Start Your Bay Beach Buyer Consultation
Contact Details

Jesse McGreevy

[email protected]

(239) 898-6072

24031 S Tamiami Trl #101

Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Marc Comisar

[email protected]

(239) 287-5873

Mon - Fri, 9 am - 6 pm

McGreevy and Comisar, Brokered by Domain Realty

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, McGreevy and Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Updated November 2026.

More about Jesse McGreevy, Marc Comisar and our team on the McGreevy and Comisar about page.

This is our buyer’s guide to Bay Beach, Fort Myers Beach, the bay-side cluster of condominium communities on the south half of Estero Island, where a buyer picks one of fifteen buildings before picking a condo or home. Our Bay Beach guide holds the record of every building, and Fort Myers Beach is the island around it.

By the Lee County Property Appraiser’s taxing district, all 1,757 residential parcels in Bay Beach belong to the Town of Fort Myers Beach, which covers Estero Island and incorporated on December 31, 1995. That means the Town, and not unincorporated Lee County, handles permits, flood rules and short-term rental registration for every Bay Beach building, and the district’s 2026 applied millage of 13.3108, down from 13.4329 in 2025, applies to every tax figure below. The ZIP code is 33931.

Bay Beach is a crowded phrase, so here is what we mean by it. This page covers the streets the county roll ties to the name: Bay Beach Lane, Lenell Road, Island Pines Way, Bella Lago Drive, Lake Valencia Court and a short run of Estero Boulevard, about four and a half to five miles by road south of Times Square. It is not a bay beach on another island, and the Bella Lago here is not Belle Lago in Estero.

The short version for a buyer is this. In the 12 months to October 7, 2026 the Southwest Florida MLS recorded 61 Bay Beach closings at a median of $425,000, from $260,000 to $2,200,000. On the same day 53 listings were active or pending, from $289,900 to $3,059,000, and the 49 active ones equal about 9.6 months of supply at the pace of the 12 months to that date. A re-check on October 29, 2026 found 54 active listings and 5 pending. No Bay Beach association publishes a current budget, rental rules or pet rules. The FEMA flood map indicates a Special Flood Hazard Area at every address we tested. The older buildings have already passed their statutory milestone inspection year and the newer ones have not reached it. All of it is a reason to choose the building first and read its documents before you offer.

How Do I Buy a Home in Bay Beach, Fort Myers Beach, in 2026?

To buy a home in Bay Beach in 2026, pick the building before the unit, price the unit from closed sales in that same building, request the budget, reserve study and estoppel certificate before you offer, get flood and wind quotes for the exact address, and sign a written buyer agreement before your first tour.

The order matters here, and our Bay Beach guide explains why: Bay Beach is nine larger condominiums and six smaller buildings, each with its own declaration, association, fee and rules, and no area-wide master association that we could find.

The six steps, in the order we work them

  1. Set the budget band. The closings of the 12 months to October 7, 2026 ran from $260,000 to $2,200,000, and each band points to different buildings.
  2. Choose two or three buildings. Age, height, plan size, dock arrangements and inspection calendars differ building by building.
  3. Price from the building’s own closings. The Bay Beach median blends fifteen buildings and should never be used to price one unit.
  4. Ask for the documents before the offer. Budget, reserve study, milestone inspection summary where one applies, rules and any assessment notice.
  5. Quote the insurance. A unit-owner policy, a flood policy and the master policy summary, using the building’s elevation certificate.
  6. Put it in writing. The buyer agreement comes before the tour, and a slip, a rental plan or a pet belongs in the contract as a condition.

Why the building comes before the home

Two condos on Bay Beach Lane can differ by decades of age, several stories of height and a full fee layer. In the 12 months to October 7, 2026 that one street recorded a $260,000 closing and a $2,200,000 closing. A buyer who starts with the building compares like with like, and reads one set of documents instead of five.

Key Takeaways

These are the facts a Bay Beach buyer on Fort Myers Beach should know in October 2026, each drawn from the Southwest Florida MLS, the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, state and federal records and the Town of Fort Myers Beach.

  • The Southwest Florida MLS recorded 61 Bay Beach closings in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, median $425,000, from $260,000 to $2,200,000, at a median of $359 per square foot.
  • Sellers took a median of 93.8 percent of final list price after a median of 99 days, and none of the 61 sold above the final list price.
  • On October 7, 2026, 53 listings were active or pending, from $289,900 to $3,059,000, about 9.6 months of supply on the 49 active listings.
  • Supply is uneven by price: 16 listings ask $1,000,000 or more against 2 closings there in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, while $300,000 to $399,999 has 11 listings against 26 closings.
  • Fees are not published. Listing-entered annual recurring fees ran from $3,604 to $26,588 on the 61 closings (not verified).
  • The 2026 applied Town of Fort Myers Beach district millage is 13.3108, about $5,657.09 a year on a $425,000 price before exemptions.
  • The FEMA flood map indicates Zone VE at 12 feet or Zone AE at 11 feet at the Bay Beach addresses we tested, and the evacuation zone is A.
  • Rental, pet and approval rules are unpublished, and a resale condo buyer has 7 days, excluding weekends and legal holidays, to cancel after receiving the resale documents.
  • McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008; call Marc at (239) 287-5873.

Table of Contents

Bay Beach for buyers on Fort Myers Beach, section by section. Each link jumps to its part of this guide, from the market read and the building choice to the fee picture, the flood map, the Pink Shell Beach Resort comparison, the buyer consultation and the sources.

Why Work With McGreevy and Comisar as Your Bay Beach Buyer’s Agent in Fort Myers Beach?

McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008 and lead the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012. We represent Bay Beach buyers building by building: what each one recorded, what its documents say, where they are silent, and what a fair offer looks like against the closed sales next door.

If you’re searching for the best buyer’s agent for a home in Bay Beach, McGreevy and Comisar represent homebuyers across Fort Myers Beach, Bonita Springs, Estero, Naples, Fort Myers and Lee and Collier Counties, from a first Florida home to a winter condo with a boat-slip question. With our Domain Realty Group team we have sold over $2.5 billion in real estate, and McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in personal sales. Domain Realty Group has completed more than 4,000 transactions, and in the 2026 RealTrends Verified rankings (Large Team category) our team recorded 241 transaction sides and $157.57 million in volume, which ranked it first in Bonita Springs, fifth in Florida by sides and eleventh in Florida by volume. Our office is at 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134. For a side-by-side look at how to choose an agent on the island, see our comparison of the best real estate agents in Fort Myers Beach.

Honors and recognition:

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

A buyer’s agent who also lists condos

Marc Comisar leads our buyer representation and Jesse McGreevy leads our listings, so a Bay Beach buyer hears how Fort Myers Beach sellers think about price, timing and repairs. Jesse has been licensed in Florida since November 4, 2004 and Marc since September 25, 2003. Selling a home to buy here? See our Bay Beach home valuation and our Bay Beach seller’s guide. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

How we researched this page

We tracked every one of the 334 Bay Beach closings in the Southwest Florida MLS in the 60 months to October 7, 2026, including two entered as Sold Data Entry, and sorted each one to its building by street number. We tracked every Lee County qualified sale in the 12, 24, 36 and 60 month windows to the roll file of October 4, 2026, read the roll for all 1,757 parcels, queried the FEMA flood layer at four Bay Beach addresses and the area’s center point, and read the state filings for each association.

What Is the Bay Beach Market Like for Buyers on Fort Myers Beach in Late 2026?

In the 12 months to October 7, 2026 the Southwest Florida MLS recorded 61 Bay Beach closings at a median of $425,000, from $260,000 to $2,200,000, after a median of 99 days on market and at 93.8 percent of final list price. On October 7, 2026, 53 listings were active or pending, and the 49 active ones equal about 9.6 months of supply.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

A re-check of the Southwest Florida MLS on October 29, 2026 found 54 Bay Beach listings active, asking $235,000 to $3,059,000 at a median of $635,000, 12 of them not on the October 7 list, and 5 pending. Three closings were recorded after October 7: $610,000 and $1,250,000 at Waterside at Bay Beach on October 15 and $310,000 at Harbour Pointe on October 26, 2026. No closing fell between October 8 and October 29, 2025, so with those three added the 12 months to October 29, 2026 hold 64 closings at a median of $432,500.

The Southwest Florida MLS series, four windows

Windows are counted back from October 7, 2026. The 12-month window holds 61 closings, well over our floor of 10, so it leads.

WindowClosingsMedian sold priceRangeMedian price per sq ftMedian days on marketMedian sale-to-final-list
12 months61$425,000$260,000 to $2,200,000$3599993.8%
24 months105$525,000$260,000 to $2,200,000$3768994.3%
36 months174$532,250$260,000 to $3,064,875$40265.594.4%
60 months334$610,000$260,000 to $3,064,875$4402596.6%

The longer windows show a higher median and fewer days on market because Grandview at Bay Beach, the 2023 tower at 4142 Bay Beach Lane, delivered 43 closings inside the 60 months, from $1,278,077 to $3,064,875, at a median of 1 day on market. Only 1 of the 43 falls in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, so the 12-month row is the cleanest read of the resale market.

