Updated October 2026
Find out what your Fiddler's Creek home is worth from McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Valuations built on village, CDD line, flood zone and condition. Call (239) 898-6072.
Updated October 2026 · Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty
If you own a home in Fiddler’s Creek, the honest answer to what it is worth starts with your village, your product and your CDD line, not with the community as a whole. Fiddler’s Creek is a gated, master-planned golf community in Naples, Florida, ZIP 34114, made of 35 villages, two Community Development Districts and a mandatory Foundation with its own Club and Spa, and the Southwest Florida MLS shows a 12-month median of $770,000 built from 189 closings that ran from $250,000 to $3,900,000 (closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). The full community picture, from the clubs and the gates to the schools and the Section 29 record, lives on our Fiddler’s Creek community guide. This page does one job: it shows how a Fiddler’s Creek home is valued, village by village, from MLS closings and public records, and it gives you two ways to get your own number. Use the Home Valuation form at the top of this page, get your free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation, or call Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072.
A Fiddler’s Creek home is worth what its village, product, size, view, CDD line, flood zone and condition support, not what a community average says. In the last 12 months the Southwest Florida MLS recorded 189 Fiddler’s Creek closings, from a $250,000 villa to a $3,900,000 estate, at a $770,000 median, so no single figure describes your address.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026, pulled Oct 13, 2026).
Before you read any online estimate, read the two ends of that range correctly. The lowest closing of the year was a Whisper Trace villa condominium at $250,000 on March 24, 2026, in a 1997 to 2003 building that pays $1,836.29 a year in CDD operations and maintenance and no CDD debt. The highest was an Isla del Sol custom estate at $3,900,000 on June 4, 2026, in a village of 34 single-family homes built 2001 to 2017 (Southwest Florida MLS; Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget; 2026 Florida DOR parcel roll). Those two homes share a gate, a Foundation and a ZIP code, and almost nothing else that a buyer prices.
We built this page the way we build a written valuation. In the last 12 months we tracked 189 Fiddler’s Creek closings in the Southwest Florida MLS, $205,175,925 in sold volume across 35 village names, then read them beside the 2026 Florida Department of Revenue parcel roll, which carries 2,901 improved residential parcels inside the gates (1,477 single-family and 1,424 condominium-coded units) plus 113 vacant residential lots. That is a turnover of about 6.5 percent of the housing stock in a year, by our arithmetic from those two sources, and it is spread very unevenly across the villages.
Fiddler’s Creek is five products that happen to share a gate. The villa-style condominiums of 1997 to 2004 (Whisper Trace, Hawk’s Nest and Deer Crossing) sit at the entry, with 21 sales from $250,000 to $530,000 and a $320,000 group median. The two-story coach-home condominiums of 2001 to 2015 fill the middle, with a $627,500 group median on 66 sales. Dorado, the newest coach-home condominium, closed four times from $1,190,000 to $1,570,000. The production and patio single-family villages with three or more sales closed at a $965,000 group median on 53 sales, and the estate villages at a $2,190,000 group median on 34 sales (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). That spread is why we never value a Fiddler’s Creek address from the community median.
Take two homes a few minutes’ walk apart. A Hawk’s Nest villa sold in a band of $300,000 to $375,000 over the year, in a paid-off CDD #1 village. A Marsh Cove estate sold in a band of $1,200,000 to $3,362,500, in the one CDD #1 village that still carries debt, at $6,936.29 a year on the November 2026 tax bill (Southwest Florida MLS; CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget). Blend them and the $770,000 median describes neither. A Fiddler’s Creek valuation therefore starts by naming your village and your product, then narrows to your floor plan, lot, view and CDD group before a single comparable is chosen.
We lay three records over one another. The Southwest Florida MLS gives us brokered closings and their dates. The public record gives us the parcel roll, the condominium filings in the Florida DBPR condominium roster, the two districts’ adopted budgets and the flood zone on FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer. The community record gives us the Foundation and village documents your buyer will ask for. Then Marc Comisar walks the home, because roof age, impact glass, the view across the lake or the fairway and the kitchen are the variables no record captures.
The two halves of the market trade at different prices and for different reasons, so we price them apart. By our arithmetic from the 189 MLS rows, the 14 condominium village names recorded 93 closings at a $575,000 median and $55,394,925 in volume, while the single-family and villa village names recorded 96 closings at a $1,235,000 median and $149,781,000 in volume.
Product group, last 12 months | Villages (sales) | Closings | Group median | Village medians (only villages with 10 or more sales) | Lowest sale | Highest sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Villa-style condominium, 1997 to 2004 | Whisper Trace 5, Hawk’s Nest 10, Deer Crossing 6 | 21 | $320,000 | Hawk’s Nest $317,500 (the only one with 10 sales) | $250,000 | $530,000 |
Coach-home condominium, 2001 to 2015 | Sonoma 4, Laguna 12, Varenna 12, Callista 3, Cherry Oaks 12, Cascada 9, Montreux 7, Serena 7 | 66 | $627,500 | $495,000 to $667,500 (Laguna, Varenna and Cherry Oaks, the three with 10 or more sales) | $390,000 | $915,000 |
New coach-home condominium | Dorado 4 | 4 | too thin | n/a | $1,190,000 | $1,570,000 |
Production and patio single-family | Cotton Green 5, Millbrook 9, Cranberry Crossing 5, Amador 6, Mallards Landing 5, Amaranda 8, Mussorie Village 4, Chiasso 4, Lagomar 0, Mulberry Row 4, Pepper Tree 3 | 53 | $965,000 | none (no village had 10 sales) | $615,000 | $1,550,000 |
Estate single-family | Runaway Bay 4, Oyster Harbor 11, Marsh Cove 16, Isla del Sol 3 | 34 | $2,190,000 | $2,125,000 to $2,288,750 (Oyster Harbor and Marsh Cove) | $1,200,000 | $3,900,000 |
Villages with one or two sales | Mahogany Bend 2, Majorca 2, Sauvignon 1, Bellagio 1, Menaggio 1, Marengo 1, Bent Creek Village 1, Cardinal Cove 1, Marsh Subd 1 | 11 | too thin | n/a | $385,000 | $2,950,000 |
All Fiddler’s Creek | 35 village names | 189 | $770,000 | $250,000 | $3,900,000 |
Source: Southwest Florida MLS, Fiddler’s Creek closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026, pulled Oct 13, 2026. Group medians are our arithmetic from the 189 MLS rows, with every village of three or more sales in its product group and villages of one or two sales in their own row; a village median is stated only where the village had 10 or more sales, and an even-count median is the mean of the middle pair. Nine sold data entry closings (two in Marsh Cove and one each in Marsh Subd, Amaranda, Laguna, Majorca, Deer Crossing, Millbrook and Serena) count in every figure above. Lagomar had no closings in the 12 months and is counted as zero.
A free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation from McGreevy and Comisar starts with the Home Valuation form at the top of this page or a call to Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072. The form takes about a minute, costs nothing and carries no obligation, and you receive a written opinion of value built from sales in your own village and its nearest matches.
The form asks for your address, a line about condition and how to reach you. For a coach home or villa, the street address and unit number tell us your building, your floor and your condominium association. For a single-family home, the address tells us your village, your lot group in the CDD budget and, often, whether your lot sits on the lake, the preserve or the Creek Course. You do not need to know your CDD line, your flood zone or your Foundation figures; we pull those from the records.
You receive a written opinion of value for your address, built from MLS closings in your village and its closest neighbors of the same product and age, adjusted for time, with every source named. Beside it you receive the carrying-cost picture your buyer will underwrite: your CDD line from the district’s adopted budget, the property tax picture, the flood file and the Foundation and village items the estoppel certificates will show. Last comes a plain recommendation on list price and timing, including the case for waiting if the evidence says wait.
Call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072 or email [email protected]. Marc Comisar is at (239) 457-1610. Many Fiddler’s Creek owners are seasonal, and the Foundation’s own occupancy reports show the community at about 2,210 occupied homes in January 2026 and about 900 in June 2026 (CDD #1 minutes, Jan 28, 2026; CDD #1 minutes, July 22, 2026). If you are away, get your free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation from anywhere and we will arrange the walk-through with your property manager or a neighbor, and the gate pass with the Foundation’s guest system.
McGreevy and Comisar should value your Fiddler’s Creek home because we build every number from MLS closings and public records, village by village, we read the CDD, Foundation and flood records before we price, and we have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. In a community of 35 village markets and two districts, method decides the outcome.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026).
McGreevy and Comisar are the #5 real estate team in Florida in the 2026 RealTrends rankings. Domain Realty, our brokerage, closed 658 transaction sides in Naples in the 60 months to October 5, 2026, $521.5 million in volume counted by side, per the Southwest Florida MLS pulled that day.
As the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate. If you are comparing agents before you choose who values your home, our guide to the best real estate agents in Naples sets the teams side by side on the public record: reviews, license history and published production.
You get Jesse and Marc, not an assistant with a template. Jesse McGreevy, in Southwest Florida real estate since 2004, builds the pricing analysis and assembles the CDD, Foundation, flood and tax paperwork your buyer will ask for. Marc Comisar walks the home and judges floor plan, view and condition against what is actually selling inside the gates, which is what lets a seasonal owner get a real opinion of value without flying down. Read more on the about McGreevy and Comisar page.
Fiddler’s Creek turned over 189 times in 12 months across about 2,900 homes, and the sales did not spread evenly. Marsh Cove recorded 16 closings and Oyster Harbor 11, while nine villages recorded one or two each: Mahogany Bend, Majorca, Marsh Subd, Sauvignon, Bellagio, Menaggio, Marengo, Bent Creek Village and Cardinal Cove (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). In those thin villages your listing competes with the one other home of your kind on the market and with the buyer’s memory of the last one that closed. Few homes in any one village come up for sale in a given year, so the next owner who sells should have the number right on the first day.
This page answers what your home is worth. If you have decided to sell and want the listing plan, read our guide to selling your home in Fiddler’s Creek. If you are buying inside the same gates, start with buying a home in Fiddler’s Creek. For valuations across the rest of the city, see our Naples home valuation guide. And for the clubs, the gates, the schools and the history, go back to the Fiddler’s Creek community guide.
