Captains Bay South

Captains Bay South

Captains Bay South is a 75-unit condominium of five 5-story buildings on Island Pines Way, on the bay side of Estero Boulevard in Fort Myers Beach, built in 1995 and 1997 with a pool and tennis court and no CDD. Sell, value or buy with McGreevy and Comisar.

Search Homes

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.

Captains Bay South is a 75-unit condominium of five 5-story buildings on Island Pines Way, on the bay side of Estero Boulevard at the south end of Estero Island in the Town of Fort Myers Beach, ZIP 33931. It sits inside the Bay Beach enclave, the group of condominiums our Bay Beach guide covers, and its buildings date from 1995 and 1997 on the Lee County building layer [1][2][9]. McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

Here is the short answer most Captains Bay South searchers need: it is one condominium association with a recorded pool and tennis court, no gate, no golf, no boat docks and no master association, every building is in FEMA Zone AE with an 11 foot base flood elevation, and all five buildings fall under Florida's milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study laws [1][4][3][13][43][44]. Lee County recorded 11 qualified sales in the 36 months to November 11, 2026, from $315,000 to $615,000 with a $400,000 median [8].

Why McGreevy and Comisar Are the Best Realtor for Captains Bay South

McGreevy and Comisar are the best realtor for Captains Bay South because 75 units with three floor plans, two building ages, an AE flood zone, statutory inspection dates and prices that fell back from a 2024 peak need an agent who reads the county record first: the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012.

If you're searching for the best realtor for Captains Bay South in Fort Myers Beach, Florida, whether you own one of the 75 units and may want to sell or you want to buy a mid-rise island condo on the bay side of Estero Boulevard, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Nationally since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. Buyers and sellers comparing the best real estate agents in Fort Myers Beach should ask each agent to explain Captains Bay South from the county record, and we do that below.

Captains Bay South market record (Lee County qualified sales): 11 qualified sales in the 36 months to November 11, 2026 at a $400,000 median, a high of $615,000 for a top-floor 1,239 square foot three-bedroom unit in May 2024, and five qualified sales at a $350,000 median, $315,000 to $430,000, in the twelve months to that date [8].

For Captains Bay South buyers: the first question is the plan, because the 1,073 square foot two-bedroom end units are 50 of the 75, while the 1,239 square foot three-bedroom middle units on floors 2 to 5 number only 20 [3][5][7]. The second is the paperwork: the 1995 buildings passed their 30-year milestone date at the end of 2025, so ask for the milestone summary and the reserve study [2][43]. The third is the fee: $887 a month on a listing that closed in June 2026, so confirm it with an estoppel [22][47].

For Captains Bay South sellers: your plan, floor and building set the comparison. The same 1,073 square foot plan recorded $600,000 in April 2024 and $315,000 in November 2025, both in the building at 22712 Island Pines Way, so your price cannot come from a community-wide average. We price from the recorded Captains Bay South sales for your plan, floor and condition [8].

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Selling your Captains Bay South condo? Get a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. You can also read our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers Beach.

Buying in Captains Bay South? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida.

Key Takeaways

Captains Bay South in brief: a 75-unit bay-side condominium on Island Pines Way in Fort Myers Beach, with every figure below traced to the Lee County Property Appraiser and county GIS layers, the Florida condominium files, FEMA, the school district, the Town of Fort Myers Beach, Florida law or news reports [3][9][13][18].

  • What it is: 75 condominium units in five 5-story buildings of 15 units each, three units a floor [2][9].
  • Built: 22748 and 22736 Island Pines Way in 1995; 22700, 22724 and 22712 in 1997; declaration recorded February 17, 1995 [2][9].
  • Sizes: 50 two-bedroom units of 1,073 square feet, 20 three-bedroom units of 1,239 square feet and 5 two-bedroom units of 1,095 square feet, all with two baths [3][5][6][7].
  • Amenities on the county record: a pool, a tennis court and shuffleboard; no marina, clubhouse, fitness center, restaurant or Gulf frontage [4][5][3].
  • Fee: $887 a month, about $10,644 a year, on a listing that closed June 30, 2026; no master association or CDD [22][9][3].
  • Recent sales: five qualified sales from November 2025 to July 2026 at $315,000 to $430,000, median $350,000 [8].
  • Flood and evacuation: FEMA Zone AE, base flood elevation 11 feet, on panel 12071C0567G; Lee County evacuation Zone A [13][14][15].
  • Condo law: five-story buildings, so milestone inspections and a structural integrity reserve study apply [43][44][2].
  • Rentals: listing records state a 14-day minimum lease and up to 26 leases a year; the Town requires short-term rental registration [22][25].
  • Beach parking: Town paid parking costs $5 an hour plus $0.25, enforced from 9 am to 9 pm [35].

What Is Captains Bay South?

Captains Bay South is Captain's Bay South Condominium, one condominium of 75 units in five buildings at 22700, 22712, 22724, 22736 and 22748 Island Pines Way, run by Captain's Bay South Condominium Association, Inc. and recorded with the state as project PR1S022330 on February 17, 1995 [9][11][3][2].

Fact

Captains Bay South

Source

Addresses

22700, 22712, 22724, 22736 and 22748 Island Pines Way, Fort Myers Beach 33931; common elements at 22704

[3][4]

Government

Town of Fort Myers Beach taxing district; Fort Myers Beach Fire District

[3][1]

Units

75 condominium units, all with two baths

[9][3]

Buildings

Five, 15 units each, five stories, coded Condominium, Mid Rise, 4 to 7 Floors

[2]

Years built

1995 (two buildings) and 1997 (three buildings)

[2]

Common-element parcel

2.45 GIS acres; county neighborhood polygon about 2.2 acres

[3][1]

Where exactly is Captains Bay South?