Where the closings were, building by building

We sorted all 334 closings to a building by street number, because the MLS files several buildings under the Waterside name. A median is shown only where a building has 10 or more closings in the window.

BuildingClosings, 12 monthsSold range, 12 monthsMedian, 12 monthsClosings, 60 monthsMedian, 60 months
Waterside at Bay Beach (five buildings)7$540,000 to $950,000not shown66$772,500
The Palms of Bay Beach10$360,000 to $650,000$392,50041$475,000
Harbour Pointe2$270,000 to $312,500not shown15$470,000
Casa Marina2$399,999 to $542,000not shown23$480,000
Hibiscus Pointe12$270,000 to $440,000$375,00034$434,750
Royal Pelican6$260,000 to $355,000not shown19$429,900
Palm Harbor Club4$465,000 to $665,000not shown19$715,000
Captains Bay4$315,000 to $375,000not shown13$475,000
Bella Lago1$505,000not shown15$625,000
Grandview at Bay Beach (4142 Bay Beach Ln)1$2,200,000not shown43$1,718,000
Manatee Bay at Bay Beach (4182 Bay Beach Ln)5$445,000 to $675,000not shown21$675,000
4192 Bay Beach Ln (filed under Waterside)4$925,000 to $1,035,000not shown9not shown
Ostego Bay3$425,000 to $575,000not shown7not shown
Admirals Bay0nonenone5not shown
Valencia Villas at Bay Beach0nonenone4not shown
All Bay Beach61$260,000 to $2,200,000$425,000334$610,000

Only Hibiscus Pointe and The Palms of Bay Beach had enough sales in one year to carry a 12-month median. Elsewhere a buyer has a range and a five-year median, which reaches back into the 2021 and 2022 market, so treat it as a position on the map and not as today’s price.

What is for sale on October 7, 2026

The MLS showed 53 Bay Beach listings: 49 active and 4 pending with contingencies, from $289,900 to $3,059,000, median $645,000. Without the 11 Grandview listings, the other 42 run from $289,900 to $1,325,000 with a median of $472,000.

BuildingActivePendingAsking price rangeMLS living area range
Waterside at Bay Beach (five buildings)111$625,000 to $1,299,9001,519 to 2,119 sq ft
The Palms of Bay Beach30$410,000 to $599,0001,024 to 1,142 sq ft
Harbour Pointe32$289,900 to $425,0001,055 to 1,175 sq ft
Casa Marina11$399,000 to $475,0001,164 to 1,244 sq ft
Hibiscus Pointe40$350,000 to $435,9001,060 to 1,197 sq ft
Royal Pelican40$305,000 to $399,9001,156 to 1,274 sq ft
Palm Harbor Club10$695,0001,394 sq ft
Captains Bay30$405,000 to $469,0001,073 to 1,239 sq ft
Grandview at Bay Beach (4142 Bay Beach Ln)110$1,500,000 to $3,059,0002,414 to 2,923 sq ft
Manatee Bay at Bay Beach (4182 Bay Beach Ln)20$495,000 to $595,0001,390 to 1,636 sq ft
4192 Bay Beach Ln (filed under Waterside)30$890,000 to $1,325,0002,045 to 2,324 sq ft
Ostego Bay10$699,9991,973 sq ft
Admirals Bay20$309,000 to $350,000811 sq ft
All Bay Beach494$289,900 to $3,059,000811 to 2,923 sq ft

More than a fifth of everything for sale is in Grandview, where 11 listings stand against 1 closing in 12 months. Bella Lago and Valencia Villas had no listing that day. Sellers are asking more per square foot than buyers have paid: a median of $378 across the 42 listings outside Grandview, against $359 on the 61 closings.

Months of supply, and where it sits by price

Bay Beach has about 9.6 months of supply: 49 active listings against 61 closings in 12 months, about 5.1 a month. All of ZIP 33931 showed about 11.5 months, on 380 active listings and 397 closings. The headline hides a split by price.

Price bandClosings, 12 months to October 7, 2026Active and pending, October 7, 2026Listings per closing, as monthsWhere the listings are
Under $300,000426Harbour Pointe 2
$300,000 to $399,99926115.1Royal Pelican 4, Hibiscus Pointe 2, Harbour Pointe 2, Admirals Bay 2, Casa Marina 1
$400,000 to $499,99961020Captains Bay 3, Hibiscus Pointe 2, The Palms 2, Manatee Bay 1, Harbour Pointe 1, Casa Marina 1
$500,000 to $749,9991785.6Waterside 4, Ostego Bay 1, Palm Harbor Club 1, The Palms 1, Manatee Bay 1
$750,000 to $999,9996612Waterside 5, 4192 Bay Beach Ln 1
$1,000,000 and above21696Grandview 11, Waterside 3, 4192 Bay Beach Ln 2
All Bay Beach615310.4Thirteen buildings and communities

The months column is listings divided by closings, times 12, and it counts the 4 pending listings, so it is a ratio for comparison and not a forecast. Between $300,000 and $399,999, about five months, a well-priced home will not wait. The closing counts in the upper bands are small, so read those rows as direction.

How much room is there to negotiate in Bay Beach?

The median Bay Beach closing was 93.8 percent of the final list price, a median gap of $29,000.

Sold price as a share of final list priceClosings, 12 months to October 7, 2026
Exactly 100 percent5
97 to under 100 percent6
95 to under 97 percent10
90 to under 95 percent28
Under 90 percent12
Above 100 percent0

Time and discount moved together. The 16 homes that closed within 30 days sold at a median of 95.0 percent of final list price, and the 16 that took 180 days or more at 91.9 percent. The widest gap was a Royal Pelican sale at 4521 Bay Beach Lane: $260,000 on a $350,000 final list price after 309 days, 74.3 percent. The record carries the final list price, not the first one, so the distance from the original ask is not in our data.

How long do Bay Beach listings sit?

Sixteen of the 61 closings sold within 30 days, 14 in 31 to 90 days, 15 in 91 to 179 days and 16 took 180 days or more, the longest 586 days at Captains Bay. The 53 listings of October 7, 2026 had been on the market a median of 103 days, and 19 had passed 180 days.

Start your Bay Beach buyer consultation

Tell us your budget, timing and whether a slip, a rental plan or a pet matters, and we send the Bay Beach buildings that fit, with the 61 closings of the 12 months to October 7, 2026 sorted to each one. Start your Bay Beach buyer consultation, read how we represent buyers, or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873. Selling first? Get a free Bay Beach home valuation.

What does the Lee County record show for Bay Beach?

The Lee County Property Appraiser recorded 53 qualified Bay Beach sales in the 12 months to the October 4, 2026 roll file, at a median of $410,000. This county series is separate and is never averaged with the MLS figures.

WindowCounty-qualified salesMedian priceRange
12 months53$410,000$250,000 to $2,200,000
24 months102$506,500$250,000 to $2,200,000
36 months163$510,000$250,000 to $3,064,876
60 months262$575,000$250,000 to $3,064,876

The roll’s median just value across the 1,413 condominium unit parcels is $376,228, an assessment figure and not a sale price. As a gauge of turnover, 334 MLS closings in 60 months, less the 21 at 4182 Bay Beach Lane that sit outside the roll count, leaves 313, which against 1,413 units over 5 years is about 4.4 percent of units a year.

How Do the Bay Beach Buildings Differ?

Bay Beach divides by building. The oldest and least expensive homes are in The Palms, Royal Pelican, Harbour Pointe and Hibiscus Pointe, the mid-range is Casa Marina, Captains Bay, Palm Harbor Club and Bella Lago, the larger plans are in Waterside and Manatee Bay, and the 2023 Grandview tower sits alone at the top.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

The nine larger buildings

Unit counts are the state’s project records, and years built and stories are the county roll’s. Where the two records disagree, the building’s declaration governs, so ask the association for its count.

BuildingUnits (state record)Year built (county)Tallest story countWhat sets it apart
Waterside at Bay Beach286 in five buildings1997 to 200311A master association and a dock cooperative
The Palms of Bay Beach152 (155 on the roll)1976 to 19787The oldest Bay Beach condominium
Hibiscus Pointe184 (182 on the roll)1992 to 19956Most closings in the 12 months to October 7, 2026; a boat cooperative
Casa Marina144 in three condominiums1990 to 20016A separate boating association
Palm Harbor Club562000 to 20018Lenell Road; a pool on the roll
Royal Pelican144 (145 on the roll)1986 to 19914Low-rise; a boating association
Harbour Pointe140 (141 on the roll)1982 to 1995 (county range)10Lowest asking prices on October 7, 2026
Bella Lago5920064Bella Lago Drive; a pool on the roll
Captains Bay93 (96 on the roll)1994 to 19975Three condominiums

The six smaller buildings

Six more buildings have a module in our Bay Beach guide. Admirals Bay is 38 two-story units on Island Pines Way. Ostego Bay is two condominiums on Lenell Road, 36 and 16 units. Grandview at Bay Beach is the 58-unit, 11-story tower built in 2023. Valencia Villas at Bay Beach is 12 one-story villas built in 2006. Estero Bayside is 45 units on Island Pines Way, and Manatee Bay at Bay Beach is 58 units in an 11-story building built in 2008. Our market counts include Manatee Bay and leave out Estero Bayside.

