Holiday Shores

Holiday Shores

Holiday Shores is a 1950s bay-side plat of 35 parcels on Coral, Coquina, Dolphin and Bayland in Fort Myers Beach, steps from the Gulf beach, Publix and a marina, with no HOA or CDD found. Sell, value or buy with McGreevy and Comisar.

Search Homes

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.

Holiday Shores is a small 1950s bay-side plat of four blocks and 35 county parcels on mid Estero Island in the Town of Fort Myers Beach, ZIP 33931, on Coral Road, Coquina Road, Dolphin Lane, Bayland Road and the 4800 block of Estero Boulevard, just southeast of the island Publix and Snook Bight Marina [1][2][6][26][28]. McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

Here is the short answer most Holiday Shores searchers need: it is a recorded plat, not a planned community, with no gate, no club, no golf, no association found under the name and no CDD; every parcel sits in FEMA's Special Flood Hazard Area, VE on Estero Boulevard and AE on the side streets; and older homes sold for $540,000 to $829,000 from June 2025 to September 2026, while a 2025 elevated new build sold for $1,759,000 [1][31][32][11]. Our Fort Myers Beach real estate guide covers the wider island.

Why McGreevy and Comisar Are the Best Realtor for Holiday Shores

McGreevy and Comisar are the best realtor for Holiday Shores because a 35-parcel plat with 1950s ranches, post-Ian vacant lots, two new elevated homes, a VE and AE flood split and very few sales a year needs an agent who prices from the county record first: the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012.

If you're searching for the best realtor for Holiday Shores in Fort Myers Beach, Florida, whether you own one of its homes or lots and may want to sell or you want to buy a bay-side street a short walk from the Gulf beach, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Nationally since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. Buyers and sellers comparing the best real estate agents in Fort Myers Beach should ask each agent to explain Holiday Shores from the county record, and we do that below.

Holiday Shores market record (Lee County qualified sales): older homes sold for $540,000 to $829,000 from June 2025 to September 2026, the new elevated home at 4841 Estero Boulevard sold for $1,759,000 on April 6, 2026, the highest price in the plat's recorded history, and vacant lots sold for $360,000 to $515,000 from September 2025 to October 2026 [1].

For Holiday Shores buyers: the first question is the house itself, because most surviving homes are ground-level 1950s to 1970s ranches of about 900 to 2,850 square feet, and the Town's 50% rule limits what you can spend on them before the whole building must meet flood rules [1][34]. The second is the flood zone: Estero Boulevard lots map VE with a 14 foot base flood elevation, the side streets AE at 11 feet [11]. The third is water: frontage and docks are not confirmed lot by lot [5].

For Holiday Shores sellers: your street, your lot and whether the buyer sees a house or a building site set the comparison. The same 2,313 square foot 1989 home at 4838 Coral Road recorded $745,000 in March 2022 and $610,000 in June 2025, so your price cannot come from an island-wide average. We price from the recorded Holiday Shores sales that fit your parcel [1].

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Selling your Holiday Shores home or lot? Get a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. You can also read our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers Beach.

Buying in Holiday Shores? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida.

Key Takeaways

Holiday Shores in brief: a four-block, 35-parcel bay-side plat on mid Estero Island in the Town of Fort Myers Beach, with every figure below traced to the Lee County Property Appraiser and county GIS layers, FEMA, the school district, the Town of Fort Myers Beach, Florida law, local history records or news reports [1][2][11][17].

  • What it is: Holiday Shores, Plat Book 9, Page 33, Blocks A to D, in Section 28, Township 46 South, Range 24 East [1].
  • Parcels on the 2026 roll: 26 single-family homes, 1 duplex, 7 vacant residential lots and 1 tiny 0.02-acre sliver [1].
  • Built: homes from 1950 to 2025; 11 of 27 improved parcels date from 1950 to 1955, and two elevated homes went up in 2024 and 2025 [1].
  • Sizes: 896 to 2,848 heated square feet, median 1,390; 2 to 4 bedrooms; lots of about 0.13 to 0.32 acre [1][3].
  • Association: none found under the name, no CDD, no gate, no club and no golf [31][32][1].
  • Recent sales: older homes $540,000 to $829,000 (June 2025 to September 2026); a 2025 new build $1,759,000 (April 2026); lots $360,000 to $515,000 [1].
  • Flood: all of it in the Special Flood Hazard Area; VE 14 on Estero Boulevard, AE 11 on the side streets, on panel 12071C0566G effective November 17, 2022 [11][12].
  • Ground elevation: about 3.6 to 4.3 feet NAVD 88 at three points in the plat [15].
  • Rentals: short-term rentals must register with the Town; the 2027 fee is $400 per unit [21].
  • Walkable: the Gulf beach across Estero Boulevard, Publix at 4791 Estero Boulevard and Snook Bight Marina at 4765 Estero Boulevard [26][28][30].

What Is Holiday Shores?

Holiday Shores is a recorded 1950s plat, Holiday Shores Blocks A to D in Plat Book 9, Page 33, on the bay side of Estero Island inside the incorporated Town of Fort Myers Beach, with 35 county parcels, Lee County Commission District 3 and Census tract 602.03; it is a set of streets, not a branded or managed community [1][6][4].

Fact

Holiday Shores

Source

Streets

Estero Blvd 4801 to 4851 (odd side), Coral Rd, Coquina Rd, Dolphin Ln, Bayland Rd

[1][6]

City and ZIP

Town of Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

[6]

County

Lee County, Commission District 3

[4]

Plat

Plat Book 9, Page 33, Blocks A, B, C and D

[1]

Parcels

35 on the 2026 roll

[1]

Opened

1953, as Holliday Shores, by Guy Holliday

[7]

Gate, club, golf

None

[1]

Where exactly is Holiday Shores?

