Admirals Bay

Admirals Bay

Admirals Bay is a 38-unit, two-story condominium on Island Pines Way at the south end of Fort Myers Beach, built in 1987 and 1991, with 811 square foot two-bedroom flats and shared pools. Sell, value or buy with McGreevy and Comisar.

Search Homes

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.

Admirals Bay is a two-building, two-story condominium of 38 units at 22676 and 22652 Island Pines Way, on the bay side of Estero Boulevard at the quiet south end of Estero Island, in the Town of Fort Myers Beach, ZIP 33931, Lee County. Florida's condominium division lists it as Admiral's Bay, a Condo [3][2][7]. McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

Here is the short answer most Admirals Bay searchers need: every unit on the county roll is a two-bedroom, two-bath flat of 811 square feet, the buildings date from 1987 and 1991, the three qualified sales after Hurricane Ian ran $363,500 to $389,000, and the site sits in FEMA Zone AE with an 11 foot base flood elevation [1][2][10].

Why McGreevy and Comisar Are the Best Realtor for Admirals Bay

McGreevy and Comisar are the best realtor for Admirals Bay because a 38-unit, two-story complex of identical 811 square foot flats, with shared common elements, three management names on public records and no qualified sale since October 2023, has to be priced from the county record and the association paperwork, and the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012 reads both first.

If you're searching for the best realtor for Admirals Bay in Fort Myers Beach, Florida, whether you own a unit on Island Pines Way and may want to sell or you want to buy one of the lowest entry prices for a condo on Estero Island, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Nationally since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. Buyers and sellers comparing the best real estate agents in Fort Myers Beach should ask each agent to explain Admirals Bay from the public record, and we do that below.

Admirals Bay market record (public sources): Lee County shows 68 qualified sales since 1991 with a median of $190,850. After Ian, unit 152 sold for $389,000 on May 19, 2023, unit 142 for $380,000 on July 5, 2023 and unit 1411 for $363,500 on October 13, 2023, about $448 to $480 per heated square foot [1].

For Admirals Bay buyers: the first question is which floor, because 19 units sit on the ground floor and 19 on the second, and the ground sits about 5 feet below the base flood elevation [1][8][10]. The second is the association record: the budget, the reserves, the master insurance policy and any storm or roof assessment, none of which is published [3][34]. The third is rental use, because the complex is not on the Town's 2026 condominium opt-out list [51].

For Admirals Bay sellers: every unit has the same 811 square foot plan, so your floor, your building, your condition and the storm repair record set the number. We price from the recorded Admirals Bay sales and the neighboring Island Pines Way condominiums, not from an automated estimate [1][2].

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Selling your Admirals Bay condo? Get a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. You can also read our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers Beach.

Buying at Admirals Bay? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida.

Key Takeaways

Admirals Bay in brief: a small, low-rise condominium on Island Pines Way at the south end of Fort Myers Beach, with every figure below traced to the Lee County Property Appraiser and county GIS, Florida DBPR, FEMA, the Town of Fort Myers Beach, Florida law and news reports, and with anything not confirmed labelled as unverified [1][2][3][16].

  • What it is: Admiral's Bay, a Condo, 38 units in two two-story buildings, declaration recorded July 9, 1990 at Official Records Book 2160, Page 4478 [3][1][5].
  • Built: 1987 for the 22-unit building at 22676 Island Pines Way, originally part of Bac-Bay Health and Racquet Club, and 1991 for the 16-unit Phase II building at 22652 [1][2].
  • One floor plan: two bedrooms, two baths, 811 square feet of heated area in every unit on the roll [1][2].
  • Prices: 68 qualified sales since 1991, median $190,850; after Ian, $363,500 to $389,000 in 2023 [1].
  • Flood: FEMA Zone AE, base flood elevation 11 feet NAVD88, ground about 5.6 to 6.4 feet; Lee County evacuation zone A [10][8][14].
  • Condo law: two stories on the county roll, so the milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study laws appear not to apply (unverified) [32][33][2].
  • Rentals: not on the Town's 2026 condominium opt-out list; each unit registers with the Town, $400 per unit for 2027 [51][48].
  • Fees: no association budget or fee schedule is published; ask for the budget and the estoppel certificate [3][4].

What Is Admirals Bay, and How Is It Different From Bac-Bay Next Door?

Admirals Bay is a 38-unit condominium in two low-rise buildings on Island Pines Way, separate from the older Bac-Bay Health and Racquet Club next door even though they share common grounds. The 22676 building was Bac-Bay's sixth building before it was re-declared into Admiral's Bay in 1990, which is why unit legal descriptions still read formerly known as Bac Bay Health and Racquet Club [1][2][3].

Fact

Admirals Bay

Source

Addresses

22676 and 22652 Island Pines Way, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

[1][7]

Government

Town of Fort Myers Beach taxing district, Lee County; Fort Myers Beach Fire District

[2][56]

Legal name (state file)

Admiral's Bay, a Condo; DBPR project PR1P021528, file 53125

[3]

Declaration

Recorded July 9, 1990; Official Records Book 2160, Page 4478

[3][5]

Phase II common elements

Official Records Book 2262, Page 2055; 0.95 acre

[1][2]

Buildings

Two residential buildings, two stories each

[2]

Units

38 (22 at 22676, 16 at 22652)

[3][1]

Association

Admiral's Bay Assn Inc (DBPR managing entity MA00019989)

[3]

Is Bac-Bay part of Admirals Bay?

