Port Carlos Cove is a resident-owned cooperative of 155 home sites at 1802 Main Street on San Carlos Island, Fort Myers Beach, with canal docks, manufactured and elevated homes, a clubhouse, a pool and a boat ramp. Sell, value or buy with McGreevy and Comisar.
By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.
Port Carlos Cove is a resident-owned cooperative of 155 home sites at 1802 Main Street on San Carlos Island, with a Fort Myers Beach 33931 mailing address but zoned and governed by unincorporated Lee County. Its canal and bay lots hold manufactured homes and newer elevated site-built homes, with a clubhouse, a pool and a community boat ramp [1][3][62]. McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
Here is the short answer most Port Carlos Cove searchers need: the multiple listing service names it Port Carlos Cove Co-Op Inc, the county carries 156 lot folios plus one common-element parcel, recorded home sales from January 2025 to July 2026 ran $175,000 to $440,000, vacant lots sold for $55,000 to $210,000, and listings put the co-op fee at about $200 a month (unverified) [1][2][64].
McGreevy and Comisar are the best realtor for Port Carlos Cove because a cooperative with 156 lot folios, a mix of 1960s manufactured homes, post-Ian elevated builds and 89 land-only lots, unpublished co-op rules and heavy storm exposure has to be priced lot by lot from the county record and the cooperative documents, and we read both first.
If you're searching for the best realtor for Port Carlos Cove in Fort Myers Beach, Florida, whether you own a home or a lot on Galleon, Doubloon, Blackbeard or Cortez Way and may want to sell, or you want to buy into a canal-front cooperative a mile from the Gulf beach, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. Buyers and sellers comparing the best real estate agents in Fort Myers Beach should ask each agent to explain Port Carlos Cove from the public record, and we do that below.
For Port Carlos Cove buyers: the first question is what you actually receive, because the multiple listing service calls it a stock cooperative, owner reviews say you own the lot, and one listing mentions a 99-year land lease [64][37][67]. The second is the co-op's own rules on approval, pets and rentals, none of which is published. The third is flood and storm exposure on San Carlos Island [24][18].
For Port Carlos Cove sellers: your home's age, size and elevation, your water frontage and whether you have a dock set the comparison. Recorded home sales since Ian ran $125,000 to $440,000 and vacant lots $55,000 to $225,000, so a seller needs the right short list of sales, not an average [2][1].
Honors and recognition:
Selling your Port Carlos Cove home or lot? Get a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. You can also read our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers Beach.
Buying at Port Carlos Cove? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida.
Port Carlos Cove in brief: a member-owned manufactured home and site-built cooperative on the east end of Main Street, with every figure below traced to the Lee County Property Appraiser, Lee County records, the National Hurricane Center, Florida's cooperative law, news reports or dated public listing records, and with anything not confirmed labelled as unverified [1][24][38][67].
Port Carlos Cove is a resident-owned cooperative park on San Carlos Island, the working-waterfront island between the mainland and Estero Island, and it is not in the Town of Fort Myers Beach: Lee County zones every parcel MHPD in unincorporated zoning area ULC, even though the mailing address reads Fort Myers Beach 33931 [1][3][62].
Fact | Port Carlos Cove | Source |
|---|---|---|
Address | 1802 Main Street (office and common area), Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931 | [3][62] |
Streets | Galleon Way, Doubloon Way, Blackbeard Way, Cortez Way, Garcia Way, Barbados Way and Spanish Main | [1] |
Government | Unincorporated Lee County, zoning MHPD (Mobile Home Planned Development), zoning area ULC | [1] |
Taxing district | FMB Fire, FMB Library, FMB Mosquito and San Carlos Light; Fort Myers Beach Fire District | [1][57][58] |
Legal description | Parcel in Government Lots 1 and 2, Section 19, Township 46 South, Range 24 East, Official Records Book 1646, Page 759, common area Tracts A to E | [1][3][10] |
Ownership form | Resident-owned cooperative; listed as a stock cooperative; each lot is its own county folio | [62][64][1] |
Gate, golf, CDD | No gate found (unverified); no golf; no community development district on the roll | [62][63][1] |
Three names appear in the public record: Port Carlos Cove Inc owns Lot 153 and applied for the 1986 county zoning action, Port Carlos Cove Assoc owns the common area, and the multiple listing service uses Port Carlos Cove Co-Op Inc. Which entity holds the cooperative documents is unverified, because the Sunbiz record could not be read [1][3][10][48].
