Carriedale Gardens is a 28-unit garden condominium of 1985 to 1986 inside Fiddlesticks Country Club in Fort Myers. Sell or buy with McGreevy and Comisar.
By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.
Carriedale Gardens is a 1985 to 1986 garden condominium of 28 residences in seven two-story buildings inside Fiddlesticks Country Club in Fort Myers, Florida, on the even side of Carriedale Lane behind the Fiddlesticks gatehouse off Daniels Parkway in south Fort Myers, ZIP 33912, in unincorporated Lee County. Every unit carries the county’s golf-course land code, and every owner joins the club.
McGreevy and Comisar are the team Carriedale Gardens sellers call first: Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with over $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc, and the Domain Realty Group team is the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026). If you are comparing agents, our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers sets local agents side by side on the public record. Inside Fiddlesticks, Carriedale Gardens is the club’s entry point by county value: two- and three-bedroom garden condominiums that carry the same club membership as the estate homes around them. From November 2024 through October 2026 we tracked 14 county-recorded qualified Carriedale Gardens resales, from $100,000 to $350,000, with a median of $237,450.
In this guide, “Carriedale Gardens” means the 28-unit garden condominium on the even side of Carriedale Lane, even addresses 15626 to 15676 Carriedale Ln, recorded with the State of Florida as Carriedale Gardens A Condo. It is separate from Carriedale Cottages, the 24 one-story villas across the lane on the odd side, which the multiple listing service often calls just “Carriedale”. Every figure on this page is for the 28 Carriedale Gardens units only.
Carriedale Gardens sells to buyers who weigh floor plan, upstairs or downstairs, parking, condition and the full cost of Fiddlesticks membership across 28 units of the same 1985 to 1986 vintage. McGreevy and Comisar bring Top 1% standing since 2008 and the #1 team record in Southwest Florida since 2012 to pricing each Carriedale Gardens unit on its own recorded sales.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, with county-recorded qualified sales through October 6, 2026; our analysis).
If you’re searching for the best realtor for Carriedale Gardens in Fiddlesticks Country Club, Fort Myers, whether you’re ready to sell your Carriedale Gardens condo or buy your next one, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Nationally since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. With 4,000+ transactions behind us, our Domain Realty Group team is also the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026).
Carriedale Gardens market (county-recorded qualified resales, November 2024 through October 2026): 14 sales, median $237,450, range $100,000 to $350,000 · highest sale in the window: $350,000 for a 1,547 square foot three-bedroom unit in Building F, October 2026 · 2026 median just value of the 28 units: $196,971
Sale-to-list ratio and days on market: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-20).
These are county-recorded deeds across all brokerages, and they include sales a listing site never shows. We tracked every qualified Carriedale Gardens sale in that window and read all 28 unit parcels and the common-element pool parcel on the county roll for building, heated area, bedrooms, parking, year built, just value and homestead status, and every figure on this page carries its own window and source.
Honors and recognition:
Selling your Carriedale Gardens condo? Get a free home valuation at mcgreevyandcomisar.com/home-valuation, read our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers, or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Our guide to home values in Fort Myers goes deeper on pricing, costs and disclosure.
Buying a condo in Carriedale Gardens? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 for a personalized buyer consultation, and see how we represent buyers.
Selling a Carriedale Gardens condo means pricing one of 28 units that share a 1985 or 1986 build year but differ by plan, section, floor, parking and condition: 1,143 to 1,547 heated square feet, two or three bedrooms. The county recorded 14 qualified resales from November 2024 through October 2026, from $100,000 to $350,000.
The second job is the paperwork, and at Carriedale Gardens there are two layers of it. The condominium association issues its estoppel certificate, stating the quarterly assessment, any balance owed and any special assessment, and the club issues its own estoppel for dues and the Capital Improvement Assessment. The seller files the club’s Notice of New Contract, and the buyer files the club’s equity application. A prepared seller gathers the assessment history, insurance details and any repair records for Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton before the first showing. In Lee County the contract decides who pays for the owner’s title policy, so that line is settled in the offer, not assumed.
We price a Carriedale Gardens condo from the county’s qualified resales of the same floor plan first, then adjust for floor, section, parking, view, condition and the buyer’s full club cost. From November 2024 through October 2026 those resales ran from $100,000 to $350,000, and units of one plan spread widely inside that range.
That spread is the reason a single median misleads here. The record shows 1,547 square foot three-bedroom units from $142,500 to $350,000 in the same window, and listing records describe the $350,000 unit as “completely remodeled throughout”. We read the sales that bracket a unit, check its plan and condition against the 2026 sales, and set the price against the competition the week it lists. Because every buyer also pays the club’s $150,000 joining fee, we price with that number in view.
For Carriedale Gardens we tracked every county-recorded qualified sale from November 2024 through October 2026, read all 28 unit parcels and the common-element pool parcel on the Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, and tested Lee County’s evacuation and school zone layers at each building.
We also read the State of Florida condominium file, the Florida corporate filings for the associations, the Fiddlesticks Country Club membership and renter packets and Lee County permit records. Where a fact is not in a public document, this page says so, names the record that would settle it, and does not guess. Details that appear only in listing records are labeled that way, and listing sites are not linked. Carriedale Cottages sales are kept out of every Carriedale Gardens figure.
Sellers can call Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072, and buyers can call Marc Comisar at (239) 457-1610. Both conversations about Carriedale Gardens are confidential, and neither obliges you to list or buy. You can also use our contact page or read about the team first, and bring any estoppel, budget or club document you hold.
Reach us through our contact page, read about the team, or meet Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar before you call.
Carriedale Gardens is a 1985 to 1986 garden condominium of 28 units in seven two-story buildings inside Fiddlesticks Country Club, where floor plan, condition and the full cost of club membership matter more than any single median. These eight facts carry the page, and each one is expanded, dated and sourced in the sections that follow.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, county-recorded qualified sales through October 6, 2026; Fiddlesticks Country Club 2026-2027 packet).
This guide to Carriedale Gardens runs from where the condominium sits inside Fiddlesticks and what it is like to live there, through county-recorded sale prices and the price trend, to the history of the condominium, its floor plans, the cost of club membership, what the condo fee covers and the property tax rate.
Carriedale Gardens is on Carriedale Lane inside the gates of Fiddlesticks Country Club, off Daniels Parkway in south Fort Myers, ZIP 33912. Carriedale Gardens holds the even addresses from 15626 to 15676 Carriedale Ln, sits in unincorporated Lee County and is reached through the Fiddlesticks gatehouse on Fiddlesticks Boulevard.
Lee County permit records give the internal route as Fiddlesticks Boulevard, left on Lochmaben Avenue, then left on Carriedale Lane. The county’s legal description places the condominium in Section 33, Township 45, Range 25, and the common-element pool parcel sits at 15646 Carriedale Ln between the two sections of buildings.
| Fact | Carriedale Gardens |
|---|---|
| City and ZIP | Fort Myers, FL 33912 |
| Jurisdiction | Unincorporated Lee County, taxing district 047, South Trail Fire |
| Location | Even side of Carriedale Lane, inside Fiddlesticks Country Club, off Daniels Parkway |
| Addresses | Even numbers 15626 to 15676 Carriedale Ln |
| State condominium file | PR1U010974, Carriedale Gardens A Condo, recorded March 22, 1985 |
| Units | 28 in seven buildings of four (A to G) |
| Stories | Two in every building |
| Year built | 1985 (Section 1) and 1986 (Section 2) |
| Common element | 3.51-acre pool parcel at 15646 Carriedale Ln, owned by the association |
| Setting | Every unit carries the county’s golf-course land code |
| Gate | Fiddlesticks gatehouse with security |
| Boat access | None; no dock on any unit |
| Association | Carriedale Gardens Condominium Association, Inc. |
| Parent community | Fiddlesticks Country Club, about 585 homes, mandatory equity membership |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll; Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums project file PR1U010974; Fiddlesticks Country Club, read November 2026.
Carriedale Gardens is seven two-story buildings of four units each, lettered A to G. Buildings A, B and C form Section 1, built in 1985 at 15626 to 15638 Carriedale Ln, and Buildings D, E, F and G form Section 2, built in 1986 at 15660 to 15676 Carriedale Ln.
Each building carries two street numbers, one for units #1 and #2 and one for units #3 and #4: Building A is 15626 and 15628, Building B 15632 and 15634, Building C 15636 and 15638, Building D 15660 and 15662, Building E 15664 and 15666, Building F 15670 and 15672 and Building G 15674 and 15676. The common-element pool parcel at 15646 Carriedale Ln sits in the numbering gap between Building C and Building D. The floor plan section below sets out which plan sits in each building.
Carriedale Gardens sits about 7 free-flow minutes from I-75 at Daniels Parkway, about 11 minutes from Gulf Coast Medical Center and about 15 minutes from Southwest Florida International Airport, measured from a Fiddlesticks community point with no traffic. Fort Myers Beach and the Sanibel Causeway are each about 29 to 30 minutes away.
| Destination | Free-flow time | Distance |
|---|---|---|
| I-75 at Daniels Pkwy (Exit 131) | about 7 min | about 2.7 mi |
| Publix at Daniels Crossing | about 11 min | about 4.8 mi |
| Gulf Coast Medical Center (Lee Health, Level II Trauma Center) | about 12 min | about 5.7 mi |
| Bell Tower Shops | about 13 min | about 6.5 mi |
| Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) | about 15 min | about 8.0 mi |
| Gulf Coast Town Center | about 16 min | about 8.0 mi |
| Miromar Outlets | about 19 min | about 11.8 mi |
| Florida Gulf Coast University | about 19 min | about 9.9 mi |
| Downtown Fort Myers (River District) | about 23 min | about 13.9 mi |
| Coconut Point (Estero) | about 25 min | about 15.3 mi |
| Sanibel Causeway (Punta Rassa end) | about 29 min | about 17.0 mi |
| Fort Myers Beach (Times Square) | about 30 min | about 15.9 mi |
| Downtown Naples (Fifth Ave S) | about 47 min | about 35.0 mi |
Source: free-flow routing estimates from a Fiddlesticks community point on OpenStreetMap data, not from Carriedale Lane itself. These are not traffic times.
Add a minute or two for the drive inside the gates, and much more in season, roughly January to April, on Daniels Parkway and the routes to the beaches. The interstate, the hospital and the airport are the short trips from Carriedale Gardens; downtown Fort Myers, the beaches and Naples are the longer ones.
No. Carriedale Gardens carries a Fort Myers mailing address, but all 28 units sit in unincorporated Lee County, taxing district 047, South Trail Fire, on the 2026 Lee County roll. Lee County, not the City of Fort Myers, handles zoning, building permits and floodplain review for Carriedale Gardens.
For an owner the practical effect shows in two places. The tax bill carries county and fire district levies rather than a City operating levy, and any renovation inside a unit that needs a permit goes through Lee County, subject to the association’s approval rules and the Fiddlesticks deed restrictions. Fire service comes from the South Trail Fire District. The tax section below sets out the district 047 rate.
Carriedale Gardens is the 28-unit garden condominium of two-story buildings on the even side of Carriedale Lane. Carriedale Cottages is a separate condominium of 24 one-story villas on the odd side of the same street, built in 1986 and 1987, with its own association records, pools and sales.
The confusion is common because the multiple listing service and many listing sites call the Cottages simply “Carriedale”, and both share a street, a manager listed by the club and the Fiddlesticks gate. Their sale prices sit far apart, so a figure that blends the two misleads in both directions. Every number on this page is matched on the county roll by the Carriedale Gardens recorded name and its even addresses, and no Cottages sale is counted in it.
Four 2026 road projects touch the drive to Carriedale Gardens: the Three Oaks Parkway extension, which opened November 2, 2026 with a new intersection at Fiddlesticks Boulevard; the eight-lane widening of Daniels Parkway; a new Fiddlesticks Boulevard roundabout; and the rebuild of I-75 Exit 131 as a diverging diamond.
WGCU reported the Three Oaks Parkway extension opening on November 2, 2026, with final completion scheduled for early 2027 and Daniels Parkway widened to eight lanes from Danport Boulevard to Appaloosa Lane and Powers Court. In May 2026 Lee County moved Fiddlesticks Boulevard traffic to a new roundabout. FDOT District One’s I-75 at Daniels Parkway project, 446296-2, rebuilds Exit 131 as a diverging diamond interchange at about $42.8 million, with construction from early 2026 and estimated completion in summer 2028. Expect work zones near the front gate until then.
Living in Carriedale Gardens means a 1985 or 1986 two-story garden condominium on a golf course inside a gated, two-course club community, with the association’s own pool parcel on the street and the Fiddlesticks clubhouse, cabana and resort pool nearby. Carriedale Gardens owners all hold club membership, and the association maintains the grounds.
The setting is Fiddlesticks Country Club, which dates itself “Since 1982” and holds about 585 homes behind one gatehouse off Daniels Parkway. Carriedale Gardens is one of the club’s smaller attached neighborhoods: seven low buildings with upstairs and downstairs units, carports in Section 1 and garage-coded parking in Section 2. Our research on Fiddlesticks places Carriedale Lane near the clubhouse, the cabana and the resort pool. Owners comparing club settings across the city can also read our guides to Crown Colony and Heritage Palms Golf and Country Club, two other Fort Myers golf communities we cover.
All 28 Carriedale Gardens units carry the county’s golf-course land code on the 2026 Lee County roll, and the condominium sits inside Fiddlesticks, which has 36 holes on two courses, the Long Mean and Loch Ness. Which course and which holes each Carriedale Gardens building faces is not confirmed in a public record.
The Long Mean is a Ron Garl design that opened in 1983; Loch Ness was redesigned by Kipp Schulties and reopened in January 2019. The Long Mean closed on March 1, 2026 for a renovation by Kris Spence, and no completion date has been published, so check the reopening date with the club. How much fairway a unit sees depends on its building, its side and its floor, so a buyer weighing two units should stand on each lanai before choosing.
Carriedale Gardens’ own amenity is its common element: a 3.51-acre pool parcel at 15646 Carriedale Ln, owned by Carriedale Gardens Condominium Association, Inc., per the Lee County Property Appraiser record. The larger amenities, golf, tennis, pickleball, fitness and dining, belong to the club.
Carriedale Cottages across the lane has its own pool and tennis parcels, and whether Carriedale Gardens owners may use them is not documented in any public record we read; ask the association. Listing records name a storage locker and a lanai with many units; confirm with the association what each unit’s documents assign to it. The condominium’s own costs, including the pool parcel, are carried in the quarterly assessment, and the club’s are carried in club dues.
Carriedale Gardens owners reach the full Fiddlesticks club: two golf courses, seven Har-Tru tennis courts, eight pickleball courts, bocce, a fitness facility, the cabana and resort pool, clubhouse dining and the Pub. Our research on Fiddlesticks places Carriedale Lane near the clubhouse, the cabana and the resort pool.
The club’s amenities page describes a 5,000 square foot fitness facility, three lighted tennis courts among the seven and lighted pickleball options. Club dues include golf, tennis, bocce, pickleball, the clubhouse, fitness and the cabana pool, and there is no food and beverage minimum in 2026-27. The amenities are changing: the Capital Improvement Assessment funds a Cabana kitchen, a Clubhouse renovation starting in May 2027 and Gatehouse work in Spring 2028, so ask the club which facilities are open during the work.
Yes. Carriedale Gardens sits inside the Fiddlesticks Country Club gates, and every visitor passes the Fiddlesticks gatehouse. Club dues include 24-hour roving security, and the listing field for the Carriedale Gardens condo fee also names security among its items, which the association can confirm.
The gate is run by the club, not the condominium, so guest access, vendor access and the rules for a listing agent’s showings follow the club’s procedures; the club asks sellers to notify the gatehouse of their listing agent. The gatehouse itself is one of the projects the club’s Capital Improvement Assessment funds, scheduled for Spring 2028. A buyer who plans to rent the unit, or to have regular visitors, should ask the club how access is managed.
On the 2026 Lee County roll, 9 of the 28 Carriedale Gardens units carry a Florida homestead exemption, which an owner claims on a permanent residence, and 11 of the 28 owners have a Florida mailing address, per the Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll.
For a buyer, a low homestead share means the current owner’s tax bill may differ sharply from the next owner’s, because the assessment resets after a sale. For a seller, it means buyers often ask about the rental rules and the full cost of membership as closely as the unit itself. The tax section below explains the reset.
If you own one of the 28 units in Carriedale Gardens, the 1985 to 1986 garden condominium inside Fiddlesticks Country Club, the numbers that matter are the 14 qualified resales from November 2024 through October 2026, median $237,450, and the seven 2026 resales at $160,000 to $350,000 that set today’s range by plan.
Selling? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or start with a free home valuation. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610, read how we represent buyers or our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers, and browse Fort Myers homes for sale on Domain Realty Group.
Carriedale Gardens condos sold at a median of $237,450 across 14 county-recorded qualified resales from November 2024 through October 2026, from $100,000 to $350,000. All 14 were resales, with no builder-direct sales, and the newest sale in the county record closed on October 6, 2026.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, county-recorded qualified sales through October 6, 2026; our analysis).