No. Bac-Bay Health and Racquet Club is a separate condominium recorded December 1, 1983, with two remaining buildings at 22772 and 22796 Island Pines Way holding 16 units of the same 811 square foot plan on the roll. The state file shows 22 units for Bac-Bay, a gap not resolved [3][1][2].

Who manages the association?

Public records name three managers. DBPR lists Admiral's Bay Assn Inc in care of P & M Property Management, 2830 Winkler Avenue, Fort Myers; the Phase II common elements are mailed in care of Bensons Inc; and the shared Bac-Bay common elements go to Sentry Management. Ask the seller which one manages your building today [3][2].

Can I look up the association on Sunbiz?

Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-21). The state corporations search returned an error to our research on November 11, 2026, so the document number, officers and registered agent of Admiral's Bay Assn Inc should be confirmed by hand [6][3].

Where Is Admirals Bay, and How Far Is Everything?

Admirals Bay sits on Island Pines Way, which runs east off Estero Boulevard on the bay side of the south end of Estero Island. Santini Marina Plaza is about 0.3 mile by road, Lovers Key State Park about 3.3 miles over the Big Carlos Pass Bridge, and Times Square about 4.6 miles to the north [9][7][2].

Destination

Miles

Minutes (free flow)

Source

Santini Marina Plaza, 7205 Estero Blvd

0.3

2

[9][74]

Lovers Key State Park, via Big Carlos Pass Bridge

3.3

9

[9]

Times Square, north end of Estero Island

4.6

14

[9]

I-75 exit 116, Bonita Beach Road

13.7

28

[9]

Coconut Point, Estero

15.4

30

[9]

Southwest Florida International Airport

21.9

45

[9]

Downtown Fort Myers

19.2

41

[9]

HealthPark Medical Center (approximate point, unverified)

11.4

27

[9]

How close is the Gulf beach?

Listing remarks describe Gulf beach access across the street. The nearest Gulf-front parcels, Sandarac at 6666 Estero Boulevard and Sand Caper at 6902, have centroids about 0.23 to 0.25 mile from the complex; the actual walk to the sand and the access point are unverified [72][71][2].

How do you get on and off the island from here?

The south end is served by the Big Carlos Pass Bridge to Lovers Key, whose new fixed span opened to traffic on November 14, 2025 with 60 feet of clearance, at about $90.8 million, and a ribbon cutting followed in 2026 [64][65].

What shopping is nearby?

Santini Marina Plaza, about 70,000 square feet of shops and restaurants, is about 0.3 mile away. A CVS at 7001 Estero Boulevard and a Publix at 4791 Estero Boulevard are on the island, and the Town trolley runs on Estero Boulevard [74][9][56].

How Was Admirals Bay Built? Phases, Dates and the Declaration

Admirals Bay was assembled in two steps: a 1987 building that began as Bac-Bay's sixth building was re-declared as Admiral's Bay in July 1990, and a Phase II building followed in 1991, with its first sales closing from December 1991 to March 1992. The developer or converter is not named in any public source, and the work predates the Town's 1995 incorporation [1][2][3][5][57].

Date

Event

Source

December 1, 1983

Bac-Bay Health and Racquet Club, a Condominium, recorded with DBPR

[3]

1987

Building now at 22676 Island Pines Way built as Bac-Bay's sixth building

[1][2]

July 9, 1990

Admiral's Bay, a Condo declaration recorded, Official Records Book 2160, Page 4478

[3][5]

July 1990 to August 1991

First transfers in the 22676 building, $50,000 to $91,400, flagged not qualified

[1]

1991

Phase II building at 22652 completed; common elements at Book 2262, Page 2055

[1][2]

December 1991 to March 1992

Five builder-direct Phase II sales, $91,600 to $92,100

[1]

September 28, 2022

Hurricane Ian; both buildings remain on the roll with original build years

[2][22]

October 13, 2023

Newest qualified sale on the county file, unit 1411 at $363,500

[1]

Who developed Admirals Bay?

Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-21). The developer or converter is not named in any public source our research read; it would appear as grantor on the 1990 to 1992 deeds in the Lee County Clerk's official records [5][1].

Was Admirals Bay torn down after Ian?

No. Both buildings remain on the county roll with their original 1987 and 1991 build years and no new-construction flag, so there was no demolition or rebuild [2].

What Units Are in Admirals Bay? Floors, Numbers and Sizes

Every Admirals Bay unit on the county roll is the same plan, a two-bedroom, two-bath stacked flat of 811 square feet of heated area, on either the ground floor or the second floor; 19 units sit on each floor. Listing sites that quote up to 1,095 square feet are mixing in a size from neighboring Captain's Bay South [1][2][71].

Building

Built

Units

Ground floor

Second floor

Source

22676 Island Pines Way (Phase I)

1987

22

141 to 149, 1410, 1411

241 to 249, 2410, 2411

[1][2]

22652 Island Pines Way (Phase II)

1991

16

151 to 158

251 to 258

[1][2]

How do the unit numbers work?

Units starting with 1 are on the ground floor and units starting with 2 are on the second floor. The 22676 building has 11 units per floor and the 22652 building has eight per floor [1][2].

Why does the floor matter so much here?

The ground sits at about 5.6 to 6.4 feet NAVD88 against an 11 foot base flood elevation, so ground-floor units carry the most flood exposure. Lowest-floor elevations are not published, so ask for the building's elevation certificate [8][10][17].

What Is It Like Living at Admirals Bay? Amenities and Daily Life

Living at Admirals Bay means a quiet, low-rise complex on a side street at the south end of the island, with shared pools on the common grounds and the Gulf beach across Estero Boulevard. The county roll shows a pool on the shared Bac-Bay and Admiral Bay Phase I common elements and a 1991 pool on an Island Pines recreation tract [2][72].

