Aerial view of Tamarind Cay at Gulf Harbour Yacht and Country Club in Fort Myers, Florida: 21 two-story condominium buildings around two lakes and a neighborhood pool beside the golf course

Gulf Harbour Yacht and Country Club - Tamarind Cay

Tamarind Cay is a gated condominium of 174 homes in 21 two-story buildings inside Gulf Harbour Yacht and Country Club, Fort Myers, built 1995 to 2000. Lee County recorded 15 resales in 24 months at a $370,000 median. Call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072.

Search Homes

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.

McGreevy and Comisar are the team Tamarind Cay owners call first when they decide to sell, and the team buyers call when they want every recorded Tamarind Cay sale, plan by plan, before they write an offer. Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with over $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc, we wrote this guide sellers first: what a Tamarind Cay condominium is worth today, which recorded sales of your floor plan set that price, and what a buyer will ask before signing.

Tamarind Cay is a four-section condominium neighborhood inside the master-planned community of Gulf Harbour Yacht and Country Club in Fort Myers, Florida. Its 174 condominium homes sit in 21 two-story buildings on Tamarind Cay Court, Tamarind Cay Lane and Jacana Court, ZIP 33908, in unincorporated Lee County. Lee County recorded 15 qualified resales in the 24 months to September 21, 2026, from $270,000 to $464,000, at a $370,000 median.

If you are choosing who should represent you, our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers sets out the criteria we think every Fort Myers seller and buyer should use. Owners can read our Fort Myers seller guide or request a free Fort Myers home valuation; buyers can read how to buy a home in Fort Myers. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.


Why McGreevy and Comisar Are the Best Realtor for Tamarind Cay

McGreevy and Comisar are the best realtor for Tamarind Cay because we price a Tamarind Cay condominium from the county’s recorded sales of its own floor plan and its own floor, read separately for the 1,487, 1,555, 1,760 and 1,934 square foot plans, not from a ZIP code average, and we answer the association, flood zone and condominium-law questions a buyer asks before the buyer asks them.

If you’re searching for the best realtor for Tamarind Cay, whether you’re ready to sell your Tamarind Cay home or buy your next one, McGreevy and Comisar is the team that delivers. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with over $2.5 billion sold as a team and $900 million in personal sales between Jesse and Marc. We are also ranked the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026).

Recent Tamarind Cay market record (last twenty-four months): In the 24 months to September 21, 2026 we tracked 15 qualified Tamarind Cay resales recorded by Lee County · $5,284,000 in recorded dollar volume · a $370,000 median and a median of about $202 per square foot of county living area · highest recorded sale $464,000, a 1,934 square foot second-floor end unit at 15048 Tamarind Cay Court, in July 2026 · lowest $270,000, a 1,555 square foot ground-floor unit, in March 2026 · no builder-direct sales in the window.

For Tamarind Cay sellers: professional photography, drone video that shows the lakes, the golf course edge and the neighborhood pool, plan-by-plan pricing from the county record across all four sections, and a qualified-buyer database built over our years leading Domain Realty Group.

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Selling your Tamarind Cay home? Read our Fort Myers seller guide, get a free Tamarind Cay home valuation, or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 (confidential conversations welcome).

Buying a home in Tamarind Cay? Read how to buy a home in Fort Myers, see how we represent buyers in Southwest Florida, or call Marc at (239) 457-1610 for a personalized buyer consultation.


Key Takeaways: What Should You Know About Tamarind Cay?

Tamarind Cay’s key takeaways are its size, its four floor plans, its two-story buildings and its resale record: 174 condominium homes in 21 buildings built 1995 to 2000, one association over four recorded condominiums, 15 qualified resales in 24 months at a $370,000 median, optional club membership, and FEMA Zone AE on every building tested.

  • Gulf Harbour’s largest single condominium neighborhood. Lee County’s neighborhood layer counts 21 buildings and 174 residential units, gated, on a 24.91-acre condominium tract on the south side of Gulf Harbour (Lee County GIS).
  • Four recorded condominiums, one association. Sections I to IV were declared between March 1995 and October 1996 (42, 44, 44 and 44 units) and now operate under Tamarind Cay Condominium Association, Inc. (Florida DBPR).
  • Four floor plans in near-equal numbers. The county roll shows 45 units of 1,487 square feet, 42 of 1,555, 45 of 1,760 and 42 of 1,934, every unit with an attached garage and a lanai.
  • Every building is two stories. All 21 buildings are two stories on the county building layer, with 87 ground-floor and 87 second-floor homes, which places Tamarind Cay below Florida’s three-habitable-story trigger for milestone inspections and structural integrity reserve studies.
  • Resale record. Lee County recorded 15 qualified resales in the 24 months to September 21, 2026, from $270,000 to $464,000, median $370,000, about $202 per square foot of living area.
  • Two fee layers. Owners pay Tamarind Cay Condominium Association and Gulf Harbour Master Association; neither publishes its budget online, so the estoppel certificate is the authority.
  • Club membership is optional. Gulf Harbour says living there does not require club membership (Gulf Harbour Yacht and Country Club).
  • No boat slip conveys. Gulf Harbour Marina’s 186 slips are sold or rented separately from homes and club.
  • Flood zone AE, base flood elevation 8 feet. Four Tamarind Cay buildings tested on FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer all return Zone AE on panel 12071C0414G, effective November 17, 2022 (FEMA NFHL).
  • No CDD. Every Tamarind Cay parcel on the November 2026 county roll carries only taxing district 068, Iona McGregor Fire.

Table of Contents

This guide answers the questions Tamarind Cay sellers and buyers ask us most, in the order below.


What Is Tamarind Cay in Fort Myers, Florida?

Tamarind Cay is a gated condominium neighborhood of 174 homes in 21 two-story buildings inside Gulf Harbour Yacht and Country Club, off McGregor Boulevard in unincorporated Lee County with a Fort Myers mailing address, ZIP 33908. It was declared as four condominiums from 1995 to 1996 and built out from 1995 to 2000.

Lee County’s own neighborhood layer names it “Tamarind Cay Condominium,” marks it gated, and counts 21 buildings and 174 residential units (Lee County GIS Neighborhoods and Areas). A Lee County zoning case is titled “Gulf Harbour at Tamarind Cay” (Lee County zoning case ADD2018-00038), which places it inside the Gulf Harbour master plan. The U.S. Census Bureau geocoder places the centroid in the Iona census-designated place (U.S. Census Bureau Geocoder).

Is Tamarind Cay inside the City of Fort Myers?

No. Tamarind Cay is in unincorporated Lee County with a Fort Myers mailing address. All 175 Tamarind Cay parcels on the November 2026 Lee County Property Appraiser roll sit in zoning area ULC, unincorporated Lee County, and in taxing district 068, the Iona McGregor Fire District, so county rules, not City of Fort Myers rules, govern zoning and permits.

Is Tamarind Cay gated?

Yes. Tamarind Cay sits behind the Gulf Harbour master gates, and the county neighborhood layer records it as gated. Gulf Harbour says visitors check in at the entrance gate, and the Gulf Harbour Master Association runs gates and security for every neighborhood inside the community, including Tamarind Cay (Gulf Harbour real estate FAQ).

How many homes are in Tamarind Cay?

Tamarind Cay has 174 condominium homes. The Lee County Property Appraiser roll carries 175 parcels with the Tamarind Cay prefix: the 174 units plus one common element parcel at 15041 Tamarind Cay Court that holds the pool and spa. Florida DBPR records Section I at 42 units and Sections II, III and IV at 44 units each.

Is Tamarind Cay the same as Tamarind Trace or Tamarindo?

No. Tamarind Cay is the Gulf Harbour condominium in Fort Myers. Tamarind Trace is a neighborhood in Shadow Wood in Estero, Tamarindo is in Naples, and Tamarind at the Reef is on Sanibel. Search results mix the names, so a buyer should confirm the street address is Tamarind Cay Court, Tamarind Cay Lane or Jacana Court in ZIP 33908.

Who runs the Tamarind Cay association?

Tamarind Cay Condominium Association, Inc. runs all four sections. It was filed February 24, 1995 as Tamarind Cay Recreation Association, Inc. (Sunbiz N95000000924); the four section associations were merged into it, and on April 16, 2008 it filed Amended and Restated Articles with the current name. Suitor, Middleton, Cox and Associates at 15751 San Carlos Boulevard manages it.


Where Exactly Is Tamarind Cay Inside Gulf Harbour?

Tamarind Cay sits on the south side of Gulf Harbour, between the golf course and lakes to the north and Westport Drive, a master-association road, to the south. Its streets are Tamarind Cay Court (addresses 15000 to 15091), Tamarind Cay Lane (11271) and Jacana Court (11251 to 11271), in Section 31, Township 45 South, Range 24 East.

A perimeter wall separates Tamarind Cay from an adjacent commercial site, the subject of Lee County zoning case ADD2018-00038 (Lee County). Gulf Harbour itself fronts the Caloosahatchee River on the Intracoastal Waterway, about 4.5 nautical miles from the Gulf (Gulf Harbour Marina). The neighborhood centroid is about 26.5214 north, 81.9437 west.

Which buildings are in each Tamarind Cay section?

Each Tamarind Cay section is a separate recorded condominium with its own set of buildings. Section I holds Buildings 1 to 4, 15 and 16; Section II holds Buildings 5 to 7, 13 and 14; Section III holds Buildings 8 to 12; Section IV holds Buildings 17 to 21 on Jacana Court. The table lists each building’s address and unit count from the county record.