By size of home

We grouped the 61 closings by MLS living area and set the 53 listings of October 7, 2026 beside them.

MLS living areaClosings, 12 months to October 7, 2026Sold rangeMedian sold priceMedian price per sq ftActive and pending, October 7, 2026
Under 1,100 sq ft18$270,000 to $560,000$369,500$35610
1,100 to 1,399 sq ft23$260,000 to $780,000$385,000$32215
1,400 to 1,799 sq ft10$425,000 to $650,000$562,500$3546
1,800 sq ft and up10$665,000 to $2,200,000$937,500$46222

Not counting plans with a den, 35 of the 61 closings were two-bedroom homes and 22 were three-bedroom. The two smaller bands hold 41 of the 61 closings. At 1,800 square feet and up the picture flips: 10 closings in a year against 22 listings, half of them in Grandview.

By age and height

The computed milestone inspection years in a later section run from already passed for The Palms and Royal Pelican to 2053 for Grandview. The roll counts 365 condominium parcels in six-story buildings, 176 in ten-story buildings and 171 in four-story buildings. Admirals Bay, Ostego Bay and Valencia Villas are two stories or fewer, which puts them outside the milestone and reserve study rules by the roll’s story count.

By water and by boat

Every Bay Beach building is on the bay side of Estero Island, and none has Gulf frontage. The county roll’s waterfront field reads bay on 646 of the 1,757 residential parcels, canal on 579 and lake on 224, and is blank on 308. The field includes dock and slip parcels, so use it as a prompt to ask what a unit looks at, not as a view guarantee.

The roll also carries 144 parcels on a street it names Boat Dock and 119 on one it names Boat Slip, which are individually owned dock and slip rights and not homes. Hibiscus Pointe has a boat cooperative, Casa Marina and Royal Pelican have boating associations, and Waterside has a recorded dock cooperative. A cooperative is governed by Florida’s chapter 719 and its own documents, so a slip is a second purchase with a second set of papers.

What Will I Pay to Own a Bay Beach Home in Fort Myers Beach?

Owning a Bay Beach home costs the Town of Fort Myers Beach property tax, the building’s association fee, a master or dock fee in some buildings, your own insurance and utilities. Listing agents entered annual recurring fees from $3,604 to $26,588 on the 61 closings of the 12 months to October 7, 2026, median $12,400, unverified; each association’s budget governs.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

What listing agents entered, by building

No Bay Beach association publishes a current budget that we could find. Listing-entered annual recurring fees on Southwest Florida MLS closings in the 60 months to October 7, 2026 ranged as follows (not verified; the association’s current budget and an estoppel certificate govern).

Building, as the MLS labels itClosings with the fee field filled inListing-entered total annual recurring fees
Waterside at Bay Beach (label includes neighboring buildings)138$3,604 to $28,640
The Palms of Bay Beach41$6,736 to $15,912
Hibiscus Pointe34$5,600 to $11,600
Casa Marina23$5,240 to $11,000
Palm Harbor Club19$7,100 to $11,308
Royal Pelican19$6,100 to $12,400
Harbour Pointe15$7,856 to $18,120
Bella Lago15$9,264 to $13,200
Captains Bay13$6,096 to $10,644

Across all 334 closings the median entry was $11,656, counting two entries of $0. Entries cover different years, plans and fee layers.

The layers to add up

  • The condominium assessment. It typically pays for the association’s insurance, exterior maintenance, the roof, the pool, management and reserves, and often water, sewer, trash and cable. Which of those a Bay Beach building covers is in its budget, and we have not seen one.
  • A master fee. Listing agents entered one on 146 of the 334 closings, typically $486 to $1,000 a quarter.
  • Dock, slip or boat cooperative charges. Separate again, and set by that entity’s own documents.
  • One-time charges at purchase. Application fees were entered as $25 to $250 on 250 closings and transfer or capital fees as $75 to $2,500 on 127. The estoppel certificate states the real figures; its own fee is capped by statute and we print no amount.

What it adds up to in a month

Take the median price of $425,000 for the 12 months to October 7, 2026, and the median listing-entered fee of $12,400 as placeholders. Tax of $5,657.09 at the 2026 applied millage of 13.3108 plus fees of $12,400 is $18,057.09 a year, about $1,505 a month, before your unit-owner policy, a flood policy, utilities, any dock charge and any loan payment. Replace the $12,400 with the figure in the building’s current budget before you rely on it.

Special assessments

We found no special assessment published for any Bay Beach building, which is not proof that none exists. Under Florida Statute 718.116 the association must furnish an estoppel certificate on request, and it lists any assessment that is levied and unpaid. Ask for the last year of board minutes as well.

A Bay Beach Purchase Worked Through: A $400,000 Budget on October 7, 2026

To show how a Bay Beach purchase works, we walk a buyer with about $400,000 through the listings and closed sales of October 7, 2026, then through one public-record closing in that range. The closing is an example drawn from the Southwest Florida MLS and is not a transaction of ours.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

Step one: what the budget reaches

On October 7, 2026, 18 of the 53 Bay Beach listings asked $425,000 or less: 5 in Harbour Pointe, 4 in Royal Pelican, 3 in Hibiscus Pointe, 2 in The Palms of Bay Beach, 2 in Admirals Bay, 1 in Casa Marina and 1 in Captains Bay. In the 12 months to October 7, 2026, 30 of the 61 closings sold under $400,000.

Step two: narrow to a building and find the twin

Say the buyer wants three bedrooms and picks Hibiscus Pointe. Its 12 closings in the 12 months to October 7, 2026 include seven sales of a three-bedroom plan of 1,197 square feet, at $325,000, $365,000, $370,000, $380,000, $385,000, $385,000 and $440,000. The median of these 7 closings is $380,000. On October 7, 2026 three homes of that size were listed there at $399,000, $425,000 and $435,900. The asking prices sit above six of the seven closed sales, and that gap is the buyer’s opening position.

Step three: one recorded closing, from the buyer’s side

The most recent of the seven closed on September 22, 2026 at 4421 Bay Beach Lane: three bedrooms, two baths, 1,197 square feet, final list price $349,000, sold price $325,000 after 5 days on the market. That is 93.1 percent of the final list price, $24,000 under it, and $272 per square foot.

Step four: what that buyer would owe

With 20 percent down the loan would be $260,000. Florida’s documentary stamp tax on the note, $0.35 per $100, is $910.00, and the nonrecurring intangible tax at 2 mills is $520.00. Property tax at the 2026 applied millage of 13.3108 is $4,326.01 a year before exemptions. The seller would customarily pay the deed’s documentary stamps, $2,275.00 at $0.70 per $100, and the owner’s title policy. Those are Lee County customs and the contract controls both.

Step five: what we would check before the offer

We would pull the FEMA map (it indicates Zone VE at 12 feet at the Hibiscus Pointe address we tested), request the elevation certificate, and ask for the budget, the reserve study, the milestone inspection summary and any assessment notice. Hibiscus Pointe’s computed milestone years are 2022 to 2025, so the summary is a document to ask for and not a future event. Listing-entered annual fees there ran from $5,600 to $11,600 on 34 closings, unverified.

What Should I Check in the Bay Beach Condominium Documents?

Check five groups of documents before you offer on a Bay Beach condo: the building’s declaration and rules, the budget and financial statement, any special-assessment notice, the milestone inspection summary and reserve study, and the insurance summary. Florida Statute 718.503 makes the seller deliver most of them, and gives the buyer a cancellation window after receipt.

Which law applies to which Bay Beach property

Every Bay Beach home we found on the state’s project list is a condominium, so chapter 718 of the Florida Statutes governs the purchase. That includes Valencia Villas at Bay Beach, whose one-story villas are recorded as a 12-unit condominium project. We found no chapter 720 homeowners association and no area-wide master association. The exception is the water: a slip held through a boat or dock cooperative is a chapter 719 interest with its own documents.

The statutory package and your cancellation window

Under Florida Statute 718.503, a unit owner who is not a developer must give the buyer the declaration, articles, bylaws and rules, the most recent annual financial statement and budget, the milestone inspection summary if one applies, the most recent structural integrity reserve study or a statement that none has been done, and the frequently asked questions document described in Florida Statute 718.504. The buyer may cancel within 7 days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and legal holidays, after signing and receiving those documents, and the same 7 days apply where a milestone inspection summary, a turnover inspection report or a structural integrity reserve study is part of the package. Ask for the package before you write the offer, along with the master insurance summary and every special-assessment notice since 2022.

Which entity decides what

These are legal names and Florida document numbers from the Division of Corporations. We publish names and numbers only.

