Governors Island Fort Myers

Governors Island Fort Myers

Governors Island is a gated condominium of 115 one-story garage villas built 1985 to 1987 behind the Bell Tower Shops in Fort Myers. Lee County recorded 9 sales at a $210,000 median in the 12 months to October 2026. Call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072.

Search Homes

Updated November 2026 · Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.

McGreevy and Comisar are the team Governors Island owners in Fort Myers call first when they decide to sell, and the team buyers call when they want every recorded Governors Island sale, the condo fee, the flood zone, the storm questions and Florida’s condominium laws explained before they write an offer. Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with over $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc, we wrote this guide sellers first: what a Governors Island villa is worth today, which recorded sales set that price, and what a buyer will ask about the fee, flood insurance, the evacuation zone and the association before signing.

Governors Island is a gated condominium of 115 one-story villas in south Fort Myers, Florida, ZIP 33907, in unincorporated Lee County. It sits off Big Pine Way inside the older Pinebrook Lakes tract, directly behind the Bell Tower Shops on the north side of Daniels Parkway, just east of US 41. Built from 1985 to 1987 on Governors Drive, Concord Way, Ashton Circle and Council Lane, every unit has two baths and a garage. Lee County recorded 9 qualified Governors Island sales in the 12 months to October 31, 2026, from $165,000 to $240,000, at a $210,000 median, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser.

This page is about Governors Island in Fort Myers, Florida, the condominium recorded at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647. It is not Governors Island in New York Harbor, and it is not the neighboring Pinebrook Lakes Condo, which shares the Big Pine Way entrance but has its own declaration and its own association.

If you are choosing who should represent you, our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers sets out the criteria we think every Fort Myers seller and buyer should use. Owners can read our Fort Myers seller guide or request a free Fort Myers home valuation; buyers can read how to buy a home in Fort Myers. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.

Why McGreevy and Comisar Are the Best Realtor for Governors Island in Fort Myers

McGreevy and Comisar are the best realtor for Governors Island because we price a Governors Island villa from Lee County’s recorded sales of its own plan, from the 1,080 square foot two-bedroom villa to the 1,361 square foot three-bedroom villa, lake front or interior, not from a Fort Myers condo average, and we answer the fee, flood, insurance and association questions before a buyer asks.

If you’re searching for the best realtor for Governors Island in Fort Myers, whether you’re ready to sell your Governors Island villa or buy your next one, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. We are also ranked the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026).

Recent Governors Island market record (36 months): From November 2023 to October 2026 we tracked 20 qualified Governors Island sales recorded by Lee County · a range of $165,000 to $345,000 · a median of $239,250 · newest recorded sale $165,000 for 5478 Governors Drive on October 5, 2026 · no builder-direct sales in the window. In the 12 months to October 31, 2026 the county recorded 9 of those sales at a $210,000 median. Days on market and sale-to-list ratio are MLS measures; the county record carries recorded prices and dates, so we read those two figures for your exact unit when we prepare your pricing.

For Governors Island sellers: professional photography, drone video that shows the lakes, the gated entry, the pool and the walk to Bell Tower, sale-by-sale pricing from the county record for your plan and your lake or interior setting, and a qualified-buyer database built over our years leading Domain Realty Group.

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Selling your Governors Island villa? Get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 (confidential conversations welcome).

Buying a villa in Governors Island? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 for a personalized buyer consultation, and see how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida.

Key Takeaways: What Should You Know About Governors Island in Fort Myers?

Governors Island’s key takeaways are its one-story garage villas under one condominium, its gate and walkable location behind Bell Tower, its moderate flood position, its bundled monthly fee and its 2026 prices: 115 units in unincorporated Lee County, built 1985 to 1987, in FEMA Zone X (shaded) and Evacuation Zone B, with 2026 prices below 2023.

  • One condominium, one association. Governors Island is a single condominium, declared at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647, with one association. The roll groups its 115 units into four phases plus 18 units recorded without a phase number. It is one of four neighborhoods off Big Pine Way inside the Pinebrook Lakes tract, but it is not part of Pinebrook Lakes Condo.
  • Every unit one story, every unit with a garage. The 2026 Lee County roll records all 115 units as one story with two baths and a garage. There are 64 two-bedroom units of 1,080 to 1,286 square feet and 51 three-bedroom units of 1,305 or 1,361 square feet. 38 units are coded lake front.
  • Recorded prices. Lee County recorded 9 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 31, 2026, from $165,000 to $240,000, median $210,000, a median $169 per heated square foot. Over 36 months, 20 sales at a $239,250 median. The 2026 median to October is $195,000, against $285,000 in 2023.
  • Zone X (shaded), Evacuation Zone B. Lee County’s copy of the effective FEMA map places every Governors Island parcel point in Zone X (shaded), a 0.2 percent annual chance area outside the special flood hazard area, on panel 12071C0436H, effective November 17, 2022. The community is in Lee County Evacuation Zone B.
  • Outside the condo safety law threshold. Florida’s milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study (SIRS) rules apply to condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories. Every Governors Island building is one story on the roll, so neither applies.
  • A bundled fee: confirm the current budget. Listings printed a monthly condo fee of $528 in 2023 and $555 to $589 in 2025 and 2026, covering items such as water, sewer, trash, cable, internet, lawn care and the building insurance. The association’s budget and the estoppel certificate give the binding figure.
  • Unincorporated Lee taxes. Taxing district 047, South Trail Fire, at 13.3623 mills adopted for 2026. We estimate about $2,442 a year at the median non-homestead value, no City of Fort Myers millage and no CDD.
  • Pool and lakes, no golf. A community pool, a gated entry, private lanes and small lakes; no golf, tennis or clubhouse program and no club membership.

Table of Contents

This guide answers the questions Governors Island sellers and buyers in Fort Myers ask us most, in the order below.

What Is Governors Island in Fort Myers?

Governors Island is a gated residential condominium of 115 one-story villas in south Fort Myers, Florida, ZIP 33907, built from 1985 to 1987 behind the Bell Tower Shops off Daniels Parkway. It has its own declaration and association, sits inside the older Pinebrook Lakes tract reached by Big Pine Way, and is in unincorporated Lee County.

The names buyers search are Governors Island, Governors Island Condo and Governors Island at Pinebrook Lakes. On the State’s condominium register the project is Governors Island Condo, project number PR1P014887, recorded August 22, 1984. On the Lee County roll every unit’s legal description begins Governors Island and cites the declaration at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647. Listings call the homes villas, attached villas, zero lot line homes or carriage homes; the county records them as residential condominium units.

Is this the Governors Island in New York?

No. Governors Island in New York Harbor is a public island park and has nothing to do with this community. Governors Island in Fort Myers is a 1980s villa condominium in Lee County, Florida, ZIP 33907, and every reference on this page means the Fort Myers condominium recorded at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647.

Is Governors Island part of Pinebrook Lakes?

Governors Island sits inside the Pinebrook Lakes tract but is not part of Pinebrook Lakes Condo. The county roll shows one older unrecorded tract, “Pinebrook Lakes Unrec,” holding four separate neighborhoods off Big Pine Way: Pinebrook Lakes Condo, Governors Island, Pinebrook Woods and Harbour Castle. Each has its own recorded documents.

Pinebrook Lakes Condo is the original condominium of the tract, registered with the State on January 20, 1981, with 56 units, its own declaration at Official Records Book 1523, Page 1641 and its own association. Governors Island is a separate condominium with a separate declaration. Pinebrook Woods is about 100 fee-simple villa lots on Tall Pine Circle, built 1984 to 1986. Harbour Castle is 73 homes on Harbour Castle Drive on the 2026 roll. Lee County’s subdivision layer draws one gated polygon over the area that counts 171 condominium units, exactly Pinebrook Lakes’ 56 plus Governors Island’s 115. So “Governors Island at Pinebrook Lakes” means Governors Island inside the Pinebrook Lakes tract.

Is Governors Island inside the City of Fort Myers?

No. Governors Island has Fort Myers mailing addresses, ZIP 33907, but all 116 of its parcels sit in unincorporated Lee County on the 2026 roll, zoning area ULC, zoning RM-2, taxing district 047 with the South Trail Fire District. Lee County, not the City of Fort Myers, issues its permits, and its tax bill carries no city millage.

The Census Bureau places the parcels in block group 120710016014, tract 16.01, which data portals file under the Villas census-designated place. The Bell Tower Shops parcel next door is also in unincorporated Lee County.

Is Governors Island a condominium or a homeowners association?

Governors Island is a condominium. Owners hold a unit plus a share of the common elements under the declaration recorded at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647, and the association runs under Florida’s Condominium Act, Chapter 718. That matters for buyers: condominium rules on budgets, reserves, records, insurance and resale disclosures apply, not the homeowners association statute.

How do we know which units are Governors Island?

We matched the Lee County Property Appraiser roll exported November 1, 2026 on every legal description beginning “Governors Island”: 116 parcels, 115 residential condominium units and 1 common-element parcel of about 17.87 acres on the county’s measure. Every strap begins with the same subdivision code, and no other roll row names Governors Island.

The unit legal descriptions read “Governors Island Condo PH-I” (50 units), “PH-II” (12), “PH-III” (22), “PH-IV” (13) and 18 units described as “Governors Island OR 1751 PG 2647 Unit 98” through “Unit 115” with no phase. A few legals carry typing errors on the roll, such as “PG 2547” for page 2647; they are the same condominium.

Where Exactly Is Governors Island in Fort Myers?

Governors Island sits on the north side of Daniels Parkway just east of US 41 (South Cleveland Avenue) in south Fort Myers, directly behind the Bell Tower Shops. It is reached from Daniels Parkway by Big Pine Way, a private road shared with Pinebrook Lakes, Pinebrook Woods and Harbour Castle, about 0.3 miles from Bell Tower in a straight line.

The community wraps around small lakes, and our aerial shows water along its west and south sides with the Bell Tower Shops beyond. The community sits at the west end of the Daniels corridor, which runs from Bell Tower at US 41 east past Interstate 75.

How do you get to Governors Island?

From Daniels Parkway, turn north onto Big Pine Way. Listing directions say to take the first intersection on the left and then the next left. Big Pine Way is a private road whose right of way, buffer and lake belong to the Big Pine Way Maintenance Organization, and listings for Harbour Castle describe a gate on Big Pine Way north of Daniels.

What is next to Governors Island?

The Bell Tower Shops lie about 0.3 miles away in a straight line, with a Regal cinema, The Fresh Market, Dave and Buster’s and restaurants. Market Square at Daniels Parkway and US 41 is also about 0.3 miles away, and Cypress Trace shopping center on South Cleveland Avenue about 0.6 miles. Listings describe Bell Tower as walking distance.

Gulf Coast Medical Center is about 0.9 miles away in a straight line. Inside the tract, Harbour Castle is about 0.1 miles away and Pinebrook Lakes and Pinebrook Woods about 0.3 miles north.

How is the land at Governors Island laid out?