Mid-island, on the bay side of Estero Boulevard at the 4800 block, just southeast of the Publix shopping center at 4791 Estero Boulevard and Snook Bight Marina at 4765 Estero Boulevard. It is about 3.5 road miles southeast of Times Square and Lynn Hall Memorial Park [26][28][20].

Is it Holiday Shores or Holliday Shores?

Both names are real. The Estero Island Historic Society says Guy Holliday opened his "Holliday Shores" subdivision in 1953, and that years later it was renamed Holiday Shores when new residents thought they were correcting a spelling error, not knowing it was named for its owner [7].

Is Holiday Shores the same as Holiday Heights?

No. Holiday Heights is a different, north-end Fort Myers Beach plat dating to 1924. Bayland Heights, a separate 1958 plat, grew up next to Holiday Shores, and Laguna Shores and Island Shores are other Estero Island plats [9].

Is the Holiday Shores Homeowners Association in Virginia the same?

No. The only Holiday Shores Homeowners Association with federal tax records is in Buffalo Junction, Virginia. It is a name collision, not a Florida association [31].

What did the web get wrong about Holiday Shores?

Two things. One portal listing confused Holiday Shores with Laguna Shores, a different mid-island plat, and the two Holiday names, Holiday Shores and Holiday Heights, are often mixed up. We use the plat book and the county roll to keep them apart [1][9] [72].

Holiday Shores Streets and Blocks at a Glance

Holiday Shores is four blocks deep from Estero Boulevard toward the bay: Block A fronts Estero Boulevard and Coral Road, Block B runs between Coral and Coquina Roads, Block C between Coquina Road and Dolphin Lane, and Block D, with the largest lots, sits along Dolphin Lane and Bayland Road nearest the back-bay shoreline [1][6][3][5].

Part

Parcels

Character on the 2026 roll

Flood zone

Source

Block A, Estero Blvd frontage (4801 to 4851)

6

1 home (2004), 1 duplex (1950), 1 new elevated home (2025), 3 vacant lots

VE, BFE 14 ft

[1][11]

Block A, Coral Rd south side and 311 Bayland

6

1950s to 1989 homes, 1 new elevated home (2024), 3 vacant lots

AE, BFE 11 ft

[1][11]

Block B, Coral Rd north side, Coquina Rd south side, 313 Bayland

12

1954 to 1989 homes, a vacant lot at 4871 Coral, a 0.02-acre sliver at 4809 Coral

AE 11

[1][11]

Block C, Coquina Rd north side, Dolphin Ln, 315 Bayland

6

1955 to 1968 homes, 896 to 2,400 sq ft

AE 11

[1][11]

Block D, Dolphin Ln and Bayland Rd

5

1970 to 1983 homes on the largest lots, 0.21 to 0.32 acre

AE 11

[1][3][11]

Have the original lots changed?

Yes. Several lots were split or combined. Lot 9 of Block A is now split between 4830 and 4834 Coral Road, and Block D Lot 1 was split into 375 and 395 Bayland Road [1].

Which block is closest to the water?

Block D. The county hydrography layers put the Estero Bay and Matanzas Pass back-bay shoreline about 165 to 230 feet from the Dolphin Lane street line, and a man-made tidal canal about 135 feet east of Bayland Road [5]. Which lots actually front the water is not confirmed.

What Is It Like Living in Holiday Shores?

Living in Holiday Shores is quiet side-street island life in the middle of Estero Island: the Gulf beach across Estero Boulevard, Newton Beach Park a short walk north at 4650 Estero Boulevard, the island's only full grocery and a marina next door, and Times Square about 11 free-flow minutes north [30][26][28][20].

Where do residents shop for groceries?

Publix at 4791 Estero Boulevard, the island's only full grocery, is next to the plat. It reopened on May 25, 2023 after Hurricane Ian [26][27].

Is there a marina nearby?

Yes. Snook Bight Marina is at 4765 Estero Boulevard, just northwest of the plat. We did not confirm its current restaurant tenant, so check before you plan around it [28][29].

Which beach park is closest?

Newton Beach Park, a Town park at 4650 Estero Boulevard, about 0.2 mile north. The Town runs traffic and beach cameras there [30]. The walking route was not measured.

Is there community beach access?

One rental listing advertises community beach access near Coquina Road. Which public beach access point serves Holiday Shores, and whether any deeded access exists, was not confirmed, so check the Town's beach access map [72].

What Homes Are in Holiday Shores?

Holiday Shores homes are mostly ground-level 1950s to 1970s ranches built one at a time, with 896 to 2,848 heated square feet and a 1,390 square foot median, plus a 2004 home, two from 1989 and two post-Ian elevated homes finished in 2024 and 2025; there was never a tract builder [1].

How big are the lots?

About 0.13 to 0.32 acre, roughly 5,700 to 14,000 square feet, with the largest in Block D along Dolphin Lane and Bayland Road [3].

How many bedrooms do the homes have?

Two to four bedrooms and one to four baths on the county roll. The 2025 home has no heated area on the roll yet [1].

Who built the new elevated homes?

The builders of the 2024 home at 4830 Coral Road and the 2025 home at 4841 Estero Boulevard were not found in the records we read. Ask for the permits and the builder's warranty [1][35].

Holiday Shores Market Snapshot: What Do Homes and Lots Sell For?

