general contractor of record was found. Lee County’s online permit records hold no 1986 or 1987 building permits for these addresses; the oldest records on the street are roof replacements and a 2002 mechanical permit. The archived Lee County building records or the recorded declarations at the Lee County Clerk are where a builder name would appear.

The club around the villas is older. Fiddlesticks dates itself from 1982, the Long Mean course by Ron Garl opened in 1983, and Golfweek ranked it 13th in its 1986 “Florida’s 50 Best.”

Is Carriedale Cottages inside the City of Fort Myers?

No. The villas carry a Fort Myers mailing address and ZIP 33912 but sit in unincorporated Lee County, in Section 33, Township 45, Range 25, so Lee County, not the City of Fort Myers, sets their zoning, permits and flood maps. The parcels are zoned PUD and fall in the South Trail Fire District, and the county roll names no community development district.

The annual tax bill confirms which district charges apply to a given villa (Lee County Property Appraiser). The state registry describes the site as “Carriedale Ln SE and Lochmaben,” inside the 640.1-acre Fiddlesticks master plat.

Is Carriedale Cottages gated, and do owners have to join the club?

Gated, yes, and the club is mandatory. The villas sit behind the Fiddlesticks gatehouse, and every owner must hold a Fiddlesticks Resident Equity membership. The joining fee rose from $115,000 to $150,000 on November 1, 2026, with $1 refundable, plus a $2,000 real estate transaction fee, and 2026-27 club dues total $2,319.50 a month with no food and beverage minimum.

That requirement matters to price. A villa sells with its condominium obligations and the club’s, including a Capital Improvement Assessment from September 1, 2026 of $295 a month for 120 months, tied to the property rather than the owner (Fiddlesticks Country Club membership; 2026-2027 Membership Information Packet). An active 2026 listing repeats “MANDATORY EQUITY MEMBERSHIP FEE OF $150,000 DUE AT CLOSING.”

Are Carriedale Cottages villas condominiums or houses?

Condominiums. Lee County codes all 24 villas as condominium units, carrying every dollar of value as building value with no separate land value, and the state registry lists both sections as approved, recorded Chapter 718 condominiums. Listing pages variously call them an “attached villa” or a “condo,” but an owner holds a deeded condominium unit plus a share of the section’s common elements.

That legal form decides which rules apply. Florida’s condominium statute governs the association’s reserves, records, insurance and approvals, and the club’s own governing documents state that its master covenants do not reach land designated for condominium or villa use, which is why the villas carry their own declarations (Fiddlesticks Rules and Regulations).

Where Exactly Is Carriedale Cottages?

Carriedale Cottages lines the odd side of Carriedale Lane, off Lochmaben Avenue, in the south-central part of the Fiddlesticks gates, near the clubhouse, cabana and resort pool. The club sits at 15391 Canongate Dr, and the community’s entrance is off Daniels Parkway in south Fort Myers, in unincorporated Lee County.

How do you reach Carriedale Cottages inside Fiddlesticks?

Through the Fiddlesticks gatehouse. Lee County permit records give the internal route as Fiddlesticks Boulevard, left on Lochmaben Avenue, then left on Carriedale Lane. I-75 Exit 131 at Daniels Parkway is about 2.67 road miles and 6.8 minutes from a Fiddlesticks community point, a free-flow estimate that runs much longer from January to April.

Every villa has its own street address on Carriedale Ln, so a visitor or delivery driver needs gate clearance, and sellers notify the gatehouse of their listing agent (Fiddlesticks realtor procedures). The north end of the Three Oaks Parkway extension opened on November 2, 2026, with a new intersection at Fiddlesticks Boulevard, and final completion is scheduled for early 2027 (WGCU).

How close is Carriedale Cottages to the clubhouse and pools?

Close. Carriedale Lane sits near the Fiddlesticks clubhouse, cabana and resort pool, and each condominium section owns its own pool and tennis parcel on the street, 2.18 acres for Section I and 2.609 acres for Section II. A listing for unit 5B at 15657 places it “steps from the Carriedale community pool.”

The county roll flags a pool on all 24 villas, but that flag reflects the shared association pools, not private pools. Whether Carriedale Gardens owners may use the Cottages pools and courts, or the reverse, is not confirmed; the declarations and association rules settle it, and the association or Suitor and Associates can answer.

How are the eight buildings arranged on Carriedale Lane?

Four buildings per section, three villas to a building, one of each plan. The Lee County roll groups the addresses as shown below, and the 2013 and 2014 roof permits confirm the groupings: Building 1 is 15621, 15623 and 15625, and Building 6 is 15661, 15667 and 15669. Carriedale Gardens’ 28 condos face them on the even side.

Building

Section

Unit A (1,966 sq ft)

Unit B (1,827 sq ft)

Unit C (2,093 sq ft)

Built

1

I

15621

15623

15625

1986

2

I

15633

15631

15627

1986

3

I

15635

15637

15641

1986

4

I

15647

15645

15643

1986

5

II

15653

15657

15659

1987

6

II

15669

15667

15661

1987

7

II

15671

15673

15679

1987

8

II

15681

15683

15685

1987

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll, unit legals and addresses; Lee County permit records.

Every villa is coded “GOLF FRONT,” and 2023 and 2026 listing descriptions add “golf course and landscaped” views at 15667 and “lake views to the north, golf views in all directions” at 15647. Which course and holes each building faces is not confirmed; the club course map or a site visit shows it.

What Is It Like Living in Carriedale Cottages?

Living in Carriedale Cottages means a one-story, three-bedroom villa of 1,827 to 2,093 county square feet with a garage and golf frontage, an association pool and tennis parcel on the street, a mandatory club with tennis, pickleball, fitness, a resort pool and four dining venues, the Fiddlesticks gatehouse at the entrance, and a 30-day minimum on any rental.

What does a Carriedale Cottages villa look like?

Single-story, three bedrooms, with a garage. Every villa is 1,827, 1,966 or 2,093 county square feet with 2 or 2.5 baths, and listing descriptions report block, concrete and stucco construction, a shingle roof, “villa style, single story, zero lot line,” a two-car attached garage, a screened or enclosed lanai and split bedrooms. Construction and garage size are listing-reported, not county figures.

A 2023 listing gave unit 4A at 1,996 square feet; the county records 1,966, and we use the county figure. Finish varies by villa: unit 6B at 15667 is marketed in 2026 as “completely remodeled,” with an updated kitchen, a separate built-in island, stainless appliances and tile throughout.

What amenities come with a Carriedale Cottages villa?

Two layers: the condominium’s own and the club’s. Each section owns a pool and tennis parcel on Carriedale Lane. Club dues cover seven Har-Tru tennis courts, eight dedicated pickleball courts, two bocce courts, fitness, the cabana and resort pool, and four dining venues: the Fiddle Inn, the Pub and Patio, the Main Dining Room and the Cabana.

Dues also include wastewater, common areas, 24-hour roving security and golf on 36 holes (2026-2027 Membership Information Packet). An undated builder’s project page describes a 17,500 square foot clubhouse with renovated dining areas and a card and game room (Owen-Ames-Kimball).

What is changing at the Fiddlesticks club?

The courses and the buildings. The Long Mean, Ron Garl’s 1983 course, has been closed since March 1, 2026 for a renovation by Kris Spence, with no published reopening date. Loch Ness, redesigned by Kipp Schulties, reopened in January 2019. The Capital Improvement Assessment funds a Cabana kitchen expansion, a Clubhouse renovation and Gatehouse improvements.

The architect’s own page lists the Long Mean as current work, with template-style hole features, Donald Ross-influenced work around the greens and a few Scottish revetted bunkers (Kris Spence Golf Design). The Cabana kitchen expansion started in August 2026, the Clubhouse renovation is set from May 2027 and the Gatehouse work for Spring 2028.

What rules shape daily life in Carriedale Cottages?

The condominium’s declaration and rules, and the club’s. The club’s 2026-27 renter information sets a 30-day minimum in half or full month increments, a $100 background check per adult renter, renter privileges at $2,457 a month plus tax and a Section K form filed by the landlord with the lease (Fiddlesticks 2026-27 Renter Information).

A 2023 listing stated up to 12 leases a year; that figure is not confirmed against the current declaration. Listing pages mark pets as “allowed” or “call, conditional,” which is not confirmed either; the association or Suitor and Associates confirms both. Federal and Florida law govern assistance-animal requests. A buyer who needs nightly rental income will not find it under the club’s 30-day minimum.

What are the trade-offs of owning in Carriedale Cottages?

Carriedale Cottages’ trade-offs are on the record: a $150,000 club joining fee, three monthly cost layers with no public condominium budget, roofs from 2013 and 2014 with reserve funding not confirmed, 1986 and 1987 construction, a closed Long Mean and a 30-day rental minimum. Every Fiddlesticks villa carries trade-offs of its own, and these are the ones a buyer should weigh here:

  • A $150,000 club entry. The joining fee from November 1, 2026 is about one quarter, about 26 percent, of the $575,000 median sale, and only $1 of it is refundable.
  • Three cost layers. Club dues of $2,319.50, a listing-reported condo assessment of about $833 and the $295 capital assessment come to about $3,448 a month before property tax and insurance.
  • No public condo budget. Listing pages show $2,500 a quarter in 2026 and $1,640 a quarter in 2023; the current budget and an estoppel letter replace them.
  • Roofs about 12 to 13 years old. Section I was re-roofed in 2013 and Section II in 2014; whether the association funds or waives its roof reserve is not confirmed.
  • 1986 and 1987 construction. The buildings predate the 1994 wind-code tightening and the 2002 Florida Building Code, so wind-mitigation credit depends on later roofs and openings.
  • One course closed. The Long Mean has been closed since March 1, 2026, with no reopening date.
  • Shared pools only. The villas have no private pools.
  • Leasing limits. The club’s 30-day minimum rules out nightly income.

What Is the Carriedale Cottages Market Doing Right Now?

The Carriedale Cottages market has held near its 2025 level. Lee County recorded 7 qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, $500,000 to $665,000, median $575,000: 3 in 2025 at a $575,000 median and 4 in 2026 at a $563,575 median. The newest qualified sale is unit 7B at $550,000 on September 1, 2026, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser.

Data updated: November 2026

The villas trade a handful of times a year from 24 units, so we price from the individual sales of the same plan rather than from any average.

Window

Sales

Median

Range

May 2025 to September 1, 2026, qualified

7

$575,000

$500,000 to $665,000

B plan, 1,827 sq ft, same window

4

$549,500

$500,000 to $577,150

A plan, 1,966 sq ft, same window

2

$580,000

$575,000 and $585,000

C plan, 2,093 sq ft, same window

1

n/a

$665,000

2025, qualified

3

$575,000

$500,000 to $585,000

2026 through September 1, qualified

4

$563,575

$549,000 to $665,000

Highest on record, March 2026

1

n/a

$665,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser public parcel roll and sale data files, county-qualified sales; parcel roll dated November 1, 2026, sale files indexed November 18, 2026. Medians are from the individual sales in the next section.

How many Carriedale Cottages villas change hands each year?

Only a few. The county sale file shows 7 qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, from 24 villas: unit 6A in May 2025, unit 4A in July 2025 and unit 4B in September 2025, then unit 5B in January 2026, unit 4C in March, unit 3B in April and unit 7B in September 2026.

On the October 2026 county roll, 10 of the 24 villas carry a homestead exemption. Several $0 and $100 transfers between 2008 and 2026 are non-qualified transfers, such as trust deeds, and we leave them out of every price comparison.

What does a Carriedale Cottages villa sell for per square foot?

About $274 to about $318 a county square foot on the 7 qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, with a median of about $300. Unit 4B at 15645, a 1,827 square foot B villa that recorded $500,000 in September 2025, sits at the low end, and unit 4C at 15643, the 2,093 square foot record sale, sits at the high end.

A per-foot figure means less with three fixed plans, because finish and condition move each price as much as size does. Unit 5B recorded about $316 a square foot in January 2026, close to the C plan record, while unit 4B, on the same plan, recorded about $274 in September 2025.

Do the three floor plans price differently?

Yes, broadly in size order. In the May 2025 to September 1, 2026 window, the four B villas of 1,827 square feet had a $549,500 median, the two A villas of 1,966 square feet a $580,000 median, and the single C villa of 2,093 square feet recorded $665,000, the highest on record.

The bands overlap. Unit 5B, a B villa, recorded $577,150 in January 2026, above unit 6A, an A villa, at $575,000 in May 2025. With one C sale in the window, the largest plan has a single current county price, which is why we compare a villa with its own plan first and then read finish.

How does the county’s just value compare with recorded prices?

The county’s just value runs well below recent prices. The 2026 just values of the 24 villas range from $320,574 to $410,844, with a median of $390,773, against the $575,000 median of the qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026. The 24 just values total $9,035,451, an average of $376,477.

By plan, the 2026 just value medians are $323,913 for B villas, $390,773 for A villas and $407,188 for C villas. A seller should not price from the just value: it is an assessment, not a sale price, and it trails the market; the recorded sales of the same plan are the better guide (Lee County Property Appraiser).

What does the county record not show yet?

The county record shows recorded prices and dates, not asking prices, days on market, concessions, fees or a villa’s condition, and it runs behind the market. Unit 5B at 15657 was advertised at $595,000 before the county recorded its sale at $577,150 on January 5, 2026, and unit 6B at 15667 was listed at $599,000 on February 5, 2026.

On November 18, 2026, unit 6B showed an asking price of $529,000 after a $20,900 reduction; it last sold in 2019 for $216,000. Those are asking prices, not sales, and they do not appear in our sale tables. We check the Lee County Clerk for newer deeds before we price a villa.

Ready to sell or buy in Carriedale Cottages?

With seven qualified sales since May 2025 and one sale of the largest plan, the right price depends on your plan, your building, your finish, your roof and reserve answers and the current club and association costs. Request a free Fiddlesticks Country Club home valuation and we will price your villa from the county’s recorded sales of the same plan, or read our Fiddlesticks Country Club seller guide.

Buyers can start with how to buy a home in Fiddlesticks Country Club. For the wider city, see our Fort Myers seller guide, a free Fort Myers home valuation and how to buy a home in Fort Myers. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.

Which Carriedale Cottages Sales Set Today’s Prices?

The seven qualified Carriedale Cottages sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026 set today’s prices, at $500,000 to $665,000 and a $575,000 median, led by the $665,000 record for unit 4C in March 2026. The 2022 to 2024 sales recorded $460,000 to $555,000, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser.

Data updated: November 2026

Recorded

Address (unit)

County size (sq ft)

Price

Approx. $/sq ft

September 1, 2026

15673 Carriedale Ln (7B)

1,827

$550,000

301

April 15, 2026

15637 Carriedale Ln (3B)

1,827

$549,000

300

March 31, 2026

15643 Carriedale Ln (4C)

2,093

$665,000

318

January 5, 2026

15657 Carriedale Ln (5B)

1,827

$577,150

316

September 30, 2025

15645 Carriedale Ln (4B)

1,827

$500,000

274

July 1, 2025

15647 Carriedale Ln (4A)

1,966

$585,000

298

May 3, 2025

15669 Carriedale Ln (6A)

1,966

$575,000

292

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser public parcel roll and sale data files, deed prices, county-qualified sales; price per square foot uses county heated area. Summary, May 2025 to September 1, 2026: 7 qualified sales, median $575,000, low $500,000, high $665,000.

Which Carriedale Cottages sale is the highest on record?

Unit 4C at 15643 Carriedale Ln, a 2,093 square foot C villa, recorded $665,000 on March 31, 2026, about $318 a county square foot. It is the highest recorded price in the two condominiums and the only C plan sale in the May 2025 to September 1, 2026 window, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser.

Before 2022, the high was $435,000, for unit 6C at 15661 in March 2008. A seller pricing a C villa today starts from that single recent C sale and the A sales at $575,000 and $585,000, then reads finish and condition, because one sale is a thin record for a plan.

What do the 2026 sales tell a seller?

That B villas are trading in a tight band and a C villa sets the top. Unit 5B recorded $577,150 on January 5, 2026, unit 3B $549,000 on April 15 and unit 7B $550,000 on September 1, while unit 4C recorded $665,000 on March 31. The four 2026 sales recorded a $563,575 median, against $575,000 for the three 2025 sales.

Unit 7B had recorded $551,000 in May 2024, so its 2026 sale came in $1,000 lower on the same villa. Finish, a clear answer on the condominium assessment and reserves, and the higher club joining fee from November 1, 2026 are what separate a villa at the top of the range from one at the bottom.