Governors Island is one condominium of 115 units on four private streets: Governors Drive with 43 units, Concord Way with 35, Ashton Circle with 31 and Council Lane with 6. The common-element parcel, about 17.87 acres on the county’s measure, holds the lanes, the lawns, the pool and the lakes around the buildings.

The roll codes 38 units as lake front and 77 as interior: 13 lake front units on Ashton Circle, 13 on Concord Way and 12 on Governors Drive, and none on Council Lane. Listings use “attached villa,” “villa detached,” “zero lot line” and “carriage” for the same one-story product; a 2023 listing for 5322 Concord Way describes two units in the building.

What Is It Like Living in Governors Island as a Condo Owner?

Living in Governors Island means a one-story villa with a garage on a quiet gated lane, a shared pool and lakes, and shops, a cinema and a hospital within about a mile. The condominium fee covers exterior insurance, water, cable and grounds, so owners mainly maintain their interiors and follow the association’s rules.

Daily life here is short trips. Groceries at The Fresh Market in Bell Tower, a film at the Regal, a pharmacy run on US 41, a medical appointment at Gulf Coast Medical Center: listings describe Bell Tower as walking distance, and the hospital is under a mile in a straight line. The lanes are private and loop around the lakes, and the gate on Big Pine Way keeps through traffic off them.

What does the tax roll show about ownership in Governors Island?

The 2026 roll shows 83 of the 115 units, 72 percent, carrying a Florida homestead exemption, which means the owner declares the unit as a permanent residence. 91 owners use a Florida mailing address, and 89 receive their tax mail at the unit itself. Those are ownership facts from the roll, not a description of residents.

Is Governors Island gated?

Yes. Listings describe Governors Island as gated with private roads, and Lee County’s subdivision layer marks the Pinebrook Lakes tract as gated. Listings for neighboring Harbour Castle describe the gate on Big Pine Way north of Daniels Parkway. Ask the association how the gate works for residents, guests and deliveries.

Where do Governors Island owners park?

Every Governors Island unit has a garage on the 2026 roll, and none is recorded with a carport. Listings describe a one-car garage. Guest parking, boat and recreational vehicle rules and commercial vehicle rules sit in the declaration and the association’s rules, so read them before you buy.

Is every Governors Island unit on one level?

Yes. The county roll records every one of the 115 units as one story. Buyers who want no stairs get a single level, and the buildings fall far below the three-story threshold of Florida’s milestone inspection and SIRS laws.

Does every Governors Island unit have a private pool?

No. The county roll sets a pool flag on all 115 units, but that reflects the shared community pool on the common grounds, not private pools. Listings describe a community pool with a pool area and picnic space. Ask the association about pool hours and guest rules.

Ready to sell or buy in Governors Island?

Governors Island owners can get a free home valuation built on Governors Island sales of the same plan, lake front or interior, or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. With 9 recorded sales in the 12 months to October 2026, each one matters to your price. Buyers comparing plans, the fee and the flood details can call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers.

What Is the Governors Island Condo Market Doing Right Now?

The Governors Island market is quieter and lower priced in 2026 than in 2023. Lee County recorded 9 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 31, 2026 at a $210,000 median, against 4 sales at a $305,000 median in the 12 months before, and the 2026 median to October is $195,000, against $285,000 in 2023.

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County recorded qualified sales.

Window (county record)

Qualified sales

Median price

Range

Median per heated sq ft

12 months, Nov 2025 to Oct 2026

9

$210,000

$165,000 to $240,000

$169

Prior 12 months, Nov 2024 to Oct 2025

4

$305,000

$190,000 to $345,000

$229

24 months, Nov 2024 to Oct 2026

13

$210,000

$165,000 to $345,000

$176

36 months, Nov 2023 to Oct 2026

20

$239,250

$165,000 to $345,000

$205

60 months, Nov 2021 to Oct 2026

34

$273,450

$100,000 to $367,900

$227

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County Property Appraiser roll exported November 1, 2026 and sale data files indexed November 18, 2026; qualified sales only. The 36-month median is the mean of the two middle sales, $238,500 and $240,000.

Why are 2026 Governors Island prices below 2023?

Governors Island prices peaked in 2022 and 2023 and have fallen since. The calendar 2026 median to October, $195,000, is 31.6 percent below 2023’s $285,000. The regional market moved the same way: Southwest Florida condo prices fell 8 percent year over year in the second quarter of 2026 while condo sales rose 17 percent, according to Florida Gulf Coast University’s regional economic research institute.

The decline is real but the sample is small: 7 sales in 2026 and 5 in 2025. A few sales of smaller interior units can move the median a long way.

What is the newest Governors Island sale?

The newest qualified Governors Island sale on the county record is 5478 Governors Drive, a 1,080 square foot two-bedroom lake front villa, at $165,000 on October 5, 2026, about $153 per heated square foot. It is the lowest recorded price in the 12-month window.

What does the county record not show?

The county record shows recorded price, date and the roll’s description of each unit. It does not show days on market, the original list price, seller concessions, condition, renovations or whether a sale was furnished. We read those from the Southwest Florida MLS for the exact units that matter to your price. Non-arm’s-length deeds, such as $100 transfers between family members or into trusts, are excluded: 30 such deeds since November 2023 are not in any median.

How many Governors Island units change hands each year?

Between 3 and 10 qualified sales a year since 2014: 3 in 2014, 9 in 2015, 5 in 2016, 7 in 2017, 6 in 2018, 9 in 2019, 6 in 2020, 5 in 2021, 7 in 2022, 10 in 2023, 5 in 2024, 5 in 2025 and 7 in 2026 to October. Nine sales in 12 months is 7.8 percent of the 115 units.

Was one Governors Island sale recorded twice?

Yes. The $345,000 sale of 5416 Ashton Circle shows on the county files twice, with instrument numbers two apart and dates of December 15, 2024 and March 20, 2025. We count it once, as a December 2024 sale; counting it twice would overstate both the number of sales and the 2025 median.

Which Governors Island Sales Set Today’s Prices?

Today’s Governors Island prices are set by the 9 qualified sales of the last 12 months, from $165,000 to $240,000, with two-bedroom villas at a $210,000 median and three-bedroom villas at $207,500. Lake front and interior units sold in the same band, and every sale in 2026 recorded at $220,000 or less.

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County recorded qualified sales.

Address

Bedrooms and heated sq ft

Setting

Recorded price

Date

5478 Governors Dr

2 / 1,080

lake front

$165,000

Oct 5, 2026

5284 Concord Way

3 / 1,305

lake front

$195,000

Jun 24, 2026

5316 Concord Way

2 / 1,080

interior

$210,000

Jun 1, 2026

5365 Governors Dr

2 / 1,080

interior

$210,000

May 8, 2026

5368 Council Ln

2 / 1,252

interior

$179,000

May 1, 2026

5282 Concord Way

3 / 1,305

interior

$188,000

Apr 29, 2026

5490 Governors Dr

3 / 1,305

lake front

$220,000

Mar 26, 2026

5323 Concord Way

2 / 1,080

interior

$238,500

Dec 29, 2025

5404 Ashton Cir

3 / 1,361

lake front

$240,000

Dec 15, 2025

5348 Governors Dr

3 / 1,305

interior

$280,000

Oct 3, 2025

5402 Ashton Cir

3 / 1,361

lake front

$330,000

Mar 27, 2025

5452 Governors Dr

2 / 1,080

interior

$190,000

Mar 7, 2025

5416 Ashton Cir

3 / 1,361

lake front

$345,000

Dec 15, 2024

5294 Concord Way

3 / 1,305

lake front

$280,000

Oct 7, 2024

5305 Concord Way

3 / 1,305

interior

$235,000

Jul 10, 2024

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County recorded qualified sales; lake front or interior is the roll’s land use code for each unit.

What is the highest recent Governors Island sale?

The highest Governors Island sale in the 12 months to October 2026 is 5404 Ashton Circle, a 1,361 square foot three-bedroom lake front villa, at $240,000 on December 15, 2025. A January 2025 listing had asked $299,000 for it. The highest over 36 months is 5416 Ashton Circle at $345,000 in December 2024, and the highest ever recorded is 5424 Ashton Circle at $367,900 in April 2022.

What are two-bedroom Governors Island villas selling for?

Two-bedroom Governors Island villas sold 5 times in the 12 months to October 2026 at a $210,000 median, from $165,000 to $238,500. Over 36 months, 10 two-bedroom sales recorded a $224,250 median. The 1,080 square foot plan sold 7 times in 36 months at a $210,000 median, from $165,000 to $272,500.

What are three-bedroom Governors Island villas selling for?

Three-bedroom Governors Island villas sold 4 times in the 12 months to October 2026 at a $207,500 median, from $188,000 to $240,000. Over 36 months, 10 three-bedroom sales recorded a $260,000 median. The 1,305 square foot plan sold 7 times in 36 months at a $235,000 median; the 1,361 square foot plan sold 3 times, at $240,000, $330,000 and $345,000.

Do lake front Governors Island villas sell for more?

On the county’s 2026 values, yes: lake front units carry a median just value of $206,641 against $176,197 for interior units, partly because more lake front units are three-bedroom. In recorded sales the gap is small: over 36 months, 7 lake front sales at a $240,000 median and 13 interior sales at $238,500. Condition moved prices more than the water view.

How Have Governors Island Prices Changed Since It Was Built?

Governors Island prices have roughly doubled since the first buyers paid a median $94,900 in 1985, but not in a straight line. Prices rose through 2006, fell to a median $81,950 in 2012, climbed to $312,000 in 2022 and $285,000 in 2023, and have fallen to $195,000 in 2026 to October on the county record.

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County recorded qualified sales.

Year

Qualified sales

Median price

Median per heated sq ft

1985

12

$94,900

$71

1986

16

$92,900

$73

1987

15

$82,900

$72

1995

7

$95,000

$73

2000

14

$95,500

$75

2004

13

$148,500

$128

2005

9

$184,900

$162

2006

5

$225,000

$204

2007

7

$170,000

$136

2011

7

$110,000

$90

2012

6

$81,950

$70

2015

9

$155,000

$132

2019

9

$168,000

$139

2020

6

$226,200

$179

2021

5

$200,000

$167

2022

7

$312,000

$252

2023

10

$285,000

$252

2024

5

$280,000

$222

2025

5

$240,000

$215

2026 to Oct

7

$195,000

$153

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County recorded qualified sales; 2008 is left out because its qualified-coded rows include a $100 deed.

What did the first Governors Island buyers pay?

The first recorded qualified Governors Island sales ran from $69,900 to $102,900 in 1985, a $94,900 median on 12 sales, followed by 16 sales at a $92,900 median in 1986 and 15 at $82,900 in 1987. Those were the developer-era sales of new villas.

What happened to Governors Island prices before 2012?

Governors Island prices climbed from a $95,500 median in 2000 to $225,000 in 2006, then fell with the housing crash to $110,000 in 2011 and $81,950 in 2012, the low point on the county record, at about $70 per heated square foot.

