Mystic Gardens is a gated condominium of 240 one-level units in 15 two-story buildings on Summerlin Road in the City of Fort Myers, built 1985. Lee County recorded 21 sales at a $124,000 median in 36 months. Call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072.
Updated November 2026 · Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty
By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.
McGreevy and Comisar are the team Mystic Gardens owners call first when they decide to sell, and the team buyers call when they want every recorded Mystic Gardens sale, the condo fee, the flood and evacuation picture, the City of Fort Myers tax rate, the financing question and the association’s rules explained before they write an offer. Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with over $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc, we wrote this guide sellers first: what a Mystic Gardens condo is worth today, which recorded sales set that price, and what a buyer and a buyer’s lender will ask before signing.
Mystic Gardens is a gated condominium of 240 units in 15 two-story buildings at 5301 to 5331 Summerlin Road in Fort Myers, Florida, ZIP 33919, inside the City of Fort Myers. Built in 1985 and declared a condominium in 2006, it sits on the east side of Summerlin Road near Boy Scout Drive, next to Whiskey Creek. Lee County recorded 21 qualified Mystic Gardens sales in the 36 months to October 31, 2026, from $80,000 to $155,000, at a $124,000 median, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser.
If you are choosing who should represent you, our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers sets out the criteria we think every Fort Myers seller and buyer should use. Owners can read our Fort Myers seller guide or request a free Fort Myers home valuation; buyers can read how to buy a home in Fort Myers. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.
McGreevy and Comisar are the best realtor for Mystic Gardens because we price a Mystic Gardens condo from Lee County’s recorded sales in this one complex, read by plan (the 1,018 square foot two-bedroom, the 810 square foot one-bedroom or the 577 square foot one-bedroom), building and condition, not from a citywide condo average, and we answer the fee, rules, flood, insurance and lender questions before a buyer asks. Our team, Domain Realty Group, has been the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012.
If you’re searching for the best realtor for Mystic Gardens in Fort Myers, whether you’re ready to sell your Mystic Gardens condo or buy your next one, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. We are also ranked the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026).
Recent Mystic Gardens market record (36 months): From November 2023 to October 2026 we tracked 21 qualified Mystic Gardens sales recorded by Lee County · a range of $80,000 to $155,000 · a median of $124,000 · newest recorded sale $150,000 for unit 708 at 5307 Summerlin Road on September 2, 2026 · all resales, no builder sales. In the 12 months to October 31, 2026 the county recorded 6 of those sales, from $98,800 to $150,000, at a $107,500 median. Days on market and sale-to-list ratio are MLS measures; the county record carries recorded prices and dates, so we read those two figures for your exact unit when we prepare your pricing.
For Mystic Gardens sellers: professional photography, drone video that shows the gated grounds, the pool and clubhouse and the Summerlin Road location, sale-by-sale pricing from the county record for your plan and building, a lease and tenant plan if your unit is rented, and a qualified-buyer database built over our years leading Domain Realty Group.
Honors and recognition:
Selling your Mystic Gardens condo? Get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 (confidential conversations welcome).
Buying a condo in Mystic Gardens? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 for a personalized buyer consultation, and see how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida.
Mystic Gardens’ key takeaways are its price, its plans and its ownership pattern: 240 one-level condominium flats in 1985 two-story buildings on Summerlin Road, inside the City of Fort Myers at 16.9702 mills for 2026, with recorded prices below their 2022 and 2023 peak, few owner-occupied units on the tax roll, and a financing question every buyer should put to a lender first.
This guide answers the questions Mystic Gardens sellers and buyers in Fort Myers ask us most, in the order below.
Mystic Gardens is a 240-unit residential condominium at 5301 to 5331 Summerlin Road in Fort Myers, Florida, ZIP 33919, made up of 15 two-story buildings of 16 units each on 12.05 acres of common grounds, built in 1985 and declared a condominium in 2006. One condominium association governs the buildings, the grounds, the clubhouse and the pool.
The State registered the condominium as “Mystic Gardens Condo,” project PR72756 with the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) Division of Condominiums, recorded on January 27, 2006, with 240 units, status approved and recorded. The county roll agrees: 240 residential condominium parcels, every one described in the same recorded instrument, 2006-41352, plus one common-element parcel owned by the association.
Mystic Gardens units are the parcels whose Lee County legal description reads “Mystic Gardens Desc in Inst#2006-41352” followed by the unit number. The 2026 roll carries exactly 240 of them, all coded as residential condominium units, plus the association’s common-element parcel at 5301 to 5333 Summerlin Road. Every unit figure on this page is computed on those 240 units.
The unit numbers carry the building. The building at 5303 Summerlin Road holds units 301 to 316, 5305 holds 501 to 516, and so on to 5331, which holds units 3101 to 3116. A unit numbered 2310 is therefore in the building at 5323, the tenth unit there.
Yes. Mystic Gardens sits inside the incorporated City of Fort Myers. The 2026 roll codes all 240 units and the common element with zoning area CFM (City of Fort Myers), fire district City of Fort Myers and taxing district 090, “City of Fort Myers.” Lee County’s flood layer labels the site City of Fort Myers, which is its own flood map community.
That matters for three things a buyer feels: the City, not Lee County, handles zoning and building permits; the tax bill carries the City of Fort Myers levy and its parks debt levy; and the City’s floodplain program applies to flood insurance and to large renovations. Whiskey Creek, next door, sits mostly outside the City on the county roll.
Mystic Gardens is a condominium, not a homeowners association of houses. Each owner holds a unit plus an undivided share of the common elements under Florida’s Condominium Act, Chapter 718. That brings condominium rules on budgets, reserves, master insurance, official records, owner meetings and the estoppel certificate a seller orders at closing.
No. Mystic Greens is a group of condominiums inside Lely Resort in Naples, in Collier County, and Mystic Ridge is a 46-unit condominium at 25100 Goldcrest Drive in Bonita Springs. Both are separate condominiums in the State registry. Mystic Gardens Drive in Apopka, near Orlando, is a street, not this community.
This guide covers only the 240-unit condominium on Summerlin Road in the City of Fort Myers. Our team’s Mystic Greens and Mystic Ridge pages describe those other places.
Mystic Gardens sits on the east side of Summerlin Road near Boy Scout Drive in south-central Fort Myers, at about 26.5766 north and 81.8828 west on the county roll, with Whiskey Creek’s single-family streets beside it and Tanglewood Elementary about a quarter mile away. Summerlin Road runs south from here toward Cypress Lake, Fort Myers Beach and Sanibel.
The aerial at the top of this page shows the layout: a wedge-shaped lot outlined on the county’s parcel map along the curve of Summerlin Road, 15 long buildings in rows around parking lanes, the pool and a fenced court at the north corner, an unbuilt strip of grass and trees at the south end above a canal, and golf fairways and houses across the road.
Yes. The parcel next to Mystic Gardens at 5339 Summerlin Road is part of the Whiskey Creek Country Club Estates plat on the county roll, and Whiskey Creek’s 937 houses spread out from there; their median point is about 0.82 mile away in a straight line. Mystic Gardens is a separate condominium with its own association; it is not part of Whiskey Creek.
Across Summerlin Road the roll shows a vacant commercial parcel at 5310 to 5350 Summerlin Road, also in the City. Our Whiskey Creek guide covers the house neighborhood next door.
Page Field, the general aviation airport near US 41, is about 1 mile from Mystic Gardens in a straight line, according to a listing data panel. Boy Scout Drive, the half-mile link between Summerlin Road and US 41, runs past it. Ask about aircraft noise for the unit you choose, and visit at different hours.
Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW), the commercial airport, is a longer trip: a rental listing estimates 22 minutes and 11.6 miles.
Gulf Coast Medical Center, Lee Health’s campus at 13681 Doctors Way, is about 3.02 miles from Mystic Gardens in a straight line on the county map, and Lee Memorial Hospital at 2776 Cleveland Avenue is about 3.63 miles. Rental listing estimates put the drives at about 10 minutes and 8 minutes.
Time those drives yourself at the hour of a shift change; Summerlin Road and US 41 traffic changes the answer.
Mystic Gardens is about 4.58 miles in a straight line from Fort Myers City Hall at 2200 Second Street on the county map, and a rental listing estimates 10 minutes and 4.8 miles to downtown by the Edison and Ford Winter Estates. Edison Mall, at 4125 Cleveland Avenue, is about 1.80 miles away in a straight line.
That is a short drive rather than a walk. Time it yourself at the hour you would go.
You reach Mystic Gardens from Summerlin Road (County Road 869), whose northern end meets Colonial Boulevard; Boy Scout Drive connects Summerlin Road to US 41. Listings and rental sites describe a gated entry, assigned parking and guest parking. Ask how guest access, the gate code and deliveries work before you buy.
Lee County’s transportation department lists a project to widen Summerlin Road to six lanes from Boy Scout Drive to Cypress Lake Drive. Check its current schedule with the county before you count on, or worry about, road work in front of the complex.
Yes. A transit listing shows LeeTran Route 130, which runs between Edison Mall and the Beach Park and Ride and serves 64 stops, cited for the Mystic Gardens area. Check LeeTran’s current route map and the nearest stop for the building you choose, since routes and stops change.
Living in Mystic Gardens means a one-level condo flat in a gated, low-rise 1985 complex on Summerlin Road, with the grounds, the building exteriors, the pool and the clubhouse run by the association, Whiskey Creek’s streets next door, and central Fort Myers, the hospitals and Page Field a short drive away.
Daily life centers on the unit, the shared grounds and the city around them rather than a club. Listings describe concrete block construction, one living level per unit, screened balconies on some units, assigned parking with guest spaces, and common laundry rooms. Each building has eight units on each floor.
A Mystic Gardens owner’s routine is short: a walk to an assigned space inside the gate, quick drives on Summerlin Road, Boy Scout Drive and US 41, and errands about a mile or two away. Tanglewood Elementary on Manchester Boulevard is about 0.27 mile away in a straight line on the county map, and Edison Mall about 1.80 miles.
Grounds care and the building exteriors are association work. A rental listing estimates 3 minutes to the shops at Stokes Plaza and 6 minutes to Florida SouthWestern State College’s Lee campus. Straight-line distances understate the drive; time your own trips at the hours you would make them.
The tax roll speaks only to ownership, not to people. 19 of the 240 units, about 8 percent, carry a Florida homestead exemption, meaning the owner has claimed the unit as a permanent residence; 221 do not. Most units are held in company names, and owners of 230 units use Florida mailing addresses for their tax bills.
That pattern bears on three things a buyer feels: property taxes, which differ sharply between homesteaded and non-homesteaded units; how many units around you are leased; and whether a lender will finance the project, which we cover in the rules section below.
Yes. Rental sites and sale listings describe a gated entry, and a 2023 listing mentions a security fence. Entry is from Summerlin Road. We tell buyers to ask the association how the gate works for guests, deliveries and emergency vehicles, how towing is handled, and to walk the grounds at night before buying.