If you are thinking, “I need someone to sell my house in Fiddler’s Creek, Florida,” McGreevy and Comisar helps homeowners price, market, negotiate, and sell with a local strategy built for Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples, Fort Myers, Lee County, Collier County, and Babcock Ranch. Whether you are selling in Marsh Cove, Oyster Harbor, Varenna, Millbrook, Cherry Oaks, Laguna, Hawk’s Nest, Cascada, or Isla del Sol, our team provides local market guidance, professional listing exposure, and a clear plan to help you sell confidently. Start with a free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. If you are buying in Fiddler’s Creek instead, call Marc at (239) 457-1610 and see how we represent buyers in Naples.
Our Fiddler’s Creek valuation beats an online automated estimate because a model cannot see what separates one Fiddler’s Creek address from the next: the village, the CDD lot group, the Foundation buy-in, the flood letter on the lot and the builder’s own square footage. An online estimate is a model; a McGreevy and Comisar valuation is a person reading your village’s record and walking your home.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026).
A model sees a square footage, a bedroom count and a recent-sale pattern. It cannot see that two Lagomar homes side by side can carry CDD totals of $1,797.75 and $6,830.73 on the November 2026 bill, because lots 1 to 42 are paid off and the replat lots 43 to 75 are not (CDD #2 FY2027 adopted budget). It cannot read a FEMA Letter of Map Revision based on fill on a Marsh Cove Phase 2 lot (FEMA LOMA and LOMR-F layer). And it usually learns square footage from the county, whose living-area figure for many single-family villages runs well above the builder’s air-conditioned area, so a model can rank two identical floor plans differently.
The gap is widest where the market is thinnest. Sauvignon, Bellagio, Menaggio, Marengo, Bent Creek Village, Cardinal Cove and Marsh Subd each recorded one closing in 12 months, Mahogany Bend and Majorca two each and Pepper Tree three (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). In those villages a model has almost nothing to learn from, and a person has to choose which neighboring village of the same product, age and CDD treatment is the right comparable. We would rather tell you “the evidence supports a range, and here is why” than hand you a single figure that looks precise and is not.
We add four things a model cannot. First, we match the home: village, product, builder plan, lot position and renovation. Second, we read the carrying costs a buyer underwrites, from the CDD line in the district’s adopted budget to the Foundation and village estoppel certificates. Third, we test the number against what is on the market today, including the developer’s own new coach homes and estate homes, which a resale competes with. Fourth, we tell you the cost of being wrong in either direction, because at a $575,000 condominium median and a $1,235,000 single-family median, a few percent either way is real money.
These are the Fiddler’s Creek valuation facts that decide most prices, each drawn from the Southwest Florida MLS, the 2026 Florida parcel roll, the two districts’ adopted budgets or the state, county and FEMA records, and each repeated with its source further down this page. Read them before you read any online estimate.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026).
We value a Fiddler’s Creek home by narrowing the product and widening the comparison: same village, same plan and same lot position first, then the nearest village of the same product, age and CDD treatment when the village is thin, all read against the 189 closings of the last 12 months and the homes on the market today.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026; 2026 Florida DOR parcel roll; CDD #1 and CDD #2 FY2027 adopted budgets).
Every Fiddler’s Creek valuation starts with the village, because each of the 35 village names in the MLS is its own small market with its own association, product, builder history, CDD line and flood pattern. The product question comes next. Fourteen of the villages are condominiums registered with the state, holding 1,392 declared units (Florida DBPR condominium roster), and about 21 are single-family and villa villages filed on Sunbiz. Cardinal Cove is a useful trap: the 2026 roll codes its 44 attached villas as condominium, but there is no DBPR condominium record for it, and the recorded Cardinal Cove declaration settles the legal form.
The second step is the line on your November tax bill. Every CDD #1 village except Marsh Cove is paid in full and pays $1,836.29 of operations and maintenance for FY2027. In CDD #2, the debt line changes by village and sometimes by lot group inside a village: Millbrook alone has four different lot-group figures, from $4,814.86 to $6,194.09 in FY2026 (CDD #2 FY2026 adopted budget). Because a buyer reads that bill, two otherwise identical homes with different CDD lines do not carry the same value, and we price the difference with the buyer’s eyes.
Square footage needs care in Fiddler’s Creek. For many single-family villages the county’s living-area figure runs well above the builder’s air-conditioned square footage, so we compare homes on builder A/C area wherever a builder figure exists. The developer’s dated press releases give those figures by village: Runaway Bay plans of 2,800 to 3,659 A/C square feet, Chiasso plans of 2,583 to 3,522, Millbrook plans of 1,649 to 2,246 and Taylor Morrison’s Oyster Harbor plans of 1,689 to 3,439 (developer press archive). A price per square foot built on mixed definitions is a number that misleads.
View premiums are real in most golf communities, and the current MLS pull does not hold the view field, so we do not publish a Fiddler’s Creek view premium. What the export does show is how the two product lines traded: single-family homes closed at a median of 65 days on market and 94.7% sale-to-list, low-rise condominiums at 89 days and 95.0%. We measure the view for each listing by pairing sales in the same village and floor plan with and without the view. One factor to separate from view: the Arthur Hills Creek Course was renovated in 2024, with greens moved toward the creek and 421 feet of new bulkhead at one green (GRAA facility profile, Oct 2, 2025), so older comparables on golf-front lots may reflect a different view than today’s.
The 2026 roll shows Fiddler’s Creek units built in every wave: 204 in 1995 to 1999, 754 in 2000 to 2004, 819 in 2005 to 2009, 203 in 2010 to 2014, 602 in 2015 to 2019 and 318 in 2020 to 2024 (2026 Florida DOR parcel roll). A 2004 coach home with its original roof, windows and kitchen and a 2004 coach home with impact glass and a new roof are different products to a buyer and to an insurer. Mallards Landing shows it: five sales ran from $670,000 to $1,400,000, a wide range that reflects homes from very different eras of renovation (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026).
The Foundation’s occupancy reports show the community filling from about 1,664 homes in December 2025 to about 2,210 in January 2026 (CDD #1 minutes, Jan 28, 2026), and by our count of the MLS close dates, 100 of the year’s 189 closings fell between December and April. A valuation done in the fall gives you time to assemble the CDD, Foundation and flood file before the buyers are inside the gates. Get your free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Before we price a Fiddler’s Creek home we read five records a buyer will read: the FEMA flood map and any letter of map change on the lot, the elevation certificate, the Foundation and village estoppel figures, the village or condominium documents and the insurance file. Each one can move the number, and each one can stall a contract if it surfaces late.
Data updated: October 2026 (FEMA NFHL and Collier County GIS layers read Oct 7, 2026; Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026).
Flood status in Fiddler’s Creek changes from village to village and sometimes from one side of a street to the other. We query your lot on FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer and on the FIRM panel layer, where all four panels covering the community carry an effective date of Feb 8, 2024. We check FEMA’s LOMA and LOMR-F layer, which lists 33 determinations for Fiddler’s Creek villages from 2013 to 2025, and we pull your certificate from the County’s elevation-certificate layer, which holds 1,378 certificates on Fiddler’s Creek street names. A certificate showing a finished floor above the base flood elevation is one of the strongest documents a seller can hand a buyer’s insurance agent.
Fiddler’s Creek Foundation membership is mandatory under the Declaration and includes access to the Club and Spa (2013 Collier Circuit Court complaint; developer legal terms). The Foundation’s quarterly dues and the current buy-in a buyer pays at closing are not published by a primary source. The governing document is the Foundation’s estoppel certificate under section 720.30851, Florida Statutes. We request the figures early, because the buy-in changes your buyer’s cash to close, and a buyer who learns it late tends to ask for it back in price.
Every village adds its own association, and some add their own rules. Montreux is the best-documented village: its association’s welcome packet of Apr 21, 2017 states that units may not be leased for less than 30 days, at most three times a calendar year, with written pre-approval, a background check, a $100 processing fee and no tenant pets. Those are Montreux’s rules only; every other village’s recorded declaration governs its own. A seasonal-rental buyer pays for leasing flexibility, so we read your village’s leasing article before we choose comparables.
Homeowner, wind and flood premiums for Fiddler’s Creek are not published by any primary source, and carriers do not publish community-level rates. What the record does show is the shift in Collier County’s market: Citizens Property Insurance’s personal residential multiperil policies in the county fell from 9,735 on Sept 30, 2024 to 1,839 on Aug 31, 2026, down 81% (Citizens, Sept 30, 2024 detail by county; Citizens, Aug 31, 2026 detail by county). Buyers now quote with private carriers, and the wind-mitigation report, the four-point inspection on older homes and the elevation certificate are the documents that decide the quote.
Where a village had fewer than ten sales in the 12 months, we do not state a 12-month median. We widen to the 24 or 36 month window, name it, and where that still falls short we list the sales or give the range, then widen to the nearest village of the same product, age and CDD treatment, list the actual sales with their dates, and test the result against the homes for sale today and the developer’s new-construction pricing. A Sauvignon home, with one closing at $1,937,500, is read beside Bellagio’s one closing at $1,845,000, the one Marsh Subd closing at $2,850,000 and the 2002 to 2017 estate homes of Mahogany Bend, which closed at $2,725,000 and $2,950,000 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026), then adjusted for size, lot and condition.
Fiddler’s Creek condominiums and coach homes sold at a $575,000 median across 93 closings in 12 months, by our arithmetic from the Southwest Florida MLS rows, with Hawk’s Nest the only villa condominium village at 10 sales ($317,500 median), the three older coach-home villages with 10 or more sales at $495,000 to $667,500 village medians and the new Dorado coach homes at $1,190,000 to $1,570,000 on four sales.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026; Florida DBPR condominium roster, updated Oct 3, 2026).
Every Fiddler’s Creek condominium is a two-story coach-home or villa building. That matters to value in a way buyers from other parts of Naples may not expect: no Fiddler’s Creek building appears among the 926 buildings on Collier County’s milestone-inspection map, and the structural integrity reserve study rule in section 718.112, Florida Statutes “does not apply to buildings less than three stories in height.” A coach-home seller here is not pricing around a milestone report the way a tower seller on the coast is.