Lee County recorded older Holiday Shores homes at $540,000 to $829,000 from June 2025 to September 2026, a 2025 new elevated home at $1,759,000 in April 2026 and vacant lots at $360,000 to $515,000 from September 2025 to October 2026; we tracked every recorded qualified sale in the plat for this guide [1].

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County Property Appraiser public parcel and qualified sale records, Holiday Shores rows, read November 2026.

Deed date

Address

Built

Heated sq ft

Price

Price per sq ft

Source

September 17, 2026

4830 Coquina Rd

1955

1,015

$675,000

$665

[1]

April 6, 2026

4841 Estero Blvd

2025, new elevated

not on roll yet

$1,759,000

n/a

[1]

October 22, 2025

4831 Coral Rd

1970

1,860

$829,000

$446

[1]

July 11, 2025

4850 Coquina Rd

1955

1,416

$540,000

$381

[1]

June 4, 2025

4838 Coral Rd

1989

2,313

$610,000

$264

[1]

August 23, 2023

4880 Coquina Rd

1973

1,176

$900,000

$765

[1]

August 17, 2023

4831 Coral Rd

1970

1,860

$650,000

$349

[1]

March 20, 2022

4838 Coral Rd

1989

2,313

$745,000

$322

[1]

November 30, 2021

4841 Estero Blvd

1956 house, since replaced

n/a

$675,000

n/a

[1]

Deed date

Vacant parcel

Price

Source

October 15, 2026

311 Bayland Rd

$395,000

[1]

November 13, 2025

4871 Coral Rd

$360,000

[1]

September 12, 2025

4839 Estero Blvd

$515,000

[1]

July 24, 2023

4805 Estero Blvd (resale)

$620,000

[1]

July 20, 2023

4801 Estero Blvd

$650,000

[1]

April 25, 2023

4805 Estero Blvd

$500,000

[1]

December 11, 2020

4809 Coral Rd (0.02-acre sliver)

$30,000

[1]

Why not quote one median for Holiday Shores?

Because the plat now holds three different products: older ground-level homes, new elevated homes and vacant lots. The all-history median of $280,000 across 71 qualified improved sales since December 1971 mixes decades of prices and says little about today [1].

Is the $1,759,000 sale typical?

No. It is one new elevated home built in 2025, the first post-Ian new build in the plat to sell, and the highest recorded price in the subdivision's history. Older homes sold for $540,000 to $829,000 in the same period [1].

Did prices fall after Ian?

For one home, yes: 4838 Coral Road sold for $745,000 six months before Ian and for $610,000 in June 2025. For another, no: 4831 Coral Road sold for $650,000 in August 2023 and $829,000 in October 2025. Condition and repairs differ sale to sale [1].

Why do some county records call lot sales builder-direct?

The county extract tags 7 sales from $97,000 to $362,500 as builder-direct, but they are the first recorded sales of parcels that are vacant on today's roll, so the tag is an artifact. They were not new-home sales [1].

Who Developed Holiday Shores, and How Did It Get Its Name?

Holiday Shores was developed by Guy Holliday, who dredged the bay-side land and opened Holliday Shores in 1953 after he and his friend Cyril Shawcross flipped a coin for their Gulf-front and bay-side sites; a historic Estero Island map record dates the plat to 1952 [7][9][10].

Date

Event

Source

1911

First subdivision on Estero Island

[48]

1938

Commodore Hotel built on the Shawcross beachside site at 5100 Estero Blvd

[7]

1952

Holiday Shores listed among the island's plats on the Davison cadastral map record

[9]

1953

Guy Holliday opens Holliday Shores

[7]

1950 to 1955

First wave of homes, 11 of today's 27 improved parcels

[1]

1958

Bayland Heights platted next door

[9]

October 15, 1979

Fixed Matanzas Pass Bridge opens

[47]

December 31, 1995

Town of Fort Myers Beach incorporates

[48]

September 28, 2022

Hurricane Ian

[42]

2024 and 2025

Two elevated new homes built

[1]

April 6, 2026

Record sale, $1,759,000

[1]

Why did Holliday and Shawcross flip a coin?

The Historic Society describes them as good friends who flipped a coin to decide who would develop which land. The Shawcrosses, Cyril and Ethel, won the beachside site, where the Commodore Hotel had been built in 1938; Holliday took the bay side and "was busy dredging and redredging his property" [7].

What happened to the Commodore Hotel site?

It later became the Smuggler's Cove condominiums, according to the Estero Island Historic Society [7][8].

Is the 1952 plat date confirmed?

Not directly. The Touchton Map Library record of the Harry K. Davison map lists 1952 Holiday Shores among the island's plats, next to Hyde Park and Miramar (1951) and the Sandpiper Village units (1952); the record page sat behind a verification wall, and a map dealer dates the map to about 1955 [9][10]. The recorded plat at the Clerk settles it [62].

Does Holiday Shores Have an HOA? Fees, Taxes and No CDD

Holiday Shores has no homeowners association found under the name and no CDD, so there is no association fee, capital contribution or transfer fee to publish; owners pay Lee County property taxes and any non-ad valorem assessments on the tax bill, and short-term rental owners pay the Town's registration fee [31][32][63][21].

Charge

Amount

Source

HOA or association fee

None found; no association fee is published

[31][32]

CDD or master association

None found

[4][63]

Capital contribution or transfer fee

None found (no association)

[32]

Short-term rental registration, 2027

$400 per unit standard; $50 for eligible grandfathered properties

[21]

Property tax

Per parcel on the Lee County Tax Collector bill

[63]

How did we check for an association?

A Florida Division of Corporations name search returned an error and was not retried, and a web search found no Florida entity under the name; the only match was the Virginia association. Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-21) on any other association, so ask for a title search [32][31][62].

