Jonathans Bay is a gated condominium of 152 coach homes with garages, built 2006 and 2007 off US 41 in south Fort Myers. Lee County recorded 6 sales at a $233,000 median in the 12 months to October 2026. Call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072.
Updated November 2026 · Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty
By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.
McGreevy and Comisar are the team Jonathans Bay owners call first when they decide to sell, and the team buyers call when they want every recorded Jonathans Bay sale, the condo fee, the flood zone, the storm questions and Florida’s condominium laws explained before they write an offer. Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with over $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc, we wrote this guide sellers first: what a Jonathans Bay coach home is worth today, which recorded sales set that price, and what a buyer will ask about the fee, flood insurance, the evacuation zone and the association before signing.
Jonathans Bay (spelled Jonathan’s Bay by its association, and JONATHANS BAY CONDO on the county roll and in the MLS) is a gated condominium of 152 coach homes in 14 two-story buildings around two lakes on Jonathans Bay Circle, off US 41 in unincorporated south Fort Myers, Florida, ZIP 33908. The buildings were finished in 2006 and 2007, every unit has a garage, and the plans run from 1,755 to 2,069 square feet. Lee County recorded 6 qualified Jonathans Bay sales in the 12 months to October 31, 2026, from $225,000 to $310,000, at a $233,000 median, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser.
If you are choosing who should represent you, our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers sets out the criteria we think every Fort Myers seller and buyer should use. Owners can read our Fort Myers seller guide or request a free Fort Myers home valuation; buyers can read how to buy a home in Fort Myers. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.
McGreevy and Comisar are the best realtor for Jonathans Bay because we price a Jonathans Bay coach home from Lee County’s recorded sales of its own floor and its own plan (the 1,755 and 1,832 square foot first-floor homes, the 2,024 and 2,069 square foot second-floor homes), not from a Fort Myers condo average, and we answer the fee, flood, insurance and association questions before a buyer asks. Our team, Domain Realty Group, has been the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012.
If you’re searching for the best realtor for Jonathans Bay in Fort Myers, whether you’re ready to sell your Jonathans Bay coach home or buy your next one, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. We are also ranked the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026).
Recent Jonathans Bay market record (36 months): From November 2023 to October 2026 we tracked 14 qualified Jonathans Bay resales recorded by Lee County · a range of $225,000 to $345,000 · a median of $270,000 · newest recorded sale $230,000 for 6021 Jonathans Bay Circle, unit 101, on September 25, 2026 · no builder-direct sales in the window. In the 12 months to October 31, 2026 the county recorded 6 of those sales at a $233,000 median. Days on market and sale-to-list ratio are MLS measures; the county record carries recorded prices and dates, so we read those two figures for your exact unit when we prepare your pricing.
For Jonathans Bay sellers: professional photography, drone video that shows the lakes, the fountains, the clubhouse and pool and the gated loop of Jonathans Bay Circle, sale-by-sale pricing from the county record for your floor and your plan, and a qualified-buyer database built over our years leading Domain Realty Group.
Honors and recognition:
Selling your Jonathans Bay coach home? Get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 (confidential conversations welcome).
Buying a coach home in Jonathans Bay? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 for a personalized buyer consultation, and see how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida.
Jonathans Bay’s key takeaways are its large single-level coach homes with garages in a gated setting, its flood and evacuation position, its quarterly condo fee and its 2026 prices: 152 units in unincorporated Lee County, built 2006 and 2007, in FEMA Zone AE and Evacuation Zone A, with a 12-month median about 39 percent below the 2023 median.
This guide answers the questions Jonathans Bay sellers and buyers in Fort Myers ask us most, in the order below.
Jonathans Bay is a gated coach-home condominium of 152 units in 14 two-story buildings set around two lakes on one loop street, Jonathans Bay Circle, on the west side of US 41 in unincorporated south Fort Myers, Florida, ZIP 33908. It was developed by Transeastern Homes companies and finished in 2006 and 2007 and has a lakeside clubhouse, a pool and spa and a fitness room.
A coach home here means a single-level condominium flat in a two-story building: each first-floor home has a second-floor home directly above it, and each has its own garage and entry. The names buyers search are Jonathans Bay, Jonathan’s Bay and Jonathans Bay Condo. On the Lee County roll every unit’s legal description begins Jonathans Bay Condo, followed by the recorded instrument of its phase.
Jonathans Bay units are the Lee County parcels whose legal description begins Jonathans Bay Condo. On the 2026 roll exported November 1, 2026, that is 152 residential condominium units and two common-element parcels, 154 parcels in all, every one with a Fort Myers 33908 address on Jonathans Bay Circle.
Each building carries one street number, 6010 to 6100, and the units are numbered by pair: unit 101 is a first-floor home and unit 102 is the second-floor home above it, then 201 and 202, and so on. The first and last pair in each building are the end units. No other parcel in Lee County carries the Jonathans Bay Condo legal description, and the local Collier County data file has no Jonathans Bay record.
No. Jonathans Bay has a Fort Myers mailing address but sits in unincorporated Lee County. The 2026 roll codes all 154 parcels with zoning area ULC (unincorporated Lee County) and taxing district 047, South Trail Fire, and the community is in FEMA community 125124, Lee County unincorporated.
That matters for three things a buyer feels: Lee County, not the City, handles zoning and building permits; the tax bill carries the unincorporated MSTU and the South Trail Fire District instead of City millage; and Lee County’s floodplain rules apply to any work on the buildings.
Jonathans Bay is a condominium, not a homeowners association of houses. Each owner holds a unit plus an undivided share of the common elements under Florida’s condominium law, Chapter 718. That brings condominium rules on budgets, reserves, master insurance, official records and the estoppel certificate a seller orders at closing.
The county roll also shows a second entity: the condominium association owns the common elements, and a separate Jonathans Bay Association, Inc. owns the clubhouse parcel. Ask how the two share costs and whether the clubhouse entity bills separately or inside the condo fee.
No. Jonathan Harbour is a different gated community with its own association, about 8 miles west on Connie Mack Island in Iona near the Sanibel Causeway, and it shares nothing with Jonathans Bay except the first word of its name and the 33908 ZIP code. Every figure on this page is a Jonathans Bay figure from the Jonathans Bay records; check the street before you compare prices or read documents.
Both spellings are used. Lee County’s roll and the MLS write Jonathans Bay without the apostrophe, and the condominium association appears on the roll as Jonathans Bay Condo Assn. The clubhouse owner appears as Jonathans Bay Assn Inc, while Lee County’s 2007 utility acceptance named it Jonathan’s Bay Association, Inc., with the apostrophe. Search both forms when you look up records.
Jonathans Bay sits on the west side of US 41 (South Tamiami Trail) in unincorporated south Fort Myers, south of Gladiolus Drive, entered by Jonathans Bay Drive from a frontage road off US 41, at about 26.5111 north and 81.8656 west, the middle of the 152 unit locations on the county roll. It is on the US 41 corridor, not on Summerlin Road or McGregor Boulevard.
On the county roll the 152 units sit between latitude 26.510419 and 26.511509, a compact site about a quarter mile across. A broker page places the community about 1.5 miles south of Gladiolus Drive, and a listing describes it as west of US 41, south of Six Mile Cypress Parkway and north of Alico Road. Nearby named roads on Lee County’s road layer include Youngquist Road, Old US 41, Briarcliff Road, Timberlakes Drive and Lake Devonwood Drive.
You reach Jonathans Bay from US 41 by Jonathans Bay Drive, which runs from a frontage road to the gate and on to Jonathans Bay Circle, a private loop road the association maintains. Listings describe the community as gated, so give visitors and delivery drivers the gate instructions along with the building number and unit number.
A listing names street lights and street maintenance among the items the fee covers, so ask the association about the reserve line for repaving the loop road before you buy.
Two commercial parcels sit at the entrance on Jonathans Bay Drive, outside the association: a 2.53-acre private school parcel at 6080, where The Learning Experience runs a preschool, and a 2.84-acre vacant commercial parcel at 6081. Both are zoned CPD (commercial planned development) on the roll and owned by companies outside the association.
The vacant parcel could be developed. Ask Lee County’s Department of Community Development whether any development order is pending on 6081 Jonathans Bay Drive before you buy. Fairway Woods at The Forest, a golf condominium covered in our Fairway Woods at The Forest guide, sits about 0.4 mile to the south.
Jonathans Bay’s grounds are two association parcels: the condominium’s common elements of about 21.05 acres on the county’s GIS measure, which hold the lakes, the loop road and the land around the 14 buildings, and the clubhouse parcel of about 4.28 acres at 6001 Jonathans Bay Circle. Together they make about 25.3 acres.
Parcel or group | What it is | Units |
|---|---|---|
Condominium common elements | Lakes, loop road, grounds and the land under the buildings; about 21.05 acres | 0 |
Clubhouse parcel, 6001 Jonathans Bay Circle | 1,968 square foot clubhouse built 2006, pool and spa; about 4.28 acres; owned by Jonathans Bay Association, Inc. | 0 |
Buildings 6010 to 6091 | Two-story coach-home buildings, 2006 | 144 |
Building 6100 | Two-story coach-home building, 2007 | 8 |
All residential units | One condominium | 152 |
The roll codes all 152 units with a lake setting. In the aerial view, the loop road circles a long lake with fountains, a second lake lies to the west, and the clubhouse and pool sit by the entrance drive on the east side.
Living in Jonathans Bay means a large single-level coach home with its own garage behind a gate, lake views from a loop road, a clubhouse, pool, spa and fitness room, and the exterior, grounds and master insurance handled by the association. There is no golf and no marina, and US 41 shopping, HealthPark and the beaches are a short drive away.
Daily life centers on the home and the clubhouse rather than a club. A listing says the fee covers cable TV, internet, irrigation water, grounds maintenance, management, exterior pest control, sewer, street lights, street maintenance, trash and water. An owner’s main separate bills are electric, the owner’s own insurance and property tax; confirm what the current budget covers.
A Jonathans Bay owner’s routine runs along US 41. A broker page puts the Gladiolus Drive shops about 5 minutes away, HealthPark Medical Center about 10 minutes, the Sanibel Causeway about 15 minutes, Fort Myers Beach about 20 minutes and Southwest Florida International Airport about 25 minutes. Grounds care and building exteriors are association work.
Those times are estimates; real trips run longer in season and at rush hour on US 41, so time the drives from the gate at the hours you would make them.
The tax roll speaks only to ownership, not to people. 74 of the 152 units carry a Florida homestead exemption, meaning the owner has claimed the unit as a permanent residence, and 87 owners mail their tax bills to their own Jonathans Bay unit. 101 owners have Florida mailing addresses; the rest mail from other states, Canada and Austria, led by Illinois with 9 and Michigan with 8.
That mix bears on two things a buyer feels: property taxes, which differ sharply between homesteaded and non-homesteaded units, and the share of owner-occupied units, a question lenders ask on condominium loans. At 49 percent, Jonathans Bay’s homestead share sits in the middle of the coach-home condominiums we compare later in this guide.
