Pirate's Cove II is a non-gated canal neighborhood of 104 parcels on the Imperial River in Bonita Springs, on Arroyal Rd, Buccaneer Dr, Gasparilla Dr, J C Ln and High Seas Ln, with no HOA and Gulf access by boat. Guide by McGreevy and Comisar.
Pirate's Cove II is a non-gated canal neighborhood of 104 parcels on the south bank of the Imperial River in the City of Bonita Springs, FL 34135, Lee County, with no HOA, Gulf access by boat and homes built from 1960 to 2024, part of our Bonita Springs coverage. Eleven qualified home sales recorded from January 2025 to September 2026 ran from $415,000 to $3,200,000. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 or the team at (239) 457-1610.
Updated November 2026 · Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty · McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group, 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 · (239) 898-6072 · (239) 457-1610.
McGreevy and Comisar are the best realtor for Pirate's Cove II because value on these canals turns on facts a portal never separates: river frontage or an interior canal, the age of the seawall and dock, whether the house sits above or below flood elevation, a 1960s ranch or a new elevated rebuild, and which of two legal names the parcel carries.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 parcel roll and recorded sales files, newest sale September 2026).
If you’re searching for the best realtor for Pirate's Cove II, whether you’re ready to sell your Pirate's Cove II home or buy your next one, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Nationally since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. Our comparison of the best real estate agents in Bonita Springs shows how local agents stack up on the public record.
Recent Pirate's Cove II track record (Lee County recorded qualified home sales, October 2025 to September 2026): 6 homes sold in the community · highest sale: $3,200,000 · median sale: $692,000 (our arithmetic: the mean of the middle pair, $685,000 and $699,000).
Every figure is a community total across all brokerages, counted from the county’s recorded qualified sales (newest recorded sale September 2026). It counts the 104 parcels of Pirates Cove II and Shannon’s Replat of Pirates Cove II only, not the older Pirates Cove streets next door. Over the 21 months from January 2025 to September 2026 the eleven qualified home sales ran from $415,000 to $3,200,000, and the March 2026 sale of a new river home on High Seas Ln at $3,200,000 is the highest recorded price in the neighborhood.
For Pirate's Cove II sellers: premium marketing, cinematic video, drone footage of the canals and the Imperial River, professional photography, a qualified-buyer database of Bonita Springs and Estero boaters, discretion and off-market capability when needed.
Honors and recognition:
Selling your Pirate's Cove II home? Get a free home valuation at mcgreevyandcomisar.com/home-valuation, read our guide to selling a home in Bonita Springs, or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 (confidential conversations welcome). Our guide to Bonita Springs home values explains how we price a home against its own street.
Buying a home in Pirate's Cove II? Call the team at (239) 457-1610 for a personalized buyer consultation, and see how we represent buyers. Our guide to buying a home in Bonita Springs covers inspections, flood insurance and seawall checks before an offer.
Pirate's Cove II is a small, non-gated canal neighborhood on the Imperial River with no HOA, no CDD, no golf and no shared amenities, where the draw is a private dock with Gulf access and the price runs from older interior-canal homes to new river rebuilds. These ten facts are the spine of the page, and each is expanded, dated and sourced below.
Data updated: November 2026.
Living in Pirate's Cove II means a mostly one-story canal home with a seawall and often a dock and a pool, on a quiet dead-end street off Pennsylvania Ave, about 7 minutes from downtown Bonita Springs and about 8 minutes from the Bonita Beach Park area on free-flow estimates, with no HOA, gate or clubhouse.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll; OSRM free-flow routing from Gasparilla Dr, November 11, 2026; public listing descriptions 2025 to 2026).
The neighborhood’s shared amenity is the water. There is no clubhouse, no community pool, no gate and no golf course. Each owner keeps up a private seawall and dock, and listing feature lists repeat boat facilities, Gulf access, a pier and water access. Most lots back onto one of the dead-end canals that run north to the Imperial River.
The 2026 county roll shows 49 of the 104 parcels with a Florida homestead exemption, and 82 of 104 owners with a Florida mailing address. The other owners mail tax bills to New Jersey, New York, Wisconsin, Illinois, Michigan, Connecticut, Colorado, Ohio, New Hampshire, Wyoming and Ontario, so roughly one owner in five is out of state.
Expect a mix on every block. A 1960s concrete ranch of 1,200 sq ft can sit beside a two-story elevated house built in the last decade, and a vacant lot can sit beside both. Seventeen lots were vacant on the 2026 roll, and new houses were under way on Arroyal Rd, Buccaneer Dr, Gasparilla Dr and High Seas Ln.
Downtown Bonita Springs, with Riverside Park, the Bonita Springs library branch, the food truck park, Shangri-La Springs and Wonder Gardens, is about 1.7 miles away. Coconut Point in Estero is about 5.9 miles and about 12 minutes on a free-flow estimate. Add time in season, January to April.
Pirate's Cove II is in the City of Bonita Springs, Lee County, ZIP 34135, on the south bank of the Imperial River east of the US 41 (Tamiami Trail) river bridge and west of downtown Bonita Springs. Pennsylvania Ave forms its southern edge, and the county roll places it between about 26.3381 N and 26.3412 N.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll; City of Bonita Springs).
