Updated October 2026
Find out what your Windstar on Naples Bay home is worth from McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Valuations built village by village on floor plan, water, flood zone and fees. Call (239) 898-6072.
Updated October 2026 · Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty
If you own a home in Windstar on Naples Bay, the honest answer to what it is worth starts with your village, your floor plan, your flood elevation and your fee stack, not with the community. Windstar on Naples Bay is a gated golf and boating community of 618 homes in 16 villages on the east shore of Naples Bay in Naples, Florida, ZIP 34112, and the Southwest Florida MLS shows a 12-month median of $1,200,000 built from 52 sales that ran from $350,000 to $6,750,000. The full community picture, from the club and the Keewaydin Island beach to the schools and the Bayshore pipeline, lives on our Windstar on Naples Bay community guide. This page does one job: it shows how a Windstar home is valued, village by village, from MLS closings and public records, and it gives you two ways to get your own number. Use the Home Valuation form at the top of this page, get your free Windstar on Naples Bay home valuation, or call Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072.
A Windstar on Naples Bay home is worth what its own village, product, floor plan, flood elevation and association layer support, not what a community average says. In the 12 months to October 13, 2026 the Southwest Florida MLS recorded 52 closings here, from $350,000 to $6,750,000, at a $1,200,000 median, so no single figure describes your address.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026; Florida DOR 2026 preliminary roll, read October 2026)
Read the two ends of that range correctly before you read any online estimate. The $350,000 sale was a Windward Cay condominium on March 17, 2026, in a 48-unit village built in phases from 1984 to 2004, and the $6,750,000 sale was an estate on the Island at Southpointe on June 16, 2026, in a ten-home village inside the City of Naples. Those two homes share a gate, a master association and a ZIP code, and almost nothing a pricing model can use.
We built this page the way we build a written valuation. We tracked the 52 Windstar on Naples Bay closings in the Southwest Florida MLS, then read them beside the Florida Department of Revenue 2026 preliminary tax roll for Collier County, which carries 618 homes in 16 villages: 9 condominium villages with 428 units and 7 homeowners-association villages with 190 homes, a split the DBPR condominium extract confirms. One of the 52 closings, a $905,000 Spinnaker Pointe sale on February 27, 2026, is a Sold Data Entry record, a sale entered into the MLS after it closed; it is a real recorded sale, so it counts in the count, the median, the range and the volume.
Windstar on Naples Bay is three products behind one gate. Condominiums closed 36 times in the 12 months at a $1,096,250 median, from the entry buildings of Compass Point South (36-month median $503,500) and Spinnaker Pointe (24-month median $630,000) to the bayfront residences of Admirals Watch (three sales from $2,375,000 to $3,625,000). Attached villas at Somerset at Windstar and Leeward Cay closed 8 times, from $660,000 to $1,300,000 (a $1,100,000 median across 13 sales over 24 months). Detached single-family homes in Ketch Cay, Clipper Cove, Harrington Sound, Spyglass Pointe and the Island at Southpointe closed 8 times, from $1,375,000 to $6,750,000 (a $1,600,000 median across 22 sales over 24 months). Those segment figures are our grouping of the MLS rows by each village’s recorded form of ownership.
Take the 16 villages one at a time and the community median dissolves. No village reached 10 sales in the 12-month window, the longer-window medians of the six villages that reach 10 sales ran from $503,500 at Compass Point South (36 months) to $1,700,000 at Yacht Harbour Cove (36 months), and three villages had a single sale each. A Spinnaker Pointe carriage home and a Somerset at Windstar villa are both “Windstar”, yet their 24-month medians sat $465,000 apart ($630,000 against $1,095,000). A Windstar valuation therefore starts by naming your village and your product, then narrows to your floor plan, your elevation certificate, your water and your association’s finances before a single comparable is chosen.
We lay three records over one another. The Southwest Florida MLS gives us brokered closings, their dates and their prices. The public record gives us the county roll, the village’s living-area range, its year built and its tax code, along with the state’s condominium filings. The building record gives us the flood zone on FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer, the elevation certificate on file with Collier County, the master and village fees and, for a condominium, the milestone and reserve-study status your buyer will ask for. Then Marc Comisar walks the home, because roof age, impact glass, the kitchen, the view across the course or the basin, and the condition of a lanai are the variables no record captures.
The three Windstar segments move differently, so we price them apart. Condominiums were about seven in ten of the 52 closings and well over half of the $70,378,500 in volume, which matches the community’s makeup: 428 of its 618 homes are condominium units.
Segment, 12 months to October 13, 2026 | Villages | Closings | Median sold | Low to high | Volume |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
All Windstar on Naples Bay | 15 of 16 villages with a sale | 52 | $1,200,000 | $350,000 to $6,750,000 | $70,378,500 |
Condominiums | Regatta Landing, Marina Cove, Spinnaker Pointe, Yacht Harbour Cove, Windward Cay, Admirals Watch, Compass Point South, Northstar | 36 | $1,096,250 | $350,000 to $3,625,000 | $43,331,500 |
Attached villas (HOA) | Somerset at Windstar, Leeward Cay | 8 | no median (fewer than 10 sales) | $660,000 to $1,300,000 | $8,692,000 |
Detached single-family (HOA) | Ketch Cay, Clipper Cove, Harrington Sound, Spyglass Pointe, Island at Southpointe | 8 | no median (fewer than 10 sales) | $1,375,000 to $6,750,000 | $18,355,000 |
Source: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026, grouped by McGreevy and Comisar from the MLS rows. By segment, the condominiums had a median of 60 days on market, a median sale-to-list ratio (sold price over final list price) of 94.7% and a median of $465 a square foot, with 15 active listings. The villa and detached groups have fewer than 10 sales in the 12 months, so their medians come from 24 months: villas 21 days on market, 98.1% sale-to-list and $509 a square foot (13 sales), detached homes 38 days, 92.4% and $617 (22 sales); neither has an active listing at the October 13, 2026 pull. The condominium median is the mean of the middle pair ($1,090,500 and $1,102,000), because 36 is an even count.
A free Windstar on Naples Bay home valuation from McGreevy and Comisar starts with the Home Valuation form at the top of this page or a call to Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072. The form takes about a minute, costs nothing and carries no obligation, and you receive a written opinion of value built from sales in your own village.
The form asks for your address, a line about condition and how to reach you. For a condominium, the unit number matters most, because it tells us your building, your floor and whether you face the course, a lake, the marina basin or the bay. For a villa or a single-family home, the street address tells us your village, your lot and, at the Southpointe end, whether you sit on the water. You do not need to know your flood zone, your millage code or your association’s reserve status; we pull those from the records.
You receive a written opinion of value for your address, built from the village’s MLS closings and the closest comparable product elsewhere in Windstar, adjusted for time, with every source named. Beside it you receive the carrying-cost picture your buyer will underwrite: the master assessment, the village or condominium layer, the property tax code your home sits in, the flood file and, for a condominium, the milestone and structural integrity reserve study status. Last comes a plain recommendation on list price and timing, including the case for waiting if the evidence says wait.
Call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072 or email [email protected]. Marc Comisar is at (239) 287-5873. Many Windstar valuations are done for owners who are not in Naples that week, and you can get your free Windstar on Naples Bay home valuation from anywhere; we arrange the walk-through with your property manager, your association or a neighbor, and the gate registration that goes with it.
McGreevy and Comisar should value your Windstar on Naples Bay home because we build every number from MLS closings and public records, village by village, we read the flood, association and condominium records before we price, and we have been Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. In a community of 16 separately governed villages, method decides the outcome.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026; Domain Realty brokerage figures per the Southwest Florida MLS pulled October 5, 2026)
McGreevy and Comisar are the #5 real estate team in Florida in the 2026 RealTrends rankings. As the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate, and Jesse and Marc alone have over $900 million in sales inside that number. Jesse McGreevy has worked in Southwest Florida real estate since 2004, and he and Marc Comisar launched the team in 2008.
Domain Realty, our brokerage, closed 658 transaction sides in Naples in the 60 months to October 5, 2026, $521.5 million in volume counted by side, per the Southwest Florida MLS pulled that day.
If you are comparing agents before you choose who values your home, our guide to the best real estate agents in Naples sets the teams side by side on the public record: reviews, license history and published production.
You get Jesse and Marc, not an assistant with a template. Jesse McGreevy builds the pricing analysis and assembles the master association, village association, flood and tax paperwork your buyer will ask for. Marc Comisar walks the home and judges floor plan, view and condition against what is actually selling inside the Windstar gates and along the Naples Bay shore, which is what lets a seasonal owner get a real opinion of value without flying down. Read more on the about McGreevy and Comisar page.
Windstar on Naples Bay turned over 52 times in 12 months across 618 homes, and the sales were spread thin: Regatta Landing led with 9, Marina Cove had 6, three villages had 5, and Harrington Sound, Spyglass Pointe and the Island at Southpointe had one sale each, while Morningstar had none. At that pace your listing competes with the one or two homes of your own village for sale at the same time, and with the buyer’s memory of the last one that closed. Few homes in any one Windstar village come up for sale in a given year, so the next owner who sells should have the number right on the first day.
This page answers what your home is worth. If you have decided to sell and want the listing plan, read our guide to selling your home in Windstar on Naples Bay. If you are buying inside the same gates, start with buying a home in Windstar on Naples Bay. For a home elsewhere in the city, our Naples home valuation page covers the wider market, and for the club, the beach, the schools and the history, go back to the Windstar on Naples Bay community guide.
Our Windstar on Naples Bay valuation beats an online automated estimate because a model cannot see the things that separate one Windstar address from the next: the village, the association layer, the tax code, the elevation certificate and the water. An online estimate is a model; a McGreevy and Comisar valuation is a person reading your village’s record and walking your home.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026; Florida DOR 2026 preliminary roll)
A model sees a square footage, a bedroom count and a recent-sale pattern. It cannot see that a Regatta Landing coach home pays 13.3696 mills while an Admirals Watch condominium pays 8.9752, because the two sit in different tax districts, or that Regatta Landing’s master assessment is collected inside its condominium budget while other villages are billed separately. It cannot read your elevation certificate, which on the Windstar certificates we read puts a Spyglass Pointe lowest floor 0.7 feet below today’s base flood elevation, a Harrington Sound lowest floor 1.5 feet above it, and Regatta Landing’s living levels 4.8 to 5.5 feet above it. It cannot tell a shaded Zone X coach home at Marina Cove from a Zone AE home next door. In a market where 12-month sales ran from $350,000 to $6,750,000, a model that learns from whatever sold last can swing toward the last closing.