From November 2024 through October 2026 we tracked 14 county-recorded qualified Carriedale Gardens resales, from $100,000 to $350,000, with a median of $237,450. Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active listings and months of supply come from the multiple listing service: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-20). The county figures below are the market evidence this page uses.
Every county-recorded qualified Carriedale Gardens resale in the window:
| Recorded | Building | Unit | Heated sq ft | Bedrooms | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| February 28, 2025 | E | 15666 #3 | 1,547 | 3 | $327,500 |
| April 30, 2025 | C | 15638 #3 | 1,490 | 3 | $305,000 |
| April 30, 2025 | E | 15664 #1 | 1,547 | 3 | $275,000 |
| May 13, 2025 | D | 15660 #2 | 1,188 | 2 | $125,000 |
| May 16, 2025 | D | 15662 #3 | 1,143 | 2 | $100,000 |
| June 18, 2025 | F | 15670 #2 | 1,547 | 3 | $142,500 |
| June 23, 2025 | G | 15676 #3 | 1,188 | 2 | $215,000 |
| March 12, 2026 | F | 15672 #4 | 1,547 | 3 | $280,000 |
| March 31, 2026 | A | 15628 #3 | 1,490 | 3 | $180,000 |
| April 15, 2026 | D | 15660 #1 | 1,188 | 2 | $249,900 |
| April 27, 2026 | E | 15664 #2 | 1,547 | 3 | $160,000 |
| August 31, 2026 | F | 15672 #3 | 1,547 | 3 | $250,000 |
| September 30, 2026 | G | 15676 #3 | 1,188 | 2 | $225,000 |
| October 6, 2026 | F | 15670 #1 | 1,547 | 3 | $350,000 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, county-recorded qualified sales.
The 14 sales split by bedroom count. Nine three-bedroom units sold from $142,500 to $350,000, and five two-bedroom units sold from $100,000 to $249,900. Twelve of the 14 sales were in Section 2 (Buildings D to G), and two were in Section 1. One unit, 15676 #3, sold twice: $215,000 in June 2025 and $225,000 in September 2026.
Carriedale Gardens recorded seven qualified resales in 2026 through October 6, from $160,000 to $350,000, with a median of $249,900. The high was a 1,547 square foot three-bedroom unit in Building F at $350,000 in October; the low was a 1,547 square foot unit in Building E at $160,000 in April.
The other five 2026 sales were a 1,547 square foot unit in Building F at $280,000 in March, a 1,490 square foot unit in Building A at $180,000 in March, a 1,188 square foot two-bedroom unit in Building D at $249,900 in April, a second Building F unit at $250,000 in August and a 1,188 square foot unit in Building G at $225,000 in September. Four of the seven were in Building F or Building E, the 1,547 square foot buildings. Seven sales is a thin year, so we read each one against its plan, floor and condition before letting it steer a price.
Carriedale Gardens three-bedroom units recorded nine qualified resales from February 2025 through October 2026, from $142,500 to $350,000, with a median of $275,000 by our arithmetic. Seven were the 1,547 square foot plan in Buildings E and F, and two were the 1,490 square foot plan in Buildings A and C.
| Recorded | Building and unit | Heated sq ft | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| February 2025 | E, 15666 #3 | 1,547 | $327,500 |
| April 2025 | C, 15638 #3 | 1,490 | $305,000 |
| April 2025 | E, 15664 #1 | 1,547 | $275,000 |
| June 2025 | F, 15670 #2 | 1,547 | $142,500 |
| March 2026 | F, 15672 #4 | 1,547 | $280,000 |
| March 2026 | A, 15628 #3 | 1,490 | $180,000 |
| April 2026 | E, 15664 #2 | 1,547 | $160,000 |
| August 2026 | F, 15672 #3 | 1,547 | $250,000 |
| October 2026 | F, 15670 #1 | 1,547 | $350,000 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, county-recorded qualified sales.
The 1,490 square foot plan’s two sales, $305,000 in April 2025 and $180,000 in March 2026, are $125,000 apart. With only 16 three-bedroom units in the condominium, a seller of this plan usually competes with few or none of the same layout at once, which makes condition and floor the deciding points.
Carriedale Gardens two-bedroom units recorded five qualified resales from May 2025 through September 2026, from $100,000 to $249,900, with a median of $215,000 by our arithmetic. Four were the 1,188 square foot plan, one was the 1,143 square foot plan, and the 1,180 square foot plan recorded none.
The 1,188 square foot plan, in Buildings D and G, ran from $125,000 in May 2025 to $249,900 in April 2026, with $215,000 and $225,000 sales of the same Building G unit between them. The one 1,143 square foot sale, in Building D, recorded at $100,000 in May 2025, the low for the window. The 12 two-bedroom units are the smaller share of the condominium, and five sales in two years is a thin record, so each sale is read on its own facts.
Carriedale Gardens’ 1,547 square foot three-bedroom units sold from $142,500 to $350,000 between June 2025 and October 2026, per county-recorded qualified sales. The spread is consistent with condition differences: listing records describe the $350,000 unit, 15670 #1, as “completely remodeled throughout”.
The county records the price, not the reason, so the record alone cannot say how much of a gap was condition, floor, view, season or furnishings. Lee County flags each sale as qualified or not, and only qualified sales count in this page’s figures; the low sales of 2025 were not checked for arm’s length beyond that flag. For a seller, the lesson is that a neighbor’s price says little until you know what was inside the unit. For a buyer, the condition of the kitchen, baths, windows and air conditioning is worth as much attention as the plan.
Carriedale Gardens resale prices peaked in 2022, when the county recorded two qualified resales at $395,000 and $390,000, the highest on file. The 2025 and 2026 resales ran below that pair: $100,000 to $327,500 in 2025 and $160,000 to $350,000 in 2026 through October 6. Small samples, direction only.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, county-recorded qualified sales by year; small samples, direction only).
| Year | Qualified resales | Price range | Median |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 | 7 | $90,000 to $254,000 | n/a |
| 2022 | 2 | $390,000 and $395,000 (the highest on file) | n/a |
| 2023 | 1 | $270,000 | n/a |
| 2024 | 1 | $80,000 | n/a |
| 2025 | 7 | $100,000 to $327,500 | $215,000 |
| 2026 to October 6 | 7 | $160,000 to $350,000 | $249,900 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, county-recorded qualified sales. Small samples, direction only.
Each year rests on one to seven sales, so a single closing can move a year’s range. Read the table as the direction of the market, not as a value for any single unit. The longer county record shows how far the condominium has moved: the first transfers in 1985 recorded at $165,900 to $181,000, and resales from 2012 to 2015 included lows of $35,000 to $62,500.
Carriedale Gardens prices peaked in 2022, when the county recorded two qualified resales: $395,000 for 15670 #1 in June and $390,000 for 15672 #4 in December. Both were 1,547 square foot three-bedroom units in Building F, and both remain the highest Carriedale Gardens sales on file.
One unit shows the whole arc. 15670 #1 recorded at $105,000 in 2015, $395,000 in June 2022 and $350,000 in October 2026, per county-recorded qualified sales. The December 2022 sale of $390,000 recorded after Hurricane Ian in September 2022, which shows a buyer closing in the condominium that year; it does not show the condition of the buildings, which only the association’s records can answer.
For a Carriedale Gardens seller, the trend means pricing to the 2025 and 2026 record, not to the 2022 peak. The seven 2026 resales ran $160,000 to $350,000, median $249,900, against $390,000 and $395,000 in 2022, and the median rose from $215,000 on seven 2025 sales.
That pattern, a 2022 high followed by lower and wider-spread resales, makes condition the main lever a seller controls. A seller who prices from a neighbor’s 2022 sale will likely sit; one who prices from the 2026 sales of the same plan, then adjusts for floor, parking and condition, meets the buyers who are actually writing offers. The buyer’s club cost also sits beside every offer, which the membership section below sets out. We show every seller the sales that bracket the unit.
The 2026 just value of the 28 Carriedale Gardens units ranges from $158,616 to $222,243, with a median of $196,971, per the Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll. Just value is the appraiser’s mass-appraisal figure for tax purposes, an assessment, not a sale price.
| Plan | Units | 2026 just value range |
|---|---|---|
| 1,490 sq ft, 3 bed, 2 bath (Buildings A, C) | 8 | $196,971 to $197,458 |
| 1,547 sq ft, 3 bed, 2 bath (Buildings E, F) | 8 | $201,359 to $222,243 |
| 1,180 sq ft, 2 bed, 2 bath (Building B) | 2 | $161,624 to $161,948 |
| 1,143 sq ft, 2 bed, 2 bath (Buildings B, D, G) | 6 | $158,616 to $174,624 |
| 1,188 sq ft, 2 bed, 2 bath (Buildings D, G) | 4 | $162,842 to $171,537 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll.
The 28 units total $5,204,368 in 2026 just value. The median sale, $237,450, sits above the median just value, but three of the 14 tracked resales recorded below the lowest just value on the roll, which shows how loosely just value tracks a unit’s actual condition. A buyer should read just value as a rough starting point for a post-purchase assessment; a seller should never price from it, because the recorded sales are the market.
Carriedale Gardens recorded between one and seven qualified resales a year from 2021 through 2026: seven in 2021, two in 2022, one in 2023, one in 2024, seven in 2025 and seven in 2026 through October 6, per county-recorded qualified sales. Seven sales is a quarter of the 28 units.
That pace means a Carriedale Gardens seller often has few direct competitors of the same plan on the street at once. Buyers also compare the condominium with other attached neighborhoods inside Fiddlesticks and with golf communities elsewhere in Fort Myers, so presentation, assessment records and price against that wider set matter as much as the Carriedale Gardens median. The 2025 and 2026 pace, seven sales in each year, is well above the one sale a year recorded in 2023 and 2024.
Carriedale Gardens was recorded with the State of Florida on March 22, 1985 as Carriedale Gardens A Condo, state file PR1U010974, with 28 units and Fiddlesticks, Ltd. named as developer. Carriedale Gardens’ Section 1 buildings were built in 1985 and its Section 2 buildings in 1986, per the county roll.
| Fact | Carriedale Gardens |
|---|---|
| State project | PR1U010974, Carriedale Gardens A Condo |
| State recording | March 22, 1985, 28 units |
| Developer on the state file | Fiddlesticks, Ltd. |
| Builder | Not named in any record we read |
| Association filed | December 20, 1984 |
| Section 1 | Buildings A, B, C, 12 units, built 1985, Official Records Book 1774, Page 2666 |
| Section 2 | Buildings D, E, F, G, 16 units, built 1986, Official Records Book 1861, Page 2870 |
| Consolidated description | One condominium under Official Records Book 2537, Page 3617 |
| Association | Carriedale Gardens Condominium Association, Inc. |
Sources: Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums project and developer files, PR1U010974; Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll; Florida Division of Corporations filings.
The first Carriedale Gardens transfers on the county file date from April to December 1985, at $165,900 to $181,000, and every sale in this page’s window is a resale between owners.
Carriedale Gardens was recorded on March 22, 1985, per the State of Florida condominium file PR1U010974, Carriedale Gardens A Condo, which lists 28 units. The county records Section 1 at Official Records Book 1774, Page 2666 and Section 2 at Official Records Book 1861, Page 2870 in the Lee County Clerk’s records.
The declaration is the founding document of the condominium: it defines the units and common elements, sets each unit’s share of expenses and holds the use rules, including leasing, pet and any age rules, as amended. The county now describes the whole condominium by the consolidated declaration recorded at Official Records Book 2537, Page 3617 in the Lee County Clerk’s records. That recording, with any later amendments, is the document a buyer’s attorney or title agent reads, not a summary in listing records. Its recording date was not retrieved for this page; the Clerk’s index shows it.
The State of Florida developer file names Fiddlesticks, Ltd., at 15000 Fiddlesticks Boulevard, as the developer of Carriedale Gardens, project PR1U010974. No builder or general contractor for Carriedale Gardens is named in any county, state, club or corporate record we read, so this page does not name one.
Fiddlesticks itself dates from the early 1980s: the club dates itself “Since 1982”, and the Long Mean course opened in 1983, so Carriedale Gardens was among the community’s early attached neighborhoods. The community’s Scottish street names, Carriedale among them, came from a list of Scottish names the founders considered for the community itself. The developer’s role ended when control passed to the owners’ association; the association’s records and the recorded documents at the Lee County Clerk show when.
Carriedale Gardens was recorded in two sections a year apart. Section 1, recorded at Official Records Book 1774, Page 2666, holds Buildings A, B and C, 12 units built in 1985; Section 2, recorded at Official Records Book 1861, Page 2870, holds Buildings D, E, F and G, 16 units built in 1986.
The sections differ in two ways an owner notices: the county codes every Section 1 unit with a carport and every Section 2 unit with a garage, and the three-bedroom plan is 1,490 square feet in Section 1 and 1,547 square feet in Section 2. Today the county describes both sections as one condominium under Official Records Book 2537, Page 3617. A separate Carriedale Gardens II association shows on the state’s corporate register as inactive by merger.
Carriedale Gardens is governed by Carriedale Gardens Condominium Association, Inc., filed December 20, 1984 and active, with amended and restated articles filed December 28, 2023, and by Fiddlesticks Country Club as the community’s master club. Carriedale Gardens owners answer to both for fees and rules.
A third entity, Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc., also filed in 1984, shares the condominium association’s address, and the club’s packets list one “Carriedale HOA” for the street. Its role is not public, so confirm with the association what, if anything, the street HOA levies. The club lists Suitor and Associates (239-437-0340) as manager for the Carriedale associations, and the county mails the common-element record in care of Suitor Middleton Cox and Associates; confirm the current manager before you buy.
Carriedale Gardens has 16 three-bedroom, two-bath units of 1,490 or 1,547 heated square feet and 12 two-bedroom, two-bath units of 1,143, 1,180 or 1,188 square feet, per the 2026 Lee County roll. Each Carriedale Gardens building holds one bedroom count: Buildings A, C, E and F are three-bedroom, and B, D and G are two-bedroom.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll).
| Building | Addresses | Units | Heated sq ft | Beds / baths | Parking (county roll) | Built |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 15626 #1, #2; 15628 #3, #4 | 4 | 1,490 | 3 / 2 | carport | 1985 |
| B | 15632 #1, #2; 15634 #3, #4 | 4 | 1,180 (#1, #2); 1,143 (#3, #4) | 2 / 2 | carport | 1985 |
| C | 15636 #1, #2; 15638 #3, #4 | 4 | 1,490 | 3 / 2 | carport | 1985 |
| D | 15660 #1, #2; 15662 #3, #4 | 4 | 1,188 (#1, #2); 1,143 (#3, #4) | 2 / 2 | garage | 1986 |
| E | 15664 #1, #2; 15666 #3, #4 | 4 | 1,547 | 3 / 2 | garage | 1986 |
| F | 15670 #1, #2; 15672 #3, #4 | 4 | 1,547 | 3 / 2 | garage | 1986 |
| G | 15674 #1, #2; 15676 #3, #4 | 4 | 1,143 (#1, #2); 1,188 (#3, #4) | 2 / 2 | garage | 1986 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll.
By size, the condominium holds 8 units of 1,490 square feet, 8 of 1,547, 6 of 1,143, 4 of 1,188 and 2 of 1,180. Listing records describe the buildings as block and stucco with shingle roofs, with a lanai or enclosed patio, split bedrooms and a storage locker; confirm each with the association and an inspection.
Carriedale Gardens has two three-bedroom, two-bath plans: a 1,490 square foot plan in Section 1 Buildings A and C, eight units with carports, and a 1,547 square foot plan in Section 2 Buildings E and F, eight units coded with garages. They carry the condominium’s highest 2026 just values.
The 1,490 square foot units range from $196,971 to $197,458 in 2026 just value, and the 1,547 square foot units from $201,359 to $222,243. The 1,547 square foot plan has the deeper sale record, seven qualified resales from $142,500 to $350,000 between February 2025 and October 2026, including the $350,000 high; the 1,490 square foot plan recorded two, at $305,000 and $180,000. A buyer who wants a third bedroom inside Fiddlesticks at the lower end of the club’s values starts with these 16 units.
Carriedale Gardens has three two-bedroom, two-bath sizes: 1,143 square feet (six units, in Buildings B, D and G), 1,188 square feet (four units, in D and G) and 1,180 square feet (two units, in Building B). The 2026 just values of these 12 Carriedale Gardens units run $158,616 to $174,624.
The two-bedroom units are spread across Section 1 (Building B, with carports) and Section 2 (Buildings D and G, garage-coded). The 1,188 square foot plan recorded four qualified resales from $125,000 to $249,900 between May 2025 and September 2026, and the 1,143 square foot plan one, at $100,000. The 1,180 square foot pair in Building B recorded no sale in the window. Because the club’s costs are the same for every unit, the two-bedroom plans carry the same membership and dues as the three-bedroom plans.