Could old deed restrictions still apply?

Possibly. Holiday Shores dates from the early 1950s, and older plats sometimes carry recorded restrictions. A title search or the seller's disclosure is the way to find them [62].

What will my property tax be?

It depends on the county's assessed value and the Town and county millage on your parcel's bill; we did not compute it for these parcels. Lee County bills for the 2026 tax year are due by March 31, 2027 [63][54].

Can You Rent Out a Holiday Shores Home?

Holiday Shores homes can be rented within the Town of Fort Myers Beach rules: short-term rental owners must register each unit under Sec. 10-198 and Ordinance 18-01, the 2027 fee is $400 per unit, renewal runs November 15 to December 15, 2026 through Rentalscape, and the Town began enforcement in early 2026 [21][22][24].

  • Stay length: weekly rentals must be 3 to 7 days, or monthly one reservation of 3 to 29 days, depending on zoning [21].
  • Grandfathered fee: $50 for eligible grandfathered properties [21].
  • Enforcement: in December 2025 the Town said about 500 short-term rentals were operating unregistered and that violation notices would follow [24].
  • Code of conduct: the Town publishes conduct rules for short-term rentals [23].
  • No association rules found: with no association found, there is no association rental approval to clear, though old deed restrictions should be checked [31][62].

Which zoning applies to my lot?

The Town's zoning map governs, because Lee County's zoning layer does not cover the Town. Confirm the district for your parcel before relying on a rental plan [59][61].

Who do I call at the Town?

The Town's main line, 239-765-0202, is listed on its 50% rule page, and the short-term rental page lists the registration steps and the Rentalscape portal [34][21].

Is Holiday Shores in a Flood Zone, and How Did It Come Through Ian?

Yes. Every Holiday Shores parcel is in FEMA's Special Flood Hazard Area on the November 17, 2022 Lee County maps: the 6 Estero Boulevard lots map VE with a 14 foot base flood elevation and the 28 side-street lots AE at 11 feet; Hurricane Ian then damaged about 97% of the island's structures [11][12][42].

  • Panel: 12071C0566G, effective November 17, 2022 [12].
  • Check each lot: the zone test used street-side address points, so confirm your parcel on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center or an elevation certificate [13][60].
  • Ground elevation: about 3.6 to 4.3 feet NAVD 88, so at AE 11 a lowest floor sits roughly 7 to 8 feet above grade before freeboard; confirm the datum with the Town [15][60].
  • Freeboard: a February 2026 local report says new homes must sit one foot above base flood elevation; confirm in the Town code [25][59].
  • Evacuation: the county layer returned surge zone 1 with a blank zone letter; barrier-island Fort Myers Beach is generally Zone A, so confirm on Lee County's Know Your Zone [16].
  • Flood insurance discount: Community Rating System Class 5, a 25% NFIP discount, for policies issued or renewed on or after April 1, 2026 [37][38].

What is the difference between VE and AE here?

VE is a coastal high hazard zone with wave action; AE is the coastal floodplain. VE lots on Estero Boulevard generally carry higher premiums and stricter construction rules, such as open foundations and breakaway walls, than AE lots on the side streets [11][14]. Get quotes for your lot.

How deep was the Ian surge?

No Holiday Shores reading was found. Surge reached about 15 to 18 feet in places on the island, and a USGS sensor on the Fort Myers Beach pier recorded about 13.2 feet [43][42][33].

Was Holiday Shores damaged by Ian?

No neighborhood-level report was found. The county record shows 7 parcels that held 1955 to 1971 homes before Ian are vacant on the 2026 roll, with vacant-land sales from April 2023; demolition dates and causes were not confirmed from permits [1][3]. Ian left more than 1,000 island homes and apartments substantially damaged [42].

What about Helene and Milton in 2024?

Helene on September 26, 2024 and Milton on October 9, 2024 both flooded parts of the island; Milton brought widespread surge flooding that evening. Street-level effects in Holiday Shores were not found [44].

Why did the Town lose and regain its flood discount?

FEMA put the Town on probation in November 2024 for failing 3 of 5 criteria, and the discount was lost for policies from April 1, 2025. Probation was lifted in November 2025, and Class 5 returned for April 1, 2026 [39][40][36][37].

What Town Rules Apply When You Repair, Rebuild or Build New?

Holiday Shores is inside the Town of Fort Myers Beach, so the Town's 50% rule governs: repairs or improvements over 50% of a structure's market value require the whole building to meet current flood rules, and the Town counts all permits from the past five years, which matters for every 1950s to 1970s ground-level home here [34][35].

Does the 50% rule apply to my 1955 house?

Yes. The Town's focus is on pre-1984 structures, and most surviving Holiday Shores homes are ground-level 1950s to 1970s ranches. A large remodel can trigger full compliance, usually by elevating [35][1].

Can I choose my own appraisal for the 50% calculation?

The Town page does not state the valuation basis. Other Florida towns let owners choose a certified appraisal or the county appraiser's value, so ask the Town before you design a remodel [34][41].

Can I build a new elevated home on a vacant lot?

Yes, subject to Town permits. Seven Holiday Shores lots are vacant on the 2026 roll, and a February 2026 report says island buyers want vacant lots for new construction, with new homes set one foot above base flood elevation [1][25].

Is Holiday Shores Waterfront, and Can You Keep a Boat?

Holiday Shores is on the bay side of Estero Island near Estero Bay and Matanzas Pass, but it is mostly interior streets: county GIS puts the back-bay shoreline about 165 to 230 feet from Dolphin Lane and a man-made tidal canal about 135 feet east of Bayland Road, and frontage and docks are not confirmed lot by lot [5][3].

