1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

What's Your Fiddler's Creek Home Worth?

What's Your Fiddler's Creek Home Worth?

Your Home Valuation

Thank You! We are going to prepare a customized report with information on the value of your home.
View Our Listings

Updated October 2026 · Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty

Sell Your Fiddler’s Creek Home with the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012

Selling a Fiddler’s Creek home means pricing against your own village, not a community median, and handing a buyer the Foundation, CDD and village paperwork before they ask. McGreevy and Comisar, the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012, price every Fiddler’s Creek listing from Southwest Florida MLS closings and run that paperwork for you.

Fiddler’s Creek is a gated, master-planned golf community in Naples, Florida, ZIP 34114, with about 2,900 homes and condominiums in 35 villages, two Community Development Districts and a mandatory Foundation with its own Club and Spa. This page is written for the owner who is ready to sell, or thinking about it. The full picture of the community, from the 1990s villa condominiums to the Section 29 approvals, lives in our Fiddler’s Creek community guide, and this seller page sits beside it. Everything below answers one question: how to sell a Hawk’s Nest villa, a Varenna coach home, a Millbrook patio home or a Marsh Cove estate for the most money, with the fewest surprises, on a date you choose. In the 12 months to October 13, 2026 we tracked 189 Fiddler’s Creek closings at a median of $770,000 in the Southwest Florida MLS. Call Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072 whenever you want to talk it through.

Why List Your Fiddler’s Creek Home With McGreevy and Comisar

Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and lead the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012. McGreevy and Comisar are the #5 real estate team in Florida in the 2026 RealTrends rankings. Domain Realty, our brokerage, closed 658 transaction sides in Naples in the 60 months to October 5, 2026, $521.5 million in volume counted by side, per the Southwest Florida MLS pulled that day. If you are interviewing listing agents before you choose, our guide to the best real estate agents in Naples compares the teams on the public record. For a Fiddler’s Creek owner the test is simple: ask every agent to show you the closings in your village, the CDD line on your tax bill, and the estoppel figures a buyer’s closing agent will request before closing.

The Credentials, Stated Plainly

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

These are career figures across Lee and Collier counties, and we label them that way. As the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate, and Jesse and Marc alone have over $900 million in sales inside that number. Jesse has been in Southwest Florida real estate since 2004 and the team has worked together since 2008. The wider team is at DomainRealtyGroup.com.

Who Does the Work on Your Listing

You get Jesse and Marc, not a coordinator reading from a template. Jesse McGreevy runs pricing, data, marketing and the association paperwork, which in Fiddler’s Creek can mean the Fiddler’s Creek Foundation, a village or condominium association, one of two CDDs and the buyer’s lender and insurer all asking for documents on one sale. Marc Comisar runs the field: showings, buyer-agent conversations, inspections, contractors and walkthroughs for owners who spend the summer up north. Reach Jesse at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610, and read how the partnership works on our about McGreevy and Comisar page.

What That Means for a Coach-Home Owner and for an Estate Owner

A coach-home or villa owner in Varenna, Laguna, Cascada or Hawk’s Nest is selling a unit in a condominium, so the association’s budget, insurance and reserves are part of what the buyer is purchasing, and the condominium statute sets the documents you deliver. An owner in Marsh Cove, Oyster Harbor, Runaway Bay or Isla del Sol is selling a single-family home with its own roof, pool, lot, elevation certificate and, in some villages, a CDD debt line. We price and prepare the two sales differently, and the sections below keep them apart.

What Makes Selling in Fiddler’s Creek Different?

Selling in Fiddler’s Creek differs from a typical Naples sale in five ways: 35 villages trade as separate markets, every home carries a Foundation, a CDD and a village layer, the Golf Club and Tarpon Club are optional, flood zones change by village, and the developer is still selling new homes beside your resale.

Data updated: October 2026

35 Villages Inside One Gate

The Southwest Florida MLS recorded Fiddler’s Creek closings under 35 village names in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, from a $250,000 Whisper Trace villa condominium to a $3,900,000 Isla del Sol estate (closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). The 2026 Florida Department of Revenue parcel roll counts 2,901 improved residential parcels inside the gates: 1,477 single-family homes and 1,424 condominium units, plus 113 vacant homesites. A Hawk’s Nest seller and a Marsh Cove seller share a gatehouse and a Club and Spa, and almost no comparable sales.

Three Layers on Every Home: Foundation, CDD and Village

Every Fiddler’s Creek home sits under three layers. The Fiddler’s Creek Foundation, Inc. is the mandatory master association; owning a home gives “social membership in the Foundation, subject to payment of assessments,” per the developer’s legal terms page (read October 2026). One of two Community Development Districts maintains the lakes, roads, irrigation and landscaping and bills you on the county tax bill. And each home belongs to a village or condominium association: 14 condominiums on the Florida DBPR condominium roster with 1,392 declared units, and about 21 single-family and villa village associations. A buyer’s closing agent will request paperwork from each layer, and the seller who has it ready controls the timeline.

Two Optional Clubs a Buyer Will Ask About

The Club and Spa comes with Foundation membership; a 2013 Collier Circuit Court complaint, archived here, quotes the Declaration: “membership in the Foundation is mandatory for homeowners. This membership includes access to the Club and Spa at Fiddler’s Creek.” The Golf Club at Fiddler’s Creek, home of the Arthur Hills Creek Course, and The Tarpon Club, with a Marco Island beach pavilion and an Isles of Capri marina, are separate and optional, per the developer’s legal page. Buyers often assume golf comes with the house. Explaining the three tiers clearly, early, keeps a buyer from walking at the estoppel stage.

A Flood Map That Changes by Village

At 108 county address points we queried on the FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer on Oct 7, 2026, 76 sit in Zone AE (69 with a base flood elevation of 7 ft NAVD88 and 7 at 8 ft) and 32 in shaded Zone X; none is in Zone VE. Whole villages such as Runaway Bay, Cherry Oaks, Mallards Landing and Whisper Trace sampled entirely in shaded Zone X, while Chiasso and most of Laguna sampled at the higher 8 ft elevation. A buyer’s lender reads that map, so your village’s zone and your elevation certificate are pricing facts. The details are in the community section below.

Resale Against the Developer’s New Construction

The developer and its building affiliate are still selling new homes inside the gates in 2026: coach homes in Dorado (the Palmetto plan from $1.7 million, per the developer’s Dorado page) and Callista II (from $1.5 million), single-family homes in Oyster Harbor (Allamanda IV from $2.4 million and Hibiscus IV from $2.8 million, each plus homesite) and custom estates in Hidden Cove, all per the developer home page read in October 2026. A ready-now resale competes with those prices, and a well-prepared resale often wins on timing and finished upgrades. We show you where your home sits against both.

Key Takeaways for a Fiddler’s Creek Seller

Fiddler’s Creek recorded 189 closings and $205,175,925 in volume in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, at a $770,000 median and a $250,000 to $3,900,000 range across 35 village names. These eight facts frame every pricing, marketing and paperwork decision on the pages that follow.

  • Market: 189 closings, a $770,000 median, a range of $250,000 to $3,900,000 and $205,175,925 in volume (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026).
  • Two products: by our arithmetic on the same pull, the 14 condominium village names account for 93 closings at a $575,000 median, and the single-family, patio and villa villages for 96 closings at a $1,235,000 median.
  • Village depth: Marsh Cove (16 sales, median $2,288,750), Cherry Oaks (12, $667,500), Varenna (12, $577,000), Laguna (12, $495,000), Oyster Harbor (11, $2,125,000) and Hawk’s Nest (10, $317,500) had ten or more sales; nine village names had only one or two.
  • CDD line: $1,836.29 of operations and maintenance per unit in CDD #1 and $1,797.75 in CDD #2 on the November 2026 bill, up to $6,936.29 in Marsh Cove with its debt line (CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget; CDD #2 FY2027 adopted budget).
  • Foundation: membership is mandatory and includes the Club and Spa; the current dues and closing buy-in are not published, and the Foundation’s estoppel certificate is the document that states them.
  • Flood: 76 of 108 sampled addresses in Zone AE and 32 in shaded Zone X, none in Zone VE (FEMA NFHL, Oct 7, 2026); every sampled point is in Collier Hurricane Evacuation Zone A.
  • Title: in Collier County the buyer customarily pays the owner’s title policy; the purchase contract controls.
  • Season: 100 of the 189 closings fell in the five months from December to April, by our count of the MLS close dates.

What Record Stands Behind a Fiddler’s Creek Listing?

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, Top 1% Nationally since 2008, and we track every Fiddler’s Creek closing: in the last 12 months we tracked 189 Fiddler’s Creek closings, $205,175,925 in volume and a $770,000 median across 35 village names in the Southwest Florida MLS.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026, pulled Oct 13, 2026)

The Team Behind the Numbers

As the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate, and Jesse and Marc alone have over $900 million in sales. Those are career figures across Southwest Florida. They tell you how many negotiations, inspections and closing-table surprises the people on your listing have already handled, which matters most on a sale with a Foundation, a village association, a CDD, a lender and an insurer in the room. McGreevy and Comisar are also the #5 real estate team in Florida in the 2026 RealTrends rankings.

The 12-Month Fiddler’s Creek Market We Tracked

Southwest Florida MLS, 12 months to Oct 13, 2026

Closings

Median price

Volume

Median days on market

Median $ per sq ft

All Fiddler’s Creek

189

$770,000

$205,175,925

74

$332

Condominium villages (14 names)

93

$575,000

$55,394,925

89

$233

Single-family, patio and villa villages

96

$1,235,000

$149,781,000

66

$497

The all-community row is the Southwest Florida MLS pull of Oct 13, 2026; the condominium and single-family rows are our arithmetic from the same 189 closings, grouping the 14 condominium village names (Varenna, Cherry Oaks, Laguna, Hawk’s Nest, Cascada, Serena, Montreux, Deer Crossing, Sonoma, Dorado, Whisper Trace, Callista, Menaggio and Marengo) against the rest. Nine of the 189 closings were Sold Data Entry records; they count in closings, medians and volume and are left out only of days on market and sale-to-list ratio (sold price over final list price), which rest on the 177 closings that carry a days-on-market figure and both prices. Price per square foot uses the MLS living area for all 189. The highest sale in the year was an Isla del Sol estate at $3,900,000 in June 2026, and the lowest a Whisper Trace villa condominium at $250,000.

How We Measure a Fiddler’s Creek Listing

We judge a Fiddler’s Creek listing on three numbers you can check: days to contract against the median for your product, the sale price against its final list price, and whether the home closed on the date you planned. The pull behind this page holds closed prices, dates, village names, days on market and final list prices; days on market averaged 110 days (median 74) and the sale-to-list ratio was 94.7% on average and 94.7% at the median over the same window, and we will report both on your own sale. Those are the yardsticks the rest of this page uses.