Carriedale Gardens’ Section 1 units, Buildings A, B and C, are coded with carports on the county roll, and listing records describe a combination one-car and golf-cart carport. Section 2 units, Buildings D to G, are coded with garages, but listing records describe a detached carport or golf-cart garage with a door.
The two sources conflict, and this page does not resolve it: confirm on site, and in the declaration, what each Section 2 unit’s parking space is and whether it is assigned to the unit or a limited common element. Lee County permit records show a 2017 permit series, finaled June 1, 2026, covering carport beam extensions at the rear of the units at 15672 and 15676 Carriedale Ln. No Section 1 unit has a private garage on the county roll.
The county roll records every Carriedale Gardens building as two stories but does not record which floor each unit is on. Listing records place 15670 #1 and 15628 #3 on the second floor and 15672 #4 and 15676 #4 on the first floor, which suggests odd-numbered Carriedale Gardens units are upstairs.
That pattern is not confirmed for all 28 units, so confirm the floor of a specific unit with the association or on a visit. Floor matters for three reasons buyers raise most often: the stairs, since the buildings are two-story garden buildings and the records we read do not describe an elevator; the view over the golf course; and the questions an insurer and a lender ask. A seller should state the floor plainly in the listing, because buyers sort by it.
Every Carriedale Gardens owner must hold a Fiddlesticks Resident Equity membership. The joining fee is $150,000 from November 1, 2026, up from $115,000, with $1 of equity refundable on resale, plus a $2,000 club real estate transaction fee at closing. Club dues for 2026-27 are $2,319.50 a month; confirm every figure with the club.
Data updated: November 2026 (Fiddlesticks Country Club Membership Information Packet 2026-2027).
| Club cost | 2026-27 figure |
|---|---|
| Resident Equity joining fee | $150,000 from November 1, 2026 (was $115,000); $1 refundable on resale |
| Club real estate transaction fee | $2,000 at closing |
| Club dues, operating | $1,730 a month |
| Club dues, capital | $383 a month |
| Road reserve | $100 a month |
| Wastewater plant | $44 a month |
| Xfinity TV and internet | $62.50 a month |
| Club dues total | $2,319.50 a month |
| Food and beverage minimum | None |
| Capital Improvement Assessment | $295 a month for 120 months, or $26,500 lump sum, or $9,365 a year over three payments |
Source: Fiddlesticks Country Club Membership Information Packet 2026-2027 and membership page. Confirm with the club.
The club’s costs are the same for a Carriedale Gardens two-bedroom unit as for any other Fiddlesticks home, which is the central fact of buying here. Club dues alone come to $27,834 a year at $2,319.50 a month, by our arithmetic. Fiddlesticks Country Club has its own guide on our site.
A Carriedale Gardens buyer pays the Fiddlesticks Resident Equity joining fee of $150,000 for purchases from November 1, 2026, up from $115,000 before that date, per the club’s 2026-2027 packet. Only $1 of that equity is refundable when the owner later sells, and a $2,000 club transaction fee is added at closing.
By our arithmetic, the joining fee can approach or exceed the price of a Carriedale Gardens unit. Three of the 14 tracked resales recorded below $150,000, and the median resale, $237,450, is only about $87,000 above it. A buyer’s cash to close is therefore the unit price plus $152,000 in club charges, before the usual closing costs. Confirm the fee in force on your closing date with the club, because the club sets it.
Fiddlesticks club dues for Carriedale Gardens owners are $2,319.50 a month for 2026-27, and they include wastewater, the club’s common areas, 24-hour roving security, golf, tennis, bocce, pickleball, the clubhouse, fitness and the cabana pool, per the club’s packet. There is no food and beverage minimum.
The dues are built from five lines: operating $1,730, capital $383, road reserve $100, the wastewater plant $44 and Xfinity TV and internet $62.50. The club dues are separate from the Carriedale Gardens condominium assessment, which the association bills quarterly and which the next section covers. Confirm the current dues with the club, which sets them each season.
The Fiddlesticks Capital Improvement Assessment began on September 1, 2026, and Carriedale Gardens owners pay it like every other owner: $295 a month for 120 months, a $26,500 lump sum, or $9,365 a year over three payments. The assessment is tied to the property and transfers with it on sale.
That transfer rule matters in a Carriedale Gardens contract. If the seller chose the monthly plan, the buyer inherits the remaining payments; if the seller paid the lump sum, the unit carries no balance. The club’s estoppel shows which applies, so ask for it early. The assessment funds the Cabana kitchen, the Clubhouse renovation starting in May 2027 and the Gatehouse in Spring 2028. Confirm the balance on a specific unit with the club.
A Carriedale Gardens buyer files the Fiddlesticks equity application and the club’s background-check form, and the seller files a Notice of New Contract with the club, per the club’s realtors page. The condominium association runs its own approval alongside the club’s.
Florida caps a condominium association’s transfer approval fee by law, so ask the association for its current fee and timeline. In practice, a Carriedale Gardens sale needs two estoppels, one from the association’s manager for the condominium assessment and one from the club for dues and the Capital Improvement Assessment, and two approvals. Build both into the contract timeline so neither holds up closing.
No Carriedale Gardens association budget is public. Listing records show a Carriedale Gardens condominium assessment of $2,160 a quarter in 2025 and $2,250 a quarter in 2026, about $720 to $750 a month, covering management, insurance, irrigation water, grounds, pest control, recreation, reserves, roads, street lights, security and water. Confirm with the association.
Data updated: November 2026 (listing records, 2025 to 2026; Fiddlesticks Country Club 2026-2027 packet; Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll).
| Item | Carriedale Gardens |
|---|---|
| Condo assessment | $2,160 a quarter (2025) and $2,250 a quarter (2026) per listing records, about $720 to $750 a month; confirm with the association |
| Fee covers, per listing records | Management, insurance, irrigation water, legal and accounting, grounds, pest control, recreation facilities, reserve fund, road maintenance, street lights, security, water |
| Club dues | $2,319.50 a month (2026-27), separate from the condo assessment |
| Capital Improvement Assessment | $295 a month for 120 months, or $26,500, or $9,365 a year over three payments; tied to the property |
| CDD | None; taxing district 047, South Trail Fire |
| Special assessments | None found in public sources; confirm on the estoppel |
| Transfer approval fee | Capped by Florida law; ask the association for its current fee |
| Association | Carriedale Gardens Condominium Association, Inc. |
| Manager | The club lists Suitor and Associates (239-437-0340); confirm the current manager before you buy |
Sources: listing records; Fiddlesticks Country Club Membership Information Packet 2026-2027; Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll.
At $2,250 a quarter, the condo assessment comes to $9,000 a year, by our arithmetic, before any special assessment. The assessment is set by the association’s annual budget, so the current figure is the one on the estoppel certificate, not the one in a listing record.
The listing field for the Carriedale Gardens condo fee names association management, insurance, irrigation water, legal and accounting, grounds, pest control, recreation facilities, the reserve fund, road maintenance, street lights, security and water. Those items come from listing records, not the association’s budget, so confirm each one with the association before you buy.
The insurance in that list is the association’s master policy for the buildings and common elements. It is not a unit owner’s own policy: an owner still carries an HO-6 policy for the interior and personal property, and flood cover is a separate question. The reserve fund line matters most to a buyer, because reserves pay for roofs, painting and paving before they become assessments. Florida’s two-story exemption from the structural integrity reserve study does not remove the reserve requirement for those items, a point the condo law section of this guide explains.
Some listing pages for Carriedale Gardens show an “HOA fee” of $2,260 or $2,327 a month. Those figures are club dues, not the Carriedale Gardens condo fee: $2,260 equals the 2025-26 club dues of $2,180 plus the $80 Loch Ness line that ended in March 2026, by our arithmetic.
The condominium’s own assessment is the quarterly figure, $2,160 to $2,250 a quarter in listing records. A buyer who reads a listing’s monthly “HOA fee” as the whole cost will undercount by the condo assessment and the Capital Improvement Assessment; one who adds it to the quarterly figure as if both were condo fees will double count. Ask the association and the club for their own current numbers, side by side.
By our arithmetic, not a published figure, a Carriedale Gardens owner on the club’s monthly capital plan pays about $3,335 to $3,365 a month before property tax and insurance: club dues of $2,319.50, a condo assessment of about $720 to $750 a month per listing records, and the $295 Capital Improvement Assessment.
| Monthly line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Fiddlesticks club dues (2026-27) | $2,319.50 |
| Condo assessment, per listing records | about $720 to $750 |
| Capital Improvement Assessment (monthly plan) | $295 |
| Total before tax and insurance | about $3,335 to $3,365 |
Source: our arithmetic from the Fiddlesticks Country Club Membership Information Packet 2026-2027 and listing records. Confirm with the association and the club.
On top of the monthly figure sits the one-time $150,000 joining fee and $2,000 transaction fee. Add property tax at about $1,336 per $100,000 of taxable value, an HO-6 policy and any flood policy. An owner who paid the capital assessment as a lump sum drops the $295 line.
No Carriedale Gardens special assessment was found in public sources, but public sources rarely show one. The estoppel certificate the association issues for a sale states any special assessment levied or approved, and that document, not a listing record, is the one that counts for a Carriedale Gardens buyer.
Three things drive assessment risk at a condominium of this age: roof, paint and paving reserves, and whether owners have voted to waive or reduce them; storm repairs, including any from Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton; and insurance renewals. The club’s Capital Improvement Assessment is a separate, already-announced charge at the club level. Recent Lee County permits at Carriedale Gardens addresses include two association condominium permits in 2025 and 2026; ask the association what work they covered and how it was paid for.
The club lists Suitor and Associates (239-437-0340) as the manager for the Carriedale associations, and the Lee County Property Appraiser mails the Carriedale Gardens common-element record in care of Suitor Middleton Cox and Associates. Confirm the current manager before you buy.
The association itself is Carriedale Gardens Condominium Association, Inc., on the State of Florida corporate register since December 20, 1984. The manager is the office that issues the association’s estoppel certificate, processes purchase and rental applications and holds the official records owners can request. The club’s own estoppel and approvals run through the club, not the manager.
A Carriedale Gardens buyer should ask the association for the estoppel certificate, the current budget, the reserve balance and any vote to waive or reduce reserves, the master insurance declarations and deductible, recent board minutes, the declaration and rules, and the record of any repairs or claims from Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton.
Those documents answer the questions a listing record cannot: what the assessment is today, whether a special assessment is coming, how the buildings are insured, how old the roofs are and what the storms cost. Add the leasing, pet and any age rules from the declaration, because none of them is public, and ask what, if anything, the Carriedale Homeowner’s Association levies. Then ask the club for its estoppel. Florida’s Division of Condominiums inspections page explains the milestone and reserve study rules. We help buyers read these before the inspection period ends.
Every Carriedale Gardens unit is taxed in Lee County district 047, South Trail Fire, in unincorporated Lee County, where the 2026 adopted total millage is 13.3623, per the Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 millage book, final printing. The 2026 proposed rate on the TRIM notices was 13.3738, and the 2025 total was 13.4125.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 Taxing District Millage Book, final printing, district 047; Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll).
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Taxing district | 047, South Trail Fire, unincorporated Lee County |
| Total millage, 2026 adopted | 13.3623 |
| Total millage, 2026 proposed (TRIM) | 13.3738 |
| Total millage, 2025 | 13.4125 |
| Of which South Trail Fire District, 2026 | 2.5000 |
| Of which Lee County general revenue, 2026 | 3.7623 |
| Of which schools, 2026 | 2.2480 and 3.0230 |
| Tax per $100,000 of taxable value at 13.3623 mills | About $1,336 a year |
| Homestead units | 9 of 28 |
| 2026 median just value | $196,971 |
| CDD | None |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 Taxing District Millage Book, final printing, district 047; Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll.
The adopted 2026 rate is a little below both the proposed 2026 rate and the 2025 rate. A 2026 TRIM notice for a parcel in the same district shows how the levies are laid out line by line.
To estimate taxes on a Carriedale Gardens purchase, multiply the expected taxable value, less any exemptions, by the total millage and divide by 1,000. At 13.3623 mills each $100,000 of taxable value is about $1,336 a year, so a taxable value of $200,000 comes to about $2,672, by our arithmetic.
As a second illustration, the 2026 median just value of the 28 units, $196,971, at 13.3623 mills is about $2,632 a year before exemptions, and a taxable value equal to the $237,450 median sale would be about $3,173. Add any non-ad valorem charges the Tax Collector’s bill shows. The seller’s current bill is not a guide, because a buyer’s assessment resets after purchase, and the club’s dues and the condo assessment are separate from the tax bill.
A Carriedale Gardens owner who makes the unit a permanent residence can claim Florida’s homestead exemption by applying with the Lee County Property Appraiser after closing. On the 2026 roll, 9 of the 28 Carriedale Gardens units carry it, and under Florida’s Save Our Homes rules that protected assessment resets when the unit sells.
That protection does not transfer to a buyer. After a sale the assessment resets to market value, and the new owner applies for the exemption in their own name. For a unit that is not a permanent residence, there is no homestead exemption and no Save Our Homes cap on the assessment, which is the case for 19 of the 28 units on the 2026 roll. We estimate a buyer’s first full bill before an offer is written.
A Carriedale Gardens seller’s tax bill reflects that owner’s exemptions and assessment history, not what a new owner will pay. Under Florida’s Save Our Homes rules, a homesteaded owner’s assessment can sit far below market value for years, and it resets to market value after the sale.
For the 19 Carriedale Gardens units without a homestead exemption, the gap is usually smaller, but the new owner’s bill still depends on the new assessment and on whether the buyer qualifies for any exemption. The tax figures in listing records are the seller’s numbers, not the buyer’s, and we do not repeat them here. The current TRIM notice and the Lee County Property Appraiser’s parcel record are the better starting points.
No. Carriedale Gardens sits in Lee County taxing district 047, South Trail Fire, and no community development district or special-district line appears on the county roll for the condominium. Carriedale Gardens owners pay the standard county, school, fire district and regional levies, plus the association’s assessment and the club’s charges.
The club’s road reserve and wastewater plant lines are billed in club dues, not on the tax bill, which is why the tax bill here looks simpler than at many newer Lee County communities with a CDD. Florida’s seller flood disclosure under section 689.302 of the Florida Statutes also applies at contract, so a seller’s disclosure package and the tax bill travel together. Confirm any non-ad valorem charge on the current bill for the specific unit.
Selling? Your tax proration and the buyer’s reassessment both shape the net; call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or request a free home valuation. Buying? Marc will estimate your post-purchase bill and your full club cost; call (239) 457-1610 or see how we represent buyers.
Carriedale Gardens sits in FEMA Zone X, an area of minimal flood hazard, on every sampled unit, and the county’s flood map layer places Carriedale Lane in Zone X on panel 12071C0439H, effective November 17, 2022. No A or V zone appears anywhere inside Fiddlesticks Country Club on the effective map.
Data updated: November 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer; Lee County GIS flood map layer; FEMA Community Rating System eligible communities list effective October 1, 2026; Lee County GIS evacuation zone layer).
| Flood fact | What the record shows | Source |
|---|---|---|
| FEMA flood zone | Zone X, area of minimal flood hazard, on five sampled units (15632 #1, 15636 #2, 15660 #2, 15672 #3, 15676 #4) | FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer |
| Flood map panel | 12071C0439H, effective November 17, 2022, the panel for Carriedale Lane | Lee County GIS flood map layer |
| Special flood hazard area | No A or V zone anywhere in Fiddlesticks | FEMA; Lee County GIS |
| Lender rule | No federal mandatory flood purchase in Zone X; a lender may still require a policy | FEMA |
| Community Rating System | Unincorporated Lee County Class 5; the 25 percent discount applies to NFIP policies in the special flood hazard area | FEMA CRS list, October 1, 2026 |
| Elevation certificates | None found in public sources | Our search |
| Evacuation zone | Lee County Zone C, storm surge zone 3 | Lee County GIS |
| Seller disclosure | Florida flood disclosure (Fla. Stat. 689.302) applies at contract | Florida Statutes |
Sources: FEMA Flood Map Service Center; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer; Lee County GIS flood map layer; FEMA Community Rating System eligible communities, October 2026.
Zone X is still a flood zone. FEMA draws it where the mapped risk is lowest, outside the special flood hazard area, but heavy rain, blocked drainage and storm water can reach any building in Lee County. The useful reading of the map is narrower: the federal lender rule that applies in Zone AE does not apply at Carriedale Gardens, and the flood premium question is usually smaller. Flood cover is still worth pricing for every unit.
A federally backed lender is not required to make flood insurance a condition of a loan at Carriedale Gardens, because Zone X sits outside the special flood hazard area where the federal mandatory purchase rule applies. Any lender may still require a flood policy under its own underwriting rules, so ask yours early.