Does a larger plan always sell for more?

Usually, but not always. The C plan holds the record at $665,000, and the two A sales recorded $575,000 and $585,000. Yet unit 5B, a 1,827 square foot B villa, recorded $577,150 in January 2026, above unit 6A, a 1,966 square foot A villa, at $575,000 in May 2025, and at about $316 a square foot, the second-highest figure in the table.

Plan is one input among several. Finish, the year of the sale and the condition of the roof, the lanai and the kitchen each move a price, so we read every sale of the same plan, and of the plans on either side of it, before we set a number for a seller.

How Have Carriedale Cottages Prices Changed?

Carriedale Cottages prices opened at $191,500 to $209,500 on the first transfers of 1986 to 1988, reached $435,000 in March 2008, fell to $190,000 to $216,000 in 2018 and 2019, climbed to $460,000 to $555,000 from 2022 to 2024 and settled at a $575,000 median on the seven qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser.

Data updated: November 2026

Period

Sales shown

Range or median

Section I first transfers, December 1986 to June 1987

3

$191,500 to $197,250

Section II early transfers, September 1987 to January 1988

2

$199,400 to $209,500

2007

1

$410,000

March 2008, highest before 2022

1

$435,000

2018 to 2019

n/a

$190,000 to $216,000

2022 to 2024

6

$460,000 to $555,000

May 2025 to September 1, 2026, qualified

7

$500,000 to $665,000; median $575,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser public parcel roll and sale data files; the sales shown are those in the county record we read, not every closing in each period.

What did the first Carriedale Cottages buyers pay?

From $191,500 to $209,500 on the earliest transfers in the county file. Unit 1C at 15625 recorded $194,000 and unit 2C at 15627 $197,250 in December 1986, unit 4B at 15645 $191,500 in June 1987, unit 8C at 15685 $199,400 in September 1987 and unit 7C at 15679 $209,500 in January 1988.

Address (unit)

County size (sq ft)

Recorded

Price

15625 Carriedale Ln (1C)

2,093

December 1986

$194,000

15627 Carriedale Ln (2C)

2,093

December 1986

$197,250

15645 Carriedale Ln (4B)

1,827

June 1987

$191,500

15685 Carriedale Ln (8C)

2,093

September 1987

$199,400

15679 Carriedale Ln (7C)

2,093

January 1988

$209,500

These are the first conveyances recorded after each declaration, which is consistent with developer closings, but the grantor on each deed is not on the county sale file and is not confirmed; the deed images at the Lee County Clerk show who sold.

How did Carriedale Cottages prices move from 2007 to 2020?

Up to a $435,000 high in 2008, then down to $190,000 to $216,000 by 2018 and 2019. Unit 3C at 15641 recorded $410,000 in 2007 and unit 6C at 15661 $435,000 in March 2008, the high before 2022. Unit 5B at 15657 recorded $190,000 in May 2019, and unit 6B at 15667 $216,000 in 2019.

Unit 6A at 15669 recorded $325,000 in August 2020. Those resales sit far below today’s range: the same B plan as unit 5B recorded $500,000 to $577,150 in the May 2025 to September 1, 2026 window, and unit 6A itself recorded $575,000 in May 2025.

What do the repeat sales show?

A step change from 2019 and 2020, then a level market. Unit 5B recorded $190,000 in May 2019 and $577,150 in January 2026, $387,150 higher. Unit 6A recorded $325,000 in August 2020 and $575,000 in May 2025, $250,000 higher. Unit 4A rose $34,500, from $550,500 in 2023 to $585,000 in 2025, and unit 7B eased $1,000, from $551,000 in 2024 to $550,000 in 2026.

A repeat sale of one villa is the cleanest comparison in a condominium of three plans, because plan, building and size stay the same. The county file does not record finish or condition between the two sales, so we read the permit history and any marketing record before we apply it to another villa.

Did Hurricane Ian change Carriedale Cottages prices?

Not on the county record. Hurricane Ian made landfall on September 28, 2022. Unit 8C at 15685 recorded $499,000 in November 2022, unit 4A at 15647 $550,500 in April 2023 and unit 5A at 15653 $475,000 in May 2023, and those post-Ian sales show no distressed pattern. Lee County’s public damage layers show no records on the street.

The other 2022 to 2024 sales were unit 2C at 15627 at $460,000 in April 2022, unit 8A at 15681 at $555,000 in April 2024 and unit 7B at 15673 at $551,000 in May 2024. No Cottages roof permit was filed after Ian in the searches run. Damage and insurance claims at the association level are not confirmed; the association’s files or an estoppel disclosure hold that record, and a buyer should ask for it.

What Villas Are in Carriedale Cottages?

Carriedale Cottages holds 24 one-story attached villas in eight three-unit buildings on the odd side of Carriedale Ln, built in 1986 and 1987. Lee County records three plans, eight of each, and every villa has three bedrooms and a garage: 1,966 square feet with 2.5 baths, 1,827 square feet with 2 baths, and 2,093 square feet with 2.5 baths. The county codes all 24 “GOLF FRONT.”

Plan

Units

Size (Lee County)

Bedrooms and baths

2026 just value (low, median, high)

Count

A

1A to 8A

1,966 sq ft

3 / 2.5

$387,035, $390,773, $410,844

8

B

1B to 8B

1,827 sq ft

3 / 2

$320,574, $323,913, $352,500

8

C

1C to 8C

2,093 sq ft

3 / 2.5

$405,237, $407,188, $409,138

8

All plans

24 villas

8 of each size

3 bedrooms, one story, garage

Total $9,035,451; average $376,477; median $390,773

24

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 parcel roll, 24 unit records on Carriedale Ln, November 2026.

How many villas and buildings does Carriedale Cottages have?

Twenty-four villas in eight one-story buildings of three. Section I holds Buildings 1 to 4, units 1A to 4C, at 15621 to 15647 Carriedale Ln, all built in 1986. Section II holds Buildings 5 to 8, units 5A to 8C, at 15653 to 15685, all built in 1987. Lee County’s roll and the state condominium register both count 12 units in each section.

Listing sites do not always keep the two Carriedale condominiums apart, and one aggregator labels a Carriedale Gardens unit as Carriedale Cottages. The county legal description settles it, and every villa can be looked up one by one on the Lee County Property Appraiser site. One quirk: the county legal for unit 6A reads “SEEC 2,” so a text search of the roll can miss it.

What are the three floor plans in the villas?

Three sizes, by the county’s heated area, and the unit letter tells you which. Every A unit is 1,966 square feet with 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths. Every B unit is 1,827 square feet with 3 bedrooms and 2 baths. Every C unit is 2,093 square feet with 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths. Each building holds one of each plan, so there are eight of every size.

That mix shapes the sale record. From May 2025 to September 1, 2026, B units made up 4 of the 7 qualified sales, A units 2, and the C plan only 1: the $665,000 sale of unit 4C in March 2026, the top recorded Carriedale Cottages sale, according to Lee County Property Appraiser records. Listing figures can differ from the county’s: a 2023 listing gave 1,996 square feet and three baths (two full, one half) for an A unit the county records at 1,966 square feet. We price from the county figure.

How do the eight buildings line up?

Each building pairs one A, one B and one C unit, and the street numbers do not run in plan order from building to building. In all eight buildings the B unit’s number falls between the A and C numbers, but whether B is the middle unit in every building is not confirmed. The declaration plot plans, recorded at Official Records Book 1871, Page 443 and Book 1923, Page 2227, show the layout.

Building

Section

Unit A (1,966 sq ft)

Unit B (1,827 sq ft)

Unit C (2,093 sq ft)

Built

1

1

15621

15623

15625

1986

2

1

15633

15631

15627

1986

3

1

15635

15637

15641

1986

4

1

15647

15645

15643

1986

5

2

15653

15657

15659

1987

6

2

15669

15667

15661

1987

7

2

15671

15673

15679

1987

8

2

15681

15683

15685

1987

Source: Lee County roll, unit legals and addresses. The 2013 and 2014 roof permits confirm the groupings.

A 2023 listing calls unit 4A a “Carriedale ‘A’ Cottage end unit” in a building of “3 units.” Position within a building affects light, privacy and shared walls, so we confirm it for the specific villa at the showing.

What garage, construction and outdoor space come with a villa?

Every villa has a garage on the county roll, and listing descriptions describe a 2-car attached garage. Listings also describe block, concrete and stucco construction, a shingle roof, “villa style, single story, zero lot line” living, a screened or enclosed lanai and split bedrooms. Those are listing descriptions, so a buyer confirms the specific villa’s garage and lanai at the showing.

The roll’s pool flag reads “Y” on all 24 villas. That reflects the two shared association pools, one per section, not private pools. Listings describe views of the course and landscaping at 15667 and “lake views to the north, golf views in all directions” at 15647, but which course and holes each building faces is not confirmed.

How old are the roofs on the villas?

About 12 to 13 years old in 2026. Lee County permits show fiberglass shingle tear-off re-roofs on all four Section 1 buildings in 2013, by Absolute Roofing of SW Florida, with a $30,000 job value for building 1, and on all four Section 2 buildings in 2014, by CFS Roofing Services. An earlier, undated re-roof series came before those. No later roof permit surfaced.

That search was not a full census of every permit on the street, so a buyer asks the association for its roof records and reads the roof line in the reserve schedule. The roofs are the largest shared component in a one-story condominium, and their age drives both reserves and insurance.

Selling in Carriedale Cottages? Request a free home valuation, see how we sell homes in Fiddlesticks Country Club or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we help buyers in Fiddlesticks Country Club.

How Did Carriedale Cottages Come to Be?

Carriedale Cottages was built in 1986 and 1987 as two 12-unit condominiums inside Fiddlesticks Country Club, a gated club community that dates itself from 1982 (our Fiddlesticks Country Club guide covers the whole community). Section I was recorded on September 29, 1986, and Section II on June 16, 1987. The state register names Fiddlesticks, Ltd. and Banyan Group, Inc. N. as the developers.

Date

Event

Record

1982

Fiddlesticks Country Club dates itself from this year

Club membership page

1983

The Long Mean course, by Ron Garl, opens

Parent research

1984

Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc. is formed

State corporate registry

1986

Golfweek ranks the Long Mean 13th in “Florida’s 50 Best”

Parent research, Florida Green, Fall 1986

September 29, 1986

Section I recorded, 12 units, Official Records Book 1871, Page 443

DBPR; Lee County

December 1986

First recorded transfers in Section I, $194,000 and $197,250

Lee County sale file

June 16, 1987

Section II recorded, 12 units, Book 1923, Page 2227

DBPR; Lee County

September 1987 to January 1988

Early Section II transfers, $199,400 to $209,500

Lee County sale file

1989

Carriedale Cottages Condominium Association, Inc. filed

State corporate registry

2013 and 2014

Section 1 and Section 2 re-roofed in fiberglass shingle

Lee County permits

What was Fiddlesticks before Carriedale Cottages?

A golf club first. Fiddlesticks dates itself from 1982, its Long Mean course by Ron Garl opened in 1983, and Golfweek ranked the Long Mean 13th in “Florida’s 50 Best” in 1986, the year Section I was recorded. Today the gated community holds 585 homes and 36 holes off Daniels Parkway, on a master plat of 640.1 acres in unincorporated Lee County.

The club corporation is the master association, and its governing documents state that the master covenants do not apply to land designated for condominium or villa use. That is why Carriedale carries its own recorded declarations, and why a buyer reads both the condominium documents and the club’s.

How do the two sections fit together?

Carriedale Cottages is two condominiums, not one. Section I covers Buildings 1 to 4 and 12 villas built in 1986; Section II covers Buildings 5 to 8 and 12 villas built in 1987. Each was recorded separately with its own declaration, and each section owns a “CE: POOL + TENNIS” common-element parcel, 2.18 acres for Section I and 2.609 acres for Section II.

Same street, same plans and same manager do not mean one set of documents. A buyer of unit 6B reads the Section II declaration at Book 1923, Page 2227; a buyer of unit 2C reads Section I at Official Records Book 1871, Page 443. Amendments recorded since then are part of each file.

Who developed Carriedale Cottages?

The state condominium developer file names Fiddlesticks, Ltd., a Florida limited partnership, as developer of Section I, and Banyan Group, Inc. N. as developer of Section II. No builder or general contractor of record was found. Lee County’s online permit portal holds no 1986 or 1987 building permits for these addresses, and its oldest records on the street are roof and mechanical permits.

The original builder would appear in Lee County’s archived building files or in the plot plans of the recorded declarations. For a resale buyer, the practical records are newer ones: the roof permits, any opening upgrades and the association’s maintenance history.

When was Carriedale Cottages recorded as a condominium?

In two steps. Section I, Carriedale Cottages, A Condo Sec I, was recorded on September 29, 1986, at Official Records Book 1871, Page 443. Section II, Carriedale Cottages A Condo Sec II, was recorded on June 16, 1987, at Book 1923, Page 2227. Older research dated Section II to a 1986 recording; the state register shows 1987, and we use that date.

Both sections appear as approved, recorded Chapter 718 condominiums in the DBPR condominium extract, and the county codes every villa as a condominium unit. The recorded instruments at the Lee County Clerk are the final word on dates and terms.

Why is it called Carriedale on the MLS?

The MLS files these villas under the name “Carriedale,” while every legal record uses Carriedale Cottages Section I or Section II. Listing pages variously call them “attached villa” or “condo,” and the county and the state treat them as condominium units. No public record explains how the Carriedale name was chosen.

For a buyer, the practical point is simple: the deed, title work, estoppel and insurance all use the legal name and section, so we put both names on the contract file so nothing is missed.

Who Governs Carriedale Cottages?

Carriedale Cottages is governed by its condominium association under Florida’s condominium law and by the Fiddlesticks club corporation, which is the master association and runs the gate. Club membership is mandatory. A street-wide Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc. also exists, though its role is not confirmed, and no community development district was found.

Layer

Entity

Record

Condominium associations (state register)

Carriedale Cottages I Condo Assoc Inc (Section I) and Carriedale Cottages II Condo Assn Inc (Section II)

DBPR register, in care of Suitor and Associates

Condominium association (corporate registry)

Carriedale Cottages Condominium Association, Inc., filed 1989, active

State corporate registry; per-section corporations inactive; which operates both is not confirmed

Street association

Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc. (1984)

State corporate registry; role and any assessment not confirmed

Management of record

Suitor and Associates

DBPR register; club 2026-27 packet

Master association

Fiddlesticks Country Club corporation

Club governing documents

Club

Mandatory Resident Equity membership

Club membership page

CDD

None found

Lee County roll; South Trail Fire District

What does the condominium association control?

The villas and their shared land. The Carriedale Cottages association maintains and insures the buildings and common elements, including the roofs and the two pool and tennis parcels, sets the budget and reserves, adopts rules and may approve leases or sales under its declarations. Florida’s condominium law, including section 718.112, governs it, along with the estoppel certificate a seller orders at closing.

That makes the association, not the club, the body a buyer questions about the quarterly assessment, reserves, roof records, the master insurance policy and any special assessment.

What does the Fiddlesticks club do as master association?

It runs the community layer above the condominium. The club corporation is the master association, operates the gatehouse and 24-hour roving security, maintains common areas and the wastewater plant, and runs golf, tennis, pickleball, bocce, fitness and the cabana pool. Every Carriedale owner holds a Resident Equity membership and pays club dues on top of the condominium assessment.

The club’s realtors page sets out the buyer, seller, renter and landlord steps, and club estoppels go to the club’s community association manager. Our Fiddlesticks Country Club guide covers the club and master layer across the whole community.

Why does the state register list two associations?

Because it has not caught up with the corporate record. DBPR’s register still lists a separate managing association for each section, both in care of Suitor and Associates. The state corporate registry shows one active Carriedale Cottages Condominium Association, Inc., filed in 1989, with both per-section corporations inactive. Which corporation now operates both condominiums is not confirmed.

The DBPR condominium extract is public. The recorded amendments at the Lee County Clerk or the association’s estoppel letter would show which entity operates each section, and we ask for that early because it decides who signs the estoppel and the approval.

What is the Carriedale Homeowner’s Association?

A separate corporation, Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc., formed in 1984, that appears to span the whole street. Its 2011 officer list included residents of both the Cottages and Carriedale Gardens, and the club’s 2025-26 and 2026-27 packets list one “Carriedale HOA” under Suitor and Associates. Whether it levies an assessment, owns land or only coordinates the street is not confirmed.

The association’s documents or an estoppel letter answer that. A third layer of fees would change the cost of ownership, so we ask before a buyer goes firm.

Who manages the villas?