  • Pools: a pool on the shared common elements and Recreation Area #5 Pool, a 0.09 acre Island Pines tract built in 1991; listing remarks describe two heated pools (unverified) [2][70][72].
  • Recreation: listing remarks also mention two tennis courts, shuffleboard, a tiki hut with grills, a fitness center and a clubhouse, each unverified [70][71][72].
  • Bay tracts: the Island Pines Recreational Assn owns a 2.73 acre recreational common area on the bay [2].
  • Restoration: listing remarks describe new roofs and freshly paved streets; dates and scope are unverified [72].
  • Not there: no golf, no bundled golf and no marina or boat slips on the roll for Admirals Bay [2].

Are pets allowed?

Aggregators show pets allowed, but the declaration's pet rules are not public. The recorded declaration and the association's rules control, so read them before you buy [70][71][5].

Admirals Bay Market Snapshot: What Do Condos Sell For?

Lee County shows 68 qualified Admirals Bay sales since December 1991, median $190,850, from $76,000 in 1997 to $389,000 in 2023. The three qualified sales after Hurricane Ian, in May, July and October 2023, ran $363,500 to $389,000 with a $380,000 median, above the pre-storm 2019 to 2022 median of $272,450 [1].

Data updated: November 2026. We tracked every qualified and unqualified Admirals Bay sale on the Lee County public sales file read November 11, 2026, plus the county GIS roll, to build the tables below.

Group

Sales

Median

Low

High

Source

All qualified, since December 1991

68

$190,850

$76,000

$389,000

[1]

Builder-direct first sales, Phase II

5

$91,800

$91,600

$92,100

[1]

Resales

63

$205,000

$76,000

$389,000

[1]

2019 to Ian (September 27, 2022)

10

$272,450

$248,000

$300,000

[1]

After Ian (2023)

3

$380,000

$363,500

$389,000

[1]

What sold after Hurricane Ian?

Unit 152 sold for $389,000 on May 19, 2023, unit 142 for $380,000 on July 5, 2023 and unit 1411 for $363,500 on October 13, 2023, about $448 to $480 per heated square foot [1].

Were there other sales the county did not count?

Yes. Unit 1410 sold for $349,000 on March 9, 2023, unit 241 for $389,000 on March 22, 2023 and unit 255 for $375,000 on July 26, 2024, all flagged unqualified. Later transfers through May 2025 were nominal $0 or $100 deeds [1].

Why has there been no qualified sale since October 2023?

No public record explains it. Neighboring Captain's Bay South recorded 11 qualified sales in the 36 months to July 30, 2026, so the gap is specific to this complex, not the street. Owner turnover, condition and the unqualified July 2024 sale are all possible factors (unverified) [1].

How have prices moved over time?

Qualified-sale medians ran $97,750 for 1991 to 1999 (18 sales), $301,750 for 2005 to 2007 (6), $188,700 for 2008 to 2012 (7), $205,000 for 2013 to 2018 (15), $272,450 for 2019 to Ian (10) and $380,000 after Ian (3) [1].

What does the county say the units are worth?

The current county GIS roll gives just values of $241,663 to $256,696 per unit, median $244,182, and $9,285,416 across all 38 units; three units carry a homestead exemption. The roll year of the GIS layer is not stated, and just value is a tax figure, not a sale price [2].

What Are the HOA Fees and Taxes at Admirals Bay?

No Admirals Bay budget, fee schedule or estoppel figure is published by the association or DBPR. Listing remarks say dues cover insurance, water, sewer, trash, pest control and grounds, but no figure is reproduced here. Property tax at the Town's 2025 millage of 13.4329 on the median just value is about $3,280 a year before exemptions [3][72][43][2].

Charge

Amount

Status

Source

Condominium association fee

Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-21)

No public budget

[3][4]

Aggregator dues estimate

About $50 a month, an estimate

Not credible for a 1987 coastal condo; ignore

[71]

Special assessments (Ian, roofs, paving)

None found in public records

Unverified; the estoppel must disclose them

[72][34]

CDD

None found

Town of Fort Myers Beach taxing district

[2]

Town district millage, 2025 final

13.4329 mills

Lee County millage book

[43]

Example tax on the median just value of $244,182

About $3,280 a year before exemptions

Estimate; taxable value unverified

[2][43]

Town short-term rental registration

$400 per unit for 2027

If renting short term

[48]

Capital contribution, transfer or application fee

Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-21)

Not published

[3]

  • Homestead: the homestead exemption and the Save Our Homes cap apply to a permanent residence, so a buyer's first bill can differ from the seller's [41][42].
  • Look it up: the Lee County Tax Collector shows each unit's bill, including any special district lines [44].

Should I expect special assessments?

None was found in public records, but listing remarks mention new roofs and paving after the storm. Ask the association for its minutes and the estoppel certificate, which must disclose any assessment owed [72][34].

Is Admirals Bay in a Flood Zone?

Yes. FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer puts both Admirals Bay buildings in Zone AE, coastal floodplain, with a static base flood elevation of 11 feet NAVD88 on panel 12071C0567G, effective November 17, 2022. USGS lidar puts the ground at about 5.6 to 6.4 feet, roughly 5 feet below that line [10][11][8].

