1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

What’s Your Eagle Creek Home Worth?

What’s Your Eagle Creek Home Worth?

Your Home Valuation

Thank You! We are going to prepare a customized report with information on the value of your home.
View Our Listings

Updated October 2026 · Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty

Sell Your Eagle Creek Home With the #1 Team in Southwest Florida Since 2012

To sell an Eagle Creek home in Naples for top dollar, price it against the closings for its own product, condominium, villa or estate home, confirm the golf or social membership it carries before you list, answer buyers’ questions about the club’s finances and the flood file up front, and market it to golf buyers in season. McGreevy and Comisar do all of it.

Eagle Creek Golf and Country Club is a private, member-owned golf community of 461 residences at US 41 and Collier Boulevard in Naples, ZIP 34113; our full Eagle Creek community guide covers the club, the homes and the flood file. This page is for owners who want to sell. If you want a number first, start with our Eagle Creek home valuation, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Selling to buy elsewhere in the city? Our guide to selling a home in Naples covers the citywide steps, and our Eagle Creek buyer guide shows what your buyer will be reading.

Why List Your Eagle Creek Home With McGreevy and Comisar

McGreevy and Comisar are the #5 real estate team in Florida in the 2026 RealTrends rankings, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with over $900 million in personal sales; Jesse has sold Southwest Florida real estate since 2004 and the team has worked together since 2008. We lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, which has sold over $2.5 billion in real estate. Sellers comparing the best real estate agents in Naples can see the full comparison there, and more about McGreevy and Comisar on our team page.

The Credentials Behind Your Listing

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Domain Realty, our brokerage, closed 658 transaction sides in Naples in the 60 months to October 5, 2026, $521.5 million in volume counted by side, per the Southwest Florida MLS pulled that day.

Who Does the Work on Your Listing

Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar price, negotiate and manage every listing personally, with the Domain Realty Group team handling photography, video, scheduling and the document file. Jesse leads pricing and the seller side; Marc leads buyer outreach, including the golf buyers and their agents who tour Naples clubs each winter.

What an Eagle Creek Seller Is Actually Selling

An Eagle Creek seller is selling a home and a club at once: a walkable private course with app tee times and no Chelsea system, a 370-member golf cap, a clubhouse renovated for $12 million in 2024 and the Crystal Lake complex, in a member-owned club with no CDD (Eagle Creek golf; Club + Resort Business). That is the case we make to every buyer.

What Makes Selling in Eagle Creek, Naples Different?

Selling in Eagle Creek is different because the buyer must join the club, not every home qualifies for golf, the club’s finances are public in IRS filings, signs are banned, the community is Zone AE and evacuation Zone A, and three products from $175,000 to $1,975,000 trade under four MLS names, so pricing and disclosure run home by home.

The Membership Comes With the Sale

“Membership is required when purchasing a property at Eagle Creek,” golf or social (social membership), and “Not all properties at Eagle Creek qualify for a Golf Membership” (Eagle Creek membership). We confirm your home’s designation and the club’s transfer terms in writing before we list, so the buyer’s first question has an answer.

The Club’s Finances Are Public

Buyers and their agents can read the club’s IRS data: fiscal 2024 revenue $7,322,767, expenses $11,228,343, liabilities $14,524,887, up from $6,490,762 a year earlier (IRS Form 990 data). We prepare a plain-language summary and the club’s own explanation of its capital plan, so the numbers help rather than scare.

No Signs, One Open House Sign

“‘For Sale’ signs … are not permitted”; an owner may display one tan and green Open House sign (Eagle Creek realtor resources). Your marketing has to work online and through agents, which is how we market anyway.

The Flood File Matters

All 44 sampled addresses are FEMA Zone AE with an 8-foot BFE, unchanged on the preliminary map, and in evacuation Zone A (FEMA NFHL). A financed buyer must carry flood insurance. Collier holds 176 elevation certificates for Eagle Creek addresses (Collier elevation certificates); we pull yours, or recommend a new one, before listing.

