Bay Haven is a 44-unit lakeside condominium of eleven two-story buildings inside gated Coco Bay in the Iona area of Fort Myers. County-recorded sales, fees, flood zone, the Ian record and selling advice.
By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.
Bay Haven is a 44-unit lakeside condominium of eleven two-story carriage-home buildings inside the gated Coco Bay community, reached through the Kelly Greens gates off Summerlin Road in the Iona area of south Fort Myers. The Lee County Property Appraiser roll counts 44 condominium units in Buildings AA to KK on Coco Hammock Way, every one a three-bedroom, two-bath plan with an attached garage: 22 ground-floor units of 1,510 square feet and 22 upper units of 1,911 square feet, built in 2004 and 2005.
McGreevy and Comisar are the team Bay Haven sellers call first: Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with over $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc, and the Domain Realty Group team is the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026). This guide walks through where Bay Haven sits in the Iona area, how it fits inside Coco Bay and beside Kelly Greens, how Centex Homes built and sold it in 2004 and 2005, its two floor plans and eleven buildings, the lakes and the Coco Bay clubhouse, daily life, recorded sales by floor, the two associations, costs and taxes, the flood map and the Hurricane Ian court record, the Florida condominium inspection rules, schools, what is nearby and how it compares with other Iona condominiums. Our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers explains how we work across the city, and you can read more about the team.
This page is about Bay Haven at Coco Bay, one condominium of 44 units in eleven buildings on Coco Hammock Way, Fort Myers, Florida 33908, in unincorporated Lee County rather than the City of Fort Myers. Every owner belongs to two associations: Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. for the condominium and Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. for all of Coco Bay. Bay Haven is not part of Kelly Greens Golf and Country Club, and there is no golf course or club membership tied to a Bay Haven unit; the Coco Bay association owns the Amenity Center clubhouse, its pool, the roads and two lakes.
Bay Haven is a gated Iona condominium of 44 units built in 2004 and 2005, and the right agent prices each condo on its floor, ground or upper, its building, its Zone AE flood facts and elevation certificate, the documents of both associations, the budgets, reserves and insurance, and the qualified sales Lee County has recorded inside Bay Haven.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, 2026 just values; Lee County recorded sales, qualified sales over $100,000, sale data through October 21, 2026; Lee County's republished effective FEMA flood layer; Lee County's evacuation map; the Coco Bay association's posted documents; our analysis).
If you're searching for the best realtor for Bay Haven in Fort Myers, whether you're ready to sell your condo in Bay Haven or buy your next one, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Nationally since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. Our Domain Realty Group team is also the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026).
Bay Haven market (Lee County recorded sales, qualified sales over $100,000, sale data through October 21, 2026): 4 qualified sales in 12 months, $325,000 to $347,000 · 7 in 24 months, $325,000 to $389,000 · 8 in 36 months, $325,000 to $430,000 · 9 in 60 months, $325,000 to $430,000 · no median printed, because no window reaches 10 sales · 44 condominium units on the county roll
We tracked every qualified sale Lee County has recorded on the 44 Bay Haven units since the 2004 and 2005 sellout, 96 qualified sales over $100,000 in the county index; we tracked the 7 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026 and matched each to its floor plan by living area on the roll; we read the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for all 44 units, including plan, year built and just value; we read the recorded 2004 Coco Bay and Kelly Greens access easement and the Coco Bay use restrictions; we read the federal appeals court opinion and the summary judgment record on Bay Haven's Hurricane Ian flood claims; and we read the FEMA flood zone, base flood elevation, FIRM panel and Lee County evacuation zone at the Bay Haven buildings on Lee County's map service.
Honors and recognition:
Selling your condo in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation at mcgreevyandcomisar.com/home-valuation, or read our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Buying a condo in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 for a personalized buyer consultation, and see how we represent buyers. Our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers walks through offers, inspections, insurance and closing costs. You can also contact us with any question about a Bay Haven building.
Bay Haven condos are priced from the papers a buyer's lender, insurer and appraiser will read: the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for plan, living area and year built, the building's elevation certificate, the flood zone, the master flood and wind insurance summaries, the budgets and reserves of both associations, and the unit's own permits and inspection reports.
The Lee County Property Appraiser roll gives every one of the 44 Bay Haven units a plan, a living area and a year built, 2004 for Building KK and 2005 for the other ten buildings. It does not tell a buyer the age of the air conditioner, whether the shutters work, when the water heater was replaced or what was rebuilt inside a ground-floor unit after Hurricane Ian, so we gather those answers from the seller's permits, invoices and inspection reports before a price is set.
The building papers matter as much as the unit papers. The association insured each of its eleven buildings under its own National Flood Insurance Program building policy, and a buyer's lender, insurer and appraiser all ask what the association carries now. We ask the Bay Haven association for the current master insurance summary, the budget and the reserve schedule, and the Coco Bay association for its budget, before a price goes on the market. Our Fort Myers home valuation page sets out the steps we follow, and we walk a seller through every one of these papers first.
Bay Haven has two plans on the county roll, a ground-floor unit of 1,510 square feet and an upper unit of 1,911 square feet, and in recent recorded sales the larger upper units have not sold for more than the ground units. That makes the floor the first question in any Bay Haven price.
In the 24 months to October 21, 2026, Lee County recorded 3 qualified sales of ground-floor units, from $325,000 to $389,000, and 4 of upper units, from $332,000 to $348,000. A buyer comparing the two plans weighs things the square footage does not show: the stairs to an upper unit, the flood exposure and the flood insurance questions on a ground unit, the view of the lake from each floor and the condition of the unit itself.
We never set an upper unit against a ground-unit sale, or the other way round, without saying so. We price a ground unit against the ground-unit sales and an upper unit against the upper-unit sales, read one by one, and then we explain to a seller why the two plans have traded in overlapping ranges even though the upper plan carries more living area on the roll.
Bay Haven recorded 7 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $389,000, and 4 in the 12 months, from $325,000 to $347,000 (Lee County recorded sales, qualified sales over $100,000). With fewer than 10 sales in any window, we list ranges and print no median.
These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county file used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
We tracked each of the 7 sales by its date, its plan and its floor, because a ground-floor sale and an upper-unit sale answer different questions. A median drawn from 7 sales would move a long way on one deed, which is why we leave it out. The county index shows no recorded Bay Haven sale between May 29 and October 21, 2026. We set a seller's condo against the sales that match its plan and condition, and we say plainly which ones are close and which are not.
Bay Haven owners pay into two associations, the Bay Haven condominium association for the buildings, insurance and condo budget, and the Coco Bay Community Association for the roads, lakes and clubhouse. A buyer prices both fees, both reserve plans and any assessment from either board into an offer.
Neither association publishes its budget openly; the Bay Haven pages on the association website sit behind an owner login. That means the fee picture a buyer sees in a listing can be incomplete or mixed, and the only reliable figures come from the associations themselves. We ask each association for its current budget and an estoppel certificate before we set a price, so a seller knows what a buyer will see.
The condominium association's papers carry extra weight at Bay Haven because of Hurricane Ian. The association's flood claims for its eleven buildings ended in federal court in 2026, and a buyer's first questions are what the reserves hold now, whether any repair cost was or will be assessed to owners, and what the current master flood and wind policies cover. A seller who has those answers in hand before listing saves the buyer's inspection period for the unit itself.
Bay Haven buyers search on facts, so we market each condo on them: the plan and floor, the building letter, the lake frontage, the attached garage, the flood zone and elevation certificate, Evacuation Zone A, both association layers and the Bay Haven name beside Coco Bay and Fort Myers 33908, so the right buyer finds the right condo.
Most buyers who reach a Bay Haven listing have filtered for a condominium in south Fort Myers or the Iona area, and their first questions are about insurance, the flood map, the fees and the stairs. We answer those up front with the papers: the building's elevation certificate, the master insurance summary, the budgets of both associations and the unit's own records.
We also make sure every listing names Bay Haven plainly and names Coco Bay too, because the two names travel together and a search for "Coco Bay" also returns a different community in Naples. A buyer who sees Bay Haven, Coco Bay and Fort Myers in the first line stays on the listing. We describe the unit, the building and the papers, never who a buyer should be.
Bay Haven is a 44-unit condominium of eleven two-story buildings inside the gated Coco Bay community in the Iona area of south Fort Myers, and these are the facts a buyer or seller checks first: location, identity, the two plans, recorded sales, the two associations, the flood and evacuation zones and the Hurricane Ian court record.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, 2026 just values; Lee County recorded sales, sale data through October 21, 2026; Lee County's republished effective FEMA flood layer; Lee County's evacuation map; the federal court record; the Coco Bay association's posted documents).
Bay Haven is the 44-unit condominium section of the gated Coco Bay community in the Iona area of south Fort Myers, on Coco Hammock Way. Owners and visitors reach it from Summerlin Road through the Kelly Greens gates, and its mailing address is Fort Myers, Florida 33908, although it sits outside the city limits.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, 2026 roll; the recorded 2004 Coco Bay and Kelly Greens access easement; Lee County's map service).
Bay Haven's recorded legal name is Bay Haven at Coco Bay, a condominium, and that is the name the Lee County Property Appraiser roll carries on all 44 units. Listings and most owners shorten it to Bay Haven, and the county record ties it to the Coco Bay plat.
The full name does real work in a transaction. The title commitment, the deed, the condominium declaration and the insurance declarations page all read Bay Haven at Coco Bay, and a buyer checks that every paper in the file uses the same name and the same building and unit. The association that runs the condominium carries the name as well, Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc.
A buyer who searches the county record by the short name alone can miss documents filed under the full name, and the reverse is also true for some listing records. When we open a Bay Haven file, we search the Lee County Property Appraiser record by the recorded name and the building address together, so every paper lines up before the inspection period starts.
Bay Haven owners and visitors reach Coco Bay from Summerlin Road through the Kelly Greens gates, then along the Kelly Greens roads, including Kelly Cove Drive, to the Coco Bay turn. A recorded 2004 easement gives Coco Bay owners a perpetual right to use those roads and gates to reach their homes.
Coco Bay has no entrance of its own from a public road; every trip in or out runs through Kelly Greens. That is why the easement matters to every Bay Haven owner. Under the easement, Kelly Greens maintains the roads and gates, and Coco Bay owners pay the same price Kelly Greens members pay for gate transponders. The recorded Coco Bay and Kelly Greens access easement is posted on the Coco Bay association's website.
For a first showing we give buyers the route through the gates rather than a map pin alone, and we tell them which building they are visiting, because the eleven buildings stand in one line along Coco Hammock Way and a building letter is faster than an address at the gate.
Bay Haven's eleven buildings stand in a north to south line along Coco Hammock Way, on the west shore of Coco Bay's main lake. Building AA, at 16227 Coco Hammock Way, sits at the north end and Building KK, at 16301, at the south end, close to the Coco Bay Amenity Center at 16315.
The line of buildings puts each one between the street on its west side and the lake on its east side. The ground under the buildings is part of one common-element parcel the condominium holds, and the Coco Bay association owns the lakes beyond it. A buyer reads the condominium declaration and its plat to see where the condominium land ends and the community land begins.
The rest of Coco Bay, the 99 single-family homes, wraps around the lakes on Coco Hammock Way, Sea Tropic Lane and Sand Ridge Court. A buyer visiting Bay Haven drives past some of those houses on the way in. They share the same gates, clubhouse and lakes, but they are not part of the condominium and they pay into the Coco Bay association only.
Bay Haven sits in unincorporated Lee County, not inside the City of Fort Myers, even though its mailing city is Fort Myers. The Iona area of south Fort Myers lies outside the city limits, so Lee County, not a city, sets the rules and services for every Bay Haven unit.
The difference shows up in the papers. Lee County issues the building permits, the Lee County Property Appraiser values each unit and the Lee County Tax Collector sends the bill; no city millage appears on a Bay Haven tax bill. A buyer's insurance quote, permit search and tax bill should all name Lee County. In an emergency, call 911.
A buyer who wants to check an address against city limits can enter it in the US Census Bureau's geocoder, which returns the place and county for an address. The Lee County Property Appraiser parcel record and the Lee County Tax Collector bill confirm the taxing districts for each unit.
Bay Haven condos are served by Lee County offices and county utilities: Lee County for permits, the Lee County Property Appraiser for the roll, the Lee County Tax Collector for the bill, Lee County Utilities for water and sewer, and Florida Power and Light for electricity. Lee County Emergency Management issues storm and evacuation orders.
Knowing which office holds which paper saves time during the inspection period. Permits for work inside a unit, or on a building, run through Lee County. The roll, the plan and the just value come from the Lee County Property Appraiser, and the bill and its non-ad valorem lines come from the Lee County Tax Collector. Water and sewer accounts run through Lee County Utilities, and the electric account through Florida Power and Light.
The associations hold the rest. The Bay Haven condominium association holds the building insurance, the condo budget and the reserves, and the Coco Bay association holds the community budget and the rules for the roads, lakes and clubhouse. We point buyers to the office that holds each answer, and we do not estimate tax bills.
Bay Haven condos use Fort Myers, Florida 33908 as their mailing address, and all 44 units sit in that ZIP on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll. Each building has its own address on Coco Hammock Way, from 16227 for Building AA to 16301 for Building KK, and each unit adds its own number.
ZIP 33908 covers a broad stretch of south Fort Myers, from the Iona area toward the Sanibel Causeway, with many condominiums and single-family communities of different ages. The ZIP alone does not narrow a search to Bay Haven. The condominium name does, and so do the Coco Bay name, the street and the building letter. A buyer setting up a saved search uses all of them.
When we market a Bay Haven condo, we check that the condominium name, the Coco Bay development name, the ZIP and the property type are all set correctly. A missing name means a buyer searching for Bay Haven never sees the condo, and a wrong property type puts a condominium in front of buyers filtering for single-family houses.
Bay Haven has no golf course, no club membership, no docks and no boating on the lakes. Coco Bay is not part of Kelly Greens Golf and Country Club, the Coco Bay rules bar watercraft, docks and swimming in the lakes, and the Coco Bay Amenity Center, not a golf club, is the shared clubhouse.
A buyer arriving through the Kelly Greens gates passes a golf course and can assume the course is part of the address. The recorded documents do not support that. The 2004 easement grants road and utility rights only, and Coco Bay homes are not among the club's deeded memberships; nothing in a Bay Haven deed or title commitment adds one. A buyer who wants golf asks the Kelly Greens club office directly.
What Bay Haven offers is the unit, its attached garage, the lake frontage of the buildings and the Coco Bay clubhouse and pool, with a condominium fee and a Coco Bay fee on every unit. The condominium declaration and the Coco Bay documents set out what each association owns and maintains, and a buyer reads both before an offer.
Bay Haven is the condominium section of Coco Bay, a gated Centex Homes community of 143 homes, 99 single-family homes plus the 44 Bay Haven units, on a 60.2-acre tract. It is not part of Kelly Greens Golf and Country Club and holds no golf membership.
Data updated: November 2026 (the recorded 2004 Coco Bay and Kelly Greens access easement; the Coco Bay association's posted documents and August 2025 FAQ; the Lee County Property Appraiser roll).
Bay Haven holds 44 of Coco Bay's 143 homes. The other 99 are single-family houses on the same roads, around the same lakes and behind the same gates. Bay Haven's condominium land sits on a replat of one tract of the Coco Bay plat, so the condominium is a piece of Coco Bay rather than a neighbor of it.
That layout explains why a Bay Haven owner belongs to two associations rather than one. The condominium association runs what belongs to the condominium, and the Coco Bay association runs what belongs to the whole community. A buyer reads both sets of documents, and both boards' decisions reach a Bay Haven unit.
The two parts of Coco Bay also differ in the papers a buyer reads. A single-family buyer in Coco Bay reads a deed, a survey and the Coco Bay documents. A Bay Haven buyer reads a condominium declaration as well, because a condominium unit is held under Florida's condominium act, with the building and its land held as common elements through the association.
Bay Haven owners belong to Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc., which runs the condominium, its buildings, insurance and condo budget, and to Coco Bay Community Association, Inc., which covers all 143 Coco Bay homes and owns the roads, the lakes, the Amenity Center clubhouse and even the Bay Haven common-element land parcel.
That last point surprises many buyers. On the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, the Coco Bay association holds the common-element land parcel under the Bay Haven buildings, while the condominium association runs the buildings themselves. A buyer reads the condominium declaration and the Coco Bay documents together to see which body maintains what, and asks both associations where the line falls for roofs, walls, grounds and drainage.
Each association has its own board of five resident directors, according to the Coco Bay association's August 2025 FAQ, and each sends its own fee, budget and estoppel certificate. Two layers mean two sets of documents, two fees and two estoppel certificates at closing. The Coco Bay association posts its governing documents page, and the Bay Haven pages on the same website sit behind an owner login.
Bay Haven is not part of Kelly Greens Golf and Country Club. Coco Bay is a separate community whose owners use the Kelly Greens roads and gates under a recorded 2004 access easement, and Coco Bay homes are not among the club's 939 deeded memberships, which no Bay Haven deed adds.
The easement was signed with the Kelly Greens Master Association, which took ownership of its roads to install gates. In exchange, it granted Coco Bay owners a perpetual right to use the Kelly Greens roads and gates to reach Coco Bay, shared with Kelly Greens' own owners, plus utility rights. Kelly Greens maintains the roads and gates, and Coco Bay owners pay the same price Kelly Greens members pay for gate transponders.
The easement grants road and utility rights only. Kelly Greens' 939 memberships are tied to homes under its own documents, and nothing in a Bay Haven deed or the recorded easement adds a membership to a Bay Haven unit. A buyer reads the deed, the title commitment and the condominium declaration, and treats golf as a separate question for the club.
Bay Haven buyers may see one listing site claim that Kelly Greens amenities come with Coco Bay ownership, though no Bay Haven deed says so. The recorded documents do not support it: the 2004 easement grants road and utility rights, not club rights, so ask the Kelly Greens club office what, if any, access it sells to Coco Bay owners.
A listing remark is not a recorded document. The papers that decide what a Bay Haven owner holds are the deed, the condominium declaration, the Coco Bay documents, the recorded easement and the title commitment, and none of the ones posted publicly adds a Kelly Greens membership. A buyer who wants golf, tennis or dining at Kelly Greens asks the club office in writing before an offer.
We treat the question the same way for a seller. We never describe a Bay Haven condo as a golf property or suggest that golf is bundled with it, and we tell a buyer plainly what the recorded documents say. If the club sells some form of access to Coco Bay owners, its own written terms, not a listing remark, set the price and the rules.
Bay Haven at Coco Bay in Fort Myers is not Coco Bay at Pelican Bay in Naples, a different community in Collier County. The two share part of a name and nothing else: different counties, different associations, different documents and different recorded sales.
The overlap catches buyers who search by "Coco Bay" alone, and it can catch an insurance quote or a records search that relies on a name without a county. A Bay Haven file names Lee County, Fort Myers 33908 and Coco Hammock Way on every paper, and a buyer checks that the title commitment, the insurance declarations page and the lender's flood determination all do too.
When we market a Bay Haven condo, the listing names Bay Haven, Coco Bay, Fort Myers and the street in the first line for the same reason. A buyer who arrives expecting a Naples community leaves quickly, and a buyer who wanted Bay Haven but searched the wrong county never finds it. Clear names fix both problems.
Bay Haven's papers name the condominium, its building and its unit, and all three must match across the deed, the title commitment, the condominium declaration and the insurance declarations page. A mismatch between the short name, the recorded name or the building letter slows a closing and can hold up a policy.
The county roll files Bay Haven under its recorded name, Bay Haven at Coco Bay, with each building declared as its own phase of one condominium. A title agent reads the declaration and every phase amendment that applies to the building in question, and a buyer's insurance agent rates the unit by its own building, floor and elevation certificate.
We read the county record for every unit we price, and we hand a buyer the recorded name, the building letter and the plan in one place. That small step saves days when the lender's flood determination, the insurance quote and the title commitment all arrive in the same week.
Bay Haven buyers confirm the condominium in three papers: the legal description on the deed, which names Bay Haven at Coco Bay and the building and unit; the title commitment, which lists the condominium declaration among its recorded documents; and the Lee County Property Appraiser record, which carries the recorded name on all 44 units.
The address alone is not proof. Coco Hammock Way also carries Coco Bay single-family houses, and some house addresses sit close in number to the Bay Haven building addresses. A Bay Haven unit carries a building address from 16227 to 16301 plus a unit number, and the legal description names the condominium.
A buyer also confirms the second layer. A Bay Haven unit belongs to the Coco Bay association as well, and the estoppel certificate from each association settles what is owed on the unit at closing. We gather both early, because each association needs time to prepare its certificate.
Bay Haven was built by Centex Homes in 2004 and 2005 as the condominium section of Coco Bay. Each of its eleven buildings was declared as its own phase of one condominium in 2005, and builder closings ran from December 23, 2004 to July 2005, when the last of the 44 units first sold.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and recorded sale files; the recorded 2004 Coco Bay and Kelly Greens access easement; the Coco Bay plat as carried on the county roll).
Bay Haven's land is part of a 60.2-acre tract known as Coco Bay, which Centex Homes co-owned when the 2004 access easement with Kelly Greens was signed. The Lee County Property Appraiser roll shows the land changing hands for $1,800,000 in December 2003 and again for $1,800,000 in May 2004.
The May 2004 deed is the one carried on every Bay Haven unit's record, the last land transfer before the condominium was declared. The easement, recorded the same month, set the terms that still govern how every Coco Bay owner reaches home: a perpetual right to use the Kelly Greens roads and gates, with Kelly Greens maintaining them.
For a buyer today, the land history is background, but the documents from that year are not. The recorded easement and the Coco Bay plat appear among the recorded documents in a Bay Haven title commitment, and a buyer reads both to see what the condominium land is, what it touches and which body maintains each piece.
Bay Haven sits on the replat of Tract MF-1 of Coco Bay, recorded at Plat Book 78, Pages 44 to 48, and the condominium's common-element parcel covers about 3.55 acres on the county's parcel map. The rest of the Coco Bay plat holds the single-family lots, the roads, the lakes and the clubhouse tract.
The recorded legal name on that land is Bay Haven at Coco Bay, a condominium, and the replat set the condominium land apart from the single-family lots around it. Tract A of the same plat holds the Coco Bay Amenity Center, and the lakes sit on their own tracts owned by the Coco Bay association.