Item

Figure

Source

FEMA zone

AE, coastal floodplain, at both buildings and two nearby points

[10]

Base flood elevation

11 ft NAVD88 (static)

[10]

FIRM panel and date

12071C0567G, effective November 17, 2022

[11][16]

Ground elevation

About 5.6 ft (22676) and 6.4 ft (22652) NAVD88, lidar

[8]

Evacuation zone

Lee County zone A

[14][15]

NFIP discount

Community Rating System Class 5, 25 percent, confirmed December 2025

[20][21]

  • An indication, not a determination: a point query is a screen; get the building's elevation certificate, which the Town posts by street [10][17].
  • Find My Flood Zone: FEMA's Map Service Center gives the official panel for any address [12].
  • Discount restored: the Town returned to Class 5 in December 2025 after a post-Ian probation, restoring a 25 percent NFIP discount [20][21].

Do I need flood insurance?

A lender will require flood coverage on a mortgaged unit in Zone AE. Whether the association's master policy carries flood is not public, and Florida law makes association flood coverage optional, so ask before you bind your own [13][34][47].

What does the 50 percent rule mean here?

Buildings below the base flood elevation that are substantially damaged or improved, at 50 percent or more of value, must be brought up to current flood rules. Ask whether the Town made any substantial damage determination for these buildings after Ian (unverified) [18][19].

How Did Admirals Bay Come Through Hurricane Ian, Helene and Milton?

No news report names Admirals Bay, so its storm record is indirect: Ian brought 10 to 15 feet of inundation to Fort Myers Beach, which against ground near 5.6 to 6.4 feet implies several feet of water at grade, an inference, not a measurement. Both buildings survived on the roll and units resold above pre-storm prices in 2023 [22][23][8][2][1].

What did Ian do to Fort Myers Beach?

Hurricane Ian struck on September 28, 2022. The National Hurricane Center put peak inundation at 10 to 15 feet above ground on Fort Myers Beach and counted about 900 structures destroyed and 2,200 damaged there, as reported. USGS marks within about 0.7 mile of Bay Beach Lane, about a mile southeast, read 11.6 to 12.7 feet NAVD88 [22][23][24].

What did Helene and Milton do in 2024?

On September 26, 2024, Helene gave Fort Myers its second-highest recorded water level, 5.12 feet, and Town officials reported water lines up to 4 feet in island homes. For Milton, on October 9 to 10, an on-island reporter estimated 5 to 6 feet of surge, below the 8 to 10 foot forecast [25][26][27][31][30].

Is the post-Ian repair finished?

Unverified. Signs of recovery include qualified sales in May, July and October 2023 above the pre-Ian peak, an unqualified $375,000 sale in July 2024, both original buildings on the roll and listing remarks about new roofs and paving. Ask for the association minutes and Town permit history for both addresses [1][2][72][18].

What Do Florida's Condo Safety Laws Mean for Admirals Bay?

Florida's milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study laws apply to condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories, and the county lists both Admirals Bay buildings at two stories, so they appear exempt. That is a real difference from five-story Captain's Bay South next door; confirm the habitable story count with the association [32][33][2].

Requirement

What it means here

Status

Source

Milestone inspection (section 553.899)

Applies to buildings three habitable stories or more

Appears not to apply; two stories on the roll (unverified)

[32][2]

Structural integrity reserve study (section 718.112(2)(g))

Three-plus-story buildings; deadline December 31, 2025

Appears not to apply (unverified)

[33][36][37]

Ordinary reserves (section 718.112(2)(f))

Still apply to every association

Waiver status unverified

[33]

Association website (section 718.111(12)(g))

Required for associations of 25 or more units; Admirals Bay has 38

No website found (unverified); effective date unverified

[34][3]

Property insurance (section 718.111(11))

Replacement-cost appraisal at least every 3 years; association flood optional

Master flood coverage not public

[34]

What should a buyer ask for?

The current budget, the reserve schedule, the insurance declarations with any flood coverage, the minutes since 2022, the roof and repair permits and the estoppel certificate [33][34][18].

Does the law give a buyer time to review documents?

Yes. Florida's resale disclosure section gives a condominium buyer a review window, 7 days on a resale, or 15 days where a milestone summary or reserve study applies; read the contract's condominium rider and the statute [35].

What Should Admirals Bay Owners Know About Insurance?

Admirals Bay owners need a unit HO-6 policy, and in Zone AE a mortgaged unit needs flood coverage. Florida law requires the association to insure the buildings at replacement cost, appraised at least every 3 years, but master flood coverage is optional and its status here is not public, so read the master declarations first [34][10][13].

  • Master policy: listing remarks say dues include insurance; ask for the declarations page and the deductible [72][34].
  • Flood: FEMA rates each policy individually under Risk Rating, and the Town's Class 5 rating cuts NFIP premiums 25 percent [13][21].
  • Wind mitigation: the state form OIR-B1-1802 was revised effective April 1, 2026 per Citizens; ask for any roof and opening documentation [45][46].

Can You Rent Out an Admirals Bay Condo?

Yes, with Town registration. Admirals Bay is not on the Town of Fort Myers Beach 2026 condominium opt-out list, so each unit registers on its own, at $400 per unit for 2027, during a window from November 15 to December 15, 2026, and units are already marketed on booking sites. The declaration's lease minimums are not public [51][48][73].

  • Town rules: Ordinance 18-01 and Land Development Code sections 34-2391 to 34-2394; weekly (3 to 7 day) or monthly (3 to 29 day) rules depend on zoning [49][50][55][48].
  • Enforcement: the Town began issuing violation notices in January 2026 and warning letters in May 2026 [53][54].
  • Opt-out: condominium opt-out is decided building by building; Captain's Bay North Two on the same street is on the 2026 list, Admirals Bay is not [52][51].