What happened after 2020?

Prices jumped. The median moved from $168,000 in 2019 to $226,200 in 2020, $312,000 in 2022 and $285,000 in 2023, when 10 sales recorded at about $252 per heated square foot. Since 2024 prices have eased each year, to $195,000 in 2026 to October.

What are Governors Island units worth on the county roll?

The 2026 roll values the 115 units at $21,448,558 in total, a median just value of $187,647, from $151,250 to $245,645. By plan, the median just value is $167,312 for the 1,080 square foot two-bedroom, $178,932 for 1,154 square feet, $191,933 for 1,252, $193,477 for the 1,305 square foot three-bedroom and $212,817 for 1,361 square feet.

Did the county roll change in 2026?

Yes, it fell. The Florida Department of Revenue rolls show the Governors Island total just value moving from $22,419,991 in 2025 to $21,449,064 in 2026, and the median from $195,657 to $187,647, about 4 percent lower. The 12-month sale median of $210,000 sits 11.9 percent above the 2026 median just value.

What Units Are in Governors Island?

Governors Island has six floor plans on the county roll, all one story with two baths and a garage: two-bedroom villas of 1,080, 1,154, 1,252 and 1,286 heated square feet, and three-bedroom villas of 1,305 and 1,361 heated square feet. The 64 two-bedroom units are 56 percent of the community.

Heated sq ft

Bedrooms

Units

Lake front units

2026 median just value

1,080

2

28

6

$167,312

1,154

2

21

5

$178,932

1,252

2

13

0

$191,933

1,286

2

2

1

$164,014

1,305

3

27

13

$193,477

1,361

3

24

13

$212,817

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County Property Appraiser roll exported November 1, 2026; all 115 units two baths, one story, garage.

How are the plans spread across the community?

The 1,361 square foot three-bedroom plan clusters on Ashton Circle: Phase IV’s 13 units are 11 of that plan and 2 of 1,252 square feet. Phase I, the largest phase with 50 units, mixes every plan but one. The 18 units without a phase, all on Governors Drive, are mostly 1,305 square foot three-bedroom villas.

What does a Governors Island villa look like?

Listings describe concrete block and stucco construction with tile roofs, a one-car garage, two bedrooms or three, two baths and a lanai. Some units have impact windows or hurricane shutters. Interiors vary widely with each owner’s updates, which is why recorded prices for the same plan span a wide band.

Why do listings show different square footage?

Listings sometimes print 1,578 or 1,625 square feet for a three-bedroom villa. Those figures count the lanai, the garage or the area under roof. The county roll’s heated living area tops out at 1,361 square feet, and every price per square foot on this page uses the roll’s heated area.

How old are the Governors Island buildings?

The roll records 13 units built in 1985, 75 in 1986 and 27 in 1987, so in 2026 the buildings are 39 to 41 years old. Roof replacement dates, plumbing updates and window upgrades are not on the roll; ask the association for the roof history of your building and the seller for the unit’s records.

Who Built Governors Island and How Did It Come to Be?

Governors Island was declared as a condominium at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647, registered with the State on August 22, 1984, and built in phases from 1985 to 1987 inside the older Pinebrook Lakes tract. The developer’s name is not in any public source we found; the recorded declaration names it.

When was each Governors Island phase finished?

The roll created unit records in 1985 (50), 1986 (47) and 1987 (18). Phase I holds 50 units built in 1986; Phase II, 12 units built 1985 to 1986; Phase III, 22 units built 1986 to 1987; Phase IV, 13 units built 1985 to 1986; and the 18 units recorded without a phase, numbered 98 to 115, were built 1986 to 1987.

Why does the State register show 97 units?

The State’s condominium register still lists 97 units for Governors Island Condo, the count when the project was first registered. The condominium grew by phases, and the Lee County roll today carries 115 residential units. We use the roll’s 115 throughout this page.

Who was the developer of Governors Island?

No public source we found names the developer or builder of Governors Island. The declaration recorded at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647 names the developer, and the Lee County Clerk’s official records hold it with any amendments. A buyer’s title company can pull it.

What is the Pinebrook Lakes tract?

The Pinebrook Lakes tract is an older unrecorded subdivision described at Official Records Book 1724, Page 3511, whose shared road, buffer and lake belong to the Big Pine Way Maintenance Organization. Pinebrook Lakes Condo came first, registered in 1981; Governors Island followed in the mid-1980s alongside Pinebrook Woods and Harbour Castle.

Who Governs Governors Island?

Governors Island is governed by its own condominium association, listed on the State’s condominium register as Condo Owners Assn of Governors Isl Inc, under Florida’s Condominium Act, Chapter 718, and the declaration recorded at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647. The shared Big Pine Way road and lake belong to a separate organization.

Who manages Governors Island?

Listings describe an owner-run association with professional management. The State register’s managing-entity line reads “Home Encounter HECM LLC” in Fort Myers, but we found no other public source tying that firm to the community today, so confirm the current manager with the association. Several listings print a contact number for the association or its manager; ask your agent for the current one.

What is the Big Pine Way Maintenance Organization?

The Big Pine Way Maintenance Organization owns the shared private road, its right of way, the buffer and a lake common area of about 9.47 acres in the Pinebrook Lakes tract, plus a submerged parcel next to the Bell Tower lake. One listing names a master association among the items the fee covers. Whether owners pay it separately or through the Governors Island budget is not public; ask for it in the estoppel certificate.

Which Florida law governs Governors Island?

Chapter 718, Florida’s Condominium Act, governs Governors Island: budgets and reserves, official records, insurance, elections, resale disclosures and the estoppel certificate. The 2024 and 2025 condominium reforms, HB 1021 and HB 913, apply to every Florida condominium association, including this one, though the milestone and SIRS parts do not reach one-story buildings.

What records can Governors Island owners and buyers ask for?

Owners can inspect the association’s official records: the declaration and amendments, bylaws, rules, budgets, financial reports, insurance policies, contracts and minutes. A buyer receives the declaration, bylaws, rules, the current budget and the most recent financial report with the contract, and the estoppel certificate before closing gives the fee status of the exact unit.

Does the Governors Island association need a website?

Yes. Since January 1, 2026, Florida condominium associations with 25 or more units must keep official records on a website or app, under HB 1021 (2024). Governors Island has 115 units, so the rule covers it. We found no public association website in searches; ask the association how owners reach the records portal.

Do Governors Island board members need training?

Yes. Florida now requires new condominium directors to complete four hours of education, covering topics including milestone inspections, SIRS and elections, and one hour of continuing education a year. The rule applies to the Governors Island board like every other Florida condominium board.

What Does It Cost to Own in Governors Island? The Fee Stack

Owning in Governors Island costs one monthly condominium fee, printed in listings at $528 in 2023 and $555 to $589 in 2025 and 2026, plus property taxes and the owner’s own insurance. There is no CDD and no golf or club fee; whether a separate Big Pine Way charge exists is a question for the estoppel certificate.

Layer

Amount

Period

What it covers

Source

Condominium fee

$528

monthly (2023 listing, 5322 Concord Way, MLS 223023303; $6,336 a year)

Water, sewer, trash, cable, internet, lawn care, insurance, irrigation water, exterior pest control, reserves, street lights and street maintenance, community pool

Listing remarks, March to April 2023

Condominium fee

$504 to $541

monthly (5340 Concord Way, October 2024; 5404 Ashton Circle, January 2025)

As above

Listing remarks, dated

Condominium fee

$555 to $589

monthly (5338 Concord Way, 2025; 5282 Concord Way, listing updated March 2026)

As above

Listing remarks, dated

Application

$100 plus an interview

per application

Association approval

2023 listing

Big Pine Way road and lake

not public

not public

Shared private road, buffer and lake

Lee County roll; ask the estoppel

CDD

none

2026 millage book, district 047

Property taxes

about $2,442 a year at the median non-homestead value

yearly

County, schools, fire, water management

2026 millage book and roll

Owner’s HO-6 insurance

quote by unit

yearly

Interior, contents, liability

Owner’s insurer

Data updated: November 2026. Fees are as printed in dated listings; confirm the current budget with the association.

What are the Governors Island HOA fees?

Governors Island has a condominium fee rather than an HOA fee. Listings printed $528 a month in 2023, $504 in October 2024, $541 in January 2025, and $555 to $589 in 2025 and 2026 listings. At $555 to $589 a month the fee is $6,660 to $7,068 a year. Listings suggest the fee varies with unit size; the association’s current budget gives the figure for each unit.

What do the Governors Island fees cover?

A 2023 listing lists water, sewer, trash, cable, internet, lawn care, insurance, irrigation water, exterior pest control, reserves, street lights and street maintenance, and the community pool. Other listings add exterior building insurance including roofs, management, and legal and accounting. Confirm the current inclusions in the budget, because an association can change what it provides.

Is there an application or transfer fee at Governors Island?

A 2023 listing printed a $100 application fee and an interview for buyers. We found no published capital contribution or transfer fee. Ask the association for its current approval process, fee and timeline before you set a closing date, and look for any capital contribution in the estoppel certificate.

Are there special assessments at Governors Island?

We found no special assessment in any public source, and the 2026 roll carries no disaster code on any unit. That does not rule one out. Ask for the current budget, the reserve schedule and any pending roof, paving or insurance assessment, and read the estoppel certificate, which must disclose assessments due.

How does the Governors Island estoppel certificate work?

The estoppel certificate is the association’s written statement of what is owed on a unit at closing: the regular fee, any special assessment, any capital contribution and any unpaid balance. Florida’s Condominium Act sets what it must contain and how long it is valid. Title companies order it, and the seller usually pays for it.

Is there a CDD in Governors Island?

No. The 2026 Lee County millage book for taxing district 047 lists no community development district or special district beyond the countywide ones. Governors Island’s tax bill carries the county, school, fire, water management and other countywide levies, plus the county’s non-ad valorem solid waste charge.

What Are Property Taxes on a Governors Island Condo?

Property taxes on a Governors Island condo are set by taxing district 047, South Trail Fire, at 13.3623 mills adopted for 2026, or $1,336.23 per $100,000 of taxable value. We estimate about $2,442 a year at the median non-homestead unit; homesteaded owners, protected by Florida’s assessment cap, carry a median estimate of about $1,108.

Authority (district 047)

2026 adopted mills

Lee County general revenue

3.7623

Public school, local board

2.2480

Public school, state law

3.0230

Lee County all hazards protection district

0.0693

Lee County unincorporated MSTU

0.8398

Lee County library district

0.4218

South Florida Water Management District, district-wide

0.0948

South Florida Water Management District, Everglades construction

0.0327

South Florida Water Management District, Okeechobee basin

0.1026

Lee County hyacinth control district

0.0190

Lee County mosquito control district

0.2096

South Trail Fire District

2.5000

West Coast Inland Navigation District

0.0394

Total, adopted

13.3623

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 Taxing District Millage Book, printed October 9, 2026, page 28, the adopted (ACTUAL) column; the proposed total was 13.3738 and the rollback rate 13.3601.