The gap is widest where the market is thinnest. Harrington Sound, Spyglass Pointe and the Island at Southpointe recorded one sale each in the 12 months, Northstar recorded two and Morningstar none. In those villages a model has almost nothing to learn from, and a human has to choose which comparable product elsewhere in Windstar is close enough, and how far to adjust it for the village’s fees, tax code and flood zone. We would rather tell you “the evidence supports a range, and here is why” than hand you a single figure that looks precise and is not.
The 2026 preliminary county just value on your tax notice is an appraisal figure for tax purposes, not a sale price. In every Windstar village with 10 or more sales in a 24 or 36-month window, the median MLS sale ran above the median 2026 preliminary just value on the Florida DOR 2026 roll:
Village | Median sale (MLS, window and sales) | Median 2026 preliminary just value (county roll) |
|---|---|---|
Admirals Watch | no median (7 sales in 36 months) | $1,846,545 |
Yacht Harbour Cove | $1,700,000 (36 months, 11 sales) | $1,487,970 |
Ketch Cay | no median (7 sales in 36 months) | $990,008 |
Clipper Cove | no median (7 sales in 36 months) | $1,199,956 |
Regatta Landing | $1,310,000 (24 months, 16 sales) | $1,043,725 |
Leeward Cay | no median (4 sales in 36 months) | $861,125 |
Somerset at Windstar | $1,095,000 (24 months, 10 sales) | $872,400 |
Windward Cay | no median (9 sales in 36 months) | $568,856 |
Marina Cove | $646,000 (24 months, 12 sales) | $532,830 |
Spinnaker Pointe | $630,000 (24 months, 11 sales) | $481,040 |
Compass Point South | $503,500 (36 months, 14 sales) | $410,990 |
Source: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2023 to October 13, 2026 (36 months) and October 13, 2024 to October 13, 2026 (24 months) as labeled; Florida DOR 2026 preliminary roll, read October 10, 2026. Villages with fewer than 10 sales in those windows show their just value with no sold median. The comparison is our arithmetic on the two records; a just value and a sale price measure different things, which is the point.
We add four things a model cannot. First, we match the home: village, product, floor plan, water and renovation. Second, we read the carrying costs a buyer underwrites, from the $4,130 master assessment for 2025 to the village fee and the tax code. Third, we test the number against what is listed and pending in your village today (15 active and 5 pending across Windstar at the October 13, 2026 pull), not only against the past. Fourth, we tell you the cost of being wrong in either direction, because at a $1,096,250 condominium median and a $1,600,000 detached single-family median over 24 months, a few percent either way is real money.
These are the Windstar on Naples Bay valuation facts that decide most prices, each drawn from the Southwest Florida MLS, the Florida DOR 2026 preliminary roll, or the master association, county, state and FEMA records, and each repeated with its source further down this page. Read them before you read any online estimate.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026)
We value a Windstar on Naples Bay home by narrowing the product and widening the evidence: same village, same floor plan and same water for the home itself, then the village’s own sales, then the closest comparable product elsewhere inside the gates, tested against what is listed now and against the fee, tax and flood picture a buyer will underwrite.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026; Florida DOR 2026 preliminary roll; DBPR condominium extract; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer)
Every Windstar home belongs to the master association, and most also belong to a village association. Nine villages are condominiums under chapter 718 of the Florida Statutes and seven are homeowners associations under chapter 720, per the DBPR condominium extract and the county roll. That legal form decides who insures the roof, what the buyer’s lender asks for and which statute governs your disclosure. The names can mislead: the Southwest Florida MLS files the ten Island at Southpointe estates as “Southpointe Yacht Club”, lists Northstar as “Northstar Villas”, and Windward Cay is recorded as The Windstar Condominium Section One. We confirm the village from the recorded documents before we choose a single comparable.
Windstar’s 618 homes sit under four zoning regimes, counted from the Collier County zoning layer and the DOR roll: 401 homes in ten villages under the Windstar PUD, Ordinance 93-23; 100 homes at Marina Cove and Yacht Harbour Cove under the Southpointe Yacht Club PUD, Ordinance 88-82; 26 homes at Admirals Watch and the Island at Southpointe inside the City of Naples; and 91 homes at Harrington Sound and Regatta Landing on county multifamily zoning. The regime lines up with the tax code on the bill, and the tax code is part of the buyer’s annual cost, so it is part of the price.
Inside one village, size and layout move price. The 2026 preliminary roll gives each village’s living-area range, and it is wide in places: Clipper Cove runs 2,506 to 7,000 square feet on the roll, Harrington Sound 3,090 to 14,256, and the Island at Southpointe 3,723 to 17,120, while Spinnaker Pointe stays within 1,832 to 2,288 and Northstar within 2,040 to 2,140. Where a village is uniform, its own sales are close comparables; where it is not, we match the plan, not the address. The median sold price per square foot for Windstar is $493 for the 12 months to October 13, 2026, and we never apply a community figure to a single home.
A bay frontage, a marina-basin position, a lake or a fairway view and a boat slip are different products. Yacht Harbour Cove’s 28 coach homes sit on the Southpointe marina basin, Admirals Watch’s 16 condominiums share eight boat slips on the bay, and many of the ten Island at Southpointe homes have private docks on the access channel, per the master association’s village pages. Southpointe Marina slips and Regatta Landing dock slips are held separately from the homes and transfer on their own documents, so we value a slip that conveys as its own line and confirm the transfer path before it appears in a price.
Windstar was built in waves: the first Windward Cay units in 1984, the original Windstar Development Company villages through 1990, a second wave of condominiums, carriage homes and single-family enclaves from 1992 to 2004, and Regatta Landing’s 64 coach homes from 2016 to 2021, per the DOR 2026 roll. Most of that construction predates the first statewide Florida Building Code, which took effect on March 1, 2002, so roof age, impact glass and the wind mitigation report carry real weight in a buyer’s insurance quote. We compare original homes to original homes and renovated homes to renovated homes.
Windstar on Naples Bay closed 52 sales in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, spread across 15 villages, so most villages saw only a handful. A correctly priced listing in a thin village wins; a hopeful one waits. If you are selling, get your free Windstar on Naples Bay home valuation, read our plan for selling your home in Windstar on Naples Bay or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, text or call, confidential conversations welcome. If you are buying, call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or read buying a home in Windstar on Naples Bay and how we represent buyers.
Before we price a Windstar on Naples Bay home we read the records a buyer’s lender, insurer and closing agent will read: the FEMA flood zone and the elevation certificate, the condominium milestone and reserve-study status, the master and village fee layers, the leasing and pet rules, and the club and slip documents that may or may not travel with the home.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer and Collier County layers queried October 10, 2026; master association documents read October 2026)
FEMA’s effective maps for Windstar, panels 12021C0581J and 12021C0582J, both effective February 8, 2024, put 58 of 68 sampled address points in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 8 or 9 feet NAVD88 and 10 in shaded Zone X, with none in Zone VE. The zone is the map’s expectation; the elevation certificate on the county’s elevation certificate layer is how high the house actually sits. A lowest floor above the base flood elevation is a selling point we put in front of buyers; one below it is a negotiating point we prepare for. The flood section below has the village table.
Florida’s milestone inspection law, section 553.899, and the structural integrity reserve study rule in section 718.112 apply to condominium buildings of three habitable stories or more. At Windstar most condominium buildings are one or two stories. The county’s milestone inspection layer lists Windward Cay buildings 4450, 4600 and 4650 Yacht Harbor Drive and Compass Point South’s four buildings as “Milestone Completed, Cycle Completed”, next inspection year 2033. For a condominium listing we request the study, the milestone summary and the budget from the association before we set a price.
Every Windstar home pays the same master assessment, $4,130 for 2025, billed at $1,032.50 a quarter, per the master association’s 2025 Annual Meeting outline dated March 31, 2025. Above it sits the village layer, which only Compass Point South has published ($1,968 a quarter in 2021, including its master share), and below it the property tax at one of three millage rates. The 2026 master figure sits in the owner-only financials and on the master estoppel certificate, and village fees sit in each association’s budget, so we read your estoppel figures before we price rather than quoting a fee we have not seen.
Leasing rules decide who your buyer can be. The master declaration, as amended in 2020, allows leases of at least 30 days or one calendar month and no more than one year, up to three a calendar year, so nightly and weekly rentals are outside the covenant everywhere in Windstar. Regatta Landing is tighter, at no more than two leases in any 12 months, and Compass Point South requires board approval of tenants and bars tenant pets, per their published documents. Pet limits come from the villages: Compass Point South allows one dog or cat of up to 25 pounds, and Regatta Landing two cats or dogs each under 60 pounds. For the other villages, the Declaration and Rules of that village govern, and we read them before we price.
A Windstar Club membership does not come with a house, a Southpointe Marina slip is a separate deeded parcel, and a Regatta Landing slip moves by Dock Slip Certificate. Each one is a separate conversation with a separate entity, and each can change what a particular buyer will pay. We confirm in writing what conveys, what the buyer must apply for, and what fees follow, so the price on the listing describes what the buyer actually receives.
Windstar on Naples Bay homes are worth very different amounts by village. On the Southwest Florida MLS the medians of the six villages with 10 or more sales in a 24 or 36-month window ran from $503,500 at Compass Point South and $630,000 at Spinnaker Pointe to $1,310,000 at Regatta Landing and $1,700,000 at Yacht Harbour Cove, Admirals Watch’s three 12-month sales ran from $2,375,000 to $3,625,000, and three villages had a single sale each, too thin to read as a market rate.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026; Florida DOR 2026 preliminary roll, read October 10, 2026)
Under 10 closings a median is not a market, and no Windstar village reached 10 in the window, so below each village we list the sales themselves, by date and price, as the MLS recorded them. Medians are shown only where a village had 10 or more sales in the window named, which means the 24 or 36-month window for the villages that reach it. Living area and just value come from the 2026 preliminary roll and are given as minimum, median and maximum; a just value is an appraisal figure for tax purposes, not a sale price.