Three Products, Four MLS Names

Eagle Creek Estates posted a $1,050,000 median on 7 sales; the community name $362,500 on 20; Eagle Creek Country Club $215,000 on 3; Stonegate one sale at $175,000 (Southwest Florida MLS). Your home is priced against the sales that match it, not the $420,000 community median.

Key Takeaways for an Eagle Creek Seller

Eagle Creek sellers price by product, confirm the membership, explain the club and the flood file, and list for season. These eight facts drive an Eagle Creek sale most, each with its source and date.

  • Market: 31 MLS closings at a $420,000 median, from $175,000 to $1,975,000, $19,288,750 in volume (Southwest Florida MLS, closed Aug 11, 2025 to Aug 11, 2026).

  • Estates: 7 sales at a $1,050,000 median, $700,000 to $1,975,000 (same source).

  • Season: 24 of the 31 closings fell between January and June 2026.

  • Membership: mandatory, golf or social; golf capped at 370 (membership).

  • Club finances: liabilities $14.52 million at fiscal 2024 (IRS Form 990 data).

  • Flood: Zone AE 8 ft; evacuation Zone A (FEMA NFHL).

  • Signs: no For Sale signs; one Open House sign.

  • Costs: the seller customarily pays deed stamps ($2,940 on the $420,000 median); the buyer customarily pays the owner’s title policy in Collier County.

Table of Contents

What Record Stands Behind a McGreevy and Comisar Eagle Creek Listing?

Behind a McGreevy and Comisar Eagle Creek listing stands a team that is Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, the #5 real estate team in Florida in the 2026 RealTrends rankings, and a brokerage with 658 Naples transaction sides in five years, plus a product-by-product read of the Eagle Creek record before we set a price.

The Team Behind the Numbers

McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in sales, and with the Domain Realty Group team over $2.5 billion. The team has worked together since 2008 and Jesse has sold Southwest Florida real estate since 2004. In a club community with a $175,000 to $1,975,000 range, that depth is what keeps a list price honest.

Domain Realty’s Naples Record

Domain Realty, our brokerage, closed 658 transaction sides in Naples in the 60 months to October 5, 2026, $521.5 million in volume counted by side, per the Southwest Florida MLS pulled that day.

The 12-Month Eagle Creek Market We Tracked

As Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, we read every row. We tracked 31 closed sales of Eagle Creek homes in the Southwest Florida MLS from August 11, 2025 to August 11, 2026: a $420,000 median, a range of $175,000 to $1,975,000 and $19,288,750 in volume, all in ZIP 34113. One of the 31, an Estates sale, carried an SDE flag; it counts as a recorded sale. Median days on market was 90.5 (30 sales reporting DOM) and the median sale-to-list ratio 92.9 percent.

How We Measure an Eagle Creek Listing

We measure an Eagle Creek listing against the closed sales for its product, the active competition inside the gates and at nearby clubs, and the membership it carries. We report all three to you every week, with showing feedback.

Is Now a Good Time to Sell in Eagle Creek?

Now is a good time to prepare an Eagle Creek sale for the winter and spring season: 24 of the last 31 Eagle Creek closings fell between January and June 2026, the renovated clubhouse is open, and the club’s 2028 State Amateur selection gives golf buyers another reason to look.

The 31 Closings by MLS Name

MLS nameClosed salesMedian or saleLowHigh
Eagle Creek20$362,500$215,000$1,700,000
Eagle Creek Estates7$1,050,000$700,000$1,975,000
Eagle Creek Country Club3$215,000$199,000$280,000
Stonegate at Eagle Creek1$175,000 (thin)$175,000$175,000

Source: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales Aug 11, 2025 to Aug 11, 2026.

Where the Closings Landed by Price

Price bandClosed sales
Under $300,0008
$300,000 to $499,9999
$500,000 to $999,9999
$1,000,000 and up5

Source: Southwest Florida MLS (our grouping).

Eagle Creek Sales by Quarter

QuarterClosed salesMedian or salesLowHigh
Aug 11 to Sep 30, 20252two sales, both $215,000$215,000$215,000
Oct to Dec 20253$355,000$175,000$939,750
Jan to Mar 202611$345,000$199,000$1,975,000
Apr to Jun 202613$580,000$220,000$1,625,000
Jul 1 to Aug 11, 20262$420,000 and $730,000$420,000$730,000

Source: Southwest Florida MLS (our grouping). Quarterly medians mix products, so read them as pace, not trend.