Yes. Broker pages, listings and a rental listing all describe Jonathans Bay as a gated community, and the private loop road sits behind the entrance on Jonathans Bay Drive. Ask the association how the gate works today, whether by code, remote or card, and how guests and deliveries are admitted, before you move in.
Every Jonathans Bay unit carries a garage on the 2026 county roll. Listings describe a one-car garage with the first-floor homes and a two-car garage with the second-floor homes, with driveway space in front. Ask the association about guest parking and any rules on trucks, boats, trailers and commercial vehicles before you bring them.
Yes. Each Jonathans Bay home is a single-level flat: the first-floor homes are at ground level and the second-floor homes sit directly above them. The roll records the first-floor units at one story and the second-floor units at two, which describes the unit’s level, not a two-level layout. If you want a home at ground level, focus on the 76 first-floor homes.
No. The county roll sets a pool flag on all 152 units, but that reflects the shared pool beside the clubhouse, not private pools. The pool and spa are on the clubhouse parcel, and a rental listing describes the pool as heated. Ask the association for the pool hours and rules.
Jonathans Bay owners can get a free home valuation built on Jonathans Bay sales of the same floor and the same plan, or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buyers comparing the plans, the fee and the flood details can call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers.
The Jonathans Bay market has reset well below its 2022 and 2023 level: Lee County recorded 6 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 31, 2026, at a $233,000 median and about $131 a square foot, against 5 sales at a $280,000 median in the 12 months before, and $270,000 on 14 sales over 36 months.
Data updated: November 2026.
Window (Lee County recorded qualified sales) | Sales | Median | Range | Median $/sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
12 months to October 31, 2026 | 6 | $233,000 | $225,000 to $310,000 | $131 |
Prior 12 months, to October 31, 2025 | 5 | $280,000 | $250,000 to $310,000 | $153 |
24 months to October 31, 2026 | 11 | $250,000 | $225,000 to $310,000 | $142 |
36 months to October 31, 2026 | 14 | $270,000 | $225,000 to $345,000 | $148 |
60 months to October 31, 2026 | 42 | $332,500 | $225,000 to $390,000 | $175 |
All sales in these windows are resales. The 12-month median of $233,000 sits 13.7 percent below the 36-month median and 16.8 percent below the prior 12 months. Square foot figures use the Property Appraiser’s heated living area.
Selling or buying in Jonathans Bay? Owners can get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072; buyers can call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers.
Jonathans Bay’s 2026 median of $230,500 on 4 sales to October 31 sits 39.5 percent below the $381,000 median of 2023, on 8 sales, and 11.3 percent below 2025’s $260,000. The county record does not say why, but it shows the step: $355,000 in 2022, $381,000 in 2023, $325,000 in 2024, $260,000 in 2025 and $230,500 in 2026.
One listing history shows the reset plainly: 6031 Jonathans Bay Circle, unit 101, was listed in December 2024 at $335,000, took four price cuts and recorded at $250,000 on October 10, 2025. A broker market summary on November 21, 2026 reported an average sold price of $230,000 at 11.2 percent under asking, with 258 average days on market, a broker estimate rather than a county figure.
The county record does not show days on market, the asking price, seller credits, the condition of the unit, whether impact windows or shutters were in place, or whether the furniture was included. Those come from the Southwest Florida MLS and the listing itself, and we read them for your exact unit when we prepare a price.
The record also excludes transfers that were not arm’s length. Since November 2025 Lee County recorded 19 deeds of all kinds on Jonathans Bay units; 13 of them were not qualified, all at $100 or less, the usual mark of family, trust or corrective deeds. None is counted in our medians.
Jonathans Bay recorded 7 qualified sales in 2025 and 4 in 2026 to October 31, out of 152 units, according to Lee County. In the 12 months to October 2026, 6 sales meant about 3.9 percent of the units changed hands, and 14 sales over 36 months about 9.2 percent, so each listing competes with only a handful of others in the community.
Annual sales were higher when prices were rising: 19 in 2021 and 17 in 2022, then 8 in 2023 and 3 in 2024.
November 2026 asking prices for Jonathans Bay ran from $229,900 to $369,000: $369,000 for 6060 Jonathans Bay Circle, unit 402, reduced from $395,000; $310,000 for 6011, unit 402; $275,000 for 6050, unit 102; and $229,900 for 6020, unit 202, reduced from $239,900. Asking prices are not sales; the recorded sales above are the market.
The gap between the top asks and the 12-month median shows how far some owners are pricing from the recorded sales. We price from the sales.
The Jonathans Bay sales that set today’s prices are the 14 qualified resales Lee County recorded from November 2023 to October 2026: 10 first-floor homes at a $255,000 median and 4 second-floor homes at a $317,500 median. The table lists every one, with the floor and the heated living area on the county roll.
Data updated: November 2026.
Recorded | Unit | Floor | Sq ft | Price | $/sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2024-06-27 | 6031 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 302 | Second | 2,069 | $345,000 | $167 |
2024-09-27 | 6060 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 201 | First | 1,832 | $300,000 | $164 |
2024-10-31 | 6091 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 202 | Second | 2,069 | $325,000 | $157 |
2025-04-10 | 6050 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 101 | First | 1,755 | $280,000 | $160 |
2025-05-23 | 6081 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 102 | Second | 2,024 | $310,000 | $153 |
2025-05-29 | 6050 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 201 | First | 1,832 | $290,000 | $158 |
2025-09-26 | 6021 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 301 | First | 1,832 | $260,000 | $142 |
2025-10-10 | 6031 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 101 | First | 1,755 | $250,000 | $142 |
2025-11-01 | 6031 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 401 | First | 1,832 | $235,000 | $128 |
2025-11-18 | 6051 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 101 | First | 1,755 | $240,000 | $137 |
2026-02-23 | 6100 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 302 | Second | 2,069 | $225,000 | $109 |
2026-02-23 | 6071 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 101 | First | 1,755 | $231,000 | $132 |
2026-05-21 | 6021 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 501 | First | 1,832 | $310,000 | $169 |
2026-09-25 | 6021 Jonathans Bay Cir, unit 101 | First | 1,755 | $230,000 | $131 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser roll and recorded qualified sales (our pull, November 2026). The 6091 unit 202 sale had been listed in September 2024 at $350,000, according to its listing.
Selling or buying in Jonathans Bay? Owners can get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072; buyers can call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers.
The highest Jonathans Bay sale in the last 36 months is $345,000 for 6031 Jonathans Bay Circle, unit 302, a 2,069 square foot second-floor home, recorded June 27, 2024. In the last 12 months the top sale was $310,000 for 6021, unit 501, a 1,832 square foot first-floor home, on May 21, 2026, at $169 a square foot.
The highest prices on the county record since 2021 were $390,000, recorded twice in 2023, for 6050, unit 202, and 6060, unit 402, both 2,069 square foot second-floor homes.
Jonathans Bay’s first-floor homes recorded 5 sales in the 12 months to October 2026, from $230,000 to $310,000, at a $235,000 median. Over 36 months the 10 first-floor sales ran from $230,000 to $310,000 at a $255,000 median; the 1,755 square foot end plan recorded a $240,000 median on 5 sales and the 1,832 square foot plan $290,000 on 5.
First-floor homes are 76 of the 152 units. Listings describe them with a one-car garage.
Jonathans Bay’s second-floor homes recorded 4 sales over 36 months, from $225,000 to $345,000, at a $317,500 median, above the first-floor median. In the 12 months to October 2026 only one second-floor home sold, 6100, unit 302, at $225,000, the lowest price in the window at $109 a square foot, so one sale sets no rule.
Second-floor homes are the larger plans, 2,024 and 2,069 square feet, and listings describe them with a two-car garage. We price a second-floor home against both its own floor’s sales and the condition behind the low 2026 sale.
Jonathans Bay prices have run in long cycles: the developer’s first buyers paid a $283,000 median in 2006, prices fell to $97,000 in 2011, climbed to $381,000 in 2023 and eased to $230,500 in 2026 to date, according to the county record of qualified sales.
Data updated: November 2026.
Year | Recorded qualified sales | Median | Median $/sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|
2006 (developer sell-out) | 125 | $283,000 | $145 |
2007 | 21 | $215,000 | $112 |
2009 | 5 | $140,000 | $75 |
2010 | 9 | $112,400 | $58 |
2011 | 20 | $97,000 | $51 |
2012 | 8 | $125,000 | $69 |
2013 | 14 | $149,750 | $76 |
2014 | 8 | $167,450 | $87 |
2015 | 13 | $183,000 | $93 |
2016 | 6 | $187,250 | $100 |
2017 | 10 | $210,000 | $104 |
2018 | 10 | $202,500 | $110 |
2019 | 5 | $199,000 | $103 |
2020 | 6 | $224,000 | $114 |
2021 | 19 | $251,000 | $131 |
2022 | 17 | $355,000 | $183 |
2023 | 8 | $381,000 | $187 |
2024 | 3 | $325,000 | $164 |
2025 | 7 | $260,000 | $142 |
2026 (to October 31) | 4 | $230,500 | $131 |
Years with fewer than ten sales carry thin medians: one sale more or less moves them, and so does the mix of first-floor and second-floor homes in a year. The 2008 qualified-coded deeds include a $100 transfer, so we leave that year out; every year is in our county pull.
The first Jonathans Bay buyers on the county record paid a $283,000 median for 125 units in 2006, from $230,000 to $396,800, and a $215,000 median for 17 units first sold in 2007, as the developer’s sell-out ran into the 2006 to 2007 market turn. The 2026 median of $230,500 is 18.6 percent below the 2006 developer median.
Your unit’s original price is on its county parcel record; we pull it with the full sale history when we prepare a valuation.
Before 2012, Jonathans Bay prices fell with the housing bust: the median dropped from $283,000 in 2006 to $215,000 in 2007, $140,000 in 2009, $112,400 in 2010 and $97,000 on 20 sales in 2011, the low point. The 2011 median was 74.5 percent below the 2023 peak that followed.
After 2020, Jonathans Bay prices jumped: the median went from $224,000 in 2020 to $251,000 in 2021, $355,000 in 2022 and $381,000 in 2023, with sales from $320,000 to $390,000 that year. Prices then eased, to $325,000 on 3 sales in 2024, $260,000 on 7 in 2025 and $230,500 on 4 in 2026 to October 31.
On the 2026 Lee County roll, Jonathans Bay units carry just (market) values from $197,865 to $259,052, median $220,211, about $34.13 million for all 152 units. By plan (medians): 1,755 square feet $210,703; 1,832 square feet $218,829; 2,024 square feet $234,350; 2,069 square feet $239,713.
Just value is the county’s mass-appraisal estimate as of January 1, not a sale price. The 12-month sale median of $233,000 sits 5.8 percent above the median just value; we use just value as a floor check, never as a list price.