The parcels lie between about 81.7994 W and 81.8030 W. The river-coded lots line the north edge of the neighborhood, where the canals meet the Imperial River. The neighborhood sits inside the City of Bonita Springs and the Bonita Springs Fire District, county taxing district code 017.
The older, unrecorded Pirates Cove on Jolly Roger Ln, Barbarosa St and Galleon Dr adjoins Pirate's Cove II and shares its canals and pirate street names. That older area was carved from Bonita Farms Lots 21 and 22, and our Bonita Farms guide covers the Bonita Farms canal streets around it. The exact line between the two areas should be read on the county parcel map for any one lot.
Street | Part of the neighborhood |
|---|---|
Arroyal Rd | Pirates Cove II Block A |
Buccaneer Dr | Pirates Cove II Block B |
Gasparilla Dr | Pirates Cove II Block C and Shannon’s Replat Block C |
J C Ln | Pirates Cove II Block D and Shannon’s Replat Block D |
High Seas Ln | Pirates Cove II Block E and Shannon’s Replat Block E |
Pennsylvania Ave (north side) | Edge parcels of Blocks A, B, C and D |
Mostly, yes. Pirate's Cove II and its Shannon’s Replat are the recorded core of the canal area most listing sites call Pirates Cove, on Arroyal, Buccaneer, Gasparilla, J C and High Seas. The older unrecorded Pirates Cove on Jolly Roger, Barbarosa and Galleon adjoins it, and the MLS uses both names loosely.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll and parcel display; MLS subdivision field as seen on public listings).
The September 2026 sale of a Gasparilla Dr home at $915,000 sits in Pirates Cove II Block C on the county roll but was marketed under “Pirates Cove.” A buyer’s agent who searches only one name misses comparable sales filed under the other. We price every Pirate's Cove II home against both.
There are 104 parcels in Pirate's Cove II on the Lee County Property Appraiser’s 2026 roll: 82 improved residential parcels (75 single-family homes and 7 small multi-family buildings of under 10 units), 17 vacant residential lots, and parcels where a new house was still under construction, on about 28.5 GIS acres.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll, STRAP prefixes 34-47-25-B1-0040 and 34-47-25-B1-0150).
Sub-area | Streets | Parcels | Mix on the 2026 roll |
|---|---|---|---|
Pirates Cove II Block A | Arroyal Rd, Pennsylvania Ave | 9 | 6 single-family (1 river), 3 vacant (2 zoned RM-2) |
Pirates Cove II Block B | Buccaneer Dr, Pennsylvania Ave | 21 | 15 single-family (1 river), 6 vacant |
Pirates Cove II Block C | Gasparilla Dr | 14 | 11 single-family (6 river), 1 small multi-family, 2 vacant |
Pirates Cove II Block D | J C Ln | 9 | 6 single-family (1 river), 3 vacant |
Pirates Cove II Block E | High Seas Ln | 2 | 2 single-family |
Shannon’s Replat Block C | Gasparilla Dr, Pennsylvania Ave | 24 | 20 single-family (3 river), 2 small multi-family, 2 vacant |
Shannon’s Replat Block D | J C Ln, Pennsylvania Ave | 15 | 9 single-family (1 river), 4 small multi-family, 2 vacant |
Shannon’s Replat Block E | High Seas Ln | 10 | 10 single-family (2 river) |
The county GIS acreage is about 13.8 acres for Pirates Cove II and 14.7 acres for Shannon’s Replat, about 28.5 acres together. Lots run from 0.14 to 0.56 acre, with a median of 0.26 acre; the typical lot is 80 by 115 ft, or 0.21 acre.
Ninety-four parcels are zoned RS-1, single-family. Ten parcels along Pennsylvania Ave and the southern end of Arroyal Rd are zoned RM-2, which is where the small multi-family buildings sit.
Fourteen parcels are coded river-front on the roll, most of them on Gasparilla Dr in Pirates Cove II Block C. These lots face the Imperial River itself rather than a dead-end canal.
Pirate's Cove II homes are mostly one-story canal houses of 1,000 to 2,200 sq ft built in the 1960s to the 1980s on 80 by 115 ft lots, mixed with newer elevated or two-story rebuilds of 2,000 to 4,300 sq ft. Living areas run from 960 to 4,800 sq ft on the 2026 roll, with a median of about 1,770 sq ft.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll, 82 improved parcels).
Measure | 2026 roll figure |
|---|---|
Stories | 63 one-story, 14 two-story, 5 split or 1.5 to 1.8 story |
Bedrooms | 20 two-bed, 45 three-bed, 12 four-bed, 5 with five or more (small multi-family) |
Living area | 960 to 4,800 sq ft; median about 1,770 sq ft |
Pools | 44 parcels flagged |
Boat docks | 56 parcels flagged |
Seawalls | 81 parcels flagged |
Garages | 60 parcels flagged |
A Gasparilla Dr home built in 1991 that sold in September 2026 shows the newer style: a two-story elevated house on stilts with 1,832 sq ft of living area, a 400 sq ft air-conditioned lower-level flex room, a 66-ft composite dock built in 2023, a lift, a private concrete ramp and a 2025 metal roof, per its public listing description.
Two homes on Gasparilla Dr and Buccaneer Dr carry a $10 building value on the 2026 roll. That usually means the county treats the house as adding no value to the land. Why is not public as of November 21, 2026; city permit records are the place to check.