The lender orders its own flood determination before closing, and that determination, not a listing field, decides what the lender asks for. For a condominium, a lender also looks at the association’s insurance, so the master policy declarations page is a document the underwriter will want. A cash buyer is outside the lender rule altogether, but the choice to carry flood cover is the same choice either way.
For a Carriedale Gardens owner, Zone X means FEMA maps the land as an area of minimal flood hazard, outside the 1 percent annual chance floodplain. It does not mean the buildings cannot take water; it means the federal map places the street in its lowest-risk category on the current panel.
The map is a planning and insurance tool, and it is revised from time to time. The panel for Carriedale Lane, 12071C0439H, took effect on November 17, 2022, and a later revision could change any address. Treat the current zone as one input alongside the association’s own claim history, the unit’s condition and what an insurance agent quotes for flood cover.
Every Carriedale Gardens unit shares the same FEMA zone, because the zone applies to the land and the building, not to the floor. In general, a ground-floor unit sits closer to any rising water than an upstairs unit, which is why insurers ask about the lowest floor when they quote flood cover.
Listing records suggest that odd-numbered units are upstairs and even-numbered units downstairs, but that pattern is not confirmed for all 28 units, so check the unit you are buying. An upstairs owner still shares the association’s exposure through the common elements, the carports and the master policy deductible. Ask the insurance agent to quote flood cover for the specific unit, by floor, rather than assuming a second floor means no exposure.
Carriedale Gardens is in unincorporated Lee County, which FEMA rates Community Rating System Class 5 on its list effective October 1, 2026. The 25 percent discount that rating carries applies to NFIP policies in the special flood hazard area, and Carriedale Gardens is outside that area in Zone X.
That makes the rating a question to ask, not a number to assume. Ask your insurance agent how the community’s class applies to a Carriedale Gardens policy, if at all. Because Carriedale Gardens is not inside the City of Fort Myers, the county’s rating, not the city’s, is the one that matters. FEMA publishes the full CRS list, and a community’s class can change at later reviews.
No elevation certificate for any Carriedale Gardens building turned up in public sources. Zone X does not require one for the federal lender rule, but an insurer may ask for one, and a certificate on file can help a flood quote, especially for a ground-floor unit.
Ask the seller and the association’s manager whether a certificate exists for the building before paying a surveyor for a new one. If one does, keep a copy with the purchase file. If none does, an insurance agent can tell you whether a certificate would change the quote enough to justify the cost for that unit.
To check one Carriedale Gardens address, enter it on FEMA’s Flood Map Service Center and note the zone and the panel number. For the even addresses from 15626 to 15676 Carriedale Lane, the effective map should return Zone X on panel 12071C0439H, effective November 17, 2022.
The FEMA Flood Map Service Center is the public record; a listing’s flood field is typed by an agent and is not a determination. FloodSmart, the National Flood Insurance Program’s public site, explains how flood policies are written. Keep a printout of the FEMA result with the purchase file, along with the association’s insurance declarations. We pull the flood zone for every Carriedale Gardens unit before a buyer binds insurance, so the quote and the lender’s determination match.
Florida’s seller flood disclosure, in Florida Statutes section 689.302, applies when a Carriedale Gardens condo goes under contract. The seller completes the statutory disclosure, so a buyer should read it, and ask about anything on it, before the inspection period ends.
Building-level flood history sits with the association, not with one unit owner, so read the disclosure alongside the association’s records. A Carriedale Gardens seller helps the sale by collecting the paperwork early: any unit claim history, the current HO-6 declarations and anything the association has disclosed about the buildings and common elements.
Selling a Carriedale Gardens condo? A clean insurance file and a completed disclosure are selling documents; call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or start with a free home valuation. Buying? Marc pulls the flood zone and the association’s insurance file for your unit; call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we represent buyers.
Carriedale Gardens is in Lee County Evacuation Zone C, storm surge zone 3, at every building, per the county’s evacuation zone layer queried on November 20, 2026. Lee County announces evacuation orders by zone, so Carriedale Gardens owners need to know their letter before a storm, not during one.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County GIS EvacuationZones layer, last edited March 11, 2025, queried at the Carriedale Gardens building points on November 20, 2026).
| Buildings | Addresses | Evacuation zone | Storm surge zone |
|---|---|---|---|
| A, B, C (Section 1) | 15626 to 15638 Carriedale Ln | Zone C | 3 |
| D, E (Section 2) | 15660 to 15666 Carriedale Ln | Zone C | 3 |
| F, G (Section 2) | 15670 to 15676 Carriedale Ln | Zone C | 3 |
Source: Lee County GIS, Evacuation Zones layer; Lee County Emergency Management, Know Your Zone.
The same query for the Carriedale Cottages side of the street returned the same zone in November 2026. The county revises the layer from time to time, so check it again at the start of each hurricane season.
No. At Carriedale Gardens the two maps answer different questions. Lee County’s Evacuation Zone C sets when owners are told to leave in a storm, based on storm surge modeling; FEMA’s Zone X sets the flood insurance and lender rules. Lee County itself says an evacuation zone is not a flood zone.
An owner needs both answers. The flood zone shapes the insurance file; the evacuation zone shapes the storm plan. Every Carriedale Gardens building sits in the same evacuation zone, so an order for Zone C applies to an upstairs unit and a downstairs unit at the same time. The order follows the address, not the floor.
A Carriedale Gardens owner plans for a storm by knowing the zone, Zone C, and the route out through the Fiddlesticks gatehouse to Daniels Parkway and I-75. If no one will be at the unit, arrange in advance who secures it, who checks it afterward and how the association reaches owners.
Our free-flow route table puts I-75 at Exit 131 about 2.67 miles and 6.8 minutes from a Fiddlesticks community point, but storm traffic is not free-flow, and FDOT’s rebuild of that interchange runs to an estimated summer 2028. Leave when the order comes. Ask the association and the club what each does before a storm: securing the pool parcel and the carports, the club’s own common areas and who reports conditions to owners after the storm passes.
To check the evacuation zone for a Carriedale Gardens unit, enter the address on Lee County’s Know Your Zone lookup or read the county’s Evacuation Zones map layer. For the even addresses from 15626 to 15676 Carriedale Lane, the layer returned Zone C, storm surge zone 3, in November 2026.
The county’s evacuation layer is the public record behind the lookup, and the zone is set by location, so every unit in a building shares it. Lee County’s public safety pages on leegov.com carry storm preparation guidance, and the state’s Florida Division of Emergency Management publishes statewide preparedness material.
No public report we read names damage at Carriedale Gardens or anywhere in Fiddlesticks. Lee County’s public damage assessment layers returned no records on Carriedale Lane, and golf-industry reports said Hurricane Ian’s damage was generally less severe east of US 41, where Carriedale Gardens lies. That is a gap, not proof of no damage.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Hurricane Ian after-action report; Lee County GIS damage layers, queried November 2026; National Weather Service Milton tornado summary; county-recorded qualified sales).
| Storm or record | What the record shows near Carriedale Gardens | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Hurricane Ian, September 28, 2022 | 24,585 damaged residential structures countywide | Lee County Ian after-action report |
| Golf courses after Ian | Damage generally less severe east of US 41 | GCM, golf industry reporting |
| County damage layers | No records on Carriedale Lane in the Initial Damage Assessments and Damage Inventory layers | Lee County GIS, November 2026 query |
| Resale after Ian | $390,000 recorded in December 2022 | County-recorded qualified sales |
| Milton tornado, October 2024 | EF2 track began about 2.6 miles west near US 41 and moved north-northwest, away from Fiddlesticks | National Weather Service survey |
| Helene and Milton, 2024 | No public report of damage at Carriedale Gardens found | Our search |
Sources: GCM, Storm warning: Lessons from Hurricane Ian; National Weather Service, Hurricane Milton tornado summary; Lee County, Hurricanes Helene and Milton After Action Report; Lee County GIS public map services.
Storm history for a condominium sits with the association. The board minutes, insurance claims and repair contracts for the seven buildings and the pool parcel are association records, so they, not a county average, answer the question for Carriedale Gardens.
Hurricane Ian struck Southwest Florida on September 28, 2022, and Lee County’s after-action report counts 24,585 damaged residential structures countywide. Golf-industry reporting after the storm said damage was generally less severe east of US 41, which is where Fiddlesticks and Carriedale Gardens sit, off Daniels Parkway.
Carriedale Gardens is inland, in FEMA Zone X and Evacuation Zone C, about 29 free-flow minutes from Fort Myers Beach by our route table. Wind and rain reach inland buildings too, which is why the association’s own records, not the coastal surge figures, are the documents to read.
No public report names damage at Carriedale Gardens in Hurricane Ian, and Lee County’s public damage layers returned no records on Carriedale Lane. That is a gap in the public record, not a finding that the buildings were undamaged; the association’s claim and repair files are where the answer for Carriedale Gardens sits.
A buyer should ask the association directly whether the roofs, carports, windows or any unit took damage, whether an insurance claim was filed, what was repaired, who paid and whether a special assessment followed. A roof or opening replaced after 2022 also matters for wind-mitigation credit, covered below, so ask for the permit and the contractor’s paperwork.
Carriedale Gardens resales kept recording after Ian. A unit at 15672 #4 recorded at $390,000 in December 2022, three months after the storm, and a 2023 sale recorded at $270,000. Those are price facts, not statements about building condition, and the samples are small.
Later resales ran lower. The seven 2025 sales had a median of $215,000 and the seven 2026 sales through October 6 a median of $249,900, both below the 2022 pair of $395,000 and $390,000. Many factors move condo prices across Lee County, including club costs, insurance and unit condition, so the sales record alone does not explain the change.
No public report of damage at Carriedale Gardens was found for Hurricanes Helene or Milton in 2024. The National Weather Service survey of Milton’s Fort Myers EF2 tornado places its start about 2.6 miles west of Carriedale Lane, near US 41, with a track running north-northwest, away from Fiddlesticks.
Lee County’s Helene and Milton after-action report documents the county’s response to both storms. Neither it nor any other public source we read names Carriedale Gardens, so the association’s minutes, claims and repair records remain the documents that answer the question for these two storms.
A Carriedale Gardens buyer should ask the association for its claim history for Ian, Helene and Milton, the repairs made to each of the seven buildings and the pool parcel, any special assessment that followed, and the current master policy’s wind deductible. The seller answers separately for the unit itself.
From the seller, ask about water intrusion, any unit-level claim, what was repaired and whether the work was permitted. From the association, through the estoppel request and the official records, ask for board minutes from late 2022 onward and the current insurance declarations. From the club, ask what its common areas and the golf courses went through, since club costs are part of every owner’s budget.
Condo insurance at Carriedale Gardens works in two layers. The association carries the master policy on the buildings and common elements, and listing records name insurance among the items the condo fee covers. Each owner carries an HO-6 policy for the unit’s interior items, contents and liability. Flood cover is a separate decision.
Data updated: November 2026 (Florida Statutes s. 718.111(11); listing records for the condo fee field; FEMA).
| Insurance layer | Who carries it at Carriedale Gardens | What to confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Master policy (wind and hazard) | The association, through the condo fee per listing records | Carrier, coverage, wind deductible |
| Association flood policy | The association, if carried | Whether carried, limits, deductible |
| HO-6 unit owner policy | Each owner | Interior items Florida law assigns to the owner, contents, liability, loss assessment |
| Unit owner flood policy | Each owner, by choice or lender requirement | Cover for interior items and contents |
| Club property | Fiddlesticks Country Club | Separate from the condominium |
Sources: Florida Statutes, section 718.111; listing records (insurance named in the condo fee field); FEMA Flood Map Service Center.
No public source gives the association’s carrier, deductible or premium, so we do not quote one. Ask the association’s manager for the current declarations page before you ask an agent for an HO-6 quote.
The Carriedale Gardens master policy is the association’s insurance on the seven buildings and the common elements, and listing records name insurance among the condo fee’s covered items. The carrier, the limits and the wind deductible are not public; confirm them with the association, because the deductible decides what owners could be assessed.
Florida law lets an association base its coverage on replacement cost set by an independent appraisal at least once every three years. Ask when the last appraisal was done and whether the master policy’s limits follow it. The master policy and the declaration of condominium together draw the line between the association’s responsibility and the owner’s, and an insurance agent needs both to write a sound HO-6 policy.
Under section 718.111(11) of the Florida Statutes, the association’s policy excludes items inside a Carriedale Gardens unit that the owner insures: personal property, floor, wall and ceiling coverings, electrical fixtures, appliances, water heaters, water filters, built-in cabinets and countertops, and window treatments. The owner’s policy covers those.
The same section says an association is not obligated to pay to repair owner-installed improvements that benefit only one unit, and that a unit owner’s policy must conform to section 627.714. In practice, a remodeled Carriedale Gardens kitchen or bathroom is the owner’s to insure. If you are buying a unit described in listing records as completely remodeled, set the HO-6 limits to match what is actually in the unit.
An HO-6 policy covers a Carriedale Gardens owner’s share of the condominium: the interior items Florida law assigns to the owner, personal property, liability and, if added, loss assessment coverage. Lenders require it on financed units, and owners without a loan usually carry it for the same reasons.
Loss assessment coverage is the part buyers most often overlook. If a storm loss falls inside the master policy’s deductible, the association can assess owners to pay it, and loss assessment coverage can help with that bill up to its limit. Ask the insurance agent to read the master policy’s deductible before setting the loss assessment limit, so the two match.
Flood insurance for a Carriedale Gardens condo is separate from the master policy and the HO-6, because standard property policies exclude flood. In Zone X no federal lender rule requires it, though a lender may, so the decision usually rests with the owner and the association’s own choices.
Ask the association whether it carries a flood policy on the buildings, and its limits and deductible. Then ask an agent to quote unit-level flood cover for the interior items and contents; in Zone X, flood cover is still worth pricing rather than dismissing. A downstairs unit and an upstairs unit share the zone but face different exposure inside the unit.
A Carriedale Gardens buyer should request the master policy declarations page, the association’s flood policy declarations if one exists, the wind deductible, the most recent replacement cost appraisal, the association’s claim history since 2022, and the seller’s current HO-6 and any flood policy declarations for the unit.
Get insurance quotes inside the inspection period, not after it. A unit owner’s insurance cost sits on top of the condo assessment, about $2,160 to $2,250 a quarter in listing records, the club dues of $2,319.50 a month and the club’s Capital Improvement Assessment. Confirm the current condo assessment and any special assessment with the association through the estoppel certificate.
Florida’s milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study apply to condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories, and all seven Carriedale Gardens buildings are two-story on the county record, so neither appears to apply. Reserve rules, the official-records website rule for 25 or more units and the DBPR account rule still reach Carriedale Gardens.
Data updated: November 2026 (Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums milestone inspection and SIRS page; Florida Statutes 2026, ss. 718.111 and 718.112; Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll).
| Requirement | What applies at Carriedale Gardens | What to confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Milestone inspection | Three or more habitable stories; the buildings are two-story, so it does not appear to apply | Written confirmation from the association |
| Structural integrity reserve study (SIRS) | Same three-story threshold; s. 718.112(2)(g) “does not apply to buildings less than three stories in height” | Written confirmation from the association |
| Statutory reserves | Roof replacement, building painting and pavement resurfacing under s. 718.112(2)(f), unless owners waive or reduce them by majority vote | The budget and any waiver vote |
| Official-records website | Associations of 25 or more units; Carriedale Gardens has 28 | The owner portal |
| DBPR online account | Every association, by October 1, 2025 | That the account exists |
| Building era | 1985 to 1986, before the 1994 wind-code tightening and the 2002 Florida Building Code | Roof ages, openings, wind-mitigation report |
Sources: Florida DBPR, Milestone Inspections and SIRS; Florida Statutes, section 718.112 and section 718.111.
On the county record, no. Florida’s milestone inspection and SIRS apply to condominium buildings three or more habitable stories in height, and every Carriedale Gardens building is two stories. Section 718.112(2)(g) states that the SIRS paragraph “does not apply to buildings less than three stories in height.” Ask the association to confirm in writing.
The DBPR milestone inspection and SIRS page sets out the same three-story threshold. The exemption is a real difference from the mid-rise condominiums elsewhere in Lee County, where a SIRS can drive large reserve contributions. It is not a statement about the buildings’ condition; that still comes from the budget, the reserves, the roof history and the unit inspection.
Yes, unless owners vote otherwise. Section 718.112(2)(f) requires every condominium budget, including the Carriedale Gardens budget, to carry reserves for roof replacement, building painting and pavement resurfacing. Where no SIRS is required, owners may waive or reduce those reserves by a majority vote of the total voting interests.
Whether Carriedale Gardens funds its reserves in full or has waived or reduced them is not public. Listing records name a reserve fund among the condo fee’s covered items, but that does not show the amount. Ask the association’s manager for the current budget, the reserve schedule and the minutes of any waiver vote. Reserves that are thin today tend to show up later as a special assessment or a higher fee.
It appears so. The 2026 text of section 718.111(12)(g)1. requires an association managing a condominium with 25 or more units to post its official records on a website or app, and Carriedale Gardens has 28 units on the county roll. Ask the association for its owner portal and what it posts.
