Home › Englewood › Coco Bay › Coco Bay Home Valuation
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, the #1 real estate team in Southwest Florida since 2012. Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, over $900 million in personal sales, and more than $2.5 billion sold as the Domain Realty Group team.
By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar. Updated November 2026. A Coco Bay home is only a few years old, and almost every price recorded around it was set by one seller: Lennar. County records show 129 qualified Coco Bay home sales from September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026, and 112 of them were the builder's own first sales (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). That makes a Coco Bay valuation a different job from valuing an older Englewood street. The streets, plats, parks and utilities are covered in our Coco Bay guide, and the steps of a listing are in our Coco Bay seller guide. This page answers one question: what is your Coco Bay home worth today, and why does the record point there?
Coco Bay is a Lennar new-construction community in unincorporated western Charlotte County, Florida, with Englewood 34224 mailing addresses. It is not a city, and it is not Coco Bay at Pelican Bay in Naples. Our counts cover three recorded plats on the county roll dated November 5, 2026: Coco Bay (183 parcels), Island Lakes at Coco Bay (239) and Palm Lake at Coco Bay (179), 601 parcels in all. On that roll they hold 287 detached homes with a median 2,198 heated square feet, 158 attached villas with a median 1,423, 127 lots still coded vacant (98 of them in Island Lakes at Coco Bay) and 29 parcels in other uses, and the roll dates the homes to 2023 (18), 2024 (325) and 2025 (102) (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). A Coco Bay value starts with three facts the address alone does not give: detached or villa, which plat, and how many heated square feet.
Coco Bay home values in late 2026 center on a $315,000 median across 129 qualified sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, at a median $173 per heated square foot. Detached homes and villas sit about $100,500 apart, and the builder's first sales still outnumber resales by more than six to one (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
How to read these figures: every Coco Bay count and median here is our tabulation of the Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026, with qualified improved sales recorded through early September 2026 (the newest is dated August 24, 2026). The 12-month window runs September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026 and the 24-month window from September 10, 2024. A "first sale" is Lennar's sale of a new home; a "resale" is a later sale of the same home by its owner. Per square foot always means per square foot of the county's heated (living) area. Any group under 10 sales is called a small group, printed with its count, and we draw no percentage conclusion from it (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Talk to McGreevy and Comisar before you list. The record behind the team that will value your Coco Bay home:
A Coco Bay home in 2026 is worth roughly what the same type and size of Coco Bay home recorded lately: a $350,000 median for 55 detached sales and $249,500 for 32 villas in the 12 months to September 9, 2026. Plat, heated size, build year and what the owner added decide the rest (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Data updated: November 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026; qualified improved sales in the Coco Bay, Island Lakes at Coco Bay and Palm Lake at Coco Bay plats, newest August 24, 2026; 12-month window September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026 and 24-month window from September 10, 2024; type, plat, size band and build-year cuts tabulated November 2026).
Coco Bay recorded 129 qualified improved sales from September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026, at a $315,000 median with the middle half between $261,000 and $350,000. Of those, 112 were Lennar first sales at a $315,000 median and 17 were owner resales at $285,000, a group that mixes villas and detached homes (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Coco Bay qualified improved sales, September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026.
| Group | Sales | Median price | Middle half of prices | Median per heated sq ft (middle half) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All qualified improved sales | 129 | $315,000 | $261,000 to $350,000 | $173 on the 87 with heated area ($162 to $186) |
| Detached homes | 55 | $350,000 | $325,000 to $415,000 | $173 ($164 to $185) |
| Villas | 32 | $249,500 | $241,250 to $270,000 | $162 ($154 to $192) |
| Parcels still coded vacant at the January 1 roll date | 42 | $311,000 | $260,000 to $330,325 | not computed (no heated area on the roll) |
| Lennar first sales, all types | 112 | $315,000 | $260,000 to $350,000 | $169 on 70 ($160 to $179) |
| Resales, all types | 17 | $285,000 | $272,500 to $437,500 | $193 ($177 to $203) |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our tabulation. Detached and villa rows use the roll's use codes; the 42 "vacant-coded" sales were Lennar closings on lots the January 1 roll still described as land, so they carry no heated area or home type and cannot be split.
That last row is the first thing to understand about the Coco Bay record. About a third of the year's sales, 42 of 129, closed on parcels the roll still called vacant, because a Lennar home finished after January 1 shows as land until the next roll (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Those sales are real home sales, and they count in the $315,000 median, but they cannot be sorted into detached or villa or measured per foot. That is why the type rows add to 87 and not 129, and why we value a Coco Bay home from its own type row rather than from the all-sales median.
The resale median needs the same care. At $285,000 it sits below the first-sale median of $315,000, but that is a mix effect, not a discount: 9 of the 17 resales were villas and 8 were detached homes, both small groups, while the first sales lean toward detached homes (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The detached resales closed at a $437,500 median and the villa resales at $275,000, each above the matching first-sale medians of $346,100 (47 sales) and $245,000 (23 sales). With 8 and 9 sales those are small groups, so we read them as a direction, not a percentage. The per-foot rows say the same thing on a larger base: resales at $193 against $169 for first sales.
Read the window as a description of Coco Bay, not of your address. The middle half of detached prices spans $90,000 (our arithmetic on $325,000 to $415,000), and inside that band sit the medians of both the 1,700 to 1,999 and the 2,000 to 2,399 square foot size bands, a lake lot and an interior one, a home with a pool cage and one without (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The rest of this section narrows the band one fact at a time.
Coco Bay homes with a recorded heated area sold at a median $173 per heated square foot in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, with the middle half from $162 to $186 on 87 sales. Detached homes ran $173 and villas $162. Every figure uses the county's heated living area, not a builder brochure's total square footage (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Coco Bay median price per heated square foot, by type and window.
| Group | 12 months: sales | 12 months: median (middle half) | 24 months: sales | 24 months: median (middle half) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All sales with heated area | 87 | $173 ($162 to $186) | 296 | $178 ($164 to $197) |
| Detached homes | 55 | $173 ($164 to $185) | 188 | $178 ($167 to $202) |
| Villas | 32 | $162 ($154 to $192) | 108 | $176 ($156 to $193) |
| Lennar first sales | 70 | $169 ($160 to $179) | 272 | $176 ($163 to $194) |
| Resales | 17 | $193 ($177 to $203) | 24 | $195 ($180 to $221) |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our tabulation of qualified improved sales with a heated area on the November 5, 2026 roll. Windows end September 9, 2026.
As a worked illustration, not a value: a detached home at the roll's median 2,198 heated square feet comes to $360,472 at $164 per foot, $380,254 at $173 and $406,630 at $185, a $46,158 spread across the middle half (our multiplication on the Charlotte County Property Appraiser figures). A villa at the roll's median 1,423 square feet comes to $219,142 at $154, $230,526 at $162 and $273,216 at $192 (our multiplication). The detached result lands above the $350,000 detached price median because the median of prices and the median of per-foot figures come from different homes; a per-foot figure gets a Coco Bay home into a band, and the plan, lot and owner additions place it inside that band.
Two cautions apply to Coco Bay per-foot figures specifically. First, Lennar's plan pages quote square footage by its own measure, and the county's heated area can differ, so set a plan's price against the roll's heated area before dividing (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Second, the 12-month villa per-foot middle half is wide, $154 to $192, because villa prices vary by plat far more than villa sizes do: the roll puts the middle half of villa sizes between 1,422 and 1,564 heated square feet, a 142 square foot band (our arithmetic), so the spread in villa per-foot prices comes mostly from something other than size. The plat table below shows where it comes from.
Detached homes and villas are two separate markets in Coco Bay. Over the 12 months to September 9, 2026, 55 detached homes sold at a $350,000 median and 32 villas at $249,500, a $100,500 gap by our arithmetic. The roll's median detached home has 2,198 heated square feet against 1,423 for the median villa (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Coco Bay detached homes and villas compared.
| Measure | Detached homes | Villas | Source window |
|---|---|---|---|
| Homes on the roll | 287 | 158 | Roll dated November 5, 2026 |
| Median heated sq ft (middle half) | 2,198 (2,027 to 2,264) | 1,423 (1,422 to 1,564) | Same roll |
| 12-month sales and median price | 55, $350,000 | 32, $249,500 | September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026 |
| 12-month median per heated sq ft | $173 | $162 | Same window |
| 24-month sales and median price | 188, $377,750 | 108, $257,000 | September 10, 2024 to September 9, 2026 |
| 24-month median per heated sq ft | $178 | $176 | Same window |
| 24-month resales | 14 | 10 | Same window |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our tabulation.
Size explains most of the dollar gap. The median detached home is 775 heated square feet larger than the median villa, about 54.5 percent more (our arithmetic), and over 24 months the two types sold at nearly the same per-foot median, $178 against $176 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). In the latest 12 months the villa per-foot median fell further behind, to $162 against $173, and the plat split below shows why: most villa sales in the window were in Palm Lake at Coco Bay, where villa per-foot prices run lowest.
A villa is never a comparable for a detached Coco Bay home, and the reverse holds too. The two types differ in more than size: a villa shares a wall, and Lennar sells them as separate collections, with Villas in Island Lakes at Coco Bay marked sold out on November 17, 2026 (Lennar, Island Lakes at Coco Bay, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026, subject to change). That last point matters to a villa owner: with no new Lennar villa to buy in Coco Bay, a buyer who wants a Coco Bay villa is choosing among resales, while a detached seller in Island Lakes at Coco Bay still competes with new Executive Homes down the street.
The tax roll shows the gap from another angle. The county set the 2026 just value of the median detached home at $290,992 and the median villa at $208,547, figures as of January 1 that run about a fifth below sale prices, and we cover them in the tax section of this page (our computation from the county roll, Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Values differ by plat mostly for villas. Over the 24 months to September 9, 2026, villas in the Coco Bay plat sold at a median $197 per heated square foot, Island Lakes at Coco Bay villas at $190 and Palm Lake at Coco Bay villas at $155, while detached per-foot medians stayed between $175 and $182 in all three plats (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Coco Bay qualified sales by plat and type, 12 and 24 months to September 9, 2026.
| Plat and type | 12 months: sales | 12 months: median price | 12 months: median per heated sq ft | 24 months: sales | 24 months: median price (middle half) | 24 months: median per heated sq ft (middle half) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coco Bay plat, detached | 4 (a small group) | $435,000 | $200 | 37 | $389,600 ($357,500 to $427,100) | $182 ($166 to $211) |
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay, detached | 28 | $350,000 | $173 | 77 | $375,000 ($340,800 to $451,900) | $175 ($166 to $197) |
| Palm Lake at Coco Bay, detached | 23 | $332,000 | $170 | 74 | $375,750 ($340,875 to $482,500) | $179 ($170 to $208) |
| Coco Bay plat, villas | 7 (a small group) | $275,000 | $193 | 15 | $280,000 ($275,000 to $298,000) | $197 ($193 to $209) |
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay, villas | 7 (a small group) | $268,000 | $190 | 43 | $268,000 ($250,000 to $297,000) | $190 ($176 to $209) |
| Palm Lake at Coco Bay, villas | 18 | $245,000 | $157 | 50 | $241,500 ($239,000 to $250,000) | $155 ($153 to $160) |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our tabulation. Plat is the recorded plat on the roll. Sales on parcels still coded vacant are not in this table.
The villa split is the largest plat effect in the record. Over 24 months, Coco Bay plat villas sold at a per-foot median 27.1 percent above Palm Lake at Coco Bay villas ($197 against $155, our arithmetic), and the two middle halves do not even overlap: $193 to $209 against $153 to $160 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Fifty Palm Lake villa sales and fifteen Coco Bay plat villa sales are enough to say the difference is real for those plats. The record cannot say why on its own; the plans, lots and dates of sale differ between the plats, and we compare a villa against villas in its own plat first.
Detached homes price much more evenly. Over 24 months the three plats sat within $7 of each other on the foot, $175 to $182, and within $14,600 on the median price, $375,000 to $389,600 (our arithmetic on the Charlotte County Property Appraiser figures). The 12-month detached rows look further apart, but the Coco Bay plat row has only 4 sales, a small group, from which we draw no conclusion. For a detached home we lean on the 24-month plat line and the home's own size band, then check the 12-month line for direction.
What sits on each plat is also uneven. The roll shows the Coco Bay plat with 112 detached homes, 61 villas and 5 vacant-coded lots; Island Lakes at Coco Bay with 83 detached homes, 41 villas and 98 vacant-coded lots; and Palm Lake at Coco Bay with 92 detached homes, 56 villas and 24 vacant-coded lots (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Island Lakes at Coco Bay is where Lennar is still building and selling, so an Island Lakes owner's buyer can still compare against homes Lennar is selling new, while a Palm Lake owner's buyer has no new Palm Lake home to choose instead: Lennar's page says "Palm Lake at Coco Bay is now sold out" (Lennar, Palm Lake at Coco Bay, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026, subject to change).
Detached Coco Bay prices climb with heated size, but not in a straight line. In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, homes of 1,700 to 1,999 heated square feet sold at a $325,000 median (19 sales) and homes of 2,000 to 2,399 at $360,000 (28 sales); the 8 homes of 2,400 square feet and up are a small group at $490,000 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Coco Bay detached sales by heated size, 12 months, September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026.
| Heated size band | Sales | Median price | Middle half of prices | Median per heated sq ft (middle half) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under 1,700 sq ft | 0 | none recorded | none recorded | none recorded |
| 1,700 to 1,999 sq ft | 19 | $325,000 | $300,000 to $332,000 | $175 ($163 to $178) |
| 2,000 to 2,399 sq ft | 28 | $360,000 | $342,275 to $401,625 | $170 ($163 to $184) |
| 2,400 sq ft and up | 8 (a small group) | $490,000 | $459,900 to $545,000 | $195 ($179 to $213) |
| All detached | 55 | $350,000 | $325,000 to $415,000 | $173 ($164 to $185) |
Coco Bay detached sales by heated size, 24 months, September 10, 2024 to September 9, 2026.
| Heated size band | Sales | Median price | Middle half of prices | Median per heated sq ft (middle half) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1,400 to 1,699 sq ft | 1 (one sale) | not computed | not computed | not computed |
| 1,700 to 1,999 sq ft | 36 | $333,300 | $312,750 to $346,200 | $180 ($169 to $186) |
| 2,000 to 2,399 sq ft | 104 | $369,050 | $350,000 to $413,750 | $173 ($164 to $192) |
| 2,400 sq ft and up | 47 | $500,000 | $455,000 to $582,400 | $203 ($177 to $235) |
| All detached | 188 | $377,750 | $345,000 to $459,200 | $178 ($167 to $202) |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our tabulation by the county's heated area.
The middle band is the Coco Bay core. Over 24 months, 104 of the 188 detached sales, 55.3 percent by our arithmetic, were homes of 2,000 to 2,399 heated square feet, which brackets the roll's 2,198 square foot detached median (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). That band has the deepest record, so a home in it has the most comparables an appraiser can draw on.
The per-foot figure dips in the middle band and rises at the top. Homes of 2,000 to 2,399 square feet sold at $173 per foot over 24 months, below the $180 of the smaller band, while homes of 2,400 square feet and up sold at $203 (our tabulation of the Charlotte County Property Appraiser file). Two explanations are plausible, though the record cannot prove either. Fixed costs such as the lot are spread over fewer feet in a smaller home, and the largest plans may have sold with more options or on chosen lots. A seller of a large Coco Bay home should expect a buyer's appraiser to look closely at the 2,400 and up band, where 47 sales over 24 months is a workable base but 8 in the latest year is not.
Villas need no size table. The roll's villa sizes sit in a narrow band, and 30 of the 32 villa sales in the latest 12 months were homes of 1,400 to 1,699 heated square feet, at a $249,500 median and $160 per foot; the other 2 were under 1,400 square feet, too few for a median (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Over 24 months the same band held 106 of 108 villa sales at a $257,000 median. For villas, the plat table above does the work a size table does for detached homes.
Coco Bay resales recorded higher per-foot prices than Lennar's first sales. Over the 24 months to September 9, 2026, detached resales carried a median $209 per heated square foot against $177 for first sales, 17.9 percent higher, and villa resales $193 against $176, 9.9 percent higher. Both resale groups are modest, 14 and 10 sales (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Coco Bay resales and Lennar first sales, 24 months, September 10, 2024 to September 9, 2026.
| Type | Resales | Resale median per heated sq ft | First sales | First-sale median per heated sq ft | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Detached homes | 14 | $209 | 174 | $177 | +17.9% |
| Villas | 10 | $193 | 98 | $176 | +9.9% |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our tabulation. Gaps are computed from the unrounded medians.
This is not a forecast that a Coco Bay home will rise, and three reasons explain most of the gap. First, a Lennar first sale is recorded at the contract price on the deed, and the county record does not show incentives, closing-cost credits or a rate buydown that came with it. Freddie Mac's chief appraisal officer notes that an appraiser "typically doesn't have access to the sales contract for the comparable sales" (Freddie Mac, Considering Financing and Sales Concessions, July 30, 2024). Second, a resale price includes everything the first owner bought or built: the lot Lennar charged for, design-center options, and owner additions such as a pool cage, pavers or window treatments. Third, the resale groups are small enough that one large home with a pool can lift the median.
Two more facts keep the gap in proportion. The resales were concentrated in one plat: over 24 months, 13 of the 24 resales were in the Coco Bay plat, against 5 in Island Lakes at Coco Bay and 6 in Palm Lake at Coco Bay (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). And the same homes that resold did not, as a group, sell above what their first owners paid. The 24 resales over 24 months closed at a median 2.1 percent below the price paid at the prior recorded sale, 11 above and 13 below (same source). So the higher per-foot figure for resales describes a different set of homes, often larger or more finished ones, not a gain on any particular home.
The appraisal rules point in the same direction. Fannie Mae says that in a subdivision with builder activity, "A resale is preferable if it is verifiable and does not involve the subject builder or developer," and that with builder sales "the appraisal must include discussion and analysis of sales concessions and upgrades" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08). Under that guidance, a buyer's appraiser in Coco Bay is pointed toward the 24 resales first and treat the hundreds of Lennar first sales as evidence that needs concession analysis. Your listing price should be built from the same evidence, which is how we build it.
Talk to McGreevy and Comisar before you list. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar will set your home against the Coco Bay sales that match it: same type, same plat, same size band, resales weighted first and Lennar's first sales read with their incentives in mind. Request your free Coco Bay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Shopping for a home in Coco Bay or elsewhere in Englewood instead? Marc leads the buying side: call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or read our guide to buying a home in Englewood.
Coco Bay values have moved with Lennar's pricing since the first closings in late 2023. The quarterly median per heated square foot ran $203 to $209 through 2024, fell to $166 in the third and fourth quarters of 2025, then read $176 in the first quarter of 2026 and $197 in the second, when resales made up a larger share (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Data updated: November 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026, every qualified improved Coco Bay sale from the first recorded closing on November 30, 2023 to the newest on August 24, 2026, by calendar quarter, with resales flagged; Lennar quarterly releases and Form 10-Q read November 17, 2026; FHFA House Price Index for the Punta Gorda metro through 2026 Q2).
The quarterly record shows a high plateau through 2024, a step down through 2025 and a partial recovery per foot in 2026. Sales volume peaked at 67 in the first quarter of 2025, and resales rose from none before the fourth quarter of 2024 to 8 of 32 sales in the second quarter of 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Coco Bay qualified improved sales by calendar quarter.
| Quarter | Sales | Median price | Median per heated sq ft | Resales in the quarter |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 Q4 | 12 | $410,300 | $199 | 0 |
| 2024 Q1 | 47 | $386,500 | $209 | 0 |
| 2024 Q2 | 59 | $399,300 | $206 | 0 |
| 2024 Q3 | 48 | $407,550 | $203 | 0 |
| 2024 Q4 | 42 | $390,950 | $208 | 2 |
| 2025 Q1 | 67 | $358,500 | $182 | 2 |
| 2025 Q2 | 53 | $338,700 | $175 | 1 |
| 2025 Q3 | 44 | $331,950 | $166 | 2 |
| 2025 Q4 | 42 | $312,500 | $166 | 1 |
| 2026 Q1 | 30 | $333,000 | $176 | 3 |
| 2026 Q2 | 32 | $309,800 | $197 | 8 |
| 2026 Q3, July 1 to the newest sale on August 24 | 15 | $275,000 | $190 | 5 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our tabulation. Per-foot medians use only sales with a heated area on the roll. The first quarter began with the first recorded closing on November 30, 2023; the last quarter is partial.
Read the two value columns separately. The median price column moves with what sold: a quarter heavy with villas or with vacant-coded closings prints a low median even if no home lost value. The per-foot column is steadier, because it adjusts for size, and it tells the clearer story: about $203 to $209 in every 2024 quarter, $166 in the second half of 2025, a fall of 20.6 percent from the first quarter of 2024 by our arithmetic (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Volume tells its own part. Coco Bay recorded 196 qualified sales across 2024 and 206 across 2025, then 77 from January 1 to the newest sale in August 2026, with 16 of those 77 being resales (our arithmetic on the Charlotte County Property Appraiser file). The fall in volume in 2026 is consistent with the sell-out of Palm Lake at Coco Bay and of the Island Lakes villa and Manor collections: fewer new homes left to close means fewer builder sales on the record, and more of the record is made of owner resales.
Coco Bay per-foot prices fell in 2025 as Lennar, the seller of nearly every Coco Bay home, cut its effective prices across its markets that year. Lennar's average delivered price fell from $430,000 in its fourth quarter of 2024 to $386,000 a year later, with about 14 percent in incentives and price adjustments (Lennar fourth quarter and fiscal 2025 results).