We cannot measure quiet, and we do not guess. What the record shows is setting: Mystic Gardens is a gated block of two-story buildings on a busy county road, about a mile from Page Field and beside a neighborhood of houses. Visit on a weekday morning and an evening, and note which way a unit faces and how close it sits to Summerlin Road.
Mystic Gardens owners can get a free home valuation built on recorded sales in this complex, plan by plan, or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buyers comparing a 1,018 square foot two-bedroom with an 810 square foot one-bedroom can call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers.
The Mystic Gardens market has eased from its 2022 and 2023 peak: Lee County recorded 21 qualified sales in the 36 months to October 31, 2026 at a $124,000 median and about $147 a square foot, and 6 in the last 12 months at a $107,500 median, against a $148,000 median in 2023 and $135,500 in 2022.
Data updated: November 2026.
Window (Lee County recorded qualified sales) | Sales | Median | Range | Median $/sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
12 months to October 31, 2026 | 6 | $107,500 (thin: sales listed below) | $98,800 to $150,000 | $135 |
24 months to October 31, 2026 | 16 | $111,500 | $80,000 to $150,000 | $143 |
36 months to October 31, 2026 | 21 | $124,000 | $80,000 to $155,000 | $147 |
60 months to October 31, 2026 | 75 | $124,350 | $45,000 to $185,000 | $147 |
Six sales make a thin 12-month median, so here they are: unit 310 at 5303, 577 square feet, $105,000 (November 6, 2025); unit 1713 at 5317, 1,018 square feet, $110,000 (November 17, 2025); unit 1514 at 5315, 577 square feet, $104,000 (February 2, 2026); unit 2310 at 5323, 1,018 square feet, $110,000 (June 1, 2026); unit 1508 at 5315, 810 square feet, $98,800 (August 21, 2026); and unit 708 at 5307, 1,018 square feet, $150,000 (September 2, 2026). The $107,500 median is the mean of the middle two, $105,000 and $110,000.
Our 12 and 36-month windows end on October 31, 2026. Over the 24 months to the same date Lee County recorded 16 qualified sales at a $111,500 median, the same figure the research team found.
Mystic Gardens’ 2025 median of $111,500 on 10 sales and its 2026 median of $107,000 on 4 sales to date sit below the $148,000 median of 2023 on 15 sales. The county record does not say why. The 2026 county roll also cut the median two-bedroom value from $116,442 to $104,011, about 11 percent, while the small one-bedroom values rose.
The timing matches the wider market: FGCU’s Regional Economic Research Institute reported Southwest Florida condo prices down 8 percent in real terms year over year to the second quarter of 2026, after Florida’s 2022 to 2025 condominium law changes and higher insurance costs. Condition drives the spread inside Mystic Gardens: a two-bedroom sold for $150,000 in September 2026 and another for $80,000 in September 2025.
The county record does not show days on market, the asking price, seller credits, the condition of the unit, whether a tenant was in place, or whether the sale was financed or paid in cash. Those come from the Southwest Florida MLS and the listing itself, and we read them for your exact unit when we prepare a price.
The record also excludes transfers that were not arm’s length and deeds that moved many units at once. Since November 2023 Lee County recorded 68 such Mystic Gardens deed rows: 3 at $0, 23 at $100, and 42 unit rows of one February 2024 bulk deed. None is counted in our medians.
Listing data seen on November 21, 2026 showed two-bedroom units asking $119,000 to $166,000: unit 1302 at 5313 asking $166,000 after 493 days on the market, unit 2112 at 5321 asking $160,000 after 89 days, and unit 3112 at 5331 asking $119,000 after a cut from $135,000 on August 29, 2026.
Asking prices are not sale prices. The 12-month recorded two-bedroom sales ran $110,000 to $150,000, and one listing service reported an 89 percent list-to-sale ratio and 178 days to sell over the past year. We price against the recorded sales, then the competing listings.
No. The $80,000 sale of unit 712 at 5307 on September 4, 2025 is the lowest Mystic Gardens price in the last 36 months, about $79 a square foot for a 1,018 square foot two-bedroom. Every other two-bedroom sale in the window recorded $110,000 or more, so that unit’s condition or terms were likely unusual; the record does not say which.
The Mystic Gardens sales that set today’s prices are the 21 qualified sales Lee County recorded from November 2023 to October 2026: six 2024 sales from $124,350 to $155,000, ten 2025 sales from $80,000 to $150,000, and four 2026 sales from $98,800 to $150,000, plus one December 2023 sale. Every one was a resale, and the table lists them all.
Data updated: November 2026.
Recorded | Building | Unit | Sq ft | Beds and baths | Price | $/sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2023-12-27 | 5327 | 2710 | 577 | 1 and 1 | $135,900 | $236 |
2024-02-05 | 5321 | 2103 | 1,018 | 2 and 2 | $131,600 | $129 |
2024-04-09 | 5321 | 2115 | 1,018 | 2 and 2 | $150,000 | $147 |
2024-05-15 | 5331 | 3107 | 1,018 | 2 and 2 | $155,000 | $152 |
2024-10-10 | 5325 | 2515 | 810 | 1 and 1 | $127,000 | $157 |
2024-11-14 | 5331 | 3106 | 1,018 | 2 and 2 | $135,000 | $133 |
2024-12-05 | 5319 | 1916 | 810 | 1 and 1 | $124,350 | $154 |
2025-02-10 | 5313 | 1309 | 1,018 | 2 and 2 | $150,000 | $147 |
2025-05-29 | 5311 | 1104 | 810 | 1 and 1 | $125,000 | $154 |
2025-06-25 | 5309 | 911 | 810 | 1 and 1 | $119,500 | $148 |
2025-06-26 | 5325 | 2507 | 810 | 1 and 1 | $112,000 | $138 |
2025-08-18 | 5303 | 307 | 810 | 1 and 1 | $111,000 | $137 |
2025-09-04 | 5307 | 712 | 1,018 | 2 and 2 | $80,000 | $79 |
2025-09-24 | 5305 | 501 | 1,018 | 2 and 2 | $124,000 | $122 |
2025-10-10 | 5327 | 2709 | 577 | 1 and 1 | $94,000 | $163 |
2025-11-06 | 5303 | 310 | 577 | 1 and 1 | $105,000 | $182 |
2025-11-17 | 5317 | 1713 | 1,018 | 2 and 2 | $110,000 | $108 |
2026-02-02 | 5315 | 1514 | 577 | 1 and 1 | $104,000 | $180 |
2026-06-01 | 5323 | 2310 | 1,018 | 2 and 2 | $110,000 | $108 |
2026-08-21 | 5315 | 1508 | 810 | 1 and 1 | $98,800 | $122 |
2026-09-02 | 5307 | 708 | 1,018 | 2 and 2 | $150,000 | $147 |
The February 5, 2024 sale of unit 2103 was recorded the same day as a bulk deed between investors; the county flags it as a qualified sale on its own deed, so it is counted here.
The highest Mystic Gardens sale in the last 36 months is $155,000 for unit 3107, a 1,018 square foot two-bedroom at 5331 Summerlin Road, recorded May 15, 2024. In the last 12 months the top sale was $150,000 for unit 708, also a two-bedroom, at 5307, on September 2, 2026.
The highest single-unit price since 2021 is $185,000 for unit 501 at 5305 on May 31, 2022; that same unit resold for $124,000 on September 24, 2025. The highest price per square foot in the last 36 months is $236, for unit 2710, a 577 square foot one-bedroom, in December 2023.
Mystic Gardens’ two-bedroom, two-bath units of 1,018 square feet, the most common plan with 136 units, recorded 10 of the 21 sales in the 36 months to October 2026, from $80,000 to $155,000, at a $133,300 median. In the last 12 months three sold, at $110,000, $110,000 and $150,000.
Buildings 5307, 5313, 5321, 5323, 5329 and 5331 hold only two-bedroom units, so a unit there is priced almost entirely on condition, floor and updates.
Mystic Gardens’ 810 square foot one-bedroom, one-bath units, 72 in all, recorded 7 sales in the 36 months to October 2026, from $98,800 to $127,000, at a $119,500 median. The newest was unit 1508 at 5315 for $98,800 on August 21, 2026, the only 810 square foot sale in the last 12 months.
The 810 square foot plan sits in nine of the 15 buildings, mixed with either two-bedroom units or the smaller one-bedrooms.
Mystic Gardens’ smallest units, 577 square foot one-bedroom, one-bath flats, 32 in all, recorded 4 sales in the 36 months to October 2026, from $94,000 to $135,900, at a $104,500 median. The two in the last 12 months sold for $105,000 and $104,000, the highest prices per square foot in the complex.
The 577 square foot units are in four buildings only: 5303, 5315, 5325 and 5327, eight in each.
Yes. Unit 501 at 5305 sold for $185,000 in May 2022 and $124,000 in September 2025. Unit 2310 at 5323 sold for $127,000 in August 2021 and $110,000 in June 2026. Unit 1514 at 5315 sold for $121,000 in April 2022 and $104,000 in February 2026. Unit 2710 at 5327 sold for $96,900 in November 2022 and $135,900 in December 2023.
Repeat sales show how much the 2022 peak has given back on the same unit, and how much condition can still add.
Mystic Gardens prices began at a $159,900 median when 73 units sold to their first condominium owners in 2006, fell to a $37,000 median in 2010 after the housing crash, stayed in the $40,000s through 2017, climbed to $111,000 in 2021 and a $148,000 peak in 2023, and have eased since to $111,500 in 2025 and $107,000 in 2026 to date.
Data updated: November 2026.
Year | Recorded qualified sales | Median | Range |
|---|---|---|---|
2006 | 73 | $159,900 | $99,900 to $199,900 |
2007 | 12 | $102,150 | |
2010 | 60 | $37,000 | $16,500 to $48,100 |
2011 | 22 | $40,000 | |
2012 | 19 | $48,000 | |
2013 | 16 | $44,400 | |
2014 | 12 | $43,500 | |
2015 | 27 | $42,500 | |
2016 | 33 | $46,000 | |
2017 | 29 | $45,000 | |
2018 | 48 | $53,500 | |
2019 | 20 | $61,000 | $30,078 to $91,000 |
2020 | 17 | $66,000 | |
2021 | 38 | $111,000 | $47,500 to $166,000 |
2022 | 20 | $135,500 | $96,900 to $185,000 |
2023 | 15 | $148,000 | $45,000 to $164,900 |
2024 | 6 | $133,300 | $124,350 to $155,000 |
2025 | 10 | $111,500 | $80,000 to $150,000 |
2026 (to October 31) | 4 | $107,000 | $98,800 to $150,000 |
The county record shows no qualified single-unit Mystic Gardens sale in 2008 or 2009, and none before 2006, when the property was not yet a condominium. Years with fewer than ten sales carry thin medians: one sale more or less moves them. Read them as a direction, not a precise level.