What would a Governors Island tax bill be?

At the 2026 adopted rate, a Governors Island unit without a homestead exemption, valued at the median non-homestead just value of $182,751, pays about $2,442 in ad valorem tax; the 32 non-homestead units range from about $2,029 to $3,066. Non-ad valorem charges, such as the county’s solid waste assessment, appear separately on the Lee County Tax Collector’s bill.

Will a buyer’s Governors Island taxes match the seller’s?

Usually not. A homesteaded seller’s assessed value is capped under Florida’s Save Our Homes rule, so the 83 homesteaded owners carry a median estimate of about $1,108. After a sale the assessment resets to market value on the next January 1, so a buyer budgets from the purchase price, not the seller’s bill.

How much does a homestead exemption save at Governors Island?

A full 2026 homestead exemption takes $25,000 off the value for every levy and another $26,411 off the non-school levies, $51,411 in all. At the median just value of $187,647, that cuts the first-year estimate from about $2,507 to about $1,960, a saving of about $548, before the assessment cap starts to work in later years.

Why does Governors Island pay South Trail Fire District millage?

Governors Island is in unincorporated Lee County, so fire protection comes from the South Trail Fire District, an independent special district, not a city fire department. Its 2026 levy is 2.5000 mills, part of the district 047 total. There is no City of Fort Myers millage on a Governors Island bill.

Does Governors Island Have a Pool, Clubhouse or Golf?

Governors Island has a community pool, a gated entry, private lanes with street lights and small lakes, and listings add a pool cabana, picnic area and sidewalks. It has no golf course, tennis or pickleball courts, fitness center, dining or marina, and no club membership, initiation fee or club dues.

What amenities are confirmed at Governors Island?

The community pool is confirmed by listings and by the county roll’s pool flag on every unit, which reflects the shared pool. Listings describe the pool area with a cabana and picnic space, sidewalks and street lights, a gated entry and private roads. The common-element parcel holds the lakes, lawns and lanes.

Can Governors Island owners boat on the lakes?

No. “Waterfront” on portals means the community’s ponds, not boating water. The lakes are stormwater and scenic water inside the common elements and the Big Pine Way tract. Ask the association about any rules on fishing, launching kayaks or feeding wildlife.

Is there a membership fee for Governors Island amenities?

No. The pool and grounds are common elements paid for through the condominium fee. There is no club, no initiation fee and no separate amenity membership on the public record.

Where is the nearest golf to Governors Island?

Seven Lakes, a separate community in Fort Myers, has an 18-hole executive course of par 60 and 3,515 yards at 1765 Augusta Drive; our Seven Lakes guide covers it. Golf clubs line the Daniels corridor east toward Interstate 75, including Fiddlesticks Country Club. None is tied to a Governors Island unit.

What Rules Should Governors Island Buyers Know About Rentals, Pets and Age?

Governors Island’s rental, pet and approval rules live in the recorded declaration and the association’s rules, which we have not read. Dated listings give a guide: a 2023 listing printed a 365-day minimum lease, one lease a year, a two-pet limit with a 25 pound weight limit, and a $100 application fee with an interview. Confirm every rule with the association.

Can you rent out a Governors Island villa?

Annual rentals appear to be allowed; short stays appear not to be. A 2023 listing for 5322 Concord Way printed a 365-day minimum lease and one lease per year, and a Governors Island villa was offered for annual rent at $2,200 a month in March 2026. Read the current declaration and rules, and confirm with the association, before buying to rent.

What are the Governors Island pet rules?

A 2023 listing printed a limit of 2 pets with a maximum weight of 25, and other listings say “pet friendly” or note a number limit. Pet rules can change by amendment or board rule, so ask the association for the current pet policy, and get it in writing, before you sign a contract.

Does Governors Island have an age requirement?

No age restriction appears in any public source we found, and no 55-and-older designation is on the public record. The declaration recorded at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647 and its amendments govern; ask the association to confirm in writing.

Do you need association approval to buy or rent in Governors Island?

A 2023 listing printed a $100 application fee and an interview, so plan for association approval of buyers and tenants. Ask for the current application, fee and timeline at the start of the contract period, and build the approval period into your closing date.

Can a Governors Island buyer use FHA or VA financing?

That depends on whether the condominium holds a current approval. FHA approval is listed by project on the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development’s condominium lookup. Check the lookup for Governors Island before choosing a loan program, and ask your lender about conventional condominium review questions as well.

Is Governors Island in a Flood Zone?

Governors Island is outside FEMA’s high-risk flood zones. Lee County’s copy of the effective FEMA flood map places all 116 Governors Island parcel points in Zone X (shaded), a 0.2 percent annual chance flood area in the coastal zone, outside the special flood hazard area, on panel 12071C0436H, effective November 17, 2022. That is moderate risk, not no risk.

Flood item

Governors Island

FEMA zone, every parcel point

Zone X (shaded), 0.2 percent annual chance flood hazard in coastal zone

Special flood hazard area

No

FIRM panel

12071C0436H, effective November 17, 2022

Nearby higher-risk area

A Zone AE polygon with a 9 foot base flood elevation lies in the same map window; no unit point falls inside it

Lee County evacuation zone

Zone B (storm surge zone 2)

County spot elevations in the community window

5.0 to 15.2 feet, median 10.0 feet, lower at the lake edges

Disaster code on the 2026 roll

None on any unit

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County GIS FEMA flood layers and evacuation layer, queried for the community window; one point per unit was tested, not building outlines.

Do Governors Island owners need flood insurance?

A lender does not require flood insurance on a Governors Island unit, because Zone X (shaded) is outside the special flood hazard area. Flood cover is still available and worth pricing: the community is in the 0.2 percent annual chance area in the coastal zone, which FEMA treats as moderate risk, not no risk.

How do you confirm the flood zone for one Governors Island unit?

Enter the address at FEMA’s Flood Map Service Center, or open panel 12071C0436H, and ask the seller for any elevation certificate. Our test used one map point per unit from the county roll, not building outlines, so the map for your exact building is the final word.

What is the Governors Island evacuation zone?

Lee County places Governors Island in Evacuation Zone B, storm surge zone 2. Lee County ordered Zones A and B, and parts of Zone C, to evacuate on September 27, 2022 for Hurricane Ian, and ordered Zones A and B out on October 7, 2024 for Hurricane Milton. Owners should plan to leave when Zone B is called.

How high is the ground at Governors Island?

Lee County’s spot elevation layer holds 608 points in the community window, ranging from 5.0 to 15.2 feet with a median of 10.0 feet; the lower readings sit at the lake edges. The layer does not state its datum here, so treat the figures as a guide and rely on an elevation certificate for a specific building.

How Did Governors Island Fare in Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton?

No news report or association record we found describes flood or wind damage inside Governors Island in Hurricane Ian in 2022 or Helene and Milton in 2024, and the 2026 county roll carries no disaster code on any unit. That is an absence of public reports, not proof of no damage; ask the association for its storm repair history.

What did Hurricane Ian do in Fort Myers?

Hurricane Ian made landfall near Cayo Costa on September 28, 2022 as a strong Category 4 storm. Storm surge was its deadliest hazard, and the Fort Myers gauge recorded a record 7.26 feet. Lee County had ordered Zones A and B, and parts of Zone C, to evacuate the day before.

What did Helene and Milton bring to Fort Myers?

In September 2024 Helene raised the Fort Myers gauge to 5.12 feet, and Milton made landfall near Siesta Key on October 9, 2024 as a Category 3 storm, raising the gauge to 5.26 feet. Lee County ordered Zones A and B to evacuate for Milton on October 7, 2024.

Did Governors Island villas keep selling after Ian?

Yes. The county recorded a $304,000 sale on November 21, 2022 and a $312,000 sale on December 6, 2022, weeks after Ian, and 10 qualified sales in 2023 at a $285,000 median. Prices fell later, from 2024, as the wider condominium market softened.

What should a Governors Island buyer ask about storm history?

Ask the association whether any building took water or roof damage in Ian, Helene or Milton, what was repaired, whether any insurance claim or assessment followed, and the roof replacement dates. Ask the seller for the unit’s own history and for any flood insurance claims, which Florida’s seller flood disclosure requires.

What Do Florida’s Condo Safety Laws Mean for Governors Island?

Florida’s condominium safety laws mean less for Governors Island than for most condominiums. Milestone inspections and structural integrity reserve studies apply to buildings of three or more habitable stories, and every Governors Island unit is one story on the county roll. The reserve, records, insurance and director-training rules still apply to the association.

Why don’t the milestone and SIRS rules apply to Governors Island?

The milestone inspection law and the structural integrity reserve study (SIRS) law, as narrowed by HB 913 in 2025, cover condominium buildings three or more habitable stories in height. The Lee County roll records a maximum of one story on all 115 Governors Island units, so neither law reaches these buildings.

What reserve rules still apply at Governors Island?

Chapter 718’s reserve rules for items such as roofs and paving still apply to a condominium that is not subject to SIRS, unless owners vote to waive or reduce reserves. HB 913 raised the threshold for a reserve item from $10,000 to $25,000. Ask for the current budget’s reserve schedule and whether owners have waived reserves.

Does the condo safety law change anything for a Governors Island buyer?

It helps. Buyers of older condominiums often worry about large SIRS-driven assessments. Governors Island’s one-story buildings fall outside that law, though roofs, paving and insurance still cost money. A buyer should still read the budget, reserves and minutes, and ask about planned roof and paving work.

What does a Governors Island seller disclose about the condo laws?

Florida Realtors’ MISIRS-1 form is the standard milestone inspection and SIRS disclosure in a condominium contract. For Governors Island the honest answer is that the buildings are one story and below the three-story threshold, which we state plainly in a listing, with the association’s written confirmation where we can get it.

What Does Insurance Look Like for a Governors Island Condo?

Insurance at Governors Island has two layers: the association insures the buildings, including roofs, through the master policy paid by the condominium fee, and each owner carries an HO-6 policy for the interior, contents and liability. Construction is concrete block and stucco with tile roofs, and some units have impact windows or shutters.

What does the Governors Island master policy cover?

Listings describe the fee as covering exterior building insurance including roofs. The master policy’s carrier, premium, deductible and flood cover are not public. Ask the association for the declarations page, the deductible and how a deductible would be shared after a storm, and whether the association carries a condominium flood policy such as FEMA’s RCBAP.

What does an HO-6 policy cost at Governors Island?

HO-6 premiums depend on the unit’s coverage, deductible, wind mitigation features and claims history, so get a quote for the exact unit before you write an offer. A wind mitigation inspection that documents shutters, impact windows and roof attachment can lower the wind portion of the premium under Florida law.

Does building age affect insurance at Governors Island?

Yes. The buildings date from 1985 to 1987, and insurers ask about roof age, electrical, plumbing and water heaters. Roof dates are not on the county roll; ask the association for the roof history of your building, and ask the seller for the age of the air conditioner and water heater.