The builder said so in plain words. Its December 2025 release attributes the lower average price "primarily" to "continued weakness in the market," says "we maintained approximately 14% in incentives and price adjustments, while continuing to focus on volume," and quotes Co-CEO Jon Jaffe: "We continued to utilize incentives, including mortgage rate buydowns, to sustain sales momentum" (Lennar fourth quarter and fiscal 2025 results). The same release puts Lennar's gross margin on home sales at 17.0 percent in that quarter against 22.1 percent a year earlier. Those are company-wide figures, not Coco Bay figures, but they describe the seller who set almost every Coco Bay price in 2025.
Lennar's filings also show the size of the incentive in its Florida segment. In the quarter ended August 31, 2025, Lennar's East segment, which it defines as Florida, New Jersey and Pennsylvania, averaged $77,600 in sales incentives per home delivered, 17.6 percent of revenue (Lennar Form 10-Q, quarter ended August 31, 2026). That quarter overlaps Coco Bay's third quarter of 2025, the first of its two $166 per-foot quarters. An incentive that large can show up in a deed price as a lower contract price, or sit outside it as a closing-cost credit or a rate buydown, and the county record cannot tell which.
The wider market moved the same way. The federal repeat-sales index for the Punta Gorda metro, which is all of Charlotte County, read 433.09 in the fourth quarter of 2024 and 385.05 in the third quarter of 2025, a fall of 11.1 percent by our arithmetic (FHFA all-transactions index via FRED). Builders nationally were cutting too: the home builders' association reported that "41% of builders reported cutting prices in November" 2025, "a record high in the post-Covid period" (NAHB, November 2025). A builder selling new homes in Charlotte County had to price against a resale market that was resetting, and Coco Bay's per-foot record shows Lennar doing it.
For an owner the 2025 drop has a specific meaning. A Coco Bay home bought from Lennar in 2024 at about $203 to $209 per foot now has comparables recorded at quarterly medians of $166 to $197. Of the 17 resales in the latest 12 months, 8 had a prior sale in 2024 and 6 of those closed below the earlier price, while 6 of the 8 whose prior sale was in 2025 or later closed above it; both are small groups, so we draw no percentage from them (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). When you bought can shape the comparison as much as what you bought.
Coco Bay's 2026 quarters show per-foot medians of $176, $197 and $190, above the $166 of late 2025, but those quarters carry more resales: 3 of 30 sales, 8 of 32 and 5 of 15. Quarterly medians shift with the mix of homes sold, so 2026 is not a price jump, and the price median of $275,000 in the third quarter is not a slide (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
The second quarter of 2026 shows the mix at work. Of its 8 resales, 5 were villas and 3 were detached homes, and resales carry higher per-foot figures than Lennar's first sales, so a quarter with a quarter of its sales as resales prints a higher per-foot median even if no single home changed value (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The third quarter is partial, with 15 sales through August 24, 2026, and 3 of its 5 resales were villas, which helps explain why its price median read $275,000 while its per-foot median held at $190.
The builder side also shifted in 2026. Lennar's East segment incentive fell to $48,000 per home delivered in the quarter ended August 31, 2026, 11.5 percent of revenue, against $77,600 and 17.6 percent a year earlier, and the 10-Q says "sales incentives on deliveries declined during the quarter" (Lennar Form 10-Q, quarter ended August 31, 2026). Company-wide, Lennar's average delivered price was $372,000 in that quarter, which it described as "reflecting approximately 12.0% in incentives, along with base price adjustments necessary to sustain volume" (Lennar third quarter 2026 results release, PR Newswire copy; Lennar Form 10-Q, quarter ended August 31, 2026). Smaller incentives are consistent with Coco Bay's all-sales per-foot median reading $176 in the first quarter of 2026 after $166, but the record cannot prove the link, and the numbers are company and segment figures.
Lennar has also named the resale seller as its competitor. Executive Chairman Stuart Miller said on the third-quarter call, as HousingWire reported: "The resale seller has become a more aggressive competitor for our customer, especially at our price range ... When a resale seller cuts price, they are competing directly for our customer, and we respond" (HousingWire, Lennar Q3 2026 earnings). In Coco Bay that competition is literal: a resale in Island Lakes at Coco Bay and a new Lennar Executive home can be a few streets apart. Until Lennar sells its last home, which a Lennar representative put at "the middle of 2027" in the Island Lake Estates CDD's April 14, 2026 minutes (Island Lake Estates CDD minutes, April 14, 2026), the builder's price sheet sits beside every Coco Bay value.
The county figures for the same months are steady rather than rising. Charlotte County's single-family median was $345,000 in October 2026, up 0.9 percent from a year earlier, on 404 closed sales (Florida Realtors, October 2026 MSA summary), and the federal repeat-sales index for the county's metro read 391.34 in the second quarter of 2026, close to its 385.05 low in the third quarter of 2025 (FHFA all-transactions index via FRED). That is the backdrop for a Coco Bay owner in late 2026: a flat county market, a builder still selling, and a resale record that is growing quarter by quarter.
Build year matters less in Coco Bay than type, plat and size, because every home is new. Over 24 months, detached homes built in 2024 sold at a $389,600 median ($181 per heated square foot, 114 sales) and those built in 2025 at $360,000 ($175, 73 sales); villas built in 2024 sold at $250,000 ($176, 76 sales) and in 2025 at $268,000 ($187, 32 sales) (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Coco Bay sales by roll build year and type.
| Type and build year | 12 months: sales | 12 months: median price | 12 months: median per heated sq ft | 24 months: sales | 24 months: median price | 24 months: median per heated sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Detached, built 2023 | 1 (one sale) | not computed | not computed | 1 (one sale) | not computed | not computed |
| Detached, built 2024 | 9 (a small group) | $355,000 | $177 | 114 | $389,600 | $181 |
| Detached, built 2025 | 45 | $346,600 | $173 | 73 | $360,000 | $175 |
| Villas, built 2024 | 19 | $248,000 | $159 | 76 | $250,000 | $176 |
| Villas, built 2025 | 13 | $268,000 | $188 | 32 | $268,000 | $187 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our tabulation by the roll's year built. Windows end September 9, 2026.
The build year mostly records when Lennar sold the home. A detached home built in 2024 most often closed in 2024, near the $203 to $209 per-foot quarters, while one built in 2025 most often closed in 2025, near the $166 to $182 quarters, so the 24-month gap between the two years, $389,600 against $360,000, is mostly the 2025 price reset and not the age of the house (our reading of the Charlotte County Property Appraiser file). In the latest 12 months, when both groups sold into the same market, detached homes built in 2024 and 2025 sat close together at $177 and $173 per foot, though the 2024 group has only 9 sales.
Villas run the other way. Villas built in 2025 sold above villas built in 2024 on both windows, $268,000 against $250,000 over 24 months and $187 against $176 per foot (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The plat explains much of this: the plat table above shows Palm Lake at Coco Bay villas at $155 per foot and Island Lakes at Coco Bay villas at $190, so which plat's villas were built in which year moves the build-year line. A 2024 villa is not worth less because it is a year older; it is priced against villas in its own plat.
Age will start to matter later. For a 2023 to 2025 home the roof, the systems and the Lennar warranty are all recent, and a buyer's appraiser rates condition on what is observed. The second part of this page covers the roof-age rules, the warranty a buyer inherits and how condition ratings work under the appraisal form that became mandatory on November 2, 2026.
The fastest way to a free Coco Bay home valuation is the address form below the page header: about a minute, no fee, and the request goes to Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, who price your Coco Bay home by hand from the county's recorded sales for your type, plat and size band, never from a website estimate.
Enter your Coco Bay address in the valuation form below the page header and tell us your timing: listing soon, sometime next year, or simply checking. Prefer to talk first? Call Jesse McGreevy direct at (239) 898-6072 or Marc Comisar at (239) 287-5873. There is no fee and no obligation.
You will be working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012. Request your free Coco Bay home valuation from anywhere on this page. We start with your parcel on the county roll: its plat, its use code (detached or villa), the heated area and year built the county records, and the sales that belong beside it among the 129 qualified Coco Bay sales of the latest 12 months (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). If you are still deciding whether to sell, our Coco Bay seller guide walks through the listing, and our Coco Bay guide covers the plats, collections and streets around your home.
If you own elsewhere in town, the same method runs on our Englewood home valuation page, and our guide to selling a home in Englewood and Englewood area guide cover the wider market. Owners in nearby communities can read our Grove City home valuation, Englewood East home valuation, Boca Royale home valuation and Beachwalk by Manasota Key home valuation. Each uses its own county file and its own comparables, because none of those places has Coco Bay's builder-heavy record. If you are weighing a newer home against yours, our page on new construction in Englewood covers the builders a Coco Bay buyer may also visit.
Nothing is required to start a Coco Bay valuation, but six papers sharpen it: your Lennar closing statement, your options and upgrades list, permits for anything added after closing, your 2026 tax bill with its Island Lake Estates CDD line, your insurance declarations and wind mitigation form, and any flood elevation or FEMA letter for your lot.
Before we give a Coco Bay number we check seven things: type, plat, heated size and plan, build and sale year, the lot, what was added, and the carrying cost on the bill. Each one moved Coco Bay prices in the record above, and together they narrow the type median to a range for one home.
You receive a written comparative market analysis for your Coco Bay home: a price range, every recorded Coco Bay sale we used with its type, plat, heated area and month, the adjustments for each, the Lennar homes your buyer can tour instead, and an estimate of what you would net. Under Florida law it is an opinion of value, never an appraisal.
Florida's licensing law exempts a broker or sales associate who "performs a comparative market analysis, gives a broker price opinion, or gives an opinion of value of real estate," but adds that "in no event may this comparative market analysis, broker price opinion, or opinion of value of real estate be referred to as an appraisal" (Florida Statutes 475.25). Your buyer's lender orders its own appraisal; our job is to set a price that appraisal will support, using the resales and builder sales the appraiser will reach for.
What the file holds:
On timing: the form takes about a minute, and Jesse or Marc follows up directly to confirm your home's details. The written analysis follows once we have your parcel and papers; a home with a closing statement and permits in hand is the quickest to value.
Still choosing who should prepare it? Our page on the best real estate agents in Englewood sets out what to ask any listing agent and where to check the answers. Talk to McGreevy and Comisar before you list: request your free Coco Bay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
An online estimate struggles with a Coco Bay home because its training data is almost all one builder's sales. Of 338 qualified Coco Bay sales over 24 months, 314 were Lennar first sales and only 24 were resales, and the deeds show none of the incentives behind the builder prices (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Data updated: November 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026; one national brokerage's published estimate accuracy figures, read November 17, 2026; the federal AVM rule, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae guidance as cited).
Automated valuation models learn from recorded sales, and in Coco Bay those are mostly Lennar's. Resales did not begin until the fourth quarter of 2024 and numbered 24 by August 24, 2026, against 467 builder first sales over the community's whole recorded history (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). A model has little open-market evidence to learn from.
Three features of the Coco Bay record trip a model. First, the builder's prices moved fast: $209 per heated square foot in the first quarter of 2024, $166 by the third quarter of 2025, and $176 to $197 in 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). A model that weights the older, higher sales prices too high; one that weights only the 2025 low prices too low. Second, the roll is thin on the facts a model reads: on the November 5, 2026 roll, no Coco Bay detached home or villa carries a bedroom or bathroom count (same source). Third, many recent closings are on parcels the roll still lists as vacant land, 42 of the latest 12 months' 129 sales, so a model can find a home sale with no house attached to it.
What a model does with plats shows the risk. Over 24 months, Palm Lake at Coco Bay villas sold at $155 per foot and Coco Bay plat villas at $197 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). A model that blends the three plats into one Coco Bay rate overprices one villa and underprices the other. On a 1,423 square foot villa the $42 per-foot gap is $59,766 (our multiplication), roughly a quarter of a villa's price.
Lennar's current listings are a fourth blind spot. A model values recorded sales, not the builder price sheet a buyer can read today, yet that sheet is what a Coco Bay buyer compares against. Fannie Mae treats "Contract offerings and current listings" as supporting data only (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08), and a model built on recorded sales does not see them as sales at all.
One national brokerage publishes accuracy figures for its own online estimate, and for Florida homes not on the market its page, read November 17, 2026, gives a 7.56 percent median error, with 36.36 percent of estimates within 5 percent. On a $350,000 Coco Bay detached median that median error is about $26,460, and on the $249,500 villa median about $18,860 (our arithmetic on the Charlotte County Property Appraiser medians).
The same brokerage page reports far smaller errors for homes listed for sale, 2.06 percent in Florida, and credits its direct access to multiple listing services for that (estimate accuracy page, read November 17, 2026). The gap between the two is the point: once a home is listed, the estimate leans on the list price. Before it is listed, which is when an owner wants a value, the error is several times larger.
Those are statewide and national figures; no estimate provider publishes an error figure for Coco Bay or Charlotte County, and we found no independent study of estimate error in new-construction communities. A median error is the middle case, so half of off-market estimates miss by more. In Coco Bay, where a detached home's middle half already spans $325,000 to $415,000 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser), an error of $26,460 can move a home from the middle of its band to the edge. We name online estimates because owners ask about them; we never use them as data.
For a Coco Bay home, the work a model cannot do is reading the incentives, the plat and the builder's sheet that a model cannot see.
Lennar's incentives stay off the Coco Bay deed because the county records one price per sale and itemizes nothing. A closing-cost credit or a rate buydown paid through Lennar Mortgage changes what the buyer paid each month or at closing without changing the recorded price, and Lennar's own current offer shows how large those can be (Lennar, Black Friday Sales Event).
Lennar's Sarasota-area promotion, read November 17, 2026, offers "up to $15,000 in closing costs" and a payment example "with a promotional Lennar Mortgage, LLC 7/6 ARM of 4.750% (7.221% APR)" for contracts "between 11/16/26 and 11/30/26," and states "Offer requires financing through Lennar Mortgage, LLC" (Lennar, Black Friday Sales Event, builder-stated, subject to change). The promotion page does not name Coco Bay, so whether a given Coco Bay homesite qualifies is a question for Lennar's sales office. On a Coco Bay home, $15,000 would be 4.3 percent of the $350,000 detached median (our arithmetic on the Charlotte County Property Appraiser figure).
None of that reaches the record an online estimate reads. Freddie Mac's chief appraisal officer wrote that "many sellers and homebuilders in the current market are offering additional concessions and rate buydowns" and that any adjustment "should approximate the market's reaction to the financing or concessions" (Freddie Mac, Considering Financing and Sales Concessions, July 30, 2024). Fannie Mae adds that "Positive adjustments for sales or financing concessions are not acceptable" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09). An appraiser can only adjust a concession-loaded Lennar sale down toward a cash price, never adjust your resale up to match it; a model does neither.
The builder's sheet hides a second gap. On November 17, 2026, two Lennar homes of the same plan in Island Lakes at Coco Bay were listed $89,608 apart on Lennar's site, and Lennar does not say whether the lot, the options or the completion stage explains it (Lennar, Island Lakes at Coco Bay, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026, subject to change). When the builder's own prices for one plan sit that far apart, a model that reads plan and size alone has no way to place a Coco Bay resale correctly.
The federal automated valuation model rule, effective October 1, 2025, makes mortgage originators and secondary market issuers hold the models they use on a borrower's principal dwelling to quality control standards. It covers a lender's model on a Coco Bay loan; it does not cover the estimate a Coco Bay owner sees on a home-value website (Federal Register, FR Doc. 2024-16197).
The rule defines an automated valuation model as "any computerized model used by mortgage originators and secondary market issuers to determine the collateral worth" of a mortgage secured by a principal dwelling (Federal Register, FR Doc. 2024-16197, via GovInfo). Six agencies issued it, the CFPB, the FDIC, the FHFA, the Federal Reserve Board, the NCUA and the OCC, and it requires covered institutions to adopt controls that "ensure a high level of confidence in estimates; protect against data manipulation; seek to avoid conflicts of interest; require random sample testing and reviews; and comply with nondiscrimination laws" (CFPB, July 17, 2024).
Three points follow for a Coco Bay owner. The rule protects the lending process: when a lender uses a model in place of, or alongside, an appraisal for a Coco Bay buyer's loan, that model is under quality control. The rule sets process standards, not an accuracy limit, so it does not make any figure right. And the rule does not reach consumer websites, so the number on a home-value page about a Coco Bay address answers to no regulator. Use it as a rough starting point at most, and test it against the type and plat medians on this page.
Searches mix up the two because they share a name. Coco Bay in Englewood is a Lennar community of three recorded plats in Charlotte County, with Englewood 34224 addresses; Coco Bay at Pelican Bay is in Naples, a separate market in another county. A value, a listing or a sale price for one says nothing about the other (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
The names inside the Englewood community add a second layer. Lennar markets its sections as Island Lakes at Coco Bay and Palm Lake at Coco Bay and lists them under its Sarasota-Manatee division, although the homes sit in Charlotte County (Lennar, Island Lakes at Coco Bay, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026). The county roll uses the three plat names, Coco Bay, Island Lakes at Coco Bay and Palm Lake at Coco Bay, and our research also turned up an unrelated "Coco Bay" homeowners association in Coconut Creek, Florida (our Coco Bay guide). A search on the bare name can return any of these.
That matters for value in a practical way. A sales list or a "homes sold nearby" panel built on a name match can mix Naples prices into a Coco Bay estimate, or split one community into three when a site uses plat names inconsistently. Every figure on this page is drawn from the 601 parcels of the three Charlotte County plats and nothing else (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). When you compare any outside number with ours, check first that it describes the same place.
Honest sources print different Coco Bay numbers because they measure different things: a 12-month or 24-month window, all sales or one type, a deed price or a tax value, or a builder's asking price. Each can be correct and still sit more than $100,000 from another (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
| Figure | What it measures | Period and source |
|---|---|---|
| $315,000 | Median of 129 Coco Bay qualified improved sales, all types | September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026, Charlotte County Property Appraiser |
| $335,400 | Median of 338 Coco Bay qualified improved sales | September 10, 2024 to September 9, 2026, same source |
| $350,000 | Median of 55 Coco Bay detached sales | 12 months to September 9, 2026, same source |
| $249,500 | Median of 32 Coco Bay villa sales | 12 months to September 9, 2026, same source |
| $290,992 | Median 2026 just value of the 287 detached homes, a tax figure | January 1, 2026 roll, our computation from the county roll, same source |
| $208,547 | Median 2026 just value of the 158 villas, a tax figure | January 1, 2026 roll, same computation |
| $345,000 | Charlotte County single-family median | October 2026, Florida Realtors |
| $372,000 | Lennar's company-wide average delivered price | Quarter ended August 31, 2026, Lennar Form 10-Q |
None of these corrects another. The $350,000 detached median and the $290,992 detached just value describe the same set of homes, $59,008 apart (our arithmetic), because one is what buyers paid and the other is the county's January 1 tax value after its cost-of-sale step; for 2025 detached sales, the 2026 just value ran a median 80.5 percent of the sale price (127 sales), and 81.0 percent for villas (79 sales) (our computation from the county roll, Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The county median covers every kind of Charlotte County home, and Lennar's average covers its whole national business. Your Coco Bay home has one price, and it comes from the sales that match it.
Talk to McGreevy and Comisar before you list: request your free Coco Bay home valuation or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, and you will have the recorded Coco Bay sales behind your number, in writing. If you are weighing a sale, our Coco Bay seller guide shows what comes next, and our Coco Bay guide maps the plats your number depends on. Shopping for a home in Coco Bay instead? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or read our guide to buying a home in Coco Bay.
A Coco Bay home's value moves first with its product, a detached Lennar house or an attached villa, then with heated size, collection and plat. Over the last 12 months detached homes sold at a $350,000 median and villas at $249,500, a gap no lot, upgrade or paint job closes (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Data updated: November 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026, qualified improved sales through September 9, 2026, newest August 24, 2026; 12-month window September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026; 24-month window September 10, 2024 to September 9, 2026; Lennar pages read November 17, 2026; Cost vs Value 2025, Fort Myers).
Coco Bay's Lennar homes are all new. County records show 18 homes built in 2023, 325 in 2024 and 102 in 2025, so age, the usual first question in an Englewood valuation, barely separates one Coco Bay house from another (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). What separates them is the plan Lennar built, the lot it sits on, what the owner added after closing, and the papers that come with the house: the roof date, the wind mitigation form, the flood file and the warranty. This section takes those levers one at a time. Every per-square-foot figure here is per square foot of the county's heated (living) area, not a listing sheet's total. For the streets, amenities and history, start with our Coco Bay guide; for how a price becomes a listing, see our Coco Bay seller guide.
It is the largest single lever in Coco Bay. County records show 287 detached homes and 158 attached villas on the November 5, 2026 roll, and over 12 months detached homes sold at $173 per heated square foot (n=55) against $162 for villas (n=32), so the villa sells for less in total and less per foot (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
That second point runs against the usual rule. Smaller homes normally carry a higher price per square foot because the kitchen, baths and lot cost the same whether the house is big or small. In Coco Bay the villa is smaller (a 1,423 square foot median on the roll, against 2,198 for detached homes) and still cheaper per foot, which suggests buyers price the shared wall and the narrower lot, not only the floor area (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The roll keeps the two apart with separate use codes, and Lennar's own villa pages describe the Magnolia and Orchid as "Villas" without saying attached or detached (Lennar Magnolia included features). An appraiser who compares a Coco Bay villa with a detached Coco Bay home of similar size is starting from the wrong comparable.