It is not San Carlos Park, an inland area of south Fort Myers, and not Gulf Cove Trailer Park Co-op at 19281 San Carlos Boulevard, a different cooperative. Some portals also mislabel its homes as single-family [70][67][63].
The common-element parcel, Tracts A to E, holds the clubhouse, the pool and the grounds at the east end of Main Street, at about 26.4598 N, 81.9399 W, facing Hurricane Bay and Estero Bay. A 1986 county resolution tied the zoning to protecting identified wetland areas, and the county parcel layer maps the tracts [3][10][6].
Port Carlos Cove sits at the dead-end east end of Main Street on San Carlos Island, reached from San Carlos Boulevard, State Road 865, just north of the Matanzas Pass Bridge to Estero Island. The Fort Myers Beach pier and Times Square area is about one mile away in a straight line, over the bridge [62][33][70].
The figures below are straight-line miles from the common area, not road miles, and drive minutes were not measured. A 2020 owner review notes that traffic on San Carlos Boulevard can be busy in peak season, and Main Street is a dead-end road [3][37][33].
Destination | Straight-line distance | Source |
|---|---|---|
Fort Myers Beach, Times Square and pier area (nearest Gulf beach) | About 1.0 mile, over the Matanzas Pass Bridge | [3][70] |
Bowditch Point Park, north tip of Estero Island | About 1.6 miles | [3][15] |
Lovers Key State Park | About 6.1 miles | [3][59] |
HealthPark Medical Center, Lee Health | About 4.6 miles | [3][60] |
I-75 Exit 128, Alico Road | About 9.9 miles | [3] |
I-75 Exit 131, Daniels Parkway | About 11.5 miles | [3] |
Coconut Point, Estero | About 9.1 miles | [3] |
Gulf Coast Town Center | About 9.7 miles | [3] |
Southwest Florida International Airport | About 12.6 miles | [3][61] |
Downtown Fort Myers | About 13.2 miles | [3] |
Downtown Naples, Fifth Avenue South | About 23.7 miles | [3] |
San Carlos Boulevard runs north to the mainland and south over the Matanzas Pass Bridge to Estero Island. The current bridge, with 65 feet of clearance, opened on October 15, 1979, replacing a 1927 swing bridge, which itself replaced a 1921 wooden drawbridge [70].
Port Carlos Cove dates from about 1960 by one listing portal's count, though that year is unverified; the oldest homes on the roll are from 1966 and 1967, the clubhouse entered the roll in 1980, and every co-op lot was created on the roll in 1983, with the first recorded lot sale in April 1983 [62][1][3][2].
Date or record | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
About 1960 | Park opening year per a manufactured-home listing portal (unverified) | [62] |
1966 and 1967 | Oldest homes on the current roll, for example 2 and 3 Galleon Way | [1] |
1980 | Clubhouse first on the roll on the common-element parcel | [3] |
April 1983 | Lots created on the roll and first recorded lot sales, consistent with a cooperative conversion (unverified) | [1][2] |
1986 | Resolution ZAB-86-15 names Port Carlos Cove, Inc. as owner at 1802 Main Street; wetland areas to be protected | [10] |
September 28, 2022 | Hurricane Ian; a sensor on San Carlos Island recorded 12.06 feet of storm surge | [24] |
2023 to 2026 | Six new homes enter the roll, at 920 to 1,200 square feet | [1] |
June 24, 2026 | 4 Galleon Way sells for $440,000, the highest post-Ian home sale in the county file | [2] |
Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-20). No public source our research read names the original developer. The recorded deeds starting at Official Records Book 1646, Page 759 are the route to that answer [9][1].
Most likely in or about 1983. Every co-op lot shows 1983 as its year created on the roll and the county sale history for the lots begins in April 1983, but the conversion date and price come from the recorded cooperative documents, which were not read, so treat the date as unverified [1][2][9].