Condominium village | Declared units and year (DBPR) | Sales, 12 months | Median (12 months unless noted) | Range, 12 months | CDD total per unit | Sampled flood points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Whisper Trace | 132, Nov 3, 1997 | 5 | $408,500 (36 months, 14 sales) | $250,000 to $399,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | All shaded Zone X |
Hawk’s Nest | 120, Mar 24, 1999 | 10 | $317,500 | $300,000 to $375,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | Zone AE, BFE 7 and 8 ft |
Deer Crossing | 140, July 19, 1999 | 6 | $451,250 (36 months, 10 sales) | $320,000 to $530,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft |
Cascada | 132, Oct 5, 2001 | 9 | $690,000 (24 months, 11 sales) | $565,000 to $799,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft |
Montreux | 96, Jan 7, 2004 | 7 | $720,000 (36 months, 11 sales) | $515,000 to $878,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | Mostly shaded Zone X |
Cherry Oaks | 116, Dec 13, 2004 | 12 | $667,500 | $475,000 to $862,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | All shaded Zone X |
Laguna | 128, Oct 14, 2005 | 12 | $495,000 | $410,000 to $715,000 | $3,090.81 (CDD #2, FY2026) | Zone AE, mostly BFE 8 ft |
Varenna | 152, Mar 30, 2006 | 12 | $577,000 | $456,000 to $705,000 | $3,349.42; Varenna II $4,211.44 (CDD #2, FY2026) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft |
Serena | 76, Feb 20, 2007 | 7 | $777,500 (24 months, 10 sales) | $600,000 to $915,000 | $3,521.82 to $4,293.41 by phase (CDD #2, FY2026) | Mostly shaded Zone X |
Callista | 64, Apr 16, 2008 | 3 | Not stated (8 sales in 36 months) | $550,000 to $625,000 | $3,897.78 (CDD #2, FY2026) | Mostly shaded Zone X |
Sonoma | July 10, 2013 | 4 | Not stated (9 sales in 36 months) | $390,000 to $500,000 | $3,521.82 (CDD #2, FY2026) | No point resolved |
Menaggio | 72, Feb 8, 2007 | 1 | one sale | $750,000 | $3,694.23 to $5,090.25 by phase (CDD #2, FY2026) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft |
Marengo | 88, Apr 5, 2007 | 1 | one sale | $555,000 | $3,349.42 to $5,591.80 by phase (CDD #2, FY2026) | All shaded Zone X |
Dorado | 32 declared, May 7, 2021 | 4 | $1,435,000 (36 months, 13 sales) | $1,190,000 to $1,570,000 | $5,257.96 (CDD #2, FY2026) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft; LOMR-Fs on tracts 1 to 5 |
Sources: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026 (a village median is stated only where the window held 10 or more sales; the 24 and 36 month windows run from Oct 13, 2024 and Oct 13, 2023); Florida DBPR condominium roster; CDD #1 FY2027 and CDD #2 FY2026 adopted budgets; FEMA NFHL point queries, Oct 7, 2026. The Marengo name in the MLS covers both the coach-home condominium and the 21 single-family Marengo III homes.
The villa condominiums are the entry point to Fiddler’s Creek and to the Foundation’s Club and Spa. Whisper Trace, whose declaration recorded on Nov 3, 1997 was the first in the community, closed five times from $250,000 to $399,000, including the year’s lowest sale at $250,000. Hawk’s Nest closed ten times in a tight $300,000 to $375,000 band, and Deer Crossing six times from $320,000 to $530,000 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). All three are paid in full in CDD #1, at $1,836.29 a unit for FY2027, which is part of their appeal to a buyer comparing monthly costs. A tight band like Hawk’s Nest’s is a gift to a seller: the buyer knows the number, so condition, floor and the view off the lanai decide where in the band you land.
Varenna was the most active condominium market in Fiddler’s Creek over the year, with 12 sales at a $577,000 median, level with Laguna and Cherry Oaks, and it is the largest condominium in the community at 152 declared units. Laguna closed 12 times at a $495,000 median and Callista three times, at $550,000, $555,000 and $625,000 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). All three sit in CDD #2 and carry debt lines, $3,090.81 a unit at Laguna and $3,349.42 at Varenna in FY2026, so their buyers carry more each November than a Cascada or Cherry Oaks buyer. Laguna is also one of two places in Fiddler’s Creek where the base flood elevation rises to 8 ft at sampled points (FEMA NFHL), which shows up in a buyer’s flood quote.
Four older coach-home villages sold above Varenna and Laguna. Cherry Oaks closed at a $667,500 median on 12 sales; the other three had fewer than 10 sales in the 12 months, so we read them over a longer window: Serena at $777,500 over 24 months (10 sales), Montreux at $720,000 over 36 months (11 sales) and Cascada at $690,000 over 24 months (11 sales) (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). Cherry Oaks, Cascada and Montreux are paid in full in CDD #1, and Cherry Oaks is one of the few coach-home villages where all three sampled points sit in shaded Zone X, outside the Special Flood Hazard Area. When we value a Cherry Oaks coach home, that combination of no CDD debt and a sampled shaded X zone is part of the story we put in front of a buyer, and it is part of why 12 Cherry Oaks homes sold in the year.
Sonoma, a 44-home Lennar coach-home condominium of 2013, closed four times, at $390,000, $400,000, $450,000 and $500,000. Menaggio and Marengo recorded one sale each, at $750,000 and $555,000 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). One sale is not a market rate, so we price these against the coach-home villages of the same era and CDD district and adjust for the phase line in the CDD #2 budget, which runs from $3,694.23 to $5,090.25 by Menaggio phase. Two naming points matter at Sonoma: county addresses on Sonoma Boulevard belong to a neighboring PUD, not to this village, and the state roster shows Sonoma’s secondary status as “Delinquent,” which a buyer’s lender may ask the association to explain (Florida DBPR condominium roster).
Dorado, built by Gulf Bay Homes in fourplex buildings since 2020, closed four times, at $1,190,000, $1,350,000, $1,527,325 and $1,570,000, too few for a 12-month median (the 36 months from Oct 13, 2023 held 13 sales at a $1,435,000 median). The developer prices its Palmetto plan from $1.7 million on its Dorado page and offers Callista II coach homes of 2,675 to 3,039 A/C square feet from $1.5 million (developer home page, read October 2026). For an owner of a 2005 to 2008 coach home, those prices are not your comparables, because a buyer paying $1.5 million is buying a new building, a new roof and a builder warranty. They are, though, the ceiling a resale buyer sees when touring, and they make a well-updated older coach home look like the value alternative.
Fiddler’s Creek single-family and villa homes sold at a $1,235,000 median across 96 closings in 12 months, by our arithmetic from the Southwest Florida MLS rows, with the production and patio villages at a $965,000 median on 53 closings ($615,000 to $1,550,000) and the estate villages at a $2,190,000 median on 34 closings ($1,200,000 to $3,900,000).
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026; developer press archive; CDD #1 and CDD #2 adopted budgets).
Single-family village | Homes on the 2026 roll, built | Sales, 12 months | Median (12 months unless noted) | Range, 12 months | CDD total per unit | Sampled flood points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cotton Green | 47, 1998 to 2018 | 5 | Not stated (7 sales in 36 months) | $650,000 to $825,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft |
Millbrook | about 89, 2007 to 2018 | 9 | $862,500 (24 months, 16 sales) | $650,000 to $990,000 | $4,814.86 to $6,194.09 by lot group (CDD #2, FY2026) | Mostly Zone AE, BFE 7 ft |
Cranberry Crossing | about 50, 2005 to 2006 | 5 | $1,030,000 (36 months, 12 sales) | $760,000 to $1,200,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | No point resolved |
Amador | 38, from 2012 | 6 | $1,030,000 (36 months, 13 sales) | $785,000 to $1,200,000 | $6,194.09 (CDD #2, FY2026) | No point resolved |
Mallards Landing | 57, 2000 to 2006 | 5 | Not stated (8 sales in 36 months) | $670,000 to $1,400,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | All shaded Zone X |
Amaranda | 71 homesites, 2018 to 2022 | 8 | $980,000 (24 months, 14 sales) | $770,000 to $1,245,000 | $4,095.21 (CDD #2, FY2026) | Mostly shaded Zone X; LOMR-Fs |
Mussorie Village | 54, 2015 to 2019 | 4 | Not stated (9 sales in 36 months) | $1,030,000 to $1,265,000 | $1,797.75 (CDD #2, FY2027) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft |
Chiasso | 59, 2012 to 2015 | 4 | $1,352,500 (36 months, 10 sales) | $1,175,000 to $1,325,000 | $4,383.85; Chiasso II $6,194.09 (CDD #2, FY2026) | Zone AE, BFE 8 ft |
Lagomar | 77, 2016 to 2017 | 0 | Not stated (no closings in the 12 months) | None in the window; 4 sales in the prior 12 months at $1,250,000 to $1,500,000 | $1,797.78 or $6,830.76 by lot group (CDD #2, FY2026) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft |
Mulberry Row | 73, 1998 to 2012 | 4 | $1,432,500 (36 months, 10 sales) | $900,000 to $1,550,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft |
Runaway Bay | 98 homesites, 2012 to 2016 | 4 | $2,000,000 (36 months, 11 sales) | $1,350,000 to $2,300,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | All shaded Zone X |
Oyster Harbor | 279 homes plus 42 lots, 2015 to 2025 | 11 | $2,125,000 | $1,299,000 to $3,200,000 | $1,797.78 to $4,474.78 by group (CDD #2, FY2026) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft; LOMR-Fs |
Marsh Cove | 217 homes plus 17 lots, 2015 to 2022 | 16 | $2,288,750 | $1,200,000 to $3,362,500 | $6,936.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft; LOMR-Fs |
Isla del Sol | 34, 2001 to 2017 | 3 | Not stated (7 sales in 36 months) | $3,250,000 to $3,900,000 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1, FY2027) | Zone AE, BFE 7 ft |
Sources: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026 (a village median is stated only where the window held 10 or more sales; the 24 and 36 month windows run from Oct 13, 2024 and Oct 13, 2023); 2026 Florida DOR parcel roll; CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget; CDD #2 FY2026 and FY2027 adopted budgets; FEMA NFHL and LOMA and LOMR-F layers, queried Oct 7, 2026.