On the north side of Island Pines Way, a side street off the bay side of Estero Boulevard near the south end of Estero Island, about one mile north of the Big Carlos Pass Bridge. The county centroid is about 26.4174 north, 81.9001 west [3][2][61].

Is Captains Bay South on the beach?

No. It is not Gulf-front. The county codes the land under every unit as on a lake, the cost cards record lake or street views, and listing remarks describe preserve and mangrove views with the Gulf beach across Estero Boulevard [3][5][7][23]. We did not confirm the nearest numbered Town beach access, so ask to see the route in person.

Is it the same as Captains Bay North?

No. Captains Bay South, North One and North Two share a name and the 1993 incorporation date, but they are separate condominiums with separate associations. North One has 3 units at 6661 Estero Boulevard and North Two has 15 units at 6691 Estero Boulevard [9][11]. Our parent research on Captains Bay counts 93 units across all three.

Which ZIP code and city?

ZIP 33931 and the Town of Fort Myers Beach, which incorporated on December 31, 1995 and covers Estero Island. Town Hall is at 6231 Estero Boulevard, telephone 239-765-0202 [3][31].

What did the web get wrong about Captains Bay South?

Three things. An aggregator calls it a pair of condo buildings, but the county building layer shows five 15-unit buildings. The same page lists a marina, restaurant, clubhouse, fitness and Gulf access, none of which the county record supports. And some unit cost cards print 1995 for buildings the building layer dates to 1997, so we use the building layer year for each building [2][23][4][7].

Captains Bay South Buildings and Floor Plans at a Glance

Captains Bay South has five identical five-story buildings of 15 units, three a floor: the two end stacks are 1,073 square foot two-bedroom units on every floor, and the middle stack is a 1,095 square foot two-bedroom on floor 1 and a 1,239 square foot three-bedroom on floors 2 to 5 [3][5][6][7].

County building

Address

Built

Units

Stories

Phase label

Footprint, sq ft

County building value

Source

1

22748 Island Pines Way

1995

15

5

Phase III

about 4,775

$4,924,598

[2][3]

2

22736 Island Pines Way

1995

15

5

Ph III-B

about 4,723

$4,760,134

[2][3]

3

22700 Island Pines Way

1997

15

5

Ph III-C

about 4,841

$4,743,471

[2][3]

4

22724 Island Pines Way

1997

15

5

none

about 4,562

$4,953,200

[2][3]

5

22712 Island Pines Way

1997

15

5

none

about 4,562

$4,969,615

[2][3]

Plan

Units

Heated sq ft

Bed and bath

Where

Porch or lanai on the cards

Source

End units

50

1,073

2 and 2

Both end stacks, floors 1 to 5

199 sq ft screened porch, or 119 sq ft lanai plus 80 sq ft porch where enclosed

[3][5][7]

Middle unit, floor 1

5

1,095

2 and 2

One per building

99 sq ft porch

[3][6]

Middle units, floors 2 to 5

20

1,239

3 and 2

Four per building

99 sq ft porch, some with an added 114 sq ft acrylic-enclosed area

[3][7]

Are ground-floor units living space?

Yes. The cost cards show units 101, 102 and 103 in each building as living units, not parking, which matters for flood insurance and for storm history [5][6][7].

Is there an elevator?

Yes, per listing remarks, which describe a working elevator after the Ian restoration at 22736. Ask about each building's elevator service and inspection record [22].

What about parking and storage?

The county roll shows no garage and no carport on any of the 75 parcels, while one listing describes one assigned parking space with a carport and another lists storage. Treat parking as unconfirmed until the association or the declaration states it [3][22].

What Is It Like Living in Captains Bay South?

Living in Captains Bay South is small-building island condo life on a quiet side street: a pool, a tennis court and shuffleboard on the common grounds, lake, preserve or street views, the Gulf beach across Estero Boulevard, and Santini Marina Plaza, Lovers Key and the new Big Carlos Pass Bridge a short drive south [4][5][23][66][71].

How many owners live here full time?

Only 12 of the 75 units carried a homestead exemption on the 2025 roll, and 20 owners used a Florida mailing address, so most units are second homes or rentals [3].

Where do residents shop?

Santini Marina Plaza at 7205 Estero Boulevard, about 70,000 square feet, is the nearest shopping center. The island Publix is mid-island at 4791 Estero Boulevard, reopened in May 2023, and listing remarks name Flipper's on the Bay nearby [66][67][22].

Are pets allowed?

Listing records describe the community as pet friendly with limits, but the recorded rules are not published, and one vacation rental listing says pets are not allowed in that rental. Ask the association for the pet rule, including number, weight and renters, in writing [22][23][24].

What Amenities Does Captains Bay South Actually Have?

Captains Bay South's recorded amenities are a pool and a tennis court on the common-element parcel at 22704 Island Pines Way, with shuffleboard on the county cost cards; listing claims of a second pool, pickleball, a fishing pier, a community room and a roof terrace are not on the county record and need confirmation [4][5][23][22].

  • On the county record: a pool, with the pool flag on all 75 parcels, a tennis court and shuffleboard [4][3][5].
  • Claimed in listings, not on the record: two heated pools, pickleball, a fishing pier, a community room, a roof terrace, BBQ picnic areas and an outdoor shower [23][22].
  • Not there: no boat dock, seawall, marina, clubhouse, fitness center, restaurant or golf [3][4][1].