Which Schools Serve Governors Island Addresses?

Governors Island is in the School District of Lee County, which assigns students by its enrollment zone map, not by distance. The nearest public schools in a straight line are South Fort Myers High School at 1.2 miles and Villas Elementary at 1.5 miles; Cypress Lake Middle is 2.3 miles away. Confirm the assigned schools for an exact address with the district.

School

Type

Straight-line distance

South Fort Myers High School, 14020 Plantation Rd

public high

1.2 mi

Villas Elementary, 8595 Beacon Blvd

public elementary

1.5 mi

Six Mile Charter Academy

charter, K to 8

1.4 mi

Florida SouthWestern Collegiate High School

public collegiate high school

1.4 mi

Cypress Lake Middle School

public middle

2.3 mi

Cypress Lake High School

public high

2.4 mi

Tanglewood Elementary

public elementary

2.5 mi

Florida SouthWestern State College, 8099 College Pkwy

state college

1.4 mi

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County GIS school points; distance is not assignment.

How do you confirm the schools for a Governors Island address?

Use the School District of Lee County’s school zones page and its address locator. Listings often show “School Choice” instead of a named school. The district proposed 2026 to 2027 enrollment changes in November 2025, including K to 8 options, waitlist windows and no busing under two miles, so check the current rules.

How close is Governors Island to Florida SouthWestern State College?

Florida SouthWestern State College at 8099 College Parkway is about 1.4 miles from Governors Island in a straight line, with its collegiate high school on the same campus.

How Far Is Governors Island From Shopping, Hospitals, I-75 and the Beaches?

Governors Island is about 0.3 miles in a straight line from the Bell Tower Shops and Market Square, 0.9 miles from Gulf Coast Medical Center, 4.1 miles from HealthPark and 5.5 miles from Lee Memorial Hospital. Interstate 75 is reached by Daniels Parkway at Exit 131; listings call Southwest Florida International Airport and the beaches minutes away.

Place

Straight-line distance from Governors Island

Bell Tower Shops, 13499 S Cleveland Ave

0.3 mi

Market Square, 5100 Daniels Pkwy

0.3 mi

Cypress Trace shopping center, S Cleveland Ave

0.6 mi

Gulf Coast Medical Center, 13681 Doctor’s Way

0.9 mi

Florida SouthWestern State College

1.4 mi

HealthPark Medical Center and Golisano Children’s Hospital

4.1 mi

Lee Memorial Hospital

5.5 mi

Data updated: November 2026. Straight-line distances computed from Lee County coordinates, not drive times; drive minutes vary with traffic and season.

What is happening at the Daniels Parkway and I-75 interchange?

FDOT is rebuilding the Interstate 75 interchange at Daniels Parkway, Exit 131, as a diverging diamond under project 446296-2, about $42.8 million. Work began in January 2026, completion is estimated for summer 2028, and night lane closures are part of the work. Expect delays on that route until it finishes.

How close is Governors Island to the beach?

Fort Myers Beach and Sanibel are reached by car; listings describe the beaches as minutes away, and drive times depend on season and the route across the bridges. We do not print a drive-time figure we have not measured.

Where do Governors Island owners shop and eat?

At the Bell Tower Shops next door, with the Regal Bell Tower cinema, The Fresh Market, Dave and Buster’s in the former Saks Fifth Avenue space and restaurants, and at Market Square and Cypress Trace on US 41. Listings call Bell Tower walking distance.

What else is nearby for Governors Island owners?

JetBlue Park and Hammond Stadium, the spring training homes of the Boston Red Sox and Minnesota Twins, and the Barbara B. Mann Performing Arts Hall are named in listings as nearby draws. The Forest, Seven Lakes and other south Fort Myers communities are close by; our Fort Myers guide covers the wider city.

How Do We Price a Governors Island Condo?

We price a Governors Island condo from the recorded Governors Island sales of the same plan and setting, adjusted for condition, updates, lake front or interior position and the date of sale, then check the result against the Southwest Florida MLS for days on market, active competition and pending sales. A Fort Myers condo average is the wrong starting point.

Step

What we check

Why it matters at Governors Island

1

Your plan’s recorded sales, 12 and 36 months

Plans run from 1,080 to 1,361 square feet; three-bedroom sales ranged $188,000 to $240,000 in 12 months

2

Lake front or interior

38 lake front units; the county values them higher

3

Condition and updates

Same-plan sales span tens of thousands of dollars

4

Roof, windows and shutters

Insurance and buyer confidence

5

Fee and any assessment

The estoppel certificate

6

Active and pending competition

MLS read on the day we price

Data updated: November 2026.

Why not price a Governors Island villa from Fort Myers averages?

Because Governors Island has its own product: one-story concrete block villas with garages, a bundled condominium fee and Zone X (shaded) flood status. A Fort Myers condo average mixes high-rises, garden apartments and newer villas with different fees and flood zones. The 9 recorded Governors Island sales of the last 12 months are the right base.

Does the plan change a Governors Island price?

Yes. Over 36 months, the 1,361 square foot three-bedroom villas recorded $240,000, $330,000 and $345,000, while the 1,080 square foot two-bedroom plan recorded a $210,000 median. The 1,305 square foot three-bedroom plan sold 7 times at a $235,000 median.

How do you price a Governors Island villa after a falling year?

We weight the newest sales most. The 7 sales of 2026 to October recorded a $195,000 median, below the 36-month median of $239,250, so a 2024 sale is not today’s price. We also read the MLS for pending sales and price cuts in Governors Island and in nearby villa communities.

How Do You Buy a Condo in Governors Island, Step by Step?

Buying a condo in Governors Island means choosing a plan and setting, checking the fee and the association’s records, pricing from recorded sales, writing a contract with condominium and inspection protections, getting association approval and closing with an estoppel certificate. Plan for the approval interview and allow time for the association’s review.

Step

What to do

1

Pick the plan: two-bedroom 1,080 to 1,286 square feet or three-bedroom 1,305 or 1,361, lake front or interior

2

Get preapproved and check the condominium’s loan eligibility

3

Compare recorded Governors Island sales for the plan with active and pending competition

4

Write the offer on the Florida condominium contract with inspection and financing periods

5

Read the declaration, bylaws, rules, budget and financial report during the review period

6

Inspect the unit, including roof leaks, air conditioning, water heater, windows and garage door

7

Apply to the association: $100 and an interview in 2023

8

Insure: HO-6 and wind quote, and price optional flood cover

9

Close with the estoppel certificate showing fees and assessments

What should a Governors Island buyer check during inspection?

Check the roof over the unit for leaks, the air conditioning and water heater ages, the windows and any shutters or impact glass, the garage door and opener, plumbing under sinks, the lanai and any sign of past water. Get a wind mitigation report and, for an older unit, a four-point inspection if the insurer asks.

Which documents does a Governors Island buyer receive?

Under Florida’s Condominium Act, a resale buyer receives the declaration, articles, bylaws and rules, the most recent annual financial report and the current budget, plus a question-and-answer sheet. Read the rental, pet and approval rules there, and ask the association for recent minutes and the insurance summary.

How does a buyer start in Governors Island?

Call Marc at (239) 457-1610. We will pull the recorded Governors Island sales for the plan you want, check the active and pending competition, and walk you through the fee, approval and insurance before you write an offer. See how we represent buyers.

How Does Governors Island Compare With Nearby Condo and Villa Communities?

Governors Island is the lowest-priced gated one-story garage villa in its corner of south Fort Myers. Over 36 months it recorded a $239,250 median, against $295,000 at Pinebrook Woods, $445,000 at Harbour Castle and $475,000 at the Courtyard Homes at Bell Tower Park, and above $192,000 at Pinebrook Lakes Condo and $170,000 at Venetian Palms.

Community

Form and era

Units on the roll

36-month sales, median

12-month sales, median

Fees (source, date)

Governors Island

one-story condominium villas, 1985 to 1987, garage on every unit

115

20, $239,250, $205 a sq ft

9, $210,000

$555 to $589 a month (listings, 2025 to 2026)

Pinebrook Lakes Condo (0.3 mi, same tract)

condominium, 1981, 39 two-story and 17 one-story units, no garage on the roll

56

9, $192,000, $141 a sq ft

5, $148,000

confirm with the association

Pinebrook Woods (0.3 mi, same tract)

fee-simple villa homes, 1984 to 1986, one story, garage

100

11, $295,000, $210 a sq ft

5, $275,000

$530 to $655 a month (listings, 2024 to 2026)

Harbour Castle (0.1 mi, same tract)

homes, 1985 to 2005

73

12, $445,000, $276 a sq ft

2 sales, $415,500 and $481,000

confirm with the association

Courtyard Homes at Bell Tower Park (0.7 mi, ZIP 33912)

one-story courtyard villas, 2004 to 2007

189

39, $475,000, $185 a sq ft

14, $432,500

$603 to $705 a month (listings)

Venetian Palms (1.0 mi, ZIP 33907)

two-story condominium, 1991

327

45, $170,000, $171 a sq ft

16, $125,000

about $520 a month for 1,033 sq ft (listing)

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County roll exported November 1, 2026 and recorded qualified sales to October 31, 2026, same method for every row; distances straight line between roll medians.

How does Governors Island compare with Pinebrook Lakes Condo?

They share the Big Pine Way entrance and the same era, but Governors Island is all one story with a garage on every unit, while Pinebrook Lakes Condo, built in 1981, is mostly two-story and records no garages on the roll. Governors Island sold higher over 36 months, $239,250 against $192,000 at Pinebrook Lakes Condo.

How does Governors Island compare with Harbour Castle?

Harbour Castle, on Harbour Castle Drive in the same tract, is a different product: 73 larger homes built from 1985 to 2005 with a 36-month median of $445,000. Buyers who want more space and no condominium structure look there; buyers who want the lower price and the bundled fee look at Governors Island.

How does Governors Island compare with the Courtyard Homes at Bell Tower Park?

The Courtyard Homes at Bell Tower Park, across Daniels Parkway in ZIP 33912, are about 20 years newer and much larger, 1,675 to 2,701 heated square feet, with a 36-month median of $475,000, about twice Governors Island’s, and higher listed fees. Our partner team’s Bell Tower Park guide covers that community.

How does Governors Island compare with Venetian Palms?

Venetian Palms, about a mile northwest on Equestrian Circle, is a 1991 two-story condominium of 327 units with smaller units, 623 to 1,154 square feet, and no garages on the roll. It is cheaper, a $170,000 36-month median, but it is not a one-story villa with a garage. Our partner team’s Venetian Palms guide covers it.

Governors Island vs Pinebrook Woods: Which Should You Choose?

Governors Island and Pinebrook Woods are the closest like-for-like choice: both sit off Big Pine Way behind Bell Tower, both were built in the mid-1980s, and both are one-story villas with garages. Governors Island is a condominium with smaller units and lower prices; Pinebrook Woods owners hold fee-simple lots with larger homes and higher prices.