Pirate's Cove II was laid out by about 1960. The oldest home on the roll was built in 1960 and the oldest qualified sale in the roll fields dates to 1969, a Gasparilla Dr lot. No developer or builder is named in any public source, and homes went up lot by lot over six decades.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll and parcel display).
The county legal descriptions refer to Official Records Book 137, Page 415 for Pirates Cove II and Official Records Book 674, Page 255 for Shannon’s Replat. They are “OR” references, not plat book pages. Whether OR 137/415 is a recorded plat or a deed-recorded map, its filing date, and the date of Shannon’s Replat are not public as of November 21, 2026 from the sources we read; the Lee County Clerk’s official records hold the documents.
The developer of Pirate's Cove II is not public as of November 21, 2026. The pirate street names (Buccaneer, Gasparilla, High Seas) carry on into the older Pirates Cove streets next door (Jolly Roger, Galleon, Barbarosa).
Era | What the roll shows |
|---|---|
1960 to 1979 | 30 homes, mostly one-story canal ranch houses |
1980 to 1999 | The median year built, 1984, falls here |
2000 to 2024 | 16 homes, including 2004 and 2007 river homes on Gasparilla Dr and Arroyal Rd, 2013 on Buccaneer Dr, 2015 to 2019 on J C Ln and 2024 on Buccaneer Dr |
2025 to 2026 | New houses started on Arroyal Rd (1,693 sq ft) and Buccaneer Dr (1,167 sq ft) in 2025, and on Gasparilla Dr (2,556 sq ft) and High Seas Ln (2,712 sq ft) in 2026 |
Pirate's Cove II prices split in two. Older homes on interior canals resold at $415,000 to $750,000 in 2025 and 2026, while rebuilt river homes reached $1,800,000 to $3,200,000. Eleven qualified home sales from January 2025 to September 2026 had a median of $749,000 by our arithmetic.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser Sale Data Files, 2026 file dated October 18, 2026; parcel display for Folio 10290908).
Recorded | Street (sub-area) | Type | Price | County code |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Feb 2025 | Gasparilla Dr (PC II, river, 2004, 2,727 sq ft) | Home | $1,800,000 | Qualified |
Feb 2025 | Gasparilla Dr (Shannon’s, 1988, 1,595 sq ft) | Home | $432,500 | Qualified in 2025 file, disqualified in 2026 file |
Mar 2025 | Gasparilla Dr (PC II, river, 1968, 1,384 sq ft) | Home | $749,000 | Qualified |
Apr 2025 | Arroyal Rd (PC II, river, 2007, 4,264 sq ft) | Home | $2,570,000 | Qualified |
Jul 2025 | Buccaneer Dr (PC II, 1963, 1,216 sq ft) | Home | $490,000 | Qualified |
Aug 2025 | J C Ln (PC II, 2015, 2,143 sq ft) | Home | $975,000 | Qualified |
Nov 2025 | Buccaneer Dr (PC II, 1972, 1,354 sq ft) | Home | $700,000 | Disqualified |
Nov 2025 | J C Ln (Shannon’s, 1981, 1,020 sq ft) | Home | $415,000 | Qualified |
Mar 2026 | High Seas Ln (Shannon’s, river, new build) | Home | $3,200,000 | Qualified |
Apr 2026 | Arroyal Rd (PC II) | Vacant lot | $400,000 | Qualified |
Apr 2026 | Gasparilla Dr (PC II, 1985, 1,838 sq ft) | Home | $699,000 | Qualified |
Apr 2026 | Gasparilla Dr (Shannon’s, 1972, 1,433 sq ft) | Home | $540,000 | Qualified |
May 2026 | Buccaneer Dr (PC II, 1985, 2,067 sq ft) | Home | $685,000 | Qualified |
Aug 2026 | Buccaneer Dr and Pennsylvania Ave (two RM-2 lots, one deed) | Vacant | $339,500 | Not yet reviewed |
Sep 2026 | Gasparilla Dr (PC II, 1991, 1,832 sq ft) | Home | $915,000 | Qualified per parcel page |
Sep 2026 | Gasparilla Dr (Shannon’s, 1988, 1,595 sq ft) | Home | $593,000 | Not yet reviewed |
We tracked every recorded deed in the county’s sale data files for the 104 parcels, street by street. Our arithmetic, from the county’s qualified home sales in the table: the eleven qualified home sales from January 2025 to September 2026 sort from $415,000 to $3,200,000, and the sixth, $749,000, is the median. The six qualified home sales from October 2025 to September 2026 have an even count, so the median is the mean of the middle pair, $685,000 and $699,000, which is $692,000. Disqualified and not-yet-reviewed sales and vacant lots are left out of both.
The split is water and age. Interior-canal homes from the 1960s to the 1980s sold at $415,000 to $750,000. River homes built in 2004 and 2007 sold at $1,800,000 and $2,570,000, and the new High Seas Ln river home recorded $3,200,000 in March 2026, the neighborhood’s highest recorded price.
Two vacant lot deeds recorded in 2026: an Arroyal Rd lot at $400,000 (qualified) and two RM-2 lots on Buccaneer Dr and Pennsylvania Ave on one deed at $339,500 (not yet reviewed by the county).
The parcel display for the September 2026 Gasparilla Dr sale shows earlier recorded sales of $525,000 in November 2003 and $515,000 in December 2016, before the $915,000 sale in 2026. Its 2026 roll value is $695,257.