Section

Buildings (number: street address, units)

Units

Section I

1: 15000 Tamarind Cay Ct (6); 2: 15010 (8); 3: 15030 (6); 4: 15036 (6); 15: 15037 (8); 16: 11271 Tamarind Cay Ln (8)

42

Section II

5: 15042 (8); 6: 15048 (8); 7: 15054 (8); 13: 15049 (10); 14: 15043 (10)

44

Section III

8: 15060 (8); 9: 15091 (10); 10: 15081 (8); 11: 15065 (8); 12: 15055 (10)

44

Section IV

17: 11271 Jacana Ct (8); 18: 11261 (8); 19: 11251 (8); 20: 11260 (10); 21: 11270 (10)

44

Common element

15041 Tamarind Cay Ct, pool and spa, folio 10216993

none

Sources: Lee County GIS Building Footprints, Lee County GIS Parcels, Florida DBPR condominium extract.

How do Tamarind Cay unit numbers work?

A Tamarind Cay unit number carries its building number first. Unit 601 is in Building 6, unit 1209 is in Building 12 and unit 2110 is in Building 21. The Lee County Property Appraiser groups all 174 units as one condominium complex, “Tamarind Cay Sec I to IV,” so a buyer can read every unit’s card on one roll.

Why does the state list a McGregor Boulevard address for Section I?

The state’s condominium registry lists Tamarind Cay Section I at 15000 McGregor Boulevard because that is the site address the county roll gives Gulf Harbour’s own master common element parcels. It is the master plan’s address, not a separate building. Sections II to IV are listed at 14581 Westport Drive.

How is Tamarind Cay zoned?

Tamarind Cay is zoned under unincorporated Lee County authority as part of the Gulf Harbour planned development, which began as the River’s Edge Yacht and Country Club rezoning in 1982. Every parcel sits in zoning area ULC on the county roll, so exterior changes go through the association first and then Lee County permitting.


What Is It Like Living in Tamarind Cay?

Living in Tamarind Cay means a single-level condominium home in a two-story building, an attached garage, a screened or glassed lanai, golf course, lake or landscape views, a private neighborhood pool and spa, and the Gulf Harbour gate, with club golf, dining, fitness and the marina available by separate membership or purchase rather than included.

Every Tamarind Cay home is a flat on one level: ground-floor homes sit beside the garages, and second-floor homes are reached by an entry stair. The county cost cards record golf course views for units 601 and 805, lake views for 1106 and 1209, and a landscape view for 2110 (Lee County Property Appraiser cost card, unit 601). Personal golf carts are permitted on Gulf Harbour streets with a licensed driver (Gulf Harbour).

What amenities does Tamarind Cay have?

Tamarind Cay’s own amenity is a private neighborhood pool and spa on the common element parcel at 15041 Tamarind Cay Court, which the county records as “CE: Pool + Jacuzzi” (Lee County Property Appraiser, folio 10216993). The county card shows no building on that parcel, so any room described beside the pool is unconfirmed on the record.

Do Tamarind Cay owners have to join the Gulf Harbour club?

No. Gulf Harbour says living in the community does not require club membership and that membership is open to residents and non-residents alike (Gulf Harbour real estate FAQ). A Tamarind Cay owner who does not join uses the neighborhood pool and spa; golf, dining, fitness and tennis require a paid membership.

What does the Gulf Harbour club offer?

Gulf Harbour Yacht and Country Club runs a private 18-hole, par 72 course of 6,671 yards, designed by Chip Powell in 1986 and redesigned by Kipp Schulties in 2020 (Kipp Schulties Golf Design), plus the Harbour Executive Course, a 30,000 square foot Wellness Center, a tennis complex, a spa and Eagle Perch Island for members.

When does the renovated Gulf Harbour clubhouse open?

The club’s renovation page describes a “$20 million Clubhouse transformation” inside a “nearly $30 million investment,” approved by members with 70 percent of the vote in February 2025, adding a 33 percent seating increase, and gives a grand opening planned for December 2026 (Gulf Harbour clubhouse renovations). Florida YIMBY named Curran Young Construction as the contractor (Florida YIMBY).

Does a boat slip come with a Tamarind Cay condo?

No. Gulf Harbour Marina’s 186 deep-water slips are sold through a realtor or rented through a realtor or the marina, separately from homes and the club, and no slip conveys with a Tamarind Cay unit. Hurricane Ian destroyed the marina docks; the rebuild ran about $6 million and reopened in March 2024 (Gulf Harbour Marina).

Talk to us about a Tamarind Cay home today

A Tamarind Cay home inside Gulf Harbour, with an attached garage on every unit and two-car garages on the 42 second-floor end units, is priced plan by plan. Sellers can start a free Tamarind Cay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072; buyers can call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or read how we represent buyers.


What Is the Tamarind Cay Market Doing Right Now?

The Tamarind Cay market recorded 15 qualified resales in the 24 months to September 21, 2026, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser, from $270,000 to $464,000 with a $370,000 median and about $202 per square foot of living area. The newest recorded sale was 11270 Jacana Court unit 2104 at $325,000 on September 21, 2026. Data updated: November 2026.

We use the 24-month window because it is the first window with 10 or more recorded closings: the 12 months from September 22, 2025 to September 21, 2026 hold 8 qualified resales at a $317,500 median (our arithmetic on the county sale list). All 15 sales in the 24-month window were resales; none was builder-direct (Lee County Property Appraiser).

Measure (qualified resales, Lee County)

Value

Window

24 months to September 21, 2026

Recorded sales

15

Median sale price

$370,000

Low to high

$270,000 to $464,000

Recorded dollar volume

$5,284,000 (our sum)

Median price per square foot of county living area

about $202

Last 12 months (8 sales) median

$317,500 (our arithmetic)

Is the Tamarind Cay market up or down?

Tamarind Cay prices are below their 2022 peak. Lee County’s qualified sales ran $316,000 to $560,000 in 2022, the peak year, and $270,000 to $464,000 in 2026 to date. In our arithmetic on the 24-month list, the 7 sales recorded in 2025 had a $370,000 median and the 7 recorded in 2026 a $325,000 median.

How many Tamarind Cay homes sold in the last 12 months?

Eight. Lee County recorded 8 qualified Tamarind Cay resales from September 22, 2025 to September 21, 2026, at a $317,500 median in our arithmetic, from $270,000 for a 1,555 square foot ground-floor unit to $464,000 for a 1,934 square foot second-floor end unit. Eight is too few for a stable median, so we price from the 24-month list.

How does the floor plan change a Tamarind Cay price?

In the 24-month list, the 3 sales of the 1,934 square foot plan had a $385,000 median, the 7 sales of the 1,760 plan a $325,000 median, the 3 sales of the 1,555 plan a $370,000 median and the 2 sales of the 1,487 plan a $312,500 median (our arithmetic). View, condition and garage size move a single unit more than the plan median does.

Do second-floor Tamarind Cay homes sell for more?

On the 24-month record, yes at the median. The 10 second-floor sales (1,760 and 1,934 square feet) had a $370,000 median, and the 5 ground-floor sales (1,487 and 1,555 square feet) a $325,000 median, in our arithmetic. Per square foot the gap narrows, because the upper plans are larger.

How should a seller read the Tamarind Cay sale list?

A Tamarind Cay seller should match the home to recorded sales of the same plan and floor first, then adjust for view, garage, lanai enclosure and condition. Two 1,760 square foot units sold at $412,500 and $280,000 inside the same 24 months, which is the spread condition and view create inside one plan.

Selling a Tamarind Cay home? Get a free Tamarind Cay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we represent buyers.


Which Tamarind Cay Sales Set Today’s Prices?

The Tamarind Cay sales that set today’s prices are the 15 qualified resales Lee County recorded from November 20, 2024 to September 21, 2026, listed below with unit, plan size and price. The high was $464,000 for a 1,934 square foot second-floor end unit; the low was $270,000 for a 1,555 square foot ground-floor unit. Data updated: November 2026.

Recorded date

Unit

Living sq ft

Price

2024-11-20

15048 Tamarind Cay Ct, unit 604

1,760

$412,500

2025-03-12

15043 Tamarind Cay Ct, unit 1408

1,760

$325,000

2025-03-28

11251 Jacana Ct, unit 1908

1,934

$370,000

2025-05-13

15030 Tamarind Cay Ct, unit 305

1,555

$375,000

2025-07-11

15055 Tamarind Cay Ct, unit 1205

1,760

$402,500

2025-08-29

15048 Tamarind Cay Ct, unit 604 (resold)

1,760

$370,000

2025-09-11

15054 Tamarind Cay Ct, unit 702

1,555

$370,000

2025-10-01

15065 Tamarind Cay Ct, unit 1106

1,487

$300,000

2026-01-08

11270 Jacana Ct, unit 2110

1,934

$385,000

2026-03-06

15055 Tamarind Cay Ct, unit 1209

1,555

$270,000

2026-03-13

15048 Tamarind Cay Ct, unit 605

1,760

$280,000

2026-05-07

11271 Jacana Ct, unit 1706

1,487

$325,000

2026-07-10

15048 Tamarind Cay Ct, unit 601

1,934

$464,000

2026-07-16

15060 Tamarind Cay Ct, unit 805

1,760

$310,000

2026-09-21

11270 Jacana Ct, unit 2104

1,760

$325,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales, newest record September 21, 2026.