Factor

Governors Island

Pinebrook Woods

Ownership

Condominium unit and common elements

Fee-simple villa lot

Units

115

100

Built

1985 to 1987

1984 to 1986

Stories on the roll

1, every unit

1, every home

Garage on the roll

Every unit

Every home

Heated area

1,080 to 1,361 sq ft, median 1,252

1,362 to 1,614 sq ft, median 1,474

Recorded sales, 12 months to Oct 2026

9, median $210,000

5, median $275,000

Recorded sales, 36 months to Oct 2026

20, median $239,250, $205 a sq ft

11, median $295,000, $210 a sq ft

Monthly fee (listings)

$555 to $589 (2025 to 2026)

$530 to $655 (2024 to 2026)

Homestead share on the roll

72%

74%

Taxing district

047, 13.3623 mills

047, 13.3623 mills

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County roll and recorded qualified sales, same method for both.

Which is the better value, Governors Island or Pinebrook Woods?

On price, Governors Island: its 36-month median of $239,250 sits well below Pinebrook Woods’ $295,000. Per heated square foot the two are close, $205 against $210, so the gap mostly reflects Pinebrook Woods’ larger homes. Governors Island’s fee covers exterior building insurance; ask what each fee covers before deciding.

How do you decide between Governors Island and Pinebrook Woods?

Choose Governors Island if you want the lower entry price, a fee that bundles the building insurance and exterior care, and a two-bedroom or smaller three-bedroom plan. Choose Pinebrook Woods if you want to own the lot, more living area and a fee-simple structure. Confirm each community’s fee, rules and insurance for the exact home before you write an offer.

What Are the Honest Pros and Cons of Governors Island?

Governors Island’s strengths are one-story concrete block villas with garages, a gate, a walk to Bell Tower, Zone X (shaded) flood status and no SIRS or milestone burden. Its limits are 1980s buildings, one pool and no clubhouse program, a small-pet limit and annual-only leases in listings, Evacuation Zone B, and prices that fell through 2026.

Pros

Cons

Every unit one story with a garage

Buildings are 39 to 41 years old

Gated, with private lanes and lakes

One community pool, no clubhouse program or golf

Walk to the Bell Tower Shops; Gulf Coast Medical Center under a mile

Daniels Parkway and I-75 interchange construction until about 2028

Zone X (shaded), outside the special flood hazard area

Evacuation Zone B, ordered out for Ian and Milton

Below the three-story milestone and SIRS threshold

Reserves, roofs and insurance still cost money

Fee bundles exterior insurance, water, cable and internet

Fee of $555 to $589 a month in recent listings

Lowest-priced gated one-story garage villa nearby

2026 median $195,000, down from $285,000 in 2023

No CDD, no city millage

Pet and leasing limits in listings

What is the biggest risk for a Governors Island buyer?

Building age and what it costs the association. Roofs, paving and insurance on 1980s buildings drive the budget and any special assessment. Read the reserve schedule, the insurance summary and recent minutes before you commit, and ask when your building’s roof was last replaced.

Is the price drop since 2023 a risk or an opening?

Both. The 2026 median of $195,000 is 31.6 percent below 2023’s $285,000, so a buyer pays less than in 2023, but values can keep moving. Price from the newest sales, not the peak, and plan to hold.

What does Governors Island do better than its neighbors?

It offers a one-story, garage, gated villa at a lower recorded price than Pinebrook Woods, Harbour Castle or Bell Tower Park, with flood status outside the special flood hazard area and a fee that bundles the building insurance. Few communities in south Fort Myers combine those at its price.

Thinking of Selling Your Governors Island Condo? List With the #1 Team in Southwest Florida Since 2012

Selling a Governors Island villa well means pricing it on the 2026 recorded Governors Island sales for its plan and setting, presenting the garage, the single level, the gate and the walk to Bell Tower as the assets they are, and answering the fee, flood, insurance and roof questions up front. McGreevy and Comisar have done this for Southwest Florida owners for more than a decade as the #1 team in the region.

If you’re searching for the best Governors Island listing agent, or thinking, ‘I need to sell my condo in Governors Island…’, McGreevy and Comisar helps owners price, market, negotiate and sell with a local strategy built for Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples, Lee County, Collier County and Babcock Ranch. Whether you are selling a 1,080 square foot two-bedroom villa or a 1,361 square foot three-bedroom lake front villa, our team provides local market guidance, professional listing exposure and a clear plan to help you sell confidently.

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026)
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Governors Island sold-market statistics we tracked: 20 recorded Lee County qualified sales from November 2023 to October 2026, $165,000 to $345,000, a $239,250 median; 9 sales at a $210,000 median in the 12 months to October 31, 2026; no builder-direct sales. Days on market and sale-to-list ratio are read from the Southwest Florida MLS for your unit when we prepare your pricing.

Selling in Governors Island is different. Your buyer asks the monthly fee and what it covers, any special assessment, the roof date for your building, the reserves, the master insurance, the flood zone and evacuation zone, the storm history, whether the unit has impact windows or shutters, the pet and leasing rules and the approval process. We gather those before the villa goes live.

What Is Your Governors Island Home Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds. Start your free Fort Myers home valuation or use our Southwest Florida home valuation form.

(239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome. Want the complete seller’s guide? Read our Sell Your Home in Fort Myers page for pricing strategy, marketing and the full McGreevy and Comisar listing process, and our selling overview. For the wider picture, see our Fort Myers real estate market report.

How quickly do Governors Island villas sell?

Governors Island villas sell at a slow, steady pace: Lee County recorded 9 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 31, 2026 and 13 in 24 months, out of 115 units, so a listing usually competes with only a few others in the community. We read days on market for your plan from the Southwest Florida MLS when we price.

What will a buyer ask about my Governors Island villa?

A Governors Island buyer will ask the monthly fee and what it covers, any special assessment, the roof date of your building, the master insurance, the flood zone and evacuation zone, any water in past storms, whether the unit has impact windows or shutters, the age of the air conditioning and water heater, and the pet, leasing and approval rules.

Should I update my Governors Island villa before selling?

Sometimes. Governors Island’s 1,305 square foot sales over 36 months ran from $188,000 to $300,000, a spread that points to condition. An update has to move your villa up that band to pay off, so we compare the cost of paint, flooring or an air conditioner with recent sales of your plan first.

Does my building’s condo-law status affect my sale?

Yes, in your favor. Buyers worried about the condo safety laws ask first whether a building needs a SIRS or a milestone inspection. Every Governors Island building is one story on the county record, below the three-story threshold, and we say so plainly in the listing, with the association’s written confirmation where we can get it.

What does it cost to sell a Governors Island villa?

A Governors Island seller typically pays the brokerage commission agreed in the listing agreement, Florida documentary stamp tax on the deed under section 201.02, the owner’s title insurance policy by Lee County custom, prorated taxes and fees, and the estoppel fee. Our Fort Myers seller guide has a full net sheet.

Your Local Real Estate Experts

McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, are the local real estate experts for Governors Island and Fort Myers: Jesse McGreevy leads listing and seller strategy, Marc Comisar leads buyer representation and negotiation, and as the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate across Southwest Florida.

Jesse McGreevy is a top-reviewed Governors Island realtor, and the reviews below are quoted exactly as clients wrote them on our Google Business Profile. We do not edit, combine or summarize client words.

★★★★★ “Their recommendation on pricing my unit was sound and proved prescient. I never questioned their integrity and found it easy to rely on their recommendations. I would work with them again in a heartbeat.” Verified Google review

★★★★★ “Not living in the area, Jesse made life easy for me when we decided to sell our condo. His attention to detail, patience, understanding, and tenacity in dealing with all the moving parts was truly impressive.” Verified Google review

★★★★★ “Marc knows the market, works for his buyer and is attentive to his goals.” Verified Google review

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners
  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 · [email protected]
  • Marc Comisar: (239) 457-1610
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC). Florida license numbers: Jesse McGreevy SL3101296, Marc Comisar BK3060671.

Meet Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, read more about McGreevy and Comisar, see our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers, or contact us.

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com, and see our partner team’s Fort Myers guide for homes across the city.

Frequently Asked Questions About Governors Island, Buyer Edition

Where is Governors Island in Fort Myers?

Governors Island sits on the north side of Daniels Parkway just east of US 41 in south Fort Myers, ZIP 33907, directly behind the Bell Tower Shops. It is reached by Big Pine Way, a private road shared with Pinebrook Lakes, Pinebrook Woods and Harbour Castle, and it is in unincorporated Lee County, not the City of Fort Myers.

Is Governors Island in the City of Fort Myers?

No. Governors Island has a Fort Myers mailing address, ZIP 33907, but the Lee County roll places all 116 parcels in unincorporated Lee County, zoning RM-2, in taxing district 047 with the South Trail Fire District. County rules and permits apply, and there is no city millage on the tax bill.

Is Governors Island a good place to live?

Governors Island offers one-story villas with garages, a gate, and shops, a cinema and a hospital within about a mile, with a fee that bundles the building insurance, water, cable and internet. Weigh those strengths against 1980s buildings, Evacuation Zone B, listing-reported pet and leasing limits and prices that fell through 2026.

How much do Governors Island condos cost?

Lee County recorded 9 qualified Governors Island sales in the 12 months to October 31, 2026, from $165,000 to $240,000, at a $210,000 median and $169 per heated square foot. Over 36 months, 20 sales recorded a $239,250 median. Prices peaked in 2022 and 2023, with medians of $312,000 and $285,000, and have fallen since.

What is the HOA fee at Governors Island?

It is a condominium fee. Listings printed $528 a month in 2023 and $555 to $589 in 2025 and 2026, about $6,660 to $7,068 a year. A 2023 listing says it covers water, sewer, trash, cable, internet, lawn care, insurance, irrigation, pest control, reserves and the pool. Confirm the current budget with the association before buying.

Does Governors Island have an age restriction?

No age restriction appears in any public source we found, and no 55-and-older designation is on the public record. The declaration recorded at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647 and its amendments govern any age rule, so ask the association to confirm in writing before you write an offer.

Are pets allowed at Governors Island?

Pets appear to be allowed with limits. A 2023 listing printed a maximum of 2 pets with a 25 pound weight limit, and other listings call the community pet friendly with a number limit. Pet rules can change by amendment or board rule, so read the current rules and confirm with the association before signing a contract.

Can I rent out my Governors Island villa?

Annual rentals appear to be allowed. A 2023 listing printed a 365-day minimum lease and one lease per year, which rules out short-term and seasonal rentals, and one villa was offered for annual rent at $2,200 a month in March 2026. Confirm the current leasing rules in the declaration and with the association.

Is Governors Island in a flood zone?

Governors Island is outside FEMA’s high-risk zones. Lee County’s copy of the effective FEMA map puts every unit point in Zone X (shaded), a 0.2 percent annual chance area, on panel 12071C0436H, effective November 17, 2022. Lenders do not require flood insurance there, but it is available. The evacuation zone is B.