Who owns the pool and tennis court?

The common-element parcel at 22704 Island Pines Way is owned by Captains Bay South Condominium, and the recorded common elements at Official Records Book 2576, Page 1730 read pool and tennis [4][12].

What is the Captain's Bay Recreational Association?

A separate Captain's Bay Recreational Association, Inc. (N93000000427) appears on the state record, filed in 1993. Its role today is not confirmed, so ask which entity maintains the pool and court [11].

Captains Bay South Market Snapshot: What Do Condos Sell For?

Lee County recorded 11 qualified Captains Bay South sales in the 36 months to November 11, 2026, from $315,000 to $615,000 with a $400,000 median, and five in the last twelve months at $315,000 to $430,000, median $350,000; we tracked every recorded transfer for this guide [8].

Data updated: November 2026. Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sale records, South rows on Island Pines Way, read November 11, 2026.

Deed date

Building

Plan and floor

Price

Source

July 30, 2026

22700

1,073 sq ft 2 and 2, floor 5

$350,000

[8]

June 30, 2026

22736

1,073 sq ft 2 and 2, floor 2

$350,000

[8]

May 19, 2026

22748

1,073 sq ft 2 and 2, floor 4

$430,000

[8]

January 6, 2026

22724

1,073 sq ft 2 and 2, floor 4

$375,000

[8]

November 24, 2025

22712

1,073 sq ft 2 and 2, floor 3

$315,000

[8]

September 9, 2025

22748

1,095 sq ft 2 and 2, floor 1

$340,000

[8]

August 15, 2025

22700

1,239 sq ft 3 and 2, floor 5

$400,000

[8]

May 30, 2024

22724

1,239 sq ft 3 and 2, floor 5

$615,000

[8]

May 6, 2024

22724

1,239 sq ft 3 and 2, floor 2

$475,000

[8]

April 29, 2024

22712

1,073 sq ft 2 and 2, floor 2

$600,000

[8]

March 13, 2024

22736

1,073 sq ft 2 and 2, floor 1

$480,000

[8]

Period

What the county recorded

Source

2006 peak

$465,000 to $630,000

[8]

2009 to 2014 trough

$210,000 to $312,500

[8]

2020 to 2021, before Ian

$330,000 to $380,000

[8]

2023, after Ian

$585,000 (April) and $475,000 (May), both 1,073 sq ft

[8]

March to May 2024

$475,000 to $615,000

[8]

November 2025 to July 2026

$315,000 to $430,000

[8]

Why did prices fall after spring 2024?

The county record shows a run-up through spring 2024 and a fall back to roughly 2020 to 2021 levels by late 2025. The record does not say why; condition, floor and view differ sale to sale, and insurance, assessments and inspection costs after Ian are the questions buyers ask [8].

What does the county say the units are worth?

The 2025 just values run $256,452 to $372,246, median $323,003, totalling $24.35 million for 75 units. Just value is a tax figure, not a sale price [3].

How Was Captains Bay South Developed?

Captains Bay South was built in phases in the mid-1990s: the Captain's Bay associations were all incorporated on March 22, 1993, the South declaration was recorded at Official Records Book 2576, Page 1724, the state dates the project to February 17, 1995, and the five buildings went up in 1995 and 1997 [11][12][9][2].

Date

Event

Source

March 22, 1993

Captain's Bay South, North One, North Two, Operations and Recreational associations filed

[11]

February 17, 1995

Captain's Bay South Condo recorded with the state, 75 units

[9]

April 1995

Earliest recorded transfers in building 1, 22748

[5]

1995

Buildings at 22748 and 22736 built

[2]

December 31, 1995

Town of Fort Myers Beach incorporates

[31]

1997

Buildings at 22700, 22724 and 22712 built

[2]

2006

Peak resales of $465,000 to $630,000

[8]

September 28, 2022

Hurricane Ian surge of 10 to 15 feet on Fort Myers Beach

[57]

2025 to 2026

Listing remarks report the building at 22736 fully restored after Ian

[22]

November 14, 2025

New Big Carlos Pass Bridge opens to traffic

[61]

Who was the developer?

No developer is named in the filings, roll legal descriptions or cost cards we read. The declaration at Official Records Book 2576, Page 1724 names the declarant, and we have not read it [12][3].

What do the phase labels mean?

The legal descriptions label building 1 at 22748 Phase III, building 2 at 22736 Ph III-B and building 3 at 22700 Ph III-C; buildings 4 and 5 carry no phase label. The Phase III numbering suggests the South phases continued a sequence begun by the North condominiums, which only the declaration can confirm [3][5][7].

Who runs Captains Bay South today?

Captain's Bay South Condominium Association, Inc., active since 1993, shows Approved and Recorded on the state file, unlike North Two, which the state shows as Delinquent on its annual fee [11][9]. The manager is not confirmed: the state file lists the association itself with a Miami care-of address, the county mails the common-element parcel to New Brittany Blvd in Fort Myers, and our parent research read the filing in care of Allied Property Group, which moved its 115 associations to the Vantaca platform on June 24, 2026 [9][4][65].

What Do Captains Bay South Owners Pay? Fees, Taxes and No CDD

A Captains Bay South owner pays one condominium fee, $887 a month or about $10,644 a year on a listing that closed in June 2026, plus a Town of Fort Myers Beach district tax bill at 13.4329 mills for 2025, with no master association and no CDD found [22][38][9][3].