A buyer reads the plat with the condominium declaration. The plat shows where the condominium land sits against the lake tracts and the roads, and the declaration shows what the condominium holds as common elements and what each unit owner holds. Where a question touches drainage or the lake bank, the plat and the Coco Bay documents tell a buyer which association to ask.
Bay Haven was declared as one condominium in eleven phases, one phase per building, all in 2005. The first county renumber date is February 17, 2005, for Building KK, and the last is September 9, 2005, for Building DD. Each phase added one building of four units to the condominium.
The phases followed the order the buildings were finished: KK first, then II, JJ, FF, GG, HH, EE, BB, AA, CC and DD. That is why the county roll shows Building KK built in 2004 and the other ten in 2005. Each phase was recorded as an amendment that brought one building, and its share of the common elements, into the condominium.
For a buyer, the phase structure is a title question. A title agent reads the original declaration and the amendment that added the building in question, and a buyer can ask to see both. The building letter on the deed ties the unit to its phase, so a buyer checks that the letter on the deed matches the building on the ground.
Bay Haven sold out between its first builder closing in December 2004 and July 2005. Lee County recorded 4 qualified sales in 2004, from $227,900 to $293,300, and 48 in 2005, from $229,700 to $379,000; the 2005 figures include some quick resales. Builder closings ran from December 23, 2004 to July 2005.
The 2004 sales were the first closings in Building KK, the first building finished. The 2005 count runs higher than the 40 remaining units because some buyers resold within the same year, and those resales sit inside the same county figures. The county records the sale price on each deed, so a builder closing and a quick resale look alike in the file.
For a seller today, the sellout prices are history rather than a guide. They show what the two plans sold for new, with original finishes and systems, at a time when insurance and flood rules were different. We read them for context and set a current price against recent recorded sales on the same plan.
Bay Haven resales have moved with the wider market. Lee County recorded 3 qualified sales in 2011, from $140,000 to $242,500, and 2 in 2012, from $177,500 to $186,100. By 2019 the 4 qualified sales ran from $250,000 to $292,500, and in 2021 the 7 sales ran from $265,000 to $455,000.
Since 2004, the county index holds 96 qualified Bay Haven sales over $100,000, across the sellout and every resale after it. Most years after the sellout hold only a handful of qualified sales, so a single deed can move a year's range a long way. That is why we read Bay Haven sales one by one, by plan and floor, rather than as a yearly average.
The years from 2023 on are the ones a buyer and seller read most closely today. We tracked each of them by plan and date, and the recent ranges, by plan and by window, sit in the market figures for Bay Haven: 7 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $389,000.
Bay Haven's two associations are run by owners today. The Coco Bay association's August 2025 FAQ lists a Coco Bay board of five resident directors and a separate Bay Haven board of five resident directors. The date Centex Homes turned control over to owners is not published.
Owner control means owner boards set the budgets, choose the insurance, schedule the reserves and adopt the rules. The Coco Bay board meets at the Amenity Center on the third Wednesday of each month, according to the August 2025 FAQ. A buyer asks each association for its recent minutes, because the minutes show what work is planned and what each board has decided about fees and insurance.
The Bay Haven board's decisions after Hurricane Ian matter most to a buyer now. A buyer asks the Bay Haven association whether any Ian repair cost beyond the flood payments was or will be assessed to owners, what the reserves hold today, and for the current master flood and wind policies. Both associations prepare their own estoppel certificates at closing.
Bay Haven has 44 condominium units on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll in eleven two-story buildings of four units each: two ground-floor units and two upper units per building. Every unit is a three-bedroom, two-bath plan with an attached garage, 1,510 square feet on the ground floor and 1,911 upstairs.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, 2026 just values; Lee County's republished effective FEMA flood layer; listings in 2025 and 2026).
Bay Haven buildings repeat one layout: two ground-floor units and two upper units, four in all, in a two-story carriage-home building with attached garages. Every one of the eleven buildings, AA to KK, holds its four units this way, which gives the condominium 22 ground-floor units and 22 upper units.
The unit numbers follow the floors. In every building, the ground-floor units are numbered 101 and 102, and the upper units 201 and 202, so the number alone tells a buyer which floor a unit is on. A buyer reads the building letter and the unit number together on the deed and the condominium declaration.
The position of a unit shapes what a buyer looks at. A ground-floor unit meets the ground, which puts its floor elevation against the flood map at the top of the list. An upper unit sits under the roof and is reached by stairs, which puts the stairs, the roof and any water intrusion at the top of its list. Each floor has its own file of papers, and we read the right file for the unit in front of the buyer.
Bay Haven's buildings date from 2004 and 2005 on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll: 2004 for Building KK, the first building finished, with its 4 units, and 2005 for the other ten buildings, with 40 units. The roll gives the year of the building, not the age of anything replaced inside it since.
A building of that age has likely seen at least one round of roof, paint and paving work at the association level, and at least one air conditioner and water heater replacement inside most units. After Hurricane Ian, many units also had flood repairs. The county roll does not show any of that, so a buyer asks for the papers.
At the building level, the association's records answer the questions: roof permits, painting and repair contracts, and the reserve schedule. At the unit level, the seller's permits, invoices and an inspection report answer them. We gather both before a price is set, because a buyer's insurer will ask the same questions during the inspection period.
Bay Haven just values on the 2026 Lee County Property Appraiser roll run from $243,126 to $268,885 for ground-floor units and from $271,160 to $285,056 for upper units. Each is an assessment figure, not a sale price, and nobody should read it as what a unit will sell for.
Plan (2026 roll) | Units | Just value range |
|---|---|---|
Ground floor, 1,510 square feet | 22 | $243,126 to $268,885 |
Upper unit, 1,911 square feet | 22 | $271,160 to $285,056 |
Just value is not market value. The just value is the county's mass-appraisal estimate for tax purposes, set as of January 1. It does not see the finish inside a unit, a replaced air conditioner or new flooring, and the taxable value on a bill can differ again, because homestead exemptions and the Save Our Homes limit apply to homesteaded units and the assessed value resets on purchase. We do not estimate tax bills.
We look at the just value for one reason: it shows how the county sees a unit beside the others on the same roll. The roll values upper units higher than ground units, while recent recorded sales have not. The price itself comes from the qualified sales Lee County has recorded inside Bay Haven, read one by one by plan, and from the seller's documents on what has been replaced.
Bay Haven buyers find the plan, the living area, the bedrooms and baths, the year built and the sale history on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, but not the facts that drive much of a price: what the owner has replaced inside, the shutters, the condition of the systems, the floor elevation or what was repaired after Hurricane Ian.
Those come from the seller's records and the inspection: the air conditioner's install date, the water heater's age, the flooring, kitchen and bath work and any permits for it, the shutters and the electrical panel. The roll also does not show the unit's elevation against the flood map, which is a building question answered by the elevation certificate, or the associations' finances, which are answered by the budgets and reserve schedule.
The roll is still the right starting point. It gives every one of the 44 units a living area that matches one of the two plans, and it lets a buyer check that a listing's size and bedroom count agree with the county. Where a listing gives a different size, we show the county figure and the source of the listing figure side by side.
Bay Haven listings describe two-car attached garages, screened lanais on the lake, electric hurricane shutters and in-unit laundry. These are listing descriptions, not a promise for every unit, so a buyer confirms each feature in the unit itself, in the seller's disclosures and in the inspection report.
The county roll confirms an attached garage on the Bay Haven plans, but it does not record how many cars a garage holds, whether a lanai is screened or whether a unit's shutters are electric. A buyer looks at each feature during the showing and asks the seller for the papers behind it: the shutter invoice and any permit, the screen enclosure's repair history, the washer and dryer's age.
Shutters raise a second question. The Coco Bay use restrictions require galvanized shutter panels to be painted, and roll-down or accordion shutters need approval under board standards. A buyer of a unit with upgraded shutters asks for the approval as well as the permit. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven buyers looking at a unit from 2004 or 2005 ask for papers on two levels: for the unit, the air conditioner and water heater ages, any permits for inside work, the shutter records and an inspection report; for the building, the elevation certificate, the master insurance summary, both budgets, the reserve schedule and each association's estoppel certificate.
The unit papers answer what the owner controls. A condo of this age has likely seen at least one air conditioner and water heater replacement, and the invoices and permits carry weight with an insurer and an inspector. A ground-floor buyer also asks what flood repairs were done after Hurricane Ian, by whom, and under which permits.
The building papers answer what the associations control. The master insurance summary shows what the condominium association insures, which sets what the owner's HO-6 policy must cover. The budgets and reserve schedule show how each association plans for roofs, paint, paving and the clubhouse. The estoppel certificates show what is owed on the unit at closing, under s. 718.116 for the condominium.
Bay Haven owners hold a condominium unit and an undivided share of the condominium's common elements, under Florida's condominium act and the Bay Haven declaration. Which parts of the building, the garage and the lanai belong to the unit, and which are common or limited common elements, is set by the declaration, so a buyer reads it.
Florida's condominium law, s. 718.103 and s. 718.104, divides a condominium into units, which owners hold, and common elements, which all owners share through the association. The declaration draws the line: where the unit ends, which parts of the building belong to the common elements, and whether any part, such as a garage or a lanai, is a limited common element tied to one unit.
Bay Haven adds one more layer. The Coco Bay association holds the common-element land parcel under the buildings on the county roll, so a buyer asks both associations who maintains the ground, the drainage and the lake bank beside a building. The condominium declaration, the Coco Bay documents and the two estoppel certificates settle those answers.
Bay Haven's buildings map to FEMA Zone AE on Lee County's republished effective flood layer, with a base flood elevation of 10 to 11 feet NAVD88 across the buildings, on FIRM panel 12071C0414G, effective November 17, 2022. Lenders require flood insurance on mortgaged units in Zone AE.
The ground at the buildings is about 8 feet, per public elevation data shown with a 2026 listing, so the finished floor of each ground-floor unit against the base flood elevation is the question an insurer asks first. The building's elevation certificate answers it. New Lee County flood maps are scheduled to take effect March 2, 2027, so a buyer checks the new map for the building too.
A buyer reads three papers together: the lender's flood determination, the building's elevation certificate and the master flood insurance summary. Those decide what the owner's flood policy must cover and how a quote is priced. The FEMA Flood Map Service Center shows the effective map for any address, and we treat every Bay Haven building as inside the mapped Zone AE floodplain.
Bay Haven sellers in Fort Myers are pricing one of 44 lakeside condominium residences with attached garages, built 2004 and 2005. We price each condo on its plan and floor, its building and elevation certificate, both associations' budgets, reserves and insurance, and the qualified sales Lee County has recorded inside Bay Haven.
Selling your condo in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Buying a condo in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers.
Bay Haven has two plans on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, both three bedrooms and two baths with an attached garage: a ground-floor unit of 1,510 square feet, 22 of them, and an upper unit of 1,911 square feet, 22 of them. This page uses the county living-area figures.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll; Lee County recorded sales, qualified sales over $100,000, sale data through October 21, 2026; listings in 2025 and 2026).
Plan (county roll) | Living area | Bedrooms and baths | Units | Qualified sales, 24 months | Range, 24 months |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ground floor | 1,510 square feet | 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, attached garage | 22 | 3 | $325,000 to $389,000 |
Upper unit | 1,911 square feet | 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, attached garage | 22 | 4 | $332,000 to $348,000 |
Bay Haven's ground-floor plan is a three-bedroom, two-bath unit of 1,510 square feet of living area on the county roll, with an attached garage, two per building and 22 in all. It is the one-level plan, entered at ground level, with no stairs inside the unit.
Some listings describe the ground plan as two bedrooms plus a den rather than three bedrooms. The county roll counts three bedrooms, and the way an owner has finished or furnished the third room can change what a listing calls it. A buyer reads the floor plan in the unit itself and confirms the room count with the seller and the appraisal.
The ground floor is also the floor that meets the flood map. The finished floor of a ground-floor unit against the base flood elevation of 10 to 11 feet NAVD88 drives the flood insurance question, and a federal appeals court opinion states that Bay Haven's buildings were flooded in Hurricane Ian. A ground-floor buyer asks what was repaired after Ian, under which permits, and for the building's elevation certificate.
Bay Haven's upper plan is a three-bedroom, two-bath unit of 1,911 square feet of living area on the county roll, with an attached garage, two per building and 22 in all. It is the larger plan, reached by stairs, and it sits directly under the building's roof.
The upper plan's extra area on the roll is the first thing a buyer notices, and its recorded sales are the second. In the 24 months to October 21, 2026, Lee County recorded 4 qualified upper-unit sales, from $332,000 to $348,000, against 3 ground-floor sales from $325,000 to $389,000. The larger plan has not sold for more in that window.
An upper-unit buyer reads a different file of papers from a ground-floor buyer. The roof and its age come first, then any history of water intrusion from the roof or the lanai, then the stairs and their condition. The association's roof permits and the reserve schedule answer the roof questions, and the seller's records answer the rest.
Bay Haven listings have quoted 1,523 square feet for a ground-floor unit and 1,791 for an upper unit, while the county roll carries 1,510 and 1,911. We price on the county living-area figures, and a buyer confirms each unit's measured size before relying on any figure.
Sizes differ because they are measured differently. The county counts living area by its own method for every unit on the roll, and a listing figure may come from a builder plan, an appraisal or an owner's measurement, each with its own rules about walls, stairs and lanais. Neither figure is wrong for its purpose, but they answer different questions.
The difference matters most in price per square foot, which can swing a long way on an upper unit depending on whether a buyer uses 1,791 or 1,911. We price on the county figure, say so, and set the listing figure beside it when a buyer asks. A buyer who needs an exact size orders a measured floor plan or reads the appraisal.
Bay Haven ground-floor and upper units differ in four ways a buyer weighs: the stairs to an upper unit, the flood exposure and flood insurance questions on a ground unit, the view of the lake from each floor, and the condition of the unit. Recorded sales do not say which of those moves a price.
In the 24 months to October 21, 2026, the larger upper units have not sold for more than the ground units. We do not claim a cause. A buyer who needs one-level living weighs the ground floor's flood file against the upper floor's stairs, and a buyer who wants more space weighs the upper plan's area against its roof and stair questions.
Each floor also brings different insurance questions. A ground-floor unit's flood policy is rated on the building's elevation certificate, while an upper unit's wind and water intrusion questions sit closer to the roof. The master flood and wind summaries from the Bay Haven association, and the owner's HO-6 quote, show how each floor's coverage fits together.
Bay Haven sales are matched to their plan by the living area the Lee County Property Appraiser roll carries for each unit: 1,510 square feet for a ground-floor unit and 1,911 for an upper unit. We tracked every qualified sale in the 24 months to October 21, 2026 this way, 3 ground and 4 upper.
The roll's living area is the cleanest match, because every one of the 44 units carries one of the two figures, and the floor follows from it. Over 60 months, Lee County recorded 5 qualified ground-floor sales, from $325,000 to $430,000, and 4 upper-unit sales, from $332,000 to $348,000. Over the same 60 months, all 9 sales ran from $325,000 to $430,000.
Matching by plan keeps a price honest. A ground-floor sale and an upper-unit sale sit in different files of papers and answer different buyer questions, so setting one against the other without saying so misleads a seller. We show a seller every sale on the same plan, by date, and we say which were close in condition and which were not.
Bay Haven buyers comparing two units on the same plan compare the papers, not the plan: the condition inside, the air conditioner and water heater ages, the shutters, the flood repairs after Ian, the building's elevation certificate and the position of the building on the lake. Two units of the same size can differ a great deal.
Start with what the seller has replaced and when. A unit with a recent air conditioner, new flooring and permitted flood repairs is a different purchase from a unit with original systems, even inside the same building. The inspection report and the seller's invoices show the difference, and the appraisal will read it too.
Then read the building. Each of the eleven buildings has its own elevation certificate and its own flood policy history, and its own place on the lake, from AA at the north end to KK at the south end near the clubhouse. A buyer asks the Bay Haven association whether either building has open repairs, and reads the minutes for any work planned on it.
Bay Haven's eleven buildings hold four condominium units each on Coco Hammock Way, on the west shore of Coco Bay's main lake. The Coco Bay association owns that lake and a second one, about 13.27 and 2.43 acres, and the Amenity Center clubhouse with its pool at 16315 Coco Hammock Way.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll; the Coco Bay use restrictions and August 2025 FAQ; listings in 2025 and 2026).
Bay Haven's eleven buildings carry addresses on Coco Hammock Way from 16227 for Building AA at the north end to 16301 for Building KK at the south end. Each building holds four units, and the county roll dates Building KK from 2004 and the other ten from 2005.
Building | Address on Coco Hammock Way | Year built (county roll) | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
AA | 16227 | 2005 | 4 |
BB | 16229 | 2005 | 4 |
CC | 16237 | 2005 | 4 |
DD | 16245 | 2005 | 4 |
EE | 16253 | 2005 | 4 |
FF | 16261 | 2005 | 4 |
GG | 16269 | 2005 | 4 |
HH | 16277 | 2005 | 4 |
II | 16285 | 2005 | 4 |
JJ | 16293 | 2005 | 4 |
KK | 16301 | 2004 | 4 |
A building address plus a unit number makes a full Bay Haven address, and the building letter appears in the legal description on the deed. A buyer reads the letter and the address together, because the letter ties the unit to its phase of the condominium and the address ties it to the street.
Bay Haven's common-element parcel covers about 3.55 acres on the county's parcel map, on the replat of Tract MF-1 of Coco Bay. It holds the land under and around the eleven buildings, between Coco Hammock Way and the main lake, and the Coco Bay association holds that parcel on the county roll.
That ownership is unusual and worth reading closely. The condominium association runs the buildings and insures them, while the Coco Bay association holds the land parcel. A buyer reads the condominium declaration for what the condominium holds as common elements and the Coco Bay documents for what the community association owns and maintains.
The practical questions are maintenance and cost. A buyer asks both associations who maintains the lawns, walks, drainage and parking beside each building, and which budget pays for it. The answers sit in the two budgets and the two sets of documents, and the estoppel certificates confirm what is owed to each.
Bay Haven owners share the Coco Bay Amenity Center, a clubhouse on Tract A at 16315 Coco Hammock Way, built in 2005, with 2,421 square feet heated and 3,225 square feet in total on the county roll, and a pool. Listings describe a spa, library, fitness room and social room.
The Coco Bay association owns and runs the Amenity Center for all 143 Coco Bay homes, and every Bay Haven owner pays toward it through the Coco Bay fee. There is no separate club membership. The Coco Bay board meets at the Amenity Center on the third Wednesday of each month, according to the August 2025 FAQ.
A buyer reads the Coco Bay rules for the clubhouse and pool hours, guest limits and any booking rules, and asks the association for them if they are not posted. The Coco Bay association adopted revised rules in March 2026, and the Coco Bay association's website carries its notices. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven's buildings face Coco Bay's main lake of about 13.27 acres, which a pipe joins to a second lake of about 2.43 acres. The Coco Bay use restrictions bar watercraft, docks and swimming in the lakes, so the lakes are views and water management, not water for boating.
The Coco Bay use restrictions, Exhibit C, set out the lake rules with the rest of the community's restrictions. A buyer who pictures a boat or a dock behind a building should know before making an offer that the rules do not allow either. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
The lakes also carry a storm history. After Hurricane Ian, surge put salt water in both lakes, ending lake-fed irrigation, and Coco Bay moved its irrigation to a freshwater well, according to its August 2025 FAQ. A buyer asks the Coco Bay association about the lake banks, the irrigation system and any planned work in its budget.
Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. runs the eleven buildings, their insurance and the condo budget, while Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. runs the roads, the lakes, the Amenity Center and the common-element land parcel. The two sets of documents draw the line between them.
The line matters for every repair. A roof, a stairway or an exterior wall on a Bay Haven building is a condominium question, answered by the Bay Haven declaration, budget and reserves. A road, a lake bank or the clubhouse pool is a Coco Bay question, answered by the Coco Bay documents and budget. A buyer asks both associations where any item in between falls.
Florida's condominium act sets duties for the condominium side: s. 718.111 for the association's powers, insurance and records, s. 718.113 for maintenance and changes to common elements, and s. 718.115 for common expenses. A buyer reads those beside the Bay Haven declaration.
Bay Haven buyers can open three Coco Bay documents on the association's website without a login: the recorded 2004 access easement with Kelly Greens, the Coco Bay use restrictions and the August 2025 FAQ. Together they explain the gates, the lake and leasing rules, the boards and the post-Ian irrigation change.
The August 2025 Coco Bay FAQ is the plainest of the three. It lists the boards, the meeting schedule and the irrigation history after Ian, when the controller work came to about $12,000 and a full new system quoted at about $448,000 was not chosen. A buyer reads it for how the community association works day to day.
The Bay Haven condominium documents, the declaration, bylaws, budget, reserve schedule and insurance summary, are not posted publicly; the Bay Haven pages sit behind an owner login. A buyer asks the Bay Haven association for each one, and a seller gathers them before listing, under the disclosure duties in s. 718.503.
Selling your condo in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation at mcgreevyandcomisar.com/home-valuation, and read our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Buying a condo in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers, or read our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers.
Bay Haven daily life runs through the Kelly Greens gates off Summerlin Road, along Coco Hammock Way to eleven two-story buildings on the west shore of the main lake, with the Coco Bay Amenity Center, its pool and two association lakes shared by all 143 Coco Bay homes, and public bay and Gulf beaches nearby.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll; the Coco Bay/Kelly Greens access easement agreement, recorded 2004; the Coco Bay Use Restrictions, Exhibit C; the Coco Bay Community Association FAQ, August 2025; listing descriptions, 2025 to 2026).
Bay Haven's eleven buildings stand in a north-south line on the west shore of the main Coco Bay lake, each holding four condominium units, two on the ground floor and two upstairs. The Lee County Property Appraiser roll lists every one of the 44 units as a condominium unit with 3 bedrooms, 2 baths and an attached garage, and every unit carries a Fort Myers mailing address in ZIP 33908. The buildings sit in unincorporated Lee County, so county services, not City of Fort Myers services, reach them.
Daily life is shaped by two sets of documents. Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. runs the buildings, their insurance and the condominium budget. Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. owns and runs the roads, the lakes and the Amenity Center clubhouse for all 143 Coco Bay homes, the 99 single-family homes and the 44 Bay Haven units. A third party matters at the front gate: the Kelly Greens Master Association owns the roads that lead to Coco Bay and keeps the gates, under a recorded 2004 easement.