Why the Community Median Misleads

A single median of $770,000 blends $250,000 villas with $3,900,000 estates. About half of the 189 closings were above it and half below, and only 28 closed within 10 percent of it: by our count, 34 closed under $500,000, 86 between $500,000 and $1,000,000, and 69 at $1,000,000 or more. Pricing a Fiddler’s Creek home off the community median is the most common and most expensive seller mistake we see, so every price we give you starts from your own village.

Is Now a Good Time to Sell in Fiddler’s Creek?

For a home priced to its own village, yes, and the calendar matters more in Fiddler’s Creek than in most of Naples. The Southwest Florida MLS shows 189 Fiddler’s Creek closings in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, and 100 of them closed between December and April, when the community is fullest.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026, pulled Oct 13, 2026)

Fiddler’s Creek Closings Month by Month

Month of closing

Closings

October 2025 (from Oct 13)

8

November 2025

10

December 2025

11

January 2026

16

February 2026

21

March 2026

24

April 2026

28

May 2026

14

June 2026

23

July 2026

14

August 2026

9

September 2026

10

October 2026 (to Oct 13)

1

Total

189

Counts are our tally of the close dates in the Southwest Florida MLS pull of Oct 13, 2026. A closing date trails the contract date by several weeks, so the March and April peak reflects contracts written in the winter season. A seller who wants that buyer pool lists in the fall, with the paperwork ready.

The Season Inside the Gates

The Foundation reports occupancy to the CDD boards, and the figures show how much the buyer pool moves. Average weekly occupancy was about 1,664 homes in December 2025 and about 2,210 in January 2026, falling from 1,315 in May 2026 to 900 in June 2026 (CDD #1 minutes, Jan 28, 2026; CDD #1 minutes, July 22, 2026). More owners in residence means more neighbors telling friends about a listing, more open-house traffic at the gate and more buyers touring in person. A summer listing still sells, usually to a buyer who has already decided on Fiddler’s Creek, so the marketing plan changes with the month.

Where the 189 Closings Landed by Price

Price band, closings Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026

Closings

Under $500,000

34

$500,000 to $999,999

86

$1,000,000 to $1,999,999

40

$2,000,000 to $2,999,999

21

$3,000,000 and up

8

Counts are our tally of the Southwest Florida MLS pull of Oct 13, 2026. The $500,000 to $1,000,000 band, the coach homes and the production single-family villages, carried 86 of the 189 closings. The $3,000,000-and-up band was eight sales in Isla del Sol, Marsh Cove and Oyster Harbor.

What Is for Sale Today

Active listings on the pull date, October 13, 2026, were 77, with 17 more pending, a median list price of $695,000 and months of supply of 4.9 (active listings divided by the last 12 months’ closing pace of about 15.8 a month). Single-family homes had 30 active listings and 3.8 months of supply; coach homes and other low-rise condominiums had 46 active and 5.9 months. Asking prices are not sale prices: a buyer’s appraiser reads closings, so we price from the closings above and then test the number against whatever is on the market in your village the week you list. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 for the current active count in your village.

Fiddler’s Creek Against Treviso Bay: The Benchmark Buyers Use

Buyers who shortlist Fiddler’s Creek almost always tour Treviso Bay, so it is the yardstick a Fiddler’s Creek seller is measured against.

Community, 12-month Southwest Florida MLS window

Closings

Median sold price

Price range

Fiddler’s Creek, all homes (Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026)

189

$770,000

$250,000 to $3,900,000

Fiddler’s Creek condominium villages (same window, our arithmetic)

93

$575,000

$250,000 to $1,570,000

Fiddler’s Creek single-family villages (same window, our arithmetic)

96

$1,235,000

$385,000 to $3,900,000

Treviso Bay, all homes (July 29, 2025 to July 29, 2026)

78

$550,000

$372,500 to $3,100,000

Fiddler’s Creek closed more than twice as many homes as Treviso Bay in the comparable year at a higher median, because a larger share of its stock is single-family. Treviso Bay publishes its master fee ($7,420 a year in its 2026 Annual Fee Sheet); the Fiddler’s Creek Foundation does not, which is why a Fiddler’s Creek seller should have the Foundation estoppel figure in hand when a buyer compares the two.

How Do We Price a Fiddler’s Creek Home?

We price a Fiddler’s Creek home from the closings of its own village and product, adjusted for size, view, lot, condition, the CDD line a buyer inherits and the flood zone, then test the number against live listings, the developer’s prices and what an appraiser will find, never the community median.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026; a village median is stated only where the village had 10 or more sales in the window named)

Start With Your Village and Your Product

Fiddler’s Creek sells four kinds of homes, and the price ladder follows the product: villa-style condominiums built 1997 to 2004, two-story coach-home condominiums mostly built 2001 to 2015, production single-family and patio homes, and estate and custom single-family homes. A Fiddler’s Creek buyer chooses a village first and the community second, so the first comparable set for your home is the closed sales in your own village, then villages of the same product and age. The tables below roll up every village with a recorded sale in the 12 months to October 13, 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS).

Villa-Style Condominiums: Whisper Trace, Hawk’s Nest and Deer Crossing

Villa condominium

Declared units (DBPR)

Sales, 12 months

Median (12 months unless noted)

Range, 12 months

Whisper Trace

132

5

$408,500 (36 months, 14 sales)

$250,000 to $399,000

Hawk’s Nest

120

10

$317,500

$300,000 to $375,000

Deer Crossing

140

6

$451,250 (36 months, 10 sales)

$320,000 to $530,000

Sources: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026 (a village median is stated only where the window held 10 or more sales, so Whisper Trace and Deer Crossing use the 36 months from Oct 13, 2023); declared units from the DBPR condominium roster. These three villages are the entry point to Fiddler’s Creek and to the Club and Spa, and all three are paid in full in CDD #1 at $1,836.29 per unit for FY2027. Hawk’s Nest is the tightest market in the community: ten sales inside a $75,000 band. A Hawk’s Nest seller who prices above $375,000 is asking a buyer to pay more than any of the last ten buyers did, so condition, updates and the unit’s position need to justify it in the listing itself.

Coach-Home Condominiums, 2001 to 2015

Coach-home condominium

Declared units (DBPR)

Sales, 12 months

Median (12 months unless noted)

Range, 12 months

Varenna

152

12

$577,000

$456,000 to $705,000

Cherry Oaks

116

12

$667,500

$475,000 to $862,000

Laguna

128

12

$495,000

$410,000 to $715,000

Cascada

132

9

$690,000 (24 months, 11 sales)

$565,000 to $799,000

Serena

76

7

$777,500 (24 months, 10 sales)

$600,000 to $915,000

Montreux

96

7

$720,000 (36 months, 11 sales)

$515,000 to $878,000

Sonoma

44

4

Not stated (9 sales in 36 months)

$390,000 to $500,000

Callista

64

3

Not stated (8 sales in 36 months)

$550,000 to $625,000

Sources: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026 (a village median is stated only where the window held 10 or more sales); DBPR condominium roster. Varenna, Cherry Oaks and Laguna, with 12 sales each, give the most reliable pricing inside the gates, and the other coach-home villages show a median only over the longer window named in the table (Cascada and Serena over 24 months from Oct 13, 2024, Montreux over 36 months from Oct 13, 2023). The carrying cost differs sharply between neighbors: Cherry Oaks, Cascada and Montreux are paid-in-full CDD #1 villages at $1,836.29 per unit for FY2027 (CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget), while CDD #2 bills Laguna $3,090.81, Varenna $3,349.42, Serena $3,521.82, Sonoma $3,521.82 and Callista $3,897.78 per unit for FY2026 (CDD #2 FY2026 adopted budget). A buyer comparing a Cascada coach home with a Varenna coach home sees that difference every November.

Thinking of Selling in Fiddler’s Creek Before the Winter Season?

With 100 of 189 Fiddler’s Creek closings landing between December and April, the weeks before the season are when a listing earns its first showings. Request a written opinion of value through our Fiddler’s Creek home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying instead? See how we help buyers purchase in Fiddler’s Creek, read how we represent buyers in Naples or call Marc at (239) 457-1610.

Dorado and the New Coach Homes

Dorado is the newest coach-home condominium in Fiddler’s Creek, built by Gulf Bay Homes in fourplex buildings; DBPR shows 32 units declared on May 7, 2021, and the developer describes 26 fourplex buildings. Dorado recorded four resales, at $1,190,000, $1,350,000, $1,527,325 and $1,570,000 (Southwest Florida MLS; too few for a 12-month median; the 36 months from Oct 13, 2023 held 13 sales at a $1,435,000 median), while the developer prices the Palmetto plan from $1.7 million on its Dorado page (read October 2026). CDD #2 bills Dorado $5,257.96 per unit (FY2026). A Dorado resale is priced against two things at once: the other resales in the building and the developer’s current list, which is the ceiling a buyer will test you against.

Production Single-Family and Patio Villages

Single-family or patio village

Sales, 12 months

Median (12 months unless noted)

Range, 12 months

CDD line

Millbrook

9

$862,500 (24 months, 16 sales)

$650,000 to $990,000

CDD #2, $4,814.86 to $6,194.09 by lot group (FY2026)

Amaranda

8

$980,000 (24 months, 14 sales)

$770,000 to $1,245,000

CDD #2, $4,095.21 (FY2026)

Amador

6

$1,030,000 (36 months, 13 sales)

$785,000 to $1,200,000

CDD #2, $6,194.09 (FY2026)

Mallards Landing

5

Not stated (8 sales in 36 months)

$670,000 to $1,400,000

CDD #1, paid in full

Cranberry Crossing

5

$1,030,000 (36 months, 12 sales)

$760,000 to $1,200,000

CDD #1, paid in full

Cotton Green

5

Not stated (7 sales in 36 months)

$650,000 to $825,000

CDD #1, paid in full

Chiasso

4

$1,352,500 (36 months, 10 sales)

$1,175,000 to $1,325,000

CDD #2, $4,383.85; Chiasso II $6,194.09 (FY2026)

Mussorie Village

4

Not stated (9 sales in 36 months)

$1,030,000 to $1,265,000

CDD #2, operations and maintenance only

Mulberry Row

4

$1,432,500 (36 months, 10 sales)

$900,000 to $1,550,000

CDD #1, paid in full

Pepper Tree

3

$685,000 (36 months, 11 sales)

$615,000 to $700,000

CDD #1, paid in full

Lagomar

0

Not stated (no closings in the 12 months; 4 in the prior 12 months at $1,250,000 to $1,500,000)

None in the window

CDD #2, O&M only on lots 1 to 42 and 76 to 77; $6,830.76 on lots 43 to 75 (FY2026)

Sources: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026 (a village median is stated only where the window held 10 or more sales; the 24 and 36 month windows run from Oct 13, 2024 and Oct 13, 2023); CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget; CDD #2 FY2026 adopted budget. Millbrook, with nine sales, is the most active single-family market below $1 million inside the gates. Chiasso’s four sales sit inside a $150,000 band, which reflects one builder’s plan library. In Lagomar two homes side by side can carry very different tax bills, so the CDD line belongs in the listing.