Cotton Green’s five closings ran from $650,000 to $825,000, the lowest range among the single-family villages with five or more sales, and Millbrook was the most active single-family market below $1 million, with nine sales from $650,000 to $990,000 and, over the 24 months from Oct 13, 2024, 16 sales at an $862,500 median (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). Millbrook was Lennar’s first Fiddler’s Creek village, launched in February 2012 on “Patio 50” lots (developer press archive). The original patio villages, Pepper Tree and Bent Creek Village, recorded three sales ($615,000, $685,000 and $700,000) and one ($440,000). Their 1997 to 2000 homes are paid in full in CDD #1, so a buyer comparing them with a Millbrook home is weighing age against a CDD #2 debt line.
Six villages built by national builders between 2012 and 2022 sit near the $1 million mark: over the longer windows named in the table, the stated medians for Amaranda, Amador and Chiasso run from $980,000 (Amaranda, 24 months) to $1,352,500 (Chiasso, 36 months). Chiasso’s four D.R. Horton homes sold in a tight $1,175,000 to $1,325,000 band that reflects one builder’s plan library, Mussorie Village’s four Taylor Morrison homes went from $1,030,000 to $1,265,000, and Lagomar recorded no closings in the 12 months after four in the prior 12 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). Their CDD lines differ sharply: every Mussorie lot pays operations and maintenance only, $1,797.75 for FY2027, while Amador pays $6,194.09 and the Lagomar replat lots $6,830.76 in FY2026 (CDD #2 FY2026 adopted budget). In a cluster this tight, that gap is visible to the buyer on the first page of the disclosure.
Marsh Cove recorded 16 sales in 12 months, the most of any village, at a $2,288,750 median and a range of $1,200,000 to $3,362,500, and its closings totaled $38,147,500 by our arithmetic (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). It is a gated village of 217 homes built 2015 to 2022 by Ashton Woods, Harbourside Custom Homes and Stock Signature Homes (developer press archive). It is also the only CDD #1 village still paying debt: $6,936.29 per lot on the November 2026 bill, with Phase 1 principal of $22,849.03 after the FY2027 payment and eight years remaining (CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget). Many Phase 2 lots carry FEMA LOMR-Fs, so lot-level flood status is read from each letter, not the map.
Oyster Harbor is the largest village in Fiddler’s Creek and the one still growing: 279 single-family homes built 2015 to 2025 plus 42 vacant lots on the 2026 roll, from a 2014 joint venture with Taylor Morrison for about 1,000 homes (Taylor Morrison newsroom, July 1, 2014). It closed 11 times at a $2,125,000 median, from $1,299,000 to $3,200,000 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). The developer’s 2026 offerings include Allamanda IV from $2.4 million plus homesite and Hibiscus IV from $2.8 million plus homesite (developer home page), so a ready-now resale with upgrades and a pool can be priced as the faster alternative to a build.
Runaway Bay closed four times, at $1,350,000, $1,750,000, $2,000,000 and $2,300,000, in a village of Lennar estate homes along The Creek that is paid in full in CDD #1 and sits in shaded Zone X at every sampled point, an unusual combination. Isla del Sol produced the year’s three highest single-village prices, $3,250,000, $3,575,000 and $3,900,000. Mahogany Bend closed twice ($2,725,000 and $2,950,000), Majorca twice ($2,100,000 and $2,200,000), Sauvignon once ($1,937,500), Bellagio once ($1,845,000) and Marsh Subd once ($2,850,000) (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). In these villages the custom build, the lot and the year of the last renovation explain more of the price than any village figure.
Fiddler’s Creek homes sold for $250,000 to $3,900,000 in the 12 months to Oct 13, 2026, with 29 closings at $2 million or more and 34 below $500,000, by our count of the 189 Southwest Florida MLS rows. The highest sales were estate homes in Isla del Sol, Marsh Cove and Oyster Harbor; the lowest were villa condominiums in Whisper Trace and Hawk’s Nest.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026, pulled Oct 13, 2026).
Close date | Village | Sold price |
|---|---|---|
Jun 4, 2026 | Isla del Sol | $3,900,000 |
Jul 6, 2026 | Isla del Sol | $3,575,000 |
Mar 19, 2026 | Marsh Cove | $3,362,500 |
Apr 21, 2026 | Marsh Cove | $3,275,000 |
Jul 6, 2026 | Isla del Sol | $3,250,000 |
Jun 1, 2026 | Oyster Harbor | $3,200,000 |
Oct 20, 2025 | Marsh Cove | $3,175,000 |
Oct 23, 2025 | Marsh Cove (sold data entry) | $3,000,000 |
Mar 18, 2026 | Mahogany Bend | $2,950,000 |
Apr 2, 2026 | Marsh Subd (sold data entry) | $2,850,000 |
Source: Southwest Florida MLS, Fiddler’s Creek closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026. Eight of the ten closed between March and July 2026.
At the other end, the seven lowest closings were all villa condominiums: Whisper Trace at $250,000 (Mar 24, 2026), $270,000 (Aug 28, 2026), $290,000 (Feb 10, 2026) and $295,000 (Oct 31, 2025), and Hawk’s Nest at $300,000 (Aug 14, 2026) and $305,000 (Jan 14 and Apr 15, 2026) (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). Those prices buy a home inside the gates with mandatory Foundation membership and access to the roughly 54,000-square-foot Club and Spa (developer About page), which is the single strongest selling point a villa seller has.
Sold price band | Closings | Share of 189 |
|---|---|---|
Under $500,000 | 34 | 18% |
$500,000 to $749,999 | 57 | 30% |
$750,000 to $999,999 | 29 | 15% |
$1,000,000 to $1,499,999 | 27 | 14% |
$1,500,000 to $1,999,999 | 13 | 7% |
$2,000,000 to $2,999,999 | 21 | 11% |
$3,000,000 and up | 8 | 4% |
Source: our count of the 189 Southwest Florida MLS rows, Fiddler’s Creek closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026. Shares are rounded.
The calendar matters to a valuation because it tells you when your competition and your buyers arrive. By our count of the MLS close dates, Fiddler’s Creek recorded 8 to 11 closings a month from October to December 2025, then 16 in January, 21 in February, 24 in March, 28 in April, 14 in May, 23 in June, 14 in July, 9 in August and 10 in September 2026. The spring peak follows the Foundation’s occupancy figures, which ran from about 1,664 homes in December 2025 to about 2,210 in January 2026 (CDD #1 minutes, Jan 28, 2026), because closings trail contracts by weeks and contracts trail showings.
The $3,900,000 Isla del Sol closing on June 4, 2026 shows that the top of Fiddler’s Creek is custom estate homes in a paid-off CDD #1 village, not new construction. The two Mahogany Bend closings on the same day, Mar 18, 2026, at $2,725,000 and $2,950,000, show how much a single village can move between two homes on the same street when the homes differ. And the Dorado sales, from $1,190,000 to $1,570,000, show a new-construction coach-home market priced more than double the older coach homes a short walk away (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). Each lesson says the same thing: the comparable is the house, not the gate.
How long a Fiddler’s Creek home takes to sell, and how close it comes to asking, depends on village, price band and season. The MLS pull behind this page holds closed prices, dates, days on market and final list prices for 189 Fiddler’s Creek sales; it does not hold original list prices, so sale-to-list here is the sold price over the final list price.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026).
Median days on market for Fiddler’s Creek over the 12 months ran 74 (average 110), the median sale-to-list was 94.7%, the median final list price of the homes that sold was $795,000, the median sold price per square foot was $332 and active listings on the pull date, October 13, 2026, numbered 77, with a median list price of $695,000. Single-family homes ran a median of 65 days at 94.7% sale-to-list and low-rise condominiums 89 days at 95.0%. The nine sold data entry closings count in the 189 closings and the $770,000 median, and they are left out only of the days-on-market and sale-to-list figures, which rest on 177 closings.
The Foundation’s own figures show the buyer pool swelling and shrinking: average weekly occupancy of about 1,664 homes in December 2025, about 2,210 in January 2026, 1,315 in May 2026 and 900 in June 2026 (CDD #1 minutes, Jan 28, 2026; CDD #1 minutes, July 22, 2026). A home priced right and on the market when the January buyers are inside the gates meets the deepest pool of the year. A home that misses the season, or comes to market with the price wrong and corrects it in May, meets a pool less than half that size.
Months of supply, the active listings divided by the monthly pace of sales, is the yardstick that tells a seller whether buyers or sellers hold the leverage. The pace side is known: 189 closings in 12 months is an average of about 15.8 a month, by our arithmetic. The inventory side, on October 13, 2026, was 77 active listings and 17 pending, so months of supply (active listings divided by the monthly closing pace of the last 12 months) was 4.9: 3.8 months for single-family homes (30 active) and 5.9 months for low-rise condominiums (46 active). We still read supply village by village for every valuation, because a village with three listings and one sale a year is a very different market from Marsh Cove with 16 closings.
The CDD line changes a Fiddler’s Creek home’s value because a buyer reads it on the tax bill: for the November 2026 bill the total runs from $1,797.75 for a paid-off CDD #2 lot to $6,936.29 in Marsh Cove, per the two districts’ FY2027 adopted budgets. Two similar homes with a $5,000 gap in yearly CDD cost are not the same purchase.
Data updated: October 2026 (Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1 and CDD #2 FY2027 adopted budgets; FY2025 audits filed June 2026).
A community development district is an independent special taxing district created under Chapter 190 of the Florida Statutes. It sold bonds to build the roads, drainage, lakes and irrigation, repays them through a “debt service” assessment on the lots that benefit, and funds upkeep through an operations and maintenance assessment on every unit. Both are flat per-unit charges, collected on the Collier County tax bill, and the County’s CDD boundary layer maps which district a parcel sits in.
CDD #1 | CDD #2 | |
|---|---|---|
Units assessed (FY2027) | 1,910 | 1,543 |
O&M per unit, November 2026 bill | $1,836.29 | $1,797.75 |
O&M per unit, FY2026 | $1,736.29 | $1,797.78 |
Villages still carrying debt | Marsh Cove only | Most villages, by lot group |
Audited bonds outstanding, Sept 30, 2025 | $16,140,000 | $33,700,000 |
Latest final maturity | May 1, 2038 | May 1, 2045 |
Sources: CDD #1 About page; CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget; CDD #2 FY2027 adopted budget; CDD #1 FY2025 audit; CDD #2 FY2025 audit.