The first Mystic Gardens condominium buyers paid $99,900 to $199,900 in the 73 qualified sales Lee County recorded in 2006, at a $159,900 median, followed by 12 sales in 2007 at a $102,150 median. That burst of first sales after a 2006 declaration on 1985 buildings is the pattern of a rental complex converted to condominium; the recorded declaration is the document that confirms it.
After 2007, Mystic Gardens prices fell with the housing crash to a $37,000 median on 60 sales in 2010, from $16,500 to $48,100. The county sales index also ties a December 2010 deed for $2,833,200 to 136 unit parcels, the kind of bulk purchase investors made after the crash. Medians then stayed between $40,000 and $53,500 from 2011 to 2018.
From 2021 to 2023, Mystic Gardens prices more than doubled: the median rose from $66,000 in 2020 to $111,000 in 2021, $135,500 in 2022 and $148,000 in 2023. On December 23, 2021 alone the county recorded 17 separate qualified unit deeds at $120,000 for two-bedrooms and $105,000 for one-bedrooms; several of those units resold in 2022 for $165,000 to $172,000.
On the 2026 Lee County roll, Mystic Gardens units carry just (market) values from $74,433 to $114,737, median $104,011, and $22,578,239 for all 240 units together, down from $24,003,689 in 2025, about 6 percent. By plan, medians run $104,011 for the 1,018 square foot two-bedrooms, $82,477 for the 810 square foot units and $74,433 for the 577 square foot units.
Just value is the county’s mass-appraisal estimate as of January 1, not a sale price. We use it as a floor check, never as a list price.
Mystic Gardens’ 240 units come in three plans in 15 two-story buildings of 16 units, eight per floor: six buildings hold only 1,018 square foot two-bedroom units, five mix two-bedroom units with 810 square foot one-bedrooms, and four mix 810 square foot one-bedrooms with 577 square foot one-bedrooms. Every unit is a flat on one level.
Building (Summerlin Rd) | Unit numbers | Plans (county roll) | 2026 median just value |
|---|---|---|---|
5303 | 301 to 316 | 8 x 577 and 8 x 810 sq ft | $80,365 |
5305 | 501 to 516 | 8 x 1,018 and 8 x 810 sq ft | $93,244 |
5307 | 701 to 716 | 16 x 1,018 sq ft | $104,011 |
5309 | 901 to 916 | 8 x 1,018 and 8 x 810 sq ft | $93,244 |
5311 | 1101 to 1116 | 8 x 1,018 and 8 x 810 sq ft | $95,357 |
5313 | 1301 to 1316 | 16 x 1,018 sq ft | $104,011 |
5315 | 1501 to 1516 | 8 x 577 and 8 x 810 sq ft | $80,365 |
5317 | 1701 to 1716 | 8 x 1,018 and 8 x 810 sq ft | $93,244 |
5319 | 1901 to 1916 | 8 x 1,018 and 8 x 810 sq ft | $93,244 |
5321 | 2101 to 2116 | 16 x 1,018 sq ft | $104,011 |
5323 | 2301 to 2316 | 16 x 1,018 sq ft | $104,011 |
5325 | 2501 to 2516 | 8 x 577 and 8 x 810 sq ft | $78,455 |
5327 | 2701 to 2716 | 8 x 577 and 8 x 810 sq ft | $82,315 |
5329 | 2901 to 2916 | 16 x 1,018 sq ft | $104,011 |
5331 | 3101 to 3116 | 16 x 1,018 sq ft | $104,011 |
The most common Mystic Gardens plan is the 1,018 square foot two-bedroom, two-bath flat, with 136 units, more than half the complex. Next come 72 one-bedroom, one-bath units of 810 square feet and 32 one-bedroom, one-bath units of 577 square feet. The median unit is 1,018 square feet, and all 240 units together hold 215,232 heated square feet on the county roll.
Rental sites round the sizes differently; we use the county roll’s heated area, which is what an appraiser and a lender read.
Yes. Each Mystic Gardens unit is a flat on one level, on the ground floor or the second floor of a two-story building; the county roll codes every unit with a two-story building code. If step-free access matters to you, ask the association how the upper units are reached before you choose a floor.
No. The county roll flags no garage or carport on any Mystic Gardens unit. Listings and rental sites describe assigned parking plus guest parking inside the gate. Confirm the assigned space for the exact unit and the rules for second vehicles, guests, boats, trailers and work vans in the association’s rules.
Listings and rental sites describe common laundry facilities rather than a washer and dryer in each unit. Whether an owner may add in-unit laundry is an association question about plumbing, electrical and the rules; ask before you count on it, and check what the listing for your unit says.
Mystic Gardens’ buildings date to 1985 on the county roll, and the condominium was created about two decades later: the State records project PR72756, Mystic Gardens Condo, as recorded on January 27, 2006 with 240 units, under the declaration Lee County cites as Instrument 2006-41352. The original developer and any earlier apartment name are not in the public record we read.
The county roll carries two build years on every unit: 1985 as the year built and 2006 as the effective year, which usually reflects renovation work counted at the conversion. Ask the association and the seller what was done to the unit and the building since, with dates and permits.
The public record we read does not name the developer who built Mystic Gardens in 1985 or the company that converted it in 2006. The state registry names the condominium and its association, not the builder, and the county roll names current owners only. The recorded declaration, Instrument 2006-41352, is the document that would name the declarant.
If the history matters to you, a title company or the Lee County Clerk’s Official Records search can pull the declaration and its exhibits. We do not guess at names the record does not carry.
Mystic Gardens became a condominium when a declaration was recorded in 2006, Instrument 2006-41352 in the Lee County Official Records, which the county roll cites in every unit’s legal description. The Florida DBPR file shows the project, PR72756, recorded on January 27, 2006 with 240 units. The roll’s common-element parcel holds the shared land and the clubhouse.
The county sales index ties earlier deeds that moved the whole property to the unit parcels, including one recorded on October 31, 2005 for $24,545,500, before the declaration. The recorded declaration and its exhibits show how the property was divided into units.
The first Mystic Gardens condominium owners bought in 2006, when Lee County recorded 73 qualified unit sales from $99,900 to $199,900 at a $159,900 median, the year the declaration was recorded. Another 12 sold in 2007, at a $102,150 median, before the housing crash stopped sales for two years.
A condominium association directory that mirrors State filings shows Mystic Gardens Condominium Association, Inc., document number N05000009790, filed on September 22, 2005, a few months before the declaration was recorded. Confirm the association’s status, registered agent and latest annual report on the Florida Division of Corporations’ Sunbiz search before you rely on it.
Yes. On February 5, 2024 Lee County recorded one deed for $5,526,500 that moved a block of Mystic Gardens units between investors, plus a separate unit deed the same day for $131,600. A commercial real estate brokerage announced the transaction as a 48-unit sale for $5,658,059, within $41 of the two recorded figures together.
A smaller block deed on October 17, 2023 moved seven two-bedroom units for $871,000. None of these bulk deeds is counted in our medians.
Mystic Gardens is governed by one condominium association, Mystic Gardens Condominium Association, Inc., which the county roll names as the owner of the 12.05-acre common-element parcel and the State registry names as the condominium’s managing entity. Its board sets the budget, the fees, the rules and the insurance for all 240 units under Florida’s Condominium Act, Chapter 718.
The association’s own documents, its declaration, bylaws, rules and budget, are the binding source for every rule a buyer asks about. Public listing sites repeat those rules inconsistently, which is why this guide says “confirm with the association” wherever a rule matters.
Mystic Gardens Condominium Association, Inc. governs Mystic Gardens. The county roll lists the common-element parcel, FolioID 10519198, at 5301 to 5333 Summerlin Road in the association’s name, and the DBPR condominium file lists the managing entity as Mystic Gardens Condo Assn Inc, at a business address in Naples. There are no sub-associations or villages: one condominium, one association, 240 units.
The DBPR registry lists the managing entity as the association itself, at 1076 Business Lane in Naples, and directory pages name a management firm without a date, so the current manager is a question for the association. Ask who manages the property today, how to reach them and who issues the estoppel certificate, before you write an offer.
A phone number widely listed for the community is (239) 275-0688; confirm it is current before relying on it.
Florida’s Condominium Act, Chapter 718 of the Florida Statutes, governs Mystic Gardens: section 718.111 covers the association’s powers, official records and insurance; section 718.112 bylaws, budgets and reserves; section 718.116 assessments and the estoppel certificate; and section 718.503 the documents a resale buyer receives. The State’s 2025 condominium law, CS/CS/HB 913, added rules for video-conference meetings and reserve funding.
Mystic Gardens owners may inspect the association’s official records under section 718.111 of the Florida Statutes, including the declaration, bylaws, rules, budgets, financial reports, insurance policies and board minutes. A buyer receives the governing documents, the rules and the most recent financial information from the seller under section 718.503, and should read the minutes for pending work or assessments.
Florida required every condominium association to open an online account with the DBPR Division of Condominiums by October 1, 2025; ask the association whether it has filed any reserve study or inspection report there.
Owning in Mystic Gardens costs the monthly or quarterly condo fee, which listings put at about $492 to $498 a month for a two-bedroom unit, plus City of Fort Myers property taxes at 16.9702 mills, the City’s non-ad valorem charges on the tax bill, an HO-6 insurance policy, and any special assessment. Fees for the one-bedroom units are not published, and no layer below is confirmed by the association.
Fee layer | Amount | Period | What it covers | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Condo fee, two-bedroom (1,018 sq ft) | About $492 to $498 a month in 2025 and 2026 listings; $1,483 a quarter on a 2023 listing | Monthly or quarterly | Listings name master insurance, roof, structure, grounds, pool, recreation, security and trash | Listing data; confirm with the association |
Condo fee, one-bedroom (810 and 577 sq ft) | Not published as of November 21, 2026 | Ask for the fee schedule by unit size | Ask the association | |
Property tax | 16.9702 mills on taxable value (about $1,765 a year for a two-bedroom at its 2026 county value, no exemption) | Yearly | City of Fort Myers, Lee County, schools, library, water management and other levies | Lee County Property Appraiser |
City fire assessment, stormwater, solid waste | Shown on the tax bill | Yearly | City fire service, stormwater and garbage districts at the site | Lee County GIS taxing layer; confirm on the tax bill |
CDD | None found | Confirm on the tax bill | ||
Special assessment | None found in public sources | Ask the association and read the minutes | ||
Application, transfer or capital contribution fee | Not published as of November 21, 2026 | One rental listing cites a 7-day association approval | Ask the association | |
HO-6 insurance | Owner’s quote | Yearly | Interior, contents, loss assessment | Your insurance agent |
Mystic Gardens listings for two-bedroom units show about $492 to $498 a month in 2025 and 2026, and a 2023 listing showed $1,483 a quarter, about $494 a month. An aggregator’s lower range of $263 to $373 a month may reflect one-bedroom units or older data. Confirm the current budget and the fee for your unit size with the association.
