Start Your Brightwater Buyer Consultation
Contact Details

Jesse McGreevy

[email protected]

(239) 898-6072

24031 S Tamiami Trl #101

Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Marc Comisar

[email protected]

(239) 287-5873

Mon - Fri, 9 am - 6 pm

McGreevy and Comisar, Brokered by Domain Realty

Updated October 2026 · Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty

Buying a home in Brightwater means buying into a gated, master-planned lagoon community in North Fort Myers, Florida, where two community development districts, a master association and a privately owned lagoon club each put a line on your annual cost. Our Brightwater community guide tells the story of the place. This guide is the buyer's version: the recorded prices, the fee stack lot by lot, the flood letters, the closing costs and the deadlines that decide what a Brightwater home really costs before you sign. By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, with every sale figure read from the Lee County Property Appraiser's recorded, DOR-qualified sales through September 10, 2026. Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

Why Work With McGreevy and Comisar as Your Brightwater Buyer's Agent

McGreevy and Comisar are the Brightwater buyer's agents who read the two CDD tax-bill lines, the master association and lagoon club documents and the FEMA letter before you write an offer. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and lead the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012.

Data updated: October 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser recorded sales, our county index built October 7, 2026; Stoneybrook North and Brightwater CDD FY2027 adopted budgets).

What a buyer's agent is actually for in Brightwater

Brightwater looks simple from the gate: new homes, wide lakes, a lagoon at the center. The paperwork is not. Two community development districts split the community at Pritchett Parkway, with different assessments and builders, and the lagoon sits outside both under separate ownership. Many homes sold directly by the builder without an MLS listing, so the county's recorded sales are the price record. We know which district bills a lot, which fee sheet is current and which resale comparable is real, and we price the difference into the offer before the inspection period closes.

How we compare with other North Fort Myers agents

If you are weighing us against other agents, our look at the best real estate agents in Fort Myers sets out the yardsticks we think a Brightwater buyer should use: verified production, years in the market, reviews you can read, and whether the agent who tours with you is the agent who negotiates.

The accolades, and what they are evidence of

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Awards are not a negotiating strategy. Two decades of continuous Southwest Florida production is how an agent recognizes a fair price on a 2021 resale without guessing, and how we know what a Lee County closing agent, district manager and insurance underwriter will ask.

Who you actually work with

Jesse and Marc handle their own buyers, and Marc leads buyer representation and negotiation. There is no junior handoff: the person who tours the house with you negotiates it. Jesse's direct line is (239) 898-6072 and Marc's is (239) 287-5873. Our office is at 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134, and we meet Brightwater buyers at the gate. The reviews section quotes three Google reviews word for word.

The Brightwater buyer's agent promise

If you are searching for the best buyer's agent in Brightwater, Florida, McGreevy and Comisar represents homebuyers across North Fort Myers, Lee County, Cape Coral, Fort Myers, Punta Gorda, Charlotte County, Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples, Collier County and Babcock Ranch. Whether you are relocating, snowbirding, investing, buying your first home or moving to a lagoon community behind a gate, our team provides honest market guidance, pre-MLS access, partner-level negotiation and a clear plan to help you buy confidently. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

Licensed, and where to check

Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate, Florida license SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate, Florida license BK3060671) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty, regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission under Chapter 475 of the Florida Statutes. Brokered by Domain Realty.

Our Record Behind This Page

McGreevy and Comisar bring a verified Southwest Florida record to a Brightwater purchase: our Domain Realty Group team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate, and Jesse and Marc's own sales exceed $900 million. In the last 12 months we tracked 86 Brightwater closings in the county's recorded sales.

Data updated: October 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser recorded, DOR-qualified sales through September 10, 2026, county index built October 7, 2026; RealTrends 2026 ranking as published).

The verified record, stated exactly

As the leaders of Domain Realty Group our team has closed over $2.5 billion in real estate, and Jesse and Marc account for more than $900 million of personal production. We are the #5 real estate team in Florida (RealTrends 2026). Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar bring over 45 years of combined direct experience. Those are the production figures we publish on every page we operate.

The Brightwater research behind this guide

In the last 12 months we tracked 86 Brightwater closings, from October 2025 through September 10, 2026, and 447 qualified sales since 2020. We split them by recorded plat and by builder-direct sale against resale, read each of the 21 resales row by row, and set them beside both CDDs' adopted fiscal 2027 budgets, the May 2026 preliminary offering document, Lee County's 2022 rezoning resolution, the lagoon operator's rules, FEMA's flood layer and the June 2026 map revision, and the school district's enrollment locator.

What a Brightwater purchase looks like when we run it

Before the first showing we pull the parcel to confirm the plat, the lot and which district bills it. We read the CDD line on the seller's Lee County tax bill, request the master association estoppel and current budget in writing, confirm how the lagoon club membership transfers, check the address against FEMA's map and the June 2026 revision, and ask for the wind-mitigation report and builder warranty. Those checks cost nothing and only count if done inside the inspection period.

Current Brightwater Market for Buyers

Brightwater recorded 86 qualified sales in the last 12 months at a median of $392,500: 65 builder-direct sales at $398,500 and 21 resales at $315,000. Lennar has sold out, so new construction now means D.R. Horton on the west side, including the 55+ Shores at Brightwater.

Data updated: October 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser recorded, DOR-qualified improved sales of $100,000 or more, our county index built October 7, 2026 from files dated October 4, 2026, sales recorded October 2025 through September 10, 2026; Lennar Brightwater Lagoon page, fetched October 10, 2026).

The county record, last 12 months

Many Brightwater homes were sold directly by the builder without an MLS listing, so the county's recorded sales lead this page. The table is the trailing 12 months across the three recorded plats in our Lee County index.

Measure, sales recorded October 2025 to September 10, 2026

All qualified sales

Builder-direct

Resale

Number of sales

86

65

21

Median price

$392,500

$398,500

$315,000

Price range

$275,000 to $597,934

all in Phase 3

$275,000 to $550,000

Dollar volume

$33,907,659

not split

not split

Over the last 24 months the county recorded 141 sales at a median of $405,000, and the 25 resales among them had a median of $369,000. Since the first closings in 2020, the three plats together hold 447 qualified sales worth $162,881,717.

The three plats that make up the built community

Plat (instrument)

Side and builder

Parcels

Homes with a year built

Qualified sales, all time

North Brook Phase One (2019000172912)

East, Lennar, Stoneybrook North CDD Area One

288

255 (built 2020 to 2023)

306 (255 builder-direct, 51 resale)

Brightwater Phase 3 (2023000206438)

East, Lennar, Stoneybrook North CDD Area Three

160 (139 lots)

137 (built 2024 to 2026)

141 (137 builder-direct, 4 resale)

Brightwater (2023000013053)

West, D.R. Horton including The Shores

435 (406 lots)

19

0

Total

883

411

447

North Brook Phase One is Brightwater: Lee County's 2022 rezoning resolution counts its 258 original homes inside the community cap, and the master association's court filings name it. If a deed or tax bill says "North Brook" or "Stoneybrook North," you are in the same community.

Builder-direct versus resale

The 65 builder-direct sales were all in Phase 3, at a median of $398,500. Of the 21 resales, 18 were in North Brook Phase One and 3 in Phase 3, at a median of $315,000. The $83,500 gap is partly size and age, since the resales skew to smaller, earlier Lennar plans. We return to this in the negotiation section.

The long arc, 2020 to 2026

Calendar year

Qualified sales

Median price

2020

28

$240,060

2021

118

$278,868.50

2022

96

$387,915

2023

37

$375,000

2024

54

$420,000

2025

51

$410,000

2026 (to September 10)

63

$390,000

Prices stepped up sharply from 2021 to 2022, peaked at a $420,000 median in 2024 and have eased about seven percent to $390,000 in 2026 so far. Fifty-four homes have both a builder sale and a later resale on record, with a median first price of $288,059.50 and a median latest price of $389,375. Those are medians of two sets of different homes, so read them as a market arc, not a gain on any one house.