Suitor and Associates, according to the DBPR register and the club’s 2026-27 packet, with Suitor, Middleton, Cox and Associates as registered agent for the active association. Associations change managers, and registers can lag, so a buyer confirms the current manager with the seller or the association before ordering the estoppel and resale documents.

The club handles its own side separately, so a buyer should expect two contacts at closing: the Carriedale manager for the condominium estoppel and the club for the club estoppel and membership transfer.

Selling in Carriedale Cottages? Request a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we help buyers in Fiddlesticks Country Club.

What Does It Cost to Own in Carriedale Cottages?

Owning in Carriedale Cottages means Fiddlesticks club dues of $2,319.50 a month for 2026-27, a condominium assessment listing-reported at $2,500 a quarter (about $833 a month), and a property-tied club Capital Improvement Assessment of $295 a month, about $3,448 a month in all before property tax and insurance. A buyer also pays the club’s $150,000 joining fee at purchase.

Cost

Amount

Basis

Club joining fee

$150,000 from November 1, 2026; $1 refundable

Club 2026-27 packet

Club transaction fee

$2,000

Club 2026-27 packet

Club dues

$2,319.50 a month, about $27,834 a year

Club 2026-27 packet

Capital Improvement Assessment

$295 a month for 120 months, $26,500 lump sum, or $9,365 a year for three years

Club 2026-27 packet; tied to the property

Condominium assessment

$2,500 a quarter, about $833 a month, $10,000 a year

2026 listings; listing-reported, not confirmed

Earlier condominium assessment

$1,640 a quarter

2023 listing

Rough carrying cost

About $3,448 a month before property tax and insurance

Club dues, condominium assessment and capital assessment

Association approval fee

Capped at $150 per applicant, CPI-adjusted (parent research cites $184)

Florida statute

Property tax example

$3,523.92 for 2025; $3,820.99 proposed for 2026

2026 TRIM notice, 15667 (unit 6B)

CDD

None found

Lee County roll

What is the Carriedale Cottages condominium assessment?

Not published. Two 2026 listings report $2,500 a quarter, which is about $833 a month or $10,000 a year, and a 2023 listing reported $1,640 a quarter. Those are listing-reported figures, not an association budget. One listing says villa dues cover cable, sewer, trash, water, security, insurance and irrigation, which is also not confirmed. The current budget is the only number to rely on.

Listing “HOA” fields of $2,174 to $2,175 a month and $2,327 track the club’s dues rather than the condominium assessment, which is why fee figures on listing sites often look inconsistent. We get the current budget and the villa’s estoppel figure from the association or Suitor and Associates before a buyer goes firm.

What are the Fiddlesticks club dues?

$2,319.50 a month for 2026-27, about $27,834 a year, according to the club’s 2026-27 membership packet. The total is $1,730 operating, $383 capital, $100 road reserve, $44 wastewater and $62.50 TV and internet. There is no food and beverage minimum for 2026-27. Dues include golf, tennis, pickleball, bocce, fitness, the cabana pool and 24-hour roving security.

The dues apply to every Fiddlesticks owner whatever the home, and they are a separate charge from the Carriedale condominium assessment. The club’s membership office gives current figures each season.

What is the club joining fee?

$150,000 from November 1, 2026, due at closing, with $1 refundable, plus a $2,000 transaction fee. The fee has climbed quickly: $65,000 in 2021-22, $90,000 on a 2023 listing, $115,000 in 2025-26 and $150,000 now, a $35,000 rise in 2026. Against the $575,000 median Carriedale sale, the fee is about one quarter, about 26 percent, of the price.

The club’s membership page states that membership is required on purchase. Because the fee is the same for every Fiddlesticks home, it weighs more heavily on a villa than on a larger house, and we put it in every buyer’s net cost from the first conversation.

What is the Capital Improvement Assessment?

A club charge that began on September 1, 2026, and is tied to the property, not the owner, so it passes to a buyer. The choices are $295 a month for 120 months, a $26,500 lump sum, or $9,365 a year for three years. It funds the Cabana kitchen expansion, started August 2026, the Clubhouse renovation from May 2027 and Gatehouse improvements in Spring 2028.

A buyer asks the club estoppel which option the seller chose and what balance remains. The purchase contract decides who pays any lump sum or remaining balance at closing.

What are property taxes on a Carriedale Cottages villa?

Specific to each villa, and set by the county’s assessment. The 2026 TRIM notice for 15667, unit 6B, shows 2025 taxes of $3,523.92 at 13.4125 mills and 2026 proposed taxes of $3,820.99 at 13.3738 mills, about $297 higher, as market value rose from $301,445 to $323,657. A 2026 listing shows $3,890 for the same villa.

That villa’s assessed value was $261,020 after a $62,637 assessment limitation benefit, so a buyer’s first full bill reflects a reset assessment, not the seller’s. On the October 2026 roll, 10 of 24 villas carried a homestead exemption. The parcels sit in the South Trail Fire District, and no community development district is named on the county roll, though the actual tax bill is where any non-ad valorem charge appears. We read the villa’s record on the Lee County Property Appraiser site before we estimate a buyer’s taxes.

Are there transfer, application or approval fees?

At the club, a $2,000 real estate transaction fee on top of the joining fee; buyers file the equity application and a background-check form with no buyer fee. Florida caps a condominium association’s transfer approval fee at $150 per applicant, CPI-adjusted every five years, which parent research cites as $184. The estoppel certificate and the declaration state what applies today.

Who pays each charge is set by the purchase contract. We ask for both the Carriedale estoppel and the club estoppel as soon as a contract is signed.

Are there special assessments at Carriedale Cottages?

None was found in public sources, which is not the same as none existing. The roofs date from 2013 and 2014, and roof, paint and paving reserves can be funded or waived by owner vote, so the reserve position matters. A buyer asks for the budget, the reserve schedule, the last two years of minutes and the estoppel certificate, which must state any assessment due.

The club’s Capital Improvement Assessment is separate from any condominium assessment. The purchase contract decides who pays an assessment voted before closing, and we put that question in writing during the inspection period.

Selling in Carriedale Cottages? Request a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we help buyers in Fiddlesticks Country Club.

What Rules Should Carriedale Cottages Buyers Know About Rentals, Pets and Approval?

Carriedale Cottages rules come from the two condominium declarations and rules, with the Fiddlesticks club rules on top. The condominium documents are not published online. The club sets a 30-day rental minimum, renter background checks and renter privileges, and requires buyers to file an equity application and a background-check form. A 2023 listing reported up to 12 leases a year, which is not confirmed.

Rule

What is reported

Status

Minimum lease

30 days, in half or full month increments

Club 2026-27 renter information

Renter background check

$100 per adult

Club 2026-27 renter information

Renter privileges

$2,457 a month plus tax

Club 2026-27 renter information

Landlord paperwork

Section K form filed with the lease

Club realtors page

Leases per year

Up to 12

2023 listing; not confirmed

Pets

“Allowed” or “call, conditional” on listing pages

Listing-reported; not confirmed

Buyer approval

Equity application and background-check form, no buyer fee

Club realtors page

Seller notice

Notify the gatehouse of the listing agent; file a Notice of New Contract with the executed contract

Club realtors page

Can you rent out a Carriedale Cottages villa?

Only by the month or longer. The club’s 2026-27 renter information sets a 30-day minimum in half or full month increments, a $100 background check per adult renter and renter privileges at $2,457 a month plus tax. A buyer who needs nightly rental income will not find it under the club’s 30-day minimum.

A 2023 listing stated a 30-day minimum and up to 12 leases a year, but the condominium’s own leasing limits sit in its declaration, which is not public, so that figure is not confirmed. A landlord files the club’s Section K form with each lease, and the tenant registers through the gatehouse.

What are the pet rules at Carriedale Cottages?

Not confirmed. Listing pages mark pets as “allowed” or “call, conditional,” and neither comes from the declarations or the current rules, which can be amended. A buyer with a pet asks the association, through Suitor and Associates, for the current rule in writing before making an offer. Federal and Florida law govern any request for an assistance animal.

Club rules on common areas and facilities apply across Fiddlesticks in addition to the condominium’s own rules.

How does buyer approval work?

Through the club, and possibly the association as well. The club requires every buyer to file the Resident Equity application and a background-check form, with no buyer fee, and the seller files a Notice of New Contract with the executed contract. Whether the condominium declarations add their own approval of sales or leases is not confirmed in public records.

Federal and Florida fair housing law applies to every approval decision. We start the club application and the association request at contract signing so approval runs alongside the inspection period and does not hold up closing.

What documents should a Carriedale Cottages buyer read before signing?

The declaration for the villa’s section and its amendments, the articles, bylaws and rules, the current budget, the reserve schedule or any reserve waiver vote, insurance declarations, roof records, the last two years of minutes, any special assessment notice, and the club’s packet and Rules and Regulations. A buyer asks management for each one.

The Florida Statutes section 718.112 text sets out what the association’s budget and reserves must contain, which helps a buyer read the documents with the right questions.

Do Florida’s Condo Safety Laws Apply to Carriedale Cottages?

Mostly not. Carriedale Cottages is eight one-story buildings, so Florida’s structural integrity reserve study (SIRS) and milestone inspection laws, which apply to buildings three habitable stories or higher, do not reach it. Reserves for roof replacement, building painting and pavement resurfacing still apply unless owners waive them by majority vote, and whether Carriedale funds or waives them is not confirmed.

Duty

Threshold

Carriedale Cottages

Status

SIRS (s. 718.112(2)(g))

Buildings three habitable stories or higher; buildings less than three stories excluded

One story

Does not apply

Milestone inspection (Florida milestone statute, per DBPR)

Condominium buildings three or more habitable stories

One story

Does not apply

Reserves (s. 718.112(2)(f))

Roof replacement, building painting and pavement resurfacing; waivable by majority vote where no SIRS is required

Roofs from 2013 and 2014

Applies; funding or waiver not confirmed

Website posting (s. 718.111(12)(g)1.)

Associations managing a condominium with 25 or more units

12 units in each section, 24 together

Does not apply

DBPR online account

Every condominium association by October 1, 2025

Applies

Account not confirmed

Does the SIRS requirement apply to Carriedale Cottages?

No. Section 718.112(2)(g) applies the structural integrity reserve study to buildings “three habitable stories or higher in height” and excludes “buildings less than three stories in height.” All eight Carriedale buildings are one story on the 2026 county roll and on listing pages, so no SIRS is required. The association still has to budget other reserves, covered below.

For a buyer, that removes the study and its funding rules from the budget. It does not remove the cost of replacing roofs, paint and paving, which the reserve schedule shows.

Does a milestone inspection apply to Carriedale Cottages?

No. DBPR’s milestone inspection and SIRS page says a milestone inspection is required for condominium buildings “three or more habitable stories in height,” the threshold set in Florida’s milestone inspection statute. The villas are one story, so the milestone law does not reach them. A buyer can still ask Lee County building records for the permit history on any villa.

A one-story block and stucco building still ages. The roof permits, the 2016 impact-rated door replacement at 15621 and routine interior trade permits are the records that show how the buildings have been kept.

What reserve rules still apply to Carriedale Cottages?

Section 718.112(2)(f) requires reserves for roof replacement, building painting and pavement resurfacing, and where no SIRS is required, owners may waive or reduce them by majority vote. With the roofs dating from 2013 and 2014, about 12 to 13 years old in 2026, the roof reserve is the line a buyer reads first. Whether Carriedale funds or waives reserves is not confirmed.

The annual budget shows the reserve balance and schedule, and the minutes show any waiver vote. A waived or thin roof reserve can become a special assessment when the roofs come due, so we read both before a buyer goes firm.

Does the 25-unit website rule reach Carriedale Cottages?

No. Section 718.111(12)(g)1. requires an association managing a condominium with 25 or more units to post official records on a website or app. Each Carriedale section has 12 units and the two together have 24, so the mandate does not reach them whether counted per condominium or combined. The threshold was lowered from 150 units to 25 by 2024 legislation, as amended by HB 913 in 2025.

The HB 913 (2025) bill analysis explains the threshold history. Without a required website, a buyer gets the official records by written request to the association.

Where can a buyer check the association’s filings?

Ask management first for the budget, reserve schedule, insurance declarations and minutes. Every condominium association had to create a DBPR online account by October 1, 2025, and the DBPR condominium extract lists both Carriedale sections. The state corporate registry shows which association corporation is active, and Lee County building records hold the permits.

We put those requests in motion as soon as a contract is signed, because the reserve position and roof age bear on price and on what a buyer will help fund.

Is Carriedale Cottages in a Flood Zone?

Not a high-risk one. Lee County’s FEMA flood layer places the whole Carriedale Cottages street in Zone X, “AREA OF MINIMAL FLOOD HAZARD,” outside the special flood hazard area and the floodway, on FIRM panel 12071C0439H effective November 17, 2022, community 125124 (Lee County FIRM layer). The villas sit in Lee County Evacuation Zone C, surge zone 3.

Flood fact

Carriedale Cottages

Source

FEMA zone

X, area of minimal flood hazard

Lee County FIRM layer

Special flood hazard area

No

Lee County FIRM layer

Floodway

Outside

Lee County FIRM layer

FIRM panel

12071C0439H, effective November 17, 2022

Lee County FIRM panel layer; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer

FIRM community

125124, unincorporated Lee County

Lee County FIRM layer

Fiddlesticks

No A or V zone found anywhere in the community

Parent research

Evacuation zone

Lee County Zone C

Lee County evacuation layer

Storm surge zone

3; the state layer shows Category 3 and Category 4 polygons over the street

FDEM storm surge layer

Elevation certificates

None found

Public sources

What does Zone X mean for a Carriedale Cottages owner?

Zone X is FEMA’s area of minimal flood hazard, outside the special flood hazard area. Property in it carries no federal requirement to buy flood insurance, though a lender may still ask for a policy. FEMA’s point checks at 15621, 15669 and 15685 return the same zone and panel, and parent research found no A or V zone anywhere in Fiddlesticks.

Minimal does not mean none. Heavy rain and drainage can still affect any Florida property, so the flood question for a buyer becomes a pricing choice with an insurance agent rather than a lender mandate.

Do the villas need an elevation certificate?

Not for federal flood rules. No elevation certificates for these villas were found in public sources, and Zone X does not require them for federal flood purposes. An insurer quoting optional flood cover may still ask for one, and a certificate can help the quote. A buyer asks the seller and the association whether one exists before ordering a new survey.

For an attached one-story villa, any certificate would describe the building the unit sits in, so the association is the first place to ask.

What is Carriedale Cottages’ hurricane evacuation zone?

Lee County Evacuation Zone C, surge zone 3, on the county’s evacuation layer. An owner plans to leave whenever Zone C is called. The state’s storm surge layer intersects the street with Category 3 and Category 4 surge-zone polygons, which is consistent with Zone C.

The state’s Know Your Zone tool and Lee County’s emergency pages confirm the zone by address before each season.

What flood paperwork should a Carriedale Cottages buyer ask for?

The seller’s flood disclosure, any elevation certificate, the association’s flood and property policy declarations, and any record of storm claims since 2022. Florida requires a seller of residential property to disclose known flood damage and flood claims. Lee County building records show what was repaired after each storm and are open to search by address in the county’s permit portal.

The FEMA flood layer confirms the zone, and an insurance agent turns it into a premium for the specific villa.

Selling in Carriedale Cottages? Request a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we help buyers in Fiddlesticks Country Club.

How Did Carriedale Cottages Fare in Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton?

No villa-specific damage report for Carriedale Cottages was found in public sources for Hurricane Ian in 2022 or for Helene and Milton in 2024. Lee County’s damage layers show no records on the street, sales continued after Ian at normal prices, and no roof permit was filed after the storm in the searches run. Association-level damage and claims are not confirmed.

Storm

Area record

Carriedale Cottages record

Ian, September 28, 2022

Lee County counts 24,585 residential and 4,690 commercial structures damaged, about $3.22 billion in property loss

County damage layers show no records on the street; association damage and claims not confirmed

Ian, Fort Myers golf clubs

Kelly Greens, Shell Point and The Forest named among badly hit clubs

No report names Fiddlesticks

After Ian

$499,000 sale in November 2022; $475,000 in May 2023

Helene, 2024

Lee County after-action report covers both 2024 storms

No building impact found

Milton, October 9, 2024

EF2 tornado in Fort Myers started about 2.6 miles west and tracked away

No damage tied to Fiddlesticks

2025 and 2026 seasons

No storm affecting the villas found

Did Hurricane Ian damage Carriedale Cottages?

