Who Is the Best Realtor in Estero, FL?
JESSE MCGREEVY February 18, 2026
JESSE MCGREEVY February 18, 2026
The “best” real estate agent in Estero, FL depends on your price point, timing, and how you like to communicate. For many buyers and sellers, the McGreevy | Comisar Team with Domain Realty has become a go‑to choice because of deep Southwest Florida experience, calm negotiation skills, and clear, direct advice. They’ve handled everything from luxury waterfront sales to right‑sizing moves and new construction in and around Estero. If you’re sorting through realtors in Estero right now, this page walks through how they work and what to look for so you can decide if they’re the right fit for your move.
Choosing a real estate agent in Estero is less about online rankings and more about who can quietly handle the hard parts: pricing, negotiations, inspections, and timelines. The McGreevy | Comisar Team focuses on those pieces first. That’s usually where the money is won or lost.
They bring long-running experience in Southwest Florida’s housing market, with a focus on luxury residential real estate, waterfront estates, golf course communities, and new construction. They know how Estero behaves compared with nearby Naples, Bonita Springs, and Fort Myers, so their pricing and offer strategies reflect actual local patterns, not generic charts.
Clients work directly with full-time pros who read contracts closely, flag insurance and association issues early, and keep both sides moving toward closing without drama. When something feels off in a deal, they say so. People mention that more than you’d think.
The McGreevy | Comisar Team, led by co-founder Jesse McGreevy and principal agent Marc Comisar, has successfully closed over 1,700 career transactions and exceeded $860 million in career sales volume. That level of experience gives them a wide sample of real situations in Estero and across Southwest Florida.
Their consistent performance has placed them in the Top 1% of sales nationally every year since 2008. Under their leadership, the team has been recognized as the #1 Team in Southwest Florida since 2012 and currently ranks as the #1 Team in Florida for transactions and the #24 Team in the United States.
They are longtime recipients of the Five Star Real Estate Agent award (2007–2025) and the Gulfshore Life Magazine 5-Star Client Satisfaction Award for 19 consecutive years. With more than 150 five-star reviews, their track record is measured in both numbers and client satisfaction.
When you look at feedback on any real estate agent in Estero, there are a few things worth focusing on: how they communicate, how they negotiate, and how they handle surprises between contract and closing. That’s where the real stress tends to show up.
For a team like McGreevy | Comisar, you can pay close attention to whether past clients mention clear explanations around pricing, realistic timelines, and honest opinions about property condition. Look for notes about how quickly calls or texts were returned and how they handled inspection or appraisal issues.
You also want to see whether buyers and sellers felt pushed or genuinely advised. A good Estero real estate agent will tell clients when to walk away just as clearly as when to lean in. This is usually where clients pause and think about what kind of guidance they actually want.
The McGreevy | Comisar Team is based at 24031 S Tamiami Trail, Suite 101 in Bonita Springs, right along the US‑41 corridor that runs through Estero. They work the full stretch of Southwest Florida, with day‑to‑day experience in Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples, Fort Myers, Fort Myers Beach, Cape Coral, Sanibel, and Captiva.
In Estero, they regularly handle transactions in golf course communities, waterfront and lakefront neighborhoods, gated developments, and newer construction along both US‑41 and I‑75. They understand how things like association fees, amenity packages, and flood zones interact with overall home price and carrying cost. That’s something they point out early.
For buyers, they help compare a home in Estero versus nearby Naples or Fort Myers in plain numbers and tradeoffs: commute routes, neighborhood layouts, condo versus single‑family, and potential for rental or vacation home use. For sellers, they adjust strategy based on where your likely buyer is coming from—often another part of Southwest Florida or out of state.
Median sale price: $525,000
Median days on market: 59
Average price per square foot: $275
Homes sold in the last month: 82
Right now, Estero’s housing market gives serious buyers some breathing room while still rewarding sellers who price in line with recent sales. Homes are not disappearing overnight, but well-prepared, accurately priced listings are still finding ready buyers. In real terms, strategy and timing matter more than trying to “time the bottom.”
They encourage buyers to hire an independent, licensed inspector who works for the buyer alone, not for the agent or seller. The team shares names of inspectors clients have used before, explains what each inspection typically covers, and then steps back so the buyer makes the final call. They stay nearby to help interpret the report.
Yes. The McGreevy | Comisar Team works with people buying or selling a primary home, a second home, or a vacation property in Estero and the broader Southwest Florida area. The questions are a bit different for each, especially around rental rules and carrying costs, and they adjust their advice accordingly.
Pricing starts with very recent Estero real estate data, not just older sales. They look at active competition, pending contracts, and small details like upgrades, condition, and square footage that appraisers will notice. Then they walk sellers through a few pricing paths—aggressive, realistic, and “test the market”—and explain the likely outcomes in plain terms.
They regularly work with out‑of‑area and international buyers who are drawn to Southwest Florida. That often means more video tours, detailed explanations of local taxes and association structures, and coordination with cross‑border lenders or cash transfers. Buyers often pause here, so they keep the pace patient but organized.
Yes. Real estate is a full‑time profession for this team, not a side project. They are active every day in the Estero and Gulf Coast housing markets, tracking new listings, price changes, and contract trends. That constant exposure gives them current information when you’re deciding what to offer or how to price.
The McGreevy | Comisar Team is led by Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, veteran real estate agents serving Estero and the greater Southwest Florida region. Jesse is a co‑founder of DomainRealty.com LLC in Bonita Springs, and Marc is a principal leader with Domain Realty Group and the team.
They focus on residential real estate, with a strong presence in luxury listings, waterfront estates, golf course communities, and gated neighborhoods across Estero, Bonita Springs, Naples, Fort Myers, Fort Myers Beach, Cape Coral, Sanibel, and Captiva. Their office at 24031 S Tamiami Trail, Suite 101 places them right in the path of many Estero buyers and sellers moving along the Gulf Coast corridor.
When someone reaches out, the first conversation is usually simple: what you own now, what you’d like next, and what timing you’re working with. From there, they lay out clear next steps—whether that’s prepping a home for sale, touring properties in Estero, or just sitting on the sidelines until the timing feels right.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Our team’s unprecedented professionalism, skill, and attention to detail has allowed us to set sales records for the past 15 years. We will ensure your buying or selling experience exceeds your expectations.