EntityFlorida document number
The Palms of Bay Beach Condominium Association, Inc.735608
Harbour Pointe Condominium Association, Inc.766271
Royal Pelican Association, Inc.N15745
Hibiscus Pointe Condominium Association, Inc.N92000000363
Palm Harbor Club at Bay Beach Condominium Association, Inc.N00000005193
Bella Lago Condominium at Bay Beach Condominium Association, Inc.N06000000652
Waterside Master Association, Inc.N97000000670
Grandview at Bay Beach Condominium Association, Inc.N23000007552
Hibiscus Pointe Boat Cooperative Association, Inc.N93000004019

The other associations, and the Official Records book and page of every declaration, are in our Bay Beach guide. We did not capture a state filing for Manatee Bay at Bay Beach.

What Do Milestone Inspection and Reserve Study Rules Mean for a Bay Beach Condo Buyer?

Florida requires a milestone inspection of a condominium building of three or more habitable stories in the year it turns 30, and a structural integrity reserve study every 10 years. By county year built, Bay Beach buildings span from already past that year to 2053. These are computed years, not a status.

The statute and the date logic

Florida Statute 553.899 sets the inspection by December 31 of the year a building reaches 30 years of age, counted from its certificate of occupancy, and every 10 years after. A building that reached 30 before July 1, 2022 had to complete its first inspection before December 31, 2024. We did not retrieve certificates of occupancy, so the table uses the county’s year built. The statute lets a local agency require the inspection at 25 years near salt water; we did not confirm that the Town of Fort Myers Beach has done so and do not state that it applies.

BuildingYears built and tallest story countMilestone inspection year at 30
The Palms of Bay Beach1976 to 1978, 7 stories2006 to 2008, so due before December 31, 2024
Royal Pelican1986 to 1991, 4 stories2016 to 2021, so due before December 31, 2024
Harbour Pointe1982 to 1995 (county range), 10 stories2012 to 2025
Hibiscus Pointe1992 to 1995, 6 stories2022 to 2025
Casa Marina1990 to 2001, 6 stories2020 to 2031
Captains Bay1994 to 1997, 5 stories2024 to 2027
Waterside at Bay Beach1997 to 2003, 11 stories2027 to 2033
Palm Harbor Club2000 to 2001, 8 stories2030 to 2031
Bella Lago2006, 4 stories2036
Estero Bayside2006 to 2007, 6 stories2036 to 2037
Manatee Bay at Bay Beach2008, 11 stories2038
Grandview at Bay Beach2023, 11 stories2053
Admirals Bay, Ostego Bay, Valencia Villas2 stories or fewerNot applicable

The reserve study, and what to ask for

Under Florida Statute 718.112, an association with a building of three habitable stories or more must have a structural integrity reserve study at least every 10 years, which covers every building in the table above the last row, and associations that existed on July 1, 2022 had to complete theirs by December 31, 2025, with a later outside date in some cases. For The Palms, Royal Pelican, Harbour Pointe and Hibiscus Pointe the computed inspection years are behind us, so ask for the milestone summary and the repairs that followed. For Casa Marina and Captains Bay the years straddle today, so ask which building your unit is in. For Waterside and newer, ask for the reserve study and its funding plan. The state runs a public reserve study reporting page; we did not query it and state no status for any Bay Beach building.

What Are the Bay Beach Rules on Leasing, Pets and Approvals in Fort Myers Beach?

Whether you can rent a Bay Beach home, keep a pet or close without association approval is set by each building’s recorded declaration and current rules, and none is published online that we could find. The Town of Fort Myers Beach adds a short-term rental registration program and a minimum-stay rule with exceptions.

Can you rent out a Bay Beach condo?

The association’s documents are the first answer and they are not published for any Bay Beach building. The recorded declaration and current rules govern minimum lease terms, leases per year, tenant approval and any rental fee. Read the leasing article before you build an income plan.

The Town of Fort Myers Beach rental registration

Because every Bay Beach parcel is in the Town, the Town’s program applies to a unit rented as a vacation rental. Under Ordinance 18-01, such a unit must register within 90 days of starting the business, show its registration number in every advertisement, name a responsible party who can act within one hour, and renew every year, through the Town’s Short-Term Rentals page. Registration numbers do not transfer with a sale. Fees are set by Town resolution and we print no figure.

Minimum stays and the opt-out list

The Town’s land development code, section 34-2391, limits rentals in certain zoning districts to one family per month with a minimum stay of one week. Its exceptions include land directly adjoining the bay side of Estero Boulevard and condominiums of six or more units that allowed stays of three days or more on or before March 3, 2003 and notified the Town in writing before January 31, 2020. We did not confirm which rule or exception applies to any Bay Beach building. Ask the association and the Town at 239-765-0202.

Associations may also opt out of Town enforcement of the rental code of conduct. The Town’s 2026 opt-out list names one Bay Beach building, Captains Bay North Two at 6691 Estero Boulevard, with “No” in its registered column. That column is a status for the 2026 cycle and does not say whether a building allows rentals.

Pets and approvals

Pet rules are set by each association and are not published for any building we reviewed. Ask in writing how many pets, what size or breed limit, and whether the rule covers tenants and guests. Assistance animals are covered by fair housing law and are generally not treated as pets. On approvals, listing agents entered an application fee on 250 of the 334 closings, which suggests most associations process one, so ask for the approval timeline before you set a closing date.

Is Bay Beach in a Flood Zone, and What Will Insurance Cost?

The FEMA flood map indicates Zone VE with a base flood elevation of 12 feet at three Bay Beach Lane addresses we tested and Zone AE at 11 feet on Island Pines Way, on the Lee County panel effective November 17, 2022. Both are Special Flood Hazard Areas. We quote no premiums.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

What the FEMA map indicates at these addresses

On October 7, 2026 we queried the FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer at four Bay Beach addresses and the area’s center point. Treat the table as a map-based indication at those addresses, not a flood determination for any unit.

Tested addressBuildingFEMA zoneBase flood elevation (NAVD88)FIRM panel
4491 Bay Beach LnHibiscus PointeVE12 ft12071C0567G
4511 Bay Beach LnRoyal PelicanVE12 ft12071C0567G
4203 Bay Beach LnThe Palms of Bay BeachVE12 ft12071C0567G
22676 Island Pines WayAdmirals BayAE11 ft12071C0567G
Bay Beach center pointVE12 ft12071C0567G

Check your address at the FEMA Flood Map Service Center and ask for the building’s elevation certificate; the Town keeps an elevation certificate page. Lee County’s evacuation layer returns zone A, and the design wind speed at the center point is 160 miles per hour in a wind-borne debris region. A third-party map layer shows no Coastal Barrier Resources System unit at these addresses; confirm with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. A coastal construction control line segment lies within about 500 meters of the center point, and whether any building is seaward of it is not confirmed.

The Town’s flood rating and repair rules

The Town of Fort Myers Beach holds a Community Rating System Class 5, a 25 percent discount on National Flood Insurance Program premiums in a Special Flood Hazard Area, effective April 1, 2026, after a November 2024 retrograde and a probation that FEMA closed by letter on November 17, 2025. Town rules set the lowest floor of a new or substantially improved building at least one foot above base flood elevation, and apply the 50 percent test to the whole building: when repair or improvement cost reaches half of the building’s pre-damage value, it must meet current floodplain rules. The Town’s page states that permits from the past five years are counted; the code text we read does not state the five years.

The insurance routes, without a premium

The association’s master policy covers the building, so ask for its summary, its wind and flood coverage and how a deductible is shared. Your unit-owner policy covers the interior. A flood policy is priced under FEMA’s Risk Rating 2.0 by flood frequency, distance to water, elevation and rebuild cost, and most rates cannot rise more than 18 percent a year. A wind mitigation inspection on the state’s uniform form is valid for five years.

Citizens Property Insurance requires flood coverage on many residential policies under Florida Statute 627.351, phased in through January 1, 2027, but the statute exempts a policy that covers a condominium unit under a unit-owners form. A lender can still require flood insurance. Since October 1, 2024, section 689.302 has also required a seller of residential property to give the buyer a flood disclosure, so ask for it with the resale package.

What Was Rebuilt After Hurricane Ian in Bay Beach, Fort Myers Beach?

On the county roll, 58 Bay Beach parcels show a year built of 2023 or later, and all 58 are in Grandview at Bay Beach. That is new construction, not storm repair. The roll cannot show how much interior or ground-level work the older buildings did after Hurricane Ian, so ask each association.

What the surge was, on the island and near Bay Beach

Hurricane Ian made landfall on September 28, 2022. The National Hurricane Center’s report gives 10 to 15 feet of storm surge above ground along Fort Myers Beach and Estero Island, and says an estimated 900 structures in Fort Myers Beach were totally destroyed and 2,200 damaged. U.S. Geological Survey high-water marks on the island read 10.5 to 13.8 feet NAVD88, and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection recorded 13.23 feet NAVD88 at the pier.

