Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

The Turtle Club's Resilient Return: A Tale of Rebuilding and Revival

SUSAN KOSCHALK January 26, 2024

After a 16-month hiatus, the iconic beachfront haven, The Turtle Club, is poised to unveil its rebirth in February, marking a triumphant return to the North Naples dining scene. Devastated by Hurricane Ian's fury in September 2022, the restaurant, nestled within the Vanderbilt Beach Resort, faced challenges that tested its resilience.

Co-owner Mick Moore expressed gratitude for having a structure to rebuild, emphasizing the community's support during the arduous recovery process. The Turtle Club, synonymous with cherished traditions and special occasions, has left an indelible mark on generations of patrons.

Despite enduring construction delays, the renovated 3,477-square-foot restaurant will retain its Old Florida charm while showcasing a lighter, fresher aesthetic with a palette of white and blue. The layout remains unchanged, providing 74 seats indoors and 84 outdoors along the Gulf beach.

Architectural plans promise a seamless blend of the familiar and the rejuvenated, with upgrades to the electrical system, lighting, and air conditioning. The Turtle Club's symbolic namesake, a large sea turtle shell, found after the hurricane, will reclaim its place as a prominent wall decoration, embodying the restaurant's enduring spirit.

Peter Tierney, co-owner of The Turtle Club, assures patrons that the essence of the beloved establishment will remain intact, inviting them to rediscover the beauty of the manicured hall adorned with gas lamps and the timeless allure of the beach.

The interior changes, subtle to the eye, are geared towards enhancing the staff's operational experience. A testament to the establishment's familial ethos, a significant portion of the staff, embodying a family culture, is set to return. Curtis McCreary, the general manager, anticipates retaining around 80% of the staff, creating a seamless transition for both loyal guests and the dedicated team.

As the renovation project enters its final stretch, The Turtle Club's staff, along with its loyal patrons, eagerly anticipates the reopening, signifying the end of a challenging chapter and the dawn of a revitalized era. The Turtle Club stands resilient, ready to welcome back its cherished guests to a slice of paradise that has been lovingly restored.

Recent Blog Posts

Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.

Aurelio’s Pizza Expands to Estero with New Location and Grand Opening Celebration

Beloved Chicago-born pizzeria brings its famous thin-crust pizza and full menu to Southwest Florida’s west coast

FGCU Launches Major Campus Upgrades to Enhance Student Life

Renovations at Cohen Student Union and the construction of Academic Building 10 mark a transformative chapter in the university’s growth.

Estero Town Homes: Toll Brothers’ Updated Plans for Sandy Lane & Corkscrew Road

Vision for 171 townhomes, enhanced buffers, and public amenities move forward under Estero’s Planned Development

Get Your Game Face On — TerraWalk’s Court Celebration Is Here!

Join the fun October 18 as TerraWalk unveils its new tennis & pickleball courts — a community event you won’t want to miss

Estero Sports & Recreation Hub – September 2025 Updates

The Future of Sports, Recreation, and Community in Estero is Taking Shape

Revised London Bay Plans for Outrigger Site Aim to Balance Height, Amenities, & Community Feedback

Developer scales back tower heights, adds parking, and outlines public‐facing amenities in fresh design for 6200 Estero Boulevard

Proposed Budget & Taxes: Estero Prepares for Public Hearings This September

Learn about the budget schedule, record-low millage rate, and how residents can participate virtually or in person.

New Exhibits, Big Impact: What’s New at CMON Golisano Children’s Museum of Naples This Fall

A look at the latest exhibits, programs, and upcoming attractions at Southwest Florida’s one-of-a-kind children’s museum

Big Decisions Ahead: Summercrest, Broadway Crossing & Coconut Trace Hotel Go to Public Hearing

Estero’s Planning, Zoning & Design Board will hear three major projects on September 9—here’s what’s being proposed and why it matters

Work With Us

Our team’s unprecedented professionalism, skill, and attention to detail has allowed us to set sales records for the past 15 years. We will ensure your buying or selling experience exceeds your expectations.