Yes, down. The 2026 roll lowered the median Jonathans Bay unit value 11.3 percent, from $248,387 on the 2025 roll to $220,211, and the 152 units’ total from about $38.07 million to $34.13 million, down 10.3 percent, according to the Florida Department of Revenue tax roll files for Lee County.
A lower just value lowers the 2026 bill most for non-homestead owners, whose taxable value follows the market. For homesteaded owners, whose assessed values sit below just value under the Save Our Homes cap, the change matters less.
Jonathans Bay’s 152 units are single-level coach homes in four plans: 1,755 and 1,832 square feet of heated living area on the first floor and 2,024 and 2,069 square feet on the second. The roll records 3 bedrooms and 2 baths and a garage on every unit; the 1,755 and 2,024 square foot plans are the end positions in each building.
Plan (heated sq ft) | Floor and position | Units | Listing description | 2026 median just value |
|---|---|---|---|---|
1,755 | First floor, end | 28 | 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, 1-car garage | $210,703 |
1,832 | First floor, interior | 48 | 3 bedrooms, 2 baths | $218,829 |
2,024 | Second floor, end | 28 | 4 bedrooms, 2 baths | $234,350 |
2,069 | Second floor, interior | 48 | 4 bedrooms, 2 baths, 2-car garage | $239,713 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll, exported November 1, 2026; listing descriptions from listings and broker pages. The roll’s heated area and total area are the same figure for every unit.
Each Jonathans Bay building mixes the four plans: two end pairs (a 1,755 square foot first-floor home under a 2,024 square foot second-floor home) and interior pairs (1,832 under 2,069). Eight buildings hold 12 units, four hold 10 and two, 6050 and 6100, hold 8.
Building (street number) | Units | Built | Phase instrument |
|---|---|---|---|
6010 | 12 | 2006 | 2006-21492 |
6011 | 12 | 2006 | 2006-21492 |
6020 | 10 | 2006 | 2006-21492 |
6021 | 12 | 2006 | 2006-77821 |
6030 | 10 | 2006 | 2006-77822 |
6031 | 12 | 2006 | 2006-123453 |
6040 | 10 | 2006 | 2006-143390 |
6050 | 8 | 2006 | 2006-143389 |
6051 | 12 | 2006 | 2006-146643 |
6060 | 10 | 2006 | 2006-146644 |
6071 | 12 | 2006 | 2006-227210 |
6081 | 12 | 2006 | 2006-227209 |
6091 | 12 | 2006 | 2006-271708 |
6100 | 8 | 2007 | 2006-271707 |
A Jonathans Bay coach home is a single-level flat in a two-story building with tile roofs, its own garage and its own entry. Listings describe a lanai, and one 2026 listing on a second-floor unit names accordion shutters and roll-down lanai screens. The roll codes every unit with a lake setting, and the buildings line the two lakes.
The county roll records every Jonathans Bay unit as 3 bedrooms and 2 baths, while listings sell the second-floor plans as 4 bedrooms, and one feed shows a 2,024 square foot unit with 3 baths. Whether a fourth room meets the bedroom definition varies by unit, so ask the listing agent how the room is used and check it at the showing.
When you compare units, use the county’s heated square footage, which is the same measure for every home, and treat bedroom counts as a description of the layout.
Jonathans Bay’s buildings were finished in 2006, except building 6100, finished in 2007, so in 2026 they are 19 to 20 years old. A 2026 listing reports that the association replaced the roofs with tile in 2024; how that work was paid for is not public as of November 21, 2026, so ask the association for the roof permits and the funding history.
Jonathans Bay was planned by Transeastern Homes as a coach-home community and built out in 2006 and 2007 on land assembled from 1990 to 2005. Its declaration was recorded in Lee County in 2006 as instrument 2006-21492, the developer sold 125 units in 2006 at a $283,000 median, and Lee County accepted its water system in 2007.
A Business Observer real estate brief of October 20, 2005 records Transeastern Jonathans Bay LLC selling Jonathans Bay, with Olympia Pointe, Laguna Lakes and Coral Lakes, to E.H. Transeastern LLC for $27.8 million in total. Technical Olympic USA (TOUSA) had formed that joint venture with The Falcone Group of Boca Raton to buy the assets of Transeastern Homes of Coral Springs. The 2005 report names the other three projects without their locations, so the shared deal is history, not a guide to any other community.
The county roll’s sale history for the Jonathans Bay unit parcels carries three earlier land deeds: Official Records Book 2139, Page 1560, on April 2, 1990, for $1,000,000; Book 4284, Page 2246, on April 28, 2004, for $2,989,500; and Book 4830, Page 0195, on August 1, 2005, for $16,352,000. The August 2005 deed matches the timing of the Transeastern transfer.
Those deeds are the land’s history, not unit sales; they appear on each unit’s record because the units were carved out of those parcels.
Jonathans Bay was declared in phases during 2006, one building per phase. Instrument 2006-21492 created the first phases, buildings 6010, 6011 and 6020, and later 2006 instruments added the other eleven buildings, the last two, 6091 and 6100, under instruments 2006-271708 and 2006-271707. The clubhouse parcel’s legal cites 2006-21492 and 2006-92165.
Lee County records after 2005 use instrument numbers rather than book and page. The declaration and its phase amendments can be read at the Lee County Clerk’s official records search.
The developer’s market turned as Jonathans Bay sold out. TOUSA’s subsidiaries defaulted on the Transeastern joint venture’s credit agreements in about September 2006, and TOUSA filed for Chapter 11 protection on January 29, 2008, case 08-10928 in the Southern District of Florida, according to its filings and press reports. How the turnover of the association to owners was handled is not public as of November 21, 2026.
The bankruptcy does not affect a resale buyer’s title today; the association has run the community for years, holding its annual meeting at Lakes Regional Library in January 2024.
On March 13, 2007, the Lee County Commission’s consent agenda carried final acceptance of a donated potable water distribution system serving “Jonathan’s Bay, a recently constructed multi-family residential development.” The agenda named Jonathan’s Bay Association, Inc., then with a Coral Springs address, and EH Transeastern Properties, Inc. A listing says the fee covers water and sewer.
Jonathans Bay is governed by its condominium association under the declaration recorded as Lee County instrument 2006-21492 and Chapter 718 of the Florida Statutes, the Condominium Act, with a second entity, Jonathans Bay Association, Inc., that owns the clubhouse parcel. The roll mails both entities’ bills to a management address in Longwood.
The condominium association owns the common elements, about 21.05 acres, and the clubhouse entity owns the 4.28-acre clubhouse parcel. Ask the manager how the two entities relate, whether the clubhouse entity has its own budget, and whether its costs sit inside the condo fee a listing prints.
Every Jonathans Bay unit is in one condominium, so one condominium association governs all 152 units, under one declaration and its 2006 phase amendments. The county roll lists the common elements owner as Jonathans Bay Condo Assn and the clubhouse owner as Jonathans Bay Assn Inc. Their filings with the Florida Department of State can be read on its corporation search.
The county roll mails both Jonathans Bay entities’ bills to 2180 W State Road 434, Suite 5000, in Longwood, which Sentry Management lists as its Longwood headquarters address; Sentry also has a Fort Myers office at 12830 University Drive, Suite 150. Management contracts change, so confirm the current manager before you request an estoppel certificate or the condominium documents.
Jonathans Bay is governed by Chapter 718 of the Florida Statutes, the Condominium Act, together with its declaration, articles, bylaws and rules. Chapter 718 sets the rules on budgets, reserves, the master insurance policy, owners’ access to official records, the estoppel certificate and the documents a buyer receives before closing.
Jonathans Bay owners can ask the association for its official records: the declaration and amendments, budgets, financial reports, insurance policies, contracts, meeting minutes and the reserve schedule. A resale buyer receives the governing documents, the budget and the most recent financial report under section 718.503, and the estoppel certificate lists what the unit owes.
They should. Since January 1, 2026, a condominium association with 25 or more units must keep its official records on a website or app within 30 days of creating or receiving them, under section 718.111(12)(g). At 152 units, Jonathans Bay is covered. Ask the manager for portal access when you go under contract.
Jonathans Bay’s cost of ownership is one condominium fee, printed on listings at $2,225 to $2,265 a quarter (about $742 to $755 a month), plus property tax, your own HO-6 insurance and utilities the fee does not cover. No community development district was found, and no golf or club membership is attached to the units.
Charge | Figure | Frequency | What it covers | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Condo fee | $2,265 a quarter ($755 a month) on 6091, unit 202, sold October 2024; $2,225 to $2,265 a quarter across 2026 listings on an aggregator; the 2026 budget per unit is not public as of November 21, 2026 | Quarterly | Cable TV, internet, irrigation water, grounds maintenance, management, exterior pest control, sewer, street lights, street maintenance, trash and water, per the 6091 listing | Listings |
Clubhouse entity | Not published separately; ask whether it is inside the condo fee | Clubhouse, pool, spa and fitness room | Association | |
Special assessment | None reported in the listings we read; the 2024 roof funding is not public | Ask for the estoppel certificate and the assessment history | Association | |
Capital contribution or transfer fee | Not published | At sale | Estoppel certificate | |
Lease application | Required, with background screening, at least 60 days before a tenant arrives, per a rental manager; fee not published | Per lease | Association | |
CDD | None found; one 2026 listing reported no CDD | Tax bill | ||
Property tax | About $2,943 a year at the median 2026 value without a homestead exemption | Annual | Our estimate from the 2026 roll and millage |
Fees are set by the association’s annual budget. The listing figures above are dated and labeled; the binding figure for a unit is the current budget and the estoppel certificate.
Selling or buying in Jonathans Bay? Owners can get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072; buyers can call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers.
Jonathans Bay has a condominium fee, not an HOA fee of houses. A listing for 6091, unit 202, sold in October 2024, printed $2,265 a quarter, which is $755 a month, and an aggregator showed $2,225 to $2,265 a quarter across 2026 listings. An earlier June 2023 sale record carried $647 a month. Whether fees differ by plan is not public; confirm the current budget with the association.
The listing for 6091, unit 202, says the fee covers cable TV, internet, irrigation water, grounds maintenance, management, exterior pest control, sewer, street lights, street maintenance, trash and water. A broker page adds exterior maintenance and the amenities. Ask the association for the current budget, which also shows the master insurance premium and the reserve contributions.
Cable TV and internet arrive under a bulk agreement: the condominium association held a Hotwire Communications town hall in September 2019. The contract’s term and end date are not public; ask for them, because a bulk service changes what an owner pays separately.
A rental manager reports that the association requires a lease application and background screening at least 60 days before a tenant’s arrival; the application fee is not published. Any capital contribution or transfer charge at resale was not found in public sources; it would appear on the estoppel certificate.
None was reported in the public listings we read, and none is confirmed either way. A 2026 listing reports that the roofs were replaced with tile in 2024, and how that work was paid for, from reserves, a loan or an assessment, is not public as of November 21, 2026. Ask for the assessment history and the estoppel certificate before you buy.