Why does the county price differ from some online sale reports?

The county records the deed consideration, while the MLS records the reported closing price, and the two can differ. For 11271 Jacana Court unit 1706, the county deed shows $325,000 on May 7, 2026; one online data page reported $350,000 on May 8, 2026. This page prints the county deed figure.

What did Tamarind Cay homes ask before they sold?

Asking prices run above recorded prices in this window. Unit 805 at 15060 Tamarind Cay Court last asked $374,000 before its $310,000 county sale in July 2026, and 15054 Tamarind Cay Court unit 706 was listed on February 13, 2026 at $389,900 and was off the market by July 16, 2026, according to listing records.

What is the highest price recorded in Tamarind Cay?

The highest qualified Tamarind Cay sales came in 2022, when the county’s yearly range reached $560,000. In 2023 a 1,934 square foot second-floor end unit with a two-car garage, 15037 Tamarind Cay Court unit 1501, sold for $520,000 according to its listing record. In the current 24 months, the high is $464,000.

Selling a Tamarind Cay home? Get a free Tamarind Cay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we represent buyers.


How Have Tamarind Cay Prices Changed Since 1995?

Tamarind Cay prices have moved from first sales of $116,000 to $197,500 in 1995 to 2000, up to $437,500 in 2005, down to a post-crash range of $132,000 to $195,000 in 2011, up to a 2022 peak range of $316,000 to $560,000, and to $270,000 to $464,000 in 2026 to date, on Lee County’s qualified sales. Data updated: November 2026.

Year

Qualified sale range (Lee County)

1995

$129,900 to $197,500

2005

up to $437,500

2011

$132,000 to $195,000

2019

$190,000 to $290,000

2022

$316,000 to $560,000

2024

$320,000 to $475,000

2026 to date

$270,000 to $464,000

What did the first Tamarind Cay buyers pay?

The earliest sale on the current county roll is 11271 Tamarind Cay Lane unit 1603 in March 1995 at $151,900, followed by Building 15 units in April 1995 at $140,800 to $160,300. Sampled first deeds include unit 601 at $164,300 (July 1996), unit 805 at $134,900 (August 1996) and unit 2110 at $162,600 (October 1999).

How far did Tamarind Cay prices fall after 2005?

Tamarind Cay’s qualified sales reached $437,500 in 2005 and fell to a range of $132,000 to $195,000 in 2011, the post-crash low on the county record. Prices rebuilt to $190,000 to $290,000 by 2019 and peaked in 2022 at up to $560,000, so the 2011 low sits well under half of the 2022 high.

What do county just values say about Tamarind Cay?

The current county roll puts Tamarind Cay just values at $245,970 to $315,284 across the 174 units, with a median of $274,492. Per plan, the county GIS layer showed medians of $261,978 for 1,487 square feet, $271,648 for 1,555, $280,505 for 1,760 and $299,194 for 1,934. Just value is an assessment, not a sale price.

What does the price history mean for a buyer or seller today?

The price history shows Tamarind Cay moves with the wider Southwest Florida condominium market rather than on its own. A seller who bought in 2022 may be pricing against a lower range today; a buyer is paying less than the 2022 peak for the same plans. Plan, floor and condition explain most of the spread in any year.


What Homes Are in Tamarind Cay?

Tamarind Cay homes are single-level condominium flats in two-story buildings of 6, 8 or 10 units, marketed as coach or carriage homes, with tile roofs, attached garages and screened or glassed lanais. The county roll shows four floor plans of 1,487, 1,555, 1,760 and 1,934 square feet of living area, built from 1995 to 2000.

Living sq ft

Floor

County beds and baths

Garage sq ft

Lanai sq ft

Units

1,487

Ground

3 and 2

224

138 screened plus 23 open porch

45

1,555

Ground

3 and 2

227

146 screened plus 35 open porch

42

1,760

Second, with den

3 and 2

241

138 screened

45

1,934

Second, end unit, with den

3 and 2

397

146 screened or glassed

42

Sources: Lee County Property Appraiser cost cards for unit 1106, unit 1209, unit 805 and unit 2110; unit counts from the county parcel layer.

How many bedrooms do Tamarind Cay condos have?

The county codes every Tamarind Cay unit as three bedrooms and two baths. Listing records describe the ground-floor plans as two bedrooms plus a den, and a 2024 listing called the den usable as an office or third bedroom, so the third county bedroom is the den. Bedroom count in a contract follows the unit’s own description.

Which Tamarind Cay units have two-car garages?

The 42 second-floor end units, the 1,934 square foot plan, have two-car garages; the other plans have one-car garages. The county records a 397 square foot garage on the 1,934 plan against 224 to 241 square feet on the others, and a 2023 sale of unit 1501 at 15037 Tamarind Cay Court was described as a second-floor end unit with two attached spaces.

How are the plans arranged inside a building?

In an 8-unit Tamarind Cay building, the end units are the 1,934 square foot plan upstairs and the 1,555 plan downstairs, and the middle units are the 1,760 plan upstairs and the 1,487 plan downstairs. The 6-unit and 10-unit buildings vary the mix, so the building number tells a buyer which plans it holds.

When were Tamarind Cay buildings built?

By roll year built, 66 units date from 1995, 54 from 1996, 26 from 1997, 8 from 1998, 10 from 1999 and 10 from 2000. Buildings 1 to 6 and 14 to 16 are 1995; 7, 8, 11 to 13 and 17 are 1996; 9, 18 and 19 are 1997; 10 is 1998; 21 is 1999; and 20 is 2000.

Why do listing sizes differ from the county sizes?

Listing records quote 1,633, 1,845 and 1,988 square feet for plans the county measures at 1,555, 1,760 and 1,934 square feet of living area. Listing figures often include space the county does not count as living area. We price on the county living area so every Tamarind Cay comparison uses the same yardstick.

Selling a Tamarind Cay home? Get a free Tamarind Cay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we represent buyers.


Who Built Tamarind Cay and How Did It Come to Be?

Tamarind Cay was declared in four sections from March 1995 to October 1996, in the same window that a new owner relaunched the failed River’s Edge Yacht and Country Club as the Gulf Harbour master plan. The public record online does not name Tamarind Cay’s builder; the declarant appears in the recorded declaration at Official Records Book 2583, Page 1863.

Gulf Harbour began as River’s Edge Yacht and Country Club with a 1982 planned development rezoning. Its original developer failed in the late 1980s and early 1990s, and in 1994 a new owner acquired the property and instituted the Gulf Harbour master plan. Lee County applicant records run from Sun City Center Corporation (1994) to Florida Design Communities (1996 to 2001) to WCI Communities (by 2007) (Lee County document search).

When was each Tamarind Cay section declared?

Florida DBPR records the four Tamarind Cay declarations as Section I, 42 units, recorded March 15, 1995 (Official Records Book 2583, Page 1863); Section II, 44 units, September 29, 1995 (Book 2639, Page 0672); Section III, 44 units, May 20, 1996 (Book 2707, Page 2550); and Section IV, 44 units, October 30, 1996 (Book 2758, Page 1873).

How were the sections phased?

Tamarind Cay Section I was built in five phases, Buildings 16, 15, 3 and 4, 1 and 2, and Section II in five, Buildings 5, 14, 6, 13 and 7, according to the county parcel record. Sections III and IV followed from 1996 to 2000, ending with Building 21 in 1999 and Building 20 in 2000 on Jacana Court.

How did the four associations become one?

Tamarind Cay Recreation Association, Inc. was filed on February 24, 1995. The four section associations (Sunbiz N95000000917, N95000002499, N95000003961 and N95000004783) were merged into it, and on April 16, 2008 it filed Amended and Restated Articles of Incorporation changing its name to Tamarind Cay Condominium Association, Inc.

What county work has been done in Tamarind Cay recently?

Lee County development order LDO2025-00189, issued April 15, 2025, covers milling and repaving the Tamarind Cay roadway, parking area and mail kiosk and reinstalling parking bumpers (Lee County Development Orders). Earlier orders covered a buffer shrub replacement along Westport Drive (LDO2022-00260) and a lake bank slope (LDO2010-00040).

Who Governs Tamarind Cay?

Tamarind Cay is governed by two associations: Tamarind Cay Condominium Association, Inc., which runs the four condominiums, the buildings, the pool and the neighborhood streets, and Gulf Harbour Master Association, Inc., which runs the master gates, security and master roads such as Westport Drive. Suitor, Middleton, Cox and Associates manages Tamarind Cay.

Gulf Harbour has 22 marketed neighborhoods, each with its own association, and about 25 legal neighborhood associations under the master (Gulf Harbour). Tamarind Cay’s association is Sunbiz document N95000000924; the master association is Sunbiz N08716. The manager’s office is at 15751 San Carlos Boulevard, unit 8, Fort Myers, (239) 437-0340.

What does the condominium association control?

Tamarind Cay Condominium Association, Inc. insures the building shell and common elements under the declarations, maintains the buildings, grounds, private streets and the pool and spa, sets the budget and reserves for the four condominiums, and enforces the declarations and rules, including leasing and pets. Unit owners insure their own interiors and contents.

What does the master association control?

Gulf Harbour Master Association, Inc. runs the entrance gates, security and master roads for every Gulf Harbour neighborhood. Grande Cay’s published rules, a neighboring Gulf Harbour condominium with the same manager, refer residents to the master association’s rules for noise and name the DwellingLive visitor system (Grande Cay association rules).