Estate Villages: Marsh Cove, Oyster Harbor, Runaway Bay and Isla del Sol

Estate village

Sales, 12 months

Median (12 months unless noted)

Range, 12 months

CDD and flood notes

Marsh Cove

16

$2,288,750

$1,200,000 to $3,362,500

CDD #1 debt line, $6,936.29 total (FY2027); Zone AE, BFE 7 ft; many Phase 2 lots carry LOMR-Fs

Oyster Harbor

11

$2,125,000

$1,299,000 to $3,200,000

CDD #2, $1,797.78 to $4,474.78 by group (FY2026); Zone AE, BFE 7 ft; multi-lot LOMR-Fs

Runaway Bay

4

$2,000,000 (36 months, 11 sales)

$1,350,000 to $2,300,000

CDD #1, paid in full; shaded Zone X at every sampled point

Isla del Sol

3

Not stated (7 sales in 36 months)

$3,250,000 to $3,900,000

CDD #1, paid in full; Zone AE, BFE 7 ft

Sources: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026; CDD #1 FY2027 and CDD #2 FY2026 adopted budgets (CDD #2 FY2027 lines on the certified roll run a few cents lower); FEMA NFHL and FEMA LOMA and LOMR-F layer, queried Oct 7, 2026. Marsh Cove and Oyster Harbor together carried 27 of the 189 closings and 30.1% of the dollar volume. Runaway Bay is the unusual combination of estate homes along The Creek, no CDD debt and no sampled Zone AE point, and a Runaway Bay listing should say so in its first paragraph.

Villages With One or Two Sales: We List the Sales

A median of one or two sales is not a market, so for these villages we list the closings themselves and price from them plus neighboring villages of the same product and age.

Village

Closings, 12 months to Oct 13, 2026

Mahogany Bend

Two sales: $2,725,000 and $2,950,000

Majorca

Two sales: $2,100,000 and $2,200,000

Marsh Subd (the MLS name on one Malaga Lane estate sale, a Sold Data Entry record)

One sale: $2,850,000

Sauvignon

One sale: $1,937,500

Bellagio

One sale: $1,845,000

Menaggio

One sale: $750,000

Marengo

One sale: $555,000

Bent Creek Village

One sale: $440,000

Cardinal Cove

One sale: $385,000

Source: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026. For a Sauvignon or Bellagio home, the right comparable is often a single-family sale in a neighboring paid-in-full CDD #1 village, adjusted for size and lot. For a Menaggio or Marengo coach home, it is the coach-home table above, adjusted for the CDD #2 line. Few homes in these villages come up for sale, so the next owner who sells should call us first: (239) 898-6072.

The CDD Line Is a Pricing Fact

The CDD assessment is a flat per-unit charge on the November tax bill, and buyers who compare villages notice it. For FY2027, a paid-off CDD #1 home pays $1,836.29, a Marsh Cove home pays $6,936.29 including its $5,100 debt line, and in CDD #2 the total runs from $1,797.75 for paid-off lots in Mussorie, Lagomar and most of Oyster Harbor to $6,830.73 for the Lagomar replat lots (CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget; CDD #2 FY2027 adopted budget). The price effect of a paid-off CDD is not measured in a public dataset, so we price it home by home, pairing sales of similar homes with different CDD lines.

Flood Zone and Elevation Certificate as Pricing Facts

A buyer with a federally backed mortgage on a Zone AE home will generally be required to carry flood insurance unless a LOMA or LOMR-F has removed the structure from the Special Flood Hazard Area. FEMA’s public LOMA and LOMR-F layer lists 33 determinations for Fiddler’s Creek villages from 2013 to 2025, including multi-lot letters for Oyster Harbor Phases 1 to 3, Amaranda, Dorado and Marsh Cove Phase 2 (FEMA NFHL layer 34, queried Oct 7, 2026). Collier County holds 1,378 elevation certificates on Fiddler’s Creek street names on its elevation-certificate layer. If your lot has a letter or a favorable certificate, it goes in the listing package on day one.

Square Footage: Builder A/C Area Against County Living Area

For many Fiddler’s Creek single-family villages, the county’s living-area figure runs well above the builder’s air-conditioned square footage. The developer’s dated press releases give builder A/C ranges by village: Millbrook plans of 1,649 to 2,246 A/C square feet, Chiasso 2,583 to 3,522, Runaway Bay 2,800 to 3,659, Oyster Harbor’s Taylor Morrison plans 1,689 to 3,439 and Isla del Sol 3,597 to 4,246 (developer press archive). We compare homes on builder A/C area wherever a builder figure exists, because a price per square foot built on two different definitions misprices the home. The median sold price per square foot over the window was $332 on the MLS living-area figure, $233 for the 14 condominium villages and $497 for the rest.

Why Automated Estimates Miss in Fiddler’s Creek

An automated estimate reads a ZIP code, square footage and recent nearby sales. In Fiddler’s Creek that means a model can blend a $320,000 Hawk’s Nest villa with a $2,288,750 Marsh Cove median, ignore a $5,000-a-year difference in CDD debt, miss a LOMR-F that lowers a buyer’s flood cost and treat county living area as air-conditioned area. None of those errors is small. Our opinion of value names the closings it relies on and the adjustments it makes, so you can check every step.

Resale Against New Construction: The Comparison a Seller Should See

Product

Resale, Southwest Florida MLS, 12 months to Oct 13, 2026

Developer’s 2026 new-construction price (read October 2026)

Dorado coach home

Four sales: $1,190,000, $1,350,000, $1,527,325 and $1,570,000

Palmetto plan from $1.7 million (Dorado page)

Callista coach home

Three sales: $550,000, $555,000 and $625,000; Callista II not yet resold

Callista II from $1.5 million (developer home page)

Oyster Harbor single-family

11 sales, median $2,125,000, from $1,299,000 to $3,200,000

Allamanda IV from $2.4 million and Hibiscus IV from $2.8 million, each plus homesite (developer home page)

Custom estate

Isla del Sol, three sales: $3,250,000, $3,575,000 and $3,900,000

Hidden Cove custom estates advertised “from over $10M” (developer home page)

A resale buyer gets a finished home, a known CDD line and a closing date in weeks; a new-construction buyer gets the newest plan and waits. The developer also discloses on its legal terms page that on approved-builder sales it “may be entitled to a marketing fee and/or brokerage commission … which may be paid by the approved builder or charged to the purchaser.” A resale listing that names its advantages against the developer’s list, in writing, gives a buyer a reason to choose it.

Selling your Fiddler’s Creek home? Get a free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying in Fiddler’s Creek? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers in Naples.

How Do We Market a Fiddler’s Creek Home?

We market a Fiddler’s Creek home to the buyers most likely to pay for its village and product, with photography, video and drone that show the lake, preserve or golf view, a document package that answers the fee and flood questions in week one, and seasonal outreach timed to when Fiddler’s Creek buyers are in Naples.

Data updated: October 2026

Photography, Video and Drone for Lake, Preserve and Golf Views

Premium marketing for a Fiddler’s Creek listing means professional photography, cinematic video and drone. The drone matters here more than in most communities: from the air a buyer can see the lake behind a Laguna coach home, the preserve edge behind an Oyster Harbor estate or The Creek behind a Runaway Bay home. The Arthur Hills Creek Course was ranked tied for 80th among U.S. residential courses in Golfweek’s Best 2026 (Jan 9, 2026), so a golf-front home’s marketing names the course and shows it.

The Fee Package Buyers Ask For in Week One

“What are the HOA fees?” is the most common question we hear about Fiddler’s Creek, and no single number answers it. A Fiddler’s Creek owner can be billed by as many as six entities: the county, a CDD, the Foundation, a village or condominium association and, by choice, the Golf Club and the Tarpon Club. We assemble the CDD line from your tax bill, the Foundation’s estoppel figures and your village budget before a listing reaches the market, so buyers price your home on the real carrying cost instead of a guess. A buyer who sees a clean, explained fee stack in week one negotiates differently from one who discovers a CDD debt line at the title stage.

Reaching Winter-Season and Out-of-State Buyers

Average weekly occupancy inside the gates rose to about 2,210 homes in January 2026 (CDD #1 minutes, Jan 28, 2026), and the March and April closing peak follows. We time the launch, the first open houses and the paid outreach to that calendar, and for a summer listing we lean on video tours, virtual walkthroughs and direct outreach to buyers who have already toured Fiddler’s Creek. Many Fiddler’s Creek sellers live elsewhere part of the year; Marc handles showings and vendors on the ground while you are away.

Off-Market and Private Sales for Owners Who Want Discretion

Some Fiddler’s Creek owners prefer not to put a sign in the yard or a price on the open market. For them we offer discretion and off-market capability: a private presentation to qualified buyers from our database and agent network, with the same pricing work and the same document package. Confidential conversations are welcome at (239) 898-6072.

Marketing the Club Structure Honestly

The quickest way to lose a Fiddler’s Creek buyer is to let them believe golf comes with the house; the developer’s legal page says owning a home gives only “an opportunity to join” the Golf Club. Our listing copy states the three tiers plainly: the Club and Spa through mandatory Foundation membership, and the Golf Club and Tarpon Club as optional memberships with their own Membership Plans. If you hold a Golf Club membership, we confirm with the club what its plan says about transfer before we mention it, because the refund and transfer terms are not published by a primary source.

What We Report to You During the Listing

You hear from Jesse every week: showings, online activity, buyer-agent feedback, new listings and closings in your village, and any change in the developer’s new-construction prices. If the market tells us something about price or presentation, we bring you the evidence and a recommendation, not a vague request to reduce.

How Do We Negotiate a Fiddler’s Creek Sale?

We negotiate a Fiddler’s Creek sale at the partner level, with the closings, the estoppel figures, the CDD line and the flood file already in hand, so the buyer’s inspection, insurance and document-review requests meet facts rather than guesses, and your price holds through closing.

Partner-Level Negotiation, Not a Template

Jesse and Marc negotiate your offers personally, with the Foundation estoppel in hand. That matters in Fiddler’s Creek because the issues that move a price are specific: a buyer’s surprise at the Foundation buy-in, a CDD debt line discovered late, an insurance quote on a Zone AE home, or a golf membership the buyer thought was included. We prepare the answers before the first offer arrives.