Example home | District | FY2027 CDD debt | FY2027 CDD O&M | FY2027 CDD total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Laguna coach home | CDD #2 | $1,293.03 | $1,797.75 | $3,090.78 |
Lagomar replat patio home, lots 43 to 75 | CDD #2 | $5,032.98 | $1,797.75 | $6,830.73 |
Mulberry Row single-family home, paid off | CDD #1 | $0 | $1,836.29 | $1,836.29 |
Marsh Cove single-family home | CDD #1 | $5,100.00 | $1,836.29 | $6,936.29 |
Sources: CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget; CDD #2 FY2027 adopted budget. Foundation, village and optional club charges come on top of these figures.
A paid-off CDD lowers the buyer’s yearly carrying cost, and buyers who compare villages notice. The market-wide price effect is not measured in a public dataset, so we do not state one. We measure it for a listing instead, by pairing sales of similar homes with different CDD lines. In CDD #1 the 2013-2 group of villages paid off on May 1, 2018 and the 2013-1 group on May 1, 2021, and those homes now pay operations and maintenance only (CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget). Operations and maintenance never goes away while the district exists, and CDD #1’s rose $100 a unit from FY2026 to FY2027.
A seller does not have to prepay the CDD debt; it runs with the land and continues on the next owner’s tax bill unless the contract says otherwise. Both districts print the per-unit principal by village group, for example $22,849.03 for Marsh Cove Phase 1 and $30,752.48 for a Lagomar replat lot after the FY2027 payment, and the exact payoff on a given date comes from the district manager. Prepayments drive the districts’ semiannual redemption notices, such as CDD #2’s May 1, 2026 calls on Series 2004 and Series 2014-2B. Whether a payoff earns back its cost in price is a question we answer with the comparables for your village.
A careful buyer reads more than the assessment. Both FY2025 audits report compliance with their bond indentures, and the districts’ EMMA filings since 2020 are annual reports and redemption notices with no default notices among them (CDD #2 EMMA issuer page). The December 2024 irrigation control summary reports a control system past its useful life with a replacement being scoped and its cost not yet published, and CDD #1’s FY2025 audit reports a pending appeal of $583,790 in Hurricane Irma reimbursement that FEMA denied. We put those facts in front of a buyer with their dates, which takes them off the renegotiation list.
The Fiddler’s Creek fee stack affects value because a buyer prices the total carrying cost: county property tax, a CDD assessment of $1,797.75 to $6,936.29 for FY2027, mandatory Foundation dues plus a buy-in at closing, the village or condominium fee, and optional Golf Club and Tarpon Club memberships. The CDD and tax layers are published; the Foundation, village and club amounts are not.
Data updated: October 2026 (CDD FY2027 adopted budgets; Collier County 2026 certified roll; Florida DOR 2025 Collier millage summary; developer legal page read October 2026).
Layer | Billed by | Amount on the public record | Where the number comes from |
|---|---|---|---|
Ad valorem property tax | Collier County Tax Collector | 10.3696 mills in 2026 on the certified county roll for every Fiddler’s Creek home (10.5058 in 2025) | |
CDD operations and maintenance | CDD #1 or CDD #2, on the tax bill | $1,836.29 (CDD #1) or $1,797.75 (CDD #2) per unit, FY2027 | CDD FY2027 adopted budgets |
CDD debt | CDD #1 or CDD #2, on the tax bill | $0 to $5,100.00 per unit by village and lot group, FY2027 | CDD FY2027 adopted budgets |
Foundation dues | Fiddler’s Creek Foundation, Inc. | Not published by a primary source | Foundation estoppel certificate and disclosure summary |
Foundation buy-in at closing | Foundation | $15,000 Capital Acquisition Assessment in 2010 court filings; current amount not published | Bankruptcy Docket 314.1, Aug 10, 2010; Foundation estoppel certificate |
Village or condominium fee | Your village or condominium association | Not published by a primary source | The association’s budget and estoppel certificate |
Solid waste | Collier County, on the tax bill | Non-ad valorem assessment printed on the bill | |
The Golf Club at Fiddler’s Creek | Developer-affiliated club, optional | Not published | Golf Club Membership Plan |
The Tarpon Club | Developer-affiliated club, optional | Not published | Tarpon Club Membership Plan |
Sources as linked in each row; the community guide’s fee section carries every layer in full.
The one primary record that states an amount is the 2010 bankruptcy-court sale filing, which describes “a Capital Acquisition Assessment for membership to The Club & Spa at Fiddler’s Creek in the amount of $15,000.00” paid to the Foundation at closing (Docket 314.1, Aug 10, 2010). The current amount, any refund terms and any capital reserve or transfer contribution are not published by a primary source in 2026. If one applies, the Foundation’s estoppel certificate shows it, and the governing documents typically assign it to the incoming owner, although the purchase contract can reallocate it. For a valuation, that unknown is a reason to request the estoppel figures before pricing, so the buyer’s cash to close is known when the list price is set.
Fiddler’s Creek separates the mandatory Foundation club from two optional ones. The Golf Club, home of the Arthur Hills Creek Course, ranked tied for 80th among U.S. residential courses in Golfweek’s Best 2026 (Jan 9, 2026), and reported 325 golf members in October 2025 (GRAA facility profile). The Tarpon Club adds a Marco Island beach pavilion and marina access (developer beach page). Because golf is optional, a non-golfing buyer is not paying for a course, which widens the buyer pool for a Fiddler’s Creek resale. Golf Club refund and transfer terms are in the Membership Plan and the member’s agreement, not on the public record, so a seller who holds a membership should read it before listing.
A Florida homestead’s capped assessed value belongs to the owner, not the house. After a sale, the parcel is reassessed at just value as of the next January 1 under section 193.155, Florida Statutes, so your buyer’s tax bill can be much higher than yours. At the 2026 certified rate of 10.3696 mills, every $100,000 of taxable value costs $1,036.96 a year before the CDD and solid waste lines. A buyer who underwrites the reset correctly is a buyer who does not walk at the inspection stage, so we show the estimate in the listing package.
Flood zones affect Fiddler’s Creek values address by address: of 108 Fiddler’s Creek address points tested against FEMA’s map on Oct 7, 2026, 76 sit in Zone AE and 32 in shaded Zone X, with none in Zone VE, and whole villages sit entirely in shaded X on the sample. The elevation certificate and any letter of map change on your lot decide what a buyer’s lender and insurer see.
Data updated: October 2026 (FEMA NFHL layers 28, 3 and 34 and Collier County GIS layers, queried Oct 7, 2026).
Effective FEMA zone | Base flood elevation | Points | Share of sample |
|---|---|---|---|
Zone AE | 7 ft NAVD88 | 69 | 64% |
Zone AE | 8 ft NAVD88 | 7 | 6% |
Zone X, shaded | none | 32 | 30% |
Zone VE | not present | 0 | 0% |
Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, layer 28, 108 county address points across 35 village groupings, queried Oct 7, 2026, cross-checked against the County’s FEMA24 flood-zone layer, which agreed at all 108 points.
Seven named villages had every sampled point in shaded Zone X, outside the Special Flood Hazard Area: Marengo, Bellagio, Cherry Oaks, Majorca, Mallards Landing, Runaway Bay and Whisper Trace (FEMA NFHL, Oct 7, 2026). For a financed buyer in shaded X, flood insurance is usually a choice rather than a lender requirement, which can lower the carrying cost a buyer underwrites. At the other end, Chiasso had every sampled point in Zone AE with an 8 ft base flood elevation and Laguna three of four. We read your own lot, not the village pattern, because a sample is a sample.
FEMA’s LOMA and LOMR-F layer lists 33 determinations for Fiddler’s Creek villages from 2013 to 2025, with multi-lot LOMR-Fs covering Oyster Harbor Phases 1 to 3, Amaranda (lots 1 to 54 and 90 to 106), Dorado (tracts 1 to 5) and Marsh Cove Phase 2; four of the 32 logged were “Structure denied” (FEMA NFHL layer 34). A 49-certificate sample from the County’s layer shows finished floors mostly between about 7.0 and 8.7 ft NAVD88 against a BFE of 7 (Collier County elevation-certificate layer; example: a Runaway Lane certificate). A seller with a letter or a favorable certificate in the listing file hands the buyer’s insurance agent the number that matters.
FEMA is revising Collier County’s flood maps. Preliminary FIRMs were released Mar 20, 2025, a 90-day appeal period opened Aug 19, 2026, and the County’s target effective date is “Summer 2027,” per the County’s Aug 19, 2026 announcement. At every Fiddler’s Creek point we tested, the preliminary panels left the zone and base flood elevation unchanged, and panel 12021C0615J is not being revised. That is a calmer story for a Fiddler’s Creek seller than many coastal Naples neighborhoods can tell.
Every sampled Fiddler’s Creek address sits in Collier Hurricane Evacuation Zone A. No primary record we found documents storm surge entering Fiddler’s Creek homes in Irma (2017) or Ian (2022). What the record does show is power loss across much of the community for nearly a week after Irma (Golfweek, Sept 27, 2017), sewage covering a section of Mahogany Bend Drive (Naples Daily News, Sept 14, 2017), and a water-line blowout that closed Fiddler’s Creek Parkway during Milton in October 2024 (CDD #2 minutes, Oct 23, 2024). A seller should be ready to answer for the specific home: any water intrusion, any roof claim, and the repairs.
Unincorporated Collier County is a Community Rating System Class 5 community, worth a 25% discount on eligible National Flood Insurance Program policies (Collier County 2026 Flood Protection Newsletter; FEMA Community Rating System). Florida law requires insurers to offer discounts for wind-mitigation features such as roof shape, roof-to-wall connections and opening protection (section 627.0629, Florida Statutes). A current wind-mitigation report in the listing file can lower the quote your buyer receives, and a lower quote is a higher price the buyer can afford.
Section 29 and new construction affect Fiddler’s Creek values in different ways. Collier County entitled 750 rental apartments inside the community’s Section 29 in December 2024, but no permits had issued by the County’s August 2025 check, while the developer is building and selling new coach homes and estate homes in 2026 that every resale seller competes with.
Data updated: October 2026 (Collier County monitoring letter Aug 15, 2025; County inventory list July 1, 2026; developer home page read October 2026).