The threshold was lowered from 150 units to 25 by 2024 legislation as amended in 2025; the Florida House’s final bill analysis of 2025 HB 913 explains the change, and the statute text controls. The two Carriedale Cottages condominiums across the lane each have 12 units, below the threshold, which is one of the quieter differences between the two neighbors.
Florida required every condominium association, including the Carriedale Gardens association, to create an online account with the DBPR Division of Condominiums by October 1, 2025. The account is how the state reaches the association and how certain filings reach the state, so ask the manager to confirm it exists.
The state’s condominium file for Carriedale Gardens is “Carriedale Gardens A Condo,” PR1U010974, 28 units, recorded March 22, 1985. Searching myfloridalicense.com by that name or number shows the state’s record. If the state file and the association’s paperwork disagree on the name or manager, ask which is current before the estoppel request goes out.
Carriedale Gardens’ block-and-stucco buildings, per listing records, date from 1985 and 1986, before Florida’s 1994 wind-code tightening and the 2002 Florida Building Code. Wind-mitigation credit on an insurance policy therefore depends on later roofs and openings, and the roof ages at Carriedale Gardens are not public.
Fiddlesticks deed restrictions cap buildings at two stories and require a roof pitch of at least 4 in 12, and listing records describe shingle roofs. Ask the association when each building was last re-roofed, by whom and under which permit, and ask the seller for any wind-mitigation report on the unit. Impact-rated windows or doors added since, with their product approvals, can change a premium.
Recent Lee County permits at Carriedale Gardens addresses are routine: air conditioning systems, two association condominium permits in 2025 and 2026, and a 2026 bathroom remodel. A 2017 permit series finaled on June 1, 2026 covered carport beam extensions at 15672 and 15676 Carriedale Lane.
The two association permits were filed at 15662 in September 2025 and at 15674 in April 2026; the public record does not describe the work in detail, so ask the association what each covered. The county’s eConnect permit search shows the permit history for any address. No roof permit for the Carriedale Gardens buildings surfaced in the searches the research ran, which is why roof ages stay on the list of questions.
A Carriedale Gardens buyer should request the declaration of condominium and its amendments, the articles and bylaws, the rules, the current budget and reserve schedule, any reserve waiver vote, the insurance declarations, recent board minutes, an association estoppel certificate and a separate club estoppel from Fiddlesticks Country Club.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser; Lee County Clerk official records references from the county legal descriptions; Florida DBPR condominium file PR1U010974; Florida Division of Corporations).
| Record | Why it matters at Carriedale Gardens | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Declaration of condominium | Leasing, pet and use rules; unit boundaries | Lee County Clerk: Section 1 at Official Records Book 1774, Page 2666; Section 2 at Book 1861, Page 2870; consolidated description at Book 2537, Page 3617 |
| Articles and bylaws | Amended and restated articles filed December 28, 2023 | Florida Division of Corporations; the association |
| Budget and reserve schedule | The quarterly assessment and the statutory reserves | The association’s manager |
| Reserve waiver vote | Whether owners waived or reduced reserves | Board and owner meeting minutes |
| Insurance declarations | Master policy, any flood policy, deductibles | The association |
| Association estoppel | Assessment, special assessments, balance owed | The association, during the contract |
| Club estoppel | Dues, Capital Improvement Assessment balance, club charges | Fiddlesticks Country Club |
| State condominium file | Name, unit count, recording date | Florida DBPR, PR1U010974 |
Sources: Lee County Property Appraiser common element record and unit record for 15670 Carriedale Ln #1; Lee County Clerk; Florida Division of Corporations; Fiddlesticks Country Club Realtors page.
The association is Carriedale Gardens Condominium Association, Inc., filed December 20, 1984 and active. The club lists Suitor and Associates (239-437-0340) as manager for the Carriedale associations, and the county mails the common-element record in care of Suitor Middleton Cox and Associates. Confirm the current manager before you buy.
Getting the manager right early keeps a Carriedale Gardens closing on schedule, because the closing agent orders the association estoppel from whoever manages now. Ask the seller for the manager’s current contact, the owner portal and the most recent budget mailing, and confirm the same name with the club when the club estoppel is ordered.
Carriedale Gardens was recorded in two sections in the Lee County Clerk’s official records: Section 1 at Official Records Book 1774, Page 2666 and Section 2 at Book 1861, Page 2870. The county now describes the whole condominium under Book 2537, Page 3617, and the state file shows a March 22, 1985 recording.
Read the full set, not the original declaration alone: each section’s declaration, the consolidated instrument, every later amendment, the amended and restated articles of December 28, 2023, the bylaws and the current rules. The seller provides the governing documents under a Florida condominium resale contract, and the Lee County Clerk holds the recorded originals as the public backup.
A Carriedale Gardens estoppel certificate is the association’s written statement, issued for a sale, of the unit’s regular assessment, its due dates, any unpaid balance, any special assessment adopted and the amounts due at closing. The closing agent orders it from the association’s manager during the contract period.
The estoppel turns listing-record figures, about $2,160 to $2,250 a quarter, into confirmed numbers, and if it shows a different figure or a pending assessment, the estoppel controls. A Carriedale Gardens sale needs a second estoppel from the club, for dues and the Capital Improvement Assessment balance, which transfers with the unit. Read both the day they arrive.
Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc., filed in 1984, is a separate corporation that shares the Carriedale Gardens association’s address, and the club’s packets list one “Carriedale HOA” for the street. Its role is not public, so confirm with the association what, if anything, the street HOA levies before you buy.
The question matters because a separate charge would add a line to the monthly budget. Ask the manager in writing, and ask that the answer appear on, or alongside, the estoppel. Whether Carriedale Gardens owners may use the Carriedale Cottages pool and tennis parcels is also not documented in public records; ask the same manager at the same time.
The rental and pet rules at Carriedale Gardens come from two places: the club’s 2026-27 renter rules, which set a 30-day minimum and renter dues, and the condominium’s own declaration and rules, which are not public. Listing records mark pets “Call, Conditional.” Read the declaration and rules before relying on either.
Data updated: November 2026 (Fiddlesticks Country Club 2026-27 Renter Information; Fiddlesticks Country Club Realtors page; listing records; Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll).
| Topic | What public sources show | What to confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum rental term | 30 days under the club’s 2026-27 renter rules | The condominium’s own leasing limits in the declaration |
| Renter dues | $2,457 a month plus tax | Current figure with the club |
| Renter background check | $100 per adult renter | Current figure with the club |
| Landlord paperwork | A Section K landlord form filed with the lease | The club’s current forms |
| Pets | Listing records mark pets “Call, Conditional” | Pet rules for owners and tenants in the declaration and rules |
| Homestead | 9 of 28 units carry a homestead exemption | County roll |
Sources: Fiddlesticks Country Club, 2026-27 Renter Information and Realtors page; Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll; listing records.
No age restriction appears in the club documents read for this guide. The condominium’s own documents were not public, so read them before relying on any assumption either way.
A Carriedale Gardens owner may rent within two sets of rules. The club’s 2026-27 renter rules set a 30-day minimum, and the condominium’s own declaration and rules set any further limits on lease terms, leases per year and tenant approval. The condominium’s leasing rules are not public, so read them first.
A buyer planning to rent should read the leasing section of the declaration and every amendment before writing an offer, and ask the association whether any leasing amendment is pending. The county roll shows 9 of 28 units with a homestead exemption and 11 of 28 owner mailing addresses in Florida, which describes how the units are held, not how many are rented.
Renters at Carriedale Gardens pay the club’s renter dues of $2,457 a month plus tax under the 2026-27 renter rules, plus a $100 background check for each adult renter. The landlord files a Section K form with the lease. Confirm the current figures with the club before quoting a rent.
Those charges sit on top of what the owner keeps paying: the club dues of $2,319.50 a month, the condo assessment and the Capital Improvement Assessment. A landlord working out the numbers should treat the renter dues as part of the tenant’s cost and ask who pays what in the lease. The club’s Rules and Regulations set the facility rules renters follow.
Listing records mark pets at Carriedale Gardens as “Call, Conditional,” which means the answer comes from the association, not the listing. The condominium’s pet rules are not public. Read the declaration and rules, or ask the association’s manager in writing, before you count on keeping a pet in a unit.
Owner and tenant pet rules can differ under a condominium’s documents, so ask about both if you plan to rent. Get the current pet rule, including any size, number or approval requirement, in writing from the association before the inspection period ends. The club’s rules also govern pets on club grounds.
To read the Carriedale Gardens rules before you buy, ask the seller for the full governing documents early in the contract: both section declarations, the consolidated instrument at Official Records Book 2537, Page 3617, every amendment, the bylaws and the current rules, plus the club’s documents and renter rules.
Read them in order: declarations first, then amendments by date, then rules, because a later amendment can change an earlier rule. Flag anything that matters to your plans, such as lease terms, pets, vehicles, golf carts in the carports or renovations, and confirm it with the manager in writing. We help buyers line up these questions during the inspection period, so the answer arrives before a deadline, not after.
Buying a Carriedale Gardens condo to rent? Marc reads the leasing rules and the club’s renter rules with you before an offer; call (239) 457-1610 or read our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers. Selling? A complete set of governing documents ready at listing keeps a contract on schedule; call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 or see our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers.
Carriedale Gardens sits in Lee County’s Elementary Zone J, Middle Zone MM and High South Zone 2 for 2026 to 2027, per the School District of Lee County’s proximity zone layers queried at the Carriedale Gardens buildings. Lee County assigns by choice within proximity zones, so confirm any address with the district.
Data updated: November 2026 (School District of Lee County SchoolProximityZones 2026 to 2027 layers, queried November 20, 2026; district 2025-26 school grades report).
| Level | Zone | Schools listed for the zone | District 2025-26 grade where reported |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elementary | Zone J | Colonial, Gateway, Ray V. Pottorf and Treeline elementary schools | Not cited here |
| Middle | Zone MM | Cypress Lake Middle and Lexington Middle | Lexington Middle B |
| High | South Zone 2 | Bonita Springs, Cypress Lake, Dunbar, Estero, Fort Myers and South Fort Myers high schools | Cypress Lake High A; Fort Myers High A |
| District | Lee County | All schools | B |
Sources: School District of Lee County, School Proximity Zones 2026 to 2027 layer; district School Zones page; district 2025-2026 school grades report.
A listing’s school field is typed by an agent and is not an assignment. The district approves its zone plan each year, so the lists can change between school years.
Carriedale Gardens sits in Lee County’s Elementary Zone J for 2026 to 2027, and the zone’s choices are Colonial, Gateway, Ray V. Pottorf and Treeline elementary schools. Applicants choose among the schools in the zone, and the district places students under its published enrollment rules.
All seven Carriedale Gardens buildings sit in the same zone, so every unit shares the same elementary list, and the Carriedale Cottages side of the street returned the same zone. Program details, application windows and transportation rules are in the district’s enrollment materials on leeschools.net. We do not rank schools on this page.
Carriedale Gardens sits in Lee County’s Middle Zone MM for 2026 to 2027, and the zone’s choices are Cypress Lake Middle and Lexington Middle. The district’s 2025-26 grades report lists Lexington Middle at B, up from C. Students choose among the zone’s schools under the district’s enrollment rules.
Confirm the zone for the exact Carriedale Gardens address, because zone lines can be revised when the School Board approves a new plan, and transportation eligibility depends on the school chosen and the district’s rules. The district’s grades report carries the full list of 2025-26 grades.
Carriedale Gardens sits in Lee County’s High South Zone 2 for 2026 to 2027, and the zone’s choices are Bonita Springs, Cypress Lake, Dunbar, Estero, Fort Myers and South Fort Myers high schools. The district’s 2025-26 grades list Cypress Lake High at A and Fort Myers High at A.
Each high school runs its own programs, and the district’s enrollment materials describe them. The district as a whole received a B for 2025-26. Because the zones are set annually, check the district’s current plan before relying on any list, and confirm the zone again before each school year.
To confirm the schools for a Carriedale Gardens address, enter the unit’s address on the School District of Lee County’s school locator, reached from the district’s School Zones page, and note the elementary, middle and high zones it returns. The district’s tool is the record; this guide and listing fields are not.
The district’s School Zones page explains the choice process and application dates. Keep the confirmation with the closing papers if school placement is part of the reason for the purchase, and check again before each school year.
Carriedale Gardens sits inside the Fiddlesticks gates, a short walk from the clubhouse, cabana and resort pool, and about 7 free-flow minutes from I-75, 10.5 from Publix at Daniels Crossing, 11.7 from Gulf Coast Medical Center, 15.3 from the airport and 23.4 from downtown Fort Myers.
Data updated: November 2026 (free-flow route table from a Fiddlesticks community point, no traffic; add a minute or two for the drive from Carriedale Lane and much more in season, January to April).
| Category | Place | Road miles | Free-flow time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Interstate | I-75 Exit 131, Daniels Parkway | 2.67 | 6.8 min |
| Groceries | Publix, Daniels Crossing | 4.83 | 10.5 min |
| Hospital | Lee Health Gulf Coast Medical Center, Level II Trauma Center | 5.67 | 11.7 min |
| Shopping | Bell Tower Shops | 6.49 | 12.7 min |
| Airport | Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) terminal | 7.98 | 15.3 min |
| Shopping | Gulf Coast Town Center | 7.98 | 16.1 min |
| Shopping | Miromar Outlets | 11.75 | 18.5 min |
| University | FGCU | 9.86 | 19.3 min |
| Downtown | Downtown Fort Myers, River District | 13.90 | 23.4 min |
| Shopping | Coconut Point, Estero | 15.29 | 24.9 min |
| Causeway | Sanibel Causeway, Punta Rassa end | 16.97 | 29.0 min |
| Beach | Fort Myers Beach, Times Square | 15.89 | 29.6 min |
| City | Downtown Naples, 5th Avenue South | 34.98 | 46.8 min |
Source: free-flow route table computed from a Fiddlesticks community point with no traffic, not a timed drive from Carriedale Lane. Real drive times in season are longer.
Inside the gates, Carriedale Gardens owners have the Fiddlesticks clubhouse and Pub, the cabana and resort pool, seven Har-Tru tennis courts, eight pickleball courts, bocce and fitness, and parent research places Carriedale Lane near the clubhouse, cabana and resort pool. The condominium’s own 3.51-acre pool parcel sits at 15646 Carriedale Lane.
Club dues include 24-hour roving security, common areas and the club’s facilities, so the inside-the-gates list is part of what every owner pays for. The club’s amenities page describes the facilities. The Capital Improvement Assessment funds a Cabana kitchen, a Clubhouse renovation from May 2027 and Gatehouse work planned for Spring 2028, so some of these spaces will be under construction for a time.
The nearest grocery store in our route table is Publix at Daniels Crossing, 6900 Daniels Parkway, about 4.83 miles and 10.5 free-flow minutes from Carriedale Gardens. That store reopened on September 11, 2025. Bell Tower Shops, about 12.7 minutes away, adds more shopping and errands.
All of these trips start through the Fiddlesticks gatehouse and out to Daniels Parkway or the new Three Oaks Parkway intersection at Fiddlesticks Boulevard, which opened on November 2, 2026. The free-flow times are no-traffic estimates from a Fiddlesticks community point; in season, plan for longer, especially on Daniels Parkway near I-75.
Lee Health Gulf Coast Medical Center, a Level II Trauma Center at 13681 Doctors Way, is about 5.67 miles from Carriedale Gardens, roughly 11.7 minutes in free-flow traffic by our route table. It is the nearest hospital on our route table.
Eleven or twelve minutes is a no-traffic estimate. From January to April, the Daniels Parkway corridor carries much heavier traffic, and FDOT’s work on the Exit 131 interchange is scheduled to run to an estimated summer 2028, so plan on more time for any appointment during the construction years.
Fort Myers Beach, near Times Square, is about 15.89 miles from Carriedale Gardens, roughly 29.6 free-flow minutes, and the Punta Rassa end of the Sanibel Causeway is about 16.97 miles, roughly 29 minutes. Carriedale Gardens is an inland golf community, not a beach location.
Carriedale Gardens has no boat access and no Gulf frontage; its water views, where listing records describe them, are of golf course lakes. A buyer who wants to be on the Gulf is shopping a different product, with a different flood and evacuation profile. A buyer who wants a golf club inside the gates and the beaches within about half an hour is shopping what Carriedale Gardens offers.
Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) is about 7.98 miles from Carriedale Gardens, roughly 15.3 minutes in free-flow traffic by our route table. I-75 at Exit 131, Daniels Parkway, is about 2.67 miles and 6.8 minutes away, and the airport trip usually runs through that interchange.
FDOT project 446296-2 is rebuilding Exit 131 as a diverging diamond interchange, about $42.8 million, with construction from early 2026 and an estimated completion in summer 2028, per FDOT District One. Expect work zones on the airport route until then. Gulf Coast Town Center is about 16 minutes away and Miromar Outlets about 18.5.