Inspection, Insurance and Estoppel Contingencies

Most Fiddler’s Creek contracts carry an inspection period, a financing contingency and, in practice, an insurance contingency, because the buyer’s carrier will ask for a wind-mitigation inspection, a four-point inspection on older homes and, for a condominium, the association’s master policy. Florida law requires insurers to offer discounts for wind-mitigation features, per s. 627.0629, Florida Statutes. Handing over a current wind-mitigation report and your elevation certificate early can turn a buyer’s insurance question into a smaller credit request, or none.

Buyer Compensation After the NAR Settlement

Since August 2024, buyer-agent compensation is negotiated separately and is never a fixed number. Brokerage compensation on your side is negotiable and set in your listing agreement. We walk you through the options, how Fiddler’s Creek buyers’ agents are approaching compensation in your price band, and how an offer of compensation, or none, affects your net. The decision is yours, in writing, before the listing goes on the market.

Closing Dates, Concessions and Seasonal Owners

A seller who leaves after Easter and a buyer who wants keys before the season do not always want the same date. We negotiate the closing date, any leaseback and the furniture question as part of price, not after it. Concessions, where a buyer asks for one, are measured against the closings in your village and the cost of the item, not against the buyer’s first number.

When the Appraisal Comes in Low

An appraiser in Fiddler’s Creek reaches for closed sales in your village first. When a village has one or two sales, the appraiser may reach outside the gate, and that is where low values come from. We send the listing agent’s comparable package to the appraiser through the proper channel, with the village sales, the builder A/C areas and the CDD differences documented, and if the value still comes in short we negotiate from the evidence.

Negotiating the CDD Debt Line

A buyer may ask you to pay off the CDD debt on your lot or credit its remaining principal. You are not required to: in Fiddler’s Creek the CDD debt assessment runs with the land and is collected on the annual tax bill. Each district’s adopted budget prints the remaining principal by village, for example $22,849.03 on a Marsh Cove Phase 1 lot and $30,752.48 on a Lagomar replat lot after the FY2027 payment (CDD #1 and CDD #2 FY2027 adopted budgets). We show the buyer the annual figure, the years remaining and the payoff, so the request is negotiated on the numbers.

Selling your Fiddler’s Creek home? Get a free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying in Fiddler’s Creek? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers in Naples.

Which Recent Fiddler’s Creek Sales Matter Most to Your Price?

The Fiddler’s Creek sales that matter most are the closings in your own village over the last 12 months, then sales of the same product in neighboring villages. The highest ten closings below show how the estate market is priced, and the village notes show the bands the busiest markets traded in.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026, pulled Oct 13, 2026)

The Ten Highest Fiddler’s Creek Closings

Village

Sold price

Closing date

Days on market

Isla del Sol

$3,900,000

Jun 4, 2026

12

Isla del Sol

$3,575,000

Jul 6, 2026

71

Marsh Cove

$3,362,500

Mar 19, 2026

37

Marsh Cove

$3,275,000

Apr 21, 2026

4

Isla del Sol

$3,250,000

Jul 6, 2026

71

Oyster Harbor

$3,200,000

Jun 1, 2026

12

Marsh Cove

$3,175,000

Oct 20, 2025

11

Marsh Cove

$3,000,000

Oct 23, 2025

Not recorded (Sold Data Entry)

Mahogany Bend

$2,950,000

Mar 18, 2026

16

Marsh Subd (Marsh Cove area)

$2,850,000

Apr 2, 2026

Not recorded (Sold Data Entry)

Source: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026; the $3,000,000 Marsh Cove closing and the $2,850,000 Marsh Subd closing are Sold Data Entry records, which carry no days-on-market figure. Seven of the ten sales are in Isla del Sol and Marsh Cove, with three in Isla del Sol and four in Marsh Cove, and the other three are Oyster Harbor, Mahogany Bend and the Marsh Subd record. The top of the Fiddler’s Creek resale market sits around $2,850,000 to $3,900,000, well below the developer’s “from over $10M” custom estates in Hidden Cove.

Marsh Cove: Sixteen Sales Across a Wide Band

Marsh Cove recorded 16 sales, the most of any Fiddler’s Creek village, at a median of $2,288,750 and a range of $1,200,000 to $3,362,500 (Southwest Florida MLS). The village has 217 single-family homes on the 2026 roll built 2015 to 2022, by Ashton Woods, Harbourside Custom Homes (2,514 to 3,672 A/C square feet) and Stock Signature Homes (2,812 to 3,600-plus A/C square feet) per the developer press archive. With a $2,162,500 spread between the lowest and highest sale, the builder, plan, lot and finish of your home decide where you sit, and the $6,936.29 CDD line for FY2027 belongs in the conversation from the first showing.

Oyster Harbor: Resales Against the Developer’s List

Oyster Harbor recorded 11 sales at a median of $2,125,000, from $1,299,000 to $3,200,000 (Southwest Florida MLS). It is the largest village in Fiddler’s Creek and still growing: the roll shows 279 single-family homes built 2015 to 2025 plus 42 vacant lots, and the developer advertises Allamanda IV from $2.4 million and Hibiscus IV from $2.8 million, each plus homesite. A ready-now resale with upgrades and a pool can be priced as the faster alternative to a build, and the CDD #2 line, $1,797.78 to $4,474.78 by lot group in FY2026, is part of that pitch.

Varenna and Millbrook: The Busiest Markets Below $1 Million

Varenna recorded 12 sales at a median of $577,000, from $456,000 to $705,000, level with Cherry Oaks and Laguna as the most active Fiddler’s Creek condominium; Millbrook recorded nine sales from $650,000 to $990,000, too few for a 12-month median, and over the 24 months from Oct 13, 2024 recorded 16 sales at a median of $862,500, the most active single-family market below $1 million inside the gates (Southwest Florida MLS). Both are CDD #2 villages with debt lines, Varenna at $3,349.42 and Varenna II at $4,211.44, and Millbrook from $4,814.86 to $6,194.09 by lot group (FY2026, CDD #2 FY2026 adopted budget). In markets this deep, the asking price is measured against a dozen recent closings, and a buyer’s agent will bring them all.

What a Buyer’s Appraiser Will Reach For

A lender’s appraiser in Fiddler’s Creek reaches first for closed sales in the same village within the last six to twelve months, then for the same product in a neighboring village. That means a Cascada appraisal will lean on the nine Cascada sales from $565,000 to $799,000, and a Sauvignon appraisal may lean on Bellagio and Mahogany Bend. When we price your home, we build the same comparable set the appraiser will, so the contract price is one the appraisal can support.

What Does It Cost to Sell a Home in Fiddler’s Creek?

Selling a Fiddler’s Creek home costs brokerage compensation set in your listing agreement, Florida documentary stamp tax of $0.70 per $100 of the price, estoppel fees from the Foundation and your village or condominium association, and prorated property tax and CDD assessments. In Collier County the buyer customarily pays the owner’s title policy.

Who Customarily Pays What in a Collier County Closing

Item

Who customarily pays on a Fiddler’s Creek resale

Governing source

Brokerage compensation

Negotiable; set in your listing agreement and the purchase contract

Your listing agreement

Documentary stamp tax on the deed

Seller, $0.70 per $100 of consideration

s. 201.02, Florida Statutes

Owner’s title insurance policy

Buyer, by Collier County custom; the contract controls

Purchase contract

Foundation estoppel certificate

Requested for closing; fees capped by statute

s. 720.30851, Florida Statutes

Village or condominium estoppel certificate

Requested for closing; condominiums follow the parallel condominium statute

s. 720.30851 or the condominium statute

Property tax for the current year

Prorated to the closing date

Tax bill

CDD assessment for the current year

Prorated with the tax bill; the debt line runs with the land

CDD #1 FY2027 and CDD #2 FY2027 adopted budgets

Any levied, unpaid special assessment

Paid from the seller’s proceeds unless the contract says otherwise

Estoppel certificate

Foundation buy-in at closing

Not published; the governing documents typically assign it to the incoming owner, and the contract can reallocate it

Foundation estoppel certificate

In Collier County the buyer customarily pays the owner’s title policy and chooses the closing agent, so the owner’s title policy is not a standard seller cost on a Fiddler’s Creek sale. The purchase contract controls, so read the title clause before you sign. We never list the owner’s title policy as a seller cost unless your contract assigns it to you.

The Documentary Stamp Tax, Worked

Florida documentary stamp tax on a deed is $0.70 per $100 of consideration under s. 201.02, Florida Statutes, customarily a seller cost. Worked at the Fiddler’s Creek medians from the Southwest Florida MLS pull of Oct 13, 2026 (our arithmetic):

Sale price

Documentary stamp tax

$575,000 (condominium village median)

$4,025.00

$770,000 (community median)

$5,390.00

$1,235,000 (single-family village median)

$8,645.00

$2,288,750 (Marsh Cove median)

$16,021.25

Two Estoppel Certificates on Most Sales

A Fiddler’s Creek sale usually needs two estoppel certificates: one from the Fiddler’s Creek Foundation and one from your village or condominium association. Each certificate states what is owed and what transfers, and each association may charge for it within limits the statute sets (s. 720.30851, Florida Statutes; condominiums follow the parallel condominium statute). Expect two fees and two delivery clocks. We request both as soon as you sign the listing, not when the buyer’s title company asks, because the Foundation figures can change a buyer’s cash-to-close math.

How Property Tax and CDD Prorations Work

Fiddler’s Creek property tax is ad valorem: the 2026 certified combined rate on the county roll is 10.3696 mills, or $1,036.96 per $100,000 of taxable value, down from 10.5058 in 2025 per the Florida Department of Revenue’s 2025 Collier millage summary. The CDD assessment rides on the same November bill. At closing the current year’s tax and CDD charges are prorated, so a seller who closes at mid-year credits the buyer for roughly the first half of the year: on a paid-off CDD #1 home that is about $918 of the $1,836.29 FY2027 CDD line, by our arithmetic.

Commission and Net Proceeds

Your net proceeds are the price less brokerage compensation, documentary stamp tax, the estoppel fees, any balance the estoppels show, the prorations and any credit you agree to. We prepare a written net sheet at two or three price points before you list, built on your village’s closings and your own tax bill, and update it with every offer so you are always comparing net dollars, not headline prices.

The Disclosure Summary Duty: Section 720.401

The Fiddler’s Creek Foundation is a homeowners’ association under chapter 720, so a resale of a home under it brings the disclosure summary duty in s. 720.401, Florida Statutes. The timing is pre-contract: the summary is to be supplied before the buyer executes the contract, not at closing, and on a resale it comes from the parcel owner, the seller. The contract must carry the statute’s voidability clause in conspicuous type, and if the summary is not delivered first, the buyer gets a cancellation right within 3 days after receipt of the summary or before closing, whichever occurs first, which cannot be waived and ends at closing. We attach the summary to every Fiddler’s Creek listing before the first offer is written. This is information, not legal advice: your closing agent or attorney confirms how it applies to your home.