The villa sizes are also tightly bunched. The middle half of villas on the roll runs from 1,422 to 1,564 heated square feet, which lines up with Lennar's two villa plans, the 1,417 square foot Magnolia and the 1,564 square foot Orchid (Charlotte County Property Appraiser; Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay brochure). With so little size spread, a Coco Bay villa's value turns on plat, condition and the papers more than on footage. The detached middle half, 2,027 to 2,264 square feet, is tight too, so the larger detached plans stand out.
The plan name matters as much as the footage. Lennar's Coco Bay pages list 14 named plans, from the 1,417 square foot Magnolia to the 2,799 square foot Bougainvillea II, and the largest detached homes sold at the highest median rate per heated foot (Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay brochure; Lennar Palm Lake at Coco Bay brochure).
The price section of this page sets out the size-band tables. The point for a valuation is what the bands mean in plan terms. Over 12 months detached homes of 2,400 heated square feet and up sold at a $195 median per foot, a small group of 8 sales, against $175 for 1,700 to 1,999 square feet (n=19) and $170 for 2,000 to 2,399 (n=28) (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The 2,400 and up group draws on Lennar's largest Manor and Estate plans, the Summerville II at 2,444 square feet and the Sunset and Bougainvillea II at 2,650 and 2,799, whose Lennar "from" prices work out to $191 to $229 a foot (our arithmetic) (Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay brochure; Lennar Palm Lake at Coco Bay brochure). Because that group is under 10 sales we draw no percentage conclusion from it, only the direction: in Coco Bay, the size class and collection move the rate, not only the total footage.
Plan names also carry hidden differences. Lennar's Island Lakes brochure says "Floorplan may vary by homesite" and "All features and products can vary by collection," and its Palm Lake Executive Homes list an electric smooth cooktop where the Island Lakes Executive list names a gas slide-in range (Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay brochure; Lennar Palm Lake at Coco Bay brochure). Two Coco Bay homes sold as a Trevi or a Marsala are close comparables, not identical ones. That is why we ask for your purchase agreement: it names the plan, elevation and options Lennar actually built.
The plat tells a buyer which Lennar collections sit on the street. Island Lakes at Coco Bay offered Villas, Executive Homes and Manor Homes; Palm Lake at Coco Bay offered Villas, Executive Homes and Estate Homes; the original plat has 5 vacant-coded lots and no current Lennar sales page (Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay brochure).
The Island Lake Estates Community Development District's own budget confirms the split by lot width. Its "Coco Bay" group, which covers the original Coco Bay plat and Island Lakes at Coco Bay together, plans 106 paired villas on 40 foot lots, 215 Executive Homes on 52 foot lots and 79 Manor Homes on 65 foot lots; its "Palm Lake" group plans 78 paired villas on 36 foot lots, 71 Executive Homes on 52 foot lots and 22 Estate Homes on 72 foot lots, 571 homes in all (Island Lake Estates CDD adopted FY2027 budget). A Palm Lake villa sits on a narrower lot than a Coco Bay plat villa, and the sales point the same way.
The price section above carries the plat table. Read it with the lot widths in mind: over 12 months Palm Lake at Coco Bay villas sold at a $157 median per heated square foot (n=18), while Coco Bay plat villas recorded $193, a small group of 7 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The Coco Bay plat figures also carry more resales: 7 of its 13 qualified improved sales in the 12 months were resales, a small group (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). We treat the direction as real and the size of the gap as unproven until more sales close. For a detached home the plat gap is narrower, and the collection (Executive, Manor or Estate) does more of the work.
Yes in direction, but no public source puts a dollar or percentage on it for Coco Bay. Lennar's homesite pages read November 17, 2026 print "Lot size: Not listed," "View (lake/preserve/water): Not listed" and "Lot or homesite premium: Not listed," and the county's 2026 land values barely vary by lot position (Lennar Carson homesite page).
The county side shows why the tax roll cannot settle the question. The 2026 roll's median land value is $28,050 for a detached Coco Bay home and $17,000 for a villa, with almost no spread for lake or interior position, because the appraiser values land in mass, by product, not by view (our cut of the Charlotte County Property Appraiser 2026 roll). So neither the builder nor the county will tell a buyer what your water view is worth.
Lenders' appraisers are held to the market. Fannie Mae says "The appraiser's adjustments must reflect the market's reaction," and that site amenities "may either detract from or enhance the marketability of a site" (Fannie Mae B4-1.3-09; Fannie Mae B4-1.3-04). In Coco Bay that means a lake-lot adjustment has to come from paired Coco Bay sales, same plan, same quarter, lake against interior, not from what Lennar charged at contract. With only 17 resales in the last 12 months, those pairs are thin, which is why we read lake, preserve and corner lots as a direction in a CMA and never print a premium.
Lennar's "Everything's Included" package makes most resale upgrades standard in Coco Bay. Quartz counters, stainless appliances, a washer and dryer, blinds, impact windows and sliders, a smart lock, thermostat and doorbell, and irrigation appear on Lennar's Coco Bay feature lists, so every Coco Bay comparable has them (Lennar Magnolia included features).
Standard features Lennar lists for Coco Bay homes (builder-stated, read November 17, 2026).
| Area | What Lennar lists as included | Valuation meaning in Coco Bay |
|---|---|---|
| Kitchen | Quartz countertops with 4 inch backsplash, stainless slide-in gas range (Island Lakes) or smooth cooktop (Palm Lake), over-the-range microwave, side-by-side refrigerator, dishwasher | Shared by every comparable, no adjustment |
| Baths | Quartz in all bathrooms, owner's walk-in shower with glass enclosure (per plan), double sinks | Shared, no adjustment |
| Laundry and interior | Washer and dryer, 2 inch faux wood blinds, tile in kitchen and baths, ceiling fan pre-wire | Shared, no adjustment |
| Storm protection | Hurricane-impact windows and sliding doors; "Code compliant hurricane panels" on the Magnolia villa page | Shared; supports a wind mitigation credit |
| Smart home | Ring Video Doorbell Pro, Honeywell Home T6 Pro Z-Wave thermostat, smart front door lock | Shared; a working set is a condition point |
| Exterior | Concrete block and stucco, painted entry door, finished garage, automatic irrigation | Shared, no adjustment |
Sources: Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay brochure; Lennar Palm Lake at Coco Bay brochure; Lennar Magnolia included features. The page notes that the New Home Consultant or purchase agreement determines actual features.
The practical rule follows. A Coco Bay listing that leads with impact glass or quartz is describing the neighborhood, not the house. What separates your home is what sits outside that list: a larger plan or collection, the homesite, a pool and cage, an extended or screened lanai, a generator, flooring beyond the tile Lennar put in wet areas, and how well the house has been kept. Those are the items we ask you to document, with receipts and permits, before we set a number.
Less than they cost. The 2025 Cost vs Value report for Fort Myers puts a generator at 94.7 percent recovered at resale, a backyard patio at 41.4 percent and solar at 29.8 percent; it has no pool project, so a Coco Bay pool's value must come from local sales (JLC Cost vs Value 2025, Fort Myers).
What remodeling and add-on projects recouped at resale, Fort Myers, 2025 (survey estimates, not Coco Bay sales).
| Project | Average cost | Resale value | Share recouped |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garage door replacement | $5,302 | $12,300 | 232 percent |
| Entry door replacement, steel | $2,383 | $4,498 | 188.8 percent |
| Minor kitchen remodel, midrange | $28,579 | $29,977 | 104.9 percent |
| Backup power generator | $13,516 | $12,797 | 94.7 percent |
| Deck addition, composite | $24,222 | $18,826 | 77.7 percent |
| Bath remodel, midrange | $26,113 | $19,797 | 75.8 percent |
| Backyard patio | $49,259 | $20,404 | 41.4 percent |
| Solar power installation | $55,694 | $16,585 | 29.8 percent |
Source: JLC Cost vs Value 2025, Fort Myers, which compares average costs for 28 projects with the value they retain at resale in 119 U.S. markets.
Read the table for a home built in 2023 to 2025. The replacement projects at the top (garage doors, entry doors, kitchens) do not apply to a Coco Bay house that is two years old. The additions Coco Bay owners actually make are lower on the list: a generator recovers most of its cost, while a patio or lanai extension and rooftop solar recover well under half. Florida law helps a little on two of them. A homeowners' association must adopt hurricane protection specifications, counts "exterior fixed generators, fuel storage tanks" as hurricane protection, and "may not deny" a conforming application (Fla. Stat. 720.3035); a covenant "may not prohibit" solar collectors, though the association may choose the roof location if that does not impair operation (Fla. Stat. 163.04).
A pool needs its own note. A new residential pool in Florida must have at least one listed safety feature (a barrier, an approved safety cover, exit alarms, self-closing door latches or a certified pool alarm) (Fla. Stat. 515.27). For a valuation, a permitted pool and cage with final inspections is a feature a buyer's appraiser can count; an unpermitted one is a question the buyer's lender and insurer will ask before closing. Bring the permit numbers and the association approval letter, and we will look for Coco Bay sales of the same plan with and without a pool before we put a figure on it.
They support value more than they move it, because every Coco Bay home shares them. Florida bars an insurer from refusing to write or renew a homeowner policy solely for roof age when the roof is under 15 years old, and Coco Bay roofs date from 2023 to 2025, so none reaches 15 years before 2038 (Fla. Stat. 627.7011).
Roof age is a real strength against older Englewood resales. Under the same statute, a roof 15 years or older must show "5 years or more of useful life remaining" on an authorized inspection to avoid refusal for age alone (Fla. Stat. 627.7011). Citizens now retrieves the "year of last roof update" automatically from Verisk for new business with effective dates on or after August 1, 2026, and asks for proof only if the year is changed (Citizens bulletin, July 1, 2026). Inside Coco Bay the roof is neutral; against a 1990s Englewood resale it is a plus.
Wind construction works the same way. Florida insurers must offer "actuarially reasonable discounts, credits, or other rate differentials" for wind-resistant features (Fla. Stat. 627.0629), and the state's consumer guide says homes built to the 2001 Florida Building Code or later are "automatically eligible for a minimum 68% discount on the windstorm coverage of the premium," with a new inspection form required for inspections on or after April 1, 2026 and a completed form valid for five years (Florida CFO hurricane mitigation guide). The value point is the paper: a Coco Bay resale with a current wind mitigation form quotes at the credit on day one.
The warranty is the last piece. Lennar's Coco Bay Magnolia page lists a "Limited one-year warranty on workmanship," a "One-year warranty on mechanical systems" and a "10-year structural warranty" (Lennar Magnolia included features). Florida's builder warranty statute requires at least one year of coverage against defects that are a material building code violation, running from the original conveyance and honored "even if the newly constructed home is sold or transferred," and requires a longer warranty to state whether it transfers beyond one year (Fla. Stat. 553.837). For most Coco Bay homes, closed in 2024, the one-year terms have passed; the structural term runs into the early 2030s (our arithmetic from the roll's build years). Confirm the transfer wording in your own Lennar booklet, and hand it to buyers.
Condition is where owners differ. Fannie Mae rates a never-occupied home C1 and an almost-new home with no deferred maintenance C2 (Fannie Mae B4-1.3-06). Every resale steps from C1 to C2 at move-in, while Lennar's inventory down the street is C1. A clean HVAC record, working irrigation and smart devices, and fresh paint keep a Coco Bay home at the top of C2.
Want a number that counts your plan, lot and additions? Request a Coco Bay home valuation built from your Lennar plan, homesite and permits. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
While Lennar still sells in Island Lakes at Coco Bay, its price sheet is the first number a buyer compares with your Coco Bay home. Builder-stated Executive Home base prices, read November 17, 2026, run $309,999 to $416,999, and the base rate per foot sits almost on 12-month Coco Bay sale medians (Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay).
Data updated: November 2026 (Lennar community, collection, homesite and promotion pages read November 17, 2026, builder-stated and subject to change; Lennar Q3 fiscal 2026 results and Form 10-Q for the quarter ended August 31, 2026; Island Lake Estates CDD minutes of April 14, 2026; Charlotte County Property Appraiser sales through September 9, 2026).
A builder still selling in the same subdivision is the toughest comparable a resale seller faces. The buyer who tours your Coco Bay home can walk to a Lennar model, see a new house of the same plan, a C1 condition rating and a financing offer, and ask why yours should cost more. This section reads what Lennar lists, how its base prices line up with recorded sales, what its incentives are worth, which segments it no longer sells, and when its own representative expects it to finish. Lennar's figures below are builder-stated, read November 17, 2026, and subject to change; we date every one.
On November 17, 2026 Lennar showed Island Lakes at Coco Bay as "Actively selling," with five homesites available, Executive Homes the only collection still offered, and Manor Homes, Villas and all of Palm Lake at Coco Bay reading sold out. These are builder-stated base prices, read November 17, 2026, subject to change (Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay).
Lennar's Coco Bay plans and "from" prices (builder-stated, read November 17, 2026, subject to change).
| Plat | Collection | Plan | Bed / bath | Heated sq ft | Builder-stated from price | From price per sq ft (our arithmetic) | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay | Executive Homes | Armstrong | 3 / 2 | 1,635 | $309,999 | $190 | Selling |
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay | Executive Homes | Venice | 3 / 3 | 1,849 | $386,999 | $209 | Selling |
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay | Executive Homes | Carson | 4 / 3 | 1,933 | $346,999 | $180 | Selling |
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay | Executive Homes | Trevi | 4 / 3 | 2,032 | $391,999 | $193 | Selling |
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay | Executive Homes | Goodall | 3 / 3 | 2,198 | $373,999 | $170 | Selling |
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay | Executive Homes | Marsala | 3 / 3 | 2,201 | $416,999 | $189 | Selling |
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay | Manor Homes | Princeton II, Tivoli, Summerville II | 3 or 4 / 2 or 3 | 2,244 to 2,444 | $426,999 to $466,999 | $190 to $191 | Sold out |
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay | Villas | Magnolia, Orchid | 3 / 2 and 2 / 2 | 1,417 and 1,564 | $294,999 and $304,999 | $208 and $195 | Sold out |
| Palm Lake at Coco Bay | Estate Homes | Napoli II, Sunset, Bougainvillea II | 3 / 2.5 or 3 | 2,395 to 2,799 | $541,999 to $639,999 (last shown) | $217 to $229 | Sold out |
Sources: Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay; Lennar Island Lakes Executive Homes; Lennar Palm Lake at Coco Bay brochure. Per-foot figures divide Lennar's from price by Lennar's stated square footage.
Lennar's own ranges do not agree with its plan prices, which is a reason to read homesites, not headers. The community header reads "$292,999 to $464,999," while the Summerville II on the same page is "from $466,999," and the Executive Homes collection header reads $379,999 to $409,999 against plan prices of $309,999 to $416,999 (Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay brochure; Lennar Island Lakes Executive Homes). Lennar's page also labels no homesite with a reduced price. A buyer comparing your home with "Lennar's price" may be looking at any of these numbers, so we pull the actual homesite prices on the day we value your home.
Closely. The Carson homesite listed at $339,999 works out to $175.89 per square foot, against a $175 median for Coco Bay detached sales of 1,700 to 1,999 heated square feet over 12 months (n=19), and the Goodall base of $373,999 is $170.15, against $170 for 2,000 to 2,399 square feet (n=28) (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Lennar base prices beside 12-month Coco Bay detached sale medians in the same size band (builder prices read November 17, 2026; sales September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026).
| Lennar plan (heated sq ft) | Builder-stated price | Per sq ft (our arithmetic) | Coco Bay detached size band | 12-month sales | Median price | Median per heated sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Armstrong (1,635) | $309,999 from | $190 | 1,400 to 1,699 | 0 | no sales in the window | no sales in the window |
| Carson (1,933), under-construction homesite | $339,999 | $175.89 | 1,700 to 1,999 | 19 | $325,000 | $175 |
| Carson (1,933), from price | $346,999 | $180 | 1,700 to 1,999 | 19 | $325,000 | $175 |
| Goodall (2,198) | $373,999 from | $170.15 | 2,000 to 2,399 | 28 | $360,000 | $170 |
| Marsala (2,201) | $416,999 from | $189 | 2,000 to 2,399 | 28 | $360,000 | $170 |
Sources: Lennar Island Lakes Executive Homes; our cut of the Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026 and its sales file. County figures use heated area; Lennar figures use Lennar's stated square footage, which can count space differently.
The match is the anchor, not the answer. Most 12-month Coco Bay sales were Lennar's own first sales recorded at the deed price, so it is no surprise that Lennar's sheet and the recorded median sit together. The middle half of 2,000 to 2,399 square foot detached sales ran from $342,275 to $401,625 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser), so a Goodall or Marsala resale can land well above or below the base depending on lot, options and condition. A resale priced above Lennar's sheet has to show the buyer what the sheet does not include: a pool, a cage, an extended lanai, window treatments, a finished yard and a move-in date with no construction wait.
There is a second reading in the 24-month figures. Over 24 months, Coco Bay resales carried a higher median rate per heated foot than Lennar's first retail sales: detached $209 against $177 (resales n=14), villas $193 against $176 (resales n=10) (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Both resale groups are small, and the first-sale figure is a contract price after incentives while a resale price includes the lot, options and the owner's additions. It does not mean every resale beats Lennar's sheet; it means finished homes with extras have sold above the base.
Because Lennar prices each homesite separately and does not say why. On November 17, 2026 Lennar listed two Carson homes of the same 1,933 square feet in Island Lakes at Coco Bay at $429,607 (move-in ready) and $339,999 (under construction), $89,608 apart, or $222 against $176 per square foot (Lennar Island Lakes Executive Homes).
Lennar's homesite pages show no lot size, view or premium field, so the gap is some mix of homesite, structural options, design upgrades and completion stage that the builder does not break out (Lennar Carson homesite page). The higher-priced Carson is $82,608 above the plan's $346,999 base (our arithmetic). That spread is the closest public evidence of what Lennar charges for lot and options in Coco Bay, and it is wider than any carrying-cost line on this page.
For a seller, the lesson is to find your own number in that spread. Your purchase agreement and closing statement list the homesite premium, structural options and design-center selections you paid Lennar for. Appraisers do not add those back dollar for dollar; they look for the market's reaction in comparable sales (Fannie Mae B4-1.3-09). But a buyer comparing your Carson with Lennar's Carson needs to know which of the two Lennar prices yours resembles, and the purchase agreement is how we show it.
Lennar sells a monthly payment as much as a price. Its Sarasota-area promotion read November 17, 2026 offers up to $15,000 toward closing costs and a 4.750 percent Lennar Mortgage 7/6 ARM (7.221 percent APR) for contracts signed November 16 to 30, 2026; the page does not name Coco Bay (Lennar Sarasota-area promotion).
Lennar's own example on that page shows the size of the offer. On a $299,499 price with 10 percent down and $525 of estimated taxes and insurance, the promotional ARM payment is "$1,931/month" against "$2,341/month" at Lennar's stated market 7/6 ARM rate of 7.125 percent (9.402 percent APR), a $410 a month difference for the seven fixed years; the offer "requires financing through Lennar Mortgage, LLC" and "Limited funds are available" (Lennar Sarasota-area promotion). Lennar reports that 83 percent of its buyers financed with Lennar Mortgage in its third fiscal quarter of 2026 (Lennar Form 10-Q, quarter ended August 31, 2026).
The company-wide figures are consistent with the fall in Coco Bay's recorded rate per foot in 2025, which the price section above charts quarter by quarter. Lennar's average delivered price fell from $430,000 in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2024 to $386,000 a year later, when it "maintained approximately 14% in incentives and price adjustments" (Lennar fourth quarter 2025 results). By the third quarter of fiscal 2026 its average was $372,000, "reflecting approximately 12.0% in incentives, along with base price adjustments necessary to sustain volume" (Lennar third quarter 2026 results). In its East segment, which includes Florida, incentives averaged $48,000 per home delivered against $77,600 a year earlier (Lennar Form 10-Q).
Lennar also says it watches resale sellers. Its 10-Q reports that resales "have also begun to increase, particularly in Texas and Florida, intensifying competition for buyers" (Lennar Form 10-Q), and Executive Chairman Stuart Miller said on the third-quarter call, as reported, "When a resale seller cuts price, they are competing directly for our customer, and we respond" (HousingWire, Lennar Q3 2026 earnings). In Coco Bay that competition is literal: the same plans, the same months, a few streets apart.
A resale seller cannot match a builder's rate buydown dollar for dollar, but can answer it. The realistic tools are a seller-paid closing credit or rate buydown within the buyer's loan program limits, an assumable FHA or VA loan if you have one, and documents that cut the buyer's insurance. The carrying-cost section below shows the payment arithmetic. Here the point is simpler: a Coco Bay resale priced at Lennar's sticker with no credit is, to a payment-minded buyer, priced above Lennar.
Villas, Manor Homes and all of Palm Lake at Coco Bay read sold out, so in those segments a buyer can only buy a resale. Lennar's Palm Lake page reads "Palm Lake at Coco Bay is now sold out," and its Island Lakes page reads "Manor Homes SOLD OUT" and "Villas SOLD OUT" (Lennar Palm Lake at Coco Bay).
Sold-out segments price against recorded sales, not a builder sheet. For a Coco Bay villa that means the 12-month villa median of $249,500 on 32 sales, not Lennar's leftover "from" figures (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The leftover figures can mislead in both directions: the sold-out Magnolia still shows "from $294,999," about $208 a foot, and the sold-out Palm Lake Orchid shows "$232,717," about $149 a foot, for the same plan Island Lakes lists at $304,999 (Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay brochure; Lennar Palm Lake at Coco Bay brochure). Neither is an offer a buyer can take, and neither is evidence of value.
The same holds for the largest homes. Manor and Estate plans of 2,244 to 2,799 square feet are no longer sold new, and the 12-month record for detached homes of 2,400 square feet and up is a small group of 8 sales at a $490,000 median (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). With so few sales, a large Coco Bay home's value leans on the 24-month record, the plan's original Lennar price and the specific additions. Owners of sold-out products have one advantage: no new unit of their plan is waiting down the street.