Every Brightwater resale in the last 12 months

This is the full list of 21 resales from the county record. "County area" is the county's recorded area figure, which in some records is total area under roof, so it is not comparable to an MLS living-area number.

Recorded

Address

County area (sq ft)

Built

Resale price

Prior builder sale

2025-11-07

8772 Cascade Price Cir

1,702

2022

$369,000

$290,056 (Nov 2022)

2025-11-14

18521 Cronin Sand Ln

1,427

2022

$280,000

$276,310 (Jan 2022)

2025-12-01

8868 Cascade Price Cir

1,671

2021

$475,000

$239,985 (Apr 2021)

2025-12-18

8728 Swell Brooks Ct

1,427

2021

$280,000

$230,310 (May 2021)

2026-01-14

8832 Cascade Price Cir

1,828

2020

$290,000

$254,615 (Jul 2020)

2026-02-19

8864 Cascade Price Cir

1,747

2021

$315,000

$250,965 (Mar 2021)

2026-03-06

18524 Cronin Sand Ln

1,616

2022

$276,500

$323,120 (Mar 2022)

2026-03-10

18160 Everson Miles Cir

2,794

2022

$490,000

$472,290 (Aug 2022)

2026-03-12

18180 Everson Miles Cir

2,243

2022

$425,000

$434,385 (Feb 2022)

2026-03-23

18789 Marlin Kite Ln

2,032

2024

$315,000

$409,597 (Aug 2024)

2026-03-31

18184 Everson Miles Cir

2,602

2022

$515,000

$471,375 (Apr 2022)

2026-04-10

18517 Cronin Sand Ln

1,616

2022

$282,000

$308,120 (Mar 2022)

2026-04-15

8824 Cascade Price Cir

1,672

2020

$410,000

$239,000 (Nov 2020)

2026-05-15

8705 Swell Brooks Ct

1,616

2021

$297,500

$302,120 (Dec 2021)

2026-06-12

8813 Swell Brooks Ct

1,616

2021

$290,000

$245,120 (Mar 2021)

2026-06-23

18821 Shimmer Dawn Ct

2,434

2024

$550,000

$498,000 (Oct 2024)

2026-07-16

8817 Swell Brooks Ct

1,427

2021

$275,000

$218,310 (Feb 2021)

2026-07-24

8804 Swell Brooks Ct

1,427

2020

$325,000

$211,810 (Sep 2020)

2026-08-14

18653 Marlin Kite Ln

2,434

2024

$455,000

$434,602 (Oct 2024)

2026-08-27

18104 Everson Miles Cir

2,255

2021

$507,000

$386,225 (Sep 2021)

2026-09-10

18540 Cronin Sand Ln

1,616

2022

$285,000

$318,120 (Mar 2022)

The county's sale file is month-level for some older sales, so builder-sale dates above are month-level.

What the resales say about price

The newest resales on 2021 and 2022 Lennar homes in North Brook Phase One cluster at $275,000 to $325,000 for 1,427 to 1,747 county-area square feet. Six of the 21 resold below the recorded builder price, four of them in that small-home group, and 15 resold above it. Larger homes and the 2024 Phase 3 homes resell above $450,000. The Phase 3 resale at 18789 Marlin Kite Ln, $315,000 against a $409,597 builder price in August 2024, is the clearest sign of competing new supply. A few rows, such as 8868 Cascade Price Cir at $475,000 against $239,985, are outliers the record does not explain. For the 21 resales the median is $189.48 per county-area square foot, a county-record statistic that will not match listing square footage because the county's area can include garage and lanai. This is data, not a reason to panic: it shows where the negotiating room is.

Lennar is sold out

Lennar's own Brightwater Lagoon page, read October 10, 2026, says "Brightwater Lagoon is now sold out." Its last published base prices ran from $367,499 (Venice, 3 bedrooms, 1,849 square feet) to $447,499 (Amalfi, 2,529 square feet) for Executive Homes and $403,499 (Tivoli) to $505,499 (Sorrento, 3,283 square feet) for Manor Homes. Every Lennar plan in Brightwater is now a resale, and the 21 closed resales above show what that product is trading at.

D.R. Horton on the west side and The Shores at Brightwater

West of Pritchett Parkway, D.R. Horton is the sole builder in the Brightwater CDD. The county's file shows no qualified sales on the west plat through September 10, 2026, and the district's preliminary May 2026 offering document says no homes had closed with homebuyers in the district. D.R. Horton's page for The Shores at Brightwater, a gated 55+ section, lists 20 homes from $326,040 to $486,350, with plans including the Delray (2,034 square feet, from the $411s) and the Shelby (2,221 square feet, from the $439s). The same preliminary document expects Phase 4's 206 lots to deliver homes from December 2027 at an average price near $330,000, a builder estimate subject to change.

The MLS view

On the Southwest Florida MLS (Matrix, pulled October 11, 2026), 48 Brightwater homes closed in the 12 months to October 11, 2026, 39 of them under the Brightwater Lagoon development on Lennar's east side and 9 under Brightwater, at a median of $385,000, a median of 67.5 days on market and a median sale-to-list ratio of 97.4 percent. On October 11, 2026 the MLS showed 33 Brightwater homes for sale, 20 of them in The Shores at Brightwater, at a median list price of $399,999. The county recorded 86 qualified sales in a comparable 12 months, so many builder sales never ran through the MLS, and every other sale figure on this page comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's recorded, DOR-qualified sales (data through September 10, 2026).

Buying or selling in Brightwater? Talk to us before you price it

With 86 recorded Brightwater sales in the last 12 months and a 21-resale list that runs from $275,000 to $550,000, the price you should pay or ask depends on the plat, the plan and the year it was built, not on a community average. If you are buying, book a Brightwater buyer consultation and Call Marc at (239) 287-5873. If you are selling first, get a free Brightwater home valuation and Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008.

Resale or New Construction in Brightwater?

In Brightwater, resale means a Lennar home on the east side that closed at a $315,000 median in the last 12 months, while new construction means D.R. Horton on the west side, including the 55+ Shores, with Phase 4 closings expected from December 2027. The right choice turns on price, district, fees and timing.

Data updated: October 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser recorded sales through September 10, 2026; Stoneybrook North and Brightwater CDD FY2027 adopted budgets; Brightwater CDD preliminary offering document, May 2026; D.R. Horton and Lennar community pages, fetched October 10, 2026).

The three paths side by side

Factor

Lennar resale (east side)

D.R. Horton new (west side)

The Shores at Brightwater (55+)

Price evidence

21 resales in 12 months, median $315,000, range $275,000 to $550,000; Lennar's last base prices ran $367,499 to $505,499

No recorded sales on the west plat through September 10, 2026; Phase 4 average expected near $330,000 (builder estimate, preliminary)

20 listed homes from $326,040 to $486,350 on D.R. Horton's page, October 2026

CDD, FY2027

Stoneybrook North: $3,103.98 to $4,620.25 (Area One 40, 50 and 60 foot) and $4,021.75 or $4,826.10 (Phase 3, 50 or 60 foot)

Brightwater CDD: $2,789.14 (35 foot) and $3,984.48 (50 foot) where operating assessments apply; $1,212.68 to $2,051.54 in limited-operating classes; Phase 4 debt about $2,515 (50 foot) or $2,012 (40 foot) before the developer's paydown

Brightwater CDD, same schedule; confirm the lot's class on the tax bill

Master HOA

$146.31 a quarter on the 2023 and 2024 developer sheets

About $600 a year anticipated in the May 2026 preliminary document

Same master association; The Shores amenity center is described by D.R. Horton

Lagoon club

$35 a month plus tax and a $2,000 initiation at closing (2023 and 2024 sheets)

About $600 a year per unit (May 2026 preliminary document)

Same recorded Club Plan

Warranty

Whatever remains of the builder's warranty depends on the closing date; request it in writing

New-home warranty from the builder; terms are not published on the pages we read, so request them in writing

Same as the D.R. Horton column

Timing

Available now; 21 closed in the last 12 months

Homes listed now; Phase 4 closings expected from December 2027

Homes listed now

Age

Not marketed as age-restricted

Not marketed as age-restricted; Metro's August 2026 site map separates D.R. Horton from D.R. Horton (Active Adult)

Marketed 55+; the recorded age restriction is not published on pages we could read

When a Lennar resale wins

A resale wins when price matters most. The smaller 2020 to 2022 Lennar plans resold at $275,000 to $325,000, below Lennar's lowest published base price of $367,499, and six of the 21 resales sold below the original builder price. The trade is a home one to six years old and fee terms set in the early fee sheets; your inspection and the seller's records do the work a builder warranty would otherwise do.