The estoppel certificate is the association’s signed statement of what a Jonathans Bay unit owes at closing: the regular fee, any special assessment, unpaid balances and transfer charges. Under section 718.116, a buyer can rely on it, and the title company orders it before closing. It is the binding fee figure, not a listing.
None was found. One 2026 listing reported no CDD, and the 2026 roll shows only standard districts on the Jonathans Bay units, South Trail Fire and residential garbage district 002. The tax bill carries non-ad valorem lines such as solid waste; check the unit’s 2026 bill on the Lee County Tax Collector’s site.
Jonathans Bay property taxes are set by Lee County taxing district 047, South Trail Fire, at an adopted 2026 total of 13.3623 mills, about $1,336 per $100,000 of taxable value. At the median 2026 value of $220,211, a buyer without a homestead exemption would pay about $2,943 a year before non-ad valorem charges, and there are no City of Fort Myers taxes.
Data updated: November 2026.
District 047, 2026 | Mills |
|---|---|
Adopted (actual) total | 13.3623 |
Proposed total on the TRIM notice | 13.3738 |
Rollback total | 13.3601 |
School levies (local board 2.2480 and state law 3.0230) | 5.2710 |
South Trail Fire Protection and Rescue District | 2.5000 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser, 2026 Taxing District Millage Book, district 047, page 28. The adopted total equals the sum of the 13 authorities’ applied rates and sits under the proposed total.
We estimate the median Jonathans Bay unit without a homestead exemption owes about $2,943 in 2026 ad valorem tax, with the 78 non-homestead units from about $2,644 to $3,462. The 74 homesteaded units owe less, a median of about $2,060, from about $853 to $2,797, because their assessed values sit below just value. Non-ad valorem charges are extra.
By plan, at each plan’s median 2026 value without an exemption, the estimate is about $2,815 for the 1,755 square foot plan, $2,924 for 1,832, $3,131 for 2,024 and $3,203 for 2,069. Listing tax figures for comparison were $3,565 for 2024 on 6031, unit 101, and $4,089.52 for 2025 on 6011, unit 402, before the 2026 values fell.
Often not. A homestead owner’s assessed value is capped and resets to market value after a sale, under section 193.155, so a buyer’s first full bill can be well above the seller’s. The gap between the homestead and non-homestead medians at Jonathans Bay is about $882 a year. We give buyers an estimate from the 2026 roll before they write an offer.
A full 2026 homestead exemption of $51,411, $25,000 off every levy plus $26,411 off the non-school levies, brings our estimate at the median value of $220,211 from about $2,943 to about $2,395 in the first year, before the assessment cap starts to work. A buyer who will live in the unit full time can file with the Property Appraiser.
Jonathans Bay sits inside the South Trail Fire Protection and Rescue District, an independent special district that serves this part of unincorporated south Fort Myers. Its 2026 rate is 2.5000 mills, the same rate as its 2025 to 2026 budget, so the fire line on a Jonathans Bay bill moves with the unit’s taxable value, not with a rate increase.
Jonathans Bay has a lakeside clubhouse of 1,968 square feet built in 2006, a pool and spa, a fitness room and a picnic and barbecue area, all owned by the association and paid for through the fee. It has no golf course, no club membership, no marina or docks and no deeded beach access.
The clubhouse sits on a 4.28-acre parcel at 6001 Jonathans Bay Circle, which the roll codes as a country club land use and lists under Jonathans Bay Association, Inc. Listings describe the clubhouse as lakeside, with social space and an outdoor bar.
Confirmed by listings, broker pages and the roll: the clubhouse with social space and an outdoor bar, a pool, which a rental listing describes as heated, a spa, a fitness room, a picnic and barbecue area and a community room. The private streets and street lights are association maintained. Ask for the current list, hours and rules.
No separate membership was found. The amenities belong to the association and are covered by the fee, according to broker pages and listings. Ask whether the clubhouse entity, Jonathans Bay Association, Inc., bills separately or inside the condo fee, so the full monthly cost is clear before you buy.
Jonathans Bay has no golf course and no club membership, no marina, docks or boat access, and no beach club or deeded beach access. The two lakes with fountains are inside the community and are not boating water. Buyers who want golf, boating or a walk to the beach should look elsewhere or plan to drive.
The nearest golf setting is The Forest, about 0.4 mile south, where Fairway Woods at The Forest is a golf-side condominium on the county roll. Our The Forest guide covers that community. Club membership there is separate and has its own terms; ask the club directly.
Jonathans Bay’s rental, pet and age rules come from the declaration and the association’s rules, which were not public as of November 21, 2026. Listings report a 90-day minimum lease with association approval and background screening, a limit of two pets, and no age restriction was found; confirm each rule in writing with the association before you buy.
Rules on leasing and pets in Florida condominiums change by owner vote and board action, and an amendment recorded after a listing was written controls. The association’s documents and an estoppel certificate are the only safe sources.
Yes, with limits. Listings report a 90-day minimum lease, and a rental manager says the association requires a lease application and background screening at least 60 days before a tenant’s arrival. One rental listing reported only one lease a year; confirm the lease frequency rule in the declaration. Asking rents ran about $2,100 to $2,850 a month.
One annual lease of 6051, unit 102, was listed at $2,150 a month in September 2025. Under section 718.110(13) of the Florida Statutes, an amendment that bans rentals or changes rental terms binds only owners who vote for it and owners who take title afterward.
Listings report that pets are allowed with a limit of two, and one aggregator reports breed restrictions. No weight limit was published in the sources we read, and some owners lease their units pet-free. Buyers with a large dog should get the written pet rules from the association before signing a contract.
We found no age restriction in the public sources we read, and we do not state an age rule for Jonathans Bay. The declaration and rules were not read; confirm with the association and its recorded declaration whether any age rule applies, because a legal age restriction would appear in those documents.
For a lease, yes: a rental manager reports an application and background screening at least 60 days before arrival. Whether the association approves resale buyers, and what it charges, depends on the declaration; ask the manager for the application and the timeline when you go under contract, so approval does not delay the closing date.
That depends on whether the condominium is on the FHA approved list and on the VA’s own review. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development publishes an FHA condominium lookup; check Jonathans Bay there and ask your lender before you write an offer. Conventional lenders also review the budget, reserves, insurance and owner-occupancy.
Yes. All 14 Jonathans Bay buildings sit in FEMA Zone AE, a special flood hazard area, with a static base flood elevation of 11 feet (NAVD88), on FIRM panel 12071C0438H effective November 17, 2022, outside the floodway, according to Lee County’s copy of the FEMA flood map. The community is in Lee County Evacuation Zone A, storm surge zone 1.
Zone AE here carries the subtype coastal floodplain on Lee County’s layer, so the risk the map describes includes storm surge, not only rainfall. Lenders on federally backed loans require flood cover on the building, which in a condominium is normally the association’s policy.
Selling or buying in Jonathans Bay? Owners can get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072; buyers can call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers.
The building needs it if any unit carries a federally backed mortgage, because Zone AE is a special flood hazard area, and condominium associations usually carry an NFIP Residential Condominium Building Association Policy on the buildings. Ask whether the Jonathans Bay master policy includes flood cover and its limits. Owners can add contents flood cover on their own.
Lee County’s LiDAR elevation points across the Jonathans Bay site, 399 of them, run from 1.7 to 9.75 feet, with a median of 8.5 feet; the lowest points are lake and swale. That puts typical ground about 2.5 feet below the 11 foot base flood elevation. A 2026 listing gave about 9 feet and Zone AE.
Ground height is not floor height. The finished floor of each building is on its elevation certificate, which sets flood insurance pricing; ask the association for the certificates.
Look the address up on FEMA’s Flood Map Service Center, or on Lee County’s flood map layer, and ask the association for the building’s elevation certificate. Flood insurance premiums under FEMA’s Risk Rating 2.0 depend on the building’s own features, including its floor height, so a certificate can matter to the price of cover.
Every Jonathans Bay building is in Lee County Evacuation Zone A, storm surge zone 1, the first zone ordered out when a storm threatens. Plan an evacuation route along US 41 and inland roads, and check Lee County’s evacuation map and the Florida Division of Emergency Management’s guidance each season.
No public report names Jonathans Bay in Hurricanes Ian, Helene or Milton. Lee County’s public damage layers return no damage assessment records inside the community, sales continued at record prices in 2023, and a 2026 listing reports tile roofs replaced in 2024; Milton’s EF2 tornado began about 0.8 mile to the north-northeast.
Absence from a public damage layer is not proof that no building was damaged. Ask the association for its claims history, roof records and any water intrusion reports before you buy.
Hurricane Ian struck on September 28, 2022 and set a record of 7.26 feet at the downtown Fort Myers gauge. In south Fort Myers, surge pushed into Estero Bay and Hendry Creek and flooded some complexes, including one off Gladiolus Drive, according to local news. No report names Jonathans Bay, and a first-floor seller stated in a 2024 to 2025 listing that the unit “has never experienced flooding.”
That is a seller’s statement about one unit, not a record for the community. Jonathans Bay recorded 8 qualified sales in 2023, at a $381,000 median, the highest on record.
Hurricane Milton made landfall near Siesta Key on October 9, 2024 as a Category 3. The National Weather Service’s final survey put the start of the EF2 Fort Myers tornado, peak winds 132 mph and a 16.56 mile path, just north of US 41 and south of Gladiolus Drive, about 0.8 mile north-northeast of Jonathans Bay, with minor roof damage there; the worst damage was farther north across Colonial Boulevard.
The Fort Myers gauge reached 5.26 feet in Milton. No Jonathans Bay damage report was found.
Hurricane Helene in September 2024 brought the Fort Myers gauge to 5.12 feet. Lee County’s after-action report says Helene and Milton did not hit Lee as severely as other parts of the state. Nothing specific to Jonathans Bay was found; ask the association whether either storm led to a claim.
Ask the association for its insurance claims history since 2022, the 2024 roof permits and how they were funded, any water intrusion or lanai damage reports, and the elevation certificates of the buildings. Ask the seller for the unit’s own insurance loss history and the flood disclosure Florida law requires at sale.
Florida’s condo safety laws, the milestone inspection and the structural integrity reserve study (SIRS), apply to condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories. Jonathans Bay’s buildings are two stories, a first-floor and a second-floor home in each pair, so neither requirement appears to apply on the public record; confirm with the association that no building counts as three habitable stories.
Associations with qualifying buildings had a SIRS deadline of December 31, 2025. Other 2025 changes reach every condominium, including Jonathans Bay.
Both rules turn on height: section 553.899 and the SIRS rules in Chapter 718 apply to buildings of three or more habitable stories, and HB 913 (2025) also exempts four-family dwellings with three or fewer habitable stories. Jonathans Bay’s buildings hold two levels of homes, and listings describe them as two stories. Ask the association for its written confirmation.