Probably not. Florida condominiums usually divide the budget by each unit’s share of the common elements in the declaration, and Mystic Gardens has three plans of 577, 810 and 1,018 square feet. Listings publish the two-bedroom fee only. Ask the association for the fee schedule by unit, or read the share in the declaration.
A 2023 Mystic Gardens listing says the fee covers the common areas, master insurance, grounds, the structure, the pool, recreation, the roof, security and trash. An older listing adds water and sewer, irrigation, pest control, streets and lights, management, and legal and accounting. Confirm the current list in the budget, because what a fee covers changes with each budget.
We found no published application, transfer or capital contribution fee for Mystic Gardens buyers or tenants. One rental listing mentions a 7-day association approval period for a lease. Ask the association for its application process, fees and timeline for both purchases and leases before you write an offer.
We found no Mystic Gardens special assessment in news reports or public records, but the absence of a report is not proof. Ask the seller and the association for any assessment adopted or under discussion, read the last year of board minutes, and check the estoppel certificate, which must list any assessment due.
The estoppel certificate is the association’s statement of what a Mystic Gardens unit owes at closing: regular fees, any special assessment, late charges and other amounts due. Section 718.116 of the Florida Statutes governs it. The seller or the title company orders it before closing, and the buyer relies on it for the fee and assessment figures.
We found no community development district (CDD) for Mystic Gardens, and a listing data panel reports no CDD on record. The Lee County taxing layer at the site lists City of Fort Myers fire, stormwater and solid-waste districts rather than a CDD. Confirm on the latest tax bill for the exact unit, which lists every non-ad valorem charge.
Property taxes on a Mystic Gardens condo run at 16.9702 mills for 2026, the adopted total for Lee County taxing district 090, City of Fort Myers, on every unit. On the 2026 roll’s median taxable value of $88,279 that is about $1,498 a year, before the November discount and the non-ad valorem charges.
Data updated: November 2026.
Levy (district 090, 2026) | Adopted mills | Proposed | Rollback |
|---|---|---|---|
Lee County general revenue | 3.7623 | 3.7623 | 3.7292 |
Public schools, local board | 2.2480 | 2.2480 | 2.2725 |
Public schools, state law | 3.0230 | 3.0230 | 3.1044 |
City of Fort Myers | 6.9000 | 7.3112 | 6.6465 |
Lee County Library District | 0.4218 | 0.4218 | 0.4189 |
South Florida Water Management District, district-wide | 0.0948 | 0.0948 | 0.0906 |
Everglades construction project | 0.0327 | 0.0327 | 0.0312 |
Okeechobee basin | 0.1026 | 0.1026 | 0.0977 |
Lee County Hyacinth Control District | 0.0190 | 0.0200 | 0.0190 |
Lee County Mosquito Control District | 0.2096 | 0.2201 | 0.2096 |
West Coast Inland Navigation District | 0.0394 | 0.0394 | 0.0389 |
City of Fort Myers parks voted debt | 0.1170 | 0.1690 | 0.1690 |
Total | 16.9702 | 17.4449 | 16.8275 |
The 2026 Taxing District Millage Book from the Lee County Property Appraiser, printed October 9, 2026, is the source; it states that its listing does not include non-ad valorem special assessments.
A Mystic Gardens tax bill depends on the plan and the exemption. At the 2026 county median values and 16.9702 mills with no exemption, we estimate about $1,765 a year for a 1,018 square foot two-bedroom, about $1,400 for an 810 square foot unit and about $1,263 for a 577 square foot unit, before the non-ad valorem charges.
The 221 units without a homestead exemption carry a median estimated ad valorem tax of about $1,498; the 19 homesteaded units about $738. These are our estimates from the roll, not tax bills.
Not always. A homesteaded seller’s assessed value may sit below the unit’s just value under the Save Our Homes cap in section 193.155 of the Florida Statutes; the cap resets when the unit sells, so the buyer’s first bill uses the new just value. A new owner who files for homestead on a two-bedroom at its 2026 county value would pay about $1,048.
Most Mystic Gardens units carry no homestead exemption, so for those units the buyer’s bill is usually close to the seller’s. Check the TRIM notice and the latest tax bill for the exact unit.
Mystic Gardens pays the City of Fort Myers levy of 6.9000 mills and the City’s parks debt levy, while condominiums a few miles south on Summerlin Road sit in unincorporated district 068, Iona McGregor Fire, at 13.3623 mills adopted for 2026. The difference is about $360 a year for each $100,000 of taxable value.
In return, City parcels get City services, including the City fire department, police and stormwater system. Compare the whole cost, fee plus tax plus insurance, not the millage alone.
Yes. The City of Fort Myers levy rose from 6.5000 mills in 2025 to 6.9000 adopted for 2026, below its 7.3112 proposed cap but above the 6.6465 rollback rate. District 090’s total rose from 16.5034 in 2025 to 16.9702 for 2026, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser’s 2025 and 2026 millage books.
The Lee County taxing layer at Mystic Gardens lists a City of Fort Myers fire assessment, City stormwater and a solid-waste area, each billed as a non-ad valorem charge rather than by millage. Published City figures show a fire assessment per residence with a proposed cap for 2026-27; confirm the adopted amount and how condominium units are billed on the latest tax bill.
Mystic Gardens has a community pool and a clubhouse on the association’s common grounds, and listings and rental sites name a fitness room, a tennis court, basketball, pickleball, a dog park, picnic and grill areas and common laundry. There is no golf course, no equity club and no membership fee beyond the condo fee.
The county roll shows the clubhouse as one 1985 building of 2,258 heated square feet on the common-element parcel, which carries 12.05 acres and a recreational land use code. Amenity lists on listing sites conflict: one feed lists community features as “None,” and some generic lists name a business center and a spa that no other source confirms. Walk the grounds and ask the association what is open and maintained.
One Mystic Gardens listing describes the pool as heated; other listings and rental sites say only “community pool.” Ask the association whether the pool is heated, its hours and season, and whether guests and tenants may use it. A 2023 listing also mentions a sundeck.
Public listings name the Mystic Gardens clubhouse without describing its rooms; the county roll shows one 1985 building of 2,258 heated square feet on the common grounds. Listings and rental sites mention a fitness room. Ask the association what the clubhouse holds, how owners reserve it, and any rules for tenants and guests.
No. Mystic Gardens has no golf, no equity or social club and no initiation fee in any source we read; the pool, clubhouse and courts are common elements paid for through the condo fee. Confirm in the budget that no separate amenity charge applies to your unit.
Mystic Gardens has no golf course of its own. Whiskey Creek, next door, grew up around a country club plat on the county roll, and our Whiskey Creek guide covers its streets. Check the current status, fees and public access of any nearby course directly with the course.
Mystic Gardens’ rental, pet and age rules come from its recorded declaration and the association’s rules, which public sources report inconsistently: one listing describes up to three rentals a year with a 30-day minimum, pet reports conflict, and no public source shows an age restriction. Read the current documents, or ask the association in writing, before you buy.
The tax roll shows most units are not homesteaded, which usually means many are leased, so leasing rules and the association’s approval process matter to almost every buyer here.
Leasing is common at Mystic Gardens: only 19 of 240 units carry a homestead exemption. One sale listing states up to three rentals a year with a 30-day minimum, and a rental listing cites a 7-day association approval. In November 2026 rental listings showed two-bedrooms at $1,200 to $1,300 a month. Confirm the leasing rules in the declaration.
One-bedroom units were listed at $975 to $1,100 a month the same month, according to the same listing service. Rents are asking rents, not signed leases.
Mystic Gardens pet rules are unclear in public sources: one sale listing says an owner may keep one pet of up to 40 pounds, several rental listings say no dogs or cats per the association, and a rental site mentions weight limits and fees for leased units. Treat pets as restricted until you have the association’s current rules in writing.
No public source we read shows an age restriction at Mystic Gardens, and the State condominium file does not list it as housing for older persons. The declaration and the association’s rules are the documents that would state any such rule. Confirm in writing with the association before you buy.
Possibly. Many Florida condominium declarations require the association to approve a sale or a lease, and a Mystic Gardens rental listing cites a 7-day approval period for tenants. Whether a purchase needs approval, and what it costs, is in the declaration and the rules. Ask the association before you set a closing date.
Ask a lender before you write an offer. Fannie Mae treats a condominium project of 21 or more units as ineligible when a single entity owns more than 20 percent of the units, and the 2026 county roll shows one ownership group appearing to hold about 32 percent of Mystic Gardens’ units. If that holds, many buyers would need cash, a portfolio loan or a non-warrantable loan.
Fannie Mae’s guide also describes a waiver for some projects where one entity owns no more than 49 percent of units. Whether Mystic Gardens qualifies, and whether any lender has approved it, is a question for your lender, not a judgment about any owner. Ask too whether the project is approved for FHA or VA loans; HUD’s condominium lookup shows FHA approvals.
Mystic Gardens listings and rental sites describe assigned parking and guest parking inside the gate; the county roll shows no garage or carport on any unit. Ask the association for the number of assigned spaces for your unit and the rules for second vehicles, guests, commercial vehicles, boats and trailers, and whether any storage comes with the unit.
Mystic Gardens units are reported in FEMA Zone X or Zone X500, outside the high-risk flood area, by listing data panels that read FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer, at a ground elevation of about 10 feet. Because the site is inside the City of Fort Myers, its own flood map community, Lee County’s flood layer does not show the zone, so confirm each building on FEMA’s Map Service Center.
Item | Finding | Source |
|---|---|---|
Flood zone, 5331 unit 3112 | Zone X, outside the high-risk area | Listing data panel reading FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer |
Flood zone, 5313 unit 1302 | Zone X500 (0.2 percent annual chance, moderate risk) | Listing data |
Flood zone, a 5315 unit | Zone X | Listing data |
Ground elevation | About 10 feet (approximate) | Listing data panels citing USGS |
FIRM panel | 12071C0409G, effective November 17, 2022 | Lee County GIS, checked November 21, 2026 |
Flood map community | City of Fort Myers, community 125106 | Lee County GIS |
Zones nearby, within about 300 meters | AE (base flood elevation 8 feet NAVD88), shaded X and X, in unincorporated Lee County | Lee County GIS |
Evacuation zone | Zone B (storm surge zone 2) | Lee County GIS, checked November 21, 2026 |
You confirm a Mystic Gardens unit’s flood zone on FEMA’s Flood Map Service Center, by entering the building’s street address, or on the City of Fort Myers’ online flood lookup. Lee County’s flood layer labels the whole site “City of Fort Myers” without a zone, and the polygons within about 300 meters of the site change from AE to shaded X to X.
Ask the seller for any elevation certificate and the current flood insurance declarations page; a flood zone on a listing is not a substitute for the map.
A lender does not require flood insurance for a unit in Zone X or X500, but owners outside the high-risk area still file flood claims, and the association’s master flood coverage, if any, protects the building, not your interior and belongings. Ask the association what flood coverage the master policy carries, then price a contents and interior policy for your unit.