When D.R. Horton new construction wins

New construction wins when you want a first-owner home, a current warranty and a builder's design choices, and can accept a listed home now or a Phase 4 closing in December 2027 or later. The trade is a district with more undeveloped land, bonds that were still preliminary in May 2026, and a lagoon fee quoted as an expectation rather than a recorded schedule. Read the CDD assessment letter and the Club Plan before you sign the builder's contract.

When The Shores at Brightwater wins

The Shores wins when you are 55 or older, want one-story living in a smaller gated section with its own clubhouse, pool, fitness center, pickleball and dog park, and still want the lagoon. D.R. Horton markets it as 55+, but we could not read a recorded age restriction, so ask for the declaration before you commit.

What Phase 4 timing means for you

The district's preliminary May 2026 document expects Phase 4 land development from June 2026 to June 2027 and closings with homebuyers from December 2027 at roughly 100 homes a year, a builder estimate that could slip. A buyer who needs a home before 2027 should plan on a resale or a listed Shores home; a buyer who can wait gains a first-owner home at an expected price near $330,000, with the CDD debt level confirmed once the Series 2026 bonds are final.

How We Find You the Right Brightwater Home

We find the right Brightwater home by screening each address for the costs a listing does not show: which district bills the lot, the lot width, the lagoon club terms, the flood letter and the recorded sales of the same plan. Then we tour the few that survive.

Data updated: October 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser roll and recorded sales, our analysis; Stoneybrook North and Brightwater CDD FY2027 adopted budgets).

Step one: the monthly number

We start with the full monthly carrying cost you are comfortable with: the mortgage payment at today's rate, property tax at your post-sale value, the CDD assessment, the master association, the lagoon club, and homeowners and, if you choose it, flood insurance. In Brightwater the CDD line alone runs from $2,789.14 to $4,826.10 a year depending on side and lot width, so we price it before we price the house.

Step two: the plat, the plan and the side

We match your list to the plat. The lowest entry price is in North Brook Phase One resales on Cronin Sand Ln, Swell Brooks Ct and Cascade Price Cir. A newer, larger home is in Phase 3 on Marlin Kite Ln, Shimmer Dawn Ct and River Burst Ct. A first-owner home or a 55+ section is west of Pritchett Parkway at Lagoon Reach Ln and Bridgewater Dr.

Step three: pre-market and off-market homes

Some Brightwater homes change hands before they are listed. As the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, we hear about some of those homes before they reach the MLS, and we run them through the same address screen as any listed home.

Step four: tours that answer questions

A Brightwater tour covers the view, whether the lake behind the lot is a district pond, how close the home sits to the lagoon and its parking, the windows and shutters, and what the street looks like on a lagoon Saturday. We bring the address file so you are not guessing.

How We Negotiate for You in Brightwater

We negotiate Brightwater purchases on the evidence the county record gives: 21 resales in 12 months at a $315,000 median, six of them below their original builder price, against builder-direct closings at $398,500. A resale is negotiated on comparables and condition, a builder sale on incentives and contract terms.

Data updated: October 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser recorded sales, our analysis and our county index of North Fort Myers subdivisions built October 7, 2026; builder pages fetched October 10, 2026; Business Observer, July 29, 2026).

Price, from the recorded comparables

We price from recorded sales of the same plat, plan and year, not from an automated estimate and not from a Brightwater-wide average that mixes a $275,000 Cronin Sand Ln home with a $550,000 Shimmer Dawn Ct home.

Builder incentives versus resale

A builder sale is negotiated through incentives the builder publishes and changes, and through the contract's terms. A resale seller negotiates price and repairs directly. Lennar is sold out in Brightwater, and D.R. Horton's page quotes estimated monthly payments rather than a published incentive schedule. When a builder offers a credit, ask in writing what it requires, whether it depends on using the builder's lender or title company, and compare it with the same money as a price reduction. Nearby North Fort Myers communities show where the alternatives price:

North Fort Myers community

County-recorded sales, 12 months

Median

Crane Landing

225

$275,000

Coral Bay

89

$323,000

Del Webb Oak Creek

84

$539,955

Brightwater (Phase 3 plat only)

68

$398,750

Herons Glen

52

$341,250

Bayshore Ranch

49

$430,000

Magnolia Landing (parcels L, N, O)

49

$311,000

Lennar's Bayshore Ranch in North Fort Myers listed homes from $379,096 to $493,499 on its page in October 2026, and a 515-home Lennar community at Caloosa Commons was reported in July 2026 with prices starting in the mid-$200,000s. The lagoon justifies a premium over those; how large is the negotiation.

Using the 21 resales

The 21 resales are the strongest tool a Brightwater buyer has. Six sold below their original builder price, 15 above, and the small-home group cleared at $275,000 to $325,000. For illustration, if a seller of a 1,616 square foot Cronin Sand Ln home asks $349,000, the record shows homes that size closing at $276,500 to $297,500 in 2026, and we put those rows in front of the seller's agent.

Terms that protect you

On the Florida AS IS contract, the inspection period is 15 days if left blank and is the buyer's main walk-away right. The initial deposit is due within 3 days and any additional deposit within 10 if those blanks are empty, and loan approval defaults to 30 days. We set each date deliberately around the inspections, estoppel, insurance quotes and disclosures a Brightwater home needs.

Using what the inspections and documents find

A flood quote higher than expected, a weak wind-mitigation form, a CDD line a lot-width class higher than assumed, an estoppel showing a past-due assessment, or a drainage or pond-repair item at the walkthrough are all negotiating points. They carry weight inside the inspection period and little after it.

Protecting your deposit

Your deposit is held by a title company, attorney or broker escrow and comes back to you on the AS IS form if you terminate in time under the inspection, financing or association disclosure provisions. We calendar every deadline in writing on day one.

What It Really Costs to Own in Brightwater

Owning a Brightwater home costs more than the mortgage: Lee County property tax, a CDD assessment of $2,789.14 to $4,826.10 on the FY2027 schedules, a master HOA and a lagoon club. On our worked example, a $399,000 Phase 3 home runs $9,653.50 a year, about $804 a month, before insurance.

Data updated: October 2026 (Stoneybrook North CDD and Brightwater CDD FY2027 adopted budgets, presented August 25, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 TRIM notice and millage books; Metro Places fee sheets for 2023 and 2024; Brightwater CDD preliminary offering document, May 2026).

The layers, one table

Layer

Who bills it

Amount on record

Source and date

Property tax

Lee County Tax Collector

14.3623 mills applied to the 2026 roll (14.4125 adopted for 2025), tax district 202

Lee Property Appraiser millage books, 2025 and 2026

CDD assessment

On the same tax bill

East: $3,103.98 to $4,826.10; West: $2,789.14 and $3,984.48 where operating assessments apply

CDD FY2027 adopted budgets

Master HOA

Brightwater Master Homeowners Association, Inc.

$146.31 a quarter ($585.24 a year); about $600 a year anticipated in 2026

Metro fee sheets 2023 and 2024; May 2026 preliminary document

Lagoon club

Club Plan, billed separately

$35 a month plus tax ($420 a year) and $2,000 initiation; about $600 a year in 2026

Metro fee sheets; May 2026 preliminary document

Insurance

Your carriers

Not published; get quotes by address

See the flood and insurance section

Stoneybrook North CDD assessments by lot width

The east side, where Lennar built, is in the Stoneybrook North CDD. These are the adopted FY2027 amounts as they appear on the tax bill, including the 4 percent early-payment discount and the county's 2 percent collection gross-up.