In December 2024 the County adopted Ordinance 2024-51, creating a 49.91-acre Section 29 development area for 750 rental units, 30% rent-restricted for 30 years. The County’s Aug 15, 2025 monitoring letter says construction “has not yet commenced, and no permits have been issued,” and the County’s July 1, 2026 inventory list still shows the project as “Approved,” not under construction. No dataset can yet measure an effect on Fiddler’s Creek home values, because nothing has been built, and we do not invent one.
The developer advertises “new coach homes from $1.5M, new single-family homes from $3M, custom estate homes from over $10M” in 2026, with Dorado, Callista II, Oyster Harbor and the new Hidden Cove estate village on offer (developer home page, read October 2026). A resale competes with that inventory on three fronts: it is ready now, it carries mature landscaping, and it is often priced well below the new product. The developer also discloses on its legal page that on approved-builder sales it “may be entitled to a marketing fee and/or brokerage commission … which may be paid by the approved builder or charged to the purchaser,” a cost a resale buyer does not face.
Collier Boulevard widening along the Fiddler’s Creek frontage is in the Collier MPO 2050 Long Range Transportation Plan as cost-feasible in FY2031 to FY2035, at $21.64 million year-of-expenditure, and no SR 951 capacity project south of US 41 is in the adopted FY2027 to FY2031 TIP. The I-75 interchange at SR 951 is in construction (FDOT project 425843-2). Buyers ask about traffic at the Main gate, and a seller who has the dated record in hand answers the question instead of absorbing it in price.
Selling a Fiddler’s Creek home costs a negotiated brokerage fee, Florida documentary stamp tax of $0.70 per $100 of the price, association estoppel fees and the year’s tax and CDD prorations. In Collier County the buyer customarily pays the owner’s title policy, so it is not a standard seller cost here; the contract controls.
Data updated: October 2026 (Florida Statutes; CDD FY2027 adopted budgets; Collier County 2026 certified roll; Florida DOR 2025 Collier millage summary).
Brokerage compensation is negotiable and set in your listing agreement. Documentary stamp tax on the deed is $0.70 per $100 of consideration under section 201.02, Florida Statutes, customarily a seller cost: at the $770,000 community median that is $5,390.00, by our arithmetic. In Collier County the buyer customarily pays the owner’s title insurance policy and chooses the closing agent, so we never list the owner’s title policy as a seller cost on a Fiddler’s Creek net sheet unless your contract assigns it to you. Read the title clause before you sign.
A Fiddler’s Creek sale usually needs two estoppel certificates: one from the Foundation and one from the village or condominium association. Florida law allows each association to charge for a certificate within limits the statute sets, under section 720.30851, Florida Statutes for the Foundation and HOA-form villages, and condominiums follow the parallel condominium statute. Expect two fees and two delivery clocks. The certificate is also where any levied and unpaid special assessment appears, and the closing agent pays it from the proceeds unless the contract assigns it otherwise.
The year’s property tax and CDD assessment are prorated to the closing date, because both are paid in arrears on the November bill. A seller in a village with a high CDD debt line, such as Marsh Cove at $6,936.29 or the Lagomar replat lots at $6,830.73 for FY2027, will see a larger proration credit to the buyer than a seller in a paid-off village. We put the proration estimate on your net sheet from the district’s adopted budget, so the number at the closing table matches the number you were shown.
A Fiddler’s Creek seller owes a buyer the Foundation’s homeowners’ association disclosure summary before the contract is signed, a flood disclosure, the known facts that materially affect value and, for a condominium, the condominium documents. The Foundation is not a condominium association, while 14 of the villages are, so the timing rules differ by product.
Data updated: October 2026 (Florida Statutes 2025; Fiddler’s Creek Foundation Articles of Incorporation; Florida DBPR condominium roster).
Fiddler’s Creek Foundation, Inc. describes itself in its Articles of Incorporation as “not a condominium association under Chapter 718,” and membership is mandatory, so section 720.401, Florida Statutes applies to a sale. Four facts from the statute matter. The disclosure summary is delivered before the buyer executes the contract, never at closing. On a resale, the parcel owner supplies it. The contract must carry the statute’s voidability clause in conspicuous type. And if it is not delivered, the buyer can cancel within 3 days after receipt of the summary or before closing, whichever occurs first, a right that cannot be waived and ends at closing.
Section 720.401 does not apply to associations under chapters 718, 719, 721 or 723. A Fiddler’s Creek coach-home or villa condominium sits under a chapter 718 condominium association inside a chapter 720 master Foundation, so a condominium seller deals with both regimes: the condominium’s own resale document rules and the Foundation’s homeowners’ association layer. How the two interact on a given sale is a question for your closing agent or attorney, and this section is information, not legal advice. We assemble both sets of documents at listing so the question never delays a contract.
Florida requires a flood disclosure for residential sales under section 689.302, Florida Statutes, and Florida law requires a seller to disclose known facts that materially affect value and are not readily observable. In Fiddler’s Creek that means any prior water intrusion, roof claims and repairs, alongside the CDD assessment with its amount. Disclosure done early and completely is a pricing tool: a buyer who trusts the file negotiates less on the inspection.
We collect five packets. First, the Foundation’s disclosure summary (section 720.401) and estoppel request (section 720.30851). Second, the village or condominium documents and estoppel. Third, the CDD information: your village’s line from the CDD #1 or CDD #2 adopted budget. Fourth, the flood disclosure, plus any elevation certificate and letter of map change. Fifth, records of the roof, windows, HVAC and any wind-mitigation inspection, which drive the buyer’s insurance quote. The full Declaration is recorded at Collier Official Records Book 2315, Page 2050, as recited in a December 2001 deed (Collier Clerk OR 2958/0099).
Fiddler’s Creek values run higher than nearby Treviso Bay on the latest MLS figures: 189 Fiddler’s Creek closings at a $770,000 median against 78 Treviso Bay closings at a $550,000 median, reflecting Fiddler’s Creek’s deeper bench of estate single-family villages and Treviso Bay’s larger share of four-story condominiums.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, Fiddler’s Creek closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026; Treviso Bay closed sales July 29, 2025 to July 29, 2026).
Yardstick | Fiddler’s Creek | |
|---|---|---|
12-month closings | 189 | 78 |
12-month median sold price | $770,000 | $550,000 |
12-month range | $250,000 to $3,900,000 | $372,500 to $3,100,000 |
Master or Foundation fee | Mandatory Foundation; dues not published | $7,420 a year master association (2026 Annual Fee Sheet) |
Closing contribution | $15,000 in 2010 filings; current amount not published | $7,500 master plus $7,500 golf club capital contribution at resale |
CDD operations and maintenance, FY2027 | $1,836.29 (CDD #1) or $1,797.75 (CDD #2) | $1,499.21 (Wentworth Estates CDD FY2027 budget) |
Condominium height | Two-story coach homes and villas; none on the milestone list | 599 units assessed as four-story condominiums |
Sampled flood zones | 64% AE 7 ft, 6% AE 8 ft, 30% shaded X | 64.6% AE 8 ft, 17.7% AE 7 ft, 16.8% shaded X |
Sources: Southwest Florida MLS for both communities in the windows named; Treviso Bay 2026 Annual Fee Sheet, May 11, 2026; Wentworth Estates CDD FY2027 adopted budget; Fiddler’s Creek CDD FY2027 adopted budgets; FEMA NFHL point queries.
The two communities share a public school feeder pattern, Evacuation Zone A at every sampled point and a CDD on the tax bill, so buyers tour both. A Fiddler’s Creek seller wins that comparison on product range, the Club and Spa included with Foundation membership, two-story condominium buildings outside the milestone and reserve-study rules, and a lower share of sampled points at an 8 ft base flood elevation. Treviso Bay wins on published fees. The Fiddler’s Creek seller who closes that gap by putting the Foundation and village estoppel figures in the listing file takes away Treviso Bay’s best argument. Our Treviso Bay page and our Naples Reserve page carry the neighbors’ records in full.
The things that move a Fiddler’s Creek number before you list are the ones a buyer prices: a complete fee and document file, a current wind-mitigation report and elevation certificate, a roof and windows a carrier will quote, and a home shown at its best in the January to April season, when most of the year’s closings happen.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026; CDD #1 minutes on occupancy).
The fastest way to protect your price is to answer the buyer’s questions before they are asked. That means your CDD line from the adopted budget, the Foundation and village estoppel figures, the village or condominium documents, the elevation certificate and any FEMA letter, and the Montreux-style leasing rules if your village has them. In a community where three of the six billing layers are not published, the seller with the file in hand removes the biggest source of renegotiation in Fiddler’s Creek.
Insurance is the line item most likely to move a closing date here. A current wind-mitigation report on the state’s uniform form, a four-point inspection on an older home and the receipts for roof, windows and HVAC give the buyer’s agent what a carrier needs. A 1998 Cotton Green patio home and a 2022 Marsh Cove home are quoted on different roofs and openings, and the home with the documents gets the quote that supports your price.
Any exterior change in Fiddler’s Creek needs approval from the Fiddler’s Creek Design Review Committee, whose meetings are “typically held on the 1st Friday of every month,” after the village board approves the application (Montreux welcome packet, Apr 21, 2017). A seller planning paint, a pool cage or landscaping before listing should start that clock early, and should close out any open approval, because an unresolved one surfaces on the estoppel and becomes the buyer’s leverage.
A free in-person Fiddler’s Creek comparative market analysis from McGreevy and Comisar starts with the Home Valuation form at the top of this page or a call to Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072. Marc Comisar walks the home, Jesse builds the analysis from your village’s closings and records, and you receive a written opinion of value with every source named.
Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and every in-person valuation is prepared by one of them.
A written opinion of value for your address, built from the MLS closings of your village and its nearest matches, adjusted for time, plan, lot and condition, with every source named. Beside it, the carrying-cost picture your buyer will underwrite: the CDD line from the district’s adopted budget, the Foundation and village items, the flood file and the tax reset. And a plain recommendation on list price and timing, including the case for waiting if the evidence says wait.