FEMA prices flood insurance under Risk Rating 2.0 by the building’s own risk, not only its zone, so get a quote for the exact unit.
Lee County’s emergency management layer places Mystic Gardens in Evacuation Zone B, storm surge zone 2. The county’s Zone B guidance says that zone is vulnerable to potentially fatal storm surge and is among the first ordered to evacuate. Plan where you would go, and keep your insurance and association contacts handy before hurricane season.
Yes. As a flood map community, the City of Fort Myers applies the National Flood Insurance Program’s substantial improvement and substantial damage rules to buildings in its floodplain, which can require a building to meet current flood standards after major work or damage. Ask the City’s building department how its rules apply before planning a large renovation.
We found no news report that names Mystic Gardens in Hurricane Ian in 2022 or Hurricanes Helene and Milton in 2024. The 2025 and 2026 county rolls carry no disaster value adjustment on any of the 240 units, and 2023 resales held a $148,000 median, so the county record shows no sign of major storm distress. That is not proof of no damage; ask the association.
The public record we read does not show Mystic Gardens flooding in Hurricane Ian. The county’s disaster code is 0 on every unit in both the 2025 and 2026 rolls, meaning no disaster value reduction was recorded, and 15 qualified sales in 2023 recorded a $148,000 median. Ask the association and the seller directly about any water intrusion, repairs or insurance claims.
A 2023 Mystic Gardens listing states that all of the roofs were replaced in 2019, and listings from about 2019 to 2021 describe new sidewalks, railings, exterior painting, a new board and new management. Ask the association for completion dates, permits and any warranties, because roof age is among the first things a buyer’s insurer asks.
A Mystic Gardens buyer should ask the association for any storm insurance claims since 2022, the repairs made and their permits, any assessment that paid for them, and the master policy’s wind deductible. Ask the seller for the unit’s own claim history and any interior repairs, and have an inspector look for past water intrusion at windows, doors and the ceiling.
Florida’s milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study (SIRS) laws apply to condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories, and Mystic Gardens’ buildings are two stories, so on that basis they appear to fall outside both requirements. Other parts of the 2022 and 2025 condominium laws, on records, meetings and reserves, still apply. Confirm with the association.
On the State’s three-story threshold in section 553.899 of the Florida Statutes, Mystic Gardens’ two-story buildings appear not to need a milestone inspection. The DBPR Division of Condominiums publishes the rules and the reporting portal. Ask the association whether counsel has confirmed the exemption and whether any voluntary structural review has been done.
The SIRS requirement applies to condominium buildings of three habitable stories or more, so Mystic Gardens’ two-story buildings appear to be outside it. The association still sets reserves under section 718.112 of the Florida Statutes for roofs, paving, painting and other major items. Ask for the reserve schedule and the reserve balance in the current budget.
CS/CS/HB 913, the 2025 condominium law that took effect on July 1, 2025 as Chapter 2025-175, Laws of Florida, added rules for board and owner meetings held by video conference, including recording those meetings, and new options for funding reserves. It applies to all Florida condominiums, including two-story ones like Mystic Gardens.
A Mystic Gardens seller should expect a buyer to ask whether a milestone inspection or SIRS applies, and to see the association’s answer. Florida Realtors’ MISIRS-1 disclosure form is the common way to record it in a contract. For a two-story building the usual answer is “not required,” confirmed by the association.
Insurance for a Mystic Gardens condo has two layers: the association’s master policy on the buildings, which listings say the condo fee includes, and the owner’s HO-6 policy on the interior, contents and liability. The master policy’s carrier, premium, deductible and any related assessment are not public; get them from the association before you buy.
Mystic Gardens listings say master insurance is included in the condo fee; the policy itself is not published. A Florida master policy usually covers the buildings and common elements, and section 718.111 of the Florida Statutes sets what it must cover. Ask for the declarations page, the wind and named-storm deductible, and how a deductible would be shared among owners.
There is no public Mystic Gardens HO-6 figure; one listing page models $500 to $1,000 a year, which is an estimate, not a quote. Your premium depends on the unit’s coverage limits, the master policy deductible you need to cover, the floor and your claim history. Get a quote for the exact unit before you write an offer.
Often. A wind mitigation inspection under section 627.711 of the Florida Statutes records roof shape, roof covering, attachment and opening protection, and insurers give credits for qualifying features. For a condo unit the roof items belong to the building, so ask the association for any building wind mitigation report and the 2019 roof records.
The Mystic Gardens buildings were built in 1985, according to the 2026 county roll, which gives every unit a 2006 effective year, so they are about 41 years old in 2026. Insurers ask about roof age, plumbing, electrical panels and water heaters on buildings of that age. Ask the association and the seller for the replacement dates of each.
Mystic Gardens addresses are served by the School District of Lee County, which assigns schools by address; Tanglewood Elementary on Manchester Boulevard is about 0.27 mile away in a straight line, and listings name Fort Myers High and Cypress Lake High in the area’s high school zone. Confirm the assigned schools for the exact unit address with the district before you rely on any listing.
Tanglewood Elementary, at 1620 Manchester Boulevard, is about 0.27 mile from Mystic Gardens in a straight line on the county map, and listing sites name it for the community. Rental sites also name Villas Elementary. Assignment, choice and transport rules change; check the district’s lookup for the exact address.
You confirm the schools for a Mystic Gardens unit with the School District of Lee County’s address lookup and its student enrollment plan for the school year you need, both on the district’s website. Listings repeat zone names that may be out of date. Call the district’s student enrollment office if the lookup and a listing disagree.
Listings and rental sites name Cypress Lake Middle, Lexington Middle, Cypress Lake High and Fort Myers High for Mystic Gardens addresses. On the county map Fort Myers High at 2635 Cortez Boulevard is about 3.55 miles away in a straight line and Lexington Middle at 16351 Summerlin Road about 5.77 miles. Confirm the assigned schools with the district.
Yes. A rental listing estimates 6 minutes and 2.5 miles to Florida SouthWestern State College’s Lee campus, and 29 minutes and 14.7 miles to Florida Gulf Coast University. Check each school’s own site for programs and parking.
Mystic Gardens is a short drive from most of central Fort Myers: rental listing estimates put Lee Memorial Hospital about 8 minutes away, downtown about 10 minutes, Gulf Coast Medical Center about 10 minutes and Southwest Florida International Airport about 22 minutes, with Page Field about a mile away in a straight line.
Destination | Estimated time and distance | Straight line on the county map | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) | 22 minutes, 11.6 miles | Rental listing estimate | |
Page Field (general aviation) | About 1 mile | Listing data panel | |
Lee Memorial Hospital, 2776 Cleveland Ave | 8 minutes, 3.9 miles | 3.63 miles | Rental listing estimate; Lee County roll |
Gulf Coast Medical Center, 13681 Doctors Way | 10 minutes, 5.1 miles | 3.02 miles | Rental listing estimate; Lee County roll |
Downtown Fort Myers (City Hall, 2200 Second St) | 10 minutes, 4.8 miles | 4.58 miles | Rental listing estimate; Lee County roll |
Edison Mall, 4125 Cleveland Ave | 1.80 miles | Lee County roll | |
Stokes Plaza shopping | 3 minutes, 1.3 miles | Rental listing estimate | |
Florida SouthWestern State College, Lee campus | 6 minutes, 2.5 miles | Rental listing estimate | |
Florida Gulf Coast University | 29 minutes, 14.7 miles | Rental listing estimate | |
Tanglewood Elementary, 1620 Manchester Blvd | 0.27 mile | Lee County roll |
Rental listing estimates do not state the time of day or traffic. Time the trips you will make at the hours you will make them.
A rental listing estimates 22 minutes and 11.6 miles from Mystic Gardens to Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW), and a listing service puts RSW about 8 miles away in a straight line. The usual route runs east to the airport by way of the major east-west roads to Interstate 75 and Daniels Parkway or Treeline Avenue; time it at the hour of your flights.
A rental listing estimates 3 minutes and 1.3 miles to Stokes Plaza, and Edison Mall on Cleveland Avenue is about 1.80 miles away in a straight line on the county map. Listings also cite grocery stores, restaurants and parks nearby. Check which stores are open now before relying on any list.
Summerlin Road runs south from Mystic Gardens toward the roads to Fort Myers Beach, Sanibel and Captiva. We did not find a reliable published drive time from the complex to the Gulf beaches, so time the trip yourself, in season and out, before you count on it.
We price a Mystic Gardens condo from the recorded sales of its own plan in this complex, the 1,018, 810 or 577 square foot flat, then adjust for condition, floor, building and any lease in place, and check the result against the competing listings and the unit’s county value. Citywide condo averages hide the three plans and the investor-heavy ownership that set prices here.
Citywide Fort Myers condo averages mix high-rise towers, new construction and older garden complexes, and they cannot see Mystic Gardens’ three plans or the share of units held by companies. A 577 square foot one-bedroom and a 1,018 square foot two-bedroom here sold within about $5,000 of each other in the last 12 months. Only recorded Mystic Gardens sales show that.
Sometimes. A ground-floor Mystic Gardens unit saves stairs and often sells to buyers who want step-free access; a second-floor unit gets more privacy and may get a better view over the grounds. The county record does not carry the floor, so we read it from each listing and compare like with like.
Often. Many Mystic Gardens units are leased, and a unit sold with a tenant in place sells to buyers who want the lease, usually priced on the rent, while a vacant unit can sell to a buyer who plans to live in it. In November 2026, two-bedroom rents listed at $1,200 to $1,300 a month. We price both paths before we list.
A little. All 15 Mystic Gardens buildings were built in 1985 and share the same association, but a unit’s position relative to Summerlin Road, the pool and the parking changes how buyers see it. The 2026 county values are the same for each plan in every building, so the market, not the roll, prices the location.
Buying a condo in Mystic Gardens takes eight steps: talk to a lender first about the project, set the plan you want, read the recorded sales, tour units at different hours, write an offer with document and inspection periods, get association approval if required, inspect and insure, then close with the estoppel certificate in hand.
A Mystic Gardens buyer should have the inspector check the air conditioning, water heater, electrical panel, plumbing, windows and sliding doors, and any sign of past water intrusion, and should ask the association about the roofs, replaced in 2019 according to a 2023 listing, and the building exteriors. Ask for a wind mitigation or four-point report if your insurer wants one.
A Mystic Gardens resale buyer receives the declaration, articles, bylaws, rules and the most recent year-end financial information, plus the frequently asked questions and answers sheet, under section 718.503 of the Florida Statutes, and has a review period set by the contract and the statute. Read the leasing, pet and approval sections first.
A Mystic Gardens buyer starts with a lender conversation and a list of the three plans and their recent recorded prices. Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 to set up tours and a lender introduction, and see how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida.
Mystic Gardens compares as one of the two lowest-priced garden condominiums in this set on the county record, at a $124,000 36-month median, with the City of Fort Myers millage and the lowest homestead share; Summerlin Woods, Myerlee Gardens, Cypress Lake Gardens and Summerlin Trace resell higher in unincorporated Lee County, and Gladiolus Gardens trades lower for much smaller units.