How high are the bridges for boats?

The island's fixed bridges have 65 feet of clearance at Matanzas Pass and 60 feet at Big Carlos Pass [47][45][46].

Do any lots have private docks?

Private docks on specific lots were not confirmed. Check the parcel record, aerials and Town dock permits before you rely on a dock [1][5][59].

Which Schools Serve Holiday Shores?

The School District of Lee County's 2026/2027 School Proximity Zones layer places Holiday Shores in elementary zone T, middle zone MM and high school zone South 4; Lee assigns students through a choice and proximity system, so confirm the actual school list with the district's student assignment tool [17][18].

  • On the island: Fort Myers Beach Elementary, 2751 Oak Street, is the only school on the island [48].
  • Aggregator data: one aggregator lists it as Pre-K to grade 5 with about 62 students in 2025; confirm with the district [19].

Which middle and high schools come next?

An aggregator lists Cypress Lake Middle, Lexington Middle, Fort Myers Middle Academy and Bonita Springs Middle, and Cypress Lake High, Dunbar High and Estero High. These are not confirmed assignments [19][18].

Where do I confirm my child's school?

With the School District of Lee County's student assignment tool, by address [18][17].

Where Is Holiday Shores, and How Long Are the Drives?

Holiday Shores is about 11 minutes from Times Square, 33 minutes from I-75 Exit 131 and 40 minutes from Southwest Florida International Airport in free-flow traffic; times below are OSRM estimates from 4838 Coral Road with hand-placed destinations, so add time in season [20].

Destination

Road miles

Free-flow minutes

Source

Times Square and Lynn Hall Park

3.5

11

[20]

I-75 Exit 131, Daniels Pkwy

16.6

33

[20]

I-75 Exit 123, Corkscrew Rd

20.7

40

[20]

RSW airport

20.1

40

[20]

Downtown Fort Myers

17.4

36

[20]

Downtown Naples, 5th Ave S

24.9

47

[20]

Coconut Point, Estero

17.3

36

[20]

Gulf Coast Town Center

18.1

37

[20]

HealthPark Medical Center

14.1

31

[20]

How long in season?

Longer. Our wider Fort Myers Beach research estimates 25 to 35 minutes to I-75 and 30 to 40 minutes to RSW in season island-wide, and real season times from mid-island are likely longer; we did not measure them with a traffic-aware tool.

What Is Changing on Fort Myers Beach Around Holiday Shores?

Three island-wide changes matter to Holiday Shores owners: the new Big Carlos Pass Bridge opened November 14, 2025 with a ribbon cutting June 30, 2026, the new Fort Myers Beach pier broke ground August 21, 2026 for late summer 2027, and the NFIP Class 5 discount returned April 1, 2026 [45][49][37].

What is the new pier like?

About 1,000 feet long and 12 feet wide, more than 70% longer and 50% wider than the one Ian destroyed, on a $14.4 million budget. R.J. Gorman Contracting holds the $11.7 million construction contract, FEMA awarded $5.5 million on July 20, 2026, and 108 piles were reported in September 2026 [49][50][51][52][53].

What is happening in Times Square?

Times Square is being rebuilt parcel by parcel. The $13M Sunset Beach Resort broke ground on July 6, 2026 for early 2028, and other projects are moving through Town approvals [55][57][56][58].

Holiday Shores vs Cases and Other Fort Myers Beach Plats: How Do They Compare?

Buyers who look at Holiday Shores usually compare it with Cases, an older mid-island plat, with Seagrape near Times Square, with San Carlos on the Gulf across Matanzas Pass and with the mid-island canal plats; the honest difference is that Holiday Shores has no Gulf-front lots and is priced below the Gulf-front plats [1][11][71].

Community

What it is

Honest difference

Source

Holiday Shores

1950s bay-side plat, 35 parcels, no HOA found

Walk to Publix, the marina and the beach; older homes $540,000 to $829,000 in 2025 to 2026

[1][26]

Cases

Older mid-island plat (1911) with Gulf-front lots on Estero Blvd and bay-side side streets near the Mound House

Gulf-front sales reach far higher ($6.9M); like Holiday Shores, no HOA and many post-Ian vacant lots

[71]

Seagrape

Small no-HOA plat at the north end near Times Square and DiamondHead

Livelier and closer to the entertainment district; listings ran $799,000 to $10.5M in November 2026

[71]

San Carlos on the Gulf

San Carlos Island, unincorporated Lee County

Bayfront lots with deeper boat water, county rather than Town rules, $348,000 lots to $7.9M new builds

[71]

Bayland Heights

Adjacent 1958 plat to the east

Not researched for this guide

[9]

How does Holiday Shores compare with the canal plats?

Laguna Shores, Fairview Isles, Siesta Isles and Sandpiper Village are other mid-island canal and bay subdivisions with more direct canal frontage per lot. Holiday Shores is mostly interior streets, with water closest on Dolphin Lane and Bayland Road [5][71].

What other Fort Myers Beach guides should I read?

Our guides to Captains Bay South, Leilani, Sea Grape Bay and Port Carlos Cove cover other Fort Myers Beach communities, and the Fort Myers Beach real estate guide covers the whole island.

What Are the Honest Pros and Cons of Holiday Shores?

McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and the lists below are our honest read of Holiday Shores from the county roll and sale files, the county GIS and FEMA layers, Town rules and local history, so buyers and sellers can weigh it before a showing.

Pros

No association found and no CDD, a short walk to the Gulf beach, Publix and a marina, a quiet four-block street grid off Estero Boulevard, prices below the Gulf-front plats, vacant lots for a new elevated home and the new Big Carlos Pass Bridge [31][26][28][1][45].