What Is for Sale Today

On October 22, 2026, Eagle Creek had 21 active listings (14 under the community name, 5 in Stonegate, 1 in the Estates, 1 in Eagle Creek Country Club), 8.1 months of supply. When you call, we pull the live listings inside Eagle Creek and at competing clubs that morning.

What the Median Hides

The $420,000 median sits between condominiums from $175,000 and estate homes near $2 million. Your number starts with your product, then your membership designation, view and condition.

How Do We Price an Eagle Creek Home?

We price an Eagle Creek home from the inside out: first the closings for its product, then its golf or social designation, its view, its renovation and its elevation, then the club and association costs a buyer will carry, and only last the community median, which mixes three products and four MLS names.

Start With Your Product

An Estates home competes with Estates sales, $700,000 to $1,975,000; a condominium with the condominium-priced names, $175,000 to $280,000, and the condominiums inside the twenty community-name sales (Southwest Florida MLS). By building design those twenty were 12 condominiums, 6 single-family homes and 2 attached villas.

Price the Membership Designation

A home that carries golf eligibility reaches golf buyers, in a club capped at 370 golf members (Eagle Creek). A social-only home reaches buyers who want the clubhouse and racquets, with summer golf. We price each against its own buyer.

View, Renovation and Elevation

Golf-course and lake views, a renovation of the kind the club calls a “renovation revival” (Eagle Creek realtor resources), and a lowest-floor elevation comfortably above the 8-foot BFE each move price. Your elevation certificate is a pricing document here.

The Carrying Costs as a Pricing Fact

Club dues, any capital charge and association fees are not published; buyers compare them with other clubs. We get them in writing and price with them.

Why Automated Estimates Miss in Eagle Creek

A model sees “Eagle Creek” and a square footage. It does not see the product, the membership designation, the view, the renovation, the elevation or the club costs, and in a $175,000 to $1,975,000 community that blindness is expensive.

Thinking of Selling an Eagle Creek Home This Season?

Start with an Eagle Creek home valuation, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. If you are also buying, Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 and read how we represent buyers.

How Do We Market an Eagle Creek Home?

We market an Eagle Creek home to the buyer who will pay most for it: golf buyers who want a walkable private course and a small membership, seasonal buyers, and downsizers from larger clubs, reached through professional media, a complete document and membership file, and our buyer-agent network across Southwest Florida and beyond.

Photography, Video and Drone

Every Eagle Creek listing gets professional photography, video and drone footage. The aerials show what a floor plan cannot: the fairway or lake behind the home and the course cut through pine and cypress.

Selling the Club With the Home

Our listing copy carries the club facts buyers care about: the Packard course redesigned in 2021, walking any time, no Chelsea system, the 370-member golf cap, the 2024 clubhouse and the 2028 State Amateur (Eagle Creek golf; Eagle Creek timeline).

The Document and Membership Package

DocumentWho holds itWhy the buyer wants it
Membership designation and transfer termsthe clubwhich membership the home carries, and its cost
Association declaration, rules, budgetyour associationfees, reserves, pet and lease rules
Condominium resale documentscondominium associationrequired under s. 718.503
HOA disclosure summaryhomeowners associationrequired under s. 720.401
Elevation certificateCollier library or a new surveythe flood insurance quote
Wind-mitigation reportyour inspectorthe wind insurance quote
Estoppel certificateyour association’s manageramounts owed at closing

Sources: s. 718.503; s. 720.401; Eagle Creek membership.

Showings, the Gate and Open Houses

We arrange gate access for every showing and use the one permitted tan and green Open House sign when an open house fits your plan (Eagle Creek realtor resources).

Reaching Golf and Seasonal Buyers

Golf buyers often compare four or five clubs in a single week. We put your listing in front of the agents who bring them, and time the launch so media and documents are ready before season.

Off-Market and Private Sales

In a 461-residence community where members know each other, some owners prefer a private sale. We can market your home quietly to qualified buyers in our database first.