There is no golf, club membership or marina attached to a Bay Haven unit under the recorded documents. The Kelly Greens course is next door, but the 2004 easement grants road and utility rights only, and Coco Bay homes are not among Kelly Greens' 939 deeded memberships. A buyer who wants to know whether the club sells any access to Coco Bay owners asks the Kelly Greens club office directly. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven owners share the Coco Bay Amenity Center on Tract A at 16315 Coco Hammock Way, built in 2005, which the Lee County Property Appraiser roll records at 2,421 square feet heated and 3,225 square feet in total, with a pool. Listings describe a spa, library, fitness room and social room; the community association decides what it holds today.
The Amenity Center belongs to Coco Bay Community Association, Inc., not to the Bay Haven condominium, so its hours, guest rules and any room bookings come from the community association's rules and board. The Coco Bay Community Association website posts notices for owners, and its August 2025 FAQ says the Coco Bay board meets at the Amenity Center on the third Wednesday of each month, so the clubhouse is also the room where community decisions are made.
A listing describes a clubhouse on the day the listing was written. A fitness room can be re-equipped, a library turned into a meeting room, a spa closed for repair. A buyer walks the building during a showing, reads the posted rules for the pool and spa, and checks the community association budget to see which rooms and services it pays to run. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven's buildings face the larger of two Coco Bay association lakes, about 13.27 acres, joined by a pipe to a second lake of about 2.43 acres. The Coco Bay Use Restrictions bar watercraft, docks and swimming in the lakes, so the water is a view and a drainage system, not a place to launch.
The Coco Bay Use Restrictions, Exhibit C set the lake rules for every Coco Bay home, including the 44 Bay Haven units. No boat, kayak or paddleboard goes on the water, no owner builds a dock, and no one swims. Because the lakes belong to the community association, their banks, fountains and water quality are community association matters, paid for through the community fee.
The lakes also carry a storm history. The August 2025 FAQ reports that Hurricane Ian's surge put salt water in both lakes and ended lake-fed irrigation, and that irrigation moved to a freshwater well. A buyer who wants to know how the lakes are managed now reads the community association's minutes and budget lines for lake and irrigation work. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven owners reach home through the Kelly Greens gates off Summerlin Road and along Kelly Greens roads, including Kelly Cove Drive, under a recorded 2004 easement that gives Coco Bay owners a perpetual shared right to use those roads and gates. Kelly Greens keeps the roads and gates, and Coco Bay owners pay Kelly Greens' price for transponders.
The Coco Bay/Kelly Greens access easement agreement, recorded in May 2004, explains the arrangement. The Kelly Greens Master Association took ownership of its roads so it could install gates, and in exchange it granted Coco Bay a perpetual road and utility easement. Coco Bay owners pay the same price Kelly Greens members pay for gate transponders. The easement grants road and utility rights only; it does not grant club, golf or amenity rights at Kelly Greens.
For daily routines, that means every trip in and out passes through gates that another association runs. A new owner asks how transponders are ordered and paid for, how guests and contractors are let in, and whether delivery drivers need a gate code. The gate rules belong to Kelly Greens, so a buyer reads them alongside the Coco Bay and Bay Haven rules rather than assuming one set covers all three.
Bay Haven units each carry an attached garage on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, and listings describe two-car attached garages, but a buyer confirms the garage for the unit being bought. The Coco Bay Use Restrictions bar trailers, boats, trucks and campers unless they are kept in the garage, so the garage shapes what an owner can park.
A garage attached to a condominium unit can be part of the unit or a limited common element, and the condominium declaration names which. That answer decides who maintains the garage door and opener, who insures the contents and whether the garage passes with the unit at closing. The declaration and its exhibits name the arrangement, and the estoppel certificate and the seller's closing documents confirm it for the unit being sold.
The vehicle rule is the one most buyers notice first. A work truck, a boat on a trailer or a camper fits the rules only inside the garage. Guest parking, overnight parking and parking for a tenant are also common subjects of condominium and community rules, and Bay Haven's condominium documents may add rules to the Coco Bay restrictions. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven sits near San Carlos Bay, Bunche Beach Preserve, the nearest Gulf beach access, with the Sanibel Causeway toll plaza at Punta Rassa and Fort Myers Beach also nearby. HealthPark Medical Center is close by, and everyday errands run along Summerlin Road and McGregor Boulevard. None of these places belongs to either association.
Lee County's land stewardship plan for San Carlos Bay, Bunche Beach Preserve explains how the county manages the preserve's mangroves, tidal flats and public access. Access can change for county work: WGCU reported a temporary beach access closure at San Carlos Bay, Bunche Beach Preserve in spring 2026, so a reader planning a visit checks county notices first.
For larger errands, Bell Tower Shops lies to the north, Gulf Coast Town Center and Coconut Point in Estero lie further out, and Southwest Florida International Airport sits east of Interstate 75. Season traffic on San Carlos Boulevard adds time toward Fort Myers Beach, and Summerlin Road traffic grows from January to April, so a buyer drives the routes at the hours that matter before deciding how a week would run.
Bay Haven recorded 4 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $347,000, and 7 in the 24 months, from $325,000 to $389,000, according to Lee County recorded sales over $100,000 and the Lee County Property Appraiser roll. No window reaches 10 sales, so no median is printed.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County recorded sales, qualified sales over $100,000, sale data through October 21, 2026; the Lee County Property Appraiser roll).
We tracked every qualified sale Lee County has recorded on the 44 Bay Haven units since the 2004 and 2005 sellout, 96 qualified sales over $100,000, and we tracked the 7 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026 and matched each to its floor plan by living area on the roll. We read the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for all 44 units, including plan, year built and just value. A median prints only for a window with 10 or more qualified sales, and no Bay Haven window reaches that count.
Qualified sales over $100,000 recorded by Lee County, window end October 21, 2026; median only at 10 or more sales:
Window (to October 21, 2026) | Qualified sales | Range | Median |
|---|---|---|---|
12 months | 4 | $325,000 to $347,000 | not printed (under 10 sales) |
24 months | 7 | $325,000 to $389,000 | not printed (under 10 sales) |
36 months | 8 | $325,000 to $430,000 | not printed (under 10 sales) |
60 months | 9 | $325,000 to $430,000 | not printed (under 10 sales) |
The county index shows no recorded Bay Haven sale between May 29 and October 21, 2026.
These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county file used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
To see condos listed in Fort Myers right now, Domain Realty Group keeps Fort Myers homes and condos on the market.
Selling your condo in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Buying a condo in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we work with buyers.
Bay Haven sale windows of 12, 24, 36 and 60 months, all ending October 21, 2026, hold 4, 7, 8 and 9 qualified sales in Lee County recorded sales over $100,000. With fewer than 10 sales in every window, a median would describe too few deeds, so each window is read as a count and a range.
A small condominium produces a short sale list. Bay Haven has 44 units, and in a typical recent year only a handful change hands. In a list that short, one unusual sale, a unit with new finishes or one that needed work, can move a median by tens of thousands of dollars without saying anything about the other units. A range keeps both ends in view and lets a reader see how far apart the recorded prices sit.
The windows also overlap. The 36-month and 60-month windows add only one and two sales to the 24-month list, so they reach back to a 2024 sale at $430,000 and a 2023 sale at $340,000 rather than describing a different market. A buyer or seller reads the 24-month list sale by sale, then turns to the unit's own floor, condition and documents.
Bay Haven recorded 7 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $389,000, according to Lee County recorded sales over $100,000. Three were ground-floor units of 1,510 square feet and four were upper units of 1,911 square feet, matched by living area on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll.
Date recorded | Floor | Living area (county roll) | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
December 17, 2024 | upper | 1,911 sq ft | $348,000 |
February 28, 2025 | ground | 1,510 sq ft | $389,000 |
October 1, 2025 | upper | 1,911 sq ft | $340,000 |
December 26, 2025 | ground | 1,510 sq ft | $325,000 |
January 16, 2026 | ground | 1,510 sq ft | $330,000 |
February 13, 2026 | upper | 1,911 sq ft | $332,000 |
May 29, 2026 | upper | 1,911 sq ft | $347,000 |
Every unit in the list has 3 bedrooms and 2 baths with an attached garage on the roll, so the plan and the floor are the main differences the county file shows. What the file does not show is the interior: the flooring, kitchen and baths, the age of the air conditioning and water heater, and whether the unit was repaired after Hurricane Ian with new finishes or older ones.
Four of the seven sales recorded from December 2025 to May 2026, from $325,000 to $347,000. The highest sale in the list, $389,000 in February 2025, was a ground-floor unit. A seller pricing a unit today reads the list for the sales that match the unit's floor and condition, rather than treating the newest sale as the price for every unit.
Bay Haven recorded from 1 to 7 qualified sales a year from 2016 through October 21, 2026, according to Lee County recorded sales over $100,000. The yearly ranges moved from $245,000 to $257,500 in 2016 to $330,000 to $347,000 in 2026 so far, with the widest spread in 2021.
Year | Qualified sales | Low to high |
|---|---|---|
2016 | 2 | $245,000 to $257,500 |
2017 | 2 | $258,000 to $268,000 |
2018 | 3 | $240,000 to $285,000 |
2019 | 4 | $250,000 to $292,500 |
2020 | 3 | $269,000 to $282,600 |
2021 | 7 | $265,000 to $455,000 |
2023 | 1 | $340,000 |
2024 | 2 | $348,000 to $430,000 |
2025 | 3 | $325,000 to $389,000 |
2026 (to October 21) | 3 | $330,000 to $347,000 |
The year with the most sales in this stretch, 2021, also had the widest range, from $265,000 to $455,000. Yearly counts this small describe which units happened to sell, not the price of the building or the condominium as a whole. A year with two sales can show a narrow range simply because the two units were alike.
Before 2016, the record holds lower prices: 3 sales in 2011 from $140,000 to $242,500 and 2 sales in 2012 from $177,500 to $186,100. A reader uses the yearly table to see the long arc of recorded prices, and then sets it aside in favour of the sales closest in time and floor to the unit being priced.
Bay Haven's sale record begins with the Centex Homes sellout: Lee County recorded 4 qualified sales in 2004, from $227,900 to $293,300, and 48 in 2005, from $229,700 to $379,000, with builder closings running from December 23, 2004 to July 2005. The 2005 figures include some quick resales.
Builder closings began on December 23, 2004 in Building KK, the one building the Lee County Property Appraiser roll dates to 2004; the other ten buildings date from 2005. Each building was declared as its own phase of one condominium, so closings followed the buildings as they were finished and declared. The 2005 count includes some quick resales, which is why the two sellout years together hold more sales than there are units.
Since the sellout, Lee County has recorded 96 qualified sales over $100,000 on the 44 units. That record is the base we read before pricing any Bay Haven unit. The sellout prices describe new construction in 2004 and 2005 and carry no direct weight on a price today, but they show where the condominium started.
Bay Haven has no qualified sale in the Lee County index between May 29 and October 21, 2026, the latest recorded sale in the county file. In a 44-unit condominium a few months without a sale can happen for many reasons, and the county index does not say which applies.
Several ordinary causes can leave a short gap in a small condominium's record. Few owners may have listed. Units may be under contract without having closed. A sale may have closed but not yet been flagged as qualified, because the county flags sales a few weeks after they record. None of these can be read from the county file.
What a buyer or seller can do is ask the current question directly: how many Bay Haven units are listed now, how many are under contract, and at what asking prices. The MLS answers those questions, and it was not pulled for this edition, so we give the recorded record and leave current listing activity to a live search.
Bay Haven figures come from Lee County recorded sales and the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, which show closed, qualified sales and the roll's unit data. Asking prices, rents and days on market come from the MLS and rental sites, which were not used for this edition, so none of those figures is printed.
An asking price is a seller's opening position, not a recorded price, and a listing can change price several times before it sells or expires. A rent is set between two parties on terms the county never sees. Days on market depend on how a listing service counts relists and contract fall-throughs. Each is useful for a live decision, and each is best read from a current search rather than from a page updated once.
A buyer who wants active listings, recent asking prices or rental history asks us to run a current search. A seller who wants to know how long similar units have taken to sell asks for the same, with each sale's listing history read alongside its recorded deed.
Bay Haven's larger upper units have not sold for more than its ground units in recent Lee County recorded sales: in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, 4 upper units sold for $332,000 to $348,000 and 3 ground units for $325,000 to $389,000, matched by living area on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County recorded sales, qualified sales over $100,000, sale data through October 21, 2026; the Lee County Property Appraiser roll).
Bay Haven has two plans on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, both 3 bedrooms and 2 baths with an attached garage: a ground-floor plan of 1,510 square feet of living area (22 units) and an upper plan of 1,911 square feet (22 units). Every building holds two of each. That makes Bay Haven a clean place to compare floors, because the building, the lake and the documents are shared and the plan and floor are what differ.
Qualified sales over $100,000 recorded by Lee County, by plan on the roll; median only at 10 or more sales:
Plan (county living area) | Units on the roll | 24 months to October 21, 2026 | 60 months to October 21, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
Ground floor, 1,510 sq ft | 22 | 3 sales, $325,000 to $389,000 | 5 sales, $325,000 to $430,000 |
Upper unit, 1,911 sq ft | 22 | 4 sales, $332,000 to $348,000 | 4 sales, $332,000 to $348,000 |
These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county file used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
Bay Haven's ground-floor units, 1,510 square feet of living area on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, recorded 3 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $389,000, and 5 in the 60 months, from $325,000 to $430,000, according to Lee County recorded sales over $100,000.
The ground-floor list carries both the highest and the lowest prices in the recent Bay Haven record. The $430,000 sale in June 2024 and the $389,000 sale in February 2025 were ground-floor units, and so were the $325,000 sale in December 2025 and the $330,000 sale in January 2026. A range that wide inside one plan says that something other than the plan, most likely condition and timing, separated those sales; the county file does not record which.
A ground-floor unit has no stairs to reach the front door, and its lanai sits at lake level. It also sits closest to floodwater in a storm, and Bay Haven's buildings were flooded in Hurricane Ian. A buyer reads each ground-floor sale with those two facts in view and asks what was replaced after the storm in the unit being considered.
Bay Haven's upper units, 1,911 square feet of living area on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, recorded 4 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $332,000 to $348,000, and the same 4 sales in the 60 months, according to Lee County recorded sales over $100,000.
The upper-unit list is short and tight. All four sales fall between December 2024 and May 2026, and the spread from the lowest to the highest is narrow. No upper unit sold in the county record between October 2021 and the first of these four sales, so the 60-month window adds nothing to the 24-month list.
An upper unit is reached by stairs, carries more living area on the roll and sits a floor higher than the ground units in the same building. Listings describe upper units with lake views from a raised lanai. A buyer who values the larger plan or the height reads these four sales as the best guide on paper, then checks the stairs, the roof and ceiling condition, and the unit's own insurance and repair history.
Bay Haven's recent sales work out to about $174 to $182 per square foot of county living area for upper units and about $215 to $258 for ground units in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, according to Lee County recorded sales over $100,000 and the Lee County Property Appraiser roll.
Price per square foot puts two plans of different sizes on one scale. On that scale, the gap between the floors is plain: upper units, with 1,911 square feet on the roll, sold for less per square foot than ground units with 1,510 square feet. The ranges do not overlap in this window.
Price per square foot is a comparison tool, not a pricing rule. It divides a price by the county's living area, and listings quote different sizes, 1,523 and 1,791 square feet, for some units. A buyer who uses a listing size will reach a different figure. We use the county living area for every unit so the comparison stays on one measure, and a buyer confirms each unit's measured size before relying on any per-foot figure.
Bay Haven sales were matched to plans by living area on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll: every unit is listed at either 1,510 or 1,911 square feet, and each qualified sale in Lee County recorded sales carries its unit's roll record, so the plan follows from the size with no guesswork.
The roll lists 22 units at 1,510 square feet and 22 at 1,911 square feet, all with 3 bedrooms and 2 baths. The ground-floor units in each building are the 1,510 square foot plan and the upper units are the 1,911 square foot plan. Because every sale ties to one unit on the roll, we tracked each of the 7 sales in the 24-month window to its plan without relying on a listing description.
That method has one limit. The roll's living area is an assessment measure, and some listings describe the ground plan as two bedrooms plus a den and quote sizes that differ from the roll. The plan match tells a reader which floor sold; it does not tell a reader how the interior is laid out today. A showing and the unit's own floor plan sheet answer that.
Bay Haven buyers choosing between floors weigh what differs inside one building: a ground unit has no stairs and a lake-level lanai but sits closest to floodwater; an upper unit has more living area on the roll and a raised view but is reached by stairs. Recent sales do not say which of these buyers valued most.
The recorded sales show a pattern, upper units not selling for more than ground units, but they do not show a cause. Several facts could bear on it. Stairs matter to some buyers and not to others. Flood exposure and flood insurance quotes can differ between the floors of one building, because the elevation certificate rates the ground floor against the base flood elevation. The lake view from each unit depends on where it sits in the line of buildings. Condition after Hurricane Ian repairs can differ unit by unit.
A seller of an upper unit uses this to set expectations, and a seller of a ground unit uses it to show what supports a price. A buyer asks for the flood quote, the repair history and the insurance declarations for the specific unit before deciding which floor fits.
Bay Haven's 2026 just values on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll run $243,126 to $268,885 for ground units and $271,160 to $285,056 for upper units. The roll values upper units higher, while recent Lee County recorded sales have not. Just value is an assessment figure, not market value.
The county sets just value by mass appraisal for tax purposes, using size and other roll data, so a larger unit tends to carry a higher just value. Recorded sales reflect what buyers paid for particular units on particular days, with their condition, floor and timing included. The two measures answer different questions, and the difference between them at Bay Haven is a reminder that the roll does not see inside a unit.
A buyer should not read a just value as a floor or a ceiling on a price, and a seller should not list from it. Its practical use is narrow: it sets the starting point for the tax bill, and it shows how the county views one unit against its neighbors on the same roll. We read it, note it and price from the recorded sales and the unit's own papers.
Bay Haven condos are valued one unit at a time: the floor and plan, the interior condition and systems, the garage, the flood zone, the elevation certificate and the Hurricane Ian record, and the budgets of both associations, read against each qualified sale Lee County has recorded inside Bay Haven, sale data through October 21, 2026.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County recorded sales, qualified sales over $100,000, sale data through October 21, 2026; the Lee County Property Appraiser roll; Lee County's copy of the effective FEMA flood map, FIRM panel 12071C0414G).
A Bay Haven price starts with the unit: which floor it sits on, how its interior was finished and repaired, the age of its systems, and the papers that come with it. Then come the building and the documents: the building's elevation certificate, the master insurance, the condominium and community budgets, and any assessment adopted or discussed. Only then do the recorded sales come in, read one by one.
McGreevy and Comisar have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and in Bay Haven we price each unit from its own papers rather than from a community average. We read the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for all 44 units, including plan, year built and just value, and we tracked the 7 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026 before we price one unit.
These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county file used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
Selling your condo in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Buying a condo in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we work with buyers.
Bay Haven has two plans, a 1,510 square foot ground-floor unit and a 1,911 square foot upper unit on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, and recent recorded sales have not paid more for the larger upper plan. A valuation starts with the unit's floor and compares it first with recorded sales on the same floor.
A ground unit is compared with the other ground-unit sales, and an upper unit with the other upper-unit sales, before any cross-floor comparison is made. In the 24 months to October 21, 2026 that means 3 ground sales and 4 upper sales. The position of the building in the line along the lake, and what the lanai faces, can matter too, and those come from a visit rather than the county file.
Listings describe some ground units as two bedrooms plus a den and quote sizes that differ from the roll. We use the county living area for every comparison and ask the seller for any measured floor plan, so the size a buyer sees in a listing and the size in the valuation are not mixed.
Bay Haven units were built in 2004 and 2005, so the interior finishes, the air conditioning, the water heater, the windows and shutters, and any work done after Hurricane Ian all move a valuation. The attached garage on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll enters too, as the declaration defines it for the unit.
Most of what separates two Bay Haven sales of the same plan is inside the walls. A unit with new flooring, a renovated kitchen and a newer air conditioning system sells to a different buyer than one with original finishes. Listings describe electric hurricane shutters and in-unit laundry in some units; a valuation counts those features only where the seller documents them and the declaration says who owns and maintains them.
A seller helps the price by gathering the papers: permits for any interior work, receipts for replaced systems, the wind mitigation report, and the dates and scope of any Ian repairs. Florida's wind mitigation statute sets the form insurers use for wind credits, and a current report on the building helps a buyer get an HO-6 quote that supports the offer.
Bay Haven's buildings sit in FEMA Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 10 to 11 feet NAVD88, and a federal appeals court opinion states that the buildings were flooded in Hurricane Ian. Both facts reach a valuation through the flood insurance cost a buyer can carry and the repair history of the unit.
A lender requires flood insurance on a mortgaged unit in Zone AE, so every financed buyer prices a flood policy before writing a firm offer. The building's elevation certificate decides how that policy rates, and a ground unit and an upper unit in the same building can rate differently. A seller who has the certificate, the current flood policy declarations page and any claim history ready lets a buyer price the cost of ownership early.
The Ian record works the same way. A buyer asks what was repaired in the unit after the storm, who paid for it, and whether any repair cost beyond the association's flood payments was or will be assessed to owners. A seller with clear answers and the paperwork behind them supports the price; one without them leaves the buyer to discount for the unknown.
Bay Haven owners pay a condominium fee to Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. and a community fee to Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. Neither association publishes its budget openly, so a valuation reads both budgets, both reserve positions and both estoppel certificates for the unit before settling on a price.
A buyer prices the monthly cost of owning, not just the purchase price. Two units with the same floor and condition can sell differently if one carries an open special assessment and the other does not, or if a fee change has been announced. The estoppel certificate from each association states what the unit owes and what has been adopted; the minutes show what is being discussed.
For a seller, a clear answer on both associations removes a question a buyer would otherwise price in. We ask the seller to request both estoppel certificates early, and we read the condominium reserve schedule beside the master insurance summary, because the reserves and the insurance deductible together decide how a future repair would be paid.
Bay Haven recorded 7 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, too few for a median, so a valuation reads each sale on its own: its floor, its date, what is known of its condition and how it compares with the unit being priced, according to Lee County recorded sales over $100,000.