Village | Product | Homes | Built | 12-month sales | Median or sales | Sampled flood zone |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Regatta Landing | Coach-home condominium | 64 | 2016 to 2021 | 9 | $1,090,500 to $1,849,000 (24 months: 16 sales, median $1,310,000) | AE, BFE 9 |
Marina Cove | Coach-home condominium | 72 | 1997 to 1999 | 6 | $507,500 to $745,000 (24 months: 12 sales, median $646,000) | 7 of 8 points shaded X |
Somerset at Windstar | Duplex villas (HOA) | 50 | 1989 to 1990 | 5 | $660,000 to $1,300,000 (24 months: 10 sales, median $1,095,000) | AE 9 |
Spinnaker Pointe | Carriage-home condominium | 88 | 1994 to 1995 | 5 | $525,000 to $905,000 (24 months: 11 sales, median $630,000) | AE 9 |
Yacht Harbour Cove | Marina-basin coach homes | 28 | 1996 to 1999 | 5 | $1,200,000 to $2,250,000 (36 months: 11 sales, median $1,700,000) | AE 8 |
Windward Cay | Two- and three-story condominium | 48 | 1984 to 2004 | 4 | $350,000 to $1,075,000 | AE 8 and 9 |
Admirals Watch | Bayfront condominium, City of Naples | 16 | 1996 to 2001 | 3 | $2,375,000 to $3,625,000 | AE 8 to 9 |
Ketch Cay | Courtyard homes and villas (HOA) | 42 | 1994 to 2000 | 3 | $1,375,000 to $1,750,000 | AE 8 |
Leeward Cay | Attached villas (HOA) | 16 | 1987 to 1989 | 3 | $800,000 to $1,270,000 | not probed; neighbors AE 8 to 9 |
Clipper Cove | Single-family pool homes (HOA) | 35 | 1996 to 1999 | 2 | $1,480,000 and $1,625,000 | AE 9 |
Compass Point South | Three-story condominium | 72 | 1992 to 1995 | 2 | $430,000 and $508,000 (36 months: 14 sales, median $503,500) | AE 9 |
Northstar | Condominium villas with pools | 16 | 1986 to 1988 | 2 | $1,325,000 and $1,375,000 | 3 AE, 1 shaded X |
Harrington Sound | Single-family estates (HOA) | 27 | 1993 to 2009 | 1 | one sale, at $2,075,000 | AE 8 |
Spyglass Pointe | Courtyard pool homes (HOA) | 10 | 1995 to 2000 | 1 | one sale, at $1,775,000 | AE 9 |
Island at Southpointe | Waterfront estates, City of Naples | 10 | 1995 to 2012 | 1 | one sale, at $6,750,000 | AE 8 to 9 |
Morningstar | Condominium | 24 | 1986 to 1988 | 0 | no closed sale in the window | 2 AE 8, 1 shaded X |
Total | 618 | 1984 to 2021 | 52 | $1,200,000 median | 58 of 68 points AE |
Source: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026; homes and years built from the Florida DOR 2026 preliminary roll; flood zones from FEMA NFHL point queries on October 10, 2026, panels 12021C0581J and 12021C0582J, effective February 8, 2024.
Regatta Landing is 64 two-story coach-home condominiums built 2016 to 2021 on Breakwater Way, Windward Ct and Mooring Stay Way along Haldeman Creek, with living area of 2,348 / 3,018 / 3,854 square feet and a 2026 preliminary just value of $861,800 / $1,043,725 / $1,271,200. Its 9 sales were October 21, 2025 at $1,200,000; January 8, 2026 at $1,700,000; February 12, 2026 at $1,795,000; April 13, 2026 at $1,500,000; April 23, 2026 at $1,849,000; June 4, 2026 at $1,200,000; July 7, 2026 at $1,090,500; August 17, 2026 at $1,150,000; and August 25, 2026 at $1,102,000. Nine is under 10, so no 12-month median is shown; over 24 months its 16 sales had a median of $1,310,000. Regatta pays tax code 0111 (13.3696 mills on the 2026 certified roll) and carries the master assessment inside its own budget, per its declaration. The two published elevation certificates put the living level at 13.8 and 14.5 feet NAVD88 against a base flood elevation of 9, a strong card for a buyer’s flood quote. A dedicated Regatta Landing neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details.
Marina Cove is 72 coach-home condominiums built 1997 to 1999 on Marina Cove Dr, Yacht Harbor Dr and Yacht Harbor Cir inside the Southpointe Yacht Club PUD, with living area of 1,561 / 1,822 / 3,522 square feet and a just value of $433,665 / $532,830 / $597,085. Its 6 sales were October 21, 2025 at $745,000; November 21, 2025 at $638,500; January 13, 2026 at $652,000; June 23, 2026 at $507,500; June 24, 2026 at $715,000; and June 30, 2026 at $674,000, the narrowest spread of any village with more than three sales; over 24 months its 12 sales had a median of $646,000. That makes Marina Cove the easiest Windstar village to price from comparables. Seven of its eight sampled points are shaded Zone X, outside the federal mandatory-purchase rule, a fact we put in front of every buyer. A dedicated Marina Cove neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details.
Spinnaker Pointe is 88 carriage-home condominiums in 22 four-unit buildings on Windjammer Cir, built 1994 to 1995, with living area of 1,832 / 2,060 / 2,288 square feet and a just value of $418,040 / $481,040 / $559,040. Its 5 sales were November 24, 2025 at $630,000; December 24, 2025 at $525,000; February 27, 2026 at $905,000 (the Sold Data Entry record); April 3, 2026 at $645,000; and June 9, 2026 at $660,000; over 24 months its 11 sales had a median of $630,000. Spinnaker Pointe has its own clubhouse, heated pool and spa and two lighted tennis courts, per the master association’s Spinnaker Pointe page. Because its floor plans sit in a narrow size band, a Spinnaker Pointe valuation turns on condition, position and the building’s association record. A dedicated Spinnaker Pointe neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details.
Somerset at Windstar is 50 one- and two-story duplex villas on Paget Cir, built 1989 to 1990 under a homeowners association, with living area of 1,833 / 2,307 / 2,817 square feet and a just value of $672,385 / $872,400 / $1,053,475. Its 5 sales were December 11, 2025 at $1,125,000; March 31, 2026 at $660,000; April 23, 2026 at $1,300,000; April 28, 2026 at $1,100,000; and May 27, 2026 at $1,300,000; over 24 months its 10 sales had a median of $1,095,000. The $660,000 to $1,300,000 spread inside one village of similar-age villas is the renovation premium at work, which is why we walk a Somerset home before we price it. The elevation certificate for 2213 to 2217 Paget Cir records a lowest floor of 9.12 feet NAVD88, 0.12 feet above the 2024 base flood elevation. A dedicated Somerset at Windstar neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details.
Yacht Harbour Cove is 28 coach-home condominiums on the Southpointe marina basin, 20 in phase I on Gulfstar Dr S and 8 in phase II on Yacht Harbor Cir, built 1996 to 1999, with living area of 2,437 / 2,699 / 2,961 square feet and a just value of $1,331,610 / $1,487,970 / $1,644,330. Its 5 sales were October 31, 2025 at $1,700,000; April 8, 2026 at $1,300,000; June 30, 2026 at $1,610,000; June 30, 2026 at $2,250,000; and July 10, 2026 at $1,200,000; over 36 months its 11 sales had a median of $1,700,000. Five sales from 28 homes is a brisk pace for a village this size, and the $2,250,000 sale was one of Windstar’s six sales at $2,000,000 or more. Its three sampled points are Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 8 feet, unlike most of neighboring Marina Cove. A dedicated Yacht Harbour Cove neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details.
Windward Cay is 48 two- and three-story condominium homes on Yacht Harbor Dr, recorded as The Windstar Condominium Section One, built in phases from 1984 to 2004, with living area of 1,589 / 1,890 / 2,250 square feet and a just value of $441,085 / $568,856 / $876,500. Its 4 sales were February 12, 2026 at $1,075,000; March 17, 2026 at $350,000; March 17, 2026 at $665,000; and April 17, 2026 at $725,000. The $350,000 to $1,075,000 spread follows the build phases: 14 units from 1984 to 1987, a 16-unit building in 1998 and three six-unit buildings in 2003 and 2004 differ in size, floor and view. Buildings 4450, 4600 and 4650 show “Milestone Completed, Cycle Completed” on the county layer. A dedicated Windward Cay neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details.
Admirals Watch is 16 luxury condominiums at 1500 to 1650 Star Point Ln on the bay, built 1996 to 2001, with private elevators, two- and three-car garages, a private pool and eight boat slips, per the master association’s Admirals Watch page. Living area runs 2,550 / 2,619 / 5,279 square feet and just value $1,595,500 / $1,846,545 / $3,310,190. Its 3 sales were November 7, 2025 at $3,625,000; November 14, 2025 at $2,935,000; and January 21, 2026 at $2,375,000, and the $3,625,000 sale was the highest condominium price in Windstar in the window. Admirals Watch lies inside the City of Naples, so it pays 8.9752 mills on the 2026 certified roll, the lowest of Windstar’s three rates. A dedicated Admirals Watch neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details.
Clipper Cove is 35 single-family pool homes on Clipper Cove Dr and Clipper Ln, built 1996 to 1999, with living area of 2,506 / 3,341 / 7,000 square feet on the roll and a just value of $1,043,509 / $1,199,956 / $1,858,942; the master association’s Clipper Cove page describes homes of 2,100 to 3,000 square feet, and the county figure can include additions. Its 2 sales were December 15, 2025 at $1,480,000 and March 30, 2026 at $1,625,000. Two closings $145,000 apart are a pair of comparables, not a market rate; over 24 months its 7 sales ran from $1,260,000 to $1,775,000. A dedicated Clipper Cove neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details.
Compass Point South is 72 condominiums in four three-story buildings with elevators and covered parking on Haldeman Creek Dr, built 1992 to 1995, with living area of 1,347 / 1,414 / 1,902 square feet and a just value of $375,990 / $410,990 / $555,070. Its 2 sales were December 23, 2025 at $508,000 and May 11, 2026 at $430,000; over 36 months its 14 sales had a median of $503,500, the lowest of any Windstar village with 10 or more sales in that window. Because the buildings are three stories, Compass Point South carries Florida’s milestone and reserve-study duties, and it has posted its Structural Integrity Reserve Study dated May 29, 2024, which sets a minimum 2025 reserve funding of $118,650. A seller with that study in hand answers the first question a condominium buyer asks. A dedicated Compass Point South neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details.
Ketch Cay is 42 single-family courtyard homes and villas on York Island Dr, Bollard Ct and Christina Ct, built 1994 to 2000, with living area of 2,185 / 2,613 / 3,103 square feet and a just value of $774,975 / $990,008 / $2,023,393. Its 3 sales were December 18, 2025 at $1,375,000; May 26, 2026 at $1,525,000; and June 26, 2026 at $1,750,000, and each sale was higher than the one before it. The elevation certificate for 1769 York Island Dr records a lowest floor of 8.7 feet NAVD88, 0.7 feet above the 2024 base flood elevation of 8. A dedicated Ketch Cay neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details.