The Lee County Property Appraiser’s 2026 roll values all 104 Pirate's Cove II parcels at about $56.8 million in total. Single-family parcels run from $198,655 to $1,289,185, with a median of $592,379, and vacant lots run from $113,535 to $543,521. Roll values are assessment figures, not sale prices.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 parcel roll, download dated November 1, 2026).
The roll lags the market and values land and building separately. The September 2026 Gasparilla Dr sale closed at $915,000 against a 2026 roll value of $695,257. Use recorded sales, not roll values, to price a home.
A homestead’s assessed value is capped from year to year under Florida law, and the cap resets at a sale. A buyer’s first full tax bill is set on the new assessed value, so the seller’s bill is not a guide.
No HOA, POA or civic association for Pirate's Cove II was found in public sources. Listings state “no HOA” and no rental restrictions, and one listing aggregator shows a $0 association fee. Lots do carry recorded deed restrictions, which a buyer reads in the title commitment before closing.
Data updated: November 2026 (public listing descriptions 2025 to 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll).
No association dues, no transfer or capital contribution fee, no estoppel letter from an association, and no association approval of a buyer or tenant. Each owner pays for the seawall, dock and lift on that lot alone.
The text of the deed restrictions is not public as of November 21, 2026 from the sources we read. Read them in the title commitment before you buy, especially for rentals, docks and additions.
A “Pirates Cove Beach Association” appears in a national nonprofit lookup but could not be tied to Bonita Springs. Any Florida corporate filing for a Pirate's Cove II association is not public as of November 21, 2026 from the sources we read.
Pirate's Cove II has no CDD line found on the county roll and no association fee. The parcels sit in the City of Bonita Springs and the Bonita Springs Fire District, county taxing district code 017, so the tax bill carries city, county, school and fire millage but no community development district.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll).
Fee | Pirate's Cove II | Source |
|---|---|---|
HOA or POA | None found | Listing descriptions; county roll |
CDD | None found | County roll |
Transfer or capital fee | None (no association) | Listing descriptions |
Taxing district | City of Bonita Springs, Bonita Springs Fire (code 017) | County roll |
Typical annual tax bill | Not public as of November 21, 2026 from a county source |
With no dues, the fixed costs of ownership here are the tax bill, insurance (wind and flood) and the upkeep of the seawall, dock and lift. A new seawall or dock is the owner’s cost alone, so its age belongs at the top of an inspection.
Pirate's Cove II has no association rules because there is no association. Listings advertise no rental restrictions, but recorded deed restrictions run with the lots and City of Bonita Springs rental permit rules apply to every rental. Read the deed restrictions in the title commitment before planning a rental, an addition or a new dock.
Data updated: November 2026 (public listing descriptions 2025 to 2026).
No age restriction was found in any record. A “55+” tag on one listing aggregator is a site label, not a community rule.
Dock length, lift size and seawall work are governed by permits rather than an association: the City’s dock and shoreline rules (Ordinance 23-11 and its dock and shoreline permit) and, for some small docks, the state permit exemptions in section 403.813, Florida Statutes. One listing describes a 66-ft composite dock built in 2023. Any city or state permit history for a lot is a records request.
Pirate's Cove II has no clubhouse, pool, gate or golf course; its amenity is private boating. Most lots front dead-end canals that run to the Imperial River, then west to Estero Bay and the Gulf. The MLS codes Gulf access as “bridge(s)/water indirect” because boats pass under the fixed US 41 bridge.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser roll flags; MLS fields as seen on public listings; Wikipedia, Imperial River).
From a Pirate's Cove II dock a boat runs down the canal to the Imperial River, west under the US 41 bridge, and on to Estero Bay at Fishtrap Bay. The bridge is fixed, so boat height matters. The bridge’s verified clearance and the river’s controlling depth are not public as of November 21, 2026 from a primary source we read; NOAA Chart 11426 and the Coast Pilot are where to check before buying for a specific boat.
Lee County’s Imperial River Boat Ramp sits on the east side of the US 41 bridge with a small fishing pier. Its hours and parking fee are not public as of November 21, 2026 from the county page, which refused our fetch; the county’s boat ramp page is listed in the sources.
Downtown’s Riverside Park has river access and a bandshell, about 1.7 miles away. An 18.3-acre park with about 2,000 ft of river frontage, a boardwalk, fishing pier and boat slips is reported under construction on the west side of the US 41 bridge; its opening date is not public as of November 21, 2026.
No golf, no tennis, no community pool and no gate. Nearby golf is private and not bundled; Highland Woods Golf and Country Club in Bonita Springs is the closest course named in our research.
At least part of Pirate's Cove II is in FEMA Zone AE, a high-risk Special Flood Hazard Area. One Block C parcel on Gasparilla Dr shows Zone AE at about 5 ft ground elevation on a listing data page using federal flood data. Flood zones vary lot by lot, so check each address on FEMA’s map.
Data updated: November 2026 (FEMA flood data as shown for one parcel; City of Bonita Springs Flood Protection Information; City of Bonita Springs FEMA CRS page).
The City of Bonita Springs says the blue areas on FEMA’s map are the 100-year zones AE and VE and unshaded areas are Zone X. The City’s current flood insurance rate maps took effect November 17, 2022. Some listings in the wider Pirates Cove area claim Zone X for elevated lots, which is why each lot must be checked on its own.