Condominium Sellers: Chapter 718, Not the Section 720.401 Summary

Section 720.401(2) is a real fork: it does not apply to associations governed by chapter 718 and the other chapters it names. Fiddler’s Creek mixes a chapter 720 master, the Foundation, with 14 chapter 718 condominiums, from Whisper Trace and Hawk’s Nest to Varenna and Dorado. A condominium seller there works under two regimes: the condominium documents the condominium statute requires (the declaration, bylaws, rules, budget and related documents) for the condominium itself, and the Foundation’s own requirements for the master layer. Which disclosures your sale needs depends on your village’s legal form, so we confirm it with your closing agent or attorney at listing. This is information, not legal advice.

The Flood Disclosure: Section 689.302

Florida now requires a flood disclosure on residential sales under s. 689.302, Florida Statutes. With 76 of 108 sampled Fiddler’s Creek addresses in Zone AE and every sampled point in Collier Hurricane Evacuation Zone A (FEMA NFHL; Collier evacuation zone layer, Oct 7, 2026), a seller should complete it carefully and attach the elevation certificate and any Letter of Map Change. Florida also requires a seller to disclose known facts that materially affect value and are not readily observable, and in Fiddler’s Creek the CDD assessment should be disclosed with its amount.

Costs Particular to Fiddler’s Creek

Four items are specific to this community. The Foundation’s capital charge at closing: the one primary record that states an amount is the 2010 bankruptcy-court sale filing, which describes “a Capital Acquisition Assessment for membership to The Club & Spa at Fiddler’s Creek in the amount of $15,000.00” paid to the Foundation at closing (Docket 314.1, Aug 10, 2010); the current amount and any refund terms are on the Foundation estoppel. The CDD debt line, which continues with the lot. Golf Club membership terms, which the club’s Membership Plan governs; the club’s 2024 Articles refer to “Equity Members” but state no refund amounts or timing (Golf Club Articles). And any condominium special assessment, which your association’s notices and estoppel show.

Selling your Fiddler’s Creek home? Get a free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying in Fiddler’s Creek? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers in Naples.

Get Your Free Fiddler’s Creek Home Valuation

You can get your free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation in about 60 seconds, then talk it through with Jesse. We read the closings in your village, the active listings, your CDD line and your flood zone, and send a written opinion of value. Or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

What Is Your Fiddler’s Creek Home Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds.

Enter your address in the valuation form below the page’s top banner and we start with the closings that match your product: your village and building for a coach home or villa, your village, lot and builder plan for a single-family home. For a fuller answer, use our dedicated Fiddler’s Creek home valuation page, which is built around the same Southwest Florida MLS pull as this page. Prefer to talk? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome.

What You Receive

You receive a written opinion of value with the closings we relied on, the active listings you compete with, the developer’s current new-construction prices where they matter, the adjustments we made for size, view, condition, CDD line and flood zone, and a net sheet at two or three price points. We also send a short checklist of the documents your home will need before a buyer’s closing agent asks: the Foundation and village estoppels, the disclosure summary, your tax bill and your elevation certificate. There is no obligation, and a valuation is not a listing agreement.

What Do Fiddler’s Creek Sellers Say About McGreevy and Comisar?

Past clients describe how McGreevy and Comisar price, communicate and close, and every quote below is a verbatim 5-star Google review from a Southwest Florida client of Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, shown without an aggregate rating.

McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Fiddler’s Creek realtor, and every quote below is a five-star review on our Google Business Profile.

★★★★★ “He met us within 20 minutes to see it and we loved it. We worked with him on the offer and the transaction was seamless!” Verified Google review

★★★★★ “Marc’s attention to detail and deep understanding of the Southwest Florida market gave us so much confidence.” Verified Google review

Talk to McGreevy and Comisar Before You List

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners
  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 · [email protected]
  • Marc Comisar: (239) 457-1610
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Selling your Fiddler’s Creek home? Get a free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying in Fiddler’s Creek? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers in Naples.

What Should a Fiddler’s Creek Seller Know About the Community?

A Fiddler’s Creek seller should know the community the way a careful buyer will read it: who governs it, what each fee layer covers, how the CDD bonds stand, which flood zone and elevation each village carries, the storm record, the rules, the schools and the drive times. Each answer below is the one we give buyers’ agents.

Who Governs Fiddler’s Creek

Fiddler’s Creek is governed in three layers: the Fiddler’s Creek Foundation, Inc., a mandatory master association still controlled by developer-appointed directors in 2026; two community development districts with resident-elected boards that own the roads, lakes and irrigation; and roughly 35 village or condominium associations. The Foundation is Sunbiz document N96000005455, filed Oct 24, 1996, with its principal address at the developer’s office (Sunbiz Foundation record). No turnover of the Foundation to resident control is documented in any record reviewed.

The Declaration and Where It Is Recorded

The original master covenants are the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions for Fiddler’s Creek, recorded at Collier County Official Records Book 2315, Page 2050, as recited in a December 2001 deed recorded at Official Records Book 2958, Page 0099. The developer now refers to an Amended and Restated Declaration on its legal page; your title agent will pull the recorded version with the buyer’s commitment. A buyer’s attorney reads the Declaration, the village declaration and, for a condominium, the condominium documents.

The Club and Spa

The Club and Spa sits on a 12.33-acre parcel at 3470 Club Center Boulevard titled to Fiddler’s Creek Foundation Inc., per Collier County GIS parcel data. The developer describes a roughly 54,000-square-foot clubhouse (developer About page) with a multi-pool complex, fitness and spa, six Har-Tru tennis courts, pickleball, bocce and dining. Because the Club and Spa comes with Foundation membership under the Declaration, it belongs in every listing’s first paragraph as part of what the buyer receives.

The Golf Club and the Tarpon Club

The Golf Club at Fiddler’s Creek operates the Arthur Hills Creek Course and the new golf clubhouse; the course land and clubhouse parcel are titled to Fiddler’s Creek Golf Club, Inc., a 2024 not-for-profit. The Tarpon Club offers a Beach Pavilion on Marco Island and preferred rates at the Tarpon Club Marina on Isles of Capri (developer beach page; developer yachting page). Both are optional, and their fees are governed by their own Membership Plans, which are not published.

The Two CDDs and Their Bonds

CDD #1

CDD #2

Units assessed (FY2027)

1,910

1,543

O&M per unit, November 2026 bill

$1,836.29

$1,797.75

Villages still carrying debt

Marsh Cove only

Most villages, by lot group

Audited bonds outstanding, Sept 30, 2025

$16,140,000

$33,700,000

Latest final maturity

May 1, 2038

May 1, 2045

Sources: CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget; CDD #2 FY2027 adopted budget; CDD #1 FY2025 audit; CDD #2 FY2025 audit. Both FY2025 audits report indenture compliance, and the districts’ filings on the CDD #2 EMMA issuer page since 2020 are annual reports and redemption notices with no default notices among them. A buyer who asks “are the bonds in good standing” gets a documented yes.

Does the CDD Fee Go Away When the Bonds Are Paid?

Only the debt portion. When a village’s bonds are paid, its debt line drops to $0, but the operations and maintenance assessment continues every year, because the districts still maintain the lakes, roads, irrigation and landscaping. Most of CDD #1 shows how that works: the 2013-2 group paid off on May 1, 2018 and the 2013-1 group on May 1, 2021, and those homes now pay O&M only, $1,836.29 for FY2027. CDD #1’s O&M rose $100 per unit from FY2026 to FY2027 (CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget).

The Irrigation System and What It Means for Future O&M

Fiddler’s Creek irrigates from its own lakes: 20 pumps of 75 horsepower in four stations, about 15,000 gallons per minute combined, per the CDDs’ May 6, 2025 irrigation system overview. A December 2024 summary reports that the master control system is past its useful life and a replacement is being scoped; its cost has not been published and would flow through future O&M budgets. Long-term buyers ask, and the documents answer.

Property Taxes and What a Buyer Inherits

A Florida homestead’s capped assessed value belongs to the owner, not the house. After a sale, the parcel is reassessed at just value as of the next January 1 under s. 193.155, Florida Statutes, so your buyer’s tax bill can be much higher than yours. At the 2026 certified combined rate of 10.3696 mills, every $100,000 of taxable value costs $1,036.96 a year before non-ad valorem charges such as the CDD and solid waste. We show buyers an estimate on their own price, so the tax reset does not surprise them after contract.

Rules a Buyer Will Ask About

Fiddler’s Creek rules live in layers: the Foundation’s recorded Declaration sets community-wide covenants, and each village adds its own. Foundation-wide leasing minimums are not published; one village that publishes its rules, Montreux, allows leases of at least 30 days, three per year, and requires written pre-approval with a background check, per the Montreux welcome packet (Apr 21, 2017). For any other village the Declaration and the village’s documents govern, and we pull them for your listing so a buyer who plans to rent sees the answer before contract.

Gates and Security

Fiddler’s Creek has three gatehouses: the Main gate off Collier Boulevard, the Sandpiper gate off US 41 and the Championship gate. “Sandpiper, Championship, and the Main gatehouses are operational 24/7. There are two patrols per shift; generally, one in CDD #1 and one in CDD #2,” per the CDD #1 minutes of July 22, 2026. For an out-of-state buyer who will leave the home empty in summer, that sentence is worth quoting in the listing.

Flood Zones, Village by Village

Village pattern on the 108-point FEMA sample

Villages

All Zone AE, BFE 7 ft

Dorado, Menaggio, Mussorie Village, Lagomar, Varenna, Oyster Harbor, Isla del Sol, Cascada, Cardinal Cove, Cotton Green, Deer Crossing, Marsh Cove Phases 1 and 2, Bent Creek Village, Mulberry Row

All Zone AE, some points at BFE 8 ft

Chiasso, Laguna, Hawk’s Nest

Mixed Zone AE and shaded Zone X

Amaranda, Callista, Millbrook, Serena, Pepper Tree, Mahogany Bend, Montreux

All shaded Zone X

Marengo, Bellagio, Cherry Oaks, Majorca, Mallards Landing, Runaway Bay, Whisper Trace

Source: FEMA NFHL layer 28 and layer 3, queried Oct 7, 2026; all four FIRM panels covering the sample carry an effective date of Feb 8, 2024. A village pattern is a sample, not a lot determination: your own lot’s zone, and any letter of map change, is what a lender reads.

LOMAs, LOMR-Fs and Elevation Certificates

A Letter of Map Amendment or Letter of Map Revision based on Fill is FEMA’s written determination that a structure or lot is above the base flood elevation. FEMA’s public LOMA and LOMR-F layer lists 33 determinations for Fiddler’s Creek villages from 2013 to 2025, mostly multi-lot LOMR-Fs in Oyster Harbor and Marsh Cove Phase 2. A 49-certificate sample from the County’s elevation-certificate layer shows finished floors mostly between about 7.0 and 8.7 ft NAVD88 against a base flood elevation of 7. If you have a certificate or a letter, it belongs in the listing package.