Downtown Fort Myers and the River District are about 13.90 miles from Carriedale Gardens, roughly 23.4 minutes in free-flow traffic. Carriedale Gardens is in unincorporated Lee County in south Fort Myers, closer to I-75 and the airport than to downtown, with Coconut Point in Estero about 24.9 minutes away.
Downtown Naples, at 5th Avenue South, is about 46.8 free-flow minutes away. Lee County’s new Three Oaks Parkway extension, reported by WGCU on its November 2, 2026 opening, adds a north-south route toward Collier County from the Fiddlesticks Boulevard intersection, with final completion scheduled for early 2027. Our Fort Myers guide covers the city as a whole.
Carriedale Gardens comes with Fiddlesticks Country Club’s 36 holes: the Long Mean, a Ron Garl course opened in 1983, and Loch Ness, redesigned by Kipp Schulties and reopened in January 2019. Golf is included in the mandatory Resident Equity membership’s dues. The Long Mean closed on March 1, 2026 for renovation.
Data updated: November 2026 (Fiddlesticks Country Club Membership Information Packet 2026-2027 and membership page; Kris Spence Golf Design projects page; Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll).
| Golf fact | What the record shows | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Courses | 36 holes: the Long Mean and Loch Ness | Fiddlesticks Country Club |
| Long Mean | Ron Garl, opened 1983; closed March 1, 2026 for a renovation by Kris Spence | Club records; Kris Spence Golf Design |
| Long Mean reopening | No completion date published; still listed as current work | Kris Spence Golf Design |
| Loch Ness | Redesigned by Kipp Schulties, reopened January 2019 | Club records |
| Golf access | Included in club dues under mandatory Resident Equity membership | 2026-27 Membership Information Packet |
| Golf setting | All 28 units carry the county’s golf-course land code | Lee County Property Appraiser, 2026 roll |
| Holes faced | Not confirmed for any building | Check with the club |
Sources: Fiddlesticks Country Club on our site; the club’s membership page and 2026-2027 Membership Information Packet; Kris Spence Golf Design, current projects.
Carriedale Gardens owners have Fiddlesticks’ two 18-hole courses: the Long Mean, designed by Ron Garl and opened in 1983, and Loch Ness, redesigned by Kipp Schulties and reopened in January 2019. The club dates itself “Since 1982” and counts about 585 homes inside the gates.
With the Long Mean closed for renovation since March 1, 2026, ask the club how play on Loch Ness, tee times, events and guest play are being handled during the closure, since the answer shapes the golf a new owner gets in the first season after closing.
No reopening date for the Long Mean has been published. The course closed on March 1, 2026 for a renovation by architect Kris Spence, and his projects page still lists the Fiddlesticks work as current with no completion date. Carriedale Gardens buyers should check the reopening date with the club.
The architect’s projects page describes the renovation’s design themes. For a Carriedale Gardens buyer, the practical questions are timing and cost: when the course reopens, and whether any of the renovation is funded through dues, the capital line or the Capital Improvement Assessment. The club’s packet and an estoppel answer the cost side.
Which course and holes each Carriedale Gardens building faces is not confirmed in any public record. All 28 units carry the county’s golf-course land code, and listing records describe golf course and lake views at some units, but no source ties each building to a specific course or hole.
Walk the building and ask the club for its course map before relying on any view description. For a seller, the view from the lanai is a selling point worth documenting with photographs; for a buyer, the view is worth seeing at the time of day you would sit outside. A renovation on the Long Mean can also change what a view looks like while work is under way.
Every Carriedale Gardens owner must hold a Fiddlesticks Resident Equity membership. The joining fee is $150,000 from November 1, 2026, up from $115,000, with $1 of equity refundable on resale and a $2,000 club real estate transaction fee at closing. Golf is included in the club dues.
The model is the opposite of a pay-as-you-play club: the large entry cost and the monthly dues buy access to both courses, tennis, pickleball, bocce, fitness and the clubhouse. The $150,000 joining fee can approach or exceed a Carriedale Gardens unit’s price; the 2025 low resale was $100,000. That is arithmetic, and each buyer weighs it differently.
Selling a Carriedale Gardens condo during the Long Mean renovation? We explain the club’s timeline and costs to buyers up front; call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or request a free Fort Myers home valuation. Buying? Marc walks you through the club’s equity application and costs; call (239) 457-1610 or see how we represent buyers.
Carriedale Gardens and Carriedale Cottages share Carriedale Lane, the club costs, the flood zone and the school zones, but they are separate condominiums. Carriedale Gardens is 28 two-story garden condos on the even side; Carriedale Cottages is 24 one-story three-bedroom villas on the odd side, at roughly double the recorded prices.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll; county-recorded qualified sales for each condominium, counted separately; listing records for condo assessments; Lee County permits).
| Yardstick | Carriedale Gardens | Carriedale Cottages |
|---|---|---|
| Building type | Seven two-story garden buildings of four units | Eight one-story buildings of three attached villas |
| Units | 28, one condominium | 24, two condominiums of 12 |
| Year built | 1985 to 1986 | 1986 to 1987 |
| Bedrooms and size | 16 three-bedroom (1,490 or 1,547 sq ft) and 12 two-bedroom (1,143 to 1,188 sq ft) | 24 three-bedroom, 1,827 to 2,093 sq ft |
| Parking | Section 1 carports; Section 2 coded with garages on the roll, described as detached carports in listing records | Garages on every unit; listing records describe two-car attached garages |
| 2026 county just value, median | $196,971 | $390,773 |
| County-recorded qualified sales | 14 from November 2024 through October 2026, $100,000 to $350,000, median $237,450 | 7 from May 2025 through September 2026, $500,000 to $665,000, median $575,000 |
| Condo assessment in listing records | $2,160 to $2,250 a quarter | $2,500 a quarter |
| Club joining fee and dues | $150,000; $2,319.50 a month | Same |
| Flood and evacuation | FEMA Zone X; Evacuation Zone C | Same |
| School zones | J, MM, South 2 | Same |
| Roofs | Roof ages not public | Re-roofed in 2013 (Section 1) and 2014 (Section 2), per county permits |
| Association pools | One 3.51-acre pool parcel | Two pool and tennis parcels |
| Official-records website rule (25 or more units) | Applies at 28 units | Does not reach the 12-unit condominiums |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, and county-recorded qualified sales, each condominium counted from its own county records; Lee County permits; listing records for the assessments. Confirm every fee with each association.
The two sales windows differ, so compare the medians as a direction, not an exact gap. Carriedale Cottages has no page of its own on our site.
How to choose, by what the property offers:
| If you need | Carriedale Gardens | Carriedale Cottages |
|---|---|---|
| The lower recorded entry price | Yes: median $237,450 | Higher: median $575,000 |
| One-story living with no stairs | Downstairs units only | Every unit |
| Two-bedroom plans | 12 units | None |
| A garage | Section 2 only, garage-coded on the roll | Every unit |
| Known roof dates | Not public | 2013 and 2014 |
| The same club, street and zones | Yes | Yes |
Carriedale Cottages has recorded roughly double Carriedale Gardens’ prices. Carriedale Gardens’ 14 county-recorded qualified resales from November 2024 through October 2026 had a median of $237,450; the Cottages’ 7 resales from May 2025 through September 2026 had a median of $575,000. The 2026 just-value medians are $196,971 and $390,773.
The gap follows the product. The Cottages are one-story, three-bedroom villas of 1,827 to 2,093 square feet with garages; Carriedale Gardens’ largest plan is 1,547 square feet. The MLS name “Carriedale” mostly means the Cottages, so a sales report that mixes the two names will overstate Carriedale Gardens prices. We count each condominium from its own county records.
Carriedale Gardens has seven two-story garden buildings of four units, with upstairs and downstairs units, two-bedroom and three-bedroom plans and carport or garage-coded parking. Carriedale Cottages has eight one-story buildings of three villas, every one a three-bedroom plan with a garage, built a year or so later.
Neither condominium’s buildings reach three habitable stories, so neither faces Florida’s milestone inspection or SIRS on the record. The documented difference is the roofs: county permits show the Cottages re-roofed in 2013 and 2014, while Carriedale Gardens’ roof ages are not public. Ask both associations for their reserve schedules and roof history, and compare the answers in writing.
Carriedale Gardens and Carriedale Cottages share the club costs: the same $150,000 joining fee, the same $2,319.50 monthly dues and the same Capital Improvement Assessment. Each condominium has its own association, its own assessment and its own pools. Listing records show $2,160 to $2,250 a quarter at Carriedale Gardens and $2,500 at the Cottages.
The club lists Suitor and Associates as manager for the Carriedale associations, and one “Carriedale HOA” appears in its packets for the whole street. Whether Carriedale Gardens owners may use the Cottages’ pool and tennis parcels is not documented, so ask the manager. The club’s own amenities are open to both, under the same membership.
For a Carriedale Gardens seller, the Cottages comparison is mostly a labeling issue. Buyers and some sales reports blur the two names, and the Cottages’ $500,000-plus sales do not describe a Carriedale Gardens unit. The right comparables are Carriedale Gardens’ own 14 recorded resales, by plan, floor and condition.
The comparison also helps a Carriedale Gardens seller answer the buyer who wants the club at a lower entry price: the club costs are identical across the street, and the unit price is where the difference sits. We price each Carriedale Gardens condo against the condominium’s own county-recorded sales first, and explain the Cottages as a separate product.
Carriedale Gardens has the second-lowest median county roll value of the Fiddlesticks neighborhoods, above only Highlands I, yet its owners pay the same club joining fee and dues as every other Fiddlesticks owner. Glen Abbey Condominium Ph I and Berriedale sit higher on the roll; Winding Stream at Spring Run in Estero bundles golf differently.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll; county-recorded qualified sales; our Fiddlesticks and comparison research, read November 2026).
| Community | Type, era | County roll median | Recorded sales (window) | Difference from Carriedale Gardens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carriedale Gardens | 28 two-story garden condos, 1985 to 1986 | $196,971 (2026 roll) | 14, $100,000 to $350,000, median $237,450 (November 2024 to October 2026) | n/a |
| Highlands I (Fiddlesticks) | 46 garden condos, 1988, 1,110 to 1,470 sq ft | $163,248, the lowest in Fiddlesticks | Not separated for this guide | Lower roll values, slightly newer, same club costs |
| Glen Abbey Condominium Ph I (Fiddlesticks) | 24 three-bedroom coach villas with garages, 1991 to 1992 | $281,561 | Six condo sales, $220,000 to $385,000, median $336,875 (2025 to 2026) | Newer, garages, higher prices |
| Berriedale (Fiddlesticks) | 11 attached villas, 1983, fee simple, all on the golf course | $326,979 | Not separated for this guide | Not a condominium, higher roll values |
| Winding Stream at Spring Run (Estero) | Two-story garden condos, 2001, 1,111 to 1,453 sq ft | Not measured for this guide | $260,000 to $450,500 (window not matched to ours) | Golf included at about $9,820 a year, no large joining fee |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll; county-recorded qualified sales; our Fiddlesticks community research. None of these neighborhoods has a page of its own on our site.
The windows differ, so read the figures as where each community sits, not an exact gap. Every Fiddlesticks product carries the same $150,000 joining fee and $2,319.50 monthly dues.
Highlands I is the other garden condominium inside Fiddlesticks: 46 units built in 1988, 1,110 to 1,470 square feet, with the lowest median county roll value in the community at $163,248. Carriedale Gardens’ median of $196,971 is the next lowest, with a largest plan of 1,547 square feet.
Both pay the same club joining fee and dues, so for both the club costs weigh heavily against the unit price. A buyer weighing the two is comparing Carriedale Gardens’ smaller 28-unit association, its golf-course land code on every unit and its position on Carriedale Lane against a larger, slightly newer condominium elsewhere in the gates. Compare the two associations’ budgets, reserves and insurance in writing.
Glen Abbey Condominium Ph I is a Fiddlesticks condominium of 24 three-bedroom coach villas with garages, built from 1991 to 1992, with a median county roll value of $281,561. Its six 2025 to 2026 condo sales ran $220,000 to $385,000, a higher range than Carriedale Gardens’ $100,000 to $350,000.
The difference is age, garages and plan size. Glen Abbey Ph I is a few years newer and every villa has a garage; Carriedale Gardens offers two-bedroom plans and carport or garage-coded parking at a lower recorded price. Both condominiums sit under the same club costs, so the comparison a buyer should make is unit to unit and association to association.
Berriedale is a Fiddlesticks neighborhood of 11 attached villas built in 1983, owned fee simple rather than as condominiums, with every villa on the golf course and a median county roll value of $326,979. Carriedale Gardens is a condominium, two years newer and lower on the roll.
The ownership form is the real difference. A fee simple villa is not governed by a condominium declaration, so Florida’s condominium statutes on reserves, insurance and records do not reach it in the same way. A buyer comparing the two should read each community’s governing documents, not just its prices.
Winding Stream at Spring Run in Estero offers two-story garden condos of 1,111 to 1,453 square feet built in 2001, with golf included at about $9,820 a year and no large joining fee. Its sales of $260,000 to $450,500 sit above Carriedale Gardens’ range, over a window not matched to ours.
The comparison is about how golf is bought. At Carriedale Gardens, golf comes through a $150,000 equity joining fee and $2,319.50 in monthly club dues; at Winding Stream, golf is bundled into a smaller annual charge with newer buildings and a higher unit price. A buyer adding up the first five years of each should include the joining fee, dues, condo assessments and taxes.
Outside Fiddlesticks, our guides to Crown Colony and Heritage Palms Golf and Country Club cover two other Fort Myers golf communities. Each has its own membership model, fees, housing types and governing documents, so compare them with Carriedale Gardens document to document.
We have not run a side-by-side of those communities’ recorded sales against Carriedale Gardens for this guide, so we do not quote a comparison. The questions that matter are the same everywhere: what the club costs to join and to belong to, what the condominium or homeowners’ association charges, what the flood and evacuation zones are, and what the county-recorded sales show for the same kind of home.
Before buying a Carriedale Gardens condo, check the association estoppel and the club estoppel, the budget and any reserve waiver vote, the insurance declarations and wind deductible, the roof history, the declaration’s leasing and pet rules, the street HOA question, the association’s storm claim history and the unit’s own condition.
Data updated: November 2026 (Florida Statutes ss. 718.111 and 718.112; FEMA; Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll; Fiddlesticks Country Club 2026-27 packet; listing records).
| Check | Why it matters at Carriedale Gardens |
|---|---|
| Association estoppel | Confirms the assessment, about $2,160 to $2,250 a quarter in listing records, and any special assessment |
| Club estoppel | Confirms dues of $2,319.50 a month and the Capital Improvement Assessment balance that transfers with the unit |
| Club application | Buyers file the equity application and background-check form; the seller files a Notice of New Contract |
| Budget and reserves | Statutory reserves apply unless owners waived or reduced them |
| Insurance declarations | Master policy, any flood policy and the wind deductible |
| Roof history | Roof ages are not public; 1985 to 1986 buildings predate the 2002 Florida Building Code |
| Two-story confirmation | Written confirmation that milestone inspection and SIRS do not apply |
| Floor and parking | Which floor the unit is on and whether its Section 2 parking is a garage or an enclosed carport |
| Declaration and rules | Leasing, pet and use rules are not public |
| Street HOA | What, if anything, Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc. levies |
| Storm history | Ian, Helene and Milton claims and repairs, from the association |
| Title | In Lee County the contract decides who pays for the owner’s title policy |
A Carriedale Gardens unit inspection should cover what the owner maintains: the air conditioning system, water heater, plumbing fixtures and supply lines, electrical panel, windows and sliding doors, the lanai, interior finishes and any signs of past water intrusion. The association maintains the building structure and common elements.
Recent county permits at Carriedale Gardens addresses include several air conditioning replacements, so ask the seller for the system’s age and the permit. On a downstairs unit, look closely at ceilings below the upstairs unit for staining; on an upstairs unit, ask about the roof above it. Check the storage locker, the carport or garage-coded space and how the declaration assigns them.
In Lee County, the contract decides who pays for the owner’s title policy on a Carriedale Gardens sale, so neither the buyer nor the seller should assume a custom. The title agent issues the policy at closing, and the cost appears on the closing statement for whichever party the contract names.
Read the title section before signing and budget for it on whichever side the contract places it. The title agent also orders the association estoppel, the club estoppel comes from the club, and the club’s $2,000 transaction fee and the joining fee are due at closing, so a Carriedale Gardens closing has more moving parts than the sale of a detached house. We set those deadlines with the closing agent at the start of the contract.
Carriedale Gardens offers the county’s golf-course land code on every unit, a street near the clubhouse, cabana and resort pool, two-story garden buildings with upstairs and downstairs units, two-bedroom and three-bedroom plans, and carport or garage-coded parking, under mandatory club membership with its joining fee and dues.