Is the Gulf Harbour master association the same as Gulf Harbors Master Association?

No. “Gulf Harbors Master Association Inc” is a New Port Richey nonprofit, EIN 59-1651411, that appears in searches for the Fort Myers name (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer). The Fort Myers community’s master association is Gulf Harbour Master Association, Inc., Sunbiz N08716.

What does Chapter 718 require of the Tamarind Cay association?

Florida’s Condominium Act, Chapter 718, governs Tamarind Cay’s association: budgets, reserves, official records, owner meetings and estoppel certificates. Every Florida condominium association had to open a DBPR online account by October 1, 2025 (Florida DBPR SIRS reporting). The statute text is at the Florida Senate, Chapter 718.


What Does It Cost to Own in Tamarind Cay? The Fee Stack

Owning in Tamarind Cay means two mandatory association fees, the Gulf Harbour master fee and the Tamarind Cay condominium fee, plus Lee County property taxes, with no CDD and optional club dues. Neither association publishes its budget online, so the current amounts come from the association and an estoppel certificate, not from this page.

Dated listing records give the pattern. The master charge was $1,350 a year in 2023, $1,620 in 2024 and $1,720 to $1,730 in 2025 to 2026, and a February 2026 listing says it includes irrigation water, pest control, road maintenance, street lights and security. The condominium fee is billed quarterly: $1,175 a quarter on several 2025 to 2026 listing records and $1,585 a quarter on a two-car second-floor end unit in 2023. On those figures a typical owner paid roughly $6,400 to $7,700 a year in the two layers combined, before club dues (approximate; listing-reported, not association figures).

Cost layer

What the record shows

Where to confirm

Gulf Harbour Master Association

about $1,730 a year (2025 to 2026 listing records)

estoppel certificate; master financial pages are behind a resident login

Tamarind Cay Condominium Association

$1,175 a quarter on several units (2025 to 2026 listing records); $1,585 a quarter on a two-car end unit (2023)

estoppel certificate and the association budget

CDD

none; every parcel carries only taxing district 068

the unit’s Lee County Tax Collector bill

Property tax

example: unit 706, 1,487 sq ft, paid $3,633 for 2025 (listing record)

the unit’s tax bill

Club

optional and separate

Gulf Harbour membership office, (239) 433-5111

Why do some sites show Tamarind Cay HOA fees of $135 to $144 a month?

That figure is the Gulf Harbour master charge of $1,620 to $1,730 a year divided by 12, not the condominium fee. The Tamarind Cay condominium fee is a separate quarterly charge, $1,175 a quarter on several 2025 to 2026 listing records. A buyer who budgets only the monthly aggregator figure misses the larger of the two layers.

What does the Tamarind Cay condominium fee cover?

Listing records name insurance, lawn and land maintenance, pest control, reserves, cable, water and the pool as items in the Tamarind Cay condominium fee. Those are listing descriptions, not the association’s budget. The association’s current budget is the document that states what the fee covers, and a buyer receives it in the condominium disclosure package.

Is there a CDD in Tamarind Cay?

No. Gulf Harbour has no community development district or special taxing district debt or operations line, and every Tamarind Cay parcel on the November 2026 Lee County roll carries only taxing district 068, Iona McGregor Fire. To confirm a single unit, read the non-ad valorem lines on its Lee County Tax Collector bill.

What are Tamarind Cay property taxes?

Tamarind Cay property taxes depend on each unit’s assessed value and homestead status. One example: 15054 Tamarind Cay Court unit 706, a 1,487 square foot ground-floor home, paid $3,633 in 2025 real estate taxes according to its listing record. On the current roll, 63 of the 174 units carry a homestead exemption, which caps their assessed value growth.

What other fees should a Tamarind Cay buyer expect?

A 2023 Tamarind Cay listing record showed a $175 lease application fee. Capital contribution, transfer and estoppel fees are not published online; the estoppel certificate the association issues under section 718.116, Florida Statutes states every amount due at closing. The master association offered gate fobs at the manager’s office for $20 in 2024, per its community newsletter.

What does the Gulf Harbour club cost?

Gulf Harbour does not publish current initiation or dues online; its membership guide is form-gated. A 2021 to 2022 club prospective-member brochure showed annual fees of $12,036 for golf equity and $6,021 for sports equity. Current figures come from the club’s membership office at (239) 433-5111, and membership is optional for Tamarind Cay owners.

Selling a Tamarind Cay home? Get a free Tamarind Cay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we represent buyers.


What Rules Should Buyers Know About Rentals, Pets and Changes to the Home?

Tamarind Cay’s leasing, pet and alteration rules are set by its declarations and the association’s rules, because Gulf Harbour leaves rental rules to each neighborhood association. The association does not publish those documents online, so a buyer reads them in the condominium disclosure package before the contract’s review period ends.

Can I rent out a Tamarind Cay condo?

Yes, within the association’s rules. A 2023 Tamarind Cay listing record stated a 30-day minimum lease and no more than five leases a year, with a $175 application fee, and furnished seasonal rentals appear in 2026 listing records, for example one at $3,000 a month in winter. The current declaration and rules govern, so confirm both before buying to rent.

Are pets allowed in Tamarind Cay?

The same 2023 listing record stated a limit of two pets. Several 2026 rental listing records say no pets, which is a landlord’s choice, not necessarily an association rule. The declaration and the association’s current rules govern pets, and a buyer with a pet should read them in the disclosure package before the review period ends.

Can I change the outside of my Tamarind Cay home?

Exterior items in Tamarind Cay, such as windows, doors, lanai enclosures, roofs and paint, are building and common-element matters controlled by the association under the declarations. Interior work usually needs association approval when it touches structure, plumbing, flooring sound or the building envelope, and Lee County permits apply to regulated work.

Does Tamarind Cay have an age rule?

No age rule appears in the public record we reviewed for Tamarind Cay. The declarations of condominium are the controlling documents for any occupancy rule, so a buyer should confirm occupancy terms in the declarations and the association’s rules, which come with the disclosure package.

What documents should I read before buying in Tamarind Cay?

Before buying in Tamarind Cay, read the declaration of condominium for the unit’s section, the articles and bylaws, the association’s rules, the current budget and reserve schedule, the insurance declarations with the wind deductible, any special assessments, recent minutes, the master association’s rules and the estoppel certificate.


Does Tamarind Cay Need a Milestone Inspection or SIRS?

On the county record, no. Florida’s milestone inspection law and structural integrity reserve study requirement apply to condominium buildings three habitable stories or more in height, and all 21 Tamarind Cay buildings are two stories, with every unit on the first or second floor. Ordinary Chapter 718 budget and reserve rules still apply.

The milestone statute, section 553.899, applies to “a building that is three habitable stories or more in height” under condominium or cooperative ownership (Florida Senate, s. 553.899), and DBPR’s inspections page states the same test (Florida DBPR inspections). The SIRS requirement in section 718.112(2)(g) “does not apply to buildings less than three stories in height” (Florida Senate, Chapter 718).

Why does the two-story count matter to a Tamarind Cay buyer?

The two-story count keeps Tamarind Cay outside the state’s milestone and SIRS mandates that have driven large special assessments at taller Florida condominiums. Within Gulf Harbour, Harbour Links stacks three residences over garages and does carry those obligations. Tamarind Cay buyers still review reserves, roofs and insurance, because ordinary reserve rules apply.

Do online sources call Tamarind Cay mid-rise?

Some online summaries label Tamarind Cay mid-rise; the county building layer shows every one of the 21 buildings at two stories, coded “Condominium, low rise, 1 to 3 floors.” The county record is the authority for the story count, and the milestone and SIRS conclusions on this page rest on it.

What should a buyer still check about reserves?

A Tamarind Cay buyer should still read the reserve schedule in the current budget, the roof and paving history, and any special assessment notices. The 2025 county development order to repave the Tamarind Cay roadway and parking area is the kind of capital project reserves fund, and minutes show how the association paid for it.


Is Tamarind Cay in a Flood Zone?

Yes. FEMA maps every Tamarind Cay building tested in Zone AE, the coastal floodplain, with a static base flood elevation of 8 feet, on FIRM panel 12071C0414G, effective November 17, 2022. Four building points (units 601, 1106, 2110 and 1601) all returned AE 8, and a parcel-point pull placed all 174 units in AE 8.

Sources: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, flood zones and FIRM panels. No part of the Tamarind Cay outline falls in the county’s Limit of Moderate Wave Action layer (Lee County GIS LiMWA). No letter of map amendment was found for Tamarind Cay; the two in Gulf Harbour are at Harbour Links and Mariposa.

How high is the ground at Tamarind Cay?

USGS 3DEP lidar at the Tamarind Cay centroid reads 6.90 feet NAVD88 (USGS Elevation Point Query Service), and a 12-parcel Gulf Harbour sample ran 6.9 to 7.2 feet with a 7.0 foot median, so ground sits roughly 1 foot below the 8 foot base flood elevation. That is ground, not finished floor; each building’s elevation certificate states the floor height.

What evacuation zone is Tamarind Cay in?

Lee County places Tamarind Cay in evacuation Zone A and surge zone 1 (Lee County GIS Evacuation Zones), and the state storm surge layer returns Category 2 at the centroid (Lee County GIS FDEM Storm Surge Zones). Zone A is the first zone Lee County orders out.

Do Tamarind Cay owners need flood insurance?