Data updated: November 2026. Every row uses the same method: Lee County recorded qualified single-unit sales in windows ending October 31, 2026, the 2026 roll for units, build years, size and homestead share, and the 2026 millage book for the taxing district.
Community | Units | Built | Median size (sq ft) | Homestead share | Taxing district (2026 mills) | 12 months | 36 months |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mystic Gardens | 240 | 1985 | 1,018 | 8% | 090 City (16.9702) | 6 sales, $107,500 | 21 sales, $124,000 |
Gladiolus Gardens | 155 | 1980 to 1981 | 562 | 20% | 068 (13.3623) | 8 sales, $103,500 | 28 sales, $121,250 |
Cypress Lake Gardens | 139 | 1974 to 1979 | 967 | 32% | 068 (13.3623) | 5 sales, $114,900 | 20 sales, $142,500 |
Centre Court Condo I | 96 | 1982 | 958 | 39% | 090 City (16.9702) | 6 sales, $115,000 | 16 sales, $143,000 |
Summerlin Woods | 264 | 1985 to 1991 | 919 | 34% | 068 (13.3623) | 11 sales, $140,000 | 31 sales, $150,000 |
Myerlee Gardens | 210 | 1982 to 1987 | 1,042 | 53% | 068 (13.3623) | 18 sales, $139,000 | 38 sales, $153,000 |
Summerlin Trace | 167 | 1989 to 1994 | 1,093 | 43% | 068 (13.3623) | 8 sales, $187,500 | 22 sales, $200,350 |
Summerlin Woods, eight condominiums of 264 units on the county roll built from 1985 to 1991, resold at a $150,000 median over 36 months against Mystic Gardens’ $124,000, with a 34 percent homestead share against 8 percent, and sits in unincorporated district 068 at 13.3623 mills. Listings show its fees at about $1,393 to $1,567 a quarter.
The full side-by-side is in the next section.
Myerlee Gardens, 210 units on Sandtrap Drive built from 1982 to 1987, resold at a $153,000 median over 36 months on 38 sales and $139,000 over 12 months on 18, with a 1,042 square foot median unit, close to Mystic Gardens’ two-bedroom. More than half its units, 53 percent, carry a homestead exemption, and it pays unincorporated millage.
Our Fort Myers coverage includes several other Myerlee condominiums, such as Myerlee Country Club Estates North; Myerlee Gardens is a separate condominium.
Cypress Lake Gardens, 139 units on the county roll built from 1974 to 1979 around Bennington Drive, resold at a $142,500 median over 36 months on 20 sales, with a 967 square foot median unit and a 32 percent homestead share. It is older than Mystic Gardens, sells about $18,500 higher at the 36-month median and pays the lower unincorporated millage.
Gladiolus Gardens, 155 units on Country Road built in 1980 and 1981, resold at a $121,250 median over 36 months on 28 sales and $103,500 over 12 months, but its median unit is 562 square feet, about the size of Mystic Gardens’ smallest plan. Mystic Gardens offers far more two-bedroom units, 136 of 240, at similar median prices.
Centre Court Condo I, 96 units at 2121 Collier Avenue built in 1982, is the other City of Fort Myers condominium in this set, in the same district 090 at 16.9702 mills. It resold at a $143,000 median over 36 months on 16 sales, with 958 square foot units and a 39 percent homestead share. Our Centre Court Condo guide covers it in full.
Whiskey Creek’s 937 houses on the county roll, built from 1953 to 2023 with a 1,983 square foot median, resold at a $510,000 median over 36 months on 122 sales, and 80 percent are homesteaded. A Whiskey Creek house is a different purchase: about four times the price, a yard, no condominium fee and mostly unincorporated taxes. Our Whiskey Creek guide covers it.
Mystic Gardens is one of many Fort Myers communities we cover. Buyers comparing a condominium with a waterfront or golf address often also read our guides to McGregor Isles, The Landings, Deep Lagoon Estates, High Point Place and Valencia Terrace, and our Fort Myers real estate market report.
Mystic Gardens vs Summerlin Woods comes down to price, taxes and financing: both are 1980s garden condominiums off Summerlin Road, but Mystic Gardens resells about $26,000 lower at the 36-month median and pays City millage, while Summerlin Woods has more owner-occupied units, lower unincorporated millage and smaller median units.
Yardstick | Mystic Gardens | Summerlin Woods |
|---|---|---|
Units on the county roll | 240, one condominium | 264, eight condominiums |
Built | 1985 | 1985 to 1991 |
Median unit size | 1,018 sq ft | 919 sq ft |
12-month recorded sales | 6, $107,500 median | 11, $140,000 median |
36-month recorded sales | 21, $124,000 median | 31, $150,000 median |
Homestead share | 8% (19 of 240) | 34% |
Taxing district, 2026 adopted | 090 City of Fort Myers, 16.9702 | 068 Iona McGregor Fire, 13.3623 |
Listed condo fee, two-bedroom | About $492 to $498 a month | About $1,393 to $1,567 a quarter |
Financing question | One ownership group appears to hold about 32 percent of units; ask a lender | Ask a lender |
On price per unit, Mystic Gardens is the better value: its two-bedroom units of 1,018 square feet resold at a $133,300 median over 36 months, against Summerlin Woods’ overall $150,000 median for smaller units. On carrying cost, the gap narrows: Mystic Gardens pays about $360 more tax per $100,000 of taxable value. Compare total monthly cost.
Summerlin Woods recorded 11 qualified sales in the last 12 months to Mystic Gardens’ 6, from a similar number of units, and listing data show one Mystic Gardens two-bedroom on the market for 493 days. The financing question at Mystic Gardens narrows the buyer pool, which shows in its pace. We read days on market for each from the MLS.
Mystic Gardens fits a purchase that puts the most square feet for the price, a gated two-bedroom flat, City of Fort Myers services and a short drive to central Fort Myers first, bought with cash or through a lender that will finance the project. Summerlin Woods fits a purchase that puts a higher homestead share on the roll, lower millage and a likely easier loan first.
DRG, our team site, has a Summerlin Woods page for buyers comparing the two.
The honest pros of Mystic Gardens are price, space and location: two-bedroom flats below the recent recorded prices of most nearby condos, a gated complex with a pool and clubhouse, and a central Fort Myers address. The honest cons are the financing question created by concentrated ownership, City millage, an unpublished fee schedule, conflicting public rules and a soft resale market.
Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
36-month median of $124,000, below every condo in our comparison except Gladiolus Gardens, whose units are about half the size | One ownership group appears to hold about 32 percent of units; many lenders may not finance |
136 two-bedroom, two-bath flats of 1,018 square feet | Only 19 of 240 units homesteaded |
Gated, with a pool, clubhouse and courts named in listings | City millage of 16.9702, about $360 more per $100,000 than district 068 |
Inside the City of Fort Myers, near the hospitals, Page Field and downtown | Fee schedule by unit size and current rules not published |
Reported Zone X or X500, outside the high-risk flood area | Evacuation Zone B, among the first ordered out for surge |
Two-story buildings, below the milestone and SIRS threshold | 1985 buildings: roofs reported replaced in 2019, other systems to confirm |
Roofs reported replaced in 2019 | Prices below the 2023 peak; one unit on the market 493 days |
The biggest risk for a Mystic Gardens buyer is financing and resale: if one ownership group holds more than Fannie Mae’s 20 percent single-entity limit, many conventional lenders will not lend, which narrows both your purchase and your future resale to cash and portfolio buyers. Ask a lender in writing before you write an offer.
Mystic Gardens suits a purchase where price per square foot, a gated complex and a central Fort Myers location matter more than a fast resale or a conventional loan: a cash or portfolio-financed buy of a one-level flat, held as a home or leased within the association’s rules. It suits a purchase that depends on conventional financing poorly.
Selling a Mystic Gardens condo well means pricing it on the recorded Mystic Gardens sales for its plan and condition, presenting the space, the gate, the pool and the Summerlin Road location as the assets they are, and answering the fee, lease, insurance and financing questions up front. McGreevy and Comisar have done this for Southwest Florida owners for more than a decade as the #1 team in the region.
If you’re searching for the best Mystic Gardens listing agent, or thinking, ‘I need to sell my condo in Mystic Gardens…’, McGreevy and Comisar helps owners price, market, negotiate and sell with a local strategy built for Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples, Lee County, Collier County and Babcock Ranch. Whether you are selling a 1,018 square foot two-bedroom or a one-bedroom unit on Summerlin Road, our team provides local market guidance, professional listing exposure and a clear plan to help you sell confidently.
Mystic Gardens sold-market statistics we tracked: 21 recorded Lee County qualified sales from November 2023 to October 2026, $80,000 to $155,000, a $124,000 median; 6 sales from $98,800 to $150,000 in the 12 months to October 31, 2026, at a $107,500 median; no builder sales. Days on market and sale-to-list ratio are read from the Southwest Florida MLS for your unit when we prepare your pricing.
Selling in Mystic Gardens is different. Your buyer asks the condo fee and what it covers, the lease and pet rules, any tenant and lease in place, the master insurance and wind deductible, the reserves, the roof and plumbing history, and whether a lender will finance the project. We gather the estoppel figure, the budget, the insurance declarations, the rules and the lease before the unit goes live.
What Is Your Mystic Gardens Home Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds. Start your free Fort Myers home valuation or use our Southwest Florida home valuation form.
(239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome. Want the complete seller’s guide? Read our Sell Your Home in Fort Myers page for pricing strategy, marketing and the full McGreevy and Comisar listing process, and our selling overview. For the wider picture, see our Fort Myers real estate market report.
Mystic Gardens condos have sold slowly since 2024: Lee County recorded 6 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 31, 2026 and 16 in 24 months, out of 240 units, and a listing service reported 178 days to sell over the past year. A listing competes with the complex’s other listings and with nearby condos; we read days on market for your plan from the MLS.
A Mystic Gardens buyer will ask the condo fee for your unit size and what it covers, any special assessment, the roof and plumbing history, the reserves, the master insurance deductible, the pet and lease rules, any tenant in place, the parking and laundry, and above all whether a lender will finance the unit. We gather those answers before listing.
Sometimes. Mystic Gardens two-bedrooms recorded $80,000 to $155,000 over 36 months, and condition explains most of that spread. Targeted work, such as paint, flooring, lighting or failing air conditioning, can pay off; a full remodel has to beat the top of the recorded range for your plan. We compare the cost with recent sales before recommending any of it.
It depends on the buyer you want. A unit sold with a tenant in place sells to buyers who want the lease, priced on the rent, while a vacant unit can also sell to a buyer who plans to live there. Read your lease’s end date and terms first; we price both paths and time the listing to the lease.