Charge

Amount

Source

Condominium fee (listing closed June 30, 2026)

$887 a month, about $10,644 a year

[22]

One-time fee on the same listing

$150

[22]

Master association or CDD

None found

[9][3]

2025 Town of Fort Myers Beach district millage

13.4329 mills (final)

[38]

2026 district millage

13.7151 mills proposed

[39]

First-year taxes estimated on listing pages

About $5,000 to $6,225

[22]

Homesteaded units, 2025 roll

12 of 75

[3]

  • What the fee covers: cable, fidelity bond, insurance, lawn and land care, legal and accounting, exterior pest control, reserves, sewer and street lights, per the listing [22].
  • Special assessments: one listing states all assessments are paid after the Ian restoration; the amount and dates of the Ian assessments are not public, so ask for the assessment history [22].
  • Worked tax example: at 13.4329 mills, a $475,000 price carries about $6,380.63 a year before exemptions, and $315,000 about $4,231.36; the county sets the assessed value, so your bill will differ [38].
  • Homestead: the exemption and the Save Our Homes cap apply to a permanent residence, so a buyer's first bill can be well above the seller's [41][42].
  • Estoppel: Florida law caps the estoppel certificate fee, and the certificate states what is owed and any approved special assessment [46][47].

Can You Rent Out a Captains Bay South Condo?

Captains Bay South units can be rented within the association's rules and the Town's: listing records state a 14-day minimum lease and up to 26 leases a year, the Town requires short-term rental registration through Rentalscape, and our parent research did not find Captains Bay South on the Town's 2026 condominium opt-out list [22][25][28].

  • Association rules: a 14-day minimum and up to 26 leases a year, per listing records; one listing describes bi-weekly rentals. The recorded declaration and current rules govern, so read them before relying on rental income [22].
  • Town registration: under Ordinance 18-01 a vacation rental shows its registration number in every advertisement and names a responsible party available 24 hours a day who can act within one hour [26][25].
  • Code of conduct: the Town publishes quiet hours, occupancy and trash rules for short-term rentals [27].
  • Enforcement: the Town began issuing violation notices in early 2026 and sent warning letters over registration compliance in May 2026 [29][30].
  • Minimum-stay exceptions: the Town's code limits rental stays in some zoning districts, with exceptions that include land on the bay side of Estero Boulevard and condominiums of six or more units whose declaration allowed rentals; which applies here is not confirmed [36].

What is the condominium opt-out list?

Condominium associations in the Town may opt out of Town enforcement of the rental code of conduct by registering the building and enforcing it themselves. The 2026 list names Captains Bay North Two; our parent research found no Captains Bay South entry [28][25].

Is Captains Bay South in a Flood Zone, and How Did It Come Through Hurricane Ian?

Yes. FEMA maps Captains Bay South in Zone AE, a coastal floodplain with an 11 foot base flood elevation, at every point tested, on panel 12071C0567G effective November 17, 2022; it is in Lee County evacuation Zone A, and Hurricane Ian's surge reached 10 to 15 feet above ground on Fort Myers Beach [13][14][15][57].

  • Zone AE: a special flood hazard area, where federally backed loans require flood insurance [13][56].
  • Ground elevation: one listing page estimates about 6 feet; only an elevation certificate settles a unit's rating [22][34].
  • Evacuation and surge: County Zone A, surge zone 1; the state storm surge layer puts the site in the Category 1 surge polygon [15][17].
  • Coastal Building Zone: inside Lee County's Coastal Building Zone under Ordinance 94-22 [16].
  • Flood insurance discount: the Town earned FEMA Community Rating System Class 5, a 25 percent discount in special flood hazard areas, effective April 1, 2026 [54].

How deep was the Ian water at Captains Bay South?

No building-specific depth was found. The National Hurricane Center gives 10 to 15 feet of surge above ground on Fort Myers Beach; U.S. Geological Survey high-water marks on the island read 10.5 to 13.8 feet NAVD88, and the Florida DEP recorded 13.23 feet NAVD88 at the pier [57][58]. With ground-floor units as living space, ask what the first floors needed.

What was restored after Ian?

A listing that closed June 30, 2026 says the building at 22736 has been fully restored after Ian, with a new roof, brick pavers and a working elevator, and that all assessments are paid [22]. Ask for permits and dates for the other four buildings.

What about Helene and Milton in 2024?

The National Weather Service put water levels in coastal Lee County at 2 to 5 feet above mean higher high water for Helene and 3 to 6 feet for Milton; no Captains Bay South report was found [59][60].

What insurance questions should I ask?

Four: what the association's master policy covers and its deductible rule, your HO-6 unit policy, flood cover, and any wind mitigation credit on the state form, revised April 1, 2026 [22][50][52]. Citizens' flood requirement has exemptions, but a lender may still require flood cover [51].

Do Florida's Milestone Inspection and SIRS Laws Apply at Captains Bay South?

Yes. All five buildings are five stories, so section 553.899 milestone inspections and the section 718.112 structural integrity reserve study apply; by the county year built, 22748 and 22736 reached 30 years in 2025, and 22700, 22724 and 22712 reach it in 2027, while inspection and filing status are not public [2][43][44][10].

Buildings

County year built

Reaches 30 years

Milestone inspection due by

SIRS applies

Source

22748 and 22736

1995

2025

December 31, 2025

Yes

[2][43]

22700, 22724 and 22712

1997

2027

December 31, 2027

Yes

[2][43]

  • SIRS deadline: December 31, 2025 for existing associations, with associations reporting through DBPR's online account and public lookup databases split at July 2025 [44][10].
  • Status: the DBPR databases are interactive apps our research could not query, so the Captains Bay South filing is not confirmed [10].
  • Resale window: a resale buyer may cancel within 7 days of receiving the documents, or 15 days where milestone or SIRS documents apply [45].
  • What to ask for: the milestone inspection summary, the reserve study, the funded reserve balance and any assessment the study triggered [44][43].