About mid 2027, by a Lennar representative's estimate. Island Lake Estates CDD minutes of April 14, 2026 record that "the last home might be sold in the middle of 2027," and the November 5, 2026 roll still coded 98 Island Lakes at Coco Bay lots vacant (Island Lake Estates CDD minutes, April 14, 2026).
The remark came in a discussion of a $343,560 bond reserve release due to Lennar once it sells the last home. The vacant count overstates what is left to sell, because a home under construction stays coded as land until the roll catches up; Lennar's page showed five homesites on November 17, 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser; Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay). The estimate is a remark in a board meeting, not a promise, and builders' schedules move with sales.
For a valuation, the date matters in two ways. Until Lennar finishes, every Coco Bay Executive resale competes with new inventory and a builder financing offer. After it finishes, Coco Bay becomes a resale-only market and the builder's sheet stops setting the anchor. No source we read forecasts what that does to prices, and we do not forecast it either. We read the sales as they record.
It widens the buyer's choices at Coco Bay's price points. Lennar's scattered-lot homes in Gulf Cove list at $286,999 to $369,999 with "zero HOA fees," its Port Charlotte scattered lots at $264,499 to $369,999, and Maronda lists Englewood scattered homesites "From the $249s," all builder-stated and read November 17, 2026 (Lennar Gulf Cove).
New construction a Coco Bay buyer can also tour (builder-stated, read November 17, 2026 unless dated, subject to change).
| Community | Builder | Builder-stated price | Fees the builder names |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gulf Cove scattered lots | Lennar | $286,999 to $369,999 | "zero HOA fees" |
| Port Charlotte scattered lots | Lennar | $264,499 to $369,999 | "no HOA fees" |
| Rotonda Lakes, Rotonda West | Lennar | Sold out, new homesites coming soon | not stated |
| Wellen Park Golf and Country Club, Venice | Lennar | $234,990 to $763,999 | not read |
| Englewood scattered homesites | Maronda | From the $249s | closing cost assistance offered |
| Rotonda scattered homesites | Maronda | From the $349s | "up to $25K" fall savings |
| Cassia Bay, Punta Gorda (announced February 4, 2026) | Pulte | Expected from the upper $200,000s | "no CDD fees" |
Sources: Lennar Gulf Cove; Lennar Port Charlotte; Lennar Rotonda Lakes; Lennar Wellen Park Golf and Country Club; Maronda Homes Rotonda West; Business Observer, February 4, 2026.
The fee column is the part that touches a Coco Bay value. A scattered-lot Lennar home in Gulf Cove has no HOA and no community development district line; a Coco Bay home carries both, and the next section shows what those lines cost a buyer in borrowing power. Coco Bay answers with what a scattered lot does not have: the gated community, the amenity center, lawn maintenance and the stormwater lakes the CDD built. Which of those a buyer values more decides whether your Coco Bay home or a Gulf Cove new build wins the showing.
For the full list of builders and communities nearby, see our guide to new construction in Englewood. If you are weighing a new build while you sell, call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or read our guide to buying a home in Englewood.
Want your home priced against Lennar's live sheet? Request a Coco Bay valuation that compares your home with today's Lennar homesites. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Every Coco Bay home sits in the Island Lake Estates Community Development District, created by Charlotte County Ordinance 2022-026. November 2026 Coco Bay tax bills carry $1,540.51 for a paired villa, $1,925.60 for an Executive Home and $2,342.77 for a Manor Home: an operations charge plus a fixed debt share (Island Lake Estates CDD adopted FY2027 budget).
Data updated: November 2026 (Island Lake Estates CDD adopted FY2027 budget of April 14, 2026, fiscal 2025 audit, April 14, 2026 minutes and November 10, 2026 landowners' meeting agenda; Lennar pages read November 17, 2026; Freddie Mac PMMS for the week of November 12, 2026).
A community development district is a special taxing district that financed Coco Bay's water management system, utilities, landscaping and offsite work, and now maintains what it owns (Island Lake Estates CDD, About the District). Charlotte County established it on May 24, 2022 by Ordinance No. 2022-026 under Chapter 190, Florida Statutes (Island Lake Estates CDD fiscal 2025 audit). The homeowners' association is separate and bills separately. Both matter to value for one reason: a buyer's lender counts them in the monthly payment, so they set how much a buyer can borrow for your home.
It is two charges added together. An operations and maintenance assessment of $256.91 per home for fiscal 2027, the same for every Coco Bay home, plus a fixed debt assessment set by product type and lot width, from $1,155.24 for a Palm Lake paired villa to $2,310.49 for an Estate Home (Island Lake Estates CDD adopted FY2027 budget).
Island Lake Estates CDD assessment by Coco Bay product, fiscal 2027 (October 1, 2026 to September 30, 2027).
| Product in the CDD budget | Planned homes | Debt assessment | O&M assessment | Total CDD line a year | Monthly equivalent (our arithmetic) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coco Bay paired villa, 40 ft lot | 106 | $1,283.60 | $256.91 | $1,540.51 | $128.38 |
| Executive Home, 52 ft lot (Coco Bay group) | 215 | $1,668.69 | $256.91 | $1,925.60 | $160.47 |
| Manor Home, 65 ft lot | 79 | $2,085.86 | $256.91 | $2,342.77 | $195.23 |
| Palm Lake paired villa, 36 ft lot | 78 | $1,155.24 | $256.91 | $1,412.15 | $117.68 |
| Palm Lake Executive Home, 52 ft lot | 71 | $1,668.69 | $256.91 | $1,925.60 | $160.47 |
| Estate Home, 72 ft lot | 22 | $2,310.49 | $256.91 | $2,567.40 | $213.95 |
Source: Island Lake Estates CDD adopted FY2027 budget. Totals are debt plus O&M; the villa 40, Executive and Manor totals match amounts on November 2026 Coco Bay tax bills to the cent. The budget's "Coco Bay" group covers the Coco Bay plat and Island Lakes at Coco Bay.
The two halves behave differently. The O&M part moves each year with the district's budget: $233.59 in fiscal 2025, $242.83 in fiscal 2026 and $256.91 in fiscal 2027, under an adopted cap of $280.31 (Island Lake Estates CDD adopted FY2027 budget; CDD fiscal 2025 assessment notice). The debt part has not moved, and it does not rise with your home's value. Lennar's Executive Homes page prints "Approximate special assessment fees $1,911.52," which is the same debt share plus the fiscal 2026 O&M rate, one budget year behind the bill (Lennar Island Lakes Executive Homes).
The line cannot be skipped. The district collects through the tax bill, "together with County and other taxes," on a single bill paid without preference for any part, so an owner cannot pay the county taxes and leave the CDD line unpaid (Island Lake Estates CDD fiscal 2025 audit). The district's notice adds that its assessments "constitute a lien against your property" each year, just as property taxes do (CDD fiscal 2025 assessment notice). Lennar's page also states an "Approximate tax rate 0.97%," while the 2026 county rate for Coco Bay's tax district 009 is 15.5683 mills, about 1.56 percent before exemptions and before the CDD line (Charlotte County Property Appraiser 2026 final rate chart). A buyer should budget from the bill, not the builder's estimate.
Until December 15, 2053. The district issued $11,895,000 of Special Assessment Bonds, Series 2023, on November 30, 2023, at fixed rates of 4.875 to 6 percent, and the debt share on each Coco Bay bill pays them down until final maturity (Island Lake Estates CDD fiscal 2025 audit).
The schedule is level. Principal payments began December 15, 2024 at $135,000 and climb to $760,000 in 2052 and $735,000 at final maturity, with coupons of 4.875 percent through 2029, 5.750 percent from 2029 to 2043 and 6.000 percent from 2044 to 2053 (Island Lake Estates CDD adopted FY2027 budget). Par outstanding was $11,590,000 after the December 15, 2025 payment and is scheduled at $11,410,000 on September 30, 2027 (same source).
For a valuation, the length is the point. A Coco Bay Executive Home carries the $1,668.69 debt share for about 27 more bill years if nobody prepays, roughly $45,000 of undiscounted payments (our estimate from the budget, not a payoff quote). Every Coco Bay comparable carries the same district and, for the same product, the same debt line, so Coco Bay to Coco Bay comparisons need no CDD adjustment. The question appears when a buyer compares your home with a Gulf Cove or Englewood home with no district at all.
Yes, by request to the district. The district's FAQ says owners "may pay off this capital assessment early, by contacting the District office for information on your property," and the district manager handles parcel inquiries (Island Lake Estates CDD FAQs). Only the district manager can quote an actual Coco Bay payoff.
We can estimate the order of size. Dividing the $11,590,000 of outstanding bonds by each product's share of the debt roll gives about $16,200 for a Coco Bay paired villa, $21,000 for an Executive Home and $26,300 for a Manor Home (our estimate, not a payoff quote; a real payoff letter adds interest to the next redemption date and may differ) (Island Lake Estates CDD adopted FY2027 budget).
A prepaid debt share removes $1,668.69 a year from an Executive Home's bill, about $139 a month. At the Freddie Mac 30-year rate of 7.11 percent for the week of November 12, 2026, with 20 percent down, that much payment supports roughly $20,800 of price for a payment-limited buyer (our arithmetic; Freddie Mac PMMS). If you have prepaid, it should show on the tax bill and the estoppel, and we put it in front of buyers. If you have not, prepaying before a sale is a decision to price with the district's quote in hand, not by rule of thumb.
They report it and study how comparable Coco Bay sales in the same district reacted to it. Fannie Mae requires appraisers to report special assessments and analyze similarly affected comparables, and, where a district is in financial difficulty, to study sales within it, with the loan ineligible if no comparable data exist (Fannie Mae B4-1.4-09).
In Coco Bay that rule works in a seller's favor. Every recorded Coco Bay sale already carries the Island Lake Estates line, so the comparables an appraiser picks inside Coco Bay are "similarly affected," and the district publishes an audit and adopted budgets showing its bond principal paid down from $11,895,000 at issue to $11,590,000 after the December 2025 payment (Island Lake Estates CDD fiscal 2025 audit; Island Lake Estates CDD adopted FY2027 budget). The county's just value does not deduct the CDD debt either, so it is not hidden inside the tax roll's figure.
Disclosure matters more than adjustment. Florida requires the initial sale contract within a district to carry a boldfaced notice that the district "MAY IMPOSE AND LEVY TAXES OR ASSESSMENTS, OR BOTH" (Fla. Stat. 190.048). That statute names the initial (Lennar) sale; on a resale the buyer sees the line on the tax bill and the escrow estimate. Showing the CDD amount up front, with the budget, avoids a late surprise that reopens price. The valuation-method section below covers how appraisers treat builder concessions and value acceptance in a new subdivision.
A lender counts both in the housing payment, so every dollar of CDD and HOA is a dollar less for the mortgage. Fannie Mae's housing expense includes "owners' association dues" and "special assessments," and at 7.11 percent a Coco Bay Executive Home's $160.47 monthly CDD line takes about $24,000 of a $350,000 buyer's borrowing power (Fannie Mae B3-6-03).
Lennar states the HOA figures but not the period. Its pages read November 17, 2026 show "Approximate HOA fees $302.67" for Island Lakes Executive Homes, $308.33 for Manor Homes and $241.33 for villas in the page data, and $282.33 for Palm Lake at Coco Bay; Lennar does not state the period (Lennar Island Lakes Executive Homes; Lennar Palm Lake at Coco Bay brochure). The association's estoppel certificate is where the actual amount and billing frequency appear.
What each Coco Bay carrying line is worth in a buyer's borrowing power (our arithmetic; 30-year fixed at 7.11 percent, week of November 12, 2026; 20 percent down; tax at 15.5683 mills on price; base case a $350,000 Executive Home).
| Line | Amount | Price it displaces for a payment-limited buyer |
|---|---|---|
| Each $100 a month of payment | $100 a month | about $14,972 |
| Executive Home CDD line | $1,925.60 a year ($160.47 a month) | about $24,026 |
| Executive Home CDD debt share, if prepaid | $1,668.69 a year removed | about $20,820 restored |
| Executive HOA, if the $302.67 is monthly | $302.67 | about $45,317 |
| Homeowners premium difference | $1,000 a year | about $12,477 |
| Flood premium | $500 a year | about $6,238 |
Sources: CDD from the Island Lake Estates CDD adopted FY2027 budget; HOA builder-stated from Lennar Island Lakes Executive Homes, period not stated; rate from Freddie Mac PMMS; millage from the Charlotte County Property Appraiser 2026 final rate chart. Each $1 a month of payment equals about $149.72 of price under these inputs. If the HOA figure is not monthly, its row shrinks sharply.
This is not a discount on Coco Bay prices. Buyers get the amenities, lawn care and infrastructure the charges pay for, and every Coco Bay comparable carries them. What the table explains is why a Coco Bay home is priced against Lennar's sheet and other Coco Bay sales, not against an Englewood resale with no district and a small HOA. When we value your home, we put the full monthly payment in front of the buyer's agent so the CDD and HOA are read as costs that come with a product, not as surprises.
Lennar does, for now. The district's audit says four of five supervisors were Lennar-affiliated at September 30, 2025, and the April 14, 2026 minutes say "the Board would start transitioning to qualified electors in 2028," when residents start taking seats (Island Lake Estates CDD fiscal 2025 audit; Island Lake Estates CDD minutes, April 14, 2026).
The most recent election was a landowners' meeting on November 10, 2026, with three seats up and voting at "one vote per acre," platted lots counted individually and rounded up to the nearest whole acre (Island Lake Estates CDD landowners' meeting agenda, November 10, 2026). The result had not been posted when we checked on November 17, 2026. The audit also notes the district's activity "is dependent upon the continued involvement of the Developer" (Island Lake Estates CDD fiscal 2025 audit).
For value, control matters mainly to the O&M half of the line. The debt half is fixed by the bond schedule no matter who sits on the board. The O&M half is set each year by the board's budget, under the adopted cap, so a buyer looking ahead to resident control is asking what maintenance will cost once Lennar leaves. We include the current budget and cap in the papers we hand buyers, so the question gets a documented answer. For how the CDD and HOA show up when you list, see our Coco Bay seller guide.
Want the CDD and HOA lines worked into your number? Request a Coco Bay valuation that prices your CDD, HOA and payoff status. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Flood status in Coco Bay varies by lot, so two neighbors can face different insurance costs and lender rules. FEMA's map shows most points we checked in shaded Zone X, some lots in Zone AE, and four 2024 FEMA letters (LOMR-Fs) removing all or part of listed Coco Bay lots from the high-risk area (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer).
Data updated: November 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer and LOMA layer queried November 17, 2026; FIRM panels effective December 15, 2022; FEMA Risk Rating page updated April 9, 2026; NFIP authorization status per NAHB, September 4, 2026, and Congressional Research Service, September 11, 2026; Citizens flood page and Florida statutes read November 17, 2026).
Coco Bay's flood picture is more uneven than a buyer expects. The homes are new, built on graded lots around stormwater lakes, and many lots were lifted out of the high-risk zone by FEMA letters after the 2022 maps took effect. But the base map still prints AE on some of those lots, Citizens changes its flood rule on January 1, 2027, and the federal flood program's authority runs only to December 11, 2026. Each of those touches a buyer's payment, and so the price. Flood zone is a lot-by-lot fact in Coco Bay, never a community-wide one.
Because FEMA maps flood risk by ground elevation, not by subdivision. Of five Coco Bay points we queried on FEMA's flood layer on November 17, 2026, four read shaded Zone X, outside the high-risk area, and one read Zone AE with a static base flood elevation of 8, on panels effective December 15, 2022 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer).
Zone X and Zone AE are different products to a lender. In shaded X there is no federal flood insurance mandate; in AE, a federally backed loan requires flood insurance unless a FEMA letter removes the structure. The AE point we checked sits on a lot FEMA later removed by letter, yet the base map still shows AE there, because the base layer does not redraw for each letter (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer). A flood determination vendor reading only the map can flag a Coco Bay lot that a letter has cleared.
Charlotte County publishes flood zones, base flood elevations and existing elevation certificates by property on its online floodplain platform (Englewood Review, August 7, 2025). Before we value a Coco Bay home, we read its zone, its letter if any, and its elevation certificate, because those three papers decide which flood rules a buyer meets.
They are four FEMA letters, all completed in 2024, that removed listed Coco Bay lots, in whole or in part, from the high-risk flood area. A LOMR-F (Letter of Map Revision based on Fill) means FEMA found the filled ground above the base flood elevation; for a removed structure, the federal flood insurance mandate falls away (FEMA LOMA layer).
FEMA LOMR-F cases naming Coco Bay plats (FEMA LOMA layer, queried November 17, 2026).
| FEMA case number | Plat named | Completed | Outcome FEMA records |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24-04-3577A | Palm Lake at Coco Bay | June 3, 2024 | Multiple (some lots removed whole, others in part) |
| 24-04-6777A | Palm Lake at Coco Bay | September 18, 2024 | Portion of property removed |
| 24-04-6894A | Coco Bay | September 27, 2024 | Property removed |
| 24-04-6852A | Island Lakes at Coco Bay | September 27, 2024 | Property removed |
Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, LOMA layer. Each case lists specific lots; your title file or the county's floodplain platform shows whether your lot is one of them.
The outcomes split Coco Bay into three groups for a buyer's lender. Homes in shaded X carry no federal mandate. Homes on lots FEMA removed whole carry no federal mandate once the letter is handed over. Homes covered by a "portion of property removed" outcome, which applies to parts of Palm Lake at Coco Bay, depend on where the house sits relative to the removed area, and need an elevation certificate or survey to settle it. All four letters postdate the December 15, 2022 maps, so the map change did not supersede them (FEMA LOMA layer).
For a seller, the letter is a value document. A buyer whose lender sees only the base map may be told flood insurance is required; the letter answers that, and a $500 a year flood premium is worth about $6,238 of price to a payment-limited buyer at 7.11 percent (our arithmetic; Freddie Mac PMMS). Bring your LOMR-F case number and elevation certificate, and we include both in the listing file.
Risk Rating 2.0 prices each Coco Bay home on its own flood risk and value, and the program's authority runs only to December 11, 2026. FEMA says most rates cannot rise more than 18 percent a year and that owners can transfer a discount "by assigning their flood insurance policy" to a buyer (FEMA Risk Rating 2.0).
Because Coco Bay homes were built from 2023 to 2025, any NFIP policy on one was written under Risk Rating 2.0, so an assigned policy brings continuity, a known premium and no new waiting period, more than a below-market rate. The deadline matters more. Congress extended the National Flood Insurance Program through December 11, 2026 in a September short-term funding measure (NAHB, September 4, 2026). The Congressional Research Service notes that during a lapse "The authority to provide new flood insurance contracts will expire," while existing policies run to the end of their term, and that real estate transactions in a high-risk area "potentially could be significantly hampered" (Congressional Research Service, IN10835).
For a Coco Bay sale closing after December 11, 2026 on a lot that needs a new federal flood policy, a lapse could slow the closing unless the buyer takes over the seller's existing policy or uses a private flood carrier. If your home carries an NFIP policy, keep it in force and tell us its term; an assignable policy is a closing tool. We found no extension beyond December 11 enacted as of November 17, 2026.
A Coco Bay buyer who insures wind with Citizens will need flood coverage too, even in shaded Zone X. Citizens says policies with wind must "have and maintain flood insurance coverage by January 1, 2027," with its value threshold stepping down from $600,000 in 2024 to "all policies, regardless of value" (Citizens flood requirement).
The exemptions are narrow: condominium unit-owner policies, tenant contents policies and policies that exclude wind (Citizens flood requirement). Coco Bay villas sit on their own platted lots in the district's budget rather than in a condominium, so the condo exemption is unlikely to reach them; a buyer should confirm with the insurance agent. Citizens remains a sizable carrier in Charlotte County: its approved 2026 rates show 3,438 HO3 homeowner policies in the county at an average approved premium of $2,887, down 5.9 percent (Citizens 2026 approved rate changes by county).
For value, the rule adds a line to some buyers' payments and not others. A buyer with a private homeowners carrier may face no flood requirement on a shaded X Coco Bay lot; a Citizens buyer will. The state's admitted-market average homeowners premium including wind was $3,736, data as of October 2026 (Florida Office of Insurance Regulation market overview). No public source gives a Coco Bay quote, so we ask buyers' agents for real quotes early. Insurance quotes for your specific Coco Bay home: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).
Florida requires a Coco Bay seller to give the buyer a flood disclosure at or before signing the sales contract. The form states that homeowners policies do not cover flood, and the seller says whether they know of flood damage, filed a flood claim, or received flood assistance, including from FEMA (Fla. Stat. 689.302).
The statute defines flooding broadly: overflow of inland or tidal waters, unusual runoff "from any established water source," and sustained standing water from rainfall (Fla. Stat. 689.302). For a Coco Bay home on a lake lot, "established water source" can include the stormwater lake behind the house, so answer from what actually happened, not from the zone on the map.
Because Coco Bay owners have held their homes only since 2023 to 2025, the disclosure covers a short window. A clean disclosure on a Coco Bay home is a document that supports value; a "yes" answer will show up in the buyer's insurance quote and inspection before closing, and it is better handled at pricing than at renegotiation. We read your disclosure answers with you before we set a list price, and our Coco Bay seller guide covers the rest of the seller's disclosure duties.
County records date Coco Bay's Lennar homes from 2023 to 2025, built under the current Florida Building Code, so each starts from the state's strongest wind position. Homes built to the 2001 code or later are "automatically eligible for a minimum 68% discount on the windstorm coverage of the premium" (Florida CFO hurricane mitigation guide).