Leeward Cay is 16 attached villas on Windstar Tract L along Yacht Harbor Dr, built 1987 to 1989 under a homeowners association, with living area of 2,125 / 2,125 / 2,585 square feet and a just value of $823,125 / $861,125 / $1,052,825. Its 3 sales were December 10, 2025 at $800,000; April 28, 2026 at $1,270,000; and June 16, 2026 at $1,137,000. The $800,000 closing was one of only two Windstar sales between $750,000 and $999,999 in the window, which shows how much condition moves a villa price here. The elevation certificate for 4403 Yacht Harbor Dr, in the Leeward Cay range, records a lowest floor of 8.5 feet NAVD88, 0.5 feet below the nearest sampled base flood elevation of 9. A dedicated Somerset at Windstar neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details. That page will also cover Leeward Cay.
Northstar is 16 condominium villas with private pools on the even side of Haldeman Creek Dr, built 1986 to 1988 by the original Windstar Development Company, with living area of 2,040 / 2,140 / 2,140 square feet and a just value of $870,520 / $906,820 / $916,820. Its two sales were December 10, 2025 at $1,325,000 and May 22, 2026 at $1,375,000, too thin to read as a market rate, though two close sales of near-identical floor plans are a useful pair of comparables. The elevation certificate for 3660 Haldeman Creek Dr records a lowest floor of 8.80 feet NAVD88, 0.8 feet above the nearest sampled base flood elevation of 8.
Harrington Sound is 27 single-family estates on Lighthouse Ln, built 1993 to 2009 on county multifamily zoning outside the Windstar PUD, with living area of 3,090 / 4,137 / 14,256 square feet, the largest median of any village, and a just value of $1,577,268 / $1,844,335 / $2,823,266. Its one sale in the window was January 28, 2026 at $2,075,000, too thin to read as a market rate. A Harrington Sound valuation leans on the home itself, its lot, its elevation against the 2024 base flood elevation of 8 feet, and the wider top of the Windstar market. The 2022 certificate for 4500 Lighthouse Ln records a lowest floor of 9.5 feet NAVD88, 1.5 feet above that elevation. A dedicated Harrington Sound neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details.
Spyglass Pointe is ten courtyard pool homes on Lookout Ln along the 15th to 17th holes and Haldeman Creek, built 1995 to 2000, with living area of 2,628 / 3,158 / 5,816 square feet and a just value of $1,126,729 / $1,462,728 / $1,842,037. Its one sale in the window was February 12, 2026 at $1,775,000, too thin to read as a market rate. The 2021 elevation certificate for 3292 Lookout Ln records a lowest floor of 8.3 feet NAVD88, 0.7 feet below the 2024 base flood elevation of 9, after sitting above the 2012 map’s 7 feet, which is exactly the kind of fact a buyer’s insurance agent will price. A dedicated Harrington Sound neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details. That page will also cover Spyglass Pointe.
The Island at Southpointe is ten waterfront estates on Gulfstar Dr S, on a small island in the Southpointe marina basin reached over a gated stone bridge, built 1995 to 2012 inside the City of Naples, with living area of 3,723 / 5,413 / 17,120 square feet and a just value of $2,998,548 / $3,700,757 / $6,883,100, the highest in Windstar. Its one sale in the window was June 16, 2026 at $6,750,000, the highest price in Windstar and too thin to read as a market rate on its own. The MLS files these homes as “Southpointe Yacht Club”, so a search by the village name misses them. A dedicated Harrington Sound neighborhood page is coming, with its own market snapshot and its association details. That page will also cover the Island at Southpointe.
Morningstar is 24 Bermuda-style condominium homes of three bedrooms and two baths on the odd side of Haldeman Creek Dr, built 1986 to 1988, with living area of 1,324 / 1,661 / 1,880 square feet and a just value of $380,340 / $481,385 / $548,800. It recorded no closed sale in the 12 months to October 13, 2026. A Morningstar valuation therefore leans on the closest comparable condominium product on Haldeman Creek Drive, Compass Point South and Northstar, adjusted for size, building form and the village’s own fees, and on the wider window of Morningstar’s own sales history that comes with a written valuation.
Windstar on Naples Bay condominiums sold at a $1,096,250 median across 36 closings in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, while attached villas (8 closings, $660,000 to $1,300,000) and detached single-family homes (8 closings, $1,375,000 to $6,750,000) were too few for a 12-month median; over 24 months their medians were $1,100,000 across 13 sales and $1,600,000 across 22, per our grouping of Southwest Florida MLS rows. The price bands show two bodies of sales and a thin middle.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026)
Price band, 12 months to October 13, 2026 | Closed sales |
|---|---|
Under $500,000 | 2 |
$500,000 to $749,999 | 14 |
$750,000 to $999,999 | 2 |
$1,000,000 to $1,499,999 | 18 |
$1,500,000 to $1,999,999 | 10 |
$2,000,000 to $2,999,999 | 4 |
$3,000,000 and up | 2 |
Total | 52 |
Source: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026.
Fourteen sales landed between $500,000 and $749,999, mostly the entry condominiums of Marina Cove, Spinnaker Pointe and Windward Cay. Eighteen landed between $1,000,000 and $1,499,999, mostly Regatta Landing, Somerset, Leeward Cay, Northstar and Yacht Harbour Cove. Only two sales fell between $750,000 and $999,999: the $905,000 Spinnaker Pointe record and the $800,000 Leeward Cay villa.
A seller whose home prices into the $750,000 to $999,999 gap has few direct comparables, and the buyer pool arrives from both directions: buyers stretching up from the entry condominiums and buyers trimming down from the villa and coach-home villages. The first list price decides which of those buyers sees the listing. We price a home in the gap from its own product’s closest sales and say plainly which side of the gap the evidence supports.
Village | Sale price | Closed |
|---|---|---|
Island at Southpointe | $6,750,000 | June 16, 2026 |
Admirals Watch | $3,625,000 | November 7, 2025 |
Admirals Watch | $2,935,000 | November 14, 2025 |
Admirals Watch | $2,375,000 | January 21, 2026 |
Yacht Harbour Cove | $2,250,000 | June 30, 2026 |
Harrington Sound | $2,075,000 | January 28, 2026 |
Source: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026.
Four of the six, the Island at Southpointe sale and the three Admirals Watch sales, are in the two Windstar villages inside the City of Naples. Water and detached product sit at the top of the Windstar market, and the bayfront City of Naples villages carry the lowest millage rate as well, which a buyer at that price notices.
The $1,200,000 median and the $1,353,433 average ($70,378,500 divided by 52, our arithmetic) differ because a handful of large sales, above all the $6,750,000 Island at Southpointe closing, pull the average up. The median is the better guide to the middle of the market, and neither number is the right anchor for a specific home; the village figures are.
Windstar on Naples Bay recorded 14 closings from June 1 to October 13, 2026, from $507,500 at Marina Cove to $6,750,000 at the Island at Southpointe, and June 2026 was the busiest month of the window with 10 closings. Recent sales are what a buyer’s appraiser reads first, so they lead every valuation we write.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026)
Closed | Village | Sale price | Days on market | Sale-to-list |
|---|---|---|---|---|
August 25, 2026 | Regatta Landing | $1,102,000 | 68 | 88.2% |
August 17, 2026 | Regatta Landing | $1,150,000 | 19 | 92.1% |
July 10, 2026 | Yacht Harbour Cove | $1,200,000 | 38 | 87.0% |
July 7, 2026 | Regatta Landing | $1,090,500 | 100 | 91.3% |
June 30, 2026 | Yacht Harbour Cove | $2,250,000 | 157 | 112.8% |
June 30, 2026 | Yacht Harbour Cove | $1,610,000 | 106 | 85.0% |
June 30, 2026 | Marina Cove | $674,000 | 60 | 97.0% |
June 26, 2026 | Ketch Cay | $1,750,000 | 1 | 95.9% |
June 24, 2026 | Marina Cove | $715,000 | 7 | 95.5% |
June 23, 2026 | Marina Cove | $507,500 | 373 | 92.3% |
June 16, 2026 | Island at Southpointe | $6,750,000 | 157 | 90.2% |
June 16, 2026 | Leeward Cay | $1,137,000 | 25 | 98.9% |
Source: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026. Sale-to-list is the sold price over the final list price. No closing is recorded after August 25, 2026.
Month | Closings |
|---|---|
Oct 2025 (from Oct 13) | 3 |
Nov 2025 | 4 |
Dec 2025 | 7 |
Jan 2026 | 4 |
Feb 2026 | 4 |
Mar 2026 | 4 |
Apr 2026 | 8 |
May 2026 | 4 |
Jun 2026 | 10 |
Jul 2026 | 2 |
Aug 2026 | 2 |
Sep 2026 | 0 |
Oct 2026 (to Oct 13) | 0 |
Source: Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026.
Closing dates trail contract dates, so a June closing usually reflects a contract written in spring. One year of data is not enough to call a seasonal pattern, and we do not read it as one; what it does tell a seller is that buyers closed in every month from October 2025 through the August that followed, with none recorded in September or the first 13 days of October 2026.
The Regatta Landing sales ran from $1,849,000 on April 23, 2026 down to $1,090,500 on July 7, 2026, with two August sales at $1,150,000 and $1,102,000, inside one village of homes built within five years of one another: floor plan, position on the creek and finish level matter more than the village name. The Windward Cay pair that closed on the same day, March 17, 2026, at $350,000 and $665,000 shows how far build phase and unit size move a condominium price in one association. And the three Ketch Cay sales climbed from $1,375,000 in December 2025 to $1,750,000 in June 2026, a reminder that the last sale in a thin village sets the buyer’s reference point, in either direction.
How long a Windstar on Naples Bay home takes to sell, and how close to its asking price, is measured on the 48 closings in the 12 months to October 13, 2026 that carry a days-on-market figure and both prices, because the one Sold Data Entry record and three closings recorded at zero days on market cannot be measured. Days on market, sale-to-list, price per square foot and active listings below all come from the October 13, 2026 Southwest Florida MLS pull.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026)
The median days a Windstar listing was on the market before it sold was 59 (average 73), and the median sale-to-list ratio over the same 48 closings was 94.7% (average 94.5%). The median final list price was $1,249,500. In the prior 12 months the median was 34 days and 95.8% (47 closings), so homes took longer to sell and closed slightly further below their final list price. Time to contract varies by village and price band, and a well-documented listing, with the estoppel figures, the elevation certificate and any condominium inspection reports ready on day one, avoids the delays that come from a buyer waiting on paperwork.