Not on the public record. Ian made landfall in Lee County on September 28, 2022, and the county’s after-action report counts 24,585 damaged residential structures and 4,690 damaged commercial structures countywide, about $3.22 billion in property loss. Lee County’s public damage assessment and damage inventory layers returned no records on Carriedale Ln, and no public document describes damage at Carriedale or Fiddlesticks.

Interior damage or insurance claims at the association level would not show on those layers. A buyer asks the association for its storm and claims history and the minutes from late 2022 and 2023.

Did Carriedale Cottages sales continue after Ian?

Yes. Unit 8C at 15685 closed at $499,000 in November 2022, after the storm, and 15653, unit 5A, closed at $475,000 in May 2023, according to the county sale file. Those prices show no distressed pattern, and no Carriedale roof permit was filed after Ian in the permit searches run.

A sale after a storm does not prove a villa was undamaged, but it shows buyers and lenders were closing on Carriedale Ln while the area recovered. Sales since then are covered in the market sections of this guide.

What happened at other Fort Myers golf clubs?

Golf-industry reports named Kelly Greens, Shell Point and The Forest among the badly hit Fort Myers clubs after Ian (TurfNet). No report read names Fiddlesticks, and the community sits in Zone X with no A or V zone anywhere inside it. That pattern fits the county’s damage layers, which show nothing on Carriedale Ln.

The Long Mean closure that began March 1, 2026 is a planned renovation by Kris Spence, not storm repair, according to the architect’s projects page.

Did Helene or Milton affect Carriedale Cottages?

No building impact was found for either 2024 storm. The National Weather Service rates Milton’s Fort Myers tornado EF2; it started about 2.6 miles west of Carriedale and tracked north-northwest, away from Fiddlesticks (NWS Milton tornado summary). A reporter described possible tornado damage on Daniels Parkway, but no source ties damage to Fiddlesticks.

That report came from Fox Weather. Lee County’s Helene and Milton after-action report covers the county response, and nothing specific was found for the 2025 or 2026 seasons. The association’s minutes and claims records are where a buyer confirms that.

How Does Insurance and Financing Work for a Carriedale Cottages Villa?

Insurance at Carriedale Cottages has two layers: the association’s master policy on the buildings and common elements, paid through the condominium assessment, and each owner’s HO-6 unit policy for interiors, contents and liability. Section 718.111(11) draws the line between them. One listing says insurance is included in the dues, but the master policy’s carrier, deductible and premium are not public.

Question

What is known

Who confirms

Master policy carrier and limits

Not public

The association or Suitor and Associates

Wind and named-storm deductible

Not public

The association

Replacement cost basis

Association may set it by independent appraisal at least once every 3 years, s. 718.111(11)

The association

Owner’s side

Personal property, floor, wall and ceiling coverings, fixtures, appliances, water heaters, cabinets, countertops and window treatments

The declaration; s. 718.111(11)

Building era

1986 to 1987 block and stucco, before the 1994 wind-code tightening and the 2002 Florida Building Code

Lee County building records

Roofs

Fiberglass shingle, 2013 (Section 1) and 2014 (Section 2)

Lee County permits

Flood zone

X, no federal purchase mandate

FEMA; the lender

What does an HO-6 policy cover at Carriedale Cottages?

The owner’s side of the line. Under section 718.111(11), the association policy excludes personal property in the unit and “floor, wall, and ceiling coverings, electrical fixtures, appliances, water heaters, water filters, built-in cabinets and countertops, and window treatments,” which are the owner’s responsibility. A unit owner policy must conform to section 627.714. The declaration fills in the details, so the agent reads it.

The association is not obligated to pay to repair owner-installed improvements that benefit only one unit, under section 718.111(11)(n). Give the agent the county size of the villa, its plan letter, the master policy declarations and any interior upgrades. That is what sets the HO-6 limit.

What is not known about the master policy?

The carrier, the limits, the wind and named-storm deductible and the premium trend are all not public. Those terms drive both the condominium assessment and an owner’s risk after a storm, since a large deductible can come back to owners as an assessment. A buyer asks the manager for the current insurance certificate and master policy declarations, or reads them in the estoppel.

Section 718.111(11) lets the association base coverage on replacement cost set by an independent appraisal at least once every 3 years. We read the deductible against the reserves in the budget, because the two together show what owners would face after a named storm.

Does the building era affect wind insurance?

Yes. The villas are 1986 to 1987 block and stucco buildings, built before the 1994 wind-code tightening and the 2002 Florida Building Code, so wind-mitigation credit depends on later roofs and openings. All eight roofs were replaced with fiberglass shingle in 2013 and 2014, and a 2016 permit replaced the front and side doors at 15621 with impact-rated products for $3,199.

Openings vary villa by villa. A buyer orders a wind-mitigation inspection on the specific villa, and an insurance agent prices the HO-6 policy from that report and the roof dates.

Do Carriedale Cottages owners need flood insurance?

Zone X carries no federal mandatory purchase requirement, though a lender may still require a policy. The association’s master policy covers the buildings, and whether the association also carries building flood cover is not confirmed. Whether an individual owner adds unit flood cover is a decision to make with a licensed insurance agent and a quote in hand.

We get that quote before the inspection period ends, so the cost is known before a buyer goes firm.

Can you get a mortgage on a Carriedale Cottages villa?

Usually, but the lender reviews the condominium as well as the buyer. Expect requests for the budget, reserves, the master insurance policy and any special assessment or litigation. A 2026 listing states that the $150,000 equity membership fee is due at closing, so a financed buyer accounts for it alongside the down payment and closing costs.

The questionnaire the lender sends the association takes time to come back, so we start it at contract signing rather than near closing. Because two condominium sections and the club are involved, we confirm which association answers for the villa’s section.

Which insurance documents should a Carriedale Cottages buyer request?

The association’s current master policy declarations (carrier, limits and wind and named-storm deductible), the reserve schedule or waiver vote, roof permit records, any elevation certificate, the claims history since 2022, the special assessment record in the minutes, and a wind-mitigation report on the villa. An insurance agent and a lender will ask for the same set, so assembling it once saves time.

Our team, among the best real estate agents in Fort Myers, collects that file for buyers during the inspection period and for sellers before a villa goes on the market.

Which Schools Serve a Carriedale Cottages Address?

Carriedale Cottages sits in Lee County elementary Proximity Zone J, middle Proximity Zone MM and high school choice zone South 2 on the district’s 2026-27 School Proximity Zones layer, queried at 15657 Carriedale Ln. Lee County uses choice zones, so a zone code is a starting point, not a single assigned school, and the district’s own lookup settles any address.

Level

Zone on the 2026-27 county layer

How to read it

Elementary

Proximity Zone J

A choice zone, confirmed by address

Middle

Proximity Zone MM

A choice zone, confirmed by address

High school

South 2

A choice zone, not a single school

Source: Lee County GIS and the School District of Lee County, School Proximity Zones 2026-27 layers, queried at the county parcel point for 15657 Carriedale Ln in November 2026. Zone codes are not school names.

Which public schools are in those zones?

Under the district’s 2026-27 Student Enrollment Plan, Zone J lists Colonial, Gateway, Ray V. Pottorf and Treeline elementary schools; Zone MM lists Cypress Lake Middle and Lexington Middle; and South Zone 2 lists Bonita Springs, Cypress Lake, Dunbar, Estero, Fort Myers and South Fort Myers high schools. Those are zone memberships, not an assignment for any one villa, so the School District of Lee County’s School Site Locator is the authority.

District 2025-26 grades: Lexington Middle B, Cypress Lake High A, Fort Myers High A, and the district overall B.

How do you confirm the school zone for a Carriedale Cottages villa?

Enter the full address, for example 15657 Carriedale Ln, Fort Myers, FL 33912, in the School District of Lee County’s School Site Locator. Lee County assigns by choice zone, so the district’s tool, not a map, a listing panel or a neighbor’s experience, decides which schools an address can choose. Run the lookup again before each school year, since zone layers are dated.

An earlier query at 15669 Carriedale Ln returned the same three zones. The county layer we queried is labelled 2026-27, so a lookup for a later year can return different zones.

Are there private schools near Carriedale Cottages?

Two private schools sit near Fiddlesticks, per school directories: Crown of Life Christian Academy at 5820 Daniels Pkwy, Fort Myers 33912, for grades PK to 8, and Canterbury School at 8141 College Pkwy, Fort Myers 33919, for grades PK to 12. Directory entries change, so confirm grades, admissions and tuition with each school directly before relying on them.

Neither school is tied to the villas; both appear in school directories for the area around Fiddlesticks.

How Far Is Carriedale Cottages From the Airport, Hospitals, Shopping and Beaches?

No timed drives have been published for Carriedale Cottages. The figures below are free-flow routing estimates from a Fiddlesticks community point, not from Carriedale Ln itself, so treat them as rough off-season estimates only: about 6.8 minutes to I-75 at Daniels Parkway, 11.7 minutes to Gulf Coast Medical Center, 15.3 minutes to the airport and about 29 to 30 minutes to the beaches.

Destination

Road miles

Free-flow minutes (rough off-season estimate)

I-75 Exit 131 (Daniels Pkwy)

2.67

6.8

Publix, Daniels Crossing (6900 Daniels Pkwy)

4.83

10.5

Lee Health Gulf Coast Medical Center (Level II Trauma Center)

5.67

11.7

Bell Tower Shops

6.49

12.7

Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) terminal

7.98

15.3

Gulf Coast Town Center

7.98

16.1

Miromar Outlets

11.75

18.5

Downtown Fort Myers (River District)

13.90

23.4

Coconut Point (Estero)

15.29

24.9

Sanibel Causeway, Punta Rassa end

16.97

29.0

Fort Myers Beach, Times Square

15.89

29.6

Downtown Naples (Fifth Avenue South)

34.98

46.8

Source: free-flow routing estimates from a Fiddlesticks community point, not timed drives. Add a minute or two for the drive inside the gates and much more from January to April. Time any route that matters to you before you buy.

What is the nearest beach to Carriedale Cottages?

By road, Fort Myers Beach at Times Square is about 15.89 miles and 29.6 minutes away in the free-flow estimate, and the Sanibel Causeway at its Punta Rassa end about 16.97 miles and 29.0 minutes. Both are rough off-season estimates from a Fiddlesticks community point, not timed drives, so allow much more time from January to April, when traffic on the routes west builds.

Fiddlesticks is an inland golf community, so no boat access comes with a villa.

What is the nearest hospital to Carriedale Cottages?

Lee Health Gulf Coast Medical Center, a Level II Trauma Center, is the nearest hospital in the estimates we have, about 5.67 road miles and 11.7 minutes from a Fiddlesticks community point in free-flow traffic. That is a routing estimate, not a timed drive, so know your route before storm season and time it once at a busy hour, especially from January to April.

The route out of the gates runs from Carriedale Ln to Lochmaben Ave and Fiddlesticks Blvd before reaching the main roads.

How far is Carriedale Cottages from the airport?

The Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) terminal is about 7.98 road miles and 15.3 minutes away in the free-flow estimate, and the I-75 interchange at Daniels Parkway, Exit 131, about 2.67 miles and 6.8 minutes. Neither figure is a timed drive. Fiddlesticks sits off Daniels Parkway, so most trips to the airport and the interstate start there, and traffic from January to April adds time.

FDOT is rebuilding Exit 131 as a diverging diamond interchange, with construction from early 2026 to an estimated summer 2028, so expect work zones on that route for now.

Where are groceries and shopping from Carriedale Cottages?

Publix at Daniels Crossing, 6900 Daniels Pkwy, is the closest grocery in the estimates, about 4.83 road miles and 10.5 minutes free-flow. Bell Tower Shops is about 12.7 minutes, Gulf Coast Town Center about 16.1 minutes and Miromar Outlets about 18.5 minutes. All are rough off-season routing estimates from a Fiddlesticks community point, not timed drives, and season traffic adds time.

Inside the gates, the clubhouse, Pub and Patio, Fiddle Inn and the cabana serve club members.

How far is downtown Fort Myers or Naples?

The Downtown Fort Myers River District is roughly 13.90 road miles and 23.4 minutes from Fiddlesticks, Coconut Point in Estero about 24.9 minutes and downtown Naples on Fifth Avenue South about 46.8 minutes, all free-flow routing estimates rather than timed drives. Allow much more from January to April. For the wider city, see our Fort Myers guide.

What Amenities Come With a Carriedale Cottages Villa?

A Carriedale Cottages villa comes with two layers of amenities: the condominium’s own two pool and tennis parcels, one per section, and Fiddlesticks Country Club, where membership is mandatory. The club runs 36 holes, seven Har-Tru tennis courts, eight pickleball courts, two bocce courts, fitness, the cabana and resort pool and four dining venues, behind the Fiddlesticks gatehouse.

Amenity layer

What it includes

How you get it

The condominium

Two “CE: POOL + TENNIS” parcels of 2.18 and 2.609 acres; a garage with every villa

Comes with ownership (county roll; confirm the common-element list with the association)

Fiddlesticks gate and common areas

Gatehouse, 24-hour roving security, common areas, wastewater, TV and internet

Comes with ownership; covered in club dues

Fiddlesticks Country Club

36 holes (Long Mean closed for renovation), seven Har-Tru courts, eight pickleball courts, two bocce courts, fitness, cabana and resort pool, four dining venues

Mandatory Resident Equity membership; $150,000 joining fee from November 1, 2026; dues $2,319.50 a month

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser records (leepa.org) for the association parcels, the Fiddlesticks Membership Information Packet 2026-2027 and the Fiddlesticks Country Club membership page. The association has not published its own amenity list.

Which amenities come with ownership in the villas?

The county roll shows two association parcels coded “CE: POOL + TENNIS,” 2.18 acres for Section I and 2.609 acres for Section II. The roll’s pool flag reads “Y” on all 24 units, which reflects those shared association pools, not private pools. Each villa has its own garage, and every unit is coded “GOLF FRONT.” The association has not published a full amenity list.

Whether Carriedale Gardens owners may use the Cottages pools and courts, or the reverse, is not confirmed; the recorded declarations and the association’s rules settle it. A 2026 listing places 15657 “steps from the Carriedale community pool.”

Do Carriedale Cottages owners have to join Fiddlesticks Country Club?

Yes. Every owner must hold a Resident Equity membership, required on purchase, per the club. The joining fee is $150,000 from November 1, 2026, with $1 refundable, plus a $2,000 real estate transaction fee, and 2026-27 dues are $2,319.50 a month with no food and beverage minimum. Golf, tennis, bocce, pickleball, the clubhouse, fitness and the cabana pool are included in dues.

The buyer and seller steps are on the club’s realtors page.

What does the Fiddlesticks club offer?

Fiddlesticks runs 36 holes on two courses, the Long Mean (Ron Garl, 1983) and Loch Ness (redesigned by Kipp Schulties, reopened January 2019), plus seven Har-Tru tennis courts, eight pickleball courts, two bocce courts, fitness, the cabana and resort pool and four dining venues: Fiddle Inn, Pub and Patio, the Main Dining Room and the Cabana. Dues also cover wastewater, common areas and 24-hour roving security.

A builder’s undated project page describes a 17,500 square foot clubhouse with renovated dining areas and a locker room converted to a card and game room, per Owen-Ames-Kimball.

Is the Long Mean course open?

No. The Long Mean has been closed since March 1, 2026 for a renovation by Kris Spence, and the architect’s own page, read November 18, 2026, still lists it as current work in progress with no completion date. Loch Ness, redesigned by Kipp Schulties and reopened in January 2019, is the course to plan on until the club announces a reopening, and golf stays included in dues throughout.

Details are on Kris Spence Golf Design. In 1986 Golfweek ranked the Long Mean 13th in “Florida’s 50 Best.”

Which course do the villas face?

All 24 villas are coded “GOLF FRONT” on the county roll, but which course and holes each building faces is not confirmed in any public source; the club’s course map or a site visit settles it. A listing for 15667 describes “golf course and landscaped” views, and a 2023 listing for 15647 described “lake views to the north, golf views in all directions.” View varies by building, so we check it villa by villa.

Carriedale Ln sits in the south-central part of the gates, near the clubhouse, cabana and resort pool.

Which amenity claims online are not confirmed?

Several. Listing descriptions say every villa has a two-car attached garage; the county confirms a garage on every unit but not its size. One listing says villa dues cover cable, sewer, trash, water, security, insurance and irrigation, and another lists golf course, grounds, manager, recreation facilities and security; no published budget confirms either. Ask the association and the club before counting on any of these.

Selling in Carriedale Cottages? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 for a valuation built on recorded Carriedale Cottages sales. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see our Fiddlesticks buyer guide.