With 3 ground-floor sales and 4 upper-unit sales in two years, every sale counts, and each needs context. A sale from February 2025 and one from May 2026 sit more than a year apart. A sale of a unit with fresh finishes is not the same evidence as one sold with original ones. We weigh the closest sales most heavily and say how far each one is from the unit being priced.
When the Bay Haven list runs thin, we look at sales in nearby condominiums of similar age and size for context, read with their own differences in view. The Bay Haven sales still frame the price; the outside sales test whether the frame is reasonable.
Bay Haven owners can request a valuation that starts with the unit's own papers: any permits for interior work, the wind mitigation report, the building's elevation certificate, the insurance declarations pages, and estoppel status from both associations. Our Fort Myers home valuation page starts the request.
We answer with the recorded Bay Haven sales read sale by sale and a price range for the unit, not a figure taken from a community average. Our guide to selling a home in Fort Myers lists the documents we gather first, including the condominium declaration, the Coco Bay use restrictions and the budgets a buyer will ask for.
A seller who prefers to talk first can call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Two associations each issue an estoppel certificate for a Bay Haven sale, so a seller who starts that paperwork early keeps the closing date in reach.
Bay Haven buyers join two associations: Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc., which runs the buildings, their insurance and the condominium budget, and Coco Bay Community Association, Inc., which runs the roads, lakes and Amenity Center for all 143 homes. Each has its own documents, board and fee, and each issues an estoppel certificate.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Coco Bay Use Restrictions, Exhibit C; the Coco Bay Community Association FAQ, August 2025; the Coco Bay governing documents page, including the rules revised March 2026; the Coco Bay/Kelly Greens access easement agreement, recorded 2004; Florida Statutes, Chapter 718).
Two associations means two sets of documents, two budgets, two boards and two sets of rules for one unit. The condominium documents, the declaration of condominium, its bylaws and the condominium rules, govern the unit, the buildings and the condominium's common elements. The Coco Bay documents, including the use restrictions, govern the whole community, Bay Haven included. Where both speak to a subject, an owner follows both.
The community association posts its governing documents on its documents page, including the use restrictions and the rules it adopted in revised form in March 2026. Bay Haven's own pages on the association website sit behind an owner login, so a buyer asks the seller or the Bay Haven association for the condominium documents directly. We do not name either association's manager; each association can say who manages it today.
Our guide to buying a home in Fort Myers sets out how we read association documents during the inspection period. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. runs the eleven buildings, their master insurance and the condominium budget and reserves. Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. owns and runs the roads, the two lakes, the Amenity Center and even the land parcel under the Bay Haven common elements, for all 143 Coco Bay homes.
That split decides who answers which question. A roof leak, a stairwell repair, the building's flood or wind policy and the condominium reserve schedule are questions for the Bay Haven association. Lake banks, irrigation, the clubhouse pool and the community roads are questions for the Coco Bay association. The Kelly Greens gates and the roads that lead to Coco Bay belong to the Kelly Greens Master Association under the 2004 easement.
Florida's condominium act on common expenses explains how a condominium association funds the costs it carries, and the declaration names which costs those are. A buyer reads the Bay Haven declaration for the line between the unit and the common elements, because that line decides which repairs an owner pays for alone and which the association pays for through the fee.
Bay Haven buyers request, from the condominium association, the declaration, bylaws, rules, current budget, reserve schedule, master insurance summary and recent minutes; and from the community association, the use restrictions, the March 2026 revised rules, its budget and minutes. Each association's estoppel certificate completes the set before closing.
Florida's condominium records statute lists the official records a condominium association keeps and makes available to owners, and Florida's resale disclosure statute sets out the documents a buyer of a resale condominium unit receives and the time allowed to review them. A buyer reads the contract for the review period it gives, then uses it.
Read in order, the documents answer the questions that matter: what the unit includes under the declaration, what the fees are under each budget, how much the condominium holds in reserves, what the master insurance covers and at what deductible, and what the boards have been discussing. A buyer who reads the minutes from the past year learns about repairs, insurance renewals and any assessment talk before signing.
Bay Haven units sit under two associations, so each issues its own estoppel certificate: the Bay Haven condominium association for the condominium fee and any condominium assessment, and the Coco Bay community association for the community fee. Together they state what the unit owes and what has been adopted on the day of closing.
An estoppel certificate is the association's written statement of a unit's account: the regular fee, its due date, any unpaid amount, any special assessment adopted and any other charge. Florida's statute on condominium assessments and estoppel certificates sets out what the condominium certificate must contain and how long it remains effective.
The closing agent orders both certificates, and the purchase contract decides who pays for each. A buyer reads both before closing, because an assessment adopted by either board shows up on that board's certificate and nowhere else. The listing figures for Bay Haven fees conflict, so the two certificates are the first documents that state the current figures with authority.
Bay Haven owners are represented by two boards: the Coco Bay board and a separate Bay Haven board, each with five resident directors according to the community association's August 2025 FAQ. The Coco Bay board meets at the Amenity Center on the third Wednesday of each month, and the community association has adopted an electronic voting resolution.
Two boards means two calendars of meetings, two sets of minutes and two budget cycles. A Bay Haven owner votes in the condominium association on matters such as the condominium budget, reserves and building projects, and in the community association on matters such as the community budget, lakes and clubhouse. The electronic voting resolution, posted on the community association's documents page, sets how owners can vote online in community matters.
A buyer who attends a board meeting, or reads the past year's minutes, learns what each board has decided and what is pending. Insurance renewals, storm repairs, landscaping contracts and fee changes all pass through the boards, and the minutes record them before they reach a budget or an estoppel certificate.
Bay Haven buyers read the Coco Bay Use Restrictions first: whole-unit leases only, none shorter than 30 consecutive days and no more than three per unit per calendar year; common household pets, with pit bull type breeds barred; no trailers, boats, trucks or campers unless garaged; and shutter approval rules. Condominium documents may add rules.
Each rule has a practical edge. A buyer who plans to lease reads the lease limits and the requirement to send a copy of each lease to the association, and asks whether the Bay Haven documents add an approval step. A buyer with a dog reads the pet rule, and assistance animals are handled under fair housing law; ask the association. A buyer with a work truck reads the vehicle rule before signing, not after.
Shutters are a building question as much as a rule. Galvanized panels must be painted, and roll-down or accordion shutters need approval under board standards. The lakes carry their own rule: no watercraft, docks or swimming. The community association revised its rules in March 2026, so a buyer reads the current version. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven owners pay two association fees, the Bay Haven condominium fee and the Coco Bay community fee, plus the Lee County tax bill with its non-ad valorem charges, HO-6, wind and flood insurance, utilities and upkeep inside the unit. Neither association publishes its budget openly, so a buyer confirms every figure with the associations.
Data updated: November 2026 (listing remarks, 2025 to 2026; the Coco Bay Community Association FAQ, August 2025; the Coco Bay/Kelly Greens access easement agreement, recorded 2004; the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and one sampled unit's tax bill; Lee County's copy of the effective FEMA flood map).
Listing figures we read from 2025 and 2026 conflict: one 2026 listing showed $332 a month, another showed a condo fee of $2,501 a quarter, and some mix the condo and community fees together; treat them as hints, not figures. Coco Bay single-family listings showed a community fee of $1,660 a quarter in 2025 and 2026; the share a condo owner pays is not published.
Neither association publishes its budget openly, and Bay Haven's pages on the association website sit behind an owner login. Ask for the current budgets of both associations, the Bay Haven reserve schedule, the master insurance summary and an estoppel certificate from each association before relying on any figure.
Cost | What sets it | Where to confirm |
|---|---|---|
Bay Haven condominium fee | The condominium association's adopted budget | The Bay Haven budget and estoppel certificate |
Coco Bay community fee | The community association's adopted budget | The Coco Bay budget and estoppel certificate |
Special assessment, if any | A board or owner vote in either association | Both sets of minutes and both estoppel certificates |
Gate transponders | Kelly Greens' price, under the 2004 easement | The Kelly Greens Master Association |
CDD | None found on the roll | The tax bill's non-ad valorem lines |
Solid waste | Solid Waste Service Area 2 | The Lee County tax bill |
Property taxes | The Lee County tax bill | The current tax bill |
Flood insurance | Zone AE, the floor and the elevation certificate | The lender's flood determination and a flood quote |
HO-6 and wind coverage | The unit's interior, the master policy's deductible and the declaration | The master insurance summary and an HO-6 quote |
Water and sewer come from Lee County Utilities and electricity from Florida Power and Light; a buyer asks the seller for recent bills and asks the Bay Haven association which utilities, if any, its budget pays. We do not estimate tax bills or premiums.
Selling your condo in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Buying a condo in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we work with buyers.
Bay Haven's condominium fee pays for what the Bay Haven budget funds, and that budget is not published openly. In a Florida condominium the fee usually funds the master insurance on the buildings, building upkeep, management and reserves; the adopted budget and the estoppel certificate say what Bay Haven's fee covers and costs today.
For a condominium of eleven two-story buildings in Zone AE, the master insurance is often one of the largest lines in the budget, because the association insures the buildings against wind and, as the court record shows for Hurricane Ian, against flood through a building policy on each building. Roofs, exterior paint, stairs and walkways, and the reserves that pay for their replacement, are other lines a buyer looks for.
A buyer compares the budget with the board minutes. If the minutes show an insurance renewal, a roofing project or a painting job under discussion, the next budget may look different from the current one. The estoppel certificate shows the fee the association bills today; the minutes hint at what it may bill next.
Bay Haven owners also pay the Coco Bay community fee, which funds the roads, lakes, irrigation and Amenity Center for all 143 homes. The community association's August 2025 FAQ says a bulk Xfinity cable and internet contract is included in the Coco Bay assessment; the community budget and the estoppel certificate confirm what it covers today.
Coco Bay single-family listings show the community fee for a house, but the share a Bay Haven condominium owner pays is not published, and some listings fold the community fee into the condominium figure. A buyer asks the community association for its current budget and for the unit's estoppel certificate, and reads the community fee as its own line, separate from the condominium fee.
The community budget also carries costs that changed after Hurricane Ian. The August 2025 FAQ reports that irrigation moved from the lakes to a freshwater well, with controller work of about $12,000, and that a full new system quoted at about $448,000 was not chosen. A buyer reads the minutes for any later decision on irrigation, because a project of that size would reach the community budget.
Bay Haven tax bills carry non-ad valorem charges beside the property tax: one sampled unit's bill showed a solid waste charge of $376.41 a year in Solid Waste Service Area 2. No community development district was found on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, and the units sit in the Iona McGregor Fire taxing district.
The non-ad valorem section of a Florida tax bill lists flat charges that do not depend on the unit's value, such as solid waste and any district assessments. A buyer reads it on the current bill for the unit being bought, posted by the Lee County Tax Collector, because charges are set parcel by parcel. The Lee County Property Appraiser posts the roll record for each unit.
The fire district appears on the ad valorem side of the bill as one of the taxing authorities. A buyer confirms the district and its millage on the bill rather than from a neighbor's unit. Bay Haven is in unincorporated Lee County, so no City of Fort Myers millage appears.
Bay Haven buyers may pay estoppel fees to both associations, any application or transfer charge either association sets, gate transponders at Kelly Greens' price, and the usual closing costs. Whether a transfer fee or capital contribution applies is not published, so a buyer asks both associations and reads the answer in each estoppel certificate.
The purchase contract decides who pays which closing cost: the owner's title policy, the two estoppel fees, recording fees and the documentary stamp tax on the deed. We confirm those terms with the buyer or seller when we write or review the offer, and the closing statement lists each charge.
A one-time charge that appears in a declaration but not in a listing is still a charge. A buyer asks the Bay Haven association whether its declaration sets a capital contribution at transfer, asks the Coco Bay association the same about its documents, and asks the Kelly Greens Master Association how many transponders a new owner needs and what each costs.
Bay Haven owners insure their unit's interior and contents with an HO-6 policy, while the condominium association insures the buildings under its master policies. Every building sits in Zone AE, so lenders require flood insurance on a mortgaged unit, and the building's elevation certificate and the unit's floor drive the flood quote.
The court record shows that when Hurricane Ian struck, the association carried a National Flood Insurance Program building policy on each building with a $1,000,000 building limit, a $5,000 deductible and no contents coverage. A buyer asks for the current master flood and wind policies, because the limits and deductibles in force today, not those in 2022, decide what a unit owner would face after a storm.
The master policy's deductible matters to every owner, because a loss under the deductible may be passed to owners by assessment or left to each owner's HO-6 policy, depending on the declaration. Florida's condominium insurance provisions set what the association must insure. A buyer gives the master insurance summary to the agent quoting the HO-6 and unit flood policies, and takes quotes on the unit itself.
Bay Haven owners can be charged a special assessment when either board adopts one for a repair, an insurance shortfall or a project the reserves do not cover. After the court case over Hurricane Ian flood claims, a buyer asks directly whether any Ian repair cost beyond the flood payments was or will be assessed.
The court record shows the association's flood payments were limited to the signed proofs of loss, and that its claim for contractor invoices beyond those amounts failed in the district court and on appeal. The record does not say how the remaining cost, if any, was paid. A buyer asks the Bay Haven board whether it was paid from reserves, operating funds, a loan or an assessment, and whether any balance is still owed.
An assessment adopted before closing is usually settled in the contract between buyer and seller; one adopted after closing falls to the new owner. Florida's statute on owner obligations sets out each owner's duty to follow the declaration and pay what it requires. A buyer who reads the minutes and both estoppel certificates knows which kind of question to ask before signing.
Bay Haven is in a flood zone: Lee County's republished effective FEMA layer, read November 20, 2026, maps Zone AE across the Bay Haven buildings, with a base flood elevation of 10 to 11 feet NAVD88, coastal floodplain, outside the floodway, on FIRM panel 12071C0414G, effective November 17, 2022.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County's republished effective FEMA flood layer and FIRM panel index, read November 20, 2026; FIRM panel 12071C0414G, effective November 17, 2022; Lee County flood map information; a 2026 listing's public elevation data).
We read the FEMA flood zone, base flood elevation and FIRM panel at the Bay Haven buildings on Lee County's map service. Two flood areas cross the buildings, both Zone AE, a Special Flood Hazard Area on the effective map: one with a base flood elevation of 10 feet NAVD88 and one with 11 feet. Both are coastal floodplain, and neither is in the floodway.
Ground at the buildings sits at about 8 feet, per public elevation data shown with a 2026 listing. Finished-floor elevations are not public: each building's elevation certificate records them. No Bay Haven unit sits outside the flood zone on the effective map, and a buyer plans for flood insurance on every unit, on either floor.
Lenders require flood insurance on mortgaged units in Zone AE. The building's elevation certificate and a lender flood determination decide how a unit is treated; ask the association for the certificate on the building you are considering.
Bay Haven's Zone AE mapping places every building in a Special Flood Hazard Area on FEMA's effective map, the zone where lenders require flood insurance on a federally backed mortgage. A buyer who finances a Bay Haven unit should expect the lender to order a flood determination and require a flood policy before closing.
The base flood elevation is the height FEMA expects floodwater to reach in the flood the map is drawn around, and Zone AE carries a stated figure. A building whose finished floor sits higher than the base flood elevation generally rates better than one that sits lower, and the elevation certificate records which is the case. FEMA's FloodSmart guide to flood zones and maps explains the zones in plain terms.
A cash buyer is not required by a lender to carry flood insurance, but the zone does not change with the way a unit is bought, and the association's own building policy covers only the building to its limits. A cash buyer reads the same certificate and takes the same quote before deciding.
Bay Haven's buildings fall across two Zone AE flood areas on FEMA's effective map, one with a base flood elevation of 10 feet NAVD88 and one with 11 feet. The map service read across the whole line of buildings did not resolve which building sits in which area, so the building's elevation certificate settles it.
FEMA assigns a base flood elevation to each area of Zone AE, and the line between two areas can fall between buildings on one site, or through one. Along Bay Haven's north-south line of eleven buildings, the read showed both figures without assigning each building to one. The difference of one foot matters to a flood policy, because the comparison that sets a rate is between the building's finished floor and its own base flood elevation.
A buyer looks up the building's address on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center, which shows the panel and the zone at the address, then reads the building's elevation certificate, which records the base flood elevation the surveyor used. A lender flood determination confirms the zone for the mortgage.
Bay Haven ground-floor units sit at ground level in Zone AE, where ground is about 8 feet per public elevation data shown with a 2026 listing, so the building's finished-floor elevation decides how they rate. Upper units sit a floor higher in the same building and zone, so their flood exposure and quotes can differ.
A ground-floor owner faces water at the floor in a flood that reaches the building; an upper-unit owner faces it at the stairs, the garage and the ground-level parts of the building. Both share the building's common elements, and damage to the ground floor of a building is a cost the association and its building flood policy carry under the declaration, which every owner shares through the fee and any assessment.
A buyer of either floor asks the same questions: what the elevation certificate shows, what the association's current building flood policy covers, and what a unit flood policy would cost for contents and any building coverage the lender requires. The garage sits at ground level for every unit, so contents kept there face the same water as a ground-floor unit.
Bay Haven buyers ask the condominium association for the elevation certificate on the building where the unit sits, and ask the seller for any certificate held for the unit. Finished-floor elevations at Bay Haven are not public, so the certificate is the document that answers how the building sits against its base flood elevation.
An elevation certificate is prepared by a licensed surveyor and records the building's finished-floor elevation and other measurements on a FEMA form. An insurance agent uses it to rate a flood policy, and a lender may ask for it. Condominium buildings often have one certificate per building, held by the association.
If no certificate exists, the association can commission one. A buyer who needs a quote during the inspection period raises the question early, because a surveyor's schedule may not match the contract's. FEMA's FloodSmart site explains how flood policies are rated and bought.
Bay Haven sits in unincorporated Lee County, where new flood maps are scheduled to take effect March 2, 2027. A new map can change a zone or a base flood elevation at an address, so a buyer or owner checks the new map for the building and asks an insurance agent how it would affect a quote.
Lee County posts flood map information for county residents, including notices about map changes. Until the new maps take effect, the effective map, panel 12071C0414G dated November 17, 2022, is the one lenders and insurers use. After March 2, 2027, the new map governs new determinations.
A buyer closing near that date asks the lender which map the flood determination will use, and asks the insurance agent whether a policy bound before the change keeps its rating. An owner planning to sell after the change checks the new zone and base flood elevation for the building so that the next buyer's questions have answers. Never assume the zone from an older listing; check the map in effect on the day.
Bay Haven's buildings were flooded in Hurricane Ian on September 28, 2022, according to a federal appeals court opinion of October 23, 2026. Flood insurance paid about $2.57 million across the eleven buildings. Bay Haven sits in Lee County Evacuation Zone A, storm surge zone 1, on the county's evacuation layer.
Data updated: November 2026 (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit opinion, October 23, 2026, not for publication; the insurer's summary judgment motion in the court record; the Coco Bay Community Association FAQ, August 2025; Lee County's evacuation zone layer, read November 20, 2026; National Hurricane Center tropical cyclone reports).
We read the federal appeals court opinion and the summary judgment record on Bay Haven's Hurricane Ian flood claims, and we read the Lee County evacuation zone at the Bay Haven buildings on Lee County's map service. The court record is public, and it is set out here plainly, as the courts and the filings state it.
The Eleventh Circuit opinion states that Bay Haven's buildings were flooded in Hurricane Ian. The association had insured each of its eleven buildings under its own National Flood Insurance Program building policy, written through Hartford, and the insurer paid the signed proofs of loss. The association then sought more for contractor invoices, and the courts held that a signed, sworn proof of loss is required for every dollar claimed.
No Bay Haven specific report on Hurricanes Helene or Milton in 2024 was found. The National Hurricane Center's reports on Hurricane Ian, Hurricane Helene and Hurricane Milton describe each storm across the region.
Selling your condo in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Buying a condo in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we work with buyers.
Bay Haven's buildings were flooded in Hurricane Ian, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit states in its October 23, 2026 opinion. Signed proofs of loss for each building ran $221,023 to $262,656, about $2.57 million in total, and the insurer paid them, according to the court record.
The opinion is not for publication, which means it decides this case without setting binding precedent for others, and it is posted with its case details on GovInfo. It describes the association as managing eleven condominium buildings that sustained flood damage in the storm. The insurer's summary judgment motion in the court record sets out the policies, the proofs of loss and the payments building by building.
The record shows what was claimed and paid under the flood policies. It does not show the full cost of every repair at Bay Haven, what was paid from other sources, or how each unit was restored. A buyer reads the record for what it is, a public account of the flood claims, and asks the association for the rest.
Bay Haven's association insured each of its eleven buildings under its own National Flood Insurance Program building policy, written through Hartford, a Write-Your-Own carrier, with a $1,000,000 building limit, a $5,000 deductible and no contents coverage, according to the court record. The policies covered the buildings, not owners' belongings.
A Write-Your-Own carrier is an insurance company that writes and services National Flood Insurance Program policies under federal rules; the policy terms come from the federal program, not from the carrier. That is why the federal proof of loss requirement governed the claim. A building policy with no contents coverage leaves each owner's furniture and belongings to the owner's own flood policy.
For a buyer today, the 2022 policies are history. The current master flood and wind policies, their limits, their deductibles and what they cover are the questions that matter, and the master insurance summary answers them. A buyer gives that summary to the agent quoting the unit's HO-6 and flood policies.
Bay Haven's association sued for contractor invoices beyond the paid proofs of loss, filing on August 2, 2024 in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida in Fort Myers. It lost on summary judgment in January 2026, and the Eleventh Circuit affirmed on October 23, 2026, according to the court record.
The appeals court held that a signed, sworn proof of loss is required for every dollar claimed under a federal flood policy, including amounts beyond those first claimed, and that invoices or other evidence of loss do not take its place. The Construction Defect Journal summarized the district court ruling in April 2026 in an article on why substantial evidence of flood loss is not a substitute for the required proof of loss.
The case ended with the insurer's payments standing at the amounts of the signed proofs of loss. What that means for owners' costs is a question for the Bay Haven association: whether the invoices beyond those payments were paid, from what source, and whether any amount was or will be assessed to owners.
Bay Haven's neighbors in Coco Bay saw the storm reach the common areas too: the community association's August 2025 FAQ reports that Hurricane Ian's surge put salt water in both lakes, ending lake-fed irrigation, and that irrigation moved to a freshwater well, with controller work of about $12,000 rather than a full new system quoted at about $448,000.