What We Report During the Listing

Every week: showings, feedback, online activity, new listings and sales in Eagle Creek and at competing clubs, and our recommendation.

How Do We Negotiate an Eagle Creek Sale?

We negotiate an Eagle Creek sale as partners: we answer offers with matched product sales, settle the membership transfer terms in the contract, protect you on inspection and flood-insurance contingencies, and prepare the appraiser with Eagle Creek’s own sales so a mixed median does not cost you money.

Partner-Level Negotiation

Jesse or Marc, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, handles every offer personally, with a written comparison of your home against the matched sales.

Membership Terms in the Contract

The membership transfer, any equity or capital charge and the timing of the club’s approval belong in the contract, not in a closing-week phone call. We confirm them with the club before acceptance.

Inspection and Insurance Contingencies

In homes from the 1980s and 1990s, inspections focus on roofs, windows and systems; flood and wind quotes depend on the elevation certificate and the wind-mitigation report. We provide both on day one.

Buyer Compensation After the NAR Settlement

Buyer-agent compensation is negotiated separately and in writing. We set your policy before you list.

When the Appraisal Comes in Low

An appraiser may average across products. We give the appraiser the matched Eagle Creek sales, your improvements with costs and the membership context, which usually closes a gap.

What Does It Cost to Sell a Home in Eagle Creek?

Selling an Eagle Creek home typically costs the listing commission, deed stamps at $0.70 per $100, the estoppel certificate, prorated taxes and association fees, and any club account balance or capital charge due at transfer. In Collier County the buyer customarily pays the owner’s title policy, and there is no CDD payoff.

Who Customarily Pays What in a Collier County Closing

ItemCustomarily paid byEagle Creek note
Deed documentary stamps ($0.70 per $100)seller$2,940 on the $420,000 median
Owner’s title policybuyer (Collier custom)the contract controls
Estoppel certificateseller on standard formsfrom your association’s manager
Club account balance or capital chargeper the club’s transfer rulesconfirm in writing
Prorated association fees and taxessplit by closing datefrom the estoppel and tax roll
CDD payoffnoneEagle Creek has no CDD

Sources: Florida DOR; s. 718.116; s. 720.30851; Collier CDD layer.

The Documentary Stamp Tax, Worked

At $0.70 per $100: $1,225 on the $175,000 low, $2,940 on the $420,000 median, $7,350 on the $1,050,000 Estates median and $13,825 on the $1,975,000 high (our arithmetic). The contract controls.

Flood Disclosure

s. 689.302 requires a written flood disclosure on residential sales; Eagle Creek is Zone AE 8 ft. Attach your elevation certificate.

Commission and Net Proceeds

Ask us for a net sheet before you list: price, commission, deed stamps, estoppel, club charges, prorations and any payoff, line by line.

Get Your Free Eagle Creek Home Valuation

A free Eagle Creek home valuation from McGreevy and Comisar compares your home with the closings for its product, adjusts for membership designation, view, renovation and elevation, and gives you a price range and a plan, usually within a day.

What Is Your Eagle Creek Home Worth? Get a Free Valuation in 60 Seconds.

Start with our Eagle Creek home valuation or the citywide home valuation form.

Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome.

What You Receive

  • A price range against the matched product sales

  • The adjustments that move your price, with reasons

  • A timing recommendation against the season

  • A net sheet estimate of your proceeds

What Do Eagle Creek Sellers Say About McGreevy and Comisar?

Sellers across Southwest Florida describe McGreevy and Comisar as responsive, precise on pricing and steady through closing. The quotes below are five-star reviews from our Google Business Profile, printed word for word.

McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Eagle Creek realtor, and every quote below is a five-star review on our Google Business Profile.

★★★★★ “Marc’s attention to detail and deep understanding of the Southwest Florida market gave us so much confidence.” Verified Google review

★★★★★ “Their professionalism, communication, and dedication to their clients truly stand out. They have a deep caring and true concern for all their client needs.” Verified Google review

Talk to McGreevy and Comisar Before You List

Before you sign with anyone, talk to McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or request an Eagle Creek valuation. If you are also buying, Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 and read how we represent buyers.