The condominium association insures the building shell under its master policy; unit owners carry HO-6 coverage. Citizens’ flood requirement does not require condominium unit owners holding an HO-6 to buy flood insurance, but a mortgage lender may require it for an AE unit. Flood policy details are at FloodSmart.

Selling a Tamarind Cay home? Get a free Tamarind Cay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we represent buyers.


How Did Tamarind Cay Fare in Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton?

Tamarind Cay came through Hurricane Ian without a recorded county damage finding at its buildings. The nearest surveyed high water marks to Gulf Harbour were 6.90 to 7.25 feet NAVD88, below the 8 foot base flood elevation, no Gulf Harbour folio received a Substantial Damage determination, and Lee County’s public damage layers show no records at the 21 buildings.

The National Hurricane Center records Ian as a Category 4 landfall in Lee County on September 28, 2022, with record surge in Fort Myers (NHC Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian). Lee County’s Initial Damage Assessments layer and its Damage Inventory layer each returned zero records inside an envelope around all 21 Tamarind Cay buildings (Lee County GIS Initial Damage Assessments, Lee County Damage Inventory).

What repairs did Gulf Harbour need after Ian?

County permit data for Gulf Harbour show repair work dominated by screens, pool cages, windows and roofs, with no Substantial Damage determination at any Gulf Harbour folio. Ian destroyed the Gulf Harbour marina docks, which were rebuilt and reopened in March 2024. Unit-level water intrusion or claims at Tamarind Cay are recorded in association minutes, not public records.

What happened in Helene and Milton in 2024?

The Fort Myers water level peaked at 5.12 feet during Helene on September 26, 2024, the second-highest on record there after Ian, and Fox 4 reported Iona neighborhoods off McGregor still dealing with floodwater about a week later (Fox 4). Lee County ordered Zones A and B, including Tamarind Cay, evacuated for Milton on October 7, 2024.

Was any storm work done at Tamarind Cay before Ian?

Lee County development order LDO2022-00260, a Tamarind Cay buffer shrub replacement along Westport Drive, closed final on September 14, 2022, two weeks before Ian. No 2025 or 2026 storm affecting Tamarind Cay was found in searches through November 18, 2026.


What Does Insurance Look Like for a Tamarind Cay Condo?

Insurance for a Tamarind Cay condominium has two parts: the association’s master policy on the building shell and common elements, paid through the condominium fee, and the owner’s HO-6 policy on interiors, contents and liability, plus flood coverage where a lender or the owner chooses it. The buildings date from 1995 to 2000, before the 2002 Florida Building Code.

A 2026 listing record reports tile roofs and casement and sliding windows, with no impact rating stated. Roof ages, wind mitigation features and any impact-window program are association and inspection matters; a wind mitigation report on the unit and the association’s insurance declarations, with the carrier and wind deductible, are the documents that set an HO-6 premium.

What does the building era mean for insurance?

Tamarind Cay’s 1995 to 1997 buildings went up after post-Andrew code tightening in South Florida but before the 2002 Florida Building Code. Insurers rate roof age, roof covering, opening protection and roof-to-wall connections, so a current wind mitigation inspection on the unit usually matters more to an HO-6 premium than the year built alone.

Which insurance documents should a Tamarind Cay buyer request?

A Tamarind Cay buyer should request the association’s insurance declarations page (carrier, building coverage, wind deductible), the most recent budget and reserve schedule, any special assessment notices, and recent minutes covering storms, roofs and claims. With those, an insurance agent can quote an HO-6 policy and flood coverage before the inspection period ends.

Selling a Tamarind Cay home? Get a free Tamarind Cay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we represent buyers.


Which Schools Serve Tamarind Cay?

Tamarind Cay is served by the School District of Lee County’s choice-zone system: the 2026 to 2027 enrollment zones place it in elementary zone O, middle zone MM and high zone South 1, the same zones as the Gulf Harbour clubhouse and Grande Cay. Each zone offers a menu of schools ranked by the student, with a lottery for oversubscribed schools.

Level

Zone menu, 2026 to 2027

2026 state grade

Elementary, Zone O

Heights Elementary (15200 Alexandria Ct), Tanglewood, Villas, Rayma C. Page

Heights A; Tanglewood B; Villas B; Rayma C. Page A

Middle, Zone MM

Cypress Lake Middle (8901 Cypress Lake Dr), Lexington Middle (16351 Summerlin Rd)

A; B

High, South 1

Cypress Lake High (6750 Panther Ln), Fort Myers High, Dunbar

A; A; C

Open to any zone on request

The Sanibel School (K to 8)

A

Sources: Lee County GIS School Enrollment Zones 2026/2027 and the School District of Lee County School Zones page.

How do I confirm the school options for a Tamarind Cay address?

Enter the unit’s street address in the School District of Lee County’s School Site Locator on its School Zones page. Lee County assigns by choice zone, not a single neighborhood school, so the locator’s list for the address, not a map distance, is what governs enrollment for the coming year.

Which private schools are near Gulf Harbour?

Private schools within a short drive of Gulf Harbour include Canterbury School (pre-K 3 to 12, 8141 College Parkway, about 9 minutes), Summit Christian School (K to 8, 9065 Ligon Court, about 10 minutes), Bishop Verot Catholic High (8 to 12, about 14 minutes) and Evangelical Christian School (pre-K to 12, about 16 minutes), on modeled drive times.


How Far Is Tamarind Cay From Hospitals, Beaches and the Airport?

Tamarind Cay is about 9 minutes from Lee Health HealthPark Medical Center, about 12 minutes from Fort Myers Beach, about 15 minutes from the Sanibel Causeway toll plaza and about 27 minutes from RSW, on free-flow model times. Add 25 to 50 percent on McGregor Boulevard, Summerlin Road and US 41 from January to April.

Destination

Road miles and model minutes

Measured from

Gulf Harbour clubhouse, 14500 Vista River Dr

1.5 mi, about 5 min

Tamarind Cay

Lee Health HealthPark Medical Center, 9981 S HealthPark Dr

3.9 mi, about 9 min

Tamarind Cay

HCA Florida West Fort Myers Emergency

4.4 mi, about 10 min

Tamarind Cay

Gulf Coast Medical Center

7.3 mi, about 15 min

Tamarind Cay

Lee Memorial Hospital, downtown

10.2 mi, about 20 min

Tamarind Cay

Fort Myers Beach, Times Square

5.9 mi, about 12 min

clubhouse

Sanibel Causeway toll plaza

6.7 mi, about 15 min

clubhouse

Bell Tower, US 41 at Daniels Pkwy

5.3 mi, about 11 min

clubhouse

Downtown Fort Myers River District

10.1 mi, about 21 min

clubhouse

Gulf Coast Town Center

12.3 mi, about 25 min

clubhouse

RSW airport terminal

15.0 mi, about 27 min

clubhouse

Coconut Point, Estero

15.2 mi, about 27 min

clubhouse

Downtown Naples, Fifth Ave S

33.2 mi, about 56 min

clubhouse

Times are OSRM free-flow model times (Project OSRM); hospital locations are from Lee County GIS Hospital and ER Locations. Tamarind Cay falls inside the county’s 10-minute hospital drive-time area (Lee County GIS).

Where do Tamarind Cay owners shop for groceries?

From the Gulf Harbour clubhouse, Publix at Gladiolus Gateway, 11600 Gladiolus Drive, is 1.3 miles; Walgreens at 15271 McGregor Boulevard is 1.0 mile; CVS at 15501 McGregor Boulevard is 1.4 miles; Walmart Supercenter at 17105 San Carlos Boulevard is 3.1 miles; and MD Now Urgent Care at 15165 McGregor Boulevard is 0.8 miles.

How close are the beaches and the nearest boat ramp?

Fort Myers Beach is about 12 minutes from the Gulf Harbour clubhouse, and Sanibel is reached over the rebuilt Sanibel Causeway, where FDOT work was completed November 1, 2025. The nearest public boat ramp is Punta Rassa, 15001 Punta Rassa Road. Bunche Beach Preserve reopened after Milton for paddlecraft launch only on October 19, 2024 (Lee County Parks).


What Is Next to Tamarind Cay Outside the Wall?

Outside the Tamarind Cay perimeter wall to the south and east is a commercial strip along McGregor Boulevard and Iona Road. The county’s March 2025 unincorporated building-permit layer shows two records in the Tamarind Cay envelope, both on Iona Road (11750 and 11760) on the commercial side of the wall, and none on Tamarind Cay streets.

Sources: Lee County GIS Building Permits, March 2025 and Lee County zoning case ADD2018-00038, titled “Gulf Harbour at Tamarind Cay,” which concerns the adjacent commercial site.

Is anything being built near Tamarind Cay?

A vacant RM-2 zoned corner lot at 11780 Iona Road, at Peppertree Drive, was marketed in 2026 as an infill site for up to 5 units. Inside Gulf Harbour, the clubhouse renovation is the main project, with a grand opening planned for December 2026. No permit record was found on Tamarind Cay streets themselves.


How Do We Price a Tamarind Cay Home?

We price a Tamarind Cay home from the Lee County record of qualified resales of the same plan and floor, then adjust for view, garage, lanai enclosure, condition and the fee and insurance picture a buyer will see. We tracked all 15 qualified Tamarind Cay resales in the 24 months to September 21, 2026, and every plan has at least two recorded sales in that window.