Area and lot width

Operating (O&M)

Debt service

Total FY2027

Area One (North Brook Phase One), 40 foot

$2,153.57

$950.41

$3,103.98

Area One, 50 foot

$2,691.96

$1,162.58

$3,854.54

Area One, 60 foot

$3,230.35

$1,389.90

$4,620.25

Area Three (Phase 3), 50 foot

$2,691.96

$1,329.79

$4,021.75

Area Three, 60 foot

$3,230.35

$1,595.74

$4,826.10

Operating assessments rose 13 percent from fiscal 2026 to 2027 while debt service stayed flat. Lennar's plan pages carried special-assessment lines of $3,708.60 (Executive Homes) and $4,450.32 (Manor Homes), matching fiscal 2026 totals for 50-foot and 60-foot Phase 3 lots.

Brightwater CDD assessments on the west side

The west side is in the Brightwater CDD, where D.R. Horton is the sole builder.

Area and class

Operating (O&M)

Debt service

Total FY2027

Area One (Series 2021), 35 foot, full operating

$1,895.52

$893.62

$2,789.14

Area One, 50 foot, full operating

$2,707.88

$1,276.60

$3,984.48

Area One, 35 foot, undeveloped limited operating

$319.06

$893.62

$1,212.68

Area One, 50 foot, undeveloped limited operating

$455.80

$1,276.60

$1,732.40

Area Two, Phase 2C (Series 2024), 50 foot, limited operating

$455.80

$1,595.74

$2,051.54

Confirm a home's class on its Lee County tax bill. Phase 4 is financed by proposed Series 2026 bonds of about $11,305,000, with preliminary annual debt of $2,515 (50-foot) or $2,012 (40-foot) that the developer expects to pay down at lot closing to contract maximums of $1,750 and $1,400.

HOA and lagoon fees, by era

Two sets of numbers exist, from different eras. The 2023 and 2024 developer fee sheets show a master HOA of $146.31 a quarter, a lagoon fee of $35 a month plus tax and a one-time $2,000 initiation plus tax, and say the lagoon is "independently owned and operated, and not affiliated with any CDD or HOA assessments." The May 2026 preliminary offering document for the west side anticipates about $600 a year for the HOA and about $600 a year per unit for the lagoon Club Plan, and says the HOA's main function is architectural review and deed-restriction enforcement. Lennar's plan pages show an HOA line of $89.64 to $89.67 with no period stated, which read as monthly would be about $1,076 a year. The current HOA amount is not published, so request the estoppel certificate and current budget under Florida Statutes 720.30851 before you write an offer.

Property tax and the Bayshore Fire district

Brightwater is in Lee County tax district 202, served by Bayshore Fire Protection and Rescue District (3.5000 mills), not North Fort Myers Fire. Total adopted millage was 14.4125 for 2025, with 14.3623 applied to the 2026 tax roll. There is no city millage, and the only non-ad valorem line on the sampled bills is the CDD. Taxes are paid in arrears with a discount of 4 percent in November, 3 in December, 2 in January and 1 in February. Homestead requires ownership and permanent residence on January 1, so a buyer who closes after that date pays on the full assessed value the first year. Amendment 3 passed on November 3, 2026 with 61.99 percent yes on the Florida Division of Elections’ unofficial count (Florida Election Watch, Amendments): from January 1, 2027 it raises the non-school homestead exemption to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028 and cuts the non-homestead cap from 10 to 5 percent, so every example here uses the 2026 rules, which govern bills until the 2027 tax year.

A worked example, line by line

Take a 2025 Phase 3 Lennar home that sold for $399,000 (Lot F33, 18632 Marlin Kite Ln, recorded November 2025). The Property Appraiser's 2026 just value is $363,846. With homestead, the taxable value is $312,435 for non-school levies and $338,846 for school levies, and the 2026 TRIM notice proposed $4,630.10 in ad valorem tax, which is $4,626.51 at the rates applied to the 2026 tax roll, our arithmetic (Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 TRIM, Folio 10621461). The lot width is not printed on the TRIM, so both Phase 3 widths are shown.

Line

50-foot lot

60-foot lot

2026 ad valorem tax at the applied rate, homestead

$4,626.51

$4,626.51

Stoneybrook North Area Three CDD, FY2027

$4,021.75

$4,826.10

Master HOA, 2024 rate ($146.31 x 4)

$585.24

$585.24

Lagoon club, 2024 rate ($35 x 12)

$420.00

$420.00

Total per year

$9,653.50

$10,457.85

Per month

about $804

about $871

That is before insurance, utilities and mortgage interest, and before the $2,000 lagoon initiation that the 2023 and 2024 sheets listed as a one-time charge at closing. The Property Appraiser's value, not the price, drives the bill.

Can you pay off the CDD bond?

Yes, in general. The district explainer says the bond portion typically runs about 30 years, does not change and can be paid off early, and that bonds are usually 45 to 55 percent of the total assessment. The operating portion is set each year by the elected board and cannot be prepaid. The recorded declaration, Club Plan, current HOA dues and rental and pet rules are not available from any public page we could read, so we request them, and the district manager's payoff figure for your lot, before you rely on either.

Closing Costs for Brightwater Buyers

A Brightwater buyer who finances pays Florida's intangible tax of $0.002 per $1 of a new mortgage and mortgage documentary stamps of $0.35 per $100, plus a lender's title policy, survey, inspections and prorations. On a $314,000 loan at the $392,500 median, the two state taxes total $1,727.

Data updated: October 2026 (Florida Statutes 201.08, 199.133, 720.401, 720.30851 and 190.048; Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation estoppel fee schedule; Lee County recorded sales, our analysis).

The state taxes on your mortgage

Florida charges a documentary stamp tax of $0.35 per $100 of the amount secured by a recorded mortgage, with no cap, and a nonrecurring intangible tax of two mills, or $0.002 per $1, on the new mortgage. The deed stamp of $0.70 per $100 on the sale price is customarily a seller cost, but the contract decides.

Item, 20 percent down

$392,500 purchase (T12 median)

$315,000 purchase (resale median)

Loan amount

$314,000

$252,000

Mortgage documentary stamp tax ($0.35 per $100)

$1,099

$882

Intangible tax ($0.002 per $1)

$628

$504

State taxes on the loan, total

$1,727

$1,386

This is our arithmetic from the statutory rates, not a closing estimate; your lender's Loan Estimate is the document that binds.

Who pays the owner's title policy in Lee County?

In Lee County the seller customarily pays for the owner's title insurance policy, and the buyer pays for the lender's title policy, but the contract controls and the box on the Florida AS IS form is negotiable. On a builder sale, the builder's contract sets the title company and who pays, so read it before you sign.

The lender's policy, survey and inspections

Budget separately for the lender's title policy, a survey if required, a general inspection and a wind-mitigation report. On a lot that backs onto a district pond, the survey confirms where the private lot ends and district land begins, which matters before you plan a pool or fence.

Property tax and CDD prorations

Taxes are paid in arrears, so the seller credits the buyer for the part of the year they owned the home, and the CDD assessments on the same Lee County bill prorate with it. The district fiscal year starts October 1, so a closing after that date should prorate against the newly adopted FY2027 amount, which on a 50-foot Phase 3 lot is $4,021.75 rather than the fiscal 2026 $3,708.60.

The HOA disclosure summary and your 3-day right

Under Florida Statutes 720.401, the buyer of a home in a mandatory homeowners' association must receive the disclosure summary before signing the contract. If it was not provided first, the buyer may cancel within 3 days after receiving it, as the statute describes. We check that it is attached before you sign, because the right is time-limited.

The CDD disclosure

Under Florida Statutes 190.048, every contract for a home in a community development district must carry a prescribed disclosure about the district's assessments, and both Brightwater CDD ordinances require it for the life of the district. If it is missing, flag it to the closing agent.

The estoppel certificate

Under Florida Statutes 720.30851, the association must provide an estoppel certificate showing amounts owed and current assessments. The Department of Business and Professional Regulation publishes the inflation-adjusted maximum charges, and the schedule we read listed $299 for the certificate, $119 expedited and $179 for a delinquent account. Who pays is a contract term, and we negotiate it.