Is Admirals Bay on the Town's opt-out list?

No. A search of the 2026 list on November 11, 2026 found no Admiral, Bac-Bay, Island Pines, 22652 or 22676 entry [51].

Are units already rented short term?

Yes. Admirals Bay units are listed on a travel booking platform under names such as Admirals Bay 153, 255 and 1410 [73].

Which Schools Serve Admirals Bay?

Lee County School District's 2026-27 proximity zones put Admirals Bay in elementary zone T, middle zone MM and high zone South 4. Fort Myers Beach Elementary has been closed since Hurricane Milton in 2024, with students attending Heights Elementary in Fort Myers, so confirm the assigned schools with Student Enrollment at 239-337-8247 [58][59][62].

  • Charter plan: on May 12, 2026 the School Board voted unanimously for an interlocal agreement giving the school to the Town for a charter school, subject to Town Council approval [60].
  • Committees: in August 2026 the Town moved to form six committees for the state charter application [61].
  • School within a school: displaced students attended Heights Elementary as a school within a school, earlier San Carlos Park Elementary [62][63].
  • Private schools: not researched for this complex [59].

What Is Changing Around Admirals Bay?

Several changes matter at the south end: the new Big Carlos Pass Bridge opened on November 14, 2025, Fire Station 31 opened on April 2, 2026, the pier rebuild broke ground on August 21, 2026, and the Town began enforcing rental registration in January 2026. Admirals Bay itself has no 2025 or 2026 news [64][66][67][53][1].

What else is being rebuilt on the island?

Bowditch Point Park closed on September 8, 2026 for a $3.9 million restoration, and residents describe constant post-Ian construction island wide [68][69].

Admirals Bay vs Captains Bay South: How Do They Compare?

Buyers who look at Admirals Bay usually compare it with Captains Bay South next door, and the honest differences are size, height and condo law: Admirals Bay is 38 units of 811 square feet in two-story buildings, while Captains Bay South is 75 larger units in five-story buildings that fall under the milestone and reserve study rules [1][3][32].

Yardstick

Admirals Bay

Captains Bay South

Source

Units

38

75

[3][1]

Buildings

Two, two stories

Five, five stories

[2][1]

Built

1987 and 1991

1995 to 1997

[1]

Unit size

811 sq ft, 2 bed, 2 bath

1,073 to 1,239 sq ft

[1]

Recent qualified median

$380,000 (3 sales, 2023)

$400,000 (11 sales in 36 months)

[1]

Recent range

$363,500 to $389,000

$315,000 to $615,000

[1]

Milestone and reserve study

Appear not to apply

Apply

[32][33]

Which one gives more space for the money?

Captains Bay South, by size: its units run 1,073 to 1,239 square feet against 811 at Admirals Bay, while recent medians are close at $400,000 and $380,000. Admirals Bay's sample is three 2023 sales, so the comparison is thin [1].

How Does Admirals Bay Compare With Other Estero Island Condos?

Beyond Captains Bay South, buyers compare Admirals Bay with Bac-Bay next door, Estero Bayside at the end of the street and the Gulf-front Sandarac and Sand Caper across Estero Boulevard. Admirals Bay holds one of the lowest entry prices of the group, with smaller units and no Gulf frontage [1][2][3].

Community

Type

Honest difference

Source

Admirals Bay

38 units, 1987 and 1991, two stories

811 sq ft 2/2; 2023 qualified sales $363,500 to $389,000

[1]

Bac-Bay Health and Racquet Club

Same street, 1983, 16 units on the roll

Same 811 sq ft plan; qualified median $84,000; newest qualified sale May 14, 2021

[1][2][3]

Estero Bayside

2006 mid-rise, 45 units

1,501 to 2,226 sq ft; 60-month qualified median $775,000 (11 sales)

[1][3]

Sand Caper, 6902 Estero Blvd

Gulf-front, 1979, about 61 units

1,078 to 1,224 sq ft; resale median $226,000, high $750,000

[1][2]

Sandarac, 6666 Estero Blvd

Gulf-front, 1979, 183 parcels

24-month qualified median $640,000 (13 sales)

[1][2]

Where can I read about other Estero Island communities?

Our guides cover Estero Bayside on the same street, the Bay Beach enclave and Grandview at Bay Beach about a mile southeast, Sea Grape Bay Condo and Leilani farther north, plus Estero Island Yacht and Racquet Club and Port Carlos Cove. Each guide uses the same public-record method [1].

What Are the Honest Pros and Cons of Admirals Bay?

McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and the lists below are our honest read of Admirals Bay from the county record, Florida DBPR, FEMA, the Town's flood and rental rules, Florida condominium law and news reports, so buyers and sellers can weigh it before a showing.

Pros

One of the lowest recorded entry prices for an Estero Island condo, a small 38-unit low-rise complex, two-story buildings that appear outside the milestone and reserve study rules, shared pools, the Gulf beach across the street, Santini Marina Plaza about 0.3 mile away and no Town rental opt-out [1][3][32][2][9][51].

Cons

Ground about 5 feet below the base flood elevation in Zone AE and evacuation zone A, 1987 and 1991 buildings, one 811 square foot two-bedroom plan, no boat slips, no Gulf frontage, no published budget, three manager names on record and no qualified sale since October 2023 [8][10][14][1][2][3].