Florida’s 2025 condominium changes still reach Jonathans Bay: the threshold for reserve items is $25,000, the association must obtain a replacement-cost appraisal at least every three years, board meetings may be held by video and must be recorded, and minutes and affidavits must be posted. Ask for the current reserve schedule and whether reserves are fully funded or pooled.
Sellers commonly use Florida Realtors’ Milestone Inspection and SIRS Disclosure (MISIRS-1) to state whether a building is subject to the rules. At Jonathans Bay the expected answer is that the two-story buildings fall below the threshold, which we confirm with the association before listing, and we keep the written confirmation in the file.
Insurance at Jonathans Bay is split: Florida law requires the association to insure the condominium property at replacement cost, re-valued at least every three years, and that premium is a common expense paid through the fee, while each owner carries an HO-6 policy for the interior, finishes, contents and liability under section 627.714. Zone AE and Evacuation Zone A make flood and wind terms central.
The master policy covers the buildings and common elements; the owner’s policy covers what the declaration leaves to the owner, usually interior finishes, fixtures, contents and liability. Ask the association for the certificate of insurance, the wind deductible, and whether it carries a master flood (RCBAP) policy and at what limits. A buyer’s lender will ask for the same.
HO-6 premiums at Jonathans Bay depend on the unit, the floor, the coverage, the deductible and the carrier, so there is no single figure. Get quotes early, ask about loss assessment cover for the master policy’s deductible, and ask whether contents flood cover is offered. Citizens Property Insurance writes HO-6 policies when private carriers will not.
Not to a condominium unit-owner policy. Citizens Property Insurance’s flood requirement, which reaches all of its non-condominium policies on January 1, 2027, exempts condominium unit-owner (HO-6) policies. A Jonathans Bay buyer financing with a federally backed loan still needs flood cover on the building, which the association’s policy normally provides.
They did as of FEMA’s November 21, 2024 decision, when unincorporated Lee County kept its Community Rating System class and the 25 percent discount on National Flood Insurance Program policies that comes with it. Jonathans Bay is in that community, FEMA community 125124. Class changes happen, so ask your insurance agent which discount applies today.
Yes. A wind mitigation inspection under section 627.711 documents roof covering, roof-to-wall connections and opening protection, and insurers credit those features. With 2024 tile roofs reported by a listing and shutters on at least one unit, ask the seller and the association for the latest reports and permits.
Lee County assigns seats by choice within proximity zones, not a single address-zoned school. On the county’s 2026-2027 school zone layer, all 14 Jonathans Bay buildings fall in elementary proximity zone O, middle zone MM and high school South sub-zone 2. The district’s 2026-2027 Student Enrollment Plan was approved December 1, 2025.
On the county’s school points layer, Rayma C. Page Elementary on South Tamiami Trail is about 1.7 miles from the community in a straight line, and South Fort Myers High on Plantation Road about 2.1 miles. The district’s school grades for 2025-2026 were posted July 1, 2026.
Use the School District of Lee County’s school zone lookup with the unit’s full address. Proximity on a map does not equal assignment, and the district’s lists change by year, so check before you sign a lease or a contract.
Yes. The Learning Experience runs a preschool and daycare on the 2.53-acre parcel at 6080 Jonathans Bay Drive, at the community’s entrance, outside the association. Contact the school directly for enrollment, hours and tuition.
Jonathans Bay is a short drive from the US 41 shops and south Fort Myers hospitals: a broker page puts the Gladiolus Drive shops about 5 minutes away, HealthPark Medical Center about 10 minutes, the Sanibel Causeway about 15 minutes, Fort Myers Beach about 20 minutes and Southwest Florida International Airport about 25 minutes.
Destination | Approximate time or distance | Source |
|---|---|---|
Gladiolus Drive shopping | About 5 minutes | Broker page |
HealthPark Medical Center (HealthPark Hospital and Golisano Children’s Hospital) | About 10 minutes; within 8 miles | Broker page; Lee County hospitals layer |
Gulf Coast Medical Center | Within 8 miles | Lee County hospitals layer |
Sanibel Causeway | About 15 minutes | Broker page |
Fort Myers Beach | About 20 minutes | Broker page |
Southwest Florida International Airport | About 25 minutes | Broker page |
Rayma C. Page Elementary | About 1.7 miles, straight line | Lee County schools layer |
South Fort Myers High | About 2.1 miles, straight line | Lee County schools layer |
Lakes Regional Library, 15290 Bass Road | Association meeting venue | Lee County Library System |
Drive times to I-75, downtown Fort Myers, Naples, Coconut Point and Gulf Coast Town Center were not measured as of November 21, 2026; time them from the gate at the hours you would drive.
A broker page puts Southwest Florida International Airport about 25 minutes from Jonathans Bay. The route depends on traffic on US 41 and the east-west roads to I-75, so check the drive at the time of day you fly, especially in season.
Fort Myers Beach is about 20 minutes away and the Sanibel Causeway about 15 minutes, according to a broker page. Jonathans Bay has no deeded beach access or beach club, so beach days mean a drive and public parking.
HealthPark Medical Center, home to HealthPark Hospital and Golisano Children’s Hospital at 9981 South HealthPark Drive, is about 10 minutes away by a broker’s estimate, and Gulf Coast Medical Center at 13681 Doctor’s Way is also within 8 miles on Lee County’s hospitals layer.
Jonathans Bay owners shop along US 41 and Gladiolus Drive, about 5 minutes away by a broker’s estimate. The US 41 commercial corridor runs past the entrance, so groceries and errands are a short drive; there are no shops inside the gate.
We price a Jonathans Bay coach home from Lee County’s recorded sales of its own floor and plan first, then adjust for condition, updates, the view and the season, and we check the result against the 2026 county value and the active competition in the community. In the 12 months to October 2026 that meant a band of $225,000 to $310,000.
Fort Myers condo averages mix high-rise, garden and coach-home condominiums of every age, in and out of flood zones, with different fees. A Jonathans Bay home is a 2006 or 2007 coach home of 1,755 to 2,069 square feet with a garage, behind a gate, in Zone AE, and its own recorded sales describe that product best.
Usually. Over 36 months the 4 second-floor sales recorded a $317,500 median and the 10 first-floor sales $255,000; the second-floor homes are larger, and listings describe them with a two-car garage. In the last 12 months the one second-floor sale was the lowest price, so we read condition before applying any floor premium.
The $225,000 sale of 6100, unit 302, on February 23, 2026, at $109 a square foot, is one transaction about one unit. We read it with its listing history and condition before using it, and we show a buyer’s appraiser how the rest of the 12-month sales, from $230,000 to $310,000, fit around it.
Buying in Jonathans Bay means choosing a floor and plan, reading the recorded sales, reviewing the condominium documents and insurance, and closing with the estoppel certificate in hand. Here are the steps we take with every Jonathans Bay buyer, in order.
Check the air conditioning, water heater, plumbing, electrical panel, windows and shutters, lanai screens and the garage door. Ask the association for the 2024 roof permits, the building’s elevation certificate and any water intrusion reports, and get a wind mitigation report for your insurer.
A resale buyer receives the declaration, articles, bylaws, rules, the current budget and the most recent financial report under section 718.503, with a review period set by the contract. Read the leasing and pet rules, the reserve schedule and the insurance certificate first; those are the items buyers most often regret missing.
Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or contact us. We set up showings, pull the recorded sales for the plans you like and request the association’s documents early, so you write an offer with the fee, the rules and the flood details already in hand.
Jonathans Bay compares as the lowest-priced of the 2003 to 2011 lake condominiums near it: its $233,000 median on 6 recorded sales in the 12 months to October 2026 sits below Reflection Key, Harmony Pointe, Carriage Homes at Bell Tower Park and Prentiss Pointe, for homes of about the same size, with a garage on every unit and a gate.
Community (Lee County roll) | Units | Built | Levels on the roll | Garage on the roll | Median heated sq ft | 2026 median just value | Homestead share | Recorded sales, 12 months to Oct 2026 | Recorded sales, 36 months to Oct 2026 | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Jonathans Bay, 33908 | 152 | 2006 to 2007 | 1 and 2 | Every unit | 1,928 | $220,211 | 49% | 6, median $233,000 | 14, median $270,000 | 0 |
Prentiss Pointe, 33908 | 104 | 2005 to 2007, plus 36 units 2019 to 2022 | 1 and 2 | Every unit | 1,982 | $298,991 | 62% | 5, median $350,000 | 12, median $431,900 | 1.9 mi west |
Reflection Key, 33907 | 173 | 2007 to 2008 | 1, 2 and 3 | 32 of 173 | 1,797 | $248,814 | 45% | 9, median $265,000 | 21, median $308,500 | 1.5 mi northwest |
Carriage Homes at Bell Tower Park, 33912 | 286 | 2003 to 2008 | 1 and 2 | Every unit | 1,970 | $269,413 | 53% | 15, median $345,000 | 42, median $359,500 | 1.8 mi north |
Harmony Pointe at Emerson Square, 33908 | 84 | 2006 to 2011 | 1 and 2 | Every unit | 1,915 | $221,430 | 62% | 4, median $321,875 | 8, median $311,250 | 1.9 mi southeast |
Fairway Woods at The Forest, 33908 | 118 | 1986 to 1991 | 1 and 2 | Every unit | 1,937 | $220,699 | 39% | 11, median $325,000 | 31, median $330,000 | 0.4 mi south |
Gladiolus Gardens Condo, 33919 | 155 | 1980 to 1981 | 2 | None | 562 | $91,253 | 20% | 8, median $103,500 | 28, median $121,250 | 1.8 mi northwest |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll and recorded qualified sales, same method for every row (our pull, November 2026); distance is straight line between the communities’ roll centers. Data updated: November 2026.
Selling or buying in Jonathans Bay? Owners can get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072; buyers can call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers.
Prentiss Pointe, about 1.9 miles west in the same ZIP, is the closest like-for-like match: 104 lake-setting coach homes with a garage on every unit, a 1,982 square foot median and a 62 percent homestead share. It recorded 5 sales at a $350,000 median in the 12 months to October 2026, well above Jonathans Bay. Our Prentiss Pointe guide covers it, and the full comparison is in the next section.
Carriage Homes at Bell Tower Park, about 1.8 miles north, is the largest coach-home condominium nearby: 286 lake-setting units from 2003 to 2008, a garage on every unit and a 1,970 square foot median. It recorded 15 sales at a $345,000 median in the 12 months to October 2026, and it shares taxing district 047 with Jonathans Bay. Our partner team’s Bell Tower Park guide covers the area.
Reflection Key, about 1.5 miles northwest in ZIP 33907, is a 173-unit lake condominium from 2007 and 2008, also in district 047, with smaller units at a 1,797 square foot median, buildings of up to three levels on the roll and garages on 32 units. It recorded 9 sales at a $265,000 median in the 12 months to October 2026, above Jonathans Bay.
Because some Reflection Key units sit in three-level buildings on the roll, ask its association about milestone and SIRS status; Jonathans Bay’s two-story buildings are below that threshold.