NAR Settlement: How Buyer's Agent Compensation Works in 2026

Since August 17, 2024, a Brightwater buyer signs a written agreement with their agent before touring a home, and the agent's compensation is stated, specific and fully negotiable. Offers of compensation no longer appear on the MLS, but a seller or a builder may still agree to pay some or all of it.

Data updated: October 2026 (National Association of Realtors settlement materials at nar.realtor; Florida Realtors forms and guidance; Florida Statutes 475.278; read October 2026).

What the national settlement changed

The National Association of Realtors' practice changes, effective August 17, 2024, require MLS participants working with a buyer to enter into a written agreement before touring a home. The agreement must state compensation that is objectively ascertainable and not open-ended, and it must say that broker fees are not set by law and are fully negotiable. NAR publishes its explanation at nar.realtor.

The Florida forms buyers sign in 2026

Florida Realtors released updated forms effective January 5, 2026. The exclusive buyer brokerage agreement comes in versions for each brokerage relationship a buyer can choose, and a separate form handles compensation that a seller or a seller's broker offers to a buyer's broker. A range such as "between two and three percent" is not allowed under Florida Realtors guidance.

The Florida agency question most buyers are never asked

Section 475.278 presumes that licensees operate as transaction brokers unless a single agent or no brokerage relationship is established in writing. A transaction broker owes limited confidentiality and no duty of loyalty. If you want an agent who represents only you in the negotiation, say so and sign the single agent version.

How a builder or seller contribution works in Brightwater

Compensation can come from you, a seller or a builder, but the written agreement controls what your agent may receive from any source. On a D.R. Horton purchase, tell the sales office you have an agent on your first visit and ask for its cooperation terms in writing.

How we structure it with Brightwater buyers

We put the agreement in front of you before the first tour, explain the versions in plain language, write a fixed and specific compensation figure, and show you where a seller or builder contribution would offset it. With Lennar sold out, most Brightwater purchases are resale negotiations with an individual seller, and the compensation question is one more term in that negotiation.

The Lagoon, Explained for Buyers

Brightwater Lagoon is a roughly six-acre Crystal Lagoons water amenity, owned and run by a separate company outside both CDDs, that Brightwater owners join through a recorded Club Plan and the public enters by ticket. For a buyer, the questions are the fee, the rules, the crowds and what happens if you rent the home.

Data updated: October 2026 (MetroLagoons operator pages and rules, fetched October 10, 2026; Lee County Resolution Z-22-015; Brightwater CDD preliminary offering document, May 2026; Gulfshore Business, May 30, 2025; TripAdvisor and Yelp rating pages, October 10, 2026).

Size, depth and what it is

Sources disagree on size, so we say "about six acres." Metro, Lennar, the News-Press and WINK say six, the operator's own page says about five, Crystal Lagoons says 5.9 and the May 2026 offering document says about 6.5. It holds about 10 million gallons and is up to 16 feet deep beneath the floating obstacle course (Gulfshore Business, May 30, 2025). It soft-opened November 22, 2024 and held its ribbon cutting May 30, 2025; Metro called it Lee County's first man-made lagoon and its fourth in Florida.

Heated and chlorinated

The operator says the water is not heated and follows seasonal Florida water temperatures. It describes chlorination and filtration under state and CDC standards, so we never call it "chemical free."

Who owns it and who pays

The lagoon was built by a special-purpose "Lagoon Developer" at a cost in excess of $5 million and is operated by Metro Lagoons, LLC. It sits outside both CDDs, so its costs are not on your CDD bill. Owners are expected to be members of a Club Plan recorded against the land, subject to fees and the plan's rules.

What owners get and pay

Metro's Resident Member Card is one free card per resident aged 14 and over, shown with photo ID at each visit, and capacity limits and blackout dates may apply. The 2023 and 2024 fee sheets show $35 a month plus tax and a $2,000 initiation at closing. The May 2026 preliminary document expects about $600 a year per unit for west-side homes. Resident-member pricing for Brightwater is not published on the operator pages, so ask for the Club Plan and current fee schedule in writing.

Public tickets and crowds

The lagoon is open to the public by ticket, online or at the gate, with free parking and no lifeguards in the free-swim areas. Prices are dynamic, so we give dated points only: $25 the week of the May 2025 ribbon cutting, $30 for adults and $28 for children in June 2025, and "starting at $22" on the operator's site in October 2026, with 20 percent off for Florida residents. Public ratings on October 10, 2026 were mixed: TripAdvisor about 2.4 on about 20 reviews, Yelp about 2.6 on about 26 and about 1,300 Google reviews. Visitors praised the clear water and obstacle course and complained about refunds, service, food waits and prices, and crowds. Weigh what a lagoon Saturday means for your street.

What the county required

Lee County's Resolution Z-22-015 classified the lagoon as a "Club, Country" use rather than a water park. It requires resident memberships with every Brightwater home purchase, limits non-resident access by reservation and parking, sets a 180 to 400 space lot with at least 33 percent reserved for residents, reserves golf-cart parking for homeowners and bars amplified outdoor sound after 10 PM.

If you plan to rent the home

The MetroLagoons members page says that if you rent out your home or live in a rented home, the homeowner must relinquish lagoon access. Renters at Brightwater are not on its list of qualifying rental communities. Rental and pet rules sit in the recorded declaration, which we could not read publicly, so for an investment purchase request the declaration and Club Plan before the inspection period ends.

Flood, Insurance and Storms

Brightwater's sampled addresses all map in FEMA flood Zone X, outside the Special Flood Hazard Area, on panels effective November 17, 2022, and a map revision effective June 30, 2026 removed parts of the community from the Bayshore Creek floodplain. Unincorporated Lee County's CRS gives Zone X policies a 10 percent discount.

Data updated: October 2026 (FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, queried October 10, 2026; FEMA LOMR 25-04-6830P; FEMA CRS Eligible Communities list, April 1, 2026; Lee County flood pages; OpenFEMA policy data; Florida Statutes 627.7011, 627.0629 and 689.302).

Zone X by plat

We queried FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer on October 10, 2026 for ten sampled Brightwater addresses.

Plat

Sampled addresses

FEMA zone

North Brook Phase One (east)

18513 Cronin Sand Ln, 8761 Swell Brooks Ct, 18100 Everson Miles Cir, 18509 Marlin Kite Ln

X, including shaded X (0.2 percent annual chance) at Everson Miles Cir and unshaded X at Marlin Kite Ln

Phase 3 (east)

18713, 18722 and 18658 Marlin Kite Ln

X shaded (0.2 percent annual chance)

Brightwater (west)

17951, 18158 and 18185 Lagoon Reach Ln

X shaded at 17951; X unshaded (minimal hazard) at the others

The panels are 12071C0277G and 12071C0281G, effective November 17, 2022. Zone X is not a guarantee of no flooding, and per-lot elevation certificates govern.

The 2026 map revision

FEMA Letter of Map Revision 25-04-6830P, "Brightwater Phases 1, 2AB, 3 and Lagoon," became effective June 30, 2026. It revised Bayshore Creek and Popash Creek based on a detention basin and fill, and it removed areas from the 1 percent annual chance floodplain. Homes closed before that date may have had lender flood determinations made under the older map, so ask your lender which determination applies and when it was dated.

What Zone X means for your lender

In Zone X, flood insurance is optional for a federally backed mortgage, so a lender will not require it on that basis alone. We still price a policy for every address, because Zone X homes flood too and homeowners policies do not cover flood. Florida Statutes 689.302 requires the seller to give a written flood disclosure at or before the contract.

Elevation and evacuation zones

USGS 3DEP elevation data put the sampled points at 16.8 to 18.6 feet (NAVD88) before construction, so finished floors differ. Lee County evacuation zones at the sampled points were C and D; Lee's Hurricane Milton order covered Zones A and B only.