Unverified. Resolution ZAB-86-15 found the request consistent with the Lee County Comprehensive Plan with the condition that the identified wetland areas are protected, including a conservation easement. The scanned resolution could not be read as text, so the exact request is unconfirmed; today every lot is zoned MHPD [10][1].
Port Carlos Cove is a cooperative, so Florida's Chapter 719 governs the association, not the condominium law: a buyer joins the member-owned co-op, which the multiple listing service lists as a stock cooperative, while the county still values and taxes each lot as its own folio. What the buyer's deed or certificate says must come from the recorded documents [39][40][64][1].
Ownership question | What the record shows | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
Form of ownership | Resident-owned cooperative; association type listed as stock cooperative | Listing and portal records | [62][64] |
Lot on the tax roll | Each lot is its own folio with its own owner of record and value | County roll | [1] |
Ownership instrument | Owner reviews say you own the lot; one listing mentions a 99-year land lease | Conflicting; unverified | [37][67] |
Share or membership price rules | Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-20) | Not published | [9][48] |
Buyer approval and fee | Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-20); the statute caps any approval fee at $100 per applicant | Co-op rule unverified | [38] |
Governing law | Chapter 719 for cooperatives; Chapter 723 may bear on the park's history | Recording under Chapter 719 unverified | [39][45][47][44] |
Under section 719.106(1)(i), a cooperative may charge a fee to approve a sale or lease only if its documents require approval, and the fee is capped at $100 per applicant, with spouses counted as one applicant. The Port Carlos Cove approval process and fee were not found [38].
Section 719.106(1)(j) requires a detailed annual budget adopted at least 14 days before the fiscal year, with reserve accounts for capital expenditures and deferred maintenance. Reserve funds stay in reserves unless a majority of the voting interests approve another use [38][42].
Florida law lets a homeowners' association that buys its mobile home park record cooperative documents under Chapter 719, and section 723.071 covers the association's rights when a park is sold. Whether Port Carlos Cove was recorded that way is unverified [45][39].
Financing depends on what a buyer receives. A lender has to see the recorded cooperative documents, the ownership instrument and the flood zone before it can quote, and those are the items still unverified here, so line up your lender and the co-op paperwork at the same time [9][18][22].
Port Carlos Cove holds manufactured homes on cooperative lots, now joined by elevated site-built and modular homes; the county roll lists 156 lot parcels on seven streets, with a median lot of 0.079 acre, about 3,400 square feet, and heated areas of 552 to 1,828 square feet on lots with a building record [1][67].
Street | Lot parcels on the roll | Note | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
Blackbeard Way | 43 | Largest street; canal and bay lots | [1] |
Doubloon Way, including 48 Doubloon Way A | 43 | Several 2025 and 2026 new builds | [1] |
Cortez Way | 26 | [1] | |
Galleon Way, including 1 Galleon Way A | 18 | Oldest 1967 homes and the 2026 $440,000 sale | [1][2] |
Barbados Way | 14 | Lot 153 is a right-of-way parcel | [1] |
Garcia Way | 6 | [1] | |
Spanish Main | 6 | [1] |
Of the 66 lots with a year built, 11 date from 1966 to 1979 and average about 780 square feet, 1 from 1986, 48 from 2000 to 2021 at about 1,170 square feet, and 6 from 2023 to 2026. Where bedrooms are recorded, 56 homes have two, 3 have one and 3 have three [1].
1 Galleon Way A (2023, 1,008 square feet), 12 Galleon Way (2024, 920), 24 Doubloon Way (2025, 984), 61 Doubloon Way (2025, 1,008), 94 Blackbeard Way (2025, 1,200) and 26 Doubloon Way (2026, 994) [1].
149 lots are coded co-operative, 6 are coded vacant residential, and Lot 153 is a right of way owned by Port Carlos Cove Inc; 60 co-op lots carry a building value and 89 are valued as land only [1].