Active Windstar listings at the October 13, 2026 MLS pull: 15, with a median list price of $659,000 (from $425,000 to $2,795,000) and 5 more pending. Months of supply is active listings divided by the monthly closing pace of the last 12 months; at 52 closings that pace is 4.3 a month across the community (our arithmetic), so supply is 3.5 months, each active listing equals about a week of the whole community’s sales pace, and far more than that for a single village. All 15 listings are condominiums, 8 of them in Marina Cove, and none is a villa or detached home. Inventory changes week to week in a community this size, so we pull a current active and pending list for your village and price band before we recommend a number.
In a community where most villages see five or fewer sales a year, the first month on the market carries the listing. Buyers in Windstar compare a new listing against the last closing in the same village and against what else is open that weekend, and a listing priced above both waits while the buyer pool moves on to the next village. Our practical advice is to price at the level your village and product have already closed, make the first month count, and have the estoppel certificates, the elevation certificate and the condominium reports ready before the first showing.
A Windstar on Naples Bay buyer prices in every recurring cost: the master assessment ($4,130 per home for 2025), the village or condominium assessment, property tax at 12.3696, 13.3696 or 8.9752 mills depending on the tax code, and any optional club or slip costs. Windstar has no Community Development District, which keeps a common line off the tax bill.
Data updated: October 2026 (master association 2025 Annual Meeting outline, March 31, 2025; 2025 Collier Taxing Authority Code Descriptions, dated October 3, 2025; Florida DOR 2025 non-ad valorem detail; Collier County Property Appraiser 2026 certified roll, file dated October 27, 2026)
Layer | Amount | Who pays | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
Master assessment | $4,130 per home for 2025 ($1,032.50 a quarter): $3,080 operating including $780 bulk Hotwire, $800 replacement reserve, $250 hurricane reserve | Every home, one equal share | |
Village or condominium assessment | Varies; Compass Point South published $1,968 a quarter in 2021, including its master share | Members of that village | Compass Point South Q and A, 2021; every other village’s budget and estoppel certificate govern |
Windstar Club (optional) | 2023 schedule: Social initiation $10,000 and dues $6,645 a year; Social Summer Golf initiation $20,000 and dues $9,545 a year | Club members only | |
Southpointe Marina and Regatta dock dues | Not published | Slip owners | Each slip association’s documents govern |
Community Development District | None | None | |
Property tax | 12.3696, 13.3696 or 8.9752 mills, 2026 certified roll (codes per the TACD) | All owners, by location | |
County non-ad valorem charge | $269.77 on the 2026 certified roll ($261.91 in 2025) | Many Windstar parcels |
An owner who does not join the club and does not own a slip carries the master assessment, the village layer, the property tax and, on many parcels, the non-ad valorem charge. Everything else is a choice, and a buyer who sees that clearly pays for a home rather than discounting it for costs that do not apply.
The master assessment was $2,212 a year in 2013, $3,250 in 2024 and $4,130 in 2025, per the master association’s recorded document compilation and the 2025 Annual Meeting outline. The 2024 to 2025 change was $880, or 27.1%, and $780 of it was the new bulk Hotwire internet and TV line under a 10-year contract from March 1, 2025; outside that line the assessment rose $100. Buyers will see the jump, so we explain it before they ask: the Hotwire service replaces a bill most owners would pay anyway.
Tax code (2026 certified roll) | Villages | Mills | Tax on $1,000,000 of taxable value |
|---|---|---|---|
0063 | Most of Windstar (unincorporated, Bayshore Beautification MSTU, Greater Naples Fire) | 12.3696 | about $12,369.60 |
0111 | Regatta Landing (code 0063 plus the 1.0000-mill Haldeman Creek MSTU) | 13.3696 | about $13,369.60 |
0004 | Admirals Watch and the Island at Southpointe (City of Naples) | 8.9752 | about $8,975.20 |
Source: The Collier County Property Appraiser 2026 certified roll (file dated October 27, 2026) for the totals; 2025 Collier Taxing Authority Code Descriptions, dated October 3, 2025, for what each code covers. The dollar column is our arithmetic, not a bill. On a $2,000,000 taxable value the difference between codes 0063 and 0004 alone is $6,788.80 a year ($24,739.20 against $17,950.40), which is part of why the bayfront City of Naples villages carry Windstar’s top prices.
Homestead exemptions and the Save Our Homes cap reduce taxable value for owners who qualify, so a new buyer’s first bill is set on the purchase-year assessment, not the seller’s. A long-time homesteaded owner’s bill can understate what a buyer will pay by a wide margin. About 45.5% of Windstar homes, 281 of 618, carried a homestead exemption on the 2026 roll, so many buyers will be comparing your bill with a reset one. We show the buyer the reset arithmetic at your price, so it does not surface for the first time at the inspection table.
These are illustrations, not bills, using the 2026 certified millage and the 2025 master assessment; the tax collector’s bill and each association’s estoppel certificate control.
The Windstar Club affects a Windstar on Naples Bay home’s value mainly by being optional: Windstar is not bundled, so a buyer pays for a home rather than a mandatory membership, and a non-golfer can buy without a club bill. The club caps golf membership at 350, and its latest published fee schedule is from 2023, so current terms come from its membership office.
Data updated: October 2026 (Windstar Club pages read October 2026; club 2023 resident offer and fee pages; master declaration Section 1.5)
The club says on its Our Club page that “Residents within the gates are not required to be Members” and that it is “an equity, Member-owned golf and Country Club that accepts non-resident Members.” Section 1.5 of the master declaration adds that “No Owner or occupant gains any right to enter or to use the facilities of a Recreational Association simply by virtue of ownership or occupancy of a Unit.” For a seller, that widens the buyer pool: a boater, a beach-first owner or a buyer who plays elsewhere can buy in Windstar without an initiation fee.
On the club’s 2023 published schedule, Social membership carried a $10,000 initiation (a resident special of $3,000 through December 31, 2023) and $6,645 a year in dues, billed $1,662 a quarter; Social Summer Golf carried a $20,000 initiation and $9,545 a year, billed $2,387 a quarter; and the schedule refers to a “Full Golf Membership Contribution ($85,000)”. The 2023 food and beverage minimum was $1,400 family or $700 single. On that 2023 schedule a Social family’s first year came to $18,045 ($10,000 + $6,645 + $1,400, our arithmetic). The club has not published a 2026 schedule, and every figure here carries its 2023 date.
Not automatically, because the membership is not tied to the house. What happens to it when you sell, whether resignation, transfer to your buyer or any equity refund, is set by the club’s bylaws and membership documents, and the club’s 2023 fee pages state that its bylaws do not permit “any refund or cessation of fees during the membership year.” Before you list, ask the membership office for the current resignation and transfer terms in writing, so your buyer knows whether joining means a new initiation, and so you know when your own dues stop.
The club publishes a WOW (“Waiting on Windstar”) category for members waiting to be accepted as golf members, with limited in-season golf, and it does not publish the length of any wait. A buyer whose plan depends on in-season golf from the first winter may want the roster answer before writing a strong offer, so we ask the membership office where the roster stands before a golf-minded buyer tours your home.
Water access adds value in Windstar on Naples Bay, but it has to be documented. Southpointe Marina slips are separately deeded parcels with a 2026 preliminary just value median of $251,497 each, Regatta Landing slips move by Dock Slip Certificate, and every resident shares the master-owned Keewaydin Island beach whether or not the home conveys a slip.
Data updated: October 2026 (Florida DOR 2026 preliminary roll; master association and dock association documents read October 2026; NOAA U.S. Coast Pilot 5, Chapter 4)
The club’s Bay Life page says “Southpointe Marina has 72 slips and can accommodate yachts up to 70 feet”, and the 2026 county roll carries 73 slip parcels at the marina with a median 2026 preliminary just value of $251,497 per slip parcel. That is an appraisal figure, not a sale price, and slip sale prices are not in the MLS extract behind this page. The slips are governed by Southpointe at Windstar Marina Association, Inc., not by the club, and slip dues are not published, so a home that conveys a slip needs the marina association’s documents and estoppel in the listing file.
Regatta Landing slips are held by Dock Slip Certificate through Regatta Landing Dock Slip Association, Inc., outside the condominium and its assessments, and move by the Dock Slip Certificate Assignment form recorded as Exhibit P at Official Records Book 5448, Page 1149. Under the 2013 annexation terms, slips were to be offered first to Regatta owners, then to other Windstar owners, and to outside buyers only later. A Regatta coach home that conveys a certificate is a different product from one that does not, and we price it that way.
NOAA’s U.S. Coast Pilot 5, Chapter 4 places the fixed US 41 bridge, with a 10-foot clearance, at the head of Naples Bay, north of Windstar, so boats from Southpointe Marina and the bay docks run south to Gordon Pass without passing under it. For a buyer with a center console or a cruiser, that answer adds confidence to a slip home’s price.
The master association owns about 5 acres on Keewaydin Island and the Keewaydin Queen III shuttle, per its Keewaydin Beach and Shuttle page, and funds them through the master assessment, so every resident uses the beach whether or not they join the club. A buyer comparing Windstar with other Naples golf communities often counts that private beach as a reason to choose a Windstar home, and we make sure the listing says so.
Flood zone and elevation affect a Windstar on Naples Bay home’s value through the buyer’s insurance quote and lender requirements. On the February 8, 2024 maps, 58 of 68 sampled addresses were Zone AE at a base flood elevation of 8 or 9 feet, 10 were shaded Zone X, none was Zone VE, and every point sits in Collier Hurricane Evacuation Zone A.