The City posts existing elevation certificates through its Community Development elevation certificate search, or by phone at (239) 444-6150. The Base Flood Elevation for each lot is not public as of November 21, 2026 from the sources we read; it is on the FEMA map and the certificate.
Bonita Springs residents with NFIP flood policies keep a 25% discount under the City’s Community Rating System Class 5 (notice of November 21, 2024). The City enforces its floodplain rules under Ordinance 22-05 and publishes a FEMA substantial damage and substantial improvement form. The threshold was not quoted on the pages we read for this neighborhood, so confirm it with the City before planning a large renovation.
The City says each foot above Base Flood Elevation can cut annual flood premiums by nearly 50%, and each foot below can double them. That is why the newest homes here are elevated.
No public report names storm damage in Pirate's Cove II itself. Low neighborhoods along the Imperial River stayed under water for days after Irma in 2017, the City warned that the river had risen after Ian in 2022, and the City urged river residents to watch water levels during Milton in 2024.
Data updated: November 2026 (City of Bonita Springs advisories, 2022 and 2024; WGCU; NPR via WOSU).
The Imperial River basin was added to Lee County’s mandatory evacuation for Irma, and the National Hurricane Center’s Irma report records the storm’s track across Southwest Florida. NPR reported low neighborhoods along the Imperial River stayed under water for days afterward.
On October 2, 2022 the City warned that the Imperial River had “slowly risen since Hurricane Ian” from sheet flow and told residents near rivers and canals to watch water levels. WGCU reported Ian’s surge on Bonita Beach Rd, Barefoot Beach and Bonita Shores, closer to the Gulf. The National Hurricane Center’s Ian report is the federal record of the storm, and the USGS keeps a stream gauge on the Imperial River near Bonita Springs (site 02291500).
The City’s Milton Advisory #9 of October 9, 2024 gave an Imperial River reading of 11.32 and urged river residents to monitor levels. Lee County ordered evacuation Zones A and B for Milton, and the City kept a Milton page and a post-storm permitting guide for owners repairing damage. The evacuation zone letter for these streets is not public as of November 21, 2026 from the sources we read; check the Lee County Know Your Zone lookup.
No named storm affecting Pirate's Cove II was found in public sources for 2025 or 2026.
Two homes valued at $10 for the building, four new houses under construction on the 2026 roll and the $3,200,000 new-build sale on High Seas Ln all point to an active teardown and rebuild cycle. No public record links any of them to storm damage.
Ask for the elevation certificate, the flood claims history, the dates of the roof, seawall and dock, and whether windows are impact rated. Recent listings here advertise 2025 metal roofs, impact glass and composite docks.
A Pirate's Cove II home in Zone AE with a federally backed mortgage generally must carry flood insurance, and the premium turns on the home’s elevation against Base Flood Elevation. Florida’s condominium milestone and SIRS laws do not apply, because every building here is a single-family to four-family dwelling under three stories.
Data updated: November 2026 (City of Bonita Springs; Florida DBPR, Condominiums: Milestone Inspections and SIRS).
The elevation certificate drives the flood quote. Get one early and get a flood quote before the inspection period ends. Premium figures for individual homes are not public as of November 21, 2026 from a primary source.
Roof age, roof shape and opening protection drive wind premiums in Florida, and the state’s My Safe Florida Home program (section 215.5586, Florida Statutes) offers inspections. Citizens Property Insurance is the state’s insurer of last resort. A newer metal roof and impact glass, both advertised on recent listings here, are the items an insurer asks about first.
Florida milestone inspections cover condominium and cooperative buildings of three or more habitable stories, and the SIRS requirement is for condominium associations. Pirate's Cove II has no condominiums.
The School District of Lee County assigns students by choice within proximity zones. Listing data places this area in Elementary Zone Q, Middle Zone G and High South Zone 3, and the district says to confirm every assignment by address on its enrollment zone map or by calling (239) 334-1102.
Data updated: November 2026 (School District of Lee County, School Zones and Transportation Optimization pages).
Private schools near downtown Bonita Springs were not part of our research for this page.
Pirate's Cove II is about 7 minutes from downtown Bonita Springs, about 8 minutes from the Bonita Beach Park area, about 9 minutes from I-75 Exit 116 and about 33 minutes from RSW airport on free-flow routing estimates from Gasparilla Dr, with no traffic. Add time in season, January to April.
Data updated: November 2026 (OSRM public routing engine, free-flow table from Gasparilla Dr, November 11, 2026).
Destination | Distance | Free-flow time |
|---|---|---|
Downtown Bonita Springs, Riverside Park (Old 41 Rd) | about 1.7 mi | about 7 min |
Bonita Beach Park area (Bonita Beach Rd at Hickory Blvd) | about 3.5 mi | about 8 min |
I-75 Exit 116 (Bonita Beach Rd) | about 4.4 mi | about 9 min |
Coconut Point (Estero) | about 5.9 mi | about 12 min |
NCH North Naples Hospital area (Health Park Blvd) | about 6.2 mi | about 12 min |
Downtown Naples (5th Ave S area) | about 14.1 mi | about 26 min |
Gulf Coast Town Center | about 17.0 mi | about 25 min |
RSW airport | about 22.8 mi | about 33 min |
Downtown Fort Myers | about 24.0 mi | about 41 min |
The Bonita Beach Park area, a Lee County park, is about 3.5 miles away, with Barefoot Beach beyond it. A sold listing described the beaches as “about 15 minutes” away, which is closer to a season drive than the free-flow estimate.