How Do We Price a Carriedale Cottages Villa?

We price a Carriedale Cottages villa from the county’s recorded sales on the street first, then adjust for plan (A, B or C), condition and updates, the association’s roof and reserve position, and the club cost a buyer carries. With seven qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, a $575,000 median and a range of $500,000 to $665,000, every sale carries weight.

Recorded

Address (unit)

Plan

County size

Price

About $/sq ft

September 1, 2026

15673 (7B)

B

1,827 sq ft

$550,000

301

April 15, 2026

15637 (3B)

B

1,827 sq ft

$549,000

300

March 31, 2026

15643 (4C)

C

2,093 sq ft

$665,000

318

January 5, 2026

15657 (5B)

B

1,827 sq ft

$577,150

316

September 30, 2025

15645 (4B)

B

1,827 sq ft

$500,000

274

July 1, 2025

15647 (4A)

A

1,966 sq ft

$585,000

298

May 3, 2025

15669 (6A)

A

1,966 sq ft

$575,000

292

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser records, the county sale file and 2026 parcel roll, county-qualified sales on the odd side of Carriedale Ln from May 2025 to September 1, 2026. Price per square foot uses county heated area. Owner names are not published here.

Our pricing sequence for a Carriedale Cottages villa:

  • Recorded sales first. We start from the county sale file, not asking prices. The seven qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026 have a $575,000 median, about $300 a county square foot.
  • Plan next. The villas come in three county sizes, 1,827, 1,966 and 2,093 square feet, eight of each. The four B sales in that window have a $549,500 median; the two A sales recorded $575,000 and $585,000; the one C sale recorded $665,000.
  • Position and view. Every unit is coded golf front, but which holes each building faces, and whether B is the middle unit in every building, is not confirmed, so we check each villa on site.
  • Condition. Remodels, finishes and systems are priced unit by unit after an inspection.
  • Roofs and reserves. The roofs date from 2013 and 2014, so the association’s roof reserve, or any waiver, goes into the math, because a buyer will ask.
  • Club and fees. The $150,000 joining fee is about one quarter, about 26 percent, of the $575,000 median, and buyers price it in.

What does a Carriedale Cottages villa sell for per square foot?

On the seven qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, about $274 to about $318 per county heated square foot, with a median of about $300, set by 15637 (3B). The high end was 15643 (4C), a 2,093 square foot C unit, and the low end 15645 (4B), a 1,827 square foot B unit. Listing measurements differ from county ones, so we always compare on county area.

A 2023 listing for 15647 gave 1,996 square feet for an A unit the county records at 1,966.

How do the three floor plans compare on price?

On the recent record, the B plan of 1,827 square feet has the most evidence: four sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026 with a $549,500 median. The A plan of 1,966 square feet had two, at $575,000 and $585,000, a $580,000 median. The C plan of 2,093 square feet had one, the $665,000 sale of 15643 in March 2026, the top Cottages sale on record.

On the 2026 roll, the plan medians run $323,913 for B, $390,773 for A and $407,188 for C.

Are Carriedale Cottages prices rising or falling?

Steady on the recent record, after a large climb. The three 2025 sales have a $575,000 median and the four 2026 sales a $563,575 median. The same unit, 15673, sold for $551,000 in 2024 and $550,000 in 2026, $1,000 lower, while 15647 went from $550,500 in 2023 to $585,000 in 2025, $34,500 higher. Over a longer span, 15657 rose from $190,000 in May 2019 to $577,150 in January 2026.

The 2026 set holds three B units and one C unit, so part of any gap between years is the mix of plans, not only the market.

How many Carriedale Cottages villas sell each year?

Few, in a condominium of 24 villas. The county file shows three qualified sales in 2025, 6A in May, 4A in July and 4B in September, and four in 2026 through September 1: 5B in January, 4C in March, 3B in April and 7B in September. With so thin a record, one sale can move the median, so we read each one individually.

Earlier sales on the county file run back to the first transfers of 1986 to 1988; non-qualified transfers of $0 and $100 are left out of every figure here.

Why is the county’s just value lower than the sale prices?

The 2026 median just value of a Carriedale Cottages unit is $390,773, while the qualified sale median from May 2025 to September 1, 2026 is $575,000. Just value is the county’s assessment, not a sale price, and it lags the market and treats units by formula. We treat it as one reference point and price from recorded sales, adjusted for the specific villa.

Unit just values on the 2026 roll range from $320,574 to $410,844 across the 24 units, a total of $9,035,451 and an average of $376,477.

Why not price Carriedale Cottages from Fiddlesticks or Fort Myers averages?

Fiddlesticks holds 585 homes across villa, condominium and detached products, and Fort Myers averages mix every size and age. Even the same street does not match: Carriedale Gardens, across the lane, recorded 2025 to 2026 sales of $100,000 to $327,500 for two-story garden condos. Few products match a one-story, three-bedroom, golf-front villa with a garage, so we price from the villas’ own sales.

For the wider market, see our Fort Myers guide, and for a unit-specific number, our Fort Myers home valuation.

Selling in Carriedale Cottages? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610.

How Do You Buy in Carriedale Cottages, Step by Step?

Buying in Carriedale Cottages starts with the recorded sales for your target plan, then moves through the condominium documents, the club’s equity application, the current fees, flood and insurance quotes, an inspection of the villa and the association’s roof and reserve records, the rental and pet rules, and closing. Each step has a document behind it, and the association, its manager or the club holds most of them.

  1. Study the recorded sales. Compare the qualified sales by plan, A, B or C, not asking prices.
  2. Request the documents. Ask for the declaration of the villa’s section, Carriedale Cottages Section I or Section II, the bylaws, rules, current budget, the reserve schedule or any waiver vote, insurance declarations, minutes and any special assessment notice.
  3. Get the current fees. No association budget is public; listings report $2,500 a quarter, so an estoppel letter from the association and one from the club give today’s numbers.
  4. File the club paperwork. The buyer files the Resident Equity application and a background-check form; the $150,000 joining fee and the $2,000 transaction fee are due at closing.
  5. Get flood and insurance quotes. The street is in FEMA Zone X and Evacuation Zone C.
  6. Inspect. Inspect the villa, its roof age and openings, and review the association’s reserve records.
  7. Read the rental and pet rules. The club sets a 30-day minimum rental; the condominium’s own leasing and pet rules are in its declaration.
  8. Close. Close once both estoppel letters and the club’s approval are in hand, and ask the club how gatehouse access is set up for a new owner.

To start, call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see our Fiddlesticks buyer guide.

Which documents should a Carriedale Cottages buyer request?

Request the recorded declaration for the villa’s section, Carriedale Cottages Section I at Official Records Book 1871, Page 443 for units 1A to 4C, or Section II at Book 1923, Page 2227 for units 5A to 8C, plus the bylaws and rules, the current budget, the reserve schedule or any waiver vote, the master insurance declarations, recent minutes and any special assessment notice. Ask under the legal name, not the MLS name “Carriedale.”

The state register still lists two per-section associations in care of Suitor and Associates, while Sunbiz shows one active Carriedale Cottages Condominium Association, Inc.; which one operates both condominiums is not confirmed, so ask the association or Suitor and Associates who holds the records. The role of Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc., listed as “Carriedale HOA” in the club packet, is not confirmed either.

Do the club and the association approve Carriedale Cottages buyers?

The club does. A buyer files the Resident Equity application and a background-check form, with no buyer fee for the check, and the seller notifies the gatehouse of the listing agent and files a Notice of New Contract with the executed contract. The condominium’s own approval terms sit in its recorded declarations, and Florida caps an association’s approval fee at $150 per applicant, adjusted for inflation every five years.

Federal and Florida fair housing law applies to any approval process. File early, because closing waits on approval.

What should a Carriedale Cottages buyer budget for in fees?

Budget for the $150,000 joining fee and $2,000 transaction fee at closing, club dues of $2,319.50 a month, a $295 monthly Capital Improvement Assessment tied to the property, and a listing-reported condominium assessment of $2,500 a quarter, about $833 a month. Together the monthly items come to about $3,448 a month before property tax and insurance. Confirm every figure with estoppel letters.

The capital assessment can also be paid as $26,500 at once or $9,365 a year for three years. Listing “HOA” fields of $2,174 to $2,175 and $2,327 track the club’s dues, not the condominium fee. There is no CDD. For one non-homesteaded villa, 15667, the 2026 TRIM notice proposes $3,820.99 in taxes.

What should a buyer know about flood and insurance?

Lee County’s FEMA flood layer places the whole street in Zone X, an area of minimal flood hazard, outside the floodway, on panel 12071C0439H effective November 17, 2022, and research found no A or V zone anywhere in Fiddlesticks. The villas are in Evacuation Zone C, surge zone 3. Zone X carries no federal flood mandate, though lenders may still require a policy.

Under s. 718.111(11), the association’s policy excludes items such as floor, wall and ceiling coverings, appliances, water heaters and cabinets, which the unit owner insures. The master carrier and deductible are not confirmed, so ask the association for the insurance declarations and an insurance agent for HO-6 and wind quotes. The Lee County FIRM layer shows the zone.

What should an inspection cover at Carriedale Cottages?

Inspect the villa itself, including the roof, air conditioning, windows and doors, lanai and plumbing. Lee County permits show fiberglass shingle tear-offs on Section I in 2013 and Section II in 2014, about 12 to 13 years old in 2026, and no later roof permit surfaced in the searches run. The buildings predate the 1994 wind-code tightening and the 2002 Florida Building Code, so openings matter for wind-mitigation credit.

Then read the association’s records: reserves for roof, paint and paving, and minutes about Ian, Helene and Milton. Association-level storm damage and claims are not confirmed; Lee County building records and the association’s files hold the detail.

How Does Carriedale Cottages Compare With Other Fiddlesticks Villas?

Carriedale Cottages stands out among Fiddlesticks villa products as 24 one-story, three-bedroom, golf-front villas with garages, at a 2026 median roll value of $390,773 that sits below Turnberry Villas’ $480,936 and above Berriedale’s $326,979 and Glen Abbey Condominium Ph I’s $281,561. Every product inside the gates carries the same $150,000 club joining fee.

Community

Where

Product

Honest difference vs Carriedale Cottages

Carriedale Cottages

Odd side, 15621 to 15685 Carriedale Ln

24 one-story attached villas, 1986 and 1987

This guide; 1,827 to 2,093 sq ft; qualified median $575,000 (May 2025 to September 1, 2026)

Carriedale Gardens

Even side, 15626 to 15676 Carriedale Ln

28 two-story garden condos, 1985 to 1986

1,143 to 1,547 sq ft; 2025 to 2026 recorded sales $100,000 to $327,500

Glen Abbey Condominium Ph I

Fiddlesticks, on Loch Ness

24 coach villas, 1991 to 1992, with garages

Median roll $281,561; six 2025 to 2026 condo sales $220,000 to $385,000 (median $336,875)

Turnberry Villas (Glen Abbey Ph II and III)

Fiddlesticks

30 detached one-story homes, 1999 to 2002

2,076 to 2,569 sq ft; median roll $480,936; 2025 to 2026 sales $537,500 to $550,000

Berriedale

Fiddlesticks

11 attached villas from 1983

Fee simple rather than condo; median roll $326,979

Winding Stream at Spring Run

Estero

Two-story garden condos with bundled golf

Golf included at about $9,820 a year and no large joining fee

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser records for Carriedale Cottages and Carriedale Gardens, the Florida DBPR condominium file, and our Fiddlesticks research for the other villa products. For the whole community, see our Fiddlesticks Country Club guide.

How does Carriedale Cottages compare with Glen Abbey Condominium Ph I?

Glen Abbey Condominium Ph I is 24 coach villas from 1991 to 1992 with garages, on the Loch Ness course, with a median roll value of $281,561 and six 2025 to 2026 condo sales of $220,000 to $385,000, a $336,875 median. Carriedale Cottages is older, built in 1986 and 1987, every villa one story with three bedrooms, at a higher median roll value of $390,773.

Both carry the same mandatory club membership. See our Glen Abbey at Fiddlesticks guide for its recorded sales.

How does Carriedale Cottages compare with Turnberry Villas?

Turnberry Villas, recorded as Glen Abbey Ph II and III, is 30 detached one-story homes from 1999 to 2002, of 2,076 to 2,569 square feet, with a median roll value of $480,936 and 2025 to 2026 sales of $537,500 to $550,000. That makes it newer and detached at a similar price to the villas, which are attached, older and 1,827 to 2,093 square feet.

The practical trade is a shared wall and condominium ownership against a detached home on its own.

How does Carriedale Cottages compare with Berriedale?

Berriedale is 11 attached villas from 1983, held in fee simple rather than as a condominium, with a median roll value of $326,979. Carriedale Cottages is a Chapter 718 condominium with its own declarations, budget and reserves, which brings condominium rules on reserves and insurance that a fee simple villa does not carry. Berriedale’s sales were not compared in our research.

Both sit inside the same gate with the same club membership.

How does a bundled-golf community like Winding Stream compare?

Winding Stream at Spring Run in Estero is two-story garden condos with golf included at about $9,820 a year and no large joining fee. It is a different product, outside Fiddlesticks, but it answers the same wish for golf plus low exterior upkeep. Carriedale Cottages trades a $150,000 joining fee and $2,319.50 monthly club dues for one-story, golf-front villas inside an equity club.

Selling in Carriedale Cottages? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610.

Carriedale Cottages vs Carriedale Gardens: Which Carriedale Lane Condominium Should You Choose?

Carriedale Cottages vs Carriedale Gardens comes down to building type, size and price. Both condominiums sit on Carriedale Lane behind the same Fiddlesticks gate, with the same manager and the same club. Carriedale Cottages holds 24 one-story, three-bedroom villas on the odd side; Carriedale Gardens, a separate condominium with its own MLS name, holds 28 two-story garden condos on the even side.

Decision factor

Carriedale Cottages

Carriedale Gardens

Addresses

15621 to 15685 Carriedale Ln (odd side)

15626 to 15676 Carriedale Ln (even side)

Recorded as a condominium

Section I September 29, 1986; Section II June 16, 1987

March 22, 1985

Built

1986 and 1987

1985 to 1986

Homes

24 one-story villas in eight three-unit buildings

28 garden condos in two-story buildings

Sizes (county)

1,827, 1,966 and 2,093 sq ft, all 3 bedrooms with a garage

1,143 to 1,547 sq ft

Recent recorded sales

7 qualified sales, May 2025 to September 1, 2026, $500,000 to $665,000, median $575,000

2025 to 2026 sales of $100,000 to $327,500 across 12 parcels

Association pool land

Two pool and tennis parcels, 2.18 and 2.609 acres

One pool parcel, 3.51 acres

Manager

Suitor and Associates

Same

MLS name

“Carriedale”

Its own MLS name

Club

Mandatory Resident Equity membership

Same club and gate

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser records and the Florida DBPR condominium file. Each is its own condominium with its own association and documents. See our Carriedale Gardens guide for its full record.

Which condominium has the larger homes?

Carriedale Cottages. Its smallest villa is 1,827 county square feet and its largest 2,093, every one with three bedrooms and a garage, while Carriedale Gardens’ units run 1,143 to 1,547 square feet. A buyer who wants a smaller footprint, or the lower price that comes with it, will find it across the lane; a buyer who wants three bedrooms on one level with a garage starts on the odd side.

How far apart are their prices?

Far enough that they are separate markets. The villas’ seven qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026 ran $500,000 to $665,000 with a $575,000 median, while Carriedale Gardens’ 2025 to 2026 recorded sales ran $100,000 to $327,500 across 12 parcels. We never blend the two into one street figure, because a lane-wide average would misprice both products.

The county legal description, not a listing label, settles which condominium a unit belongs to; one aggregator has labelled a Gardens unit as Carriedale Cottages.

What do Carriedale Cottages and Carriedale Gardens share?

Both sit on Carriedale Lane inside the Fiddlesticks gates, near the clubhouse, cabana and resort pool, under the same manager, Suitor and Associates, with the same mandatory club membership and $150,000 joining fee. A street-wide Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc. also exists, though its role is not confirmed. Each is a separate condominium with its own declaration, board and budget.

Whether owners of one may use the other’s pools and courts is not confirmed, so ask the association.

What Are the Honest Pros and Cons of Carriedale Cottages?

Carriedale Cottages’ main advantages are one-story, three-bedroom villas of 1,827 to 2,093 square feet, every one golf front with a garage, FEMA Zone X, no milestone inspection or SIRS, roofs replaced in 2013 and 2014, and a full club. Its main drawbacks are the $150,000 joining fee and $2,319.50 monthly club dues, an unpublished condominium budget, aging roofs with unconfirmed reserves, and a pre-1994 build.