The storm record

The first North Brook Phase One homes were built from 2020 to 2023, so the oldest were standing for Hurricane Ian on September 28, 2022. Brightwater-specific storm damage is not documented in public sources. A 70-foot relief ditch runs along the north boundary, Popash and Bayshore creeks flank the property, and the county barred development within 50 feet of the creek top of bank. The SFWMD permit 36-06899-P was issued April 22, 2020 and expires December 12, 2030.

Flood insurance and the CRS discount

Lee County is a Class 5 community in FEMA's April 1, 2026 CRS list, with a 25 percent discount in the Special Flood Hazard Area and 10 percent in Zone X. In OpenFEMA data for ZIP 33917, the median premium for Zone X policies on homes built in 2023 or later was $517 (67 policies; policies effective June 2025 or later; range $204 to $7,069). The ZIP includes riverfront areas far from Brightwater, so treat that as context, not a quote.

Homeowners insurance, wind and your roof

Brightwater's design wind speed lies between the 150 and 160 mph contours on Lee's 2023 Florida Building Code map, which by the map's own note puts it in the wind-borne debris region (our reading), and Lennar lists impact-resistant windows or shutters. Under Florida Statutes 627.7011 an insurer may not refuse a policy solely because of roof age on a roof under 15 years old, and every Brightwater roof is far newer. Wind-mitigation features earn discounts under Florida Statutes 627.0629 on the OIR-B1-1802 form, so order the inspection. The regulator reported in May 2026 that 20 new insurers had entered since the reforms, and Citizens writes new policies only when private coverage is unavailable or more than 20 percent costlier. Quotes depend on the carrier, so we print none.

Schools and Daily Life

Brightwater is zoned for Elementary Zone C, Middle Zone CC and High School East Zone 1 in Lee County's 2026-27 enrollment plan, based on the district's own locator at five Brightwater points. Zoning can differ by address and future phase, so confirm yours with the district before you buy.

Data updated: October 2026 (Lee County School District enrollment locator and zone pages, run October 10, 2026; Florida Department of Education 2026 School Grades file; Lee County GIS; OSRM computed drive times).

Which schools serve Brightwater

We ran the district's locator for the lagoon and four Brightwater parcels, two in Phase 3 and two in the west plat, and all five returned the same result. North Brook Phase One addresses were not individually tested, so confirm those. Elementary Zone C includes Bayshore and J. Colin English elementary schools and North Fort Myers Academy for the Arts; Middle Zone CC includes The Bayshore School, Caloosa and Diplomat middle schools and the Academy for the Arts; the high school zone is East Zone 1. North Fort Myers High School is not a zoned option, though families can apply to other schools under the district's choice rules and transportation depends on the subzone. Check any address with the district's locator.

School grades and drive times

School

Role for Brightwater

2026 grade

2025 grade

Computed drive

The Bayshore School (K-8)

Elementary Zone C, Middle Zone CC

B

B

9 min, 3.8 mi

J. Colin English Elementary

Elementary Zone C

A

C

15 min, 7.4 mi

North Fort Myers Academy for the Arts (K-8)

Elementary Zone C, Middle Zone CC

C

C

19 min, 9.8 mi

Diplomat Middle

Middle Zone CC

B

B

23 min, 11.7 mi

Caloosa Middle

Middle Zone CC

B

C

25 min, 13.0 mi

Gateway High

High School East Zone 1

A

B

25 min, 17.1 mi

Riverdale High

High School East Zone 1

C

B

17 min, 8.3 mi

Dunbar High

High School East Zone 1

C

C

18 min, 10.2 mi

Lehigh Senior High

High School East Zone 1

C

C

27 min, 14.5 mi

Grades are from the Florida Department of Education's 2026 School Grades file; confirm each letter on the department's site before you rely on it. Drive times are our computed free-flow estimates, so add 25 to 50 percent at peak times.

Where to go for the basics

Our computed estimates from the lagoon: I-75 Exit 143 about 5 minutes, the nearest Publix on Bayshore Road about 10, downtown Fort Myers 19, the airport 27 and Punta Gorda 35. There is no LeeTran stop within three miles, so plan on a car.

Healthcare and emergency services

We could not verify a hospital or freestanding emergency room in ZIP 33917. The nearest emergency departments are Lee Health Cape Coral Hospital and the HCA Florida Cape Coral emergency room, both about 13 miles and 23 to 26 minutes away. Bayshore Fire Protection and Rescue Station 131 is at 17350 Nalle Rd.

Utilities and services

Power comes from Lee County Electric Cooperative, not FPL. The county's GIS puts the area in Lee County Utilities' water franchise and FGUA's sewer franchise; confirm the billing entity for your address. Metro lists ULTRAFi internet and Streetleaf solar streetlights, and provider availability should be checked by address.

Brightwater vs Babcock Ranch for Buyers

Brightwater and Babcock Ranch both draw buyers off the Bayshore Road corridor, about 15 minutes apart by our computed estimate, but they sell different things. Brightwater offers a lagoon, I-75 access and resale pricing from $275,000 to $550,000; Babcock offers a town, schools and a far wider price range.

Data updated: October 2026 (Babcock Ranch releases, January and June 2026; Pulte Northridge brochure; FDOT swflroads project pages; Lee Health and TGH releases; Brightwater data as cited above).

Why this is the natural comparison

Babcock Ranch is the area's best-known planned community and Brightwater's nearest rival for buyers who want a new, amenity-rich home in northern Lee County. Babcock Ranch reported 1,066 net home sales in 2025 and 5,516 homes sold through 2025.

The decision table

Factor

Brightwater

Babcock Ranch

Scale

741 acres, cap of 1,475 homes, 411 with a year built

18,000 acres, up to 19,500 homes, more than 15,000 residents

Signature

Roughly six-acre lagoon with resident membership

Town center, solar farm, parks, on-site schools, built about 30 feet above sea level (community statement)

Price evidence

Resales $275,000 to $550,000, median $315,000; Horton homes $326,040 to $486,350

Low $200,000s to over $4 million

Annual fee example

$9,654 to $10,458 in our Phase 3 example, tax included

Northridge 52-foot lot: HOA $243.33 a month, residential association $141 a month, district $2,107 a year (Pulte estimate, FY2024-25), before tax

Commute

I-75 Exit 143 about 5 minutes

SR 31, no interstate; SR 31 widening due mid-2027; SR 78 study due late 2026, design not yet funded

County

Lee

Charlotte and Lee

Schools

Zoned Lee schools, 9 to 27 minutes

On-site public schools

Healthcare

None inside; nearest ER about 13 miles

Lee Health center; TGH primary care opened August 18, 2026

Age

Mostly all ages; The Shores is 55+

All ages with several 55+ neighborhoods

Where Brightwater has the edge

Choose Brightwater if you want I-75 five minutes away, a lagoon outside your door, a resale price in the $300,000s, and you are comfortable with two CDDs and a separate lagoon club. It also suits 55+ buyers who want a gated one-story section with the lagoon alongside.

Where Babcock Ranch has the edge

Choose Babcock Ranch if you want a town with schools, shops and medical care inside the gate, a wider range of builders and prices, and you accept SR 31 as your road. See our Babcock Ranch guide for the Babcock side of the comparison.

Get Your Personalized Brightwater Buyer Consultation

Book a Brightwater buyer consultation by phone or through our buying page. It is a working session, not a sales meeting: we build your monthly carrying number, screen the east and west sides against it, flag the CDD, lagoon and flood questions for each address, and give you the document list. There is no charge.

What you get out of it

A carrying-cost model with the CDD separated from the tax line and the HOA and lagoon figures marked as estoppel items; recorded comparables for the homes you are considering; the plat, lot width and district for any address you name; a first read on insurability; and an estimate of your cash to close.

What we will ask you

Your timing, how you are financing, whether you will homestead or use the home seasonally, whether you are 55 or older and want The Shores, how often you will use the lagoon, whether you are selling a Florida home, and whether you plan to rent.

How to book it

Call Marc at (239) 287-5873, or see how we represent buyers across Southwest Florida. Or call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. You are working with Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and there is no obligation.