Data updated: October 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer and Collier County layers queried October 10, 2026; OpenFEMA NFIP policies and claims; National Hurricane Center reports)
Village | Points | Zones | BFE ft NAVD88 | NFIP community |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Regatta Landing | 5 | AE | 9 | Collier County |
Marina Cove | 8 | 7 shaded X, 1 AE | 8 | Collier County |
Spinnaker Pointe | 4 | AE | 9 | Collier County |
Somerset at Windstar | 4 | AE | 9 | Collier County |
Yacht Harbour Cove | 3 | AE | 8 | Collier County |
Windward Cay | 6 | AE | 8 and 9 | Collier County |
Compass Point South | 3 | AE | 9 | Collier County |
Ketch Cay | 5 | AE | 8 | Collier County |
Clipper Cove | 4 | AE | 9 | Collier County |
Admirals Watch | 4 | AE | 8 to 9 | City of Naples |
Harrington Sound | 6 | AE | 8 | Collier County |
Spyglass Pointe | 2 | AE | 9 | Collier County |
Island at Southpointe | 3 | AE | 8 to 9 | City of Naples |
Northstar | 4 | 3 AE, 1 shaded X | 8 to 9 | Collier County |
Morningstar | 3 | 2 AE, 1 shaded X | 8 | Collier County |
Leeward Cay | 0 direct | not probed; neighbors AE 8 to 9 | n/a | Collier County |
Source: FEMA NFHL flood hazard zones, FIRM panels and political jurisdictions, queried October 10, 2026; 53 points on panel 12021C0582J and 15 on 12021C0581J, both effective February 8, 2024. Three common-area points and the marina point make up the rest of the 68. The house-level answer is the elevation certificate and the lender’s determination, not a sample.
Shaded Zone X, the 0.2 percent annual chance flood area, is not under the federal mandatory-purchase rule, though a lender may still require coverage. At Marina Cove seven of eight sampled points are shaded X, and Northstar and Morningstar each had one shaded X point. For a seller in those spots, the zone belongs in the listing, documented by the lender-grade determination, because the buyer’s insurance picture is different from the Zone AE home next door. Shaded X does not change the evacuation picture: those homes are in Evacuation Zone A like the rest of Windstar, per the county’s evacuation zone layer.
The base flood elevation at Windstar has changed with each map: 8.0 feet NAVD88 on Paget Circle on the 2005 map, 7 feet on Lighthouse Lane, Lookout Lane and York Island Drive on the 2012 map, and 8 to 9 feet across Windstar on the 2024 map. So a certificate surveyed under the 2012 map can show a house comfortably above base flood elevation that now sits below it. The 3292 Lookout Lane certificate is the example: 8.3 feet against a 2012 elevation of 7.0, and against a 2024 elevation of 9. FEMA issued preliminary map data for Collier County on March 20, 2025, and for Windstar panel 0582 becomes 0582K with no change in zone or base flood elevation at any of the 53 sampled points on that panel.
NFIP policies in force from June 2025 to July 2026 in the census block group that contains Windstar and older neighboring streets ran a median premium of $1,562 for houses, $842 for condominium unit owners and $4,975 for condominium association master policies, per OpenFEMA NFIP Policies. On the claims side, OpenFEMA NFIP Claims for the same block group show Hurricane Ian’s 164 claims, 141 paid, at about $8.77 million, of which buildings built 1980 or later, a proxy for Windstar-era construction, accounted for 89 claims and about $1.70 million; Milton produced 3 claims and about $3,700 on those newer buildings. The block group is wider than Windstar, so a buyer asks the seller about the specific home, and a seller who has the claim history and repair records ready answers before the question slows a contract.
The National Hurricane Center’s report on Hurricane Ian records a 7.1-foot NAVD88 reading at the Gordon River Bridge sensor about 3.4 kilometres north of Windstar, and Milton pushed the Naples Bay, North gauge to 5.77 feet NAVD88 in 2024, per the NHC report on Milton. No surveyed Ian high water mark sits inside the Windstar gates, so no one can state from the public record how deep the water stood at a particular Windstar address. The master association’s hurricane reserve held $632,382 at December 31, 2024 after about $127,000 of 2024 storm spending, which tells a buyer the shared property has its own storm money.
Florida’s structural integrity reserve study and milestone inspection rules affect a Windstar on Naples Bay condominium’s value only where a building has three habitable stories or more, which at Windstar means Compass Point South and certain Windward Cay buildings; most Windstar condominium buildings are one or two stories and fall outside both rules.
Data updated: October 2026 (Collier milestone inspection layer queried October 10, 2026; Florida Statutes and Laws of Florida; DBPR)
Under section 718.112, a residential condominium must complete a structural integrity reserve study at least every 10 years for each building three habitable stories or higher, and associations that existed on or before July 1, 2022 had until December 31, 2025, and in no event later than December 31, 2026. Under section 553.899, such a building needs a milestone inspection by December 31 of the year it turns 30. Chapter 2025-175, Laws of Florida, lets an association that completed a milestone inspection delay its study for up to two consecutive budget years. At Windstar, the county layer shows Windward Cay buildings 4450, 4600 and 4650 Yacht Harbor Drive and Compass Point South’s four buildings as “Milestone Completed, Cycle Completed”, next inspection 2033; Regatta Landing’s buildings are capped at two stories by the 2013 annexation terms.
A condominium buyer who sees a completed milestone cycle and a posted reserve study stops asking whether a special assessment is coming and starts asking about the unit. Compass Point South’s study, dated May 29, 2024, sets a minimum 2025 reserve funding of $118,650 and projects a starting reserve balance of $221,360 at January 1, 2025. A seller in a building the rules reach should have the study, the milestone summary and the current budget in the listing file, and check the association’s filing on the DBPR SIRS reporting page.
Admirals Watch lies inside the City of Naples, so its building matters fall under the city’s building department rather than Collier County, and its reserve-study and milestone status are not published. For an Admirals Watch seller, we request the association’s documents directly so the buyer’s attorney sees them early. The Island at Southpointe homes are single-family homes under a homeowners association, so the condominium study law does not reach them.
Selling a Windstar on Naples Bay home costs a negotiated commission, Florida documentary stamp tax on the deed, which the seller pays by custom, prorated property taxes and assessments, and the estoppel certificates from the master and village associations; in Collier County the buyer customarily pays the owner’s title policy, and the contract controls.
Data updated: October 2026 (master association recorded documents; Florida Statutes)
The listing commission is negotiable. The seller pays Florida documentary stamp tax on the deed by custom, payoff of any mortgage, prorated taxes and association assessments through closing, and the estoppel certificate fees, which are set by each association within the limits of Florida law. In Collier County the buyer customarily pays the owner’s title insurance policy and chooses the closing agent, and the purchase contract controls, so a seller relocating from elsewhere should not budget for it as a seller cost. Your title agent’s settlement statement is the final word on each line.
Every Windstar home belongs to the master association, which issues its own estoppel certificate; most homes also belong to a village association or condominium, which issues a second. If a Regatta Landing dock slip goes with the sale, the dock association joins the closing too. Estoppel rules sit in section 718.116 of the Florida Statutes for condominiums and section 720.30851 for homeowners associations, and none of Windstar’s associations publishes its fee schedule. Order the certificates as soon as you are under contract, because each one has its own turnaround.
The master board proposed a resale capital contribution in 2023, per the master association’s October 2023 newsletter, and the amendment certificate recorded in January 2024 (Official Records Book 6322, Page 2115) does not contain one. At the village level, the Regatta Landing declaration defines “Capital Contribution Assessments”, and amounts for Regatta and the other villages are not published. Each association’s estoppel certificate states what applies, and we put those figures in front of the buyer early so they do not reopen the price at closing.
Under Bylaw 8.3, master assessments are due on the first day of each quarter and delinquent if unpaid by the 11th day of the quarter’s first month, and the master association holds lien rights for unpaid assessments. The estoppel certificate states the balance as of closing, and the title agent pays it from your proceeds, so bring the account current early to keep the closing statement clean.
A Windstar on Naples Bay seller owes a buyer copies of the master Declaration, Bylaws and Rules, disclosure of known material defects that are not readily observable, and the statutory disclosure for the home’s association type: the section 718.503 condominium package in the nine condominium villages, and the section 720.401 summary where a chapter 720 association governs.
Data updated: October 2026 (master declaration Article 7.1; Florida Statutes chapters 718 and 720)
Article 7.1 of the master declaration requires owners to give purchasers copies of the Declaration, Bylaws and Rules, per the master association’s recorded document compilation. Add your village’s declaration, rules and budget, the estoppel certificates, your elevation certificate, and for a condominium the association’s milestone and reserve-study reports where they apply. A buyer who finds these on day one stops asking about them on day twenty.
Windstar mixes both regimes under one chapter 720 master association. Under section 720.401, the disclosure summary for a homeowners association is delivered before the buyer signs the contract, not at closing, and on a resale it is the seller who supplies it; the contract must carry the statute’s voidability language, and a buyer who does not receive the summary has a cancellation right that ends at closing. Section 720.401 does not apply to associations under chapters 718, 719, 721 or 723, so a seller in one of Windstar’s nine condominium villages delivers the condominium package under section 718.503 instead, while the master layer above every home is a chapter 720 association. Which documents your sale needs, and in what order, is a question for your closing agent or attorney; this is information, not legal advice.
Florida sellers must disclose known facts that materially affect a home’s value and are not readily observable to the buyer, and storm damage and its repair history fall squarely in that category. No Windstar-specific damage record is public, so the disclosure comes from what you and your association know: repairs, insurance claims and permits. If a building was substantially damaged, federal floodplain rules treat repairs costing 50 percent or more of market value as substantial improvement under 44 CFR 59.1, which a buyer’s lender may ask about.
Before you list a Windstar on Naples Bay home, the items that move the number most are the ones a buyer’s insurer, lender and closing agent check first: the elevation certificate and wind mitigation report, the association package and estoppel figures, the condominium safety record, and the slip and club paperwork. A kitchen refresh matters less than a clean file.
Data updated: October 2026 (Collier County layers; master association documents; FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer)
Pull your elevation certificate from the county’s layer if one is on file, or have a surveyor prepare one, and gather your wind mitigation report. Both shorten a buyer’s insurance quote, and a lowest floor above the 2024 base flood elevation is a fact worth putting in the listing. Florida wind premiums turn on the roof’s age, shape and attachment and on impact protection for windows and doors, and most Windstar homes predate the 2002 Florida Building Code, so the report carries real weight.
Ask your village manager for the current budget, the estoppel fee, any pending assessment and, for a condominium three stories or taller, the milestone summary and reserve study. Ask the master association office at 1700 Windstar Boulevard for the current master figure. The 2026 master assessment is not on the public side of the master association’s site, so the estoppel is where a buyer will read it.
If a slip conveys, collect the deed or Dock Slip Certificate, the slip association’s documents and its dues. If you are a club member, get the membership office’s resignation and transfer terms in writing. A buyer who knows exactly what conveys, and what the club will ask of them, writes a cleaner offer.
Every exterior change in Windstar goes through the village association and then the master Architectural Review Committee under the master’s Design Guidelines and Tree Policy, approved May 26, 2022. Keep the approvals for your roof, hurricane protection, generator and lanai work in the listing file; a buyer’s inspector and insurer will ask, and approvals on paper close the question.