Pros

Every villa one story, three bedrooms, with a garage

All 24 units coded “GOLF FRONT” on the county roll

Three plans of 1,827, 1,966 and 2,093 square feet

FEMA Zone X, minimal flood hazard; Evacuation Zone C

One-story buildings: no milestone inspection or SIRS

Fiberglass shingle roof tear-offs in 2013 and 2014

Club: 36 holes, seven Har-Tru courts, eight pickleball courts, fitness, resort pool, four dining venues; no CDD

Cons

$150,000 joining fee from November 1, 2026, about 26 percent of the $575,000 median

Club dues $2,319.50 a month plus a $295 monthly capital assessment; about $3,448 a month before tax and insurance

Condominium budget not public; the $2,500 quarterly assessment is listing-reported

Roofs about 12 to 13 years old in 2026; reserve funding or waiver not confirmed

Built 1986 and 1987, before the 1994 wind code and the 2002 Florida Building Code

Long Mean closed since March 1, 2026, with no reopening date

Thin sales record; club 30-day minimum rental

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser, Lee County GIS, Lee County permit records, Florida Statutes 718.112, the Fiddlesticks 2026-27 membership packet and dated listing pages.

What is the biggest risk for a Carriedale Cottages buyer?

An unplanned cost is the biggest risk. The roofs were about 12 to 13 years old in 2026, owners may waive roof, paint and paving reserves by majority vote, and whether Carriedale funds or waives them is not confirmed. On top of that, the club’s Capital Improvement Assessment runs $295 a month for 120 months and stays with the property. Read the budget, reserves and minutes before the document review ends.

The second risk is paperwork: the only condominium fee and lease figures are listing-reported, so the association supplies the current ones.

Is the 2026 dip in the median a bargain or a warning?

Neither, on the record alone. The 2026 median of $563,575 sits below the 2025 median of $575,000, but the 2026 set holds three B units and the one C sale, the $665,000 record, so the mix of plans drives much of it. The same B unit, 15673, sold for $551,000 in 2024 and $550,000 in 2026, which reads as steady, not falling.

Compare same-plan sales, the association’s reserves and the insurance quote before deciding what a given price means.

What do the villas offer, and what do they not offer?

The villas offer one-level space of 1,827 to 2,093 square feet with three bedrooms and a garage, every unit golf front, inside an equity club. A buyer who wants one-story living on the course will find all 24 villas single-story and golf-front. A buyer who needs nightly rental income will not find it under the club’s 30-day minimum, and a buyer who wants a private pool or boat access will not find either here.

Selling in Carriedale Cottages? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or start with our Fiddlesticks seller guide. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610.

What Is Changing Around Carriedale Cottages?

The changes that matter around Carriedale Cottages: the club joining fee rose to $150,000 on November 1, 2026; a Capital Improvement Assessment began September 1, 2026 for the Cabana, Clubhouse and Gatehouse; the Long Mean has been closed since March 1, 2026; the Three Oaks Parkway extension opened November 2, 2026; and 2026 qualified sales recorded from $549,000 to $665,000.

What does the higher joining fee mean for buyers?

The Resident Equity joining fee climbed from $65,000 in 2021-22 to $90,000 in 2023, $115,000 in 2025-26 and $150,000 from November 1, 2026, a $35,000 rise in the latest step. At $150,000 it equals about one quarter, about 26 percent, of the $575,000 median sale, and only $1 of it is refundable. Buyers weigh it against the villa price, so it shapes what a seller can ask.

The fee is set in the 2026-27 membership packet.

What is the club’s Capital Improvement Assessment paying for?

From September 1, 2026, every property carries a Capital Improvement Assessment of $295 a month for 120 months, $26,500 as a lump sum, or $9,365 a year for three years. It funds the Cabana kitchen expansion, started in August 2026, the Clubhouse renovation from May 2027 and Gatehouse improvements in Spring 2028. It is tied to the property, not the owner, so it passes to the buyer.

Ask the club’s estoppel for the balance left on any villa you are pricing.

When does the Long Mean reopen?

No reopening date has been published. The Long Mean closed on March 1, 2026 for a renovation by Kris Spence, built by Clark Golf Course Construction with Bimini Bermuda surfaces and Tif3D greens, and the architect’s page still listed it as current work in progress on November 18, 2026. Loch Ness, reopened in January 2019, carries play meanwhile. Ask the club for the current schedule.

What road work is under way near Fiddlesticks?

The Three Oaks Parkway extension’s north end opened on November 2, 2026, with a new intersection at Three Oaks Parkway and Fiddlesticks Boulevard, and final completion is scheduled for early 2027, per WGCU. Daniels Parkway has been widened to eight lanes, and FDOT is rebuilding I-75 Exit 131 as a diverging diamond interchange.

The Exit 131 work runs from early 2026 to an estimated summer 2028, at about $42.8 million.

What do the 2026 Carriedale Cottages sales show?

Four qualified sales recorded in 2026: 15657 (5B) at $577,150 in January, 15643 (4C) at $665,000 in March, the top Cottages sale on record, 15637 (3B) at $549,000 in April, and 15673 (7B) at $550,000 on September 1, the latest found, for a $563,575 median. 15657 had been advertised at $595,000 before its sale. No association news, special assessment or litigation was found, though that is not confirmed either way.

One villa, 15667 (6B), was asking $529,000 on November 18, 2026, after an earlier asking price of $599,000 in February 2026.

When will the Carriedale Cottages roofs need attention?

Not on a published schedule. The current fiberglass shingle roofs date from tear-offs in 2013 on Section I and 2014 on Section II, about 12 to 13 years old in 2026, and no later roof permit surfaced in the searches run, which were not a full census. Whether the association funds a roof reserve or has waived it is not confirmed, so the budget and minutes are where the answer lives.

As one-story buildings, the villas need no milestone inspection or structural integrity reserve study under Fla. Stat. 718.112 and the DBPR milestone and SIRS page, but roof, paint and paving reserves still apply unless owners vote to waive them.

Selling in Carriedale Cottages? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 for a valuation built on recorded Carriedale Cottages sales, or start with our Fiddlesticks home valuation. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610.

Thinking of Selling Your Carriedale Cottages Villa? List With the #1 Team in Southwest Florida Since 2012

Selling a villa in Carriedale Cottages well means pricing it on the recorded Lee County sales of villas like yours, by plan and size, presenting the one-story layout, the garage and the golf-front setting inside Fiddlesticks Country Club as the assets they are, and answering the club joining fee, club dues, Capital Improvement Assessment, condo assessment, roof age, reserve, flood zone, evacuation zone and rental rule questions up front. McGreevy and Comisar have done this for Southwest Florida owners for more than a decade as the #1 team in the region.

If you’re searching for a Carriedale Cottages listing agent, or thinking, ‘I need someone to sell my Carriedale villa…’, McGreevy and Comisar helps homeowners price, market, negotiate and sell with a local strategy built for Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples, Lee County, Collier County and Babcock Ranch. Whether your villa is the A plan of 1,966 square feet, the B plan of 1,827 square feet or the C plan of 2,093 square feet, in Section I or Section II of the condominium, our team provides local market guidance, professional listing exposure and a clear plan to help you sell confidently.

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026)
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Carriedale Cottages sold-market statistics we tracked: 7 qualified sales in Lee County Property Appraiser records from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, $500,000 to $665,000, a $575,000 median; about $274 to about $318 per county heated square foot, a median of about $300; 4 sales of the 1,827 square foot B plan at a $549,500 median, 2 of the 1,966 square foot A plan at a $580,000 median and 1 of the 2,093 square foot C plan at $665,000; 3 sales in 2025 at a $575,000 median and 4 in 2026 at a $563,575 median; and a condominium record of $665,000 for 15643, unit 4C, in March 2026, about $318 a square foot. The newest qualified sale in the county file is 15673, unit 7B, at $550,000 on September 1, 2026. Days on market and sale-to-list ratio are read from the regional multiple listing service for your villa when we prepare your pricing.

Selling in Carriedale Cottages is different. Your buyer is choosing a one-story, three-bedroom villa with a garage in a three-unit building inside gated Fiddlesticks Country Club, where every owner must hold a Resident Equity membership and the joining fee is $150,000 from November 1, 2026. The buyer will ask about the condo assessment, the club dues, the Capital Improvement Assessment, the roof ages, reserves, Zone X, Evacuation Zone C, Hurricane Ian and the rental rules. We gather those answers before the villa goes live.

What Is Your Carriedale Cottages Villa Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds. Start your free Fiddlesticks home valuation, a free Fort Myers home valuation or use our Southwest Florida home valuation form.

(239) 898-6072, text or call. Want the complete seller’s guide? Read our Sell Your Home in Fiddlesticks Country Club and Sell Your Home in Fort Myers pages for pricing strategy, marketing and the full McGreevy and Comisar listing process, and our selling overview.

How quickly do Carriedale Cottages villas sell?

The Lee County record shows when a sale was recorded, not how long the villa was on the market. It shows 7 qualified sales at Carriedale Cottages from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, 3 in 2025 and 4 in 2026, in a condominium of 24 villas. That is a steady but thin pace, so we read days on market for villas like yours from the regional multiple listing service when we prepare your pricing.

What will a buyer ask about my Carriedale Cottages villa?

A Carriedale Cottages buyer will ask how the villas differ from Carriedale Gardens across the lane, what the condo assessment, club dues and Capital Improvement Assessment total, how the $150,000 joining fee is paid, how old the roofs are, whether the association funds reserves, what the rental and pet rules say, and how the street sits in flood Zone X and Evacuation Zone C. We gather the association’s and the club’s current documents before the villa goes live.

Does a golf view matter to my price?

It can, and buyers look at it first. The county codes all 24 villas “GOLF FRONT,” and listing pages describe golf course and landscaped views at 15667 and lake views to the north with golf views in all directions at 15647. Which course and holes each building faces is not in the county record, so we price yours from recorded sales of the same plan and show the view from the lanai in photography.

Did Hurricane Ian change how Carriedale Cottages villas sell?

Not in a way the sale record shows. Sales continued after the storm: 15685 closed at $499,000 in November 2022, and 15647 at $550,500 and 15653 at $475,000 in spring 2023, according to Lee County Property Appraiser records. County damage layers show no records on the street, and association-level damage and claims are not confirmed, so we pair the association’s records with your own and present them to buyers plainly.

What does it cost to sell a Carriedale Cottages villa?

A Carriedale Cottages seller typically pays the brokerage commission agreed in the listing agreement, Florida documentary stamp tax on the recorded deed where it applies under section 201.02, prorated taxes, condo assessment and club dues, and any estoppel charge the association or the club sets. The club lists a $2,000 real estate transaction fee. Who pays each charge is a contract term. Our Fiddlesticks seller guide has a full net sheet.

Your Local Real Estate Experts

McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, are the local real estate experts for Carriedale Cottages, Fiddlesticks Country Club and Fort Myers: Jesse McGreevy leads listing and seller strategy, Marc Comisar leads buyer representation and negotiation, and as the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate across Southwest Florida.

Jesse McGreevy is a top-reviewed Carriedale Cottages realtor, and the reviews below are quoted exactly as clients wrote them on our Google Business Profile. We do not edit, combine or summarize client words.

★★★★★ “Jesse was very professional, helpful and kept in touch with ideas and suggestions which developed into a sale. Highly recommend his company for their excellent follow through.” Verified Google review

★★★★★ “We had been on the market for several months with no offers. When we signed with Marc our house was sold in 2 weeks. He has a unique system for selling homes.” Verified Google review

★★★★★ “He knew the area and therefore knew exactly where to take us to find the exact kind of neighborhood we were looking for and he was right on the money.” Verified Google review

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners
  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 · [email protected]
  • Marc Comisar: (239) 457-1610
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC). Florida license numbers: Jesse McGreevy SL3101296, Marc Comisar BK3060671.

Meet Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, read more about McGreevy and Comisar, see our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers, or contact us. To explore the community around Carriedale Cottages, visit our Fiddlesticks Country Club guide.

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.

Frequently Asked Questions, Buyer Edition

Carriedale Cottages buyers ask most often how the villas differ from Carriedale Gardens, what they sell for, how big they are, the mandatory club membership and joining fee, the club dues and the Capital Improvement Assessment, the condo assessment, rentals and pets, the flood and evacuation zones, Hurricane Ian, roof ages and reserves, and how the villas compare with other Fiddlesticks villas. Each answer below draws on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale files, Lee County GIS and permit records, the Florida DBPR condominium extract, Fiddlesticks Country Club’s own documents and the Florida Statutes, with listing-reported figures labeled as such. To start your search across the area, see our Fiddlesticks buyer guide, our Fort Myers buyer guide, our Fort Myers community guide and our Fiddlesticks Country Club guide.

What is Carriedale Cottages at Fiddlesticks?

Carriedale Cottages is 24 one-story attached villas in eight three-unit buildings at odd addresses 15621 to 15685 Carriedale Ln, Fort Myers, FL 33912, inside gated Fiddlesticks Country Club off Daniels Parkway, in unincorporated Lee County. Buildings 1 to 4 were built in 1986 and Buildings 5 to 8 in 1987. Every villa has three bedrooms and a garage, every one is coded golf front, and every owner must join the club.

Is Carriedale Cottages the same as Carriedale Gardens?

No. They are separate condominiums on the same lane. Carriedale Gardens, recorded March 22, 1985, is 28 two-story garden condos of 1,143 to 1,547 square feet on the even side, 15626 to 15676, built 1985 to 1986, with its own pool parcel and its own MLS name. The county legal description, not a listing label, settles which one a unit belongs to. See our Carriedale Gardens guide.

Why is Carriedale Cottages recorded as two condominiums?

Because it was declared in two sections. Carriedale Cottages Section I, 12 units in Buildings 1 to 4, was recorded September 29, 1986 at Official Records Book 1871, Page 443, and Section II, 12 units in Buildings 5 to 8, was recorded June 16, 1987 at Book 1923, Page 2227. The state register names Fiddlesticks, Ltd. as developer of Section I and Banyan Group, Inc. N. as developer of Section II.

How big are the villas in Carriedale Cottages?

County records list three plans, eight of each, all three bedrooms on one story with a garage: the A plan of 1,966 square feet with 2.5 baths, the B plan of 1,827 square feet with 2 baths, and the C plan of 2,093 square feet with 2.5 baths. Listing descriptions add block and stucco construction, two-car attached garages, screened or enclosed lanais and split bedrooms, which are listing-reported features.

Is the B villa always the middle unit?

That is not confirmed. In all eight buildings the B unit’s street number falls between the A and C numbers, and a 2023 listing calls unit 4A an end unit in a building of three, but the county roll cannot show physical order. The declaration plot plans recorded at Official Records Book 1871, Page 443 and Book 1923, Page 2227, held by the Lee County Clerk, show the layout.

Why do listing square footages differ from the county figures?

Because listing pages use other measurements. A 2023 listing for 15647, an A villa, gave a larger square footage than the county’s 1,966 and counted three baths, two full and one half. The county heated area is the consistent figure across all 24 villas, so compare villas, and price per square foot, on county figures and treat listing figures as marketing measurements.

What do Carriedale Cottages villas sell for?

Lee County Property Appraiser records show 7 qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, from $500,000 to $665,000, at a $575,000 median, or about $274 to about $318 per county heated square foot, a median of about $300. The newest was 15673, a B villa, at $550,000 on September 1, 2026. The villa at 15667 was asking $529,000 in November 2026, an asking price, not a sale.

What is the highest price recorded in Carriedale Cottages?

The record is $665,000 for 15643, unit 4C, a 2,093 square foot C villa, recorded March 31, 2026, about $318 a county heated square foot, according to Lee County Property Appraiser records. Before 2022 the high was $435,000 for 15661 in March 2008. The C plan recorded only that one qualified sale from May 2025 to September 1, 2026.

How do 2026 prices compare with 2025?

They run close. The 3 qualified sales in 2025 carried a $575,000 median, and the 4 in 2026 through September 1 a $563,575 median, according to the county sale file. The same villa, 15673, sold for $551,000 in 2024 and $550,000 in 2026, $1,000 lower, while 15647 sold for $550,500 in 2023 and $585,000 in 2025, $34,500 higher. These are readings of the record, not forecasts.

Do I have to join Fiddlesticks Country Club?