The 2027 Flood Map

FEMA is running a map revision for Collier County. Per the County’s Aug 19, 2026 announcement on the proposed flood maps, preliminary maps were released Mar 20, 2025, a 90-day appeal period opened Aug 19, 2026 and the County’s target effective date is “Summer 2027.” At the Fiddler’s Creek points we tested, the zone and base flood elevation are unchanged on the preliminary panels. That is a useful, documented answer for a buyer who asks whether the map is about to move.

Insurance Context for a Seller

Homeowner, wind and flood premiums for Fiddler’s Creek are not published by any primary source, so the figure for your buyer comes from a bound quote. The context: Citizens Property Insurance’s Collier County personal residential multiperil book fell from 9,735 policies on Sept 30, 2024 to 1,839 on Aug 31, 2026 (Citizens detail by county, Aug 31, 2026), so most buyers are placed with private carriers. Unincorporated Collier County is a Community Rating System Class 5 community, worth a 25% discount on eligible NFIP policies, per the Collier County 2026 Flood Protection Newsletter. A current wind-mitigation report and elevation certificate shorten your buyer’s insurance step.

Hurricane History a Buyer Will Ask About

No primary record we found documents storm surge entering Fiddler’s Creek homes in Hurricane Irma (2017) or Hurricane Ian (2022). The public record does show that in Irma “much of the community and the clubhouse at Fiddler’s Creek was without power for nearly a week” (Golfweek, Sept 27, 2017), and that Hurricane Milton brought 9 inches of rain and a water-line blowout that closed Fiddler’s Creek Parkway, per the CDD #2 minutes of Oct 23, 2024, which also record that “The Foundation is responsible for cleanup after a named storm.” A seller who knows the record answers the question once, calmly, with the sources.

No Milestone Inspections on Two-Story Buildings

Florida’s milestone inspection law (s. 553.899, Florida Statutes) and the structural integrity reserve study requirement (s. 718.112, Florida Statutes) apply to condominium buildings three or more habitable stories high. Fiddler’s Creek’s condominiums are two-story coach-home and villa buildings, and no Fiddler’s Creek building appears among the 926 buildings on Collier County’s milestone-inspection map (read Oct 7, 2026). For a condominium seller that is a selling point against taller buildings elsewhere in Naples, and we say so in the listing.

Schools by Address

Every Fiddler’s Creek address we tested is zoned for Manatee Elementary, Manatee Middle and Lely High for 2026-27; the Collier County Public Schools address lookup returned that trio for all 59 county subdivision codes inside the two CDDs on Oct 7, 2026. Both Manatee schools earned an A for 2025-26 and Lely High a B, per the Florida Department of Education’s 2025-26 school grades file. For a family buyer those are the first facts in the conversation.

Drive Times From the Gates

Destination

Road miles

Free-flow minutes (floor)

Fifth Avenue South, downtown Naples

11.9 to 13.2

21 to 25

Tigertail Beach Park, Marco Island

7.0 to 10.2

16 to 29

Physicians Regional, Collier Boulevard (closest ER)

6.6 to 8.0

11 to 15

I-75 Exit 101 (Collier Boulevard)

10.7 to 12.0

18 to 22

Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW)

40.0 to 41.4

52 to 56

Source: OSRM routing service on OpenStreetMap, free-flow estimates from three Fiddler’s Creek addresses on Oct 7, 2026; in season, plan on more. Fiddler’s Creek is closer to Marco Island’s beaches than to any Naples beach, and the Publix at the Sandpiper gate sits just outside the eastern entrance.

Section 29 and What Is Being Built Nearby

In December 2024 the County adopted Ordinance 2024-51, creating a 49.91-acre Section 29 development area for 750 rental units, 30% rent-restricted for 30 years. The County’s Aug 15, 2025 monitoring letter says construction “has not yet commenced, and no permits have been issued,” and the County’s July 1, 2026 affordable housing list still shows the project as “Approved,” not under construction. No dataset can measure an effect on home values yet, because nothing has been built; a buyer who asks gets the record.

Selling your Fiddler’s Creek home? Get a free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying in Fiddler’s Creek? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers in Naples.

Where Can I Learn More About Fiddler’s Creek and Its Villages?

Fiddler’s Creek has a full community guide, a dedicated valuation page and a buyer page, and our Naples seller guide covers the wider market. This section links them, notes the village pages in preparation, and names the neighboring communities sellers often compare.

The Fiddler’s Creek Guide and Its Sibling Pages

Our Fiddler’s Creek community guide covers the history, governance, CDDs, clubs, golf, flood zones, schools and drive times in full. If you want a number now, use the dedicated Fiddler’s Creek home valuation page. If you are also looking to buy, our Fiddler’s Creek buyer page is written for that side of the move, and Marc Comisar can be reached at (239) 457-1610. For the county-wide picture, read how we sell homes in Naples.

Village Pages

A dedicated Marsh Cove neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details. A dedicated Oyster Harbor neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details. A dedicated Varenna neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details. Until then, each village’s sales, CDD line and flood pattern are on the Fiddler’s Creek guide, and Jesse will send your own village’s closings on request.

Neighboring Communities Sellers Compare

Fiddler’s Creek buyers often tour Treviso Bay, Naples Reserve and Lely Resort the same week, and Esplanade by the Islands sits next door inside the same county zoning district but is a separate community. Knowing which of them your buyer is also viewing shapes how we position your home.

Frequently Asked Questions, Seller Edition (Fiddler’s Creek)

These are the questions Fiddler’s Creek sellers ask most, answered from the Southwest Florida MLS pull of Oct 13, 2026, the CDD budgets, county, state and federal records and our own process. Each answer is short on purpose; call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 for the version that applies to your village and home.

What is my Fiddler’s Creek home worth?

It depends on your village and product. In the 12 months to Oct 13, 2026, closings ran from $250,000 in Whisper Trace to $3,900,000 in Isla del Sol, and among the six villages with 10 or more sales the village medians ran from $317,500 in Hawk’s Nest to $2,288,750 in Marsh Cove, around a community median of $770,000 on 189 closings (Southwest Florida MLS). For a written opinion of value built on your own village’s closings, CDD line and flood zone, request a free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation or call Jesse.

Who is the best listing agent for Fiddler’s Creek?

The best listing agent for Fiddler’s Creek prices from your village’s closed sales, documents every fee layer before the buyer asks and markets to the buyers most likely to pay for your product. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, lead the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012 and are the #5 real estate team in Florida in the 2026 RealTrends rankings. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How long does it take to sell a home in Fiddler’s Creek?

Median days on market was 74 days (average 110) over the 12 months to Oct 13, 2026, and the median sale-to-list was 94.7%; those figures rest on the 177 closings with a days-on-market figure and leave out the Sold Data Entry closings. What shapes timing most here is season and paperwork: 100 of 189 closings fell between December and April, and a sale cannot close until the Foundation and village estoppel certificates arrive. Requesting them at listing saves weeks.

What is the current Fiddler’s Creek real estate market for sellers?

Over the latest 12 months the Southwest Florida MLS shows 189 closings, a $770,000 median, a $250,000 to $3,900,000 range and $205,175,925 in volume (closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026; data updated October 2026). Active inventory on the pull date, October 13, 2026, was 77 listings, with 17 pending. Sellers compete with resales in their own village and with the developer’s new construction.

Is it a good time to sell a Fiddler’s Creek coach home?

For a coach home priced to its own building, yes. The 14 condominium village names recorded 93 closings in the 12 months to Oct 13, 2026, at a $575,000 median by our arithmetic on the MLS pull, with Varenna (12), Cherry Oaks (12) and Laguna (12) the deepest markets. Listing before the winter season reaches the most buyers.

How much does it cost to sell a house in Fiddler’s Creek?

Expect brokerage compensation set in your listing agreement, documentary stamp tax of $0.70 per $100 of the price ($5,390.00 at the $770,000 median), two estoppel fees, any balance the estoppels show, and prorated property tax and CDD assessments. In Collier County the buyer customarily pays the owner’s title policy. We give you a written net sheet before you list.

Who pays for title insurance when selling in Collier County?

In Collier County the buyer customarily pays for the owner’s title insurance policy and chooses the closing agent, so it is not a standard seller cost on a Fiddler’s Creek sale. The purchase contract controls, so read the title clause before you sign. We never list the owner’s title policy as a seller cost unless your contract assigns it to you.

How much is the documentary stamp tax when I sell?

Florida documentary stamp tax on the deed is $0.70 per $100 of consideration under s. 201.02, Florida Statutes, customarily paid by the seller. On a $575,000 sale it is $4,025.00; on $1,235,000 it is $8,645.00; on a $2,288,750 Marsh Cove sale it is $16,021.25 (our arithmetic). Your net sheet carries the exact figure on your contract price.

What is an estoppel certificate, and how many will I need?

An estoppel certificate is an association’s written statement of what is owed on your home and what transfers at closing. Most Fiddler’s Creek sales need two: one from the Fiddler’s Creek Foundation and one from your village or condominium association, each with a fee the statute limits (s. 720.30851, Florida Statutes; condominiums follow the parallel condominium statute). We request both at listing.

Do I have to give the buyer a section 720.401 disclosure summary?

Under s. 720.401, Florida Statutes, on a home under the Foundation, a chapter 720 homeowners’ association, the seller supplies the disclosure summary before the buyer signs the contract, and the contract carries the statute’s voidability clause. If the summary comes late, the buyer can cancel within 3 days after receipt or before closing, whichever comes first. Condominium sellers face a fork, covered next. Your closing agent or attorney confirms how it applies.

What disclosures must I give when I sell a Fiddler’s Creek condominium?

Fiddler’s Creek has 14 chapter 718 condominiums under a chapter 720 master. Section 720.401(2) does not apply to chapter 718 associations, so a condominium seller delivers the condominium documents the condominium statute requires and works through the Foundation’s own requirements for the master layer. We confirm the exact package with your closing agent or attorney at listing; this is information, not legal advice.

What flood disclosure do I owe when I sell?

Florida requires a flood disclosure on residential sales under s. 689.302, Florida Statutes. In Fiddler’s Creek, 76 of 108 sampled addresses are in Zone AE and 32 in shaded Zone X, with every sampled point in Collier Hurricane Evacuation Zone A (FEMA NFHL and County layer, Oct 7, 2026). Attach your elevation certificate and any letter of map change.

Do I have to pay off the CDD bond before closing?

No. In Fiddler’s Creek the CDD debt assessment runs with the land and is collected on the annual tax bill, so a seller is not required to prepay it; the remaining installments continue for the next owner unless the contract says otherwise. Each district’s adopted budget prints the remaining principal by village, for example $22,849.03 on a Marsh Cove Phase 1 lot after the FY2027 payment.