Get your free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation with the Home Valuation form at the top of this page, request our free home valuation from anywhere, or call Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072 or email [email protected]. Marc Comisar is at (239) 457-1610, and our office is at 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134. There is no charge and no obligation to list. If you have already decided to sell, our plan for selling your home in Fiddler’s Creek covers pricing, marketing, negotiation and the Foundation and CDD package in full, and our guide to selling a home in Naples covers the citywide process.
McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Fiddler’s Creek listing agent on Google Business Profile, and the quotes below are genuine five-star client reviews reproduced in each reviewer’s own words. None is presented as a Fiddler’s Creek sale, and we publish no aggregate score, because a review describes the people who wrote it.
McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Fiddler’s Creek realtor, and every quote below is a five-star review on our Google Business Profile.
★★★★★ “Their professionalism, communication, and dedication to their clients truly stand out. They have a deep caring and true concern for all their client needs.” Verified Google review
★★★★★ “Jesse is the best Realtor I have used. He found us our dream home even though it took months as we were not the easiest to please.” Verified Google review
Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are the local real estate experts behind this Fiddler’s Creek valuation page. They lead Domain Realty Group, a team of agent partners across Southwest Florida, and build every valuation from the Southwest Florida MLS and the public record. Reach Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.
Jesse McGreevy is a licensed Florida REALTOR and Sales Associate with Domain Realty and one half of McGreevy and Comisar. He has been in Southwest Florida real estate since October 2004 and has lived in Estero since 2003. He runs the pricing analysis, the record work and the association paperwork on every valuation the team writes. Reach him at (239) 898-6072 or [email protected], and read his full profile on the Jesse McGreevy agent page.
Marc Comisar is a licensed Florida REALTOR and Broker Associate with Domain Realty and the other half of McGreevy and Comisar, whose partnership alone has over $900 million in sales. The two have worked as a team since 2008. He runs the field side, in the homes, at the inspections and at the closing table, and he is the one who walks your Fiddler’s Creek home before any number is written down. Reach him at (239) 457-1610, and read his full profile on the Marc Comisar agent page.
Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC). Our Naples office is at 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109.
These are the valuation questions Fiddler’s Creek owners actually ask, answered from the Southwest Florida MLS (closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026), the two districts’ adopted budgets, FEMA’s records and the state’s statute and condominium records. Nothing here is tax or legal advice, and none of it replaces a written valuation of your specific home.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026).
It depends on your village, product, plan, lot, view, CDD line, flood zone and condition. The MLS recorded 189 Fiddler’s Creek closings in the last 12 months at a $770,000 median, with village medians, where a village had 10 or more sales, from $317,500 at Hawk’s Nest to $2,288,750 at Marsh Cove, and closings from $250,000 at Whisper Trace to $3,900,000 at Isla del Sol. For a number on your address, use the Home Valuation form at the top of this page or call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072.
We start with your village’s closed sales in the Southwest Florida MLS, then adjust for the three things that move price most inside Fiddler’s Creek: product and size, view and lot position, and the carrying cost a buyer inherits. A paid-off CDD #1 home carries $1,836.29 a year in CDD operations and maintenance on the November 2026 bill, while a Marsh Cove home carries $6,936.29, and buyers notice the difference.
An automated model learns from square footage, bedrooms and recent sales. It cannot see your CDD lot group, the Foundation buy-in, a FEMA letter on your lot or the gap between the county’s living area and the builder’s air-conditioned square footage. In villages with one or two sales a year, such as Sauvignon or Menaggio, a model has almost nothing to learn from, so its figure can swing toward whatever sold last nearby.
The median sold price was $770,000 on 189 closed sales between Oct 13, 2025 and Oct 13, 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, pulled Oct 13, 2026). With an odd number of sales, that median is the middle sale. By our arithmetic from the same rows, the condominium villages closed at a $575,000 median and the single-family and villa villages at $1,235,000.
The 2001 to 2015 coach-home condominiums closed at a $627,500 median across 66 sales over the 12 months, with Laguna at $495,000, Varenna at $577,000 and Cherry Oaks at $667,500 on 12 sales each; villages with fewer than 10 sales are read by range, from $390,000 at Sonoma to $915,000 at Serena. The new Dorado coach homes closed from $1,190,000 to $1,570,000, and the developer prices new Callista II coach homes from $1.5 million (developer home page, read October 2026).
The three villa-style condominiums built 1997 to 2004 are the entry to Fiddler’s Creek. Whisper Trace closed five times from $250,000 to $399,000, Hawk’s Nest ten times at a $317,500 median in a tight $300,000 to $375,000 band, and Deer Crossing six times from $320,000 to $530,000 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). All three are paid in full in CDD #1, at $1,836.29 a unit for FY2027.
Marsh Cove recorded 16 sales in the last 12 months, the most of any Fiddler’s Creek village, at a $2,288,750 median and a range of $1,200,000 to $3,362,500 (Southwest Florida MLS). It is the only CDD #1 village still carrying debt: $6,936.29 a lot on the November 2026 bill, with Phase 1 principal of $22,849.03 after the FY2027 payment (CDD #1 FY2027 adopted budget). Your plan, lot, LOMR-F status and finishes set your place in that range.
Oyster Harbor recorded 11 sales in the last 12 months at a $2,125,000 median, from $1,299,000 to $3,200,000 (Southwest Florida MLS). Resales compete with the developer’s 2026 offerings, Allamanda IV from $2.4 million plus homesite and Hibiscus IV from $2.8 million plus homesite, so a finished resale with a pool can be priced as the ready-now alternative. Your CDD #2 bond group, from operations only to $4,474.78 in FY2026, also matters.
Millbrook recorded nine sales from $650,000 to $990,000 (an $862,500 median over the 24 months from Oct 13, 2024, on 16 sales), and Cotton Green five sales from $650,000 to $825,000, too few for a median (Southwest Florida MLS). Their carrying costs differ: Cotton Green is a paid-off CDD #1 village at $1,836.29 for FY2027, while Millbrook pays CDD #2 totals of $4,814.86 to $6,194.09 by lot group in FY2026 (CDD #2 FY2026 adopted budget).
The highest closing in the 12 months to Oct 13, 2026 was an Isla del Sol custom estate home at $3,900,000 on June 4, 2026. Isla del Sol also recorded closings at $3,575,000 and $3,250,000 on July 6, 2026, and Marsh Cove’s highest was $3,362,500 on Mar 19, 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS). The developer advertises new custom estate homes in Hidden Cove from over $10 million, a market with no recorded sale yet.
The median home that sold in Fiddler’s Creek in the 12 months to Oct 13, 2026 took 74 days on market (average 110), and the median closing came at 94.7% of its final list price (Southwest Florida MLS, 177 closings with a days-on-market figure). What shapes timing here is season and paperwork: by our count, 100 of the 189 closings fell between December and April, and a sale cannot close until the Foundation and village estoppel certificates arrive.
The timing answer is partly seasonal and partly about your own file. Foundation-reported occupancy ran about 2,210 homes in January 2026 against 900 in June 2026 (CDD #1 minutes), so a fall valuation and a winter listing meet the deepest buyer pool. On October 13, 2026 there were 77 active listings and 17 pending, about 4.9 months of supply at the last 12 months’ closing pace. Whether now is right also depends on your CDD line, your roof and your plans, which we lay out in a confidential conversation at (239) 898-6072.
Over the latest 12 months the Southwest Florida MLS shows 189 closings, a $770,000 median and $205,175,925 in volume (closed sales Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026). The prior 12 months (closed Oct 13, 2024 to Oct 12, 2025) held 103 closings at a $1,050,000 median, so closings rose 83.5% while the community median fell 26.7%. Most of that fall is mix: low-rise condominiums were 93 of the 189 closings against 29 of the 103 a year earlier. Within each product line the change was smaller, with single-family medians down 4.2% ($1,245,000 from $1,300,000) and low-rise condominium medians down 8.7% ($575,000 from $630,000), and the median sale-to-list moved from 94.1% to 94.7%. For your decision the more useful trend is your village’s, and the villages with ten or more sales (Marsh Cove, Cherry Oaks, Varenna, Laguna, Oyster Harbor and Hawk’s Nest) give the most readable price bands.
Six villages recorded ten or more closings in the 12 months: Marsh Cove (16), Cherry Oaks (12), Varenna (12), Laguna (12), Oyster Harbor (11) and Hawk’s Nest (10) (Southwest Florida MLS). In those villages a valuation can rest on the village’s own sales. Nine villages recorded one or two closings, and there we widen to the nearest village of the same product, age and CDD treatment before we price.
View premiums are real in most golf communities, but our current MLS pull does not hold the view field, so we do not publish a Fiddler’s Creek premium. What the export does show is days on market and sale-to-list by product line: single-family homes at 65 days and 94.7%, low-rise condominiums at 89 days and 95.0%. We measure the view for each listing by pairing sales in the same village and plan with and without the view, remembering that the Creek Course renovation of 2024 changed some golf-front views (GRAA facility profile, Oct 2, 2025).
A paid-off CDD lowers the buyer’s yearly carrying cost, and buyers who compare villages notice; the market-wide price effect is not measured in a public dataset, so we do not state one. The cost gap is large: a paid-off CDD #1 home pays $1,836.29 on the November 2026 bill, a Marsh Cove home $6,936.29, and a Lagomar replat lot $6,830.73 (CDD FY2027 adopted budgets).
No. The CDD debt assessment runs with the land and is collected on the annual tax bill, so the remaining installments continue for the next owner unless the contract says otherwise. Each district’s adopted budget prints the remaining principal by village, such as $22,849.03 for Marsh Cove Phase 1 and $30,752.48 for a Lagomar replat lot after the FY2027 payment, and the district manager gives the exact payoff on a date.
No primary source publishes current refund terms, so your Foundation documents decide it. The one primary record that states an amount is the 2010 bankruptcy-court sale filing, which describes “a Capital Acquisition Assessment for membership to The Club & Spa at Fiddler’s Creek in the amount of $15,000.00” paid to the Foundation at closing (Docket 314.1, Aug 10, 2010).
Golf Club refund and transfer terms are not published by a primary source; they are in the Golf Club’s Membership Plan and your membership agreement. The club’s 2024 Articles refer to “Equity Members” and to “the holders of the Equity Memberships” receiving assets on dissolution (Golf Club Articles of Incorporation), but they do not state refund amounts or timing. Read your agreement before you list.