Yes. Every Fiddlesticks owner must hold a Resident Equity membership, and the club’s membership page says membership is required on purchase. Buyers file the club’s equity application and a background-check form, with no buyer fee for the check. Fiddlesticks has 585 homes and 36 holes, has been a club since 1982, and the club corporation is also the master association for the community.

How much is the Fiddlesticks joining fee?

$150,000 from November 1, 2026, up $35,000 from $115,000, with $1 refundable and a $2,000 real estate transaction fee. The fee was $65,000 in the club’s 2021-22 options sheet and $90,000 on a 2023 Carriedale listing. Against the $575,000 median Carriedale Cottages sale, the new fee is about 26 percent, about one quarter, of the price. A 2026 listing states the fee is due at closing.

What are the Fiddlesticks club dues?

Dues for 2026-27 are $2,319.50 a month, about $27,834 a year: $1,730 operating, $383 capital, $100 road reserve, $44 wastewater and $62.50 for TV and internet. There is no food and beverage minimum. The club says dues cover wastewater, common areas, 24-hour roving security, golf, tennis, bocce, pickleball, the clubhouse, fitness and the cabana pool.

What is the Capital Improvement Assessment?

A club charge from September 1, 2026, tied to the property rather than the owner: $295 a month for 120 months, a $26,500 lump sum, or $9,365 a year for three years. It funds the Cabana kitchen expansion, started August 2026, the Clubhouse renovation from May 2027 and Gatehouse improvements in Spring 2028. Because it runs with the villa, ask the club which option applies to the villa you are considering.

What are the condo fees at Carriedale Cottages?

The association does not publish a budget. 2026 listing pages report the condo assessment at $2,500 a quarter, about $833 a month or $10,000 a year, up from $1,640 a quarter on a 2023 listing. Listing “HOA” fields of $2,174 to $2,175 and $2,327 a month track club dues, not the condo fee. With club dues and the capital charge, carrying cost runs about $3,448 a month before tax and insurance.

Is there a CDD at Carriedale Cottages?

None. The county roll places the villas in the South Trail Fire District with no community development district, and the charges that apply are the condo assessment, the club dues and the club’s Capital Improvement Assessment. Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc., formed in 1984, spans the street, but its role and any assessment are not confirmed, so ask Suitor and Associates or read an estoppel letter.

What are property taxes on a Carriedale Cottages villa?

They depend on the villa’s assessed value and exemptions. The 2026 TRIM notice for 15667, unit 6B, with no exemptions, shows 2025 taxes of $3,523.92 at 13.4125 mills and proposed 2026 taxes of $3,820.99 at 13.3738 mills, about $297 higher, on an assessed value of $261,020 after a $62,637 limitation benefit. A listing shows $3,890. Your assessment resets after you buy, so ask the Lee County Property Appraiser for an estimate.

What amenities come with a Carriedale Cottages villa?

Carriedale Cottages owns two association pool and tennis parcels, one per section, of 2.18 and 2.609 acres, and the county’s pool flag on every villa reflects those shared pools. Club dues add seven Har-Tru tennis courts, eight pickleball courts, two bocce courts, fitness, the cabana and resort pool, and four dining venues. Carriedale Ln sits near the clubhouse, cabana and resort pool.

Is the Long Mean course open?

Not in November 2026. The Long Mean, a 1983 Ron Garl design ranked 13th in Golfweek’s 1986 “Florida’s 50 Best,” has been closed since March 1, 2026 for a renovation by Kris Spence, whose own projects page lists it as current work with no reopening date. The Loch Ness course was redesigned by Kipp Schulties and reopened in January 2019.

Can I rent out a Carriedale Cottages villa?

Only within limits. The club’s 2026-27 renter rules set a 30-day minimum in half or full month increments, a $100 background check per adult renter, renter privileges at $2,457 a month plus tax, and a Section K form the landlord files with the lease. A 2023 listing cited up to 12 leases a year, which is not confirmed. A buyer who needs nightly rental income will not find it under the club’s 30-day minimum.

Are pets allowed at Carriedale Cottages?

Listing pages mark pets as “allowed” or “call, conditional,” listing-reported labels that are not confirmed from the condominium’s declarations or rules. Rules can change by owner vote, so read the current declarations and rules from the association before you make an offer. Federal and Florida law govern requests for assistance animals, and the association handles those requests under that law.

Is Carriedale Cottages gated?

Yes. The villas sit inside Fiddlesticks Country Club, a gated community of 585 homes off Daniels Parkway, and visitors check in at the Fiddlesticks gatehouse. Club dues include 24-hour roving security, and the club’s Capital Improvement Assessment funds Gatehouse improvements planned for Spring 2028. Ask the club about gate access, guest passes and vendor rules for move-ins and contractors.

Is Carriedale Cottages in a flood zone?

Not a high-risk one. Lee County’s FEMA flood layer places the whole street in Zone X, an area of minimal flood hazard outside the special flood hazard area, on panel 12071C0439H effective November 17, 2022, and no A or V zone appears anywhere in Fiddlesticks. Zone X carries no federal flood-insurance mandate, though a lender may still require a policy. No elevation certificates for these villas were found in public sources.

Do you have to evacuate Carriedale Cottages for a hurricane?

It depends on the storm and on Lee County’s order. Lee County GIS places the street in Evacuation Zone C, surge zone 3, and the state’s storm surge layer intersects the area with Category 3 and Category 4 surge polygons. Plan to leave whenever an order names Zone C, and check Florida’s Know Your Zone tool and Lee County’s emergency notices for the address before each season.

How did Carriedale Cottages fare in Hurricane Ian?

No damage at Carriedale Cottages appears in public records. Ian struck on September 28, 2022, and Lee County’s after-action report counts 24,585 damaged residential and 4,690 damaged commercial structures countywide, about $3.22 billion in property loss, yet the county’s damage layers show no records on Carriedale Ln. Association-level damage and claims are not confirmed, so ask the association for its repair records.

What about Hurricanes Helene and Milton?

No villa-specific impacts were found for either 2024 storm. The National Weather Service rates the Fort Myers tornado Milton produced an EF2; it started about 2.6 miles west of Carriedale near US 41 and tracked north-northwest, away from Fiddlesticks. A reporter described possible tornado damage on Daniels Parkway, but no source ties damage to Fiddlesticks. Ask the association for storm reports, claims and any special assessment.

Do Florida’s milestone inspection and SIRS rules apply to Carriedale Cottages?

No. Florida Statutes section 718.112 applies the structural integrity reserve study to buildings three habitable stories or higher, and section 553.899 applies milestone inspections to the same height, while all eight Carriedale Cottages buildings are one story. Reserves for roof replacement, painting and paving still apply unless owners waive or reduce them by majority vote, and whether the association funds or waives them is not confirmed.

How old are the roofs at Carriedale Cottages?

About 12 to 13 years old in 2026, on the permit record. Lee County permits show fiberglass shingle tear-off re-roofs of the four Section I buildings in 2013 by Absolute Roofing of SW Florida, with a $30,000 job value for building 1, and the four Section II buildings in 2014 by CFS Roofing Services, after an undated earlier series. No later roof permit surfaced, though the search was not a full census.

What insurance does a Carriedale Cottages owner need?

An HO-6 policy for the interior, since Florida Statutes section 718.111(11) leaves personal property, floor, wall and ceiling coverings, electrical fixtures, appliances, water heaters, built-in cabinets, countertops and window treatments to the unit owner. The master carrier and deductible are not confirmed. The buildings predate the 1994 wind code and the 2002 Florida Building Code, so ask an insurance agent for quotes and wind-mitigation credits before you write an offer.

What documents should I request before buying?

Ask the association or Suitor and Associates for the current budget, the reserve schedule and any waiver vote, the master insurance declarations, recent minutes, any special assessment, the declarations and rules, and an estoppel letter. Ask the club for its estoppel, the Capital Improvement Assessment status and the membership packet. Together those settle the fee, reserve, rental, pet and insurance questions this guide can only describe from listing-reported figures.

Which schools serve a Carriedale Cottages address?

Lee County uses choice zones. The district’s 2026-27 School Proximity Zones layer places the street in elementary Zone J, middle Zone MM and high zone “South 2.” Zone J lists Colonial, Gateway, Ray V. Pottorf and Treeline elementary; MM lists Cypress Lake and Lexington middle; South 2 includes Cypress Lake High and Fort Myers High, both graded A for 2025-26. Confirm any address in the district’s School Site Locator.

How far is Carriedale Cottages from the airport, beaches and hospitals?

Only free-flow estimates from a Fiddlesticks community point exist, not timed drives: about 6.8 minutes to I-75 Exit 131, 11.7 minutes to Lee Health Gulf Coast Medical Center, 15.3 minutes to the Southwest Florida International Airport terminal, 29.0 minutes to the Sanibel Causeway and 29.6 minutes to Fort Myers Beach. Add a minute or two for the drive inside the gates and much more in season, January to April.

Who manages Carriedale Cottages?

Suitor and Associates. The state condominium register still lists two per-section associations in its care, while the state corporate registry shows one active Carriedale Cottages Condominium Association, Inc., filed in 1989, with the per-section corporations inactive; which entity operates both condominiums is not confirmed. The club’s packet lists “Carriedale HOA” under Suitor and Associates. An estoppel letter or the recorded amendments at the Lee County Clerk settle it.

How does Carriedale Cottages compare with other Fiddlesticks villas?

Carriedale Cottages’ median roll value of $390,773 sits below Turnberry Villas’ $480,936 and above Berriedale’s $326,979 and Glen Abbey Phase I’s $281,561, and the club’s $150,000 joining fee is the same for every product. Glen Abbey Phase I holds 24 coach villas from 1991 to 1992 with garages. See our Glen Abbey at Fiddlesticks guide and our Carriedale Gardens guide.

Frequently Asked Questions, Seller Edition

Carriedale Cottages sellers ask most often what their villa is worth, how the A, B and C plans price, why 2026 sales run close to 2025’s, what fee figures to give buyers, how the $150,000 joining fee and the Capital Improvement Assessment affect a sale, what the roof ages and reserves mean, what they must disclose, and how the flood zone, the evacuation zone and Hurricane Ian affect the price. Each answer below draws on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale files, Lee County GIS and permit records, the Florida DBPR condominium extract, Fiddlesticks Country Club’s documents and the Florida Statutes, with listing-reported figures labeled as such.

Who is the best listing agent for Carriedale Cottages?

McGreevy and Comisar, the leaders of Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012 and Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. We price a Carriedale Cottages villa on the recorded Lee County sales of villas like yours, gather the association’s budget, insurance and rules, the roof record and the club’s fee papers before the villa goes live, and market the one-story, golf-front setting. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

What is my Carriedale Cottages villa worth?

It depends on the plan, golf view, finish and condition. The 7 qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026 ran $500,000 to $665,000, a $575,000 median, or about $274 to about $318 a county heated square foot. A single median says little about one villa, so request a free Fiddlesticks home valuation built on recorded sales like yours.

What did the latest Carriedale Cottages sales bring?

The newest qualified sales were 15637, unit 3B, at $549,000 on April 15, 2026, and 15673, unit 7B, at $550,000 on September 1, 2026, both 1,827 square foot B villas, according to Lee County Property Appraiser records. Before those, 15643, unit 4C, set the record at $665,000 on March 31, 2026, and 15657, unit 5B, recorded $577,150 on January 5, 2026. Those set the current reference point.

How does price per square foot vary in Carriedale Cottages?

Within a fairly narrow band. On the 7 qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, price per county heated square foot ran from about $274 for 15645, a B villa, in September 2025, to about $318 for 15643, the C villa that set the record, with a median of about $300. Finish and condition explain much of that spread, so we compare your villa with sales of the same plan.

Does my floor plan affect my price?

Yes, mainly through size. From May 2025 to September 1, 2026, 4 sales of the 1,827 square foot B plan carried a $549,500 median, 2 sales of the 1,966 square foot A plan a $580,000 median, and the one 2,093 square foot C sale brought $665,000. The 2026 roll follows the same order, with plan medians of $323,913 for B, $390,773 for A and $407,188 for C.

Does my villa’s position in the building affect my price?

It may, but the record cannot show it. A 2023 listing called unit 4A an end unit in a building of three, and every B unit’s street number falls between the A and C numbers, yet B as the middle unit in all eight buildings is not confirmed. The declaration plot plans at the Lee County Clerk show the layout, and we present an end position plainly once your plans confirm it.

Why did 15673 sell slightly lower in 2026 than in 2024?

The market leveled. The same B villa sold for $551,000 in May 2024 and $550,000 in September 2026, $1,000 lower, according to Lee County Property Appraiser records. Over longer spans the record shows large gains: 15657 rose from $190,000 in May 2019 to $577,150 in January 2026, $387,150 higher, and 15669 from $325,000 in August 2020 to $575,000 in May 2025, $250,000 higher.

Is now a good time to sell in Carriedale Cottages?

Prices sit near the top of the record. The $575,000 median of the 7 qualified sales from May 2025 to September 1, 2026 stands well above the 2018 to 2019 sales of $190,000 to $216,000 and the 2008 high of $435,000, and the $665,000 record was set in March 2026. Timing depends on your next move; preparation, current association and club papers and an accurate price set the result more than the calendar does.

How many Carriedale Cottages villas sell each year?

Few. The county sale file shows 3 qualified sales in 2025 and 4 in 2026 through September 1, in a condominium of 24 villas. With so few, one C villa sale can swing a yearly figure, so we price from the individual recorded sales of villas like yours rather than a yearly average or a condominium-wide median.

What does the county just value tell me?

Less than buyers will pay attention to. The 2026 roll carries just values of $320,574 to $410,844 for the 24 villas, a $390,773 median, well below the $575,000 median sale. The just value is an assessment for taxes, not a price. Buyers compare your villa with recorded sales, so we price on those and use the roll for taxes and unit facts.

How do you price a C villa with only one recent sale?

From the older sales of that plan and the current sales of the other plans. Only 15643 recorded a qualified C sale from May 2025 to September 1, 2026, at $665,000, but the plan also recorded 15627 at $460,000 in April 2022 and 15685 at $499,000 in November 2022. We weigh those against today’s A and B sales and the C plan’s 2026 roll median of $407,188.

What fee figure do I tell buyers?

The association’s current figure, not an old advertisement. The public condo figures are listing-reported: $2,500 a quarter on 2026 listing pages and $1,640 a quarter in 2023, while listing “HOA” fields of $2,174 to $2,175 and $2,327 a month track club dues. Ask Suitor and Associates for the current assessment in writing, add the $2,319.50 club dues and $295 capital charge, and we show them from the first showing.

Who pays the estoppel, transfer and club fees?

The contract decides. The club lists a $2,000 real estate transaction fee and the $150,000 joining fee a 2026 listing states is due at closing, and Florida caps a condominium association’s transfer approval fee at $150 per applicant, adjusted for inflation every five years. Ask the association and the club for current estoppel and transfer charges in writing, and we write who pays each one into the contract.

Does the club or the association approve my buyer?

The club runs the main step: buyers file its equity application and a background-check form, with no buyer fee for the check. Whether the condominium’s declarations add their own approval is not confirmed, so we ask the association for its process at once. Both reviews are subject to federal and Florida fair housing law, and we file them early so they fit inside the closing date.

How does the $150,000 joining fee affect my sale?

Buyers count it in their price. The fee rose from $115,000 to $150,000 on November 1, 2026, about one quarter, about 26 percent, of the $575,000 median sale, and every Fiddlesticks owner must hold the membership. It is the same for every Fiddlesticks product, so it does not favor a rival villa, but we show the full entry cost in the listing materials so buyers arrive with it already in their budget.

Does the Capital Improvement Assessment transfer to my buyer?

It runs with the property, not the owner. From September 1, 2026, the club charges $295 a month for 120 months, a $26,500 lump sum, or $9,365 a year for three years, funding the Cabana kitchen started in August 2026, the Clubhouse renovation from May 2027 and Gatehouse improvements in Spring 2028. Tell buyers which option you chose, and ask the club to state any balance in writing.

Do SIRS and milestone rules affect my sale?

Not directly. Florida’s structural integrity reserve study and milestone inspection apply to condominium buildings three habitable stories or higher, and all eight Carriedale Cottages buildings are one story. Buyers still ask about reserves: section 718.112 requires roof, painting and paving reserves unless owners waive or reduce them by majority vote, and whether the association funds them is not confirmed, so we ask for the budget first.

Do the roof ages affect my sale?

Buyers and insurers ask. Lee County permits show fiberglass shingle re-roofs on Section I in 2013 and Section II in 2014, so the roofs were about 12 to 13 years old in 2026, and no later roof permit surfaced in a search that was not a full census. Ask the association for its roof reserve and any replacement plan, and we present those with the permit dates.