A Mystic Gardens seller typically pays the brokerage commission agreed in the listing agreement, Florida documentary stamp tax on the deed under section 201.02, the owner’s title insurance policy by Lee County custom, prorated taxes and condo fees, and the estoppel fee. Our Fort Myers seller guide has a full net sheet.
McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, are the local real estate experts for Mystic Gardens and Fort Myers: Jesse McGreevy leads listing and seller strategy, Marc Comisar leads buyer representation and negotiation, and as the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate across Southwest Florida.
Jesse McGreevy is a top-reviewed Mystic Gardens realtor, and the reviews below are quoted exactly as clients wrote them on our Google Business Profile. We do not edit, combine or summarize client words.
★★★★★ “Their recommendation on pricing my unit was sound and proved prescient. I never questioned their integrity and found it easy to rely on their recommendations. I would work with them again in a heartbeat.” Verified Google review
★★★★★ “Not living in the area, Jesse made life easy for me when we decided to sell our condo. His attention to detail, patience, understanding, and tenacity in dealing with all the moving parts was truly impressive.” Verified Google review
★★★★★ “Marc knows the market, works for his buyer and is attentive to his goals.” Verified Google review
Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC). Florida license numbers: Jesse McGreevy SL3101296, Marc Comisar BK3060671.
Meet Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, read more about McGreevy and Comisar, see our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers, or contact us.
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com, and see our team’s Fort Myers community pages.
Mystic Gardens suits a buyer who wants an affordable one-level condo flat in a gated complex with a pool and clubhouse, inside the City of Fort Myers and a short drive from the hospitals and downtown. The trade-offs are 1985 buildings, City millage, few owner-occupied units on the tax roll, a likely lender question and rules that listings report inconsistently.
Mystic Gardens listings show about $492 to $498 a month for a two-bedroom unit in 2025 and 2026, and a 2023 listing showed $1,483 a quarter. Listings say the fee covers master insurance, the roof, structure, grounds, pool, recreation, security and trash. One-bedroom fees are not published; confirm the current budget with the association.
Lee County recorded 21 qualified Mystic Gardens sales in the 36 months to October 31, 2026, from $80,000 to $155,000, at a $124,000 median, and 6 in the last 12 months from $98,800 to $150,000 at a $107,500 median. Two-bedroom units recorded a $133,300 median over 36 months; 810 square foot units $119,500.
Mystic Gardens has 240 condominium units in 15 two-story buildings of 16 units each, according to both the 2026 Lee County roll and the State condominium file. There are 136 two-bedroom, two-bath units of 1,018 square feet, 72 one-bedroom units of 810 square feet and 32 one-bedroom units of 577 square feet.
Mystic Gardens was built in 1985, according to the 2026 Lee County roll, which dates all 15 buildings and the clubhouse to that year and gives every unit a 2006 effective year. The condominium was declared in 2006: the State records project PR72756 as recorded on January 27, 2006, and first condominium sales followed that year.
No public source we read shows an age restriction at Mystic Gardens, and the State condominium file does not list it as housing for older persons. The declaration and the association’s rules would state any such rule. Confirm in writing with the association before you buy, as you would any rule that matters to your plans.
Mystic Gardens pet rules are unclear in public sources: one sale listing says an owner may keep one pet of up to 40 pounds, while several rental listings say no dogs or cats per the association. Treat pets as restricted until you have the association’s current written rules, and ask how the rules differ for owners and tenants.
Yes, leasing is common: only 19 of 240 Mystic Gardens units carry a homestead exemption. One sale listing reports up to three rentals a year with a 30-day minimum, and a rental listing cites a 7-day association approval. November 2026 rental listings showed two-bedrooms at $1,200 to $1,300 a month. Confirm the leasing rules in the declaration.
Listing data panels that read FEMA’s map place Mystic Gardens units in Zone X or Zone X500, outside the high-risk flood area, at a ground elevation of about 10 feet. The site is in the City of Fort Myers flood map community on panel 12071C0409G, effective November 17, 2022. Confirm each building on FEMA’s Map Service Center.
Lee County’s evacuation layer places Mystic Gardens in Evacuation Zone B, storm surge zone 2, checked on November 21, 2026. The county describes Zone B as vulnerable to potentially fatal storm surge and among the first areas ordered to evacuate. Plan where you would go before hurricane season, and keep your insurance contacts handy.
We found no news report naming Mystic Gardens in Hurricane Ian, Helene or Milton. The 2025 and 2026 county rolls show no disaster value adjustment on any unit, and 2023 sales held a $148,000 median, so the county record shows no sign of major storm distress. Ask the association about claims, repairs and any assessment.
All Mystic Gardens units are in Lee County taxing district 090, City of Fort Myers, at 16.9702 mills adopted for 2026. The median 2026 taxable value of $88,279 means about $1,498 a year. A new buyer of a two-bedroom without a homestead exemption would pay about $1,765, plus City fire, stormwater and solid-waste charges.
Yes. All 240 Mystic Gardens units sit inside the City of Fort Myers: the 2026 county roll codes them with zoning area CFM, the City of Fort Myers fire district and taxing district 090. The City handles zoning and permits, and the tax bill carries the City’s 6.9000 mill levy and its parks debt levy.
No. Mystic Greens is a group of condominiums at Lely Resort in Naples, and Mystic Ridge is a 46-unit condominium at 25100 Goldcrest Drive in Bonita Springs. Both are separate condominiums in the State registry. Mystic Gardens is the 240-unit condominium at 5301 to 5331 Summerlin Road in the City of Fort Myers.
Ask a lender before you write an offer. Fannie Mae treats a project of 21 or more units as ineligible when one entity owns more than 20 percent of units, and one ownership group appears to hold about 32 percent of Mystic Gardens’ units on the 2026 roll. Many buyers may need cash, a portfolio loan or a non-warrantable loan.
Florida’s milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study laws apply to condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories. Mystic Gardens’ 15 buildings are two stories on the county roll, so on that basis they appear to fall outside both. Confirm with the association, and still ask for its reserve schedule and reserve balance.
The State condominium file lists the managing entity as Mystic Gardens Condominium Association, Inc., at a business address in Naples, and directory pages name a management firm without a date. Ask the association who manages the property today, how to reach them and who issues the estoppel certificate, before you write an offer.
Yes. Rental sites and sale listings describe a gated entry at Mystic Gardens, and a 2023 listing mentions a security fence. Entry is from Summerlin Road. Ask the association how the gate works for guests, deliveries and emergency vehicles, and walk the grounds at night before you buy.
Mystic Gardens has a community pool and a clubhouse of 2,258 heated square feet on the county roll, and listings and rental sites name a fitness room, a tennis court, basketball, pickleball, a dog park, picnic and grill areas and common laundry. There is no golf course and no club membership. Confirm what is open and maintained.
Listings and rental sites describe common laundry facilities at Mystic Gardens rather than a washer and dryer in each unit. Whether an owner may add in-unit laundry is an association question about plumbing, electrical and the rules. Ask before you count on it, and check what the listing for your unit says.
The School District of Lee County assigns schools by address. Tanglewood Elementary on Manchester Boulevard is about 0.27 mile from Mystic Gardens in a straight line, and listings name Cypress Lake Middle, Lexington Middle, Cypress Lake High and Fort Myers High for the area. Confirm the assigned schools for the exact address with the district.
The Mystic Gardens buildings were built in 1985 according to the 2026 county roll, about 41 years ago, and carry a 2006 effective year from the condominium conversion. A 2023 listing reports all roofs replaced in 2019. Ask the association and the seller for replacement dates of the roofs, plumbing, electrical and air conditioning.
We found no community development district (CDD) for Mystic Gardens, and a listing data panel reports none on record. The county taxing layer at the site lists City of Fort Myers fire, stormwater and solid-waste charges instead. Confirm on the latest tax bill for the exact unit, which lists every non-ad valorem charge.
McGreevy and Comisar, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, price a Mystic Gardens condo from the Lee County recorded sales of its plan in this complex, not a citywide average, and prepare the fee, lease, insurance and financing answers a buyer asks for before the unit goes live. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
A Mystic Gardens condo is worth what recent recorded sales of its plan and condition support: over 36 months, two-bedrooms recorded a $133,300 median, 810 square foot units $119,500 and 577 square foot units $104,500. In the last 12 months the six sales ran $98,800 to $150,000. Request a free valuation and we will read yours against them.
Mystic Gardens two-bedroom units of 1,018 square feet recorded three sales in the 12 months to October 31, 2026, at $110,000, $110,000 and $150,000, and ten in 36 months from $80,000 to $155,000 at a $133,300 median. Condition and a tenant in place move a unit within that range; current asks run $119,000 to $166,000.
Mystic Gardens’ 810 square foot one-bedrooms recorded seven sales in 36 months from $98,800 to $127,000 at a $119,500 median, the newest $98,800 in August 2026. The 577 square foot units recorded four sales from $94,000 to $135,900 at a $104,500 median, the two newest at $105,000 and $104,000.
Mystic Gardens prices have eased from a $148,000 median in 2023 to $111,500 in 2025 and $107,000 in 2026 to date, and sales have slowed, so timing matters less than pricing. A well-priced unit in good condition still sold for $150,000 in September 2026. We read the current listings and recent sales for your plan before advising.
Lee County recorded 10 qualified Mystic Gardens sales in 2025 and 4 in 2026 through October 31, against 38 in 2021, 20 in 2022 and 15 in 2023. Bulk deeds between investors are not counted. Out of 240 units, that is a thin market, so every comparable sale matters to your price.
Mystic Gardens’ first condominium sales in 2006 ran $99,900 to $199,900 at a $159,900 median, on 73 recorded sales, after the 2006 declaration. If you bought then, today’s recorded prices sit below that; if you bought from 2010 to 2020, when medians ran $37,000 to $66,000, today’s prices sit well above it.
Mystic Gardens’ median fell from $148,000 in 2023 to $133,300 in 2024, $111,500 in 2025 and $107,000 in 2026 to date. The county record does not give a reason; the timing matches a regional condo price decline FGCU’s Regional Economic Research Institute reported, higher insurance costs and the financing limits that concentrated ownership can bring.
Usually only targeted work. Mystic Gardens two-bedrooms recorded $80,000 to $155,000 over 36 months, and a full remodel has to clear the top of that range to pay off. Paint, flooring, lighting and a working air conditioner often return more than they cost. We compare each item with recent sales before recommending it.
Possibly. Many Florida condominium declarations require association approval of a sale or lease, and a Mystic Gardens rental listing cites a 7-day approval period for tenants. Read your declaration and ask the association what a buyer must submit, so the approval does not delay closing.
A Mystic Gardens seller must deliver the condominium documents and financial information under section 718.503 of the Florida Statutes, disclose known defects that materially affect value, and give the flood disclosure section 689.302 requires. Disclose any special assessment, insurance claim or water intrusion you know of; the estoppel certificate shows amounts owed.