Living at Port Carlos Cove centres on the water and the co-op's shared grounds: a clubhouse, an unheated pool, shuffleboard, pickleball, a barbecue and picnic area, a community boat ramp with Gulf access, and boat, trailer and RV storage, all covered by the monthly fee per listings, with the Gulf beach about a mile away [3][62][64][67].
Sources conflict. A manufactured-home portal lists pets as disallowed, one listing excerpt says no dogs allowed, and the July 2026 listing for 3 Galleon Way shows pets allowed conditional. Treat dogs as likely restricted and get the written pet rule from the co-op before you write an offer (unverified) [62][67][64].
Yes. Listings cite a community boat ramp with Gulf access, boat and trailer storage and canal-front lots, fee launches run at island marinas such as Salty Sam's, and the county roll codes 102 parcels on a canal and 18 on the bay, with 90 boat-dock flags and 116 seawall flags, so many members keep a boat behind the home [64][67][1][16].
Water item | Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|
Canal lots | 102 parcels coded on a canal | [1] |
Bay lots | 18 parcels coded on the bay; 37 parcels carry no water code | [1] |
Docks and seawalls | 90 parcels flag a boat dock and 116 a seawall | [1] |
Seawall | A listing remark cites over a mile of seawall; seawall upkeep is said to be in the co-op fee | [67][64] |
Boat size | One lot listing cites dockage for a boat up to 26 feet (unverified) | [67] |
Ramp | Community boat ramp with Gulf access | [64][67] |
Recorded qualified home sales at Port Carlos Cove ran $175,000 to $440,000 from January 2025 to July 2026, with a median of $337,500 across six sales, and 16 vacant-lot sales ran $55,000 to $210,000, median $141,500. The top was 4 Galleon Way at $440,000 in June 2026 [2][1].
Data updated: November 2026. We tracked every qualified sale period below from the Lee County Property Appraiser's sale files, so a reader can see how prices moved before Ian, after Ian and since January 2025.
Period | Home sales | Median | Range | Vacant-lot sales | Lot median | Lot range | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
January 2019 to September 27, 2022, before Ian | 32 | $218,750 | $123,500 to $450,000 | Not split | [2] | ||
October 2022 to July 2026, after Ian | 12 | $307,500 | $125,000 to $440,000 | 25 | $150,000 | $55,000 to $225,000 | [2] |
January 2025 to July 2026 | 6 | $337,500 | $175,000 to $440,000 | 16 | $141,500 | $55,000 to $210,000 | [2] |
Recorded | Address (built, heated sq ft) | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
July 7, 2026 | 7 Galleon Way (2000, 1,361) | $285,000 | [2] |
June 24, 2026 | 4 Galleon Way (2002, 1,176) | $440,000 | [2] |
December 11, 2025 | 151 Barbados Way (2005, 1,319) | $345,000 | [2] |
April 2025 | 70 Cortez Way (2013, 1,029); sold for $450,000 in February 2022 | $400,000 | [2] |
March 27, 2025 | 3 Galleon Way (1967, 672) | $175,000 | [2] |
January 2025 | 2 Galleon Way (1967, 780) | $330,000 | [2] |
December 31, 2024 | 31 Doubloon Way (2014, 936) | $375,000 | [2] |
39 Doubloon Way and 84 Blackbeard Way sold for $210,000 each in January and February 2026; 142 Barbados Way and 140 Garcia Way for $75,000 each in February and March 2026; 49 Doubloon Way for $65,000 in March 2026; 150 Barbados Way for $60,000 on July 17, 2026; and 117 Blackbeard Way for $55,000 on July 22, 2026 [2].
3 Galleon Way, a 1967 manufactured home of 710 square feet with 2 bedrooms and 1.1 baths on a canal with Gulf access, was listed July 14, 2026 at $249,000 and was active on November 11, 2026. 4 Galleon Way was listed at $445,000 before its $440,000 sale, and 65 Cortez Way was listed at $375,000 and is off market. An aggregator showed 12 lots averaging $147,917, unverified [64][65][66][63].
The 2026 roll gives the 149 co-op lots just values of $80,000 to $300,158, median $108,015; land runs $80,000 to $100,000 a lot; lots with a building have a median of $206,266 and land-only lots $101,201. Just value is a tax figure, not a sale price [1].