Our order of work for a Tamarind Cay valuation: confirm the plan from the county card (1,487, 1,555, 1,760 or 1,934 square feet), pull the same-plan sales, read the view and garage from the cost card, read the condominium and master fees from a fresh estoppel, and check the unit’s tax bill for homestead status. Then we set a price a buyer’s appraiser can defend.

Which features add value to a Tamarind Cay unit?

On the Tamarind Cay record, the features that separate prices inside a plan are a second-floor end location with a two-car garage, a golf course or lake view, a glassed lanai, and updated kitchens, baths and systems. The $464,000 July 2026 sale was a 1,934 square foot end unit; the 2023 $520,000 sale was the same plan with a two-car garage.

How do we account for the fee and insurance picture?

A buyer prices a Tamarind Cay unit on its monthly carrying cost as well as its price, so we read the condominium fee, the master fee, the HO-6 quote range and any open special assessment before we list. A clean estoppel and a current wind mitigation report shorten a buyer’s review and protect the contract price.


How Do You Buy a Home in Tamarind Cay, Step by Step?

Buying in Tamarind Cay runs in seven steps: set the budget with both fee layers, choose a plan and floor, compare recorded same-plan sales, write the offer, review the condominium documents and estoppel, inspect and insure, and close with the association’s approval. Marc Comisar leads our buyer work at (239) 457-1610.

  1. Budget both fee layers. Add the Tamarind Cay quarterly condominium fee and the Gulf Harbour master fee to the mortgage, taxes and HO-6 and flood premiums.
  2. Choose a plan and floor. Ground-floor plans of 1,487 and 1,555 square feet have no stairs; second-floor plans of 1,760 and 1,934 square feet add a den, and the 1,934 end units have two-car garages.
  3. Compare recorded sales. Use the county’s same-plan resales, not asking prices.
  4. Write the offer. Florida condominium contracts give a buyer a review period for the association documents.
  5. Read the documents. Declaration, rules, budget, reserves, insurance declarations, minutes and the estoppel certificate.
  6. Inspect and insure. A home inspection, a wind mitigation report and HO-6 and flood quotes before the inspection period ends.
  7. Close. The association’s lease or sale approval, the gate credentials and the title work.

Does the association approve Tamarind Cay buyers?

Many Florida condominium declarations give the association a right to approve sales and leases, and a 2023 Tamarind Cay listing record shows a lease application fee, which points to an application process. The declaration for the unit’s section states whether a sale needs approval, and the manager states the timeline.

Who pays for title insurance in a Tamarind Cay sale?

In Lee County the seller customarily pays for the owner’s title insurance policy and chooses the closing agent, and the contract controls. A buyer pays for the lender’s policy when financing. Our Fort Myers buyer guide covers the rest of the closing costs.


How Does Tamarind Cay Compare With Other Gulf Harbour Neighborhoods?

Tamarind Cay compares with its Gulf Harbour neighbors as the largest condominium resale pool, priced between the older River’s Edge condominiums and the newer Mariposa, with two-story buildings that sit outside the milestone and SIRS mandates. County qualified-sale figures over 24 months in ZIP 33908 put the medians side by side below.

Neighborhood (Gulf Harbour)

Homes

Built

24-month qualified sales

Median

Range

Tamarind Cay

174

1995 to 2000

15

$370,000

$270,000 to $464,000

Grande Cay

114

1999 to 2000

20

$306,500

$245,000 to $545,000

Mariposa

104

2000 to 2002

12

$590,000

$400,000 to $727,000

River’s Edge 1 to 4

not counted here

mid-1980s

10

$266,250

$195,000 to $400,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales, county index run November 18, 2026; yardstick: median qualified sale price over 24 months.

How does Tamarind Cay compare with Mariposa?

Mariposa is newer (2000 to 2002), smaller (104 units) and priced well above Tamarind Cay, with a $590,000 24-month median against $370,000. Part of Mariposa maps to shaded Zone X under a letter of map amendment, while every Tamarind Cay building tested is Zone AE. Mariposa buyers pay more for a newer building and lower flood exposure.

How does Tamarind Cay compare with River’s Edge?

River’s Edge 1 to 4 are mid-1980s Gulf Harbour condominiums with smaller units of about 1,064 to 1,561 square feet and carports, and a $266,250 24-month median on 10 sales. River’s Edge is the cheaper Gulf Harbour entry; Tamarind Cay offers newer buildings, attached garages and larger plans for roughly $100,000 more at the median.

Harbour Links reads like coach homes but stacks three residences over garages, so it carries milestone and SIRS obligations that Tamarind Cay does not. The county match for Harbour Landings, 75 parcels with 15 sales at a $1,385,000 median, is a far higher price tier than Tamarind Cay.

Selling a Tamarind Cay home? Get a free Tamarind Cay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we represent buyers.


Tamarind Cay vs Grande Cay: Which Should You Choose?

Tamarind Cay versus Grande Cay is the most common comparison inside Gulf Harbour: both are two-story condominium neighborhoods with a private pool and spa, the same master association and the same manager. Tamarind Cay is larger and about four years older with a higher median; Grande Cay is newer and cheaper at the median with a wider price range.

Decision factor

Tamarind Cay

Grande Cay

Homes and buildings

174 units, 21 two-story buildings

114 units, 12 two-story buildings

Built

1995 to 2000

1999 to 2000, Pulte-built

24-month qualified sales

15

20

24-month median

$370,000

$306,500

24-month range

$270,000 to $464,000

$245,000 to $545,000

Floor plans

four (1,487 to 1,934 sq ft), two upper plans with den

see the Grande Cay declarations

Own amenity

private pool and spa

private pool and spa

Master association and manager

Gulf Harbour Master Association; Suitor, Middleton, Cox

same

Milestone and SIRS

outside (two stories)

outside (two stories)

Sources: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales (county index run November 18, 2026) and the Gulf Harbour parent research.

When is Tamarind Cay the better choice?

Tamarind Cay is the better choice when a buyer wants a second-floor plan of 1,760 or 1,934 square feet with a den, a two-car garage on an end unit, or a larger resale pool to choose from. With 174 homes, Tamarind Cay offers more plan, floor and view combinations in any given season.

When is Grande Cay the better choice?

Grande Cay is the better choice when a buyer puts the lower median price or a building finished in 1999 to 2000 first. Its 24-month median of $306,500 sits below Tamarind Cay’s $370,000, though Grande Cay’s range reaches $545,000. Both share the master association, the manager and the gate.

Selling a Tamarind Cay home? Get a free Tamarind Cay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 or see how we represent buyers.


What Are the Honest Pros and Cons of Tamarind Cay?

Tamarind Cay’s honest pros are its Gulf Harbour gate, single-level homes with attached garages, four plans with views, a private pool and spa, optional club membership and two-story buildings outside the milestone and SIRS mandates. Its cons are Zone AE flood exposure, 1995 to 2000 construction, two unpublished fee layers and prices still below the 2022 peak.

Pros

Cons

Gated, inside Gulf Harbour, with optional club and marina

FEMA Zone AE, base flood elevation 8 feet, ground about 7 feet

Single-level homes, attached garage on every unit

Buildings from 1995 to 2000, before the 2002 Florida Building Code

Four plans, golf course, lake or landscape views

Condominium and master fees are not published online

Two-story buildings, outside milestone and SIRS mandates

Evacuation Zone A

No CDD

24-month median below the 2022 peak range

87 ground-floor homes with no stairs

Builder not named in the public record online

Is Tamarind Cay a good value inside Gulf Harbour?

On the county record, Tamarind Cay sits in the middle of Gulf Harbour’s condominium price range: above River’s Edge and Grande Cay at the median and well below Mariposa. Gulf Harbour describes its overall range as $300,000 to $10 million, so Tamarind Cay is one of the lower-priced ways to own inside the gate.

What is the biggest risk for a Tamarind Cay buyer?

The biggest risk for a Tamarind Cay buyer is cost, not structure: flood and wind insurance on 1995 to 2000 buildings in Zone AE, plus two fee layers that are not published online. Reading the insurance declarations, the budget and the estoppel before the review period ends turns that risk into a known number.

Thinking of Selling Your Tamarind Cay Home? List With the #1 Team in Southwest Florida Since 2012

Selling a Tamarind Cay home well means pricing it on the recorded same-plan resales of the last 24 months, presenting the floor, view, garage and lanai as the assets they are, and answering the fee, flood, insurance and condominium-law questions before a buyer asks. McGreevy and Comisar have done this for Southwest Florida owners for more than a decade as the #1 team in the region.

If you’re searching for a Tamarind Cay listing agent, or thinking, ‘I need someone to sell my Tamarind Cay home,’ McGreevy and Comisar helps owners price, market, negotiate and sell with a local strategy built for Gulf Harbour, Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples and Lee and Collier counties. Whether you are selling in Tamarind Cay or anywhere else in Gulf Harbour, our team provides local market guidance, professional listing exposure and a clear plan to sell confidently.

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026)
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Tamarind Cay sold-market statistics we tracked (24 months to September 21, 2026): 15 qualified resales recorded by Lee County, $5,284,000 in recorded volume, a $370,000 median, a $464,000 high, a $270,000 low and a median of about $202 per square foot of county living area. Days on market and sale-to-list ratio are MLS measures; this edition prints the county record.

What Is Your Tamarind Cay Home Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds. Start your free Tamarind Cay home valuation or our Fort Myers home valuation.