Did Governors Island flood in Hurricane Ian?

No public report we found describes flood or wind damage inside Governors Island, and the 2026 roll shows no disaster code on any unit. The community is in evacuation Zone B, which Lee County ordered to evacuate for both Ian in 2022 and Milton in 2024. Ask the association for its storm repair history before buying.

What are property taxes at Governors Island?

The 2026 adopted total for district 047 is 13.3623 mills. A unit without a homestead exemption at the median non-homestead value of $182,751 pays about $2,442 in ad valorem tax, and homesteaded units carry a median estimate of about $1,108. The county’s solid waste charge is billed separately on the Tax Collector’s bill.

How many units are in Governors Island?

Governors Island has 115 residential condominium units on the 2026 Lee County roll, plus one common-element parcel of about 17.87 acres. The State’s condominium register still lists 97 units, the count when the project was first registered; the condominium grew by phases to 115 units built from 1985 to 1987.

Is Governors Island gated?

Yes. Listings describe Governors Island as gated with private roads, and Lee County’s subdivision layer marks the Pinebrook Lakes tract as gated. Listings for neighboring Harbour Castle place the gate on Big Pine Way north of Daniels Parkway. Ask the association how residents, guests and deliveries enter.

Do Governors Island villas have garages?

Yes. The 2026 Lee County roll records a garage on all 115 Governors Island units and no carports, and listings describe a one-car garage. Every unit also has two baths. Guest parking and vehicle rules are in the declaration and the association’s rules, which a buyer receives during the contract review period.

Are Governors Island villas one story?

Yes. The county roll records every Governors Island unit as one story. The plans run from 1,080 to 1,286 heated square feet for the two-bedroom villas and 1,305 or 1,361 square feet for the three-bedroom villas, all with two baths, so owners live on a single level with no stairs.

Does Governors Island have a pool?

Yes. Governors Island has a community pool on its common grounds, and listings add a pool cabana, picnic area, sidewalks and street lights. There is no golf course, tennis, fitness center or clubhouse program on site, and no club membership or initiation fee. The pool is paid for through the condominium fee.

Do Governors Island buildings need milestone inspections or a SIRS?

No. Florida’s milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study laws, as narrowed by HB 913 in 2025, cover condominium buildings three or more habitable stories in height. Every Governors Island unit is one story on the county roll, so neither applies. Reserve, records and insurance rules under Chapter 718 still apply to the association.

Does Governors Island have a CDD?

No. The 2026 Lee County millage book for taxing district 047 lists no community development district or special district beyond the countywide ones, so a Governors Island tax bill carries no CDD assessment. The shared Big Pine Way road belongs to a separate maintenance organization; ask whether any charge for it appears in the estoppel certificate.

What schools serve Governors Island?

The School District of Lee County assigns schools by its enrollment zone map, not distance, so confirm an exact address with the district. The nearest public schools in a straight line are South Fort Myers High at 1.2 miles, Villas Elementary at 1.5 miles and Cypress Lake Middle at 2.3 miles.

How far is Governors Island from shopping and hospitals?

Governors Island is about 0.3 miles in a straight line from the Bell Tower Shops and Market Square, and listings call Bell Tower walking distance. Gulf Coast Medical Center is about 0.9 miles away, HealthPark Medical Center about 4.1 miles and Lee Memorial Hospital about 5.5 miles, measured in a straight line.

Governors Island or Pinebrook Woods?

Both sit off Big Pine Way behind Bell Tower. Governors Island is a condominium with villas of 1,080 to 1,361 square feet, listed fees of $555 to $589 and a 36-month median of $239,250. Pinebrook Woods is fee-simple villa homes of 1,362 to 1,614 square feet, listed fees of $530 to $655 and a 36-month median of $295,000.

Is Governors Island the same as Pinebrook Lakes?

No. Governors Island sits inside the Pinebrook Lakes tract but is a separate condominium with its own declaration and association. Pinebrook Lakes Condo is the tract’s original 1981 condominium of 56 units, mostly two-story. “Governors Island at Pinebrook Lakes” means Governors Island inside the tract, not a section of Pinebrook Lakes Condo.

What insurance does a Governors Island owner need?

A Governors Island owner carries an HO-6 policy for the interior, contents and liability, while listings say the association’s master policy covers the buildings including roofs through the fee. Flood insurance is optional in Zone X (shaded) but available. Ask the association for the master policy’s deductible and how a storm deductible would be shared.

Do I need association approval to buy in Governors Island?

Plan on it. A 2023 listing printed a $100 application fee and an interview for buyers. Ask the association for its current application, fee and timeline as soon as your offer is accepted, and set a closing date that leaves time for the review and interview.

Frequently Asked Questions About Governors Island, Seller Edition

Who is the best listing agent for Governors Island?

McGreevy and Comisar are the best listing agents for Governors Island because we price from Lee County’s recorded Governors Island sales of your plan and setting, market the single level, garage, gate and walk to Bell Tower, and answer the fee, flood and insurance questions before buyers ask. Our Domain Realty Group team has been the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012.

What is my Governors Island villa worth?

Your Governors Island villa’s value starts from the 9 qualified sales Lee County recorded in the 12 months to October 31, 2026, from $165,000 to $240,000 at a $210,000 median, adjusted for your plan, lake front or interior setting, condition and updates. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 for a valuation built on those sales.

What is a three-bedroom Governors Island villa worth in 2026?

Three-bedroom Governors Island villas sold 4 times in the 12 months to October 2026 at a $207,500 median, from $188,000 to $240,000. The 1,361 square foot plan’s newest sale was $240,000 for a lake front villa in December 2025. Condition and setting decide where your villa falls in that band.

What is a two-bedroom Governors Island villa worth?

Two-bedroom Governors Island villas sold 5 times in the 12 months to October 2026 at a $210,000 median, from $165,000 to $238,500. The 1,080 square foot plan recorded $165,000 in October 2026 and $210,000 twice in May and June 2026. Updates and setting move a villa within that range.

Do lake front Governors Island villas sell for more?

On the county’s values, lake front units carry a higher median just value, $206,641 against $176,197 for interior units. In recorded sales the gap was small over 36 months: 7 lake front sales at a $240,000 median and 13 interior sales at $238,500. Condition moved prices more than the view.

Is now a good time to sell in Governors Island?

It depends on your plans. The 2026 median to October, $195,000, is below 2023’s $285,000, so sellers who bought near the peak may wait, while owners who bought before 2020 hold large gains: the 2019 median was $168,000. With only a few Governors Island listings competing at once, a well-priced villa stands out.

How many Governors Island villas sell each year?

Between 3 and 10 qualified Governors Island sales a year since 2014 on the county record: 10 in 2023, 5 in 2024, 5 in 2025 and 7 in 2026 to October. Nine sales in the 12 months to October 2026 is 7.8 percent of the 115 units.

What did my Governors Island villa cost new?

The first recorded qualified Governors Island sales were the developer-era sales of 1985 to 1987: 12 in 1985 at a $94,900 median, from $69,900 to $102,900, 16 in 1986 at $92,900 and 15 in 1987 at $82,900. Your own deed history is on the Lee County Property Appraiser’s parcel record.

Why did Governors Island prices fall in 2026?

Governors Island prices followed the regional condominium market, where Southwest Florida condo prices fell 8 percent year over year in the second quarter of 2026. The Governors Island sample is small, 7 sales in 2026 to October, so a few sales of smaller units can move the median a long way. We price from your plan’s sales.

Does my plan change my price?

Yes. The six Governors Island plans run from 1,080 to 1,361 heated square feet, and the 2026 county values rise with size, from a $167,312 median for 1,080 square feet to $212,817 for 1,361. Recorded sales follow the same pattern over 36 months, with the largest plan’s sales reaching $345,000.

Should I renovate before selling?

Renovate only where the numbers work. Same-plan Governors Island sales span a wide band, so a dated villa and an updated one can sell tens of thousands of dollars apart. We compare the cost of paint, flooring, kitchen or bath work with recent sales of your plan before recommending any project.

Do impact windows add value to my Governors Island villa?

Impact windows and shutters help buyers on insurance and storm preparation, and some Governors Island listings highlight them. A wind mitigation report documents them and can lower the wind portion of a buyer’s insurance premium. We feature them in the listing and give buyers the report up front.

What does it cost to sell a Governors Island villa?

Expect the brokerage commission set in the listing agreement, documentary stamp tax on the deed, the owner’s title insurance policy by Lee County custom, prorated taxes and condominium fees, the estoppel fee and any repairs you agree to. We prepare a full net sheet before you list.

Do I need association approval to sell my Governors Island villa?

Your buyer needs association approval. A 2023 listing printed a $100 application fee and an interview. We start the application as soon as the contract is signed and build the review time into the closing date, so approval does not delay your sale.

What must I disclose when selling in Governors Island?

Florida sellers must disclose known material defects, and section 689.302 requires a flood disclosure covering flood insurance claims and federal flood assistance. Condominium contracts also carry the MISIRS-1 milestone and SIRS disclosure; for Governors Island it states that the buildings are one story and below the three-story threshold.

Does my buyer need flood insurance?

Not for a lender, because every Governors Island unit point sits in Zone X (shaded), outside the special flood hazard area. Many buyers still price flood cover. We give buyers the FEMA panel number, 12071C0436H, and the flood disclosure up front so the question does not slow the sale.

Can I sell my Governors Island villa to an investor?

Yes, but an investor buyer must accept the leasing rules. Dated listings printed a 365-day minimum lease and one lease a year, so a Governors Island villa suits annual-rental investors, not short-term rental buyers. We confirm the current leasing rules with the association before marketing to investors.

How long does a Governors Island sale take to close?

A Governors Island sale closes on the timeline in the contract, usually a few weeks for cash and longer for a financed buyer, but the association’s approval and interview often set the pace. Ordering the estoppel certificate and starting the application as soon as the contract is signed keeps the closing on schedule.

Should I sell my Governors Island villa furnished?

Sometimes. Furnished sales can appeal to buyers relocating from out of state, but furniture rarely adds much to the price. We list the furniture separately when it helps and price the villa itself on recorded sales, so the furniture never muddies the value.

Does my Governors Island villa need a wind mitigation report?

It is not required, but it helps. A wind mitigation report documents roof attachment, roof shape, shutters and impact windows, and Florida law requires insurers to credit qualifying features. Giving buyers the report up front makes their insurance quote easier and the sale smoother.

How do I find my Governors Island plan size?

Your plan size is on the Lee County Property Appraiser’s parcel record as heated area: 1,080, 1,154, 1,252 or 1,286 square feet for a two-bedroom villa and 1,305 or 1,361 for a three-bedroom villa. Listing square footage can be larger because it counts the lanai or garage.

Which declaration governs my Governors Island unit?

Every Governors Island unit is governed by the declaration of condominium recorded at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647, with its amendments, the bylaws and the association’s rules. The phase on your legal description, Phase I to IV or none, does not change the declaration that applies.