The credit needs paper. The discounts apply only to the windstorm part of the premium; inspections on or after April 1, 2026 use the new form, and a completed form stays valid for five years if the structure is not materially changed (Florida CFO hurricane mitigation guide). Lennar's Coco Bay features include hurricane-impact windows and sliding doors and concrete block and stucco construction, which the form records (Lennar Magnolia included features). Roof shape can differ by elevation, so two Coco Bay homes of the same size can earn different credits.
State grant money is not the route here. The state's hurricane mitigation grant program requires a home "built before January 1, 2008" (state mitigation grant eligibility), so no Coco Bay home qualifies; a private wind mitigation inspection is the realistic step. At 7.11 percent, each $1,000 a year a buyer saves on premium is worth about $12,477 of price (our arithmetic; Freddie Mac PMMS). A current form in the listing file is one of the cheapest value supports a Coco Bay seller has.
For values in neighboring Englewood communities with older homes and different flood files, see our Englewood home valuation guide, and for the selling steps across town, our Englewood seller guide.
Want your flood and insurance papers read before a buyer reads them? Request a Coco Bay valuation with your zone, LOMR-F letter and wind form reviewed. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
We value a Coco Bay home by matching it to recorded Charlotte County sales of the same home type, plan size and plat, then giving the few true resales more weight than Lennar's own first sales. We test every builder comparable for incentives, adjust older sales for time, and show you each sale we used.
Data updated: November 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026, qualified improved sales through August 24, 2026; 12-month window September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026; 24-month window September 10, 2024 to September 9, 2026; Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, HUD and VA guidance as dated below; our tabulation).
Coco Bay is a new market with a short record. The county shows 491 qualified improved sales since the first closings in late 2023, and only 24 homes have sold a second time (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Everything else is a Lennar first sale, recorded at the contract price, with any closing-cost credit or rate buydown Lennar gave that buyer left off the deed. Our method sorts those 467 first sales and 24 resales apart before anything else. If you want the place itself, plats, amenities and location, our Coco Bay guide covers it.
Every per-square-foot figure here is a recorded price divided by the county's heated (living) area for that home. A plan sheet or listing sheet can measure a home differently, so we use the county's heated area for every Coco Bay figure and never mix two measures on one home.
Our comparative market analysis for a Coco Bay home runs in eight steps: sort by home type, match plan size, keep the plat, read the lot, weight resales over builder sales, strip out builder concessions, adjust for time, and state a range with every sale shown. Each step starts from county-recorded Coco Bay sales.
Step 1: sort by home type. A detached Executive or Manor home and an attached paired villa are different products with different buyers, so they never serve as comparables for each other. The November 5, 2026 roll holds 287 detached homes at a median 2,198 heated square feet and 158 villas at a median 1,423 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Over the 12 months to September 9, 2026, detached homes sold at a $350,000 median on 55 sales and villas at $249,500 on 32 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). That gap is a product gap, not a location gap, so the first cut is always the type.
Step 2: match the plan size. Coco Bay homes come from a short list of Lennar floor plans, so size bands line up closely with plans. The middle half of detached homes on the roll runs from 2,027 to 2,264 heated square feet, and the middle half of villas from 1,422 to 1,564 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). We look for the same plan first, then the same size band, then a neighboring band with a size adjustment.
Step 3: keep the plat. Coco Bay, Island Lakes at Coco Bay and Palm Lake at Coco Bay were platted and sold at different times, with different lot widths and collections. Over 24 months, villas in the Coco Bay plat recorded a median $197 per heated square foot on 15 sales, Island Lakes at Coco Bay villas $190 on 43, and Palm Lake at Coco Bay villas $155 on 50 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Part of that spread is plan mix and timing, so we never borrow a Palm Lake villa sale for a Coco Bay plat villa without saying so.
Step 4: read the lot. Lake, preserve and interior positions matter to Coco Bay buyers, but no primary source publishes a dollar or percentage lake premium for Coco Bay, so the lot is a directional adjustment: a lake or preserve lot leans toward the upper part of a size band's middle half, an interior lot toward the lower part. The roll's median land value is $28,050 on detached parcels and $17,000 on villa parcels (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, 2026 roll, our computation), a figure by product type rather than a measured lake premium, so the roll will not do this step for us.
Step 5: weight resales over builder sales. A resale shows what a buyer paid an owner, with a choice of new Lennar homes nearby. A first sale shows what Lennar accepted on a given week, with incentives the deed does not show. Here is how thin the resale pool is once the filters from Steps 1 and 2 are applied (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
How the Coco Bay comparable pool narrows, 24 months ending September 9, 2026
| Filter | Detached homes | Villas |
|---|---|---|
| All qualified improved sales of that type | 188 | 108 |
| Within the most common size band (detached 2,000 to 2,399 sq ft; villas 1,400 to 1,699 sq ft) | 104 | 106 |
| Resales of that type, any size | 14 | 10 |
| Resales of that type in the last 12 months | 8, a small group | 9, a small group |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our tabulation. The other 42 of the 338 qualified improved sales in the 24-month window were homes on parcels the roll still coded vacant, so they carry no type or heated area.
So the few resales set the level and the many Lennar sales set the shape: how price moves with size, plat and date. Lenders use the same order.
Step 6: strip out builder concessions. Lennar's first sales carried closing-cost credits and Lennar Mortgage rate buydowns that never appear on the deed. Lennar's own quarterly filing shows how large those were in its East segment, which includes Florida: average sales incentives of $48,000 per home delivered in the third quarter of fiscal 2026, against $77,600 a year earlier, or 11.5 percent of revenue against 17.6 percent (Lennar Form 10-Q, quarter ended August 31, 2026). Those are segment averages, not Coco Bay figures; the Lennar section above covers Lennar's current price sheet and offer.
The lender rules are specific about which direction the adjustment can go. Fannie Mae says comparables with sales or financing concessions "must be adjusted," that the adjustment reflects the difference between what they sold for with the concession and what they would have sold for without it, and that "Positive adjustments for sales or financing concessions are not acceptable" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09). Freddie Mac's chief appraisal officer adds that an adjustment "should not be calculated on a mechanical dollar for dollar cost" and should "approximate the market's reaction" (Freddie Mac, July 30, 2024). In plain terms for a Coco Bay owner: a Lennar sale that came with a buydown can only be adjusted down toward your home, never your home up toward it.
Step 7: adjust for time. Coco Bay's quarterly median per heated square foot moved from about 209 in 2024 Q1 to 166 in 2025 Q3 and Q4, then to 176 and 197 in the first two quarters of 2026 as more resales and larger homes entered the mix (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). A 2024 Lennar sale used today needs a supported time adjustment. Fannie Mae requires that "Time adjustments, or the lack thereof, must be supported by evidence," and accepts home price indices as support (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09). We use the Coco Bay quarterly series alongside the FHFA index for Charlotte County, reading both with the mix warning in the price section above, because neither one alone separates a builder price cut from a market move.
Step 8: state a range and show the sales. You get a range, the sales behind each end, the adjustment made to each, and the Lennar homes your buyer will see that week.
In Florida, a CMA or broker price opinion on a Coco Bay home is a lawful pricing opinion a licensed real estate broker or sales associate gives in the ordinary course of business. It is never an appraisal. Only a state-licensed or certified appraiser may issue an appraisal report, which lenders, courts and estates usually require.
The line is drawn in Chapter 475 of the Florida Statutes. Section 475.25(1)(t) says the appraisal-standards ground "does not apply to a real estate broker or sales associate who, in the ordinary course of business, performs a comparative market analysis, gives a broker price opinion, or gives an opinion of value of real estate," and adds that "in no event may" that analysis or opinion "be referred to as an appraisal" (Florida Statutes s. 475.25). Section 475.611 defines an appraiser as a registered trainee, licensed or certified real estate appraiser, and a certified residential appraiser as one certified "to issue appraisal reports for residential real property of one to four residential units" (Florida Statutes s. 475.611). Section 475.612 then states that "Only a certified or licensed appraiser may issue an appraisal report and receive direct compensation" (Florida Statutes s. 475.612).
Appraisers are regulated under Chapter 475, Part II, by the Florida Real Estate Appraisal Board inside the Department of Business and Professional Regulation, whose members "are appointed by the Governor and confirmed by the Florida Senate"; you can check any appraiser's license "by name or license number" (DBPR, Florida Real Estate Appraisal Board). Licensed appraisers follow USPAP, whose current edition is the 2024 edition, effective January 1, 2024 (The Appraisal Foundation).
So a lender, a court or an estate needs an appraisal, while a list price needs a CMA. A CMA also reads the Lennar homes a buyer can tour this week, which a closed-sales appraisal does not.
A lender's appraiser treats Coco Bay as a new subdivision still being marketed by its builder. Fannie Mae, FHA and VA rules all push that appraiser toward arm's length resales inside Coco Bay, at least one sale from a competing community outside it, and a written analysis of any Lennar concessions behind the builder sales used.
Fannie Mae. For a home in a subdivision or PUD, the report needs "At least one settled comparable sale from the subject condo project, subdivision, or PUD" and "At least one settled comparable sale from outside" it, and "A resale is preferable if it is verifiable and does not involve the subject builder or developer" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08). When builder sales are used, "the appraisal must include discussion and analysis of sales concessions and upgrades." The same topic asks for "A minimum of three closed comparables," says sales closed within the last 12 months "should be used," and allows "Contract offerings and current listings" only "as supporting data." For a Coco Bay resale that means the Lennar homes still listed in Island Lakes at Coco Bay can support the appraiser's reading but cannot be one of the three closed comparables. It also means the owner's own Lennar purchase can appear in the report, because "The subject property can be used as a fourth comparable sale or as supporting data if it was previously closed."
FHA. HUD's Handbook 4000.1, in the version we read (pages marked last revised August 14, 2019; a lender applies the current Handbook and later mortgagee letters), says "Arm's length resale activity from within the established subdivision, condominium or PUD project is often the best indicator of value," and for new subdivisions requires at least one sale from a competing project and one from inside the subject project "whenever possible"; once a new project "is mature enough to have experienced arm's length resales, the Appraiser must also analyze and report those properties" (HUD Handbook 4000.1). Coco Bay crossed that line with its first resales in late 2024. The Handbook counts "upgraded features in newly constructed houses, or special financing incentives" as sales concessions, and treats an occupied home completed less than a year earlier "as an existing Property." Interested parties may contribute up to 6 percent of the sales price, including rate buydowns; anything above that is "an inducement to purchase" and comes off the price dollar for dollar (HUD Handbook 4000.1). On the 12-month Coco Bay detached median of $350,000, 6 percent is $21,000; on the villa median of $249,500 it is $14,970 (our arithmetic).
VA. Under VA's Tidewater step, an appraiser who expects a value below the sales price allows 2 business days for more sales data; after the Notice of Value, a reconsideration is reviewed "Within 5 business days" (VA appraisal policies bulletin, December 16, 2021). Have recent Coco Bay resales ready before a VA appraiser visits.
Conventional seller credits. On a principal-residence loan, Fannie Mae caps interested-party contributions at 3 percent of the lower of price or appraised value above 90 percent loan-to-value, 6 percent from 75.01 to 90 percent, and 9 percent at 75 percent or less, and treats any excess as a sales concession deducted from the price (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02). On a $350,000 Coco Bay home those caps are $10,500, $21,000 and $31,500 (our arithmetic).
The new appraisal form. All appraisal reports on loans sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac must use UAD 3.6 and the redesigned URAR as of the November 2, 2026 mandate; the broad production period began January 26, 2026 (Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac joint announcement). The old 1004 form is retired (Freddie Mac UAD FAQ). Two details matter for Coco Bay. A home that meets the new-construction definition is reported as "Fully Updated" to represent it as C1, the top condition rating, while a Coco Bay home that has been lived in is rated on its observed condition. And the new grid places porches, patios and decks under "Outdoor Living features" and inground pools under "Water Features" (GSE UAD 3.6 Job Aid), so a screened lanai extension or pool an owner added after closing now has its own visible line in the report.
The cost approach. Fannie Mae does not require it except for manufactured homes, though it "may be appropriate" for new construction (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-10). Lennar's company-wide construction cost of "approximately $80" per square foot (Lennar Form 10-Q) leaves out land, site work and the CDD-financed infrastructure, so on a Coco Bay home the sales comparison does the work.
Sometimes. Fannie Mae's automated underwriting may offer value acceptance, with no appraisal, on some Coco Bay resales. A brand-new Lennar home qualifies only if an as-is appraisal already exists for it. Value acceptance is offered by the lender's system, not requested by the seller, so a Coco Bay owner should plan for a full appraisal.
Fannie Mae's rule reads: "For certain loan casefiles, DU offers value acceptance, in which case an appraisal is not required." Proposed construction, construction-to-permanent loans, and any purchase price or estimated value of $1,000,000 or more are ineligible, and "DU may offer value acceptance on a recently constructed property (i.e., new construction) when there is an existing "as is" prior appraisal for the subject property" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.4-10). Freddie Mac's version, ACE, uses "models and algorithms" built on appraisal data, MLS data and public records, and Freddie says "most loans delivered to Freddie Mac still require an appraisal report" (Freddie Mac ACE FAQ).
Nationally, the combined Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac waiver share "reached 28% in March 2026" (Appraisal Institute, August 2026). Price a Coco Bay home as though a full appraisal is coming, and keep your evidence in one folder the buyer's agent can hand to the appraiser.
To value a Coco Bay home well, we need the paperwork that shows what the county record cannot: your Lennar contract and closing statement, the plan and options you chose, the lot premium, anything added after closing, and the documents that change a buyer's insurance and payment, such as a wind mitigation form or a FEMA flood letter.
The Coco Bay valuation checklist
| Item | Why it moves the number |
|---|---|
| Lennar purchase agreement and closing statement | Shows the base price, lot premium, options and any closing-cost credit or buydown behind your recorded price |
| Plan name, elevation and design-center selections | Lets us match the exact Lennar plan and separate paid options from standard features |
| Additions after closing, with invoices and permits | Pools, lanai extensions, shutters and landscaping are not in the county's heated area or your prior price |
| Uniform Mitigation Verification Inspection form | A form is valid for five years if the structure is not materially changed (Florida CFO guide) |
| FEMA LOMR-F letter or elevation certificate, and any flood policy | Decides whether a buyer's lender mandates flood cover; the flood section above lists the Coco Bay LOMR-F cases |
| Your most recent tax bill and any CDD prepayment confirmation | Shows the Island Lake Estates CDD line a buyer will carry |
| HOA statement or estoppel | Confirms the dues and their billing period |
| Your mortgage type and rate (FHA or VA) | An assumable low-rate loan can be worth real money to a buyer (see carrying costs below) |
You do not need every item to start. Send what you have and we will tell you which missing document matters most for your home. Request your free Coco Bay home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. If you are already weighing timing, fees and the listing itself, our Coco Bay seller guide covers the selling side, and our seller closing costs page shows what comes off the top.
The just value on a Coco Bay record card is the Property Appraiser's mass-appraisal estimate of market value as of January 1, reduced by a 15 percent cost-of-sale step (county rule). It is a tax figure, not a price. On the 2026 roll, Coco Bay just values ran about 80.5 to 81 percent of 2025 sale prices (county records).
Data updated: November 2026 (Charlotte County 2026 roll file dated August 21, 2026, matched to the 601 Coco Bay parcels; qualified sales from the county sales file; Charlotte County 2026 final millage rate chart; Island Lake Estates CDD adopted FY2027 budget; our computation).
Every Coco Bay record card shows three values. Just value is the county's January 1 market estimate after the cost-of-sale step (county). Assessed value is just value limited by any Save Our Homes or non-homestead cap. Taxable value is assessed value minus exemptions such as homestead. Only taxable value is multiplied by the millage rate.
Florida law lists eight factors the Property Appraiser weighs, starting with present cash value, the amount a willing purchaser would pay a willing seller in cash, before reasonable fees and costs of purchase, and ending with "The net proceeds of the sale of the property, as received by the seller, after deduction of all of the usual and reasonable fees and costs of the sale" (Florida Statutes s. 193.011). That eighth factor also calls for an allowance for "unconventional or atypical terms of financing arrangements," the kind of term a Lennar buydown represents (our reading).
Charlotte County applies those two factors with a flat step: "'just value' is adjusted by 15%, the Florida Department of Revenue standard" (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, Just Value Adjustment). The office describes its job as "discovering the most probable price people would pay for it, in the shape it's in on January 1, Florida's valuation date," and says plainly that "Buyers and sellers set value by their transactions in the market place" (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Values set as of January 1 rest on "market data from the prior calendar year" (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, Notice to Petitioner), so a Coco Bay home's 2026 just value is built on 2025 sales, the year the price section above shows Lennar's per-foot prices at their lowest.
Four reasons the record card and the market part ways on a Coco Bay home:
On the 2026 roll, the median Coco Bay detached home carried a just value of 80.5 percent of its 2025 qualified sale price, on 127 sales, and the median villa 81.0 percent, on 79 sales (county records). Both sit near what the 15 percent step predicts, so read just value as a conservative tax estimate.
Coco Bay 2026 just value against recorded sale prices
| Measure | Detached homes | Villas |
|---|---|---|
| Median 2026 just value | $290,992 | $208,547 |
| Middle half of 2026 just values | $274,009 to $363,870 | $188,977 to $243,402 |
| Median just value per heated sq ft | about $139 | about $134 |
| Median sale price per heated sq ft, 12 months to September 9, 2026 | $173 (n=55) | $162 (n=32) |
| Just value as a share of the 2025 sale price, median | 80.5 percent (n=127) | 81.0 percent (n=79) |
| Middle half of that share | 75.7 to 84.9 percent | 72.8 to 87.0 percent |
| Same share for 2026 sales through September 9 | 76.8 percent (n=22) | 83.9 percent (n=13) |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser 2026 roll and qualified sales, our computation; just value rule from the Just Value Adjustment page.
Two readings matter. First, 76 percent of the detached ratios fell under 85 percent, so most Coco Bay detached just values sit a little further below price than the 15 percent step alone would explain (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our computation). Some of that may be the roll reading 2025 Lennar prices, set in a year of heavy builder incentives (our reading). Second, the 2026 sales ratios differ by type (76.8 percent detached, 83.9 percent villas), but both groups are small and were priced after the January 1 valuation date, so we draw no conclusion from the gap.
The arithmetic for an owner: a detached just value of $300,000 at the 80.5 percent median ratio sits beside a 2025 price of about $372,700 (our arithmetic). That is a reading of the roll, not a value for your home, because individual Coco Bay ratios spread widely and the median hides it. Use the record card to sanity-check a number, never to set one. If you want the real figure, ask for your free Coco Bay home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
A Coco Bay home first appears on the roll as a finished house on the January 1 after it is substantially complete (s. 192.042). Until then the parcel is valued as a lot. That is why a Coco Bay owner's first bills can look low, and why those bills tell a buyer little about the bill they will pay.
Florida law sets the rule: "Improvements or portions not substantially completed on January 1 shall have no value placed thereon," and "Substantially completed" means "the improvement or some self-sufficient unit within it can be used for the purpose for which it was constructed" (Florida Statutes s. 192.042). The county confirms that "Status of property on this date determines its just value" (Charlotte County 2026 TRIM supplement).
On the 2026 roll, 101 Coco Bay detached homes and 38 villas were added as new construction, meaning homes finished during 2025 and valued complete for the first time on January 1, 2026, at median new-construction values of $303,121 and $195,039 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, 2026 roll, our computation). The 127 parcels still coded vacant, 98 of them in Island Lakes at Coco Bay, are mostly Lennar inventory; their median just value was $22,950, and 81 of them already show a capped assessed value below just value under the 10 percent non-homestead cap (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our computation).
What this means when you sell: your lot-year bill and your first finished-year bill are both history. The buyer's bill depends on the buyer's January 1 status (county), the new just value and the buyer's exemptions, so the payment table further down this page uses the buyer's numbers, not yours.
On the August 2026 roll, 140 of 287 Coco Bay detached homes and 61 of 158 villas carried a homestead exemption (county records). Because most Coco Bay homesteads began in 2024, 2025 or 2026, the Save Our Homes gap between just and assessed value is small, so a buyer inherits little tax increase from losing the seller's cap.
That is 48.8 percent of detached homes and 38.6 percent of villas, or 201 of 445 built homes overall (45.2 percent, our arithmetic) (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, 2026 roll, our computation). Only 28 homesteaded detached homes and 12 villas show an assessed value below just value; the rest are first-year homesteads assessed at full just value. Twenty-nine Coco Bay homes carry a portability transfer, 20 detached and 9 villas, meaning the owner brought a Save Our Homes benefit from an earlier Florida homestead.
Save Our Homes limits each year's increase in a homestead's assessed value to the lower of 3 percent or the change in the Consumer Price Index (Florida Statutes s. 193.155); the cap is 2.7 percent for 2026 (Florida Department of Revenue). The cap works in one direction only. Under the recapture rule, a homestead's assessed value still rises by the cap "even when just (market) value decreases, as long as assessed value does not exceed market value" (Charlotte County Property Appraiser), so a Coco Bay owner whose just value fell can still see assessed value rise until the two meet.
The 2026 homestead exemption on a Coco Bay bill is $25,000 against school levies and $51,411 against other levies: the $25,000 base plus the additional exemption of $26,411 for 2026, which applies to assessed value above $50,000 (Florida Department of Revenue). To qualify, an owner must hold title, live in the home as a permanent residence on January 1 and file by March 1 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, Exemptions).