What Should an Eagle Creek Seller Know About the Community?

An Eagle Creek seller should know the community the buyer is buying into: a member-owned equity club since 1997 with mandatory membership, seven condominiums and villa and estate neighborhoods, no CDD, Zone AE and evacuation Zone A, Manatee schools, and 20 free-flow minutes to Marco Island.

Who Governs Eagle Creek

Eagle Creek Golf and Country Club, Inc., N43890, owns and runs the club; Eagle Creek of Naples Condominium Association serves six of the seven condominiums (Sunbiz; DBPR registry).

Rules a Buyer Will Ask About

Rentals of 30 days to six months with a club rental membership, no For Sale signs, and pet and alteration rules in each declaration (Eagle Creek membership).

Schools, Healthcare and Drive Times

Manatee Elementary (A), Manatee Middle (A) and Lely High (B) for 2025 to 2026 (CCPS 2026 Accountability Brief); Physicians Regional and NCH Southeast on Collier Boulevard about 19 minutes; Marco Island about 20 and Fifth Avenue South about 26 (OSRM routing).

How Should You Sell Each Eagle Creek Product?

Each Eagle Creek product sells to a different buyer: estate homes to golf buyers paying for a fairway view and space, carriage-home villas to buyers who want a detached guest suite without an estate’s upkeep, and condominiums to seasonal and first-time club buyers, often as the most affordable way into a private, walkable course.

Selling an Estate Home

Eagle Creek Estates posted 7 sales at a $1,050,000 median, from $700,000 to $1,975,000 (Southwest Florida MLS). Lead with the golf-course view the club itself highlights, the lot, and the renovation; confirm golf eligibility before listing, because an estate buyer is usually a golf buyer (Eagle Creek realtor resources).

Selling a Carriage-Home Villa

The villas with “detached guest suites” on the Eagle Creek Country Club plat (same source) sell to buyers who host family and want lower upkeep. Their sales file under the community name; Matrix shows two attached-villa sales there in the 12 months, at $580,000 and $725,000, and we match villa sales by address before pricing.

Selling a Condominium

The condominium-priced MLS names traded from $175,000 to $280,000 (Southwest Florida MLS), and the club markets condos “starting around $249K” (Eagle Creek real estate). Condominium buyers ask about the building’s age, roof, reserves and the association fee first; we have those answers in the listing file. Waterford Place, recorded in 1999, is the newest building (DBPR registry).

Selling to a Renter Who Wants to Stay

The club’s Rental Membership Program brings renters for 30 days to six months, and golf rental memberships run up to three years (Eagle Creek real estate). Renters already in the community are some of the best buyers for a resale; we reach them through the club’s own channels and our database.

Frequently Asked Questions: Seller Edition

These are the questions Eagle Creek owners ask before they sell, answered from the club’s pages, Florida statutes and the Southwest Florida MLS. An Eagle Creek seller’s first jobs are to separate the product from the community median and to confirm the membership the home carries.

How do I sell my home in Eagle Creek?

Price it against the closings for its own product, condominium, villa or estate home, confirm its golf or social designation with the club, gather the association documents and the club’s transfer requirements, and market it to golf buyers in season. McGreevy and Comisar run every step; Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

What is my Eagle Creek home worth?

In the 12 months to August 11, 2026, Eagle Creek closings ran from $175,000 to $1,975,000 with a $420,000 median; Eagle Creek Estates posted $1,050,000, sales under the community name $362,500 and the condominium-priced names $175,000 to $280,000 (Southwest Florida MLS). Ask for a free home valuation built from the sales that match your home.

What did Eagle Creek homes sell for in the last 12 months?

We tracked 31 sales for $19,288,750: 20 under the community name at a $362,500 median ($215,000 to $1,700,000), 7 in Eagle Creek Estates at $1,050,000 ($700,000 to $1,975,000), 3 under Eagle Creek Country Club at $215,000 ($199,000 to $280,000) and 1 in Stonegate at $175,000 (Southwest Florida MLS, Aug 11, 2025 to Aug 11, 2026).

How fast do Eagle Creek homes sell?