Does a paid-off CDD raise my sale price?

A paid-off CDD lowers the buyer’s annual carrying cost, and buyers who compare villages notice; no public dataset measures the price effect, so we price it home by home. The gap is real: on the November 2026 bill a paid-off CDD #1 home pays $1,836.29, while a Marsh Cove home pays $6,936.29 and a Lagomar replat lot $6,830.73 (CDD #1 and CDD #2 FY2027 adopted budgets).

Which CDD is my home in?

Each village belongs to one district. CDD #1 covers most of the original villages, from Whisper Trace and Hawk’s Nest to Runaway Bay and Marsh Cove; CDD #2 covers most villages built after 2004, including Varenna, Laguna, Millbrook, Chiasso, Amaranda, Dorado and Oyster Harbor. The CDD line on your last tax bill names the district, and the County’s CDD boundary layer maps it.

Do I get my Capital Acquisition Assessment back when I sell?

No primary source publishes the current refund terms, so your Foundation documents decide it. The one primary record stating an amount is the 2010 bankruptcy-court sale filing, which describes a $15,000 Capital Acquisition Assessment for membership to the Club and Spa paid to the Foundation at closing (Docket 314.1, Aug 10, 2010). The Foundation estoppel states the current figure.

Who pays the Foundation buy-in at closing, buyer or seller?

The governing documents typically assign a capital or transfer charge to the incoming owner, and the purchase contract can reallocate it. The current Fiddler’s Creek amount is not published by a primary source in 2026; if one applies, the Foundation’s estoppel certificate shows it. We put that figure in front of buyers early so it never becomes a late negotiation.

Are Foundation dues published?

No. Foundation dues, any capital reserve or transfer contribution, any special assessment and any food and beverage minimum are not published by a primary source as of October 2026. The Foundation’s estoppel certificate and disclosure summary are the documents that state them for your home, and we request them at listing so your buyer prices on facts.

Is the Fiddler’s Creek golf membership refundable or transferable when I sell?

Golf Club refund and transfer terms are not published by a primary source; they are in the Golf Club’s Membership Plan and your membership agreement. The club’s 2024 Articles refer to “Equity Members” and their rights on dissolution but state no refund amounts or timing. We confirm your terms with the club before your listing mentions golf.

Do I owe a remaining special assessment when I sell?

Any Foundation or association special assessment that has been levied and is unpaid will appear on the estoppel certificate, and the closing agent pays it from your proceeds unless the contract assigns it otherwise. Installments due after closing are handled by the contract’s assessment clause. Read your own notices and estoppel; no current Fiddler’s Creek special assessment is published by a primary source.

How do property taxes reset for my buyer?

Your capped homestead value does not transfer. After a sale the parcel is reassessed at just value as of the next January 1 under s. 193.155, Florida Statutes. At the 2026 certified combined rate of 10.3696 mills, each $100,000 of taxable value costs $1,036.96 a year, before the CDD and solid waste charges on the same bill (Collier County 2026 certified roll).

Does my Fiddler’s Creek condominium need a milestone inspection or SIRS?

Not on the record. Those requirements apply to condominium buildings three or more habitable stories high, and Fiddler’s Creek’s condominiums are two-story coach-home and villa buildings; no Fiddler’s Creek building is among the 926 on Collier County’s milestone-inspection map (read Oct 7, 2026). That is a selling point against taller condominium buildings elsewhere in Naples.

Is my Fiddler’s Creek home in a flood zone?

Probably Zone AE or shaded Zone X, depending on village and lot. In the 108-point FEMA test of Oct 7, 2026, villages such as Runaway Bay, Cherry Oaks and Whisper Trace sampled entirely in shaded Zone X, while Chiasso and most of Laguna sampled in Zone AE at an 8 ft base flood elevation. Your lot’s own determination and any LOMA or LOMR-F decide it.

Do I need an elevation certificate to sell?

Florida law does not require one to list, but a buyer with a Zone AE home and a mortgage will want it for the flood quote. Collier County holds 1,378 elevation certificates on Fiddler’s Creek street names, and a sample shows finished floors mostly between about 7.0 and 8.7 ft NAVD88 against a base flood elevation of 7. We pull yours, if it is on file, before you list.

Will the 2027 FEMA map change my flood zone?

Not at the Fiddler’s Creek points we tested: the zone and base flood elevation are unchanged on FEMA’s preliminary panels. The County opened a 90-day appeal period on Aug 19, 2026 and targets an effective date of “Summer 2027,” and until then the preliminary maps are not the effective regulatory map (Collier County announcement, Aug 19, 2026).

Did Hurricane Ian or Irma flood Fiddler’s Creek homes?

No primary record we found documents storm surge entering Fiddler’s Creek homes in Irma (2017) or Ian (2022). The record does show a power outage of nearly a week after Irma and, in Hurricane Milton (2024), 9 inches of rain and a water-line blowout that closed Fiddler’s Creek Parkway (CDD #2 minutes, Oct 23, 2024). Disclose what you know about your own home.

Does insurance cost affect my Fiddler’s Creek sale?

Yes, because your buyer’s lender requires a bound policy before closing. Premiums are not published by any primary source and depend on roof, openings, floor height and carrier. A current wind-mitigation report, a four-point inspection on an older home and your elevation certificate let a buyer bind faster, and Florida law requires insurers to offer wind-mitigation discounts (s. 627.0629, Florida Statutes).

Can a buyer lease my Fiddler’s Creek home?

It depends on the village. Foundation-wide leasing minimums are not published; Montreux, which publishes its rules, allows leases of at least 30 days, three per year, with written pre-approval (Montreux welcome packet, 2017). For every other village the Declaration and the village documents govern, and we pull them for your listing so an investor buyer sees the answer before contract.

Should I sell or rent my Fiddler’s Creek home?

Seasonal rental rates are not published by a primary source, and leasing rules vary by village. We can pull leased comparables from the MLS for your village and floor plan, set them beside a net sheet for a sale, and add the carrying cost of the CDD line, Foundation dues and insurance while you hold. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 to run both numbers.

Will the Section 29 apartments hurt my home’s value?

No dataset can measure an effect yet, because nothing has been built. Ordinance 2024-51 created a 49.91-acre development area for 750 rental units; the County’s Aug 15, 2025 letter says construction “has not yet commenced, and no permits have been issued,” and its July 1, 2026 list still shows the project as “Approved.” A buyer who asks gets that record.

Does the 2010 bankruptcy still affect title or buyers?

The 2010 case is closed history. Fiddler’s Creek, LLC and related entities filed Chapter 11 in February 2010, the plan was confirmed in August 2011 and the case closed in December 2013. The CDD bonds that defaulted in that era were restructured, and both districts’ FY2025 audits report compliance with their bond indentures.

Is the developer still in control of the Foundation?

Yes, at the Foundation level. The officers and directors on the Foundation’s Sunbiz record are developer personnel and the developer’s outside counsel, and no turnover to resident control is documented. Residents elect the five-seat boards of both CDDs. Buyers ask about this, and the answer belongs in the listing conversation, not the inspection period.

What is the price of a Marsh Cove home?

Marsh Cove recorded 16 sales in the 12 months to Oct 13, 2026, the most of any Fiddler’s Creek village, at a median of $2,288,750 and a range of $1,200,000 to $3,362,500 (Southwest Florida MLS). It is the only CDD #1 village still carrying debt: $6,936.29 per unit on the November 2026 bill. Request a Marsh Cove valuation.

What is the price of an Oyster Harbor home?

Oyster Harbor recorded 11 sales at a median of $2,125,000, from $1,299,000 to $3,200,000 (Southwest Florida MLS, Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). Resales compete with the developer’s 2026 offerings, Allamanda IV from $2.4 million and Hibiscus IV from $2.8 million, each plus homesite, so a ready-now resale can be priced as the faster alternative.

How fast are Varenna condos selling?

Varenna recorded 12 sales in the 12 months to Oct 13, 2026, level with Cherry Oaks and Laguna as the most active Fiddler’s Creek condominium, at a median of $577,000 and a range of $456,000 to $705,000 (Southwest Florida MLS). Varenna median days on market was 88 days, with a median sale-to-list of 95.3%. It is a 152-unit coach-home condominium in CDD #2 at $3,349.42 per unit (FY2026).

What sells for the least and the most in Fiddler’s Creek?

The villa-style condominiums are the entry point: Whisper Trace closed from $250,000 to $399,000, Hawk’s Nest at a $317,500 median and Deer Crossing from $320,000 to $530,000. The top of the resale market is Isla del Sol, Marsh Cove and Oyster Harbor, and the ten highest closings ran from $2,850,000 to $3,900,000 (Southwest Florida MLS, Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026).

What is the price per square foot in Fiddler’s Creek?

The median sold price per square foot over the window was $332 on the MLS living-area figure (condominium villages $233, all other villages $497). Read any figure carefully here: for many single-family villages the county’s living-area number runs well above the builder’s air-conditioned square footage, so we compare homes on builder A/C area wherever a builder figure exists.

How many homes are for sale in Fiddler’s Creek right now?

Active inventory on the pull date, October 13, 2026, was 77 listings (30 single-family and 46 low-rise condominium, plus 1 attached villa), and it changes weekly, village by village. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 for the current active count in your village, and the list prices you would compete with.

When is the best time of year to sell a Fiddler’s Creek home?

Fall listing for winter contracts. In the 12 months to Oct 13, 2026, 100 of 189 Fiddler’s Creek closings fell between December and April, and April alone had 28 (our tally of MLS close dates). Foundation occupancy peaked at about 2,210 homes a week in January 2026 against 900 in June 2026 (CDD #1 minutes).

Do I need to live in Florida to sell my home?

No. Many Fiddler’s Creek sellers live elsewhere part of the year. Marc handles showings, inspections, vendors and the final walkthrough on the ground, documents are signed electronically or with a remote notary where the closing agent allows, and Jesse keeps you updated every week.

Can I sell my Fiddler’s Creek home by owner?

You can, and the paperwork is where it gets hard: two estoppels, a disclosure summary that must reach the buyer before contract, a CDD line to explain and a buyer’s insurance step. If you want to compare, we will give you a net sheet for a listed sale so you can measure it against a by-owner attempt.

Can I list my Fiddler’s Creek home off-market?

Yes. For owners who want discretion we offer a private presentation to qualified buyers from our database and agent network, with the same pricing work and document package as a public listing. Confidential conversations are welcome at (239) 898-6072.

Are real estate commissions negotiable after the NAR settlement?

Yes. Brokerage compensation is negotiable and set in your listing agreement, and since August 2024 buyer-agent compensation is negotiated separately rather than published as a fixed offer. We walk you through the options and their effect on your net before you sign.