For a Coco Bay seller moving to another Florida home, portability can carry up to $500,000 of the Save Our Homes difference to the next homestead if it is set up by the third January 1 after leaving (Charlotte County 2026 TRIM supplement). Because most Coco Bay homesteads are new, that transferable amount is usually small. Portability is personal; it does not change the market value of the house.
When a Coco Bay home sells, its assessed value resets to just value on the next January 1 and the seller's exemptions end (county). A homestead buyer then applies for their own exemption. A second-home or rental buyer pays at full just value, then gets the 10 percent non-homestead cap on non-school levies from the following year.
The statute: property "shall be assessed at just value as of January 1 of the year following a change of ownership" (Florida Statutes s. 193.155). The county warns buyers directly that they "should base their estimate of future property taxes on the current just (market) value, not assessed value" (Charlotte County Property Appraiser), and that a cap reset "along with the removal of the prior owner's exemptions may greatly increase the total amount of taxes due" (Charlotte County 2026 TRIM supplement).
For non-homestead property, the cap limits the yearly increase in assessed value to 10 percent for all levies other than school levies, starting the year after the property is first assessed at just value, and resets at a change of ownership (Florida Statutes s. 193.1554). The county applies it automatically, with no application (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Why this belongs on a valuation page: a buyer prices your Coco Bay home from the monthly payment they will carry, and the tax line in that payment is theirs, not yours. Because the Coco Bay Save Our Homes gap is small, the buyer's reset is mostly about exemptions, not about a large capped difference. That keeps Coco Bay simpler to explain to a buyer than an older Englewood neighborhood where a long-held homestead can hide a much larger reset.
All 601 Coco Bay parcels sit in Charlotte County tax district 009, with a 2026 total of 15.5683 mills, or about $15.57 per $1,000 of taxable value (rate chart). On top of that come flat non-ad valorem lines: sanitation, Englewood fire, stormwater and the Island Lake Estates CDD, which no homestead exemption reduces.
Charlotte County 2026 final millage, tax district 009 (all Coco Bay parcels)
| Levy | Mills |
|---|---|
| County | 6.1275 |
| Law Enforcement | 2.3578 |
| Lighting | 0.1907 |
| Integrated Shoreline | 0.1978 |
| Environmentally Sensitive Debt | 0.2000 |
| West Coast Inland Navigation District | 0.0394 |
| Southwest Florida Water Management District | 0.1831 |
| School, state | 3.0240 |
| School, local | 3.2480 |
| Total | 15.5683 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, 2026 Final Rate Chart, row "009 601". School levies total 6.2720 mills and non-school levies 9.2963 mills (our arithmetic), which matters because the homestead exemption is $25,000 against the first and $51,411 against the second.
The flat lines on 2026 Coco Bay bills were the Charlotte County Sanitation Unit at $335.51, the Englewood Area Fire Control District at $290.78, West Charlotte Stormwater at $11.34 to $21.65, and the Island Lake Estates CDD at $1,540.51, $1,925.60 or $2,342.77 depending on product type (Charlotte County Tax Collector, 2026 bills; Island Lake Estates CDD FY2027 budget). The fire district says its charge is "not based on the value of real and personal property" and is "not affected by the Homestead Exemption" (Englewood Area Fire Control District). The CDD section above breaks the CDD line into its operations and debt parts and explains the Series 2023 bonds.
One builder figure is worth flagging. Lennar's Island Lakes at Coco Bay Executive Homes page lists an "Approximate tax rate" of 0.97 percent (builder-stated, read November 17, 2026, subject to change) (Lennar). The district 009 rate is 1.557 percent of taxable value before exemptions, and the CDD and other flat lines come on top (our arithmetic from the 2026 Final Rate Chart). A resale buyer should budget from the real millage, not the builder's estimate. Bills paid in November earn a 4 percent discount, then 3 percent in December, 2 percent in January and 1 percent in February (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Each August, Charlotte County mails a TRIM notice with the proposed value and taxes for every Coco Bay parcel. An owner who thinks the January 1 just value is too high has 25 days from mailing to petition the Value Adjustment Board, with a $50 fee per parcel (county). The CDD line cannot be appealed there.
The county's calendar: "Mid-August Notice of Proposed Property Taxes (NOPPT) mailed," and "25 days after NOPPT mailed Deadline for filing petition contesting property value" (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, Important Dates). The filing fee is "fifty dollars ($50.00) for each separate parcel," and filing a petition "does not change the Tax Collector's collection process"; taxes are due March 31 and delinquent April 1 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, Notice to Petitioner). To win on value, petitioners "must present applicable market data and evidence" showing the s. 193.011 factors were not properly considered and the county figure exceeds just value (same source). The statute allows an informal conference with the Property Appraiser first and requires evidence to be exchanged at least 15 days before the hearing (Florida Statutes s. 194.011). The office's own advice is "But See Us First" (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, TRIM).
For a Coco Bay owner, the hurdle is real. With just values already around 80.5 to 81 percent of 2025 prices, a petition succeeds only with evidence that comparable Coco Bay homes were selling below the county's figure, before the 15 percent step, on January 1 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our computation). The CDD's operations rate is set at the district's own public hearing, which the TRIM notice announces (Island Lake Estates CDD FAQ). If you plan to contest a 2027 notice, a CMA dated close to January 1 is the kind of market evidence the board asks for; request a Coco Bay home valuation early in the year.
Florida's 2026 Amendment 3 property tax measure passed on unofficial November 3, 2026 results (WGCU), but the result was not certified and no implementing law was published in any source we read as of November 17, 2026. Coco Bay owners should treat any change to exemptions or caps as pending, and it does not touch the CDD line.
WGCU reported the measure passed with 62 percent statewide and 74 percent yes in Charlotte County (WGCU, November 4, 2026). The Charlotte County Property Appraiser's summary says that for non-homesteaded property "the annual assessment cap would change from 10% to 5%," and that the measure does not apply to non-ad valorem assessments or fees (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, Amendment 3). We print no exemption dollar figures for future years here, because they depend on certification and on legislation not yet published.
Lennar's Island Lakes at Coco Bay page carried the banner "Amendment 3 approved! Close on your Lennar home by Nov. 30" when we read it on November 17, 2026 (Lennar). That is builder marketing, not a tax ruling. What matters for valuation is that any homestead change belongs to the buyer's tax status, not the house: it can help a resident buyer's payment, while a second-home buyer gets none of the homestead change. We will update this section once certification and the implementing statute are published.
Coco Bay prices are not crashing in 2026, but they are not back at 2024 levels either. Quarterly medians per heated square foot recovered from the 2025 low (county records), with more resales and larger homes in the mix, while Charlotte County prices held roughly flat and mortgage rates rose. Lennar's remaining inventory still sets the ceiling.
Data updated: November 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026, qualified sales through August 24, 2026; Florida Realtors October 2026 and year-end 2025 releases for the Punta Gorda MSA; FHFA House Price Index through the second quarter of 2026; Census Bureau Building Permits Survey through September 2026; Freddie Mac PMMS for the week of November 12, 2026; our tabulation).
From January through August 24, 2026, Coco Bay recorded 61 Lennar first sales at a $315,600 median and 16 resales at a $282,500 median (county records). The resale median is lower largely because 9 of the 16 resales were villas. The bigger 2026 change is volume: Lennar's recorded first sales fell sharply while several of its collections read sold out.
Coco Bay qualified improved sales, January through August of each year
| Period | Lennar first sales | Resales |
|---|---|---|
| January to August 2025 | 149 | 5 |
| January to August 2026 (newest sale August 24) | 61 | 16 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, monthly counts, our tabulation.
The 2026 calendar-year medians, $315,600 for 61 first sales and $282,500 for 16 resales, are a mix story (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Of the 16 resales, 9 were villas and 7 detached homes (our count from the county resale list), so the resale median leans toward villa prices. The per-foot view in the price section above corrects for size: the quarterly median per heated square foot was 176 in 2026 Q1 on 30 sales with 3 resales, 197 in Q2 on 32 sales with 8 resales, and 190 in Q3 on 15 sales with 5 resales (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Quarterly medians shift with the mix of homes sold. With resales now a quarter to a third of a quarter's sales (8 of 32 in Q2, 5 of 15 in Q3), and the Q3 count still partial, we read 2026 as a recovery from the 2025 low rather than a jump.
What would show a real drop: Coco Bay resales of the same plan closing below the Lennar sales of that plan in the same months, quarter after quarter. With 16 resales in 2026, the county record is still too thin to show that pattern either way. What it does show is a market where the builder's last homes and a growing number of owner resales now compete for the same buyers. Our Coco Bay seller guide explains how to position a listing in that overlap.
Charlotte County single-family prices have been roughly flat through 2026 after falling in 2025. Florida Realtors put the county's October 2026 median at $345,000, up 0.9 percent (Florida Realtors), and the FHFA index for the Punta Gorda metro sat 0.2 percent below a year earlier. Coco Bay's 2025 low lines up with that county trough.
Florida Realtors reports the Punta Gorda MSA, which is all of Charlotte County. Here are the county figures (Florida Realtors October 2026 MSA summary; Florida Realtors year-end 2025).
Charlotte County (Punta Gorda MSA) closed sales, Florida Realtors
| Period | Single-family sales | Single-family median | Townhouse and condo median |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calendar year 2025 | 5,422 (up 6.8 percent) | $343,725 (down 5.6 percent) | $235,000 (down 14.5 percent) |
| October 2026 | 404 (down 12.4 percent) | $345,000 (up 0.9 percent) | $250,000 (up 6.4 percent) |
| 2026 year to date through October | 4,853 (up 6.5 percent) | $350,000 (up 2.3 percent) | $246,600 (up 4.1 percent) |
Sources: Florida Realtors October 2026, Florida Realtors year-end 2025. Percent changes are year over year.
The county single-family median of $350,000 for 2026 so far happens to match the Coco Bay detached 12-month median of $350,000 (Florida Realtors; Charlotte County Property Appraiser). That is a coincidence of mix: the county figure blends older canal homes, waterfront and new construction. Florida Realtors' townhouse and condo category is not a benchmark for Coco Bay's fee-simple paired villas either.
The FHFA all-transactions index measures repeat sales of the same homes with conforming loans. For the Punta Gorda metro it read 433.09 in 2024 Q4, 385.05 in 2025 Q3 and 391.34 in 2026 Q2 (FRED, FHFA Punta Gorda HPI). That is 9.6 percent below the 2024 Q4 reading (the series stood higher still, 437.69, in 2023 Q3), 1.6 percent above the 2025 Q3 low and 0.2 percent below 2025 Q2 (our arithmetic). The annual Charlotte County index fell 7.4 percent from 2024 to 2025 and 11.6 percent from its 2023 level (FRED, FHFA Charlotte County HPI). FHFA does not include new-construction first sales, so it cannot see Lennar's Coco Bay pricing directly. It does show that the resale market Lennar was pricing against reset in 2025 and has steadied since.
Florida Realtors' chief economist put the October slowdown this way: "it's important not to confuse slowing demand with a distressed housing market" (Florida Realtors, November 16, 2026). For Coco Bay, the market-wide measures that would normally round out this picture are not published at the community level: Coco Bay days on market, sale-to-list ratio, months of supply and active listing counts: Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026).
New-home supply is one of the main pressures on Coco Bay resale prices. Charlotte County single-family permits rose 24.1 percent in the first nine months of 2026 (Census), and Coco Bay itself still had 127 lots coded vacant on the November roll, 98 of them in Island Lakes at Coco Bay, where Lennar's Executive Homes collection is still selling.
Charlotte County one-unit building permits, Census Bureau
| Period | Units | Reported construction value per unit |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 3,804 | $303,330 |
| 2024 | 3,583 | $312,439 |
| 2025 | 2,571 | $318,406 |
| January to September 2026 | 2,523 (2,033 in the same months of 2025) | $313,149 |
Source: Census Bureau Building Permits Survey, Charlotte County and the annual county files for 2023, 2024 and 2025. Construction value excludes land and is not a sale price.
Permits fell 28.2 percent in 2025 after the 2024 storms and came back in 2026, with 298 one-unit permits in September 2026 alone (Census Bureau; FGCU Regional Economic Research Institute). More homes under construction now means more finished new homes competing for buyers over the next year. Our new construction in Englewood page tracks the communities a Coco Bay buyer is likely to tour.
Lennar has described the other side of that competition in its own filing: "Resales of existing housing inventory have also begun to increase, particularly in Texas and Florida, intensifying competition for buyers in those markets" (Lennar Form 10-Q). Inside Coco Bay, the end of Lennar's selling is in sight. At the Island Lake Estates CDD's April 14, 2026 meeting, a Lennar representative on the board said the last home "might be sold in the middle of 2027" (CDD minutes, April 14, 2026). Once that happens, Coco Bay resales stop competing with the builder inside Coco Bay and start setting the community's prices themselves. Villa and Manor resales are already there, since Lennar's Island Lakes at Coco Bay page showed those collections sold out (builder-stated, read November 17, 2026, subject to change); the Lennar section above explains what that means.
Most Coco Bay buyers finance, so the rate decides how much house a monthly budget buys. Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average was 7.11 percent for the week of November 12, 2026, against 6.24 percent a year earlier (Freddie Mac). At the same budget, each quarter point of rate moves a Coco Bay buyer's price by roughly $7,000 to $8,000.
The rate path: Freddie Mac reported 7.11 percent on November 12, 2026, down from 7.18 percent the week before (Freddie Mac PMMS). The 2026 low was 5.98 percent on February 26 and the high 7.40 percent on October 8 and October 15 (FRED, Freddie Mac 30-year series). On a $280,000 loan, 80 percent of a $350,000 Coco Bay home, principal and interest is about $1,722 a month at 6.24 percent and $1,884 at 7.11 percent, a 9.4 percent rise for the same loan (our arithmetic from the PMMS rates).
What one monthly budget buys in Coco Bay at different rates
| 30-year rate | Price supported by the same total payment |
|---|---|
| 6.10 percent | $380,396 |
| 6.24 percent | $375,956 |
| 6.50 percent | $367,908 |
| 6.86 percent | $357,179 |
| 7.11 percent | $350,000 |
| 7.40 percent | $341,942 |
Source: our computation on a $3,094.94 total monthly payment (the $350,000 Executive home case in the carrying-cost section below, 20 percent down, Coco Bay millage, CDD, other non-ad valorem lines, builder-stated HOA and an average insurance figure); rate from Freddie Mac PMMS. A budget estimate, not a loan quote.
This is the link between rates and Coco Bay prices. When rates rise and a builder can buy them down while an owner cannot, the owner's home must close the payment gap some other way: price, a seller credit within the caps above, or a feature such as an assumable loan. Florida Realtors' chief economist expects that "If they stay above 7%, we should expect sales to remain subdued and inventory to gradually rebuild" (Florida Realtors, November 16, 2026).
Local Realtor board closings, mostly in Charlotte County, peaked from March through June in 2026, so the deepest pool of Coco Bay buyers likely signs contracts from January into April. The board's monthly closings ran from 396 in January to a high of 665 in March (board data), then eased. Seasonal price differences are partly mix.
The board's 2026 monthly closed sales were 396 in January, 502 in February, 665 in March, 604 in April, 651 in May, 609 in June, 531 in July, 490 in August, 488 in September and 443 in October (REALTORS of Punta Gorda-Port Charlotte-North Port-DeSoto, October 2026 report). The board notes its data "reflects only The sales published through Stellar MLS," and its October member sales were 66 percent Charlotte County, so these counts describe the area's rhythm, not a Coco Bay figure.
Coco Bay's own record follows the builder's calendar more than the season. Lennar's first sales in Coco Bay ran 32 in March 2025 but 8 in March 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser), as Lennar had fewer Coco Bay homes left to sell. As Lennar finishes, Coco Bay resales should start to follow the county's spring peak. A Coco Bay owner who wants the widest choice of buyers is usually best served by being photographed, priced and listed by late January.
Five things will move Coco Bay values over the next year: how fast Lennar sells its remaining Island Lakes lots and at what incentive, the mortgage rate, the next FHFA and Florida Realtors readings, the NFIP authorization date of December 11, 2026 (NAHB), and the certification of Amendment 3. Each has a date we can watch.
The better question is not where the market goes next but what your home would sell for now, against the Lennar homes a buyer can tour this week. That takes a CMA, and it takes days. Request your free Coco Bay home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. For the wider area, our Englewood home valuation page applies the same method to Englewood's older neighborhoods, and our Englewood area page gives the bigger picture.
A Coco Bay buyer pays for the home through a monthly payment that includes far more than the mortgage: county taxes, the Island Lake Estates CDD line, other flat assessments, HOA dues and insurance. Every extra dollar a month lowers the price a payment-limited buyer can offer, so carrying costs set a working ceiling on Coco Bay values.
Data updated: November 2026 (Freddie Mac PMMS for the week of November 12, 2026; Charlotte County 2026 final millage; Island Lake Estates CDD FY2027 budget; Lennar Island Lakes at Coco Bay Executive Homes page read November 17, 2026; Citizens 2026 approved rate changes by county; FHFA and HUD 2026 loan limits; our computation).
A Coco Bay buyer's lender counts principal and interest, ad valorem taxes, the CDD and other non-ad valorem lines, HOA dues and homeowners insurance, plus flood insurance where it applies. Fannie Mae includes taxes, insurance, association dues and special assessments in housing expense, so each of them reduces how much a Coco Bay buyer can borrow.
Fannie Mae's housing expense includes "real estate taxes," "property, flood, and mortgage insurance premiums, as applicable," "owners' association dues" and "special assessments" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-03). The CDD is collected on the Coco Bay tax bill, so in practice it usually sits inside the tax escrow (our reading; the topic does not name CDDs). For DU loans, "the maximum allowable DTI ratio is 50%"; manually underwritten loans are capped at 36 percent, up to 45 percent with credit and reserve requirements (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-02).
The inputs behind our Coco Bay payment examples
| Input | Figure used | Source and note |
|---|---|---|
| Mortgage rate | 7.11 percent, 30-year fixed, 20 percent down | Freddie Mac PMMS, week of November 12, 2026 |
| Ad valorem tax | 15.5683 mills on a taxable value equal to price | 2026 Final Rate Chart; a ceiling, since just value usually sits below price |
| Homestead case | $25,000 school and $51,411 non-school exemptions | Florida Department of Revenue |
| CDD line | $1,540.51 (villa 40 ft), $1,925.60 (Executive 52 ft), $2,342.77 (Manor 65 ft) a year | Island Lake Estates CDD FY2027 budget |
| Other flat lines | $642.79 a year (sanitation, fire, stormwater) | 2026 Coco Bay tax bills, Charlotte County Tax Collector, our total |
| HOA | $302.67, treated as monthly; Lennar does not state the period | Lennar, builder-stated, read November 17, 2026 |
| Homeowners insurance | $2,887 a year, the Citizens HO3 approved average for Charlotte County; an average, not a Coco Bay quote | Citizens 2026 approved rate changes by county |
| Flood insurance | $0 in the base case (shaded Zone X or a whole-lot LOMR-F, no lender mandate) | See the flood section above for the Coco Bay flood picture |
If the HOA figure turns out to be quarterly or annual rather than monthly, every total below falls; at an annual $302.67, the monthly totals would drop by about $277 (our arithmetic) (Lennar). Confirm the period on an estoppel certificate before relying on these numbers.
At 7.11 percent with 20 percent down, our estimate is about $2,562 a month for a $275,000 Coco Bay villa, $3,095 for a $350,000 Executive home and $3,798 for a $450,000 Manor home, as a non-homestead first year (PMMS rate). These are worked estimates from the inputs above, not quotes, and insurance is an average.
Estimated monthly cost of a Coco Bay home at three price points
| Line | $275,000 villa, 40 ft | $350,000 Executive, 52 ft | $450,000 Manor, 65 ft |
|---|---|---|---|
| Principal and interest at 7.11 percent | $1,479.95 | $1,883.58 | $2,421.74 |
| Ad valorem tax, non-homestead | $356.77 | $454.08 | $583.81 |
| Homeowners insurance (Charlotte Citizens HO3 average) | $240.58 | $240.58 | $240.58 |
| Island Lake Estates CDD | $128.38 | $160.47 | $195.23 |
| Sanitation, fire, stormwater | $53.57 | $53.57 | $53.57 |
| HOA (builder-stated, period not stated) | $302.67 | $302.67 | $302.67 |
| Total, non-homestead | $2,561.92 | $3,094.94 | $3,797.60 |
| Total with 2026 homestead exemptions | $2,509.03 | $3,042.04 | $3,744.71 |
| Total at last year's 6.24 percent rate | $2,435.12 | $2,933.55 | $3,590.10 |
| Total at a 4.75 percent builder-style ARM, years 1 to 7 | $2,229.59 | $2,671.97 | $3,253.79 |
| Total with VA, 0 down, 2.15 percent funding fee financed, 7.11 percent | $2,971.68 | $3,616.45 | $4,468.12 |
Sources: our computation from Freddie Mac PMMS, the 2026 Final Rate Chart, the CDD FY2027 budget, Lennar's builder-stated HOA figure, the Citizens county rate table and the VA funding fee page. The 4.75 percent row uses the rate Lennar advertised on a Sarasota-area promotion for contracts from November 16 to November 30, 2026, which does not name Coco Bay (Lennar); the Lennar section above covers that offer.
The income a buyer needs follows from the totals. With no other debts, the $350,000 Executive home's $3,094.94 payment needs about $119,804 a year at a 31 percent housing ratio, $103,165 at 36 percent, and $74,279 at the 50 percent DU maximum; the $275,000 villa needs $99,171, $85,397 and $61,486; the $450,000 Manor home needs $147,004, $126,587 and $91,143 (our arithmetic) (Fannie Mae). Real buyers carry car loans and cards, so their limits bind sooner.