Thinking of Selling Your Admirals Bay Condo? List With the #1 Team in Southwest Florida Since 2012

If you're searching for an Admirals Bay listing agent, or thinking, 'I need someone to sell my Admirals Bay condo...' start with the record: qualified sales of $389,000, $380,000 and $363,500 in 2023, an unqualified $375,000 sale in July 2024, a county median just value of $244,182 and no qualified sale since October 2023 [1] [2].

We tracked all 68 qualified Admirals Bay sales on the county file for this guide, because with one floor plan a buyer compares your unit directly with the last few sales, so we price from the floor, the building, the condition, the storm repair record and the association documents, not from an automated estimate.

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Admirals Bay Sales, by the Numbers

  • Unit 152: sold $389,000, May 19, 2023 [1].
  • Unit 142: sold $380,000, July 5, 2023 [1].
  • Unit 1411: sold $363,500, October 13, 2023 [1].
  • Unit 255: $375,000, July 26, 2024, recorded as unqualified [1].
  • Price per square foot: about $448 to $480 on the 2023 qualified sales [1].

Selling at Admirals Bay Is Different in Five Ways

  • One plan means direct comparison. Every unit is 811 square feet, so condition and floor carry the price [1].
  • The floor sets the buyer. Second-floor units sit above the flood line buyers worry about; ground-floor sellers should have the elevation certificate ready [8][17].
  • Storm history is disclosed. Florida's seller flood disclosure covers flood claims and federal assistance [38].
  • The association record comes first. Buyers ask for the budget, insurance and any assessments; the estoppel shows what is owed [34].
  • Rental status widens the pool. No Town opt-out means investors can register for short-term rental [51][48].

What Is Your Admirals Bay Condo Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds.

Start with a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation. Jesse follows up with a written range built from your floor, building, condition and the Admirals Bay sales that fit your unit.

(239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome. Our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers Beach walks through the sale step by step, and our Fort Myers Beach real estate hub covers the wider island market.

What closing costs does an Admirals Bay seller pay in Lee County?

A Florida seller customarily pays the documentary stamp tax on the deed [39], plus the brokerage fee, any mortgage payoff, prorated taxes and the association's estoppel fee. In Lee County the seller customarily pays the owner's title policy, and the contract controls [40].

Your Local Real Estate Experts

Admirals Bay sellers and buyers work directly with Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, who have sold Southwest Florida real estate for more than twenty years, lead Domain Realty Group, and read the Lee County roll, the county flood and evacuation layers, Town rules, Florida condominium law and the public sale records behind this guide.

You can read how the team was built on our about the McGreevy and Comisar team page. McGreevy and Comisar are the Domain Realty team behind this Admirals Bay guide: Jesse McGreevy leads on listings and pricing, and Marc Comisar leads on buyer representation across Southwest Florida. If you are comparing agents, see the best real estate agents in Fort Myers Beach.

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.

McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

What Our Clients Say

McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Admirals Bay realtor on Google, and the quotes below are genuine five star client reviews reproduced in the reviewer’s own words. We publish no aggregate score and no Admirals Bay testimonial we do not have.

★★★★★ “Not living in the area, Jesse made life easy for me when we decided to sell our condo. His attention to detail, patience, understanding, and tenacity in dealing with all the moving parts was truly impressive.” Eric Acra, verified Google review

★★★★★ “Their recommendation on pricing my unit was sound and proved prescient. I never questioned their integrity and found it easy to rely on their recommendations. I would work with them again in a heartbeat.” Charlie Carroll, verified Google review

★★★★★ “Working with Jesse and his team was truly an amazing experience. From the very beginning, they were professional, attentive, and incredibly knowledgeable. They guided us through every step of the process with patience and clarity, always making sure we felt comfortable and informed with every decision.” Leonardo Silva, verified Google review

Contact McGreevy and Comisar

  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 · [email protected]
  • Marc Comisar: (239) 457-1610
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Selling your Admirals Bay condo? Get a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

Buying at Admirals Bay? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida, or our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers Beach.

Licensure, and the Office of Record

Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission, and licenses can be verified with the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation. Florida law requires a brokerage relationship disclosure (s. 475.278, Florida Statutes).

  • Jesse McGreevy, Florida license SL3101296
  • Marc Comisar, Florida license BK3060671
  • Brokerage office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Frequently Asked Questions: Admirals Bay Buyer Edition

These are the Admirals Bay questions buyers ask most, each answered from the Lee County record, Florida DBPR, FEMA, the school district, Town rules and Florida condominium law cited on this page. Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 to tour both buildings and the shared grounds with us.

Where is Admirals Bay in Fort Myers Beach?

At 22652 and 22676 Island Pines Way, on the bay side of Estero Boulevard at the south end of Estero Island, inside the Town of Fort Myers Beach [2][7].

How many units does Admirals Bay have?

38: 22 in the 1987 building at 22676 and 16 in the 1991 building at 22652. A listing site's 48 is wrong [3][1][70].

When was Admirals Bay built?

1987 for 22676, originally Bac-Bay's sixth building, re-declared July 9, 1990, and 1991 for 22652 [1][3].

How big are Admirals Bay condos?

Every unit on the roll is two bedrooms, two baths and 811 square feet; 1,095 square feet belongs to Captain's Bay South [1][71].

What do Admirals Bay condos sell for?

68 qualified sales since 1991, median $190,850; three 2023 sales ran $363,500 to $389,000 [1].

Was Admirals Bay rebuilt after Ian?

No; both original buildings remain on the roll with 1987 and 1991 build years [2].

What flood zone is Admirals Bay in?

Zone AE, base flood elevation 11 feet NAVD88, panel 12071C0567G, effective November 17, 2022 [10][11].