Three marks sit in or beside Bay Beach: 11.9 feet NAVD88 at a 4509 Bay Beach Lane address, about 7 feet above ground; 11.6 feet at a 301 Lenell Road address, about 6.8 feet above ground; and 12.3 feet on Lake Valencia Court, about 2.7 feet above ground. A mark records water height at one spot, which is why our questions to a mid-rise association start with the ground level: parking, lobbies, elevators and electrical rooms. For Helene and Milton in 2024 the National Weather Service put coastal Lee County water levels at 2 to 5 and 3 to 6 feet above mean higher high water, with no island-specific marks.

What we found, and what to ask each building

We found no association-published damage account for any Bay Beach building. Ask for the post-Ian repair summary, the insurance claim history, any special assessment levied for the work, and the permits pulled and closed. Under the Town’s land development code, section 34-3238, a building that exceeds today’s density or height limits and is damaged by a disaster may be replaced at up to its pre-disaster lawful size, but over 50 percent damage it must meet the new-building floodplain rules.

Can I Finance a Bay Beach Condo?

A Bay Beach condo can be bought with a mortgage or with cash, and a lender reviews the condominium project as well as the borrower. Because Bay Beach is many separate associations, the lender’s questionnaire goes to the one building you choose, and its budget, reserves, insurance and inspection record decide whether the loan is straightforward.

What a lender asks the association

Lenders typically send a questionnaire covering the budget and reserve funding, the master insurance policy, special assessments, delinquent dues, pending litigation, the share of units that are owner-occupied or rented, and any structural or inspection report. A building with a milestone inspection due, a storm repair still open or a reserve shortfall can draw more questions.

The warrantability questions to raise before you offer

Ask your loan officer whether the project has been reviewed before, what reserve funding and insurance the loan program requires, how rental activity in the building affects eligibility, and whether a pending assessment changes the approval. A building that fits one program may not fit another. We name no lender on this page, and the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey is the public reference for the weekly average rate.

What Will My Property Taxes and Closing Costs Be on a Bay Beach Home?

Property tax on a Bay Beach home is billed by the Lee County Tax Collector at the Town of Fort Myers Beach district millage, 13.3108 for 2026 (13.4329 in 2025). On a $425,000 price that is $5,657.09 a year before exemptions, and a buyer financing 80 percent also pays $1,190.00 in note stamps and $680.00 in intangible tax.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026; Florida Department of Revenue rates)

Property tax: the reset and the route to your number

Each mill is $1 for every $1,000 of taxable value. The 2026 applied millage for the Town of Fort Myers Beach taxing district, which covers every Bay Beach parcel, is 13.3108 mills, according to the Lee County Property Appraiser’s 2026 Taxing District Millage Book, printed October 9, 2026. The 2025 rate was 13.4329 mills, so the 2026 rate is about $51.89 a year lower on a $425,000 home. Florida limits non-homestead residential property to a 10 percent annual assessment increase under section 193.1554, and a change of ownership generally resets the assessment to just value, so never carry the seller’s bill forward. The roll at leepa.org shows each unit’s assessment.

Worked example at four recorded Bay Beach prices

All four prices are closings recorded in the Southwest Florida MLS in the 12 months to October 7, 2026: the lowest ($260,000, September 30, 2026), a closing at the 12-month median ($425,000, September 10, 2026), a Manatee Bay closing ($675,000, October 1, 2026) and a closing at 4192 Bay Beach Lane ($965,000, June 25, 2026). Tax rows are before exemptions and non-ad valorem charges. Financed rows assume 20 percent down, our example and not a recommendation, at the Florida Department of Revenue’s rates for documentary stamp tax on a note and the nonrecurring intangible tax.

ItemLowest closingClosing at the medianManatee Bay closingClosing at 4192 Bay Beach Ln
Price$260,000$425,000$675,000$965,000
Tax at the 2026 applied rate of 13.3108 mills$3,460.81$5,657.09$8,984.79$12,844.92
Tax at the 2025 rate of 13.4329 mills$3,492.55$5,708.98$9,067.21$12,962.75
Loan with 20 percent down$208,000$340,000$540,000$772,000
Documentary stamps on the note at $0.35 per $100$728.00$1,190.00$1,890.00$2,702.00
Nonrecurring intangible tax at 2 mills$416.00$680.00$1,080.00$1,544.00
Deed stamps at $0.70 per $100, customarily the seller’s$1,820.00$2,975.00$4,725.00$6,755.00

Who customarily pays what in Lee County

In Lee County the seller customarily pays the owner’s title insurance policy and the documentary stamp tax on the deed, $0.70 per $100 of the price under section 201.02. The buyer pays the lender’s title policy and the loan charges. These are customs and not law, and the contract controls each one.

What the table leaves out

The table omits the lender’s title premium, recording fees, appraisal, inspection, prepaid insurance, escrows, prorations and the association’s application, transfer and capital charges. Lee County’s solid waste assessment for fiscal year 2026 in the area that includes the Town is $358.45 per single-family unit, and how it reaches a condominium unit is on the tax bill. Your lender’s Loan Estimate and the title company’s settlement statement control every number.

How Does Buyer Representation Work in Florida After the NAR Settlement?

Since August 17, 2024, an MLS participant working with a buyer must have a written agreement with that buyer before touring a home, in person or by live video. The agreement must state the agent’s compensation as a specific amount or rate, so the fee is settled before the first Bay Beach showing begins.

What the agreement must say

According to the National Association of Realtors, the agreement must disclose the amount or rate of compensation in terms that are objectively ascertainable and not open-ended, state that the agent may not receive more than the agreed amount from any source, and state conspicuously that broker fees are not set by law and are fully negotiable.

How we handle it for a Bay Beach purchase

We put the agreement and the fee in writing before we open the first door. You may ask the seller in your offer to cover some or all of the fee, and any part the seller does not cover is yours. We walk you through the NAR settlement questions and answers before you sign anything. Start your Bay Beach buyer consultation or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.

Which Schools Serve Bay Beach, Fort Myers Beach?

The Lee County school district’s GIS layer places Bay Beach Lane in elementary zone T, middle zone MM and high school South Zone 4. Zone T’s only school, Fort Myers Beach Elementary, is closed, so confirm the assigned school by address with the district’s Student Enrollment office before a school decides a purchase.

What we found, and what conflicts

Fort Myers Beach Elementary closed again after Hurricane Milton in 2024, and its former students have been bused to Heights Elementary. On May 12, 2026 the Lee County School Board voted to give the campus to the Town of Fort Myers Beach to operate as a charter school within three years; an opening date is not confirmed. Middle zone MM is served by Cypress Lake Middle and Lexington Middle under the district’s 2026-27 enrollment plan. The district layer returns South Zone 4 for Estero Island, but the plan’s published high school sub-zones run 1 to 3, so we could not confirm which high schools serve the zone. Use the district’s school zones page with the street address.

What Is Daily Life Like at Bay Beach on Fort Myers Beach?

Daily life at Bay Beach is a quiet bay-side condominium address about four and a half to five miles by road south of Times Square, with a grocery, a pharmacy and a fire station at the island’s south end and the Gulf beaches a short drive or trolley ride across Estero Boulevard.

Distances and drive times, with their origin

These are road distances and drive times from Bay Beach Lane estimated by the open OSRM routing engine on October 7, 2026 at free-flow speed. Winter traffic and bridge delays lengthen them.

DestinationMilesMinutes
Lovers Key State Park entrance3.512
Fort Myers Beach Public Library4.012
HealthPark Medical Center10.827
Bonita Springs12.025
Estero (Coconut Point)14.829
Sanibel Island16.636
Downtown Fort Myers19.742
Southwest Florida International Airport22.546
Naples (Fifth Avenue South)23.043

Groceries, services and the south bridge

The Publix at 4791 Estero Boulevard and the CVS at 7001 Estero Boulevard are at the south end; the CVS was reported as the island’s only pharmacy when it reopened on December 15, 2023. The Fort Myers Beach Fire Control District’s Station 33 is at 121 Lenell Road, inside Bay Beach. Estero Boulevard is the island’s single spine, and the new Big Carlos Pass Bridge at its south end is a fixed span with 60 feet of vertical clearance; traffic moved onto it on November 14, 2025 and its ribbon cutting was June 30, 2026.

Beaches, parks and what is under construction

Bay Beach has no Gulf frontage. The Town and Lee County keep public beach accesses along Estero Boulevard, and LeeTran’s Route 410 and 490 service links Times Square, Bowditch Point Park, the library and Lovers Key State Park. Two north-end parks are in construction: Lee County closed Bowditch Point Regional Park’s parking and amenities from September 8, 2026 for a $3.9 million restoration, and the Fort Myers Beach pier rebuild at Lynn Hall Memorial Park, about $14.4 million, broke ground on August 21, 2026 with about a year of work expected.

Bay Beach vs Pink Shell Beach Resort: How Do They Compare?

Bay Beach is a bay-side cluster of independent condominium associations with 61 closings and a $425,000 median in the 12 months to October 7, 2026. Pink Shell Beach Resort is a Gulf-front resort campus on the same island with 14 closings and a $325,000 median. Pink Shell costs less per home and more per square foot.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

The decision table

See the Pink Shell Beach Resort guide and the Pink Shell Beach Resort buyer page. Both columns are Southwest Florida MLS figures for the 12 months to October 7, 2026 unless the row says otherwise.