(239) 898-6072, text or call. We respond same-day. Want the complete seller’s guide? Read our Sell Your Home in Fort Myers page for pricing strategy, marketing and the full McGreevy and Comisar listing process, and our selling overview. The Tamarind Cay selling insight: a buyer prices your unit against the same plan in the other 20 buildings, so the estoppel, the insurance declarations and a wind mitigation report should be ready before the first showing.

How quickly do Tamarind Cay homes sell?

The county record shows when a Tamarind Cay sale was recorded, not how long the home was marketed. It shows 15 qualified resales in the 24 months to September 21, 2026, about one every seven weeks, and 8 in the latest 12 months. A well-priced unit competes with the same plan in other buildings.

What will a buyer ask about my Tamarind Cay home?

A Tamarind Cay buyer asks the plan and floor, the view, the garage size, whether the lanai is glassed, the condominium and master fees, the flood zone and elevation certificate, the association’s insurance and wind deductible, roof history, special assessments, the leasing and pet rules, and storm history. We gather those answers before listing.

Should I update my Tamarind Cay condo before selling?

Usually only cosmetic work and the repairs a buyer’s inspector would flag. Tamarind Cay homes date from 1995 to 2000, so buyers price in air-conditioning systems, water heaters, windows and lanai screens; paint, flooring touch-ups and a current wind mitigation report usually return more than a new kitchen.

Does my floor plan matter to my price?

Yes. In the 24 months to September 21, 2026, the 1,934 square foot plan recorded a $385,000 median on 3 sales, the 1,760 plan $325,000 on 7, the 1,555 plan $370,000 on 3 and the 1,487 plan $312,500 on 2 (our arithmetic). Small samples move with each sale, so we price on plan, view and condition together.

What does it cost to sell a Tamarind Cay home?

A Tamarind Cay seller typically pays the brokerage commission agreed in the listing agreement, Florida documentary stamp tax on the deed, the owner’s title insurance policy by Lee County custom, prorated property taxes and association fees, and the association’s estoppel fee. Our Fort Myers seller guide has a full net sheet.

Do I need the association’s approval to sell?

The declaration for your Tamarind Cay section states whether the association approves a sale or only a lease. Ask Suitor, Middleton, Cox and Associates for the current application and timeline when you list, so the buyer’s approval does not delay closing.


Your Local Real Estate Experts

McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, are the local real estate experts for Tamarind Cay, Gulf Harbour and Fort Myers: Jesse McGreevy leads listing and seller strategy, Marc Comisar leads buyer representation and negotiation, and as the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate across Southwest Florida.

Jesse McGreevy is a top-reviewed Tamarind Cay realtor, and the reviews below are quoted exactly as clients wrote them on our Google Business Profile. We do not edit, combine or summarize client words.

★★★★★ “Jesse was very professional, helpful and kept in touch with ideas and suggestions which developed into a sale. Highly recommend his company for their excellent follow through.” Verified Google review

★★★★★ “We had been on the market for several months with no offers. When we signed with Marc our house was sold in 2 weeks. He has a unique system for selling homes.” Verified Google review

★★★★★ “He knew the area and therefore knew exactly where to take us to find the exact kind of neighborhood we were looking for and he was right on the money.” Verified Google review

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners
  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 · [email protected]
  • Marc Comisar: (239) 457-1610
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC). Florida license numbers: Jesse McGreevy SL3101296, Marc Comisar BK3060671.

Meet Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, read more about McGreevy and Comisar, see our guide to the best real estate agents in Fort Myers, or contact us. Buyers who want to see Gulf Harbour on the market today can browse Gulf Harbour on DomainRealtyGroup.com.

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.


Frequently Asked Questions, Buyer Edition

These Tamarind Cay buyer questions are the ones buyers ask us most about the Gulf Harbour condominium: where it is, how big the homes are, what they cost to buy and to own, the club and marina, flood and storms, condominium law, schools, rentals and pets, each answered from the county, state and federal record cited on this page.

Where is Tamarind Cay in Fort Myers?

Tamarind Cay is a gated condominium neighborhood inside Gulf Harbour Yacht and Country Club, off McGregor Boulevard in unincorporated Lee County, ZIP 33908. Its 21 buildings sit on Tamarind Cay Court, Tamarind Cay Lane and Jacana Court, between the golf course and Westport Drive, about 1.5 road miles from the clubhouse.

How many units are in Tamarind Cay and when was it built?

Tamarind Cay has 174 condominium units in 21 two-story buildings, declared as four condominium sections between March 1995 and October 1996. County records date the buildings from 1995 to 2000, with the first recorded sale in March 1995 and the last two Jacana Court buildings finished in 1999 and 2000.

How big are Tamarind Cay condos?

Tamarind Cay has four plans. Ground-floor units have 1,487 or 1,555 square feet, marketed as two bedrooms plus a den; second-floor units have 1,760 or 1,934 square feet with a den. The county codes every unit as three bedrooms and two baths, and every unit has an attached garage.

What do Tamarind Cay condos sell for?

Lee County recorded 15 qualified Tamarind Cay resales between November 2024 and September 2026, from $270,000 to $464,000, median $370,000, about $202 per square foot. Prices peaked in 2022, when sales reached $560,000. The highest recent sale was a second-floor end unit at $464,000 in July 2026.

What are the HOA fees in Tamarind Cay?

Tamarind Cay owners pay two layers. Listing records show the Gulf Harbour master fee at about $1,730 a year in 2025 and 2026, and a quarterly condominium fee of $1,175 on several units and more on the largest. The associations do not publish their budgets online, so the estoppel certificate is the authority.

Do I have to join the Gulf Harbour club to buy in Tamarind Cay?

No. Gulf Harbour says living in the community does not require club membership and membership is open to residents and non-residents. Tamarind Cay owners who do not join use the neighborhood pool and spa; golf, dining, fitness and tennis require a paid membership.

Does Tamarind Cay need a milestone inspection or SIRS?

No, on the county record. Florida’s milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study laws apply to condominium buildings three habitable stories or higher, and all 21 Tamarind Cay buildings are two stories. Ordinary Chapter 718 reserve and budget rules still apply.

What flood zone is Tamarind Cay in?

FEMA maps every tested Tamarind Cay building in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 8 feet on panel 12071C0414G, effective November 17, 2022, outside the moderate wave action area. Lidar ground is about 7 feet. Lee County places Tamarind Cay in evacuation Zone A.

How did Tamarind Cay fare in Hurricane Ian?

The nearest surveyed high water marks to Gulf Harbour were 6.90 to 7.25 feet, below the 8 foot base flood elevation; no Gulf Harbour folio received a Substantial Damage determination; and Lee County’s public damage layers show no records at Tamarind Cay’s buildings. The Gulf Harbour marina docks were rebuilt by March 2024.

Is a boat slip included with a Tamarind Cay condo?

No. Gulf Harbour Marina’s 186 deep-water slips are bought or rented separately from both the home and the club, and owning a Tamarind Cay unit gives no slip rights by itself.

Can I rent out a Tamarind Cay condo?

Gulf Harbour leaves rental rules to each neighborhood association. A 2023 Tamarind Cay listing record stated a 30-day minimum lease and no more than five leases a year, and furnished seasonal rentals appear in 2026 listing records. Confirm the current declaration and rules before buying to rent.

Are pets allowed in Tamarind Cay?

A 2023 Tamarind Cay listing record stated a limit of two pets. The declaration and the association’s current rules govern, and some landlords bar pets in their own leases. Read the rules in the disclosure package before the review period ends.

Is there a CDD in Tamarind Cay?

No. Every Tamarind Cay parcel on the November 2026 Lee County roll carries only taxing district 068, the Iona McGregor Fire District, and Gulf Harbour has no community development district.

Which schools serve Tamarind Cay?

Tamarind Cay sits in Lee County choice zones O (elementary), MM (middle) and South 1 (high) for 2026 to 2027. Heights Elementary, Cypress Lake Middle and Cypress Lake High, each graded A in 2026, are on those menus. Confirm options with the district’s School Site Locator.

How far is Tamarind Cay from the hospital and the beach?

Lee Health HealthPark Medical Center is 3.9 miles, about 9 minutes, from Tamarind Cay on a free-flow model, and Fort Myers Beach is about 12 minutes from the Gulf Harbour clubhouse. Add 25 to 50 percent in season.

Do Tamarind Cay units have garages?

Yes. Every Tamarind Cay unit has an attached garage: one-car for the 1,487, 1,555 and 1,760 plans and two-car for the 42 second-floor end units of 1,934 square feet.

How many Tamarind Cay homes are homesteaded?

On the November 2026 county roll, 63 of the 174 Tamarind Cay units carry a homestead exemption, about 36 percent; the others are taxed without the homestead cap.


Frequently Asked Questions, Seller Edition

These Tamarind Cay seller questions are the ones owners ask us before they list: what the unit is worth, which sales count, how plan, floor, view and garage change the price, how fees, flood, insurance and condominium law affect a buyer, what selling costs, and how long it takes, answered from the Lee County record.

What is my Tamarind Cay condo worth today?

A Tamarind Cay condo is worth what buyers have recently paid for the same plan and floor, adjusted for view, garage, lanai and condition. Lee County recorded 15 qualified resales in the 24 months to September 21, 2026, from $270,000 to $464,000 at a $370,000 median. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 for a unit-specific valuation.

Which sales will a buyer compare to my Tamarind Cay unit?