What Town Rules Apply When You Repair or Remodel?

Captains Bay South is in the Town of Fort Myers Beach, so the Town's flood rules apply to any repair: improvements or repairs equal to 50 percent of a structure's value in a flood hazard area trigger full compliance, the Town counts all permits from the past five years, and contractors must hold Town licensing since July 1, 2023 [32][33][36].

Can a damaged mid-rise be rebuilt at its present size?

Under the Town's buildback section, a building that exceeds today's density, intensity or height and is damaged by a disaster may be replaced at up to its pre-disaster lawful size; over 50 percent damage, it must meet the floodplain and coastal rules for new buildings. For a condominium, that is an association decision [36].

Which Schools Serve Captains Bay South?

The Lee County school district's 2026-27 zone layer places Captains Bay South in elementary zone T, middle zone MM and high school zone South 4; Fort Myers Beach Elementary is closed and students are bused to the mainland, so confirm the assigned schools by address with Student Enrollment at 239-337-8247 [18][19][21].

  • Fort Myers Beach Elementary: the School Board voted on May 12, 2026 to give the building to the Town for a charter school [20].
  • Where students go now: WGCU reports island students bused to Heights Elementary [21].
  • High school zone: the layer reads South 4, while the enrollment plan text we read lists sub-zones 1 to 3, so confirm with the district [18][19].

What Is Changing Around Island Pines Way?

Three changes matter around Captains Bay South: the new Big Carlos Pass Bridge opened to traffic on November 14, 2025, the empty Wyndham Garden hotel site at 6890 Estero Boulevard is moving toward redevelopment, and the Town's 2045 comprehensive plan work names Island Pines Way as one end of a Santini Village district [61][62][68].

What is planned on the Wyndham Garden site?

The hotel, empty since Ian, was demolished in April 2025. In June 2026 the Local Planning Agency voted 6-1 for a development agreement for a tiki restaurant and bar, six food trailers, a recreation area and public beach access in phase 1, and a wave wall, a 5,000 square foot restaurant, a pool and a lazy river in phase 2, at least three years out [64][62]. Council hearings were set for August 3 and 24, 2026, and we did not find the outcome [63].

What is the Santini Village district?

Our parent research noted a draft Santini Village district running from Island Pines Way to Bella Lago Drive. Town Council was reported to have adopted the amended plan in December 2025; we did not confirm the final district boundaries [68].

What else is being rebuilt on the island?

Fire Station 31 opened at 2545 Estero Boulevard on April 2, 2026, Lee County broke ground on the pier rebuild on August 21, 2026, about a $14.4 million project expected to take about a year, and Bowditch Point Park closed on September 8, 2026 for a $3.9 million restoration [37][69][70].

Where Is Captains Bay South, and How Long Are the Drives?

Captains Bay South is about 12 minutes from Lovers Key State Park, 27 minutes from HealthPark Medical Center and 46 minutes from Southwest Florida International Airport; times below are free-flow estimates from Bay Beach Lane, about half a mile away, so add time in season and when the bridges back up [71].

Destination

Miles

Free-flow minutes

Source

Lovers Key State Park entrance

3.5

12

[71]

HealthPark Medical Center

10.8

27

[71]

Coconut Point, Estero

14.8

29

[71]

Gulf Coast Medical Center

15.8

35

[71]

Sanibel

16.6

36

[71]

Downtown Fort Myers

19.7

42

[71]

Southwest Florida International Airport

22.5

46

[71]

Downtown Naples

23.0

43

[71]

How do you reach I-75?

The nearest interchange is Exit 116 at Bonita Beach Road, reached over the Big Carlos Pass Bridge, through Lovers Key and along Bonita Beach Road; we did not measure the mileage [61][71].

Captains Bay South vs Estero Bayside and Other Bay Beach Condos: How Do They Compare?

Buyers who look at Captains Bay South usually compare it with its Island Pines Way neighbor Estero Bayside, with Captains Bay North Two and with other Bay Beach condominiums, and the honest differences are age, height and amenities: Captains Bay South is mid-1990s and five stories, Estero Bayside is 2006 and six stories with its own clubhouse [2][9].

Community

Units, era and height

Honest difference

Source

Captains Bay South

75 units, 1995 and 1997, 5 stories

Pool, tennis and shuffleboard on the record; AE zone; milestone dates 2025 and 2027

[2][4][13]

Estero Bayside

45 units, 2006, 6 stories, 22604 and 22628 Island Pines Way

Same street, about a decade newer and taller, with its own clubhouse at 22631

[2]

Captains Bay North Two

15 units, 1997, 5 stories, 6691 Estero Blvd

Same name and era, separate association; Delinquent on the state annual fee; on the Town's opt-out list

[2][9][28]

Captains Bay North One

3 units, 1994, 2-story villa, 6661 Estero Blvd

Larger 1,183 to 1,352 sq ft units; below the milestone and SIRS trigger

[2]

Bac-Bay Health and Racquet Club and Admirals Bay

2-story, 1983 to 1991, Island Pines Way

Same street, older and low-rise, below the milestone trigger

[2]

What other Bay Beach guides should I read?

Our guides to Waterside at Bay Beach, Grandview at Bay Beach, The Palms of Bay Beach and Hibiscus Pointe cover other Bay Beach condominiums, and the Bay Beach guide covers the enclave as a whole.