It does not offer boat access, a private garage in Section 1, or one-story living in an upstairs unit. The county roll shows 9 of 28 units with a homestead exemption and 11 of 28 with a Florida mailing address, which describes how the units are held, not who lives there. The club costs are the same as for a Fiddlesticks estate home, so the unit price is the variable.
Carriedale Gardens offers a golf-course setting on every unit, a position on Carriedale Lane near the club’s center, 36 holes and full club amenities, FEMA Zone X and a lower recorded entry price than most of Fiddlesticks. Its drawbacks are the $150,000 joining fee, high monthly club costs and several undisclosed association facts.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll; county-recorded qualified sales; FEMA; Lee County GIS; Fiddlesticks Country Club 2026-27 packet; Florida Statutes; listing records).
Pros:
Cons:
By property need, Carriedale Gardens offers a lower recorded entry price into a 36-hole equity club, a golf-course land code on every unit, a street near the club’s center, two-bedroom plans for less space and three-bedroom plans up to 1,547 square feet for more. It does not offer boating or a beach location.
A buyer who needs one-story living with a garage is looking across the lane at Carriedale Cottages, at a higher price. A buyer who wants golf without a large joining fee is shopping a bundled-golf community instead. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and we walk each kind of buyer through the trade, unit by unit, before an offer. Read more about our team or meet Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar.
A Carriedale Gardens seller should lead with what the property offers, the golf-course setting, the plan, the floor, the condition and the walk to the club, and answer the cons with documents before a buyer asks: the budget and reserves, the insurance declarations, the roof history, both estoppels and the association’s storm history.
With 14 county-recorded qualified resales from November 2024 through October 2026, and a wide spread within one plan, every comparable counts, and condition moves the price. In Lee County the contract decides who pays for the owner’s title policy, so a seller’s budget should plan for it alongside any repairs and reports. We price each unit against the condominium’s own recorded sales first.
Selling your Carriedale Gardens condo? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or start with a free Fort Myers home valuation; our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers covers the process. Buying at Carriedale Gardens? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610, see how we represent buyers, or contact us.
Carriedale Gardens sellers offer one of 28 golf-coded garden condominiums in seven two-story buildings inside Fiddlesticks Country Club, priced against a clear county record: 14 qualified resales from November 2024 through October 2026, from $100,000 to $350,000, median $237,450. McGreevy and Comisar price each Carriedale Gardens condo from that record, plan by plan and building by building.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, qualified sales recorded through October 6, 2026; our analysis).
If you’re searching for a Carriedale Gardens listing agent, or thinking, “I need someone to sell my Carriedale Gardens condo…”, you are choosing between a team that quotes a portal estimate and a team that has read the condominium record and the club’s paperwork. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and our Domain Realty Group team is the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026). We price a Carriedale Gardens condo against every qualified resale the county recorded in the seven buildings, its floor plan and floor, its parking, its condition, and the association and club paperwork a buyer will ask for.
From November 2024 through October 2026 we tracked 14 county-recorded qualified Carriedale Gardens resales, from $100,000 to $350,000, with a median of $237,450. The county shows no builder-direct sales in the window, so every comparable is an owner selling to a buyer. Section 2, Buildings D, E, F and G, recorded 12 of the 14; Section 1, Buildings A, B and C, recorded 2.
By plan, the record splits into two ladders. The nine three-bedroom sales ran from $142,500 to $350,000, and the five two-bedroom sales from $100,000 to $249,900. The 1,547 square foot plan alone recorded seven sales across that whole $142,500 to $350,000 spread, which tells a seller that condition, not square footage, decides where a unit lands. Listing records call the $350,000 unit, recorded October 6, 2026, “completely remodeled throughout”.
The direction is mixed and the samples are small. The seven 2025 sales recorded a median of $215,000 and the seven 2026 sales through October 6 a median of $249,900, both below the 2022 pair of $395,000 and $390,000, the highest Carriedale Gardens sales on file. Read those as direction only.
Days on market, sale-to-list ratio, active listings and months of supply: Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-20). We pull those measures for the closest Carriedale Gardens comparables when we prepare your listing, and the county record above is the market evidence this section rests on.
Selling in Carriedale Gardens differs from selling a house in five ways: every buyer must join Fiddlesticks Country Club, two associations and a club each issue paperwork, two bedroom counts and five sizes compete inside 28 units, upstairs and downstairs units draw different buyers, and the two parking types read differently on the county roll and in listing records.
The club comes first. Every Fiddlesticks owner must hold a Resident Equity membership, and the joining fee rose from $115,000 to $150,000 on November 1, 2026, with $1 of equity refundable on resale, plus a $2,000 club real estate transaction fee at closing. Your buyer files the club’s equity application and background-check form, and you file a Notice of New Contract with the club. Confirm every figure with the club before you list.
The paperwork comes second. A buyer reads the Carriedale Gardens Condominium Association budget, reserves, insurance and rules, and separately reads the club’s dues, the Capital Improvement Assessment and the club estoppel. A third entity, Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc., shares the association’s address, and its role is not public; confirm with the association what, if anything, the street HOA levies, so your buyer is not surprised.
The plans come third. The 2026 roll counts 16 three-bedroom units of 1,490 or 1,547 heated square feet and 12 two-bedroom units of 1,143, 1,180 or 1,188 square feet. A buyer can usually compare your unit with another of the same plan on the same street, which keeps pricing honest and puts condition and finish at the center.
Floor and parking come last. Listing records place some odd-numbered units upstairs and some even-numbered units downstairs, but that pattern is not confirmed for all 28, so we confirm your floor from the unit itself. The roll codes Section 1 with carports and Section 2 with garages, while listing records describe Section 2 parking as a detached carport or golf-cart garage with a door. We describe what is on site and let the buyer see it.
A Carriedale Gardens seller’s costs include the items any Florida condominium sale carries: the agent’s commission, which is negotiable, the association’s estoppel certificate, your prorated share of the condo assessment, the club dues and property taxes, the deed taxes and closing charges the contract assigns to you, and any mortgage payoff.
Two club items need a careful read. The $2,000 club real estate transaction fee is paid at closing, and the contract should say who pays it. The Capital Improvement Assessment that began September 1, 2026 is tied to the property and transfers on sale, so if you chose the monthly plan of $295 for 120 months, the remaining payments follow the unit; if you paid the $26,500 lump sum, your buyer inherits that benefit. Confirm your own balance with the club.
In Lee County the contract decides who pays for the owner’s title policy, so we read that line with you before you accept an offer. Any special assessment levied before closing, and who pays it, is also a contract term, and the estoppel certificate shows what is owed. Because only 9 of the 28 units carry a homestead exemption on the 2026 roll, most bills already reflect a non-homestead assessment, but your own bill sets the proration. We build a net sheet from your own numbers before you list.
Start with our free home valuation, and we will follow up with a number built on the county’s recorded Carriedale Gardens resales, the 2026 Lee County roll and your condo’s plan, floor, parking, updates and furnishings. Our Fort Myers home valuation page explains how we price across the city.
(239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome.
For the full process, read our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers.
Yes. In Carriedale Gardens the bedroom count sets the range and condition moves the unit within it. The nine three-bedroom resales recorded $142,500 to $350,000 and the five two-bedroom resales $100,000 to $249,900, per county-recorded qualified sales from November 2024 through October 2026, so the larger plans usually carry the higher price.
The county’s 2026 just values follow the same order: $196,971 to $197,458 for the 1,490 square foot plan, $201,359 to $222,243 for the 1,547 square foot plan, and $158,616 to $174,624 across the two-bedroom plans, per the Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll. Those are assessments, not prices, but they confirm the ladder buyers see.
Floor is harder to price from 14 sales. Listing records place 15670 #1 and 15628 #3 upstairs and 15672 #4 downstairs; those three recorded $350,000, $180,000 and $280,000 in 2026, so the floor alone does not explain the spread. A downstairs unit offers step-free entry, and an upstairs unit offers a higher outlook over the course; we compare your unit with the same plan and the same floor before we read any floor difference into the price.
The golf setting is part of every Carriedale Gardens unit, so it does not set one apart on paper. The 2026 county roll gives all 28 units the golf-course land code, and parent research places Carriedale Lane near the Fiddlesticks clubhouse, cabana and resort pool. What a buyer sees from your lanai sets your unit apart.
Which course and which holes each building faces is not confirmed in the records we read, so we photograph the actual outlook from your lanai, note the direction it faces, and compare your unit with sales of the same plan whose view we can document, rather than claiming a golf premium the record cannot show. The Long Mean course closed on March 1, 2026 for a renovation by architect Kris Spence; buyers will ask when it reopens, so check the reopening date with the club before you list.
A Carriedale Gardens buyer pays the unit price plus a $150,000 club joining fee from November 1, 2026, with $1 refundable, then club dues of $2,319.50 a month for 2026-27. On our arithmetic, the joining fee equals about 63 percent of the $237,450 median resale and exceeds the lowest recorded sale.
Buyers who reach you have usually run that math already, and the ones who have not will run it after the first showing. The dues lines for 2026-27 are operating $1,730, capital $383, road reserve $100, wastewater plant $44 and Xfinity TV and internet $62.50, with no food and beverage minimum, and they include wastewater, common areas, 24-hour roving security, golf, tennis, bocce, pickleball, the clubhouse, fitness and the cabana pool. Add the Capital Improvement Assessment of $295 a month and the listing-record condo assessment of about $720 to $750 a month, and the all-in runs about $3,335 to $3,365 a month before tax and insurance, our arithmetic, not a published figure. We put that sheet in front of buyers early, so the ones who make offers have already accepted the numbers. Confirm every figure with the club and the association.
A Carriedale Gardens seller should order the association estoppel and the club estoppel early and know both fee figures before a buyer asks. Listing records show a condo assessment of $2,160 a quarter in 2025 and $2,250 a quarter in 2026, about $720 to $750 a month; confirm the current figure with the association.
That list of covered items, management, insurance, irrigation water, legal and accounting, grounds, pest control, recreation facilities, reserve fund, road maintenance, street lights, security and water, comes from a listing field, not the association, so confirm the current budget with the manager. Listing pages that show an “HOA fee” of $2,260 or $2,327 a month are showing club dues, not the condo fee, which is our arithmetic against the club’s dues sheets; we correct that in your listing so buyers do not count the same money twice. The club lists Suitor and Associates (239-437-0340) for the Carriedale associations, and the county mails the common-element record in care of Suitor Middleton Cox and Associates; confirm the current manager before you order.
Carriedale Gardens buyers ask four questions: whether the association funds or waived its roof, painting and paving reserves, what the master policy covers and its deductible, what their own HO-6 and flood cover will cost, and whether Florida’s milestone inspection and SIRS rules apply to two-story buildings. The budget and the insurance declarations answer the first two.
All seven buildings are two-story on the county roll, and Florida’s milestone inspection and Structural Integrity Reserve Study apply to condominium buildings three or more habitable stories, so on the county record neither applies; ask the association to confirm that in writing. Reserves for roof replacement, building painting and pavement resurfacing still apply under section 718.112(2)(f) of the Florida Statutes unless owners waive or reduce them by majority vote, and whether Carriedale Gardens funds or waives them is not public. Roof ages are not public either. On flood, FEMA’s map puts the sampled units in Zone X, an area of minimal flood hazard, where no federal flood purchase is mandatory, though a lender may still require a policy. Florida’s seller flood disclosure law, section 689.302, applies at contract, so we prepare that disclosure with you.
The best time to sell a Carriedale Gardens condo is when the unit, the association and club documents and your next move are ready, and the county record shows when buyers have closed: 11 of the 14 qualified resales from November 2024 through October 2026 recorded from February through June.
The other three recorded in August, September and October 2026, including the $350,000 high of the window on October 6. Four of the 2026 sales recorded between March 12 and April 27, which means a seller in season often competes with another unit on the same street at the same moment. Seventeen of the 28 units have an owner mailing address outside Florida on the 2026 roll, so many sales here are handled from out of state. We time a listing to your plans, have the paperwork in hand before the busiest months, and price against the units that will be on the market beside yours.
Carriedale Gardens owners call McGreevy and Comisar when a condo in a 28-unit association inside a mandatory-membership golf club has to be priced against the units next door and sold without surprises. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and lead the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and our Domain Realty Group team is the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026).
As the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate across more than 4,000 transactions, and McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales. Read more about our team.
Meet Jesse McGreevy, who leads the team’s listing and seller strategy. Selling in Carriedale Gardens? Get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Meet Marc Comisar, who leads buyer representation and negotiation. Buying in Carriedale Gardens? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610, read about how we represent buyers, or see our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers. You can also contact us any time.
Jesse McGreevy is a top-reviewed Carriedale Gardens realtor, and Marc Comisar is a top-reviewed buyer’s agent. The reviews on the team’s Google Business Profile describe what a Carriedale Gardens seller or buyer needs most: honest advice, steady communication and a team that sells.
Five-star Google review: “Jesse was very professional, helpful and kept in touch with ideas and suggestions which developed into a sale. Highly recommend his company for their excellent follow through.” Verified Google review
Five-star Google review: “Marc is extremely knowledgeable, professional and a true pleasure to work with. He kept us informed throughout the process and went over and beyond our expectations to ensure an extremely smooth process.” Verified Google review
Five-star Google review: “We have purchased many properties over the years and Jesse is without a doubt the most knowledgeable, personable and efficient real estate broker we have ever worked with!” Verified Google review
Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC).
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.
Carriedale Gardens buyers ask where the condominium is, how it differs from Carriedale Cottages, what the units and plans are, what condos sell for, what the club and the association cost, what taxes run, how the flood and evacuation zones read, whether the safety laws apply, what the rental and pet rules say, which schools serve it and how far the airport and beaches are. Each answer draws on a county record, a federal or state source, the club’s own documents, or our route table.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, qualified sales recorded through October 6, 2026; Fiddlesticks Country Club 2026-27 packets; FEMA; Lee County GIS; Florida DBPR; School District of Lee County; our route table).
Carriedale Gardens is on the even side of Carriedale Lane, at even addresses 15626 to 15676 Carriedale Ln, inside the gates of Fiddlesticks Country Club off Daniels Parkway in south Fort Myers, ZIP 33912. The association’s 3.51-acre pool parcel sits at 15646 Carriedale Ln, and parent research places the street near the clubhouse.
No. Carriedale Gardens is in unincorporated Lee County, not inside the City of Fort Myers, even though its mailing address reads Fort Myers. Every unit sits in Lee County taxing district 047, South Trail Fire, on the 2026 roll, so Lee County, not the City, handles zoning, permits and floodplain rules for the buildings.
They are two separate condominiums on one street. Carriedale Gardens is 28 garden condominiums in seven two-story buildings on the even side of Carriedale Lane, built 1985 to 1986. Carriedale Cottages, often listed as just “Carriedale,” is 24 one-story villas on the odd side, built 1986 to 1987, with their own association documents.
Carriedale Gardens has 28 condominium units in seven two-story buildings of four, Buildings A to G, per the Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll. Section 1, Buildings A, B and C, holds 12 units built in 1985; Section 2, Buildings D, E, F and G, holds 16 units built in 1986. The state file also records 28 units.
The county roll lists 16 three-bedroom, two-bath Carriedale Gardens units, 8 of 1,490 heated square feet in Buildings A and C and 8 of 1,547 in Buildings E and F, and 12 two-bedroom, two-bath units of 1,143, 1,180 or 1,188 square feet in Buildings B, D and G. Every unit has two baths.
Not confirmed for all 28. Listing records place 15670 #1 and 15628 #3 on the second floor and 15672 #4 and 15676 #4 on the first, which suggests odd-numbered Carriedale Gardens units are upstairs and even-numbered units downstairs. The county roll records only building height, so confirm the floor of any unit you are considering.
The records conflict. The county roll codes the 12 Section 1 units with carports and the 16 Section 2 units with garages, while listing records describe Section 2 parking as a detached carport or golf-cart garage with a door. No Section 1 Carriedale Gardens unit has a private garage on the roll. See the parking before you buy.
No builder is named in any county, state or club record we read. The state condominium file, PR1U010974, “Carriedale Gardens A Condo,” records 28 units on March 22, 1985 and names Fiddlesticks, Ltd. as developer. The county dates Section 1 to 1985 and Section 2 to 1986. Carriedale Gardens Condominium Association, Inc. was filed December 20, 1984.
Yes. Every Fiddlesticks owner, including every Carriedale Gardens owner, must hold a Resident Equity membership. The joining fee is $150,000 from November 1, 2026, up from $115,000, with $1 of equity refundable on resale, plus a $2,000 club real estate transaction fee at closing. Confirm the current figures with the club before you make an offer.
Club dues for 2026-27 are $2,319.50 a month: operating $1,730, capital $383, road reserve $100, wastewater plant $44 and Xfinity TV and internet $62.50, with no food and beverage minimum. Dues include golf, tennis, bocce, pickleball, the clubhouse, fitness, the cabana pool, 24-hour roving security and wastewater. Confirm with the club.