Location supports Windstar on Naples Bay values: the community is about 7 minutes from Fifth Avenue South and 10 from the Naples Pier without traffic, every tested address is zoned for A-rated Gulfview Middle and Naples High, and nothing inside the gates is left to build, so new supply competes from outside the community rather than next door.
Data updated: October 2026 (OSRM free-flow routing run October 10, 2026; Collier County Public Schools address lookup, 2026-27; FLDOE 2025-26 school grades; Collier County legal notices)
From the Windstar Boulevard entrance on Bayshore Drive, free-flow drives run about 0.7 miles and 2 minutes to the Naples Botanical Garden, 3.1 miles and 7 minutes to Fifth Avenue South, 4.4 miles and 10 minutes to the Naples Pier, 4.0 miles and 10 minutes to the NCH Baker Hospital emergency department and 36.5 miles and 51 minutes to Southwest Florida International Airport, per the OSRM public routing service run on October 10, 2026. Season traffic is slower, and the Southpointe end adds about 3 to 4 minutes to every trip.
Every Windstar address tested in the district’s lookup, including the City of Naples villages, is zoned for 2026-27 to Avalon Elementary (graded B), Gulfview Middle (A) and Naples High (A), per the Collier County Public Schools address lookup and the FLDOE 2025-26 school grades, as of September 1, 2026. Families should confirm the exact address before relying on a zone.
Collier County lists both Windstar PUDs as built out on its PUD layer, so a Windstar seller faces no builder inside the gates with incentives and a model home. Outside them, the county approved the Windward Landing RPUD for up to 90 single-family homes about 0.64 miles south, and The Halcyon, 66 condominium units and a 120-slip marina on Rock Creek about 0.95 miles away, per the county’s Windward Landing legal ad and Davis Brookside MPUD legal ad. Neither adds a golf course, a private beach or a master gate, so a Windstar resale competes on a different footing. Windward Landing is a separate 2026 rezoning, not Windstar’s Windward Cay.
Across Bayshore Drive, about 0.16 miles from the Windstar gate, the Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA posted Invitation to Negotiate 26-8663 on July 15, 2026 for outparcels of its 17-acre arts village site, and the Bayshore Boardwalk to Sugden Regional Park opened on February 26, 2026. As of October 10, 2026 no award under the ITN had been reported, so we describe the site to buyers as an open question and not as an amenity.
A free in-person Windstar on Naples Bay comparative market analysis from McGreevy and Comisar starts with the Home Valuation form at the top of this page or a call to Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072. Marc Comisar walks the home, Jesse builds the analysis from your village’s closings, and you receive a written opinion of value with every source named. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and every in-person valuation is prepared by one of them.
A written opinion of value for your address, built from the MLS closings of your village and the closest comparable product elsewhere in Windstar, matched for floor plan, water and view, flood zone and condition, adjusted for time, with every source named. Beside it, the carrying-cost picture your buyer will underwrite: the master and village assessments, the tax code and the reset arithmetic, the flood file, any condominium safety record and what conveys in slips and club terms. And a plain recommendation on list price and timing, including the case for waiting if the evidence says wait.
Get your free Windstar on Naples Bay home valuation with the Home Valuation form at the top of this page, request our free home valuation from anywhere, or call Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072 or email [email protected]. Marc Comisar is at (239) 287-5873, and our office is at 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134. There is no charge and no obligation to list. If you have already decided to sell, our plan for selling your home in Windstar on Naples Bay covers pricing, marketing, negotiation and the association package in full, and our guide to selling a home in Naples covers the wider city.
McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Windstar realtor, and every quote below is a five-star review on our Google Business Profile.
★★★★★ “Marc’s attention to detail and deep understanding of the Southwest Florida market gave us so much confidence.” Verified Google review
★★★★★ “Their professionalism, communication, and dedication to their clients truly stand out. They have a deep caring and true concern for all their client needs.” Verified Google review
Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are the local real estate experts behind this Windstar on Naples Bay valuation page. They lead Domain Realty Group, a team of agent partners across Southwest Florida, and build every valuation from the Southwest Florida MLS and the public record, as Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008. Jesse has lived in Estero since 2003, and our Naples office is at 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109. Reach Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Jesse McGreevy is a licensed Florida REALTOR and Sales Associate with Domain Realty and one half of McGreevy and Comisar, in Southwest Florida real estate since October 2004. He runs the pricing analysis, the record work and the association paperwork on every valuation the team writes. Reach him at (239) 898-6072 or [email protected], and read his full profile on the Jesse McGreevy agent page.
Marc Comisar is a licensed Florida REALTOR and Broker Associate with Domain Realty and the other half of McGreevy and Comisar, whose partnership alone has over $900 million in sales. He runs the field side, in the homes, at the inspections and at the closing table, and he is the one who walks your Windstar on Naples Bay home before any number is written down. Reach him at (239) 287-5873, and read his full profile on the Marc Comisar agent page.
Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC).
These are the valuation questions Windstar on Naples Bay owners actually ask, answered from the Southwest Florida MLS (closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026), the Florida DOR 2026 preliminary roll, the master association’s published documents, FEMA’s records and the state statutes. Nothing here is tax or legal advice, and none of it replaces a written valuation of your specific home.
Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS, pulled October 13, 2026; Florida DOR 2026 preliminary roll, read October 2026)
It depends on your village, product, floor plan, water and view, flood elevation and condition. The Southwest Florida MLS recorded 52 Windstar closings in the 12 months to October 13, 2026 at a $1,200,000 median, with sales from $350,000 at Windward Cay to $6,750,000 at the Island at Southpointe (no village reached 10 sales in the window). For a number on your address, use the Home Valuation form at the top of this page or call Jesse McGreevy at (239) 898-6072.
Ask for a written opinion built from sales in your own village and building, matched for floor plan, floor and view, adjusted for time and tested against active listings, with the estoppel figures, flood zone and, for a building three stories or taller, the milestone and reserve-study status behind it. We provide that free with no obligation to list. Get your free Windstar on Naples Bay home valuation and we will name every source.
An automated estimate learns from recent sales nearby and cannot see your village’s fee layer, your tax code, your elevation certificate or whether a slip conveys. In a community where village sales ran from $350,000 to $6,750,000 in the same 12 months, and three villages had a single sale, a model has too little village-level evidence to work with. We read the record and walk the home.
We tracked 52 closed sales in Windstar on Naples Bay in the 12 months to October 13, 2026: $70,378,500 in volume, a $1,200,000 median and a range of $350,000 to $6,750,000 (Southwest Florida MLS). The average was $1,353,433, pulled up by a handful of estate and bayfront sales, so the median is the better guide, and your village’s figures are better still.
Regatta Landing recorded 9 sales in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, from $1,090,500 to $1,849,000, too few for a 12-month median; over 24 months its 16 sales had a median of $1,310,000 (Southwest Florida MLS). It is Windstar’s newest village, 64 coach homes built 2016 to 2021, and its most active in the window. Floor plan, creek position and finish level explained most of the spread.
Marina Cove recorded 6 sales in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, from $507,500 to $745,000 (24 months: 12 sales, median $646,000) (Southwest Florida MLS), the narrowest spread of any village with more than three sales. Seven of its eight sampled points are shaded Zone X on the 2024 maps, a point we put in front of buyers.
Spinnaker Pointe recorded 5 sales in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, from $525,000 to $905,000 (24 months: 11 sales, median $630,000) (Southwest Florida MLS). The $905,000 sale is a Sold Data Entry record; it counts in the count and the range. Spinnaker Pointe is 88 carriage homes with its own clubhouse, pool and two lighted tennis courts.
Somerset at Windstar recorded 5 sales in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, from $660,000 to $1,300,000 (24 months: 10 sales, median $1,095,000) (Southwest Florida MLS). It is 50 duplex villas on Paget Circle under a homeowners association, built 1989 to 1990, so condition and renovation explain most of the spread between sales.
Yacht Harbour Cove recorded 5 sales in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, from $1,200,000 to $2,250,000 (36 months: 11 sales, median $1,700,000) (Southwest Florida MLS). Its 28 coach homes sit on the Southpointe marina basin, and its three sampled points are Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 8 feet.
Admirals Watch recorded 3 sales in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, at $2,375,000, $2,935,000 and $3,625,000 (Southwest Florida MLS). It is 16 bayfront condominiums with eight boat slips inside the City of Naples, which gives it the lowest of Windstar’s three millage rates, 8.9752 mills on the 2026 certified roll.
Windward Cay recorded 4 sales, from $350,000 to $1,075,000, and Leeward Cay recorded 3 sales, from $800,000 to $1,270,000, in the 12 months to October 13, 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS). Windward Cay is a 48-unit condominium built in phases from 1984 to 2004; Leeward Cay is 16 attached villas built 1987 to 1989.
Ketch Cay recorded 3 sales from $1,375,000 to $1,750,000, and Clipper Cove 2 sales, $1,480,000 and $1,625,000, in the 12 months to October 13, 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS). Both are single-family villages under homeowners associations, with private pools at the homes.
Compass Point South recorded 2 sales, $430,000 and $508,000 (36 months: 14 sales, median $503,500), and Northstar two sales, $1,325,000 and $1,375,000, too thin to read as a market rate (Southwest Florida MLS, 12 months to October 13, 2026). Compass Point South is 72 condominiums in four three-story buildings; Northstar is 16 villas with private pools.
Each recorded one sale in the window: Harrington Sound at $2,075,000, Spyglass Pointe at $1,775,000 and the Island at Southpointe at $6,750,000 (Southwest Florida MLS). One sale is too thin to read as a market rate, so we widen the evidence to the village’s own sales history, the closest detached product elsewhere in Windstar and the home’s lot, water, elevation certificate and living area, and we show you each comparable.
Morningstar recorded no closed sale in the 12 months to October 13, 2026. We value a Morningstar home from its own earlier sales, then from the closest condominium product on Haldeman Creek Drive, Compass Point South and Northstar, adjusted for size, building form and the village’s fees. The written valuation names each comparable and its date.
The median days on market for the 48 Windstar closings that carry a days-on-market figure in the 12 months to October 13, 2026 was 59, up from 34 in the prior 12 months (Southwest Florida MLS; the Sold Data Entry record and three closings recorded at zero days are left out). Time to contract varies by village and price band, and a listing with its estoppel figures, elevation certificate and condominium reports ready avoids the delays of a buyer waiting on paperwork.
The median sale-to-list ratio for the 48 closings measured in the window was 94.7%, against 95.8% in the prior 12 months (Southwest Florida MLS). In a thin village market, the first list price matters more than the negotiation, because buyers compare a listing with the last closing in the same village.