Listings put the Port Carlos Cove co-op fee at about $200 a month, said to cover lawn care, water, sewer, trash and seawall maintenance plus the pool, clubhouse and shuffleboard, but the co-op's budget is not public, so the fee is unverified. Each lot is taxed as its own folio, and no community development district appears on the roll [64][67][1].
Charge | Amount | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
Monthly co-op fee | About $200 a month | Listing records, unverified | [64][67][63] |
Special assessments | None found in public sources; post-Ian seawall, clubhouse and pool work may have been funded by one | Unverified; ask the co-op | [67][42][43] |
Approval or transfer fee | Information not available at time of publishing (checked 2026-11-20); state cap $100 per applicant | Co-op rule not found | [38] |
Property tax, 3 Galleon Way | $2,034 a year | Listing record | [64] |
Average property tax | $1,713.78 | Aggregator, unverified | [63] |
CDD | None on the roll | County roll | [1] |
Ask for the cooperative documents, bylaws, budget, reserve schedule and two years of minutes, which Chapter 719 requires the association to keep. No public source found an assessment, but owners rebuilt the pool, clubhouse and grounds after Ian, so confirm how that work was paid for [42][41][37].
Port Carlos Cove's FEMA flood zone is not confirmed: the Lee County Property Appraiser pages read for the co-op showed no flood map data. With 120 canal or bay parcels on an island, a coastal high-hazard zone is likely but unverified, so check each lot on FEMA's Map Service Center before you buy [4][3][18][1].
Item | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
FEMA zone | Not confirmed; check lot by lot | [4][18][19] |
FIRM panel | Panel 12071C0554 is nearby; the panel for this site is unconfirmed | [17] |
Rebuild elevation | A listing remark says new homes must be raised roughly 10 feet (unverified) | [67] |
Evacuation zone | Reported as Lee County Zone A in Hurricane Milton coverage (unverified) | [29][12] |
Ian evacuation | Lee County's Ian order named the Town of Fort Myers Beach including San Carlos Island | [11] |
If you finance a home in a special flood hazard area, your lender will require it. Confirm the zone first, then get a quote that reflects your home's elevation [22][18].
Hurricane Ian hit Port Carlos Cove hard: the National Hurricane Center lists a USGS sensor on San Carlos Island at 12.06 feet of storm surge, owner reviews from 2023 describe devastation and a rebuild, and on the 2026 roll 89 of 149 co-op lots are valued as land only, with 25 qualified vacant-lot sales since October 2022 [24][37][1][2].
Ian made landfall on Cayo Costa at 1905 UTC with 130-knot winds on September 28, 2022. The report puts surge at greater than 9 feet above mean higher high water from San Carlos Island southward, maximum inundation of 10 to 15 feet above ground on Fort Myers Beach, about 900 structures destroyed and 2,200 damaged in Fort Myers Beach, and 5,369 structures destroyed in Lee County, where 36 of the 41 U.S. surge deaths occurred [24].
Fox Weather reported destroyed manufactured homes on the island, including the Nancy Lane park, and residents' fear of being priced out if Zone A stopped allowing manufactured homes. Photos showed shrimp boats grounded on a former island mobile home park [27][30].
Unverified. No news story names the park. The county data shows 89 land-only lots and 25 vacant-lot sales since the storm, which fits wide losses and a slow lot-by-lot rebuild, but whether every empty lot is an Ian loss rather than a long-vacant storage lot is unconfirmed [1][2].
Milton coverage reported unsecured debris worries on San Carlos Island. No damage report specific to Port Carlos Cove was found for Helene or Milton, and no named storm impact was found for 2025 or 2026; the National Weather Service summaries cover the coast [29][25][26].
Yes. Six homes built from 2023 to 2026 are on the county roll at 920 to 1,200 square feet, and listing remarks say elevated site-built, modular or manufactured homes are allowed under Lee County rules, raised to current FEMA standards. The zoning is MHPD, and the co-op's own building rules are unverified [1][67].
Lee County enforced FEMA's substantial-damage rule after Ian: if repairs cost 50 percent or more of the structure's market value, the building must meet current floodplain standards [28][21].