Two cautions. The tax line assumes taxable value equal to price, which overstates the first-year tax for most buyers because just value usually sits below price; it is a deliberate ceiling. And no homeowners or flood quote exists for any Coco Bay address in the public sources we read, so insurance is the only line that is purely an average. A 2023 to 2025 Coco Bay home built to the current Florida Building Code qualifies for at least a 68 percent discount on the windstorm portion of the premium once documented (Florida CFO guide), so a real quote may come in below the average.
If you are shopping for a home rather than selling one, call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or see our Englewood buyer's guide. If you own in Coco Bay and want a price that accounts for what your buyer will actually pay each month, request your free Coco Bay valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
At 7.11 percent, each dollar of monthly cost on a Coco Bay home displaces about $150 of price a buyer could otherwise finance (PMMS rate). On that scale the Executive home's CDD line is worth about $24,000 of borrowing power, and a prepaid CDD debt portion restores about $20,800. That is how carrying costs turn into price.
Price equivalent of Coco Bay carrying-cost lines, at the $350,000 Executive home budget
| Line | Monthly amount | About this much price |
|---|---|---|
| Each $1 a month of payment | $1 | $149.72 |
| Each $100 a month | $100 | $14,972 |
| Executive CDD line ($1,925.60 a year) | $160.47 | $24,026 |
| CDD debt portion prepaid ($1,668.69 a year removed) | $139.06 | $20,820 |
| HOA at $302.67 if monthly | $302.67 | $45,317 |
| $1,000 a year of homeowners premium (for example, with or without a documented wind credit) | $83.33 | $12,477 |
| $500 a year of flood premium | $41.67 | $6,238 |
Source: our computation at the PMMS 7.11 percent rate, 20 percent down and district 009 millage; CDD amounts from the CDD FY2027 budget. Price equivalents are our estimates, not a discount the market applies one for one.
This table does not say Coco Bay homes are discounted by their CDD and HOA. Buyers also get the lakes, infrastructure and amenities those charges pay for, and every Coco Bay comparable carries the same district (CDD budget). What it does say is why a Coco Bay value is set against other homes carrying the same charges, mainly Lennar's own inventory and other Coco Bay resales, and not against an older Englewood home with no CDD and a low HOA. It also shows which documents are worth money at a sale: a CDD prepayment confirmation, a wind mitigation form, and a flood letter that keeps a lender's mandate off the file. The CDD section above explains how to obtain the CDD payoff figure from the district manager.
Conforming loan limits do not cap Coco Bay prices. The 2026 conforming limit for a one-unit home in Charlotte County is $832,750, above every recorded Coco Bay sale, and HUD's 2026 national FHA floor is $541,287 (HUD), above most Coco Bay sales. Veterans with full entitlement face no VA loan limit at all.
FHFA set the 2026 baseline conforming limit at $832,750, up $26,250 (FHFA, November 25, 2025), and FHFA's county list shows Charlotte County at the baseline (FHFA 2026 county loan limits). HUD set the 2026 FHA one-unit floor at $541,287 for case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2026 (HUD No. 25-145); we did not retrieve HUD's own Charlotte County row, so treat the floor as the working figure until a lender confirms it. VA says that with full entitlement there is no VA loan limit (VA loan limits).
For comparison, the middle half of Coco Bay detached sales over 24 months ran from $345,000 to $459,200 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Every Coco Bay sale on record fits under the conforming limit, and FHA fits all but the largest Coco Bay homes, which keeps the buyer pool wide (our comparison with the county sales file). The 2027 conforming limit had not been announced in the sources we read.
Yes, with conditions. FHA and VA loans can be assumed by a qualified buyer, and a Coco Bay owner who closed with a below-market fixed rate can offer that rate as part of the sale. The buyer must still cover the gap between the price and the loan balance, and the seller should obtain a formal release of liability.
HUD's assumption notice says the seller remains liable "unless you obtain a release from liability," which comes through form HUD-92210.1, Approval of Purchaser and Release of Seller, and that HUD can accelerate the loan if the buyer will not occupy the home or has not been credit-approved (HUD assumption notice). VA lists assuming a VA-backed loan as a purchase option (VA purchase loans) and charges a funding fee of 0.5 percent of the loan amount on assumptions (VA funding fee).
The value in numbers: a $300,000 balance at 5.5 percent costs $1,703.37 a month in principal and interest, against $2,018.12 at the current 7.11 percent, a $314.75 monthly difference that is worth roughly $47,000 of price to a buyer who can fund the difference between price and balance (our estimate, from the PMMS rate and the price multiplier above). Two caveats keep this honest. The Lennar promotional loans we read were adjustable-rate loans that reset after their fixed period, so they carry less value than a fixed note. And how many Coco Bay owners hold FHA or VA loans, and at what rates, is not in any public source we read. If you have one, tell us when you request your Coco Bay home valuation; it can change how we market your home.
Coco Bay's recorded resales are still few, and they split almost evenly. Of 17 homes resold in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, 8 sold above and 9 below the price paid at the prior recorded sale, for a median change of 2.5 percent below, after a median 19 months (county records). Owner additions are not in either price.
Data updated: November 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026, with qualified sales through August 24, 2026; repeat-sale pairs where the later sale fell between September 10, 2025 and September 9, 2026, and for the 24-month view between September 10, 2024 and September 9, 2026; our tabulation).
In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, 17 Coco Bay homes sold a second time. Eight sold above the price paid at the prior recorded sale and nine below, a median 2.5 percent below, with a median 19 months between the two sales (county records). Split by type or plat, every group is small, so we show counts only.
Coco Bay repeat sales, later sale in the 12 months to September 9, 2026
| Group | Pairs | Sold above the prior price | Sold below the prior price |
|---|---|---|---|
| All Coco Bay | 17 | 8 | 9 |
| Detached homes | 8, a small group | 5 | 3 |
| Villas | 9, a small group | 3 | 6 |
| Coco Bay plat | 7, a small group | 2 | 5 |
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay | 5, a small group | 3 | 2 |
| Palm Lake at Coco Bay | 5, a small group | 3 | 2 |
| Prior sale in 2023 | 1, a small group | 0 | 1 |
| Prior sale in 2024 | 8, a small group | 2 | 6 |
| Prior sale in 2025 or later | 8, a small group | 6 | 2 |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our tabulation. No pair sold at exactly its prior price. Small groups are shown so the counts are visible; we draw no percentage conclusion from them.
The median time between the two sales was 19 months, with a middle half of 12 to 26 months (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The one pattern worth noting, with the small-group caution attached, is timing: owners whose prior purchase closed in 2024 mostly resold below that price (6 of 8), while owners who bought in 2025 or later mostly resold above it (6 of 8). That fits the quarterly record in the price section above, where 2024 Lennar prices per heated square foot sat well above 2025's. It is a reading of when the prior price was set, not a measure of the homes themselves.
Widening the window to 24 months gives every Coco Bay resale on record: 24 pairs, 11 above and 13 below the prior price, a median 2.1 percent below over a median 14 months (county records). Detached homes split evenly, 7 and 7; villas leaned below, 4 above and 6 below. Only these groups are large enough for a median.
Coco Bay repeat sales, later sale in the 24 months to September 9, 2026
| Group | Pairs | Above | Below | Median change from the prior price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All Coco Bay | 24 | 11 | 13 | 2.1 percent below |
| Detached homes | 14 | 7 | 7 | 0.2 percent below |
| Villas | 10 | 4 | 6 | 3.7 percent below |
| Coco Bay plat | 13 | 4 | 9 | 4.8 percent below |
| Prior sale in 2024 | 15 | 5 | 10 | 4.8 percent below |
| Island Lakes at Coco Bay | 5, a small group | 3 | 2 | not stated |
| Palm Lake at Coco Bay | 6, a small group | 4 | 2 | not stated |
| Prior sale in 2025 or later | 8, a small group | 6 | 2 | not stated |
Source: Charlotte County Property Appraiser, our tabulation. The median time between sales was 14 months.
Every Coco Bay home that has ever sold twice is in this table: the county shows 467 parcels that sold at least once as a finished home and 24 that sold twice (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The Coco Bay plat holds the most pairs, and 12 of its 13 prior prices date from 2024, with the other from 2023 (our count from the county resale list). That is why its median sits below the others: it is the same timing effect as the 2024 row, seen through the plat.
Set beside the price section's per-foot comparison, which shows 24-month resales recording higher median prices per heated square foot than Lennar's first sales, these pairs show two things at once (county records). In the 24-month medians, Coco Bay resales recorded more per foot than Lennar first sales (14 detached and 10 villa resales), and 10 of the 15 homes first bought in 2024 resold below that 2024 price. Both are true because Lennar's prices fell between 2024 and 2025, and resales carry options, lot premiums and finished extras that a base-price first sale did not.
Coco Bay repeat sales compare two recorded prices for one home, and nothing else. They cannot show the Lennar incentive inside the first price, the pool or lanai added between sales, the selling costs, or the lot. With 17 pairs in 12 months (county records), they describe a pattern for Coco Bay, not a forecast for your home.
Five limits to keep in mind:
That is why we treat repeat sales as one input in a Coco Bay CMA, beside current resales of the same plan, Lennar's live price sheet and the buyer's monthly payment. If you want a figure built that way for your home, request your free Coco Bay home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. Our Coco Bay guide covers the community itself, and our Englewood seller guide explains selling across the wider area.
Yes, and there is no charge. A comparative market analysis for a Coco Bay home starts inside the house, then prices it against recorded Coco Bay sales of the same product, plan size and plat, with every Lennar first sale checked for incentives, not against one Coco Bay median that blends villas, Executive Homes and Estate Homes.
Data updated: November 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026, qualified improved sales through September 9, 2026; Lennar pages, district records and agency pages read November 17, 2026).
Coco Bay is almost entirely a builder market, which is why the visit matters more here than a database search. County records show 129 qualified improved sales in the 12 months to September 9, 2026, and 112 of them were first sales by the builder, with only 17 resales (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). A recorded Lennar deed price tells us what a buyer paid after whatever closing credit or rate buydown came with it. It does not tell us the lot, the options or the owner additions. Our job at your door is to find which of those 129 sales truly match your home, and which ones need explaining. Our Coco Bay guide describes the three plats and the amenity center, and our Coco Bay seller guide covers the selling steps once you have a number.
Send the Coco Bay valuation request on this page or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, and we will set a time, by video if you are out of town. Pulling your Lennar closing papers and a few Coco Bay records first lets us return a tighter written price range for your home.
The papers that move a Coco Bay price are the ones that separate your home from Lennar's base product. Start with your Lennar purchase agreement and the options addendum, because the move-in ready and under-construction listings of one Carson plan on Lennar's site sit $89,608 apart with no lot-premium field shown (Lennar, Island Lakes at Coco Bay). Add your closing statement, which shows any builder credit, the permits for a pool, cage, lanai extension or generator added after closing, and your wind mitigation form. Florida's consumer guide says homes built to the 2001 Florida Building Code or later qualify for a minimum 68 percent discount on the windstorm part of the premium, and a completed form stays valid for five years if the structure does not change (Florida Department of Financial Services, hurricane mitigation discounts).
Bring your flood paperwork too. Four FEMA LOMR-F cases cover groups of Coco Bay lots (24-04-3577A, 24-04-6777A, 24-04-6894A and 24-04-6852A, all completed in 2024), and FEMA's base map does not show those removals, so the letter is what a buyer's lender reads (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, LOMA layer). If you have prepaid any of the Island Lake Estates CDD debt, bring the district's confirmation; the district says owners may pay off the capital assessment early by contacting its office (Island Lake Estates CDD, FAQs).
These records count for more since November 2, 2026, the date UAD 3.6 became mandatory for appraisal reports on loans sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac (Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, UAD 3.6 announcement). Under the new form a never-occupied Lennar spec home that meets the new construction definition can be represented as C1, while a lived-in Coco Bay home is rated on its observed condition, and porches and patios are reported as Outdoor Living features and inground pools as Water Features (Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, UAD 3.6 lessons learned job aid). Paper proof of each addition fills those rows from facts.
The written range we return names every Coco Bay sale we relied on by plat, product, month, year built, county heated area and price, drawn from the roll dated November 5, 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). It sets your home beside Lennar's builder-stated price for the same plan, read on the day we write it, and shows the tax lines a buyer will carry: 15.5683 mills in tax district 009 for 2026 and the CDD line for your product type, $1,540.51 for a 40 foot paired villa, $1,925.60 for an Executive Home and $2,342.77 for a Manor Home (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, 2026 final rate chart; Island Lake Estates CDD, FY2027 adopted budget). You can also reach us through our contact page.
Buying your next home as well? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or see our Englewood buyer representation page. The visit carries no obligation, and it comes from Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.
A Coco Bay CMA is our written price opinion, prepared before you list, so the asking price holds up against Lennar's sheet and the buyer's appraisal. A lender's appraiser works later, for the buyer's loan, under Fannie Mae, FHA or VA rules that limit how Lennar sales and their concessions can be used.
Florida law keeps the two apart. A broker or sales associate may give a comparative market analysis or a broker price opinion in the ordinary course of business, but "in no event" may it be referred to as an appraisal (Florida Statutes 475.25). Only a certified or licensed appraiser may issue an appraisal report (Florida Statutes 475.612).
| Question | Coco Bay CMA from our team | Lender appraisal |
|---|---|---|
| Who writes it | Your listing team | A Florida certified or licensed appraiser |
| When | Before the listing goes live | After a financed contract is signed |
| Inside Coco Bay | Resales first, then Lennar first sales of your plan and plat | At least one sale from inside the subdivision; a verifiable resale not involving the builder is preferred |
| Outside Coco Bay | Named only when it explains your price | At least one sale from outside the subdivision |
| Lennar incentives | Read from closing statements and Lennar's dated offers | Builder comps adjusted downward for concessions; no upward adjustment allowed |
| Market time | Coco Bay quarterly medians per heated square foot | Time adjustment must be supported by evidence |
| Goal | A list price that draws offers against Lennar's sheet | Support for the loan amount |
Fannie Mae requires at least three closed comparables, and in a new subdivision at least one settled sale from inside it and one from outside, adding that "a resale is preferable if it is verifiable and does not involve the subject builder or developer" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08). Comparables with sales or financing concessions must be adjusted, and "positive adjustments for sales or financing concessions are not acceptable" (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09). FHA's handbook says arm's length resales inside an established subdivision are "often the best indicator of value" (HUD Handbook 4000.1). With 24 Coco Bay resales in the 24 months to September 9, 2026 against 314 first sales by the builder (Charlotte County Property Appraiser), every resale carries weight, and a CMA that lays them out by plan and plat gives the appraiser a head start.
A Coco Bay valuation answers what your home is worth today. Most owners then ask how to sell it, what a buyer sees in the community, and how Coco Bay prices sit beside the rest of Englewood, and each of those questions has its own page on our site, linked below.
Our Coco Bay seller guide covers disclosures, the CDD estoppel, listing against Lennar and a net sheet. Our Coco Bay community guide walks through the plats, the amenity center and the location off Placida Road. The Florida seller closing costs guide explains each settlement line. For the wider town, open the Englewood home values page, the Englewood seller guide, our Englewood area guide and our Englewood new construction guide. Neighboring valuation pages cover Grove City home values, Englewood East home values, Boca Royale home values and Beachwalk by Manasota Key home values. Buying next? Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.
Coco Bay owners ask these questions about value, and each answer rests on a county record, a district filing, a statute, a lender rule, a Lennar page read on a stated date or a primary market report. Unless an answer names another period, a sales figure counts qualified improved sales in the three Coco Bay plats recorded September 10, 2025 through September 9, 2026.
Those sales come from the Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Price per square foot always divides by the heated (living) area the county records, not the total under roof a Lennar brochure or listing may quote. Where fewer than 10 sales sit behind a figure we call it a small group, show how many sales it holds and draw no percentage conclusion. Lennar prices are builder-stated, read November 17, 2026, and subject to change. Figures for all of Charlotte County come from Florida Realtors' Punta Gorda MSA reports, which cover the whole county, not Coco Bay alone.
Data updated: November 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026, sales through September 9, 2026; Island Lake Estates CDD FY2027 budget; Florida Realtors October 2026 report; Freddie Mac rate for the week of November 12, 2026; Lennar, statute and agency pages read November 17, 2026).
Start with the product, because a villa and a detached home are separate markets. In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, Coco Bay's 129 qualified improved sales had a $315,000 median, but detached homes sold at a $350,000 median on 55 sales and villas at $249,500 on 32 sales (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Your plan size, plat and lot then narrow the number. Request a free Coco Bay valuation and we will name the sales that match yours.
Neither. Coco Bay is a Lennar new-construction community in unincorporated western Charlotte County with Englewood 34224 addresses, and it has nothing to do with Coco Bay at Pelican Bay in Naples. The county records three plats: Coco Bay (183 parcels), Island Lakes at Coco Bay (239) and Palm Lake at Coco Bay (179), 601 parcels in all (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Online estimates that mix the two names value the wrong houses.
The November 5, 2026 roll lists 287 detached homes with a median 2,198 heated square feet, 158 attached villas with a median 1,423, 127 lots still coded vacant and 29 other-coded parcels, with homes built from 2023 to 2025 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Ninety-eight of the vacant-coded lots are in Island Lakes at Coco Bay, where Lennar is still selling. Vacant coding can lag construction, so some of those lots may already have homes going up.
It depends on the product. Over 24 months, villas recorded a median $197 per heated square foot in the Coco Bay plat (15 sales), $190 in Island Lakes at Coco Bay (43 sales) and $155 in Palm Lake at Coco Bay (50 sales). Detached medians were close: $389,600 in the Coco Bay plat (37 sales), $375,000 in Island Lakes (77) and $375,750 in Palm Lake (74) (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Plan mix explains much of each gap.
Across the 87 sales of the last 12 months with a county heated area, the median was $173 per heated square foot, with a middle half of $162 to $186 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Detached homes ran a $173 median (55 sales, middle half $164 to $185) and villas $162 (32 sales, middle half $154 to $192). Divide by the county's heated area, not a brochure's total under roof, or the comparison will mislead.
Over 12 months, yes on the median: villas recorded $162 per heated square foot on 32 sales against $173 for detached homes on 55 sales (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The villa middle half ran wider, $154 to $192, because Palm Lake at Coco Bay villas sold lower than those in the other two plats. A Coco Bay villa is valued against villa sales in its own plat first, then the others.
In the last 12 months, detached homes of 1,700 to 1,999 heated square feet sold at a $325,000 median on 19 sales ($175 per square foot), and homes of 2,000 to 2,399 at $360,000 on 28 sales ($170). Homes of 2,400 and up are a small group in that window, 8 sales at a $490,000 median (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Over 24 months the 2,400 and up band holds 47 sales at a $500,000 median.
At the top, yes. Over 24 months detached homes of 2,400 heated square feet and up recorded a $203 median per square foot on 47 sales, against $173 for 2,000 to 2,399 (104 sales) and $180 for 1,700 to 1,999 (36 sales) (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The largest homes include Palm Lake's Estate Homes, which Lennar listed at 2,395 to 2,799 square feet (Lennar, Palm Lake at Coco Bay brochure), so collection and lot travel with size.
Per heated square foot, the builder's price level fell and then partly recovered. County records show quarterly medians of $209 in 2024 Q1 and $203 to $208 through the rest of 2024, then $166 in both 2025 Q3 and Q4, $176 in 2026 Q1 and $197 in 2026 Q2 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The 2026 Q2 figure had more resales and larger homes in the mix, so read it as a shift in what sold, not a jump in price.
Almost every Coco Bay sale is a Lennar first sale, so the county record follows Lennar's pricing. Company-wide, Lennar's average delivered price fell from $430,000 in its fourth quarter of 2024 to $386,000 a year later, and it said it "maintained approximately 14% in incentives and price adjustments" (Lennar, fourth quarter 2025 results). In Coco Bay the quarterly median fell to $166 per heated square foot in 2025 Q3 and Q4 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Lennar's filings say yes. In its East segment, which includes Florida, average sales incentives per home delivered were $48,000 in the quarter ended August 31, 2026, against $77,600 a year earlier, or 11.5 percent of revenue against 17.6 percent (Lennar Form 10-Q, Q3 fiscal 2026). Coco Bay's median per heated square foot was $176 in 2026 Q1 after $166 in late 2025 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser), a timing match, not proof of cause.
Per square foot, they have. Over 24 months, detached resales recorded a $209 median per heated square foot on 14 sales against $177 for 174 first sales by the builder, 17.9 percent higher; villa resales ran $193 on 10 sales against $176 on 98, 9.9 percent higher (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). First sales are recorded at the contract price after incentives, while a resale includes the lot, options and owner additions. The groups are small, and this is not a forecast.
Some have and some have not. In the 12 months to September 9, 2026, 17 Coco Bay homes resold: 8 sold above the price paid at the prior recorded sale and 9 below, with a median change of minus 2.5 percent over a median 19 months between sales (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). The prior price does not include a pool, cage or lanai added later, so a home with additions is not a like-for-like pair.
The resale record hints that it does, but the groups are small. Of the 12-month resales whose prior sale was in 2024, a small group of 8, 2 sold above the price paid at the prior recorded sale and 6 below. Of those first bought in 2025 or later, also 8, 6 sold above and 2 below (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). That pattern fits the 2024 Q1 builder level of $209 per heated square foot against $166 in late 2025.
Over 24 months, detached homes built in 2024 sold at a $389,600 median on 114 sales ($181 per heated square foot) and those built in 2025 at $360,000 on 73 sales ($175). Villas reversed it: 2024 builds sold at $250,000 on 76 sales ($176) and 2025 builds at $268,000 on 32 sales ($187) (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Year built tracks the plat and the price sheet of the month, so we compare plan to plan, not year to year.