Harmony Pointe at Emerson Square, about 1.9 miles southeast in the same ZIP, is a smaller coach-home condominium of 84 units from 2006 to 2011, with a garage on every unit, a 1,915 square foot median and a 62 percent homestead share. It recorded 4 sales at a $321,875 median in the 12 months to October 2026. Its county values run close to Jonathans Bay’s; its recent sales ran higher.
Fairway Woods at The Forest, about 0.4 mile south, offers about the same size, a 1,937 square foot median with a garage on every unit, in a golf-side setting, but its buildings date from 1986 to 1991. It recorded 11 sales at a $325,000 median in the 12 months to October 2026. Our Fairway Woods at The Forest guide covers it; club membership terms there are separate.
Gladiolus Gardens Condo, about 1.8 miles northwest, is a different product: 155 one- and two-bedroom units from 1980 and 1981 with a 562 square foot median and no garages on the roll. It recorded 8 sales at a $103,500 median in the 12 months to October 2026. Jonathans Bay’s homes are more than three times as large, and every one has a garage.
Other south Fort Myers communities we cover include The Forest, Briarcliff, Devonwood Estates and Island Park Woods. Each guide reads its own recorded sales, flood zone and fees the way this one does.
For the wider market, see our Fort Myers real estate market report and the Fort Myers area guide.
Jonathans Bay and Prentiss Pointe are the closest like-for-like coach-home condominiums in ZIP 33908, about 1.9 miles apart: both lake-setting coach-home condominiums with median homes of 1,928 and 1,982 square feet, both with a garage on every unit and both in Zone AE. Jonathans Bay recorded the lower prices over the last 12 months, by a wide margin.
Factor | Jonathans Bay | Prentiss Pointe |
|---|---|---|
What it is | One condominium, 152 coach homes in 14 buildings | Coach-home condominium, 104 units |
Built | 2006 to 2007 | 2005 to 2007, plus 36 units 2019 to 2022 |
Levels on the roll | 76 first-floor, 76 second-floor | 52 at one level, 52 at two |
Garage on the roll | Every unit | Every unit |
Median unit size | 1,928 sq ft | 1,982 sq ft |
Recorded sales, 12 months to Oct 2026 | 6, median $233,000, $131 a sq ft | 5, median $350,000, $200 a sq ft |
Recorded sales, 36 months to Oct 2026 | 14, median $270,000 | 12, median $431,900 |
2026 median just value | $220,211 | $298,991 |
Homestead share on the roll | 49% | 62% |
Flood zone | AE, 11 foot base flood elevation | AE, 10 foot base flood elevation (our Prentiss Pointe guide) |
Taxing district, 2026 adopted | 047 South Trail Fire, 13.3623 mills | 068 Iona McGregor Fire, 13.3623 mills |
On price per square foot, Jonathans Bay. Its 12-month median of $131 a square foot sits well below Prentiss Pointe’s $200, for homes of about the same median size, and the county values Jonathans Bay units about a quarter lower. Prentiss Pointe also includes 36 units built from 2019 to 2022, which a buyer should weigh; compare the fees, what they cover and the roof dates before deciding.
Choose Jonathans Bay if you want the lower recent price per square foot, a larger community of 152 units and its gated clubhouse setting with a pool, spa and fitness room. Choose Prentiss Pointe if you want a higher homestead share and the option of a newer building. Confirm each community’s fees, leasing rules and master insurance for the exact unit before you write an offer.
Our partner team’s Fort Myers guide covers the wider city and what is on the market in its condominium communities.
Jonathans Bay’s main advantages are large single-level coach homes with a garage on every unit, a gate, a lakeside clubhouse with a pool, spa and fitness room, cable and internet in the fee, two-story buildings below the condo safety law threshold, and the lowest recent prices among its coach-home peers. Its drawbacks are FEMA Zone AE below the base flood elevation, Evacuation Zone A, falling resale prices and a fee of about $755 a month.
Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
1,755 to 2,069 square foot single-level homes | FEMA Zone AE (11 foot base flood elevation) and Evacuation Zone A |
A garage for every unit on the roll | Typical ground about 2.5 feet below the base flood elevation |
Gated, with a private loop road | 12-month median about 39 percent below the 2023 median |
Lakeside clubhouse, pool, spa and fitness room | Condo fee printed at about $742 to $755 a month |
Cable TV, internet, water, sewer and trash in the fee, per a listing | US 41 traffic at the entrance |
Two-story buildings; no milestone inspection or SIRS on the public record | No golf, no boating, no beach access |
Tile roofs replaced in 2024, per a 2026 listing | Roof funding, budget and rules not public |
$131 a square foot on 12-month sales, the lowest in our comparison table | Few sales a year, so few direct comparisons |
Selling or buying in Jonathans Bay? Owners can get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072; buyers can call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers.
The biggest risk for a Jonathans Bay buyer is flood exposure: Zone AE with typical ground about 2.5 feet below the 11 foot base flood elevation, and Evacuation Zone A. Read the master policy’s flood cover, ask for elevation certificates and the claims history, and get your own HO-6 and contents flood quotes before your inspection period ends.
It depends on your horizon. Jonathans Bay’s 12-month median of $233,000 sits 38.8 percent below the 2023 median of $381,000, so a buyer pays far less than recent owners did, but the record does not show where prices go next. We read the active and pending units, the fee and the condition behind each sale before advising.
On the roll, Jonathans Bay pairs a garage on every unit with homes of 1,755 to 2,069 square feet, a gate and a clubhouse, at the lowest 12-month price per square foot of the seven condominiums in our comparison table. Only Gladiolus Gardens, a much smaller and older product, recorded a lower median.
Selling a Jonathans Bay coach home well means pricing it on the 2026 recorded Jonathans Bay sales for its floor and plan, presenting the size, the garage, the lake view and the gated clubhouse setting as the assets they are, and answering the fee, flood, insurance and roof questions up front. McGreevy and Comisar have done this for Southwest Florida owners for more than a decade as the #1 team in the region.
If you’re searching for the best Jonathans Bay listing agent, or thinking, ‘I need to sell my condo in Jonathans Bay…’, McGreevy and Comisar helps owners price, market, negotiate and sell with a local strategy built for Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples, Lee County, Collier County and Babcock Ranch. Whether you are selling a first-floor 1,755 or 1,832 square foot home or a second-floor 2,024 or 2,069 square foot home, our team provides local market guidance, professional listing exposure and a clear plan to help you sell confidently.
Jonathans Bay sold-market statistics we tracked: 14 recorded Lee County qualified resales from November 2023 to October 2026, $225,000 to $345,000, a $270,000 median; 6 resales at a $233,000 median in the 12 months to October 31, 2026; no builder-direct sales. Days on market and sale-to-list ratio are read from the Southwest Florida MLS for your unit when we prepare your pricing.
Selling in Jonathans Bay is different. Your buyer asks for the quarterly fee and what it covers, the 2024 roof and how it was paid for, the reserves, the master insurance and its flood cover, the flood zone and evacuation zone, the storm history, whether the unit has shutters or impact glass, the leasing and pet rules, and how the bulk cable and internet contract works. We gather those before the home goes live.
What Is Your Jonathans Bay Home Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds. Start your free Fort Myers home valuation or use our Southwest Florida home valuation form.
(239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome. Want the complete seller’s guide? Read our Sell Your Home in Fort Myers page for pricing strategy, marketing and the full McGreevy and Comisar listing process, and our selling overview. For the wider picture, see our Fort Myers real estate market report.
Jonathans Bay homes sell at a slow pace: Lee County recorded 6 qualified resales in the 12 months to October 31, 2026 and 11 in 24 months, out of 152 units. One 2024 listing went from a December list date to an October 2025 recording after four price cuts, and a broker summary put average days on market at 258. We read days on market for your plan from the Southwest Florida MLS.
A Jonathans Bay buyer will ask the quarterly fee and what it covers, any special assessment, how the 2024 roofs were funded, the master insurance and its flood cover, the flood zone and evacuation zone, any water in past storms, whether the unit has shutters or impact glass, the age of the air conditioning and water heater, and the leasing and pet rules.
Sometimes. Jonathans Bay’s first-floor sales in the 12 months to October 2026 ran from $230,000 to $310,000 on similar plans, a spread that points to condition. An update has to move your home up that band to pay off, so we compare the cost of paint, flooring or an air conditioner with recent sales of your floor and plan first.
Yes, in your favor. Buyers worried about the condo safety laws ask first whether a building needs a SIRS or a milestone inspection. Jonathans Bay’s buildings are two stories, below the three-story threshold, and we say so plainly in the listing, with the association’s written confirmation where we can get it.
A Jonathans Bay seller typically pays the brokerage commission agreed in the listing agreement, Florida documentary stamp tax on the deed under section 201.02, the owner’s title insurance policy by Lee County custom, prorated taxes and fees, and the estoppel fee. Our Fort Myers seller guide has a full net sheet.
McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, are the local real estate experts for Jonathans Bay and Fort Myers: Jesse McGreevy leads listing and seller strategy, Marc Comisar leads buyer representation and negotiation, and as the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate across Southwest Florida.
Jesse McGreevy is a top-reviewed Jonathans Bay realtor, and the reviews below are quoted exactly as clients wrote them on our Google Business Profile. We do not edit, combine or summarize client words.
★★★★★ “Their recommendation on pricing my unit was sound and proved prescient. I never questioned their integrity and found it easy to rely on their recommendations. I would work with them again in a heartbeat.” Verified Google review
★★★★★ “Not living in the area, Jesse made life easy for me when we decided to sell our condo. His attention to detail, patience, understanding, and tenacity in dealing with all the moving parts was truly impressive.” Verified Google review
★★★★★ “Marc knows the market, works for his buyer and is attentive to his goals.” Verified Google review
Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC). Florida license numbers: Jesse McGreevy SL3101296, Marc Comisar BK3060671.
Meet Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, read more about McGreevy and Comisar, see our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers, or contact us.
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.
Jonathans Bay is a gated condominium on Jonathans Bay Circle in unincorporated south Fort Myers, ZIP 33908. Its entrance is on Jonathans Bay Drive off US 41 (South Tamiami Trail), on the west side of the highway south of Gladiolus Drive. It is on the US 41 corridor, not on Summerlin Road or McGregor Boulevard.
Jonathans Bay offers large single-level coach homes of 1,755 to 2,069 square feet, a garage on every unit, a gate and a lakeside clubhouse with a pool, spa and fitness room, at a 12-month median of $233,000. The trade-offs are FEMA Zone AE, Evacuation Zone A, a fee of about $755 a month and falling resale prices since 2023.
Lee County recorded 6 qualified Jonathans Bay sales from November 2025 through October 2026, from $225,000 to $310,000, at a $233,000 median and about $131 a square foot. Over 36 months there were 14 sales at a $270,000 median. The 2023 median was $381,000, and November 2026 asking prices ran from $229,900 to $369,000.