Both the county and the co-op. Lee County issues the permit under MHPD zoning and floodplain rules; the cooperative's documents may add architectural rules, which were not published [14][1][9].
Very likely not. Florida's milestone inspection and reserve study rules target buildings of three stories or more, and the homes and the one-story clubhouse here are low-rise; a Florida real estate attorney can say for certain [46][3].
Only on a limited basis, per listing remarks: one says rentals are limited to 30-day minimums, six times a year, and another says there are no yearly leases but members may rent monthly. The Town of Fort Myers Beach rental program does not govern this unincorporated park, so the co-op's own rule controls [67][1].
No. A listing notes that Town of Fort Myers Beach restrictions do not apply, because the park sits in unincorporated Lee County, zoning area ULC [67][1].
Lee County uses a school choice zone system, and the 2009 Fort Myers Beach plan placed the area in the South zone, sub-zone S-4, unverified today. Fort Myers Beach Elementary, grades K to 5, is the only public school on the islands, and the plan listed Cypress Lake Middle and Cypress Lake High in the South zone [55][56].
Main Street around Port Carlos Cove is changing: four new homes entered the 2025 and 2026 roll, a former storage site nearby sold for $18 million for a marina plan, a resort plan near Main and Oak Streets has approvals but delays, and Lee County is funding a San Carlos Island boat ramp and maritime park [1][31][34][35][36].
The 7.58-acre former Southern Comfort Storage site on Main Street sold for $18 million in July 2022 to Bay Harbour Marina Village LLC. Its approved plan includes 286 dry and 29 wet slips, while an administrative law judge rejected the residential part of the county plan amendment over coastal high-hazard and evacuation concerns, and the developer appealed [31][32].
Fox 4 reported a plan to convert 55 approved residential units into a 240-room resort with hundreds of boat slips and a rooftop lazy river; a later report said it had approvals but faced delays. Current status is unverified [33][34].
Buyers who look at Port Carlos Cove usually compare it with other San Carlos Boulevard parks such as Gulf Cove Trailer Park Co-op, with Gulf Waters RV Resort on the mainland, and with fee-simple San Carlos on the Gulf, and the honest differences are ownership form, water access, storm exposure, fees and price [67][69][70].
Community | Type | Honest difference | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
Port Carlos Cove | 155-site resident-owned cooperative, 1802 Main Street | Canal and bay lots, ramp and docks; about $200 a month (unverified); home sales $175,000 to $440,000 in 2025 and 2026 | [1][2][64] |
Gulf Cove Trailer Park Co-op | Resident-owned co-op, 19281 San Carlos Boulevard | Another co-op on the San Carlos Boulevard corridor; its boating features were not researched | [67] |
Gulf Waters RV Resort | 318 deeded RV lots on 33 acres, mainland, 11201 Summerlin Square Drive | RVPD zoning bars permanent residence; $1,220 per quarter; no boat storage; about 8 feet of Ian surge water per owners | [69] |
San Carlos on the Gulf | Recorded plat of about 78 acres on San Carlos Island | Fee-simple single-family homes and bayfront lots, no association found; asking prices about $348,000 to $7,895,000 | [70] |
Across the Matanzas Pass Bridge, inside the Town, our Sea Grape Bay Condo, Estero Island Yacht and Racquet Club, Captains Bay South, Bay Beach and Leilani guides cover condominiums and single-family streets on Estero Island, which run under different law and Town rental rules [1].
It is one of the few resident-owned parks with private canal docks and its own ramp a mile from the beach; the trade-offs are the reported Zone A evacuation status, 12 feet of Ian surge, a partly rebuilt park, and unsettled pet and rental rules [64][1][24][29][62].
McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and the lists below are our honest read of Port Carlos Cove from the county roll and sale files, the National Hurricane Center, Florida's cooperative law, news reports and dated public listing records, so buyers and sellers can weigh it before a showing.
Canal and bay lots with docks and seawalls, a community ramp with Gulf access and boat storage; a co-op fee reported at about $200 a month; the Gulf beach about a mile away; lot values that let owners build new elevated homes; no CDD; and a member-run association [1][64][67][2].