Does Admirals Bay need a milestone inspection or SIRS?

It appears not, because both buildings are two stories on the roll; confirm with the association [32][33][2].

Can I rent short term?

Yes, with Town registration at $400 per unit for 2027; Admirals Bay is not on the opt-out list [48][51].

What are the HOA fees?

Not published; ask for the budget and estoppel certificate from Admiral's Bay Assn Inc [3][34].

Frequently Asked Questions: Admirals Bay Seller Edition

These are the questions Admirals Bay owners ask us, answered from the county record, Florida DBPR, Town rules and Florida law. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 for a number on your unit based on its floor, building, condition and the sales that fit it.

What is my Admirals Bay condo worth?

Start with a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation, then Jesse builds a range from the recorded Admirals Bay sales for your floor and building [1].

What did Admirals Bay units sell for in 2023?

$389,000 for unit 152 in May, $380,000 for unit 142 in July and $363,500 for unit 1411 in October [1].

What sold in 2024?

Unit 255 recorded at $375,000 on July 26, 2024, flagged unqualified [1].

Why is there no qualified sale since October 2023?

No public record explains it; later transfers were nominal deeds through May 2025 [1].

What is the price per square foot?

About $448 to $480 on the three 2023 qualified sales [1].

Is a second-floor unit worth more?

Buyers weigh flood exposure, and the ground floor sits below the base flood elevation; we price each floor from the sales [8][10][1].

Does the county value equal my selling price?

No; just value of $241,663 to $256,696 is a tax figure [2].

Does my building matter, 22676 or 22652?

Slightly; the full-history medians are $193,000 and $183,000 on identical plans [1].

Should I correct the 48-unit figure buyers see online?

Yes; the state file and county roll both show 38 units [3][1].

Should I correct the 1,095 square foot figure?

Yes; every Admirals Bay unit is 811 square feet on the roll [1][71].

Do I need a flood disclosure?

Yes; Florida's seller flood disclosure covers flood claims and federal assistance [38].

Will buyers ask about Ian?

Yes; share what the association repaired and when, including roofs and paving [72][22][19].

Will buyers ask about Helene and Milton?

Yes; both storms brought surge to the island in 2024 [28][29].

Will buyers ask for the elevation certificate?

Often, especially for ground-floor units; ask the association or the Town [17].

Do I need a milestone inspection to sell?

It appears not for these two-story buildings, but buyers may ask the association to confirm [32][2].

Will buyers ask about reserves?

Yes; ordinary reserve rules still apply to every association [33].

What will the estoppel certificate show?

What you owe the association, including any special assessment [34].

Which manager do I ask for the estoppel?

Confirm first; P & M Property Management, Bensons Inc and Sentry Management all appear on records [3][2].

Does the CRS discount help my sale?

Yes; the Town's Class 5 rating cuts NFIP premiums 25 percent [21].

Do new roofs help my sale?

Yes, with documents; roof dates can support wind mitigation credits [45][46].

Can I sell to an investor?

Yes; Admirals Bay is not on the Town's opt-out list, so a buyer can register for short-term rental [51][48].

Does my rental registration transfer?

No; the buyer registers as their own operator under the Town ordinance [48][49].

Who pays the documentary stamp tax?

In Florida the seller customarily pays it on the deed [39].

Who pays for the owner's title policy in Lee County?

The seller customarily, and the contract controls [40].

Can I keep my homestead savings when I move?

Portability can carry part of the Save Our Homes benefit to your next Florida home [42][41].

What will my buyer pay in property tax?

About $3,280 a year on the median just value at the Town's 2025 millage, before exemptions [43][2].

How do I find my unit's sale history?

The Lee County Property Appraiser's property search lists each recorded sale [1][5].

How many units sell in a year?

Few; there were three qualified sales in 2023 and none since [1].

Does Captains Bay South compete with my unit?

Partly; it had 11 qualified sales in 36 months at a $400,000 median with larger units [1].

Should I sell now or wait?

That depends on your plans; we price from the latest Admirals Bay sales for your floor [1].

Who should I call first about selling at Admirals Bay?

Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072. He will review your unit, floor and association documents against the recorded Admirals Bay sales, then give you a written price range. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

Sources and Authoritative References

Every fact in this Admirals Bay guide traces to a record below: the Lee County Property Appraiser and county GIS, Florida DBPR, FEMA, USGS, the Town of Fort Myers Beach, Florida statutes and agencies, the school district and news reports. No listing portal or brokerage site is linked, and the numbers match the bracket citations on this page.