Median days on market was 90.5 across 30 sales reporting DOM: 81 days for the 14 low-rise condominiums and 133 for the 12 single-family homes reporting. The record also shows pace: 31 sales in 12 months, about 6.7 percent of the community, with 24 between January and June 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS; our arithmetic). A home priced to its product, with its membership confirmed, sells faster.

What is the best time of year to sell in Eagle Creek?

Season. Twenty-four of the 31 closings fell between January and June 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS), when golf buyers are in Naples and can see the course at its best. Listing in late fall, with photography and documents ready, meets them as they arrive.

Does a golf membership designation add value?

Yes, for golf buyers. Not every Eagle Creek property qualifies for golf, and golf is capped at 370 members (Eagle Creek membership). A home that carries golf eligibility reaches a different buyer from a social-only home. We confirm the designation with the club and price it from matched sales.

How does the equity membership transfer when I sell?

The club sets the transfer process; its pricing and equity terms are “available upon request” (Eagle Creek membership). Ask the membership office, before you list, how your equity, any refund and the buyer’s membership are handled at closing, and put those terms in the listing file.

Do I have to tell buyers about the club’s finances?

Buyers will ask, and the facts are public: liabilities rose from $6.49 million to $14.52 million between fiscal 2023 and 2024, the year of the $12 million clubhouse project (IRS Form 990 data). Florida law requires disclosure of known facts that materially affect value; any capital assessment you know of belongs in your disclosure.

What documents must I give my Eagle Creek buyer?

For a condominium, the declaration, articles, bylaws, rules, year-end financial information and the question-and-answer sheet under s. 718.503; for a home in a homeowners association, the disclosure summary under s. 720.401; and the club’s membership and transfer documents.

How do I order an estoppel certificate?

From your association’s manager. For a condominium, s. 718.116 sets its content, timing and fee caps; for a homeowners association, s. 720.30851. The club issues its own statement of member account balances; we order both at listing.

Who pays documentary stamp tax when I sell?

In a Collier County resale the seller customarily pays deed documentary stamps at $0.70 per $100 (Florida DOR). Worked: $1,225 on a $175,000 sale, $2,940 on the $420,000 median, $7,350 on the $1,050,000 Estates median and $13,825 on a $1,975,000 sale (our arithmetic). The contract controls.

Who pays the owner’s title policy in Collier County?

In Collier County the buyer customarily pays for the owner’s title policy, and the seller does not. The contract controls, so we confirm the title provisions in every Eagle Creek offer before you accept it.

What does it cost to sell a home in Eagle Creek?

The listing commission, deed stamps, the estoppel certificate, prorated taxes and association fees, any club account balance or capital charge due at transfer, and settlement charges the contract assigns to the seller. There is no CDD payoff (Collier CDD layer). Ask us for a net sheet before you list.

How are dues and association fees prorated at closing?

The closing agent prorates association fees to the closing date from the estoppel and taxes for the calendar year from the Collier roll. Club dues and any capital charge follow the club’s transfer rules, which we confirm in writing before closing.

Can I put a For Sale sign on my Eagle Creek home?

No. For Sale signs visible from the common areas are not permitted; you may display one tan and green Open House sign (Eagle Creek realtor resources). We market through photography, video, the buyer-agent network and our database instead.

How do buyers get through the gate for showings?

Eagle Creek is gated (The Club). We arrange showing access with the gate in advance and accompany buyers so the club’s guest rules are met.

Do I have to disclose flood information when I sell?

Yes. Florida’s s. 689.302 requires a written flood disclosure on residential sales. Eagle Creek is Zone AE 8 ft at every sampled point (FEMA NFHL); disclose claims and assistance honestly, and attach your elevation certificate if you have one.

Should I get an elevation certificate before I list?

If one is not already on file, usually yes. Collier holds 176 certificates for Eagle Creek addresses (Collier elevation certificates); a current certificate lets your buyer quote flood insurance on day one instead of in week three of the contract.

Do I need to disclose Irma or Ian damage?

Florida law requires sellers to disclose known facts that materially affect value and are not readily observable. The club itself records Irma’s direct hit and Ian’s course flooding (Eagle Creek timeline); any water intrusion, repairs or claims on your home belong in your disclosure.