Cons

Every lot in the Special Flood Hazard Area, VE on Estero Boulevard, older ground-level homes under the 50% rule, no confirmed docks or frontage, a thin resale record, Estero Boulevard as the only road out and no amenities of its own [11][34][5][1][20].

Thinking of Selling Your Holiday Shores Home? List With the #1 Team in Southwest Florida Since 2012

If you're searching for a Holiday Shores listing agent, or thinking, 'I need someone to sell my Holiday Shores home...' start with the record: older homes sold for $540,000 to $829,000 from June 2025 to September 2026, the 2025 new build for $1,759,000, and vacant lots for $360,000 to $515,000 [1].

We tracked every Holiday Shores sale in the county file for this guide, because a buyer compares your parcel with a short list of the right sales: older home, new elevated home or building lot, Estero Boulevard or side street, VE or AE. We price from those recorded sales and your condition, not from an automated estimate.

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Holiday Shores Sales, by the Numbers

  • Older homes, June 2025 to September 2026: $540,000 to $829,000 [1].
  • New elevated home, April 6, 2026: $1,759,000 [1].
  • Vacant lots, September 2025 to October 2026: $360,000 to $515,000 [1].
  • Highest older-home sale: $900,000, 4880 Coquina Road, August 2023 [1].
  • All history: 71 qualified improved sales since December 1971, median $280,000 [1].

Selling in Holiday Shores Is Different in Five Ways

  • House or lot. Buyers weigh an older home against a lot plus a new build, so we show both values [1].
  • The flood zone sets the buyer pool. VE on Estero Boulevard, AE on the side streets; an elevation certificate helps the buyer's quote [11][60].
  • The 50% rule shapes the offer. Buyers of 1950s to 1970s homes price in what they can spend before full compliance [34][35].
  • Permits are the paperwork. Have Ian repair permits and dates ready [35][42].
  • Water claims need proof. Docks and frontage are not confirmed in public records, so document yours [5].

What Is Your Holiday Shores Home Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds.

Start with a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation. Jesse follows up with a written range built from your street, lot, flood zone, condition and the Holiday Shores sales that fit your parcel.

(239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome. Our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers Beach walks through the sale step by step, and our Fort Myers Beach real estate hub covers the wider island market.

What closing costs does a Holiday Shores seller pay in Lee County?

A Florida seller customarily pays the documentary stamp tax on the deed [67], plus the brokerage fee, any mortgage payoff and prorated taxes. In Lee County the seller customarily pays the owner's title policy, and the contract controls [70].

Your Local Real Estate Experts

Holiday Shores sellers and buyers work directly with Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, who have sold Southwest Florida real estate for more than twenty years, lead Domain Realty Group, and read the Lee County roll and sale files, the county flood, evacuation and parcel layers, Town of Fort Myers Beach rules and Florida law behind this guide.

You can read how the team was built on our about the McGreevy and Comisar team page. McGreevy and Comisar are the Domain Realty team behind this Holiday Shores guide: Jesse McGreevy leads on listings and pricing, and Marc Comisar leads on buyer representation across Southwest Florida. If you are comparing agents, see the best real estate agents in Fort Myers Beach.

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.

McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

What Our Clients Say

McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Holiday Shores realtor on Google, and the quotes below are genuine five star client reviews reproduced in the reviewer’s own words. We publish no aggregate score and no Holiday Shores testimonial we do not have.

★★★★★ “Not living in the area, Jesse made life easy for me when we decided to sell our condo. His attention to detail, patience, understanding, and tenacity in dealing with all the moving parts was truly impressive.” Eric Acra, verified Google review

★★★★★ “Their recommendation on pricing my unit was sound and proved prescient. I never questioned their integrity and found it easy to rely on their recommendations. I would work with them again in a heartbeat.” Charlie Carroll, verified Google review

★★★★★ “Working with Jesse and his team was truly an amazing experience. From the very beginning, they were professional, attentive, and incredibly knowledgeable. They guided us through every step of the process with patience and clarity, always making sure we felt comfortable and informed with every decision.” Leonardo Silva, verified Google review

Contact McGreevy and Comisar

  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 · [email protected]
  • Marc Comisar: (239) 457-1610
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Selling your Holiday Shores home or lot? Get a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

Buying in Holiday Shores? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida, or our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers Beach.

Licensure, and the Office of Record

Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission, and licenses can be verified with the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation. Florida law requires a brokerage relationship disclosure (s. 475.278, Florida Statutes).

  • Jesse McGreevy, Florida license SL3101296
  • Marc Comisar, Florida license BK3060671
  • Brokerage office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Frequently Asked Questions: Holiday Shores Buyer Edition

These are the Holiday Shores questions buyers ask most, each answered from the Lee County roll and sale records, county GIS, FEMA, the school district, Town of Fort Myers Beach rules and the local history cited on this page. Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 to plan a showing.

How many homes are in Holiday Shores?

35 parcels: 26 single-family homes, 1 duplex, 7 vacant lots and 1 sliver parcel on the 2026 roll [1].

Is Holiday Shores gated?

No; it is a set of public streets off Estero Boulevard [1].

Is there an HOA?

None was found under the name; confirm deed restrictions with a title search [31][62].

Is there a CDD?

No CDD was found; check the tax bill for any non-ad valorem assessment [63].

Do I need flood insurance?

With a federally backed loan, yes; every lot is in the Special Flood Hazard Area [11][69].

Which flood zone is my street?

Estero Boulevard lots map VE 14, side streets AE 11; confirm your lot [11][13].

Can I rent short term?