QuestionBay BeachPink Shell Beach Resort
WaterBay side, canals and docksGulf-front resort campus on the Gulf side of Estero Boulevard
Residential parcels on the roll1,757, of which 1,413 are condominium units229
Year built (county)1976 to 20231976 to 2007
Tallest building11 stories9 stories
Closings, 12 months to October 7, 20266114
Median sold price$425,000$325,000
Range$260,000 to $2,200,000$175,000 to $890,000
Median price per square foot$359$495
Median days on market99145.5
Median share of final list price93.8%94.2%
Active and pending, October 7, 20265311
County-qualified sales, 12 months53, median $410,00016, median $412,500
FEMA map at the tested addressesVE at 12 feet, AE at 11 feetVE at 13 feet
RentalsSet by each association, plus Town registrationResort-operated rental setting; owner program terms not confirmed

What the numbers say

Pink Shell’s median home sold for $100,000 less than Bay Beach’s and for $136 more per square foot, so a Pink Shell buyer pays for Gulf frontage and a resort and gets less space. Bay Beach had more than four times the closings and nearly five times the listings, which means more comparable sales to price from. Days on market were longer at Pink Shell, 145.5 against 99, on a sample of 14.

Where Bay Beach stands out

Bay Beach offers full-size condos, a choice of fifteen buildings across nearly fifty years of construction, a dock arrangement in several of them and a bay-side setting. The Gulf is a drive or a trolley ride away.

Where Pink Shell Beach Resort stands out

Pink Shell puts the Gulf beach at the door in a resort setting, with less square footage for the price, a smaller market, owner program terms we could not confirm and fewer closed sales to price from. Both places share the Town district’s 2026 applied millage of 13.3108, evacuation zone A and the same milestone inspection rules.

How Does Bay Beach Compare With the Rest of Fort Myers Beach?

Bay Beach had 61 of the 397 closings in ZIP 33931 in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, more than any other community in our Fort Myers Beach research, and its $425,000 median matched the $425,000 median for condominiums across the ZIP. Each row of the table keeps its own window.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

The benchmark table

Each row shows the window that leads for that place, the first of 12, 24, 36 and 60 months with 10 or more closings. The county column is the Lee County Property Appraiser’s qualified-sale series, a separate count never mixed with the MLS column.

NodeKindResidential parcelsYear builtMLS closings 12 moMLS closings 60 moMLS publish windowMLS median $/sq ft (same window)Active+pending 2026-10-07County-qualified (publish window)
Bay Beachcommunity17571976 to 20236133412 mo: n 61, median $425,000, range $260,000 to $2,200,000359.05312 mo: n 53, median $410,000
Pink Shellcommunity2291976 to 2007147012 mo: n 14, median $325,000, range $175,000 to $890,000495.01112 mo: n 16, median $412,500
Estero Beach and Tennis Clubcondo2971979 to 1982178312 mo: n 17, median $405,000, range $305,000 to $475,000783.01712 mo: n 20, median $407,500
Lovers Key Beach Clubcondo2071984 to 2000104712 mo: n 10, median $362,500, range $296,000 to $525,000652.01612 mo: n 10, median $362,500
Bayside Estatesneighborhood5981968 to 20242821112 mo: n 28, median $362,500, range $138,000 to $690,000235.02312 mo: n 30, median $364,750

What the comparison says to a Bay Beach buyer

Among these 12-month rows, the Gulf-side resort and beach condominiums carry higher prices per square foot than Bay Beach’s $359: Lovers Key Beach Club on Black Island at $652 is the clearest example, while Bayside Estates on the mainland sits lower at $235. We leave out the Estero Beach and Tennis Club per-foot figure because the county’s heated-area field for that building repeats a single value. Sale prices tell the other half: Bay Beach’s $425,000 median is close to Estero Beach and Tennis Club’s $405,000 and above Lovers Key Beach Club’s $362,500, on a median Bay Beach living area of 1,224 square feet. That is the Bay Beach trade in one line: a lower price per square foot, on the bay instead of the Gulf.

Owners in those three can read our seller guides for Estero Beach and Tennis Club, Lovers Key Beach Club and Bayside Estates, and buyers can read our Fort Myers Beach buyer page.

Bay Beach against the town-wide market

Across ZIP 33931 the Southwest Florida MLS counts 397 closings in the same 12 months at a median of $510,000, $455 per square foot, 92 days on market and 93.8 percent of final list price. By joining MLS addresses to the county roll, condominiums had 238 closings at a median of $425,000 and single-family homes 111 at $1,000,000; 98 of 2,064 sixty-month closings did not match an address and are excluded from the split.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Buying in Bay Beach?

Bay Beach gives a buyer choice, interior space for the price and a dock arrangement in several buildings. It asks a buyer to accept flood zone VE or AE, unpublished fees and rules that differ in every building, statutory inspection calendars on the older mid-rises, and no Gulf frontage.

What we like

  • Fifteen buildings across ages, heights and sizes, with listings from $289,900 to $3,059,000 on October 7, 2026, so one area serves very different budgets.
  • A median of $359 per square foot in the 12 months to October 7, 2026, below the Pink Shell campus at $495 and Lovers Key Beach Club at $652.
  • Real negotiating room in the record: a median of 93.8 percent of final list price, and 12 of 61 closings under 90 percent.
  • Docks, slips and boat cooperatives in several buildings, on the bay side.

What gives us pause

  • Every tested address is in a Special Flood Hazard Area, and the area is in evacuation zone A.
  • Hurricane Ian’s surge reached 10 to 15 feet above ground on the island, and no association has published its damage and repair account.
  • No budget, reserve study, rental rule or pet rule is published for any building, so the true carrying cost is unknown until you read the documents.
  • The older buildings have passed their computed milestone inspection years, and we could not confirm any building’s inspection or reserve study status.

How Do I See Bay Beach Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach?

To see Bay Beach homes for sale, search the listings on DomainRealtyGroup.com, then send us your favorites, and we pull the closed sales, fee entries and document list for each building before you tour. Buyers choose McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, for that preparation.

Data updated: October 2026 (Southwest Florida MLS closings through October 7, 2026; Lee County Property Appraiser roll file October 4, 2026)

The October 2026 count, and why we do not list addresses

On October 7, 2026 the Southwest Florida MLS showed 53 Bay Beach condominiums active or pending, spread over thirteen buildings and communities, as the market section shows. A re-check on October 29, 2026 found 54 active listings and 5 pending. We do not name individual listings on this page because they change weekly. A saved search is how you see the next one first, above all in a building with a thin shelf such as Bella Lago, which had no listing that day, or Palm Harbor Club, which had one.

Read the street number before you tour

The MLS files closings at 4142 Bay Beach Lane (Grandview at Bay Beach), 4182 (Manatee Bay at Bay Beach) and 4192 under the Waterside name, although none of the three is one of the five Waterside buildings at 4137, 4141, 4183, 4191 and 4198. Each has its own association, fee and documents, so check the street number before you compare a price.

How Do I Get a Personalized Bay Beach Buyer Consultation?

You get a personalized Bay Beach buyer consultation from McGreevy and Comisar by using the buyer form on this page or by calling Marc Comisar at (239) 287-5873. Tell us your budget, timing, preferred size and whether a boat slip, a rental plan or a pet matters, and we send the buildings and homes that fit.

What the consultation covers

We map your budget to the 61 closings of the 12 months to October 7, 2026, set each listing beside its building’s closed sales, price the monthly cost at the listing-entered fee figures with their caveats, and list the documents your lender and insurer will ask for. As Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, we would rather you hear the hard questions from us than from an underwriter.

Start your Bay Beach buyer consultation

Start your Bay Beach buyer consultation with the form on this page, or read how we represent buyers. Call Marc at (239) 287-5873, or talk to Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

Buying here and selling a home first?

If you need to sell to buy, read how we sell Bay Beach homes and get a free Bay Beach home valuation so the sale and the purchase line up. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

Buying a Winter Home on Fort Myers Beach: What Seasonal Buyers Should Know

A seasonal Bay Beach buyer owns a bay-side condo that sits empty for months, so plan the storm routine, the insurance and a trusted local contact, and read the rental and approval rules first, because none is published. Lee County’s evacuation layer puts Bay Beach in zone A, typically among the first ordered to leave.

Before you leave for the summer

Ask the manager for the building’s storm plan, the shutter or impact-glass status of your unit and the elevator shutdown plan. Tell your insurer the unit will be unoccupied, because a policy can limit coverage for vacancy, and name a caretaker the manager knows. The Town’s sea turtle rules treat May 1 through October 31 as nesting season, with shielded long-wavelength exterior lighting required on all properties in the Town, beachfront or not.

Closing from out of state

Florida title companies routinely close by mail-away signing or remote online notarization; confirm wire instructions by phone with the title company, never from an email alone. Buyers from outside the United States should ask a tax adviser about FIRPTA withholding on a future sale.