Set Up Custom Listing Alerts

A custom Brightwater listing alert tells you about the right home the day it reaches the market, filtered on plat, plan, side of Pritchett Parkway, build year and price. Tell us your criteria or save a search on our brokerage's listing site, Domain Realty Group, and the alerts also route to Jesse and Marc.

Reviews From Buyers Who Worked With Us

McGreevy and Comisar is a top-reviewed Brightwater buyer's agent on Google, and the quotes below are five-star reviews from clients we represented, reproduced word for word. We publish no aggregate score, and none of the quotes names Brightwater, because we have not trimmed or tailored them.

On knowing the market and working for the buyer

★★★★★ "Marc knows the market, works for his buyer and is attentive to his goals." Verified Google review

On listening and finding exactly what was wanted

★★★★★ "Jesse listened to what we were looking for and found us exactly what we wanted. Jesse was always available to answer any questions and helped us through the entire process." Verified Google review

On being down to earth

★★★★★ "Marc is one of the most down to earth realtors that really listens to your needs and is exceptional at finding the right house." Verified Google review

Frequently Asked Questions: Buyer Edition

These are the questions Brightwater buyers search for and ask us most, drawn from real search phrasing and our own tours, each answered from the records cited in this guide. Where a fact is not published, the answer says so plainly.

How do I buy a house in Brightwater?

Get pre-approved, sign a written buyer agreement before touring, and check each address's plat, CDD, lot width, flood letter and lagoon club terms. Use an inspection period long enough for the HOA estoppel and insurance quotes.

Is Brightwater in Fort Myers or North Fort Myers?

North Fort Myers, in unincorporated Lee County, ZIP 33917, north of I-75 Exit 143 on both sides of Pritchett Parkway. It pays no city taxes.

Is Brightwater the same as North Brook or Stoneybrook North?

Yes, the land is the same. Lee County's records call it Heritage Creek (2001 to 2004), Stoneybrook North, North Brook (2008) and Brightwater RPD from 2017. The east-side CDD is still Stoneybrook North, and North Brook Phase One is Brightwater's first neighborhood.

Who is the developer of Brightwater?

Metro Development Group of Tampa, founded in 2003, through North Brook Holdings, LLC, filed in Florida in November 2007. Lennar and D.R. Horton are the builders.

How many homes will Brightwater have?

Lee County's Resolution Z-22-015 caps it at 1,475 dwelling units: 885 single-family units or an equivalent mix, plus 590 senior units. The developer asked for 1,500, and the two CDDs plan 679 and 797 lots, within one unit of the cap.

What are homes selling for in Brightwater right now?

In the last 12 months the county recorded 86 qualified sales at a $392,500 median. Builder-direct sales, all in Phase 3, had a $398,500 median, and 21 resales had a $315,000 median, from $275,000 to $550,000, through September 10, 2026.

Is Brightwater a good buy now that Lennar is sold out?

It can be at the right price. Lennar homes are now resales, which cleared at a $315,000 median and sometimes below the original builder price. Verify the fee terms with the association.

Who builds homes in Brightwater?

Lennar built the east side and has sold out. D.R. Horton is the sole builder in the west-side Brightwater CDD, including The Shores at Brightwater, a gated 55+ section. We found no DRB Homes or Maronda product.

What is The Shores at Brightwater?

D.R. Horton's gated 55+ section on the west side, with one-story homes and attached twin villas, a clubhouse, pool, fitness center, pickleball and dog park. D.R. Horton listed 20 homes from $326,040 to $486,350 in October 2026.

Do 55+ residents get lagoon access?

Lee County's zoning requires a resident lagoon membership with every Brightwater home purchase, and the 590 senior units are inside the master development. The recorded Club Plan controls, so ask for it and for The Shores' association documents before you sign.

What is the total yearly cost of owning in Brightwater?

Our worked example, a $399,000 Phase 3 home with homestead, comes to $9,653.50 a year on a 50-foot lot and $10,457.85 on a 60-foot lot, about $804 and $871 a month, before insurance.

What is the Brightwater CDD, and which one applies to my lot?

A community development district is a local government that finances and maintains infrastructure by assessing the homes it serves. Stoneybrook North CDD serves the east of Pritchett Parkway and Brightwater CDD the west. The parcel's tax bill shows which applies.

How much is the CDD assessment in Brightwater?

On adopted FY2027 schedules, Stoneybrook North runs from $3,103.98 for a 40-foot Area One lot to $4,826.10 for a 60-foot Phase 3 lot. Brightwater CDD shows $2,789.14 for a 35-foot class and $3,984.48 for a 50-foot class where operating assessments apply.

Will CDD and HOA fees go up?

The CDD debt portion is fixed for the bond term, but the operating portion is set yearly by the board and rose 13 percent at Stoneybrook North for FY2027. The May 2026 preliminary document calls the roughly $600 HOA fee subject to change.

Can I pay off the CDD bond early?

The district's explainer says the bond portion typically lasts about 30 years, does not change and can be paid off early. The operating portion cannot be prepaid. Ask the district manager for your lot's payoff figure and weigh it against your mortgage rate.

What does the Brightwater HOA cover?

According to the May 2026 preliminary offering document, its main function is architectural review and deed-restriction enforcement. The CDD funds common landscaping, roads, ponds, streetlights and gates. Read the declaration for the rest.

How much is the HOA in Brightwater?

The 2023 and 2024 developer sheets show $146.31 a quarter ($585.24 a year), and the May 2026 preliminary document anticipates about $600 a year. The current amount is not published, so request the estoppel certificate and current budget under Florida Statutes 720.30851.

Is the lagoon fee part of the HOA?

No. The lagoon is independently owned and operated, outside both CDDs, and its fee comes through a recorded Club Plan billed separately: $35 a month plus tax and a $2,000 initiation on the 2023 and 2024 sheets, about $600 a year per unit in the May 2026 document.

How big is Brightwater Lagoon, five acres or six?

About six acres. Metro, Lennar, the News-Press and WINK say six, Crystal Lagoons says 5.9, the May 2026 offering document says about 6.5, and the operator's own page says about five. We write "about six acres" and name the operator's five.

How deep is Brightwater Lagoon?

Up to 16 feet beneath the floating obstacle course, according to Gulfshore Business in May 2025, with about 10 million gallons of water. The operator says free-swim areas have no lifeguards.

Is Brightwater Lagoon heated?

No. The operator's FAQ says the water is not heated and follows seasonal Florida water temperatures, so expect cooler water in winter.

Is the water treated with chemicals?

Yes. The operator says its water-quality team follows industry-approved chlorination and filtration standards under state and CDC requirements. We never write "chemical free."

Can anyone swim in Brightwater Lagoon, or only residents?

The public can buy tickets online or at the gate, subject to availability. Lee County's rezoning allowed limited non-resident access, limited by parking, with at least 33 percent of the lot reserved for residents. Owners get membership included; the public pays per visit.

How much does a Brightwater Lagoon ticket cost?

Prices are dynamic. Dated points: $25 the week of the May 2025 ribbon cutting, $30 for adults and $28 for children in June 2025, and "starting at $22" on the operator's site in October 2026.

What do residents get that day-pass guests do not?

Per Metro's materials, resident members get a free card for each resident aged 14 and over, resident events and discounts on rentals and food, subject to capacity limits and blackout dates. The Club Plan's terms are not public.

Can I rent out my Brightwater home?

Rental terms, including any lease minimum, rental cap or short-term rule, sit in the recorded declaration, which we could not read publicly, so we state none. The lagoon operator says a homeowner who rents out the home must relinquish lagoon access. Request the declaration first.

Is Brightwater in a flood zone?

All ten sampled Brightwater addresses were in FEMA Zone X, outside the Special Flood Hazard Area, on panels effective November 17, 2022. A June 30, 2026 map revision removed parts of the community from the Bayshore Creek floodplain. Ask for an elevation certificate.

Did Brightwater flood in Hurricane Ian or Milton?

Brightwater-specific storm damage is not documented in the public sources we read. The oldest homes, built from 2020, were standing for Ian in September 2022. Lee's Milton evacuation order covered Zones A and B, and Brightwater's sampled points were in Zones C and D.