What repairs should I make before listing in Fiddler’s Creek?

Start with what drives the buyer’s insurance and inspection: roof, windows and openings, HVAC and any open permit. A wind-mitigation report and four-point inspection done before listing show you what a buyer’s inspector and carrier will see. Cosmetic updates are worth doing when your village’s recent closings show buyers paying for them.

How do you price a home in a village with one or two sales?

We list the sales themselves rather than a median, then add the closest neighboring villages of the same product and age, adjusted for size, CDD line and flood zone. Sauvignon, Bellagio, Menaggio, Marengo, Bent Creek Village, Cardinal Cove and Marsh Subd each had one sale in the 12 months to Oct 13, 2026, so the comparable set reaches next door.

Is the valuation really free, and do I have to list?

Yes, it is free, and no, you do not have to list. A valuation is a written opinion of value with the closings we relied on and a net sheet, not a listing agreement. Request it on our Fiddler’s Creek home valuation page or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How do I start selling my Fiddler’s Creek home?

Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or request a free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation. We will pull your village’s closings, your CDD line and your flood file, request the estoppels and disclosure summary, and give you a price, a plan and a net sheet before you decide anything.

Sources

These are the primary sources behind the figures and rules on this page. Market figures come from the Southwest Florida MLS (closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026, pulled Oct 13, 2026), member data with no public URL, and are cited in the text by date range.

  1. State of Florida statewide cadastral service (Florida DOR 2026 parcel roll, Collier)
  2. Fiddler’s Creek (developer), Legal / Terms of Use
  3. Florida DBPR Division of Condominiums, condominium roster extract Condo_CW.csv (updated Oct 3, 2026)
  4. Collier Circuit Court Case No. 13-CA-314 complaint dated Jan 30, 2013 (archived; mandatory Foundation membership, Club & Spa management agreement)
  5. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, layer 28 Flood Hazard Zones (108 point queries Oct 7, 2026)
  6. Fiddler’s Creek (developer), Dorado Coach Homes
  7. Fiddler’s Creek (developer), home page
  8. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1, Adopted Budget FY2027
  9. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2, Adopted Budget FY2027
  10. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1 minutes, Jan 28, 2026
  11. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1 minutes, July 22, 2026
  12. Treviso Bay, 2026 Annual Fee Sheet, May 11, 2026
  13. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2, Adopted Budget FY2026
  14. FEMA NFHL, layer 34 LOMA and LOMR-F determinations
  15. Collier County GIS, Elevation_Certificates_view layer 36 (1,378 certificates on Fiddler’s Creek street names)
  16. Fiddler’s Creek developer press archive (pages 1 to 18, 2011 to 2019 releases)
  17. Golfweek, “Golfweek’s Best 2026 top 200 residential golf courses in the U.S.,” Jan 9, 2026
  18. Florida Statutes 2025, s. 627.0629 (wind mitigation discounts)
  19. Florida Statutes 2025, s. 201.02 (documentary stamp tax on deeds)
  20. Florida Statutes 2025, s. 720.30851 (estoppel certificates)
  21. Florida Department of Revenue, 2025 Collier Taxing Authority Code Descriptions and Millage Code Summary
  22. Florida Statutes 2025, s. 720.401 (disclosure summary for prospective parcel owners)
  23. Florida Statutes 2025, s. 689.302 (flood disclosure in residential sales)
  24. Collier County GIS, Hurricane_Evacuation_Zone
  25. Same case, Docket 314.1 (Aug 10, 2010; Club & Spa, Golf Club, Tarpon Club; $15,000 Capital Acquisition Assessment)
  26. Sunbiz image, Articles of Incorporation of Fiddler’s Creek Golf Club, Inc. (filed Aug 16, 2024; Equity Members clauses)
  27. Sunbiz detail, Fiddler’s Creek Foundation, Inc. (N96000005455)
  28. Collier Clerk Official Records OR 2958 PG 0099 (Dec 2001 deed reciting master Declaration OR 2315/2050 and Bellagio Village declaration OR 2834/1189)
  29. Collier County GIS, Parcels Join (Editable) layer 42 (owner and acreage by folio)
  30. Fiddler’s Creek (developer), About
  31. Fiddler’s Creek (developer), The Beach
  32. Fiddler’s Creek (developer), Yachting
  33. Florida Auditor General e-file, CDD #1 Financial Report FYE 9/30/2025 (Grau and Associates, June 2026)
  34. Florida Auditor General e-file, CDD #2 Financial Report FYE 9/30/2025 (Grau and Associates, June 2026)
  35. MSRB EMMA issuer page, Fiddlers Creek CDD No. 2 special assessment revenue
  36. Fiddler’s Creek Irrigation System Overview, CDD No. 1 and 2, May 6, 2025
  37. Master Irrigation Control System presentation summary, Dec 2024
  38. Florida Statutes 2025, s. 193.155 (homestead assessments; reassessment after change of ownership)
  39. Montreux at Fiddler’s Creek Condominium Association, welcome packet (Apr 21, 2017; lease application rev. Aug 15, 2017)
  40. FEMA NFHL, layer 3 FIRM Panels
  41. Collier County, “Proposed Flood Insurance Rate Map Reflects Changes to Local Flood Risk,” Aug 19, 2026
  42. Citizens Property Insurance, Detail by County, Aug 31, 2026
  43. Collier County, 2026 Flood Protection Newsletter
  44. Golfweek, “Back in business: Florida golf courses offer relief, get back on track after Irma,” Sept 27, 2017
  45. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2 minutes, Oct 23, 2024 (Helene and Milton)
  46. Florida Statutes 2025, s. 553.899 (milestone inspections)
  47. Florida Statutes 2025, s. 718.112 (SIRS, three habitable stories or higher)
  48. Collier County GIS, MilestoneMap (926 milestone-inspection buildings)
  49. Collier County Public Schools, Address_v3 school-zone lookup (59 queries, year=2027; one with year=2026)
  50. Florida Department of Education, SchoolGrades26.xlsx (2025-26 grades as of Sept 1, 2026)
  51. OSRM public routing service on OpenStreetMap (sample route; free-flow, no traffic)
  52. Publix, Shoppes at Fiddler’s Creek (#1730)
  53. Collier County Ordinance No. 2024-51 (Fiddler’s Creek Section 29 small-scale GMPA), adopted Dec 10, 2024
  54. Collier County Community and Human Services, Fiddler’s Creek (Marco Shores) PUD monitoring letter (Ord. 24-51 and 24-52), Aug 15, 2025
  55. Collier CHS, Affordable Housing Commitment/Inventory List, July 1, 2026
  56. Collier Clerk legal notice PDF, BCC hearing Dec 10, 2024 (PL20210003111 / 3115 / 3112: GMPA, DO amendment, PUD amendment)
  57. Collier Clerk of Courts, “BCC Unanimously Approved 750 Multi-Family Unit Development at Fiddler’s Creek” (Jan 2025)
  58. Collier CHS, Affordable Housing Monitoring Results page
  59. Collier County, Approved Affordable Housing Commitment/Inventory List, Jan 14, 2026
  60. Collier CHS, Isle of Capri PUD monitoring letter, Feb 6, 2026
  61. Collier CHS, Tamiami Trail 58 Acre PUD monitoring letter, Aug 31, 2026
  62. Collier County 2024 AUIR/CIE (Aug 23, 2024)
  63. Collier County 2025 AUIR/CIE (BCC Jan 27, 2026)
  64. Collier MPO FY2027 to FY2031 TIP, adopted June 12, 2026
  65. Collier MPO 2050 Long Range Transportation Plan, approved Dec 11, 2025
  66. Collier County Tax Collector property tax search, query “Fiddlers Creek Pkwy” (entity owners only)
  67. Collier County Solid Waste, Residential Collections Services
  68. Collier County Airport Authority, Marco Island Executive Airport
  69. Collier County GIS, FEMA24_FloodZones
  70. Collier County GIS, FEMA24_Panels
  71. Collier County elevation certificate PDF host (sample, 3397 Runaway Ln)
  72. Collier County GIS, EMS Stations
  73. Collier County, Floodplain Management (2024 FIRM, PMR status, CRS Class 5, 2024 SOMA)
  74. Collier County, Building Within the Floodplain
  75. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1, About the District
  76. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1, home page
  77. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1, Required Reporting of Information
  78. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1, Adopted Budget FY2026
  79. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1, Proposed Budget FY2027
  80. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1, establishing rule (Ch. 42X-1, F.A.C.)
  81. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1 minutes, Oct 22, 2025
  82. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2, home page
  83. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2, Required Reporting of Information
  84. Collier County Ordinance 02-61 (CDD #2 establishment)
  85. Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2 minutes, Feb 28, 2024

Downloadable Documents

These are official documents a Fiddler’s Creek seller or buyer is likely to be asked for, from the two CDD budgets and audits to the flood guidance and the Florida statutes that govern a resale. Every link goes directly to the publishing authority, not to a summary site.

Document

Publisher

Link

Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1 Adopted Budget, FY2027

Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1

Open the document

Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2 Adopted Budget, FY2027

Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2

Open the document

Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2 Adopted Budget, FY2026 (village debt lines)

Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2

Open the document

CDD #1 Audited Financial Report, FYE Sept 30, 2025

Florida Auditor General

Open the document

CDD #2 Audited Financial Report, FYE Sept 30, 2025

Florida Auditor General

Open the document

Florida Statutes s. 720.401 (disclosure summary)

Florida Senate

Open the document

Florida Statutes s. 720.30851 (estoppel certificates)

Florida Senate

Open the document

Florida Statutes s. 689.302 (flood disclosure)

Florida Senate

Open the document

Florida Statutes s. 201.02 (documentary stamp tax)

Florida Senate

Open the document

Florida Statutes s. 193.155 (homestead reassessment)

Florida Senate

Open the document

Collier County 2026 Flood Protection Newsletter

Collier County

Open the document

Collier County notice on the proposed FIRM, Aug 19, 2026

Collier County

Open the document

Fiddler’s Creek Irrigation System Overview, May 6, 2025

Fiddler’s Creek CDDs

Open the document

Collier County Ordinance 2024-51 (Section 29)

Collier County

Open the document

Articles of Incorporation, Fiddler’s Creek Golf Club, Inc. (2024)

Florida Division of Corporations

Open the document

Your Local Real Estate Experts

Whether you own a Hawk’s Nest villa, a Varenna coach home or a Marsh Cove estate, the next step is a conversation: a written price, plan and net sheet with no obligation. To see what your home is worth first, get your free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Buying as well? Call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers in Naples.

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners
  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 · [email protected]
  • Marc Comisar: (239) 457-1610
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC).

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more about our team at DomainRealtyGroup.com.

Market data from Southwest Florida MLS, pulled Oct 13, 2026. Brokered by Domain Realty.