The NCH North Naples Hospital area on Health Park Blvd is about 6.2 miles and about 12 minutes on a free-flow estimate.
A Pirate's Cove II tax bill carries the millage of taxing district 017: the City of Bonita Springs, Lee County, the school district, the Bonita Springs Fire District and regional levies, and no CDD or association line. The amount turns on the assessed value and any homestead exemption, so two neighbors’ bills can differ widely.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll).
Forty-nine of the 104 parcels carry a homestead exemption. A homestead’s assessed value rises no more than the cap set in section 193.155, Florida Statutes, each year (non-homestead parcels have their own cap under section 193.1555), so a long-held homestead can carry a much lower bill than the same house after a sale.
Look up any parcel’s current bill with the Lee County Tax Collector and its values with the Property Appraiser. A typical Pirate's Cove II bill is not public as of November 21, 2026 from a county source.
Downtown Bonita Springs, about 1.7 miles away, has the Imperial 41 mixed-use project under way, with completion scheduled for 2027. Closer to home, an 8-acre infill site on Pennsylvania Ave was rezoned in April 2025 for 40 homes, and four new houses were under construction inside Pirate's Cove II on the 2026 roll.
Data updated: November 2026 (Barron Collier Companies, December 11, 2025; City of Bonita Springs; Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll).
Barron Collier Companies, CAPREIT and the City broke ground on December 10, 2025 on a two-building project spanning the Imperial River downtown: 120 apartments, 19,000 sq ft of commercial space, two public parks, public restrooms and parking, with completion scheduled for 2027 and leasing in late 2027.
An 8-acre site on Pennsylvania Ave was rezoned on April 2, 2025 for 40 homes, 14 single-family and 26 two-family attached. No construction start was found, and its status is not public as of November 21, 2026 from City council records we read.
The City’s Stormwater Master Plan Update lists Flood Area #12, Arroyal Mall (Crown Lake Blvd). A 2024 City notice covered a HUD CDBG-MIT flood project in the Quinn, Downs and Dean area on the river, 19.97 acres, 18.77 of them in Special Flood Hazard Areas.
Pirate's Cove II and the older Pirates Cove next door share the same canals, the same no-HOA model and the same pirate street names, but they differ in legal footing and scale. Pirate's Cove II is 104 parcels on recorded legal descriptions; Pirates Cove is about 9.3 acres of unrecorded Bonita Farms lots on Jolly Roger, Barbarosa and Galleon.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sales files; vault research on Bonita Farms and Pirates Cove).
Factor | Pirate's Cove II | Pirates Cove (older) |
|---|---|---|
Streets | Arroyal, Buccaneer, Gasparilla, J C, High Seas, Pennsylvania (north side) | Jolly Roger Ln, Barbarosa St, Galleon Dr |
Legal basis | OR 137 PG 415 and Shannon’s Replat, OR 674 PG 255 | Unrecorded, carved from Bonita Farms Lots 21 and 22 |
Size | 104 parcels, about 28.5 acres | About 9.3 acres |
HOA | None found | None found |
Water | Canals to the Imperial River; 14 river-coded parcels | Same canal system |
Highest recorded sale, 2025 to 2026 | $3,200,000 (March 2026) | $2,155,000 (October 2025) |
Flood zone | Zone AE on the one parcel checked | Some listings claim Zone X for elevated lots; check each lot |
You want a lot on a recorded legal description with a block and lot number, a choice of river or interior canal, and the widest range of homes, from a 1960s ranch to a new elevated river house.
You want the same canal life on the older streets next door and you are comfortable with title work on unrecorded, deed-described lots.
Pirate's Cove II is one of several no-HOA canal neighborhoods in Bonita Springs with Gulf access. It is upriver of the US 41 bridge, so boats clear the bridge on every trip, while Imperial Shores sits west of US 41. Pirate's Cove II also has the highest recorded 2025 to 2026 sale of the group we read.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser sales files; vault research; public listing descriptions).
Community | Similarity | Honest difference |
|---|---|---|
Pirate's Cove II | No HOA, canal lots, Gulf access | Upriver of the US 41 bridge; sales $415,000 to $3,200,000 |
Pirates Cove (Jolly Roger Ln, Barbarosa St, Galleon Dr) | Next door, same canals, no HOA | Unrecorded Bonita Farms lots; sales reached $2,155,000 in October 2025 |
Bonita Farms canal streets | Same river corridor, no HOA | Mixed lot shapes and unrecorded subdivisions |
No-HOA Gulf-access canal lots | West of US 41, so the route to the bay may skip the US 41 bridge | |
Estero Bay Shores | No HOA, city water and sewer | Closer to Estero Bay |
Older canal neighborhood | Near the beach; took Ian surge |
The communities differ in lot shape, bridge route and flood exposure more than in home style. Compare recorded sales street by street, river against river and interior canal against interior canal.
Pirate's Cove II matches a search for a no-HOA canal home with Gulf access in Bonita Springs, a private dock and seawall, a pool, a one-story ranch or an elevated rebuild, or a vacant canal lot to build on. It does not match a search for a gate, golf, a community pool or Zone X ground.
Data updated: November 2026 (our analysis of the county roll).