The lakes belong to Coco Bay Community Association, Inc., so the irrigation change was a community association decision paid through the community budget. The FAQ describes it as the approach the board chose instead of replacing the whole system. A buyer reads it as a record of how one storm reached shared property beyond the buildings.
The practical questions follow the budget. A buyer asks the community association whether irrigation work is finished, whether any further project is planned, and how it will be paid for. The answers appear in the community minutes and the next budget, and any assessment would appear on the community association's estoppel certificate.
Bay Haven sits in Lee County Evacuation Zone A, storm surge zone 1, on the county's evacuation layer at the middle of the buildings. Zone A is drawn for the highest storm surge risk, and Lee County names its evacuation orders by zone, so a Bay Haven owner plans to leave when Zone A is called, on either floor.
An evacuation zone is drawn for storm surge, not for the height of a unit, so an order for Zone A applies to upper units as well as ground units. Lee County lets residents look up their evacuation zone by address, and Lee County Emergency Management posts orders, shelter openings and storm updates. The National Hurricane Center's national storm surge risk maps show surge risk across the coast.
An owner keeps the plan simple: confirm the zone for the address, know the route out through the Kelly Greens gates to Summerlin Road, and follow the county's orders rather than the forecast alone. A unit that will sit empty through a storm needs its shutters handled under the board's standards before the owner leaves.
Bay Haven buyers ask the condominium association whether any Hurricane Ian repair cost beyond the flood payments was or will be assessed to owners, what the reserves hold now, and for the current master flood and wind policies. They ask the community association about lake, irrigation and clubhouse work since the storm.
The questions are best asked in writing and answered with documents: the minutes that discuss Ian costs, the current reserve schedule, the master insurance summary with its limits and deductibles, and the building's elevation certificate. A seller can add the unit's own record: what was replaced inside the unit after the storm, the permits, and any flood claim the owner made on a personal policy.
Each answer has a place in the decision. An open assessment goes into the contract terms. The reserve figure tells a buyer how the next repair might be paid. The insurance summary and the elevation certificate let an agent quote the unit before the inspection period ends. A buyer who gathers all of them knows what owning a Bay Haven unit costs through a storm season, not just on the day of closing.
Bay Haven's Hurricane Ian flood claims are public court record: the association's eleven building policies paid about $2.57 million in total, a suit for contractor invoices beyond those amounts ended in summary judgment for the insurer, and the federal appeals court affirmed on October 23, 2026. For a buyer, the case turns into document questions.
Data updated: November 2026 (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit opinion, October 23, 2026, unpublished; the insurer's summary judgment motion in the court record, U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida; Construction Defect Journal, April 2026; National Flood Insurance Program references).
We read the federal appeals court opinion and the summary judgment record on Bay Haven's Hurricane Ian flood claims. We print the case as the courts recorded it: what was insured, what was paid, what was asked for and what each court decided. We add no view on who was right, and we name no person. The point for a reader is practical. A condominium's flood claim history becomes part of what a buyer reads, because it can shape the association's reserves, its budget and any assessment owners are asked to pay.
The full opinion is public on GovInfo as a PDF of the Eleventh Circuit opinion, with its GovInfo record and details. The opinion is unpublished, which means it decides this case and is not binding precedent in the circuit, but it sets out the facts and the court's reasoning in plain terms.
Bay Haven's buildings were flooded in Hurricane Ian on September 28, 2022, according to the Eleventh Circuit opinion of October 23, 2026. The opinion describes an association managing eleven condominium buildings that sustained flood damage, each insured under its own National Flood Insurance Program building policy.
The National Hurricane Center's tropical cyclone report on Hurricane Ian is the federal account of the storm across Southwest Florida. The court record is narrower: it concerns the eleven Bay Haven buildings and the flood policies on them.
The record does not describe damage unit by unit, and we make no claim about any one unit. A buyer looking at a particular ground-floor or upper unit asks the seller in writing what water reached that unit, what was repaired, by whom, and with which permits. The answer belongs in the same file as the elevation certificate and the association's insurance summary.
Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. insured each of its eleven buildings under its own National Flood Insurance Program building policy written through Hartford, a Write-Your-Own carrier, with a $1,000,000 building limit, a $5,000 deductible and no contents coverage, according to the court record.
A Write-Your-Own carrier is an insurance company that writes and services National Flood Insurance Program policies under the federal program's rules. The policy terms are federal; the carrier handles the claim. FloodSmart, the program's public site, explains how National Flood Insurance Program cover works.
Two lines in that record matter to a unit owner. First, the policies were building policies with no contents coverage, so the association's flood cover did not extend to an owner's furniture or belongings. Second, each building had its own limit and its own deductible. Ask the association whether the current flood policies follow the same pattern, what each limit and deductible now reads, and whether contents remain the owner's to insure. The declaration and the current policy declarations pages govern.
Bay Haven's signed proofs of loss ran from $221,023 to $262,656 per building, about $2.57 million in total across the eleven buildings, and the insurer paid them, according to the court record. The record also shows federal waivers of the filing deadline before payment, so the claims were paid on the signed proofs.
A proof of loss is the sworn statement a policyholder signs to set out the amount claimed under a flood policy. Under the National Flood Insurance Program, the signed proof is the document the claim is paid against. The per-building figures sit inside the $1,000,000 building limit on each policy.
The paid amounts tell a buyer that flood money came in after Ian. They do not say whether the payments met every repair cost. That question belongs to the association's records: the repair contracts, the invoices, the minutes and the budget lines that show how the gap, if any, was met.
Bay Haven's association sued the insurer for contractor invoices beyond the paid proof-of-loss amounts, filing on August 2, 2024, in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida in Fort Myers. The district court granted summary judgment to the insurer in January 2026, and the Eleventh Circuit affirmed on October 23, 2026.
The appeals court held that a signed, sworn proof of loss is required for every dollar claimed under a National Flood Insurance Program policy, including amounts beyond a prior proof. Invoices and other evidence of loss, however detailed, did not take the place of that sworn document for the amounts in dispute.
Construction Defect Journal summarized the district court ruling in an April 2026 article, Substantial Evidence of Flood Loss Not a Substitute for Required Proof of Loss. We read the court documents themselves and state only what they record. The case is closed at the appeals level as of the opinion date; any later filing would appear on the court's public docket.
Bay Haven owners who carry their own unit flood policy face the same federal rule the appeals court applied: a National Flood Insurance Program claim is paid against a signed, sworn proof of loss, and any further amount needs its own sworn proof. An invoice or a contractor's estimate alone does not count.
The practical habit is simple. After any flood, read the policy's deadlines, file the notice of loss, keep every invoice and photograph, and sign a proof of loss for each amount claimed, including any supplemental amount found later. FloodSmart publishes the program's claim guidance on its public site, and the policy itself sets the deadlines.
A unit owner's flood policy and the association's building policy are separate contracts. The association claims on the building; the owner claims on whatever the owner's own policy insures. Ask the insurance agent who writes the unit policy how the two fit together for a Bay Haven unit, and keep the answer with the master policy summary.
Bay Haven buyers ask the association, in writing, whether any Ian repair cost beyond the flood payments was or will be assessed to owners, what the reserves hold now, and for the current master flood and wind policies. The estoppel certificate then states what is owed on the unit at closing.
Put the questions in one written request, sent the day the contract is signed:
Read the answers with the board minutes from late 2022 onward. The minutes show when repair contracts were signed, how they were funded and whether owners voted on any assessment. Under the condominium act, owners share common expenses as the declaration sets them (s. 718.115), and an owner's liability for assessments, along with the estoppel certificate, sits in s. 718.116. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven's current master insurance is not published, so a buyer asks Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. for the declarations pages of the building flood policies and the wind or property policy, and reads the limit, the deductible and what each policy insures on the building.
The court record describes the flood policies in force for Ian. Policies renew, and limits, deductibles and carriers can change. Ask for the current year's pages, not a copy kept from a prior sale. The condominium act sets the association's insurance duties in s. 718.111, and the declaration says where the association's cover stops and the owner's begins.
Read the wind or hurricane deductible closely. Florida defines hurricane coverage and its deductibles in s. 627.4025, and a condominium deductible can be shared among owners after a storm under the declaration's terms. Ask how the association would fund a deductible: from reserves, the operating budget or an assessment.
Bay Haven buyers ask an independent insurance agent to quote an HO-6 policy and a unit flood policy together, with the association's master policy summary and the building's elevation certificate in hand. All eleven buildings sit in FEMA Zone AE, so lenders require flood insurance on mortgaged units.
The HO-6 policy covers what the master policy leaves to the owner under the declaration: interior finishes, personal property, liability and, often, loss assessment cover for a share of an association deductible or assessment. The flood quote turns on the building's elevation and the unit's floor. A ground-floor unit and an upper unit in the same building can rate differently for flood.
Start the quotes in the first days of the contract. A lender reads both declarations pages before closing, and a late quote can move a closing date. FloodSmart explains flood zones and maps as a rater reads them. We quote no premium for any Bay Haven unit.
Bay Haven's eleven buildings are two stories on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, and Florida's structural integrity reserve study and milestone inspection laws are written for buildings three habitable stories or more. By that text neither mandate is aimed at Bay Haven; confirm with the association that no building has a third habitable story.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for all 44 units; Florida Statutes s. 718.112 and s. 553.899; Florida DBPR Division of Florida Condominiums, Timeshares and Mobile Homes inspection and SIRS reporting pages).
We read the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for all 44 Bay Haven units: plan, year built and just value. The roll places them in 11 buildings lettered AA to KK, four units each, two ground-floor units and two upper units, with Building KK built in 2004 and the other ten in 2005. No unit sits on a third floor on the roll. That record is the starting point for the state inspection questions, because both laws turn on building height.
No Bay Haven milestone inspection or structural integrity reserve study filing was found. That is consistent with two-story buildings, but it is not a statement from the association. The statutes decide who must act; the association's records show what it has done. And the height-based laws are only part of the inspection picture: reserves, roofs, insurance, permits and the Ian repair history still decide what an owner may be asked to pay.
Bay Haven buyers read the structural integrity reserve study rule in s. 718.112(2)(g), which applies to condominium buildings three habitable stories or higher and excludes buildings under three stories. The Bay Haven buildings are two stories on the county roll, so the rule's text does not reach them.
The current text is on the Florida Senate's site at s. 718.112. Read paragraph (2)(g) in the current year's version rather than a summary, because the paragraph has been amended several times since 2022.
Because the rule turns on height, the question for a Bay Haven unit is a factual one about its building. The roll shows units on two floors in every building. Ask the association to confirm that in writing and keep the answer with the contract file. The Division of Florida Condominiums, Timeshares and Mobile Homes posts a SIRS reporting page explaining what covered associations file.
Bay Haven's two-story buildings sit outside the text of s. 553.899, Florida's milestone inspection law, which applies to condominium and cooperative buildings three habitable stories or more in height as the Florida Building Code measures it. The Lee County Property Appraiser roll shows two stories for all eleven buildings, AA to KK.
The law is on the Florida Senate's site at s. 553.899, and the Division of Florida Condominiums, Timeshares and Mobile Homes explains both programs on its inspections page.
The height test is set by the building code, not by a listing description. If the association has commissioned any structural review on its own, after Ian or at any other time, ask for the report. A voluntary engineer's report is still a useful document for a buyer, whatever the statute requires.
Bay Haven buyers ask Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc., in writing, whether any of the eleven buildings has a third habitable story, whether it has received any notice from a building official about a milestone inspection, and whether it has filed anything with the state under the SIRS rule.
Put the question in the same written request that asks for the estoppel certificate, the budget and the reserve schedule. A short answer is enough: the number of habitable stories in each building, whether any study or inspection has been done, and whether any is planned.
The Lee County Property Appraiser site shows the building record for each unit. Match the building letter on the purchase contract to the building record, so the buyer knows which building's permits, flood claim and repair history apply. The Division's public records page lets anyone search condominium records for the association.
Bay Haven reserves still matter, because the general condominium act asks associations to budget reserves for capital items such as roofs and painting even where the SIRS rule does not reach. A Bay Haven buyer asks whether reserves are fully funded, partly funded or waived by owner vote, and for the reserve schedule.
A reserve schedule lists each capital item, its estimated remaining life and the amount the budget sets aside each year. Funded reserves spread the cost of a roof or a repaint across the years; waived or reduced reserves leave those costs to be met when they come due, often by special assessment. After a storm year with a lawsuit, the reserve balance is one of the clearest signals of where the money stands.
Ask for three documents together: the current budget with its reserve lines, the reserve schedule and the minutes of any owner vote on reserves in recent years. Remember that Bay Haven owners also pay the Coco Bay community layer, so ask Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. for its budget and reserves too. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven ground-floor units are 1,510 square feet of living area on the county roll, three bedrooms and two baths with an attached garage, and they sit closest to the ground in buildings that flooded in Ian. An inspector looks for signs of past water and dates every system.
Ask the inspector to check the floor coverings, baseboards, lower drywall, door frames and cabinet bases for staining, swelling or patching, and to note any moisture readings. Ask the seller in writing what was replaced after Ian, by whom, with which permits, and whether any work was paid for by the association or by the owner.
Date the air conditioning, the water heater and the electrical panel, and identify the plumbing material. The roll records the year built, 2004 or 2005, not the age of any system, and post-storm repairs may have replaced some of them. The garage is worth its own look: door, opener, slab, and any water line on the walls. A ground-floor buyer also reads the building's elevation certificate, because the flood rating turns on it.
Bay Haven upper units are 1,911 square feet of living area on the county roll, three bedrooms and two baths with an attached garage, reached by stairs over the ground-floor units. The inspector checks the ceilings under the roof, the stairs and landings, the lanai and every system.
On an upper unit, the roof sits directly over the ceilings, so ask the inspector to look for staining, past patching or soft spots, and ask the association for the date of the building's last roof work and its permit. Check the exterior stairs and landings and ask the association which parts it maintains.
Ask which supply lines, drains and air conditioning lines serve the upper unit and where they run. In a two-story building, a line from an upper unit can pass through the space over a ground-floor unit, and the declaration says who maintains which part. That split matters when a leak touches two units at once, and it is why the upper-unit buyer reads the same insurance summary as the ground-floor buyer.
Bay Haven buyers gather the building's roof permits and dates, the shutter and window permits, any wind mitigation report on the unit or building, the elevation certificate and the Ian repair permits. Listings describe electric hurricane shutters on some units; confirm what is on the unit under contract and who maintains it.
A wind mitigation report records the roof shape, roof deck attachment, roof-to-wall connection and opening protection on a standard state form; Florida sets the form in s. 627.711. Ask whether the seller holds a current report and whether the association holds one for the building. Roof work also carries state wind-loss mitigation rules in s. 553.844.
Hurricane shutters on a condominium are governed by the condominium act's maintenance section, s. 718.113, and by the board's standards. Under the Coco Bay restrictions, galvanized panels must be painted and roll-down or accordion shutters need approval. Ask for the approval behind any shutter on the unit. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven buyers collect two sets of documents: the Bay Haven condominium declaration, bylaws, rules, budget, reserve schedule, master insurance summary, minutes and estoppel certificate, and the Coco Bay declaration, use restrictions, budget and estoppel certificate. Neither association publishes its budget openly, so every document comes by request.
The condominium act gives a resale buyer the right to the declaration, bylaws, rules and other documents named in s. 718.503, and the purchase contract sets the review period. Coco Bay posts its governing documents page on the association site, including the Coco Bay Use Restrictions, Exhibit C.
Read them in order: the condominium declaration for what the owner and the association each maintain and insure; the use restrictions for leasing, pets, vehicles and shutters; both budgets and the reserve schedule for the money; the minutes for Ian repairs and the lawsuit; and both estoppel certificates for what is owed at closing. Ask whether either association must approve a sale or a lease.
Bay Haven condos are taxed by Lee County and the other taxing authorities on each unit's bill, with no city millage because Bay Haven sits in unincorporated Lee County. We do not estimate tax bills. A buyer reads the seller's current bill, then plans for a fresh assessment after the purchase under Florida's homestead rules.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for all 44 units, 2026 just values and homestead status; one sampled unit's tax bill; Florida Statutes s. 193.155, s. 196.011, s. 196.031, s. 197.122 and s. 689.261).
We read the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for all 44 Bay Haven units. Each unit is its own parcel, with its own just value, assessed value, exemptions and tax bill. A buyer's tax question is always about one unit, never the community as a whole.
The mailing city is Fort Myers and the ZIP is 33908, but the property sits outside the City of Fort Myers, so county services apply and the bill carries no city millage. Bay Haven units are in the Iona McGregor Fire taxing district, and no community development district was found on the roll; confirm both on the tax bill's lines.
Bay Haven tax bills carry ad valorem taxes, set by each taxing authority's millage on the unit's taxable value, plus non-ad valorem lines for services. Bay Haven units sit in the Iona McGregor Fire taxing district with no city millage. We do not estimate tax bills; read the seller's most recent bill for the exact unit.
The ad valorem part of the bill starts from the taxable value on the roll after any exemption, multiplied by the millage of each authority on the parcel. The non-ad valorem lines are flat charges, listed separately. We print no millage, no total and no line amount except the one sampled solid waste charge.
The Lee County Tax Collector publishes each parcel's bill, and the Lee County Property Appraiser shows the values behind it. Unpaid taxes become a lien on the parcel under s. 197.122, so the closing agent checks the bill and prorates the year's taxes at closing. Florida's sale contracts also carry a property tax disclosure under s. 689.261, which warns a buyer not to rely on the seller's current taxes.
Bay Haven's 2026 county just values run from $243,126 to $268,885 on ground-floor units and from $271,160 to $285,056 on upper units, on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll. Just value is not market value; it is the Property Appraiser's starting figure, before any assessment limit or exemption.
The Property Appraiser sets just value each year from a mass appraisal of the county. Recorded sales are a different measure. Lee County recorded 7 qualified sales at Bay Haven in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $389,000, and a just value can sit well apart from what a unit sells for.
A buyer uses the just value for one purpose: reading the tax bill. A seller uses it for none of the pricing work. The price of a Bay Haven unit comes from its plan, its floor, its condition, its documents, its flood and repair history and the recorded sales of matching units, not from the roll.
Bay Haven owners who make a unit their permanent residence can apply for Florida's homestead exemption, which lowers the taxable value and brings in the Save Our Homes limit on yearly increases in assessed value. On the 2026 roll, 18 of the 44 Bay Haven units carry a homestead exemption.
That count is a fact about the parcels' filings, not about the people in them. It matters to a buyer because a unit with a long-held exemption can carry a bill well apart from what a new owner will pay, while a unit without one is assessed without the limit. The exemption line on each seller's bill shows which case applies.
The exemption is set out in s. 196.031, the application rules in s. 196.011, and the Save Our Homes limit in s. 193.155. We print no exemption amount and no cap figure. A buyer who will live in the unit files a new application with the Lee County Property Appraiser after closing, by the county's deadline.
Bay Haven buyers should expect the assessed value to reset after the purchase. Under Florida's Save Our Homes rules, the assessment limit a seller built up belongs to that seller, so the unit is assessed fresh for the buyer, and the next bill can differ from the seller's.
Because the reset follows the sale, the seller's bill is a guide to the lines on the bill, not a forecast of the buyer's. The property tax disclosure in a Florida sale contract says the same thing in its own words, and it is worth reading slowly.
A buyer moving from another Florida homestead asks about the state's portability rules in s. 193.155 and files the paperwork with the Property Appraiser. We do not estimate tax bills, and we do not estimate any portability benefit.
Bay Haven bills carry non-ad valorem lines for services, and one sampled unit's bill showed a solid waste charge of $376.41 a year in Solid Waste Service Area 2. No community development district was found on the roll. Confirm every line on the exact unit's bill with the Lee County Tax Collector.
A non-ad valorem line is a flat charge for a service, not a tax on value, so it does not change with the unit's assessment. The sampled solid waste figure is one unit's bill, and other units can show different lines; read the bill for the unit under contract.
If a line appears that the buyer does not recognise, ask the Tax Collector which authority levies it. The Iona McGregor Fire taxing district appears among the ad valorem authorities on the bill, and its millage is the district's to set each year.
Bay Haven owners pay several recurring charges outside the county tax bill: the Bay Haven condominium assessment, the Coco Bay community assessment, the HO-6 premium and, for a mortgaged unit in Zone AE, a flood premium. Gate transponders are bought at the Kelly Greens price. Any special assessment is billed by the association that levies it.
Neither association publishes its budget openly, so the assessment side of the picture comes from documents: the current budget of each association and an estoppel certificate from each, which states the current assessment, its due dates and anything owed on the unit at closing.
The insurance premiums come from quotes, not from the associations. Ask for the HO-6 and flood quotes early, with the master insurance summary and the building's elevation certificate in hand. Together with the county bill, those documents show every recurring cost on a unit without any estimate from us.
Bay Haven addresses were not checked one by one, but neighboring Kelly Greens, about 0.3 mile east, falls in the School District of Lee County's 2026-2027 Elementary Proximity Zone O, Middle Zone MM and High School South Zone sub-zone 1, with placement by capacity. Confirm each Bay Haven address with the district's School Site Locator.
Data updated: November 2026 (School District of Lee County, 2026-2027 proximity zones read at neighboring Kelly Greens; Student Enrollment Plan 2026-2027).
Lee County assigns students by proximity zone rather than to one school per address. Each zone lists several schools, and the district places a student among them according to the choices made and each school's capacity. The zones read at Kelly Greens, about 0.3 mile east of Bay Haven, are:
The district publishes its school zones page and its 2026-2027 Student Enrollment Plan. We print no grade, rating or ranking for any school, and we do not use schools to describe the community or the people in it.
Selling your condo in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Buying a condo in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent you when buying.
Bay Haven's neighbor Kelly Greens sits in Elementary Proximity Zone O under the School District of Lee County's 2026-2027 plan, which lists Heights, Rayma C. Page, Tanglewood and Villas elementary schools. Students at Bay Haven addresses would choose among a zone's schools, and the district places each by capacity.
A choice is a request, not a guarantee. The enrollment plan sets out how requests are handled, the deadlines and the order in which the district fills seats.
Because the zone was read next door rather than at each Bay Haven building, run the exact unit address in the district's locator and save the result with its date. Zones are the district's to set and can change from one plan year to the next.