On November 17, 2026, Lennar's Island Lakes at Coco Bay page showed Executive Homes plans from $309,999 (Armstrong, 1,635 square feet) to $416,999 (Marsala, 2,201 square feet), with Manor Homes and Villas marked sold out (Lennar, Island Lakes at Coco Bay). Those are builder-stated base prices, read November 17, 2026, and subject to change. Lots, options and incentives move the final figure.
For a base-option home of the same size, it sets the first comparison. Lennar's Goodall plan is listed from $373,999 at 2,198 square feet, about $170 per square foot, builder-stated and read November 17, 2026 (Lennar, Island Lakes at Coco Bay). Detached Coco Bay sales of 2,000 to 2,399 heated square feet recorded a $170 median over 12 months on 28 sales (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Anything above that needs a lot, options or additions to justify it.
Lennar's own site showed two Carson homes of the same 1,933 square foot plan listed $89,608 apart on November 17, 2026, one move-in ready and one under construction, with no lot size, view or premium field explaining the gap (Lennar, Island Lakes at Coco Bay). Lot position, structural options, design selections and completion timing all sit inside a Lennar price, which is why we read your options addendum before we compare.
Lennar's page reads "Palm Lake at Coco Bay is now sold out," and in Island Lakes the Manor Homes and Villas are sold out too (Lennar, Palm Lake at Coco Bay). In those segments a buyer can only buy a resale, so the stale Lennar "from" price is a listing figure, not evidence of value. Palm Lake detached homes sold at a $375,750 median over 24 months on 74 sales (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
At the Island Lake Estates CDD board meeting of April 14, 2026, a Lennar representative said "the last home might be sold in the middle of 2027," in a discussion of a $343,560 bond reserve release tied to Lennar's last sale (Island Lake Estates CDD, April 14, 2026 minutes). Until then, Island Lakes resales compete with Lennar inventory a few streets away, and the roll still codes 98 Island Lakes lots as vacant (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Lennar's Sarasota-area promotion offers up to $15,000 toward closing costs and a Lennar Mortgage 7/6 ARM at 4.750 percent (7.221 percent APR), for purchase agreements on select homes signed November 16 to November 30, 2026, with financing through Lennar Mortgage required (Lennar, Sarasota-area sales event). The offer page does not name Coco Bay. A resale buyer compares your price with that payment, not only with Lennar's sticker.
They adjust the Lennar sale, not yours. Fannie Mae requires comparables with sales or financing concessions to be adjusted to what they would have sold for without them, and bars positive adjustments for concessions (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09). A Coco Bay resale with no credit therefore cannot be lifted to match a Lennar sale that carried one. In late 2025 Lennar said it maintained about 14 percent in incentives and price adjustments (Lennar, fourth quarter 2025 results).
It depends on the loan. Fannie Mae caps interested party contributions on a principal residence at 3 percent above 90 percent loan-to-value, 6 percent from 75.01 to 90 percent and 9 percent at 75 percent or less (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02). FHA allows up to 6 percent of the sales price, buydowns included (HUD Handbook 4000.1). On a $350,000 Coco Bay home, 6 percent is $21,000 (our arithmetic).
Fannie Mae requires the property to be appraised within the 12 months before the note date, with an update when the report is more than four months old (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.2-04). FHA's initial validity is 180 days, extendable by update to one year (HUD Mortgagee Letter 2022-11). In Coco Bay, where the quarterly median per heated square foot moved from $166 to $197 within a year as the mix of homes sold shifted (Charlotte County Property Appraiser), an older report may describe an older market.
Not once it has been lived in. Fannie Mae reserves condition rating C1 for a home with no physical depreciation that has never been occupied, while an almost-new, well-kept home is C2 (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-06). Coco Bay's homes on the roll were built from 2023 to 2025 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser), so a resale competes with Lennar's never-occupied homes on condition as well as price.
Sometimes. Fannie Mae's automated underwriting can offer value acceptance, and it may do so on a recently built home when an "as is" prior appraisal exists for it; loans of $1,000,000 or more and proposed construction are excluded (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.4-10). The lender's system decides, not the seller. Every recorded Coco Bay sale so far sits well under that dollar line (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Only as far as buyers pay for them. Fannie Mae requires an appraisal that uses builder sales to include discussion and analysis of sales concessions and upgrades (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08). Some features are not upgrades in Coco Bay at all: Lennar lists hurricane-impact windows and sliding doors as standard, with a 10-year structural warranty (Lennar, Magnolia included features). Over 24 months, 174 detached first sales recorded a $177 median per heated square foot (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
No Coco Bay pairing exists, so we use the nearest regional study. In Cost vs Value 2025 for Fort Myers, a backup power generator recouped 94.7 percent of a $13,516 cost, a backyard patio 41.4 percent of $49,259 and a solar installation 29.8 percent of $55,694 (JLC Cost vs Value 2025, Fort Myers). The report has no pool project. We price a Coco Bay addition from permits, condition and the resales that have one.
Usually buyers pay more for water or preserve views, but no primary source gives a Coco Bay lot premium, and we print no figure. The county's mass appraisal barely separates lots: the median 2026 land value is $28,050 on a detached Coco Bay home and $17,000 on a villa (our computation from the county's 2026 roll, Charlotte County Property Appraiser). An appraiser must support any lot adjustment with market evidence, so we look for resales on similar lots.
Less accurate than most owners expect. One national brokerage's own published accuracy page, read November 17, 2026, reports a 7.56 percent median error for off-market Florida homes, with only 36.36 percent of those estimates within 5 percent. On a $350,000 Coco Bay home that median miss is about $26,460 (our arithmetic). Lender-used AVMs fall under federal quality-control rules, but website estimates do not (Federal Register, AVM quality control rule).
The model learns from recorded deeds, and in Coco Bay those are mostly Lennar first sales: 467 parcels have sold as homes and only 24 have sold twice or more (Charlotte County Property Appraiser). A deed price does not show the closing credit or rate buydown behind it, and Freddie Mac notes the appraiser "typically doesn't have access to the sales contract for the comparable sales" (Freddie Mac, concessions guide for appraisers). A walkthrough sees what the deed does not.
No. The interagency rule, effective October 1, 2025, sets quality-control standards for automated valuation models used by mortgage originators and secondary market issuers to value a principal dwelling (Federal Register, AVM quality control rule). It does not regulate consumer website estimates. For a Coco Bay home with 129 recorded sales in a year, 112 of them builder sales (Charlotte County Property Appraiser), a human read of the comparables still matters.
Yes. Coco Bay homes sit in the Island Lake Estates Community Development District, created on May 24, 2022 by Charlotte County Ordinance 2022-026 under Chapter 190, Florida Statutes (Island Lake Estates CDD, About the District). Its line appears on Coco Bay tax bills each November. The district's adopted budget counts 571 planned units across the Coco Bay and Palm Lake groups (Island Lake Estates CDD, FY2027 adopted budget).
It has two parts. For FY2027, operations and maintenance is $256.91 for every home, plus a fixed debt amount by product: $1,283.60 for a 40 foot paired villa, $1,668.69 for an Executive Home and $2,085.86 for a Manor Home (Island Lake Estates CDD, FY2027 adopted budget). Together they make the bill lines of $1,540.51, $1,925.60 and $2,342.77. The line follows product type, not your home's value.
The district issued $11,895,000 of Special Assessment Bonds, Series 2023, on November 30, 2023, with final maturity on December 15, 2053 (Island Lake Estates CDD, FY2025 audit). Owners may pay off the capital assessment early by asking the district manager for the figure on their parcel (Island Lake Estates CDD, FAQs). For an Executive Home, a proportional share of the bonds is about $21,000, our estimate, not a payoff quote.
Not against other Coco Bay homes, because every Coco Bay comparable carries the same district and a similar line for the same product. Fannie Mae requires appraisers to report special assessments and analyze similarly affected sales (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.4-09). It does affect borrowing power: at 7.11 percent, the $1,925.60 Executive line is about $160 a month, roughly $24,000 of price a payment-limited buyer cannot spend elsewhere (our estimate).
Lennar, for now. At September 30, 2025, four of the five supervisors were affiliated with Lennar Homes, and the audit says the district depends on the developer's continued involvement (Island Lake Estates CDD, FY2025 audit). The April 14, 2026 minutes say the board "would start transitioning to qualified electors in 2028" (Island Lake Estates CDD, April 14, 2026 minutes). The debt line follows the bond schedule whoever sits on the board.
Lennar's Island Lakes at Coco Bay Executive Homes page lists "Approximate HOA fees" of $302.67, builder-stated and read November 17, 2026 (Lennar, Island Lakes at Coco Bay Executive Homes). Lennar does not state the period. Fannie Mae counts association dues and special assessments in a buyer's monthly housing expense (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-6-03), so confirm your dues on an estoppel certificate before we price.
No. On the 2026 roll, Coco Bay just value ran a median 80.5 percent of the 2025 sale price for detached homes (127 sales) and 81.0 percent for villas (79 sales) (our computation from the county's 2026 roll). The county values every home as of January 1 and applies a 15 percent cost-of-sale step (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, just value adjustment). Just value is a mass-appraisal tax figure, not a price.
Florida values property as of January 1, and improvements not substantially completed on that date carry no value (Florida Statutes 192.042). A Coco Bay home finished after January 1 was taxed as a lot that year, plus the flat CDD line. The 2026 roll added 101 detached homes and 38 villas as newly completed (our computation from the county's 2026 roll, Charlotte County Property Appraiser). Your bill history is not your buyer's.
All 601 Coco Bay parcels sit in tax district 009 at 15.5683 mills for 2026 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, 2026 final rate chart). A sale resets the assessed value to just value on the following January 1 (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, real property), and your exemptions end. Because 140 of 287 detached homes and 61 of 158 villas carried homestead in August 2026, many buyers will not inherit your bill.
Not on any record we can price from yet. Amendment 3 passed on unofficial returns on November 3, 2026, but it is not certified, so we print no effective-year exemption figures. The Property Appraiser says it does not apply to non-ad valorem assessments (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, property tax amendment), so CDD lines on Coco Bay bills, such as $1,925.60 for an Executive Home, would not change (Island Lake Estates CDD, FY2027 adopted budget).
It varies by lot, so we check yours. FEMA's map showed shaded Zone X at four of five Coco Bay points we read, while one Island Lakes interior lot still prints Zone AE on the base map even though a LOMR-F removed it (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer). Four Coco Bay LOMR-F cases were completed in 2024: 24-04-3577A, 24-04-6777A, 24-04-6894A and 24-04-6852A (FEMA, LOMA layer). Two Palm Lake cases removed only portions of some lots.
They can. Citizens requires personal residential policies that include wind to carry flood insurance by January 1, 2027, regardless of value or zone (Citizens Property Insurance, flood). The National Flood Insurance Program is authorized only through December 11, 2026 (Congressional Research Service, IN10835). A Coco Bay buyer prices that premium into the payment, so your flood paperwork matters.
Roof age works in your favor. Florida bars an insurer from refusing to write or renew a homeowner policy solely because of roof age when the roof is under 15 years old (Florida Statutes 627.7011), and Coco Bay's homes were built from 2023 to 2025. Homes built to the 2001 code or later are automatically eligible for a minimum 68 percent windstorm discount (Florida Department of Financial Services).
Part of it may still be running. Lennar's Coco Bay Magnolia page lists a one-year workmanship warranty, a one-year mechanical warranty and a 10-year structural warranty (Lennar, Magnolia included features). Florida law requires a one-year builder warranty against material code violations, running from the first conveyance to the initial owner and honored even after a resale (Florida Statutes 553.837). Bring your warranty booklet so we can state the remaining term.
Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed rate was 7.11 percent for the week of November 12, 2026, against 6.24 percent a year earlier (Freddie Mac PMMS). In our worked payment for a $350,000 Coco Bay Executive Home, each 0.25 point moves the price the same monthly budget supports by roughly $6,000 to $7,000 (our arithmetic). That is why a seller credit toward a buydown can compete with Lennar's financing offer without cutting the headline price.
It can to a buyer who qualifies and can pay the gap between your price and the loan balance in cash. HUD requires credit approval of the buyer and a release form for the seller to be freed of liability (HUD, release of personal liability for assumptions), and VA charges a 0.5 percent funding fee on an assumption (VA, funding fee and closing costs). On a $300,000 balance, 5.5 percent against 7.11 percent is $314.75 a month less (our arithmetic).
Florida Realtors reports a Punta Gorda MSA (all of Charlotte County) single-family median of $345,000 for October 2026, up 0.9 percent, on 404 closed sales, down 12.4 percent (Florida Realtors, October 2026 MSA summary). FHFA's index for the metro read 391.34 in 2026 Q2 against 392.05 a year earlier (FHFA via FRED). Those are county figures; the county median blends many older neighborhoods with Coco Bay's new homes.
More builder inventory means more choices for the buyers you want. Charlotte County issued permits for 2,523 single-family units from January through September 2026, against 2,033 in the same months of 2025 (U.S. Census Bureau, Building Permits Survey). Lennar's 10-Q also says resales "have also begun to increase, particularly in Texas and Florida, intensifying competition for buyers" (Lennar Form 10-Q, Q3 fiscal 2026). See our Englewood new construction guide.
Information not available at time of publishing (checked November 17, 2026). That covers days on market, sale-to-list ratio, months of supply and active listings for Coco Bay, which are MLS-only fields. For context only, Florida Realtors put statewide single-family months of supply at 4.6 for October 2026 and median time to contract at 47 days (Florida Realtors, October 2026 single-family summary). Those are state figures, not Coco Bay figures.
For 2026 the window has closed. A value petition to the Value Adjustment Board is due 25 days after the mid-August notice is mailed (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, important dates), with a $50 fee for each parcel (Charlotte County Property Appraiser, notice to petitioner). Because Coco Bay just value already sits near 80.5 to 81.0 percent of 2025 prices (our computation from the 2026 roll), a petition needs Coco Bay sales showing a lower January 1 value. The CDD line cannot be appealed there.
A valuation is only as useful as the team that stands behind it at the negotiating table. These five-star reviews come from sellers who worked with McGreevy and Comisar, and they describe the pricing judgment, marketing and follow-through we bring to a Coco Bay listing.
McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Southwest Florida listing team, recognized with the Gulfshore Life 5 Star Award for customer satisfaction for 21 straight years. Each quote below is labelled with the site where the client posted it and is quoted exactly as written. We do not edit, combine or summarize client words.
★★★★★ "We had been on the market for several months with no offers. When we signed with Marc our house was sold in 2 weeks. He has a unique system for selling homes."
Verified Google review
★★★★★ "Marc Comisar did an excellent job working with a very difficult client (me) selling our condo in a tough condo market. He went above and beyond."
Verified Google review
★★★★★ "I can only say he is a refreshing and highly motivated professional. No tricks exaggerations nor falsehoods. His way of bringing quality clients is exceptional. He does not bring lookers. He brings buyers!"
Verified Google review
★★★★★ "Marc and Jesse were amazing to work with AGAIN! We just sold our 3rd home with them and couldn't have been happier! If we ever move again we'll always call Jesse and Marc!"
Verified Google review
★★★★★ "Marc helped me through the home selling process every step. He was very responsive and knows the market well. With another agent my house did not sell for one year, but Marc got me 3 offers within a few months."
Verified Zillow review
When you value your Coco Bay home with a top-reviewed team of Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, the partners who price it are the partners who negotiate it. Read every client review on our Google Business Profile. Request your free Coco Bay home valuation or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.
Every figure on this Coco Bay valuation page traces to a public document. These are the ones a Coco Bay owner opens when the question is value: county sales and roll files, just value and tax sources, district budgets and bond records, flood and insurance rules, builder filings and appraisal rules. Each link goes to the publisher.
| Document | Publisher | What a Coco Bay seller uses it for | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roll and sales downloads | Charlotte County Property Appraiser | The qualified Coco Bay sales and 2026 just values behind every figure here | Charlotte County Property Appraiser downloads |
| Section 193 just value adjustment | Charlotte County Property Appraiser | The 15 percent cost-of-sale step that keeps just value below sale prices | CCPA just value adjustment |
| 2026 Final Rate Chart | Charlotte County Property Appraiser | The 15.5683 mills for tax district 009, where all 601 Coco Bay parcels sit | CCPA 2026 final rate chart |
| Real property guidance | Charlotte County Property Appraiser | The reset after a sale, recapture and the bill discount schedule | CCPA real property |
| 2026 TRIM insert | Charlotte County Property Appraiser | Portability, new-owner reassessment and the March 1 deadline | CCPA 2026 TRIM insert |
| Notice to Petitioner | Charlotte County Property Appraiser | The Value Adjustment Board fee, deadline and evidence rules | CCPA notice to petitioner |
| Section 192.042, Florida Statutes | Florida Legislature | Why a home finished after January 1 is taxed as a lot that year | Section 192.042 |
| Section 193.011, Florida Statutes | Florida Legislature | The factors behind just value, including the deduction for costs of sale | Section 193.011 |
| FY2027 adopted budget | Island Lake Estates CDD | The O&M rate and the debt line for each Coco Bay product type | Island Lake Estates CDD FY2027 budget |
| FY2025 audit report | Island Lake Estates CDD | The Series 2023 bonds, their maturity and the board's Lennar affiliation | Island Lake Estates CDD audit |
| April 14, 2026 board minutes | Island Lake Estates CDD | Lennar's sell-out estimate and the board transition timing | Island Lake Estates CDD minutes |
| District FAQs | Island Lake Estates CDD | How to ask for a capital assessment payoff on your parcel | Island Lake Estates CDD FAQs |
| Section 190.048, Florida Statutes | Florida Legislature | The CDD disclosure that appears in initial sale contracts | Section 190.048 |
| Flood risk and Risk Rating 2.0 | FEMA | How a flood premium is set and how a policy transfers to a buyer | FEMA Risk Rating 2.0 |
| Flood requirement | Citizens Property Insurance | The January 1, 2027 flood rule for policies that include wind | Citizens flood |
| Section 689.302, Florida Statutes | Florida Legislature | The flood disclosure a seller completes before the contract is signed | Section 689.302 |
| Hurricane mitigation discounts | Florida Department of Financial Services | The minimum windstorm credit for homes built to the 2001 code or later | DFS mitigation discounts |
| Form 10-Q, quarter ended August 31, 2026 | Lennar Corporation (SEC) | Lennar's incentive levels and its comments on Florida resale competition | Lennar 10-Q |
| Selling Guide B4-1.3-08, Comparable Sales | Fannie Mae | The inside and outside comparable rule for a new subdivision | Fannie Mae B4-1.3-08 |
| Selling Guide B4-1.3-09, Adjustments | Fannie Mae | How Lennar concessions are adjusted on comparables | Fannie Mae B4-1.3-09 |
| Selling Guide B4-1.4-09, Special Assessments | Fannie Mae | How an appraiser reports the CDD on a Coco Bay home | Fannie Mae B4-1.4-09 |
| UAD 3.6 announcement | Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae | The November 2, 2026 appraisal form mandate | UAD 3.6 announcement |
| October 2026 MSA summary | Florida Realtors | The Charlotte County single-family median and year-over-year change | Florida Realtors October 2026 |
| Primary Mortgage Market Survey | Freddie Mac | The weekly 30-year fixed rate behind every payment example | Freddie Mac PMMS |
Every source below was read between October 21 and November 17, 2026, and each figure on this page carries its own date and window beside it in the text. Primary documents come first: Florida Statutes and rules, state and federal agencies, Fannie Mae, FHA and VA guides, Charlotte County, its Property Appraiser and Tax Collector, the Island Lake Estates Community Development District and FEMA. Builder prices come from Lennar's own pages, read November 17, 2026, and are builder-stated. Coco Bay sales figures come from the Charlotte County Property Appraiser roll dated November 5, 2026 with qualified sales recorded through early September 2026 (12-month window September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026). No listing site, brokerage or valuation aggregator was used for any figure on this page.
By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, who together bring over 45 years of combined direct experience. For this Coco Bay page we tracked 129 qualified improved sales from September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026 across the three recorded plats, 112 of them first sales by the builder and 17 resales (Charlotte County Property Appraiser).
Those sales sit beside the county's 2026 roll for all 601 Coco Bay parcels (Charlotte County Property Appraiser), Lennar's dated price sheet and the Island Lake Estates CDD's own budget and bond records, and we tracked every tax, assessment, flood and insurance rule a buyer's lender, insurer and appraiser will apply to your home, so each figure here comes from a public record you can check.
If you are thinking, "I need someone to sell my house in Coco Bay, Florida," McGreevy and Comisar helps homeowners price, market, negotiate, and sell with a local strategy built for Englewood, Charlotte County, Sarasota County, Port Charlotte, Punta Gorda, Babcock Ranch, Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers. Whether you are selling in Coco Bay, at Englewood Beach, on Lemon Bay, on Manasota Key, Englewood Isles, Englewood East, Oyster Creek, Boca Royale, Beachwalk by Manasota Key or Grove City, our team provides local market guidance, professional listing exposure, and a clear plan to help you sell confidently.
Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072, [email protected]
Marc Comisar: (239) 287-5873
Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more at DomainRealtyGroup.com, or read about McGreevy and Comisar. For buying questions, see how we represent Englewood buyers, and for a seller's first step, request your free Coco Bay home valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and there is no obligation.
Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) are licensed Florida real estate professionals regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) under Chapter 475, Florida Statutes.
Updated November 2026. This page is general information about Coco Bay home values, not an appraisal and not legal or tax advice. Market figures change with each county file and statutory figures change annually. For your specific property, ask us for the file.