Severe storm exposure, with 12.06 feet of Ian surge recorded on the island and a reported Zone A evacuation status; 89 land-only lots in a partly rebuilt park; an unverified flood zone; conflicting pet rules; tight rental limits; and an ownership instrument that must be read in the recorded documents [24][29][1][62][67].
If you're searching for a Port Carlos Cove listing agent, or thinking, 'I need someone to sell my Port Carlos Cove home...' start with the record: a $440,000 sale in June 2026, a $285,000 sale in July 2026, a 2025 to 2026 home median of $337,500 and vacant lots from $55,000 to $210,000 [2].
We tracked the recorded sales by build period, heated area and water frontage in this guide, because a buyer compares your home with a short list of the right sales, so we price from the home's age, elevation, condition, dock and the co-op's paperwork, not from an automated estimate.
Honors and recognition:
Start with a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation. Jesse follows up with a written range built from your home's age, size, water frontage and the Port Carlos Cove sales that fit it.
(239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome. Our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers Beach walks through the sale step by step, and our Fort Myers Beach real estate hub covers the wider island market.
A Florida seller customarily pays the documentary stamp tax on the deed [50], plus the brokerage fee, any payoff, prorated taxes and any co-op transfer charge. In Lee County the seller customarily pays the owner's title policy, and the contract controls [51].
Port Carlos Cove sellers and buyers work directly with Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, who have sold Southwest Florida real estate for more than twenty years, lead Domain Realty Group, and read the Lee County roll and sale files, the storm and flood records, Florida's cooperative law and the public listing records behind this guide.
You can read how the team was built on our about the McGreevy and Comisar team page. McGreevy and Comisar are the Domain Realty team behind this Port Carlos Cove guide: Jesse McGreevy leads on listings and pricing, and Marc Comisar leads on buyer representation across Southwest Florida. If you are comparing agents, see the best real estate agents in Fort Myers Beach.
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.
McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Port Carlos Cove realtor on Google, and the quotes below are genuine five star client reviews reproduced in the reviewer’s own words. We publish no aggregate score and no Port Carlos Cove testimonial we do not have.
★★★★★ “Not living in the area, Jesse made life easy for me when we decided to sell our condo. His attention to detail, patience, understanding, and tenacity in dealing with all the moving parts was truly impressive.” Eric Acra, verified Google review
★★★★★ “Their recommendation on pricing my unit was sound and proved prescient. I never questioned their integrity and found it easy to rely on their recommendations. I would work with them again in a heartbeat.” Charlie Carroll, verified Google review
★★★★★ “Working with Jesse and his team was truly an amazing experience. From the very beginning, they were professional, attentive, and incredibly knowledgeable. They guided us through every step of the process with patience and clarity, always making sure we felt comfortable and informed with every decision.” Leonardo Silva, verified Google review
Selling your Port Carlos Cove home or lot? Get a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Buying at Port Carlos Cove? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida, or our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers Beach.
Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission, and licenses can be verified with the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation. Florida law requires a brokerage relationship disclosure (s. 475.278, Florida Statutes).
These are the Port Carlos Cove questions buyers ask most, each answered from the Lee County record, the National Hurricane Center, the school district, Florida's cooperative law and dated public listing records cited on this page. Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 to walk the streets, the ramp and the clubhouse with us.
At 1802 Main Street, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, at the east end of Main Street on San Carlos Island, in unincorporated Lee County [3][1].
155 home sites; the county lists 156 lot parcels plus one common-element parcel [62][1].
The county lists each lot as its own folio, owner reviews say you own the lot, and one listing mentions a 99-year land lease, so read the recorded documents (unverified) [1][37][67].
About $200 a month per listings, unverified; ask the co-op for the current budget [64][67].
Not published; if the documents require approval, Florida caps the fee at $100 per applicant [38].
Sources conflict between disallowed, no dogs and conditional; get the written rule [62][67][64].
Many lots have docks and seawalls, and there is a community ramp with Gulf access and boat storage [1][64].