Bay Haven's neighbor Kelly Greens sits in Middle Zone MM, which lists Cypress Lake Middle and Lexington Middle under the School District of Lee County's 2026-2027 plan. Placement follows the district's choice process and each school's capacity, so a buyer timing a move around a school year reads the plan first.
The district's process runs on its own calendar. A household moving in partway through a school year asks the district how a mid-year placement works for a new address and what documents it needs to show the new address.
A listing page or a sales sheet is the wrong place to settle a school question. The district's answer for the exact Bay Haven address is the one to keep.
Bay Haven's neighbor Kelly Greens sits in the High School South Zone, sub-zone 1, which lists Cypress Lake High, Dunbar High, Fort Myers High and South Fort Myers High under the School District of Lee County's 2026-2027 plan. Placement depends on the choices made and each school's capacity.
Busing, programs and enrollment rules can change from one school year to the next. Read the current year's plan rather than an older copy, and ask the district directly about any program a student needs.
A Coco Bay listing in 2026 named one school in each zone, which is consistent with the zones but is not an assignment. The district's locator result for the exact address is the document to rely on.
Bay Haven students would be placed under the School District of Lee County's 2026-2027 Student Enrollment Plan, which explains that choices are made among the schools in a proximity zone and that placement depends on capacity. The zone sets the list of choices; capacity at each school sets the result.
That is different from a one-school boundary. Two students at the same address can be placed at different schools in the same zone, depending on their choices, the timing of their applications and the space at each school.
The Student Enrollment Plan sets the rules. A buyer who needs a particular school for a particular year asks the district about that school's capacity and the application window before fixing a closing date.
Bay Haven buyers confirm the zones for a unit by entering the exact address, with its building number on Coco Hammock Way, in the School District of Lee County's School Site Locator, reached from the district's school zones page. Save the result with its date and keep it with the property file.
Start at the district's school zones page. The eleven Bay Haven buildings stand in one line on the lake's west shore, close together, but the district's result for the exact address is the one to rely on.
If a buyer is comparing a Bay Haven unit with a home elsewhere in south Fort Myers, run both addresses, because two places a short drive apart can sit in different zones.
Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. and Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. have no say in school placement; the School District of Lee County sets proximity zones and places students by choice and capacity. The district's answer for the exact Bay Haven address is the one to rely on.
The declaration, use restrictions and budgets cover the buildings, the lakes, the roads, leasing, pets and assessments. They say nothing about schools, and no association can promise a placement.
An owner who leases a unit reads the Coco Bay lease rules first: whole units only, no lease shorter than 30 consecutive days and no more than three leases a year. Those rules, not the school district, decide when a lease can start. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven sits inside Coco Bay, reached through the Kelly Greens gates off Summerlin Road, with Bunche Beach Preserve, the Sanibel Causeway, Fort Myers Beach and HealthPark Medical Center nearby, and downtown Fort Myers, Gulf Coast Town Center, Southwest Florida International Airport and Coconut Point in Estero farther out.
Data updated: November 2026 (approximate free-flow drive times from the middle of Bay Haven, routed by a public routing service, November 2026; Lee County's land stewardship plan for San Carlos Bay, Bunche Beach Preserve; WGCU, March 30, 2026).
The table gives distances and free-flow times with no traffic. Real trips run longer, most of all in season and at rush hour, so treat each figure as the floor, not the usual.
Approximate free-flow drive times from the middle of Bay Haven, routed by a public routing service, November 2026; add time in season (January to April).
Destination | Distance | Free-flow time |
|---|---|---|
Bunche Beach Preserve | about 2.9 miles | about 8 minutes |
Sanibel Causeway toll plaza (Punta Rassa) | about 4.8 miles | about 10 minutes |
Fort Myers Beach (Lynn Hall Park, Times Square area) | about 4.6 miles | about 11 minutes; season traffic on San Carlos Boulevard adds time |
HealthPark Medical Center (from neighboring Kelly Greens) | about 3.9 miles | about 9 minutes |
I-75 at Daniels Parkway (Exit 131) | about 12.7 miles | about 23 minutes |
Downtown Fort Myers | about 11.9 miles | about 24 minutes |
Gulf Coast Town Center | about 14.0 miles | about 26 minutes |
Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) terminal | about 15.6 miles | about 29 minutes |
Coconut Point (Estero) | about 16.6 miles | about 29 minutes |
Downtown Naples (Fifth Avenue South) | about 34.5 miles | about 58 minutes |
Every trip from Bay Haven starts on Coco Hammock Way and leaves through the Kelly Greens roads and gates under the recorded 2004 access easement, then reaches Summerlin Road. A buyer who wants to test a routine drives it at the hour it would happen, in season, before deciding. In an emergency, call 911.
Bay Haven's nearest beach access is Bunche Beach Preserve on San Carlos Bay, about 2.9 miles and about 8 minutes away on free-flow routing. Lee County manages the preserve as conservation land, so its hours, parking and rules are the county's to set and can change after storms or during repairs.
Lee County publishes its land stewardship plan for San Carlos Bay, Bunche Beach Preserve, which describes the preserve's habitats, access and management.
Access can close for work. WGCU reported on March 30, 2026 a temporary beach access closure at San Carlos Bay, Bunche Beach Preserve. Check the county's notices before a visit.
Bay Haven sits about 4.8 miles from the Sanibel Causeway toll plaza at Punta Rassa and about 4.6 miles from Lynn Hall Park on Fort Myers Beach on free-flow routing. Season traffic on San Carlos Boulevard adds time to the Fort Myers Beach trip, and the causeway route runs slower in season too.
Both routes carry visitor traffic in the busy months, and the free-flow minutes in the table describe an empty road. Our Fort Myers Beach guide covers the island itself.
Beach parks set their own parking, hours and closures, and access can change after a storm season. Check before a trip.
Bay Haven's nearest full hospital checked is HealthPark Medical Center, about 3.9 miles and about 9 minutes away on free-flow routing measured from neighboring Kelly Greens. For an emergency, call 911 rather than driving; the route figures are for planning appointments and visits, not urgent care.
A buyer plans routine visits from the table's figure plus time for season and rush hour. The trip runs out through the Kelly Greens gates to Summerlin Road, so the gate exit is part of every route.
Bay Haven is in unincorporated Lee County, inside the Iona McGregor Fire taxing district on the tax roll. A buyer who wants to know which fire station serves the exact address asks the district directly.
Bay Haven owners run daily errands along the Summerlin Road and McGregor Boulevard corridors, with Bell Tower Shops about 16 minutes away measured from neighboring Kelly Greens, Gulf Coast Town Center about 14.0 miles away and Coconut Point in Estero about 16.6 miles away on free-flow routing.
We name places by what they are and where they sit, and we make no claim that any store or centre changes the value of a Bay Haven unit. A buyer who wants the latest stores, hours or tenants checks with each place directly.
The larger centres off I-75 share the interstate route, so the trip to them runs slower in season. Downtown Fort Myers, about 11.9 miles away, is reached by Summerlin Road or McGregor Boulevard.
Bay Haven owners reach I-75 at Daniels Parkway, Exit 131, about 12.7 miles and about 23 minutes away on free-flow routing, and Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) terminal about 15.6 miles and about 29 minutes away. Allow extra time in season.
Rush hour shapes the trip to the interstate as much as the distance does. Downtown Naples, about 34.5 miles and about 58 minutes away on free-flow routing, is the longest trip in the table.
RSW is the region's commercial airport. A buyer who flies often checks the route at the times flights usually leave and land, because the table's figure describes an empty road.
Bay Haven sits inside Coco Bay, and Coco Bay is reached through Kelly Greens Golf and Country Club's roads and gates under a recorded 2004 access easement. Kelly Greens' golf course adjoins Coco Bay, but the easement grants road and utility rights only, not club or golf rights.
Kelly Greens is a separate golf community with its own associations, documents and 939 deeded memberships tied to homes whose legal descriptions read Kelly Greens, and Coco Bay homes are not among them under the Coco Bay and Kelly Greens access easement. Ask the Kelly Greens club office what, if any, access it sells to Coco Bay owners.
Farther along the same south Fort Myers corridor, Gulf Harbour Yacht and Country Club is a separate club community with its own guide. Each neighbour has its own recorded documents, and no neighbour's amenities come with a Bay Haven unit.
Bay Haven units receive water and sewer from Lee County Utilities and electric service from Florida Power and Light. A buyer sets up the electric account in the new owner's name before closing and asks the association which utility charges, if any, the condominium budget pays for the building.
Water and sewer arrangements in a condominium can run through a building meter or a unit meter, and the declaration and budget say which. Ask the association whether water appears in the condominium budget or on the owner's own bill, so the buyer reads every utility cost once and only once.
After Ian, the Coco Bay association moved common-area irrigation from the lakes to a freshwater well, and that cost sits with the community association rather than with each unit. Ask for the community budget to see how irrigation is carried today.
Bay Haven is one of several Iona choices a buyer may weigh, alongside Mandolin Bay, Royal Pointe at Majestic Palms, Coco Bay's own houses and Kelly Greens next door. We compared them on the same 24-month Lee County window, by legal description, so each row counts the same kind of recorded sale. The table shows spread, not rank.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County recorded sales, qualified sales over $100,000, sale data through October 21, 2026, by legal description; the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for unit counts and years built).
We compared Bay Haven with Mandolin Bay, Royal Pointe at Majestic Palms, Coco Bay's own houses and Kelly Greens on the same 24-month county window. We tracked the 7 qualified Bay Haven sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026 and matched each to its floor plan by living area on the roll. Every row uses the same window end and the same rule: a median prints only where a row has at least 10 qualified sales.
Qualified sales over $100,000 recorded by Lee County, 24 months to October 21, 2026, by legal description; median printed only at 10 or more sales
Community | Homes on the roll | Built | Stories or type | Qualified sales, 24 months | Range | Median |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bay Haven | 44 condo units | 2004 to 2005 | two stories | 7 | $325,000 to $389,000 | not printed (under 10) |
72 condo units | 2004 | two stories | 10 | $195,000 to $310,000 | $237,250 | |
Royal Pointe at Majestic Palms | 244 condo units on the roll | 2006 to 2023 | condominium; ask its association | 22 | $195,000 to $330,000 | $245,000 |
Coco Bay single-family homes (same gates and amenities) | 99 single-family homes | mostly 2005 and 2006 | houses, 2,032 to 2,801 sq ft | 16 | $392,500 to $695,000 | $589,500 |
Kelly Greens Golf and Country Club (next door; condos and houses combined) | 946 parcels | 1988 to 1998 | condos and houses | 122 | $145,000 to $1,200,000 | $250,000 |
The five rows differ in home type, size, age, height, association structure and club model, so the table shows the spread of recorded prices in each, not a ranking.
These are Lee County recorded sales by legal description (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
Selling your condo in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Buying a condo in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent you when buying.
Bay Haven recorded 7 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $389,000, Lee County recorded sales. Seven is under our floor of 10, so no median prints. The range describes the units that sold, three ground-floor and four upper, not a price for any one unit.
By plan in the same window, the 1,510 square foot ground-floor units recorded 3 sales, $325,000 to $389,000, and the 1,911 square foot upper units recorded 4 sales, $332,000 to $348,000. Every Bay Haven unit on the roll has three bedrooms, two baths and an attached garage.
Seven sales across two plans and eleven buildings are too few to stand in for a price level. Each one reflects a unit's floor, condition, lake view and repair history. That is why we read the sales one by one against the unit in question rather than leaning on the range alone.
Bay Haven and Mandolin Bay are both two-story Iona condominiums from the mid-2000s on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll: Bay Haven with 44 units built 2004 to 2005, Mandolin Bay with 72 units built 2004. Mandolin Bay recorded 10 qualified sales in the 24 months, enough for a median of $237,250.
Both sit outside the text of Florida's SIRS and milestone inspection laws on building height, so the same document list applies to each: the reserve schedule, the master insurance summary, the budget and the association's written confirmation of height.
The two differ in structure. Bay Haven units sit inside a larger gated community with a second association layer and a shared clubhouse, and every Bay Haven unit on the roll carries three bedrooms and an attached garage. Mandolin Bay's own guide covers its plans, association and storm history; read it for its figures rather than taking any from this page.
Bay Haven holds 44 units built 2004 to 2005, while Royal Pointe at Majestic Palms holds 244 condo units on the roll, built 2006 to 2023. Royal Pointe recorded 22 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $195,000 to $330,000 with a median of $245,000, Lee County recorded sales.
A condominium of 244 units built across many years holds a wider mix of buildings, plans and ages than an 11-building condominium completed in about a year. That mix shapes its median, so the figure describes Royal Pointe's sales, not a yardstick for a Bay Haven unit.
Building height decides which state inspection rules apply. A buyer comparing a Royal Pointe unit with a Bay Haven unit asks each association how many habitable stories its buildings have and whether any milestone inspection or structural integrity reserve study applies, then reads the reports or the written answer.
Bay Haven and Coco Bay's 99 single-family homes share the same gates, roads, lakes and Amenity Center under Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. The houses run 2,032 to 2,801 square feet and recorded 16 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $392,500 to $695,000 with a median of $589,500.
The two products differ in what an owner holds. A Bay Haven owner holds a condominium unit with shared walls, a shared roof and an association that insures the building; a Coco Bay homeowner holds a house and lot and insures the house. The insurance, maintenance and reserve questions differ accordingly.
What the two share is the community layer: the Coco Bay use restrictions, the community budget and the access easement through Kelly Greens. A buyer weighing one against the other reads the same Coco Bay documents for both, then the Bay Haven condominium documents for a unit.
Bay Haven's neighbor Kelly Greens Golf and Country Club combines condos and houses across 946 parcels built 1988 to 1998 on the roll, with 122 qualified sales in the 24 months, $145,000 to $1,200,000, median $250,000. Kelly Greens has 939 deeded memberships; Coco Bay homes are not among them.
The recorded 2004 access easement gives Coco Bay owners a perpetual, shared right to use the Kelly Greens roads and gates, and Coco Bay owners pay the same price Kelly Greens members pay for gate transponders. The easement grants road and utility rights only. It does not make a Bay Haven unit part of the club.
A buyer comparing a Kelly Greens condominium with a Bay Haven unit compares different document sets: the club's membership documents and its association documents on one side, the Bay Haven and Coco Bay documents on the other. Ask the Kelly Greens club office what, if any, access it sells to Coco Bay owners before counting on golf.
Bay Haven buyers comparing Iona condominiums get the clearest answer unit by unit. Line up each unit's declaration, its building's height and age, the roof and repair permits, the flood zone, base flood elevation and elevation certificate, each association's budget, reserves and master insurance summary, and any storm claim or assessment history.
Flood history belongs in the comparison as a document question. Bay Haven's Ian flood claims and the court case are public record; for any other condominium, ask its association what its buildings sustained in 2022 and 2024, what its insurance paid and whether owners were assessed.
Then put the insurance quotes side by side: the HO-6, the unit flood policy and each master policy's deductible. Those costs follow the building and the documents, so they belong next to the recorded sales.
Bay Haven is compared with its neighbours only on facts measured the same way for every row: homes on the roll, years built, qualified sales over $100,000 in the same 24-month Lee County window and a median only at 10 or more sales. Each row holds its own mix of plans, sizes, ages, rules and club model.
A ranking would describe that mix, not a unit. An 11-building, two-story condominium with garages, a 72-unit two-story condominium, a 244-unit condominium built from 2006 to 2023, a group of houses and a golf community with condos and houses do not sell the same product.
What a buyer can compare is the paperwork on two specific homes: the plan and floor, the building's roof and permits, the flood zone and elevation certificate, the declaration, the rules and the assessments. Those papers decide the comparison for a particular unit.
Bay Haven units follow the Coco Bay Use Restrictions, Exhibit C, which Coco Bay revised in March 2026: whole-unit leases only, no lease shorter than 30 consecutive days, no more than three leases a year, common household pets with pit bull type breeds barred, no trailers, boats, trucks or campers outside the garage, and approved shutters.
Data updated: November 2026 (Coco Bay Use Restrictions, Exhibit C; Coco Bay rules revised March 2026; Coco Bay Community Association FAQ, August 2025).
We read the recorded 2004 Coco Bay and Kelly Greens access easement and the Coco Bay use restrictions. The Coco Bay Use Restrictions, Exhibit C apply across all 143 homes, the 44 Bay Haven units included. Coco Bay adopted revised rules in March 2026, and it posts its documents on its governing documents page.
Bay Haven's own condominium documents may add rules on top of the Coco Bay restrictions. Those condominium documents are not posted openly, so a buyer asks the Bay Haven association for them. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven leasing follows the Coco Bay restrictions: whole units only, no time-sharing, no lease shorter than 30 consecutive days, no more than three leases per unit per calendar year, and a copy of each lease delivered to the association. Bay Haven's condominium documents may add further leasing terms.
Three leases a year at a 30-day minimum sets the outer limit; it does not describe how any unit is used. Read the restrictions for the exact wording on renewals and extensions, because how a renewal counts toward the yearly limit is a question of the text.
Ask the Bay Haven association whether its declaration requires approval of a lease, how long approval takes and whether it charges an application fee. Condominium lease rules can change by amendment under s. 718.110, and an amendment can treat owners differently by purchase date, so read the current recorded version.
Bay Haven sellers with a tenant in place have the signed lease, proof that a copy went to the association as the Coco Bay restrictions require, any Bay Haven approval, the lease end date and the deposit records ready for the buyer. The declaration and restrictions decide what notice the associations need after a sale.
A buyer who plans to live in the unit needs to know when the lease ends and whether the tenant will leave by closing. A buyer who plans to keep the tenant needs the lease, the deposit records and the associations' requirements for a new owner.
Showings in a leased unit run on the lease's notice terms. Agree a showing plan with the tenant in writing, and count the gate transponders, keys and garage openers that must change hands at closing.
Bay Haven units follow the Coco Bay restrictions on pets: common household pets are allowed, and pit bull type breeds are barred. Assistance animals are handled under fair housing law; ask the association. Bay Haven's condominium documents may add limits on number, size or registration.
Pet rules in a condominium can differ for owners and for tenants, and the condominium documents may set rules the community restrictions do not. Ask both associations, in writing, for the current pet rules and whether any registration is required.
Ask how the association handles a request for an assistance animal, so the process is known before closing. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven units each carry an attached garage on the county roll, and the Coco Bay restrictions bar trailers, boats, trucks and campers unless kept in the garage. A buyer with a work truck, a boat or a camper reads the restriction's exact wording before writing an offer.
The garage does double duty: it is where a restricted vehicle may be kept, and it is storage space for the unit. Measure it against the vehicles that will use it.
Ask the associations where guests park, whether overnight parking on the roads is limited and how gate transponders are issued. Coco Bay owners pay the same price Kelly Greens members pay for transponders under the recorded 2004 access easement, so count the devices that convey with the unit and confirm on the closing statement. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven units follow the Coco Bay restrictions on hurricane shutters: galvanized panels must be painted, and roll-down or accordion shutters need approval under board standards. Listings describe electric hurricane shutters on some units; ask for the approval behind any shutter on the unit under contract.
The condominium act allows boards to set hurricane shutter specifications and addresses who installs and maintains them in s. 718.113. The Bay Haven declaration says whether shutters belong to the owner or the association.
Ask for the permit and approval behind any shutter installed after the buildings were completed, and check that the wind mitigation report on file reflects the shutters as they stand. Temporary panels should be counted, labelled and stored where the next owner can find them.
Bay Haven's buildings stand in a north-south line on the main lake's west shore, and the Coco Bay restrictions bar watercraft, docks and swimming in the lakes. The two association lakes, about 13.27 acres and 2.43 acres, are joined by a pipe and belong to the community association.
The lakes are drainage as well as views. After Ian, surge put salt water in both lakes, and the community association moved irrigation to a freshwater well. Questions about the lake banks, the water and any lake work go to Coco Bay Community Association, Inc.
A buyer drawn by a lake view reads the rule plainly: the view is the use. Ask the association whether any bank or drainage work is planned near the building under contract, and read the survey or plat for the easements along the shore.
Bay Haven owners belong to two boards, each with five resident directors, according to the Coco Bay August 2025 FAQ. The Coco Bay board meets at the Amenity Center on the third Wednesday of each month, and Coco Bay has adopted an electronic voting resolution for owner votes.
Board meetings are where budgets, assessments, rules and repair contracts are decided, and the minutes record them. A buyer reads the last year of minutes from both boards before the offer goes firm.
Disputes between an owner and a condominium association over certain matters go to the state's process under s. 718.1255, and fines and owner obligations are set in s. 718.303. Ask the Bay Haven association how and when its board meets.
Bay Haven buyers ask both associations, in one written request each, for the recorded declaration with all amendments, the current rules, any lease application and the pet rules. The Coco Bay restrictions are posted on the association site; Bay Haven's condominium documents sit behind an owner login.
Ask the seller to send the requests the day the contract is signed, and read the contract's terms for how long the buyer has to review the documents.
Read the lease, pet, vehicle and shutter sections against the buyer's own plans for the unit. A rule a buyer cannot live with is far easier to act on inside the review period than after closing. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven offers 44 three-bedroom condominium units with attached garages in eleven two-story buildings on a lake inside gated Coco Bay, outside the text of Florida's SIRS and milestone laws. Bay Haven also brings FEMA Zone AE, Evacuation Zone A, an Ian flood claim history, two association layers and too few recent sales for a median.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for all 44 units; Lee County recorded sales, qualified sales over $100,000, sale data through October 21, 2026; FEMA effective flood map, FIRM panel 12071C0414G; Lee County's evacuation zones; the Eleventh Circuit opinion, October 23, 2026; approximate free-flow drive times routed by a public routing service, November 2026).
Each point is a property fact from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, Lee County recorded sales, FEMA's flood map, Lee County's evacuation zones, the recorded Coco Bay documents, the court record or the drive-time table. Which side of the ledger a fact sits on depends on the buyer's plans for the unit.
Bay Haven has these facts in its favour on paper: three-bedroom, two-bath units with attached garages in two-story buildings, lake frontage on the county roll, gated access through the Kelly Greens gates under a recorded easement, a shared Amenity Center with a pool, and no community development district found.
The pros on paper:
Bay Haven trade-offs are just as factual: FEMA Zone AE across the buildings with a base flood elevation of 10 to 11 feet NAVD88, Evacuation Zone A, Ian flood damage and a flood claim suit that ended in judgment for the insurer, two associations that do not publish budgets openly, and few recorded sales.