The median sold price per square foot for Windstar in the 12 months to October 13, 2026 was $493, up from $455 in the prior 12 months (Southwest Florida MLS). Living area runs from 1,324 square feet at the smallest Morningstar home to 17,120 at the largest Island at Southpointe estate on the county roll, so compare your home with its own village, never with a community figure.
Active Windstar listings at the October 13, 2026 MLS pull: 15, plus 5 pending. For context, the market closed 52 sales in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, about 4.3 a month across all 16 villages (our arithmetic), which makes 3.5 months of supply, so a handful of listings in one village is a lot of supply for that village.
For a home priced to its own village, yes: Windstar is built out, so every competing home is another resale, and buyers closed in every month from October 2025 through the following August in the 12 months to October 13, 2026, with June 2026 the busiest at 10 closings (Southwest Florida MLS). Whether it is your time depends on your village’s current listings, which we pull for your written valuation.
No. The 2026 preliminary just value is an appraisal figure for tax purposes, not a sale price. In every Windstar village with 10 or more sales in a 24 or 36-month window, the median MLS sale ran above the median just value on the Florida DOR 2026 preliminary roll; at Yacht Harbour Cove the 36-month median sale was $1,700,000 against a median just value of $1,487,970.
Yes, and it shows inside single villages. Yacht Harbour Cove’s homes on the marina basin, Admirals Watch on the bay and the Island at Southpointe on its access channel sit at the top of the market, and Spyglass Pointe faces the 15th to 17th holes and Haldeman Creek. We measure a view premium from closed sales of the same village with and without the exposure, and where the sample is too thin to measure it, we say so.
It can, but no public sales record prices it. Southpointe Marina slips are separate deeded parcels; the 2026 county roll carries 73 slip parcels with a median 2026 preliminary just value of $251,497 each, an appraisal figure and not a sale price. Regatta Landing slips move by Dock Slip Certificate. A slip widens the buyer pool, and we confirm the transfer path before it appears in a price.
Windstar is not bundled, so a buyer pays for a home, not a mandatory membership, and a non-golfer can buy without a club bill. On the club’s 2023 schedule a Social family’s first year came to $18,045, and the club has not published a 2026 schedule. A golf-minded buyer will ask about the roster, so we ask the membership office before that buyer tours.
Most likely Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 8 or 9 feet NAVD88: 58 of 68 Windstar address points we queried on FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer on October 10, 2026 were AE, on panels effective February 8, 2024. Most of Marina Cove is shaded Zone X, and no sampled home fell in Zone VE. The lender’s determination and your elevation certificate settle it for your house.
Yes. No law requires one to list, but lenders and flood insurers use it, and a buyer will ask. The Windstar certificates we read show lowest floors from 8.0 to 9.5 feet NAVD88 against base flood elevations of 8 or 9 feet, with Regatta Landing’s living levels at 13.8 and 14.5 feet. If yours is not on file, a surveyor can prepare one before you list.
Buyers will see it, so explain it. The master assessment went from $3,250 in 2024 to $4,130 in 2025, an increase of $880 or 27.1%, and $780 of that is the new bulk Hotwire internet and TV line (master association, 2025 Annual Meeting outline). Outside the Hotwire line, the increase was $100 a year.
The master association’s March 2025 deck projects a reserve outlay of about $1.70 million in 2030 for docks, channel, road and marina entrance dredging, funded from the reserve plan as projected, and no special assessment is announced in the published sources. A master dock dredge is estimated at about $400,000. Village associations set their own budgets, so your estoppel certificate shows any village assessment.
Only if the building has three habitable stories or more. At Windstar the county layer lists Windward Cay buildings 4450, 4600 and 4650 Yacht Harbor Drive and Compass Point South’s four buildings as “Milestone Completed, Cycle Completed”, next inspection 2033, and most other condominium buildings are one or two stories. Ask your association which applies, and have the documents ready before you list.
On the 2026 certified roll, code 0063 at 12.3696 mills covers most of Windstar, code 0111 at 13.3696 covers Regatta Landing, and code 0004 at 8.9752 covers Admirals Watch and the Island at Southpointe in the City of Naples (12.6162, 13.6162 and 9.0514 for tax year 2025, per the 2025 Collier Taxing Authority Code Descriptions). Your buyer’s first bill resets to the purchase-year assessment, not yours.
Often, if you have a homestead exemption. Homestead exemptions and the Save Our Homes cap reduce a qualifying owner’s taxable value, and a new buyer’s first bill is set on the purchase-year assessment. About 45.5% of Windstar homes carried a homestead exemption on the 2026 roll, so we show the buyer the reset arithmetic at your price before the question comes up.
In Collier County the buyer customarily pays the owner’s title insurance policy and chooses the closing agent, and the purchase contract controls. A seller relocating from elsewhere should not budget for it as a seller cost; the title agent’s settlement statement is the final word on every line.
The main seller costs are the negotiated commission, Florida documentary stamp tax on the deed, which the seller pays by custom, prorated taxes and assessments through closing, and the estoppel certificate fees from the master and village associations. The owner’s title policy is customarily the buyer’s cost in Collier County.
At least two, and sometimes three: one from the master association, one from the village association or condominium, and one from the dock association if a Regatta Landing slip certificate transfers. None of Windstar’s associations publishes its estoppel fee schedule, so order the certificates as soon as you are under contract.
Article 7.1 of the master declaration requires owners to give purchasers copies of the Declaration, Bylaws and Rules. Condominium sellers deliver the section 718.503 package, and where a chapter 720 homeowners association governs, the section 720.401 summary is delivered before the buyer signs; that statute does not apply to condominium associations. Add known material defects. Your closing agent or attorney confirms the exact package.
The club’s bylaws govern, and its 2023 fee pages state that the bylaws do not permit “any refund or cessation of fees during the membership year.” How a membership transfers or is resigned when you sell sits in the club’s membership documents, which the club has not published, so ask the membership office before you set a closing date.
Nothing. Our written valuation is free and carries no obligation to list. It is prepared by Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, not by an automated tool, and it names every source: the MLS closings, the county roll, the flood maps and the association records behind your number.
No. Many Windstar owners are seasonal, and we arrange the walk-through with your property manager, your village association or a neighbor, including the gate registration. Jesse McGreevy builds the analysis, Marc Comisar walks the home, and you receive the written valuation wherever you are. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
That depends on your plans. Leasing in Windstar is limited by the master declaration to terms of 30 days or one calendar month up to one year and no more than three leases a year, with stricter village rules such as Regatta Landing’s two leases in any 12 months, while the sales market recorded 52 closings at a $1,200,000 median in the 12 months to October 13, 2026. A written valuation lets you weigh both with your village’s numbers.
Yes. McGreevy and Comisar offer discretion and off-market capability when needed, which suits owners who would rather not advertise a sale inside a gated community or who want to test a price quietly first. Confidential conversations welcome: call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, text or call.
For-sale signs follow your village association’s rules and never go on master association property, and association-approved open house signs are signed out at the guardhouse, under the 2018 master rules. Because Windstar is gated, visitors are admitted when an owner registers them, so plan how open house guests will clear the gate.
Every figure on this Windstar on Naples Bay valuation page traces to a primary source below: the Southwest Florida MLS, Collier County and Florida records and GIS layers, FEMA and NOAA, the master association, village association and club documents, and state statutes. Nothing comes from a listing aggregator or another brokerage.
Southwest Florida MLS figures (closed sales October 13, 2025 to October 13, 2026, pulled October 13, 2026) are cited rather than linked because the MLS is members-only, and the Domain Realty brokerage figures come from the same MLS pulled October 5, 2026. Every linked source below was retrieved in October 2026.
Every Windstar on Naples Bay document below links its official publisher: the master association, a village association, the club, Collier County, the State of Florida or FEMA. You always see the authoritative version, not a copy we made, and village documents not listed here come from that village’s association.
Document | What it shows for a Windstar valuation | Official link |
|---|---|---|
Master declaration, bylaws, articles and amendments (compiled January 24, 2024) | Who belongs, one equal master assessment per home, lien rights, the 2020 leasing amendment and the December 2023 amendment | |
2025 Annual Meeting outline (March 31, 2025) | The $4,130 assessment by fund, 2024 results, reserves and the hurricane fund | |
Master Rules and Regulations (May 15, 2018) | Gates, guests, pets, signs, vehicles and open house rules | |
Design Guidelines and Tree Policy (May 26, 2022) | The architectural review a buyer’s renovation plan must clear | |
Master lease application | The $145 master lease fee and the 20-day notice rule | |
Regatta Landing declaration | Master assessment collected inside the Regatta budget; club not mandatory; leasing limits | |
Regatta Landing dock slip certificate assignment | How a Regatta Landing slip transfers (Exhibit P, OR 5448 PG 1149) | |
Compass Point South Q and A (2021) | Quarterly dues including the master share, leasing and pet rules | |
Compass Point South Structural Integrity Reserve Study (May 29, 2024) | Minimum 2025 reserve funding and the starting reserve balance | |
Windstar Club 2023 resident membership offer and fee pages | The 2023 initiation, dues and food and beverage minimums | |
2025 Collier Taxing Authority Code Descriptions (October 3, 2025) | The three millage rates inside Windstar | |
Ordinance 93-23 | The controlling Windstar PUD ordinance, adopted May 11, 1993 | |
Ordinance 88-82 | The Southpointe Yacht Club PUD, adopted October 25, 1988 | |
Elevation certificate, 4500 Lighthouse Ln (2022) | A Harrington Sound lowest floor 1.5 feet above the 2024 base flood elevation | |
Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian | Storm surge readings on Naples Bay in September 2022 |
You reach the Windstar on Naples Bay valuation team by using the Home Valuation form at the top of this page, requesting a free home valuation, calling Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072, or calling Marc Comisar at (239) 287-5873. The first conversation costs nothing, and you will be working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
Get your free Windstar on Naples Bay home valuation from anywhere, or use our general free home valuation request. If you have decided to sell, read our plan for selling your home in Windstar on Naples Bay. If you are buying too, start with buying a home in Windstar on Naples Bay and call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC).
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more at DomainRealtyGroup.com. Read more about the team on the about McGreevy and Comisar page, and about the community on our Windstar on Naples Bay community guide. Nothing on this page is legal, tax or insurance advice; confirm anything that affects your transaction with your closing agent, attorney, accountant or insurance professional.
Market data from Southwest Florida MLS, pulled October 13, 2026, and from Collier County public records. Brokered by Domain Realty.