Of 108 Fiddler’s Creek address points tested on Oct 7, 2026, 69 sit in Zone AE with a 7 ft base flood elevation, 7 in Zone AE at 8 ft and 32 in shaded Zone X, with none in Zone VE (FEMA NFHL). For a financed buyer, Zone AE usually means required flood insurance unless a LOMA or LOMR-F removes the structure, which affects the payment the buyer can carry and so the price.
Yes. Collier County holds 1,378 elevation certificates on Fiddler’s Creek street names, and a 49-certificate sample shows finished floors mostly between about 7.0 and 8.7 ft NAVD88 against a base flood elevation of 7 (Collier County elevation-certificate layer, read Oct 7, 2026). A certificate showing your floor above the base flood elevation is a document the buyer’s insurance agent prices from.
Not at the points we tested. The County’s target effective date for the revised maps is “Summer 2027,” and at every Fiddler’s Creek point we ran against FEMA’s preliminary flood layer, the zone and base flood elevation were unchanged; panel 12021C0615J is not being revised (Collier County announcement, Aug 19, 2026; FEMA preliminary NFHL). Confirm your own lot before you list.
Florida’s milestone inspection (section 553.899) and structural integrity reserve study (section 718.112) requirements apply to condominium buildings three or more habitable stories high. Fiddler’s Creek condominiums are two-story coach-home and villa buildings: none is among the 926 buildings on Collier County’s milestone list, and county unit numbers use first and second floors only. Confirm story count in your condominium documents.
No primary record we found documents storm surge entering Fiddler’s Creek homes in Irma or Ian, and no dataset isolates a storm effect on prices. The record shows power loss for nearly a week after Irma (Golfweek, Sept 27, 2017) and a Parkway water-line blowout during Milton (CDD #2 minutes, Oct 23, 2024). Your home’s own claim and repair history is what a buyer prices.
In Collier County the buyer customarily pays for the owner’s title insurance policy and chooses the closing agent, so it is not a standard seller cost on a Fiddler’s Creek sale. The purchase contract controls, so read the title clause before you sign. We never list the owner’s title policy as a seller cost on your net sheet unless your contract assigns it to you.
Seller costs fall into four groups: a negotiated brokerage fee, documentary stamp tax of $0.70 per $100 of the price (section 201.02), the Foundation and village estoppel certificate fees, and prorations of the year’s property tax and CDD assessment. At the $770,000 community median, documentary stamps come to $5,390.00 by our arithmetic. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 for a net sheet on your home.
A Fiddler’s Creek seller delivers the Foundation’s homeowners’ association disclosure summary before the contract is signed (section 720.401), a flood disclosure (section 689.302) and the known facts that materially affect value. Condominium sellers also deliver their condominium documents, because their association sits under chapter 718. Ask your closing agent or attorney how the two regimes apply to your sale.
Yes, usually. Florida law allows each association to charge for an estoppel certificate within limits the statute sets: section 720.30851 for the Foundation and HOA-form villages, and the parallel condominium statute for condominiums. A Fiddler’s Creek sale often needs two certificates, so expect two fees and two delivery clocks. The current fee each association charges is stated on its request form.
Your buyer’s will. A Florida homestead’s capped assessed value belongs to the owner, not the house, and after a sale the parcel is reassessed at just value as of the next January 1 (section 193.155). At the 2026 certified rate of 10.3696 mills on the county roll, every $100,000 of taxable value costs $1,036.96 a year, before the CDD and solid waste lines.
No dataset can measure an effect yet, because nothing has been built. The County entitled 750 rental units on 49.91 acres in December 2024 (Ordinance 2024-51), but its Aug 15, 2025 monitoring letter says construction “has not yet commenced, and no permits have been issued,” and its July 1, 2026 list still shows the project as “Approved.” We follow the filings and show buyers the dated record.
Yes. The developer advertises new coach homes from $1.5 million, new single-family homes from $3 million and custom estate homes from over $10 million in 2026 (developer home page). A resale competes on readiness, mature landscaping and price, and it carries no developer marketing fee, which the developer’s legal page says may be “charged to the purchaser” on approved-builder sales.
Florida law allows it, and the work is the same: price it from your village’s closings, assemble the Foundation disclosure summary, both estoppel certificates, the CDD figures and the flood disclosure, arrange gate access for every showing, and negotiate with buyers who now sign written agreements with their own agents. With closings from $250,000 to $3,900,000 and thin village samples, a pricing miss is costly.
It depends on your village’s leasing rules, your tax position and your plans. Montreux, the one village that publishes its rules, allows leases of at least 30 days, three a year, with written approval and no tenant pets (Montreux welcome packet, 2017); every other village’s declaration governs its own. The MLS recorded 14 residential rentals in Fiddler’s Creek from Oct 13, 2025 to Oct 13, 2026: three in Callista; two each in Varenna, Deer Crossing and Hawk’s Nest; and one each in Whisper Trace, Laguna, Pepper Tree, Sonoma and Menaggio. Eleven carry a seasonal rate and rented between $5,200 and $17,500 (median $6,999), and the three monthly-only rentals ran from $2,100 to $4,250. The rented-price field mixes monthly and seasonal rates and no village has 10 leases, so we read each lease comparable by village and floor plan. We run the sell-and-rent comparison with you.
Nothing. A McGreevy and Comisar valuation is free and carries no obligation to list. Use the Home Valuation form at the top of this page, get your free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation, or call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072. You receive a written opinion of value from your village’s closings with every source named, plus the carrying-cost picture your buyer will underwrite.
No. Many Fiddler’s Creek owners are seasonal, and the Foundation’s occupancy figures fall to about 900 homes in June. We can complete the record work from anywhere and arrange the walk-through with your property manager or a neighbor, with the guest pass handled through the Foundation’s gate system. Call Jesse at (239) 898-6072 or Marc at (239) 457-1610.
The best listing agent for Fiddler’s Creek is the one who prices from your village’s closed sales, documents every fee layer before the buyer asks and markets to the buyers most likely to pay for your product. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and lead the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
If you are selling in Fiddler’s Creek and buying again, call Marc Comisar at (239) 457-1610 and read our guide to buying a home in Fiddler’s Creek or how we represent buyers in Naples. We price the sale first, then shop the purchase with the same CDD, Foundation and flood file in hand, so the two closings line up.
Every figure on this Fiddler’s Creek valuation page traces to a primary source below: the Southwest Florida MLS, Collier County records and GIS layers, the two Community Development Districts’ budgets, minutes and audits, Florida Statutes and state agencies, FEMA and the developer’s own pages. Nothing comes from a listing aggregator or another brokerage, and the links were retrieved in October 2026.
Southwest Florida MLS figures are cited rather than linked because the MLS is members-only. Parcel and build-year counts come from the 2026 Florida Department of Revenue parcel roll, and CDD figures from each district’s adopted budget for the year named.
Every Fiddler’s Creek document below links its official custodian: the two Community Development Districts, Collier County, the State of Florida, FEMA or the federal court record. You always see the authoritative version, not a copy we made, and each row says what the document proves for a Fiddler’s Creek valuation.
Document | What it proves for a Fiddler’s Creek valuation | Official authority |
|---|---|---|
Fiddler’s Creek CDD #1 Adopted Budget, FY2027 (PDF) | The $1,836.29 operations and maintenance line, the Marsh Cove debt line and remaining principal by village | |
Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2 Adopted Budget, FY2027 (PDF) | The $1,797.75 operations and maintenance line and the debt line for every CDD #2 village and lot group | |
Fiddler’s Creek CDD #2 Adopted Budget, FY2026 (PDF) | The FY2026 per-unit totals by village and phase quoted on this page | |
CDD #1 Audited Financial Report, FYE Sept 30, 2025 (PDF) | Bonds outstanding of $16,140,000, indenture compliance and the Irma reimbursement note | |
CDD #2 Audited Financial Report, FYE Sept 30, 2025 (PDF) | Bonds outstanding of $33,700,000 and indenture compliance | |
Official Statement, CDD #2 Series 2019 Refunding Bonds (PDF) | The bond disclosure, including the bankruptcy history and the assessment method | |
Bankruptcy Docket 314.1, Aug 10, 2010 (PDF) | The $15,000 Capital Acquisition Assessment paid to the Foundation at closing in 2010 | |
Articles of Incorporation, Fiddler’s Creek Foundation, Inc. (1996) | The Foundation is “not a condominium association under Chapter 718” | |
Collier County 2026 Flood Protection Newsletter (PDF) | Community Rating System Class 5 and the 50% substantial-improvement rule | |
Collier County Ordinance 2024-51 (PDF) | The Section 29 entitlement for 750 rental units on 49.91 acres | |
Collier County PUD monitoring letter, Aug 15, 2025 (PDF) | Section 29 construction “has not yet commenced, and no permits have been issued” | |
Fiddler’s Creek Irrigation System Overview, May 6, 2025 (PDF) | The CDD-run lake irrigation system that operations and maintenance pays for | |
Florida Statutes section 720.401 | The disclosure summary a seller delivers before the contract | |
Florida Statutes section 720.30851 | Estoppel certificates and their fee limits | |
Florida Statutes section 689.302 | The flood disclosure in residential sales | |
Florida Statutes section 201.02 | Documentary stamp tax of $0.70 per $100 on the deed | |
Florida Statutes section 193.155 | The homestead reassessment after a change of ownership |
You reach the Fiddler’s Creek valuation team by using the Home Valuation form at the top of this page, requesting a free home valuation, calling Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072, or calling Marc Comisar at (239) 457-1610. The first conversation costs nothing, and it is usually the most valuable hour a Fiddler’s Creek seller spends. You will be working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
Get your free Fiddler’s Creek home valuation from anywhere, or use our general free home valuation request. If you have decided to sell, read our plan for selling your home in Fiddler’s Creek. If you are buying too, start with buying a home in Fiddler’s Creek and call Marc at (239) 457-1610.
Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC).
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more at DomainRealtyGroup.com. Read more about the team on the about McGreevy and Comisar page, and about the community on our Fiddler’s Creek community guide. Nothing on this page is legal, tax or insurance advice. Confirm anything that affects your transaction with your closing agent, attorney, accountant or insurance professional.
Market data from Southwest Florida MLS, pulled Oct 13, 2026, and from Collier County and State of Florida public records. Brokered by Domain Realty.