The trade-offs on paper:
The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven recorded sales show what units sold for, not what a given unit is worth today. Lee County recorded 7 qualified sales at Bay Haven in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $389,000, and 4 in the latest 12 months, from $325,000 to $347,000.
We tracked every qualified sale Lee County has recorded on the 44 Bay Haven units since the 2004 and 2005 sellout: 96 qualified sales over $100,000 in the index. In the recent window, the larger upper units have not sold for more than the ground units: 24 months, upper units $332,000 to $348,000 against ground units $325,000 to $389,000. Each sale reflects one unit's floor, condition, lake view and repair history.
These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
A buyer reads the sales by plan and floor, matching each to the unit in question. A seller does the same, then adds the documents: the elevation certificate, the Ian repair record, the master insurance summary and both associations' budgets and reserves. A Fort Myers home valuation puts those pieces together for one address.
Bay Haven closings bring together documents from five sources: the title agent's commitment and the recorded declarations, the Bay Haven association's budget, reserves, insurance summary and estoppel certificate, the Coco Bay association's budget and estoppel certificate, the insurance agent's HO-6 and flood quotes, and the seller's permits, disclosures and repair records.
Read them in the order the money moves. The two estoppel certificates state what is owed to each association at closing. The insurance declarations pages show the lender what protects the unit and the building. The tax bill and the closing agent's proration settle the county side. The declarations and the Coco Bay restrictions set what the new owner may do with the unit from the first day. Florida's brokerage relationship rules in s. 475.278 set out how an agent represents each side through those steps.
Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, walk buyers and sellers through these documents unit by unit in Bay Haven. See how we help when you buy a home in Fort Myers, or start at sell my home in Fort Myers.
Selling your condo in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Buying a condo in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent you when buying.
Bay Haven sellers need a team that prices from Lee County's recorded sales, not a portal estimate. If you're searching for a Bay Haven listing agent, or thinking, 'I need someone to sell my Bay Haven condo...', McGreevy and Comisar prices each unit on its floor plan, its floor, its condition, its flood file and both associations' documents.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County recorded sales, qualified sales over $100,000, sale data through October 21, 2026; the Lee County Property Appraiser roll; the Coco Bay use restrictions and FAQ posted by the community association; the federal appeals court record; our analysis).
We read the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for all 44 Bay Haven units, with plan, year built and just value, and we tracked every qualified sale Lee County has recorded on them since the 2004 and 2005 sellout: 96 qualified sales over $100,000 in the index. We tracked the 7 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026 and matched each to its floor plan by living area on the roll, so a ground-floor unit is never priced from an upper unit's sale.
Lee County recorded 7 qualified sales in Bay Haven in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $389,000, and 4 in the latest 12 months, from $325,000 to $347,000. No Bay Haven window reaches 10 qualified sales, so the sales are shown as counts and ranges rather than reduced to a median.
These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
What sets a Bay Haven sale apart is how few plans carry every sale and how differently they have traded. The Lee County Property Appraiser roll lists 44 condominium units in eleven two-story buildings lettered AA to KK, four units each: 22 ground-floor units of 1,510 sq ft and 22 upper units of 1,911 sq ft, all 3 bedrooms and 2 baths with an attached garage, built 2004 for Building KK and 2005 for the other ten. Because the buildings share an age and a builder, buyers separate one unit from another on plan, floor, lake view, condition and updates inside the unit, and on the association file.
We read the 24-month sales by plan: 3 ground-floor sales from $325,000 to $389,000 and 4 upper-unit sales from $332,000 to $348,000. In those recorded sales the larger upper units have not sold for more than the ground units; per square foot that is about $174 to $182 for upper units against about $215 to $258 for ground units. We do not claim a cause. Stairs, flood exposure and insurance on a ground unit, the lake view and condition all enter a buyer's decision, so we price your unit from its own plan's sales and its own file. The county index shows no recorded Bay Haven sale between May 29 and October 21, 2026, so we read current market activity before we set a price.
The association file is the next thing buyers ask for. A Bay Haven owner belongs to two associations: Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. for the buildings, insurance and condominium budget, and Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. for the roads, lakes and Amenity Center clubhouse. Neither publishes its budget openly, so before the listing goes live we ask for the current budgets of both associations, the reserve schedule, the master insurance summary and the estoppel figures from each, and we hand the buyer's agent the declaration and rules with the first offer. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
The flood file finishes the package. Lee County's republished effective FEMA layer places the Bay Haven buildings in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 10 to 11 feet NAVD88, and Lee County places them in Evacuation Zone A. A federal appeals court opinion states that Bay Haven's buildings were flooded in Hurricane Ian, so buyers ask what the master flood and wind policies cover now, whether any Ian repair cost beyond the flood payments was assessed to owners and what the reserves hold. Your HO-6 declarations page, any flood policy declarations page and the building's elevation certificate answer the first insurance questions.
Selling your condo in Bay Haven? Start with our free home valuation, read how we sell a home in Fort Myers, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying a condo in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers.
Bay Haven owners can start with our free home valuation, and our Fort Myers home valuation page explains the method in depth. We then walk the unit and refine the figure from its plan and floor, lake view, condition, updates, flood file, both associations' documents and Bay Haven's recorded sales.
The online figure is a starting point. The Lee County Property Appraiser roll gives a second reference: 2026 just values run $243,126 to $268,885 for ground units and $271,160 to $285,056 for upper units. Just value is an assessment figure, not market value, so we use it only as a cross-check beside the recorded sales.
Talk to Jesse direct: (239) 898-6072, text or call.
Bay Haven sellers should gather the deed, the HO-6 insurance declarations page, any flood policy declarations page, the tax bill, permits for any work inside the unit, the gate transponder details, and both associations' declarations, rules and current budgets, with the reserve schedule and master insurance summary. Those papers answer a buyer, a lender and an insurer.
The title commitment will list the recorded condominium declaration and the Coco Bay community documents that bind the unit, and the closing agent reads them beside the two estoppel certificates. A buyer's insurer reads the master policy summary to see what the association insures and what the unit owner insures, so have the current one, not an old copy from a closing years ago.
Bay Haven sales close with two association files, the condominium association and the Coco Bay community association, so the closing agent orders an estoppel certificate from each once a contract is signed. We ask for both early, so any open balance or assessment can be settled before the closing date rather than on it.
Chapter 718 governs condominium estoppel certificates, and s. 718.116 sets the rules on assessments and estoppel. A transfer fee or capital contribution is not published by either association, so ask both and write any charge into the contract terms. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven has two plans on the roll, both 3 bedrooms and 2 baths with an attached garage: ground-floor units of 1,510 sq ft and upper units of 1,911 sq ft. We price each from its own plan's recorded sales first, then from floor, lake view, condition and updates inside the unit.
Over 60 months the county recorded 5 ground-floor sales from $325,000 to $430,000 and 4 upper-unit sales from $332,000 to $348,000. Each count is under 10, so they are listed as ranges, never reduced to a median. Listings quote other sizes, so the page uses the county living-area figures and a buyer confirms each unit's measured size.
These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
Bay Haven sellers should answer Ian with the public record and their own papers. The federal appeals court opinion states that Bay Haven's buildings were flooded; each building carried its own National Flood Insurance Program building policy, signed proofs of loss per building ran $221,023 to $262,656, about $2.57 million in total, and the insurer paid them.
The association's suit for contractor invoices beyond those amounts lost on summary judgment in January 2026, and the appeals court affirmed on October 23, 2026. Ask the association whether any Ian repair cost beyond the flood payments was or will be assessed to owners, and hand buyers your own repair invoices and permits for work inside the unit.
Bay Haven sellers start with a free home valuation, and we build the price from Lee County's qualified recorded sales inside Bay Haven, read by floor plan, then from your floor, lake view, condition, updates, flood and insurance documents and both associations' files, gathered before the first showing.
We gather the HO-6 and flood declarations pages, the elevation certificate, the tax bill and both associations' declarations, rules, budgets, reserve schedule and master insurance summary first. Read how we sell a home in Fort Myers, then Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying instead? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers.
Bay Haven buyers and sellers work directly with Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, who have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and lead the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, pricing every condo in Bay Haven from Lee County's recorded sales and the unit's own documents rather than a portal estimate.
Data updated: November 2026 (team honors as published by McGreevy and Comisar; Gulfshore Life Magazine; RealTrends 2026).
As the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate, and McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales. The Domain Realty Group team is the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026). Read more about our team. Meet Jesse McGreevy, who leads the team's listing and seller strategy, and Marc Comisar, who leads buyer representation and negotiation.
Selling in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610, or read about buying a home in Fort Myers and how we represent buyers. You can also contact us any time, or meet us at our office on South Tamiami Trail in Bonita Springs.
Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are top-reviewed realtors for Bay Haven, and the reviews on the team's Google Business Profile describe what a seller or buyer in Bay Haven needs most: honest advice, steady communication and a team that sells.
★★★★★ "Their knowledge of the Southwest Florida market really stood out, and you can tell they genuinely care about their clients and getting the best results possible. They were always available to answer questions, kept us informed every step of the way, and paid attention to every detail." Verified Google review
★★★★★ "Marc was great! He helped us find a place that matched our needs, without trying to upsell us into something too big. And he's helped us settle into the area. 100% recommendation!" Verified Google review
★★★★★ "No one knows real estate, especially Florida real estate like Marc and Jesse. Smart and savvy. They also have a great team that is knowledgeable and professional." Verified Google review
Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC).
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team.
Bay Haven buyers ask where the condominium sits, whether it belongs to Coco Bay or Kelly Greens, how many units it holds, what two associations charge, how leasing and pets work, what units have sold for, what the Ian court case means, and which flood, evacuation and school zones apply. Each answer rests on a public record.
Data updated: November 2026 (the Lee County Property Appraiser roll; Lee County recorded sales, sale data through October 21, 2026; Lee County's republished effective FEMA flood layer, panel 12071C0414G; Lee County's evacuation zone map; the Coco Bay use restrictions, easement and FAQ; the federal appeals court record; the School District of Lee County's 2026-2027 proximity zones).
These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
Bay Haven sits on Coco Hammock Way inside the gated Coco Bay community, reached through the Kelly Greens gates off Summerlin Road in the Iona area of south Fort Myers, ZIP 33908. The mailing city is Fort Myers, but the address lies in unincorporated Lee County, so county services serve it.
The eleven buildings stand in a north-south line on the west shore of Coco Bay's main lake, with the Coco Bay Amenity Center clubhouse at the south end of the line.
Bay Haven is the condominium section of Coco Bay, a gated Centex Homes community of 143 homes: 99 single-family homes plus the 44 Bay Haven units, on a 60.2-acre tract. Coco Bay is not part of Kelly Greens Golf and Country Club; a recorded 2004 easement gives Coco Bay owners a perpetual right to use the Kelly Greens roads and gates.
The easement grants road and utility rights only. Coco Bay owners pay the same price Kelly Greens members pay for gate transponders. Read the Coco Bay and Kelly Greens access easement during your inspection period.
No golf membership comes with a Bay Haven condo under the recorded documents. Bay Haven is not a golf community: the 2004 access easement grants Coco Bay owners road and utility rights through Kelly Greens, not club rights, and Coco Bay homes are not deeded Kelly Greens memberships. One listing site claims otherwise; the recorded documents do not support it.
Ask the Kelly Greens club office what, if any, access it sells to Coco Bay owners, and get the answer in writing before you rely on it.
Bay Haven has 44 condominium units in eleven two-story carriage-home buildings, lettered AA to KK, four units each: two ground-floor units and two upper units. The Lee County Property Appraiser roll lists two plans, both 3 bedrooms and 2 baths with an attached garage: 22 ground-floor units of 1,510 sq ft and 22 upper units of 1,911 sq ft.
Listings quote 1,523 and 1,791 sq ft, and some call the ground plan two bedrooms plus a den, so confirm each unit's measured size. Listings describe two-car attached garages, screened lanais on the lake, electric hurricane shutters and in-unit laundry; confirm what the unit you are buying has.
Centex Homes built and sold Bay Haven, with the land co-owned at the 2004 access easement. The county roll dates Building KK to 2004 and the other ten buildings to 2005, and each building was declared as its own phase of one condominium in 2005. Builder closings ran from December 23, 2004 to July 2005.
The first county renumber date is February 17, 2005, for Building KK, and the last is September 9, 2005, for Building DD. Ask the seller for permits on any work inside the unit since then.
Bay Haven owners belong to two associations. Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. runs the condominium, its buildings, insurance and condo budget. Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. covers all 143 Coco Bay homes, with the roads, lakes, the Amenity Center clubhouse and even the Bay Haven common-element land parcel.
Both boards have five resident directors, per Coco Bay's August 2025 FAQ, and the Coco Bay board meets at the Amenity Center on the third Wednesday of each month. Read the Coco Bay governing documents page.
Bay Haven fees come in two layers: the Bay Haven condominium fee and the Coco Bay community fee. Neither association publishes its budget openly; Bay Haven's pages on the association website are behind an owner login. Listing figures conflict and sometimes mix the two fees, so treat them as hints, not figures.
Coco Bay single-family listings showed a community fee of $1,660 a quarter in 2025 and 2026; the share a condo owner pays is not published. Ask for the current budgets of both associations, the reserve schedule, the master insurance summary and an estoppel certificate from each. The budget, not a listing remark, says what the assessment is and what it covers.
Lee County recorded 4 qualified Bay Haven sales in the 12 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $347,000, and 7 in 24 months, from $325,000 to $389,000. Over 36 months the county recorded 8 sales and over 60 months 9, both from $325,000 to $430,000. No window reaches 10 sales, so no median is printed.
The county index shows no recorded Bay Haven sale between May 29 and October 21, 2026. These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
Not in recent recorded sales. In the 24 months to October 21, 2026, Lee County recorded 4 Bay Haven upper-unit sales from $332,000 to $348,000 and 3 ground-floor sales from $325,000 to $389,000. Per square foot that is about $174 to $182 for upper units against about $215 to $258 for ground units.
The records do not give a cause. Stairs, flood exposure and insurance on a ground unit, the lake view and condition each matter to a buyer, so compare the units you are considering on those points. These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
Yes, on a mortgaged unit. Lee County's republished effective FEMA layer, read November 20, 2026, places the Bay Haven buildings in Zone AE, coastal floodplain, outside the floodway, with a base flood elevation of 10 to 11 feet NAVD88, on FIRM panel 12071C0414G, effective November 17, 2022. Lenders require flood insurance on mortgaged units in Zone AE.
Ground at the buildings is about 8 feet, per public elevation data shown with a 2026 listing. The building's elevation certificate and a lender flood determination decide; ask the association for the certificate. New unincorporated Lee County flood maps are scheduled to take effect March 2, 2027, so check the new map too, on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center.
A federal appeals court opinion states that Bay Haven's buildings were flooded in Hurricane Ian on September 28, 2022. The association insured each of its eleven buildings under its own National Flood Insurance Program building policy written through Hartford, with a $1,000,000 building limit, a $5,000 deductible and no contents coverage.
Signed proofs of loss per building ran $221,023 to $262,656, about $2.57 million in total, and the insurer paid them. After Ian, surge put salt water in both Coco Bay lakes, ending lake-fed irrigation, and irrigation moved to a freshwater well, per Coco Bay's August 2025 FAQ. Read the National Hurricane Center's Ian report for the storm itself.
Bay Haven's association sued for contractor invoices beyond the signed proofs of loss, filed August 2, 2024 in federal court in Fort Myers, lost on summary judgment in January 2026, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit affirmed on October 23, 2026, holding that a signed, sworn proof of loss is required for every dollar claimed.
For a buyer, the questions are practical: was any Ian repair cost beyond the flood payments assessed or proposed to owners, what do the reserves hold now, and what do the current master flood and wind policies cover? Read the appeals court opinion, then ask the association for its answers in writing.
Lee County's evacuation layer places Bay Haven in County Evacuation Zone A, storm surge zone 1. An evacuation zone is not a flood zone: it tells you when a county evacuation order may reach the address, and it does not set an insurance rate.
Check the address on Lee County's Know Your Zone page and see Lee County Emergency Management for shelters each season. The National Storm Surge Hazard Maps show surge risk across the region.
Florida's SIRS rule in s. 718.112 and milestone inspection law in s. 553.899 apply to buildings three habitable stories or more. Bay Haven's buildings are two stories on the county roll, so by that text neither mandate is aimed at them, and no Bay Haven milestone or SIRS filing was found.
Confirm with the association that no building has a third habitable story. Reserves still matter under the general condominium act, so ask for the reserve schedule and any vote to waive or reduce reserves. The state's SIRS reporting page is where filings appear.
Bay Haven leasing follows the Coco Bay use restrictions: whole units only, no time-sharing, no lease shorter than 30 consecutive days, no more than three leases per unit per calendar year, and a copy of each lease to the association. Bay Haven's condominium documents may add rules of their own.
Coco Bay adopted revised rules in March 2026, so read the current set. Read the Coco Bay use restrictions and ask the condominium association for its declaration and rules. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven pets follow the Coco Bay use restrictions, which allow common household pets and bar pit bull type breeds. Assistance animals are handled under fair housing law; ask the association. The condominium association's own documents may add rules, so ask for them with the rest of the file.
The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven parking follows the Coco Bay use restrictions: no trailers, boats, trucks or campers unless kept in the garage. Every Bay Haven unit has an attached garage on the county roll, so plan any second vehicle, a work truck or a boat around that rule before you sign.
Listings describe two-car attached garages; confirm the garage size of the unit you are buying. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
No. Bay Haven's buildings face Coco Bay's main lake, one of two association lakes of about 13.27 acres and 2.43 acres joined by a pipe, and the Coco Bay rules bar watercraft, docks and swimming in the lakes. The lakes are association property, not part of any unit.
The lake view is part of what a buyer weighs; the lake use is set by the rules. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven itself was not tested point by point. Kelly Greens, about 0.3 mile east, tested in 2026-2027 Elementary Proximity Zone O (Heights, Rayma C. Page, Tanglewood, Villas), Middle Zone MM (Cypress Lake Middle, Lexington Middle) and High School South Zone sub-zone 1 (Cypress Lake High, Dunbar High, Fort Myers High, South Fort Myers High).
Placement is by capacity, so students at Bay Haven addresses are confirmed with the district's School Site Locator. Read the district's school zones page and the Student Enrollment Plan.
Bay Haven tax bills carry Lee County ad valorem lines plus non-ad valorem lines. No community development district was found on the roll; Bay Haven units are in the Iona McGregor Fire taxing district, and one sampled unit's bill showed solid waste at $376.41 a year (Solid Waste Service Area 2). We do not estimate tax bills.
Confirm the non-ad valorem lines on the current bill at the Lee County Tax Collector. Association assessments are paid to the two associations, not on the tax bill; confirm them with estoppel certificates.
No. When a Bay Haven condo sells, the assessed value resets on purchase, so the seller's Save Our Homes capped assessment and homestead exemption do not pass to the buyer. If the unit becomes your homestead, apply for your own exemption and read the seller's bill for its line items only.
Read s. 193.155 on the assessment limitation and s. 196.031 on the homestead exemption. We do not estimate tax bills.
Bay Haven owners reach Coco Bay through the Kelly Greens gates under the recorded 2004 access easement, and Coco Bay owners pay the same price Kelly Greens members pay for gate transponders. Kelly Greens maintains the roads and gates it took ownership of to install them.
Ask the seller to hand over the unit's transponders at closing, and ask the Coco Bay association how a new owner registers. The transponder price is set by Kelly Greens, so ask its office for the current figure.
Bay Haven owners insure their own units while the association insures the buildings. The association's flood cover in the court record was building-only National Flood Insurance Program policies, with no contents coverage, so a unit owner needs an HO-6 policy and contents cover, and a lender will require flood insurance on a mortgaged unit in Zone AE.
Ask for the master insurance summary so your insurer can see what the master flood and wind policies cover and what falls to you. Read s. 718.111 on association insurance and FloodSmart on flood policies. We do not quote premiums.
Bay Haven sits in Iona near Bunche Beach Preserve, the Sanibel Causeway at Punta Rassa, Fort Myers Beach, HealthPark Medical Center and the shopping on Summerlin Road and McGregor Boulevard. Season traffic on San Carlos Boulevard adds time on the way to Fort Myers Beach, and every drive runs longer from January to April.
Lee County Utilities supplies water and sewer, and Florida Power and Light supplies electric. Read Lee County's Bunche Beach Preserve stewardship plan and WGCU's report on a 2026 temporary beach access closure there.
Bay Haven sellers ask how a unit is priced from Lee County's recorded sales by floor plan, why upper units have not sold for more, which documents two associations must produce, how to answer the Hurricane Ian and court case questions, and what the flood, evacuation and condo law answers are. Each answer rests on a public record.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County recorded sales, qualified sales over $100,000, sale data through October 21, 2026; the Lee County Property Appraiser roll; Lee County's republished effective FEMA flood layer; Lee County's evacuation zone map; the Coco Bay use restrictions, easement and FAQ; the federal appeals court record; Florida Statutes, Chapter 718; our analysis).
Bay Haven sellers start by pricing from the qualified sales Lee County has recorded inside Bay Haven, read by floor plan, then from their own floor, lake view, condition and updates. Gather the deed, the HO-6 and flood declarations pages, the tax bill, any permits, and both associations' declarations, rules, budgets, reserve schedule and master insurance summary.
Start with our free home valuation, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Bay Haven units are valued from the qualified sales Lee County has recorded inside Bay Haven, read by plan. The county recorded 7 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $389,000, and 4 in the latest 12 months, from $325,000 to $347,000. No window reaches 10 sales, so no median is printed.
These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown. Our Fort Myers home valuation page explains the method.
Bay Haven ground-floor units, 1,510 sq ft on the roll, are priced from ground-floor sales first. Lee County recorded 3 ground-floor sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $325,000 to $389,000, and 5 over 60 months, from $325,000 to $430,000. Each count is under 10, so they are listed as ranges.
Buyers of a ground unit read the flood file closely: Zone AE, the building's elevation certificate, the master flood policy and your own flood and HO-6 declarations pages. Have permits and invoices for any flooring, drywall or cabinet work done inside the unit since Ian. These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
Bay Haven upper units, 1,911 sq ft on the roll, are priced from upper-unit sales first. Lee County recorded 4 upper-unit sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, from $332,000 to $348,000, and the same 4 over 60 months. With fewer than 10 sales, they are listed rather than reduced to a median.