Will the condominium fee scare buyers?

Not when it is explained. At $555 to $589 a month in recent listings, the fee covers the building insurance including roofs, water, sewer, trash, cable, internet, lawn care and the pool. We show buyers what the fee replaces in their own budget, which turns it from a cost into a convenience.

How do Governors Island property taxes affect my buyer?

Your buyer’s taxes reset to market value on the January 1 after the sale, so they may pay more than you do. At the 2026 rate of 13.3623 mills, a non-homestead buyer pays about $1,336 per $100,000 of taxable value. A buyer who homesteads the villa takes $51,411 off the value in 2026 terms.

What do I owe in capital gains tax?

That depends on your gain and your use of the home. IRS Publication 523 explains the exclusion of up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 for married couples filing jointly, on a main home owned and lived in for two of the last five years. Ask your tax adviser about your own numbers.

Can I sell my Governors Island villa if it is in a trust or an LLC?

Yes. The trustee or the LLC’s authorized manager signs, and the title company asks for the trust or company documents. The county record since November 2023 holds 28 Governors Island deeds at $100 or less, the kind of nominal transfer used for trusts and family moves; those do not affect your value and are excluded from every median on this page.

How do you market a Governors Island villa?

We market a Governors Island villa with professional photography, drone video of the lakes, the gate and the walk to Bell Tower, a listing that answers the fee, flood and condo-law questions, and outreach to our qualified-buyer database. We price from recorded sales of your plan so the villa shows well against the competition from day one.

Does the roof history matter to my sale?

Yes. Buyers and insurers ask the age of the roof over a Governors Island unit, and the association, not the owner, typically replaces the building roof. We ask the association for the roof replacement date of your building before listing and put it in the buyer’s packet.

Can I sell my Governors Island villa myself?

You can, but the details sink many owner sales: association approval, the estoppel certificate, the condominium disclosures, the flood disclosure and pricing from a thin set of recorded sales. We handle those for you and reach far more buyers than a sign in the yard.

Is Governors Island priced differently from Pinebrook Woods?

Yes. Pinebrook Woods’ fee-simple villa homes are larger and recorded a $295,000 median over 36 months, against Governors Island’s $239,250. Per heated square foot the two are close, $210 and $205. Buyers comparing them weigh the condominium fee and its bundled insurance against owning the lot.

How do I get a free valuation of my Governors Island villa?

Request a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. We build it from Lee County’s recorded Governors Island sales of your plan and setting, then check the Southwest Florida MLS for active and pending competition. Confidential conversations are welcome.

Sources and Authoritative References

The sources below are the primary records behind every Governors Island figure on this page: the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, millage book and recorded sales (roll exported November 1, 2026, sales index built November 18, 2026), the Florida Department of Revenue tax rolls, the State condominium register, Lee County GIS layers, FEMA, USGS, the School District of Lee County, FDOT, news reporting and the Florida Statutes. This edition prints no MLS statistics; listing-reported fees and rules are labeled with their dates.

County, tax and parcel records

Source

Publisher

What it supports

Tax roll and data downloads

Lee County Property Appraiser

2026 roll, values, years built, sizes

Property Appraiser home

Lee County Property Appraiser

Online parcel inquiry

Parcel data download (ZIP)

Lee County Property Appraiser

115 units, plans, garages, stories, land use

Sale data file, 2026 (TXT)

Lee County Property Appraiser

Recorded 2026 sales

Sale data file, 2025 (TXT)

Lee County Property Appraiser

Recorded 2025 sales

Sale data files, earlier years

Lee County Property Appraiser

Price history since 1985

Parcel display, Governors Island common elements

Lee County Property Appraiser

Common elements, about 17.87 acres

2026 Taxing District Millage Book (PDF)

Lee County Property Appraiser

District 047, 13.3623 mills adopted

Property tax data portal

Florida Department of Revenue

2025 and 2026 tax rolls

Property tax exemptions

Florida Department of Revenue

Homestead exemption

Lee County parcels layer

Lee County GIS

Parcel outlines

Subdivisions layer

Lee County GIS

Gated Pinebrook Lakes tract, 171 condominium units

Official Records search

Lee County Clerk of Court

Declaration at OR Book 1751, Page 2647

Lee County Tax Collector

Lee County Tax Collector

Tax bill, non-ad valorem section

Corporation search

Florida Department of State

Association filings

FHA condominium approval lookup

U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development

FHA approval by condominium

Census geocoder

US Census Bureau

Census tract 16.01

State condominium records and condominium law guidance

Source

Publisher

What it supports

Condominium register public extract (CSV)

Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums

Governors Island Condo, project PR1P014887, recorded August 22, 1984; Pinebrook Lakes, 56 units

DBPR licensing and condominium records

Florida DBPR

Condominium and managing entity records

Milestone inspections and SIRS

Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums

Three-story threshold

SIRS reporting

Florida DBPR

SIRS database

Milestone Inspection and SIRS Disclosure, MISIRS-1 (PDF)

Florida Realtors

Seller disclosure form

Realtor-supported condo bill becomes law

Florida Realtors

HB 913, June 2025

October 2026 Florida condo market summary (PDF)

Florida Realtors

Statewide condominium market

SWFL Real Estate Third Quarter 2026 Report

FGCU Regional Economic Research Institute

Condo prices down 8 percent, sales up 17 percent, Q2 2026

Flood, storm and insurance records

Source

Publisher

What it supports

FEMA flood zones layer

Lee County GIS

Zone X (shaded) at all 116 parcel points

FEMA flood map panel index

Lee County GIS

Panel 12071C0436H, effective November 17, 2022

FIRM panel 12071C0436 (PDF)

Lee County GIS

The panel map

Evacuation zones layer

Lee County GIS

Evacuation Zone B, surge zone 2

Spot elevation layer

Lee County GIS

Elevations 5.0 to 15.2 feet

Flood Map Service Center

FEMA

Address flood map lookup

Flood maps

FEMA

Flood zone definitions

Risk Rating 2.0

FEMA

How flood premiums are set

Residential Condominium Building Association Policy, F-144 (PDF)

FEMA

Condominium building flood policy

FloodSmart

National Flood Insurance Program

Flood insurance basics

Citizens Property Insurance

Citizens Property Insurance

HO-6 and wind policy information

Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian (PDF)

National Hurricane Center

Ian landfall and surge, September 2022

Lee County issues mandatory evacuations in Zone A, partial in Zone B

WGCU

Ian evacuation orders, September 27, 2022

Evacuations ordered ahead of Hurricane Milton (PDF)

Lee County

Milton evacuation orders, October 7, 2024

Hurricane Milton evacuations, full list by county

Patch

Milton evacuation orders

Hurricane Milton by the numbers

WUSF

Fort Myers gauge in Ian, Helene and Milton

Storm Events Database

NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information

Storm event records

Florida Division of Emergency Management

State of Florida

Evacuation planning

USGS NAIPPlus imagery service

USDA NAIP via USGS

Hero aerial

Schools, hospitals, roads and location

Source

Publisher

What it supports

School zones

School District of Lee County

Address-based school assignment

School District of Lee County

School District of Lee County

Enrollment and choice

Schools layer

Lee County GIS

School locations and distances

Hospitals layer

Lee County GIS

Hospital locations and distances

School district looks to make changes to student enrollment process

Fort Myers Beach Talk

2026 to 2027 enrollment proposals

I-75 at Daniels Parkway interchange, project 446296-2

Florida Department of Transportation

Diverging diamond rebuild

Diverging diamond interchange coming to Exit 131 by 2028

96K Rock

Construction start January 2026

Madison Marquette transforming iconic Florida center

Madison Marquette

Bell Tower Shops redevelopment

Dave and Buster’s to open at Bell Tower Shops

Madison Marquette

Former Saks Fifth Avenue space

The Bell Tower Shops

MallsCenters

Bell Tower tenants

Florida Statutes, legislation and federal guidance

Source

Publisher

What it supports

Chapter 718, Condominiums

The Florida Senate

Condominium Act

Section 718.111, association powers, records and insurance

The Florida Senate

Official records, insurance, website rule

Section 718.112, bylaws and reserves

The Florida Senate

Budgets, reserves, director education

Section 718.116, assessments and estoppel

The Florida Senate

Estoppel certificate

Section 718.503, disclosure prior to sale

The Florida Senate

Resale documents

Section 553.899, milestone inspections

The Florida Senate

Milestone inspection rule

CS/CS/HB 913 (2025) bill summary

The Florida Senate

Habitable-story threshold, reserve changes

HB 1021 (2024) bill summary

The Florida Senate

Website rule for 25 or more units, director education

Section 689.302, flood disclosure

The Florida Senate

Seller flood disclosure

Section 201.02, documentary stamp tax

The Florida Senate

Deed stamp tax

Section 196.031, homestead exemption

The Florida Senate

Homestead exemption

Section 193.155, homestead assessments

The Florida Senate

Assessment cap and reset after sale

Section 627.711, wind mitigation

The Florida Senate

Mitigation credits

Publication 523, Selling Your Home

Internal Revenue Service

Home-sale exclusion

Downloadable Documents

Governors Island’s downloadable documents are public records a buyer or seller uses in a Governors Island transaction, each linked to the publisher’s own copy: the Lee County millage book, the FEMA panel map and condominium flood policy form, the Florida Senate summaries of the 2024 and 2025 condominium laws, the DBPR milestone and SIRS guidance, the Florida Realtors disclosure form, the National Hurricane Center’s Ian report and the IRS home-sale guide.

Document

Publisher

Date

Link

2026 Taxing District Millage Book (PDF)

Lee County Property Appraiser

2026

Download

FIRM panel 12071C0436 (PDF)

Lee County GIS, from FEMA

effective November 17, 2022

Download

Residential Condominium Building Association Policy, F-144 (PDF)

FEMA

2021

Download

CS/CS/HB 913 bill summary

The Florida Senate

2025

Read

HB 1021 bill summary

The Florida Senate

2024

Read

Milestone inspections and SIRS guidance

Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums

current

Read

Milestone Inspection and SIRS Disclosure, MISIRS-1 (PDF)

Florida Realtors

2025

Download

Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian (PDF)

National Hurricane Center

storm of September 2022

Download

Publication 523, Selling Your Home

Internal Revenue Service

current edition

Read

Market data from the Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 parcel roll exported November 1, 2026, the Florida Department of Revenue 2025 and 2026 tax rolls for Lee County and the Lee County sale data files indexed November 18, 2026; newest recorded Governors Island sale October 5, 2026. Data updated: November 2026. Southwest Florida MLS statistics were not pulled for this edition. Governors Island is recorded as one condominium, declared at Official Records Book 1751, Page 2647; its unit count on this page is the Lee County roll’s. Listing-reported fees, rules and features are labeled as such. This guide is general information about Governors Island in Fort Myers, not an appraisal and not legal, tax or insurance advice. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.

McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Governors Island. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.


Work With Us

Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.