Pirate's Cove II offers a private dock with Gulf access, no HOA dues, no CDD and a short drive to downtown and the beach, at prices from about $415,000 for an older interior-canal home. Buyers trade off FEMA Zone AE on at least part of the neighborhood, a fixed bridge on the route to the bay, older homes and river flood history.
Data updated: November 2026.
Selling a Pirate's Cove II home well means pricing it against the right recorded sales, river against river and interior canal against interior canal, adjusted for elevation, seawall and dock age, roof and windows, and marketing it under both the Pirate's Cove II and the Pirates Cove names that buyers search.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County recorded sales, our analysis).
If you’re searching for the best Pirate's Cove II listing agent, or thinking, “I need to sell my house in Pirate's Cove II…”, you are choosing between a team that reads the market from a portal and a team that reads it from the record. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar price canal homes against the county’s recorded sales by water frontage, elevation and size, and line up the elevation certificate and seawall history before a buyer has to ask.
Start with a number from the record. Get a free home valuation for your Pirate's Cove II home, or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Buyers can call the team at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers.
In the 12 months from October 2025 to September 2026, six qualified home sales recorded from $415,000 to $3,200,000, with a $692,000 median by our arithmetic. Water frontage and the age of the house moved those prices more than anything else.
Both. The county uses Pirates Cove II and Shannon’s Replat, and many buyers search Pirates Cove; we use both names in every campaign.
The three highest recorded sales in 2025 and 2026, $1,800,000, $2,570,000 and $3,200,000, were all river homes, but each was also a newer, larger house. We price each home against its closest recorded matches.
The flood zone and elevation certificate, the flood claims history, the seawall and dock age, the roof year, impact windows and the bridge route to the Gulf.
Some older homes here sell for close to land value. Two homes carry a $10 building value on the roll, and a vacant Arroyal Rd lot recorded $400,000 in April 2026. We price both ways before you decide.
McGreevy and Comisar are the Southwest Florida team Pirate's Cove II owners call when a canal home has to be priced on the record and sold without surprises. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, lead the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and know Bonita Springs street by street.
Data updated: November 2026 (career totals as published by the team).
As the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate, and McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales. Read more about our team.
Meet Jesse McGreevy, who leads the team’s seller strategy, and Marc Comisar, who leads buyer representation and negotiation. Selling a Pirate's Cove II home? Get a free home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying in Pirate's Cove II? Call the team at (239) 457-1610, or read about buying a home in Bonita Springs. Nearby, see our Estero and Naples guides.
Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are top-reviewed Southwest Florida realtors, and the reviews on the team’s Google Business Profile describe what a Pirate's Cove II seller or buyer needs most: steady communication, local knowledge and a team that follows through.
Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC).
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.
These are the questions buyers ask most about Pirate's Cove II, answered from the county record and public agency pages. Each answer is short enough to quote and points to the section above with the detail.
Pirate's Cove II is a non-gated canal neighborhood of 104 parcels on the south bank of the Imperial River in Bonita Springs, FL 34135, with no HOA and homes built from 1960 to 2024.
Mostly. Pirate's Cove II and Shannon’s Replat are the recorded core of the canal area listing sites call Pirates Cove; the older unrecorded Pirates Cove on Jolly Roger, Barbarosa and Galleon adjoins it.
No HOA has been found. Listings say no HOA and no rental restrictions, but lots carry recorded deed restrictions that a buyer reads in the title commitment.
Yes. Most lots front canals that run to the Imperial River and then west to Estero Bay and the Gulf, passing under the fixed US 41 bridge.
Eleven qualified home sales from January 2025 to September 2026 ran from $415,000 to $3,200,000, with a $749,000 median by our arithmetic. Older interior-canal homes mostly sold for $415,000 to $750,000.
At least part of it is FEMA Zone AE. One Block C parcel shows Zone AE at about 5 ft ground elevation. Check each address on the FEMA map and ask the City for the elevation certificate.
No public report names this neighborhood. Low areas along the Imperial River flooded for days after Irma in 2017, and the City warned of rising river levels after Ian in 2022. Ask each seller for the claims history.
Homes were built from 1960 to 2024, with a median of 1984. Thirty date from before 1980 and sixteen from 2000 or later.
Living areas run from 960 to 4,800 sq ft, median about 1,770 sq ft. Typical lots are 80 by 115 ft (0.21 acre); the full range is 0.14 to 0.56 acre.
The 2026 roll flags 56 boat docks, 81 seawalls and 44 pools across the 104 parcels.
Listing data puts the area in Elementary Zone Q, Middle Zone G and High South Zone 3. The School District of Lee County says to confirm each address on its enrollment zone map.
No. No age restriction appears in any record found; a 55+ tag on one aggregator is a site label.
No. The neighborhood is non-gated and has no shared amenities.
No CDD line was found on the county roll. The tax district is 017, City of Bonita Springs and Bonita Springs Fire.
The 2026 roll shows 17 vacant lots and four new houses under construction. Zoning is RS-1 on most lots; the deed restrictions and the City’s flood rules set what can be built.
The Bonita Beach Park area is about 3.5 miles and about 8 minutes on a free-flow estimate.
Lee County’s Imperial River Boat Ramp is on the east side of the US 41 bridge, with a small fishing pier.
In Zone AE a federally backed mortgage generally requires flood insurance. The premium turns on the home’s elevation against Base Flood Elevation.