Jonathans Bay has a condominium fee. Listings show $2,225 to $2,265 a quarter, about $742 to $755 a month, and one listing says it covers cable TV, internet, irrigation water, grounds, management, exterior pest control, sewer, street lights, street maintenance, trash and water. No CDD was found. Confirm the current budget with the association.
The county roll mails both Jonathans Bay association entities’ bills to 2180 W State Road 434, Suite 5000, in Longwood, which Sentry Management lists as its headquarters address; Sentry has a Fort Myers office on University Drive. Management contracts change, so confirm the current manager before you request an estoppel certificate or the condominium documents.
The Lee County roll shows 152 condominium units in 14 two-story buildings of 8, 10 or 12 units, built in 2006 and 2007. Each building pairs first-floor and second-floor homes. Plans are 1,755, 1,832, 2,024 and 2,069 heated square feet, and every unit has a garage on the roll.
Yes. Broker pages, listings and a rental listing describe Jonathans Bay as a gated community, with a private loop road, Jonathans Bay Circle, behind the entrance on Jonathans Bay Drive. Ask the association how the gate works today and how guests and deliveries are admitted, and give visitors the building and unit number.
We found no age restriction for Jonathans Bay in the public sources we read, and we do not state an age rule. The declaration and rules were not read, so confirm with the association and the recorded declaration whether any age rule applies; a legal age restriction would appear in those documents.
Yes, with limits. Listings report a 90-day minimum lease, and a rental manager says the association requires a lease application and background screening at least 60 days before a tenant’s arrival. One rental listing said only one lease a year is allowed. Read the declaration and rules before you buy a unit to rent.
Yes. Listings show a limit of two pets, and one aggregator reports breed restrictions. No weight limit was published in the sources we read, and some owners lease their units pet-free. Buyers with a large dog should get the written pet rules from the association before signing a contract.
Every Jonathans Bay building sits in FEMA Zone AE with an 11 foot base flood elevation on panel 12071C0438H, effective November 17, 2022. Lee County’s LiDAR puts typical ground near 8.5 feet, and the community is in Evacuation Zone A. Lenders on federally backed loans require flood cover; check each building’s elevation certificate.
No public report names Jonathans Bay. Lee County’s damage layers show no assessment records inside it, sales reached record prices in 2023, and a 2026 listing reports tile roofs replaced in 2024. Milton’s EF2 tornado began about 0.8 mile north. Ask the association for its claims history before you buy.
Yes. Every one of the 152 Jonathans Bay units carries a garage on the 2026 Lee County roll. Listings describe a one-car garage with the first-floor homes and a two-car garage with the second-floor homes. Ask the association about guest parking and its rules on trucks, boats and trailers.
Yes. Each Jonathans Bay home is a single-level flat in a two-story building: 76 first-floor homes at ground level and 76 second-floor homes above them. The roll records the unit’s level, not a two-level layout. If you want a ground-level home, focus on the 1,755 and 1,832 square foot first-floor plans.
Yes. The clubhouse is a 1,968 square foot building from 2006 on a 4.28-acre parcel at 6001 Jonathans Bay Circle, and listings name a pool, which a rental listing describes as heated, a spa, a fitness room and a picnic and barbecue area. No separate membership was found; the amenities are covered by the fee.
Not on the public record. Florida’s milestone inspection and SIRS rules apply to condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories, and Jonathans Bay’s buildings are two stories, a first-floor and a second-floor home in each pair. Ask the association for its written confirmation, and still ask for its reserve schedule.
No. Jonathans Bay has a Fort Myers mailing address and ZIP 33908, but it sits in unincorporated Lee County. The roll codes every parcel ULC with taxing district 047, South Trail Fire, so Lee County handles zoning and permits and the tax bill carries county and fire district millage instead of City millage.
At the adopted 2026 rate of 13.3623 mills in district 047, the median homesteaded Jonathans Bay unit owes about $2,060 a year in ad valorem tax and the median non-homestead unit about $2,943, based on the 2026 roll. Solid waste and other non-ad valorem charges are extra, and a buyer’s assessment resets at purchase.
No CDD was found. One 2026 listing reported no CDD, and the 2026 roll shows only the standard districts on Jonathans Bay units, South Trail Fire and residential garbage district 002. The tax bill carries non-ad valorem lines such as solid waste; check the unit’s bill on the Lee County Tax Collector’s site.
Lee County assigns by choice within proximity zones. The county’s 2026-2027 layer places every Jonathans Bay building in elementary zone O, middle zone MM and high school South sub-zone 2. Rayma C. Page Elementary is about 1.7 miles away and South Fort Myers High about 2.1 miles. Confirm any address with the district’s lookup.
A broker page puts Southwest Florida International Airport about 25 minutes from Jonathans Bay, Fort Myers Beach about 20 minutes and the Sanibel Causeway about 15 minutes. Traffic on US 41 in season adds time, so time the drives at the hours you would make them. There is no deeded beach access.
Jonathans Bay recorded the lower recent price: a $233,000 median over 12 months, against $350,000 at Prentiss Pointe and $345,000 at Carriage Homes at Bell Tower Park, for coach homes of about the same size with garages. Buyers there paid more per square foot; compare fees, roofs and flood details before choosing.
A Jonathans Bay owner needs an HO-6 policy for the interior, finishes, contents and liability, with loss assessment cover for the master policy’s deductible. The association insures the buildings at replacement cost, paid through the fee; ask whether its master policy carries flood cover, and consider contents flood cover in Zone AE.
Check before you write an offer. FHA loans on condominiums need the project on HUD’s approved list, which you can search on HUD’s FHA condominium lookup. VA loans have their own review, and conventional lenders review the budget, reserves, insurance and owner-occupancy, so ask your lender early about Jonathans Bay.
McGreevy and Comisar are the best listing agents for Jonathans Bay because we price a coach home from Lee County’s recorded Jonathans Bay sales of its own floor and plan, present the size, the garage, the lake view and the gated clubhouse setting, and answer the fee, flood and insurance questions before buyers ask. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
A Jonathans Bay home’s value starts from its floor’s and plan’s recorded sales. In the 12 months to October 31, 2026, Lee County recorded 6 sales at a $233,000 median, from $225,000 to $310,000. Condition, the view and updates shape your figure; request a free home valuation built on those sales.
Jonathans Bay’s first-floor homes recorded 5 sales in the 12 months to October 2026, from $230,000 to $310,000, at a $235,000 median. Over 36 months the 1,755 square foot end plan recorded a $240,000 median on 5 sales and the 1,832 square foot plan $290,000 on 5. Your unit’s condition decides where it sits.
Jonathans Bay’s second-floor homes, 2,024 and 2,069 square feet, recorded 4 sales over 36 months at a $317,500 median, from $225,000 to $345,000. The only second-floor sale in the last 12 months recorded $225,000 in February 2026, so we read its condition and listing history before pricing yours against it.
They are different plans. The end positions are the 1,755 square foot first-floor and 2,024 square foot second-floor homes, and the interior positions are 1,832 and 2,069 square feet. Over 36 months the 1,755 square foot end plan recorded a lower median than the 1,832 square foot interior plan, so we price each against its own plan.
It depends on your plans. Jonathans Bay’s 12-month median of $233,000 sits 16.8 percent below the prior 12 months and 38.8 percent below 2023, and only 6 units sold in 12 months. If you are buying again in Southwest Florida, you sell and buy in the same market. We read the active and pending units before advising on timing.
Jonathans Bay recorded 7 qualified sales in 2025 and 4 in 2026 to October 31, out of 152 units, according to Lee County; 2021 and 2022 brought 19 and 17. With so few sales, each listing faces little direct competition inside the gate, and price, condition and presentation decide how fast it sells.
Jonathans Bay’s first buyers paid a $283,000 median for 125 units in 2006, from $230,000 to $396,800, and a $215,000 median for 17 units first sold in 2007, according to the county record of first qualified sales per unit. Your unit’s original price is on its county parcel record; we pull it with the full sale history.
The county record shows the fall but not the cause: Jonathans Bay’s median went from $381,000 on 8 sales in 2023 to $325,000 in 2024, $260,000 in 2025 and $230,500 in 2026 to October 31. Flood exposure, insurance costs and the fee are what buyers ask about most, so a listing that answers them well competes best.
Usually. Over 36 months Jonathans Bay’s second-floor homes recorded a $317,500 median and the first-floor homes $255,000; the second-floor plans are larger and listings describe them with a two-car garage. Some buyers want a ground-level home and pay for it, so we price your home against its own floor’s sales first.
Yes. Jonathans Bay has four plans, 1,755, 1,832, 2,024 and 2,069 square feet, and the county values each differently, from a $210,703 median for the 1,755 square foot plan to $239,713 for the 2,069 square foot plan. We price your home against recent sales of its own plan, then adjust for condition and the view.
Usually not a full renovation. Paint, lighting, a deep clean and repairs an inspector would flag tend to pay; a new kitchen rarely returns its cost in Jonathans Bay’s price band. First-floor sales in the last 12 months ran from $230,000 to $310,000, so we compare any project’s cost with the step it could earn within that band.
They help in two ways: buyers in Zone AE and Evacuation Zone A ask about storm protection first, and a wind mitigation report under section 627.711 can credit opening protection on the buyer’s insurance. Keep the permits and product approvals for the listing file; we feature them in the description and the disclosures.
A Jonathans Bay seller typically pays the brokerage commission agreed in the listing agreement, Florida documentary stamp tax on the deed under section 201.02, the owner’s title insurance policy by Lee County custom, prorated taxes and fees, and the estoppel fee. Our Fort Myers seller guide has a full net sheet.
Your buyer may. The declaration and rules decide whether the association approves buyers and how long it takes, and a rental manager reports approval and background screening for tenants. Ask the manager for the application and the timeline when you list, so approval does not delay the closing date in the contract.
Florida sellers must disclose known facts that materially affect value and are not readily observable, and section 689.302 requires a flood disclosure, including any flood insurance claims and federal flood assistance. In Zone AE that disclosure matters. The condominium documents go to the buyer under section 718.503. We prepare the package with you before listing.
If your buyer uses a federally backed mortgage, the lender requires flood cover on the building, which in a condominium is normally the association’s flood policy on the buildings. Ask your association whether its master policy carries flood cover and have the declarations page ready, because a buyer’s lender will ask for it.
Yes, if the buyer’s plan fits the association’s leasing rules. Investors ask first about the 90-day minimum lease reported by listings, any limit on leases a year and the screening process, and those come from the declaration and rules, not from a listing. Ask the association for the current leasing rules in writing.
A financed Jonathans Bay sale usually takes several weeks from contract to closing, and a cash sale can close sooner, subject to the contract, the estoppel certificate, the buyer’s document review period and any association approval. Order the estoppel early and confirm the approval timeline when you sign the listing agreement.
It depends on the buyer pool. With 74 of 152 units homesteaded on the roll, many buyers plan to live in the home full time and may not want the furniture, while buyers who will lease or use the home part of the year often like it furnished. We decide with you after reading the current competition.