Yes, with Town registration, $400 per unit for 2027, within the zoning stay rules [21].

Are there boat docks?

Docks on specific lots were not confirmed; ask for permits [5].

How far is the beach?

Across Estero Boulevard, with Newton Beach Park about 0.2 mile north [30].

Where is the nearest grocery?

Publix at 4791 Estero Boulevard, next to the plat [26].

Can I build new on a vacant lot?

Yes, with Town permits; 7 lots are vacant on the 2026 roll [1][25].

What did homes sell for recently?

Older homes $540,000 to $829,000 from June 2025 to September 2026 [1].

Frequently Asked Questions: Holiday Shores Seller Edition

These are the questions Holiday Shores owners ask us, answered from the county record, Town rules, FEMA and Florida law. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 for a number on your home or lot based on its street, flood zone and the sales that fit it.

What is my Holiday Shores home worth?

Start with a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation, then Jesse builds a range from the recorded Holiday Shores sales that fit your parcel [1].

What did older homes sell for in 2025 and 2026?

$540,000 to $829,000 on qualified county sales from June 2025 to September 2026 [1].

What is the record price?

$1,759,000 for the 2025 elevated home at 4841 Estero Boulevard on April 6, 2026 [1].

What did vacant lots sell for?

$360,000 to $515,000 from September 2025 to October 2026 [1].

Do Estero Boulevard lots sell higher than side-street lots?

In the record, yes: Estero Boulevard lots sold for $500,000 to $650,000 in 2023 and $515,000 in 2025, side-street lots $360,000 and $395,000 [1].

How many homes sell in a year?

Few; three qualified older-home sales in 2025 and two so far in 2026 [1].

Should I sell as a house or as a lot?

We show both, because lots sold for $360,000 to $515,000 and older homes for $540,000 to $829,000 [1].

Does a new elevated home sell for more?

The one recorded sale, $1,759,000, was about double the older-home range [1].

Does the county value equal my selling price?

No; just value is a tax figure, and the sale record is what buyers compare [1][64].

Does my flood zone affect my sale?

Yes; VE lots carry stricter rules and generally higher premiums than AE lots [11][14].

Do I need an elevation certificate?

It is the best way to support a buyer's flood quote [60][13].

Do I need a flood disclosure?

Yes; Florida's seller flood disclosure covers flood claims and federal assistance [66].

Will buyers ask about Ian?

Yes; keep repair permits and dates, and disclose what you know [35][42].

Will the 50% rule affect my buyer?

Yes; buyers of older homes price in the Town's five-year permit lookback [34][35].

Is there an association estoppel?

No association was found, so there is no estoppel; title still searches for restrictions [31][62].

Are there deed restrictions?

Possibly from the 1950s; a title search will show them [62].

Does the flood discount help my sale?

It helps the buyer's premium: Class 5, 25%, from April 1, 2026 [37].

Can I sell to a buyer who plans to rent?

Yes; the buyer registers with the Town and follows the stay rules [21][22].

What does a rental buyer need to know?

Registration renews November 15 to December 15 through Rentalscape, $400 per unit for 2027 [21].

Can I claim bay or canal frontage?

Only with documented frontage; public records did not confirm it lot by lot [5].

Does the name confusion matter when I list?

Yes; we use Holiday Shores, note Holliday Shores, and keep it apart from Holiday Heights [7][9].

Will the pier and bridge projects help my value?

We cannot say; buyers do ask about the pier and the new bridge [49][45].

Who pays the documentary stamp tax?

In Florida the seller customarily pays it on the deed [67].

Who pays for the owner's title policy in Lee County?

The seller customarily, and the contract controls [70].

Can I keep my homestead savings when I move?

Portability can carry part of the Save Our Homes benefit to your next Florida home [65][64].

When are my property taxes due?

Lee County bills for the 2026 tax year are due by March 31, 2027 [54][63].

How do I find my parcel's sale history?

The Lee County Property Appraiser's property search lists each recorded sale with its date and price [1][62].

Should I sell my lot with plans?

Buyers want lots for new construction, so a survey and flood information help [25][60].

Will hurricane features help my sale?

A wind mitigation inspection on the state form can support insurance credits [68].

Does my street change the buyer's insurance?

Yes; VE on Estero Boulevard and AE on the side streets rate differently [11][14].

Should I sell now or wait?

That depends on your plans; we price from the latest Holiday Shores sales for your parcel [1].

Who should I call first about selling in Holiday Shores?

Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072. He will review your home or lot against the recorded Holiday Shores sales, then give you a written price range. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

Sources and Authoritative References

Every fact in this Holiday Shores guide traces to a record below: Lee County Property Appraiser and GIS layers, FEMA and USGS, the school district, the Town of Fort Myers Beach, Florida law, local history records and news reports. No listing portal is linked, and the numbers match the bracket citations on this page.