Buyers of an upper unit ask about the stairs, the lake view from the lanai and the building's roof history, which the association can supply. These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
Bay Haven's recorded sales do not give a cause. In the 24 months to October 21, 2026, upper units sold for $332,000 to $348,000 and ground units for $325,000 to $389,000, about $174 to $182 per square foot for upper units against about $215 to $258 for ground units.
Several things a buyer weighs pull in different directions: stairs on an upper unit, flood exposure and insurance on a ground unit, the lake view and the condition of each unit. An upper-unit seller should not assume the larger plan earns a higher price, and a ground-unit seller should have the flood file ready. We price each unit from its own plan's sales and its own documents.
Bay Haven price per square foot shows how the two plans have traded, not what one unit is worth. In the 24 months to October 21, 2026, upper units sold for about $174 to $182 per square foot and ground units for about $215 to $258, on the county's living-area figures.
Listings quote different sizes, 1,523 and 1,791 sq ft, so a per-square-foot figure depends on which measure is used; we use the county living area and a buyer confirms each unit's measured size. We price from the plan's recorded sales and the unit's condition, and use the per-foot range only as context.
No. Just value is an assessment figure, not market value. On the 2026 Lee County Property Appraiser roll, Bay Haven ground units carry just values of $243,126 to $268,885 and upper units $271,160 to $285,056, while recorded sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026 ran $325,000 to $389,000.
The roll values a unit as of January 1 and does not see its condition, updates or view the way a buyer does, so we use just value only as a cross-check beside the recorded sales.
Bay Haven's county index shows no recorded Bay Haven sale between May 29 and October 21, 2026. With 44 units, months without a recorded sale happen, and the county flags new deeds a few weeks after they record, so a recent closing may not be counted yet.
The gap means the most recent recorded price is months old when you list, so we read current market activity, active and pending units, beside the county record before we set a price. These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
Bay Haven qualified sales by year, from Lee County's record: 2016 2 ($245,000 to $257,500), 2017 2 ($258,000 to $268,000), 2018 3 ($240,000 to $285,000), 2019 4 ($250,000 to $292,500), 2020 3 ($269,000 to $282,600), 2021 7 ($265,000 to $455,000), 2023 1 ($340,000), 2024 2 ($348,000 to $430,000), 2025 3 ($325,000 to $389,000) and 2026 to October 21, 3 ($330,000 to $347,000).
Counts this small swing with the units that happen to sell, so the yearly ranges show the spread, not a trend line. Earlier lows were 2011, 3 sales from $140,000 to $242,500, and 2012, 2 sales from $177,500 to $186,100.
Bay Haven's original sales set the base of the county record. Lee County recorded 4 qualified sales in 2004, from $227,900 to $293,300, and 48 in 2005, from $229,700 to $379,000, a figure that includes some quick resales. Builder closings ran from December 23, 2004 to July 2005.
Since then the index holds 96 qualified sales over $100,000. Every unit shares the same builder, two plans and a 2004 or 2005 build year, so a buyer compares units on floor, condition, updates and the association file rather than on age.
Bay Haven fees come in two layers, the condominium fee and the Coco Bay community fee, and buyers ask about both. Neither association publishes its budget openly, and listing figures conflict and sometimes mix the two, so hand buyers the current budgets of both associations rather than a number from memory.
The estoppel certificates from each association state what is owed at closing. Ask both associations for the reserve schedule and the master insurance summary too, because the budget decides what each assessment covers.
Bay Haven units sit under two associations, the condominium association and the Coco Bay community association, so the closing agent orders an estoppel certificate from each once a contract is signed. Each certificate states what is owed on the unit, whether the account is current and any assessment due.
Chapter 718 governs condominium estoppel certificates under s. 718.116. Ask for both early enough that an open balance or assessment can be settled before closing.
Bay Haven sellers should produce the declaration of condominium and its amendments, the articles, bylaws and rules, the current budget, the reserve schedule, the master insurance summary, recent minutes and any special assessment notice from the condominium association, plus Coco Bay's declaration, use restrictions, revised rules and budget.
Bay Haven's pages on the association website are behind an owner login, so request copies early. Section 718.503 sets the disclosure a resale buyer receives, and the Coco Bay governing documents page posts the community documents.
Bay Haven's transfer or capital contribution is not published by either association, so ask both before you list. Whatever applies should appear in the governing documents and be confirmed on the estoppel certificates, and the purchase contract should name who pays it.
We put the answer in the listing file, so a buyer reads it with the first showing rather than at closing.
Bay Haven sellers should ask both associations whether any special assessment is levied or proposed, how much is due on the unit and when. After the Ian flood case, buyers ask directly whether any repair cost beyond the flood payments was or will be assessed to owners.
The estoppel certificates state assessments owed, and the purchase contract sets whether the seller pays an assessment levied before closing. Read s. 718.115 on common expenses and s. 718.116 on assessments.
Bay Haven sellers should answer with the public record. A federal appeals court opinion states that Bay Haven's buildings were flooded in Hurricane Ian; each building had its own National Flood Insurance Program building policy, signed proofs of loss ran $221,023 to $262,656 per building, about $2.57 million in total, and the insurer paid them.
Then add your own unit's file: repair invoices, permits for work inside the unit and any HO-6 or flood claim records. Your own documents decide what you disclose; ask your closing agent or attorney about the disclosure forms. Read the National Hurricane Center's Ian report for the storm itself.
Bay Haven's association sued its flood insurer for contractor invoices beyond the signed proofs of loss (filed August 2, 2024, federal court in Fort Myers), lost on summary judgment in January 2026, and the appeals court affirmed on October 23, 2026, holding that a signed, sworn proof of loss is required for every dollar claimed.
State it plainly as court record and point buyers to the appeals court opinion and its GovInfo record. A Construction Defect Journal summary explains the proof of loss rule. Then hand over the association's answer on assessments and reserves.
Bay Haven sellers should hand buyers the HO-6 insurance declarations page, any flood policy declarations page and both associations' master insurance summaries. The declaration sets what the master policy insures and what the unit owner insures, so the buyer's insurer reads both before quoting.
The association's flood cover in the court record was building-only, with no contents coverage, so buyers ask what the current master flood and wind policies hold. Read s. 627.4025 on hurricane deductibles. We do not quote premiums.
Bay Haven sellers should ask the association for the building's elevation certificate before listing. The buildings sit in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 10 to 11 feet NAVD88, and ground is about 8 feet, per public elevation data shown with a 2026 listing, so a buyer's flood quote turns on the certificate.
The building's elevation certificate and a lender flood determination decide; a map read alone does not. If the association has no certificate on file, ask whether it will order one from a licensed surveyor.
Bay Haven's buildings are in FEMA Zone AE, coastal floodplain, outside the floodway, on Lee County's republished effective FEMA layer, FIRM panel 12071C0414G, effective November 17, 2022. Lenders require flood insurance on mortgaged units in Zone AE, so tell buyers that plainly with the map and the address.
Never describe a unit as out of a flood zone. Point buyers to the FEMA Flood Map Service Center and FloodSmart's flood zones and maps page, and hand over the building's elevation certificate.
Bay Haven buyers ask about the current and the coming flood map. New unincorporated Lee County flood maps are scheduled to take effect March 2, 2027, so check the address on the new map before you list and hand buyers both the effective and the new zone with the elevation certificate.
Lee County's flood information page is the place to start. A buyer's lender and insurer will read whichever map is effective at closing.
Bay Haven is in Lee County Evacuation Zone A, storm surge zone 1, on the county's evacuation layer. An evacuation zone says when a county order may reach the address; it is not a flood zone and does not set an insurance rate, so answer with the map and the county's page.
Point buyers to Lee County's Know Your Zone page, and have your shutter details, any claim history and the association's storm procedures ready for buyers who ask.
Bay Haven buyers often ask whether Florida's newer condominium inspection and reserve laws reach the property. The SIRS rule in s. 718.112 and the milestone law in s. 553.899 apply to buildings three habitable stories or more; Bay Haven's buildings are two stories on the county roll, so by that text neither mandate is aimed at them.
Confirm with the association that no building has a third habitable story, and point buyers to the state's condominium inspections page. Reserves still matter, so hand over the reserve schedule and any vote to waive or reduce reserves.
Bay Haven shutters follow the Coco Bay use restrictions: galvanized panels must be painted, and roll-down or accordion shutters need approval under board standards. Listings describe electric hurricane shutters on some units, so hand buyers the approval and permit for any shutters you added.
A buyer's insurer reads opening protection in a wind mitigation report, and s. 718.113 covers hurricane protection in condominiums. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven sellers should ask the association first, because the building's roof and walls are common elements and an inspection may already exist for the building. A wind mitigation report on the uniform state form documents roof attachment and opening protection, which a buyer's insurer reads.
Read s. 627.711 on the uniform inspection form and s. 553.844 on roof mitigation. Hand any report and your shutter permits to the buyer's agent with the first offer.
Bay Haven sellers should gather permits and invoices for any work inside the unit, such as flooring, kitchen or bath remodels, air conditioning replacement or post-Ian drywall and cabinet repairs. A buyer's agent and lender read an open permit as work that may not be finished.
Check the unit's permit history on the Lee County Property Appraiser record before you list, and close any permit still open with its final inspection. Changes to common elements need association approval under the declaration.
Bay Haven units can sell with a tenant in place if the lease followed the rules and the buyer agrees to take it. The Coco Bay use restrictions require whole-unit leases of at least 30 consecutive days, no more than three leases per unit per calendar year, and a copy of each lease to the association.
Hand the buyer the lease, proof the association received it and the move-out terms, and check whether Bay Haven's condominium documents add rules. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven buyers ask about the lease limits (no lease shorter than 30 consecutive days, no more than three leases per unit per calendar year), the pet rule (common household pets, pit bull type breeds barred) and the vehicle rule (no trailers, boats, trucks or campers unless kept in the garage).
Hand over the Coco Bay use restrictions, the March 2026 revised rules and the condominium association's documents. Assistance animals are handled under fair housing law; ask the association. The declaration and rules govern; read the current versions before you sign.
Bay Haven is not a golf community. Tell buyers that the recorded 2004 easement gives Coco Bay owners road and utility rights through the Kelly Greens gates, not club rights, and that Coco Bay homes are not deeded Kelly Greens memberships. Never imply golf comes with the unit.
If a buyer wants golf, send them to the Kelly Greens club office to ask what, if any, access it sells to Coco Bay owners, and keep that question out of the purchase contract unless the club confirms in writing.
Bay Haven buyers ask how they get through the Kelly Greens gates. Under the recorded 2004 easement, Coco Bay owners pay the same price Kelly Greens members pay for gate transponders, and Kelly Greens maintains the gates and roads it took ownership of to install them.
List the transponders that stay with the unit in the contract, hand them over at closing, and tell the buyer to register with the Coco Bay association.
Bay Haven sellers should name the place in full: Bay Haven at Coco Bay, a condominium inside the gated Coco Bay community on Coco Hammock Way, Iona area of south Fort Myers, ZIP 33908. That lets appraisers, closing agents and insurers land on the right building and association.
Name the plan as a ground-floor or upper unit, use the county living area with a note that the buyer confirms the measured size, and describe features such as the garage, lanai and shutters only as the unit actually has them.
Bay Haven buyers often compare other Iona condominiums, and facts, not rankings, carry the comparison. Bay Haven has 44 units in two-story buildings from 2004 and 2005, each with an attached garage, inside Coco Bay's gates; Mandolin Bay has 72 units in two-story buildings from 2004.
Royal Pointe at Majestic Palms, Coco Bay's own single-family homes and Kelly Greens condos next door differ in size, building height, the golf membership model at Kelly Greens and flood history. Each property has its own documents, so buyers compare plan, floor, flood file and association papers unit by unit.
Bay Haven owners share the Coco Bay Amenity Center on Tract A, built 2005, with 2,421 sq ft heated and 3,225 sq ft total on the roll, and a pool. Listings describe a spa, library, fitness room and social room. The Coco Bay community association owns and runs it.
Buyers ask how clubhouse costs are shared, which sits in the Coco Bay budget, so hand over the current budget and any rules on clubhouse use.
Bay Haven sellers' homestead exemptions and Save Our Homes capped assessments do not pass to the buyer, because the assessed value resets on purchase. A buyer's first tax bill can therefore differ from yours. We do not estimate tax bills, so point buyers to the current bill and their own homestead application.
Read s. 689.261 on the property tax disclosure a seller gives and s. 196.011 on the annual application for exemptions.
Bay Haven sellers should read the title and closing agent terms in the contract, because the contract sets who pays the owner's title policy and who chooses the closing agent. Ask the closing agent for a seller's net sheet that shows the title charges, both estoppel charges and the prorated assessments before you sign.
Taxes are a first lien on the unit under s. 197.122, so the closing agent prorates the year's taxes on the settlement statement.
Bay Haven sellers should list when their documents are ready and the unit shows well. With 4 qualified sales in the latest 12 months, we do not read a month-by-month pattern into the county's sales, and this edition prints no days on market. We time a listing around your plans and a complete two-association file.
Bay Haven sellers who live out of state should send the file before they leave: the deed, the HO-6 and flood declarations pages, the tax bill, any permits for work inside the unit, the transponder details and both associations' documents. Ask the closing agent whether it offers a remote closing or closing documents by mail.
We walk the unit, meet inspectors and handle showings while you are away.
Bay Haven condos can sell furnished or empty. If furniture stays, list it in a written inventory attached to the contract so the buyer, the lender and the closing agent read the same list. A recorded sale price does not separate furniture from the unit, so we price the real estate first.
Bay Haven pricing in this edition rests on Lee County recorded sales, which show the deed price but not active listings, list prices, list-to-sale ratios or days on market. Those come from the MLS, and we read current listings when we price your unit, beside the qualified sales recorded inside Bay Haven.
These are Lee County recorded sales on the 44 Bay Haven units (qualified sales over $100,000 flagged by the county, sale data through October 21, 2026, the latest sale in the county index used). The county flags sales a few weeks after they record, so the newest deeds may not be counted yet. The MLS (Matrix) was not pulled for this edition, so active listings, list-to-sale ratios and days on market are not shown.
Bay Haven buyers ask about public school zones. Bay Haven itself was not tested point by point; Kelly Greens, about 0.3 mile east, tested in 2026-2027 Elementary Proximity Zone O, Middle Zone MM and High School South Zone sub-zone 1, with placement by capacity.
Tell buyers to confirm students at Bay Haven addresses with the district's School Site Locator, and point them to the school zones page.
Bay Haven condos are marketed on the facts buyers ask about: the plan and floor from the county roll, the lake view, the attached garage, the condition and updates inside the unit, the flood zone and elevation certificate, the Ian record and both associations' documents, with Bay Haven at Coco Bay, Iona and Fort Myers named in every listing field.
We put the two estoppel requests, the budgets and the master insurance summary in the listing file, so a buyer reads the association answers at the first showing.
Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. We tracked every qualified sale Lee County has recorded on the 44 Bay Haven units since the 2004 and 2005 sellout, 96 qualified sales over $100,000, read the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for all 44 units and matched each recent sale to its floor plan.
We also read the federal appeals court opinion and the summary judgment record on Bay Haven's Hurricane Ian flood claims, so we answer buyers' questions from the record. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, or start with our free home valuation.
Bay Haven sellers and buyers work with McGreevy and Comisar because we price from Lee County's recorded sales by floor plan and ask for both associations' declarations, rules, budgets, reserve schedule, master insurance summary and estoppel certificates, plus the elevation certificate and tax bill, first. Jesse McGreevy leads listings and seller strategy; Marc Comisar leads buyer representation.
Data updated: November 2026 (Lee County recorded sales, sale data through October 21, 2026; the Lee County Property Appraiser roll; Lee County's map service reads of November 20, 2026; team honors as published by McGreevy and Comisar).
We tracked the 7 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026 and matched each to its floor plan by living area on the roll, we read the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for all 44 Bay Haven units, we read the recorded 2004 Coco Bay and Kelly Greens access easement and the Coco Bay use restrictions, we read the FEMA flood zone, base flood elevation, FIRM panel and Lee County evacuation zone at the Bay Haven buildings on Lee County's map service, and we compared Bay Haven with Mandolin Bay, Royal Pointe at Majestic Palms, Coco Bay's own houses and Kelly Greens on the same 24-month county window.
Selling in Bay Haven? Get a free home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying in Bay Haven? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610, or read about how we represent buyers. Read how we sell a home in Fort Myers or buy a home in Fort Myers, see our Fort Myers guide, meet our Fort Myers real estate team, and contact us. Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
Bay Haven buyers work with Marc Comisar, who reads both associations' declarations and rules, the budgets and reserve schedule, the master insurance summary, the flood zone and elevation certificate, the Ian court record, the permit history and Lee County's recorded sales inside Bay Haven before you offer, on a ground-floor or an upper unit. Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 to start.
Read about how we represent buyers and buying a home in Fort Myers, then call Marc at (239) 457-1610.
Bay Haven owners and buyers can ask us through our contact page or request a free home valuation for a condo on Coco Hammock Way, in any of the eleven buildings, AA to KK. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610, and we answer by phone or email.
Bay Haven owners and buyers can open the public documents we cite: the Coco Bay easement, use restrictions and FAQ, the appeals court opinion, condominium statutes, state SIRS pages, the school enrollment plan and the FEMA map center. Both associations' declarations, budgets, reserves, insurance summaries and estoppel certificates come from the associations, the seller and the title agent.
Data updated: November 2026 (documents as posted by Coco Bay Community Association, Inc., the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit on GovInfo, the Florida Legislature, the Florida DBPR Division of Florida Condominiums, Timeshares and Mobile Homes, the School District of Lee County, FEMA, Lee County and the Lee County Property Appraiser, accessed November 2026 unless a publication date is given).
Document | Publisher | Link |
|---|---|---|
Coco Bay and Kelly Greens Access Easement Agreement, recorded 2004 | Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. (recorded agreement) | https://cocobayhoa.info/documents/Coco%20Bay%20-Kelly%20Green%20Easement%20Agreemeny.pdf |
Coco Bay Use Restrictions, Exhibit C | Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. | https://cocobayhoa.info/documents/Coco%20Bay%20Use%20Restrictions%20Exhibit%20C.pdf |
Coco Bay FAQs, August 2025 | Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. | https://cocobayhoa.info/documents/FAQs%20%20Coco%20Bay%20FINAL.pdf |
Coco Bay governing documents page | Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. | https://cocobayhoa.info/documents.htm |
Appeals court opinion on Bay Haven's Hurricane Ian flood claims, October 23, 2026 | U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit (GovInfo) | https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-ca11-26-10485/pdf/USCOURTS-ca11-26-10485-0.pdf |
Property record search: unit and common element records, values and permits | Lee County Property Appraiser | https://www.leepa.org |
Section 553.899, milestone inspections | Florida Legislature | https://m.flsenate.gov/Statutes/553.899 |
Section 718.112, structural integrity reserve studies and reserves | Florida Legislature | https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/718.112 |
Section 718.503, disclosure prior to sale of a resale unit | Florida Legislature | https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2025/718.503 |
Section 718.116, assessments and estoppel certificates | Florida Legislature | https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2025/718.116 |
Condominium and cooperative SIRS reporting | Florida DBPR, Division of Florida Condominiums, Timeshares and Mobile Homes | https://www2.myfloridalicense.com/condos-timeshares-mobile-homes/condominiums-and-cooperatives-sirs-reporting |
Condominium inspections: milestone inspections and SIRS | Florida DBPR, Division of Florida Condominiums, Timeshares and Mobile Homes | https://condos.myfloridalicense.com/inspections/ |
Student Enrollment Plan, 2026-2027 | School District of Lee County | https://www.leeschools.net/common/pages/GetFile.ashx?key=c5aKDQZk |
Flood Map Service Center | FEMA | https://msc.fema.gov/portal/home |
Land stewardship plan, San Carlos Bay, Bunche Beach Preserve | Lee County | https://www.leegov.com/parks/Documents/Conservation%202020/Land%20Stewardship%20Plans/SCBBBP.pdf |
Bay Haven declaration of condominium and amendments | Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. | Ask the association; behind the owner login |
Bay Haven articles, bylaws and rules | Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. | Ask the association; behind the owner login |
Bay Haven current budget and reserve schedule | Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. | Ask the association; not published |
Master insurance summary, flood and wind | Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. | Ask the association; not published |
Elevation certificate for the building | Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. | Ask the association |
Estoppel certificate, condominium | Bay Haven at Coco Bay Condominium Association, Inc. | Ordered by the closing agent once a contract is signed |
Coco Bay current budget and March 2026 revised rules | Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. | Ask the association |
Estoppel certificate, community | Coco Bay Community Association, Inc. | Ordered by the closing agent once a contract is signed |
Bay Haven figures and rules come from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, Lee County recorded sales, Lee County's republished effective FEMA flood layer and evacuation map, the Coco Bay association's posted documents, the federal court record, the school district, the Florida Statutes and listing remarks where named. Linked entries were accessed November 2026 unless a publication date is given.
Data updated: November 2026 (linked entries accessed November 2026 unless a publication date is given; Lee County recorded sales, qualified deeds through October 21, 2026).
Plain text (no URL):
# | Source |
|---|---|
1 | The Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale data files, local index to October 21, 2026 (44 condominium units, use 04; 11 buildings, AA to KK; plans of 1,510 and 1,911 sq ft; built 2004 and 2005; 2026 just values; 96 qualified sales over $100,000 since 2004) |
2 | Lee County's public geographic map service, reads of November 20, 2026 (FEMA Zone AE, base flood elevation 10 to 11 feet NAVD88, FIRM panel 12071C0414G effective November 17, 2022; County Evacuation Zone A, storm surge zone 1) |
3 | Approximate free-flow drive times from the middle of Bay Haven, routed by a public routing service, November 2026 |
4 | Listing remarks read 2025 to 2026 (unit sizes, features, fee figures and ground elevation of about 8 feet from public elevation data; listing-reported and conflicting) |
5 | The insurer's summary judgment motion in the court record, U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida (policy limits, deductibles and proofs of loss per building) |
6 | Florida Statutes, Chapter 718 |
Linked:
Market data from Lee County recorded sales, sale data through October 21, 2026; Southwest Florida MLS not pulled for this edition. McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Bay Haven. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.
Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.