It helps. A current wind mitigation report under section 627.711 documents the roof covering, roof-to-wall connections and opening protection, and your buyer’s insurer uses it to price the policy. With the 2024 tile roofs reported by a listing, an updated report can lower the buyer’s premium and make the home easier to sell.
Less than it seems, when it is explained. The $225,000 sale of 6100, unit 302, a 2,069 square foot second-floor home, recorded February 23, 2026 at $109 a square foot, the lowest in the 12 months. It describes one transaction; we explain it in your pricing file so an appraiser reads it in context.
Your unit’s heated living area is on its Lee County Property Appraiser parcel record: Jonathans Bay’s plans are 1,755, 1,832, 2,024 and 2,069 square feet on the roll. Units ending in 1 are first-floor homes and units ending in 2 are second-floor homes. Use the county figure when you compare your home with recent sales.
Every Jonathans Bay unit is governed by the Jonathans Bay Condo declaration recorded in Lee County as instrument 2006-21492, with the 2006 phase instrument for your building, for example 2006-271708 for building 6091. Each comes with its amendments, bylaws and rules. Read them at the Lee County Clerk’s official records search.
Not if it is explained. Listings printed Jonathans Bay fees of $2,225 to $2,265 a quarter, and one listing says the fee covers cable TV, internet, water, sewer, trash, irrigation, grounds, management and pest control. Buyers compare what a fee covers, not only the number, so we present the current budget and what it pays for.
Your buyer’s taxes reset at purchase. With 74 of 152 units homesteaded, many sellers pay far less than a buyer will: we estimate about $2,943 a year at the median 2026 value without an exemption, or about $2,395 in the first year with a homestead exemption. We give buyers that estimate up front.
That depends on your basis, how long you owned and lived in the home, and your tax situation. The federal home-sale exclusion explained in IRS Publication 523 can exclude much or all of the gain on a main home if the ownership and use tests are met. Ask your tax adviser before you list.
Yes. A home owned by a trust, an estate or an LLC can be sold by the trustee, personal representative or manager with authority to sign. The title company will ask for the trust certificate, letters of administration or the company’s documents. Gather them early, because the estoppel request uses the owner’s legal name.
We market a Jonathans Bay home with professional photography, drone video of the lakes, the fountains, the clubhouse and the gated loop road, a listing written around the plan, the floor, the garage and the view, the association facts buyers ask for, and our qualified-buyer database. We price from the plan’s recorded sales.
Yes. Roofs are common elements, so the roof date, the permit and how the work was paid for go straight to the buyer’s insurance quote and inspection. A 2026 listing reports tile roofs replaced in 2024; ask the association for your building’s roof permit and the funding history before you list, and we feature it.
You can, but few owners net more that way. A Jonathans Bay buyer needs the floor and plan comparison, the association documents, the flood and insurance answers and a negotiation that holds the price through inspection. We handle all of it, and our marketing reaches buyers who never drive past the gate on US 41.
Yes. In the 12 months to October 2026, Jonathans Bay recorded a $233,000 median at $131 a square foot, and Prentiss Pointe a $350,000 median at $200 a square foot, for coach homes of about the same median size. We use that comparison to show buyers what a Jonathans Bay home offers for the money.
Request a free Fort Myers home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. We read your home against the recorded Jonathans Bay sales of its floor and plan, then adjust for condition, the view, the roof and updates, and send you the sales we used.
The sources below are the primary records behind every Jonathans Bay figure on this page: the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, millage book and recorded sales (roll exported November 1, 2026, sales index built November 18, 2026), the Florida Department of Revenue tax rolls, Lee County GIS layers, FEMA, the National Weather Service, the School District of Lee County, news reporting, listings and the Florida Statutes. This edition prints no MLS statistics; listing-reported details are labeled.
Source | Publisher | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
Lee County Property Appraiser | 2026 roll: units, plans, years built, values, homestead | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | Recorded qualified sales | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | Online parcel inquiry | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | Common elements, 21.05 acres | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | Clubhouse parcel, 4.28 acres | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | District 047, 13.3623 mills adopted | |
Lee County Property Appraiser | Preliminary 2026 rates | |
Florida Department of Revenue | 2025 and 2026 tax rolls | |
Florida Department of Revenue | Homestead exemption | |
Lee County GIS | Parcel outlines for the aerial | |
Lee County Clerk of Court | Declaration, instrument 2006-21492 and phases | |
Lee County Tax Collector | Tax bill, non-ad valorem section | |
Florida Department of State | Association filings | |
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development | FHA approval by condominium | |
South Trail Fire Protection and Rescue District | 2.5000 mill rate | |
Lee County Board of County Commissioners | Jonathan’s Bay water system acceptance |
Source | Publisher | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
Business Observer | Transeastern sale of Jonathans Bay and three other projects, $27.8 million | |
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission | Transeastern joint venture defaults | |
Builder | January 29, 2008 filing | |
Lee County Library System | Association meeting at Lakes Regional Library | |
Lee County Library System | Bulk cable and internet | |
Greater Fort Myers Chamber of Commerce | Bulk service provider | |
Sentry Management | Longwood headquarters and Fort Myers office |
Source | Publisher | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
My Sanibel Real Estate | Location, gate, amenities, drive times | |
My Sanibel Real Estate | 2024 tile roofs, shutters, 2025 tax | |
My Sanibel Real Estate | $2,150 a month lease | |
Bex Realty | Plans, pets, no golf | |
Keegan Sells Naples | November 2026 asking prices and days on market (broker estimate) | |
Neighborhoods.com | Quarterly fees on 2026 listings | |
Royal Shell Vacation Rentals | Lease application and screening, heated pool | |
Move With Momentum | About 9 feet, Zone AE, no CDD |
Source | Publisher | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
Lee County GIS | Zone AE, 11 foot base flood elevation, all 14 buildings | |
Lee County GIS | Panel 12071C0438H, effective November 17, 2022 | |
Lee County GIS | The panel map | |
Lee County Department of Community Development | 2022 map revision | |
Lee County GIS | Evacuation Zone A, surge zone 1 | |
Lee County GIS | LiDAR ground heights, median 8.5 feet | |
Lee County GIS | No records inside the community | |
Lee County GIS | No records inside the community | |
FEMA | Address flood map lookup | |
FEMA | How flood premiums are set | |
Residential Condominium Building Association Policy, F-144 (PDF) | FEMA | Condominium building flood policy |
Citizens Property Insurance | Flood requirement, condominium unit-owner exemption | |
Citizens Property Insurance | Condominium policies | |
Citizens Property Insurance | HO-6 and wind policy information | |
WGCU | Community Rating System discount, November 2024 | |
FEMA decision to maintain Community Rating System classification (PDF) | Lee County | Community Rating System class |
National Hurricane Center | Ian, September 2022 | |
AccuWeather | 7.26 foot record at Fort Myers | |
WUSF | Fort Myers gauge in Ian, Helene and Milton | |
National Weather Service Tampa Bay | EF2 Fort Myers tornado start point | |
NBC Miami | 5 to 10 foot surge estimate in coastal Lee | |
Lee County | Helene and Milton in Lee County | |
State of Florida | Evacuation planning | |
USDA NAIP via USGS | Hero aerial |
Source | Publisher | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
Lee County GIS | Zones O, MM and South 2 | |
School District of Lee County | Grades posted July 1, 2026 | |
School District of Lee County | Choice zones | |
School District of Lee County | Proximity and transportation | |
Lee County GIS | Jonathans Bay Drive and nearby roads | |
Lee County GIS | HealthPark and Gulf Coast Medical Center | |
Lee County GIS | School distances | |
MapQuest | Preschool at the entrance |
Source | Publisher | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
The Florida Senate | Condominium Act | |
Online Sunshine | Rental amendments, subsection 13 | |
The Florida Senate | Official records, insurance, website rule | |
Online Sunshine | Replacement-cost insurance, website within 30 days | |
The Florida Senate | Budgets, reserves | |
The Florida Senate | Estoppel certificate | |
The Florida Senate | Resale documents | |
The Florida Senate | Milestone inspection rule | |
Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums | Three-story threshold, December 31, 2025 SIRS deadline | |
The Florida Senate | Habitable-story threshold, reserve changes | |
Withum | HB 913 inspection and reserve changes | |
The Florida Senate | Website rule for 25 or more units | |
Becker | Website rule from January 1, 2026 | |
The Florida Senate | Building safety law | |
Florida Realtors | Seller disclosure form | |
The Florida Senate | Seller flood disclosure | |
The Florida Senate | Deed stamp tax | |
The Florida Senate | Homestead exemption | |
The Florida Senate | Assessment reset after sale | |
The Florida Senate | Mitigation credits | |
The Florida Senate | HO-6 coverage | |
Internal Revenue Service | Home-sale exclusion |
Jonathans Bay’s downloadable documents are public records a buyer or seller uses in a Jonathans Bay transaction, each linked to the publisher’s own copy: the Lee County millage book, the FEMA panel map and condominium flood policy form, Lee County’s 2007 water system acceptance, the Florida Senate summaries of the 2024 and 2025 condominium laws, the DBPR milestone and SIRS guidance, the Florida Realtors disclosure form, the storm reports and the IRS home-sale guide.
Document | Publisher | Date | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
2026 Taxing District Millage Book (PDF) | Lee County Property Appraiser | 2026 | |
FIRM panel 12071C0438 (PDF) | Lee County GIS, from FEMA | effective November 17, 2022 | |
Residential Condominium Building Association Policy, F-144 (PDF) | FEMA | 2021 | |
Consent agenda item C10G, Jonathan’s Bay water system (PDF) | Lee County Board of County Commissioners | March 13, 2007 | |
CS/CS/HB 913 bill summary | The Florida Senate | 2025 | |
HB 1021 bill summary | The Florida Senate | 2024 | |
Milestone inspections and SIRS guidance | Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums | current | |
Milestone Inspection and SIRS Disclosure, MISIRS-1 (PDF) | Florida Realtors | 2025 | |
Hurricane Milton tornado summary (PDF) | National Weather Service Tampa Bay | final summary November 2, 2024 | |
Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian (PDF) | National Hurricane Center | storm of September 2022 | |
Publication 523, Selling Your Home | Internal Revenue Service | current edition |
Market data from the Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 parcel roll exported November 1, 2026, the Florida Department of Revenue 2025 and 2026 tax rolls for Lee County and the Lee County sale data files indexed November 18, 2026; newest recorded Jonathans Bay sale September 25, 2026. Data updated: November 2026. Southwest Florida MLS statistics were not pulled for this edition. Jonathans Bay is recorded as one condominium, Jonathans Bay Condo, declared in 2006 in 14 phases and built in 2006 and 2007; its unit counts on this page are the Lee County roll’s. Listing-reported fees, rules and features are labeled as such. This guide is general information about Jonathans Bay, not an appraisal and not legal, tax or insurance advice. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.
McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Jonathans Bay. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.
Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.