Can my buyer rent the home out?

Yes, for 30 days to six months at a time, with a club rental membership (Eagle Creek membership). Your home’s declaration may add limits. We put the rules in the listing file so investor buyers know them before they offer.

Should I rent my home instead of selling?

Some owners do, using the club’s Rental Membership Program; leases run 30 days to six months (Eagle Creek real estate). You keep paying dues and fees while you rent. We compare the net rent against a sale today before you decide.

Should I sell furnished or unfurnished?

Both sell. Seasonal buyers often want a furnished condominium; estate-home buyers usually furnish their own. List furnishings clearly and keep them out of the lender’s appraisal.

Should I renovate before selling?

The club notes a “renovation revival” in Eagle Creek’s homes (Eagle Creek realtor resources), so an unrenovated home competes with renovated ones. Targeted updates such as paint, lighting and a dated kitchen or bath usually pay; full remodels rarely return their cost before a sale. Get association approval first.

Does a golf-course view add value?

Usually. Estate homes “featuring panoramic golf-course views” are part of the club’s own pitch (Eagle Creek realtor resources). The MLS record does not price a view on its own, so we measure the premium from matched listing records when we price your home.

Can I sell my Eagle Creek home by owner?

You can, but the membership transfer, the club’s finances, the flood file and the sign rule make it harder than it looks. A listing with McGreevy and Comisar reaches agents and golf buyers across Southwest Florida and beyond, with professional media and a complete document file from day one.

Will I owe capital gains tax when I sell?

That depends on your basis, holding period and whether the home was your primary residence; federal rules allow an exclusion for a qualifying primary home. Florida has no state income tax. Talk to your tax adviser before you list, and give us the closing date that suits your tax year.

Can a foreign owner sell easily?

Yes. A foreign seller’s closing is subject to federal FIRPTA withholding unless an exemption or a reduced-withholding certificate applies, so start with a tax adviser early. We coordinate remote signing and the closing agent’s requirements.

What happens to my club account when I sell?

The club closes your member account at transfer under its own rules; your buyer joins as a golf or social member (Eagle Creek membership). Ask the club for a written statement of any balance, assessment or equity terms so the closing agent can settle them.

How do I price against an estate-home sale near $2 million?

Carefully. The $1,975,000 Estates sale in March 2026 was one of seven Estates closings, from $700,000 up (Southwest Florida MLS). Lot, view, size and renovation explain that spread. We price your estate home from the Estates sales closest to it, not from the top one.

Who is the best listing agent for an Eagle Creek home?

An agent who prices by product, explains the membership and the club’s finances, and reaches golf buyers. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, the #5 real estate team in Florida in the 2026 RealTrends rankings, and lead the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

What should I do first if I am thinking about selling?

Get a product-level valuation, confirm your membership designation with the club, pull your association’s budget and your elevation certificate, and decide timing against the season. Start with a free home valuation, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, text or call. Confidential conversations welcome.

Downloadable Documents

DocumentWhat it isOfficial link
Eagle Creek 40th-anniversary timelinethe club’s history from 1980Eagle Creek Golf and Country Club
Membership pagemembership types, cap, rentalsEagle Creek Golf and Country Club
Realtor resourcesproducts, sign rule, lightning systemEagle Creek Golf and Country Club
IRS Form 990 dataclub finances by yearProPublica Nonprofit Explorer
Florida condominium registry extractunits and recording datesFlorida DBPR
Elevation certificate, 547 Eagle Creek Drexample certificateCollier County
Elevation certificate, 720 Waterford Dr, Building Texample certificateCollier County
CCPS 2026 Accountability Briefschool gradesCollier County Public Schools
NHC Hurricane Ian reportstorm surge recordNational Hurricane Center
Florida Statutes s. 718.503condominium resale disclosure dutiesFlorida Legislature
Florida Statutes s. 720.401homeowners association disclosure summaryFlorida Legislature
Documentary stamp taxrate and filing guidanceFlorida Department of Revenue

Your Local Real Estate Experts

McGreevy and Comisar are your Eagle Creek real estate experts: Jesse has sold Southwest Florida real estate since 2004, the team has worked together since 2008, and they read the Eagle Creek record line by line, from the 1997 member buyout and the club’s IRS filings to the seven condominiums, the AE flood file and 31 MLS closings. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 · [email protected]

  • Marc Comisar: (239) 287-5873

  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC).