  1. Lee County Property Appraiser, parcel roll and qualified sale records for the Holiday Shores plat (35 parcels), read November 2026
  2. Lee County GIS, Lee County Parcels layer (Holiday Shores, Blocks A to D)
  3. Lee County GIS, Existing Landuse layer (acres, land use, year built)
  4. Lee County GIS, Planning Communities and Commission Districts
  5. Lee County GIS, Hydrography layers (bay, tidal canals, coastline)
  6. US Census Bureau Geocoder, Holiday Shores parcel addresses
  7. Estero Island Historic Society, The Commodore Hotel
  8. Estero Island Historic Society, Early Development on Fort Myers Beach
  9. Tampa Bay History Center, Touchton Map Library, Harry K. Davison map of Estero Island
  10. Rare Charts, Davison map of Estero Island (dealer record)
  11. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, flood hazard zones
  12. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, FIRM panels
  13. FEMA Flood Map Service Center
  14. FEMA, flood insurance risk rating method
  15. USGS Elevation Point Query Service, 3DEP ground elevation
  16. Lee County, evacuation zones layer
  17. School District of Lee County, School Proximity Zones layer
  18. School District of Lee County, student enrollment and school zones
  19. AllK12, Fort Myers Beach Elementary School profile
  20. OSRM public routing engine, free-flow drive estimates from Coral Road
  21. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Short-Term Rental registration
  22. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Ordinance 18-01, short-term rentals
  23. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Short-Term Rentals Code of Conduct
  24. WGCU, Town of Fort Myers Beach to issue short-term rental violation notices (December 30, 2025)
  25. Fort Myers Beach Talk, New construction on the beach giving Realtors confidence (February 1, 2026)
  26. Publix newsroom, Fort Myers Beach Publix reopens (June 15, 2023)
  27. Supermarket News, Publix reopens store damaged by Hurricane Ian
  28. Marinas.com, Snook Bight Marina, Estero Boulevard
  29. Fort Myers Beach Chamber of Commerce, Snook Bight Marina listing
  30. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Traffic Cams (Newton Beach Park)
  31. ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, Holiday Shores Homeowners Association (Buffalo Junction, Virginia)
  32. Florida Division of Corporations, entity name search
  33. WINK News, storm surge from Hurricane Ian, USGS sensors (July 10, 2023)
  34. Town of Fort Myers Beach, FEMA's 50% Rule
  35. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Substantial Improvement and Substantial Damage
  36. Town of Fort Myers Beach, FEMA National Flood Insurance Program
  37. WGCU, FEMA confirms Fort Myers Beach earns CRS Class 5 rating (December 24, 2025)
  38. Fort Myers Beach Talk, Fort Myers Beach to regain flood insurance discount (December 2025)
  39. Insurance Journal, FEMA action on Fort Myers Beach after rebuilding in the flood area (December 3, 2024)
  40. WGCU, Fort Myers Beach loses flood program discount (November 21, 2024)
  41. Paradise News, an elevating conversation on FEMA's 50% Rule (December 2, 2024)
  42. Fort Myers News-Press, which Fort Myers Beach houses damaged in Hurricane Ian must be demolished (March 23, 2023)
  43. NPR, Fort Myers Beach six months after Ian (2023)
  44. Fort Myers Beach Talk, widespread flooding from storm surge begins on Fort Myers Beach (October 9, 2024)
  45. WGCU, ribbon cutting set for the new Big Carlos Pass Bridge (June 11, 2026)
  46. Big Carlos Pass Bridge project site
  47. Wikipedia, Matanzas Pass Bridge
  48. Wikipedia, Fort Myers Beach, Florida
  49. Lee County, Fort Myers Beach Pier FAQ (August 17, 2026)
  50. Gulfshore Business, Fort Myers Beach pier replacement breaks ground (August 2026)
  51. Fort Myers Beach Talk, FEMA award for the Fort Myers Beach Pier (July 2026)
  52. Fort Myers Beach Talk, pier project approved by the Army Corps (June 30, 2026)
  53. WGCU, work progressing on the new Fort Myers Beach pier (September 17, 2026)
  54. Fort Myers Beach Chamber of Commerce, island project updates
  55. Fort Myers Beach Talk, Sunset Beach Resort breaks ground at Times Square (July 2026)
  56. Fort Myers Beach Talk, new development plans for Times Square properties (March 16, 2026)
  57. Business Observer, Fort Myers Beach resort project to start construction (June 29, 2026)
  58. Gulfshore Business, Fort Myers Beach moves ahead with Times Square rebuild (December 16, 2025)
  59. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Code of Ordinances
  60. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Elevation Certificates
  61. Town of Fort Myers Beach, home page
  62. Lee County Clerk of Court, Official Records search
  63. Lee County Tax Collector, property tax bills and non-ad valorem assessments
  64. Florida Department of Revenue, homestead exemption guide
  65. Florida Department of Revenue, Save Our Homes assessment limitation and portability
  66. Florida Statutes, seller flood disclosure
  67. Florida Statutes, documentary stamp tax on deeds
  68. Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, wind mitigation resources
  69. Citizens Property Insurance, flood insurance requirement
  70. Attorneys' Title Fund, who pays for title insurance
  71. Lee County Property Appraiser records and listing records for Cases, Seagrape, San Carlos on the Gulf and the mid-island canal plats, read November 2026 (not linked)
  72. Brokerage listing and portal pages for Holiday Shores addresses, read November 2026 (listing claims only; not linked)

Downloadable Documents

Holiday Shores' key public documents are published by the Town of Fort Myers Beach, Lee County and the Florida Department of Revenue; the table links each to its issuer. The recorded plat and any deed restrictions come from the Lee County Clerk of Court, so a title company can pull them for your parcel.

Document

Issued by

Date

Link

Ordinance 18-01, Short-Term Rentals Regulation

Town of Fort Myers Beach

2018

Ordinance, PDF

Short-Term Rentals Code of Conduct

Town of Fort Myers Beach

Current

Code of conduct, PDF

Fort Myers Beach Pier FAQ

Lee County

August 17, 2026

Pier FAQ, PDF

Homestead exemption guide

Florida Department of Revenue

Current

Guide, PDF

Save Our Homes and portability

Florida Department of Revenue

Current

Guide, PDF


Market data from the Lee County Property Appraiser public parcel and qualified sale records and county GIS layers, read November 2026. McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Holiday Shores. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.


Work With Us

Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.