What We Could Not Verify

This list gathers every place where this page says a fact about Bay Beach is not available to us today. Each item names the document or route that would settle it, so a buyer can close the gap before making an offer.

  • Association budgets, fees and assessments. None was found for any Bay Beach building, and the fees we print are listing-entered. Route: the current budget and an estoppel certificate.
  • Rental, pet and approval rules. Not published for any building. Route: the recorded declaration and the current rules, in the resale package.
  • Which Town minimum-stay rule or exception applies to each building. Route: the association and the Town, 239-765-0202.
  • Milestone inspection and reserve study status. We computed statutory years from the county’s year built and stories. Route: the seller’s package, the manager and the state reporting page.
  • Slip and dock rights for any unit. The roll records dock and slip parcels and several cooperatives, not which unit holds what. Route: the cooperative’s or boating association’s documents and the recorded instrument.
  • A flood determination for any unit, and insurance premiums. Our table is a map-based indication at tested points. Route: an elevation certificate and a Florida insurance agent.
  • Whether any building is seaward of the coastal construction control line. Route: the Florida Department of Environmental Protection.
  • Post-storm damage and repair by building. No association account was found. Route: the association’s repair summary, claim history and the Town’s permit records.
  • The original list prices behind the closings. The MLS record we pulled carries the final list price only.
  • The condominium name and association for 4192 Bay Beach Lane, and the association for Manatee Bay at Bay Beach. Not captured in our state-record research. Route: the Florida Division of Corporations and the recorded declaration.
  • The high school serving South Zone 4. Route: the Lee County school district.

What Buyers Say About Working With Us

Marc Comisar is a top-reviewed Fort Myers Beach buyer’s agent and Jesse McGreevy is a top-reviewed Bonita Springs realtor, and every review below is copied word for word from our Google Business Profile. Reviews like these are how a buyer can check the way we work before the first call.

Matt Haines, client

★★★★★ “Jesse and his team were the most professional and communicative people throughout the entire process! Always available and helpful! Highly recommended!” Verified Google review

Ian Matheson, buyer

★★★★★ “Marc is one of the most down to earth realtors that really listens to your needs and is exceptional at finding the right house.” Verified Google review

Christian Schnabel, client

★★★★★ “No one knows real estate, especially Florida real estate like Marc and Jesse. Smart and savvy. They also have a great team that is knowledgeable and professional.” Verified Google review

Guy Avagliano, buyer

★★★★★ “Marc was great! He helped us find a place that matched our needs, without trying to upsell us into something too big. And he’s helped us settle into the area. 100% recommendation!” Verified Google review

Frequently Asked Questions, Bay Beach Buyer Edition

These are the questions Bay Beach buyers ask most, answered in plain terms from the records cited on this page. Where a fact is not published, we say so and name the document that settles it. Every answer stands on its own.

Where is Bay Beach in Fort Myers Beach?

Bay Beach is on the bay side of the south half of Estero Island, along Bay Beach Lane, Lenell Road, Island Pines Way, Bella Lago Drive and Lake Valencia Court, about four and a half to five miles by road south of Times Square.

Is Bay Beach inside the Town of Fort Myers Beach?

Yes. The county roll places all 1,757 Bay Beach residential parcels in the Town of Fort Myers Beach taxing district, so the Town handles permits, flood rules and rental registration.

Is Bay Beach one community or many?

Bay Beach is many: nine larger condominiums and six smaller buildings, each with its own declaration and association. We found no area-wide Bay Beach master association.

Is Bay Beach on the Gulf?

No. Bay Beach buildings face Estero Bay, canals and interior courts. The Gulf beaches are across Estero Boulevard, and Lovers Key State Park is about 3.5 miles south by road.

What do homes in Bay Beach sell for?

The Southwest Florida MLS recorded 61 Bay Beach closings in the 12 months to October 7, 2026 at a median of $425,000, from $260,000 to $2,200,000.

How many Bay Beach homes are for sale now?

On October 7, 2026 the MLS showed 53 Bay Beach listings, 49 active and 4 pending, from $289,900 to $3,059,000. Eleven were in Grandview at Bay Beach; the other 42 had a median asking price of $472,000.

Is Bay Beach a buyer’s market?

Bay Beach had about 9.6 months of supply on October 7, 2026. Supply is uneven: about five months between $300,000 and $399,999, and 16 listings against 2 closings at $1,000,000 and above.

How much below asking do Bay Beach homes sell?

The median Bay Beach closing in the 12 months to October 7, 2026 was 93.8 percent of the final list price, a median gap of $29,000. Five of 61 sold at the final list price, none above it, and 12 under 90 percent.

How long do Bay Beach homes take to sell?

The median Bay Beach closing of the 12 months to October 7, 2026 spent 99 days on the market. Sixteen of 61 sold within 30 days and 16 took 180 days or more.

What is the least expensive building in Bay Beach?

On October 7, 2026 the lowest Bay Beach asking prices were in Harbour Pointe, at $289,900 and $299,000. Hibiscus Pointe had the lowest median for the 12 months to October 7, 2026 among buildings with 10 or more closings, $375,000.

What is the most expensive building in Bay Beach?

Grandview at Bay Beach, the 58-unit tower built in 2023, is the most expensive Bay Beach building. Its 43 closings in 60 months ran from $1,278,077 to $3,064,875, and its 11 listings asked $1,500,000 to $3,059,000.

How big are Bay Beach condos?

The 61 Bay Beach closings of the 12 months to October 7, 2026 ranged from 997 to 2,923 square feet of MLS living area, median 1,224. Not counting plans with a den, 35 were two-bedroom homes and 22 were three-bedroom.

When were the Bay Beach buildings built?

Bay Beach was built one condominium at a time from 1976 to 2023 by the county’s year built. The Palms of Bay Beach is the oldest and Grandview the newest.

What are the HOA and condo fees in Bay Beach?

No Bay Beach association publishes its assessment. Listing agents entered annual recurring fees from $3,604 to $26,588 on the 61 closings of the 12 months to October 7, 2026, median $12,400, not verified. Ask for the current budget.

Are there special assessments in Bay Beach?

We found no published special assessment for any Bay Beach building, which is not proof that none exists. Request the estoppel certificate, the board minutes and every assessment notice since 2022.

Can I rent out a Bay Beach condo?

It depends on the building’s declaration, and no Bay Beach association publishes its rental rules. The Town of Fort Myers Beach also requires vacation rentals to register and sets a one-week minimum stay in certain districts, with exceptions.

Are pets allowed in Bay Beach?

Pet rules in Bay Beach are set by each association and are not published. Ask how many pets, what size or breed limit, and whether the rule covers tenants and guests, in writing.

Can I keep a boat at Bay Beach?

Hibiscus Pointe, Casa Marina, Waterside and Royal Pelican in Bay Beach have docks or slips held through a cooperative, a boating association or separately recorded parcels. A slip is not automatic with a unit, so make it a written condition.

Is Bay Beach in a flood zone?

The FEMA flood map indicates Zone VE at 12 feet at three Bay Beach Lane addresses we tested and Zone AE at 11 feet on Island Pines Way. Both are Special Flood Hazard Areas, so get the building’s elevation certificate.

Do I need flood insurance to buy in Bay Beach?

A lender will generally require flood insurance on a financed Bay Beach purchase in this zone. Citizens does not require flood on a condominium unit-owners policy. Ask a Florida insurance agent to quote the specific unit.

Was Bay Beach damaged in Hurricane Ian?

Hurricane Ian’s surge reached 10 to 15 feet above ground on Estero Island, and U.S. Geological Survey marks near Bay Beach read 11.6 to 12.3 feet NAVD88. We found no building-level damage account, so ask each association.

Which Bay Beach buildings need a milestone inspection?

Bay Beach buildings of three or more stories owe a milestone inspection at 30 years. By county year built, The Palms, Royal Pelican, Harbour Pointe and Hibiscus Pointe have reached that year and Waterside reaches it from 2027 to 2033. These are computed years, not a status.

What documents does a Bay Beach seller owe me?

A Bay Beach condominium seller must give you the declaration, bylaws and rules, the latest financial statement and budget, the milestone inspection summary if one applies, and the reserve study or a statement that none exists.

How long do I have to cancel a Bay Beach condo contract?

Under Florida Statute 718.503, a Bay Beach condo buyer can cancel within 7 days, excluding weekends and legal holidays, after receiving the resale documents, including any milestone inspection summary or reserve study that applies.

Do I need association approval to buy in Bay Beach?

Probably, in most buildings. Listing agents entered an application fee, from $25 to $250, on 250 of the 334 Bay Beach closings. Ask for the approval timeline before you set a closing date.

Can I get a mortgage on a Bay Beach condo?

Yes, or you can pay cash. A lender reviews the Bay Beach building as well as you, and will ask its association about the budget, reserves, insurance, assessments and inspections.

What are the property taxes on a Bay Beach home?

At the 2026 applied millage of 13.3108 for the Town of Fort Myers Beach district, a $425,000 Bay Beach home carries $5,657.09 a year before exemptions. A change of ownership resets the assessment, so do not reuse the seller’s bill.