Our Naples office is at 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109. McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more at DomainRealtyGroup.com. Selling? Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072 or request an Eagle Creek home valuation. Buying? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 and read how we represent buyers.

Sources

  1. Eagle Creek golf, retrieved October 2026

  2. Club + Resort Business, retrieved October 2026

  3. social membership, retrieved October 2026

  4. Eagle Creek membership, retrieved October 2026

  5. IRS Form 990 data, retrieved October 2026

  6. Eagle Creek realtor resources, retrieved October 2026

  7. FEMA NFHL, retrieved October 2026

  8. Collier elevation certificates, retrieved October 2026

  9. Eagle Creek, retrieved October 2026

  10. Eagle Creek timeline, retrieved October 2026

  11. s. 718.503, retrieved October 2026

  12. s. 720.401, retrieved October 2026

  13. Florida DOR, retrieved October 2026

  14. s. 718.116, retrieved October 2026

  15. s. 720.30851, retrieved October 2026

  16. Collier CDD layer, retrieved October 2026

  17. s. 689.302, retrieved October 2026

  18. Sunbiz, retrieved October 2026

  19. DBPR registry, retrieved October 2026

  20. CCPS 2026 Accountability Brief, retrieved October 2026

  21. Eagle Creek real estate, retrieved October 2026

  22. The Club, retrieved October 2026

  23. Collier County, retrieved October 2026

  24. Collier County, retrieved October 2026

  25. National Hurricane Center, retrieved October 2026

  26. Collier PUD layer, retrieved October 2026

  27. Crystal Lake Sports Complex, retrieved October 2026

  28. address point layer, retrieved October 2026

  29. golf equity membership, retrieved October 2026

  30. Sunbiz, retrieved October 2026

  31. Collier fire district layer, retrieved October 2026

  32. Collier commission district layer, retrieved October 2026

  33. Collier floodplain management, retrieved October 2026

  34. s. 718.112, retrieved October 2026

  35. s. 553.899, retrieved October 2026

  36. weddings and special events, retrieved October 2026

  37. Eagle Creek golf course, retrieved October 2026

  38. hole 7, retrieved October 2026

  39. hole 11, retrieved October 2026

  40. hole 18, retrieved October 2026

  41. FSGA results, retrieved October 2026

  42. 1, retrieved October 2026

  43. 2, retrieved October 2026

  44. 3, retrieved October 2026

  45. 4, retrieved October 2026

  46. 5, retrieved October 2026

  47. 6, retrieved October 2026

  48. 8, retrieved October 2026

  49. 9, retrieved October 2026

  50. 10, retrieved October 2026

  51. 12, retrieved October 2026

  52. 13, retrieved October 2026

  53. 14, retrieved October 2026

  54. 15, retrieved October 2026

  55. 16, retrieved October 2026

  56. 17, retrieved October 2026

  57. Rookery Bay, retrieved October 2026

  58. Collier GIS services, retrieved October 2026

  59. Collier basins layer, retrieved October 2026

  60. Collier FEMA24 layer, retrieved October 2026

  61. FEMA preliminary NFHL, retrieved October 2026

  62. Collier County news release, retrieved October 2026

  63. Collier evacuation zones, retrieved October 2026

  64. Know Your Zone, retrieved October 2026

  65. Collier CHHA layer, retrieved October 2026

  66. Citizens release, retrieved October 2026

  67. Florida OIR, retrieved October 2026

  68. Manatee Elementary, retrieved October 2026

  69. Manatee Middle, retrieved October 2026

  70. Lely High, retrieved October 2026

  71. CCPS address lookup, retrieved October 2026

  72. Physicians Regional, retrieved October 2026

  73. FDOT project 425843-2, retrieved October 2026

  74. Wentworth Estates CDD, retrieved October 2026