What Are the Honest Pros and Cons of Captains Bay South?

McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and the lists below are our honest read of Captains Bay South from the county roll and building layer, the recorded sales, the state condominium files, the FEMA and evacuation layers, Town rules and listing records, so buyers and sellers can weigh it before a showing.

Pros

Entry pricing for a bay-side island condo, a side-street setting off Estero Boulevard, a recorded pool and tennis court, only 75 units in one association, a 14-day minimum lease on listing records, no master association or CDD, the Gulf beach across Estero Boulevard and the new bridge close by [8][4][9][22][61].

Cons

Zone AE and evacuation Zone A, ground-floor living units, a thin resale record, prices that fell from 2024, milestone and SIRS obligations whose status is not public, an $887 monthly fee on one listing and amenity claims that need confirmation [13][15][5][8][10][22][23].

Thinking of Selling Your Captains Bay South Condo? List With the #1 Team in Southwest Florida Since 2012

If you're searching for a Captains Bay South listing agent, or thinking, 'I need someone to sell my Captains Bay South condo...' start with the record: 11 qualified sales in 36 months, from $315,000 to $615,000, and the five most recent, from November 2025 to July 2026, at $315,000 to $430,000 [8].

We tracked every Captains Bay South sale in the county file for this guide, because a buyer compares your unit with a short list of the right sales, so we price from the recorded sales, the plan, the floor, the view, the inspection paperwork and the condition, not from an automated estimate.

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Captains Bay South Sales, by the Numbers

  • 36 months to November 11, 2026: 11 qualified sales, median $400,000, $315,000 to $615,000 [8].
  • 12 months to November 11, 2026: 5 qualified sales, median $350,000, $315,000 to $430,000 [8].
  • March to May 2024: $475,000 to $615,000 [8].
  • 2023 after Ian: $585,000 and $475,000 [8].
  • Homestead share: 12 of 75 units [3].

Selling in Captains Bay South Is Different in Five Ways

  • Your plan sets the comparison. The 1,239 square foot three-bedroom and the 1,073 square foot two-bedroom are different markets [3][8].
  • The paperwork is the product. Buyers ask for the milestone summary, the reserve study and the estoppel before they negotiate [43][44][47].
  • Flood questions come first. Zone AE means lenders require flood cover, and an elevation certificate helps the buyer's quote [13][34].
  • Rental rules shape the buyer pool. A 14-day minimum and up to 26 leases a year, per listing records [22].
  • Restoration shows in price. Have the Ian repair record, the roof date and the assessment history in writing [22].

What Is Your Captains Bay South Condo Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds.

Start with a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation or our Captains Bay condo valuation page. Jesse follows up with a written range built from your building, plan, floor, view, condition and the Captains Bay South sales that fit your unit.

(239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome. Our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers Beach walks through the sale step by step, and our Fort Myers Beach real estate hub covers the wider island market.

What closing costs does a Captains Bay South seller pay in Lee County?

A Florida seller customarily pays the documentary stamp tax on the deed, 70 cents per $100 of price, so $3,325.00 on a $475,000 sale [49], plus the brokerage fee, any mortgage payoff, prorated taxes and the association charges the contract assigns to the seller. In Lee County the seller customarily pays the owner's title policy, and the contract controls [53].

Your Local Real Estate Experts

Captains Bay South sellers and buyers work directly with Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, who have sold Southwest Florida real estate for more than twenty years, lead Domain Realty Group, and read the Lee County roll and sale files, the county flood, evacuation and building layers, the state condominium files and Florida condominium law behind this guide.

You can read how the team was built on our about the McGreevy and Comisar team page. McGreevy and Comisar are the Domain Realty team behind this Captains Bay South guide: Jesse McGreevy leads on listings and pricing, and Marc Comisar leads on buyer representation across Southwest Florida. If you are comparing agents, see the best real estate agents in Fort Myers Beach.

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.

McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

What Our Clients Say

McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Captains Bay South realtor on Google, and the quotes below are genuine five star client reviews reproduced in the reviewer’s own words. We publish no aggregate score and no Captains Bay South testimonial we do not have.

★★★★★ “Not living in the area, Jesse made life easy for me when we decided to sell our condo. His attention to detail, patience, understanding, and tenacity in dealing with all the moving parts was truly impressive.” Eric Acra, verified Google review

★★★★★ “Their recommendation on pricing my unit was sound and proved prescient. I never questioned their integrity and found it easy to rely on their recommendations. I would work with them again in a heartbeat.” Charlie Carroll, verified Google review

★★★★★ “Working with Jesse and his team was truly an amazing experience. From the very beginning, they were professional, attentive, and incredibly knowledgeable. They guided us through every step of the process with patience and clarity, always making sure we felt comfortable and informed with every decision.” Leonardo Silva, verified Google review

Contact McGreevy and Comisar

  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 · [email protected]
  • Marc Comisar: (239) 457-1610
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Selling your Captains Bay South condo? Get a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

Buying in Captains Bay South? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida, or our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers Beach.

Licensure, and the Office of Record

Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission, and licenses can be verified with the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation. Florida law requires a brokerage relationship disclosure (s. 475.278, Florida Statutes).

  • Jesse McGreevy, Florida license SL3101296
  • Marc Comisar, Florida license BK3060671
  • Brokerage office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Frequently Asked Questions: Captains Bay South Buyer Edition

These are the Captains Bay South questions buyers ask most, each answered from the Lee County roll, building layer and sale records, the state condominium files, FEMA, the school district, Town rules and Florida law cited on this page. Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 to plan a showing.