Only on a limited basis per listing remarks, with 30-day minimums reported (unverified) [67].
Not confirmed; check each lot on FEMA's Map Service Center [18][4].
Yes, elevated site-built, modular or manufactured homes appear on the roll since 2023; confirm county and co-op rules [1][67].
No community development district appears on the roll [1].
These are the questions Port Carlos Cove owners ask us, answered from the county roll and sale files, dated listing records, Lee County rules and Florida law. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 for a number on your home or lot based on its age, size, water frontage and the recorded sales that fit it.
Start with a free Fort Myers Beach home valuation, then Jesse builds a range from the recorded Port Carlos Cove sales that fit your home [2].
4 Galleon Way at $440,000 on June 24, 2026 [2].
7 Galleon Way, built 2000, 1,361 square feet, at $285,000 on July 7, 2026 [2].
$337,500 across six qualified sales [2].
32 qualified sales from January 2019 to September 27, 2022, median $218,750 [2].
12 qualified sales, median $307,500, $125,000 to $440,000 [2].
$55,000 to $210,000 in 2025 and 2026, median $141,500 [2].
117 Blackbeard Way at $55,000 on July 22, 2026 [2].
39 Doubloon Way and 84 Blackbeard Way at $210,000 each in early 2026 [2].
Yes; 2 Galleon Way, built 1967, sold for $330,000 in January 2025 [2].
No; just value is a tax figure, $80,000 to $300,158 on the 2026 roll [1].
3 Galleon Way at $249,000, listed July 14, 2026 [64].
Buyers compare docked canal lots with each other; 90 parcels flag a dock [1].
Yes; only 18 parcels are coded on the bay, so the comparison set is small [1].
The buyer's tax bill resets with the sale; the exemption applies only to a permanent residence [52][53].
Yes; Florida's seller flood disclosure covers flood claims and federal assistance [49].
Yes; share what was repaired, the permits and any substantial-damage finding [28][14].
Some will; no park-specific damage report was found [29][26].
Yes; pull the zone for your lot from FEMA before listing [18].
Yes; have the documents, bylaws, rules and budget ready [41][9].
Only if the documents require approval; the co-op process was not found [38].
Up to $100 per applicant under section 719.106(1)(i) [38].
Yes; the published sources conflict, so give buyers the written rule [62][64].
Yes; listing remarks report 30-day minimums, six times a year (unverified) [67].
It depends on your plans; six new homes since 2023 show builds can proceed [1].
In Florida the seller customarily pays it on the deed [50].
The seller customarily, and the contract controls [51].
Portability can carry part of the Save Our Homes benefit to your next Florida home [53][52].
The Lee County Property Appraiser's property search lists each recorded sale [2][3].
That depends on your plans; we price from the latest Port Carlos Cove sales for your home type [2].
Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072. He will review your home and the co-op documents against the recorded Port Carlos Cove sales, then give you a written price range. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
Every fact in this Port Carlos Cove guide traces to a record below: the Lee County Property Appraiser and county GIS, Lee County government, FEMA, the National Hurricane Center, Florida statutes and agencies, the school district, news reports and dated public listing records. No listing portal or brokerage site is linked, and the numbers match the bracket citations on this page.
Port Carlos Cove's key public documents are published by Lee County, the National Hurricane Center, the Florida Legislature and the Florida Department of Revenue; the table links each to its issuer. The recorded cooperative documents come from the Lee County Clerk, and the budget, rules and minutes come from the co-op office.
Document | Issued by | Date | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
Resolution ZAB-86-15, Port Carlos Cove, Inc. | Lee County Board of County Commissioners | 1986 | |
Hurricane Ian evacuation order resolution | Lee County | 2022 | |
Evacuation Zone A map sheet | Lee County Emergency Management | Current | |
Hurricane Ian tropical cyclone report | National Hurricane Center | 2023 | |
Cooperative bylaws statute | Florida Legislature | 2025 | |
2026 taxing district millage book | Lee County Property Appraiser | 2026 | |
Homestead exemption guide | Florida Department of Revenue | Current |
Market data from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale files and dated public listing records, read November 2026. McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Port Carlos Cove. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.
Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.