It is a club assessment that began September 1, 2026: $295 a month for 120 months, a $26,500 lump sum, or $9,365 a year over three payments. It is tied to the property and transfers on sale, so a Carriedale Gardens buyer inherits the seller’s plan. It funds the Cabana kitchen, the Clubhouse renovation and the Gatehouse.
No association budget is public. Listing records show a Carriedale Gardens condo assessment of $2,160 a quarter in 2025 and $2,250 a quarter in 2026, about $720 to $750 a month, naming management, insurance, irrigation water, grounds, pest control, the reserve fund, road maintenance and water among other items. Confirm the current budget with the association through an estoppel.
On our arithmetic, not a published figure, about $3,335 to $3,365 a month before tax and insurance: club dues of $2,319.50, a listing-record condo assessment of about $720 to $750, and the $295 monthly Capital Improvement Assessment. The $150,000 joining fee is separate, at closing. Confirm each figure with the club and the Carriedale Gardens association.
From November 2024 through October 2026 we tracked 14 county-recorded qualified Carriedale Gardens resales, from $100,000 to $350,000, with a median of $237,450. The seven 2026 sales through October 6 ran from $160,000 to $350,000, median $249,900. The 2026 county just values run $158,616 to $222,243, an assessment, not a price.
Mixed, on small samples. Carriedale Gardens resales recorded a $215,000 median on seven 2025 sales and a $249,900 median on seven 2026 sales through October 6, both below the 2022 pair of $395,000 and $390,000, the highest on file. Prices within one plan spread widely, so read the trend as direction only.
No community development district appears on the roll; the units sit in taxing district 047, South Trail Fire. A separate Carriedale Homeowner’s Association, Inc., filed in 1984, shares the Carriedale Gardens association’s address, and the club lists one “Carriedale HOA” for the street. Its role is not public, so confirm with the association what, if anything, it levies.
The 2026 adopted total for district 047, South Trail Fire, is 13.3623 mills in the Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 millage book, final printing, after 13.3738 proposed on the TRIM notices and 13.4125 for 2025. Each $100,000 of taxable value is about $1,336 a year in ad valorem tax. Carriedale Gardens taxes reset on sale under Save Our Homes.
Carriedale Gardens is in FEMA Zone X, an area of minimal flood hazard, on the sampled units; the county’s flood map layer puts Carriedale Lane in Zone X on panel 12071C0439H, effective November 17, 2022. Zone X is still a flood zone. Confirm a unit’s zone on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center before you buy.
Zone X carries no federal mandatory flood purchase, though a lender may still require a policy on a Carriedale Gardens unit. Owners carry HO-6 cover for the inside of the unit, and flood cover is still worth pricing. Unincorporated Lee County is Community Rating System Class 5; ask your agent how that applies to a Zone X policy.
Lee County’s evacuation layer puts every Carriedale Gardens building in County Zone C, storm surge zone 3. Check the county’s evacuation map before each season. An evacuation zone is not a FEMA flood zone: the evacuation zone tells you when the county may ask you to leave, and the flood zone shapes insurance and lender rules.
No public report names damage at Carriedale Gardens or Fiddlesticks, and Lee County’s public damage assessment layers returned no records on Carriedale Lane. That does not prove the buildings were undamaged. A December 2022 resale recorded at $390,000. Ask the association for its Ian, Helene and Milton claims and repair records before you buy.
On the county record, no. Florida’s milestone inspection and Structural Integrity Reserve Study apply to condominium buildings three or more habitable stories, and all seven Carriedale Gardens buildings are two-story. Ask the association to confirm that in writing, and ask whether it funds or has waived its roof, painting and paving reserves.
The club’s 2026-27 renter rules set a 30-day minimum, renter dues of $2,457 a month plus tax, a $100 background check per adult renter, and a Section K landlord form filed with the lease. The Carriedale Gardens condominium’s own leasing rules are not public, so read the declaration and rules before you count on renting.
Listing records mark pets “Call, Conditional,” which means the rules come from the association, not from a listing. The Carriedale Gardens declaration and rules are not public online, so read them, or ask the association’s manager, before you count on keeping a pet in the unit or renting to a tenant with one.
The School District of Lee County assigns by choice within proximity zones. For 2026 to 2027, Carriedale Gardens sits in Elementary Zone J (Colonial, Gateway, Ray V. Pottorf, Treeline), Middle Zone MM (Cypress Lake Middle, Lexington Middle) and High South Zone 2 (Bonita Springs, Cypress Lake, Dunbar, Estero, Fort Myers, South Fort Myers). Confirm by address with the district.
On parent research’s free-flow estimates from a Fiddlesticks community point, I-75 Exit 131 at Daniels Parkway is about 2.67 miles and 7 minutes from Carriedale Gardens, the airport terminal about 7.98 miles and 15 minutes, and Fort Myers Beach at Times Square about 15.89 miles and 30 minutes. January to April traffic adds time.
The Three Oaks Parkway extension opened November 2, 2026 with a new intersection at Fiddlesticks Boulevard, final completion early 2027, and Daniels Parkway was widened to eight lanes from Danport Boulevard to Appaloosa Lane and Powers Court. FDOT project 446296-2 rebuilds I-75 Exit 131 as a diverging diamond, estimated completion summer 2028, near Carriedale Gardens.
The club lists Suitor and Associates (239-437-0340) for the Carriedale associations, and the county mails the Carriedale Gardens common-element record in care of Suitor Middleton Cox and Associates. Confirm the current manager before you buy, because the manager issues the association estoppel, holds the records and answers budget and reserve questions.
Ask for the current budget and reserve balance, any reserve waiver vote, the master insurance declarations and deductible, any special assessment notice, the declaration and rules on leasing, pets and age, recent board minutes, Ian, Helene and Milton repair records, roof ages, the club estoppel and your Capital Improvement Assessment balance. We request these early in every Carriedale Gardens contract.
Carriedale Gardens sellers ask what their condo is worth, how the plan, floor and parking change the price, how the club joining fee and dues affect buyers, what selling costs in Lee County, what to tell buyers about the condo fee, the reserves, flood insurance and the storms, and when to list. Each answer draws on the county’s recorded sales, the 2026 roll, the club’s own documents, federal and state records and the way we sell here.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll, qualified sales recorded through October 6, 2026; Fiddlesticks Country Club 2026-27 packets; FEMA; Lee County GIS; Florida DBPR).
McGreevy and Comisar: Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012, leading a Domain Realty Group team with over $2.5 billion in sales and the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026). We price every Carriedale Gardens condo against the county’s recorded resales. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
It depends on the plan, the floor, the parking, the outlook and above all the condition. From November 2024 through October 2026, Carriedale Gardens resales ran from $100,000 to $350,000, with a median of $237,450, and the seven 2026 sales ran from $160,000 to $350,000. Request a free home valuation for your own number.
Few, and the count swings. The county recorded 7 qualified Carriedale Gardens resales in 2021, 2 in 2022, 1 in 2023, 1 in 2024, 7 in 2025 and 7 in 2026 through October 6. With 28 units, a well-prepared condo usually has only a handful of direct competitors on the street in any season.
The highest qualified Carriedale Gardens resale from November 2024 through October 2026 was $350,000 on October 6, 2026, for 15670 #1, a 1,547 square foot three-bedroom unit that listing records call “completely remodeled throughout.” The highest on file are older: $395,000 for the same unit in June 2022 and $390,000 for 15672 #4 in December 2022.
The lowest qualified Carriedale Gardens resale in the window was $100,000 in May 2025, for 15662 #3, a 1,143 square foot two-bedroom unit. A 1,547 square foot unit, 15670 #2, recorded $142,500 in June 2025. Those low sales were not checked beyond the county’s qualified flag, and we read each one for condition before it steers a price.
The just value is the county’s assessment, not a price. The 2026 Carriedale Gardens just values run $158,616 to $222,243, median $196,971, while the 14 qualified resales from November 2024 through October 2026 recorded a $237,450 median. Price your condo from recorded sales and condition, not from the tax notice in your mailbox.
The three-bedroom plans. The nine three-bedroom Carriedale Gardens sales in the window ran from $142,500 to $350,000, against $100,000 to $249,900 for the five two-bedroom sales. The 1,547 square foot plan in Buildings E and F also carries the highest 2026 just values, $201,359 to $222,243, and recorded the top sale.
The record cannot say yet. Listing records place 15670 #1 and 15628 #3 upstairs and 15672 #4 downstairs, and those three Carriedale Gardens units recorded $350,000, $180,000 and $280,000 in 2026. Condition and timing differ, so we compare your unit with the same plan on the same floor before pricing any floor difference.
Less than plan and condition. Section 2, Buildings D to G from 1986, recorded 12 of the 14 Carriedale Gardens resales in the window, and Section 1, Buildings A to C from 1985, recorded 2. The sections differ in parking on the county roll, carports in Section 1 and garage-coded parking in Section 2, so we describe your parking exactly.
Exactly as it is. The county roll codes Section 1 Carriedale Gardens units with carports and Section 2 units with garages, while listing records describe Section 2 parking as a detached carport or golf-cart garage with a door. We photograph and describe what is on site, so a buyer’s expectations match the space they will use.
It is shared by every unit, so it does not set yours apart on paper: the 2026 roll gives all 28 Carriedale Gardens units the county’s golf-course land code. Which course and holes each building faces is not confirmed in public records, so we photograph your actual outlook and compare it with sales of the same plan.
Buyers will ask about it. The Long Mean course closed on March 1, 2026 for a renovation by Kris Spence, and the architect’s own project page still lists it as current work with no completion date. Loch Ness, redesigned by Kipp Schulties, reopened in January 2019. Check the Long Mean reopening date with the club before you list Carriedale Gardens.
It narrows it to buyers who want the club. A Carriedale Gardens buyer pays the price plus a $150,000 joining fee from November 1, 2026, with $1 refundable, and $2,319.50 a month in 2026-27 dues. On our arithmetic the fee exceeds the lowest recorded sale, so we market to buyers who have already priced the membership.
It sets a recent marker, not a ceiling. Two 1,547 square foot Carriedale Gardens units recorded $160,000 in April 2026 and $350,000 in October 2026, the second described in listing records as completely remodeled. Condition, floor and timing differ between those sales, so we read every 2026 comparable before we price yours.
Fix what a buyer’s inspector or insurer will flag first: air-conditioning, water heater, any water stains and anything at the lanai. With the buildings dating to 1985 and 1986, updated kitchens, baths and flooring compete best, as the record’s widest spreads show. Ask the association which interior work needs its approval and which needs a Lee County permit.
It depends on the buyer you expect. Some Carriedale Gardens buyers want to move in at once and use the club the same week, while others prefer to furnish the unit themselves. We price the condo first and treat the furniture as a negotiable term in the contract, listed on an inventory both sides sign.
Gather the declaration, bylaws and rules, the current budget and any reserve waiver vote, the master insurance declarations, any special assessment notice, recent board minutes, your HO-6 and any flood policy, permits for interior work, your Capital Improvement Assessment statement from the club, and your own Carriedale Gardens records of Ian, Helene and Milton repairs or claims.
On the county record, no. Florida requires both only for condominium buildings three or more habitable stories, and all seven Carriedale Gardens buildings are two-story. Buyers still ask, so we request the association’s written confirmation and its reserve schedule for roofs, painting and paving before you list, and put both in the file.
A buyer will see it, so plan for it. Florida lets owners waive or reduce the roof, painting and paving reserves by majority vote, and whether Carriedale Gardens funds or waives them is not public. A waiver can mean a special assessment later, and buyers price that in, so we read the budget with you before you set a price.
An estoppel certificate is the association’s written statement of what a unit owes: the condo assessment, any special assessment and any amount past due. A Carriedale Gardens sale needs one from the association’s manager and a separate club estoppel through the club, and the title company usually requests both after contract.
With the association’s own figures. Listing records show $2,160 a quarter in 2025 and $2,250 a quarter in 2026, about $720 to $750 a month, but buyers want the current Carriedale Gardens budget, what it covers and the reserve balance. We get those from the manager before you list, so your listing matches the estoppel.
Because they are showing club dues, not the condo fee. Listing pages that show $2,260 or $2,327 a month for a Carriedale Gardens unit match the club’s dues sheets on our arithmetic. We separate the club dues, the condo assessment and the Capital Improvement Assessment in your listing, so buyers see each cost once.
No association budget or special assessment notice is public, and the estoppel certificate is the record that counts. If one is levied or pending at Carriedale Gardens, the contract decides who pays it, and buyers price it in. Disclose what you know early; a surprise late in the contract costs more than the assessment itself.
The club runs its own process: your buyer files the equity application and background-check form, and you file a Notice of New Contract. For the Carriedale Gardens association, read the declaration and rules; Florida law caps an association’s transfer approval fee, so ask the association for its current fee and how long approval takes.
Yes. Florida’s seller flood disclosure law, section 689.302 of the Florida Statutes, applies at contract, and FEMA’s map puts the sampled Carriedale Gardens units in Zone X, an area of minimal flood hazard. Stating your zone, any flood policy and your claim history answers a buyer’s first insurance question before it slows the deal.
Usually not first. No elevation certificate for Carriedale Gardens turned up in public records, and in Zone X no federal flood purchase is mandatory. If a buyer’s lender or insurer asks for one on a downstairs unit, a surveyor can measure the building; ask the association first whether one is already on file.
With records. No public report names damage at Carriedale Gardens, and the county’s damage layers show nothing on Carriedale Lane, but that is not proof. Milton’s Fort Myers EF2 tornado began about 2.6 miles west near US 41 and tracked away. Share the association’s claims and repair records and your own, and let documents answer.
Buyers ask about it. Lee County puts every Carriedale Gardens building in County Zone C, storm surge zone 3. Evacuation zones are not FEMA flood zones, and we explain the difference to buyers, insurers and lenders so the evacuation zone and the Zone X flood designation are not confused during the contract.
What the master policy covers and its deductible, what an HO-6 policy for the unit will cost, whether a lender wants flood cover in Zone X, and how the 1985 to 1986 construction affects wind-mitigation credit. Roof ages at Carriedale Gardens are not public, so ask the association for roof dates before a buyer’s insurer does.
When the condo and the documents are ready. County records show 11 of the 14 qualified Carriedale Gardens resales from November 2024 through October 2026 recorded from February through June, and the other three from August through October 2026. We time your listing to your plans and to the units on the street beside it.
Days on market are a multiple listing service measure, and we pull them for the closest Carriedale Gardens comparables when we prepare your listing. The county record shows 1 to 7 qualified resales a year since 2021, so a well-priced, well-documented condo meets a steady stream of buyers, though few compete in any one month.
In Lee County the contract decides who pays for the owner’s title policy, so read that line before you accept an offer on your Carriedale Gardens condo. Order the association and club estoppels and the title search early anyway, so any lien, unpaid assessment or open permit surfaces well before closing.
Expect the agent’s commission, which is negotiable, the association and club estoppels, any repairs the contract requires, the deed taxes and closing charges the contract assigns to you, any mortgage payoff, and your prorated share of the condo assessment, club dues and property taxes. The $2,000 club transaction fee is a contract term. We build a net sheet.
It stays with the unit. The Fiddlesticks Capital Improvement Assessment is tied to the property and transfers on sale, so a Carriedale Gardens buyer takes over your remaining payments on the $295-a-month or three-payment plan, or inherits the benefit if you paid $26,500 at once. Get your balance from the club before you set a price.
Tell buyers your bill will not be theirs. Taxes reset on sale under Save Our Homes, and 9 of the 28 Carriedale Gardens units carry a homestead exemption, so a long-held homestead bill can run far below a new owner’s. The 2026 adopted total for district 047 is 13.3623 mills, about $1,336 per $100,000 of taxable value.
Yes, if the lease, the club’s renter rules and the association’s rules allow it, and the contract states who keeps the lease and the deposit. The club sets a 30-day minimum and requires a Section K landlord form with each lease. A Carriedale Gardens buyer may want the lease, or the unit empty, so we show around it.
Remotely, and routinely. Seventeen of the 28 Carriedale Gardens units have an owner mailing address outside Florida on the 2026 roll, so many sales here run from out of state. We handle showings, inspections, both estoppel requests, the club’s Notice of New Contract and closing logistics, and documents can be signed with a mobile notary.
Often. The multiple listing service name “Carriedale” mostly means the Cottages, the 24 one-story villas on the odd side of the lane, whose county-recorded sales run far higher. We name Carriedale Gardens, the even-numbered address and the building letter in your listing, so buyers and appraisers compare like with like.
Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or request a free home valuation. We will pull the county record for your plan and building, walk through your condo’s condition, floor and parking, request the association and club documents a buyer will want, and show you the Carriedale Gardens sales your price rests on.
Every number on this page comes from the records below, read November 2026 unless stated. Listing-described details are labeled where they appear; listing, brokerage, portal and aggregator websites are not linked. Lee County Property Appraiser figures come from the county’s published public data files, read locally.
Market data from Lee County Property Appraiser public data files, 2026 roll and county-recorded qualified sales, read November 2026.
McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Carriedale Gardens. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.
Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.