  1. Lee County Property Appraiser, public sales records for Admirals Bay and Island Pines Way condominiums (read November 11, 2026)
  2. Lee County GIS, Lee County Parcels layer (Admirals Bay units and common elements)
  3. Florida DBPR, condominium project extract (Admiral's Bay, a Condo)
  4. Florida DBPR, Condominiums, Timeshares and Mobile Homes public records
  5. Lee County Clerk of Court, Official Records search
  6. Florida Division of Corporations, entity search (record not reachable to our research)
  7. U.S. Census Bureau geocoder, 22652 and 22676 Island Pines Way
  8. USGS Elevation Point Query Service (3DEP 1 meter lidar)
  9. OSRM public routing engine, free-flow drive estimates from Island Pines Way
  10. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, flood hazard zones
  11. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, FIRM panels (panel 12071C0567G)
  12. FEMA Flood Map Service Center (Find My Flood Zone)
  13. FEMA, Risk Rating flood insurance pricing
  14. Lee County GIS, Evacuation Zones layer
  15. WGCU, evacuations in Lee and Collier counties ahead of Hurricane Ian (September 27, 2022)
  16. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Flood Information
  17. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Elevation Certificates
  18. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Substantial Improvement and Substantial Damage
  19. Town of Fort Myers Beach, FEMA's 50% Rule
  20. Fort Myers Beach Talk, Fort Myers Beach to regain National Flood Insurance Program discount (December 2025)
  21. WGCU, FEMA confirms Fort Myers Beach earns CRS Class 5 rating (December 24, 2025)
  22. National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report AL092022, Hurricane Ian
  23. Insurance Journal, coverage of the National Hurricane Center's Hurricane Ian report (April 4, 2023)
  24. NPR, after Hurricane Ian, Fort Myers Beach struggles to become a functional paradise
  25. Fort Myers Beach Talk, widespread flooding from storm surge begins on Fort Myers Beach (October 2024)
  26. USA Today via AOL, Hurricane Helene storm surge spared few areas (2024)
  27. AccuWeather, Hurricane Milton aftermath
  28. National Weather Service Tampa Bay, Helene impact narratives
  29. National Weather Service Tampa Bay, Milton impact narratives
  30. CBS News Miami, Fort Myers Beach community rises and rebuilds after Ian, Helene and Milton
  31. Fox 4, Hurricane Helene brings mounds of sand to Estero Island
  32. Florida Statutes, section 553.899, milestone inspections
  33. Florida Statutes, section 718.112, reserves and structural integrity reserve studies
  34. Florida Statutes, section 718.111, insurance and official records
  35. Florida Statutes, section 718.503, resale disclosure
  36. Lowndes, Florida condo reform bill signed into law
  37. Florida DBPR, Condominiums and Cooperatives SIRS reporting
  38. Florida Statutes, seller flood disclosure
  39. Florida Statutes, documentary stamp tax on deeds
  40. Attorneys' Title Fund, who pays for title insurance
  41. Florida Department of Revenue, homestead exemption guide
  42. Florida Department of Revenue, Save Our Homes
  43. Lee County Property Appraiser, 2025 taxing district millage book
  44. Lee County Tax Collector, property tax bill lookup
  45. Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, wind mitigation resources
  46. Citizens Property Insurance, mitigation inspection form changes
  47. Citizens Property Insurance, flood coverage requirement
  48. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Short-Term Rental registration
  49. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Ordinance 18-01, Short-Term Rentals Regulation
  50. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Short-Term Rentals Code of Conduct
  51. Town of Fort Myers Beach, 2026 condominium rental opt-out list (searched November 11, 2026)
  52. Town of Fort Myers Beach, RentalScape update and condominium opt-out (civic alert)
  53. WGCU, Town of Fort Myers Beach to issue short-term rental violation notices (December 30, 2025)
  54. Fort Myers Beach Talk, warning letters over short-term rental registration (May 2026)
  55. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Code of Ordinances and Land Development Code
  56. Town of Fort Myers Beach, home page
  57. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Island History (1995 incorporation)
  58. Lee County GIS, School Proximity Zones 2026-27 layer
  59. School District of Lee County, school zones and Student Enrollment
  60. Fort Myers Beach Talk, School Board votes to give Fort Myers Beach Elementary to the Town (May 12, 2026)
  61. Fort Myers Beach Talk, Town officials seeking to create six charter school committees (August 2026)
  62. WGCU, Beach Elementary School future remains uncertain (October 8, 2025)
  63. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Fort Myers Beach Elementary and FEMA award (civic alert, August 2025)
  64. WGCU, new Big Carlos Pass Bridge to open to traffic November 14 (November 9, 2025)
  65. Superior Construction, Big Carlos Pass Bridge opening
  66. Fort Myers Beach Fire Control District, Fire Station 31 grand opening
  67. DeepArrival, Fort Myers Beach pier rebuild groundbreaking (August 2026)
  68. WGCU, parking closures at Bonita and Fort Myers Beach parks (September 9, 2026)
  69. WGCU, some Fort Myers Beach residents frustrated with constant development (February 5, 2025)
  70. Admirals Bay community page, national brokerage site (not linked)
  71. Admirals Bay subdivision page, Southwest Florida brokerage site (not linked)
  72. Listing remarks for a 22652 Island Pines Way unit, brokerage site (not linked)
  73. Admirals Bay vacation rental listings, travel booking platform (not linked)
  74. Santini Marina Plaza, commercial property listing site (not linked)

Downloadable Documents

Admirals Bay's key public documents are published by the Town of Fort Myers Beach, Florida DBPR, the National Hurricane Center and the Lee County Property Appraiser; the table links each to its issuer. The recorded declaration comes from the Lee County Clerk, and the budget, rules and insurance papers come from the association.

Document

Issued by

Date

Link

Ordinance 18-01, Short-Term Rentals Regulation

Town of Fort Myers Beach

Current

Ordinance, PDF

Short-Term Rentals Code of Conduct

Town of Fort Myers Beach

Current

Code of conduct, PDF

2026 condominium rental opt-out list

Town of Fort Myers Beach

2026

Opt-out list

Hurricane Ian tropical cyclone report

National Hurricane Center

2023

Report, PDF

2025 taxing district millage book

Lee County Property Appraiser

2025

Millage book, PDF

Homestead exemption guide

Florida Department of Revenue

Current

Guide, PDF


Market data from the Lee County Property Appraiser public sales file and county GIS roll, read November 11, 2026. McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Admirals Bay. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.


Work With Us

Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.