How much is flood insurance in Brightwater?

In OpenFEMA data for ZIP 33917, the median premium for Zone X policies on 2023-or-later homes was $517 (67 policies, $204 to $7,069), and Lee County's CRS gives Zone X a 10 percent discount. Get a quote for your address.

How much is homeowners insurance in Brightwater?

We print no number, because premiums depend on the carrier, roof, openings and wind-mitigation credits. Brightwater roofs are under 15 years old, which protects against roof-age declinations under Florida Statutes 627.7011.

What schools are zoned for Brightwater?

The district's locator returned Elementary Zone C, Middle Zone CC and High School East Zone 1 for the five points we tested. Confirm by address.

How far is Brightwater from Fort Myers, Cape Coral and the airport?

Our computed free-flow estimates from the lagoon: downtown Fort Myers 19 minutes, Cape Coral Hospital 26, Southwest Florida International Airport 27, Punta Gorda 35 and the Fort Myers Beach pier 44. Add 25 to 50 percent at peak.

Where is the nearest hospital to Brightwater?

We could not verify a hospital or emergency room in ZIP 33917. The nearest are Lee Health Cape Coral Hospital and HCA Florida's Cape Coral emergency room, about 13 miles away, and Gulf Coast Medical Center at about 15.

Who provides electric, water and sewer in Brightwater?

Lee County Electric Cooperative provides power, not FPL. The county's GIS puts the area in Lee County Utilities' water franchise and FGUA's wastewater franchise. Confirm the billing entity for your address.

What fire district serves Brightwater?

Bayshore Fire Protection and Rescue District, Station 131 at 17350 Nalle Rd, not North Fort Myers Fire. Brightwater is in tax district 202, where the Bayshore levy is 3.5000 mills. The Lee County Sheriff's Office provides law enforcement.

How does Brightwater compare with Babcock Ranch?

Brightwater is a smaller lagoon community with I-75 five minutes away and resales near $315,000. Babcock Ranch is a town with schools and medical care inside the gate and prices from the low $200,000s to over $4 million.

Is Brightwater a good investment property?

That depends on rules that are not public. The operator says a homeowner who rents out the home relinquishes lagoon access, which weakens the amenity for a tenant,. Request the declaration and Club Plan and model the rental without the lagoon.

What is a CDD disclosure, and when must I get it?

Florida Statutes 190.048 requires every contract for a home in a community development district to carry a prescribed disclosure of the district's assessments, and both Brightwater ordinances require it for the life of the district. If it is missing, flag it to the closing agent.

What is the HOA disclosure summary and my 3-day right?

Under Florida Statutes 720.401, the buyer must receive the association disclosure summary before signing. If it was not provided first, the buyer may cancel within 3 days after receiving it. We confirm it is attached before you sign.

Who pays the owner's title policy in Lee County?

In Lee County the seller customarily pays for the owner's policy and the buyer for the lender's policy, but the contract controls and the AS IS form's box is negotiable. On a builder sale, the builder's contract sets the title company and who pays.

What closing costs does a Brightwater buyer pay?

A financing buyer pays mortgage documentary stamps of $0.35 per $100 and intangible tax of $0.002 per $1, which total $1,727 on a $314,000 loan, plus the lender's title policy, survey, inspections, prorations and estoppel charges. Your lender's Loan Estimate binds.

Do I need a written agreement with an agent before touring?

Yes. Since August 17, 2024, an agent working with a buyer must have a written agreement before touring a home, stating compensation that is specific and negotiable.

Should I hire an inspector for a new-construction home?

Yes. A builder's walkthrough is not an independent inspection. Hire a licensed inspector, order a wind-mitigation report, and get the warranty terms in writing before the contract is final, since your remedies after closing depend on them.

When will Phase 4 homes close?

The Brightwater CDD's preliminary May 2026 document expects closings with homebuyers from December 2027 for Phase 4's 206 lots, at about 100 homes a year and an average price near $330,000. Those are builder estimates.

How much are property taxes in Brightwater?

Total millage for tax district 202 was 14.4125 in 2025, with 14.3623 applied to the 2026 tax roll. On our worked example the 2026 ad valorem tax with homestead is $4,626.51 at that rate (the TRIM notice proposed $4,630.10) on a home the county values at $363,846. The CDD is a separate line on the same bill.

Is Brightwater safe?

We found no published crime statistic specific to Brightwater, so we state none. The community is gated and the Lee County Sheriff's Office covers it from District 1, Zone 12. Ask the sheriff's office for call data on your street.

Selling a Florida Home to Buy in Brightwater?

Many Brightwater buyers are also selling a Florida home, and the two sales need one plan: the sale price funds the purchase, the closing dates must line up, and a Florida homestead may carry portable Save Our Homes savings into the new home if you file within the three-year window. We run both sides together.

If your current home is in Brightwater, start with a free Brightwater home valuation, or read our guide to selling your home in Brightwater. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. If you are still weighing other markets, our buyer guides to Heritage Landing and Fort Myers show how we handle the same questions there. A sale-contingent offer is weaker than a clean one, so we model the timeline and the portability filing first.

Sources

All sources for this Brightwater guide were read on October 10, 2026 unless a line says otherwise. Where a figure is our own tabulation of a public file, the text says so beside it. Member-only MLS data is not cited, and no competitor brokerage or listing portal appears in this list, by policy.

Downloadable Documents

Every document below links to the body that issues it, not to a copy we host, so it stays current the moment the issuer updates it. A Brightwater buyer is handed several of these during a purchase, and reading them before you make an offer costs nothing.

Document

Issuing body

Link

Resolution Z-22-015, rezoning, unit cap and lagoon conditions

Lee County

Resolution Z-22-015 (PDF)

Hearing Examiner Recommendation, DCI2021-00012

Lee County

Recommendation (PDF)

Ordinance 14-23, Stoneybrook North CDD

Lee County

Ordinance 14-23 (PDF)

Ordinance 18-02, Brightwater CDD

Brightwater CDD

Ordinance 18-02 (PDF)

Adopted Budget FY2027

Stoneybrook North CDD

Budget (PDF)

Adopted Budget FY2027

Brightwater CDD

Budget (PDF)

May 26, 2026 agenda packet with preliminary offering document

Brightwater CDD

Agenda packet (PDF)

Understanding Your CDD Assessment Letter

Stoneybrook North CDD

Explainer (PDF)

Letter of Map Revision 25-04-6830P

FEMA

LOMR (PDF)

Brightwater map brochure, August 2026

Metro Development Group

Brochure (PDF)

Fee sheet FY2024

Metro Places

Fee sheet (PDF)

Estoppel certificate fees

Florida DBPR

Fee schedule (PDF)

AS IS contract, ASIS-7, redline

Florida Realtors and The Florida Bar

ASIS-7 (PDF)

Buyer brokerage agreement, single agent, EBBA-8sa

Florida Realtors

EBBA-8sa (PDF)

Your Local Real Estate Experts

McGreevy and Comisar are the Southwest Florida team Brightwater buyers call when a purchase has to be priced on the county record and closed without surprises. Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and lead the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012.

More about Jesse McGreevy, Marc Comisar and our team on the about page.

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar. For this guide we read the county's recorded Brightwater sales, both CDDs' budgets, Lee County's rezoning resolution, the lagoon operator's rules, FEMA's flood layer and the school district's locator, so the figures come from public records. Return to the Brightwater community guide or explore North Fort Myers.

  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 · [email protected]
  • Marc Comisar: (239) 287-5873
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate, SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate, BK3060671) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty; Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC).

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team. Learn more at DomainRealtyGroup.com.

Send us a Brightwater address and we will send back the plat, the district, the FEMA reading and the recorded comparables, with the source document behind every figure. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072, book a Brightwater buyer consultation, or call Marc at (239) 287-5873.

This guide is general information about buying a home in Brightwater, North Fort Myers, Florida. It is not legal, tax or insurance advice, and it is not an offer of representation. Statutory figures change annually and market figures change monthly. Brokered by Domain Realty.