These are the questions Pirate's Cove II owners ask before they list, answered from the county record and our pricing work.
It depends first on the water (river or interior canal), then the age and elevation of the house, then the seawall, dock and roof. Get a free home valuation or call Jesse at (239) 898-6072.
Six qualified home sales recorded from October 2025 to September 2026, from $415,000 to $3,200,000.
A new river home on High Seas Ln recorded $3,200,000 in March 2026, the highest recorded price in the neighborhood.
A 1981 home of 1,020 sq ft on J C Ln recorded $415,000 in November 2025.
The two highest recorded prices for the neighborhood were set in 2025 and 2026, $2,570,000 and $3,200,000, both river homes. Interior-canal resales held at $415,000 to $750,000.
No. The September 2026 Gasparilla Dr sale closed at $915,000 against a 2026 roll value of $695,257. Recorded sales set the price.
Docks, lifts and seawalls are what buyers come here for. A 2023 composite dock and lift were featured in the September 2026 sale. We price the dock and seawall age into every comparison.
Elevation cuts the buyer’s flood premium, which buyers weigh in every offer. The City says each foot above Base Flood Elevation can cut annual flood premiums by nearly 50%.
Yes. Check whether the City already has one for your address, and have it ready for the first buyer who asks.
Yes. Roof age drives the buyer’s wind insurance quote. Recent listings here advertise 2025 metal roofs.
In a flood zone a large renovation can trigger the City’s floodplain rules. Talk to us before spending, because some buyers here are paying for the lot.
Yes. Two homes carry a $10 building value on the roll, and new houses are going up on lots that once held older homes.
No association estoppel is needed, because Pirate's Cove II has no HOA. The title company still searches the deed restrictions.
Buyer traffic in Bonita Springs peaks from January to April. Canal homes also show best on a clear day with the boat in the water.
Your homestead cap does not transfer to the buyer, so the buyer’s tax bill will be set on the new assessed value. We explain that to buyers up front.
Yes. We can market quietly to our qualified-buyer database of Bonita Springs and Estero boaters when discretion matters.
Drone footage of the canal and the river route, professional photography of the dock and water view, and both names, Pirate's Cove II and Pirates Cove, in every campaign.
Against recorded county sales on the same water type, adjusted for size, year built, elevation, seawall, dock and roof.
It can. Buyers with tall boats ask about the bridge first. We tell them up front so the buyers who come are the ones who fit.
In Lee County the seller customarily pays for the owner’s title policy, plus documentary stamp tax on the deed under section 201.02, Florida Statutes, and any commission agreed.
Yes. Lot buyers and rebuilders are often cash buyers. We compare a cash offer against the market before you accept.
Florida sellers must disclose known facts that materially affect value, and Florida’s flood disclosure law, section 689.302, Florida Statutes, sets a flood disclosure form for residential sales. Have your flood claims history and any permits ready.
Zone AE raises a buyer’s insurance cost. A good elevation certificate and an elevated house soften that.
A well-priced canal home with documents ready moves faster. Pricing against the right water type is the single biggest factor.
Yes. We plan the timing of both sides so you move once.
Get a seawall inspection first. Buyers and their lenders ask about it, and a known repair priced into the deal is easier than a surprise in the inspection period.
The title company finds the recorded deed restrictions and lists them in the buyer’s title commitment. Buyers planning a rental, a dock or an addition read them closely, so we pull them early.
Yes, subject to the lease. A buyer takes the property subject to an existing lease, so have the lease and deposit records ready.
Permits and final inspections for the roof, seawall, dock, lift, windows and any additions. Buyers in a flood zone ask whether past work was permitted.
Florida lets a homestead owner transfer some of the assessment savings to a new Florida homestead, under section 193.155. Ask the Property Appraiser before you sell.
We read Pirate's Cove II from the county record, price on recorded sales, and lead the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 or the team at (239) 457-1610.
These are the official records and lookup tools we used for this page, each linked at the office or organization that issues it.
# | Document | Issuer | What it shows |
|---|---|---|---|
1 | FEMA | Flood zone by address | |
2 | Lee County Property Appraiser | Pirates Cove II Block C record and sale history | |
3 | City of Bonita Springs | Flood maps and elevation certificates | |
4 | City of Bonita Springs | Class 5 rating and NFIP discount | |
5 | School District of Lee County | Address school assignment | |
6 | Florida DBPR | Condo rules that do not apply here | |
7 | Lee County Clerk | OR 137 PG 415, OR 674 PG 255 and deed restrictions | |
8 | City of Bonita Springs | Flood areas near the river |
Every source below was read or queried for this Pirate's Cove II page on November 11, 2026 unless another date is shown, or is the official lookup tool named in the text. County parcel, sales and value figures come from the Lee County Property Appraiser’s 2026 parcel roll (download dated November 1, 2026) and sale data files (2026 file dated October 18, 2026), read from a downloaded copy, with the newest recorded sale in September 2026. The single-parcel flood zone, home features and the no-HOA statements come from public listing descriptions and listing data pages, read November 11, 2026, and are not linked here. Drive times are free-flow estimates from a public routing engine. The sales medians are our own arithmetic from the record. The aerial image is USDA NAIP imagery from the USGS with Lee County parcel outlines. General references (Florida Statutes, City forms and pages, federal storm reports and school sites) were read for our Bonita Springs canal neighborhood guides in October 2026 and apply here as background.
Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.