What must I disclose when selling in Carriedale Cottages?

Known defects that materially affect value, plus the flood disclosure Florida requires under section 689.302. Disclose any water intrusion, storm damage and repair inside your villa, any work done without a permit and any insurance claim. The association’s budget, rules, insurance and any special assessment, and the club’s assessment status, are part of what a buyer needs, so we ask for them early and present them plainly.

Do I need a flood disclosure for a Carriedale Cottages villa?

Yes. Florida’s flood disclosure under section 689.302 asks about flood insurance claims and federal flood assistance, and the street sits in FEMA Zone X, minimal flood hazard, on panel 12071C0439H effective November 17, 2022. Answer the form from your own records of claims and assistance for your villa; no elevation certificates for these villas were found in public sources, and Zone X does not require them for federal flood rules.

Does Hurricane Ian history affect my sale?

Buyers ask, and the record helps. Sales continued through the storm: 15685 closed at $499,000 in November 2022 and 15647 at $550,500 in April 2023, and Lee County’s damage layers show no records on Carriedale Ln. Association-level damage and claims are not confirmed, so we pair the association’s repair records with your own and show buyers what was repaired and when.

Does the evacuation zone affect my sale?

Buyers will ask. The street is in Lee County Evacuation Zone C, surge zone 3, and in FEMA Zone X. A buyer who sees that in the listing materials, alongside the 2013 and 2014 roof permits, the block and stucco construction listing pages describe and any impact door or shutter permits on your villa, prices it in rather than reopening the deal later.

Can I sell to a buyer who needs a mortgage?

Yes, but the lender will review the association as well as the villa. Expect requests for the budget, reserves, the master insurance declarations and any special assessment. Zone X carries no federal flood-insurance mandate, though a lender may still require a policy. We gather the association’s documents before the villa goes live, so a financed buyer’s lender can review them without delaying the closing date.

Can I sell to a buyer who plans to rent it out?

Only within the club’s and the association’s rules. The club sets a 30-day minimum in half or full month increments, a $100 background check per adult renter and a Section K landlord form, and a 2023 listing cited up to 12 leases a year, which is not confirmed. A buyer who needs nightly rental income will not find it here, so we hand over the current rules up front.

Can I sell to a buyer with a pet?

Listing pages mark pets as “allowed” or “call, conditional,” listing-reported labels that are not confirmed. A buyer with a pet should read the association’s current rules before signing a contract. Federal and Florida law govern requests for assistance animals, which the association handles under that law. We share the current rules with every buyer at the first showing.

Does the Long Mean closure affect my sale?

Buyers ask about it. The Long Mean has been closed since March 1, 2026 for a Kris Spence renovation with no published reopening date, and the Loch Ness course, redesigned by Kipp Schulties, reopened in January 2019. We describe the renovation as the club and the architect do, and price your villa on recorded sales, which continued through 2026, including the $665,000 record in March.

Does the club’s capital program help my sale?

It gives buyers something current to see. The Capital Improvement Assessment funds a Cabana kitchen expansion started in August 2026, a Clubhouse renovation from May 2027 and Gatehouse improvements in Spring 2028, and an undated builder page describes a 17,500 square foot clubhouse with renovated dining areas. We describe each project as the club does, with its dates, so buyers see where the charge goes.

How do I answer the Carriedale Cottages and Carriedale Gardens name question?

Directly, with the record. The MLS name “Carriedale” maps to Carriedale Cottages, the county legal reads Carriedale Cottages Section 1 or Section 2, and Carriedale Gardens across the lane is a separate condominium of two-story garden condos with its own MLS name. One aggregator has mislabeled a Gardens unit, so we put the legal description in the listing materials and keep the two markets apart.

What does the club require when I list?

Two steps on the club’s realtor page. Sellers notify the gatehouse of the listing agent and, once a contract is signed, file a Notice of New Contract with the executed contract. The buyer then files the equity application and the background-check form. Club estoppels go to the club’s community association manager, and we handle each step so the club’s timeline fits inside the closing date.

How long does a Carriedale Cottages sale take to close?

The closing date is set in the contract. Inside it sit the club’s equity application and estoppel, the association’s estoppel and any approval, the buyer’s lender review of the association and title work on the condominium. Because neither timeline is published, we request the estoppels and documents the day the contract is signed. A cash buyer usually closes faster than a financed one.

Should I sell my Carriedale Cottages villa furnished?

Some buyers want a villa ready to use on arrival, and some do not. Offer furnishings on a separate bill of sale so the price of the villa stands alone, and price it on the recorded sales without the contents. We tell buyers clearly what stays, from furniture and art to anything in your garage and on your lanai.

Does a wind-mitigation report help my sale?

It can help your buyer’s quote. The buildings date from 1986 and 1987, before the 1994 wind code and the 2002 Florida Building Code, so credit depends on later roofs and openings: the 2013 and 2014 fiberglass shingle roofs, and impact-rated doors such as those permitted at 15621 in 2016. A licensed inspector confirms whether a report under section 627.711 helps; we gather your roof and opening records first.

How do property taxes affect my buyer?

Your buyer’s assessed value resets after the sale under Florida’s Save Our Homes rule, so their bill can be higher than yours if you hold a homestead cap. The 2026 TRIM notice for 15667, unit 6B, shows proposed taxes of $3,820.99 at 13.3738 mills with no exemptions, on an assessed value of $261,020 after a $62,637 limitation benefit. We show the buyer an estimate in the listing materials.

What do I owe in capital gains tax?

A villa you owned and used as your main home may qualify for the federal home-sale exclusion the IRS describes. A Carriedale Cottages villa held as a second home is treated differently, and so is one held for rental, where depreciation matters. Ask your tax adviser before you list; this guide is general information, not tax advice, and the exclusion rules turn on your own ownership and use.

Can I sell if the villa is in a trust or an estate?

Yes. For a trust, the trustee signs and the title agent reviews the trust documents; for an estate, the personal representative signs once the court or the title agent confirms the authority. Plan time for that review in your closing schedule. The club’s equity application and any association application go in at the same time, and the Lee County Clerk’s official records show how the villa is now held.

How do you market a Carriedale Cottages villa?

With professional photography and drone video of the golf frontage and your lanai, a sale-by-sale price case from the county record for villas like yours, a clear explanation of the Cottages and Gardens names, the association’s current fee and rules, the club’s fees and projects, and our qualified-buyer database built over our years leading Domain Realty Group. Our Fiddlesticks seller guide sets out the full listing process.

What should I fix before listing my Carriedale Cottages villa?

Usually the items a buyer’s inspector looks at first: the air conditioning, the water heater, plumbing leaks, the lanai and garage doors, and any storm or water damage. Recent permits on the street are routine interior trades for air conditioning, electrical and plumbing. Work inside a condominium unit often needs the association’s approval as well as a permit, so close any open permit and compare a project’s cost with the recorded sales first.

Can I sell my Carriedale Cottages villa myself?

You can, but the Cottages and Gardens names, the unpublished condo budget, the $150,000 joining fee, the Capital Improvement Assessment, roof ages and reserves, and a buyer pool that compares every price per square foot make pricing and paperwork harder than they look. With only a few sales a year, an overpriced villa can sit. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610 for a confidential review.

How do I get a free valuation of my Carriedale Cottages villa?

Use our Fiddlesticks home valuation or Fort Myers home valuation form, or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. We start from the recorded Carriedale Cottages sales of villas like yours, adjust for plan, golf view, finish, roof age and storm history, check the result against the 2025 and 2026 sales, and only then suggest a price. For the full process, read our Sell Your Home in Fiddlesticks Country Club guide.

Sources and Authoritative References

The sources below are the primary records behind every Carriedale Cottages figure on this page: the Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, sale files and TRIM notices, the Florida DBPR condominium extract, Lee County permit records and GIS layers, FEMA, Fiddlesticks Country Club’s own documents, the Florida Statutes, state, county and federal storm reports, and news reports. Brokerage and listing-reported prices, fees and rules are labeled as such where they appear and are not linked.

  1. Lee County Property Appraiser, 2026 parcel roll (export dated November 1, 2026; 24 Carriedale Cottages units and 2 common-element parcels on Carriedale Ln)
  2. Lee County Property Appraiser, sale data files and parcel sale history (indexed November 18, 2026)
  3. Lee County Property Appraiser, 2026 TRIM notice and parcel record, 15667 Carriedale Ln (unit 6B)
  4. Lee County Property Appraiser, parcel record, Carriedale Cottages Section I pool and tennis common element
  5. Florida DBPR, Division of Condominiums public extract (Carriedale Cottages Sections I and II, Carriedale Gardens)
  6. Lee County eConnect, building permit search (Carriedale Cottages roof, door and trade permits)
  7. Lee County eConnect, 2013 Carriedale Cottages Section I re-roof permit detail
  8. Lee County eConnect, earlier Carriedale Cottages fiberglass shingle tear-off re-roof permit detail
  9. Lee County GIS, FIRM flood zone layer
  10. Lee County GIS, evacuation zones layer
  11. Lee County GIS, public damage assessment and damage inventory layers (service directory)
  12. Lee County GIS and School District of Lee County, 2026-27 school proximity zones
  13. Lee County GIS, Subdivisions and Condominiums layer
  14. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, map service
  15. Florida DBPR, Division of Condominiums, Milestone Inspections and SIRS
  16. Florida Statutes, section 718.111 (2026), condominium association insurance and official records
  17. Florida Statutes, section 718.112, reserves and structural integrity reserve study
  18. Fiddlesticks Country Club, Membership
  19. Fiddlesticks Country Club, Realtors (buyer, seller, renter and landlord process)
  20. Fiddlesticks Country Club, Membership Information Packet 2026-2027
  21. Fiddlesticks Country Club, 2026-27 Renter Information
  22. Kris Spence Golf Design, Future, Current and Recent Projects (Fiddlesticks Long Mean renovation)
  23. National Weather Service Tampa Bay, Hurricane Milton tornado summary (PDF)
  24. Fox Weather, Fort Myers tornado reported as Milton spawns outbreak
  25. Fox 4, NWS confirms two tornadoes hit Lee County in Milton
  26. TurfNet, Ian’s effects felt from one side of Florida to the other
  27. GCM, Storm warning: Lessons from Hurricane Ian
  28. Owen-Ames-Kimball, Fiddlesticks Country Club clubhouse additions and renovations
  29. Lee County, Hurricanes Helene and Milton After Action Report (PDF)
  30. WGCU, Another north-south Lee to Collier route opens after years of planning changes, November 2, 2026
  31. Florida House of Representatives, HB 913 (2025) final bill analysis (PDF)
  32. Fiddlesticks Country Club, Rules and Regulations, updated 2025 (PDF)

Further authoritative references for any Carriedale Cottages buyer or seller checking flood, storm, tax, title, insurance and school questions at the address level:

  1. Lee County Clerk of Court, Official Records (plat images and recorded deeds)
  2. Florida Division of Corporations (Sunbiz), corporation search (to confirm the association’s registration)
  3. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, flood hazard zones
  4. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, FIRM panels
  5. FEMA, substantial improvement and substantial damage
  6. Lee County, Floodplain Management
  7. Florida Division of Emergency Management, Know Your Zone
  8. Village of Estero, Know Your Evacuation Zone (Lee County zone guidance)
  9. City of Bonita Springs, Lee County evacuation order for Zone A, Zone B and parts of Zone C, September 27, 2022
  10. Lee County Attorney, Hurricane Milton evacuation order resolution (PDF)
  11. National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian (PDF)
  12. National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Helene (PDF)
  13. National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Milton (PDF)
  14. Lee County, Hurricane Ian recovery progress
  15. Coastal and Heartland National Estuary Partnership, Hurricane Ian
  16. Florida Statutes, section 689.302, seller flood disclosure
  17. Florida Statutes, section 627.711, wind mitigation verification
  18. Florida Statutes, section 193.155, Save Our Homes assessment limits
  19. Florida Statutes, section 201.02, documentary stamp tax on deeds
  20. Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
  21. Lee County GIS, Lee County Parcels layer
  22. Lee County GIS, FIRM panels layer
  23. Lee County GIS, hospital locations
  24. Lee County GIS, evacuation routes
  25. US Census Bureau Geocoder, geographies by address or coordinates
  26. USGS Elevation Point Query Service
  27. OpenStreetMap Nominatim, place lookups
  28. Wikipedia, Fort Myers, Florida
  29. Wikipedia, Lee County, Florida
  30. FEMA Flood Map Service Center, address lookup
  31. Lee County, flood insurance and flood zone information, with the LeeEOC Know Your Zone lookup
  32. Lee County, Hurricane Milton evacuation press release, October 7, 2024 (PDF)
  33. WGCU, Lee County issues mandatory evacuations in Zone A, partial in Zone B, September 27, 2022
  34. Lee County Tax Collector
  35. School District of Lee County
  36. Lee County GIS, fire districts layer
  37. Florida Statutes, section 553.899 (2026), mandatory structural inspections for condominium and cooperative buildings
  38. Florida Statutes, section 718.112 (2026), structural integrity reserve study and reserves
  39. McGreevy and Comisar, Fiddlesticks Country Club community guide
  40. McGreevy and Comisar, Carriedale Gardens community guide
  41. McGreevy and Comisar, Glen Abbey at Fiddlesticks community guide
  42. McGreevy and Comisar, Fort Myers community guide
  43. McGreevy and Comisar, best real estate agents in Fort Myers
  44. McGreevy and Comisar, sell your home in Fiddlesticks Country Club
  45. McGreevy and Comisar, free Fiddlesticks Country Club home valuation
  46. McGreevy and Comisar, buy a home in Fiddlesticks Country Club
  47. McGreevy and Comisar, sell your home in Fort Myers
  48. McGreevy and Comisar, free Fort Myers home valuation
  49. McGreevy and Comisar, buy a home in Fort Myers

Downloadable Documents

Carriedale Cottages’ downloadable documents are public files a buyer or seller uses in a Carriedale Cottages transaction, each linked to the publisher’s own copy: the state’s condominium law on reserves and the structural integrity reserve study, the state’s condominium law on association insurance and official records, the National Hurricane Center’s Ian report, the National Weather Service’s Milton tornado summary, Lee County’s Helene and Milton after-action report, the club’s Rules and Regulations and the House analysis of HB 913. The flood map for the street is on FEMA’s flood hazard layer by address.

Document

Publisher

Date

Link

Florida Statutes s. 718.112, condominium bylaws, reserves and the structural integrity reserve study

Florida Senate

2026 statute

Download

Florida Statutes s. 718.111, condominium association insurance and official records

Florida Legislature

2026 statute

Download

Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian (PDF)

National Hurricane Center

2022 storm

Download

Hurricane Milton tornado summary (PDF)

National Weather Service Tampa Bay

2024 storm

Download

Hurricanes Helene and Milton After Action Report (PDF)

Lee County

2024 storms

Download

Rules and Regulations (PDF)

Fiddlesticks Country Club

Updated 2025

Download

HB 913 (2025) final bill analysis (PDF)

Florida House of Representatives

2025

Download

Market data from the Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll (dated November 1, 2026) and sale files (indexed November 18, 2026); newest recorded Carriedale Cottages qualified sale September 1, 2026. Data updated: November 2026. Regional multiple listing service data was not pulled for this edition; brokerage and listing-reported prices, fees and rules are labeled as such, and asking prices are not sales. Carriedale Cottages is recorded as two condominiums, Carriedale Cottages Section I (Official Records Book 1871, Page 443) and Section II (Book 1923, Page 2227), and appears on the MLS as “Carriedale”; its 24 villas and three plans are the county roll’s figures. It is a different condominium from Carriedale Gardens across the lane, though both share the street and the Fiddlesticks gate. Not public online when this guide was written (November 2026): the association’s current budget, quarterly assessment and what it covers, reserve funding or any waiver, the master insurance carrier and deductible, any special assessment, which corporation operates both condominiums, the role of Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc., the builder of record, the grantors on the 1986 to 1988 first deeds, the physical order of units in each building, which course and holes each building faces, the current leasing and pet rules, the dates of the earliest roof series, association-level storm damage and claims, and the Long Mean reopening date; ask the association or Suitor and Associates, request an estoppel letter, search the Lee County Clerk’s official records, check DBPR or Sunbiz, ask the club membership office, or check Lee County building records. This guide is general information about Carriedale Cottages, not an appraisal and not legal, tax or insurance advice. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.

McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Carriedale Cottages. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.


Work With Us

Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.