How many units are in Captains Bay South?

75, in five five-story buildings of 15 [2][9].

Which plan is most common?

The 1,073 square foot two-bedroom, two-bath end unit, 50 of the 75 [3].

Are there three-bedroom units?

Yes, 20 middle units of 1,239 square feet on floors 2 to 5 [3][7].

Is Captains Bay South gated?

No; the county neighborhood layer records it as not gated [1].

Is there an age restriction?

No age restriction was found on the records we read; confirm in the declaration [12].

Do I need flood insurance?

With a federally backed loan, yes; every tested point is Zone AE [13][56].

Can I rent my unit weekly?

Listing records show a 14-day minimum lease and up to 26 leases a year; confirm the recorded rules [22].

Is there a CDD or master fee?

None was found on the state record or the roll [9][3].

What does the condo fee include?

Cable, insurance, lawn care, legal and accounting, pest control, reserves, sewer and street lights, per one listing [22].

Are boat docks available?

No; the roll shows no boat dock or seawall on any South parcel [3].

Frequently Asked Questions: Captains Bay South Seller Edition

These are the questions Captains Bay South owners ask us, answered from the county record, the state files, Town rules and Florida law. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 for a number on your unit based on its plan, floor and the sales that fit it.

What is my Captains Bay South condo worth?

Start with a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation, then Jesse builds a range from the recorded Captains Bay South sales for your plan [8].

What did units sell for in 2026?

$350,000 to $430,000 on qualified county sales from January to July 2026 [8].

What is the record price?

$630,000 for a top-floor three-bedroom at 22700 in March 2006 [8].

Have prices fallen since 2024?

Yes; spring 2024 sales ran $475,000 to $615,000 and the last five ran $315,000 to $430,000 [8].

How many units sell in a year?

Five qualified sales in the twelve months to November 11, 2026 [8].

Does my floor plan change my price?

Yes; the 1,239 square foot three-bedroom and the 1,073 square foot two-bedroom record different prices [8].

Does a top-floor unit sell differently?

The two highest recorded prices were top-floor three-bedroom units, so we compare floors as well as plans [8].

Does the county value equal my selling price?

No; just value is a tax figure [3].

Do I need an estoppel?

Yes; the association issues one showing the fee, any balance and any special assessment [46][47].

Which fee do I tell buyers?

The current one on your estoppel; one 2026 listing showed $887 a month [22][47].

What do I give a condo buyer?

The condominium resale documents Florida law lists [45].

Does the milestone inspection affect my sale?

Yes; buyers ask for the summary, and the 1995 buildings passed their date at the end of 2025 [43][2].

Does the SIRS affect my sale?

Yes; buyers and lenders ask for the reserve study and the funded reserves [44][10].

Does it lengthen the buyer's review period?

Yes; 15 days instead of 7 where milestone or SIRS documents apply [45].

Do I need a flood disclosure?

Yes; Florida's seller flood disclosure covers flood claims and federal assistance [48].

Does Zone AE affect my sale?

Yes; lenders require flood cover, so an elevation certificate helps the buyer's quote [13][34][55].

Will buyers ask about Ian?

Yes; keep the permits, the repair dates and the assessment history, and disclose what you know [57][22].

Will buyers ask about the roof and elevator?

Yes; listing remarks report a new roof and a working elevator at 22736, so have dates in writing [22].

Will hurricane features help my sale?

Yes; a wind mitigation inspection on the state form can support insurance credits [50][52].

Can I sell to an investor?

Yes; listing records show a 14-day minimum lease and up to 26 leases a year [22].

Does my rental registration transfer?

No; Town registration numbers do not transfer, so the buyer registers as their own operator [25][26].

Is Captains Bay South on the opt-out list?

Our parent research did not find it on the 2026 list; North Two is on it [28].

Will the Wyndham site affect my value?

We cannot say; the Council outcome was not found, and buyers may ask about it [62][63].

Who pays the documentary stamp tax?

In Florida the seller customarily pays it, $2,205.00 on a $315,000 sale [49].

Who pays for the owner's title policy in Lee County?

The seller customarily, and the contract controls [53].

Can I keep my homestead savings when I move?

Portability can carry part of the Save Our Homes benefit to your next Florida home [42][41].

What if there is a special assessment?

It appears on the estoppel and affects what buyers pay, so tell us before you list [46].

How do I find my unit's sale history?

The Lee County Property Appraiser's property search lists each recorded sale of your parcel with its date and price [40][12].

Should I sell now or wait?

That depends on your plans; we price from the latest Captains Bay South sales for your plan [8].

Who should I call first about selling in Captains Bay South?

Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072. He will review your unit and documents against the recorded Captains Bay South sales, then give you a written price range. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

Sources and Authoritative References

Every fact in this Captains Bay South guide traces to a record below: Lee County Property Appraiser and GIS layers, Florida condominium and corporation files, FEMA, the school district, the Town of Fort Myers Beach, Florida statutes and news reports. No listing portal is linked, and the numbers match the bracket citations on this page.