A buyer compares your Tamarind Cay unit to recorded sales of the same plan, then the other plan on the same floor. The 24-month list has 3 sales of the 1,934 plan, 7 of the 1,760, 3 of the 1,555 and 2 of the 1,487.

What did the most recent Tamarind Cay sale bring?

The most recent qualified Tamarind Cay sale on the county record is 11270 Jacana Court unit 2104, a 1,760 square foot second-floor home, at $325,000 on September 21, 2026.

What was the highest Tamarind Cay sale in the last two years?

The highest qualified Tamarind Cay sale in the 24 months to September 21, 2026 was 15048 Tamarind Cay Court unit 601, a 1,934 square foot second-floor end unit, at $464,000 on July 10, 2026.

Are Tamarind Cay prices higher or lower than in 2022?

Lower. Lee County’s qualified Tamarind Cay sales ran $316,000 to $560,000 in 2022, the peak year, against $270,000 to $464,000 in 2026 to date. The 7 sales recorded in 2026 had a $325,000 median in our arithmetic.

How many Tamarind Cay units sell in a year?

Lee County recorded 8 qualified Tamarind Cay resales in the 12 months to September 21, 2026 and 15 in 24 months, out of 174 units.

Does a two-car garage add value in Tamarind Cay?

On the record, the top Tamarind Cay sales are 1,934 square foot second-floor end units, the plan with the two-car garage: $464,000 in July 2026 and $520,000 in 2023. Only 42 of the 174 units have that garage.

Does a golf course or lake view add value?

The county cost cards record golf course, lake and landscape views unit by unit, and buyers pay for the view inside a plan. We read your unit’s view from its card and compare it with sales that share it.

Is a ground-floor Tamarind Cay unit harder to sell?

Not on the record. The 5 ground-floor sales in the 24 months to September 21, 2026 had a $325,000 median and the 10 second-floor sales a $370,000 median, in our arithmetic; ground-floor homes have no stairs, which many buyers want.

Does the county just value tell me my price?

No. The current county roll puts Tamarind Cay just values at $245,970 to $315,284, median $274,492, below every recorded sale in the 24-month list. Just value is an assessment for taxes, not a sale price.

Why do online estimates of my Tamarind Cay unit differ?

Online estimates mix plans, use listing sizes that run larger than county living area, and sometimes report a price that differs from the recorded deed. We use the county’s recorded deed prices and county living area for every comparison.

What fees will a buyer ask me about?

A buyer will ask the Tamarind Cay quarterly condominium fee, the Gulf Harbour master fee, any special assessment and the estoppel fee. Ordering the estoppel certificate early lets us put the current figures in front of buyers from the first showing.

Will Florida’s milestone or SIRS rules affect my sale?

No, on the county record. Every Tamarind Cay building is two stories, below the three-habitable-story trigger for milestone inspections and structural integrity reserve studies, and we say so in the listing with the statute.

How does the flood zone affect my sale?

Every tested Tamarind Cay building is in FEMA Zone AE with an 8 foot base flood elevation, so a financed buyer’s lender may require flood insurance. An elevation certificate for your building and a flood quote help a buyer price that cost.

Did Hurricane Ian damage hurt Tamarind Cay values?

Lee County’s public damage layers show no records at Tamarind Cay’s 21 buildings and no Gulf Harbour folio received a Substantial Damage determination. Tamarind Cay’s 2022 qualified sales, recorded that year, ran up to $560,000.

What does a buyer’s insurance quote depend on?

A buyer’s HO-6 quote on a Tamarind Cay unit depends on the association’s master policy and wind deductible, the unit’s wind mitigation features and the buyer’s coverage choices. A current wind mitigation report on your unit gives the buyer’s agent what they need.

Should I get a wind mitigation report before listing?

Yes. Tamarind Cay buildings date from 1995 to 2000, before the 2002 Florida Building Code, and insurers rate roof covering, roof-to-wall connections and opening protection. A current report lets a buyer quote insurance during the inspection period instead of after it.

Do I need to disclose storm repairs?

Florida sellers disclose known facts that materially affect value. Unit-level storm repairs at Tamarind Cay live in association minutes and your own records, so we gather permits, invoices and the association’s account before listing.

Can I sell my Tamarind Cay unit with a tenant in it?

Yes, subject to the lease and the association’s leasing rules. A 2023 listing record stated a 30-day minimum and up to five leases a year; a buyer takes the unit subject to the tenant’s lease unless the contract says otherwise.

What does it cost to sell a Tamarind Cay condo?

A Tamarind Cay seller usually pays the brokerage commission, Florida documentary stamp tax on the deed, the owner’s title insurance policy by Lee County custom, prorated taxes and association fees, and the estoppel fee. We give every seller a net sheet before listing.

Who pays for title insurance when I sell in Tamarind Cay?

In Lee County the seller customarily pays for the owner’s title insurance policy and chooses the closing agent; the contract controls.

How do capital gains work when I sell?

Federal capital gains rules on a home sale, including the exclusion for a main home, are in IRS Publication 523. Owners of the 63 homesteaded Tamarind Cay units and owners who rent should each confirm treatment with a tax adviser.

What is the best season to sell in Tamarind Cay?

The county record shows Tamarind Cay sales recorded in every season of the 24-month window, from January to November, so there is no closed season. Traffic on McGregor Boulevard, Summerlin Road and US 41 rises from January to April, so we plan showings around it.

How long does a Tamarind Cay closing take?

A Tamarind Cay closing usually runs on the buyer’s financing timeline plus the association’s application and approval time. Ordering the estoppel certificate and confirming the approval process early keeps the closing date.

Does the master association need to approve my buyer?

The Gulf Harbour master association runs gates and security; sale and lease approvals, where required, come from the Tamarind Cay declaration. Ask the manager which approvals apply before listing.

Should I sell furnished?

Furnished seasonal rentals appear in the 2026 Tamarind Cay listing record, so a furnished sale can appeal to a buyer who plans to rent. We list furnishings on a separate inventory so the appraisal values the real estate alone.

How do I compete with other Tamarind Cay units on the market?

You compete on price per plan, view, condition and paperwork. With 174 units in four plans, the unit with the current estoppel, insurance declarations and wind mitigation report ready usually wins the buyer.

What do buyers misread about Tamarind Cay?

Buyers misread three things: they budget the master fee as the whole fee, they believe a two-story condominium carries milestone and SIRS costs, and they compare listing sizes to county sizes. We correct all three in the listing.

Can I list my Tamarind Cay unit privately?

Yes, but a private sale reaches fewer buyers. We market Tamarind Cay units with professional photography, drone video of the lakes, golf course and pool, and our qualified-buyer database.

How does McGreevy and Comisar price a Tamarind Cay unit?

We tracked all 15 qualified Tamarind Cay resales in the 24 months to September 21, 2026, by plan and floor, then adjust for view, garage, lanai, condition, fees and insurance. Start with our free home valuation.

Who should I call to sell my Tamarind Cay condo?

Call Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072, text or call. Jesse leads listing and seller strategy for McGreevy and Comisar of Domain Realty Group, the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012.

Do you also help Tamarind Cay owners buy their next home?

Yes. Marc Comisar leads our buyer work at (239) 457-1610 and can line up your purchase with your Tamarind Cay sale; see how we represent buyers.


Sources and Authoritative References

The sources below are the primary records behind every Tamarind Cay figure on this page: Lee County Property Appraiser cost cards, roll and recorded sales, Lee County GIS layers, Florida DBPR condominium records, the Florida Statutes, FEMA’s flood maps, USGS and NHC records, School District of Lee County zones and Gulf Harbour’s own pages. This edition prints no MLS figures.

County property and sales records

Lee County GIS layers

County planning and parks

State records and statutes

Federal flood, elevation and storm records

Schools

Gulf Harbour, club and marina

News and other records


Downloadable Documents

Tamarind Cay’s downloadable documents are public records a buyer or seller uses in a Tamarind Cay transaction, each linked to the publisher’s own copy: the state condominium registry extract, the milestone and condominium statutes, the federal hurricane reports for Ian, Helene and Milton, the county’s post-Milton beach notice and the IRS home-sale guide.

Document

Publisher

Date

Link

Condominiums by county extract, Central West (CSV)

Florida DBPR

current extract

Download

Section 553.899, milestone inspections

The Florida Senate

2026 statutes

Read

Chapter 718, Condominiums

The Florida Senate

2025 statutes

Read

Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian (PDF)

National Hurricane Center

storm of September 2022

Download

Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Helene (PDF)

National Hurricane Center

storm of September 2024

Download

Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Milton (PDF)

National Hurricane Center

dated March 31, 2025

Download

Beach site reopenings after Hurricane Milton (PDF)

Lee County Parks and Recreation

October 2024

Download

Publication 523, Selling Your Home

Internal Revenue Service

current edition

Read


Market data from the Lee County Property Appraiser parcel file of November 2026 and its recorded qualified sales, newest recorded sale September 21, 2026. Data updated: November 2026. Tamarind Cay is recorded as four condominiums, Tamarind Cay Sections I to IV, at Official Records Books 2583, 2639, 2707 and 2758; its home counts on this page are the Lee County roll’s. This guide is general information about Tamarind Cay, not an appraisal and not legal, tax or insurance advice. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.

Market data from the Lee County Property Appraiser, pulled November 2026.

McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Tamarind Cay. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.


Work With Us

Thinking about buying or selling in Southwest Florida? Tell us what you are trying to do and we will tell you honestly what it will take. McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group.