No. You do not need flood insurance to sell, but Florida’s flood disclosure law requires a seller to tell the buyer about known flood damage, flood insurance claims and federal flood assistance. Listing data place Mystic Gardens units in Zone X or X500; your buyer’s lender decides whether flood insurance is required.
Yes. Many Mystic Gardens units are held by companies, and cash buyers who want leased units are a natural market here, priced on the rent and the lease in place. We market to investor buyers and to buyers who plan to live in the unit, and we price both paths before listing.
A cash Mystic Gardens sale can close in about 30 days once association approval, the estoppel certificate and title are in hand; a financed sale takes longer, and only if the lender will finance the project. Order the estoppel early and ask the association its approval timeline.
Sometimes. A furnished unit with a lease in place can appeal to buyers who want an income unit from day one, while an owner who plans to live there often prefers to choose furniture. List the furniture in the contract either way. We look at the comparable listings for your plan before advising.
It helps. A buyer’s insurer often asks for a wind mitigation or four-point report on a 1985 building, and the roof items belong to the building, so ask the association for its roof records from the 2019 replacement reported in a 2023 listing. Having them ready speeds the buyer’s insurance quote.
A Mystic Gardens unit at the low end, like the two-bedroom that recorded $80,000 in September 2025, usually needs work or carries unusual terms. Price it on the recorded sales of units in similar condition, disclose what needs repair, and consider targeted updates. We show you both the as-is and the updated price.
Your Mystic Gardens unit size is on the Lee County Property Appraiser’s parcel page for your unit: 1,018 square feet for the two-bedroom plan and 810 or 577 square feet for the one-bedroom plans, by heated area. Your unit number also tells the building: unit 708 is in 5307, unit 3107 in 5331.
Usually not. Listings show about $492 to $498 a month for a Mystic Gardens two-bedroom, and buyers compare the fee with what it covers: master insurance, the roof, grounds, the pool and trash, according to listings. Have the current budget and the fee schedule by unit size ready to show.
A Mystic Gardens buyer pays 16.9702 mills on the unit’s value, so a two-bedroom at its 2026 county value carries about $1,765 a year without a homestead exemption, or about $1,048 with one. If you have a homestead, your buyer’s bill will be higher than yours; we show buyers the estimate.
It depends on your purchase price, improvements and whether the unit was your home. IRS Publication 523 explains the home-sale exclusion for a main home; a leased unit is taxed differently and may include depreciation recapture. Ask your tax adviser before listing; we give you the expected sale price to plan with.
Yes. Many Mystic Gardens units are held by companies or trusts, and they sell like any other unit once the person signing has authority. The title company will ask for the trust certificate or the company’s authorizing documents. Gather them early so closing is not delayed.
We market a Mystic Gardens condo with professional photography, drone video of the gated grounds and the Summerlin Road location, the recorded sales for its plan, the fee and lease facts up front, and outreach to both investor and owner buyers in our database. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 to start.
Yes. A Mystic Gardens buyer and the buyer’s lender look at any special assessment, paid or pending, and the estoppel certificate must show amounts owed. We found no public report of an assessment; gather the association’s answer and the minutes before listing so the question is settled before a buyer asks.
You can. Florida allows an owner to sell without an agent, but you still need the condominium documents, the estoppel certificate, association approval if required and a title company. Most of a Mystic Gardens sale’s work is pricing against the recorded sales and handling the buyer’s financing question; we do that for our sellers.
Yes. Over 36 months Lee County recorded a $124,000 median at Mystic Gardens and a $150,000 median at Summerlin Woods, whose units are smaller at the median and which pays lower unincorporated millage. Buyers notice the gap, so we show your buyer how much more space the price buys at Mystic Gardens.
Possibly. Lee County’s transportation department lists a project to widen Summerlin Road to six lanes from Boy Scout Drive to Cypress Lake Drive. Check its current schedule; buyers ask about road work and noise on Summerlin Road, and a clear answer helps your sale.
After the 2006 to 2010 fall from a $159,900 median to $37,000, Mystic Gardens medians stayed below $70,000 until 2021, then reached $148,000 in 2023. That history shows long, uneven cycles. We do not predict the next one; we price your unit on today’s recorded sales.
Yes. Seller financing is legal in Florida, and at Mystic Gardens, where some buyers may not find a conventional loan, it can widen your buyer pool. It carries credit risk and legal requirements; use a real estate attorney to draft the note and mortgage, and price the terms with us before you list.
Yes. Because one ownership group appears to hold about 32 percent of the units on the 2026 roll, many buyers’ lenders may decline the project, which narrows the market to cash and portfolio buyers. We plan for that from day one: we qualify buyers early and price for the buyers who can close.
Request a free home valuation online or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. We read your unit against the recorded Mystic Gardens sales of its plan, its condition and any lease, then give you a price range and the plan to reach it. Confidential conversations are welcome.
The sources below are the primary records behind every Mystic Gardens figure on this page: the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, tax rolls, millage books and recorded sales (roll exported November 1, 2026, sales index built November 18, 2026), the Florida DBPR condominium file, Lee County GIS, FEMA, the School District of Lee County, Fannie Mae, the Florida Statutes and the Florida Senate. This edition prints no MLS statistics; listing-reported details are labeled.
Source | Publisher | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
Lee County Property Appraiser | 2025 and 2026 tax rolls, values | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | Online parcel inquiry | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | 240 units, sizes, year built, district 090 | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | Recorded qualified sales | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | 2026 recorded sales | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | 12.05 acres, clubhouse, association owner | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | September 2026 sale | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | May 2024 sale | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | 2022 and 2025 sales | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | August 2026 sale | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | Taxing authorities | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | District 090, 16.9702 mills adopted; district 068, 13.3623 | |
Lee County GIS | Parcel outline on the aerial | |
Lee County GIS | District 090, fire, stormwater and solid-waste districts | |
Florida Department of Revenue | Tax roll and sales files | |
Florida Department of Revenue | Homestead exemption | |
Lee County Clerk of Court | Declaration, Instrument 2006-41352 | |
Lee County Tax Collector | Tax bill, non-ad valorem section | |
Florida Department of State | Association filings | |
U.S. Census Bureau | Census geography at the address | |
Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums | Project PR72756, 240 units, recorded January 27, 2006 | |
Florida DBPR | Managing entity | |
Florida DBPR | Association filings |
Source | Publisher | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
Fannie Mae | 20 percent single-entity limit, waiver | |
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development | FHA approval by condominium | |
FGCU Regional Economic Research Institute | Regional condo prices | |
WGCU | Lee County and City values | |
Horvath and Tremblay | 48-unit sale, $5,658,059 | |
Wikipedia | County Road 869, Boy Scout Drive | |
Lee County Department of Transportation | Summerlin Road six-laning | |
Transit | Edison Mall to Beach Park and Ride | |
Lee County Transit | Current routes and stops | |
Lee County Port Authority | Airports | |
Lee Health | Lee Memorial Hospital, Gulf Coast Medical Center | |
City of Fort Myers | City services, permits | |
City of Fort Myers | Floodplain program | |
City of Fort Myers | Flood zone lookup by address |
Source | Publisher | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
FEMA | Address flood map lookup | |
FEMA | Flood zone data | |
Lee County GIS | City of Fort Myers community, nearby AE zones | |
Lee County GIS | Panel 12071C0409G | |
Lee County GIS | Zone B | |
Lee County GIS | Zone B, surge zone 2 | |
Lee County Emergency Management | Zone B guidance | |
FEMA | How flood premiums are set | |
National Flood Insurance Program | Flood insurance basics | |
FEMA | Flood zone definitions | |
State of Florida | Evacuation planning | |
National Weather Service Tampa Bay | Helene in Lee County | |
National Weather Service Tampa Bay | Milton in Lee County | |
National Hurricane Center | Ian, September 2022 | |
Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums | Three-story threshold, online account | |
Florida Realtors | Seller disclosure form | |
USDA NAIP via USGS | Hero aerial |
Source | Publisher | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
School District of Lee County | Enrollment rules | |
School District of Lee County | Zone assignment | |
School District of Lee County | Address lookup | |
School District of Lee County | High school zones | |
School District of Lee County | Enrollment and choice | |
Lee County GIS | Zone layer |
Source | Publisher | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
The Florida Senate | Condominium Act | |
The Florida Senate | Leasing amendments | |
The Florida Senate | Official records, insurance | |
The Florida Senate | Budgets and reserves | |
The Florida Senate | Estoppel certificate | |
The Florida Senate | Resale documents | |
The Florida Senate | Three-story threshold | |
The Florida Senate | 2025 condominium law | |
Florida Department of State | HB 913 as enacted | |
The Florida Senate | Seller flood disclosure | |
The Florida Senate | Deed stamp tax | |
The Florida Senate | Homestead exemption | |
The Florida Senate | Assessment reset after sale | |
The Florida Senate | Mitigation credits | |
Internal Revenue Service | Home-sale exclusion |
Mystic Gardens’ downloadable documents are public records a buyer or seller uses in a Mystic Gardens transaction, each linked to the publisher’s own copy: the Lee County millage book, the 2026 TRIM notice for a Mystic Gardens unit, Lee County’s Zone B evacuation sheet, the Fannie Mae project rule, the Florida Senate summary of the 2025 condominium law, the DBPR milestone and SIRS guidance, the Florida Realtors disclosure form, the National Weather Service storm reports and the IRS home-sale guide.
Document | Publisher | Date | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
2026 Taxing District Millage Book (PDF) | Lee County Property Appraiser | 2026 | |
2026 TRIM notice, 5307 Summerlin Rd unit 708 | Lee County Property Appraiser | 2026 | |
Evacuation Zone B (PDF) | Lee County Emergency Management | current | |
Selling Guide B4-2.1-03, Ineligible Projects | Fannie Mae | 2026 | |
CS/CS/HB 913 bill summary | The Florida Senate | 2025 | |
Milestone inspections and SIRS guidance | Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums | current | |
Milestone Inspection and SIRS Disclosure, MISIRS-1 (PDF) | Florida Realtors | 2025 | |
Hurricane Milton impact narratives (PDF) | National Weather Service Tampa Bay | storm of October 2024 | |
Hurricane Helene impact narratives (PDF) | National Weather Service Tampa Bay | storm of September 2024 | |
Publication 523, Selling Your Home | Internal Revenue Service | current edition |
Market data from the Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 parcel roll exported November 1, 2026, the 2025 and 2026 tax rolls, the 2025 and 2026 millage books, and the Lee County sale data files indexed November 18, 2026; newest recorded Mystic Gardens sale September 2, 2026. Data updated: November 2026. Southwest Florida MLS statistics were not pulled for this edition. Mystic Gardens is recorded as a condominium under Instrument 2006-41352; its unit counts on this page are the Lee County roll’s. Listing-reported fees, rules and features are labeled as such. Straight-line distances are measured on Lee County roll coordinates, not road miles. This guide is general information about Mystic Gardens, not an appraisal and not legal, tax, lending or insurance advice. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.
McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Mystic Gardens. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.
Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.