  1. Lee County GIS, Neighborhoods and Areas layer (NBHD-13420, Captains Bay South Condominium)
  2. Lee County GIS, Building Footprints layer (Island Pines Way buildings)
  3. Lee County GIS, Lee County Parcels layer (STRAP 03-47-24-W1-069, 76 parcels)
  4. Lee County Property Appraiser, common elements cost card, 22704 Island Pines Way
  5. Lee County Property Appraiser, condominium cost card, 22748 Island Pines Way, 1,073 sq ft
  6. Lee County Property Appraiser, condominium cost card, 22748 Island Pines Way, 1,095 sq ft
  7. Lee County Property Appraiser, condominium cost cards for 22736, 22700, 22724 and 22712 Island Pines Way
  8. Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sale records, Captains Bay South rows, read November 2026 from our research copy
  9. Florida DBPR, Division of Condominiums extract (project PR1S022330)
  10. Florida DBPR, SIRS reporting and public lookup
  11. Florida Division of Corporations, Captain's Bay entity filings
  12. Lee County Clerk of Court, Official Records search
  13. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, flood zones (point queries, November 11, 2026)
  14. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, FIRM panels
  15. Lee County GIS, Evacuation Zones layer
  16. Lee County GIS, Coastal Building Zone layer
  17. Lee County GIS, FDEM storm surge zones layer
  18. Lee County GIS, School Proximity Zones 2026-27 layer
  19. School District of Lee County, school zones
  20. Fort Myers Beach Talk, School Board votes to give Fort Myers Beach Elementary to the Town (May 2026)
  21. WGCU, Beach Elementary School future remains uncertain (October 8, 2025)
  22. Public listing records for Captains Bay South units, 2025 to 2026, read November 2026 (brokerage pages, not linked)
  23. A listing aggregator's Captain's Bay South page, read November 2026 (not linked)
  24. Vacation rental listings for Captains Bay units, read November 2026 (not linked)
  25. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Short-Term Rentals
  26. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Ordinance 18-01
  27. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Short-Term Rentals Code of Conduct
  28. Town of Fort Myers Beach, 2026 condominium opt-out list
  29. WGCU, Town to issue short-term rental violation notices (December 30, 2025)
  30. Fort Myers Beach Talk, warning letters over rental registration (May 2026)
  31. Town of Fort Myers Beach, home page
  32. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Substantial Improvement and Substantial Damage
  33. Town of Fort Myers Beach, FEMA's 50% Rule
  34. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Elevation Certificates
  35. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Parking
  36. Town of Fort Myers Beach, Code of Ordinances
  37. Fort Myers Beach Fire Control District, Fire Station 31 grand opening
  38. Lee County Property Appraiser, 2025 taxing district millage book
  39. Lee County Property Appraiser, 2026 preliminary millage book
  40. Lee County Property Appraiser, property search
  41. Florida Department of Revenue, homestead exemption guide
  42. Florida Department of Revenue, Save Our Homes
  43. Florida Statutes, section 553.899, milestone inspections
  44. Florida Statutes, section 718.112, reserves and SIRS
  45. Florida Statutes, section 718.503, resale disclosure
  46. Florida Statutes, section 718.116, assessments and estoppel
  47. Florida DBPR, Estoppel Certificate Fees
  48. Florida Statutes, section 689.302, seller flood disclosure
  49. Florida Statutes, section 201.02, documentary stamp tax
  50. Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, wind mitigation resources
  51. Citizens Property Insurance, flood requirement
  52. Citizens Property Insurance, mitigation inspection form changes
  53. Attorneys' Title Fund, who pays for title insurance
  54. WGCU, Fort Myers Beach earns CRS Class 5 (December 24, 2025)
  55. FEMA, Risk Rating 2.0
  56. FEMA Flood Map Service Center
  57. National Hurricane Center, Hurricane Ian report
  58. Florida DEP, Hurricane Ian and Nicole report (August 2023)
  59. National Weather Service Tampa Bay, Helene impact narratives
  60. National Weather Service Tampa Bay, Milton impact narratives
  61. WGCU, new Big Carlos Pass Bridge to open November 14 (November 9, 2025)
  62. Fort Myers Beach Talk, Wyndham Garden development agreement approved by LPA (June 2026)
  63. Fort Myers Beach Talk, Wyndham Garden Inn redevelopment first Council hearing (August 2026)
  64. 96K Rock, Wyndham Garden hotel comes down (April 3, 2025)
  65. Vantaca, Allied Property Group goes live on Vantaca (June 24, 2026)
  66. Santini Marina Plaza, 7205 Estero Boulevard, lease listing (not linked)
  67. Gulfshore Business, Publix reopens Fort Myers Beach location
  68. Soar Citizen Portal, council adopts amended comprehensive plan 2045 (December 2025; not linked, host did not resolve)
  69. Fort Myers Beach Talk, pier groundbreaking (August 2026)
  70. WGCU, parking closures at Bonita and Fort Myers Beach parks (September 9, 2026)
  71. OSRM public router, free-flow estimates from Bay Beach Lane

Downloadable Documents

Captains Bay South's key public documents are published by the Town of Fort Myers Beach, the State of Florida, the National Hurricane Center and the Lee County Property Appraiser; the table links each to its issuer. The declaration, budget, reserve study and estoppel come from the association, so ask its manager for them.

Document

Issued by

Date

Link

Ordinance 18-01, Short-Term Rentals Regulation

Town of Fort Myers Beach

2018

Ordinance, PDF

Short-Term Rentals Code of Conduct

Town of Fort Myers Beach

Current

Code of conduct, PDF

2026 condominium opt-out list

Town of Fort Myers Beach

2026

Opt-out list

Hurricane Ian tropical cyclone report

National Hurricane Center

2023

Report, PDF

Estoppel Certificate Fees

Florida DBPR

Current

Fee schedule, PDF


Market data from the Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sale records and county GIS layers, read November 11, 2026. McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Captains Bay South. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.


Work With Us

Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.