What closing costs does a Bay Beach buyer pay?

With 20 percent down on a $425,000 Bay Beach home, the buyer’s stamp tax on the note is $1,190.00 and the intangible tax is $680.00. In Lee County the seller customarily pays the deed stamps and the owner’s title policy.

Do I need to sign an agreement to tour Bay Beach homes?

Yes. Since August 17, 2024 an MLS participant must have a written agreement with a buyer, stating the compensation, before touring a home. We sign it before the first Bay Beach showing, and the fee is negotiable.

Which schools serve Bay Beach?

The district’s GIS layer places Bay Beach Lane in elementary zone T, middle zone MM and high school South Zone 4. Fort Myers Beach Elementary is closed, so confirm the assigned school by address.

Is Bay Beach a good place for a winter home?

Bay Beach works for a lock-and-leave owner who plans the storm routine, tells the insurer about vacancy and names a local caretaker. The area is in evacuation zone A.

How is Bay Beach different from Pink Shell Beach Resort?

Bay Beach is a bay-side cluster of independent condominium associations with 61 closings and a $425,000 median in 12 months. Pink Shell Beach Resort is a Gulf-front resort campus with 14 closings, a $325,000 median and a higher price per square foot.

Why do MLS and county numbers differ for Bay Beach?

They are separate series. The MLS counts every listed Bay Beach closing, 61 at a $425,000 median, and Lee County counts the sales it qualifies as arm’s-length, 53 at $410,000.

Should I price an offer from the Bay Beach median?

No. The Bay Beach median blends fifteen buildings whose closings ran from $260,000 to $2,200,000. Price an offer from closed sales of the same plan in the same building.

How do I start buying in Bay Beach with McGreevy and Comisar?

Tell us your budget, timing and what matters most, and we send the Bay Beach buildings that fit with their closed sales. Call Marc at (239) 287-5873 or use the buyer form on this page.

Why Does a Fort Myers Beach Specialist Matter When You Buy?

A Fort Myers Beach specialist matters because price is the smaller part of a Bay Beach decision. Fifteen buildings, unpublished fees, a flood zone, a storm history and rules you cannot read online sit behind every listing, and McGreevy and Comisar, Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, read them before we show you a home.

Owners thinking about the other side of this market can read how we sell Bay Beach homes or request a free Bay Beach valuation. Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072. For the building-by-building record behind this page, read the Bay Beach guide, and for the island as a whole see Fort Myers Beach.

If you are ready to buy a home in Bay Beach, start your Bay Beach buyer consultation or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873, and we will send the buildings that fit your budget, their closed sales and the documents to request. McGreevy and Comisar are the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and our credentials are below.

Your Local Real Estate Experts

Your local real estate experts for Bay Beach are Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar of McGreevy and Comisar, the team that leads Domain Realty Group from its office at 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101 in Bonita Springs. We read the county roll, the state filings and the Town’s pages before writing about any Fort Myers Beach building.

Jesse McGreevy is a Sales Associate and Marc Comisar is a Broker Associate, and you can read how the team was built on our about McGreevy and Comisar page. McGreevy and Comisar are Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008, and the full record is below.

  • Top 1% Real Estate Agents Nationally Since 2008
  • 5 Star Award for Customer Satisfaction for 21 Straight Years. Only 5 out of 21k+ Licensees (Gulfshore Life Magazine)
  • #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012
  • McGreevy and Comisar and their Domain Realty Group team have sold over $2.5 Billion in Real Estate
  • McGreevy and Comisar alone have over $900 million in Sales
  • Nationally Recognized Top Producing Realtors
  • Platinum Sales Production Award Winners

Contact McGreevy and Comisar

  • Jesse McGreevy: (239) 898-6072 ·
  • Marc Comisar: (239) 287-5873
  • Office: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134

Buying in Bay Beach? See how we represent Bay Beach buyers or Call Marc at (239) 287-5873.

Selling a Bay Beach home? Get a free Bay Beach home valuation, or Call Jesse direct at (239) 898-6072.

Licensure, and the office of record

Jesse McGreevy (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar (Broker Associate) are licensed Florida REALTORS® with Domain Realty, and Florida real estate licensure is regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC). Florida DBPR license numbers: Jesse McGreevy SL3101296 (Sales Associate) and Marc Comisar BK3060671 (Broker Associate), with the brokerage Domain Realty.

McGreevy and Comisar lead Domain Realty Group, a full-service Southwest Florida real estate team.

Where else to find the team

Follow our Southwest Florida market updates on Facebook, Instagram and YouTube.

Sources and Authoritative References

Every figure on this page traces to a county, Town, state or federal record, a published agency document or news reporting, retrieved on or before October 7, 2026. We do not cite brokerage or listing sites. Market figures are from the Southwest Florida MLS and the Lee County Property Appraiser, kept as two separate series.

Florida statutes and state records

  1. Florida Statute 718.503
  2. Florida Statute 718.504
  3. Florida Statute 718.116
  4. Florida Statute 718.112
  5. Florida Statute 553.899
  6. Florida Statute 201.02
  7. Florida Statute 193.1554
  8. Florida Statute 627.351
  9. Florida Statute 689.302
  10. Florida DBPR condominium public records
  11. Florida DBPR condominium extract file
  12. Florida DBPR structural integrity reserve study reporting
  13. Florida Division of Corporations, Sunbiz
  14. Citizens Property Insurance, flood requirement
  15. Florida Department of Revenue, documentary stamp tax
  16. Florida Department of Revenue, nonrecurring intangible tax
  17. Florida DEP, Hurricanes Ian and Nicole report

Town of Fort Myers Beach

  1. Town of Fort Myers Beach
  2. Short-Term Rentals
  3. Ordinance 18-01, Short-Term Rentals Regulation
  4. Short-Term Rentals Code of Conduct
  5. 2026 short-term rental opt-out list
  6. Substantial improvement and substantial damage
  7. FEMA’s 50 percent rule
  8. National Flood Insurance Program
  9. Elevation certificates
  10. Sea turtles
  11. Town of Fort Myers Beach code of ordinances
  12. Fort Myers Beach Fire Control District

Lee County and the Property Appraiser

  1. Lee County Property Appraiser
  2. 2025 taxing district millage book
  3. 2026 taxing district millage book
  4. Property Appraiser hazard and flood zone map service
  5. Lee County adopted solid waste rates
  6. Lee County Parks, Bowditch Point Regional Park
  7. Lee County DOT, Big Carlos Pass Bridge ribbon-cutting release
  8. LeeTran Route 410 and 490 timetable

Flood, storms and federal data

  1. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer
  2. FEMA Flood Map Service Center
  3. FEMA, Risk Rating 2.0
  4. National Hurricane Center report on Hurricane Ian
  5. National Weather Service Tampa Bay, Helene impact narratives
  6. National Weather Service Tampa Bay, Milton impact narratives
  7. U.S. Geological Survey high-water marks for Hurricane Ian
  8. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Coastal Barrier Resources System property documentation
  9. WGCU on the Town’s Class 5 flood rating
  10. U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey

Schools, projects and island news

  1. Lee County school district, school zones
  2. Lee County school district, 2026-27 student enrollment plan
  3. Fort Myers Beach Talk on the School Board vote
  4. WGCU on Fort Myers Beach Elementary
  5. WGCU on the new Big Carlos Pass Bridge
  6. WGCU on parking closures at Bowditch Point and Lynn Hall
  7. Fort Myers Beach Talk on the pier construction contract
  8. Publix at Fort Myers Beach

Buyer references and our team

  1. National Association of Realtors, written buyer agreements
  2. National Association of Realtors, settlement questions and answers
  3. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Loan Estimate
  4. Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey
  5. Internal Revenue Service, FIRPTA withholding
  6. McGreevy and Comisar about page
  7. Jesse McGreevy
  8. Marc Comisar

Downloadable Documents

The official documents below are published by the Town of Fort Myers Beach, the Lee County Property Appraiser, the Lee County school district and the National Hurricane Center. They are the public primary documents behind the rental, tax, school and storm sections of this page, and each link opens the issuing authority’s own copy.

DocumentIssuerWhat it is
Ordinance 18-01, Short-Term Rentals RegulationTown of Fort Myers BeachThe rental registration ordinance, adopted May 7, 2018
2026 short-term rental opt-out listTown of Fort Myers BeachCondominium buildings that opted out of Town enforcement
2025 taxing district millage bookLee County Property AppraiserFinal 2025 millage by district, including the Town of Fort Myers Beach
2026 taxing district millage bookLee County Property Appraiser2026 applied millage by district, printed October 9, 2026
2026-27 student enrollment planLee County school districtElementary and middle proximity zones and high school zones
Hurricane Ian tropical cyclone reportNational Hurricane CenterStorm surge and damage figures for Fort Myers Beach and Estero Island

Market data from Southwest Florida MLS, pulled October 2026.

McGreevy and Comisar, Best Realtor for Bay Beach. Brokered by Domain Realty. Jesse McGreevy, FL Lic. SL3101296 · Marc Comisar, FL Lic. BK3060671.